Hubbry Logo
search
logo
1830228

Marian Rejewski

logo
Community Hub0 Subscribers
Read side by side
from Wikipedia

Key Information

Marian Adam Rejewski (Polish: [ˈmarjan rɛˈjɛfskʲi] ; 16 August 1905 – 13 February 1980) was a Polish mathematician and cryptologist who in late 1932 reconstructed the sight-unseen German military Enigma cipher machine, aided by limited documents obtained by French military intelligence.

Over the next nearly seven years, Rejewski and fellow mathematician-cryptologists Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zygalski, working at the Polish General Staff's Cipher Bureau, developed techniques and equipment for decrypting the Enigma ciphers, even as the Germans introduced modifications to their Enigma machines and encryption procedures. Rejewski's contributions included the cryptologic card catalog and the cryptologic bomb.

Five weeks before the outbreak of World War II in Europe, the Poles shared their achievements with French and British counterparts who had made no progress, enabling Britain to begin reading German Enigma ciphers. The intelligence gained by the British from Enigma decrypts formed part of what they code-named Ultra and contributed—perhaps decisively—to the defeat of Nazi Germany.[Note 1]

Soon after the outbreak of war, the Polish cryptologists were evacuated to France, where they continued breaking Enigma ciphers. After the fall of France in June 1940, they and their support staff were evacuated to Algeria in North Africa; a few months later, they resumed work clandestinely in southern Vichy France. After the Vichy "Free Zone" was occupied by Nazi Germany in November 1942, Rejewski and Zygalski escaped via Spain (and Spanish imprisonment), Portugal, and Gibraltar to Britain. There they enlisted in the Polish Armed Forces and were put to work solving low-grade German ciphers.

After the war, Rejewski returned to Poland and his family. For two decades, he remained silent about his prewar and wartime work so as to avoid the attention of Poland's Soviet-dominated government. In 1967, he broke his silence, providing Poland's Military Historical Institute his memoirs of work at the Cipher Bureau.

Early life

[edit]
Rejewski's birthplace
Rejewski studied mathematics at Poznań University.
Rejewski laid flowers on Gauss's grave (Göttingen).[7]

Marian Rejewski was born 16 August 1905 in Bromberg in the Prussian Province of Posen (now Bydgoszcz, Poland)[8] to Józef and Matylda, née Thoms.[9] After completing secondary school, he studied mathematics at Poznań University's Mathematics Institute, housed in Poznań Castle.[10]

In 1929, shortly before graduating from university, Rejewski began attending a secret cryptology course which opened on 15 January,[11] organized for select German-speaking mathematics students by the Polish General Staff's Cipher Bureau with the help of the Mathematics Institute's Professor Zdzisław Krygowski. The course was conducted off-campus at a military facility[12] and, as Rejewski would discover in France in 1939, "was entirely and literally based" on a 1925 book by French colonel Marcel Givierge [fr], Cours de cryptographie (Cryptography Course).[13] Rejewski and fellow students Henryk Zygalski and Jerzy Różycki were among the few who could keep up with the course while balancing the demands of their normal studies.[14]

On 1 March 1929, Rejewski graduated with a Master of Philosophy degree in mathematics.[15] A few weeks after graduating, and without having completed the Cipher Bureau's cryptology course, he began the first year of a two-year actuarial statistics course at Göttingen, Germany. He did not complete the statistics course, because while home for the summer of 1930, he accepted an offer, from Professor Krygowski, of a mathematics teaching assistantship at Poznań University.[16] He also began working part-time for the Cipher Bureau, which by then had set up an outpost at Poznań to decrypt intercepted German radio messages.[16] Rejewski worked some twelve hours a week near the Mathematics Institute in an underground vault referred to puckishly as the "Black Chamber".[17]

The Poznań branch of the Cipher Bureau was disbanded in the summer of 1932. In Warsaw, on 1 September 1932, Rejewski, Zygalski, and Różycki joined the Cipher Bureau as civilian employees working at the General Staff building (the Saxon Palace).[18] Their first assignment was to solve a four-letter code used by the Kriegsmarine (German Navy). Progress was initially slow, but sped up after a test exchange—consisting of a six-group signal, followed by a four-group response—was intercepted. The cryptologists guessed correctly that the first signal was the question, "When was Frederick the Great born?" followed by the response, "1712."[19]

On 20 June 1934 Rejewski married Irena Maria Lewandowska, daughter of a prosperous dentist. The couple eventually had two children: a son, Andrzej (Andrew), born in 1936; and a daughter, Janina (Joan), born in 1939. Janina would later become a mathematician like her father.[20]

Enigma machine

[edit]
Enigma machine, solved by Rejewski in 1932

The Enigma machine was an electromechanical device, equipped with a 26-letter keyboard and 26 lamps, corresponding to the letters of the alphabet. Inside was a set of wired drums (rotors and a reflector) that scrambled the input. The machine used a plugboard to swap pairs of letters, and the encipherment varied from one key press to the next.[21] For two operators to communicate, both Enigma machines had to be set up in the same way. The large number of possibilities for setting the rotors and the plugboard combined to form an astronomical number of configurations, and the settings were changed daily,[Note 2] so the machine code had to be "broken" anew each day.[23]

Before 1932, the Cipher Bureau had succeeded in solving an earlier Enigma machine that functioned without a plugboard,[Note 3] but had been unsuccessful with the Enigma I, a new standard German cipher machine that was coming into widespread use.[25][26] In late October or early November 1932, the head of the Cipher Bureau's German section, Captain Maksymilian Ciężki, tasked Rejewski to work alone on the German Enigma I machine for a couple of hours per day; Rejewski was not to tell his colleagues what he was doing.[25]

Solving the wiring

[edit]

To decrypt Enigma messages, three pieces of information were needed: (1) a general understanding of how Enigma functioned; (2) the wiring of the rotors; and (3) the daily settings (the sequence and orientations of the rotors, and the plug connections on the plugboard). Rejewski had only the first at his disposal, based on information already acquired by the Cipher Bureau.[23]

A cycle formed by the first and fourth letters of a set of indicators. Rejewski exploited these cycles to deduce the Enigma rotor wiring in 1932, and to solve the daily message settings.

First Rejewski tackled the problem of discovering the wiring of the rotors. To do this, according to historian David Kahn, he pioneered the use of pure mathematics in cryptanalysis.[27] Previous methods had largely exploited linguistic patterns and the statistics of natural-language texts—letter-frequency analysis. Rejewski applied techniques from group theory—theorems about permutations—in his attack on Enigma. These mathematical techniques, combined with material supplied by Gustave Bertrand,[Note 4] chief of French radio intelligence, enabled him to reconstruct the internal wirings of the machine's rotors and nonrotating reflector. "The solution", writes Kahn, "was Rejewski's own stunning achievement, one that elevates him to the pantheon of the greatest cryptanalysts of all time."[29] Rejewski used a mathematical theorem—that two permutations are conjugate if and only if they have the same cycle structure—that mathematics professor and Cryptologia co-editor Cipher A. Deavours describes as "the theorem that won World War II".[30]

Before receiving the French intelligence material, Rejewski had made a careful study of Enigma messages, particularly of the first six letters of messages intercepted on a single day.[25] For security, each message was encrypted using different starting positions of the rotors, as selected by the operator. This message setting was three letters long. To convey it to the receiving operator, the sending operator began the message by sending the message setting in a disguised form—a six-letter indicator. The indicator was formed using the Enigma with its rotors set to a common global setting for that day, termed the ground setting, which was shared by all operators.[31] The particular way that the indicator was constructed introduced a weakness into the cipher.[32]

For example, suppose the operator chose the message setting KYG for a message. The operator would first set the Enigma's rotors to the ground setting, which might be GBL on that particular day, and then encrypt the message setting on the Enigma twice; that is, the operator would enter KYGKYG (which might come out to something like QZKBLX). The operator would then reposition the rotors at KYG, and encrypt the actual message. A receiving operator could reverse the process to recover first the message setting, then the message itself. The repetition of the message setting was apparently meant as an error check to detect garbles, but it had the unforeseen effect of greatly weakening the cipher. Due to the indicator's repetition of the message setting, Rejewski knew that, in the plaintext of the indicator, the first and fourth letters were the same, the second and fifth were the same, and the third and sixth were the same. These relations could be exploited to break into the cipher.[31]

