Hubbry Logo
All-ProAll-ProMain
Open search
All-Pro
Community hub
All-Pro
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
All-Pro
All-Pro
All-Pro
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

All-Pro is an honor bestowed upon professional American football players that designates the best player at each position during a given season. All-Pro players are typically selected by press organizations, who select an "All-Pro team," a list that consists of at least 22 players, one for each offensive and defensive position, plus various special teams players depending on the press organization that compiles the list. All-Pro lists are exclusively limited to the major leagues, usually only the National Football League; in the past, other leagues recognized as major, such as the American Football League of the 1960s or the All-America Football Conference of the 1940s, have been included in All-Pro lists.[1]

History

[edit]

Beginning in 1923,[2] All-Pro teams have traditionally been assembled from press polls of individually voting sportswriters.[3] After polling the writers, the votes are tallied to determine the selected players and the results have historically been published through various news syndicates. Today, the teams are mostly published online or announced on various televised sports programs. Some organizations publish two All-Pro lists, a first team and a second team, with the first consisting of more prominent players than the second.

The Associated Press (AP) and its All-Pro selections are the most widely recognized today.[4][5] Other polls include the United Press International All-Pro poll, which began in the 1940s and continued in various forms until 1997, the Newspaper Enterprise Association All-Pro team, which ran from 1955 until 1992, and the Pro Football Writers Association All-Pro teams, which were inaugurated in 1966 and continue to be released annually. The NFL itself compiled official All-Pro lists beginning in 1931 but abandoned the practice in 1942.

The All-Pro designation, while not officially sanctioned by the NFL, is generally considered a more prestigious honor than selections to the Pro Bowl, the NFL's annual all-star game.[6] A minimum of twice as many Pro Bowlers are selected as first and second team All-Pro slots combined. This is because, in 2010, the date of the Pro Bowl game was permanently moved to the week before Super Bowl, ensuring that the Super Bowl would always be the last game of the season. Since they are preparing for the championship, all Pro Bowl selections bound for the Super Bowl are replaced by alternates, as are any Pro Bowl selections who decline to play due to injury or lack of interest. Both the original selection and alternate will be credited as being a member of that year's Pro Bowl squad. This results in a larger number of picks than the All-Pro list, which does not have alternates.

Selecting entities

[edit]

National Football League

[edit]

The NFL compiled its own 11-man "All-League" teams beginning in 1931.[7] Through the 1939 NFL season players selected to this elite list were chosen by the coaches of the league; however, beginning in 1940, the selection of this team was turned over to the membership of the Professional Sports Writers Association.[7] Selection of this team ended after the 1942 season.[8]

Associated Press

[edit]

The AP began selecting All-Pros in 1940, and is the longest running annual selector of the top NFL players.[9] The All-Pro Team is an annual selection of the best players in the NFL by position as selected by a national panel of AP media members. Unlike selection to the Pro Bowls, votes are cast for outstanding players by position without consideration for whether the player competes in the American Football Conference (AFC) or National Football Conference (NFC).

The first team consists of the top one or two players at each position; the second team consists of the runners-up at each position. One player is selected at quarterback, fullback, tight end, center, punter, kicker, and return specialist, while two players are selected at running back, wide receiver, offensive tackle, offensive guard, outside linebacker, inside/middle linebacker, defensive end, defensive tackle, cornerback, and safety. In 2016, for the first time, the AP picked specific positions on the offensive line, a "flex" player on offense, and a fifth defensive back.[10] In 2020, the "flex" position was discontinued and replaced with a third wide receiver slot.[11] Beginning with the 2022 season, voters list choices for both the first and second teams; prior to 2022, voters only listed candidates for the first team, with the second team made up of the runners-up (if any) at that position.

The AP claims that the selection panel is a national one, but some NFL media markets such as Detroit, a city that has had an NFL team since 1934, do not have a vote.[12]

United Press International

[edit]

Also a press poll, it began in the 1930s and continued until 1969. In 1970 UPI began selecting All-AFC and All-NFC teams, which ran through 1996.

The Sporting News

[edit]

The Sporting News published All-Conference teams beginning in the 1950s. In 1980 it began choosing an All-Pro team, rather than two All-Conference teams. Since its teams are published in Total Football: The Official Encyclopedia of the NFL, they are recognized by the NFL and the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

Newspaper Enterprise Association

[edit]

The Newspaper Enterprise Association All-Pro team was different from the press polls. It was created by Murray Olderman in 1955 and considered the "players' All-Pro Team" as it was a poll of NFL players as opposed to writers, which were used by other publications.[13][14][15] In 1984, sportswriter Paul Zimmerman touted the NEA for its All-Pro team, since they involved polling the players, rather than sportswriters' opinions.[15] The NEA poll was last published in 1992.[13]

Pro Football Writers Association

[edit]

The PFWA All-NFL Team was inaugurated in 1966 and is still released each year. A press poll of the members of the Pro Football Writers Association, it has been released since the 1990s in Pro Football Weekly. Additionally, the editors and writers of Pro Football Weekly have personally selected All-AFC and All-NFC teams since 1970.

National Football League Players' Association

[edit]

The NFLPA began selecting a Players' All-Pro team in 2022, voted on solely by NFL players.

