Hubbry Logo
The New MoonThe New MoonMain
Open search
The New Moon
Community hub
The New Moon
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
The New Moon
The New Moon
The New Moon
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Sheet music cover for "Lover, Come Back to Me" from The New Moon (1928)

The New Moon is an operetta with music by Sigmund Romberg, lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein II and book by Oscar Hammerstein II, Frank Mandel, and Laurence Schwab. The show was the third in a string of Broadway hits for Romberg (after The Student Prince (1924) and The Desert Song (1926)) written in the style of Viennese operetta. Set around the time of the French Revolution, the story centers on a young French aristocrat in disguise, who has fled his country and falls in love with the daughter of a prominent New Orleans planter.

It premiered in Philadelphia in 1927 and played on Broadway in 1928. It spawned a number of revivals and two film adaptations, and it remains popular with light opera companies. The piece turned out to be "Broadway's last hit operetta",[1] as World War II and the Golden Age of musicals approached, heralding a change in musical theatre genres.[2]

Performance history

[edit]

The New Moon debuted in Philadelphia on December 22, 1927 at the Chestnut Street Opera House.[3] The tryout was a failure, and the show was extensively revised before another tryout in Cleveland in August 1928 and then moving to New York City. Al Goodman conducted in both Philadelphia and New York.[4][5]

The operetta opened on Broadway at the Imperial Theatre on September 19, 1928, ran for 519 performances, and closed at the Casino Theatre on December 14, 1929. The production used set designs by Donald Oenslager. The work was produced in London's West End at the Drury Lane Theatre in 1929.[6] Although the piece received international productions and stock revivals lasting into the 1950s,[7] it subsequently disappeared from the repertoire for a few decades. One commentator wrote, "What has kept The New Moon from being as familiar as Naughty Marietta or The Student Prince is perhaps its chronological place at the end of operetta's reign over the musical stage.[5]

The operetta was restaged faithfully in 1986 by the New York City Opera[8] and was telecast by PBS in 1989. The Light Opera of Manhattan staged the work several times in the 1980s.[9]

City Center Encores! presented a semi-staged revival at New York City Center in March 2003. The Encores production was presented during the run-up to the Iraq War and part of the audience responded with loud applause and cheers to the line "One can be loyal to one's country and yet forswear its leader".[1][7]

Roles and original Broadway cast

[edit]
  • Marianne Beaunoir (soprano) — Evelyn Herbert
  • Monsieur Beaunoir, her father — Pacie Ripple
  • Julie, her maid (soprano) — Marie Callahan
  • Captain Georges Duval — Edward Nell Jr.
  • Robert Misson (tenor) — Robert Halliday
  • Alexander (baritone) — Gus Shy
  • Philippe L'Entendu (tenor) — William O'Neal
  • Clotilde Lombaste (soprano) — Esther Howard
  • Besac, boatswain of the 'New Moon' (baritone) — Lyle Evans
  • Jacques, ship's carpenter — Earle Mitchell
  • Vicomte Ribaud — Max Figman
  • Flower Girl — Olga Albani
  • Fouchette — Thomas Dale
  • Emile, Brunet, Admiral de Jean, etc.

Synopsis

[edit]

Robert is a young French aristocrat whose revolutionist inclinations force him to flee his country. Under an assumed name, he sells himself as a bond-servant to planter and ship-owner Monsieur Beaunoir and his family in New Orleans in 1792. Because the Paris police are looking everywhere for him, Robert cannot tell Beaunoir or Beaunoir's beautiful daughter Marianne, with whom he has fallen in love, that he is of noble blood. Eventually he is tracked down by Vicomte Ribaud, the detective villain, and put aboard a ship, the New Moon, so that he can be returned to France. Robert thinks he has been betrayed by Marianne, who has gained her father's consent to travel on the same ship, pretending that she is in love with the ship's captain, Duval. A mutiny occurs, and Robert and the bond-servants come into power. Everyone goes ashore on the Isle of Pines, and a new republic is founded.

The republic flourishes under Robert's guidance, but Marianne, her pride hurt, at first refuses to marry Robert. French ships arrive, apparently to reclaim the island. Vicomte Ribaud expects them to conquer the island for the King of France. But the French Commander reveals that there has been a revolution in France, and that all aristocrats must die unless they renounce their titles. Ribaud, a Royalist, heads for execution, but republican Robert renounces his title. All ends happily for him and Marianne.