Rejewski studied these related pairs of letters. For example, if there were four messages that had the following indicators on the same day: BJGTDN, LIFBAB, ETULZR, TFREII, then by looking at the first and fourth letters of each set, he knew that certain pairs of letters were related. B was related to T, L was related to B, E was related to L, and T was related to E: (B,T), (L,B), (E,L), and (T,E). If he had enough different messages to work with, he could build entire sequences of relationships: the letter B was related to T, which was related to E, which was related to L, which was related to B (see diagram). This was a "cycle of 4", since it took four jumps until it got back to the start letter. Another cycle on the same day might be AFWA, or a "cycle of 3". If there were enough messages on a given day, all the letters of the alphabet might be covered by a number of different cycles of various sizes. The cycles would be consistent for one day, and then would change to a different set of cycles the next day. Similar analysis could be done on the 2nd and 5th letters, and the 3rd and 6th, identifying the cycles in each case and the number of steps in each cycle.[33]

Enigma operators also had a tendency to choose predictable letter combinations as indicators, such as girlfriends' initials or a pattern of keys that they saw on the Enigma keyboard. These became known to the allies as "Cillies" ("Sillies" misspelled). Using the data thus gained from the study of cycles and the use of predictable indicators, Rejewski was able to deduce six permutations corresponding to the encipherment at six consecutive positions of the Enigma machine. These permutations could be described by six equations with various unknowns, representing the wiring within the entry drum, rotors, reflector, and plugboard.[34]

French help

[edit]

At this point, Rejewski ran into difficulties due to the large number of unknowns in the set of equations that he had developed. He would later comment in 1980 that it was still not known whether such a set of six equations was solvable without further data.[35] But he was assisted by cryptographic documents that Section D of French military intelligence (the Deuxième Bureau), under future General Gustave Bertrand, had obtained and passed on to the Polish Cipher Bureau. The documents, procured from a spy in the German Cryptographic Service, Hans-Thilo Schmidt, included the Enigma settings for the months of September and October 1932. About 9 or 10 December 1932,[36][Note 5] the documents were given to Rejewski. They enabled him to reduce the number of unknowns and solve the wirings of the rotors and reflector.[38]

There was another obstacle to overcome, however. The military Enigma had been modified from the commercial Enigma, of which Rejewski had had an actual example to study. In the commercial machine, the keys were connected to the entry drum in German keyboard order ("QWERTZU..."). However, in the military Enigma, the connections had instead been wired in alphabetical order: "ABCDEF..." This new wiring sequence foiled British cryptologists working on Enigma, who dismissed the "ABCDEF..." wiring as too obvious. Rejewski, perhaps guided by an intuition about a German fondness for order, simply guessed that the wiring was the normal alphabetic ordering. He later recalled that, after he had made this assumption, "from my pencil, as by magic, began to issue numbers designating the connections in rotor N. Thus the connections in one rotor, the right-hand rotor, were finally known."[35]

The settings provided by French Intelligence covered two months that straddled a changeover period for the rotor ordering. A different rotor happened to be in the right-hand position for the second month, and so the wirings of two rotors could be recovered by the same method.[Note 6] Rejewski later recalled: "Finding the [wiring] in the third [rotor], and especially... in the [reflector], now presented no great difficulties. Likewise there were no difficulties with determining the correct torsion of the [rotors'] side walls with respect to each other, or the moments when the left and middle drums turned." By year's end 1932, the wirings of all three rotors and the reflector had been recovered. A sample message in an Enigma instruction manual, providing a plaintext and its corresponding ciphertext produced using a stated daily key and message key, helped clarify some remaining details.[35]

There has been speculation as to whether the rotor wirings could have been solved without the documents supplied by French Intelligence. Rejewski recalled in 1980 that another way had been found that could have been used to solve the wirings, but that the method was "imperfect and tedious" and relied on chance. In 2005, mathematician John Lawrence claimed that it would have taken four years for this method to have had a reasonable likelihood of success.[39] Rejewski had earlier written that "the conclusion is that the intelligence material furnished to us should be regarded as having been decisive to solution of the machine."[35]

Solving daily settings

[edit]

After Rejewski had determined the wiring in the remaining rotors, he was joined in early 1933 by Różycki and Zygalski in devising methods and equipment to break Enigma ciphers routinely. Rejewski later recalled:

Now we had the machine, but we didn't have the keys and we couldn't very well require Bertrand to keep on supplying us with the keys every month ... The situation had reversed itself: before, we'd had the keys but we hadn't had the machine—we solved the machine; now we had the machine but we didn't have the keys. We had to work out methods to find the daily keys.[40]

Early methods

[edit]
Cyclometer, devised in the mid-1930s by Rejewski to catalog the cycle structure of Enigma permutations.

A number of methods and devices had to be invented in response to continual improvements in German operating procedure and to the Enigma machine itself. The earliest method for reconstructing daily keys was the "grill", based on the fact that the plugboard's connections exchanged only six pairs of letters, leaving fourteen letters unchanged.[22] Next was Różycki's "clock" method, which sometimes made it possible to determine which rotor was at the right-hand side of the Enigma machine on a given day.[41]

After 1 October 1936, German procedure changed, and the number of plugboard connections became variable, ranging between five and eight. As a result, the grill method became considerably less effective.[22] However, a method using a card catalog had been devised around 1934 or 1935, and was independent of the number of plug connections. The catalog was constructed using Rejewski's "cyclometer", a special-purpose device for creating a catalog of permutations. Once the catalog was complete, the permutation could be looked up in the catalog, yielding the Enigma rotor settings for that day.[22]

The cyclometer comprised two sets of Enigma rotors, and was used to determine the length and number of cycles of the permutations that could be generated by the Enigma machine. Even with the cyclometer, preparing the catalog was a long and difficult task. Each position of the Enigma machine (there were 17,576 positions) had to be examined for each possible sequence of rotors (there were 6 possible sequences); therefore, the catalog comprised 105,456 entries. Preparation of the catalog took over a year, but when it was ready about 1935, it made obtaining daily keys a matter of 12–20 minutes.[22][42] However, on 1 or 2 November 1937, the Germans replaced the reflector in their Enigma machines, which meant that the entire catalog had to be recalculated from scratch.[22] Nonetheless, by January 1938 the Cipher Bureau's German section was reading a remarkable 75% of Enigma intercepts, and according to Rejewski, with a minimal increase in personnel this could have been increased to 90%.[43]

Bomba and sheets

[edit]
Zygalski sheet

In 1937 Rejewski, along with the German section of the Cipher Bureau, transferred to a secret facility near Pyry in the Kabaty Woods south of Warsaw. On 15 September 1938, the Germans introduced new rules for enciphering message keys (a new "indicator procedure"), making the Poles' earlier techniques obsolete.[Note 7] The Polish cryptanalysts rapidly responded with new techniques. One was Rejewski's bomba, an electrically powered aggregate of six Enigmas, which solved the daily keys within about two hours. Six bombas were built and were ready for use by mid-November 1938.[46] The bomba exploited the fact that the plugboard connections did not affect all the letters; therefore, when another change to German operating procedure occurred on 1 January 1939, increasing the number of plugboard connections, the usefulness of the bombas was greatly reduced. The British bombe, the main tool that would be used to break Enigma messages during World War II, would be named after, and likely inspired by, the Polish bomba, though the cryptologic methods embodied in the two machines were different.[47]

Around the same time as Rejewski's bomba, a manual method was invented by Henryk Zygalski, that of "perforated sheets" ("Zygalski sheets"), which was independent of the number of plugboard connections. Rejewski describes the construction of the Zygalski mechanism and its manipulation:

