Hubbry Logo
Manik SarkarManik SarkarMain
Open search
Manik Sarkar
Community hub
Manik Sarkar
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Manik Sarkar
Manik Sarkar
Manik Sarkar
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Manik Sarkar (born 22 January 1949) is an Indian communist politician who served as the Chief Minister of Tripura from March 1998 to March 2018. He is a Politburo member of the Communist Party of India (Marxist).[1][2] In March 2008, he was sworn in as leader of Left Front, the Tripura coalition government.[3] In assembly elections held in 2013, he became the chief minister for the fourth consecutive time. He served as the Leader of the Opposition in the Tripura Legislative Assembly from 2018 to 2023.

Key Information

Early life and background

[edit]

Manik Sarkar was born into a middle-class Bengali Kayastha family.[4][5] His father, Amulya Sarkar, worked as a tailor, while his mother, Anjali Sarkar, was a State and later Provincial government employee.[6] Sarkar became active in student movements in his student days, and in 1968, at the age of 19, he became a member of the Communist Party of India (Marxist). He was a candidate of the Students' Federation of India throughout his academic life at MBB College, from where he graduated with a B. Com. degree.[7] During his first year at the college there came the turbulent times of the food movement of 1967, campaigning against the policy of the then Congress government of Tripura, and Sarkar threw himself headlong into the related student struggle. His vigorous role in this mass movement led him to join the Communists.[8] Due to his early political exposure, he also became the General Secretary of the MBB College Student Union and was also made the Vice President of the Students' Federation of India. In 1972, at the early age of 23, he joined the State Committee of the Communist Party of India (Marxist).[7]

Political career

[edit]
The Vice President, Shri Mohd. Hamid Ansari being received by the Chief Minister of Tripura, Shri Manik Sarkar, on his arrival at Agartala Airport, in Agartala, Tripura on September 25, 2013

In 1978, six years after being selected in the CPI (M) State Committee, Sarkar was included in the party state secretariat. This was also the year when the first Left Front government had taken control in Tripura.

In 1980, at the age of 31, he was elected as the Member of the Legislative Assembly from the Agartala constituency. This was the start of Manik Sarkar's leadership in his state.[9] Around the same time, he was appointed the Chief Whip of the CPI (M). In 1983, he was again elected to the Assembly as MLA from Krishnanagar, Agartala.[4] When the Left Front government took control in 1993, Sarkar was appointed the State Secretary of the CPI (M).

The biggest success came to Sarkar in 1998. At the age of 49, he became a member of the Politburo of the CPI (M), which is the principal policy-making and executive committee in a Communist party.[9][10] In the same year, he became the Chief Minister of the state of Tripura. Since then, he was elected to the same position four consecutive times in 20 years.[9] He is one of the very few chief Ministers in India who was in the office for so long. His party lost majority in the 2018 elections and he had to step down as a result.

It was noted that Sarkar did not contest the 2023 elections. He revealed that he had done so in order to pave way for younger leadership.

Personal life

[edit]

Sarkar is married to Panchali Bhattacharya, who was employed with the Central Social Welfare Board till she retired in 2011. He chooses to live in an old and a very small house that belonged to his great grandfather. He used to donate his entire salary that he received as a Chief Minister to his party and in return, got ₹ 5,000 per month as allowance.[11][12][13][14]

Election Contested

[edit]

Tripura Legislative Assembly

[edit]
Year Constituency Party Votes % Opponent Opponent Party Opponent Votes % Result Margin %
2018 Dhanpur CPI(M) 22,176 54.43 Pratima Bhoumik BJP 16,735 41.08 Won 5,441 13.35
2013 21,286 57.1 Shah Alam INC 15,269 40.96 Won 6,017 16.14
2008 17,992 52.91 15,074 44.32 Won 2,918 8.59
2003 15,613 55.85 Dipak Chakraborty 11,111 39.74 Won 4,502 16.11
1998 12,771 53.9 Majibur Islam Majumder 9,668 40.81 Won 3,103 13.09
1988 Agartala 12,695 49.4 Maharani Bidhu Kumari Debi 12,776 49.72 Lost -81 -0.32
1983 10,623 52.18 Promode Ranjandas Gupta 9,485 46.59 Won 1,138 5.59

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Manik Sarkar

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Manik Sarkar (born 22 January 1949) is an Indian politician and senior leader of the Communist Party of India (Marxist), serving as a member of its Politburo. He was the Chief Minister of Tripura from March 1998 to March 2018, holding the position for four consecutive terms and becoming the longest-serving chief minister in the state's history. Currently, he is the Leader of the Opposition in the Tripura Legislative Assembly, representing the Dhanpur constituency as a seven-term MLA. Sarkar is noted for his personal frugality, with his wife managing family finances and the couple owning minimal assets, leading to his characterization as India's "poorest" chief minister during his tenure. His leadership emphasized policies aligned with Marxist principles, including land reforms and public welfare initiatives under the Left Front government, which governed Tripura for 25 years until 2018. As a student activist who joined the CPI(M) in the 1960s, Sarkar's career reflects commitment to communist ideology amid the challenges of administering a northeastern state prone to ethnic tensions and insurgencies.

Early Life and Education

Family Background and Upbringing

Manik Sarkar was born on 22 January 1949 in Radhakishorepur, a locality in Udaipur, South Tripura, into a lower middle-class Bengali Kayastha family. His father, Amulya Sarkar, worked as a tailor, supporting the family through manual labor in a region marked by economic challenges and ethnic diversity. His mother, Anjali Sarkar, served as a state government employee, initially in the health department and later in provincial roles, providing a modest stability amid the family's circumstances. This background of frugality and self-reliance in post-partition Tripura, where Bengali refugees and locals navigated insurgency and underdevelopment, shaped Sarkar's early exposure to socioeconomic disparities. Limited public records detail his upbringing, but contemporaries describe a childhood emphasizing simplicity, with Sarkar performing household tasks independently and maintaining honest habits from a young age. The family's residence in rural South Tripura immersed him in a milieu of agricultural communities and emerging leftist influences, precursors to his later political engagement.

Academic Pursuits

Sarkar completed his Bachelor of Commerce degree from Maharaja Bir Bikram College in Agartala, Tripura, in 1971. This institution, affiliated with Tripura University, provided his primary higher education in commerce-related subjects. While pursuing his undergraduate studies, Sarkar engaged in campus activities that aligned with his emerging political interests, though his formal academic focus remained on commerce coursework leading to graduation. No records indicate postgraduate qualifications or advanced academic endeavors beyond this bachelor's level.