Compensatory draft selections

[edit]

The 2020 Collective Bargaining Agreement between the NFL and NFL Players Association specifically stipulated that being selected to either the AP or PFWA first teams (but not the Sporting News team) is a consideration in the ranking of players that determines the assignment of compensatory draft picks for teams losing free agents.[16]

Other selectors

[edit]

Past

[edit]

Present

[edit]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

All-Pro

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
In , particularly the (NFL), an All-Pro is an honorary designation awarded to players recognized as the best at their respective positions during a given season, signifying exceptional performance and elite skill. This accolade, widely regarded as more prestigious than a Pro Bowl selection due to its merit-based selection process and smaller number of honorees, highlights top performers across offense, defense, and special teams. The most influential All-Pro team is the (AP) All-Pro Team, which has been compiled annually since 1940 through voting by a national panel of up to 50 media professionals who evaluate players based on regular-season contributions. Selections include first-team and second-team designations, with first-team players universally referred to as All-Pros, and the process emphasizes objective excellence over popularity. Prior to the AP's involvement, the (UPI) produced similar All-Pro teams from 1931 to 1939, establishing the tradition during the early professional era. Other notable All-Pro recognitions include those from outlets like and , but the AP version remains the benchmark for prestige and historical significance. In 2022, the NFL Players Association (NFLPA) launched the Players' All-Pro Team, voted exclusively by active NFL players to honor peers based on on-field impact, with eligibility restrictions for those missing five or more games. Earning All-Pro status, especially multiple first-team nods, is a cornerstone achievement in a player's career, often factoring heavily into awards like MVP and induction.

Overview

Definition

All-Pro is an honorary recognition bestowed upon professional players in the (NFL), designating the top performers at each position based on their regular-season play. This accolade highlights exceptional individual contributions over the course of a season, serving as a benchmark for elite performance across the league. The All-Pro team typically comprises first-team and second-team selections, with one or two players named per position, encompassing offensive, defensive, and special teams roles such as quarterbacks, linemen, linebackers, and kickers. These teams are assembled through voting by media panels, coaches, or fellow players, ensuring a consensus view of the season's standouts. In contrast to all-star events like the , which invite players to participate in a postseason often influenced by fan votes, All-Pro status is solely a performance-based honor without any associated event. Eligibility is restricted to active players who have competed in the regular season, focusing exclusively on on-field achievements rather than popularity or postseason participation.

Significance

All-Pro honors represent the pinnacle of individual achievement in the , serving as a benchmark for elite performance that surpasses even the in prestige due to their rigorous selection process and limited roster spots. Unlike the fan-influenced , which selects 88 players across both conferences, All-Pro teams recognize only the top performers at each position, often limited to one first-team and one second-team honoree per spot, making the distinction a rare and highly coveted validation of a player's dominance during a season. These honors significantly boost player by affirming excellence through peer and media recognition, fostering a sense of respect that enhances motivation and cohesion; for instance, the Players Association's own All-Pro voting initiative underscores this peer validation as a key morale booster. On a level, All-Pro selections elevate internal dynamics by highlighting standout contributors, which can inspire collective performance and strengthen leadership roles within the locker room. Beyond the field, they drive fan engagement through targeted marketing campaigns that spotlight honorees in promotions, broadcasts, and merchandise, while also playing a pivotal role in Hall of Fame deliberations, where multiple All-Pro nods are frequently cited as evidence of sustained greatness. Statistically, All-Pro selections correlate strongly with higher (MVP) voting outcomes, as the same panel selects both awards; until 2024, no MVP winner had failed to earn first-team All-Pro status since 2003, though broke this trend in 2024, underscoring their intertwined prestige. In contract negotiations, these honors often trigger performance bonuses—commonly $250,000 to $500,000 per selection—and bolster a player's leverage for extensions, as teams value the proven elite status for long-term deals. For legacy building, repeated All-Pro recognitions, such as the 10 first-team selections earned by , serve as a quantitative benchmark for Hall of Fame induction and historical greatness, distinguishing players in era-defining narratives. In the broader NFL ecosystem, All-Pro teams shape league-wide narratives by fueling discussions on position battles—such as races influencing MVP debates—and affirming era dominance, where clusters of honorees from one team or conference highlight competitive shifts and strategic trends. This influence extends to media coverage and fan discourse, positioning All-Pro selections as cultural touchstones that define seasonal success and player legacies beyond mere statistics.