Fairly thick paper sheets, lettered "a" through "z", were prepared for all twenty-six possible positions of rotor L [the left-hand Enigma rotor] and a square was drawn on each sheet, divided into 51 by 51 smaller squares. The sides, top, and bottom of each large square (it could as well be a rectangle) were lettered "a" through "z" and then again "a" through "y". This was, as it were, a system of coordinates in which the abscissas and ordinates marked successive possible positions of rotors M [the middle Enigma rotor] and N [the right-hand Enigma rotor], and each little square marked permutations, with or without constant points, corresponding to those positions. Cases with constant points were perforated.[48] [E]ach constant point had to be perforated as many as four times. [...] When the sheets were superposed and moved in the proper sequence and the proper manner with respect to each other, in accordance with a [precisely] defined program, the number of visible apertures gradually decreased. And, if a sufficient quantity of data was available, there finally remained a single aperture, probably corresponding to the right case, that is, to the solution. From the position of the aperture one could calculate the order of the rotors, the setting of their rings, and, by comparing the letters of the cipher keys with the letters in the machine, likewise permutation S; in other words, the entire cipher key.[49]

However, application of both the bomba and Zygalski sheets was complicated by yet another change to the Enigma machine on 15 December 1938. The Germans had supplied Enigma operators with an additional two rotors to supplement the original three, and this increased the complexity of decryption tenfold. Building ten times as many bombas (60 would now be needed) was beyond the Cipher Bureau's ability—that many bombas would have cost fifteen times its entire annual equipment budget.[50]

Two and a half weeks later, effective 1 January 1939, the Germans increased the number of plug connections to 7–10, which, writes Rejewski, "to a great degree, decreased the usefulness of the bombs." Zygalski's perforated ("Zygalski") sheets, writes Rejewski, "like the card-catalog method, was independent of the number of plug connections. But the manufacture of these sheets, [...] in our [...] circumstances, was very time-consuming, so that by 15 December 1938, only one-third of the whole job had been done. [T]he Germans' [introduction of rotors] IV and V [...] increased the labor of making the sheets tenfold [since 60, or ten times as many, sets of sheets were now needed], considerably exceeding our [...] capacities."[51]

Allies informed

[edit]
2002 plaque, Bletchley Park, "commemorat[ing] the work of Marian Rejewski, Jerzy Różycki, and Henryk Zygalski, mathematicians of the Polish intelligence service, in first breaking the Enigma code [sic: it was a cipher]. Their work greatly assisted the Bletchley Park code breakers and contributed to the Allied victory in World War II."

As it became clear that war was imminent and that Polish financial resources were insufficient to keep pace with the evolution of Enigma encryption (e.g., due to the prohibitive expense of an additional 54 bombas and due to the Poles' difficulty in producing in timely fashion the full 60 series of 26 "Zygalski sheets"[52]), the Polish General Staff and government decided to initiate their Western allies into the secrets of Enigma decryption.[53] The Polish methods were revealed to French and British intelligence representatives in a meeting at Pyry, south of Warsaw, on 25 July 1939. France was represented by Gustave Bertrand and Air Force cryptologist Captain Henri Braquenié; Britain, by Government Code and Cypher School chief Alastair Denniston, veteran cryptologist Alfred Dillwyn Knox, and Commander Humphrey Sandwith, head of the section that had developed and controlled the Royal Navy's intercept and direction-finding stations. The Polish hosts included Cipher Bureau chief Gwido Langer, the Bureau's German-Section chief Maksymilian Ciężki, the Bureau's General-Staff-Intelligence supervisor Stefan Mayer, and the three cryptologists Rejewski, Różycki and Zygalski.[54]

The Poles' gift of Enigma decryption to their Western allies, five weeks before the outbreak of World War II, came not a moment too soon. Knowledge that the cipher was crackable was a morale boost to Allied cryptologists.[Note 8] The British were able to manufacture at least two complete sets of perforated sheets—they sent one to PC Bruno, outside Paris,[57] in mid-December 1939—and began reading Enigma within months of the outbreak of war.[Note 9]

Without the Polish assistance, British cryptologists would, at the very least, have been considerably delayed in reading Enigma. Hugh Sebag-Montefiore concludes that substantial breaks into German Army and Air Force Enigma ciphers by the British would have occurred only after November 1941 at the earliest, after an Enigma machine and key lists had been captured, and similarly into Naval Enigma only after late 1942.[59]

Intelligence gained from solving high-level German ciphers—intelligence codenamed Ultra by the British and Americans—came chiefly from Enigma decrypts. While the exact contribution of Ultra intelligence to Allied victory is disputed, Kozaczuk and Straszak note that "it is widely believed that Ultra saved the world at least two years of war and possibly prevented Hitler from winning."[60] The English historian Sir Harry Hinsley, who worked at Bletchley Park, similarly assessed it as having "shortened the war by not less than two years and probably by four years".[61] The availability of Ultra was due to the earlier Polish breaking of Enigma; Gordon Welchman, head of Bletchley Park's Hut 6 (which solved German Army and Air Force Enigma ciphers), writes: "Hut 6 Ultra would never have gotten off the ground if we had not learned from the Poles, in the nick of time, the details both of the German military version of the commercial Enigma machine, and of the operating procedures that were in use."[62][Note 10]

In France and Britain

[edit]

PC Bruno

[edit]

On 5 September 1939 the Cipher Bureau began preparations to evacuate key personnel and equipment from Warsaw. Soon a special evacuation train, the Echelon F, transported them eastward, then south. By the time the Cipher Bureau was ordered to cross the border into allied Romania on 17 September, they had destroyed all sensitive documents and equipment and were down to a single very crowded truck. The vehicle was confiscated at the border by a Romanian officer, who separated the military from the civilian personnel. Taking advantage of the confusion, the three mathematicians ignored the Romanian's instructions. They anticipated that in an internment camp they might be identified by the Romanian security police, in which the German Abwehr and SD had informers. The mathematicians went to the nearest railroad station, exchanged money, bought tickets, and boarded the first train headed south. After a dozen or so hours, they reached Bucharest, at the other end of Romania. There they went to the British embassy. Told by the British to "come back in a few days", they next tried the French embassy, introducing themselves as "friends of Bolek" (Bertrand's Polish code name) and asking to speak with a French military officer. A French Army colonel telephoned Paris and then issued instructions for the three Poles to be assisted in evacuating to Paris.[64]

On 20 October 1939 the three Polish cryptologists resumed work on German ciphers at a joint French–Polish–(anti-fascist) Spanish radio-intelligence unit stationed at Gretz-Armainvilliers, forty kilometers northeast of Paris, and housed in the Château de Vignolles (code-named PC Bruno).[65]

As late as 3–7 December 1939, when Lt. Col. Langer and French Air Force Capt. Henri Braquenié visited London and Bletchley Park, the British asked that the Polish cryptologists be made available to them in Britain. Langer, however, took the position that they must remain where the Polish Army in exile was forming—on French soil.[66]

On 17 January 1940 the Poles found the first Enigma key to be solved in France, one for 28 October 1939.[67] The PC Bruno staff collaborated by teleprinter with counterparts at Bletchley Park in England. For their mutual communications security, the Polish, French, and British cryptologic agencies used the Enigma machine itself. Bruno closed its Enigma-encrypted messages to Britain with an ironic "Heil Hitler!"[68]

In the first months of 1940, Alan Turing—principal designer of the British cryptological Bombe, elaborated from the Polish bomba—would visit Bruno to confer about Enigma decryption with the three Polish cryptologists.[69]

On 24 June 1940, after Germany's victory in the Battle of France, Gustave Bertrand flew Bruno's international personnel—including fifteen Poles, and seven Spaniards who worked on Italian ciphers[70]—in three planes to Algeria.[71]

Cadix

[edit]

Some three months later, in September 1940, they returned to work covertly in unoccupied southern, Vichy France. Rejewski's cover was as Pierre Ranaud, a lycée professor from Nantes. A radio-intelligence station was set up at the Château des Fouzes, code-named Cadix, near Uzès. Cadix began operations on 1 October. Rejewski and his colleagues solved German telegraph ciphers, and also the Swiss version of the Enigma machine (which had no plugboard).[72] Rejewski may have had little or no involvement in working on German Enigma at Cadix.[Note 11]

In early July 1941, Rejewski and Zygalski were asked to try solving messages enciphered on the secret Polish Lacida cipher machine, which was used for secure communications between Cadix and the Polish General Staff in London. Lacida was a rotor machine based on the same cryptographic principle as Enigma, yet had never been subjected to rigorous security analysis. The two cryptologists created consternation by breaking the first message within a couple of hours; further messages were solved in a similar way.[75]

