Early games like "Digital: A Love Story" received widespread critical acclaim for their innovative storytelling, unique atmosphere, and exploration of complex themes, establishing Christine Love as a prominent voice in the independent game development community.

"Ladykiller in a Bind" sparked considerable controversy due to its explicit content and exploration of potentially sensitive themes. Discussions revolved around the game's representation of sexuality, gender identity, and power dynamics, with some critics praising its boldness and others criticizing its perceived exploitation or problematic portrayals.

Despite the controversies, Christine Love's games have consistently been praised for their thoughtful writing, complex narratives, and willingness to tackle challenging and uncomfortable topics. Her work has been recognized for its impact on the visual novel genre and its contribution to the broader conversation about representation in games.