Hubbry Logo
The New 52The New 52Main
Open search
The New 52
Community hub
The New 52
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
The New 52
The New 52
The New 52
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The New 52
Cover of DC Comics: The New 52 #1, July 2011
Publication information
PublisherDC Comics
Genre
Publication dateAugust 31, 2011 – May 25, 2016
Main characterDC Universe
Creative team
Written byVarious
ArtistVarious
Collected editions
DC Comics The New 52ISBN 978-1-4012-3451-5
DC Comics The New 52 Zero OmnibusISBN 978-1-4012-3884-1
DC Comics The New 52 Villains OmnibusISBN 978-1-4012-4496-5

The New 52 was the 2011 revamp and relaunch by DC Comics of its entire line of ongoing monthly superhero comic books. Following the conclusion of the "Flashpoint" crossover storyline, DC cancelled all its existing titles and debuted 52 new series in September 2011.[1] Among the renumbered series were Action Comics and Detective Comics, which had retained their original numbering since the 1930s.

The relaunch included changes to the publishing format; for example, print and digital comics began to be released on the same day. New titles were released to bring the number of ongoing monthly series to 52. Various changes were also made to DC's fictional universe to entice new readers, including changes to DC's internal continuity to make characters more modern and accessible. In addition, characters from the Wildstorm and Vertigo imprints were absorbed into the DC Universe.[2][3]

The New 52 branding ended after the completion of the "Convergence" storyline in May 2015, although its continuity continued. In June 2015, 24 new titles were launched, alongside 25 returning titles, with several of those receiving new creative teams. In February 2016, DC announced the New 52's successor, Rebirth, which reset the continuity to its prior status quo, and "synchronized" it with the New 52 continuity. The Rebirth branding was launched with the release of an 80-page one-shot on May 25, 2016.

Publication history

[edit]

Launch and Second Wave

[edit]
Jim Lee and Geoff Johns at the August 31, 2011, midnight signing for Flashpoint #5 and Justice League #1 at Midtown Comics Times Square

Following the conclusion of the Flashpoint limited series, DC cancelled and relaunched all titles set in the DC Universe with new #1 issues.[4] The new continuity features new outfits and backstories for many of DC's long-established heroes and villains. An interview with DC Comics executive editor Eddie Berganza and editor-in-chief Bob Harras revealed that the new continuity did not constitute a full reboot of the DC Universe but rather a "soft reboot".[citation needed] While many characters underwent a reboot or revamp, much of the DC Universe's history remained intact. Many major storylines such as "War of the Green Lanterns", "Batman: A Death in the Family" and Batman: The Killing Joke remained part of the new continuity, while others have been lost in part or in whole.[5] DC editorial constructed a timeline that details the new history and which storylines to keep or ignore.[5]

On August 31, 2011, Midtown Comics Times Square held a midnight event at which they began selling Justice League #1 and Flashpoint #5. On hand to sign the books were DC Chief Creative Officer Geoff Johns, who was the writer of both titles, and co-publisher and writer/artist Jim Lee, who illustrated Justice League.[1][6]

On January 12, 2012, DC announced that after their eighth issues, Blackhawks, Hawk and Dove, Men of War, Mister Terrific, O.M.A.C., and Static Shock would be cancelled and replaced with six new titles, which would reveal more of The New 52 DC Universe.[7] The new titles were dubbed the Second Wave: Dial H, Earth 2, G.I. Combat, World's Finest, Ravagers and Batman Incorporated, which was absent from the initial line of Batman titles, and would continue Grant Morrison's storyline from before The New 52 involving the conflict between Batman and Talia al Ghul.[8]

"Zero Month" and continued title changes

[edit]

On June 9, 2012, DC announced that in September 2012, the first anniversary of The New 52 launch, all titles would get a zero issue, dubbed "Zero Month".[9] In addition, the Third Wave of titles was announced: Talon, Sword of Sorcery, Phantom Stranger, and Team 7. With these additions to the line, Justice League International, Captain Atom, Resurrection Man, and Voodoo were cancelled.[10]

In October and November 2012, DC announced new titles Threshold,[11] Justice League of America,[12] Katana, Justice League of America's Vibe,[13] and Constantine.[14] Threshold would be published in January 2013, Constantine in March 2013, while the others would be published in February 2013. DC later consolidated these new titles as the Fourth Wave of The New 52.[15] G.I. Combat, Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E., Grifter, Blue Beetle, and Legion Lost were cancelled as a result.[16] Young Romance: A New 52 Valentine's Day Special #1 was published as the 52nd title in February 2013.[15]

In January 2013, DC Comics announced the cancellation of I, Vampire and DC Universe Presents in April 2013.[17] To celebrate the 60th birthday of Mad Magazine mascot Alfred E. Neuman, DC solicited variants drawn by Mad artists for 13 titles being published in April 2013.[18]

Starting with titles released on January 28, 2013, all printed New 52 publications featured advertisements for the fictional news channel Channel 52. The two page back-ups, titled Channel 52, appear in all books, starting in February 2013, and replaced the previous "DC Comics: All Access" features. This news feature stars Bethany Snow, Ambush Bug, Vartox, and Calendar Man as reporters and anchors on the fictional in-universe news show. The art is provided by Freddie E. Williams II.[19] Each week brings new content regarding the current or future goings-on in the DC universe. Channel 52 and Bethany Snow make an appearance in the second season of Arrow.[20]

On January 30, 2013, DC announced that all titles released in April 2013 would be "WTF Certified". Each title would feature a gatefold cover and storylines and moments that will leave readers in a state of shock, including the return of Booster Gold.[21][22] However, DC later dropped the "WTF Certified" branding and did not feature it on any of The New 52 books.[23] In February 2013, it was announced that DC Comics would launch two new politically motivated books as parts of the Fifth Wave: The Green Team: Teen Trillionaires and The Movement. These would explore concepts similar to the Occupy Movement and the role money has in a world of superheroes.[24] A wave of cancellations was also announced for May 2013, including The Savage Hawkman, The Fury of Firestorm: The Nuclear Man, Sword of Sorcery, Team 7, Deathstroke, and The Ravagers.[25]

In March 2013, DC announced that it would launch four new titles in June 2013, making up the rest of the Fifth Wave: Superman Unchained, Batman/Superman, Larfleeze, and Trinity of Sin: Pandora.[26] In April 2013, the cancellation of Batman Incorporated was announced for July 2013. DC also solicited two director's cut one-shots for the Superman Unchained book and the "Batman: Zero Year" story arc.[27] In May 2013, it was announced that Batman Incorporated Special #1 would be published to finish off the Batman Incorporated series in August 2013.[28] Another director's cut one-shot was solicited for the "Trinity War" story arc, along with the cancellations of Demon Knights, Legion of Super-Heroes, Threshold, and Dial H.[29]

"Villains Month", "Forever Evil" and "Zero Year"

[edit]

In June 2013, DC announced that all titles in September 2013 would be "relaunched" as a #1, featuring a villain from that respective book, as part of "Villains Month". For example, Detective Comics, which would have published issue 24 in September, would be released as Detective Comics #23.1 and Poison Ivy #1, with the issue being known by both titles.[30] It was the first major crossover in the New 52 since "Flashpoint" and spun out of the aftermath of "Trinity War". Each book featured 3D lenticular front and back covers.[31] DC also released 2D versions of the covers.[32] Some books published multiple "Villains Month" issues, while others skipped publication in September 2013. For example, Batman, Superman, and Justice League are some of the titles that published four issues, while The Flash published three issues, Aquaman and others published two issues, and Green Arrow and others published only one.[31][33]

In addition to "Villains Month", a seven-issue limited series titled Forever Evil, by Geoff Johns and David Finch, launched in September 2013 and focused on the Crime Syndicate, an evil version of the Justice League from Earth-Three, as they attempt to take over Prime Earth in the Justice Leagues' defeat at the end of "Trinity War".[34] The "Forever Evil" event ran in other titles starting in October 2013, including three 6-issue tie-in books that launched: Forever Evil: Rogues Rebellion by Brian Buccellato and Patrick Zircher; Forever Evil: Arkham War by Peter Tomasi, Scot Eaton and Jaime Mendoza; and Forever Evil: A.R.G.U.S. by Matt Kindt and Manuel Garcia.[35] Other tie-in titles included: Teen Titans, Suicide Squad, Justice League, Justice League of America and the "Forever Evil: Blight" storyline in Constantine, Justice League Dark, Trinity of Sin: Pandora, and Trinity of Sin: The Phantom Stranger.[35][36] Forever Evil #1 was also reprinted in a director's cut one-shot in October 2013.[35]

It was also announced in June 2013 that the "Batman: Zero Year" storyline in Batman would spin off into an event during November 2013, which would include other titles outside the "Batman" line of titles.[37] The event, initially conceptualized to tell Batman's origin in The New 52,[38] was featured in issue #25 of Action Comics, The Flash, Green Arrow, and Green Lantern Corps, along with Batgirl, Batwing, Batwoman,[39] Birds of Prey, Catwoman, Detective Comics, Nightwing, and Red Hood and the Outlaws in the "Batman" line.[40][41] The various books explored their characters' connections to Gotham City, and their first encounters with Batman.

On June 17, 2013, DC announced two new titles, Justice League 3000[42] and Superman/Wonder Woman as the first titles of the Sixth Wave,[43] which began publication in October 2013. On July 16, 2013, DC announced Harley Quinn, the third and last title of the Sixth Wave, which began publication in November 2013.[44][45] In August 2013, it was announced that Justice League 3000's initial publication would be delayed to December 2013, following creative changes on the title.[46]

Launch of weeklies and start of "second phase"

[edit]

In October 2013, DC announced Batman Eternal, a weekly year-long series which would feature Batman, his allies, and others in Gotham City.[47] It was announced in January 2014 that the series would begin in April of that year.[48] The cancellation of Katana and Justice League of America's Vibe was also announced, with the titles' final publication in December 2013, while Green Team: The Teen Trillionaires would end in January 2014.[49] Following the release of Scribblenauts Unmasked: A DC Comics Adventure, DC announced cover variants for 20 titles published in January 2014, featuring Scribblenauts-inspired artwork.[50]

In November 2013, DC announced one-shot issues Superman: Lois Lane #1 and Batman: Joker's Daughter #1 for February 2014, featuring Lois Lane and the new Joker's Daughter, respectively.[51] DC also announced that 20 titles being published in February 2014 would feature steampunk-inspired cover variants.[52] As well, Johns revealed that the end of "Forever Evil" in March 2014 would mark the end of the first phase of The New 52, with a new phase starting in April 2014, "one that will see the introduction, and re-introduction, of a lot of characters, concepts and a decidedly new center to the DC universe."[53]

In December 2013, it was announced that another weekly year-long series titled The New 52: Futures End would begin publication in May 2014, with a free zero issue for Free Comic Book Day. The series would be set five years in the New 52's future. Co-writer Jeff Lemire stated that the series was "an exploration of DC's past, present and its future." Batman Beyond made his New 52 debut in the series.[54] Solicitations published in December 2014 also revealed that 22 titles to be published in March 2014 would feature variant covers based on Robot Chicken, to promote the second Robot Chicken DC Comics Special.[55][56]

In January 2014, DC announced Aquaman and the Others, Justice League United, Secret Origins and Sinestro ongoing series and Forever Evil Aftermath: Batman vs Bane #1 for publication in April 2014. In addition, DC revealed that Justice League of America, Nightwing, Stormwatch, Suicide Squad, Superman Unchained, and Teen Titans would end in April 2014.[48] It was also announced that April 2014 publications would feature a second wave of variant covers inspired by MAD magazine.[57]

In February 2014, Gail Simone revealed that her series The Movement would be canceled in May 2014 after 12 issues.[58] It was also revealed that 19 titles published in May 2014 would feature variant covers drawn by Mike Allred in the style of Batman '66.[59] A one-shot issue, Superman: Doomed #1 would also be published in May, as a tie-in to a crossover story arc of the same name.[60]

DC later announced that as part of the celebration of The New 52's third anniversary, all ongoing titles published in September 2014 would feature stories that tied into The New 52: Futures End. DC Comics co-publisher Dan DiDio declared:

These stories aren't going to just be tied into the weekly. But what you'll be seeing is a lot of the writers who are working on series right now projecting forward—their ideas, their storylines, where they think their character might be five years from now. [...] The [lenticluar 3D] covers now will also have the ability to have a 'flicker' effect. That means that the images change and show the transformation going on... There is a level of change that is taking place with our characters during the course of this story.

