Hubbry Logo
SaversSaversMain
Open search
Savers
Community hub
Savers
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Savers
Savers
Savers
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Savers in Boston, Massachusetts

Key Information

Savers Value Village Inc. is a publicly held, for-profit thrift store retailer headquartered in Bellevue, Washington, United States, offering second hand merchandise, with supermajority ownership by private equity firm Ares Management.[1] An international company, Savers has more than 315 locations throughout the United States, Canada, and Australia, and receives its merchandise by paying money to non-profit organizations for donated clothing and household items. Savers is known as Value Village in the Pacific Northwest, the Baltimore metropolitan area, and most of Canada, and Village des Valeurs in Quebec. Chicago stores and some locations in the Washington, DC metropolitan area are under the name Unique.[2] In other regions of the U.S. and in Australia, the stores are named Savers.

History

[edit]

The company was founded by Bill Ellison in 1954 at a former movie theater in the Mission District of San Francisco, California.[3][4] By 1970, the chain had six thrift stores in the states of California, Oregon, and Washington under various names, including Value Village and Thrift Village. The company's headquarters were moved to Bellevue, Washington in 1970 and expanded to Canada with a store in Vancouver that opened in 1980.[3] In October 1997, the first Savers store in Australia opened in Brunswick, Victoria.[5] Ellison was the chairman of the company until 2000; he died in 2008.[3]

Berkshire Partners bought a 50% stake in the company in 2000.[6] Freeman Spogli & Co. became the majority owner in 2006.[7] Leonard Green & Partners and TPG Capital bought out Freeman's shares in 2012.[8]

In March 2019, Savers reached a restructuring agreement to hand ownership of the company over to private equity firms Ares Management and Crescent Capital Group.[9] Ares acquired Crescent's stake in 2021 and took the company public in a June 29, 2023 initial public offering, retaining an 88% ownership stake.[10][1]

Business operations

[edit]
A Value Village on Bloor Street in Toronto, Canada
Value Village interior

Savers' business model involves partnership with local non-profits and purchasing and reselling donated items. The non-profits collect and deliver donated goods to Savers, which pays them for the items at a bulk rate regardless of whether they ever make it to the sales floor. As of 2011, the company had paid $1.1 billion to approximately 130 nonprofit partners, and as of 2012, had 315 stores worldwide and reached $1 billion in revenue.[11][12]

Items deemed resellable are displayed for purchase in stores. Savers also has a recycling program and attempts to recycle any reusable items that cannot be sold at the stores, as well as any items that do not sell over a period of time to make room for fresh merchandise. Savers has buyers for its recyclables throughout the world and attempts to keep as much donated product out of the waste stream as possible.[citation needed] In Minnesota, Savers pays non-profit partners $0.053 per pound of clothing, $0.035 per pound of homewares, $0.02 per pound of books and $0.02 per pound of large items (e.g., furniture).[13] By the end of 2018, the company had discontinued the use of plastic bags in its stores.[14]

According to Diabetes Canada, it has had a reusable goods donation program with Value Village where donations of clothing and small household items generate $5,000,000 CAD annually to support diabetes research.[15]

Controversy

[edit]

In May 2015, the Minnesota Attorney General filed suit[16] claiming that Savers was misleading the public, paying only a very small percentage to the non-profit charities which partner with the company. Savers settled in June 2015, increasing transparency and paying $300,000 to each of its partner charities in Minnesota to compensate for fundraising disruptions. In the same year, the Attorney General filed suit[17] against the Epilepsy Foundation for failing to monitor Savers for compliance with their partnership contract. Money raised through their partnership with Savers accounted for 38-50% of the Epilepsy Foundation's revenue.[18]

In November 2019 King County Superior Court Judge Roger Rogoff ruled that the corporation had misled the public into believing the organization was a charity, but the ruling was overturned in August 2021 by a Washington state appeals court.[19] The Washington state Supreme Court further ruled that the Washington state Attorney General's Office violated the corporation's First Amendment rights.[20] Subsequently, King County Superior Court Judge David Whedbee ruled that the state of Washington had to pay the corporation's legal expenses due to the Attorney General's Office's aggressive litigation.

Safety concerns

[edit]

In December 2018, a family in Pitt Meadows, British Columbia, Canada reported their six-year-old son found a hypodermic needle and two partially-used tubes of glue in a used Mouse Trap board game they had bought from a Value Village in Coquitlam, British Columbia.[21][22]

In October 2019, a man reported getting a needlestick injury when he tried on a boot at a Value Village (in New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada) and was told he would need blood tests including for HIV and hepatitis.[23]

Pricing

In Canada, Value Village has seen frequent criticism for its alleged unfair pricing.[24][25]

CBC News reported that shoppers were finding items marked up higher than they were new. In response, a spokesperson for the company said that "Customers should feel free to chat with a store manager if they think that an item has been inadvertently mispriced so we can quickly address it."[26]

Valentina Guerra of the Brock Press heavily criticized the company. She echoed complaints about removing paid worker positions in favor of self-checkout machines, opening expensive boutiques in Toronto and raising prices on secondhand items. She claimed that the company's actions as a company were unethical and recommended other consumers to boycott them.[24]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Savers

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Savers Value Village, Inc., commonly known as , is a for-profit multinational retailer specializing in secondhand goods through a chain of thrift stores operating under brands including Savers and Value Village. Founded in 1954 by Bill Ellison with its first store in San Francisco's Mission District, the company sources inventory by purchasing merchandise from nonprofit organizations and resells it to the public at discounted prices. Headquartered in , Savers has expanded to operate more than 300 stores across 25 U.S. states, 10 Canadian provinces, and , establishing itself as the largest for-profit thrift store operator in the United States and . The emphasizes , with the company diverting over 3.2 billion pounds of goods from landfills and paying more than $490 million to nonprofit partners between 2020 and 2024. By promoting the reuse of textiles, , accessories, items, and , Savers contributes to reduction while generating revenue through value-priced retail.

