Variable Cylinder Management
Variable Cylinder Management
Main page
V

Variable Cylinder Management

logo
Community Hub0 subscribers
Read side by side
Variable Cylinder Management
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) is Honda's term for its variable displacement technology, which saves fuel by deactivating the rear bank of 3 cylinders during specific driving conditions—for example, highway driving. It was first introduced in the 2003 Honda Inspire sedan.[1] The second version of VCM (VCM-2) took this a step further, allowing the engine to go from 6 cylinders, down to 4 or 3 during cruising and deceleration. This version had an "ECO" indicator light on the dashboard.[2] The most recent version of VCM (VCM-3) reverted to the previous 3- and 6-cylinder operation.

Unlike the pushrod systems used by DaimlerChrysler's Multi-Displacement System and General Motors' Active Fuel Management, Honda's VCM uses overhead cams. A solenoid unlocks the cam followers on one bank from their respective rockers, so the cam follower floats freely while the valve springs keep the valves closed. The system operates through controlling the flow of hydraulic engine oil pressure to locking mechanisms in the cam followers. The engine's drive by wire throttle allows the engine management computer to smooth out the engine's power delivery, making the system nearly imperceptible on some vehicles. When the VCM system disables cylinders, an "ECO" indicator lights on the dashboard, Active Noise Cancellation (ANC) pumps an opposite-phase sound through the audio speakers to reduce cabin noise, and Active Control Engine Mount (ACM) systems reduce vibration.

Problems

[edit]

The VCM hydraulic circuit control is defaulted open, meaning that the engine has to build up enough oil pressure on initial startup to disable the rear bank of cylinders. A single solenoid on the rear camshaft is activated to close oil pressure to unlock the cam followers, thereby closing the valves. In theory, the closing of all rear bank valves produces an ‘air spring’ effect. However, the reciprocating effect of the piston with closed valves reportedly produces a vacuum condition where oil can get pulled past the piston rings to flood the cylinder. When VCM disengages, the engine then misfires if needing to clear the cylinder of oil. This unique type of oil consumption has led to premature failure of parts like spark plugs, catalytic converters, engine mounts, pistons/rings, and cylinder walls. Newer versions of VCM have been developed to improve system reliability but consumers continue to log complaints.[citation needed]

Owners of vehicles equipped with VCM frequently face vibration problems due to engine motor mount malfunction while ECO mode is enabled.[3] Instead of replacing motor mounts, owners often override the VCM with a bypass mechanism, such as an in-line resistor based temperature override module. This has the effect of the vehicle computer believing that a sufficient engine temperature to enable VCM has not been reached. While this cannot guarantee that VCM will be disabled (e.g. differing climates/load scenarios), it can generally keep VCM from engaging under normal driving conditions. More advanced VCM disabler systems include a variable-resistance potentiometer[4] or a microcontroller[5] to manually or automatically adjust the resistance according to different conditions, which makes it possible to fully disable the VCM system, though at a somewhat higher cost.

Lawsuit

[edit]

In a 2012 class-action lawsuit, Soto et al v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc., plaintiffs Vince Eagen and Alex Soto alleged that certain Honda vehicles had a systemic design defect that resulted in vehicles burning motor oil at a faster rate than intended, engine misfire symptoms and conditions, and premature spark plug fouling[6][7]

In 2013, Honda agreed to settle the lawsuit involving 1.6 million vehicles with V-6 engines with VCM technology.[8][9] The Settlement between Honda and more than 1.87 million consumers[10] included certain Honda vehicles with 6-cylinder engines with Variable Cylinder Management (“VCM-2”) purchased or leased between 2008 and 2013 including the Honda Accord (2008-2012), Honda Odyssey (2008-2013), Honda Pilot (2009-2013), Honda Accord Crosstour (2010-2011), Honda Crosstour (2012). The settlement included a warranty extension for a period of eight years to cover Engine Misfire repairs. In addition, the settlement included full reimbursement to settlement class members who submitted proof of payments for repairs or parts involving diagnostic trouble codes (“DTC”) P0301, P0302, P0303, or P0304.[11]

Post-Lawsuit

[edit]

Customers continued to experience engine misfires and spark plug fouling on Honda vehicles equipped with VCM sold after the settlement.[12] On June 17, 2025, American Honda announced another warranty extension for certain 2013-2015 Pilot and 2013-2017 Odyssey vehicles.[13]