DiDio added that new ongoing titles would launch in June and July to be included in the event.[61] Following the month of tie-ins, a third weekly titled Earth 2: World's End launched in October 2014. This title is set in the present DC Universe on Earth 2, while showcasing the events and circumstances that lead to the future depicted in Futures End.[62][63]

In March 2014, DC announced the launch of Infinity Man and the Forever People, the one-shot Harley Quinn Director's Cut #0, and the cancellation of Larfleeze for June 2014.[64] March also saw the announcement of variant covers for 20 titles in June 2014, based on the DC Collectibles "Bombshells" statue line designed by Ant Lucia, the covers feature retro and pinup versions of female characters.[65] DC also revealed two new publications for July 2014: an ongoing series Star-Spangled War Stories and a one-shot Harley Quinn Invades San Diego Comic-Con.[66]

The Multiversity, new titles, new creative teams and DC You

[edit]

In April 2014, DC announced Suicide Squad and Teen Titans would be relaunched in July 2014, with the former being retitled New Suicide Squad.[67][68] A new series, titled Grayson, focusing on character Dick Grayson following his role in "Forever Evil",[69] and a one-shot issue Robin Rises: Omega, tied into the Batman and Robin storyline "The Hunt for Robin", would also debut.[70] It was revealed that July 2014's variant theme would be Batman's 75th anniversary, with 21 publications featuring "Batman 75" themes.[71] April also saw the official announcement of The Multiversity, which began publication in August 2014;[72] the 8-issue limited series was first mentioned by writer Grant Morrison in April–May 2009 intended for a 2010 release date.[citation needed] The Multiversity was intended to pick up on storylines left over from 52 and Final Crisis.[73]

In May 2014, DC announced that six titles, All-Star Western, Batwing, Birds of Prey, Superboy, Trinity of Sin: Pandora and Trinity of Sin: The Phantom Stranger, would have their final publications in August 2014.[74] It was also revealed that 22 titles published in August 2014 would feature "DC Universe Selfie" variant covers, focusing on the popular trend of taking selfies.[75] A second Superman: Doomed one-shot was also announced.[74]

In June 2014, DC announced six new titles for their Ninth Wave: Arkham Manor,[76] Deathstroke,[77] Gotham Academy,[76] Klarion,[78] Lobo,[79] and Trinity of Sin[80] for publication in October 2014.

"Convergence": the return of Hypertime and the Pre-"Crisis" multiverse

[edit]

In February 2015, it was announced that following the Convergence storyline in May, the New 52 branding would not be used anymore, although the continuity of the New 52 would continue. That June, 24 new titles were unveiled under a newly introduced DC You initiative, and most of the 25 remaining titles of The New 52 had new creative teams.[81]

The Multiversity Guidebook #1 changed the nature of the 52 multiverse. In this book, the New 52 multiverse was the result of a phenomenon called Hypertime. In the book, Brainiac takes cities from the Pre-"Crisis", Post-"Crisis", and Post-"Flashpoint" multiverses and placed them on a planet in another reality. He leaves a portion of himself behind; this part of Brainiac renames himself Telos and has the cities battle each other.[82] Deimos of Skartaris tries to take complete control of the Telos' world but is killed by the Parallax-possessed Hal Jordan.[83] This triggers a chain reaction that threatens to collapse the multiverse.[84] To prevent this, Telos sends several of the heroes back to the Crisis on Infinite Earths to prevent the destruction of the original multiverse. Telos states "They have done it. Reality is resetting, stabilizing. Each world has evolved, but they all still exist." In an interview, writer Jeff King stated "Post-Convergence, every character that ever existed, in either Continuity or Canon, is now available to us as storytellers."[85]

The end of The New 52 and DC Rebirth

[edit]

In February 2016, DC announced its Rebirth initiative, a line-wide relaunch of its titles, to begin in June 2016. Beginning with an 80-page one-shot which was released on May 25, 2016, Rebirth also saw Action Comics and Detective Comics return to their previous numbering (#957 and #934, respectively), nearly all books releasing at US$2.99, multiple books shifting to a twice-monthly release schedule, a number of existing titles relaunching with new #1 issues, and the release of several new titles.[86][87][88] DC has used the Green Lantern: Rebirth and The Flash: Rebirth miniseries as examples of the basis for the initiative, which has been described as a rebirth of the DC Universe. The Rebirth initiative reintroduced concepts from pre-Flashpoint continuity, such as legacy, that had been lost with The New 52 and built "on everything that's been published since Action Comics #1 up through The New 52."[86]

Changes to the DC Universe

[edit]
Scott Snyder and Ivan Brandon at a September 21, 2011, signing for Batman #1 and Men of War #1 at Midtown Comics

In June 2011, DC co-publisher Jim Lee revealed that he and DC Art Director Mark Chiarello had enlisted artist Cully Hamner to help spearhead the redesign of characters for the relaunch of the DC Universe.[89]

In late July 2011, DC released The New 52, a free preview book giving solicitations and previews of all of the new titles launching from August 31, 2011. Notable continuity changes shown included Superman's two new looks: one which consists of jeans, a blue T-shirt with the "S" logo and a cape, the other consisting of Kryptonian battle armor that resembles his classic costume. Other notable changes included the integration of the WildStorm imprint's characters into DC continuity, with Martian Manhunter as a part of the new Stormwatch team in the relaunched Stormwatch series.[90]

Justice League was the first book of the relaunch, with the first issue released on August 31, 2011. The first story arc takes place five years in the past, detailing the first meeting of the Justice League members and the formation of the team.[5]

The initial run of first issues show a universe in which superheroes have only appeared within the last five years and are viewed with suspicion and hostility,[91] with Superman and Batman being pursued by the police five years ago at the start of their careers.[91][92] In the present day, organizations such as the United Nations and the United States government seek to exploit and control the superheroes through groups such as the Justice League International[93] and the Justice League of America.[12]

The "Batman" family of titles strongly resemble the past continuity. However, former Batgirls Stephanie Brown and Cassandra Cain have had their histories erased. Additionally, all of the Robins have been accounted for, including the previously non-canonical Carrie Kelley.[94] Stephanie made her first appearance in The New 52 as the Spoiler in the teaser issue to Batman Eternal in Batman #28.[95] Barbara Gordon recovered from the paralysis inflicted upon her by the Joker's bullet in Batman: The Killing Joke and returned to crimefighting as Batgirl.[96]

As for Superman, his romantic relationship and marriage to Lois Lane has not transpired, and his adoptive parents Jonathan and Martha Kent have died.[97][98][99] He was depicted as being slightly more short-tempered, retaining his American identity, and in a relationship with Wonder Woman.[100] Various character changes were implemented, such as Starfire,[101] Guy Gardner,[102] and Tim Drake[103] having their origins significantly changed. Sinestro was depicted as having returned recently to the Green Lantern Corps, where he became a villain again.[citation needed] Meanwhile, the Earth-Two version of Alan Scott was depicted as gay.[104]

Publications

[edit]
Main articles: List of The New 52 publications and List of The New 52 imprint publications

Imprint titles

[edit]

The imprint titles are divided into seven families of titles, revolving around central characters or themes. By the release of the October 2013 solicitations, DC was no longer grouping the titles by these families. Instead they began releasing one larger solicit, titled "The New 52 Group". However, titles that were not participating in an event for the month, such as "Forever Evil", were still grouped together in the larger solicit by the previous family headings.[105]

The original Justice League team, as they appear in The New 52; art by Jim Lee
  • "Justice League" – These titles featured characters related to the Justice League.
  • "Batman" – These titles featured Batman and the "Batman Family" of characters.
  • "Superman" – These titles featured Superman and the "Superman Family" of characters.
  • "Green Lantern" – These titles featured the members of the Green Lantern Corps and the other Lantern Corps of the emotional spectrum.
  • "Young Justice" – These titles featured teenaged characters and superhero teams.[106]
  • "The Edge" – These are titles with war, science fiction, western, or crime themes, and include titles and characters formerly belonging to the WildStorm imprint.[107]
  • "The Dark" – These are titles with supernatural, fantasy and horror themes, including titles and characters formerly belonging to the Vertigo imprint.[108][109]

Post-imprint titles

[edit]

In February 2015, it was revealed that after the Convergence miniseries in June 2015, DC would no longer use The New 52 name to brand their books; however the continuity established in September 2011 would continue. Dan DiDio stated, "In this new era of storytelling, story will trump continuity as we continue to empower creators to tell the best stories".[110]

Rather than having 52 books all in the same continuity, and really focusing on keeping a universe that's tightly connected and has super-internal consistency, and really one flavor, we've really broken it up. We'll have a core line of about 25 books that will have that internal consistency, that will consist of our best-selling books. But then the rest of the line, about 24 titles, will be allowed to really shake things up a little bit.