Entry into Politics

Student Activism

Sarkar enrolled at Maharaja Bir Bikram College in Agartala, Tripura, where he pursued undergraduate studies and became active in student politics through the Students' Federation of India (SFI), the student organization affiliated with the Communist Party of India (Marxist) (CPI(M)). At age 19, in 1968, he formally joined the CPI(M), marking his entry into organized leftist activism during his college years. In 1971, Sarkar contested the students' union election at Maharaja Bir Bikram College on an SFI ticket and was elected general secretary of the college students' union, a position that solidified his leadership within campus politics. His involvement extended beyond the college level, as he rose to become general secretary of the Tripura unit of SFI, organizing student mobilizations aligned with CPI(M)'s broader ideological campaigns against perceived feudal and capitalist influences in education and society. This period of activism laid the groundwork for his subsequent full-time commitment to party work, emphasizing grassroots organizing among youth in Tripura's politically charged environment.

Affiliation with CPI(M)

Manik Sarkar joined the Communist Party of India (Marxist) in 1968 at the age of 19, while studying at Maharaja Bir Bikram College in Agartala, Tripura. His entry into the party followed involvement in student politics through the Students' Federation of India (SFI), the CPI(M)'s student wing, amid widespread unrest over food shortages and demands for democratic reforms in the state during the late 1960s. After graduating with a bachelor's degree in arts, Sarkar transitioned to full-time party work as a "whole-timer," forgoing salaried employment to focus on organizing peasants, workers, and youth in rural and urban areas of Tripura. He contributed to CPI(M)-affiliated mass organizations, including the All India Kisan Sabha and the Centre of Indian Trade Unions, building grassroots support in a region marked by ethnic tensions and insurgent activities. By the early 1970s, he had attended the party's 9th Congress in Madurai as a delegate, solidifying his commitment to Marxist-Leninist ideology and anti-imperialist struggles. Sarkar's ascent within the CPI(M) hierarchy accelerated in the 1980s and 1990s. He was elected to the Tripura state committee and later the state secretariat, playing a key role in coordinating party responses to violence from tribal separatist groups and central government policies. In 1993, following the Left Front's assembly victory, he was appointed secretary of the CPI(M)'s Tripura state unit, a position that centralized his influence over party strategy and mobilization efforts. In 1998, at age 49, Sarkar was inducted into the CPI(M) Politburo, the party's central policy-making body, recognizing his organizational acumen and leadership in sustaining the Left's dominance in Tripura despite national declines for communist parties. He has retained Politburo membership continuously, including as of the 24th Party Congress in 2025, where he addressed sessions on ideological continuity and mass movements. Throughout his affiliation, Sarkar has adhered to CPI(M) principles of class struggle and opposition to neoliberal reforms, often critiquing coalition compromises at the national level while prioritizing state-level land redistribution and anti-insurgency operations aligned with party directives.

Political Career in Tripura

Legislative Roles and Elections

Manik Sarkar served as a Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA) for the Tripura Legislative Assembly for seven terms, spanning from the early 1980s until 2018. During his four terms as Chief Minister from 1998 to 2018, Sarkar functioned as the leader of the CPI(M)-led Left Front legislative party in the assembly, guiding its agenda and policy implementation following victories in the 1998, 2003, 2008, and 2013 elections. In the 2018 Tripura Legislative Assembly election held on February 18, Sarkar secured victory in the Dhanpur constituency by a margin of 5,441 votes despite the Left Front's overall defeat, enabling him to assume the role of Leader of the Opposition from March 2018 until 2023. Sarkar did not contest the 2023 Tripura Legislative Assembly election, marking the end of his direct legislative participation as the CPI(M) opted for a generational shift in candidacy.

Rise to Leadership in CPI(M)

Sarkar joined the CPI(M) Tripura state committee in 1972, shortly after completing his education and amid the party's efforts to consolidate peasant and worker support in the state. His early involvement included organizing underground activities during the Emergency period (1975–1977), which strengthened his standing within the party's cadre amid repression by the central Congress government. By 1978, he had been inducted into the CPI(M) Tripura state secretariat, the party's key decision-making body at the state level, reflecting his growing influence through consistent electoral mobilization and grassroots organizing. In 1983, Sarkar was elected as a Member of the Legislative Assembly from Baramura, marking his transition from party organizer to elected representative, and he retained the seat in subsequent elections, bolstering the Left Front's dominance in the assembly. Following the Left Front's victory in the 1993 state elections, he was appointed secretary of the CPI(M) Tripura state committee, succeeding the previous leadership under Dasarath Deb, who became chief minister. In this role until 1998, Sarkar oversaw party strategy, including countering ethnic insurgencies and expanding membership among tribal communities, which contributed to the Left's sustained control despite national declines for communists. Sarkar's ascent continued nationally; by 1998, at age 50, he was elected to the CPI(M) central committee and subsequently the Politburo, the party's highest executive body, coinciding with his selection as chief minister after Deb's tenure. This elevation underscored his reputation for austere leadership and effectiveness in Tripura's volatile political landscape, where the party relied on land reforms and anti-insurgency measures to maintain loyalty, though critics from rival parties questioned the centralization of power within a few long-serving figures. He retained Politburo membership until 2025, when age limits enforced retirement.

Chief Ministership (1998–2018)

Path to Power and Terms Served

Manik Sarkar ascended to the position of Chief Minister following the Communist Party of India (Marxist)-led Left Front's victory in the Tripura Legislative Assembly elections on February 16, 1998, where the alliance secured a majority of seats in the 60-member house. Elected as a Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA) from the Dhanpur constituency, Sarkar was chosen by the CPI(M) as leader of its legislature party, succeeding Dasarath Debbarma, who had served as Chief Minister since 1993. He was sworn in on March 11, 1998, marking the beginning of his tenure at the helm of Tripura's government. Sarkar's leadership saw the Left Front retain power through three subsequent assembly elections. In 2003, the alliance won 46 seats, enabling his continuation as Chief Minister. The 2008 polls resulted in 49 seats for the Left Front, securing his third term, sworn in on March 10, 2008. By 2013, despite a reduced margin, they captured 50 seats, allowing Sarkar to assume office for a record fourth consecutive term on March 7, 2013. His uninterrupted service from March 11, 1998, to March 9, 2018—spanning exactly 20 years—made Sarkar the longest-serving Chief Minister in Tripura's history, overseeing a period of sustained CPI(M) dominance in the state's politics. This era ended with the Left Front's defeat in the 2018 elections to the Bharatiya Janata Party-led alliance.