History

Origins in Early Professional Football

The concept of All-Pro teams emerged in the early amid the nascent American Professional Football Association (APFA), later renamed the () in 1922, as informal selections by newspaper writers to recognize top performers in a fragmented professional landscape. The first such team was compiled in by a sportswriter for the Rock Island Argus in , focusing on standout players from the league's inaugural season. This was followed by similar efforts, including a 1921 selection by the Buffalo Evening News and teams chosen that year by major outlets like the and , which polled coaches, players, and journalists to highlight elite talent across positions. A notable milestone came in 1922 when Chicago Bears player-coach , in collaboration with Canton Bulldogs coach Guy Chamberlin, assembled an All-Pro team published in several Midwestern newspapers, emphasizing players from APFA/NFL rosters and marking one of the earliest efforts by league insiders to formalize recognition. Halas's selection underscored the Bears' growing influence, as the team featured multiple honorees and helped elevate professional football's visibility. Key figures from this era included running back , whose 1925 debut with the Bears after a legendary college career at the University of Illinois drew massive crowds and media attention, though he received no All-Pro selections during his limited play in the due to injuries. Similarly, the began dominating selections in the late under coach , with players like quarterback Verne Lewellen earning repeated honors on teams compiled by the Green Bay Press-Gazette, reflecting the team's rise to championship contention. These early All-Pro efforts faced significant challenges due to the league's incomplete structure, with teams frequently folding or relocating, leading to uneven participation and incomplete rosters for evaluation. Selections varied widely because of a lack of , as individual newspapers relied on subjective polls without unified criteria, often resulting in disparate lineups. Regional biases further complicated matters, with Midwestern outlets like the favoring local stars while East Coast papers overlooked emerging western talent, creating inconsistent honors that reflected more on media access than objective merit.

Evolution and Standardization

In the intervening years, the (UPI) produced annual All-Pro teams from 1926 to 1939, building on the early newspaper traditions by aggregating votes from a broader network of journalists and providing a more consistent national perspective during the league's formative growth. The 1940s marked a pivotal shift in All-Pro selections toward greater national media involvement, as the (AP) published its inaugural All-Pro team in 1940, polling sportswriters across the country to identify the league's elite performers and establishing a standardized model that emphasized consensus among experts. This approach contrasted with earlier, more localized efforts and helped elevate All-Pro recognition as an authoritative benchmark for excellence in professional football. Following , the growth of the fueled further evolution in All-Pro processes during the , with selectors expanding coverage to encompass a broader array of specialized positions amid increasing player rosters and tactical complexity. By mid-decade, organizations like the AP routinely included second teams alongside first-team honors, allowing for deeper recognition of standout talent as the league absorbed teams from the and professionalized its operations. This period's selections reflected the era's emphasis on versatile linemen and ball-carriers, contributing to a more consistent framework that influenced fan perceptions and player legacies. The 1960s brought additional refinements, particularly in response to tactical innovations, as All-Pro teams began to delineate offensive and defensive linemen more explicitly in their positional breakdowns, aligning with the widespread adoption of balanced line formations like the 4-3 defense. Concurrently, the rise of the passing game—accelerated by the American Football League's (AFL) high-octane aerial attacks—influenced selections by highlighting quarterbacks and wide receivers who excelled in downfield play, such as and , thereby broadening the criteria beyond run-heavy dominance. The 1970 AFL-NFL merger profoundly standardized All-Pro honors by unifying the player pool into a single 26-team league, eliminating separate AFL and teams and curtailing duplicate selections that had fragmented recognition during the rival leagues' coexistence. This consolidation enhanced the prestige and consistency of All-Pro lists, as selectors like the AP now evaluated talent from an integrated roster, fostering a more cohesive standard that mirrored the 's emergence as a monolithic professional entity.

Primary Selectors

The (AP) launched the first national All-Pro team in 1940, marking a significant milestone in recognizing professional football excellence through a collaborative effort of sportswriters nationwide. This inaugural selection process involved a panel of media members voting on the top performers at each position, establishing the AP as a pioneering and enduring authority in All-Pro honors. Unlike earlier, more localized or newspaper-specific teams, the AP's approach aimed for broader consensus, reflecting performances across the league during its formative years. The AP's selection methodology relies on ballot-based voting conducted by a national panel, currently comprising 50 media members who cover the regularly. Voters rank players at each position based on positional excellence, with first- and second-team designations determined by point totals—first-place votes weighted highest, followed by subsequent rankings. The teams are released annually in early January, just before the , allowing for a full-season evaluation that emphasizes standout statistical achievements, such as passing yards or tackles, alongside qualitative impact like game-changing plays. This process has evolved slightly over time; since , voters rank up to five candidates for major awards and three for All-Pro spots to refine consensus. Over its 85-year history, the AP All-Pro selections have highlighted thousands of individual performances, recognizing hundreds of unique players for their dominance and contributions to the sport. The 1940 team, for instance, featured early NFL icons like quarterback of the Washington Redskins and halfback Byron "Whizzer" White of the , setting a standard for elite play. In more recent decades, the honor has consistently gone to quarterbacks with sustained excellence, such as , who earned three first-team selections (2007, 2010, 2017) and additional second-team nods, underscoring the AP's focus on longevity and peak impact. This enduring format distinguishes the AP from other media selectors by prioritizing a wide-ranging journalistic perspective.