Vehicles equipped with VCM

[edit]
  • 2003 Honda Inspire (3- and 6-cylinder operation)
  • 2004+ Honda Elysion V6
  • 2005–2007 Honda Accord Hybrid (JNA1)
  • 2005-10 Honda Odyssey (USDM) - EX-L and Touring Models only (J35A7) - 2005-2007 models are equipped with VCM-1 (3- and 6-cylinder operation) - 2008-2010 models are equipped with VCM-2 (3-, 4-, and 6-cylinder operation).
  • 2011+ Honda Odyssey (USDM) - 2011-2017 models are equipped with VCM-2 (3-, 4-, and 6-cylinder operation) - 2018+ models are equipped with VCM-3 (3- and 6-cylinder operation).
  • 2006–2008 Honda Pilot 2WD Models only (J35Z1) - VCM-1 (3- and 6-cylinder operation)
  • 2008–2017 Honda Accord V6 (except EX-L V6 6MT Coupe) - 2008-2012 models are equipped with VCM-2 (3-, 4-, and 6-cylinder operation) - 2013-2017 models are equipped with VCM-3 (3- and 6-cylinder operation).[14]
  • 2009+ Honda Pilot (all models) - 2009-2015 models are equipped with VCM-2 (3-, 4-, and 6-cylinder operation) - 2016+ models are equipped with VCM-3 (3- and 6-cylinder operation).
  • 2010-2014 Acura TSX (V6)
  • 2013-2015 Acura RDX V6 VCM-2, 2016-2018 VCM-3
  • 2013 Acura RLX - VCM-3 (3- and 6-cylinder operation)
  • 2014 Acura MDX - VCM-3 (3- and 6-cylinder operation)
  • 2015 Acura RLX Sport Hybrid - VCM-3 (3- and 6-cylinder operation)
  • 2016-2020 Acura TLX V6
  • 2017 Honda Ridgeline
  • 2026 Honda Passport

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Variable Cylinder Management

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) is a cylinder deactivation technology developed by Honda for its V6 engines, which allows the engine to seamlessly switch between operating on all six cylinders for maximum power and deactivating three cylinders during light-load conditions to improve fuel efficiency.[1][2] Honda introduced VCM in 2005 with the third-generation Odyssey minivan, marking it as the first application of this system in a production vehicle to achieve better economy without sacrificing performance.[3] Since its debut, VCM has been integrated into various Honda and Acura models equipped with V6 engines, including the Pilot, Accord, and MDX, evolving through versions that sometimes include a four-cylinder mode for additional optimization.[1][4] The system operates by using the engine's Variable Timing Electronic Control (VTEC) mechanism to hold the intake and exhaust valves of the deactivated cylinders—typically one bank of three—in a closed position, while simultaneously shutting off fuel injection to those cylinders.[1] This deactivation occurs automatically under low-torque demands, such as steady highway cruising between 30-70 mph, reducing pumping losses and allowing the active cylinders to operate more efficiently at higher loads.[1] When acceleration or higher power is needed, the system reactivates all cylinders within one engine cycle for smooth transitions without driver intervention.[2] VCM contributes to fuel economy gains of up to 7.5% on average, as estimated by the U.S. Department of Energy for cylinder deactivation technologies, by dynamically reducing engine displacement and minimizing unnecessary fuel consumption during part-load operation.[2] It also lowers CO₂ emissions by optimizing combustion efficiency, aligning with broader industry efforts to meet environmental standards while preserving the responsive performance characteristic of Honda's V6 powertrains.[2][5]

Introduction

Definition and Purpose

Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) is Honda's proprietary variable displacement technology for V6 engines, which deactivates cylinders under light-load conditions to switch between six-cylinder operation for full power and three- or four-cylinder modes for efficiency, thereby reducing fuel consumption and emissions during cruising or low-demand driving.[1][6] The primary purpose of VCM is to enhance fuel economy while maintaining the performance and responsiveness of Honda's V6 engines, enabling compliance with stringent standards like the Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) regulations without significant compromises to drivability.[7] By deactivating cylinders, the system reduces pumping losses and optimizes engine load, achieving up to an 11% improvement in fuel efficiency over comparable non-VCM V6 engines, with approximately 8-10% gains during highway operation.[8][9] As of 2025, VCM continues to be featured in Honda's V6-equipped vehicles, with advanced versions enhancing efficiency further.[10] Introduced in 2005, VCM was developed amid rising oil prices and escalating environmental regulations in the early 2000s, allowing internal combustion engines to deliver hybrid-like efficiency gains under partial load without the added complexity and cost of full hybridization.[11][12] This innovation reflected Honda's broader strategy to balance performance with sustainability in response to global demands for reduced CO2 emissions and improved resource efficiency.[8]

Basic Operation

The Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) system activates under conditions of low power demand, such as steady cruising speeds between 30 and 70 mph with light throttle input and minimal engine load.[13] The engine control unit (ECU) continuously monitors inputs from sensors including throttle position, vehicle speed, engine speed, accelerator pedal position, automatic transmission gear selection, engine oil pressure, and catalytic converter temperature to determine when to engage cylinder deactivation.[14][15] In primary operation, VCM switches a V6 engine from six-cylinder mode to three-cylinder mode by deactivating one bank of three cylinders, typically the rear bank, to maximize fuel efficiency during low-load scenarios.[1] Some implementations include a transitional six-to-four cylinder mode, deactivating two cylinders for smoother shifts during moderate acceleration or varying loads.[16][14] During deactivation, the ECU commands the system to cut fuel delivery to the inactive cylinders while maintaining spark to prevent plug fouling; the pistons in those cylinders continue to move without combustion, and intake and exhaust valves are held closed to minimize pumping losses.[14] Engine oil pressure is actively managed to balance forces and vibrations across the engine, ensuring smooth operation without imbalance.[14] Reactivation to full six-cylinder operation occurs instantaneously upon detection of increased power demand, such as during acceleration, with the ECU signaling the reopening of valves and resumption of fuel injection in milliseconds for seamless torque delivery.[14][4]

