Hubbry Logo
Ring LardnerRing LardnerMain
Open search
Ring Lardner
Community hub
Ring Lardner
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Ring Lardner
Ring Lardner
from Wikipedia

Ringgold Wilmer Lardner (March 6, 1885[1] – September 25, 1933) was an American sports columnist and short story writer best known for his satirical writings on sports, marriage, and the theatre. His contemporaries—Ernest Hemingway, Virginia Woolf, and F. Scott Fitzgerald—all professed strong admiration for his writing, and author John O'Hara directly attributed his understanding of dialogue to him.

Key Information

Early life

[edit]

Ring Lardner was born in Niles, Michigan, the son of wealthy parents, Henry and Lena Phillips Lardner. He was the youngest of nine children. Lardner's name came from a cousin of the same name. The cousin had been named by Lardner's uncle, Rear Admiral James L. Lardner, who had decided to name his son after a friend, Rear Admiral Cadwalader Ringgold, who was from a distinguished military family. Lardner never liked his given name and abbreviated it to Ring, although he named one of his sons Ringgold Jr.

In childhood he wore a brace for his deformed foot until he was eleven. He had a passion for baseball, the stage, and music.[2] He later attended the Armour Institute in Chicago.[2]

Career

[edit]

Syndicated writing

[edit]

Lardner started his writing career as a sports columnist, finding work with the newspaper South Bend Times in 1905. In 1907, he relocated to Chicago, where he got a job with the Inter-Ocean. Within a year, he quit to work for the Chicago Examiner, and then for the Tribune.[3] Two years later, Lardner was in St. Louis, writing the humorous baseball column Pullman Pastimes for Taylor Spink and The Sporting News. Some of this work was the basis for his book You Know Me Al. Within three months, he was an employee of the Boston American.

In 1913, Lardner returned to the Chicago Tribune, which became the home newspaper for his syndicated column In the Wake of the News (started by Hugh Keough, who had died in 1912). The column appeared in more than 100 newspapers, and is still published in the Tribune. Lardner's Tribune and syndicated writing was not exclusively sports-related: his dispatches from/near the World War One front were collected in the book My Four Weeks in France, and his immersive coverage of the 1920 Democratic Convention resulted in Lardner receiving 0.5 votes on the 23rd ballot.

Books and stories

[edit]

In 1916, Lardner published his first successful book, You Know Me Al, an epistolary novel written in the form of letters by "Jack Keefe", a bush-league baseball player, to a friend back home. The letters made much use of the fictional author's idiosyncratic vernacular. It had initially been published as six separate but interrelated short stories in The Saturday Evening Post, causing some to classify the book as a collection of stories, others as a novel. Like most of Lardner's stories, You Know Me Al employs satire.

Journalist Andrew Ferguson wrote that "Ring Lardner thought of himself as primarily a sports columnist whose stuff wasn't destined to last, and he held to that absurd belief even after his first masterpiece, You Know Me Al, was published in 1916 and earned the awed appreciation of Virginia Woolf, among other very serious, unfunny people." Ferguson termed the book one of the top five pieces of American humor writing.[4]

Sarah Bembrey has written about a singular event in Lardner's sportswriting experience: "In 1919 something happened that changed his way of reporting about sports and changed his love for baseball. This was the Black Sox scandal when the Chicago White Sox sold out the World Series to the Cincinnati Reds. Ring was exceptionally close to the White Sox and felt he was betrayed by the team. After the scandal, Ring always wrote about sports as if there were some kink to the outcome."[3] Lardner's last fictional baseball writing was collected in the book Lose with a Smile (1933).

Lardner later published such stories as "Haircut", "Some Like Them Cold", "The Golden Honeymoon", "Alibi Ike", and "A Day with Conrad Green". He also continued to write follow-up stories to You Know Me Al, with the protagonist of that book, the headstrong, egotistical but gullible Jack Keefe, experiencing various ups and downs in his major league career and in his personal life. Private Keefe's World War I training camp letters home to his friend Al were collected in the book Treat 'Em Rough: Letters From Jack the Kaiser Killer. The sequel, The Real Dope, followed Keefe overseas to the trenches in France. He then returned home to pitch for the 1919 Chicago White Sox, but the sequence of stories closed with Keefe being traded to the Philadelphia A's before the 1919 World Series—Jack Keefe, whatever his flaws, would not be involved in the Black Sox scandal. Lardner returned to the character when he wrote the continuity for a daily You Know Me Al comic strip that ran from 1922 to 1925.