History

Founding and early development

William O. (Bill) Ellison founded Savers in 1954 by opening the company's first thrift store in an abandoned movie theater located in San Francisco's Mission District. At age 24, Ellison, who had recently earned a degree from the in 1950 and grown up influenced by his father Benjamin's management of thrift stores in Sacramento as a officer, launched the operation with initial funding from his father. The store operated under the initial name Salvage Management and emphasized affordable secondhand goods sourced through contracts with nonprofit organizations, paying them for reusable donations to generate steady revenue streams—a model rooted in Ellison's philosophy of treating partners as he wished to be treated, often described as applying the to . In the early years, Savers focused on building a sustainable by partnering with charities for inventory, distinguishing itself from traditional nonprofit thrift shops through its for-profit structure while providing nonprofits with reliable income above market rates. By 1966, Ellison expanded with the opening of a Value Village store in , followed by a Thrift Village location in , in 1967. This marked the beginning of branded diversification and geographic growth, with additional stores established in , Portland, and within the next five years. In 1970, the company relocated its headquarters to , by which point it operated six stores across three states, solidifying its regional presence in the . These developments laid the groundwork for Savers' emphasis on volume-driven retail of donated goods, prioritizing efficiency in processing and merchandising to offer low prices and attract budget-conscious shoppers.

Domestic expansion and acquisitions

Following its founding, Savers pursued domestic expansion primarily through organic store openings and selective acquisitions of complementary thrift operations, concentrating on high-density urban and suburban markets in the western and during the late . By the early 2000s, the company had established a network exceeding 100 locations, leveraging partnerships with nonprofits for donation sourcing to fuel growth without significant capital outlays for inventory. A pivotal acquisition occurred in March 2011, when Savers purchased 18 stores from Unique Thrift LLC, a Minnesota-based operator, for $180 million; these locations were situated in mid-Atlantic and Midwest states including , , and , enhancing Savers' regional footprint and operational synergies in productive resale markets. This deal aligned with Savers' strategy of integrating established chains to accelerate while maintaining its for-profit model tied to nonprofit donations. Private equity investments further supported expansion; in 2003, Bain Capital's acquisition of Savers enabled infrastructure investments and store development, followed by a 2012 recapitalization involving and TPG Capital, which provided capital for additional U.S. openings amid rising demand for affordable secondhand goods. Ownership transitions, including Sun Capital Partners' 2019 buyout, continued to prioritize domestic scaling, with Savers reaching approximately 172 U.S. stores by 2024. In recent years, has complemented acquisitions, with Savers opening 22 new U.S.-focused stores in fiscal 2024, including nine in the fourth quarter, targeting underserved areas with strong and thrift demand. A May 6, 2024, acquisition of 2 Peaches Group added seven stores in the metropolitan area, bolstering southeastern presence and contributing to a 29-store net increase that year. The company plans 25 to 30 additional openings in 2025, emphasizing locations with potential for high donation volumes and customer traffic to sustain growth amid economic pressures favoring value retail.

International growth and rebranding

Savers expanded internationally beyond the United States by establishing stores in Canada, operating primarily under the Value Village brand, and in Australia under the Savers brand. The company's entry into Australia occurred with the opening of its first store in October 1997 in Brunswick, Victoria. This marked the beginning of a modest but steady presence in the Australian market, focused on thrift retail through nonprofit partnerships similar to its U.S. model. By fiscal year 2023, Savers operated 157 stores in and 12 in , reflecting and selective expansion in these markets. Store counts continued to increase, reaching 166 in and 15 in by March 2025, supported by new openings such as in . International operations emphasize sourcing donated goods from local nonprofits, processing them for resale, and maintaining low-cost retail formats tailored to regional preferences. In January 2022, Savers converted into a corporation and rebranded its corporate identity to Savers Value Village, Inc., incorporating its primary retail brands to unify oversight of U.S., , and operations. This structural change, ahead of its 2023 , facilitated enhanced capital access for further while preserving localized branding, such as Value Village in and Savers in . The rebranding aligned with efforts to modernize the thrift sector's image, targeting younger demographics without altering core international store formats.

Path to public listing

Savers Value Village, Inc., the parent company operating Savers and related thrift brands, pursued an (IPO) after years of private equity ownership. In March 2019, the company underwent a financial that transferred control to private equity firms, including and Crescent Capital Group, amid efforts to address debt obligations. Ares later acquired Crescent's stake in 2021, consolidating its position as the primary owner, and provided recapitalization support through a $540 million first-lien alongside partners like KKR. This private equity involvement focused on operational improvements and expansion, setting the stage for a public debut. The company filed confidential IPO paperwork with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on October 12, 2021, followed by a public S-1 registration statement on December 22, 2021, signaling intent to list on the . On January 7, 2022, Savers converted from a Washington corporation to a Delaware corporation and rebranded as Savers Value Village, Inc., aligning its structure for public markets. The IPO process advanced in June 2023, with the company announcing the offering on June 20, targeting a valuation of up to $2.7 billion and planning to sell 18.75 million shares at an initial price range of $15 to $17 per share. Pricing occurred on June 28, 2023, at $18 per share for an upsized offering of 22.3 million shares, generating gross proceeds of approximately $461.4 million, including shares sold by the company and selling stockholders affiliated with . Trading commenced on the NYSE under the ticker "SVV" on June 29, 2023, with shares opening at $24.77—38% above the IPO price—and closing at $22.91, yielding a debut of nearly $4 billion. retained approximately 88% ownership post-IPO, using proceeds in part to repay indebtedness. This listing marked the culmination of a multi-year transition from distressed private operations to public status, driven by stabilization and amid rising interest in sustainable retail.