Economic Policies and Development Initiatives

The economic policies of Manik Sarkar's administration in Tripura prioritized agrarian reforms and public sector-led development over rapid industrialization, reflecting the CPI(M)'s ideological commitment to socialism and land redistribution as foundations for equity. Land reforms, initiated in the 1970s but intensified under Left Front rule, redistributed excess holdings to landless families and restored tribal lands encroached upon by non-tribals, covering approximately 1.5 lakh hectares by the early 2000s. These measures aimed to bolster agricultural productivity and reduce rural inequality, though implementation faced challenges from population pressures and influx-related land scarcity. Agricultural development focused on diversification beyond subsistence paddy cultivation, with promotion of cash crops like rubber, horticulture (including pineapple and jackfruit), and bamboo-based enterprises to leverage Tripura's natural resources. Rubber plantations expanded significantly, reaching over 40,000 hectares by 2010, supported by state subsidies and cooperative models, contributing to rural employment. Irrigation coverage rose from under 5% of cultivable land prior to sustained Left Front governance to around 25-30% by the mid-2010s through canal projects and minor irrigation schemes. However, critics argued that over-reliance on agriculture, which employed over 60% of the workforce, perpetuated low productivity and vulnerability to monsoons, with minimal mechanization due to policy emphasis on manual labor cooperatives. Industrial policies offered incentives such as capital subsidies and tax exemptions to attract small-scale units in agro-processing and garments, including welcoming Bangladeshi investments in textile units around 2014 to utilize local labor and proximity to markets. Yet, private investment remained subdued, with the state's industrial sector contributing less than 10% to GSDP by 2018, hampered by militant disruptions in the 1990s-2000s, poor connectivity, and ideological aversion to large-scale privatization. Efforts to develop infrastructure, including national highways and power generation from gas and hydel sources, were funded largely through central schemes, as Tripura's revenue depended heavily on devolved funds and royalties. Sarkar's government allocated substantial budgets to social infrastructure, yielding improvements in human development indicators; Tripura's literacy rate climbed to over 87% by 2011, with tribal literacy exceeding non-tribal rates in some districts, supported by universal education drives. Per capita net state domestic product rose from lagging India by 25% in 1997-98 to a narrower gap by 2017-18, reflecting modest growth averaging 6-7% annually in the 2010s amid national trends. Nonetheless, persistent unemployment, estimated at 20-25% among youth, and limited job creation outside agriculture fueled migration and critiques of economic stagnation, with the state blamed for failing to industrialize despite natural gas reserves and border trade potential.

Security Measures and Insurgency Control

During Manik Sarkar's tenure as Chief Minister from 1998 to 2018, Tripura faced persistent insurgency driven by ethnic tensions between indigenous tribes and Bengali settlers, with groups like the National Liberation Front of Tripura (NLFT) and All Tripura Tiger Force (ATTF) engaging in violence, kidnappings, and demands for tribal autonomy or secession. The CPI(M)-led government adopted a "carrot and stick" approach, integrating intensified security operations by state police and central forces such as the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) with negotiated surrenders and rehabilitation packages for militants. This included area domination tactics, intelligence-led raids, and the establishment of village defense committees to enhance local security. Key to the strategy was diplomatic coordination with Bangladesh, where insurgent training camps had long provided sanctuary; Sarkar credited the Sheikh Hasina government's post-2009 crackdowns on these bases for disrupting external support and supply lines, leading to a marked decline in cross-border incursions by 2015. Domestically, the administration facilitated over 8,000 militant surrenders by June 2011 through amnesty offers, vocational training, and financial incentives under schemes like the Surrender-cum-Rehabilitation Policy, targeting mid-level commanders and foot soldiers from NLFT, ATTF, and allied factions. Parallel efforts emphasized addressing root causes via land reforms restoring tribal holdings, expanded tribal autonomous district councils, and infrastructure projects to curb unemployment-fueled recruitment; Sarkar repeatedly stated that economic development, including job creation in agriculture and education, was essential to erode insurgency's appeal among youth. Psychological operations and confidence-building measures, such as community outreach by security forces, complemented kinetic actions to rebuild trust in tribal areas. These measures yielded a substantial reduction in violence: insurgency-related incidents, which peaked in the early 2000s with hundreds of fatalities annually, dropped to near negligible levels by the mid-2010s, with official data indicating fewer than 20 civilian and security personnel deaths per year in the latter half of Sarkar's term. While critics from opposition parties alleged over-reliance on force and occasional human rights lapses in counterinsurgency operations, the government's framework was credited by independent analyses for stabilizing the state without full-scale military escalation.

Social Reforms and Welfare Programs

During Manik Sarkar's tenure as Chief Minister, the Left Front government prioritized land reforms as a core social initiative, implementing ceiling laws that redistributed over 7,000 acres to tribal communities by the early 2000s, addressing historical dispossession of indigenous lands. These measures extended irrigation coverage from under 5% of arable land prior to 1978 to significantly higher levels by 2017, enhancing agricultural productivity for smallholders and landless laborers. Tribal lands illegally occupied by non-tribals were systematically restored, fostering social equity in a state with substantial indigenous populations. In education, the administration achieved marked progress, elevating Tripura's literacy rate to 97% overall and 95.71% for females by 2015, among India's highest, through expanded access to primary and secondary schooling in rural and tribal areas. Public investment focused on universal enrollment and infrastructure, contributing to the state's transition toward full literacy status in subsequent years. Healthcare reforms emphasized free public services, including essential medicines in government hospitals and improved maternal-child health outcomes, with the government providing adequate facilities as a welfare priority. Welfare programs under Sarkar included high-fidelity execution of central schemes like the Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) and social pensions, alongside state initiatives for vulnerable groups, such as those managed by the Social Welfare and Social Education Department. The government introduced around 30 pension schemes benefiting the elderly, widows, and disabled, which were later continued by successors, reflecting a commitment to income support for the poor. Efforts toward women's empowerment featured programs promoting gender balance, including events on International Women's Day emphasizing equitable societal roles. These initiatives aligned with CPI(M)'s redistributive ethos, though implementation relied heavily on central funding and faced critiques for uneven coverage in remote areas.