Development and History

Origins and Introduction

Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) originated from research and development efforts at Honda R&D in the early 2000s, aimed at enhancing engine efficiency through cylinder deactivation technology as part of broader initiatives to improve fuel economy and reduce emissions.[17] This system built upon earlier cylinder deactivation concepts pioneered by General Motors in the 1980s, notably the 1981 Cadillac 8-6-4 V8 engine, which dynamically deactivated cylinders to vary displacement but was adapted by Honda for smoother operation in V6 configurations.[18] Key milestones in VCM's development included the initial prototypes for the 3.0L V6 around 2003.[19] The technology was first publicly announced in September 2004 for the 2005 model year, highlighting its role in optimizing fuel efficiency by deactivating cylinders under light loads.[3] VCM made its market debut in October 2005 with the redesigned Honda Odyssey minivan, equipped with the J35A7 3.5-liter V6 engine.[3] It was subsequently introduced in the 2006 Honda Pilot SUV, initially on two-wheel-drive models, to further extend fuel-saving benefits to larger vehicles. By 2008, amid escalating global oil prices that peaked above $140 per barrel and drove widespread demand for eco-friendly technologies, VCM expanded to the all-new Honda Accord sedan, solidifying Honda's commitment to variable displacement as a core efficiency strategy.[20][21]

Technological Evolution

Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) was first implemented in production vehicles with the 2003 Honda Inspire in Japan, featuring a 3.0-liter V6 i-VTEC engine that utilized hydraulic valve lifters to deactivate three cylinders during low-load cruising conditions, operating in a 6-to-3 mode for improved fuel economy.[19] This initial system, expanded to U.S. models like the 2005 Honda Odyssey, relied on solenoid-controlled lifters to hold valves closed on the rear cylinder bank, but required ongoing refinements to mitigate vibration through updated engine mounts and ECU mapping based on early field data.[8] By 2006, Honda enhanced the system for broader application across V6 engines, targeting an 11% fuel efficiency gain over 2005 levels by optimizing cylinder deactivation transitions and integrating more precise throttle and speed sensor inputs, as part of the company's mid-term powertrain efficiency plan.[8] These updates addressed initial smoothness concerns without altering the core 6-to-3 hydraulic mechanism, setting the stage for further evolution driven by regulatory demands for emissions and economy. The 2008 eighth-generation Accord introduced multi-mode operation, allowing 3- and 4-cylinder deactivation alongside 6-cylinder mode.[22] Further evolution occurred with the 2013 Earth Dreams Technology suite, debuting in models like the ninth-generation Accord V6, where VCM was refined for finer load matching and reduced vibration.[23] Key refinements included active engine mounts that countered torque fluctuations, revised piston ring designs to minimize oil dilution during deactivation, and ECU algorithms for smoother mode switching, all aimed at enhancing drivability while maintaining efficiency gains.[23] In the 2020s, VCM advanced with the adoption of direct injection in the 3.5-liter DOHC V6 engine for 2023 models such as the Pilot and Odyssey, combining cylinder deactivation with port and direct fuel injection for better combustion control.[24] ECU software updates enabled adaptive learning from driving patterns, allowing dynamic adjustment of deactivation thresholds for varied conditions, while the next-generation large-size hybrid system announced in 2025 features a new V6 engine targeting over 30% efficiency improvements over conventional ICE setups, potentially incorporating advanced engine management techniques.[25] Honda's foundational intellectual property for VCM includes U.S. Patent No. 7,836,866, which details control methods for valve deactivation to balance power and economy, influencing iterative designs across generations.[26]

Technical Implementation

Mechanism in Honda V6 Engines

In Honda's Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) system for V6 engines, cylinder deactivation is achieved through modifications to the valvetrain, primarily in the SOHC J-series engines such as the J35 and J37 variants. The core components include ECU-controlled solenoids, known as rocker arm oil control solenoids or VTEC solenoid valves, which regulate oil pressure to specialized hydraulic lash adjusters in the rocker arms. These lash adjusters collapse under controlled oil pressure to decouple the cam followers from the valves on the deactivated cylinders, preventing the intake and exhaust valves from opening while the pistons continue to move. High-pressure oil passages integrated into the intake and exhaust rocker shafts deliver pressurized engine oil to actuate this mechanism, ensuring precise control over valve operation without mechanical interference in active cylinders.[27] The physics of deactivation centers on reducing pumping losses and friction during light-load conditions by holding valves closed in one cylinder bank, typically the rear bank (cylinders 1, 2, and 3). In 3-cylinder mode, the firing order adjusts to 4-5-6 among the active front bank cylinders (4, 5, and 6) to maintain crankshaft balance and minimize torsional vibrations. The pistons in the deactivated cylinders continue to reciprocate, effectively acting as pumps that circulate oil through the engine, while targeted oil spray from the lubrication system cools the cylinder walls and components to prevent overheating and thermal stress. This configuration allows the engine to operate efficiently as an inline-3 equivalent within the V6 architecture, with the crankshaft and connecting rods experiencing altered but balanced loads.[27] VCM integrates seamlessly with the SOHC design of the J-series V6 engines, where the single overhead camshaft per bank facilitates the rocker arm modifications without compromising the overall layout. It is compatible with Honda's VTEC system, enabling variable valve timing and lift on the active cylinders to optimize performance and efficiency during transitions. The 60-degree V-bank angle and transverse mounting of these engines support the hydraulic actuation paths, ensuring compact packaging in vehicles like the Accord and Odyssey.[1] The control logic is managed by the engine control unit (ECU), which employs an algorithm monitoring engine RPM, throttle load, vehicle speed, and inputs from vibration sensors to determine optimal mode switching. Deactivation occurs automatically under steady cruise conditions without driver input, directing oil flow via the solenoids to engage deactivation; if faults such as low oil pressure or excessive vibration are detected, the system defaults to full 6-cylinder operation for reliability. This sensor-driven approach ensures smooth transitions, typically within milliseconds, while active engine mounts further dampen any residual vibrations.[27]