Theatre and music

[edit]

Lardner also had a lifelong fascination with the theatre, although his only Broadway three-act successes were the thrice-filmed Elmer, the Great, co-written with George M. Cohan, and June Moon, a comedy authored with Broadway veteran George S. Kaufman. Lardner also wrote skits for the Ziegfeld Follies and a series of brief nonsense plays that ridiculed the conventions of the theatre, using zany humor and outrageous, impossible stage directions, such as "The curtain is lowered for seven days to denote the lapse of a week."[5]

He was a dedicated composer and lyricist: both his first (Zanzibar (1903)) and last (June Moon (1929)) published stage works included several Lardner tunes. He wrote at least one recorded song for Bert Williams, co-wrote one for Nora Bayes, and provided the lyrics for the song "That Old Quartet" (1913) by Nathaniel D. Mann. Other collaborators of note included Aubrey Stauffer, Jerome Kern on Very Good Eddie (1915), and Vincent Youmans—with whom he toiled on the Ziegfeld–Marilyn MillerAsstores musical Smiles (1930).[6][7]

Legacy

[edit]

Lardner's books were published by Maxwell Perkins, who also edited Lardner's most important contemporaries, including Fitzgerald who, unlike Hemingway,[8] also became Lardner's friend. Although Lardner held his own short stories in low regard—he did not save copies and had to get them from the magazines that had first published them to compile a book[9]—Lardner influenced several of his more famous peers:

  • In some respects, Lardner was the model for the tragic character Abe North in Fitzgerald's last completed novel, Tender Is the Night.[10]
  • Lardner also influenced Ernest Hemingway, who sometimes wrote articles for his high school newspaper using the pseudonym Ring Lardner Jr.[11]
  • Lardner's gift for dialogue heavily influenced the writer John O'Hara, who said he learned from reading Lardner "that if you wrote down speech as it is spoken truly, you produce true characters, and the opposite is also true: if your characters don't talk like people they aren't good characters" and added, "[I]t's the attribute most lacking in American writers and almost totally lacking in the British."[12]

Cultural references

[edit]

Personal life

[edit]

Lardner married Ellis Abbott of Goshen, Indiana, in 1911. They had four sons who each became writers. John Lardner, born in 1912, was a newspaperman, sports columnist, and magazine writer. Ring's second born, James Lardner, worked as a newspaperman before he was killed in the Spanish Civil War fighting with the International Brigades. In 1939, James was remembered with the book Somebody Had to Do Something. A Memorial to James Phillips Lardner, a book that printed 500-copies. It was financed by the James Lardner Memorial Fund and featured contributions by Ernest Hemingway, Ring Lardner Jr., Jay Allen, Don Jesus Hernandez, El Campesino, Dolores Ibarruri, Vincent Sheean and drawings by Castelao.[17][18][19][20][21] Ring Lardner's third son, Ring Lardner Jr., was an Academy Award-winning screenwriter who was blacklisted after the Second World War as one of the Hollywood Ten, screenwriters who were incarcerated for contempt of Congress after refusing to answer questions posed by the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC).[22] His book, The Lardners, My Family Remembered (ISBN 0-06-012517-9), is a source of information on his father. The youngest, David Lardner, worked for The New Yorker as a general reporter and war correspondent before he was killed by a landmine near Aachen, Germany on October 19, 1944, less than one month after his arrival in Europe.

Lardner died on September 25, 1933, at the age of 48 in East Hampton, New York, of a heart attack due to complications from tuberculosis.[23]

Lardner's grand-nephew is George Lardner Jr., a journalist at The Washington Post from 1963 and a 1993 Pulitzer Prize winner.[24]

Works

[edit]

Plays

[edit]

Books

[edit]

Essays and other contributions

[edit]
  • Lardner, Ring (18 April 1925). "The constant Jay". The New Yorker. Vol. 1, no. 9. p. 20.

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Sources

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
Ringgold Wilmer Lardner (March 6, 1885 – September 25, 1933) was an American author and journalist best known for his satirical short stories and columns that skewered sporting culture, social vanities, and everyday American vernacular. Lardner began his career as a sports reporter for newspapers including the Chicago Tribune and Chicago Post, where he honed a distinctive voice blending humor with cynicism, evident in his popular baseball-themed epistolary tales collected in You Know Me Al (1916). His work extended to broader satire in magazines like the Saturday Evening Post, producing over a dozen short story collections that captured phonetic dialogue and the absurdities of , marriage, and celebrity pretensions, influencing contemporaries such as and . Though plagued by health issues including cardiac problems that curtailed his later productivity, Lardner's legacy endures through his innovative use of and deadpan wit, earning posthumous recognition such as the 1963 J.G. Taylor Spink Award for meritorious contributions to writing. His , often overlooked amid his , filled daily columns like "In the Wake of the News" with sharp observations on athletics and urban life, solidifying his status as a pivotal figure in early 20th-century American letters.

