Hubbry Logo
search
logo
Robert Aron avatar
Robert Aron
Robert Aron
current hub
R

Robert Aron

logo
Community Hub0 Subscribers

Wikipedia

Robert Aron
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Robert Aron (/ɑːˈrɒn/; French: [ʁɔbɛʁ aʁɔ̃]; 25 May 1898 – 19 April 1975) was a French historian and writer who wrote several books on politics and European history.

Key Information

Early life and career

[edit]

Robert Aron was born in Le Vésinet on 25 May 1898 to an upper-class Jewish family from eastern France.[1]:132 He attended the Lycée Condorcet and served in the French Army during World War I. He was wounded in action in 1918.

Interwar Period

[edit]

In 1922, while at university studying for a degree in Languages and Classics, Aron was the President of the Cercle International d'Etudiants.[1]:132 In this role he organised a series of lectures focused on avant-garde literature, music, film and painting. Among the participants were Jean Cocteau and Erik Satie. The series' success attracted the attention the Nouvelle Revue Française, a literary magazine, where he was invited to join the staff as an editor, a position he remained in for many years.[1]:132 After university he joined the Éditions Gallimard publishing house where he was briefly secretary to Gaston Gallimard. He also worked as a film critic for the magazine La Revue du Cinéma, and wrote about politics in the foreign service for the Revue des Deux Mondes.

Théâtre Alfred Jarry (1926-1928)

[edit]

His interest in avant-garde literature and art and its most modern and provocative expressions during the interwar period, was the impetus behind the creation, together with Antonin Artaud and Roger Vitrac, of the Théâtre Alfred Jarry.[2] Aron primarily worked as a producer for the theatre, which mounted four productions from 1926-1928.[2] His experience left him questioning the revolutionary attributes of art. In a response to a disruption of theatre's production of Strindberg's A Dream Play by members of the Surrealist movement, Aron wrote

the Surrealists, whatever attributes they may have, by remaining within the literary or artistic domain, incur no risks except that which is most sought after as a consecration of their childish acts, namely a short stay in the police cells.[3]

For Aron, the work of the Théâtre Alfred Jarry, 'provoked the only dangerous and disturbances of a Surrealist nature' in the last two years, and were almost 'Revolutionary disturbances'.[3]

Ordre Nouveau (1929-1938)

[edit]

In 1927, he became reacquainted with a fellow former student of the Lycée Condorcet, Arnaud Dandieu. Their work together in political and philosophical research spawned three works in the early 1930s: Décadence de la Nation Française (1931), Le Cancer Américain (1931) and La Révolution Nécessaire (1933). Those works constituted the principal theoretical base on which he created the group "Ordre Nouveau" (The New Order) in 1929, and its literary magazine Esprit represented one of the most original expressions of the Nonconformist Movement during the 1930s.[4] Closely collaborating with Dandieu until his death in 1933, Aron took a very active part in all of the activities of Ordre Nouveau until its end in 1938. Thereafter, Aron's activities and viewpoints would be influenced by those experiences.

World War II

[edit]

In 1940, the advent of World War II interrupted his editorial work at the Nouvelle Revue Française. In 1941 he was arrested in one of the Nazis' first anti-semitic operations and held in the Mérignac camp near Bordeaux. After being released, he was not allowed to travel to Paris and instead moved to Lyon, where he became involved, through his friend Jean Rigaut, in preparations for the AAllied invasion of North Africa.

Soon after he was able to escape to Algiers, thanks to Jean Jardin, a former contributor to l'Ordre Nouveau, and at the time director of Pierre Laval's cabinet. In Algiers, Robert Aron became a part of one of the first administrative teams of General Giraud and then General Charles de Gaulle. With Lucie Faure and Jean Amrouche he founded a new literary review, La Nef ("The Nave"), for which he would continue writing until 1952. In 1944–1945, he contributed to the creation of the "Federation" Movement and would remain an active supporter of the French Federalist Movement until his death by regularly collaborating in the monthly publication Le XXe siècle Fédéraliste, and participating in initiatives to create a federation of European States. Aron took up editorial duties again after the Liberation of France, most notably at the publishing houses Librairie Académique Perrin and later, Éditions Fayard.