Versions of VCM

The original implementation of Variable Cylinder Management (VCM), introduced in 2005 on select Honda V6 engines, operated exclusively in a 6-to-3 mode, deactivating the rear bank of three cylinders during low-load conditions such as steady cruising or deceleration to reduce fuel consumption by minimizing pumping losses. This system relied on basic solenoid actuators integrated with the i-VTEC mechanism, where a three-way spool valve directed engine oil pressure to lock the rocker arms, effectively closing the intake and exhaust valves in the deactivated cylinders while cutting fuel delivery. The design's simpler damping approach resulted in more perceptible engine vibrations during operation, as it lacked advanced noise and vibration mitigation technologies.[3] Starting in 2008, Honda introduced an enhanced version known as VCM-2, which expanded operational flexibility by incorporating a 6-to-4 mode alongside the existing 6-to-3 mode, enabling deactivation of two or three cylinders depending on transitional loads like moderate acceleration or higher-speed cruising. This iteration featured improved piston ring designs with thinner lands to better manage oil control and reduce blow-by, alongside active noise cancellation (ANC) systems and active control engine mounts (ACM) that utilized electric actuators to counteract vibrations in real time. The engine control unit (ECU) software was also advanced to enable predictive deactivation, analyzing inputs such as throttle position, vehicle speed, engine load, and temperature for smoother mode transitions and optimized efficiency.[28][29] In the 2020s, subsequent VCM variants have been tailored for the 3.5-liter Earth Dreams engine family, integrating direct injection (GDI) for more precise fuel delivery and compatibility with mild hybrid systems in select applications to further boost thermal efficiency and reduce emissions. These versions emphasize enhanced durability through refined piston ring materials and coatings, along with ECU algorithms that prioritize seamless integration with broader powertrain features like stop-start functionality. Overall, VCM-2 and later iterations have demonstrated incremental fuel economy improvements, with examples showing up to 2-3% better miles per gallon in highway driving compared to the original system under similar conditions.[30][31]
AspectOriginal VCM (pre-2008)VCM-2 (2008+)Later Variants (2020s, Earth Dreams)
Operating Modes6-to-3 only6-to-4 and 6-to-3Primarily 6-to-3, with GDI and mild hybrid support
Key ComponentsBasic solenoid spool valves, i-VTEC lockingANC, ACM with electric actuators, thinner piston ring landsDirect injection, advanced ECU predictive logic, durable ring coatings
Vibration ControlLimited dampingActive noise/vibration cancellationEnhanced ACM integration with hybrid systems
Efficiency GainsBaseline fuel savings via 3-cylinder mode2-3% MPG improvement over original in mixed drivingAdditional 5-10% via GDI and stop-start (vehicle-dependent)

Applications

Equipped Vehicles

Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) technology was first introduced by Honda in 2005 on select models equipped with the 3.5-liter J35A7 V6 engine, marking its debut in the North American market to enhance fuel efficiency under light load conditions.[32] The initial rollout included the 2005–2010 Honda Odyssey (EX-L and Touring trims) and 2006–2008 Honda Pilot (2WD models), all utilizing the original VCM system that deactivates three cylinders in the rear bank.[33] During the expansion phase from 2008 to 2012, VCM was integrated into additional Honda and Acura vehicles, still relying on the early version of the technology paired with 3.5-liter V6 engines. Models such as the 2008–2012 Honda Accord V6 (sedan and coupe, excluding certain manual transmission variants) and 2009–2015 Honda Crosstour adopted VCM to meet stricter emissions and efficiency standards.[34] The VCM-2 system, an improved iteration introduced in 2008 that expanded cylinder deactivation capabilities to include 3-, 4-, or 6-cylinder modes, was featured in vehicles with the J35 series engine. This era (2008–2020) saw VCM-2 and later versions in the eighth- and ninth-generation 2008–2017 Honda Accord V6, fourth-generation 2011–2017 Honda Odyssey (updated in 2014), third-generation 2016–2022 Honda Pilot, 2013–2018 Acura RDX, 2015–2020 Acura TLX V6, and 2014–present Acura MDX.[33][34] In recent years (2021 onward, as of November 2025), VCM continues in updated forms (including VCM-3 and VCM-4) on Honda's larger SUVs and minivans, primarily with the 3.5-liter direct-injection V6 engines, including implementation in select hybrid variants for optimized efficiency. Equipped models include the fifth-generation 2021–present Honda Odyssey, fourth-generation 2023–present Honda Pilot, second-generation 2019–present Honda Passport, second-generation 2017–present Honda Ridgeline, all targeted at North American consumers.[35][34] VCM-equipped vehicles are predominantly available in North American and Japanese markets, with no adoption in European models that favor diesel engines or smaller displacements.[36]
EraModelsEngineNotes
2005–2007 (Debut)Honda Odyssey (EX-L, Touring)J35A7 3.5L V6Original VCM (3/6-cylinder modes); North America focus; Odyssey extended to 2010 for select trims
2008–2012 (Expansion)Honda Accord V6, Crosstour3.5L V6 (J35 series)VCM-2 introduction (3/4/6-cylinder modes); added performance applications
2013–2020 (VCM-2/3)Honda Accord (8th/9th gen) V6, Odyssey (4th gen), Pilot (3rd gen 2016-2020); Acura RDX, TLX V6, MDX (2014+)J35Y/Z 3.5L V6Enhanced deactivation modes; Pilot 3rd gen extends to 2022
2021+ (Recent, as of 2025)Honda Pilot (4th gen), Odyssey (5th gen), Passport, Ridgeline (2nd gen); select hybrids3.5L direct-injection V6VCM-3/4; ongoing North America/Japan; confirmed in 2025 models