Early Life

Childhood and Family Background

Ringgold Wilmer Lardner was born on March 6, 1885, in Niles, , to Henry Lardner and Lena Bogardus Phillips Lardner. His unusual first name derived from Cadwallader Ringgold, a U.S. Navy and family acquaintance, while "Wilmer" honored a relative. As the youngest of nine children in a prosperous household, Lardner grew up in relative comfort in a small Midwestern town, where his family's wealth stemmed from local business interests. Lardner's mother, a poet who provided his initial homeschooling, fostered an early interest in language and literature amid the family's stable environment. Little documented detail exists on his father's professional life beyond general affluence, though the Lardners maintained a middle-class existence typical of Niles' mercantile class in the late 19th century. The large sibling cohort likely influenced his observational skills, later evident in his vernacular depictions of everyday American life, though specific childhood anecdotes remain sparse in primary records. By his early years, Lardner exhibited a sociable demeanor, reportedly weighing 14 pounds at birth—a detail underscoring his robust start—within a family structure that emphasized and regional values. This background in rural-industrial shaped his grounded perspective, free from urban elite influences, setting the stage for his later journalistic pursuits.

Education and Initial Interests

Lardner received his early education at home in , supplemented by local schooling, before enrolling at Niles High School. As a junior there, he encountered classical texts including , marking an early exposure to that contrasted with his later vernacular style. He graduated from Niles High School in 1901. Following high school, Lardner briefly attended the Armour Institute of Technology in , enrolling around 1901 to study engineering. He completed only one term, failing every class except , before leaving without a degree. From youth, Lardner showed keen interest in , playing the game despite a deformed foot that necessitated a brace until age 11. He also participated in school plays and sang in the church choir, reflecting creative inclinations in performance and music that persisted into adulthood. These pursuits, alongside his rhetorical aptitude, laid groundwork for his eventual focus on and satirical writing.

Journalism Beginnings

Entry into Sports Reporting

Lardner began his journalism career in the fall of 1905 at the South Bend Times in , initially securing the position through a misrepresentation to the editor who had sought his older brother Rex for the role. There, he primarily covered , serving as sporting editor for two years and acting as the for the local team, which provided hands-on experience with the game's intricacies and players' . His work at the Times focused on minor league baseball in the Central League, where he reported on teams like the South Bend Benders, honing a style that blended observational detail with the slang of athletes. This early immersion established his reputation in sports writing, emphasizing authentic dialogue and behind-the-scenes insights over formal analysis. By the fall of 1907, Lardner relocated to , joining the Inter-Ocean as a sports reporter, marking his entry into major metropolitan coverage of , including the Chicago Cubs and White Sox. He continued this trajectory across Chicago dailies, building toward his influential columns at the Chicago Tribune starting in 1913.

Chicago Tribune and Early Columns

Lardner arrived in Chicago in the fall of 1907, where he launched a 12-year career in local sportswriting, initially with the Inter-Ocean before transitioning to the . His early reporting centered on , particularly the Chicago Cubs and White Sox, honing a style marked by ironic detachment and mastery of vernacular speech drawn from players and fans. This work established his ear for authentic dialogue, often capturing the unpolished cadences of everyday Americans in the stands and dugouts. By 1913, after brief stints reporting for newspapers in and , Lardner returned to the Tribune at age 28 to take over the established column In the Wake of the News, originally created by Hugh Keough. The daily feature, syndicated to over 100 papers, relieved him of the grind of game recaps, allowing space for eclectic humor, parodies, and vignettes on sports, theater, and urban life. From 1913 to 1919, he authored more than 1,600 installments, blending factual commentary with fictional elements like dialect-driven sketches of gullible characters. Early columns in the series showcased Lardner's satirical edge through concise, dialogue-heavy pieces, such as parodies like "Cubist Baseball," which lampooned modernist art via sports analogies, and proto-stories foreshadowing his You Know Me Al collection. These often featured archetypes like the naive White Sox rookie Jack Keefe, whose semiliterate letters home exposed the absurdities of professional athletics and small-time ambitions. His approach prioritized empirical observation of 's underbelly—player superstitions, managerial follies, and fan delusions—over heroic narratives, reflecting a realist toward institutional hype.

Professional Career

Syndicated Writing and National Reach

In 1913, Ring Lardner rejoined the Chicago Tribune and took over the daily column "In the Wake of the News," originally started by Hugh Keough, which offered concise, witty observations on , theater, and contemporary events. Syndicated through the Bell Syndicate, the column appeared in more than 100 newspapers nationwide, broadening Lardner's audience beyond local readership. Its mix of sports reporting and satirical commentary on figures like and emerging cultural trends helped cultivate a dedicated following, with the feature continuing under Lardner's byline until 1919. By 1915, the column's national distribution had elevated Lardner to household-name status among American readers, as evidenced by its coverage of alongside baseball dispatches. After resigning from the Tribune in 1919 and relocating to , Lardner shifted to a weekly syndicated column for the Bell Syndicate, which expanded to over 150 newspapers and reached an estimated eight million readers weekly. This arrangement marked his transition from regional to broader commentary, including pieces like "Why Ring Stopped Covering Baseball" in 1921, critiquing changes in the sport's "." The syndication model amplified Lardner's influence, positioning him as America's most widely read columnist during the early 1920s, with content that often eschewed straight reporting for ironic takes on , Prohibition-era absurdities, and institutional hypocrisies. This national platform not only boosted his earnings—reportedly exceeding $50,000 annually by the mid-1920s—but also paved the way for adaptations into books like You Know Me Al (1916), drawn from serialized Jack Keefe letters originally featured in the column. Despite the column's popularity, Lardner grew disillusioned with syndication constraints, leading him to prioritize freelance magazine work for outlets like by the decade's end.