Business Model

Donation sourcing and nonprofit partnerships

Savers sources the majority of its inventory through collaborations with local nonprofit organizations, which collect used clothing, household goods, books, and other items via public donation bins, in-store drop-off locations, and arranged pickups. These nonprofits handle initial solicitation and sorting, after which Savers purchases the goods outright, compensating the organizations with unrestricted payments typically calculated by weight and item category. This arrangement enables nonprofits to fund community programs without managing retail, processing, or sales logistics themselves. From 2020 to 2024, Savers reported paying over $490 million to its nonprofit partners while diverting more than 3.2 billion pounds of goods from landfills through these channels. In certain regions, such as Washington state, payments to local partners exceeded $45 million over a comparable five-year period ending around 2023. Examples of partnered entities include the American Red Cross, for which Savers acts as a for-profit commercial fundraiser in applicable jurisdictions, accepting donations on the organization's behalf. Other collaborations involve veterans' groups and health-related nonprofits, though specific national tallies of partners vary by location and are often community-specific. The model has drawn for its for-profit structure amid that emphasizes charitable impact, leading to donor confusion in some cases; investigations have noted that while payments occur, the share of gross directed to nonprofits can range from 4 to 17 percent based on 2013 California filings. Savers maintains that donations directly benefit partnered nonprofits via purchase proceeds, distinct from store sales , which funds operations. This payment-based sourcing constitutes the primary channel, supplementing minor direct acquisitions from retail overstock or other commercial sources.

Processing, merchandising, and retail operations

Savers acquires the majority of its inventory through purchases from local nonprofit partners, who collect donations from the public; these transactions occur by weight—typically measured in pounds—without prior inspection of contents, enabling nonprofits to receive immediate payment to fund their programs. This procurement method, established since the company's founding, allows Savers to source vast quantities of used , housewares, accessories, and other , with over 700 million pounds processed annually across its network as of recent operations. Processing begins upon receipt at either in-store backrooms or dedicated processing centers, such as the facility in , where teams of merchandise processing associates sort incoming donations by category (e.g., apparel, electronics, books). Items undergo grading for condition—discarding heavily damaged, soiled, or unsafe goods—and basic preparation, including steaming clothes, wiping down housewares, attaching price tags via automated or manual systems, and boxing or hanging for transfer to sales floors. Unsellable or low-value items are segregated for or baling into bulk lots for wholesale , a process that diverts materials from landfills while generating secondary revenue; critics note this export focus means only a fraction of donations reach local retail, with payments to nonprofits often representing 8-15% of eventual retail value depending on local contracts. Merchandising emphasizes efficient, visually appealing presentation to maximize turnover in a low-price thrift environment, with sorted by color gradients on racks for aesthetic appeal and faster browsing, while housewares and accessories are arranged on shelves by function and theme. algorithms or guidelines assign values based on item type, recognition, and condition—e.g., garments fetching higher tags than generics—with color-coded systems signaling progressive discounts (often 25-50% reductions weekly) to clear quickly. Retail operations span over 300 stores under brands like Value Village and Unique, featuring open-layout floors that facilitate , daily influxes of fresh stock to drive repeat visits, and point-of-sale systems tracking for optimization; stores operate extended hours, typically 9 a.m. to 9 p.m., with merchandising teams rotating stock to maintain dynamic displays amid high-volume throughput.

Revenue generation and cost management

Savers Value Village generates the majority of its revenue through retail sales of second-hand clothing, household goods, and accessories across its network of stores in the United States, Canada, and Australia. In fiscal year 2024, retail sales totaled $1.463 billion, accounting for approximately 95% of total net sales of $1.538 billion. These sales are recognized at the point of customer purchase, net of taxes and discounts, with an average unit retail price of around $5, emphasizing a "treasure-hunt" shopping experience that drives repeat visits and loyalty program engagement, where 5.9 million members contributed 72.4% of retail sales. Wholesale sales provide a supplementary revenue stream, comprising about 5% of total net sales at $74 million in 2024, derived from selling unsold or unsuitable inventory—such as textiles not viable for retail—to global buyers for reuse, recycling, or repurposing across four continents. This segment benefits from the company's processing of over 1 billion pounds of goods annually, allowing efficient diversion of non-retailable items while maintaining overall supply chain throughput. No significant e-commerce or other revenue sources were reported as material in recent filings. Cost management centers on controlling the (COGS), which stood at $670 million or 43.6% of net in , yielding a gross product margin of 56.4%. Acquisition costs are kept predictable by purchasing baled goods from nonprofit partners at fixed rates per pound—averaging $0.66 per pound processed—facilitated by local sourcing programs like Opportunity Shop Donations and GreenDrop, which supplied 76.3% of merchandise in , up from 53% in 2019, reducing transportation and dependency on imported bales. Operational efficiencies further mitigate costs through centralized processing at five community processing centers and 18 automated baling press systems, which sort, grade, and prepare items for retail or wholesale, minimizing in-store labor and waste. Operating expenses, including salaries, selling, general, and administrative costs, totaled $1.407 billion in 2024, but scale from 351 stores and automation has supported sales yield stability at $1.46 per pound despite fluctuations. These practices contributed to adjusted EBITDA of $296 million, though margins faced pressure from rising labor and compliance costs in a high-inflation environment.
Revenue StreamFiscal 2024 Amount (millions)Percentage of Total Net Sales
Retail$1,46395%
Wholesale$745%