Pro Football Writers Association

The Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA), founded on December 28, 1963, in Chicago as the Pro Football Writers Association of America, began selecting All-NFL teams in 1966 to recognize outstanding professional football players based on journalistic expertise. After a one-year hiatus in 1967, the organization issued combined All-AFL/NFL teams in 1968 and 1969 before standardizing its first-team All-NFL selections starting in 1970, coinciding with the AFL-NFL merger. This post-merger unification in 1970 marked a key evolution, aligning the PFWA's process with the newly consolidated 26-team league and emphasizing nationwide coverage through its local chapters in over 30 NFL markets. The PFWA's All-Pro team is determined through open to all members, comprising more than 300 accredited pro football writers from chapters across major cities, which fosters a consensus built on in-depth, localized reporting rather than broad polling. Ties are resolved by the executive committee, ensuring a definitive first team of typically 26-27 players, with second-team honors also awarded in earlier years from 1968-1976. The process prioritizes players' on-field impact as observed by beat writers, and while not formally biased, selections have historically favored dominant defensive performers, reflecting the membership's emphasis on game-altering contributions across the ball. Announcements of PFWA All-Pro teams include detailed player profiles highlighting career achievements and seasonal stats, providing context beyond mere listings. Over more than five decades, the organization has honored hundreds of players, with recent trends showcasing versatile athletes capable of multi-faceted roles, such as hybrid edge rushers and dual-threat linemen who adapt to modern schemes. Notable examples include , who earned his eighth PFWA first-team All-NFL selection in 2023, spanning 2015-2021 and 2023, underscoring the enduring recognition of elite, adaptable performers. The PFWA's selections often align with voting, contributing to broader media consensus on All-Pro honors.

The Sporting News

The Sporting News (TSN), long recognized as a premier authority in , began featuring All-Pro teams in the during the 1930s by publishing selections originally compiled by the from 1931 to 1953. This marked an early contribution to the recognition of professional football's elite players through a curated lens, drawing on insights and performance analysis rather than widespread public voting. In 1954, TSN launched its own original NFL All-Pro team selections, initially structured as All-Conference teams for the Eastern and Western divisions to reflect the league's divisional alignment at the time. This approach continued through 1979, emphasizing comprehensive coverage of standout performers across conferences in TSN's annual year-end issue, a print tradition that highlighted longevity, consistency, and intangible contributions like leadership and versatility. By 1980, TSN evolved its format to a unified All-Pro team for the entire league, streamlining recognition amid the NFL's merger and expansion. The methodology for TSN's All-Pro selections has historically prioritized expert curation over broad polling, relying on input from editors, contributors, and league insiders informed by scouting reports to balance statistical excellence with qualitative factors. Today, this process involves anonymous voting by the NFL's 32 head coaches, who evaluate peers based on season-long impact, providing a coach's-eye view that often spotlights undervalued contributors differing from media-driven lists like the Associated Press's. TSN's selections have had lasting historical impact, notably recognizing early icons such as quarterback with second-team All-NFL/AAFC honors in 1948, underscoring the publication's role in chronicling the sport's pioneers during its formative professional era. Following TSN's transition to a primarily digital platform in 2008—while ceasing weekly print editions—the All-Pro team retained its traditional editorial flavor, published annually in digital year-end summaries to honor over 1,800 total selections across positions since 1954.

Other Historical Selectors

United Press International

The United Press International (UPI), a major American wire service founded in 1907 as a rival to the Associated Press, entered the realm of NFL All-Pro selections in the early years of professional football's growth. UPI began compiling comprehensive All-Pro teams in 1931, focusing on the top performers across the league and continuing these full NFL-wide selections through 1969. These early teams were determined by polls among UPI-affiliated sportswriters from newspapers nationwide, providing an alternative perspective to the AP's offerings during a time when media coverage of the sport was expanding rapidly. With the NFL-AFL merger in 1970, UPI adapted by shifting to conference-specific teams, selecting separate All-AFC and All-NFC squads that highlighted the best players in each division. This format persisted into the , with selections continuing through 1996; for instance, earned first-team All-NFC recognition from UPI in 1980, 1984, and 1985. UPI's All-Pro teams played a significant role in recognizing standout performers during pivotal eras, contributing to the validation of players' achievements alongside other press-based honors. However, as the media industry underwent consolidation in the —marked by UPI's financial struggles, including a 1982 sale to new ownership and reduced operations—the service discontinued its NFL All-Pro selections in 1996. This defunct status left UPI's historical contributions as a key competitor in All-Pro recognition, particularly for its emphasis on wire service-driven in an era before modern and player-voted awards.

Newspaper Enterprise Association

The Newspaper Enterprise Association (NEA) introduced its NFL All-Pro team in 1955 as a syndicated feature created by sports editor Murray Olderman, distinguishing it from other honors by polling active players for selections rather than relying solely on media votes. Distributed through the NEA syndicate to more than 750 newspapers nationwide, the team reached a broad audience of local readers, offering an accessible alternative to more centralized media recognitions like the All-Pro. This wide dissemination emphasized its role in bringing peer-evaluated excellence to everyday fans, with ballots sent to hundreds of players annually—starting with 396 in the mid-1950s and growing to nearly 700 by the decade's end. The methodology centered on player perspectives, prioritizing versatile "all-purpose" performers who excelled in multiple facets of the game, including hybrid positions that blended traditional roles, such as blitzers or multi-tool linemen. Annual first- and second-team rosters were published from 1955 through 1992, providing consistent recognition amid competition from wire services like . Notable selections highlighted defensive standouts like St. Louis Cardinals Larry Wilson, who earned multiple NEA All-Pro honors for his innovative blitzes and interception prowess during the 1960s and early 1970s. Over its 38-year span, the team distributed approximately 200 unique honors to players, contributing significantly to career legacies before its discontinuation in 1992 due to declining newspaper syndication amid broader industry shifts toward . Compared to the AP's elite media panel, the NEA's syndicated, player-focused model made it more grassroots-oriented and inclusive for regional audiences.