Musical numbers

[edit]
Act I
  • Dainty Wisp of a Thistledown (Ensemble)
  • Marianne (Robert)
  • The Girl on The Prow (Marianne, Besac and Ensemble)
  • Gorgeous Alexander (Julie, Alexander and Girls)
  • An Interrupted Love Song (Captain Georges Duval, Marianne and Robert)
  • Tavern Song (Flower Girl, a Dancer and Ensemble)
  • Softly, as in a Morning Sunrise (Philippe and Ensemble)
  • Stout-hearted Men (Robert, Philippe and Men)
  • Fair Rosita (Girls and The Dancers)
  • One Kiss (Marianne and Girls)
  • Ladies of the Jury (Alexander, Julie, Clotilde Lombaste and Girls)
  • Wanting You (Marianne and Robert)
Act II
  • A Chanty (Besac and Men)
  • Funny Little Sailor Man (Clotilde Lombaste, Besac and Ensemble)
  • Lover, Come Back to Me (Marianne)
  • Love Is Quite a Simple Thing (Robert, Besac, Alexander and Julie)
  • Try Her Out at Dances (Alexander, Julie and Girls)
  • Softly, as in a Morning Sunrise (reprise) (Phillippe and Men)
  • Never (for You) (Marianne)
  • Lover, Come Back to Me (reprise) (Robert and Men)

Film versions

[edit]
Main article: New Moon (1930 film)
Main article: New Moon (1940 film)

Two film versions were produced by MGM. The first, in 1930, starred Grace Moore and Lawrence Tibbett, with a setting in Russia. It added two new songs by Herbert Stothart and Clifford Grey. The second, in 1940, starred Jeanette MacDonald and Nelson Eddy.

A television version of a performance at New York City Opera aired on PBS's Great Performances in 1989 and was subsequently issued on VHS and DVD.

Recordings

[edit]

No original Broadway cast recording was made, but the 1928 London cast recorded some selections for Columbia. These 78 rpm records have been transferred to CD on the Pearl Label. The song "Stout-hearted Men" was recorded in 1930 by Perry Askam[10] and in 1967 by Barbra Streisand, peaking at No. 2 on the Easy Listening chart.[11]

Earl Wrightson and Frances Greer starred in Al Goodman's recording for RCA Victor (LK-1011).[12] Decca made an album in 1953 with Lee Sweetland and Jane Wilson covering six selections from the score, which has been reissued on CD paired with The Desert Song.[citation needed] Gordon MacRae recorded a 10-inch LP for Capitol Records (Capitol H-219) in 1950 with Lucille Norman. It was repackaged as a split release in 1956 on one side of a 12-inch album with Rudolf Friml's The Vagabond King on the reverse, also with Lucille Norman (Capitol T-219). That release was reissued on CD in 2011 by Vintage Music.[13]

Reader's Digest included the operetta in the 1963 collection, A Treasury of Great Operettas, starring Jeanette Scovotti and Peter Palmer and conducted by Lehman Engel. As part of a new series of stereo recordings of classic operettas, Capitol had MacRae and Dorothy Kirsten record three studio cast albums in 1962 and 1963. Their selections from The New Moon (Capitol SW-1966) are available on the EMI CD Music of Sigmund Romberg, along with selections from The Student Prince (Capitol SW-1841), and The Desert Song (Capitol SW-1842).[14]

The Encores! cast recorded the score in 2004, using the original orchestrations, for Ghostlight Records. A reviewer wrote in Playbill that the recording "is eminently enjoyable. ... The New Moon is vibrant, full-bodied and – yes – stouthearted."[7] John Kenrick praised Rodney Gilfry, Christiane Noll, Brandon Jovanovich, the supporting cast and the conducting, writing: "What a spectacular delight! ... [the] songs soar, exploding with romance and swashbuckling bravado."[15]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