Operations

Store network and locations

Savers Value Village maintains a network of over 350 thrift stores across three countries: the , , and , as of mid-2025. As of March 29, 2025, the company operated 172 stores in the , 166 in , and 15 in . These locations are primarily situated in urban and suburban areas to maximize access to donation sources and customer traffic, with a strategic focus on markets supporting high donation volumes from nonprofit partners. In the United States, stores operate under banners such as Savers and Value Village, with concentrations in states including (18 locations), Washington (15), and (14) as of June 2025, spanning 29 states overall. Canadian operations, mainly under the Value Village brand, are densely distributed across provinces like and , reflecting the company's origins and early expansion in the region. Australian stores, fewer in number, target major metropolitan areas to build in a thrift sector dominated by nonprofit operators. The company pursues ongoing expansion through organic openings and acquisitions, adding four new stores in the second quarter of 2025 alone and planning 25 to 30 additional locations for the full year. Recent moves include the 2024 acquisition of a seven-store chain in Georgia, enhancing U.S. presence in the Southeast. This growth strategy aims to increase store density in existing markets while entering underserved regions, supporting scalable donation processing and retail operations.

Workforce and supply chain logistics

Savers Value Village employs approximately 22,700 workers across its North American and Australian operations as of December 2024, encompassing roles in retail stores, processing facilities, and support. The includes production associates for sorting and merchandising, warehouse staff for inventory management, and transportation personnel for distribution, with the company reporting adherence to fair wage standards and employee training programs in its sustainability disclosures. The for Savers rely on three primary sourcing channels: on-site donations collected at stores or partner locations, delivered supply from nonprofit partners, and automated GreenDrop collection stations. Nonprofits such as local charities gather used and , which Savers purchases by weight on a sight-unseen basis, enabling efficient bulk acquisition without individual inspection at handover. These materials are then transported to centralized processing centers, where dedicated teams sort items by category, condition, and resale potential—discarding unsellable goods for or while preparing viable inventory for and distribution. From processing facilities, logistics operations involve regional trucking networks to replenish over 300 stores, optimizing routes to minimize transport costs and support daily merchandising needs. Unsold or lower-grade items enter a secondary wholesale channel, often baled and shipped internationally for processing in developing markets, which helps manage excess supply and recover value from non-retail streams. This vertically integrated model, supported by dedicated supply chain roles, processes millions of pounds of donations annually, though it has faced scrutiny over the proportion of proceeds returned to originating nonprofits, typically ranging from 1% to 17% of resale value after operational deductions.

Technology integration and sustainability practices

Savers Value Village employs advanced networking to support across its retail footprint. In November 2023, the company partnered with to upgrade its infrastructure, facilitating Bluetooth-enabled data collection for in-store analytics and . This builds on a 2017 deployment of Aerohive access points in all stores and corporate facilities, providing scalable coverage for point-of-sale systems and inventory tracking. Technological investments include kiosks to accelerate transactions and reduce labor dependency at checkout. The firm has also replatformed its infrastructure to overcome legacy platform constraints, enhancing online inventory visibility and sales integration with physical stores. A data-driven retail streamlines workflows from intake to , minimizing processing bottlenecks in its vertically integrated model. Sustainability practices are embedded in Savers' reuse-centric operations, which diverted over 3.2 billion pounds of goods from landfills as of 2024. Annually, the company processes approximately 700 million pounds of textiles, extending product lifecycles and curbing waste, where 50% of items are discarded within one year. Wearing secondhand garments for an additional nine months can reduce their carbon, , and footprint by 20-30%. In July 2025, Savers articulated an positioning thrift retailing as a mechanism to minimize contributions through resale channels. The company earned the SDG Pioneer Award from in October 2024 for advancing via its for-profit thrift framework. Technology aids these efforts by optimizing sorting and distribution, further lowering energy use in processing.