Performance and Efficiency Impacts

Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) enhances fuel efficiency by deactivating cylinders during low-load conditions such as steady highway cruising, thereby reducing pumping losses and improving overall engine efficiency. In the 2008 Honda Accord V6 sedan equipped with VCM, this technology contributed to EPA-estimated ratings of 19 mpg city and 28 mpg highway, reflecting an approximate 10% average improvement over comparable non-VCM V6 configurations in prior models when adjusted for testing methodology changes.[37][38] Regarding performance, VCM maintains full V6 power output during acceleration or high-demand situations by reactivating all cylinders seamlessly, with transitions designed to occur without noticeable lag or power interruption at full throttle. While operating in 3-cylinder mode, minor vibrations may occur but are effectively mitigated through specialized engine mounts and active control systems to ensure smooth drivability. Dyno testing of VCM-equipped engines confirms consistent torque delivery across operating modes, preserving the vehicle's responsive handling characteristics.[20][39] On emissions, VCM supports reduced CO₂ output by optimizing fuel consumption and combustion efficiency in historical models compliant with U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Tier 2 Bin 5 standards.[1] Real-world data indicates improved fuel economy with VCM active in mixed driving conditions, aligning with EPA projections of up to 7.5% gains for cylinder deactivation technologies without long-term quantified impacts on engine wear in this context.[2]

Issues and Controversies

Reported Engine Problems

Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) in Honda V6 engines has been associated with spark plug fouling, primarily due to unburnt oil entering the deactivated cylinders during operation. When cylinders are deactivated, typically under light load conditions, oil can seep past the piston rings into the combustion chambers, fouling the spark plugs upon reactivation and leading to incomplete combustion. This issue is exacerbated by piston rings that may rotate and align their end gaps, allowing increased oil passage.[40] Excessive oil consumption is another common problem, often linked to accelerated piston ring wear from VCM's partial load cycles. Affected engines may consume up to 1 quart of oil per 1,000 miles, a rate Honda deems acceptable but frequently attributed to VCM-induced wear in owner diagnostics. This consumption results from inadequate ring sealing, permitting oil to burn in the cylinders over time. Misfires frequently occur as a result, generating diagnostic trouble codes P0300 through P0306 from carbon buildup on fouled plugs and valves. These misfires are particularly noted in cylinders 1 through 4, where fouling is most pronounced. Additionally, the unbalanced firing during deactivation contributes to vibrations that stress engine mounts, accelerating their degradation. Such problems were more prevalent in early VCM applications from 2005 to 2012.[40] Common diagnostic indicators include rough idle, hesitation or reduced power during acceleration, and activation of the check engine light. Root causes trace to oil intrusion during cylinder deactivation phases and suboptimal piston ring performance under varying loads, as identified in Honda service bulletins. NHTSA has received hundreds of engine-related complaints for these models, many citing VCM as a contributing factor.