Transition to Literary Works

While maintaining his syndicated sports columns, Lardner initiated his literary career in 1914 by selling baseball-themed short stories to , employing semi-literate slang to depict players' perspectives. These pieces, initially extensions of his journalistic observations, demonstrated his emerging skill in satirical fiction beyond mere reporting. The 1916 publication of You Know Me Al, a collection of epistolary stories featuring bush-league Jack Keefe's letters, marked a commercial breakthrough that facilitated greater emphasis on fiction. This success, built on his Tribune-honed ear for authentic dialogue, allowed Lardner to expand his output despite ongoing syndication commitments. Following the 1919 , which disillusioned him with baseball's integrity, Lardner increasingly produced non-sports narratives, broadening his thematic scope and elevating his literary standing. His relocation to New York around this period further immersed him in literary circles, though he continued journalistic work to sustain income. By the early 1920s, contributions to magazines like Collier's and Cosmopolitan solidified this dual-track evolution into a prolific fiction writer.

Involvement in Theater and Music

Lardner's earliest contributions to theater came through song lyrics interpolated into the 1915 Princess Theatre musical Very Good Eddie, a featuring music by and book by Philip Bartholomae and , where his verses supplemented the original score by and others. This marked his initial Broadway credit, though limited to a handful of lines amid the production's 341 performances. Throughout his career, Lardner aspired to songwriting success, particularly composing for theatrical productions, an ambition reflected in his satirical short stories like (1916) and (1927), which mocked aspiring tunesmiths while drawing from his own frustrations in the field. Despite this drive, his musical output remained modest, with no major hits attributed solely to him, though he supplied and during rehearsals for later works. In theater proper, Lardner penned over one hundred short plays, sketches, and skits, many unpublished or confined to magazines, showcasing his ear for in comedic scenarios. His most notable Broadway achievements were collaborative: Elmer the Great (1928), co-written with as an adaptation of Lardner's baseball-themed story "Alibi Ike," which ran for 216 performances and was thrice adapted to film; and June Moon (1929), a of lyricists and hackneyed popular songs co-authored with , enjoying 317 performances while lampooning the very milieu Lardner once sought to conquer. In June Moon's development, Lardner drafted initial versions, contributed song elements, and revised amid Kaufman's input, blending his journalistic cynicism with stage . These successes contrasted with broader theatrical efforts, as Lardner's full-length plays often faltered outside partnership, underscoring his strengths in concise, character-driven humor over sustained plotting.

Writing Style and Themes

Use of Vernacular Dialogue

Ring Lardner's use of vernacular dialogue stemmed from his journalistic practice of verbatim transcription of athletes' speech, which he adapted into to depict the unpolished of everyday Americans, particularly working-class figures like players. This approach relied on phonetic , grammatical deviations, and to replicate oral cadences, creating an illusion of unmediated authenticity that exposed characters' limitations and hypocrisies. His ear for such speech was honed during his sports reporting tenure, where he captured players' colloquialisms without embellishment, a skill evident as early as his personal letters incorporating idiomatic expressions. In works like You Know Me Al (1916), a collection of letters from the semi-literate pitcher Jack Keefe, Lardner rendered and narration in bush-league , such as "Al I seen a good many games since I come here and I dont seen a good one yet," to satirize naive ambition and the gap between self-perception and reality. This dialect-heavy style, characterized by syntactical looseness and non-standard grammar, amplified comedic effects by underscoring characters' rhetorical authenticity while highlighting their intellectual and social pretensions. Critics noted the fidelity of this representation, with contemporary reviews praising its avoidance of false notes in mimicking actual American speech patterns. Lardner's vernacular extended beyond baseball to broader portraits of the "common man," employing regional dialects and ungrammatical constructions in stories and plays to convey isolation and miscommunication, as in his short fiction where dialogue revealed unspoken failures in human connections. This technique persisted across his oeuvre, from journalistic sketches to literary output, prioritizing empirical mimicry over polished prose to critique societal illusions, though it sometimes challenged readers unaccustomed to orthographic innovations beyond standard spelling.