Financial Performance

Initial public offering and market entry

Savers Value Village, Inc. confidentially submitted its draft registration statement to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on October 12, 2021, and publicly filed its S-1 registration statement on December 22, 2021, initiating the process toward an initial public offering (IPO). The company, previously controlled by Ares Management Corporation following its 2021 acquisition of a majority stake, aimed to raise capital primarily to repay outstanding indebtedness, using net proceeds alongside existing cash reserves. In its amended S-1 filing on June 20, 2023, Savers disclosed terms for an offering of 18.75 million shares priced between $15.00 and $17.00 each, with Ares expected to grant underwriters an option for an additional 2.81 million shares. The IPO was upsized and priced above the initial range at $18.00 per share for 22.29 million shares on June 28, 2023, generating gross proceeds of approximately $401 million before underwriting discounts and expenses. Trading commenced on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) under the ticker symbol "SVV" the following day, June 29, 2023, marking Savers' entry into public markets as a for-profit thrift retailer with operations across North America and Australia. Shares opened at $24.77, reflecting a 37.6% premium over the IPO price, and propelled the company's market capitalization to nearly $4 billion on debut, signaling strong investor interest in the resilient thrift sector amid economic pressures favoring value-oriented retail. Post-IPO, retained an approximately 88% ownership stake, underscoring the offering's structure as a partial divestiture while providing and debt reduction for the issuer. The transaction, underwritten by firms including W. Baird & Co., positioned Savers to access public equity markets for future growth initiatives, such as store expansions and enhancements, in a model reliant on donated goods processed for resale. This market entry occurred against a backdrop of recovering on discretionary items, with thrift operators benefiting from heightened demand for affordable apparel and . Savers Value Village's annual net sales grew from $1.204 billion in fiscal year 2021 to $1.538 billion in fiscal year 2024, reflecting a of approximately 8% over the period, driven primarily by comparable store sales increases and store expansions in the U.S. and . Growth accelerated in 2022 with a 19.3% year-over-year rise to $1.437 billion, amid post-pandemic recovery in thrift retail demand, but moderated to 4.4% in 2023 and 2.5% in 2024 as pressured on discretionary items. Profitability metrics showed compression during this timeframe, with net income declining from $83.39 million in 2021 (6.9% margin) to $29.03 million in 2024 (1.9% margin), attributable to higher operating expenses, including store-level costs and investments in digital loyalty programs. Gross profit margins remained relatively stable, averaging around 58-60%, supported by efficient sourcing from nonprofit partners, though operating income fell from $206.23 million in 2022 to $134.59 million in 2024 due to elevated SG&A expenses. Adjusted EBITDA, a key non-GAAP metric favored by management for assessing core operations, stood at approximately 13.4% of revenue in fiscal 2024, with quarterly margins reaching 16.5% in Q2 2025 amid 7.9% net sales growth to $417.2 million. Recent quarters indicate stabilizing trends, with Q1 2025 net sales up 4.5% year-over-year and comparable store sales growth of 2.8% overall (6.2% in the U.S.), signaling resilience in core thrift demand despite macroeconomic headwinds.
Fiscal YearNet Sales ($M)YoY Growth (%)Net Income ($M)Net Margin (%)Adj. EBITDA Margin (%)
20211,204-83.396.9-
20221,43719.384.725.9-
20231,5004.453.123.5-
20241,5382.529.031.913.4

Recent developments and challenges (2023–2025)

In June 2023, Savers Value Village, Inc. completed its initial public offering on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker SVV, pricing 25.6 million shares at $18 each and raising approximately $461 million before underwriting discounts. The stock debuted strongly, opening at $24.77, but subsequently declined, trading around $12.77 by late 2025 amid broader market pressures on retail stocks and concerns over post-IPO valuation. Fiscal year 2024 saw net sales rise 2.5% to $1.54 billion, driven by U.S. store expansions and comparable store sales growth, though profitability faced headwinds from elevated operating costs and a net loss of $1.9 million in the fourth quarter. Into 2025, first-quarter net sales increased 4.5% to $370.1 million with U.S. comparable sales up 6.2%, but the company reported a $4.7 million net loss due to rising labor and supply chain expenses outpacing revenue gains. Second-quarter results improved, with net sales up 7.9% to $417.2 million and net income of $18.9 million, reflecting stronger U.S. demand (comparable sales +6.2%) despite softer Canadian performance (+2.6%). Key developments included a May 2025 secondary public offering of common stock paired with a concurrent share repurchase to offset dilution and support shareholder value, alongside plans for 25-30 new stores in 2025 targeting EBITDA margin expansion. The company raised its full-year 2025 net sales guidance to $1.67-1.69 billion, citing resilient thrift demand amid inflation but noting inventory management and cost pressures as ongoing hurdles. Challenges persisted from macroeconomic factors, including weaker discretionary spending in Canada and competition in the second-hand retail sector, where growth is projected at 8.3% for 2025 but faces saturation risks. Analysts highlighted vulnerabilities in vertically integrated operations, such as reliance on local donations and vulnerability to regional economic downturns, contributing to stock undervaluation despite expansion momentum.

Societal Impact

Economic contributions and consumer value

Savers Value Village employs approximately 22,700 individuals across its operations in the United States, Canada, and Australia, contributing to local labor markets through full-time and part-time positions in retail, logistics, and processing. The company's 2024 annual revenue reached $1.54 billion, representing a 2.49% increase from the prior year and injecting substantial economic activity into communities via sales taxes, supplier payments, and wage expenditures. Between 2020 and 2024, Savers Value Village paid over $490 million to its non-profit processing partners for sourced inventory, enabling these organizations to fund community programs such as job training, youth services, and disaster relief without relying solely on donations. For consumers, Savers provides access to second-hand clothing, household goods, and electronics at prices typically 50-70% below comparable new retail equivalents, offering budget-conscious households an affordable alternative amid rising living costs. This model supports lower-income demographics by extending product lifecycles and reducing out-of-pocket spending on essentials; for instance, thrift apparel averages under $10 per item, compared to $30+ for similar new garments. Industry data indicates that 90% of U.S. consumers have engaged with thrift channels, with brick-and-mortar visits driving the majority of second-hand expenditures due to immediate availability and tactile selection. By channeling reusable goods into commerce rather than disposal, the company indirectly enhances consumer purchasing power through a circular economy that minimizes replacement costs.