The youngest of the three Polish mathematicians who had worked together since 1929—Jerzy Różycki—died in the sinking of a French passenger ship on 9 January 1942, as he was returning to Cadix from a stint in Algeria.[76] By summer 1942 work at Cadix was becoming dangerous, and plans for evacuation were drawn up. Vichy France was liable to be occupied by German troops, and Cadix's radio transmissions were increasingly at risk of detection by the German Funkabwehr, a unit tasked with locating enemy radio transmitters. Indeed, on 6 November a pickup truck equipped with a circular antenna arrived at the gate of the Château des Fouzes where the cryptologists were operating. The visitors, however, did not enter, and merely investigated nearby farms, badly frightening their occupants. Nonetheless, at Bertrand's suggestion French intelligence ordered the evacuation of Cadix. The order was carried out on 9 November, the day after the Allied "Operation Torch" landings in North Africa. Three days later, on 12 November, the Germans occupied the chateau.[77]

Escaping France

[edit]

The Poles were split into groups of two and three. On 11 November 1942, Rejewski and Zygalski were sent to Nice, in the Italian-occupied zone. After coming under suspicion there, they had to flee again, moving or hiding constantly. Their trek took them to Cannes, Antibes, back to Nice, then on to Marseille, Toulouse, Narbonne, Perpignan, and Ax-les-Thermes, near the Spanish border.[78] On 29 January 1943, accompanied by a local guide, Rejewski, and Zygalski, bound for Spain, began a climb over the Pyrenees, avoiding German and Vichy patrols. Near midnight, close to the Spanish border, the guide pulled out a pistol and demanded that they hand over their remaining money.[79]

After being robbed, Rejewski and Zygalski succeeded in reaching the Spanish side of the border, only to be arrested within hours by security police.[80] They were sent first to a prison in La Seu d'Urgell, then on 24 March transferred to a prison at Lerida. On 4 May 1943, after having spent over three months in Spanish prisons, on intervention by the Polish Red Cross the pair were released and sent to Madrid.[81] Leaving there on 21 July,[82] they made it to Portugal; from there, aboard HMS Scottish, to Gibraltar; and then by air to RAF Hendon in north London, arriving on 3 August 1943.[83]

Britain

[edit]
Marian Rejewski, second lieutenant (signals), Polish Army in Britain, in late 1943 or in 1944, 11 or 12 years after he first broke Enigma

Rejewski and Zygalski were inducted as privates into the Polish Armed Forces on 16 August 1943 and were posted to a Polish Army facility in Stanmore Park, cracking German SS and SD hand ciphers. The ciphers were usually based on the Doppelkassettenverfahren ("double Playfair") system, which the two cryptologists had already worked on in France.[84] British cryptologist Alan Stripp suggests that "Setting them to work on the Doppelkassetten system was like using racehorses to pull wagons."[85] On 10 October 1943, Rejewski and Zygalski were commissioned second lieutenants;[86] on 1 January 1945 Rejewski, and presumably also Zygalski, were promoted to lieutenant.[87] When Gustave Bertrand fled to England in June 1944, he and his wife were provided with a house in Boxmoor, a short walk from the Polish radio station and cryptology office, where it seems likely that his collaboration with Rejewski and Zygalski continued.[77]

Enigma decryption, however, had become an exclusively British and American domain; the Polish mathematicians who had laid the foundations for Allied Enigma decryption were now excluded from making further contributions in this area.[88] By that time, at Bletchley Park, "very few even knew about the Polish contribution" because of the strict secrecy and the "need-to-know" principle.[85]

Back in Poland

[edit]

After the Germans suppressed the 1944 Warsaw Uprising, they sent Rejewski's wife and children west, along with other Warsaw survivors; the family eventually found refuge with her parents in Bydgoszcz.[20] Rejewski was discharged from the Polish Army in Britain on 15 November 1946. Six days later, he returned to Poland to be reunited with his wife and family.[20] On his return, he was urged by his old Poznań University professor, Zdzisław Krygowski, to take a university mathematics post at Poznań or Szczecin, in western Poland. Rejewski could have looked forward to rapid advancement because of personnel shortages as a result of the war. However, he was still recovering from rheumatism, which he had contracted in the Spanish prisons. Soon after his return to Poland, in the summer of 1947, his 11-year-old son Andrzej died of polio after only five days' illness. After his son's death, Rejewski did not want to part, even briefly, with his wife and daughter, so they lived in Bydgoszcz with his in-laws.[20] He took a position in Bydgoszcz as director of the sales department at a cable-manufacturing company, Kabel Polski (Polish Cable).[89]

2005 Bydgoszcz memorial unveiled on the centennial of Rejewski's birth. It resembles the Alan Turing Memorial in Manchester.
2005 Polish prepaid postcard, on centennial of Rejewski's birth

Between 1949 and 1958 Rejewski was repeatedly investigated by the Polish Office of Public Security, who suspected he was a former member of the Polish Armed Forces in the West.[90] He retired in 1967, and moved with his family back to Warsaw in 1969, to an apartment he had acquired 30 years earlier with financial help from his father-in-law.[20]

Rejewski had written a "Report of Cryptologic Work on the German Enigma Machine Cipher" in 1942.[91] Before his 1967 retirement, he began writing his "Memoirs of My Work in the Cipher Bureau of Section II of the [Polish] General Staff", which were purchased by the Polish Military Historical Institute [pl], in Warsaw.[20] Rejewski had often wondered what use Alan Turing (who in early 1940 had visited the Polish cryptologists at PC Bruno outside Paris[69]) and the British at Bletchley Park had ultimately made of the Polish discoveries and inventions. For nearly three decades after the war, little was publicly known due to a ban imposed in 1945 by British Prime Minister Winston Churchill.[92] In a 1967 book[93] Władysław Kozaczuk, associated with the Military Historical Institute, disclosed Poland's breaking of the German Enigma ciphers.

Until 1974, the scant information published concerning Enigma decryption attracted little attention. Ladislas Farago's 1971 best-seller The Game of the Foxes presented a garbled account of Ultra's origins: "Commander Denniston went clandestinely to a secluded Polish castle [sic] on the eve of the war [to pick up an Enigma, 'the Wehrmacht's top system' during World War II]. Dilly Knox later solved its keying [sic]..."[94] Still, this was marginally closer to the truth than many British and American best-seller accounts that would follow after 1974. Their authors were at a disadvantage: they did not know that the founder of Enigma decryption, Rejewski, was still alive and alert, and that it was reckless to fabricate stories out of whole cloth.[Note 12]

Rejewski's grave in Powązki Military Cemetery, Warsaw

With Gustave Bertrand's 1973 publication of his Enigma, substantial information about the origins of Ultra began to seep out; and with F. W. Winterbotham's 1974 best-seller, The Ultra Secret, the dam began to burst. Still, many aspiring authors were not averse to filling gaps in their information with whole-cloth fabrications. Rejewski fought a gallant (if, into the 21st century, not entirely successful) fight to get the truth before the public. He published a number of papers on his cryptologic work and contributed generously to articles, books, and television programs. He was interviewed by scholars, journalists, and television crews from Poland, East Germany, the United States, Britain, Sweden, Belgium, the Soviet Union, Yugoslavia, and Brazil.[96]

Rejewski maintained a lively correspondence with his wartime French host, General Gustave Bertrand, and at the General's bidding he began translating Bertrand's Enigma into Polish.[96] In 1976, at the request of the Józef Piłsudski Institute of America, Rejewski broke enciphered correspondence of Józef Piłsudski and his fellow Polish Socialist conspirators from 1904.[97] On 12 August 1978 he received from a grateful Polish people the Officer's Cross of the Order of Polonia Restituta.[96]

Rejewski, who had been suffering from heart disease, died of a heart attack on 13 February 1980, aged 74, after returning home from a shopping trip. He was buried with military honors at Warsaw's Powązki Military Cemetery.[20]

Recognition

[edit]
2007 monument to cryptologists Rejewski, Różycki, and Zygalski before Imperial Castle, Poznań University