Satirical Portrayal of American Life

Lardner's short stories often employed vernacular dialogue and episodic narratives to expose the pretensions, hypocrisies, and mundane disappointments of early 20th-century American middle-class life, particularly among athletes, vaudevillians, and small-town residents. His mordant wit highlighted characters' self-delusions and social climbing failures, portraying the American dream as fraught with gullibility and unfulfilled ambitions rather than triumphant success. In works like the 1916 collection You Know Me Al, protagonist Jack Keefe's semi-literate letters reveal a bush-league pitcher's greed, poor judgment, and inability to capitalize on baseball opportunities, satirizing the era's sports culture as rife with exploitation and naivety. Stories such as "Haircut" (1925) critiqued small-town Midwestern obliviousness and complicity in social abuses, with the narrator's cheerful recounting of a bully's murder underscoring collective denial and moral numbness. Similarly, "The Golden Honeymoon" (1922) lampooned retirement fantasies, depicting a couple's Florida vacation as marred by petty bickering and unromantic realities, thus deflating nostalgic ideals of marital bliss and leisure. Through these vignettes, Lardner targeted institutions like marriage and professional sports not with overt polemic but through ironic detachment, allowing characters' own words to underscore their vulgarity and shortsightedness. His satire extended to urban aspirations in collections like Gullible's Travels, Etc. (1917), where protagonists' attempts at sophistication abroad or in expose cultural clumsiness and materialistic motives, reflecting broader disillusionment with post-World War I . Critics have noted that Lardner's focus on "the mechanisms of American civilization" through such flawed everymen anticipated modernist toward , prioritizing empirical observation of human folly over idealized narratives.

Cynicism Toward Institutions and Individuals

Lardner's cynicism toward institutions was particularly evident in his treatment of , which he viewed as riddled with greed and moral compromise. In his serialized stories collected as You Know Me Al (1916), the protagonist Jack Keefe embodies player arrogance and avarice, as seen in his letter demanding a $3,000 annual salary from owner , who responds sarcastically about Keefe buying the ballpark himself. This portrayal undercut the romanticized image of baseball heroes, highlighting instead the precarious, self-interested maneuvers of athletes navigating trades and contracts. The 1919 further intensified his disillusionment; having covered the team closely, Lardner felt personally betrayed by the players' corruption, prompting a shift away from sports writing and a more jaundiced lens on the sport's institutional integrity. His skepticism extended to individuals within and beyond sports, often depicting ordinary Americans as foolish, hypocritical, or deluded through that exposed their intellectual and ethical shortcomings. Stories like "Haircut" (1925) illustrate small-town , where a barber's rambling unwittingly reveals community complicity in and moral blindness, satirizing the "plain man's" unwitting endorsement of social ills. Lardner targeted athletes, chorus girls, and everyday figures with "" realism, using phonetic misspellings—such as "I could of told you"—to mimic uneducated speech and underscore personal failings like boastfulness and relational deceit. In broader cultural institutions like Hollywood and entertainment, Lardner critiqued superficiality and pretense, as in "The ," which mocks celebrity marriages as contrived spectacles devoid of authenticity. His overall approach privileged unsparing observation of human "morons and illiterates," rejecting sentimentalism in favor of exposing systemic flaws in social communication and ambition, though critics noted this sometimes veered into bitterness rather than constructive .

Personal Life

Marriage and Family Dynamics

Ring Lardner married Ellis Abbott, whom he met while working in , on June 28, 1911, in . The couple settled initially in , where Lardner advanced his career in , before relocating to New York in 1919 amid his rising national profile. They had four sons—John (born 1912), James (born circa 1914), Ring Jr. (born August 19, 1915), and (born March 11, 1919)—all of whom pursued careers in writing or journalism, reflecting their father's influence. Tragically, three sons died young: James at age 24 fighting in the in 1938, at 25 from a mine explosion during training in 1944, and John in a 1946 plane crash while serving as a war correspondent. Ellis Lardner emerged as the stabilizing force in the household, managing frequent moves tied to her husband's syndication deals and providing continuity for the boys amid Ring's demanding schedule and peripatetic lifestyle. The family maintained an upper-middle-class existence, with the sons attending elite schools like and Harvard, though James dropped out to join the Abraham Lincoln Brigade. Ring Jr., the sole survivor into advanced age, later credited his mother's resilience for fostering their literary ambitions despite paternal absenteeism. Lardner's chronic alcoholism, which intensified in the 1920s, strained family relations and contributed to his withdrawal into cynicism and silence, as recounted in Ring Jr.'s 1976 memoir The Lardners: My Family Remembered. This habit exacerbated his tuberculosis and cardiac issues, culminating in his death at age 48 on September 25, 1933, from a heart attack during a bridge game with Ellis and friends. While Lardner expressed devotion to his family in letters and avoided overt neglect, his drinking impaired emotional availability and productivity, shaping a home environment marked by talent and tension rather than overt conflict. Ellis outlived him by decades, dying in 1960 at age 72, having supported the surviving son's career amid the losses.