Postwar Period

[edit]

In 1950, he undertook an important work of historical research on contemporary French history: Histoire de Vichy [History of Vichy] (1954). Nicholas Birns, discussing the English translation, termed it a "neglected but pivotal book".[5] The original French edition was over 700 pages and relied mainly on the testimonies of eye-witnesses and on the records of the High Court.[6] It was the standard work of reference on Vichy for more than fifteen years and the original edition sold 53,000 copies between 1954 and 1981.[7] Aron argued that in Philippe Pétain's view "the armistice was not and could not be anything more than a pause, allowing France to subsist temporarily while awaiting the outcome of the war between England and the Axis...for Laval, the armistice was supposed to have paved the way for a reversal of alliances".[8] Aron therefore argued that there were "two Vichy's", Pétain's and Laval's. He also claimed that the Vichy government played a "double game" between the Allies and the Axis by holding secret talks with the Allies while officially collaborating.[8] Aron attacked the "crimes" committed by the Resistance and he claimed that they had summarily executed "thirty to forty thousand people".[9] Charles de Gaulle wrote to Aron disputing this figure, citing 10,000 as the more accurate estimate.[9] According to Henry Rousso, Aron's book was made obsolete by Robert Paxton's Vichy France (1972).[10]

His Histoire de la Libération (1959, "History of the Liberation") was translated into English as De Gaulle Before Paris (trans. Humphrey Hare, Putnam 1962) and he also wrote the Histoire de l'Epuration (1967–1975, "History of the Purges").

An agnostic during the 1930s, Aron returned to his Jewish faith after 1945 and participated in formal Jewish-Christian dialogue. His book The God of the Beginnings (New York: Morrow, 1966) explores the origins of religion and its development in the traditions of the Old Testament (e.g., Abraham, Moses, the Sinai Covenant). He also wrote books about Jesus's identity as a Jew, including Jesus of Nazareth: The Hidden Years (New York: Morrow, 1962), and The Jewish Jesus (New York Maryknoll, 1971). In 1974, he was elected a member of the Académie française (number 650) but he died suddenly of a heart attack on 19 April 1975, before he was able to attend his public acceptance ceremony.[11]

His final work, Léopold III ou le choix impossible ("Leopold III or the Impossible Choice"), looked at the history of the Belgian monarch Leopold III and the German invasion of Belgium in May 1940 and was published posthumously in 1977.

References

[edit]

Grokipedia

Robert Aron

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Robert Aron is a French historian and writer known for his detailed historical analyses of France during World War II, particularly his influential studies of the Vichy regime and the country's liberation. [1] Born in 1898 and dying in 1975, Aron began his career in literary and intellectual circles, engaging in avant-garde theatre and political reform movements before turning to historical writing after the war. [2] His major works include Histoire de Vichy (1954), which offered an early comprehensive account of the Vichy period drawing on extensive documentation, and Histoire de la libération de la France (1959), chronicling the end of the Occupation and return of republican governance. [3] He later produced a multi-volume Histoire de l'épuration (1967–1975) examining post-Liberation purges in France. [3] Aron's scholarship, while pathbreaking in its use of eyewitness accounts and official records, attracted debate over interpretations such as the notion of a "double game" played by Vichy leaders. [4] Beyond political history, Aron explored religious themes in later years, reflecting his renewed engagement with Jewish tradition and interfaith dialogue through books like Les Années obscures de Jésus (1960) and The Jewish Jesus (1971). [3] In 1974 he was elected to the Académie française, though he died before formal induction. [1]

Early Life and Background

Birth and Family Origins

Robert Aron was born on May 25, 1898, in Le Vésinet, a suburb in the Seine-et-Oise department (now part of the Yvelines department), France. [5] [6] He came from an old bourgeois Jewish family originating from eastern France. [7] [8] His father served as the fondé de pouvoir (authorized representative or managing clerk) for a stockbroker, reflecting the family's position within the assimilated Jewish bourgeoisie of the period. [7] This background placed Aron in an upper-middle-class environment typical of French Jewish families integrated into professional and financial circles in the early 20th century. [7] Limited details are available about his immediate family or extended relatives, with sources focusing primarily on this broader heritage rather than individual biographies of parents or siblings. [8]

Entry into Theater

Robert Aron entered the theater scene in 1926 as a co-founder of the Théâtre Alfred Jarry, an avant-garde company established with Antonin Artaud and Roger Vitrac in Paris.[9][10] Named in homage to the provocative playwright Alfred Jarry, the theater sought to challenge naturalist traditions and promote experimental, revolutionary performances amid the interwar period's vibrant artistic ferment in France.[9] Aron served as a founder and producer, helping to organize and mount the company's productions during its brief but influential run.[11] The Théâtre Alfred Jarry presented four programs between 1927 and 1929, encompassing a total of eight evenings of performance.[11] Among the notable works staged were August Strindberg's A Dream Play and Roger Vitrac's Victor, ou les Enfants au pouvoir, alongside contributions from Artaud such as scenarios emphasizing surrealist and anti-conventional elements.[9] These productions reflected the group's ambition to disrupt conventional theater through bold, innovative staging, though they encountered tensions with surrealist circles led by André Breton.[12] Aron's involvement represented his initial immersion in Parisian theatrical life, where he held administrative and production responsibilities in this short-lived but significant avant-garde venture.[13]