— Jim Lee[111]

The new titles would be about "reinventing key characters", such as Black Canary, Cyborg, Bizarro, and Starfire, with a new "contemporary tonality to ensure a diverse offering of comic books." In the initial "relaunch", 24 new publications joined 25 existing publications from before Convergence, with new titles continuing to be added.[110]

In March 2015, DiDio revealed there would not be an "overarching brand on this" stating the relaunch was just "DC Comics, pure and simple."[111] However, in May 2015, DC announced the advertising campaign DC You for the relaunch, which highlighted the four main themes of characters, talent, stories and fans. The initiative, which began in DC's print and digital comics on May 20, before transitioning to other digital content on June 3, was featured on print inserts and ads, as well as on the DC Comics website and across social media with a special hashtag of #DCYou.[112]

Reception

[edit]

Sales

[edit]
Jim Lee and Geoff Johns at a May 11, 2012 signing for the Justice League Vol. 1: Origin, the hardcover which collected the first six-issue story arc of that series

Pre-orders for Justice League #1 exceeded 200,000 copies.[113] Justice League #1 has been sent back to press at least four times and all of The New 52's first issue titles sold out by September 24, 2011.[114] For the month of September 2011, DC had eight of the top ten comic books, in spite of Marvel's heavily publicized replacement Ultimate Spider-Man, Miles Morales debuting in that title the same month.[115] Justice League #1 was the top selling comic book in 2011.[116]

Writer Warren Ellis was unimpressed with the relaunch's sales, stating that it garnered DC a half-point lead in dollar share and a five-point lead in units sold over Marvel Comics. Ellis also pointed out that the units DC sold were returnable.[117]

Columnist Heidi MacDonald stated that, while the market share comparisons were correct, the sales figures for single issue books did not take into account the fact that returnable comics were downgraded by approximately 10%, and that DC's sales were about that amount lower than the actual sales, in order to allow for potential returns. MacDonald opined that while the sellouts and reprintings made returns unlikely, the sales would remain 10% lower throughout the period in which the books could be returned, which lasted through December 2011, and that actual sales would be adjusted for this factor in Diamond Comic Distributors' end of year figures.[118]

Writer and ComicMix columnist Glenn Hauman wrote that relying solely on Diamond's numbers, to the exclusion of newsstand, overseas and digital sales, does not provide a complete measure of the relaunch's success. Hauman emphasized that the infinite long-term availability of digital editions meant that sales would continue on the books for weeks and months afterwards, and that the market share for that market was uncertain.[119]

By December 2011, Marvel Comics regained the top spot for market share in both dollars and units.[120] In April 2013, DC's unit share fell below 28%, but rose to a 45.17% market share in September due to high orders for Villain Month.[121][122] It fell back to 30.77% by January 2014.[123]

Critical reception

[edit]

Forbes, The New York Times and The A.V. Club saw The New 52 as a good editorial move from DC.[124][125][126] The Christian Science Monitor's Rich Clabaugh cited the relaunched Action Comics and Detective Comics as the strongest of the first week's releases.[127]

In terms of the books themselves, Keith Phipps and Oliver Sava of The A.V. Club praised the art in Justice League #1, but thought its writing and structure was a weak point.[128] In all, the two reviewers named O.M.A.C., Captain Atom, Animal Man and Wonder Woman their favorite books of the relaunch.[125] They gave Batman high praise,[129] and enjoyed Action Comics, Swamp Thing,[130] Batwoman, Frankenstein Agent Of S.H.A.D.E., Demon Knights, Batman and Robin,[129][131] Nightwing,[129] Aquaman, The Flash, All Star Western, and Voodoo.[125] However, they both disliked Detective Comics, Hawk and Dove,[130] Legion Lost, Red Lanterns,[131] Legion of Super-Heroes, DC Universe Presents: Deadman,[129] Superman, Batman: The Dark Knight, The Fury of Firestorm: The Nuclear Men, and The Savage Hawkman.[125] On the remaining titles, the reviewers were either split, or exhibited mixed reactions ranging from indifference to cautious optimism or curiosity.

Corrina Lawson of Wired dubbed the New 52 "a big, fat failure" from a reader standpoint, noting that the same stories could have been told without rebooting the fictional universe. She did, however, state that the New 52 was good from a business perspective, as it led to an increased market share for DC.[132]

Criticism

[edit]

Lack of female creators

[edit]

The launch of the New 52 was criticized for the lack of female creators, which had dropped from 12% to 1%, the latter figure represented by writer Gail Simone and Amy Reeder, an alternating artist on Batwoman who would not debut on that title until issue #6.[133] This led to a tense interaction between fans and DC Comics co-publisher Dan DiDio at the 2011 San Diego Comic Con,[133][134] where DiDio was asked by a fan about the drop in female creators from 12% to 1%. DiDio responded by saying, "What do those numbers mean to you? What do they mean to you? Who should we be hiring? Tell me right now. Who should we be hiring right now? Tell me."[134]

In an editorial responding to DiDio, ComicsAlliance editor-in-chief Laura Hudson wrote, "Women are half of the world, and a significant percentage of the DC Comics character stable, and yet only 1% of their creators. And the way that you treat and represent half of the people in your world—and by extension, half of the people in the real world who might potentially buy your books—should be more than a marginal concern."[135]

On July 29, 2011, DC released a letter addressing the lack of female creators on their official blog, highlighting notable female creators currently being published by them and promising more in the future.[136] Hudson called the letter "an enormous and very positive departure from how DC Comics has dealt with controversies about gender and race in the past, which was almost uniformly not to comment", adding, "While it remains to be seen what sort of meaningful changes in either attitudes or hiring practices will follow, it certainly leaves me feeling more optimistic than I have in some time, or maybe ever."[137]

Portrayal of female characters

[edit]

DC also received criticism for its handling of certain female characters during the relaunch, sparking discussion of exploitative overtones in titles such as Catwoman #1 and Red Hood and the Outlaws #1. Laura Hudson of ComicsAlliance and Andrew Wheeler of Bleeding Cool criticized the relaunch for oversexualized characterization of its female characters, such as Catwoman, Harley Quinn, Starfire, and Voodoo, for cancelling books with female leads like Power Girl, and relegating the star of that series to the status of Mister Terrific's girlfriend.[138][139] Writer/editor Jim Shooter disliked the treatment of female characters in general, and referred to the treatment of Starfire in particular as "porn for kids".[140] Keith Phipps and Oliver Sava agreed with the observations of Catwoman and Red Hood and the Outlaws,[129] but opined that Voodoo was a positive example how to incorporate a female character's sexuality as a relevant aspect of the story without appearing exploitative.[125] Wheeler also complained that retconning Barbara Gordon's paralysis as a temporary injury from which she recovered,[96] and restoring her as Batgirl, to the exclusion of Cassandra Cain and Stephanie Brown, made the DC Universe less diverse and inclusive.[139] Responding to the criticism, Catwoman writer Judd Winick explained that it was DC that desired this tone for that book.[141]

Restoration of Barbara Gordon's mobility and aftermath

[edit]

In June 2011, DC announced that Barbara Gordon would be returning to the role of Batgirl in September 2011, in her own eponymous monthly comic, as part of a company-wide relaunch of all of their titles. In addition, former Birds of Prey writer Gail Simone would be writing the series.[142] This announcement became one of the most controversial aspects of the DC Comics relaunch.[143] Supporters of Barbara Gordon in her persona as Oracle have expressed dismay over losing an iconic character for the disabled community. Journalist and blogger Jill Pantozzi, who is diagnosed with muscular dystrophy, stated that:

[...] people being disabled is part of the real world, it is essential it be part of the fictional world as well... Writer Kevin Van Hook did a great job showing what disabled individuals have to go through in the mini-series Oracle: The Cure. It's that type of honesty I expect more of ... While some diverse characters were mishandled over the years, Oracle was always treated with the utmost respect but this move is the most disrespectful I've seen in a long time.[144]

Simone responded directly by stating that at times when others had attempted to restore Gordon's mobility, she fought to keep her as a disabled character, even in light of requests from readers who also had disabilities that wished to see the character healed.[145] However, part of her reasoning for reversing her decision and writing Batgirl with Gordon as the title character was that:

[a]rms and legs get ripped off, and they grow back, somehow. Graves don't stay filled. But the one constant is that Barbara stays in that chair. Role model or not, that is problematic and uncomfortable, and the excuses to not cure her, in a world of purple rays and magic and super-science, are often unconvincing or wholly meta-textual. And the longer it goes on, the more it has stretched credibility. But now, everything has changed. If nearly everyone in the DCU, not just Batgirl but almost everyone, is now at a much earlier stage in their career, then my main objection no longer applies, because we are seeing Barbara at an earlier starting point.[145]

Former Batman writer and editor Dennis O'Neil and Oracle co-creator John Ostrander expressed disappointment over the change. O'Neil stated that during his tenure at DC, "[W]e had hordes of people in spandex beating up criminals ... We didn't have anybody like Oracle, who overcame a disability and was just as valuable and just as effective in a way that didn't involve violence." However, he also stated that from an alternate point of view, "Barbara Gordon's perception in the mainstream public as Batgirl would be a very valid consideration." Ostrander continues to view Oracle as a stronger character than Batgirl, but has also expressed faith in Gail Simone's skills as a writer. He commented that "[t]imes change and characters and people evolve. I changed things when I wrote characters, including changing Barbara to Oracle. Others do the same for this era ... Gail Simone is a good friend and a wonderful writer and I'm sure her work will be wonderful."[146]

Editorial controversies

[edit]

A number of editorial controversies emerged in the wake of The New 52, prompting Topless Robot, a genre website owned by The Village Voice, to publish an article in September 2013, "The Eight Biggest DC Creative Screw-Ups Since the New 52 Began". A number of these controversies concerned firings or resignations of creators which, in some cases, stemmed from conflicts between those creators and editorial decisions.[147]

Writer/artist George Pérez, who left Superman after six issues, explained his departure in July 2012 as a result of the level of editorial oversight exerted on the title. This included the inconsistent reasons given for rewrites of his material, the inability of editors to answer basic questions about the new Superman's status quo, such as whether his adoptive parents were still alive, and the restrictions created by not being told that Action Comics, with which Superman had to remain consistent, was set five years before Superman, a situation complicated by the fact that Action writer Grant Morrison was not forthcoming about his plans.[148]

In the following month Rob Liefeld, who had been hired by DC to plot Grifter and The Savage Hawkman, and to plot and draw Deathstroke, and who had indicated the previous month that his run on those titles would last into 2013,[149][150] announced that he was quitting DC Comics, with his last issues being the #0 issues to be published that September. Though he characterized his experience on The New 52 as positive overall, he did not disguise his animosity toward editor Brian Smith, with whom he clashed, being among his reasons for leaving the company.[151][152] Other reasons he cited were frequent rewrites of his material, and the overall corporate culture that was more prevalent now that both DC and Marvel were owned by large media conglomerates. Liefeld also referred to Scott Clark's artwork on Grifter as "crap".[153] In response to these events, artist Pete Woods defended DC editorial, stating that the restrictions placed on creators was the result of a plan they had for all 52 of their titles that required them to be consistent with one another.[153] Marvel's Senior Vice President of Publishing Tom Brevoort and writer Gail Simone defended Brian Smith, disputing Liefeld's characterization of him, leading to a heated exchange on Twitter between Liefeld and Brevoort,[153][154] and eventually head Batman writer Scott Snyder as well.[153][154][155]

In late November 2012, Rich Johnston of Bleeding Cool had noted the possibility of Gail Simone leaving Batgirl and possibly DC Comics as a whole.[156] In December 2012, Simone had revealed that she was no longer the writer of Batgirl,[157] despite the title being a consistent top-seller which had received favorable reviews.[133] She had been informed by her new editor, Brian Cunningham, via e-mail of the creative change.[158] Ray Fawkes would fill in for two issues, Batgirl #17 and 18.[159] Twelve days after being fired, Simone had announced that she had been re-hired as the writer of Batgirl, and that she would return following Fawkes' issues.[160]

In March 2013, both Andy Diggle and Joshua Hale Fialkov announced that they would be leaving their writing duties at DC Comics. Diggle had previously signed as ongoing writer of Action Comics starting with issue #19, following Grant Morrison's run on the title. However, Diggle later announced that he would be leaving the title before the first issue had been published, citing professional reasons. He is credited as the sole writer in issue #19. Series artist Tony Daniel finished Diggle's work on the title as a scripter.[161] Fialkov was signed to write both Red Lanterns and Green Lantern Corps following Geoff Johns's departure from the Green Lantern line, however, Fialkov left DC Comics without a single issue being written by him due to creative differences with editorial.[162]