The New Moon

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
is a by American author , published in on September 6, 2006, by . It serves as the second installment in the Twilight Saga, succeeding Twilight (2005) and preceding (2007). The narrative follows protagonist Isabella "Bella" Swan as she navigates profound despair after her lover abruptly ends their relationship to shield her from supernatural dangers, prompting her immersion in the tribe's lore through friendship with . Central to the plot is Bella's emotional turmoil, marked by reckless actions to hear Edward's voice in her mind and a deepening entanglement in interspecies conflicts between vampires and werewolves. The novel rapidly ascended bestseller lists upon release, propelled by fervent fan enthusiasm for the series' blend of and adolescent angst, though exact sales figures for New Moon independent of the franchise remain elusive in publisher disclosures. Meyer's work spawned a 2009 film adaptation directed by , which grossed approximately $710 million worldwide despite mixed for its pacing and effects. New Moon has drawn scrutiny for depicting Bella's response to abandonment—characterized by clinical-like depression and thrill-seeking self-endangerment—as a pathway to personal growth, potentially normalizing codependent and self-harming behaviors in romantic contexts. Literary analysts have highlighted the protagonist's passivity and reliance on male figures for agency, critiquing it as perpetuating outdated dynamics amid . Such elements fueled broader debates on the series' impact on teen readers, contrasting its commercial dominance with concerns over idealized dysfunction in relationships.

Creation and Background

Development and Influences

The operetta The New Moon originated from inspirations rooted in 18th-century pirate legends and French colonial dynamics in the Caribbean and New Orleans, with the protagonist Robert Mission modeled after the real-life Captain Robert Misson, whose exploits involved mutinying against royal authority to form an egalitarian pirate settlement known as Libertatia. Misson's documented adventures, including pirating a vessel bound for France and establishing a short-lived republic free from monarchic rule, provided the causal framework for the story's themes of rebellion and self-governance, as chronicled in historical accounts like Daniel Defoe's A General History of the Pyrates (1724). This historical basis allowed the creators to infuse empirical elements of naval conflict and colonial servitude into a romantic structure, diverging from purely fictional escapism prevalent in earlier operettas. Sigmund Romberg composed the score following the triumph of in 1926, which had solidified his reputation for exotic, tuneful works, but amid subsequent commercial disappointments like (1927), which closed after 88 performances, and The Love Call (1927), a short-lived attempt at modern revue-style elements. These flops, totaling fewer than 200 combined performances, underscored the challenges of adapting Viennese formulas to shifting Broadway preferences for lighter musical comedies, prompting Romberg to refine his approach by emphasizing lush orchestration and rhythms while incorporating revolutionary motifs to appeal to audiences weary of post-World War I nostalgia. By late 1927, Romberg juggled The New Moon alongside five other projects, delaying its refinement until early 1928. The librettists—, Frank Mandel, and Laurence Schwab—faced collaborative hurdles in merging adventure-driven piracy with romantic subplots, requiring multiple revisions to balance operetta's melodic demands against the era's trend toward dialogue-heavy musicals that diminished formats. After out-of-town tryouts revealed pacing issues and underdeveloped undertones, the reworked the script for seven months, streamlining the narrative to heighten dramatic contrasts between aristocratic oppression and pirate liberty while adhering to Broadway's expectation for spectacle amid operetta's declining dominance by 1928. This iterative process, directed uncredited by the librettists themselves, reflected broader pressures where producers like the Shuberts demanded hits to counter the rise of revues and integrated musicals, yet The New Moon succeeded by preserving operetta's core causal logic of fate-driven romance intertwined with historical upheaval.

Creative Team and Premiere

The creative team for The New Moon was led by composer , who drew on his background in European traditions to craft the score's melodies prior to lyrical integration, a method characteristic of his Viennese-influenced style. Lyrics were written by , while the book was co-authored by Hammerstein alongside Frank Mandel and Laurence Schwab, who also served as producers. Direction was handled uncredited by the librettists Hammerstein, Mandel, and Schwab, with choreography by Bobby Connolly and musical direction by Alfred Goodman. The premiered on Broadway on September 19, 1928, at the in , following tryouts in , , and . The production featured lavish staging typical of late-1920s Broadway operettas, including elaborate sets evoking 18th-century and nautical scenes, supported by a large cast and orchestra. It achieved commercial success with an initial run of 519 performances, transferring to the Casino Theatre before closing on December 14, 1929, amid the onset of economic downturn preceding the .