National Football League Players Association

The National Football League Players Association (NFLPA) All-Pro team represents a unique peer-voted recognition, selected exclusively by active players to honor the top performers based on on-field experiences and respect. Introduced for the 1963 season, the inaugural team was determined through ballots cast by players across all positions, marking the first instance of such an internal league honor. This selection process emphasized direct matchups and competitive encounters, providing insight into how players viewed their toughest opponents. The voting process for the PA All-Pro team involves confidential ballots distributed to all active players, who nominate the best at their own position and the key opposing positions they face regularly, such as linemen selecting standout blockers or rushers. Voters are prohibited from choosing themselves or current teammates to ensure impartiality, and players who miss five or more games in the season become ineligible for selection. This approach prioritizes demonstrated impact in high-stakes games, often highlighting interior linemen and other "trench" players who embody the physical challenges of competition. The resulting team, comprising approximately 29 honorees across offense, defense, and special teams, is announced in early January following the regular season, aligning closely with preparations. After the 1963 edition, which closely resembled contemporary media-selected teams like the All-Pro but featured subtle differences in positional choices reflecting player perspectives, the NFLPA discontinued annual selections for nearly six decades. The honor was revived in 2022 as "The Players' All-Pro" team, restoring the peer-driven format amid growing emphasis on player input in league accolades. This revival has produced annual teams since, with voting conducted solely by the league's approximately 1,700 active members, each submitting a single ballot. Notable examples include the 2022 inaugural team, where of the and wide receiver of the Minnesota Vikings earned spots for their dominant play, underscoring the value peers place on clutch performance and matchup dominance. Subsequent years, such as 2024 and 2025 (announced January 8, 2025, with at ), continued this tradition with similar high-profile selections, reinforcing the team's role in celebrating internal respect within the . The NFLPA All-Pro stands apart from the official NFL All-Pro team by focusing purely on player votes rather than media panels, though overlaps in honorees are common due to shared recognition of elite talent. This peer-centric model offers a distinctive lens on excellence, particularly for positions like offensive and defensive lines where direct confrontations shape reputations.

NFL-Specific Recognition

Official NFL All-Pro Team

The Official NFL All-Pro Team represents the league's highest individual honor for player excellence, recognized as the standard benchmark since the AFL-NFL merger in unified the professional football landscape into a single 26-team circuit. Selected annually by the (AP), it highlights the top performers across all positions based on their contributions during the regular season. This recognition, which predates the merger but gained prominence in the post-merger era as the league's de facto official All-Pro designation, is compiled through input from established media organizations and serves to celebrate league-wide impact rather than conference-specific achievements. The selection process is a collaborative effort involving a national panel of 50 media members from major outlets across the , who vote based on comprehensive evaluation of , film study, and overall influence on team success. This approach ensures a balanced view focused on objective, league-wide metrics like yards gained, tackles, and turnovers forced. First- and second-team honors have been part of the format since the , providing depth to the recognition while maintaining consistency post-1970; voters submit ballots for each position, with the top vote-getters forming the teams. Distinguishing itself from purely independent selectors, the Official NFL All-Pro Team holds authoritative status for official records, Hall of Fame considerations, and player legacies. To adapt to evolving offenses, the AP introduced a flex position in , allowing for versatile selections such as an additional , , or to reflect formations emphasizing spread attacks and multi-role athletes. The team's composition has also evolved in response to rule changes, including the emphasis on reviews and protections that heightened the value of secondary play and quarterback accuracy, influencing selections for cornerbacks and safeties in particular. Player peer voting through the NFL Players Association offers a parallel recognition but lacks the media-driven breadth of this official process.

Selection Criteria and Process

The selection of All-Pro players in the relies on evaluating a player's overall performance throughout the regular season, with core criteria emphasizing statistical output such as yards gained, tackles made, or interceptions recorded, alongside their contributions to team success like enabling key wins or defensive stands. Versatility is also factored in, particularly for positions like offensive and defensive linemen, where players demonstrating adaptability across alignments or roles often receive preferential consideration, though evaluations are weighted differently by position without a rigid . These assessments draw from game film, statistical compilations, and observer insights rather than automated algorithms. For the Associated Press All-Pro Team, voting involves a national panel of 50 media members who rank their top choices for first- and second-team selections at each position, using a point system where higher ranks yield more weight. Ballots are typically due in late or early January, ensuring comprehensive review of Weeks 1 through 17. Challenges in the All-Pro process stem from inherent subjectivity, especially when assessing intangibles like or performance, which lack quantifiable metrics and can lead to divergent voter opinions on borderline cases. Ties are mitigated through ranked-choice systems, as implemented by the since 2022 to award points and reduce deadlocks, or via internal committees for final in other selectors when votes split evenly. These mechanisms help maintain fairness but underscore the interpretive nature of selections across panels. In the 2010s, traditional All-Pro voting began informally incorporating advanced metrics, such as (PFF) grades that adjust for situational context like opponent quality or snap counts, allowing voters to supplement traditional stats with data-driven insights. However, these tools remain supplementary rather than dominant, as core decisions continue to prioritize holistic evaluation over algorithmic outputs, with organizations like PFF issuing separate All-Pro teams based exclusively on their proprietary grades.