In September 2013, J. H. Williams III and Haden Blackman announced their intention to leave Batwoman with issue 26, citing last-minute editorial changes as the reason.[163] Among these editorial decisions was a prohibition on having the title character marry her fiancée Maggie Sawyer. Co-Publisher Dan DiDio explained that the major superheroes in the Batman family of books should not get married because finding true happiness would undermine the angst and turmoil that typify those characters, and their commitment to the superhero lives they lead. Writer Marc Andreyko, who is openly gay himself, took over the title with issue 25, which featured a "Batman: Zero Year" tie-in.[164] This creative change interrupted the finale to Williams' and Blackman's work on the title; they had already written issues 25 and 26 prior to their departure.[165] Andreyko resolved Batwoman #24's cliffhanger ending in Batwoman Annual #1.[166]

In other media

[edit]
  • In the video game Batman: Arkham Origins, skins based on Batman's New 52 costume design (and a metallic variant) and the Batman of Earth 2's New 52 design, are available to be unlocked.[167][168][169]
  • In the video game Injustice: Gods Among Us, three alternate costumes based on The New 52 designs of Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman were packaged with the Collector's Edition of the game.[170] "The New 52" skin pack was later released as DLC, alongside an "Earth 2" skin pack, featuring Solomon Grundy, the Flash and Hawkgirl's designs from the Earth 2 series.[171] Alternate costumes based on The New 52 designs of Nightwing, the Flash, Green Lantern, and Shazam are also unlockable in the game.[172] In the PlayStation 4 edition of the game, a skin based on The New 52 Black Adam is available.[173]
  • The 2014 direct-to-video animated film, Justice League: War, is based on the first New 52 Justice League storyline, "Origin". Aquaman's New 52 origin is examined in the DC Universe animated film Justice League: Throne of Atlantis.[174]
  • Many of the design changes to DC Comics characters brought about by the New 52 continue to persist in licensed products and representations of the characters outside of comics. For instance, DC characters as they appear in theme parks and attractions at various Six Flags parks[175] as well as in the extensive DC Comics representations at both Warner Bros. World Abu Dhabi[176] and Warner Bros. Movie World in Australia are represented by their New 52 character designs.[177] Character meet-and-greets with DC superheroes and villains at these parks also feature performers wearing physical costumes based on New 52 character designs.[178][179]

See also

[edit]
  • "Flashpoint", the storyline that leads directly into The New 52
  • DC Rebirth, the initiative that follows The New 52
  • DC Implosion, a 1978 event in which DC cancelled or reformatted many of its titles, although not for the purposes of rebooting the fictional universe
  • "Crisis on Infinite Earths", a similar 1985 storyline, used to simplify and reboot concepts in the DC Universe
  • "Infinite Crisis", the 2005–2006 sequel storyline to Crisis on Infinite Earths

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

The New 52

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The New 52 was a comprehensive relaunch of DC Comics' primary superhero continuity, unveiled in September 2011 following the Flashpoint crossover event, which reset the timeline and enabled a fresh narrative foundation. This initiative introduced 52 new ongoing series—each commencing with issue #1—including core titles like by and , Batman, , and , with the goal of streamlining decades of accumulated backstory to appeal to new audiences while refreshing character aesthetics, powers, and interrelations. The relaunch generated substantial initial sales momentum, with several debut issues exceeding 100,000 units sold and #1 achieving over 370,000 copies, marking a commercial high point for DC amid competition from Marvel's event-driven strategies. Notable creative highlights included innovative arcs such as Scott Snyder's Batman: , which expanded Gotham's lore, and Grant Morrison's , reimagining as a more socially conscious, working-class figure in a pseudo-historical context. Despite early successes, The New 52 faced criticism for inconsistent editorial oversight, abrupt creative team shifts, and tonal shifts toward grittier, more violent depictions—such as a willingness to employ lethal force in characters like —alongside controversial costume redesigns emphasizing sexualization and the sidelining of established supporting characters like . These elements contributed to fan division, with some praising the bold reinventions and others lamenting the erosion of legacy elements and perceived overemphasis on shock value over coherent world-building. The era concluded in 2016 with the initiative, which reintegrated pre-2011 continuity aspects to address lingering dissatisfaction.

Publication History

Launch in 2011 and Initial Rollout

The New 52 relaunch followed the conclusion of DC Comics' Flashpoint crossover event in 2011, which depicted a distorted timeline created by the Flash's attempts, ultimately necessitating a reset of the publisher's continuity. On May 31, 2011, DC Comics announced the initiative, stating it would involve a "historic renumbering" of its entire line with 52 new #1 issues, alongside the introduction of day-and-date digital distribution for print releases. This move canceled all existing titles and aimed to refresh the by portraying most heroes as younger and less experienced, with many prior events reimagined or excised. The rollout commenced on August 31, 2011, with the midnight release of #1, scripted by and drawn by , which served as the cornerstone title chronicling the team's initial assembly against Darkseid's forces in a post-reset world. The remaining 51 titles debuted weekly through September 2011, encompassing flagship series such as , Batman, , Superman, Wonder Woman, , and , alongside newer or revived books like , , and All-Star Western. Co-publishers and oversaw the effort, emphasizing accessibility for new readers while retaining core character elements amid the altered backstory. Initial sales were robust, with all 52 first issues selling out at point-of-purchase and ordered for second printings, reflecting strong retailer and fan interest in the rebooted lineup. The launch also featured promotional events, including reveals at in July 2011, where detailed solicitations and creative teams were unveiled to build anticipation. This structured debut marked DC's most ambitious line-wide initiative since the 1980s , positioning The New 52 as a unified entry point into the .

Expansion and Title Adjustments (2012–2013)

In early 2012, DC Comics announced a "Second Wave" of six new ongoing series launching in May, replacing titles that concluded after their eighth issues to refine the lineup and further develop the DC Universe. The cancelled series included Blackhawks, Hawk and Dove, Men of War, Mister Terrific, O.M.A.C., and Static Shock, which had struggled with sales and reader engagement since the September 2011 relaunch. The incoming titles diversified genres and introduced multiversal elements: (Vol. 2), written by with art by Chris Burnham, depicted Batman's global organization confronting Leviathan; Earth 2, by James Robinson and , reimagined the Justice Society on a parallel world amid Apokoliptian threats; , by with and Kevin Maguire, followed Huntress and exiled from Earth 2; Dial H, by and Mateus Santolouco, explored temporary superhero transformations via a dialing device; G.I. Combat, by J.T. Krul and Ariel Olivetti, revived "The War That Time Forgot" with anthology war stories featuring characters like the ; and The Ravagers, by Howard Mackie and Ian Churchill, tracked , , and others fleeing N.O.W.H.E.R.E. control. These launches expanded the initiative beyond its original 52 titles, prioritizing narrative innovation over strict numerical limits. September 2012 marked the first anniversary with #0 issues across all ongoing New 52 series, offering prequel origins and backstory to hook readers and address continuity gaps. This event coincided with additional launches, such as the Third Wave in September, including Sword of Sorcery and Justice League Dark, further broadening the shared universe while testing market viability. Into 2013, DC continued iterative adjustments amid fluctuating sales, cancelling underperformers like The Savage , Fury of : The Nuclear Man, Sword of Sorcery, Team 7, , Ravagers, and Presents by mid-year to introduce fresh series such as , The Movement, and Trinity of Sin: The Phantom Stranger. These changes, totaling over a dozen swaps, reflected a strategy of to sustain momentum, resulting in more than 70 active titles by late 2013 and emphasizing high-stakes events like "" to interconnect the expanding roster.

Major Events and Shifts (2013–2014)

In mid-2013, the "" crossover event spanned July and August, drawing the , Justice League of America, and into conflict over , which unleashed secrets tied to the Trinity of Sin—Pandora, the Phantom Stranger, and the Question. Written primarily by with art by and others, the six-issue arc revealed betrayals and culminated in the Crime Syndicate's invasion from Earth-3, fracturing alliances and introducing multiversal threats that reshaped heroic dynamics. September 2013 marked "Villains Month," a company-wide push where issue #23 of 52 titles spotlighted antagonists with 3D lenticular covers, aiming to elevate villain narratives and sales through gimmick packaging. This initiative fed directly into "," a seven-issue by Johns and launching that month and concluding in May 2014, where the Crime Syndicate subdued Earth after the Justice League's disappearance into the matrix, compelling uneasy villain coalitions led by to resist. The event, encompassing dozens of tie-ins, inverted traditional hero-villain roles, killed off characters like the Crime Syndicate's Earth-3 analogue, and prompted retcons such as the Suicide Squad's relocation, signaling a pivot toward darker, antagonist-driven continuity adjustments. By May 2014, DC debuted "The New 52: ," an 11-month weekly series from May 7 to April 2015, co-written by , , and others, depicting a five-years-future scenario dominated by Brother Eye's surveillance regime, with Terry McGinnis's time-traveling to prevent it. Accompanied by #0 issues and tie-ins across 20-plus titles, the event tested weekly publishing viability and foreshadowed existential threats, contributing to narrative fragmentation critiques while experimenting with long-term plotting in the New 52 framework.

Final Phase and Transition to Rebirth (2014–2016)

In 2014, the New 52 continuity saw further developments through major crossovers such as , which concluded in May and explored the Crime Syndicate's invasion, resulting in the deaths of key villains like the Rogues and the introduction of new elements like the Crime Bible. Simultaneously, the weekly The New 52: Futures End series launched on May 7, projecting a dystopian future influenced by Brother Eye, which influenced ongoing titles by foreshadowing threats like a corrupted timeline. These events aimed to inject momentum amid growing fan critiques of fragmented storytelling, though sales for flagship titles like had declined 35% year-over-year by March. The year 2015 marked a pivotal pause with the Convergence event, running from April 8 to May 27, during which all monthly New 52 series halted publication to facilitate DC's relocation of offices from New York to . Story-wise, Brainiac ensnared cities from collapsing —including pre-Flashpoint eras—into domes for gladiatorial contests, culminating in the restoration of the DC and subtle integrations of legacy histories. Over 40 two-issue featured cross-era matchups, such as classic versus New 52 versions, generating mixed reception for prioritizing over but allowing editorial flexibility for future continuity adjustments. Post-event relaunches in June included Earth 2: Society and Green Lanterns, alongside tie-ins like Superman: Lois and Clark, which hinted at suppressed pre-New 52 elements, signaling an impending shift as overall line sales continued to soften compared to the 2011 peak. By early 2016, amid retailer feedback on declining engagement and calls for restorative changes, DC announced the Rebirth initiative on at the ComicsPRO trade show, positioning it as a soft relaunch rather than a full reboot to reclaim emotional depth and legacy lost in the New 52's compressed timeline. The cornerstone DC Universe: Rebirth #1, written by and released May 25, revealed Dr. Manhattan's interference—drawn from —as the cause of excised heroic histories and the "missing 10 years," thereby hybridizing New 52 elements with pre-Flashpoint characterizations without erasing prior developments. Subsequent titles renumbered selectively (e.g., Detective Comics to #934 to honor its legacy) while debuting new #1s, effectively phasing out the New 52 branding by June and boosting initial sales through renewed focus on interconnected optimism over isolated grit. This transition addressed long-standing criticisms of the era's causal inconsistencies and thematic pessimism, as articulated by executives like , by privileging multiversal reconciliation and character-driven causality.