On 21 July 2000, Poland's President Aleksander Kwaśniewski posthumously awarded Poland's second-highest civilian decoration, the Grand Cross of the Order of Polonia Restituta, to Marian Rejewski and Henryk Zygalski.[1] In July 2005 Rejewski's daughter, Janina Sylwestrzak, received on his behalf the War Medal 1939–1945 from the British Chief of the Defence Staff.[2] On 1 August 2012 Marian Rejewski posthumously received the Knowlton Award of the U.S. Military Intelligence Corps Association;[98] his daughter Janina accepted the award at his home town, Bydgoszcz, on 4 September 2012. Rejewski had been nominated for the Award by NATO Allied Command Counterintelligence.[3]

In 2009, the Polish Post issued a series of four commemorative stamps, one of which pictured Rejewski and fellow mathematician-cryptologists Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zygalski.[99]

On 5 August 2014 the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) honored Rejewski, Różycki, and Zygalski with its prestigious Milestone Award, which recognizes achievements that have changed the world. The award was given for "the first breaking of Enigma ciphers by the Polish Cipher Bureau, in 1932-1939." Their work was the foundation for British cipher-breaking efforts which helped end World War II.[4][5]

A three-sided bronze monument was dedicated in 2007 in front of the Imperial Castle in Poznań. Each side bears the name of one of the three Polish mathematicians who broke the Enigma cipher.[100]

Rejewski and colleagues were the heroes of Sekret Enigmy (The Enigma Secret), a thriller movie about the Poles' solution of the German Enigma cipher. Late 1980 also saw a Polish TV series with a similar theme, Tajemnice Enigmy ("The Secrets of Enigma").[101]

In 2017, a contest was held to design a mural commemorating Rejewski. The winning entry, Odszyfrowany Rejewski ("Rejewski Decrypted") by Juliusz Nowicki was painted on Rejewski's former residence on Gdańska Street in Bydgoszcz later that year.[102]

In 2021 the Enigma Cipher Centre, an educational and scientific institution dedicated to the Polish mathematicians who broke the Enigma cipher, including Marian Rejewski, opened in Poznań.[103]

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
Marian Adam Rejewski (16 August 1905 – 13 February 1980) was a Polish mathematician and cryptologist who in late 1932 mathematically reconstructed the wiring of the German military Enigma cipher machine without access to a physical example, enabling systematic decryption of intercepted messages.[1][2]
Working at the Polish General Staff's Cipher Bureau in Warsaw with mathematicians Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zygalski, Rejewski applied permutation group theory and empirical analysis of message characteristics to solve the Enigma's core substitution, producing daily keys and developing specialized tools like the electromechanical bomba for automation.[1][2]
In July 1939, the Poles transferred their methods, partial Enigma replicas, and decryption techniques to French and British cryptanalysts at Pyry near Warsaw, providing a critical foundation for wartime Allied successes against enhanced Enigma variants at Bletchley Park.[1] Following the 1939 Soviet and German invasions of Poland, Rejewski escaped to continue cryptanalytic work in southern France and then Britain, though he contributed less directly after Enigma modifications outpaced initial Polish approaches.[1] Postwar, under Poland's communist government, his intelligence background barred him from academic positions, confining him to accounting until retirement; full recognition came posthumously through declassified records and Western honors.[1][3]

Early Years

Childhood and Family Background

Marian Rejewski was born on 16 August 1905 in Bromberg (now Bydgoszcz), in the Prussian Province of Posen, part of the German Empire.[1] [4] His parents were Józef Rejewski, a cigar and tobacco merchant, and Matylda, née Thoms, who lived together with their son in an apartment house at Wileńska 6 street in the city.[1] [5] [4] Although Bydgoszcz had a Polish ethnic majority, the region remained under German administration until Poland's independence in 1918, shaping the bilingual environment of Rejewski's early years.[1] In 1912, at age seven, Rejewski began primary school in Bydgoszcz.[4] He continued his education at the German-speaking Königliches Gymnasium of Bromberg (later renamed Fryderyk Wilhelm Royal Gymnasium), transitioning after independence to the Polish-administered State Classical Gymnasium.[1] [4] [5] From a young age, he displayed a strong interest in exact sciences, laying the groundwork for his later mathematical pursuits.[5] Rejewski graduated from the gymnasium in 1923.[1] [5]

Mathematical Education and Early Influences

Rejewski was born on 16 August 1905 in Bydgoszcz (then Bromberg, under Prussian partition), to a cigar merchant father and a homemaker mother, in a family that valued education despite modest means.[1] He attended the Königliches Gymnasium in Bydgoszcz, a prestigious German-language secondary school, where he demonstrated early aptitude in mathematics and physics, graduating in 1923.[1] In 1923, Rejewski enrolled at Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań to study mathematics at the Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, completing his undergraduate studies and remaining for a master's degree.[1] [6] His master's thesis, supervised by Professor Zdzisław Krygowski, focused on doubly periodic functions and was awarded on 1 March 1929.[1] [7] Krygowski, recognizing Rejewski's exceptional analytical skills from an early stage, provided pivotal mentorship, including recommending him for advanced opportunities and offering a teaching assistant position upon his return from abroad.[7] A key early influence occurred in March 1929, when Krygowski selected Rejewski for a secret cryptology course organized by the Polish Cipher Bureau at Poznań University, targeting top German-speaking mathematics students.[6] [8] Although Rejewski did not complete the course, it introduced him to cryptographic principles, bridging his mathematical training with practical codebreaking applications.[1] That year, he briefly pursued further studies in Göttingen, Germany, enrolling in a two-year actuarial statistics program, but departed in summer 1930 to assume teaching duties at Poznań University.[1] These experiences, grounded in rigorous permutation theory and function analysis under Krygowski's guidance, laid the theoretical foundation for Rejewski's later innovations in cryptanalysis.[7]

Pre-War Cryptographic Breakthroughs

Recruitment to the Polish Cipher Bureau

By 1932, the Polish Cipher Bureau (Biuro Szyfrów), part of the Second Department of the General Staff, had been attempting to read German Enigma-encrypted messages since the mid-1920s but achieved no breakthroughs using philological and manual cryptanalytic techniques. Recognizing the limitations of these approaches, Bureau leadership, including Maksymilian Ciężki, head of the German section, shifted strategy toward recruiting mathematically adept individuals capable of applying permutation theory and statistical methods to the problem. The Bureau targeted recent mathematics graduates from Poznań's Adam Mickiewicz University who possessed strong German language skills, essential for handling intercepted diplomatic and military traffic.[9] In September 1932, three top students were selected: Marian Rejewski, Henryk Zygalski, and Jerzy Różycki, all alumni of Poznań University with master's degrees in mathematics. Rejewski, born on August 16, 1906, had completed his degree in 1929 under professors including Włodzimierz Stożek and Zdzisław Krygowski, and further honed his analytical skills during a 1930–1931 fellowship at Germany's University of Göttingen, where he studied under Max Born and encountered advanced German mathematical texts. This background positioned him uniquely for the task, as the Enigma's wiring represented unknown permutations amenable to group-theoretic analysis. The recruits underwent initial training in Warsaw before assignment to the Bureau's Enigma subsection (BS-4).[10][9] Rejewski commenced dedicated analysis of Enigma message characteristics in October 1932, initially without machine access but using perforated message sheets and theoretical modeling. The team's formal integration marked a pivotal causal shift, enabling systematic progress where prior efforts had stalled due to inadequate mathematical framing of the cipher's daily key settings and rotor wirings.[2]

Reconstruction of Enigma's Internal Wiring

In January 1932, Marian Rejewski joined the Polish Cipher Bureau's German section (BS-4) in Warsaw, tasked with cryptanalyzing the Enigma machine used by the German military. Armed with intercepts provided by French intelligence—primarily from December 1931 traffic—and partial knowledge of the commercial Enigma's structure, Rejewski lacked the internal wiring details of the military rotors I, II, and III, as well as the reflector.[11] The breakthrough relied on the German operators' procedure of enciphering the three-letter message key twice consecutively in the initial six characters of each message, creating observable chains in the ciphertext that reflected the machine's permutation behavior across six successive right-rotor positions.[12] Rejewski applied permutation group theory to model the Enigma's encryption process as a composition of fixed rotor wirings, the reflector, and variable daily settings including rotor order and starting positions. By constructing graphs from these indicator chains—linking ciphertext letters that corresponded to the same plaintext under rotor advancement—he derived the cycle structures of key permutations, such as the product of the Enigma permutation and its inverse shifted by three positions. This approach reduced the vast number of possible wirings (initially on the order of 10^14 for three rotors) to a solvable set through algebraic constraints and manual computation, assuming the plugboard's effect could be isolated or approximated initially.[11][13] By late November 1932, Rejewski had deduced the wiring for the first rotor, followed by the second and third by early December, enabling reconstruction of the full core mechanism. Collaborating with Jerzy Różycki, he then determined the reflector's pairings, confirming the model's accuracy against additional intercepts. This mathematical reconstruction, achieved without physical access to a machine, allowed the Poles to simulate Enigma encryptions and pursue daily key recovery, marking the first systematic break into the cipher.[14][15]