Legal Actions and Settlements

In 2012, plaintiffs Alex Soto and Vince Eagen filed a class-action lawsuit against American Honda Motor Co., Inc. in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, titled Soto et al. v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc. (Case No. 3:2012-cv-01377). The suit targeted approximately 1.6 million Honda vehicles equipped with V6 engines featuring Variable Cylinder Management (VCM), specifically the 2008-2013 Accord, Odyssey, Pilot, Ridgeline, and Crosstour models. It alleged that defective piston rings in these engines caused excessive oil consumption, leading to oil burning and engine misfires.[41][42] The plaintiffs claimed that the defect violated Honda's express warranties, implied warranties of merchantability, and various state consumer protection laws, including California's Unfair Competition Law and Consumers Legal Remedies Act. Owners reported repair costs exceeding $2,000 per vehicle for issues such as piston ring replacement, spark plug fouling, and catalytic converter damage, with the suit seeking compensatory damages, restitution, and injunctive relief to address the alleged design flaw. Honda denied the allegations, maintaining that the vehicles met all safety standards and that no systemic defect existed.[43] The parties reached a settlement agreement in October 2013, which received preliminary approval in March 2014 and final court approval on May 3, 2015. Under the terms, Honda extended the powertrain warranty for affected vehicles to eight years from the original purchase or lease date, with no mileage limitation, specifically covering piston rings and related components for engine misfire conditions linked to VCM. Additional benefits included software updates to limit VCM activation and reduce misfire risks, free inspections at dealerships, and reimbursements for eligible out-of-pocket repair expenses up to $1,280 per claim, plus average payouts of $235 to $294 for class members. Honda made no admission of liability, and the settlement resolved claims for over 1.87 million vehicles without requiring a recall.[44][45][46] Prior to the Soto case, Honda faced smaller lawsuits and consumer complaints between 2010 and 2012 related to VCM-induced vibrations and shuddering during cylinder deactivation, often addressed through technical service bulletins rather than class-wide actions. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) received related complaints but closed investigations without mandating a recall, determining the issues did not pose an unreasonable safety risk.[47][48]

Post-Settlement Developments

Following the 2015 class action settlement, Honda implemented additional warranty extensions for vehicles affected by Variable Cylinder Management (VCM)-related engine issues. In June 2025, American Honda announced an extension of the powertrain warranty to 10 years or 150,000 miles, whichever comes first, specifically covering piston ring wear leading to misfires (diagnostic trouble codes P0301 through P0304) in certain 2013-2015 Pilot and 2013-2017 Odyssey models.[49] This built on the original settlement's eight-year/unlimited-mileage coverage for earlier models, extending protections to include 2014-2016 vehicles within the specified ranges.[41] Under these extended warranties, Honda provides free piston ring replacements for eligible affected owners experiencing oil consumption or misfire issues tied to VCM operation. Service bulletins such as TSB 25-060 (for Pilot) and TSB 25-061 (for Odyssey) outline the repair process, including inspection and replacement of rings on cylinders 1-4, with no out-of-pocket costs for covered vehicles.[50] These measures addressed ongoing claims from owners whose vehicles developed problems post-settlement, offering reimbursement for prior repairs in some cases.[41] Despite these extensions, reports of misfires persisted in some 2013 and later models equipped with VCM-2, the updated deactivation system introduced to mitigate earlier flaws. Owners of 2013 Odyssey vehicles, for instance, continued to document cylinder misfires linked to carbon buildup on rings during deactivation modes, even after VCM-2 implementation.[51] Broader NHTSA investigations have highlighted ongoing engine concerns in Honda V6 models. A probe opened in 2022 and upgraded to an engineering analysis in March 2025 (EA25-001) examines auto idle stop-start system failures to restart in approximately 2.2 million Honda and Acura vehicles from 2016-2022, including the Pilot. Separately, an August 2025 probe (PE25-011) investigates connecting rod bearing failures in over 1.4 million Honda and Acura vehicles equipped with 3.5L V6 engines from 2016-2022, based on more than 400 complaints of engine malfunctions potentially leading to failure; both probes remain ongoing as of November 2025 and are not directly attributed to VCM operation.[52][53][54] Honda introduced refinements to VCM in subsequent models to reduce associated risks. Starting with 2018 vehicles using the Earth Dreams J35Y6 engine, design changes—such as improved oil control and reduced deactivation frequency—minimized oil fouling and ring sticking compared to prior generations.[55] Software updates via technical service bulletins, like TSB 23-008 for 2016-2022 models, addressed related idle-stop and engine control issues, indirectly limiting excessive VCM engagement in certain conditions.[56] As of 2025, VCM remains a standard feature in new Honda models, including the 2025 Pilot's 3.5-liter V6 engine, which employs cylinder deactivation for fuel efficiency under light loads.[57] Owners can monitor general engine health through the HondaLink app, which provides real-time diagnostics, maintenance alerts, and fault notifications via connected telematics.[58] No major new class action lawsuits specifically targeting VCM have emerged since the 2015 settlement, though isolated engine defect claims persist under broader NHTSA scrutiny.[59]