Core Changes to the DC Universe

Continuity Overhaul and Retcons

The New 52 initiated a comprehensive continuity reboot for the , enacted through the "Flashpoint" miniseries (issues #1–5, May–August 2011), where Barry Allen's time-travel intervention to avert his mother's death fractured the timeline, resulting in a divergent reality that DC Comics leveraged to reset its shared universe. This overhaul compressed the effective history of most superheroes to approximately five years of activity prior to the relaunch, discarding decades of accumulated events, alliances, and character developments from the Post-Crisis era (1986–2011) to streamline accessibility for new readers while retaining select core elements. The relaunch, announced in June 2011 and executed with 52 new #1 issues in September 2011, positioned the 's formation—depicted in "" #1—as a pivotal recent event that united icons like Superman, Batman, and against Darkseid's invasion five years earlier, fundamentally altering the timeline's foundational chronology. Key retcons targeted flagship characters' origins and relationships to inject freshness and edginess. Superman's backstory was revised in "Action Comics" #1 (September 2011), portraying a younger, less polished who debuts publicly in civilian attire (jeans and a ) as a social activist exposing corruption, rather than the established global protector with decades of heroic precedent; this version also eliminated his marriage to and prior fatherhood with Superboy (Kon-El), severing ties to expansive lore. Wonder Woman's heritage shifted dramatically in "Wonder Woman" vol. 4 #1 (September 2011), retconning her from a being sculpted from clay and granted life by the gods to the biological daughter of and , emphasizing a more mythological, warrior-goddess with divine conflicts central to her . Batman's continuity incorporated new lore like the —a secret society predating his vigilante career—in "Batman" vol. 2 #1–3 (September–November 2011), while compressing his global travels and retaining as his assassin-trained son and Robin, but within the foreshortened timeline that omitted deeper pre-Robin mentorships and alliances. Broader universe-wide adjustments included de-aging supporting casts, reinstating certain deaths (e.g., Jason Todd's resurrection as was preserved but isolated from prior team affiliations in "" #1), and reconfiguring cosmic elements like the ' scale and the magical hierarchy, with introduced in "" #1 as a multiversal artifact explaining lingering anomalies. These changes aimed to resolve perceived continuity bloat but introduced inconsistencies, such as fragmented histories for the and , whose future connections to present-day heroes were initially nullified. While some retcons, like Superman's initial indigent portrayal, drew from first-issue experiments to highlight alien vulnerability, others faced criticism for undermining iconic stability, prompting later New 52 events like "[Forever Evil](/page/Forever Evil)" (2013–2014) to patch gaps without fully restoring prior canon.

Character Redesigns and Backstories

The New 52 relaunch featured extensive visual redesigns for DC's characters, often modernizing costumes by incorporating tactical elements, advanced armor, and streamlined aesthetics, while compressing the overall DC Universe timeline to roughly five years of superhero activity since the Justice League's formation. Creators including Jim Lee, Mark Chiarello, and Cully Hamner oversaw these updates to refresh iconic looks for contemporary audiences. Superman received a notably younger portrayal, depicted as less experienced with dying in a car accident prior to his relocation to , echoing elements of his origins. His initial costume in * (September 2011) consisted of a emblazoned with the House of El symbol paired with jeans, evolving into a trunkless suit that abandoned the traditional red briefs-over-tights design. Romantic ties to were severed, with no established marriage, and later developments paired him with . Batman similarly shed the iconic trunks for a more grounded, armored suit, maintaining his core origin but integrating new lore such as the in Batman #1 (September 2011). Wonder Woman's backstory shifted to position her as the biological daughter of and Queen Hippolyta, diverging from prior clay-sculpted narratives, with portrayed as engaging in ritualistic breeding practices involving kidnapped men to align more closely with Greek mythological roots. Her costume retained pants briefly in early concepts before reverting to shorts. Cyborg's role expanded dramatically, becoming a founding Justice League member in place of , with his origin revised to involve a from an early incursion. Barbara Gordon reverted to active status in Batgirl #1 (September 2011), undoing her paralysis from The Killing Joke (1988) and eliminating the hacker persona, set at age 21 to emphasize youthful dynamics. Nightwing adopted a red-and-black costume scheme over the classic blue-and-black. 's portrayal gained seriousness, launching with Aquaman #1 (September 2011) to counter prior perceptions of him as a lesser hero. These alterations positioned the as the inaugural superhero team, erasing prior generational elements like the from main Earth-0 continuity and prioritizing a streamlined, modern heroic mythos.

Thematic Shifts in Tone and Scope

The New 52 initiative marked a deliberate pivot toward a grittier, more mature tone in DC Comics storytelling, diverging from the relatively optimistic and legacy-driven narratives of the Post-Crisis era by emphasizing flawed heroes confronting immediate, visceral threats in a compressed five-year timeline since superheroes' emergence. This shift, articulated by DC Co-Publisher as a means to modernize characters for contemporary audiences, resulted in portrayals of icons like as more aggressive and isolated figures, with his debut issue depicting brutal confrontations against military forces amid public distrust. Similarly, Batman's mythos under incorporated gothic horror elements, such as the , amplifying psychological dread and over procedural detective work. In terms of scope, the relaunch expanded the DC Universe's narrative canvas by launching 52 ongoing titles in September 2011, encompassing a wider array of genres—from cosmic epics in to body horror in —while integrating supernatural and multiversal elements earlier in character arcs to heighten stakes without decades of accumulated history. , as Chief Creative Officer, described this as creating a "new playground" where events like the Darkseid invasion in (released August 31, 2011) served as foundational threats, broadening the universe's existential scale but often at the expense of interpersonal depth seen in prior continuities. The compressed timeline, limiting major events to roughly five years, narrowed historical scope to foster accessibility yet introduced inconsistencies, such as truncated Justice Society legacies, prioritizing immediate action over generational lore. Critics and creators later noted that this tonal darkening, while boosting initial sales through edgier visuals and themes like increased violence and sexualization (e.g., redesigned female costumes), sometimes veered into gratuitous grimness, as evidenced by controversial elements in titles like , which faced backlash for amid a broader push for "realism." Johns reflected in 2024 interviews that the intent was , not , but execution led to a perception of cynicism over heroism, influencing subsequent eras like Rebirth to restore balance. Overall, these shifts reflected industry trends toward serialized prestige TV-style narratives, yet they underscored tensions between innovation and fidelity to core archetypes.

Publications and Imprints

Mainline Titles and Lineups

The New 52 initiative relaunched DC Comics' mainline superhero continuity with 52 ongoing series, all debuting as #1 issues beginning August 31, 2011, with Justice League #1, and the majority releasing across September. These titles formed the core of the DC Universe, featuring revamped versions of iconic characters and teams, including multiple books centered on Batman (Batman, Detective Comics, Batman and Robin, Batwoman, Batgirl, Nightwing, Red Hood and the Outlaws, Batman: The Dark Knight), Superman-related properties (Action Comics, Superman, Supergirl, Superboy), Wonder Woman, The Flash, Green Lantern (Green Lantern, Green Lantern Corps), Aquaman, Green Arrow, and team books such as Justice League, Justice League International, and Justice League Dark. Additional series expanded into niche genres, such as horror (Animal Man, I, Vampire), Western (All Star Western), military (Men of War), and supernatural (Demon Knights, Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E.). Lineup adjustments began early to address sales performance, with the first wave of changes announced January 12, 2012. Six titles—Blackhawks, Hawk and Dove, Men of War, Mister Terrific, O.M.A.C., and Static Shock—concluded after their eighth issues in April 2012 and were replaced starting May 2012 by Batman Incorporated (written by Grant Morrison), Earth 2 (James Robinson), Worlds' Finest (Paul Levitz), Dial H (China Miéville), G.I. Combat (J.T. Krul), and The Ravagers (Howard Mackie). This "Second Wave" aimed to refresh the slate with new creative teams and storylines while maintaining the total around 52 books, incorporating elements from cancelled series into ongoing narratives. Subsequent years saw further rotations, including a third wave in late 2012 with titles like Talon, Justice League of America's Vibe, , Justice League of America, and Threshold, often tied to events such as "." By mid-2014, 47 New 52 titles had been discontinued overall, reflecting ongoing efforts to sustain commercial viability amid fluctuating readership. The era concluded with the "DC You" initiative in June 2015, introducing 24 new series (e.g., Justice League United, : Lost Army) alongside 25 continuing ones with refreshed teams, before transitioning to in mid-2016, which retained select New 52 elements but largely reverted to pre-relaunch numbering and continuity.

Vertigo and Other Imprints

The Vertigo imprint maintained its focus on mature-audience titles outside the core New 52 , continuing series like Fables (issues #116–150, 2011–2015) and (issues #20–66, 2011–2016) without altering their established continuities. These publications emphasized creator-owned and licensed properties with themes of horror, fantasy, and , distinct from the mainline DC Universe's revised timeline. Selective crossover occurred, as DC relocated certain Vertigo-adjacent characters to the New 52 framework; Hellblazer concluded its 300-issue run on February 13, 2013, enabling John Constantine's debut in the mainline Justice League Dark #1 (October 2011), where he operated in a younger, rebooted persona integrated with Justice League events. Similarly, Swamp Thing (New 52 vol. 1, #1–52, 2011–2014) and Animal Man (New 52 vol. 2, #1–58, 2011–2014) shifted from Vertigo's orbit to core titles, incorporating environmental horror elements into the rebooted DC cosmology while retaining mature content ratings. In contrast, the WildStorm imprint underwent full integration into the New 52 DC Universe starting September 28, 2011, folding its characters—such as Apollo, Midnighter, and the WildC.A.T.s team—into main continuity to broaden the shared universe. Titles like Stormwatch (#0–#30, 2011–2014) reimagined The Authority as a covert team monitoring cosmic threats, while Grifter (#0–#16, 2011–2013) depicted Cole Cash combating Daemonites in a street-level narrative. This merger retconned Martian Manhunter as Checkmate's founder, linking WildStorm's espionage motifs to DC's Justice League International history, though many series faced cancellation by 2014 due to inconsistent sales. No other major DC imprints, such as Milestone, saw revival or restructuring during this period.

Digital and Weekly Initiatives

The New 52 initiative marked DC Comics' adoption of simultaneous print and digital releases, beginning with #1 on August 31, 2011, and extending to all 52 relaunched titles, which were made available digitally on the same day as their physical counterparts. This day-and-date strategy aimed to broaden accessibility and compete in the growing digital market, with initial #1 issues offered at $0.99 digitally to encourage sampling. In June 2013, introduced the DC2 format, an enhanced digital platform that incorporated motion comics, interactive panels, and dynamic artwork layered onto static pages, debuting with titles like Batman: Black and White Motion Comics and expanding New 52 storytelling dimensions. Digital-first publications emerged as a complementary effort, prioritizing online before print collections. Injustice: Gods Among Us, a to the 2013 , launched digitally in 2013 with chapter-based releases—such as three chapters compiled into #1—before physical bundling, generating over 2 million digital downloads in its first year. Similarly, Sensation Comics Featuring debuted as a weekly digital-first in July 2014, reviving the title with non-canonical stories by diverse creators, alternating with other digital series like Batman '66. Weekly series initiatives intensified in 2014 to sustain reader engagement amid monthly norms, launching multiple ongoing titles. began April 9, 2014, as a 52-issue weekly narrative exploring Batman's rogues and allies in a continuous storyline crafted by rotating writers including and . followed on May 7, 2014, as an 11-month weekly miniseries depicting a dystopian five-years-ahead timeline with Brother Eye's rise, involving creators like and , and tying into broader New 52 futures exploration. Earth 2: World's End commenced weekly in September 2014, chronicling apocalyptic events on the alternate Earth-2, serving as a bridge to the 2015 Convergence event and concluding the New 52's multiversal arcs. These efforts, producing over 150 weekly issues collectively, tested serialized momentum but faced criticism for diluted creative focus due to rapid production demands.