Electoral Defeat and Aftermath

2018 Assembly Elections

The 2018 Tripura Legislative Assembly election, held on February 18 for 59 constituencies with vote counting on March 3, ended the CPI(M)-led Left Front's 25-year governance under Chief Minister Manik Sarkar, who had served four terms since 1998. The incumbent Left Front faced the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) allied with the Indigenous People's Front of Tripura (IPFT), which mounted an aggressive campaign emphasizing economic development, implementation of the Seventh Pay Commission for state employees, and critiques of alleged stagnation and militancy under Sarkar's administration. Sarkar, contesting from the Dhanpur constituency, highlighted the Left Front's achievements in literacy, land redistribution, and welfare programs while accusing the BJP of divisive tactics and unfulfilled national promises. The BJP-IPFT alliance capitalized on anti-incumbency, surging from negligible prior representation to win 43 seats (BJP securing 35-36, IPFT 8), forming a majority in the 60-member assembly, while the Left Front, dominated by CPI(M), retained 16 seats and the Congress none. Vote shares were razor-thin, with BJP at approximately 43% and Left Front at 42%, reflecting consolidated opposition support against fragmented Left votes, though both sides reported incidents of poll violence and irregularities. Sarkar personally won re-election in Dhanpur amid disruptions alleged by CPI(M) during counting, but the overall defeat prompted his resignation as Chief Minister on March 4, 2018, to Governor Tathagata Roy, after which he continued in a caretaker role until BJP's Biplab Kumar Deb assumed office on March 9. In later reflections, Sarkar attributed the loss to the Left's inability to effectively counter BJP's populist appeals, despite the government's sustained focus on equity over rapid industrialization.

Post-Election Developments

Following the Left Front's defeat in the 2018 Tripura Legislative Assembly elections, where the BJP-IPFT alliance secured 50 of 60 seats, Manik Sarkar tendered his resignation as Chief Minister to Governor Tathagata Roy on March 4, 2018, and continued in a caretaker capacity until Biplab Kumar Deb assumed office on March 9. The CPI(M), retaining 16 seats, formed the principal opposition, with Sarkar retaining his position as the party's Tripura state secretary and leader of the legislative opposition, focusing on protests against the new government's policies, including land allocation to refugees and alleged communal polarization. Sarkar led CPI(M) efforts to forge alliances with secular parties, including overtures to Congress ahead of the 2023 assembly polls, criticizing the BJP's rule as a "one-party dictatorship" that suppressed dissent through violence and institutional control. He did not contest the February 2023 elections, instead campaigning statewide for Left candidates, while publicly urging the Election Commission to prevent a repeat of what he described as the 2018 polls' conversion into a "farce" marked by voter intimidation. The Left Front won 10 seats, prompting Sarkar to lead a delegation that met Chief Minister Manik Saha on April 10, 2023, to protest post-poll violence, citing five deaths and drawing parallels to 2016 incidents under prior CPI(M) rule, though emphasizing demands for accountability rather than retaliation. Through 2024 and into 2025, Sarkar sustained CPI(M)'s organizational activities, overseeing the 24th state conference in January 2025, which resolved to bolster ideological training and mass mobilization against "communal and fascist forces," despite reported government delays in permissions. He highlighted growing rally attendance as evidence of shifting public sentiment against BJP governance, including economic grievances and tribal unrest, while calling for intensified protests in July 2025 to resist perceived authoritarian encroachments. These efforts have positioned the CPI(M) as a vocal minority opposition, though electoral gains remain limited amid BJP's dominance, with Sarkar attributing setbacks to systemic biases in media and enforcement rather than policy reevaluation.

Controversies and Criticisms

Allegations of Corruption and Party Control

Despite his widely acknowledged personal frugality—declaring assets worth only around ₹10,000 in 2018 and donating most of his salary to the party—Manik Sarkar faced allegations of enabling systemic corruption within the Tripura government during his tenure. In September 2018, shortly after the BJP's electoral victory, Tripura's new Chief Minister Biplab Deb publicly labeled Sarkar "the most corrupt" chief minister in the state's history, accusing him of fostering a coterie of dishonest officials who manipulated public resources. Opponents, including BJP leaders, further claimed that Sarkar's administration provided patronage to chit fund schemes like Rose Valley, which defrauded thousands of investors in Tripura; victims staged protests against him as late as December 2024, asserting that the Left Front government under his leadership failed to curb these operations despite warnings, allegedly to sustain electoral influence through informal financing networks. The Congress party also leveled specific financial misconduct charges, alleging Sarkar's direct involvement in a ₹16.87 crore scam at Bishalgarh Rural Development Block, where funds for development projects were purportedly siphoned off through irregularities in procurement and execution between 2010 and 2015. Additional accusations encompassed irregularities in public works departments (PWD), with post-2018 BJP probes uncovering unexecuted projects and inflated contracts awarded to party-aligned entities, though Sarkar countered that he had whistleblown on some PWD discrepancies to successors. These claims, often amplified by BJP and Congress during campaigns, contrasted sharply with Sarkar's defense of transparent governance, but empirical audits post-2018 revealed discrepancies in sectors like rural development and cooperatives, where party loyalists allegedly dominated tender processes. Regarding party control, critics contended that the CPI(M) under Sarkar exerted authoritarian dominance over Tripura's institutions, blurring lines between party and state apparatus to perpetuate one-party rule for 25 years. BJP officials alleged that CPI(M) cadres systematically intimidated opposition workers, with reports of over 1,000 political murders attributed to Left militants between the 1980s and 2018 to secure electoral victories through booth capturing and voter suppression. This control extended to labor unions, educational bodies, and local governance, where dissent was stifled via party-enforced "democratic centralism," leading to accusations of undemocratic practices such as pre-poll violence and cadre-led enforcement of policy compliance. For example, during the 2013 and 2018 assembly elections, opposition parties documented instances of CPI(M)-backed assaults on BJP and Congress rallies, with Sarkar accused of tacitly endorsing such tactics to maintain hegemony, though he attributed unrest to insurgent groups like NLFT rather than party actions. Post-defeat analyses by outlets like Swarajya highlighted how this entrenched control prioritized ideological conformity over pluralistic governance, contributing to administrative inertia and opposition marginalization.