Alternatives and Comparisons

Other Cylinder Deactivation Technologies

General Motors' Active Fuel Management (AFM), introduced in 2005 on vehicles equipped with the 5.3-liter Vortec V8 engine such as the Chevrolet TrailBlazer EXT, GMC Envoy XL, and Pontiac Grand Prix, deactivates four cylinders in an 8-to-4 mode during light-load conditions to enhance fuel efficiency by up to 12 percent.[60] The system employs specialized hydraulic valve lifters that collapse via oil pressure control, preventing valve opening on deactivated cylinders while maintaining fuel cutoff and seamless reactivation for acceleration demands.[60] In truck applications like the Chevrolet Silverado and GMC Sierra, AFM has been associated with increased vibration and harshness (NVH) during mode transitions, often requiring active engine mounts and software calibration to mitigate torsional imbalances from uneven firing orders. Chrysler's Multi-Displacement System (MDS), debuting in 2005 on the 5.7-liter HEMI V8 in models including the Chrysler 300C, Dodge Magnum R/T, and Charger R/T, similarly operates in an 8-to-4 cylinder mode, switching seamlessly in approximately 40 milliseconds under steady-state driving.[61] MDS integrates electronic throttle control and solenoids to hold intake and exhaust valves closed on deactivated cylinders, with the system tailored for smoother operation in luxury sedans through refined camshaft profiles and damping strategies that prioritize refinement over heavy-duty performance.[61] Unlike broader truck implementations, MDS emphasizes fuel savings of up to 20 percent in highway scenarios while minimizing perceptible shifts, though it shares hydraulic lifter mechanisms akin to AFM for valve control.[61] European manufacturers have adopted cylinder deactivation with adaptations suited to inline and overhead-cam architectures. BMW's Valvetronic system, a variable valve lift technology refined in the 2010s with updates to engines like the N63 V8 (introduced 2008, with Valvetronic from 2013 and cylinder deactivation from 2016), enables partial cylinder deactivation by reducing lift to near zero on select cylinders in later V8 variants, allowing for more granular control over airflow and efficiency without dedicated lifters.[62] This integration supports deactivation during low-load cruising, contributing to EfficientDynamics goals with up to 15 percent fuel improvements, though it focuses on smooth torque delivery via electric valve actuation rather than full hydraulic collapse.[62] Volkswagen's Cylinder on Demand (COD), or Active Cylinder Technology (ACT), extended to 2.0-liter TSI inline-four engines by 2017 in models like the Golf and Passat, deactivates two cylinders in a 4-to-2 mode between 1,400 and 4,000 rpm under partial throttle, achieving up to 15 percent efficiency gains through valve deactivation and fuel cutoff.[63] The system uses camshaft-specific profiles for the deactivated pair, emphasizing urban and highway cycles with minimal NVH via balanced firing.[63] In contrast to Honda's Variable Cylinder Management (VCM), which centers on V6 engines for 6-to-3 or 6-to-4 transitions in family vehicles, these systems predominantly target V8 architectures for trucks and sedans, with VCM's design prioritizing rapid, imperceptible reactivation to avoid drivability disruptions.[60] GM's AFM and Chrysler's MDS, while effective for V8 displacement reduction, have encountered more noticeable mode-shift lurching in truck variants due to higher inertia loads, whereas Honda's VCM achieves smoother transitions through advanced ECU mapping and mount tuning optimized for V6 balance. European approaches like BMW's Valvetronic-enhanced deactivation offer finer variability but at higher complexity, diverging from VCM's simpler lifter-based V6 focus.[62]

Aftermarket Disabling Methods

Owners of vehicles equipped with Honda's Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) system often turn to aftermarket devices to disable the feature, primarily to address concerns over engine wear and vibrations associated with cylinder deactivation. These methods typically involve intercepting signals from the engine coolant temperature (ECT) sensor to trick the engine control unit (ECU) into maintaining full-cylinder operation, thereby preventing VCM activation.[64][65] One popular option is the VCMTuner II, a plug-and-play device compatible with 2005-2017 Honda 3.5L V6 models such as the Odyssey, Pilot, and Accord. It connects to the ECT sensor harness under the hood in a 5-10 minute installation process, using a microcontroller to dynamically adjust resistance and simulate elevated coolant temperatures, forcing the engine to run on all six cylinders without triggering a check engine light. This device has been reported to reduce oil consumption by 50-90% in cases where VCM-related fouling contributed to excessive usage, such as dropping from 1 quart per 1,000 miles to negligible amounts over 5,000 miles.[66][67] Another hardware-based solution is the S-VCM Controller, designed for the same 3.5L V6 engines, which employs digital logic to monitor and compensate ECT signals, ensuring VCM deactivation 100% of the time while preserving accurate overheating detection for safety. Installation involves unplugging the ECT#1 harness, connecting the controller, and wiring it to the battery, a straightforward under-hood modification that requires no ongoing adjustments. Like the VCMTuner II, it aims to mitigate VCM-induced issues such as oil fouling and misfires by eliminating deactivation cycles.[65] A similar device is the VCMuzzler II, compatible with Honda Odyssey models from 2005 to 2025 equipped with the 3.5L V6 engine. It functions by plugging into the OEM wiring harness without modifications, using adjustable resistor plugs to suppress VCM activation and keep all six cylinders firing, thereby preventing issues like spark plug misfires, oil consumption, and engine vibrations. Installation is plug-and-play, and it includes a bypass option to revert to factory settings.[68] These disabling methods can enhance driving smoothness by avoiding the torque fluctuations of cylinder deactivation and potentially extend engine longevity by reducing uneven wear on components like piston rings and spark plugs. However, they may result in a minor fuel economy penalty of approximately 1 MPG on highways, though city driving impacts are often negligible. While manufacturers claim these devices do not void warranties under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act and maintain emissions compliance, some owners report potential warranty disputes during repairs; the products are 50-state legal with California Air Resources Board (CARB) Executive Order approval, as they do not alter air-fuel ratios or OBD-II functionality.[64][67][65] The adoption of such devices has been particularly encouraged through enthusiast communities, including the OdyClub forum, where discussions highlight user experiences with VCM-related problems and the benefits of disablement, fostering widespread interest among owners of older affected models.