Environmental benefits of thrift retailing

Thrift retailing mitigates environmental degradation primarily by extending the lifecycle of textiles and household goods, thereby reducing landfill waste and the resource-intensive processes of virgin production. In fiscal year 2024, Savers Value Village processed 1 billion pounds of secondhand items, diverting reusable materials that would otherwise contribute to landfill accumulation and associated methane emissions. This model avoids the extraction of raw materials, such as cotton requiring 2,700 liters of water per kilogram for new production, by repurposing existing stock. A core benefit is greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions avoidance through displaced new manufacturing, which accounts for 8-10% of global CO₂ emissions in the apparel sector alone. Savers' operations in 2024 prevented over 43 million pounds of CO₂ equivalent emissions in the United States, 31 million pounds in Canada, and nearly 3 million pounds in Australia, equivalent to removing 164,897 passenger vehicles from roads annually. These savings stem from lifecycle analyses attributing emissions reductions to reuse rather than incineration or landfilling, where textiles decompose anaerobically. Resource conservation further amplifies these gains, with thrift retailing curtailing energy and water demands. For example, Savers' textile reuse in Canada equated to saving 80.9 billion liters of water in 2022, comparable to the annual consumption of over 1 million individuals, while avoiding energy equivalent to 4 million kilowatt-hours. Cumulatively, from fiscal years 2020 to 2024, the company diverted 3.2 billion pounds of goods from North American landfills, preventing over 10,000 dump-truck loads of waste in the U.S. alone. By fostering a circular economy for consumer goods, thrift retailing diminishes pollution from dyeing, finishing, and transportation in linear supply chains. Peer-reviewed assessments confirm that secondhand clothing trade extends garment utility, reducing overall environmental burdens compared to fast fashion's high-volume disposal cycles. Savers' for-profit model scales this impact, processing donations into resale while recycling non-reusable items like plastic bags—over 10 million pounds in 2024—into composite materials.

Charitable outcomes and community engagement

Savers Value Village operates a for-profit model in which it partners with local nonprofits to accept donations of used clothing and household goods on their behalf, purchasing these items by weight to provide unrestricted revenue streams that fund the partners' community programs. Between fiscal years 2019 and 2023, the company paid over $530 million to these nonprofit partners across the United States, Canada, and Australia, enabling support for initiatives such as veteran services through the Disabled American Veterans and Purple Heart Foundation, and monthly aid to over 65 individuals and families via organizations like Inclusion New Brunswick. Community engagement extends beyond payments through programs like FUNDrive, which facilitated over 4,000 fundraising events in 2023 for local schools, sports teams, and nonprofits, allowing participants to donate goods for direct credit to participating organizations. The Get2Give initiative saw nearly 900 donations in 2023, totaling approximately 81,000 pounds of items directed to over 350 community partners including shelters and schools, diverting goods from landfills while addressing immediate local needs. Direct charitable giving complements these efforts, with the Savers Value Village Charitable Giving Fund disbursing $215,000 USD, $107,500 CAD, and $10,000 AUD in grants during 2023 to organizations such as Dress for Success and the Trevor Project, alongside roughly $300,000 in donations via Donor Advised Funds for mental health and workforce support programs. These activities have historically supported over 1,200 nonprofit partners, generating more than $20 million in payments in 2021 alone to sustain missions ranging from education to disaster relief. While these outcomes provide verifiable financial and material support to communities, critics have questioned the transparency of the model, noting that store purchases do not directly benefit nonprofits and past marketing has led to public confusion about the for-profit nature of operations, as highlighted in legal disputes resolved in Savers' favor by 2019. Nonetheless, the scale of payments and targeted engagements demonstrates tangible contributions to nonprofit capacities and local welfare.

Controversies

In 2015, the Minnesota Attorney General's office filed a lawsuit against Savers, operating as Value Village, alleging deceptive marketing practices that misled consumers into believing the chain was a nonprofit charity rather than a for-profit entity. The complaint claimed that Savers' advertising and in-store promotions implied substantial donations to partner nonprofits, when in reality, the company purchased goods from those organizations at fixed prices, retaining most profits. Savers settled the case for $1.8 million without admitting wrongdoing, agreeing to clarify its for-profit status in marketing materials. Washington Attorney General Bob Ferguson initiated a similar consumer protection lawsuit against Savers in December 2017, accusing the company of violating the state's Consumer Protection Act through deceptive acts in advertising, including websites and signage that blurred the line between charitable operations and commercial enterprise. The suit contended that Savers' practices, such as prominently displaying partner charity names and donation bins, created a false impression that customer purchases directly funded nonprofits, potentially influencing purchasing decisions based on perceived charitable support rather than price or value. Lower courts initially ruled against Savers in 2019, finding sufficient evidence of consumer deception, but the Washington Supreme Court overturned this in February 2023, holding unanimously that the company's marketing constituted protected commercial speech under the First Amendment, as it did not make explicitly false claims. Following the Supreme Court victory, a King County Superior Court judge in October 2023 ordered Ferguson's office to pay Savers approximately $4.3 million in attorney fees and costs, deeming the state's pursuit of the case after clear First Amendment precedents as "needless" and lacking substantial justification. No separate legal actions specifically targeting pricing strategies, such as alleged false advertising of discounts or comparative values, have been documented in major disputes against Savers; claims in the Washington and Minnesota cases centered on charitable misrepresentation rather than direct pricing deception. Advocacy groups like Truth in Advertising (TINA.org) supported the state's position in amicus briefs, arguing that implied endorsements by charities could mislead on overall value propositions, but courts prioritized verifiable falsity over subjective impressions.