Commercial Performance

Initial Sales Surge and Metrics

The New 52 initiative launched on September 21, 2011, with the release of 52 new #1 issues across DC Comics' line, resulting in an immediate sell-out of all titles and subsequent announcements of second printings for each by September 27. This surge was driven by pre-publication hype, including high-profile creative teams and a full continuity , leading to DC Comics capturing eight of the top ten best-selling comics for the month based on orders to specialty retailers. Pre-order estimates from indicated strong initial demand, with Batman #1 topping the charts at approximately 188,420 units ordered to shops. Key flagship titles exceeded 200,000 copies in first-printing sales, including #1, , and Batman #1, with #1 specifically surpassing 200,000 units and becoming the best-selling comic of 2011 up to that point excluding reprints and digital. DC reported eleven titles achieving over 100,000 copies sold, with #1 marking the eleventh such entry. At least six titles cleared the 100,000-unit threshold in retailer orders alone, underscoring the relaunch's broad appeal beyond core icons. Overall, DC Comics achieved an estimated 3,417,090 units sold across its titles in September 2011, averaging 65,713 units per title—a record-breaking monthly performance that reversed prior downward trends and boosted the publisher's market position. This total encompassed approximately 3.0 million units from superhero books, generating $10.9 million in revenue for the month. The relaunch's metrics reflected a temporary influx of lapsed and new readers enticed by the zero-issue entry point, though figures represent primarily direct-market sales to comic shops via , excluding bookstore, digital, and international channels.
TitleEstimated September 2011 Sales (Diamond Orders)
Batman #1188,420
~150,000+ (first printing >200,000 total)
Justice League #1~150,000+ (first printing >200,000 total)
Green Lantern #1~120,000+
Superman #1~100,000+
Note: Sales estimates derive from retailer orders; actual consumer , including reprints, exceeded these for top titles. Following the September 2011 launch, for many New 52 titles declined steadily after an initial surge driven by curiosity and variant covers, with mid-tier series often failing to sustain direct market orders above breakeven thresholds. DC Comics enforced a cancellation for ongoing titles when estimated fell below approximately 18,000 units in the direct market, reflecting the economic realities of print runs, distribution costs, and retailer reorders in the specialty sector. Early examples included , which ended with issue #12 in May 2012 despite co-publisher describing its performance as "okay," prioritizing resources for higher-potential projects like Justice League of America. Similarly, concluded after eight issues in early 2012, as its sales did not align with DC's benchmarks for the expanded lineup. By February 2013, DC had already announced multiple cancellations tied to sub-18,000 thresholds, signaling instability in non-flagship books. The trend accelerated through 2013–2014, with DC replacing underperformers via new launches but facing persistent churn; by May 2014, 47 New 52-originated titles had been cancelled or discontinued, nearing the original 52-title count. That month, solicitations confirmed six more low-sellers—All-Star Western, Batwing, The Phantom Stranger, Suicide Squad, Trinity of Sin: Pandora, and Nightwing (relaunched)—set for August 2014 endings due to inadequate sales. Flagships like Batman and Justice League endured with stronger averages (often 70,000+ units), but the overall line's high turnover underscored a failure to build broad, sustained readership beyond launch hype. This pattern contributed to DC's eroding market share relative to Marvel, with 2013 marking a peak after which unit sales trended downward, culminating in the New 52's phase-out via the 2015 Convergence event and 2016 Rebirth relaunch.

Factors Influencing Market Outcomes

The New 52's market outcomes were initially propelled by an aggressive marketing campaign and the novelty of a comprehensive relaunch, with all 52 debut issues selling out and necessitating second printings in 2011. This surge marked the highest average sales point for DC in over a decade, driven largely by curiosity purchases from lapsed readers and collectors capitalizing on uniform #1 issues. Retail analysts noted that early sales reflected speculative buying rather than sustained demand, as first- and second-issue figures exceeded typical thresholds but failed to convert into long-term readership. Subsequent declines were exacerbated by rapid erosion in ongoing sales, with most titles dropping below viable levels within months, prompting numerous cancellations by 2013. Key contributors included fan alienation from rebooted character origins and storylines that diverged sharply from pre-Crisis continuity, such as alterations to , which correlated with plummeting unit sales for flagship titles. DC's editorial policy of canceling series dipping under approximately 18,000 estimated direct market copies accelerated title turnover, undermining line stability and reader investment. Broader industry dynamics, including competition from Marvel's concurrent initiatives like Marvel NOW! and a stagnant direct market, amplified vulnerabilities, as the New 52's average sales boost proved unsustainable beyond the launch window. While the relaunch temporarily elevated DC's through sheer volume of new content, inconsistent creative execution and failure to recapture legacy fans led to a relative decline in performance against competitors by 2013. Creator reflections, including from former CCO , highlighted internal missteps in balancing reboot scope with audience retention as pivotal to the faltering trajectory.

Creative Reception

Strengths in Storytelling and Art

The New 52 initiative featured several standout titles that demonstrated strengths in storytelling through fresh, accessible narratives designed to attract new readers while delivering compelling arcs. Scott Snyder's run on Batman, paired with Greg Capullo's artwork, was widely regarded as a highlight, with the "Court of the Owls" storyline (Batman #1–11, 2011–2012) introducing a secretive Gotham cult that challenged Batman's mastery of his city, blending horror elements with in a manner that balanced exposition and action effectively. This approach revitalized the character for contemporary audiences, earning praise for its innovative lore expansion without relying on overused villains. Capullo's illustrations enhanced these narratives with dynamic, intense sequences that evoked a cinematic quality, as seen in infiltration scenes and high-stakes confrontations that intensified emotional stakes. Similarly, Geoff Johns and Jim Lee's Justice League #1 (September 2011) reimagined the team's formation against Darkseid's invasion, emphasizing team dynamics and blockbuster action in a self-contained origin that prioritized visual spectacle and forward momentum over dense backstory. Lee's detailed, iconic designs for the heroes set a visual benchmark for the relaunch, influencing subsequent issues with polished, high-energy panels that supported the epic scope. Titles like and , both written by starting in September 2011, excelled in weaving interconnected horror narratives rooted in environmental and familial themes, with Yanick Paquette's lush, atmospheric art on providing immersive depictions of rot and regeneration that amplified the story's mythic undertones. These works highlighted the relaunch's capacity for genre experimentation within frameworks, fostering deeper character explorations amid threats. Overall, the involvement of top-tier creators enabled visually striking issues that often prioritized artistic innovation, contributing to memorable set pieces across the line.

Weaknesses in Coherence and Execution

The New 52 relaunch, initiated in September 2011 following the Flashpoint event, aimed to streamline DC Comics' continuity but frequently resulted in fragmented narratives and unresolved plot threads due to uneven implementation across its 52 launch titles. Editorial overambition in producing such a volume of series simultaneously led to inadequate oversight, allowing inconsistencies in character histories and universe-building to proliferate; for instance, incorporated a convoluted "retroboot" that retained pre-reboot elements, rendering the title's timeline unapproachable for new readers while clashing with the broader reboot's intent. Similarly, titles featured conflicting origin details, compelling artist to invent new villains to reconcile discrepancies between and . Characterization often suffered from abrupt, poorly justified shifts that undermined established traits, contributing to incoherent portrayals. In , Starfire was depicted as hyper-sexualized and emotionally detached, diverging sharply from her prior compassionate depictions and prioritizing titillation over depth, which alienated longstanding fans. Teen Titans similarly presented as a clichéd, unlikable leader in meandering stories lacking purpose, while endured erratic creative shifts, including the absence of key allies like , resulting in jarring tonal inconsistencies across runs. These execution flaws were exacerbated by a compressed timeline that erased decades of legacy, raising logical gaps such as the unexplained origins of characters like in relation to Bruce Wayne's history. Cross-title events highlighted broader execution shortcomings, with initiatives like the box storyline in Trinity of Sin: Pandora building mystery without resolution, serving merely as a setup for subsequent crossovers rather than a cohesive arc. Justice League: Origin by and exemplified narrative mismatches, including awkward paired with mismatched art that suggested insufficient creative alignment during production. Editorial mandates further hampered coherence, as Batman writer recounted a specific demand for a controversial plot element that nearly prompted his departure, illustrating how top-down interventions disrupted organic storytelling. Former DC Chief Creative Officer later reflected that the initiative's scale—launching dozens of interdependent titles—overwhelmed coordination efforts, fostering disconnection rather than unity in the . Quick cancellations of underperforming series, such as Hawk and Dove and Static Shock, left dangling threads without closure, compounding perceptions of sloppy execution.

Creator Perspectives and Innovations

The New 52 initiative introduced innovations aimed at revitalizing DC's lineup, including the simultaneous relaunch of 52 titles numbered at #1 to appeal to new readers by simplifying entry points and erasing much prior continuity. Co-publisher proposed the number 52 for its symbolic resonance in DC lore and oversaw widespread character redesigns, such as updated costumes for , and the , to convey a more contemporary aesthetic. These changes emphasized younger iterations of iconic heroes, edgier narratives, and diversified genres, initially incorporating non-superhero books like Westerns and war stories to broaden market appeal. Creators viewed the reboot as an opportunity for bold reinvention, though experiences varied. , as chief creative officer, described it as driving DC's largest modern successes through innovative storytelling in select titles, praising and Greg Capullo's Batman run for its excellence and highlighting creative highs in series like . , writing Batman, found the process "innovative and fun," likening it to daily reinvention that enabled fresh arcs like , which introduced a hidden Gotham society, despite editorial tensions over unresolved mysteries. His Zero Year storyline reimagined Bruce Wayne's origin to align with the rebooted timeline, emphasizing detective elements and urban threats. Grant Morrison approached Action Comics by focusing on Superman's nascent years, innovating with a "New Deal"-inspired portrayal of the hero in jeans and a T-shirt as a populist rebel addressing post-financial crisis themes, before evolving to the classic costume. Morrison aimed to restore symbolic depth to amid the reboot's constraints, viewing the character as a tool for exploring establishment versus rebellion. Judd Winick expressed enthusiasm for the creative prospects of rebooting titles like Catwoman and Batwing, seeing it as a chance to explore new dynamics unburdened by decades of history. Overall, while the lack of a unified plan led to ad-hoc development, creators credited the initiative with fostering ambitious, standalone narratives that influenced subsequent DC events.