Characters and Libretto

Principal Roles

The principal roles in The New Moon center on archetypal figures central to the 's romantic and adventurous narrative. Robert Misson, portrayed as the romantic lead, functions as the —a French aristocrat fleeing revolutionary persecution, indentured as a bondservant, who orchestrates a aboard the ship New Moon to establish a pirate , embodying themes of defiance, , and heroic pursuit of and love. Marianne Beaunoir, the heroine and daughter of a New Orleans ship owner, serves as the primary object of affection and moral anchor, adhering to conventional conventions of feminine virtue, loyalty, and romantic devotion amid peril. Antagonistic figures provide dramatic opposition, including Vicomte Ribaud, a French nobleman who acts as the scheming rival suitor to and enforcer of authority, highlighting conflicts between aristocratic entitlement and emerging egalitarian ideals. Georges Duval, commander of the New Moon, represents rigid naval hierarchy and , catalyzing the mutiny through his and personal vendettas. Supporting roles add levity and ensemble dynamics, such as , a bondservant who aids Misson as a loyal , and Philippe or other comedic foils among the crew, drawing from pirate lore to inject humor and camaraderie without overshadowing the central romance. In the original Broadway production opening September 19, 1928, at the , Robert Halliday originated Robert Misson, while Evelyn Herbert played Marianne Beaunoir, selections reflecting era-specific preferences for strong-voiced performers suited to Romberg's melodic demands.

Synopsis

In 1792, amid the tensions of the , Robert Mission, a nobleman disguised as a bond servant, resides in the New Orleans household of planter Monsieur Beaunoir after fleeing royalist persecution in . There, he falls in love with Beaunoir's daughter, Marianne, while harboring revolutionary ideals that draw the suspicion of the authoritarian Vicomte Ribaud. Arrested for , Robert is shackled and loaded onto the ship The New Moon, captained by Ribaud, for transport back to to face execution. Marianne, unwilling to abandon her lover, rallies the indentured servants, crew, and passengers—including the opportunistic —in a daring against Ribaud and his officers. With assuming command, the mutineers overpower the loyalists, cast them adrift, and redirect the vessel to a remote, uninhabited island. Establishing a , they cultivate the land and form communal structures emphasizing personal freedom, though underlying romantic rivalries and hierarchical impulses among the settlers create friction. A year later, a French warship arrives to eradicate the perceived , prompting defenses from the islanders. Confrontations ensue, but dispatches reveal the Revolution's triumph in , nullifying prior royal warrants and offering clemency to the exiles. Robert and Marianne reconcile amid the group's decision to disband the colony and return to civilized society, affirming individual choices over sustained rebellion.

Music and Score

Composition and Style

The score of The New Moon integrates Viennese operetta conventions, such as lilting rhythms and lush string-dominated , with the rhythmic vitality and verse-chorus structures of 1920s American , marking Romberg's evolution toward a hybridized Broadway style. This fusion is evident in the work's melodic lines, which prioritize lyrical expansiveness over strict symphonic development, while incorporating syncopated patterns and simplified harmonies to appeal to U.S. audiences accustomed to forms. Characteristic of the era's operettas, the composition employs elaborate vocal ensembles—often involving principals, secondary characters, and chorus in layered —and continuous orchestral underscoring to heighten dramatic tension during spoken scenes, with a full pit supporting transitions between numbers. The score encompasses approximately 18 to 20 musical numbers, encompassing , solos, duets, production numbers, and choral pieces that collectively span recitative-like passages and fully staged ballets. Romberg's approach underscores a melody-centric propulsion, where recurring thematic motifs in the orchestra subtly reinforce character arcs and emotional states amid the book's dialogue-driven exposition, reflecting his of Central European training—rooted in Hungarian and Viennese traditions—to the demands of American commercial theater, which favored integrated yet separable units over through-composed forms. This structural choice causally elevates musical sequences as pivotal plot advancers, compensating for the libretto's episodic construction by embedding emotional in tonal resolutions and key modulations rather than verbal alone.