Pre-War Career in Performing Arts

Theater Production Work

Robert Aron played a central role in the avant-garde Parisian theater scene during the late 1920s as co-founder and director of the Théâtre Alfred-Jarry, established in 1926 with Antonin Artaud and Roger Vitrac. [14] He assumed primary administrative and financial responsibilities for the company, receiving and managing its limited initial funds—approximately 3,000 francs collected by April 1927 from patrons including René Allendy and his wife—and personally covering substantial losses after the inaugural performances. [14] Aron organized the theater's first program, staged on 1 and 2 June 1927, which featured his own short surrealist play Gigogne alongside Roger Vitrac's Les Mystères de l'amour and Artaud's Ventre brûlé ou la Mère folle. [15] [14] Gigogne included provocative elements, such as a character known as "the son of Citroën" who harangued the audience, shot infants onstage, and insulted spectators from the prompter's box. [14] Through the Théâtre Alfred-Jarry, which presented four programs before dissolving in 1929, Aron developed professional connections within experimental theater circles, including close collaboration with Artaud and Vitrac as well as interactions with financial backers like the Allendys and tensions with André Breton's Surrealist group. [14] He also wrote two other plays during this period: Le Jardin des Miracles, a three-act work that remained unpublished and unproduced, and La Reine du Monde, staged in 1927 at the Théâtre des Ursulines under the direction of Hungarian painter Medgyes. [14] Aron's theater activities, focused on producing and directing avant-garde works, remained concentrated in the late 1920s with no documented continuation into the early 1930s. [14]

Film Production Management

Robert Aron served as production manager on Jean Renoir's 1934 adaptation of Gustave Flaubert's Madame Bovary. [16] In this capacity, he oversaw key production aspects of the film, which was produced by La Nouvelle Société de Film with Gaston Gallimard and Aron also listed as producer in some records. [17] [18] The project exemplified the ambitious literary adaptations characteristic of French cinema in the 1930s, with Renoir's meticulous direction noted by Aron himself, who described the filmmaker as both fastidious and visionary, particularly in handling complex scenes like those set in the forest. [19] Aron's involvement in Madame Bovary marked his primary verified contribution to film production management, with no other major cinematic credits in this role identified beyond minor or unrelated television work later in his career. [20] His production supervision helped facilitate Renoir's vision for the film, which featured extensive location shooting and detailed period recreation despite eventual commercial challenges. [19]

World War II Period

Activities and Experiences During the War

During World War II, Robert Aron's life was profoundly affected by the German occupation and Vichy regime's anti-Semitic policies. In 1940, the disruption caused by the defeat and mobilization halted his long-standing editorial contributions to the Nouvelle Revue Française, where he had been active since 1922. [8] In 1941, Aron fell victim to one of the earliest mass arrests targeting Jews and was interned at the Mérignac camp near Bordeaux. Following his release, he was barred from residing in Paris and relocated to Lyon in the unoccupied zone. [8] There, through his friend Jean Rigault, he became involved in clandestine efforts supporting preparations for the Allied landing in North Africa. [8] After Operation Torch in November 1942, Aron traveled toward Algiers, briefly taking refuge for two weeks in Charmeil near Vichy at the home of his friend Jean Jardin, who was then serving in Pierre Laval's cabinet. [8] Upon reaching Algiers, he integrated into the emerging administrative structures under General Giraud and later General de Gaulle. [8] In this setting, he co-founded the literary and political review La Nef with Lucie Faure and Jean Amrouche, remaining a key contributor until 1952. [8] These wartime experiences in the unoccupied zone and then in Free French territory shaped his later engagement with the history of the Vichy period. [8]