Labor conditions and safety allegations

In April 2024, a class action lawsuit was filed against TVI, Inc., doing business as Savers, in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California (Case No. 5:24-cv-01649-BLF), alleging systemic wage and hour violations under California's Private Attorneys General Act. The complaint, brought by plaintiff Jose Villanueva on behalf of current and former non-exempt hourly employees from July 28, 2021, onward, claims failures to pay all overtime wages, minimum wages for off-the-clock work, timely and uninterrupted meal and rest breaks, and premium pay for missed breaks, as well as improper use of payroll debit cards and untimely wage payments upon termination. The case remains pending as of October 2025, with no settlement reported. An unfair labor practice charge was filed against Savers, Inc., doing business as Value Village Thrift Stores and Unique Thrift Stores, with the National Labor Relations Board in Region 5 (covering the Pacific Northwest), under case number 05-CA-118436. Specific details of the allegations and any resolution are not publicly detailed in available records, though such charges typically involve claims of interference with employee rights under the National Labor Relations Act, such as discriminatory practices or refusal to bargain. Regarding workplace safety, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) has issued citations to Savers and affiliated Value Village locations for violations, including a 2012 citation against Savers classified as "Other" with an issuance date of May 23, 2012. Earlier inspections, such as one in 2004 resulting in penalties totaling $5,500 for formal settlement and issuance, indicate compliance issues, though specific violation descriptions (e.g., hazard communication or general duty clause breaches) are not detailed in public summaries. Employee reviews on platforms like Indeed have raised concerns about understaffing leading to heightened shoplifting risks and inadequate security, potentially compromising worker safety, but these remain anecdotal without formal adjudication. No major safety incidents or large-scale lawsuits have been documented in credible reports as of 2025.

Ethical critiques of the for-profit thrift model

Critics argue that Savers' for-profit model, which involves purchasing bulk donations from charitable partners at low rates per pound—often cited as around 6 to 10 cents in older agreements—and reselling sorted items at retail markups, diverts resources intended for direct charitable aid into corporate profits. This structure has generated over $1 billion in annual revenue for Savers while returning minimal portions to nonprofits, prompting accusations that it exploits donation pipelines built by charities without commensurate benefits to those causes. A primary ethical concern centers on deceptive marketing practices that blur the line between philanthropy and commerce, leading donors and shoppers to overestimate charitable impacts. Savers has faced multiple lawsuits from state attorneys general, including a 2015 Washington case alleging misrepresentation as a charity through signage, websites, and ads emphasizing partnerships with organizations like Goodwill or local nonprofits, without clearly disclosing its for-profit status or the limited funds passed to partners. Although Savers prevailed in some defenses, such as a 2023 ruling awarding it $4.3 million in legal fees against Washington after partial dismissals, critics from nonprofit sectors maintain that persistent consumer confusion undermines genuine charitable thrift operations. Donors' intentions are further compromised, as contributions meant to support specific causes end up funding shareholder returns rather than program delivery, with Savers not routinely disclosing the exact percentage of donation value retained—estimated by watchdogs as low single digits after processing costs. This has led to claims of inflated tax deduction perceptions, particularly for non-clothing items where deductibility rules differ, potentially violating Internal Revenue Service guidelines on donor advisories. Broader critiques highlight how the model commercializes thrift, pricing goods above donation costs in ways that prioritize margins over accessibility for low-income buyers, thus failing to maximize societal good from reused resources. Nonprofits like Salvation Army have expressed concerns that for-profits like Savers crowd out direct charitable sales, reducing funds available for services such as job training or poverty alleviation, as evidenced by competitive tensions in shared markets. While Savers counters that its payments sustain partner operations and expand donation volumes, detractors from outlets like CharityWatch argue this rationalizes profit extraction from altruism, eroding trust in the thrift sector overall.