Musical Numbers

The musical numbers in The New Moon primarily serve to propel the narrative of romance, , and , with Act I emphasizing shipboard anticipation and conflict through and choruses, while Act II incorporates island-based ensembles for and solos for character reflection. Iconic selections include "Lover, Come Back to Me," a poignant plea by to reclaim Robert's affection before their forced separation, underscoring her devotion amid political intrigue. Similarly, "Wanting You" functions as Robert's introspective in Act II, expressing his unyielding desire for Marianne during their seclusion, deepening his heroic resolve. The ensemble piece "Softly, as in a Morning Sunrise" heightens dramatic tension in Act I, capturing the lovers' thwarted reunion through its lyrical interplay, often highlighting themes of longing and dawn-like hope. Act I features shipboard sequences that build revolutionary fervor and romantic stakes, such as the opening "Dainty Wisp of a Thistledown," an chorus establishing the exiles' lighthearted yet precarious journey aboard the vessel. "," a descriptive number sung by and others, introduces the protagonist's allure and sets her central emotional role. "The Girl on the Prow," performed by Marianne with , evokes seafaring imagery to advance her pursuit of Robert, blending wistfulness with the ship's motion. Later, "Stouthearted Men" rallies the mutineers in a stirring , propelling the plot toward rebellion and escape. "," a between Marianne and Robert, marks their clandestine vow, intensifying the interpersonal drama before the act's climax. Act II shifts to island revelry for levity, opening with lighter fare like "Funny Little Sailor Men," a comedic ensemble lampooning the castaways' adaptations and providing contrast to earlier strife. "Gorgeous ," a satirical number involving secondary characters, injects humor through exaggerated , relieving tension while commenting on superficial attractions. Reprises of "Lover, Come Back to Me" and other motifs reinforce unresolved passions, though the original 1928 score included cut numbers like "Neath a New Moon" (a title-referential duet) and "When I Close My Eyes," excised in standard versions to streamline pacing, as evidenced by production revisions. These adjustments preserved core emotional arcs without diluting the finale's triumphant resolution.

Original and Early Productions

Broadway Premiere and Run

The New Moon opened on Broadway at the on , 1928, after out-of-town tryouts in , , and . Directed by with choreography by Bobby Connolly, the production starred Evelyn Herbert as Marianne and Robert Halliday as Robert, emphasizing live vocal performances in the style that demanded stamina from the cast amid continuous singing and ensemble numbers. The show transferred to the Casino Theatre in November 1929 and concluded its run on December 14, 1929, accumulating 509 performances. This extended engagement reflected strong audience draw during a competitive season that included concurrent hits like Good News, which had debuted the prior year and sustained popularity through 1929. Staging incorporated scenic designs evoking the ship's deck and island locales central to the plot, alongside period costumes approximating 18th-century French colonial attire to enhance historical immersion. Technical execution relied on an of around 25-30 players, standard for Broadway operettas, supporting Romberg's lush score while navigating the challenges of synchronizing live music with elaborate scene shifts between maritime and terrestrial settings. The production's logistical demands, including frequent costume changes and prop handling for and ensemble sequences, underscored the era's reliance on manual without modern automation.

Initial Tours and International Performances

Following the closure of the original Broadway production on December 14, 1929, after 509 performances, The New Moon embarked on national tours across the , bringing the operetta to regional audiences in the Midwest and beyond. Performances included a mounting at the Great Northern Theatre, featuring actors such as Charlotte Lansing in the role of , which adapted the show for local venues while retaining its core romantic and musical elements. The tour extended to other Midwest cities, such as , where it played to audiences in January 1930, emphasizing the operetta's themes of romance and revolution set against an 18th-century backdrop. These stagings often involved scaled-down productions compared to Broadway, reflecting logistical challenges in transporting elaborate sets like pirate ships to distant theaters. Internationally, The New Moon saw swift adoption in , premiering at the Theatre Royal, Drury Lane on April 4, 1929, under the direction of local producers who cast British stars Evelyn Laye as Marianne and Harry Welchman as Robert to resonate with West End tastes less steeped in American traditions. The production ran for 148 performances, incorporating scenic spectacles such as a blazing pirate ship to heighten dramatic appeal for European viewers unfamiliar with the form's Viennese-influenced style. Further expansion reached , with a opening on January 4, 1930, at the Theatre Royal, where adjustments similarly prioritized accessible romance and melody over Broadway's full orchestral grandeur. By the early 1930s, however, touring and international interest waned amid the Great Depression's economic constraints, which made financing lavish operettas—requiring large casts, orchestras, and sets—prohibitively expensive. This decline coincided with shifting audience preferences toward integrated book musicals, such as those by , which favored contemporary stories and dance over escapist romance, rendering Romberg's style increasingly passé outside stock revivals.