Controversies and Editorial Practices

Micromanagement and Creative Control

During the New 52 initiative launched on September 21, 2011, DC Comics' editorial leadership, headed by Editor-in-Chief Bob Harras under co-publishers Dan DiDio and Jim Lee, imposed stringent oversight on creative teams to enforce a unified reboot of the DC Universe continuity. This approach frequently led to contradictory directives and last-minute interventions, frustrating writers and artists who sought greater autonomy in storytelling. Creators reported receiving shifting guidelines on character histories and universe rules, with DiDio later attributing continuity errors to the company's "hubris" in assuming a clean slate could be maintained without a comprehensive underlying plan. Specific instances highlighted tensions over creative control. Scott Snyder, writer on Batman, clashed with DiDio and Harras over a format choice in Batman #5 (November 2011), where the issue was designed to be read upside-down; executives rejected it, prompting Snyder to defend the decision vigorously. Similarly, Snyder threatened to terminate his contract when editors pushed to alter the ending of the "Court of Owls" arc in Batman #11 (May 2012), arguing it undermined the narrative's integrity. Paul Cornell faced inconsistent rules for Stormwatch, being told the team "could and couldn’t have" Martian Manhunter due to evolving continuity mandates. Christy Marx's Amethyst series (starting June 2012) was disrupted by demands to insert Eclipso for a crossover event, overriding her standalone storyline plans. These interventions extended to page-level edits and team assignments. An anonymous writer described an editor rearranging completed art pages, forcing a complete story rewrite as a "complete nightmare." High-profile exits underscored the fallout: departed Superman after six issues (ending April 2012) due to editorial's inability to clarify basic reboot elements, such as the status of Superman's adoptive parents. and W. Haden Blackman quit Batwoman in September 2013 after DC prohibited the character's same-sex marriage, a plot point central to their vision, with the decision attributed to editorial policy. Joshua Fialkov left Green Lantern Corps in 2013 upon learning of plans to kill off John Stewart, while was briefly fired from Batgirl in late 2012 over unapproved changes before being rehired amid backlash. DiDio's enforcement of a 20,000-copy sales minimum further pressured titles, contributing to rapid cancellations and creator churn as books failed to align with imposed metrics over organic development. The New 52 relaunch in September 2011 featured redesigned costumes and portrayals for several female characters that prioritized visual , prompting widespread debate over and the in . Critics argued these depictions reduced complex heroines to props for male protagonists or readers, with exaggerated proportions, minimal clothing, and poses emphasizing body parts over narrative agency. A study analyzing DC covers and panels from the era found in 136 of 144 sampled issues, including "broke back" or arched poses in 50-66% of relevant panels and clothing designed to appear precarious, though the New 52 series stood out as the sole title without such covers. Starfire's portrayal in #1 (September ), written by , exemplified the controversy: her costume was reduced to a bikini-like minimalism, and she was depicted initiating with teammates and Roy Harper as a form of "," stripping away her prior empathetic, emotionally vulnerable traits in favor of an emotionally detached, sexually voracious archetype. Fans and reviewers condemned this as turning her into a "" or "," deviating from her roots as a princess valuing deep bonds, while defenders noted her historical sensuality on Tamaran but contended the execution prioritized titillation over character depth. Similarly, #1 by and Guillem March opened with an extended sex scene between Kyle and Batman, featuring risqué artwork that some deemed gratuitous, though aligned with her seductive canon persona; the issue targeted an older, male-skewing audience but fueled accusations of exploitative content. Harley Quinn's New 52 redesign in her solo series (2013 launch) shifted to a taut, revealing ensemble resembling lingerie fused with athletic wear—red-and-black , shorts, and thigh-highs—amplifying her chaotic allure but drawing fire for hyper-sexualizing a character already known for playful mania, with critics linking it to broader industry trends favoring visual appeal over psychological nuance. Wonder Woman's run by and Cliff Chiang (2011-2016) received praise for portraying her as a fierce Amazon warrior confronting gods, yet alterations like naming her father diluted her traditional parthenogenetic, all-female origins, prompting feminist critiques of undermining her as a symbol of female autonomy. Editorial decisions under co-publisher Dan Didio contributed to the debates, as the relaunch reduced female-led titles from 13 to 10 and female creators from 12% to 1% of teams, prompting Comic-Con queries on gender imbalance; Didio emphasized hiring the "best" talent regardless of demographics, while DC issued a statement acknowledging fan concerns and pledging responsiveness. These choices reflected a strategy to recapture a core male readership through bold, fantasy-oriented aesthetics, correlating with initial sales surges (e.g., Red Hood and the Outlaws #1 sold over 80,000 copies), but alienated segments of female fans and critics who viewed the patterns as symptomatic of institutional bias toward adolescent male fantasies rather than balanced storytelling. Proponents countered that comics inherently involve idealized physiques for escapism, with sexualization as artistic liberty not unique to females, though empirical data on declining female readership (around 7% for New 52 titles per DC surveys) suggested causal links to such portrayals. The backlash influenced later shifts, as Rebirth (2016) reverted designs like Starfire's to less provocative forms, signaling market corrections.

Diversity in Creative Teams and Hiring

The initial creative teams for the New 52 relaunch in September 2011 featured limited diversity, particularly in gender representation. Across the 52 titles, there were 160 credited creators, of whom 157 were male and only 3 were , equating to approximately 1% female participation. This disparity drew immediate criticism from readers and industry observers, who highlighted the underrepresentation of women despite female characters comprising a significant portion of DC's roster. DC co-publisher addressed the issue at panels in July 2011, questioning the low submission rates from female creators and suggesting that hiring should reflect applicant pools rather than quotas. He remarked, "If you can’t get the number of female writers that you need for your books, why would you put on books that you don’t think are as good?" This stance intensified backlash, with critics arguing it overlooked systemic barriers in the industry, such as networking challenges and historical male dominance in comics hiring. DC's editorial team, led by figures like DiDio and Bob Harras, prioritized established talent for the high-stakes relaunch, which favored proven male creators like and over emerging diverse voices. In response to the outcry, DC issued a statement on August 1, 2011, affirming it was "taking [the] concerns very seriously" and actively seeking more female creators for ongoing titles. Subsequent hires included women like on Batgirl and , but overall female representation in New 52 creative roles remained below 5% through the initiative's run until 2016, per industry analyses. Data on racial and ethnic minorities in teams was less documented, though complaints noted a similar predominance of white creators, with few hires from underrepresented groups amid the focus on rapid relaunch production. Hiring practices emphasized freelance pitches aligned with editorial mandates, which critics contended perpetuated homogeneity by relying on insular industry networks rather than broader outreach.

Legacy and Ongoing Impact

Integration into Post-Rebirth Continuity

The initiative, launched with DC Universe: Rebirth #1 on May 25, 2016, succeeded The New 52 by maintaining its core continuity as the foundation while selectively restoring pre-Flashpoint elements through narrative retcons and mergers, creating a hybrid timeline rather than a full . This integration expanded the New 52's compressed five-year hero history to approximately 15 years, accommodating legacy events from 1986 to 2011 without invalidating major New 52 developments like the formation of the or character origin overhauls. A pivotal mechanism was the revelation in DC Universe: Rebirth #1 that external forces, including from Watchmen, had manipulated the timeline post-Flashpoint (2011), erasing 10 years of history and altering relationships; this framework allowed New 52 events to persist as canon while reintroducing pre-Flashpoint figures like , who returned as a bridge between eras. Many New 52 titles transitioned directly into Rebirth with new #1 issues, such as Justice League continuing its storyline under writer , ensuring ongoing arcs like the Justice League's battles against threats from Trinity War and Forever Evil remained intact. Character-specific integrations included mergers to resolve dual versions: in the 2017 "Superman Reborn" crossover (Superman #18-19 and Action Comics #975-976), the New 52 and pre-Flashpoint Superman fused into a single entity, blending their histories, powers, and family dynamics (including son Jon Kent's retention from New 52 continuity) to streamline the narrative. Similarly, restorations addressed New 52 alterations to relationships, such as hinting at reuniting —separated in The New 52 but iconic pre-Flashpoint partners—and reinstating marriages like /Lois Lane and /Mera, which had been undone. This approach preserved New 52 innovations, such as updated origins for characters like (revealed as Zeus's daughter) and (Barbara Gordon's paralysis retconned via the persona), while prioritizing fan-favored legacy elements; however, not all pre-Flashpoint aspects returned fully, as evidenced by the Justice Society of America's limited reintroduction and the retention of New 52's darker tone in select books. Subsequent events like (2017-2019) further contextualized the integration by linking New 52 divergences to multiversal anomalies, affirming the era's events as a distorted but valid branch of DC history.

Influence on DC's Broader Franchise

The New 52 relaunch in September 2011 generated significant initial sales increases across DC Comics titles, with all 52 launching issues achieving strong first-month figures that positioned DC as the top publisher in the direct market for several months. This surge attracted new readers and boosted overall franchise visibility, though sales declined sharply after the initial hype, failing to sustain long-term market dominance against competitors like Marvel. In film adaptations, the New 52 influenced the tone and character portrayals in the (DCEU), particularly through darker, more modernized depictions of heroes like and the integration of elements such as Cyborg's expanded role in the . Zack Snyder's films, starting with Man of Steel in 2013, drew from New 52 aesthetics and storylines, emphasizing gritty realism and rebooted origins that aligned with the initiative's goal of appealing to contemporary audiences. The initiative also shaped DC's animated output by establishing the DC Animated Movie Universe (DCAMU), a shared continuity launched with Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox in 2013, which directly adapted New 52 elements and redesigned characters to match the rebooted comic designs. This universe spanned over 15 films until 2020, extending New 52 characterizations into direct-to-video releases and influencing merchandising tied to those properties, though it faced criticism for inconsistent execution mirroring the comics' issues. Long-term, certain New 52 character alterations—such as streamlined origins for and —persisted into subsequent continuities like in 2016, while others were retconned, but the reboot's compression of DC history into a five-year timeline created ongoing narrative challenges that affected cross-media and fan engagement across the franchise. Recent developments, including 2024-2025 storylines, have canonized select New 52 events to resolve lingering inconsistencies, ensuring some rebooted elements remain integral to DC's framework.

Retrospective Assessments of Success and Failure

The New 52 initiative achieved immediate commercial success upon its September 2011 launch, with all 52 debut issues selling out prior to publication and necessitating second printings across the line. Average per-title sales for the inaugural month reached 67,411 units, reflecting a 40,000-unit increase compared to August 2011 figures, driven by widespread retailer orders and media hype. Titles such as Justice League #1 and Batman #1 exceeded 100,000 copies sold, bolstering DC's market share against Marvel and introducing elements like a younger Superman and integrated WildStorm characters to appeal to lapsed and new readers. However, long-term sustainability proved elusive, as sales declined sharply after the initial surge, with many series failing to maintain viability beyond 20-30 issues. By 2016, DC transitioned to Rebirth, acknowledging the New 52's inability to retain audiences, as evidenced by Rebirth's superior sales persistence—outpacing New 52 averages by sustaining higher monthly figures without equivalent drops. Approximately 20 of the 52 launch titles were deemed mediocre or worse in retrospective rankings, attributable to inconsistent creative assignments and insufficient quality oversight, contrasting with standout runs like Scott Snyder's Batman, which anchored ongoing success through narrative innovation. Critics and analysts have characterized the era as a "successful failure," praising its ambition in rebooting continuity to streamline accessibility but faulting execution for eroding character depth and fan loyalty through erratic retcons and tonal shifts toward aesthetics. Empirical indicators include high cancellation rates—over half the line ended prematurely—and a return to pre-Flashpoint elements in Rebirth, signaling the reboot's limited lasting integration. While it expanded DC's digital presence and diversified some imprints, the initiative's core failure lay in prioritizing volume over cohesive storytelling, resulting in fragmented universe-building that alienated core readership without proportionally converting newcomers.

