Singer Matt Scannell said, "'You're A God' was written about when we give people in our lives power over us. It can be anything, whether it's a romantic thing or not - this one wasn't." He added that the song was partially inspired by a person in his life who had power over him and was making him miserable, and he realized all he had to do was stop looking up to them and start looking down on them, and he could take their power away. "And that's why that song starts off, 'I gotta be honest, we're covered in lies and that's okay.' ... Really, the title is ironic: you're a god and I am not – well, that's actually not true anymore, because now you're not a god."[1] "You're a God" was included on the Bruce Almighty soundtrack released on June 3, 2003, by Varèse Sarabande.
The music video (directed by The Malloys) was based around a beauty pageant contestant, played by actress Tiffani Thiessen.