Adaptations

Film Versions

The first film of The New Moon was released in 1930 by , directed by Jack Conway and starring baritone as Lieutenant Petroff and soprano as Princess Tanya. Set aboard a ship crossing the during the rather than in colonial as in the original , the film significantly altered the while incorporating Sigmund Romberg's music, including songs like "Lover Come Back to Me." This pre-Code production, released on December 23, 1930, received mixed reviews for its vocal performances but was commercially underwhelming compared to later versions, partly due to its loose fidelity to the source material. A second adaptation followed in 1940, again from , directed by Robert Z. Leonard and featuring as Marianne de Beaumanoir and as Charles Berrien. Released on , 1940, this version restored the Louisiana plantation setting amid French indentured servants plotting revolt but simplified the plot and rearranged the score for cinematic pacing, emphasizing romantic duets over the stage operetta's fuller operatic structure. Key numbers such as "Wanting You" and "Stouthearted Men" were retained, with MacDonald and Eddy's vocal chemistry highlighted, though critics noted the film's Hollywood polish diluted the original's theatrical grandeur. The 1940 film proved profitable for , grossing over its production costs through domestic earnings and capitalizing on the stars' established popularity from prior operettas like Naughty Marietta. Contemporary reception praised the musical sequences but faulted repetitive narrative elements and the shift toward lighter entertainment, contrasting the stage version's more elaborate musical integration. No major cinematic adaptations have followed, with subsequent interest confined to stage revivals and recordings.

Recordings and Other Media

The earliest preserved audio adaptations of The New Moon include radio broadcasts from The Railroad Hour, a series that dramatized musical theater works, featuring selections from the operetta in episodes aired during the late 1940s and early 1950s. These performances, often abridged for broadcast, prioritized narrative highlights with integrated songs but lacked the full orchestral scope of the stage score. Studio cast recordings emerged in the mid-20th century, such as the 1953 Decca release with Thomas Hayward, Jane Wilson, and Lee Sweetland, which captured key vocal numbers in a format faithful to Romberg's romantic style but omitted much of the dialogue and connective material. Similarly, the 1963 Capitol album by Gordon MacRae and Dorothy Kirsten presented eight selections, emphasizing operatic vocal interpretations while adhering closely to the original melodies, though in a condensed arrangement. Orchestral excerpts and vocal compilations by Romberg interpreters appear on labels like , including tracks from The New Moon alongside other works, performed by artists such as Kirsten and MacRae, which highlight instrumental underscoring and standalone songs like "Lover, Come Back to Me" for concert use. These often feature abridged versions to suit symphonic programs, contrasting with fuller vocal-focused releases. The 2004 Ghostlight Records album from the Encores! concert production, recorded in July 2004 with Rodney Gilfry and Christa Meyer, marked the first complete recording of the score, utilizing original orchestrations by Emil Gerstenberger and Alfred Goodman for high fidelity to the 1928 Broadway version. In the digital era, these recordings have gained wider accessibility through streaming platforms and reissues by labels including Capitol and , with complete versions like the Encores! album offering superior preservation of the full score compared to earlier abridged efforts, though some legacy releases remain limited to or archival access.

Reception and Analysis

Initial Critical Response

The initial critical response to The New Moon, which premiered on Broadway on September 19, 1928, at the , highlighted Romberg's score as a high point, with reviewers lauding its sweeping romantic melodies and enduring hits such as "Stout Hearted Men," noted for its vigorous, rousing quality evoking revolutionary fervor. The music was seen as Romberg's finest in the form, effacing prior disappointments like and providing a melodic pinnacle that propelled the show's appeal. In contrast, the book by , Frank Mandel, and Laurence Schwab drew criticism for its convoluted plot involving French aristocrats, mutinies, and romantic entanglements set against the French Revolution's backdrop in 1790s New Orleans, which some contemporaries found formulaic and melodramatic even within the genre's conventions. Hammerstein's were generally viewed as secondary to the score, serviceable but lacking the integration that would later define his work. Despite mixed press, the production achieved commercial success with a run of 509 performances, underscoring a divide between critics' reservations and audience enthusiasm for the escapist romance and stars Evelyn Herbert and Robert Halliday, signaling operetta's transitional status amid rising preferences for more narrative-driven musicals.