Impact and Benefits

Compensatory Draft Selections

Since the 1993 collective bargaining agreement, the has awarded compensatory draft selections to teams that suffer a net loss of unrestricted free agents (UFAs), with All-Pro honors playing a key role in elevating the value of those lost players within the league's proprietary formula. This system, developed jointly by the and the NFL Players Association, aims to promote competitive balance by compensating teams for significant personnel departures. The formula evaluates each qualifying UFA loss based on factors including the player's new contract value, playing time, and postseason accolades, such as All-Pro selections by the () or Pro Football Writers Association (PFWA). A first-team All-Pro designation adds substantial value, often pushing the compensatory pick into an earlier round compared to non-honored players. The playing time and honors component of the formula is calculated by first assigning snap points: one point for each of a team's total offensive or defensive in which the player participated (with a minimum of 25% required for eligibility), capped at 100 points for full participation. Postseason honors are added as bonus points: 20 points for a first-team All-Pro selection by the AP or first-team All-NFL by the PFWA, and 5 points for an All-Conference honor by the PFWA (second-team equivalent; AP second-team selections do not award bonus points). These adjusted points contribute to an overall player value score, which—combined with the average annual value of the new contract relative to the top five salaries at the position—determines the compensatory pick's round equivalent, ranging from the third to seventh round based on ranking among all qualifying losses league-wide. For instance, the loss of a first-team All-Pro UFA who logged 90% of offensive could generate a total of 110 playing time and honors points (90 snap points + 20 All-Pro bonus), potentially yielding a third-round compensatory pick if the contract value ranks highly. The NFL's Management Council Executive Committee reviews and finalizes these calculations annually, awarding picks at the end of the third through seventh rounds, with a maximum of four per team. Compensatory picks apply exclusively to UFAs with at least three accrued seasons whose contracts have expired, and no selections are granted if a team's UFA gains offset losses or if the departing player signs a below a certain threshold relative to positional averages. Special teams players, kickers, and punters follow modified criteria based on statistical performance rather than . This structure ensures awards reflect meaningful contributions, including All-Pro status, but caps total picks to maintain draft balance.

Player Careers and Recognition

All-Pro selections provide players with substantial leverage in contract negotiations, enabling them to secure higher average annual values (AAV) compared to peers without such honors. NFL agents frequently highlight how these accolades demonstrate elite performance, justifying premium compensation; for instance, back-to-back All-Pro nods can strengthen a player's position to demand extensions exceeding $60 million annually. exemplifies this, as his first-team All-Pro selection in 2023—following his first-team honor in 2019—bolstered his leverage for a potential new deal after his 2023 five-year, $260 million extension, with analysts noting his recent dominance positions him for $65-67 million per year. Beyond immediate financial gains, multiple All-Pro selections mark key career milestones that enhance long-term prospects, including a strong correlation with induction. Historical data shows that players earning five or more first-team All-Pro honors have an induction rate approaching 90% among eligible candidates, underscoring the honor's role as a hallmark of sustained excellence. These achievements also amplify endorsement opportunities, as brands seek association with proven stars, thereby extending a player's influence and income streams off the field. Recognition for All-Pro status extends through official NFL announcements and archival listings, contributing to a player's enduring legacy. Honorees are often celebrated during the annual ceremony, where top performers from the season receive public acclaim alongside other awards. Over time, this manifests in career summaries as "X-time All-Pro," a prestigious descriptor that cements their reputation in statistical records and team histories. Players like have effectively incorporated All-Pro honors into their career narratives to highlight dominance and leadership. Lewis earned seven first-team All-Pro selections across his 17-year tenure with the , which were pivotal in framing his legacy as a transformative defender and securing his first-ballot induction into the in 2018.

Alternative Modern Selectors

Analytics-Based Organizations

(PFF), a leading provider founded in 2007, has selected annual All-Pro teams since the 2010 season, basing selections on comprehensive player evaluations derived from film study. PFF analysts grade every player on every snap using a detailed -2.0 to +2.0 scale that assesses performance relative to expectations, with grades normalized to a 0-100 scale where scores above 90 indicate elite play, 70-89 denote starting-caliber contributions, and below 60 reflect subpar efforts. These grades form the core of All-Pro determinations, where a panel of senior analysts identifies first- and second-team honorees for offensive, defensive, and special teams positions by prioritizing top-percentile performers in overall grades, contextual factors like consistency and situational impact, and advanced metrics such as pass-rush win rates or coverage efficiency. Complementing PFF's approach, other analytics organizations emphasize metrics over raw volume statistics to highlight All-Pro talent. , now integrated into FTN Fantasy, utilizes its signature Defense-adjusted Value Over Average (DVOA) metric, which evaluates plays by comparing outcomes to league baselines adjusted for opponent strength, down, distance, and field position, thereby rewarding efficient execution in high-leverage situations. Selections draw from player-level DVOA rankings, favoring those who maximize value per opportunity, such as running backs with strong adjusted line yards or quarterbacks excelling in success rate. Similarly, ESPN's annual All-Pro teams, curated by analysts like since 2019, incorporate (QBR)—a 0-100 holistic measure for passing, rushing, and fumbles adjusted for defensive —alongside broader stats to underscore players who drive team success beyond traditional counting metrics. Other contributors include the NFL's Next Gen Stats and Pro Football Reference, which provide advanced metrics influencing All-Pro evaluations. These methodologies blend algorithmic precision with expert oversight, often diverging from volume-based traditional voting by rewarding contextual excellence; for instance, quarterback earned PFF first-team All-Pro honors in 2022 after posting a 91.3 overall PFF grade, the highest among qualifiers, reflecting his elite decision-making and big-play creation despite not always leading in raw yards. propelled by the broader Moneyball-inspired revolution in the , which addresses limitations in subjective media polls by providing objective, reproducible insights into player impact. Each organization typically honors around 100 players annually across first- and second-team rosters, filling coverage gaps for specialized roles and emerging talents overlooked in conventional assessments.