Post-War Shift to Writing

Transition to Historical Scholarship

After the traumatic events of World War II—including several arrests, his arrival in Algiers, and service in the provisional French governments under Generals Giraud and de Gaulle—Robert Aron found his vocation as a political historian.[6] The experiences of the Occupation, Resistance, and Liberation, which had deeply divided France, prompted him to document and analyze the recent past with a commitment to scrupulous inquiry.[6][21] In the immediate postwar years, Aron resumed editorial work in publishing while sustaining his long-standing political engagement, particularly as a leader in the French federalist movement advocating European unity.[5] He also explored religious-historical themes influenced by the war's impact on his Jewish identity, publishing works such as Retour à l'Éternel (1946).[2] These efforts reflected a gradual reorientation toward historical scholarship as he sought to make sense of France's divisive recent history.[6] By the late 1940s, this shift became more pronounced with publications that blended political reflection and historical analysis, including Le Piège où nous a pris l'histoire (1950).[6] Aron added contemporary history to his activities from 1954 onward, producing objective accounts of periods that had passionately divided the French.[5] This transition culminated in his major work Histoire de Vichy.

Major Historical Works

Histoire de Vichy and Reception

Robert Aron's most prominent work, Histoire de Vichy 1940-1944, appeared in 1954 published by Librairie Arthème Fayard in Paris and written in collaboration with Georgette Elgey. [22] The book offered a detailed chronological narrative of the Vichy regime's operations from the armistice in 1940 through liberation in 1944, relying primarily on stenographic transcripts of postwar collaboration trials in which Vichy officials defended their actions by emphasizing resistance to German demands. [23] Aron presented Marshal Pétain as pursuing a "double game," serving as a shield to protect the French population and mitigate occupation hardships in the short term while Charles de Gaulle embodied the long-term sword of resistance. [24] This framework suggested that Vichy's intentions to preserve national honor and limit German exactions outweighed its errors, framing the regime as a pragmatic, if flawed, effort to safeguard France amid defeat. [24] Upon publication, the book quickly established itself as the authoritative general account of Vichy, satisfying a widespread desire for national reconciliation after the war's divisions and remaining largely unchallenged as the standard reference for more than a decade. [24] [23] It enjoyed broad acceptance in many French circles for its emphasis on Pétain's protective role against a more overtly collaborationist faction led by Pierre Laval, though some early critics, such as Wladimir Rabi, distilled its thesis as "De Gaulle is right, but Pétain is not wrong." [25] The work's methodological limitations—stemming from restricted access to German archives and heavy dependence on French trial records—resulted in an interpretation that overemphasized German pressures as the primary driver of Vichy policy while underplaying internal French initiatives. [23] The book's reception shifted decisively in later decades as new archival evidence emerged. Robert O. Paxton's Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order (1972) and its French edition La France de Vichy (1973), along with subsequent studies by Paxton and Michael Marrus on Vichy and the Jews (1981) and Serge Klarsfeld's Vichy-Auschwitz (1983–1985), refuted the "shield" narrative by documenting Vichy's autonomous conservative agenda rooted in prewar domestic conflicts and its active participation in anti-Jewish measures, including deportations. [23] [25] Aron's portrayal came under criticism for perceived leniency toward Pétain and the regime, as it maintained a protective dichotomy that minimized the extent of collaboration and helped sustain an indulgent view of Vichy's role in the occupation era until these later works reshaped French historiography. [24] [25] Despite these revisions, Aron's Histoire de Vichy retains significance as a foundational early postwar attempt to produce a comprehensive, truth-seeking history of the period using the sources then available. [23]

Other Publications

Robert Aron produced a substantial body of work beyond Histoire de Vichy, encompassing additional studies of mid-20th-century French history as well as explorations of religious themes following his postwar return to Judaism. These writings reflect his continued engagement with France's recent past and his interest in Judeo-Christian relations. One of his prominent subsequent historical works is Histoire de la libération de la France, Juin 1944 - Mai 1945, published in 1959, which provides a detailed narrative of the Allied landings, the progressive liberation of French territory, and the restoration of republican governance amid political complexities. [3] [8] Between 1967 and 1975, Aron published Histoire de l'épuration, a multi-volume examination of the postwar purges in France, analyzing the legal, social, and political processes directed against alleged collaborators, from extrajudicial actions to official trials. [3] [26] He also authored Charles de Gaulle in 1964, a biographical study of the general's role in French politics and leadership. [3] Aron's religious writings include Les Années obscures de Jésus (1960), which investigates the formative and lesser-documented periods of Jesus' life from a historical perspective informed by Jewish tradition. [3] Other notable publications from this period encompass compilations such as Les Grands dossiers de l'histoire contemporaine (1962) and Les Nouveaux grands dossiers de l'histoire contemporaine (1963), which address key episodes and issues in modern history. [3]