Handling of Violence and Democratic Norms

During Manik Sarkar's tenure as Chief Minister, the CPI(M)-led government was accused by opposition parties, particularly the BJP, of failing to prevent or actively enabling violence perpetrated by ruling party cadres against political rivals. A notable incident occurred on December 26, 2016, when BJP leader Chandramohan Tripura was hacked to death in Belonia, South Tripura, in what the BJP described as the first targeted political murder of one of its members in the state; suspects identified by investigators were allegedly linked to CPI(M) supporters. BJP leaders claimed that such attacks were part of a broader pattern, with over 100 reported assaults on party workers during membership drives in 2016–2017, often involving CPI(M) cadres disrupting rallies and targeting new recruits. Sarkar himself acknowledged the of post-poll violence under previous CPI(M) administrations, stating in 2022 that "earlier, we used to witness heavy post-poll violence," contrasting it with the absence of such incidents immediately after the 2018 elections under the incoming BJP government. Critics, including BJP spokespersons, argued this reflected a systemic tolerance for partisan intimidation to maintain one-party dominance, with police often unresponsive to complaints against ruling party affiliates. While overall crime rates and insurgency-related declined significantly under Sarkar's rule—attributed to effective policing and cross-border with —opposition groups contended that political violence was underreported or selectively prosecuted, undermining fair . On democratic norms, the administration faced allegations of constraining dissent through administrative overreach and party influence over institutions. Opposition rallies, such as BJP's 2017 campaigns, were frequently met with counter-mobilization by CPI(M) supporters, leading to clashes that authorities were accused of handling unevenly. Reports highlighted media pluralism, with outlets wary of criticizing the government to CPI(M)'s control over unions and distribution networks, though no formal laws were enacted. Tribal groups also criticized heavy-handed responses to ethnic protests, including police firings during land disputes, as prioritizing Bengali settler interests over , exacerbating tensions without broader dialogue. Despite these claims, the government upheld regular elections, with CPI(M) securing victories through organizational machinery rather than outright , as evidenced by its eventual 2018 defeat amid shifting voter alignments.

Policy Failures and Economic Stagnation

During Manik Sarkar's tenure as Chief Minister from 1998 to 2018, Tripura's economy exhibited signs of stagnation relative to national trends, characterized by persistent high unemployment, limited industrial diversification, and heavy reliance on agriculture and natural gas without substantial private sector-led growth. The state's Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP) grew at an average annual rate of approximately 7-9% in the later years of CPI(M) rule, such as 8.9% in 2013-14, but this masked underlying weaknesses including low per capita income and failure to generate sufficient employment opportunities. Per capita Net State Domestic Product (NSDP) rose from around 24,394 INR in 2004-05 to 69,705 INR in 2013-14, yet remained below the national average throughout the period, reflecting slower catch-up growth compared to faster-developing states. A primary policy failure was the ideological aversion to private investment and market-oriented reforms, rooted in CPI(M)'s socialist framework, which deterred industrialization and perpetuated dependence on subsistence agriculture, rubber plantations, and gas royalties. This approach, while maintaining public sector dominance, resulted in negligible large-scale private industry establishment, with no major industries entering the state despite national liberalization post-1991. Critics attributed this to distrust of capitalists and rigid land policies that discouraged external investment, leading to economic structures ill-suited for job-intensive growth. Consequently, Tripura's economy stagnated in diversification, with agriculture and allied sectors contributing over 20% to GSDP well into the 2010s, far exceeding national shares and limiting productivity gains. Unemployment emerged as a critical indicator of stagnation, particularly among , fueling discontent that contributed to the CPI(M)'s electoral loss. Urban unemployment reached 25.2% in 2011-12 according to National Sample Survey (NSSO) , the highest in and over four times the national urban average of around 5-6%. Estimates indicated over 700,000 unemployed by the mid-2010s, with the state among the top four nationally for overall unemployment, exacerbated by development and job creation policies favoring over entrepreneurial incentives. Infrastructure deficits compounded these issues, with inadequate road connectivity, power reliability, and transport links hindering trade and investment despite some gains in literacy and basic amenities. The Policy Effectiveness Index stood at 0.302 in 2011, marginally above the national 0.285 but trailing industrialized states, reflecting uneven progress where Scheduled Tribe access to amenities like sanitation lagged at 22.9% without basic facilities versus the national ST average of 15.4%. Policies emphasizing state control over public-private partnerships delayed critical projects, contributing to Tripura's isolation as a landlocked state and perpetuating fiscal dependence on central transfers, which averaged over 80% of revenue receipts. Overall, these failures highlighted a causal link between ideological rigidity and economic underperformance, prioritizing equity over efficiency in a manner that failed to adapt to post-liberalization realities.

Post-2018 Activities

Role in Opposition Politics

Following the Left Front's defeat in the 2018 Tripura Assembly elections, where the CPI(M)-led coalition secured 16 seats amid allegations of BJP-orchestrated violence and defections, Manik Sarkar served as Leader of the Opposition in the state legislature until 2023. In this role, he consistently challenged the BJP government's governance, accusing it of establishing a "one-party dictatorship" through intimidation of opposition activists and failure to deliver on pre-poll pledges like job creation and infrastructure development. Sarkar led protests and delegations, including a September 2021 visit to New Delhi with other Left leaders to publicize attacks on CPI(M) workers, claiming over 1,000 incidents of assault and property damage since the BJP's rise to power. Sarkar criticized the BJP for undermining democratic norms, such as in January 2022 when he condemned Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah's speeches during Tripura's statehood day events for glorifying pre-Left rule monarchs while ignoring post-1978 governance achievements in literacy and insurgency control. He also highlighted economic mismanagement, including persistent unemployment—pegged at around 20% by state surveys—and inadequate flood relief, as seen in his October 2024 remarks blaming administrative lapses for exacerbating disasters affecting over 1.5 million people. Despite the CPI(M)'s vote share dropping to below 2% in the 2023 Assembly elections, where Sarkar did not contest but campaigned for alliances with secular parties like Congress to counter BJP dominance, he remained a pivotal figure in opposition coordination. Post-2023, with the Left Front holding no legislative seats, Sarkar focused on grassroots mobilization as a CPI(M) Politburo member and de facto state opposition head, urging party cadres in November 2023 to prioritize village-level agitations on issues like rising essential commodity prices (e.g., rice inflation exceeding 10% annually) and public service breakdowns. He organized rallies decrying corruption, such as a July 2025 protest alleging "rampant loot" under BJP rule, including irregularities in job distributions and contracts worth billions of rupees. Sarkar accused the government of fostering anarchy through "vote tactics," like exploiting ethnic tensions in bandh calls and labeling Bengali residents as "Bangladeshis," which he termed deliberate provocation amid 2025 communal flare-ups displacing thousands. In January 2025, he warned of BJP's push toward dictatorship, citing inflation and service erosion even among supporters, while asserting the unstoppability of CPI(M)'s state conference despite official hurdles. Throughout, Sarkar's opposition strategy emphasized mass movements against communalism and fascism, as reiterated in a July 2025 call for intensified resistance, drawing on CPI(M)'s cadre base of over 50,000 in Tripura despite electoral setbacks. His efforts sustained the party's visibility, though critics from BJP quarters dismissed them as attempts to defame development projects like highway expansions adding 500 km since 2018.