Achievements and Criticisms

The New Moon achieved commercial success with its Broadway premiere running for 509 performances from September 19, 1928, to October 5, 1929, at the , establishing it as one of Romberg's final major hits in the genre. This longevity underscored its appeal amid the waning popularity of Viennese-style operettas, as audiences favored its romantic score featuring hits like "Stouthearted Men" and "Lover, Come Back to Me," which contributed to Romberg's career total of over 900 songs across 66 stage productions. The work's demanding vocal demands, rooted in operatic traditions, influenced theater training by emphasizing techniques and ensemble singing, with selections enduring in vocal repertoires for their technical challenges. Critics have faulted the by , Frank Mandel, and Laurence Schwab for poor integration of dialogue and music, resulting in narrative drag and contrived plot progression that prioritized spectacle over coherent storytelling. The over-reliance on escapist romance tropes, such as idealized heroism and exotic settings in New Orleans and a fictional colony, clashed with the rising realism in contemporary theater, exemplified by 's integrated book and score debuted in 1927. Historical depictions contain inaccuracies, including anachronistic social dynamics and oversimplified French Revolutionary-era politics, which prioritize fantasy over factual grounding. Traditionalists commend the operetta's unapologetic heroism and lush orchestration as a bulwark against encroaching cynicism in musical theater, valuing its escapist purity as a of pre-Depression . Skeptics, however, highlight its formulaic repetition of Romberg's earlier successes like , arguing it exemplified the genre's stagnation amid innovations favoring character-driven narratives over star-vehicle arias.

Legacy and Revivals

Following , The New Moon experienced a sharp decline in popularity as the operetta form waned amid the ascendancy of integrated book musicals emphasizing character-driven narratives over escapist romance and lavish scores, exemplified by works like Rodgers and Hammerstein's Oklahoma! (1943), which prioritized dramatic cohesion and shifted Broadway away from Romberg's melodic-centric style. By the , full-scale productions became rare, with fewer than a dozen documented professional stagings in the U.S. through the , reflecting operetta's marginalization in favor of realism and in musical theater. Revivals remained sporadic, underscoring the work's niche appeal. The New York City Opera mounted a faithful adaptation in 1986 at the New York State Theater, running for 16 performances through September 7 with a cast including Jerry Hadley as Robert and Judith Blegen as Marianne, praised for its orchestral vigor under conductor Jim Coleman despite dated libretto elements. This production was reprised in 1988 for seven performances, highlighting persistent interest in Romberg's orchestration but limited commercial viability. A concert version by Encores! at New York City Center in March 2003, directed by Gary Griffin with Martin Vidnovic and Judy Kaye, drew acclaim for its score's romantic sweep across five performances, yielding a 2004 cast recording that preserved hits like "Stouthearted Men." Internationally, the South Australian Light Opera Society staged a production in Adelaide opening April 24, 2021, emphasizing the operetta's tuneful endurance amid regional theater recovery from pandemic disruptions. The score's melodic potency ensured cultural persistence beyond stage revivals, with individual numbers infiltrating and sustaining the work's influence. "Lover, Come Back to Me" received a jazz-inflected cover by in 1944 with Eddie Heywood's trio, charting briefly and inspiring subsequent interpretations by artists from to , amassing over 500 recorded versions by diverse performers. Similarly, "Softly, as in a Morning Sunrise" and "Wanting You" appeared in film soundtracks and repertoires, evidencing the operetta's appeal rooted in hummable, harmonically rich melodies that contrasted with post-1960s musicals' de-emphasis on overt tunefulness in favor of conceptual integration, as critiqued by observers noting Romberg's unapologetic romanticism as a to plot-heavy . This melodic legacy, rather than the contrived plot of exiles in 1780s New Orleans, accounts for the work's empirical footprint: while full productions numbered under 20 post-1945, songbook citations exceed thousands in sales and recordings, affirming causality in audience retention via auditory pleasure over narrative innovation.