Later Life and Legacy

Final Years and Death

In his later years, Aron continued his intellectual work, with a particular emphasis on religious subjects that reflected his profound attachment to Judaism.[1] On March 7, 1974, Aron was elected to the Académie française to occupy seat 32, succeeding Georges Izard.[5] However, he died before the formal induction ceremonies could take place. Aron died suddenly of a heart attack in Paris on April 19, 1975, at the age of 76.[1] His final work, Lettre ouverte à l’Église de France, appeared almost simultaneously with his death and was regarded by contemporaries as a form of testament.[21]

Influence and Critical Assessment

Robert Aron's historical work, particularly his 1954 book Histoire de Vichy 1940-1944, exerted considerable influence on post-war French understanding of the Vichy regime, serving as one of the earliest detailed and documented accounts based on extensive archival material and interviews with participants. This work helped establish a framework that portrayed Marshal Pétain as pursuing a "shield" strategy to protect France from harsher German occupation policies, while assigning greater responsibility for collaboration to Pierre Laval and other figures. This interpretation enjoyed wide acceptance in France during the 1950s and 1960s but faced substantial revision starting in the early 1970s. Robert O. Paxton's 1972 study Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order directly challenged Aron's thesis, demonstrating through German and French archives that Vichy actively collaborated beyond necessity and pursued its own ideological project of national regeneration, independent of German pressure. Paxton's analysis effectively discredited the shield-collaboration dichotomy that Aron's book had helped popularize, marking a turning point toward more critical historiography. Subsequent scholarship has further assessed Aron's methodology as problematic, noting his reliance on self-serving testimonies from Vichy officials and a tendency to minimize the regime's antisemitic measures and ideological commitments. Henry Rousso's 1987 work Le Syndrome de Vichy situates Aron's publication within the broader evolution of French collective memory, arguing that it contributed to a prolonged period of euphemistic narratives about the Occupation that delayed full confrontation with collaborationist realities until the late 1960s and 1970s. Despite these criticisms, Aron's book remains acknowledged as a foundational text in Vichy studies for its breadth of documentation and its role in opening the subject to serious historical inquiry at a time when official archives were largely inaccessible. Modern historians view his contribution as historically significant yet ultimately limited by the political and cultural context in which it was written, with later works superseding it in interpretive rigor and archival depth. Aron's earlier contributions to theater and cinema, including administrative roles and minor script work in the interwar period, have attracted little sustained critical or scholarly attention, remaining largely eclipsed by his postwar historical output.

References

  1. https://www.nytimes.com/1975/04/20/archives/robert-aron-76-french-historian.html
  2. https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/aron-robert
  3. https://openlibrary.org/authors/OL132612A/Robert_Aron
  4. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2929246
  5. https://www.academie-francaise.fr/les-immortels/robert-aron
  6. https://www.lemonde.fr/archives/article/1974/03/09/robert-aron-le-temoin-d-une-generation-passionnee_2513886_1819218.html
  7. https://booknode.com/auteur/robert-aron
  8. https://www.babelio.com/auteur/Robert-Aron/23957
  9. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Theatre-Alfred-Jarry
  10. https://www.confinity.com/legacies/antonin-artaud
  11. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/theatre-survey/article/theatre-before-its-double-artaud-directs-in-the-alfred-jarry-theatre/DB1BAD9072EB64945DE6B40E9EC591EB
  12. https://essentialdrama.com/tag/theatre-of-cruelty/
  13. https://read.dukeupress.edu/theater/article-pdf/9/3/20/305668/ddthe_9_3_20.pdf
  14. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/theatre-research-international/article/homage-to-robert-aron-18981975/A04A85193BB5819DEC02284AB8C95AE5
  15. https://classes.bnf.fr/pdf/artaud3.pdf
  16. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0025442/fullcredits/
  17. https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2003/great-directors/renoir/
  18. https://monoskop.org/images/6/66/Bazin_Andre_Jean_Renoir.pdf
  19. https://www.manchesterhive.com/display/9781526133151/9781526133151.00010.pdf
  20. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0036892/
  21. https://www.academie-francaise.fr/discours-prononce-loccasion-de-la-mort-de-m-robert-aron
  22. https://openlibrary.org/works/OL1306109W/Histoire_de_Vichy_1940-1944_..
  23. https://www.nationalww2museum.org/war/articles/robert-paxton-vichy-france
  24. https://harpers.org/archive/2023/12/robert-o-paxton-the-discreet-eminence/
  25. https://clio-cr.clionautes.org/le-savoir-des-victimes.html
  26. https://www.fayard.fr/livre/histoire-de-lepuration-9782213001937/
User Avatar
No comments yet.