Regional and Independent Honors

Regional honors in the NFL All-Pro context primarily manifest through conference-specific selections, such as the All-AFC and All-NFC teams announced annually by the Professional Football Writers of America (PFWA). Established in 1992, these teams are voted on by PFWA members—accredited media covering franchises—who evaluate players based on their impact within their respective conferences, often spotlighting performances in high-stakes divisional matchups and rivalries. For the 2024 season, for instance, the AFC team featured four players from the and , underscoring the emphasis on intra-conference excellence. Independent All-Pro honors, distinct from league-affiliated or major media selectors, are produced by diverse online platforms and outlets that offer subjective or community-driven evaluations. Organizations like compile their own All-Pro teams through expert analysis, as seen in Bill Barnwell's 2024 selections highlighting 50 top performers across positions. Similarly, releases an annual All-Pro roster based on staff assessments, with the 2024 edition featuring strong representation from contenders like the and . These selections frequently recognize under-the-radar talents from smaller markets, such as interior linemen or specialists who might be overlooked in national voting. Platforms like contribute to this landscape with staff-curated or fan-influenced teams, often released midseason or thematically, such as divisional all-stars ahead of . While lacking the authority of primary selectors, these independent efforts play a niche role in fan engagement, amplifying discussions around overlooked contributors and fostering divisional pride. As of , numerous such groups remain active, bolstered by digital tools that enhance their reach through online polls and interactions. Unlike analytics-based organizations that prioritize objective data, these honors emphasize narrative-driven and subjective insights into player impact.