References

  1. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/49041.New_Moon
  2. https://wordsrated.com/twilight-novel-series-statistics/
  3. https://blog.oup.com/2009/12/racism-new-moon/
  4. http://operetta-research-center.org/new-moon-romantic-musical-play-sigmund-romberg/
  5. http://www.musicaltheatreguide.com/composers/romberg/new_moon.htm
  6. https://www.pbs.org/wnet/broadway/essays/operetta/
  7. https://rodgersandhammerstein.com/show/the-new-moon/
  8. https://rodgersandhammerstein.com/production/the-new-moon/1928-broadway/
  9. https://www.concordtheatricals.com/p/44658/the-new-moon
  10. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-production/the-new-moon-10719
  11. https://www.guidetomusicaltheatre.com/shows_n/new_moon.htm
  12. https://playbill.com/production/the-new-moon-imperial-theatre-vault-0000006096
  13. https://www.theatretrip.com/the-new-moon/
  14. https://academic.oup.com/yale-scholarship-online/book/19771
  15. https://climber.uml.edu.ni/index.jsp/browse/M5a751/SigmundRomberg.pdf
  16. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-companion-to-the-musical/american-and-british-operetta-in-the-1920s-romance-nostalgia-and-adventure/AE6E8B4BAEBB04BFC25A896AA3FC1677
  17. https://castalbums.org/shows/The-New-Moon/1310/
  18. https://classicjazzstandards.com/songs/lover-come-back-to-me/
  19. https://rodgersandhammerstein.com/the-new-moon-songs/
  20. https://www.preserveoldbroadway.org/new-moon-1927/
  21. https://trace.tennessee.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1093&context=gamut
  22. https://newspapers.library.in.gov/?a=d&d=IPT19300125.1.6&
  23. http://www.guidetomusicaltheatre.com/london_shows_chronology/1929.htm
  24. https://www.lwtheatres.co.uk/theatres/theatre-royal-drury-lane/about-theatre-royal-drury-lane/
  25. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/biography/sigmund-romberg
  26. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0021178/
  27. https://catalog.afi.com/Catalog/moviedetails/7840
  28. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/new_moon_1930
  29. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0032840/
  30. https://catalog.afi.com/Catalog/moviedetails/1064
  31. https://cometoverhollywood.com/2016/09/12/musical-monday-new-moon-1940/
  32. https://www.ultimatemovierankings.com/1940s-box-office-grosses/
  33. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/new_moon
  34. http://www.jimramsburg.com/therailroadhour.html
  35. https://rodgersandhammerstein.com/record/the-new-moon/1953-studio-cast/
  36. https://rodgersandhammerstein.com/record/the-new-moon/1963-studio-cast-macrae-kirsten/
  37. https://ml.naxos.jp/album/0077776905259
  38. https://rodgersandhammerstein.com/record/the-new-moon/2004-city-center-encores/
  39. https://www.ghostlightrecords.com/en/ghostlight-records/albums/the-new-moon-2004-encores-cast-recording/791558440331.html
  40. https://castalbums.org/recordings/The-New-Moon-2004-New-York-Concert-Cast/2199
  41. https://variety.com/2007/music/reviews/the-broadway-musicals-of-1928-1200510032/
  42. https://www.theatermania.com/news/the-new-moon_3309/
  43. https://www.musicals101.com/1920bway2.htm
  44. https://academic.oup.com/edited-volume/34868/chapter/298300749
  45. https://www.naxos.com/catalogue/item.asp?item_code=8.110866
  46. https://www.nytimes.com/2003/03/29/theater/operetta-review-much-silliness-in-a-gilt-frame.html
  47. https://www.nytimes.com/1981/11/25/theater/music-new-amsterdam-s-new-moon.html
  48. https://www.nytimes.com/1986/08/24/arts/unabashed-romanticism-was-romberg-s-specialty.html
  49. https://mdtheatreguide.com/2023/03/operetta-review-sigmund-rombergs-the-new-moon-by-victorian-lyric-opera-company-at-the-f-scott-fitzgerald-theatre/
  50. https://www.nytimes.com/1986/08/27/arts/operetta-new-moon-romberg-staged-by-city.html
  51. https://ovrtur.com/production/2889432
  52. https://www.nytimes.com/1988/07/22/arts/review-music-romberg-s-new-moon-in-reprise-at-city-opera.html
  53. https://variety.com/2003/legit/reviews/the-new-moon-1200542475/
  54. https://ovrtur.com/production/2892739
  55. https://glamadelaide.com.au/theatre-review-the-new-moon/
  56. https://secondhandsongs.com/performance/520823/all
  57. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcgbsL_53Yw
  58. https://www.nytimes.com/1986/08/28/arts/operetta-romberg-s-new-moon-by-city-opera.html
  59. https://playbill.com/article/one-kiss-more-the-new-moon-will-have-concert-cast-album-in-2004-com-116801
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.