Health Struggles and Habits

Lardner was diagnosed with following a medical examination in 1926, a condition that manifested in recurrent attacks alongside heart ailments, digestive disorders, and possibly . These afflictions progressively weakened him, culminating in a fatal heart attack on September 25, 1933, at age 48 while asleep at his , home. His health deterioration was aggravated by longstanding habits of excessive alcohol consumption, which evolved into and likely hastened the complications from and cardiac issues. Lardner engaged in patterns, particularly during his time as F. Scott Fitzgerald's neighbor in the , driven in part by disillusionment with societal norms. Despite these struggles, he continued writing, including musicals and plays, until near the end.

Reception During Lifetime

Critical Acclaim and Public Popularity

Ring Lardner's short stories and columns achieved widespread public popularity in the , particularly through syndication and publication in mass-market magazines like , which boasted circulations exceeding 2 million copies weekly by the late . His syndicated column "In the Wake of the News" appeared in over 100 newspapers, reaching a broad audience of everyday readers drawn to his humorous depictions of sports and American vernacular. At the peak of his fame, Lardner ranked among the ten best-known people in America, reflecting his status as one of the era's most highly paid and read writers. Critically, Lardner garnered praise from prominent contemporaries for his satirical edge and mastery of dialogue, though some reviewers overlooked his work due to its rejection of sentimentalism. lauded Lardner's focus on the "visible" absurdities of life and his ear for dialects, positioning him as a key satirist of . Admirers including , , and hailed his influence, with his 1924 collection How to Write Short Stories marking a turning point in critical interest for its innovative form. Over nearly two decades, he accumulated plaudits from virtually every major literary figure of his time, cementing his reputation as a foremost despite his aversion to overt . By 1929, with the release of the retrospective Round Up, his popularity and acclaim stood at their zenith.

Contemporary Criticisms and Debates

While Ring Lardner enjoyed significant acclaim from contemporaries such as H.L. Mencken, who in 1924 declared him unmatched among American short story writers for his mastery of vernacular dialogue and ironic detachment, debates arose over the potential transience of his style. Mencken praised Lardner's precision in capturing the "American vulgate" but questioned whether works so embedded in era-specific slang and colloquialisms could withstand the test of time, suggesting they risked obsolescence as language evolved. Critics also contended with Lardner's unyielding cynicism, which eschewed sentimental resolutions in favor of exposing human folly and institutional hypocrisies without offering uplift or redemption. In a assessment, Mencken attributed Lardner's relative neglect by broader literary circles to this trait, arguing that his relentless assault on American idealism and booboisie—evident in stories depicting petty betrayals and self-delusion—clashed with tastes favoring aspirational narratives amid the era's cultural . This perspective fueled discussions on whether Lardner's realism constituted profound or mere , with some reviewers viewing his portrayals of athletes, fans, and everyday figures as authentically disillusioned reflections of post-World War I society, while others deemed them excessively bleak and dismissive of potential for personal or social improvement. A focal point of early contention was "Haircut" (1925), where the naive barber-narrator's oblivious recounting of a town's moral decay elicited mixed responses for its "cruel" irony and indictment of communal complicity. Published in magazine, the story drew praise for its technical ingenuity but sparked debate over Lardner's intent: whether it critiqued small-town ignorance as a systemic failure or merely exploited it for dark humor, lacking deeper philosophical engagement. Such discussions highlighted broader tensions between Lardner's journalistic roots—rooted in sports reporting—and his literary ambitions, with detractors arguing his aversion to "highbrow" elevation limited his scope, even as admirers like Mencken defended it as unflinching truth-telling.

Posthumous Assessment

Scholarly Re-evaluations

Following Lardner's death in , initial scholarly assessments often dismissed his oeuvre as lightweight entertainment, overshadowed by his journalistic persona and popular appeal, with critics like arguing in that his stories lacked depth beyond phonetic mimicry of vernacular speech. However, by the mid-1960s, reevaluations emerged that repositioned him as a sophisticated observer of human disconnection, emphasizing the recurrent theme of failed communication as central to his fiction rather than mere cynicism or pettiness. This shift highlighted how Lardner's ironic narrators—often unreliable and self-deluded—exposed broader societal pathologies, such as provincial ignorance and interpersonal isolation, through minimalist prose and dramatic irony, predating similar techniques in mid-century . Subsequent academic works, including Walton R. Patrick's 1963 analysis of Lardner's later stories, praised his evolution toward third-person narration in collections like The Love Nest (1926) and Round Up (1929), which refined his satirical edge while maintaining vernacular authenticity drawn from his Chicago sports reporting. Biographies and editions, such as Jonathan Yardley's 1977 Ring: A Biography of Ring Lardner, further elevated his status by documenting his influence on figures like and , attributing his undervaluation to premature death and the era's preference for modernism over populist . Modern scholars, including those in the 2019 anthology, affirm Lardner's mastery of era-specific idiom and plot , positioning him as a pivotal voice in capturing early-20th-century American vernacular and social pretense. These reappraisals underscore Lardner's technical innovations, such as embedding critique within seemingly innocuous monologues (e.g., "Haircut," 1925), which reveal moral blindness without authorial intrusion, influencing later realists. While some critiques persist regarding his episodic structure limiting novelistic ambition, consensus holds that his short fiction endures for its unsparing realism, with recent editions like The Lost Journalism of Ring Lardner (2017) recovering overlooked columns that demonstrate his prescience in dissecting celebrity culture and institutional fraud.