References

  1. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/All-Pro
  2. https://www.nfl.com/news/2014-all-pro-teams-analysis-of-the-full-rosters-0ap3000000452986
  3. https://www.steelers.com/news/labriola-on-the-quest-pro-bowl-vs-all-pro-20240045
  4. https://apnews.com/article/nfl-all-pro-2024-cdf9837431c51929b072c357988bc024
  5. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/about/allpro.htm
  6. https://nflpa.com/posts/the-players-all-pro
  7. https://www.nfl.com/news/nflpa-to-create-all-pro-team-voted-on-by-nfl-players
  8. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/2024/allpro.htm
  9. https://www.bbc.com/sport/articles/c2eg2j0eyzpo
  10. https://www.si.com/nfl/saints/editorial-opinion/saints-all-pro-more-impressive-than-pro-bowl
  11. https://sports.yahoo.com/nfl-players-launch-players-all-pro-team-where-they-not-the-media-determine-best-players-in-the-league-200118662.html
  12. https://talkoffametwo.com/nfl/all-decade-teams-as-tools-for-canton-voters
  13. https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/every-nfl-teams-most-likely-future-hall-of-famer-making-the-call-on-tyreek-hill-t-j-watt-others/
  14. https://www.buffalorumblings.com/2025/1/10/24340787/its-been-20-years-since-the-nfl-mvp-wasnt-first-team-all-pro-lamar-jackson-josh-allen
  15. https://www.nbcsports.com/nfl/profootballtalk/rumor-mill/news/all-pro-voting-points-to-lamar-jackson-as-mvp
  16. https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/43726453/commanders-daniels-named-top-offensive-rookie-nfl-honors
  17. https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/agents-take-player-performance-bonuses-that-can-be-earned-in-2025-nfl-playoffs/
  18. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/R/RiceJe00.htm
  19. https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/nfl-mvp-award-ap-voters-explain-controversial-choices-in-josh-allens-split-the-baby-win-over-lamar-jackson/
  20. https://www.si.com/nfl/what-ap-voters-all-pro-qb-pick-lamar-jackson-josh-allen-mvp-race
  21. https://www.profootballhof.com/news/2010/01/news-nfl-s-all-decade-team-of-the-1920s/
  22. https://profootballresearchers.com/archives/Website_Files/Coffin_Corner/05-07-147.pdf
  23. https://www.profootballhof.com/players/harold-red-grange/
  24. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/G/GranRe20.htm
  25. https://www.packers.com/news/george-calhoun-s-press-gazette-all-pro-teams-unmatched
  26. https://www.profootballhof.com/news/2010/01/news-nfl-s-all-decade-team-of-the-1940s/
  27. https://operations.nfl.com/learn-the-game/nfl-basics/rookies-guide/evolution-of-the-nfl-player/
  28. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/1950/allpro.htm
  29. https://www.profootballhof.com/news/2010/01/news-nfl-s-all-decade-team-of-the-1960s-defense/
  30. https://apnews.com/a-look-at-the-nfl-in-the-1960s-ff16ff682379467f914d823ff4988c58
  31. https://www.nfl.com/news/it-s-hard-to-imagine-today-s-game-without-afl-s-impact-09000d5d81235ee2
  32. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/sports-and-leisure/nfl-afl-merger-creates-sports-industry-giant
  33. https://apnews.com/article/nfl-all-pro-lamar-jackson-c57d41fdc185e2b036412a2ec2cf3563
  34. https://apnews.com/article/nfl-all-pro-2024-888c24e48accae0aed78547a22562331
  35. https://www.ap.org/media-center/press-releases/2022/ap-updates-voting-system-for-its-nfl-awards/
  36. https://www.footballperspective.com/the-aps-all-pro-voting-process-is-a-joke/
  37. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/1940/allpro.htm
  38. https://www.marca.com/en/nfl/2022/01/14/61e0db52268e3e7a558b45c7.html
  39. https://www.profootballwriters.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/PFWARecordBook_071824.pdf
  40. https://www.profootballwriters.org/on-field-awards/pfwa-all-nfl-teams/
  41. https://www.profootballwriters.org/about-the-pfwa/
  42. https://www.profootballwriters.org/2025/01/20/pfwa-2024-all-nfl-all-afc-and-all-nfc-teams-announced/
  43. https://nflfootballjournal.blogspot.com/2018/01/side-by-side-comparison-of-ap-and-pfwa.html
  44. https://www.profootballwriters.org/2024/01/22/pfwa-2023-all-nfl-all-afc-and-all-nfc-teams-announced/
  45. https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/aaron-donald-bobby-wagner-climbing-up-list-of-most-first-team-all-pro-selections-in-nfl-history/
  46. https://www.sportingnews.com/us/nfl/news/nfl-awards-history-winners-results/qdey5fuegm3zgbeuqlxgoymv
  47. https://www.sportingnews.com/us/nfl/news/nfl-all-pro-team-2024-chiefs-eagles-coaches-vote/199144006d61a4b5ffec3938
  48. https://www.statscrew.com/football/stats/p-baughsam001
  49. https://sportingnewsholdings.com/history/
  50. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/P/PaytWa00.htm
  51. https://nflfootballjournal.blogspot.com/2022/12/for-second-time-nflpa-to-choose-all-pro.html
  52. https://talkoffametwo.com/nfl/nflpa-all-pro-team-ap-pfwa
  53. https://bleacherreport.com/articles/10061313-patrick-mahomes-justin-jefferson-highlight-nfl-players-inaugural-all-pro-team
  54. https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/nflpa-creates-all-pro-team-voted-on-by-nfl-players-selections-to-be-revealed-jan-11/
  55. https://www.foxsports.com/stories/nfl/nflpa-unveils-first-ever-players-all-pro-team
  56. https://www.britannica.com/topic/National-Football-League
  57. https://thefalconswire.usatoday.com/2016/12/16/associated-press-all-pro-team-will-now-include-a-flex-spot/
  58. https://www.nfl.com/news/next-gen-stats-2024-all-pro-team-defense-special-teams
  59. https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-measuring-defensive-line-alignment-versatility-entropy
  60. https://halloffootball.substack.com/p/ap-vs-pfwa-dueling-honors-lists
  61. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VnF6D8pBWVI
  62. https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-pff-2025-midseason-all-pro-team
  63. https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-advanced-coverage-grade
  64. https://operations.nfl.com/journey-to-the-nfl/the-nfl-draft/the-rules-of-the-draft/
  65. https://overthecap.com/compensatory-formula
  66. https://www.steelcurtainnetwork.com/explaining-how-the-compensatory-draft-picks-system-works/
  67. https://overthecap.com/collective-bargaining-agreement/appendix/V/
  68. https://operations.nfl.com/updates/the-players/nfl-announces-35-compensatory-draft-choices-to-15-clubs/
  69. https://www.si.com/nfl/dolphins/onsi/news/trying-to-explain-the-nfl-s-compensatory-draft-pick-formula-01jj52gnypvt
  70. https://www.si.com/nfl/ravens/news/baltimore-ravens-lamar-jackson-perfect-timing-contract-leverage
  71. https://sports.yahoo.com/article/former-agent-breaks-down-enormous-185206100.html
  72. https://www.profootballhof.com/players/ray-lewis/
  73. https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-quarterback-play-level-data
  74. https://www.blog.fc.pff.com/blog/pff-fc-grades-explained
  75. https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-2024-pff-all-pro-team
  76. https://ftnfantasy.com/nfl/dvoa-explainer
  77. https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/43241328/nfl-all-pro-team-2024-season-barnwell-50-best-players-picks-every-position-pro-bowl
  78. https://www.espn.com/nfl/qbr
  79. https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-pff-2022-all-pro-team-patrick-mahomes-justin-jefferson-micah-parsons
  80. https://theanalyst.com/articles/evolution-of-the-analytics-movement-in-the-nfl
  81. https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/2024-cbs-sports-nfl-all-pro-team-lions-ravens-eagles-among-best-represented-contenders-in-all-star-voting/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.