References

  1. Variable Cylinder Management™ (VCM) (V-6 Engines)
  2. Cylinder Deactivation Systems
  3. 2005 Honda Odyssey Powertrain
  4. Variable Cylinder Management (VCM) - Acura Info Center
  5. Cylinder deactivation (gasoline and diesel engine) - Eaton
  6. Honda VCM - Variable Cylinder Management - Autoweb
  7. - TRANSPORTATION SECTOR FUEL EFFICIENCY - GovInfo
  8. Honda Announces Next-Generation Powertrain Fuel-Efficiency ...
  9. Driveability Corner | Honda's VCM System | MOTOR Magazine
  10. VTEC® - Honda Newsroom
  11. Form 6-K - SEC.gov
  12. Honda's VCM Tech Explained - Economy Honda Superstore
  13. https://hondanews.com/releases/2009-honda-pilot-powertrain
  14. Honda Pilot: What is variable cylinder (VCM) ratio?
  15. VCM Operation - honda-mideast.com
  16. Research paper site of ... - Honda R&D Technical Review Vol.20 No.1
  17. The Failure of Cadillac's 8-6-4 Engine - Driving Line
  18. Development of V6 Engine with New Variable Cylinder Management
  19. All-New 2008 Honda Accord Emphasizes Technology, Safety and ...
  20. Oil spike 2008 all over again? Not for U.S. economy | Reuters
  21. Honda Announces a Full Model Change for the Inspire
  22. Earth Dreams® Technology SOHC i-VTEC® V-6 with Variable ...
  23. 3.5-Liter DOHC V-6 Engine with Direct Injection and Variable ...
  24. Honda Unveils Next-generation Technologies at “Honda Automotive Technology Workshop” for Electrified Models to be Launched in Second Half of 2020s | Honda Global Corporate Website
  25. Methods and systems for overriding automotive computer controlled ...
  26. https://charm.li/Honda/2008/Pilot%202WD%20V6-3.5L/Repair%20and%20Diagnosis/Powertrain%20Management/Computers%20and%20Control%20Systems/Description%20and%20Operation/Variable%20Cylinder%20Management%20(VCM
  27. 2008 Honda Odyssey Showcases a Freshened Style with New ...
  28. 2011 Honda Pilot SUV Offers Room for Eight People, Standard V-6 ...
  29. 2017 Honda Ridgeline Press Kit - Powertrain
  30. None
  31. [PDF] 2021 Honda Digital FactBook - Manuals.plus
  32. Honda 3.5L J35A/J35Z/J35Y Engine Specs, Problems, Reliability, Info
  33. Supported Vehicles – VCMTUNER
  34. 2023 Honda Pilot Specifications & Features
  35. Chapter II: Global Expansion of Business Section 2: North America
  36. 2008 Honda Accord Prices and EPA Data
  37. With 3.5L V-6, Honda Proves Less is More - WardsAuto
  38. [PDF] Honda's Six Cylinder Engine Technologies
  39. Honda Meets EPA Auto Emission Reductions Years Ahead of ...
  40. [PDF] Service Bulletin - nhtsa
  41. Honda Engine Misfire Class Action Lawsuit Settlement
  42. Soto et al v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc., No. 3:2012cv01377
  43. [PDF] Case3:12-cv-01377-SI Document89-1 Filed10/09/13 Page1 of 12
  44. Honda Engine Misfire Class Action Settlement Gets Final OK
  45. [PDF] Service Bulletin - honda tech info
  46. [PDF] PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Defendant American Honda Motor Co., In
  47. Honda settles class-action lawsuit and extends powertrain warranty
  48. [PDF] Warranty Extension: MIL Comes On With DTCs P0301 thru P0304
  49. 2013-2017 Pilot and Odyssey VCM Warranty Extension Announced ...
  50. Honda VCM Warranty Extended 10 years/150,000 miles - YouTube
  51. PISTON RINGS/MISFIRES/FOULED SPARK PLUGS - The VCM ...
  52. 2016-2020 Honda Pilot Under NHTSA Investigation for Engine ...
  53. NHTSA Investigating 1.4 Million Honda and Acura Vehicles over ...
  54. What's with the VCM paranoia? : r/HondaOdyssey - Reddit
  55. TSB 23-008 PGM-FI Idle Stop Software Update (2016-2022)...
  56. 2025 Pilot Features & Specs - Honda
  57. HondaLink: Connectivity for Smart Phones and Honda Vehicles
  58. Honda class action alleges some vehicles have engine defect that ...
  59. GM Active Fuel Management Cylinder Deactivation Technology
  60. Special Report: HEMI ® Engine - Stellantis Media
  61. [PDF] Naturally aspirated gasoline engines and cylinder deactivation
  62. Volkswagen Debuts Cylinder Shut-Off Tech In 4-Cyl Engines
  63. VCMTUNER - Disable VCM / ECO for Honda Odyssey, Pilot, Accord ...
  64. S-VCM Controller - Disable VCM / deactivate VCM and stop ECO in ...
  65. VCMTUNER II - 2007+ for Honda Acura 3.5L I-VTEC Disable VCM
  66. VCMTUNER II FAQ
  67. VCMuzzler II to Disable - Honda Odyssey
User Avatar
No comments yet.