Recent Statements and Engagements (up to 2025)

In July 2023, Manik Sarkar, as Leader of Opposition in the , criticized the state government's budget for exacerbating the debt burden on public finances. On , 2023, he instructed CPI(M) leaders and workers in Tripura to prioritize grassroots engagement by visiting villages and launching agitations centered on local people's issues, such as and deficits. During the lead-up to the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, Sarkar on April 16 attributed the 2018 ouster of the CPI(M)-led government in Tripura to the BJP's reliance on unfulfilled electoral promises, noting the saffron party's subsequent consolidation of power through alliances like with the TIPRA Motha. Earlier that month, on April 9, he warned of a "catastrophic future" for India under a potential third consecutive BJP term at the national level, highlighting risks to secularism and economic equity from the party's policies. In 2025, Sarkar presided over the inaugural session of the CPI(M)'s 24th Party Congress in Madurai, Tamil Nadu, on April 2, where he delivered a speech calling for intensified resistance against Hindutva ideology and what the party described as fascist tendencies under BJP rule, framing it as essential for preserving democratic and socialist principles. In January, amid government hesitance to provide venues, he affirmed on January 27 that the CPI(M)'s 24th Tripura State Conference—held from January 29 to 31 at Agartala Town Hall—would proceed undeterred, emphasizing ideological strengthening of the party cadre against ruling pressures. The conference resolutions focused on expanding mass movements and countering communal divisions. Sarkar continued critiquing state governance, accusing authorities on January 4 of inadequate intelligence leading to militant threats, which he deemed worrisome for public safety. On June 26, he publicly expressed alarm over eroding democratic norms globally, linking them to authoritarian drifts in various nations. In December 2024, he slammed the BJP's 'One Nation, One Election' initiative as a precursor to one-party dominance, arguing it would undermine federalism and electoral accountability. By October 24, 2025, following violent incidents tied to bandh calls, Sarkar charged the government with tacit endorsement of such disruptions, labeling them deliberate provocations to suppress opposition voices. Throughout this period, Sarkar maintained active engagement through rallies, such as addressing a large CPI(M)-organized gathering at Agartala's Swami Vivekananda Maidan, where he reiterated demands for accountability on governance failures. His statements consistently aligned with CPI(M)'s platform, prioritizing anti-BJP mobilization and advocacy for leftist policies amid Tripura's polarized politics.

Personal Life and Public Perception

Family and Relationships

Manik Sarkar was born on January 22, 1949, to Amulya Sarkar, a tailor by profession, and Anjali Sarkar, who worked as an employee in the Tripura state health department. Both parents predeceased him; his mother passed away prior to 2013, leaving behind a modest 432-square-foot tin-shed home valued at approximately ₹220,000 at that time. Sarkar married Panchali Bhattacharya in 1992. Bhattacharya, who later adopted the surname Sarkar, served as an employee with the Central Social Welfare Board under the Government of India until her retirement in 2011. The couple has no children. Panchali Bhattacharya has been described in media reports as a supportive figure in Sarkar's personal and political life, maintaining a low-profile existence aligned with his austere principles, including reliance on public transport for daily errands. In December 2022, she sustained injuries in a road accident in Agartala while returning home in a battery-operated rickshaw, prompting visits from political figures including then-Chief Minister Manik Saha.

Lifestyle, Assets, and Integrity Claims

Manik Sarkar has long been noted for his austere personal lifestyle, eschewing luxuries typical of political leaders in India. He resides in a modest party-allotted accommodation without air conditioning, owns no personal vehicle, and is often seen traveling by bicycle or public transport. Sarkar typically wears simple cotton kurtas and dhotis purchased from local markets, and he donates his entire salary as Chief Minister—approximately Rs 5,500 monthly at the time—to the Communist Party of India (Marxist) coffers, receiving in return a party allowance of Rs 9,700 for living expenses. His wife, Panchali Bhattacharjee, a government school teacher, contributes to household income through her salary. In his 2018 election affidavit filed with the Election Commission of India, Sarkar declared minimal assets: Rs 1,520 in cash, Rs 2,410 in bank deposits, and no immovable property such as land or housing. He reported no jewelry, vehicles, or other significant movable assets, with total declared value under Rs 10,000, positioning him as among the least wealthy chief ministers in the country at the time. Sarkar has never filed income tax returns, as his personal income fell below the taxable threshold, relying instead on party stipends and spousal earnings. Earlier declarations, such as in 2013, showed slightly higher bank balances around Rs 13,920, but the pattern of frugality persisted across his tenure. Sarkar's personal integrity has been a cornerstone of his public image, with supporters and even some political opponents describing him as incorruptible and exemplifying communist ideals of austerity. No major personal corruption charges or scandals have been leveled against him throughout his over two-decade tenure as Tripura's Chief Minister from 1998 to 2018, distinguishing him from many contemporaries amid India's widespread political graft exposés. This reputation earned him sobriquets like India's "poorest" and "cleanest" chief minister in media analyses, though critics attribute his asset minimalism to party-enforced discipline rather than innate virtue, noting the CPI(M)'s centralized control over members' finances. Post-2018, his lifestyle has reportedly remained unchanged, with no updates indicating asset accumulation.