Criticisms of Dated Elements

Posthumous scholarly assessments have identified Lardner's portrayals of women as frequently relying on common to early 20th-century , such as the materialistic social climber or the fickle, vapid flirt, which critics argue limit character depth and perpetuate reductive gender attitudes of the era. These depictions, evident in stories like those in How to Write Short Stories (1924), prioritize satirical exaggeration over nuanced , leading contemporary analysts to view them as emblematic of broader cultural biases against female agency and intellect. In his lesser-known short plays, Lardner employed ethnic humor and racial caricatures that, while drawing on traditions of the and , strike modern audiences as overtly offensive due to their reliance on stereotyped dialects and puns targeting immigrant or minority groups. For instance, annotations in editions of these works highlight how such elements, including exaggerated accents and cultural mockery, reflect the casual prejudices normalized in popular entertainment at the time but now seen as undermining the plays' comedic intent with bigotry. Lardner's , particularly his columns from the , contains instances of overtly racist language and attitudes, such as derogatory references to non-white players or fans, which biographers and reviewers have cited as persistent stains on his otherwise innovative reportage. These elements, aligned with the era's widespread journalistic tolerance for slurs and exclusionary , contrast with Lardner's ear for vernacular authenticity but have prompted re-evaluations questioning the universality of his satirical lens.

Legacy and Influence

Impact on American Literature

Ring Lardner's pioneering use of phonetic spelling to capture vernacular dialects—termed "Lardnerese"—advanced realistic dialogue in American fiction by prioritizing the raw cadences of everyday speech over conventional grammar, as seen in his "You Know Me Al" letters series published serially in the Saturday Evening Post starting in 1914. This approach influenced Ernest Hemingway's early style, with the younger writer emulating Lardner's terse, speech-heavy narratives and even signing high school contributions as "Ring Lardner, Jr." around 1916–1917. Lardner's ear for malapropisms and idioms from Chicago and East Coast locales also shaped John O'Hara's colloquial authenticity in works like Appointment in Samarra (1934). His satirical dissections of the "common man"—often through first-person narrators revealing their own follies, as in stories featuring the boastful pitcher Jack Keefe—provided a model for ironic detachment in short fiction, impacting mid-century writers such as James Thurber, John Cheever, and John Updike. These authors drew on Lardner's templates for middle-class dysfunction and small-town absurdities, extending his focus on athletes' psychic vulnerabilities into broader social critique. Contemporaries like F. Scott Fitzgerald, a neighbor in Great Neck, New York, during the 1920s, incorporated Lardner-like vernacular irony into character sketches, evident in Fitzgerald's Abe North from Tender Is the Night (1934). Lardner's legacy extended to postwar literature, where echoes of his voice appear in J.D. Salinger's portrayals of alienated youth, with critics noting the "shine of ... Ring Lardner" in The Catcher in the Rye (1951)'s phonetic quirks and sarcastic tone. Overall, his blend of journalistic immediacy and literary cynicism exerted an influence on early 20th-century American letters greater than that of any peer, bridging popular entertainment and highbrow satire while chronicling cultural shifts like Prohibition and sports mania.

Cultural and Media References

Lardner's play Elmer the Great, co-written with and first staged in 1928, was adapted into a of the same name in 1933, directed by and starring as the boastful player Elmer Kane. The story's portrayal of rural American vernacular and sports exaggeration resonated in early Hollywood baseball comedies, influencing subsequent adaptations like Alibi Ike (1935), which drew from Lardner's fictional character known for fabricating excuses, directed by Ray Enright and starring alongside . His short story "The Golden Honeymoon" (1922), depicting a bickering elderly couple's anniversary trip, received a television adaptation in 1980 as part of PBS's The American Short Story anthology series, featuring James Whitmore and Teresa Wright and directed by Daniel Petrie; the production aired on February 4, 1980, emphasizing the story's subtle humor on marital endurance. Lardner appears as a character in John Sayles's 1988 film Eight Men Out, which dramatizes the 1919 Black Sox scandal; Sayles portrays Lardner himself as a skeptical sportswriter among the press who uncovered the fix, reflecting his real-life contemporary journalism on the event. In literature, J.D. Salinger's (1951) features protagonist citing Lardner as a favorite author alongside his brother D.B., praising his realistic dialogue; Salinger also references Lardner in (1961), underscoring the elder writer's influence on capturing authentic American speech patterns.