Acquisition of French Intelligence

The Polish Cipher Bureau's efforts to cryptanalyze the German Enigma machine had stalled by early 1932, prompting collaboration with allied intelligence services. French Deuxième Bureau obtained critical Enigma materials from Hans-Thilo Schmidt, a German Chiffrierstelle official codenamed "Asché," who initiated contact in March 1931 and supplied documents over subsequent meetings.[16][17] Schmidt provided an Enigma operating handbook detailing procedures such as message key encipherment—where the operator's chosen three-letter key was doubled and enciphered under daily settings—along with sample daily key configurations.[18][17] The French, lacking the mathematical expertise to exploit these fully, shared portions with Poland during a December 1931 meeting between Cipher Bureau head Gwido Langer and French counterparts, including initial procedural documents.[15] Further deliveries followed in 1932, with Schmidt furnishing key sheets to French handlers in summer meetings; these covered daily settings for September and October 1932, including rotor selections, ringstellung (ring settings), grundstellung (ground settings for key encipherment), and steckerbrett (plugboard) connections.[19][15] The materials arrived in Warsaw by December 1932, formatted as perforated zettel (slips) for secure distribution, enabling correlation with Polish-intercepted Enigma traffic from those months.[15][18] This intelligence transfer, coordinated by Gustave Bertrand, marked a turning point, as prior Polish attempts relied solely on a commercial Enigma variant differing from the military model in rotor wirings and features.[17] The shared data provided verifiable plaintext-ciphertext pairs from key encipherments, essential for permutation-based reconstruction without direct access to machine internals. Schmidt's ongoing supply—over 20 contacts through 1938—ensured periodic updates, though the 1932 batch proved decisive for initial breakthroughs.[16][19]

Methods for Decrypting Daily Settings

Following the reconstruction of the Enigma machine's internal rotor and reflector wirings in December 1932, Marian Rejewski turned to recovering the variable daily settings, which comprised the selection and order of rotors, their ring settings, and the plugboard pairings.[11] These settings transformed the core permutation of the machine, rendering each day's traffic a distinct cipher.[2] Rejewski's approach leveraged the standardized German procedure for transmitting message keys: operators selected a random three-letter key, set the machine to the fixed daily Grundstellung position, and enciphered it twice consecutively, yielding six indicator letters prefixed to each message.[11] This repetition created detectable patterns, as the fourth letter was the encipherment of the same plaintext as the first but after three rotor advances, and similarly for the other pairs.[20] From approximately 50 to 100 daily messages, Rejewski aggregated the indicator pairs to construct three characteristic permutations: A mapping first letters to fourth, B second to fifth, and C third to sixth.[11] Each permutation represented the composition of the Enigma's decryption at the initial position followed by encryption shifted by three steps, equivalent to E_{G+3} \circ E_G^{-1}, where G denotes the Grundstellung and E the machine's action.[20] Because the plugboard S acted symmetrically before and after the core mechanism K (rotors and reflector), the characteristic permutation took the form P = S \cdot Q \cdot S, where Q was the shifted core permutation independent of S.[21] Consequently, the cycle decomposition of P matched that of Q exactly, unaffected by the plugboard.[20] The observed cycle structures of A, B, and C thus directly revealed properties of the core, enabling identification of the rotor order among the six possible permutations of the three available rotors.[11] Different orders produced distinct cycle length distributions for the three-step shift, precomputable from the known wirings.[22] With the order fixed, the relative consistency across A, B, and C—shifted versions of one another by one rotor step—permitted deduction of the ring settings, which adjusted the rotors' effective wirings via letter offsets.[20] Finally, substituting the candidate core permutation back into P = S \cdot Q \cdot S yielded equations solvable for the plugboard's 13 transpositions (or fewer, with fixed points), as mismatches in cycle alignments or fixed points eliminated incorrect trials.[11] This permutation-based technique, grounded in group theory and the Enigma's structural constraints (such as the reflector's pairing and absence of fixed points in core permutations), allowed manual recovery of daily settings within hours for early configurations.[2] By January 1933, it enabled decryption of roughly three-quarters of daily German Enigma traffic, though the process demanded 10 to 20 man-hours per key and struggled with incomplete message collections.[11] As German changes increased complexity—such as additional rotors in 1936—the method's scalability prompted development of aids like the cyclometer for precomputing cycle catalogs, but the core analytical framework remained permutation cycle analysis.[22]

Invention of Key Tools: Bomba and Zygalski Sheets

In response to German Enigma procedure changes implemented on 15 September 1938, which expanded the search space for rotor starting positions by a factor of 1,000 due to the introduction of "female" indicators in some messages, Marian Rejewski devised the Bomba, a specialized electromechanical device for recovering daily keys.[23] The Bomba consisted of six identical assemblies, each mimicking the Enigma's three-rotor setup, wired in parallel to simultaneously test all six possible rotor orders (III-II-I, III-I-II, etc.) against the observed encipherments of repeated message keys.[24] By exploiting the fixed relative positions and the cyclic structure of Enigma permutations—specifically, the fact that the repeated indicator produced detectable inconsistencies unless the rotor order matched—it could identify valid configurations in approximately two hours per daily key, assuming sufficient message traffic.[24] The Polish Cipher Bureau constructed six such machines by early 1939, enabling the team to decrypt an average of 65-75% of daily German Army and Air Force messages despite the added complexity.[15] As a complementary manual technique, Henryk Zygalski, working under Rejewski's direction, developed perforated cardboard sheets in autumn 1938 to pinpoint rotor orders and ring settings without machinery. Each sheet, sized approximately 6 by 26 inches and gridded into 26x26 cells corresponding to the alphabet, was perforated at positions representing the encipherment of one specific "female" indicator under all possible rotor alignments for a fixed order.[25] Stacking sheets aligned with observed six-letter chains (from the doubly enciphered message key plus a female indicator) allowed light to pass through overlapping holes only for compatible settings, typically reducing thousands of possibilities to one or two testable candidates via manual verification on replica Enigma machines.[23] Producing the full set required 1,560 sheets for the five available rotors—initially hand-punched by female clerks using mathematical tables, later mechanized—though degradation from repeated use and the need for secrecy limited their scalability.[25] This low-tech method proved reliable for sparse traffic days when the Bomba's mechanical synchronization faltered, sustaining Polish cryptanalytic output until further German alterations on 15 December 1938, which turned all indicators into females and demanded over 75 messages per key for viability, ultimately overwhelming both tools' efficiency.[23]