References

  1. https://www.oneindia.com/politicians/manik-sarkar-20867.html
  2. https://cpim.org/manik-sarkar/
  3. https://nlcbharat.org/manik-sarkar/
  4. https://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ians/cpi-m-s-manik-sarkar-is-india-s-poorest-cm-118020100476_1.html
  5. https://www.tripuraassembly.nic.in/LOP.html
  6. https://cpim.org/report-political-developments-mar-2003/
  7. https://www.mapsofindia.com/who-is-who/government-politics/manik-sarkar.html
  8. https://electionpandit.com/candidate/manik_sarkar
  9. https://www.elections.in/political-leaders/manik-sarkar.html
  10. https://www.freepressjournal.in/india/manik-sarkar-birthday-all-you-need-to-know-about-indias-poorest-chief-minister
  11. https://www.facebook.com/groups/1043785698977216/posts/1943490309006746/
  12. https://biotrusted.com/manik-sarkar
  13. https://www.newsclick.in/real-fight-tripura-time-restoration-democracy-manik-sarkar
  14. https://www.deccanherald.com/elections/manik-sarkar-cpim-s-old-war-horse-in-battlefield-tripura-1191450.html
  15. https://www.hindustantimes.com/india/manik-sarkar-a-middle-class-chief-minister/story-Cm00Oygk6VpbgWoI20S6wI.html
  16. https://zeenews.india.com/entertainment/hollywood/paltrow-took-help-from-downey-jr-to-play-addict_84566.html/amp
  17. https://www.indianetzone.com/manik_sarkar
  18. https://cpim.org/manik-sarkars-speech-at-the-inaugural-session-of-the-24th-congress-of-cpim/
  19. https://cpim.org/leadership/
  20. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/manik-sarkar-cm-for-four-terms-fails-to-steer-lf-to-victory-in-tripura/articleshow/63151770.cms
  21. https://www.indiatoday.in/assembly-elections-2018/story/tripura-assembly-election-cm-manik-sarkar-wins-from-dhanpur-constituency-1181352-2018-03-03
  22. https://www.indiablooms.com/phoenix/public/news/manik-sarkar-wins-from-tripuras-dhanpur-constituency/details
  23. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/guwahati/manik-sarkar-not-to-contest-tripura-assembly-election/articleshow/97337220.cms
  24. https://m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/manik-sarkar-to-take-oath-as-tripura-cm-today/articleshow/2851215.cms
  25. https://m.rediff.com/news/1998/mar/11trip.htm
  26. https://indianexpress.com/article/india/jitendra-chaudhary-cpim-politburo-manik-sarkar-tripura-9928536/
  27. https://www.indiavotes.com/vidhan-sabha/1998/tripura/138/25
  28. https://vajiramandravi.com/current-affairs/chief-ministers-of-tripura/
  29. https://www.jagranjosh.com/general-knowledge/list-of-chief-ministers-of-tripura-1652679734-1
  30. https://frontline.thehindu.com/books/article30015935.ece
  31. https://peoplesdemocracy.in/2016/1127_pd/tripura-aiks-state-conference-held
  32. https://www.facebook.com/cpimcc/posts/tripura-cm-manik-sarkar-was-the-inaugural-speaker-at-the-kisanmazdoorrally-which/800678906770458/
  33. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/agartala/tripura-revises-industrial-investment-scheme/articleshow/52019924.cms
  34. https://m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/tripura-cm-manik-sarkar-welcomes-bangladeshi-investment-in-garment-sector/articleshow/44748669.cms
  35. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/agartala/manik-bid-to-boost-industry-in-tripura/articleshow/52600028.cms
  36. https://swarajyamag.com/politics/the-last-red-citadel-crumbles-to-dust
  37. https://m.thewire.in/article/politics/how-the-cpim-itself-is-aprincipal-contradiction
  38. https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/opinion/tripura-elections-nine-charts-states-political-and-socio-economic-trajectory-over-the-last-decade-10093571.html
  39. http://www.tripurainfoway.com/column-details/272/why-manik-sarkar-a-failure-as-tripura-chief-minister.html
  40. https://www.vifindia.org/sites/default/files/tripura-model-of-holistic-approach-to-combat-insurgency.pdf
  41. https://m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/manik-sarkar-credits-bangladesh-for-curb-in-tripura-insurgency/articleshow/50398902.cms
  42. https://www.satp.org/terrorist-activity/india-insurgencynortheast-tripura-jan-2011
  43. https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/Economic-development-key-to-tackle-insurgency-Tripura-CM/article16133093.ece
  44. https://www.thestatesman.com/opinion/triumph-over-insurgency-1499286920.html
  45. https://www.satp.org/terrorism-assessment/india-insurgencynortheast-tripura
  46. https://peoplesworld.org/article/tripura-communists-face-terror-and-violence/
  47. https://cpim.org/resolution-tripura/
  48. https://www.rosalux.de/fileadmin/rls_uploads/pdfs/sonst_publikationen/cic_EVENTS-2013-10_M_Sarkar_last.pdf
  49. https://northeasttoday.in/northeast/tripuras-ex-cm-manik-sarkar-slams-government-over-healthcare-education-crisis/
  50. https://www.thehansindia.com/posts/index/Latest-News/2019-02-18/Tripura-BJP-government-to-continue-with-Lefts-pension-schemes-Minister/497269
  51. https://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ani/manik-sarkar-social-welfare-programme-in-tripura-115031000207_1.html
  52. https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/tripura-assembly-election-results-2018-all-you-need-to-know-1818984
  53. https://indianexpress.com/article/india/tripura-assembly-elections-2018-results-bjp-manik-sarkar-amit-shah-narendra-modi-5085186/
  54. https://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2022/Sep/10/cpmcouldnt-counter-bjps-populist-campaign-in-tripura-concedes-manik-sarkar-2496817.html
  55. https://www.indiavotes.com/vidhan-sabha/2018/tripura/264/25
  56. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/counting-begins-in-tripura-assembly-elections-2018-highlights/articleshow/63143075.cms
  57. https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/tripura-elections-were-converted-to-a-farce-ex-chief-minister-manik-sarkar-3835452
  58. https://www.business-standard.com/article/politics/a-day-after-poll-defeat-manik-sarkar-resigns-as-tripura-chief-minister-118030400182_1.html
  59. https://indianexpress.com/article/north-east-india/tripura/cpim-couldnt-counter-bjps-populist-campaign-in-tripura-in-2018-concedes-manik-8142424/
  60. https://indianexpress.com/article/political-pulse/manik-sarkar-assembly-elections-8426450/
  61. https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/ensure-fair-elections-in-tripura-people-couldnt-vote-freely-last-time-manik-sarkar-to-election-commission/article66355824.ece