References

  1. https://www.dc.com/graphic-novels/dc-comics-the-new-52-2011/dc-comics-the-new-52
  2. https://comicvine.gamespot.com/the-new-52/4015-56061/
  3. https://www.dc.com/graphic-novels/dc-comics-the-new-52-10th-anniversary-deluxe-edition
  4. https://www.comicbookherald.com/the-old-52-dcs-new-52-10-years-later-the-launch-what-went-wrong/
  5. https://henchman4hire.com/2015/02/11/the-6-best-and-the-6-worst-parts-of-dcs-new-52/
  6. https://www.cbr.com/dc-new-52-rereading-harsh-realities-downsides/
  7. https://comicbook.com/comicbook/news/fiv-lingering-controversies-of-the-new-52/
  8. https://www.polygon.com/comics/22679756/dc-comics-reboot-new-52-writers-oral-history/
  9. https://www.sideshow.com/blog/dc-comics-flashpoint-explained
  10. https://www.dc.com/blog/2011/05/31/dc-comics-announces-historic-renumbering-of-all-superhero-titles-and-landmark-day-and-date-digital-distribution
  11. https://www.dc.com/blog/2011/08/29/buzz-and-anticipation-for-dc-comics-the-new-52-continues-to-build
  12. https://www.ign.com/articles/2011/07/02/dc-reveals-the-new-52
  13. https://www.crushingkrisis.com/crushing-comics-guide-collecting-dc-comic-books/dc-new-52-definitive-collecting-guide/
  14. https://comicsalliance.com/dc-comics-september-2011/
  15. https://www.dc.com/blog/2011/09/27/inside-the-numbers-all-52-first-issues-of-dc-comics-the-new-52-sell-out-and-receive-second-printings
  16. https://www.dc.com/blog/2012/01/12/dc-comics-in-2012-introducing-the-second-wave-of-dc-comics-the-new-52
  17. https://bureau42.com/view/10792/dc-announced-new-52s-second-wave
  18. https://www.ign.com/articles/2012/01/12/the-second-wave-of-the-new-52
  19. https://www.sideshow.com/blog/how-the-new-52-changed-batman-dc
  20. https://heykidscomics.fandom.com/wiki/The_New_52
  21. https://www.polygon.com/comics/22679756/dc-comics-reboot-new-52-writers-oral-history
  22. https://www.usatoday.com/story/life/2013/04/07/justice-league-trinity-war/2050575/
  23. https://www.dc.com/blog/2013/07/19/sdcc-2013-dc-comics-justice-league-trinity-war
  24. https://www.dc.com/blog/2013/06/06/full-villains-month-breakdown
  25. https://www.dc.com/comics/forever-evil-2013/forever-evil-1
  26. https://www.comicbooktreasury.com/futures-end-a-dc-comics-universe-wide-event-from-the-new-52-era/
  27. http://angriest.blogspot.com/2014/04/judging-new-52-march-2014-superman.html?m=1
  28. https://www.wired.com/2014/11/dc-comics-convergence/
  29. https://comicsalliance.com/convergence-dc-dan-didio-interview/
  30. https://vertigology.net/2015/06/05/what-was-convergence-anyway-what-does-this-event-mean-for-dc-and-continuity/
  31. https://batman-news.com/2016/02/18/dc-comics-rebirth-details/
  32. https://www.dc.com/comics/dc-universe-rebirth-2016/dc-universe-rebirth-1
  33. https://www.howtolovecomics.com/2016/02/20/dc-comics-rebirth-guide/
  34. http://comicandscreen.blogspot.com/2016/11/dc-rebirth-and-new-52-sales-comparison.html
  35. https://comicbook.com/comics/news/10-worst-retcons-in-dc-history-superman-wonder-woman-the-flash-new-52/
  36. https://aiptcomics.com/2025/09/16/dc-fixing-continuity-problem-explained/
  37. https://www.cbr.com/ten-biggest-new-52-continuity-changes-dc-universe-rebirth-reversed/
  38. https://www.cbr.com/dc-comics-new-52-biggest-changes/
  39. http://www.sequentialtart.com/article.php?id=2698
  40. https://screenrant.com/dc-comics-new-52-reboot-impact-explained/
  41. https://jimshooter.com/2011/10/dc-comics-new-52-part-3.html/
  42. https://www.thepopverse.com/dc-new-52-geoff-johns-january-2024
  43. https://comicvine.gamespot.com/profile/avenger693/lists/all-the-new-52-titles/43948/
  44. https://comicsalliance.com/dc-new-52-cancelations-new-titles-second-wave/
  45. https://comicsalliance.com/dc-comics-new-52-47-cancelation/
  46. https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?pl=DC%252FVertigo
  47. https://hyperallergic.com/506906/best-vertigo-comics-graphic-novels/
  48. https://community.cbr.com/threads/pre-new52-vertigo-aka-the-berger-era-appreciation-2021.152350/
  49. https://www.comicbookherald.com/best-vertigo-comics/
  50. https://www.dc.com/blog/2022/11/30/wild-storm-a-crash-course
  51. https://www.cbr.com/wildstorm-characters-dc-universe/
  52. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/dc-comics-launches-historic-era-of-comic-books-with-52-new-1-issues-128723408.html
  53. https://www.dc.com/blog/2012/05/02/dc-comics-the-new-52-1-issues-now-available-digitally-for-s-99
  54. https://www.dc.com/blog/2013/06/04/dc-entertainment-brings-digital-comics-to-the-next-level-with-new-dc2-and-dc2-multiverse-innovations
  55. https://www.dc.com/comics/injustice-gods-among-us-2013/injustice-gods-among-us-1
  56. https://www.cbr.com/dc-shakes-up-digital-first-release-schedule-with-new-titles/
  57. https://www.comicsbeat.com/batman-eternal-vs-futures-end-dcs-two-very-different-weekly-comics/
  58. https://www.dc.com/comics/the-new-52-futures-end-2014/the-new-52-futures-end-1
  59. https://insidepulse.com/2015/04/02/demythify-last-3-pages-rant-spoilers-dc-comics-batman-eternal-52-new-52-futures-end-48-earth-2-worlds-end-26-convergence-0/
  60. https://www.diamondcomics.com/Article/113704-Top-100-Comics-September-2011
  61. https://www.cbr.com/dc-comics-dominates-septembers-sales/
  62. https://www.dc.com/blog/2011/09/12/inside-the-numbers-justice-league-1-is-officially-the-best-selling-comic-book-of-2011
  63. https://icv2.com/articles/comics/view/21222/batman-1-tops-september-sales
  64. https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/comics/article/55947-how-stable-are-dc-comics-sales-after-their-relaunch.html
  65. https://www.comicsbeat.com/dc-comics-month-to-month-sales-september-2011/
  66. https://icv2.com/articles/comics/view/21220/top-300-comics-actual-september-2011
  67. https://sponge-cobalt-7f87.squarespace.com/articles/p0flmnc2cnkz7978alpuuggyjpcblc
  68. https://readrant.wordpress.com/2012/05/22/new-52-news-justice-league-international-canceled/
  69. https://www.quora.com/Why-did-DC-stop-making-the-Static-Shock-New-52-comics-after-8-issues
  70. https://www.comicsbeat.com/how-much-did-the-new-52-really-help-sales-these-charts-may-hold-the-answer/
  71. https://sktchd.com/longform/dc-troubles-longform/
  72. https://www.cbr.com/rood-wayne-unpack-dcs-new-52-sales-success/
  73. https://comicsalliance.com/dc-new-52-sales-bump-data-charts/
  74. https://comicbookclublive.com/2024/01/10/geoff-johns-shares-what-went-wrong-with-new-52-adult-graphic-novel-sales-fall-usagi-yojimbo-turns-forty-comic-book-club-news-for-january-10-2024/
  75. https://comicsalliance.com/batman-1-review/
  76. https://comicsalliance.com/new-52-reviews-week-3/
  77. https://www.ign.com/articles/2012/09/12/batman-0-review
  78. https://jimshooter.com/2011/10/dc-comics-new-52.html/
  79. https://them0vieblog.com/2013/06/12/geoff-johns-and-jim-lees-run-on-justice-league-the-villains-journey/
  80. https://screenrant.com/rebirth-new-52-got-wrong/
  81. https://www.syfy.com/syfy-wire/batman-writer-scott-snyder-almost-drove-out-new-52
  82. https://comicsalliance.com/dcs-new-52-jim-lee-and-dan-didio-behind-the-scenes-of-the-rela/
  83. https://comicsalliance.com/scott-snyder-batman-zero-year-interview-dc-comics/
  84. https://comicsalliance.com/grant-morrison-action-comics-exit-interview-final-issue-new-52/
  85. https://www.cbr.com/dc-dan-didio-new-52-continuity-errors/
  86. https://bleedingcool.com/comics/editorial-and-creative-clashes-in-dc-comics-new-52-ten-years-on/
  87. https://www.toplessrobot.com/2013/09/8writer_andy_diggle_quits_action.php
  88. https://www.lehighvalleylive.com/entertainment-general/2011/09/sex_causes_controversy_in_week.html
  89. https://cah.ucf.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/27/2019/10/KWS17_Turberville.pdf
  90. https://screenrant.com/harley-quinn-rebirth-costume-return-best/
  91. https://comicsalliance.com/wonder-woman-feminism-meredith-finch-david-finch-dc/
  92. https://comicsalliance.com/dc-dan-didio-female-creators/
  93. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2011/aug/01/dc-comics-women-writers-creators
  94. https://jimshooter.com/2011/10/dc-comics-new-52.html
  95. https://comicvine.gamespot.com/dc-comics/4010-10/forums/dc-responds-to-concerns-over-lack-of-female-comic--626450/
  96. https://www.comicsbeat.com/scoop-what-really-happened-at-the-infamous-dan-didiohire-more-women-incident/
  97. https://www.comicsbeat.com/the-week-in-women-do-we-write-about-gender-issues-too-much/
  98. http://siskoid.blogspot.com/2012/09/the-new-52-and-dcs-communications.html
  99. https://www.denofgeek.com/comics/dc-universe-rebirth-spoilers-a-complete-guide-to-what-it-all-means/
  100. https://comicsalliance.com/superman-reborn-recap/
  101. https://www.denofgeek.com/comics/superman-continuity-finally-fixed-by-dc-comics/
  102. https://the-artifice.com/current-state-of-the-comic-book-industry-dc-and-the-new-52/
  103. https://www.thewrap.com/the-batman-a-short-history-of-the-new-52/
  104. https://www.imdb.com/news/ni64539493/
  105. https://www.dc.com/blog/2014/02/05/figuring-it-out-designing-a-new-animated-justice-league
  106. https://new-52-animated-universe.fandom.com/wiki/DC_Animated_Movie_Universe
  107. https://comicbook.com/comics/feature/dc-just-canonized-everything-in-the-most-genius-way-it-wasnt-even-hard/
  108. http://www.multiversitycomics.com/news/dc-announces-complete-sell-out-of-new-52/
  109. https://bleedingcool.com/comics/dc-rebirth-improved-sales-better-and-longer-than-the-new-52-did-so-far/
  110. https://www.comicbookherald.com/the-old-52-dcs-new-52-10-years-later-the-launch-and-what-we-can-learn/
  111. https://chrxpthr.medium.com/ranking-all-52-title-of-the-new-52-a-10th-anniversary-retrospective-9996fe5988b
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.