Intelligence Collaboration and Wartime Exile

Handover of Enigma Knowledge to Allies in 1939

In July 1939, following Anglo-French guarantees of military support to Poland against potential German aggression, the Polish Cipher Bureau elected to disclose its long-secret Enigma decryption capabilities to its Western allies, despite internal concerns over security risks.[26] This decision stemmed from the Bureau's recognition that Polish successes in breaking early Enigma variants were increasingly strained by German modifications, necessitating collaborative Allied efforts ahead of war.[27] The pivotal handover occurred during a clandestine meeting on 25–26 July 1939 in the Pyry forest complex south of Warsaw, hosted by Cipher Bureau head Colonel Gwido Langer.[28] Marian Rejewski, the mathematician who had pioneered Enigma's reconstruction in 1932, collaborated with colleagues Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zygalski to brief British delegates Alastair Denniston and Dilly Knox from the Government Code and Cypher School, as well as French intelligence representatives including Gustave Bertrand.[26] [28] Rejewski detailed his permutation-based mathematical methods for deducing rotor wirings from intercepted message characteristics, augmented by French-supplied German operator settings from 1931 spy Hans-Thilo Schmidt.[27] The Poles transferred two electromechanical replica Enigma machines—one to the British and one to the French—precisely rewired to match the German model's internal connections, enabling hands-on study.[28] They also shared operational insights into daily key recovery using Rejewski's Bomba device, which tested rotor starting positions via cycle detection, and Zygalski's perforated sheets for tracking message permutations amid Enigma's growing complexity.[26] [27] This comprehensive revelation, encompassing theoretical foundations, tools, and procedural adaptations, furnished the Allies with a foundational advantage, directly informing subsequent British developments like the Turing-Welchman Bombe at Bletchley Park.[27] Rejewski emphasized the urgency, noting that German Enigma enhancements post-1937 had reduced Polish decryption rates from near-daily to sporadic, underscoring the imperative for industrialized Allied cryptanalysis.[28] The exchange marked a rare pre-war instance of full inter-Allied cryptographic transparency, though Polish contributions remained underacknowledged until declassifications decades later.[26]

Operations at PC Bruno in France

Following the German invasion of Poland on September 1, 1939, Marian Rejewski and key members of the Polish Cipher Bureau's German section, including Henryk Zygalski and Jerzy Różycki, evacuated via Romania and arrived in France by late September. Under the supervision of Polish military intelligence chief Gwido Langer and French liaison Gustave Bertrand, they established PC Bruno—a secretive signals intelligence station—in the Château de Vignol at Gretz-Armainvilliers, southeast of Paris, in October 1939.[29][30] The facility, financed by the French army and incorporating Spanish Republican exiles for radio interception, focused on intercepting and decrypting German Enigma-encrypted communications, building on pre-war Polish techniques.[30] Rejewski's team adapted their earlier methods, including Zygalski perforated sheets for identifying daily wheel settings and cyclometers for permutation analysis, supplemented by Polish-built Enigma replicas and the bomba kryptologiczna electromechanical device for testing plugboard configurations.[29] Despite German procedural changes—such as increased message keys and turnover notches—the Poles achieved their first Enigma decryption at PC Bruno on January 17, 1940, recovering a message originating from October 28, 1939.[29] Operations intensified through spring 1940, yielding decrypts of Luftwaffe, Heer, SS, police, and diplomatic traffic that revealed German military orders, including preparations for the invasions of Norway (April 1940) and the Western Front (May 1940).[30] Notably, by May 26, 1940, the team decrypted details of Operation Paula, a Luftwaffe bombing campaign against French airfields, providing actionable intelligence to the French General Staff.[30] PC Bruno maintained a teleprinter link with Britain's Government Code and Cypher School at Bletchley Park, sharing key findings and cribs to accelerate Allied Enigma recovery, though British decrypts lagged initially due to resource constraints.[29] The station's outputs contributed to several thousand Enigma messages broken between January and June 1940, emphasizing the Polish team's efficiency in manual and semi-mechanized cryptanalysis amid limited manpower—typically under 20 Poles—and rudimentary computing aids.[29] Challenges included signal interception delays from distant German transmitters and the need to counter Enigma variants without full German traffic access, yet the operation validated Rejewski's permutation-group theory as foundational for wartime codebreaking.[29] As German forces advanced during the Battle of France, PC Bruno evacuated on June 10, 1940, with personnel and equipment dispersing southward; Rejewski and core cryptologists relocated to Algeria briefly before establishing the successor site, Cadix, in unoccupied France.[29][30]

Work at Cadix and Team Challenges

Following the German occupation of northern France in June 1940, Rejewski and the surviving Polish cryptologists relocated from PC Bruno to the Château des Fouzes near Uzès in the Vichy-controlled unoccupied zone, establishing PC Cadix in September or November 1940 under the administrative oversight of French Major Gustave Bertrand while operationally reporting to the Polish General Staff in London—a dual structure kept secret from the French.[1][31] There, Rejewski, Henryk Zygalski, and a reduced team including Antoni Palluth focused on decrypting Enigma traffic as "L'équipe Z," processing approximately 4,000 messages, including early reports on Einsatzgruppen atrocities, and tackling non-Enigma ciphers such as columnar transpositions and Playfair variants to support French counterintelligence efforts, like identifying German agents leading to arrests in Marseille hotels.[31] The team supplemented French intercepts from the Groupement des Contrôles Radioélectriques (GCR) with their own radio equipment due to persistent technical failures in French systems, enabling breaks into German teletype ciphers (e.g., Source K from October 1941) to safeguard Allied communications, though overall output was constrained by sparse traffic and German procedural changes.[31] Decrypts were transmitted via the Polish "Rygor" radio network, coordinated from Algiers by Maksymilian Ciężki until 1942, but the Poles operated in isolation from Bertrand's French and Antonio Camazón's Spanish teams, exacerbating coordination issues.[31] Challenges intensified from resource shortages, including inadequate cipher material and equipment inferior to that at Bletchley Park, compounded by the death of Jerzy Różycki on January 9, 1942, when his ship sank en route from Algiers, leaving the core mathematical team depleted.[1] Interpersonal and command tensions emerged, with Rejewski later alleging Bertrand's obstructionism during evacuation planning, while Bertrand cited Polish alcohol consumption and resistance to his directives as factors in the discord.[31] The Allied landings in North Africa on November 8, 1942, prompted German and Italian occupation of Vichy France ("Fall Anton") on November 10, forcing evacuation; a submarine escape failed due to Italian blockades, leading Rejewski and Zygalski to cross the Pyrenees into Spain on January 29–30, 1943, where they faced internment in camps like Séo de Urgel and Lerida until release on May 24, 1943, before reaching Britain on August 3.[1] Langer and Ciężki were captured on March 10–11, 1943, after a botched crossing involving a suspected collaborator, highlighting the perils of clandestine flight amid Vichy-German collaboration risks.[31]

Escape from Occupied France

Following the German occupation of the Vichy Free Zone on November 11, 1942, during Operation Anton, the cryptologic team at PC Cadix in the Pyrénées-Orientales dispersed to evade capture, with Marian Rejewski and Henryk Zygalski opting to flee southward toward neutral Spain.[1] The pair, accompanied by a local guide, crossed the Pyrenees mountains under cover of night on January 29–30, 1943, but were robbed at gunpoint en route, losing most of their possessions including money and documents.[31] [1] Upon reaching Spanish territory near Puigcerdà, Rejewski and Zygalski were arrested by Spanish authorities as illegal border-crossers and initially detained in Seo de Urgel for two weeks, followed by transfer to Figueras for approximately one month.[1] They were then relocated to the Miranda de Ebro concentration camp, a facility primarily for Republican refugees and Allied escapers, where they endured harsh conditions including forced labor and inadequate rations until their release in May 1943, facilitated by interventions from British diplomatic channels and the Polish government-in-exile.[1] After liberation, the two mathematicians traveled to Lisbon, Portugal, where they boarded a ship for England, arriving on June 3, 1943, and subsequently integrating into Polish exile military structures in Britain despite initial suspicions due to their extended time in Vichy France.[1] This arduous escape preserved their expertise but marked a shift from collaborative cryptanalysis to more peripheral roles amid Allied codebreaking efforts.