  62. https://indianexpress.com/article/north-east-india/tripura/post-poll-violence-manik-sarkar-cpim-team-meets-tripura-cm-manik-saha-8548935/
  63. https://northeasttoday.in/northeast/tripuras-ex-cm-manik-sarkar-asserts-cpim-state-conference-unstoppable-despite-governments-reluctance/
  64. https://tripurachronicle.in/local-news/touch-of-change-evident-in-tripura-politics-as-cpim-rally-participation-surges-ex-cm-manik-sarkar/
  65. https://swarajyamag.com/politics/tripura-and-the-myth-of-manik-sarkar
  66. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/agartala/manik-sarkar-was-most-corrupt-cm-biplab/articleshow/65748304.cms
  67. https://organiser.org/2021/12/22/15488/bharat/cpi-m-killed-hundreds-in-tripura-to-win-elections-manik-sarkar-patronage-chit-fund-scams-to-remain-in-the-cm-chair-minister-sushanta-chowdhury/
  68. https://tripurachronicle.in/local-news/public-outrage-erupts-against-former-cm-manik-sarkar-over-rose-valley-scam/
  69. http://www.tripurainfoway.com/news-details/TN/12693/cm-manik-sarkar-s-involvement-in-rs-17-cr-scam-proved-now-congress.html
  70. https://www.business-standard.com/article/pti-stories/cpi-m-s-ex-cm-informed-bjp-govt-of-pwd-scam-in-tripura-nath-119102901465_1.html
  71. https://indianexpress.com/article/india/tripura-cm-manik-saha-allegations-feud-between-allies-bjp-tipra-motha-10162322/
  72. https://archives.vsktelangana.org/myth-reality-tripura-cm-manik-sarkar
  73. https://swarajyamag.com/politics/why-left-ruled-tripura-can-no-longer-be-allowed-to-slip-under-the-radar
  74. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/24-cpim-workers-killed-in-past-four-years-says-manik-sarkar-1081732.html
  75. https://scroll.in/article/868842/brewing-in-poll-bound-tripura-tribal-resentment-against-manik-sarkars-left-front-government
  76. https://niti.gov.in/sites/default/files/2025-03/Macro-and-Fiscal-Landscape-of-the-State-of-Tripura.pdf
  77. https://swarajyamag.com/commentary/understanding-manik-sarkar-phenomenon
  78. https://tripura.gov.in/sites/default/files/Economic_Review.pdf
  79. http://tripurainfoway.com/news-details/TN/46955/manik-sarkar-s-tripura-achieves-dubious-distinction-of-india-s-highest-unemployment-rate-at-25-2-percent-cpi-m-govt-pushing-states-economic-future-to-peril.html
  80. https://scroll.in/article/868978/we-gave-them-enough-chances-tripuras-angry-unemployed-youth-test-the-lefts-25-year-rule
  81. https://www.newindianexpress.com/opinions/editorials/2018/Feb/19/a-battle-of-strength-and-ideas-in-tripura-1775414.html
  82. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/tripura-a-laboratory-for-bjp-to-establish-a-dictatorial-fascistic-regime-former-cm-manik-sarkar/articleshow/86221177.cms
  83. https://cpim.org/attacks-tripura-0/
  84. https://m.thewire.in/article/politics/cpims-manik-sarkar-slams-pm-modi-amit-shahs-statehood-speeches
  85. https://tripuratimes.com/ttimes/manik-sarkar-criticizes-bjp-govt-for-failing-to-address-public-oriented-issues-20759.html
  86. https://www.business-standard.com/india-news/focus-on-people-s-issues-ex-tripura-cm-manik-sarkar-advices-cpi-m-123110800347_1.html
  87. https://www.devdiscourse.com/article/politics/3523448-manik-sarkars-scathing-critique-of-bjps-reign-of-loot-in-tripura
  88. https://northeasttoday.in/northeast/tripura-ex-cm-manik-sarkar-slams-governments-tacit-support-for-bandh-calls-incident-deliberate-provocation/
  89. https://www.facebook.com/cpimcc/posts/senior-cpim-leader-and-former-tripura-chief-minister-manik-sarkar-called-upon-th/1301923791299414/
  90. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/agartala/manik-sarkar-slams-govt-for-increasing-debt-burden/articleshow/101653628.cms
  91. https://indianexpress.com/elections/tripura-manik-sarkar-cpim-lok-sabha-elections-2024-9273027/
  92. https://northeasttoday.in/northeast/tripura-ex-cm-manik-sarkar-warns-of-catastrophic-future-under-bjps-potential-third-term/
  93. https://thefederal.com/category/states/south/tamil-nadu/cpim-party-congress-fascism-bjp-prakash-karat-179765
  94. https://x.com/cpimspeak/status/1907425130038338022
  95. https://peoplesdemocracy.in/2025/0209_pd/tripura-cpim-state-conference-calls-strengthening-party-ideologically-and
  96. https://www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1010482817779341&id=100064528966526
  97. https://www.facebook.com/TIWNUSA/videos/ex-cm-manik-sarkar-expressed-concerns-about-democracy-across-the-world-tiwn-vide/694212823438917/
  98. https://tripurachronicle.in/local-news/manik-sarkar-slams-bjps-one-nation-one-election-as-step-toward-one-party-dictatorship/
  99. https://www.tripuranews24.com/newss.php?data=0099data98&M=5986=56&aHBr=MTMxOTY=&klo=lkm49
  100. https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/manik-sarkar-the-frugal-cm/article4344566.ece
  101. https://starsunfolded.com/manik-sarkar/
  102. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ranchi/panchali-sarkar-the-woman-behind-countrys-poorest-cm/articleshow/50237277.cms
  103. https://tripuranewslive.com/panchali-bhattacharya-wife-of-manik-sarkar-injured-after-being-hit-by-a-car/
  104. https://neindia.com/chief-minister-visit-gb-inquired-about-panchali-bhattacharjees-health-condition/
  105. https://www.telegraphindia.com/7-days/39-bengal-model-modi-wanted-to-learn-something-from-the-tripura-model-39/cid/1315046
  106. https://www.news18.com/news/politics/frugal-cms-arvind-kejriwal-joins-mamata-banerjee-manik-sarkar-manohar-parrikar-657907.html
  107. https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/tripura-chief-minister-has-rs-3-930-was-richer-in-2013-reveals-affidavit-1807371
  108. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/tripura-cm-has-rs-3930-never-filed-i-t-returns-affidavit/articleshow/62712273.cms
  109. https://www.firstpost.com/india/tripura-polls-manik-sarkars-election-affidavit-shows-he-has-less-than-rs-4000-never-filed-i-t-returns-4327967.html
  110. https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/tripura-cm-manik-sarkar-has-rs-3-930-never-filed-i-t-returns-affidavit/story-s3dM8kCucRxW2IH4tpDCRL-amp.html
  111. https://www.thestatesman.com/india/cpi-ms-manik-sarkar-indias-poorest-chief-minister-1502577873.html
  112. https://www.nationalheraldindia.com/politics/tripura-chief-minister-for-20-years-manik-sarkar-couldnt-even-build-himself-a-house
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.