Complete Works

Short Stories and Collections

Lardner authored over 100 short stories, frequently published initially in magazines such as and Cosmopolitan, before compilation into volumes that emphasized satirical portrayals of players, vaudevillians, and ordinary Americans through phonetic dialect and ironic understatement. His narratives often exposed hypocrisies in , , and , drawing from his experiences as a sportswriter. Key collections include:
  • You Know Me Al (1916), epistolary tales of bush-league pitcher Jack Keefe's misadventures.
  • Gullible's Travels (1917), sketches of Midwestern gullibility and urban disillusionment.
  • Treat 'Em Rough: Letters from Jack the Kaiser Killer (1918), World War I-era continuations of the Jack Keefe character.
  • The Real Dope (1919), further Jack Keefe baseball yarns reflecting post-1919 cynicism.
  • Own Your Own Home (1919), domestic and real estate-themed satires.
  • The Young Immigrunts (1920), phonetic accounts of family life via observations.
  • How to Write Short Stories (With Samples) (1924), parodic "guides" interspersed with actual stories mocking literary pretensions.
  • The Love Nest and Other Stories (1926), tales of theatrical ambition and relational , including the play-adapted title story.
  • Round Up (1929), a gathering of previously uncollected pieces.
Among his most acclaimed standalone stories are "Alibi Ike" (1915, Saturday Evening Post), depicting a evasive ballplayer; "The Golden Honeymoon" (1922, Cosmopolitan), a wry ; and "Haircut" (1925, ), a revealing small-town malice. These works exemplify Lardner's technique of unreliable narrators and understated tragedy, influencing later realists.

Books and Longer Prose

You Know Me Al (1916), Lardner's breakthrough book-length work, takes the form of letters written by Jack Keefe, a bush-league player from , to his friend Al Blanchard, chronicling Keefe's naive attempts to succeed in amid exploitation by managers and teammates. The narrative employs phonetic spelling to capture Midwestern , underscoring themes of and the harsh realities of early 20th-century sports. Published by George H. Doran Company, it originated from serialized pieces in . Gullible's Travels (1917), another Doran publication, comprises monologues by the character Ikey Gulible, a Chicago workingman, who recounts domestic squabbles and everyday hypocrisies with biting sarcasm, extending Lardner's critique of marital discord and social pretensions seen in his shorter fiction. Lardner's sole conventional novel, The Big Town (1921), depicts a provincial couple's relocation to , where they encounter the city's fast-paced temptations, culture, and interpersonal deceptions, reflecting post-World War I urban alienation through first-person narration laced with dialect. Issued by , it drew from Lardner's own observations of metropolitan life. Additional longer prose includes Own Your Own Home (1919), a satirical tract on real estate schemes; The Young Immigrunts (1920), a phonetic parodying a family's cross-country auto journey; and How to Write Short Stories (With Samples) (), a mock instructional manual blending advice with embedded tales to lampoon literary aspirations. These Bobbs-Merrill and Scribner's titles, often structured as unified sequences rather than discrete stories, highlight Lardner's preference for forms over plotted narratives.

Plays and Miscellaneous Writings

Lardner authored over one hundred plays, sketches, and skits throughout his career, though most remained unpublished or unproduced on Broadway and are accessible primarily through archival collections. These works often featured experimental comic elements, drawing on his satirical style to explore everyday absurdities, with twenty-one short plays compiled and annotated in a 2001 scholarly edition edited by Scott A. Topping. His dramatic output included early efforts like the 1903 comic opera Zanzibar co-written with Harry B. Smith, but these garnered limited attention compared to his prose. The most successful of Lardner's plays was June Moon, a 1929 Broadway comedy co-authored with , which satirized aspiring songwriters in the scene and ran for 317 performances. Adapted from Lardner's 1921 Saturday Evening Post story "Some Like Them Cold," the play highlighted his ear for dialogue and critique of pretensions, earning praise for its sharp humor despite Lardner's health issues limiting his involvement in rehearsals. Other dramatic pieces, such as Tridget of Greva, appeared in theatrical catalogs but saw minimal staging. Beyond plays, Lardner's miscellaneous writings encompassed sports columns, humorous verses, and song lyrics, reflecting his early career as a journalist. He contributed baseball dispatches and satirical sketches to newspapers like the Chicago Tribune, including the 1914–1916 "You Know Me Al" series, fictionalized letters from a semi-literate pitcher that lampooned athletic egos and were later collected in book form. In 1915, he published Bib Ballads, a collaboration with illustrator Frank Chance featuring dialect poems mimicking fans' slang during the Chicago Cubs' World Series appearance. Lardner also penned song lyrics, as documented in his papers at the Newberry Library, which include unpublished musical contributions alongside his prose experiments on marriage and theater. These varied outputs underscored his versatility but were often overshadowed by his short fiction, with columns providing financial stability through syndication in outlets like Collier's and The Saturday Evening Post.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.