Internment and Reluctant Service in Britain

Following their arduous escape over the Pyrenees into neutral Spain in late 1942, Rejewski and fellow cryptologist Henryk Zygalski were interned by Spanish authorities under Francisco Franco from January to March 1943, first at the Séo de Urgel camp and subsequently at Lerida.[1] This detention stemmed from Spain's policy toward Allied personnel entering from occupied France, though the Poles avoided formal refugee camp internment earlier in Romania during their 1939 evacuation.[32] Released with diplomatic intervention, they transited through Portugal and were evacuated by Royal Navy vessel to Gibraltar, arriving in Britain on August 3, 1943.[1] In Britain, Rejewski and Zygalski were incorporated into the Polish Armed Forces in the West, assigned to the Communications Unit of the Polish Supreme Command at Boxmoor, Hertfordshire—a signals intelligence outpost focused on non-Enigma German systems.[33] Commissioned as a second lieutenant in the Polish signals corps by late 1943, Rejewski contributed to cryptanalysis of German hand ciphers, such as those used in field communications, rather than machine-based systems like Enigma.[10] This work, while valuable, did not leverage his pioneering expertise in Enigma reconstruction from 1932, as British Government Code and Cypher School operations at Bletchley Park maintained exclusive control over Enigma exploitation post-1939 handover.[2] Rejewski's service reflected broader frictions: British intelligence, unaware of the full scope of his pre-war mathematical breakthroughs in permutation theory applied to Enigma wiring, did not integrate him into their advanced decryption efforts, resulting in underutilization of his capabilities until war's end in 1945.[1] He remained with the Polish exile forces, decoding lower-priority manual codes amid the unit's resource constraints, a placement that historians attribute to compartmentalization and skepticism toward foreign specialists rather than deliberate exclusion.[33]

Postwar Life Under Communism

Return to Poland and Professional Reintegration

Upon demobilization from the Polish Armed Forces in Britain on 21 November 1946, Rejewski returned to communist-controlled Poland and reunited with his wife Irena and their three daughters in Bydgoszcz, where the family had resettled after wartime displacements.[1][5] Despite his prewar academic credentials in mathematics and wartime cryptologic expertise, Rejewski encountered systemic suspicion from the regime, which regarded individuals with extended stays in the West as potential security risks, leading to ongoing surveillance and harassment by the Polish Security Service (Urząd Bezpieczeństwa).[2][34] To support his family, Rejewski initially secured a position as sales department supervisor at Kabel Polski, a state-owned cable manufacturing firm in Bydgoszcz, holding the role from 1946 to 1950.[1][5] This administrative job marked a sharp departure from his specialized background, reflecting the regime's reluctance to reintegrate former intelligence personnel into sensitive or intellectual fields amid fears of Western influence and loyalty to the pre-communist Polish state. In 1950, under direct pressure from security organs, he was dismissed from Kabel Polski, forcing further job instability.[1] Rejewski then occupied a series of low-level administrative posts in local enterprises and cooperatives before obtaining employment as a bookkeeper at the Provincial Union of Labour Cooperatives (Wojewódzka Unia Spółdzielni Pracy) in Bydgoszcz in 1954, a position he retained until mandatory retirement at age 62 in 1967.[1] These roles, often described as clerical or factory office work, underscored the barriers to professional advancement; the communist authorities prioritized ideological conformity over merit, marginalizing figures like Rejewski whose wartime exile precluded verifiable alignment with Soviet-aligned narratives.[2] He maintained silence on his Enigma-breaking achievements to evade further reprisals, preserving personal security at the cost of public or academic recognition during this period.[34][1]

Academic Career and Publications

Upon returning to Poland on November 21, 1946, Rejewski was unable to secure or resume an academic position at Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań, where he had previously studied and contributed to cryptologic training before the war.[1] Instead, he was employed in non-specialized roles, serving as a sales supervisor at the Polish Cable factory (Kabel Polski) in Bydgoszcz from 1946 until his dismissal in 1950 amid pressure from the communist security apparatus.[1] [5] He then worked as a bookkeeper for the Provincial Union of Labour Cooperatives until retiring in 1967, reflecting the regime's sidelining of prewar intelligence figures despite their expertise.[1] [35] Rejewski's postwar output focused on documenting his cryptologic contributions rather than advancing pure mathematics. In 1967, while retired, he composed the memoir Wspomnienia z mej pracy w Biurze Szyfrów Oddziału II Sztabu Głównego w latach 1930–1945 (Memories of My Work in the Cipher Bureau of the General Staff's Second Department, 1930–1945), which detailed Enigma-breaking methods and was later published in Poznań in 2011.[35] He also authored technical papers on permutation theory and Enigma reconstruction, with his seminal English-language account, "How Polish Mathematicians Deciphered the Enigma," appearing posthumously in 1981 in Annals of the History of Computing (vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 213–234). These works provided mathematical reconstructions of his prewar innovations, including the cyclometer and bomba, but were constrained by ongoing secrecy oaths and political oversight until partial declassification in the 1970s.[1]

Personal Struggles and Family Separation Effects

Recognition, Legacy, and Debates

Delayed Acknowledgments During Cold War

Posthumous Honors and Recent Reappraisals

Following Rejewski's death on February 13, 1980, formal acknowledgments of his cryptologic contributions emerged more prominently after the Cold War. In 2000, he was posthumously awarded the Grand Cross of the Order of Polonia Restituta, Poland's second-highest civilian honor, alongside colleagues Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zygalski, recognizing their 1932 breakthrough in deciphering the Enigma machine.[36][37] International recognition followed, including the 2005 presentation of the British War Medal 1939–1945 by the Chief of the Defence Staff, honoring his wartime intelligence efforts.[38] In 2012, Rejewski received the Knowlton Award from the U.S. Military Intelligence Corps Association, with his daughter Janina accepting on his behalf at a NATO ceremony.[38] The National Security Agency inducted him into its Hall of Honor in 2014, crediting his initial analysis as foundational to Enigma exploitation.[2] Poland commemorated Rejewski through physical memorials, including a dedicated statue unveiled in Bydgoszcz, his birthplace, highlighting his role in reconstructing the Enigma cipher sight-unseen.[39] A monument to Rejewski, Różycki, and Zygalski stands at Poznań University of Technology, their alma mater.[19] In Warsaw, an IEEE Milestone plaque installed on August 5, 2014, at the Saxon Palace honors their Enigma codebreaking, affirming the mathematical innovations that predated Allied adaptations.[40] Recent scholarly reappraisals underscore Rejewski's pioneering use of permutation group theory to deduce Enigma's rotor wirings with minimal resources, often independently of German commercial models, challenging narratives that downplay prewar Polish achievements in favor of later Anglo-American developments.[41] These assessments, including analyses from 2020 onward, emphasize how his cyclometer and bomba devices provided methodological foundations that accelerated wartime decryption, saving an estimated years of Allied effort despite modifications to Enigma post-1938.[36]

Controversies Over Credit for Enigma Breaking

Rejewski and his colleagues Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zygalski achieved the first break into the German military Enigma cipher in December 1932, reconstructing the machine's rotor wirings through permutation theory without physical access to the device. This foundational success enabled daily decrypts of Wehrmacht messages until German modifications in 1937-1938 increased difficulty, prompting innovations like Rejewski's cyclometer and bomba machine. British cryptanalysts at Bletchley Park, lacking this early insight, struggled until the Poles' July 1939 handover of methods, replicas, and accumulated data, which directly informed Turing's design of the electromechanical bombe for exploiting message weaknesses.[42][43] Postwar narratives, shaped by Allied secrecy and national priorities, often centered credit on Bletchley Park's wartime output, with Turing's contributions to handling evolved Enigma variants (e.g., naval and four-rotor models) receiving prominence in declassified accounts from the 1970s onward. Rejewski contested such portrayals, notably in a 1979 letter critiquing F.H. Hinsley's "British Intelligence in the Second World War," where he argued the official history understated Polish mathematical breakthroughs and implied independent British rediscovery of key techniques, contrary to the documented 1939 transfer. Rejewski emphasized that GC&CS had no Enigma break prior to Polish aid, as evidenced by pre-1939 British reports admitting failure.[41][23] These disputes reflect broader tensions over intellectual origins versus scalable application: Polish work provided the theoretical entry point and accelerated British progress by 2-3 years, per expert assessments, while Bletchley scaled operations amid daily key changes and resource constraints. Rejewski's posthumously published memoirs, detailing his independent permutation-group analysis, reinforced this primacy, countering claims of parallel invention by highlighting resource disparities—Poles operated with limited staff and no computers, achieving the initial solution through pure mathematics.[44][45] Public controversies peaked with media depictions, such as the 2014 film "The Imitation Game," which attributed the break primarily to Turing without Polish context, drawing rebukes from historians for compressing timelines and omitting the 1939 collaboration essential to averting potential decryption delays into 1942. Such accounts, while dramatizing British innovations like crib-based attacks, overlook causal dependencies: simulations indicate Enigma yields would have halved without Polish foundations, underscoring debates on crediting initiators versus wartime executors.[46][47]

References

User Avatar
No comments yet.