References

  1. https://www.savers.com/
  2. https://ir.savers.com/overview/default.aspx
  3. https://www.savers.com/about-us
  4. https://berkshirepartners.com/portfolio-companies/savers/
  5. https://images3.loopnet.com/d2/-z9KfLJ4q-vx8eGAOyFdVeUqs3xHSXt9NVvYteTISxU/document.pdf
  6. https://ir.savers.com/esg/default.aspx
  7. https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/obituaries/value-village-founder-bill-ellison-79-built-chain-on-golden-rule/
  8. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/secondhand-stores-prove-to-be-first-rate/
  9. https://dcfmodeling.com/blogs/history/svv-history-mission-ownership
  10. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/savers-expands-thrift-store-footprint-with-unique-thrift-acquisition/
  11. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/savers-inc-continues-north-american-growth-with-purchase-of-18-stores-from-unique-thrift-llc-117517473.html
  12. https://www.bizjournals.com/seattle/blog/2011/03/savers-buys-18-stores-from-unique-thrift.html
  13. https://www.freemanspogli.com/news/savers-inc-enters-into-financial-partnership-with-leonard-green-partners-lp-and-tpg/
  14. https://www.williamblair.com/News/Savers-Value-Village-Inc-Initiation
  15. https://ir.savers.com/news/news-details/2025/Savers-Value-Village-Inc.-Reports-Fourth-Quarter-Financial-Results/
  16. https://ir.savers.com/news/news-details/2024/Savers-Value-Village-Inc.-Reports-First-Quarter-Financial-Results-and-Acquisition-of-Thrift-Store-Chain-with-Seven-Locations-in-Georgia/default.aspx
  17. https://freedom24.com/ideas/details/14992
  18. https://seekingalpha.com/news/4411679-savers-value-village-targets-25minus-30-new-store-openings-in-2025-with-1_61b-1_65b-sales
  19. https://ir.savers.com/financials/quarterly-results/default.aspx
  20. https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10153349493128773&id=137186713772&set=a.154962983772
  21. https://www.tsinetwork.ca/daily-advice/growth-stocks/savers-value-village-grew-earnings-66-thanks-to-cost-reductions
  22. https://www.rwbaird.com/transactions/investment-banking/dealcard/6506/
  23. https://www.facebook.com/thewesternsydneymums/posts/%25EF%25B8%258F-marsden-park-its-finally-happening-savers-australia-is-opening-their-doors-thi/1258742052959842/
  24. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1883313/000119312523169542/d264743ds1a.htm
  25. https://www.theshelf.com/portfolio/case-study-savers-value-village/
  26. https://www.buyoutsinsider.com/turnaround-deal-of-the-year-ares-management-and-savers-value-village/
  27. https://www.iposcoop.com/ipo/savers-value-village/
  28. https://www.reuters.com/markets/deals/private-equity-backed-savers-value-village-targets-27-billion-valuation-us-ipo-2023-06-20/
  29. https://ir.savers.com/news/news-details/2023/Savers-Value-Village-Announces-Pricing-of-Initial-Public-Offering/default.aspx
  30. https://www.reuters.com/business/retail-consumer/thrift-store-operator-savers-valued-nearly-4-billion-market-debut-2023-06-29/
  31. https://www.savers.com/partners
  32. https://www.valuevillage.com/donate
  33. https://convergenceri.com/stories/savers-the-large-for-profit-thrift-store-chain-filed-a-private-offering-for-500-million%2C7866
  34. https://www.savers.com/disclosures
  35. https://www.investigatewest.org/profiting-from-thrift-whos-getting-rich-off-your-secondhand-stuff/
  36. https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/questions-are-raised-over-thrift-store-chains-charitable-deeds-n452541
  37. https://scw-mag.com/news/268-savers/
  38. https://www.valuevillage.com/contact-us
  39. https://americanbuildersquarterly.com/2017/savers/
  40. https://careers.savers.com/en/search/operations/jobs
  41. https://www.glassdoor.com/job-listing/merchandise-processing-associate-savers-value-village-JV_KO0%2C32_KE33%2C53.htm?jl=1009262525911
  42. https://www.savers.com/thrift-proud/community/what-happens-to-items-that-dont-sell-in-our-stores
  43. https://www.indeed.com/cmp/Savers__value-Village/reviews?fcountry=ALL&fjobtitle=Production%2BWorker
  44. https://www.ziprecruiter.com/c/Savers-Value-Village/Job/Merchandise-Processing-Associate/-in-Chicago%2CIL?jid=4f4d2b784585601f
  45. https://stores.savers.com/
  46. https://materials.proxyvote.com/Approved/80517M/20250407/AR_603713.PDF
  47. https://csimarket.com/stocks/markets_glance.php?code=SVV
  48. https://www.quiverquant.com/news/Savers%2BValue%2BVillage%2BStock%2B%28SVV%29%2BOpinions%2Bon%2BRaised%2BGuidance%2Band%2BExpansion%2BPlans
  49. https://www.scrapehero.com/location-reports/Savers%2520Thrift-USA/
  50. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/investing/markets/stocks/SVV/pressreleases/33826101/savers-value-village-svv-q2-sales-jump/
  51. https://insideretail.us/savers-value-villages-annual-sales-rise/
  52. https://stockrow.com/SVV/business-profile
  53. https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/svv/employees/
  54. https://downloads.ctfassets.net/312853a4ptgv/5UoYxjmhzeMDhzjRas2tbb/bd9f16dfdbbbf93b190f5df0301b3486/ESG-2024.pdf
  55. https://seekingalpha.com/article/4620952-savers-value-village-finding-treasure-in-thrift-shop
  56. https://careers.savers.com/en/search/supply-chain-logistics/jobs
  57. https://www.extremenetworks.com/resources/case-study/largest-thrift-store-chain-in-north-america-selects-wireless-retail-solution-from-extreme
  58. https://chainstoreage.com/operations/thrift-store-chain-goes-wireless
  59. https://www.savers.com/real-estate
  60. https://www.metaltoad.com/casestudy/savers
  61. https://www.epicor.com/en-us/blog/industries/how-technology-can-enhance-thrift-retail-operations/
  62. https://www.villagedesvaleurs.ca/en/thrift-proud/impact
  63. https://www.savers.com/thrift-proud/rethink-reuse
  64. https://www.marketscreener.com/news/savers-value-village-environmental-policy-ce7c5fdedb89f024
  65. https://ir.savers.com/news/news-details/2024/Savers-Value-Village-Inc.-Honored-with-the-SDG-Pioneer-Award-at-the-2024-Reuters-Sustainability-Awards/default.aspx
  66. https://www.rwbaird.com/transactions/investment-banking/dealcard/6188/
  67. https://www.iposcoop.com/the-ipo-buzz-savers-value-village-svv-prices-upsized-ipo-at-18-00-above-range/
  68. https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/svv/financials/
  69. https://companiesmarketcap.com/savers-value-village/revenue/
  70. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/SVV/
  71. https://www.alphaquery.com/stock/SVV/fundamentals/annual/ebitda-margin
  72. https://ir.savers.com/news/news-details/2025/Savers-Value-Village-Inc--Reports-Second-Quarter-Financial-Results/
  73. https://www.stocktitan.net/news/SVV/
  74. https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/svv
  75. https://www.renaissancecapital.com/Profile/SVV/Savers-Value-Village/IPO
  76. https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/svv/
  77. https://stockinvest.us/digest/savers-value-village-reports-47m-net-loss-amid-rising-costs-despite-sales-growth-in-q1-2025
  78. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/savers-value-village-inc-announces-124500548.html
  79. https://seekingalpha.com/news/4440619-savers-value-village-projects-25minus-30-new-stores-in-2025-with-ebitda-margin-improvements
  80. https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/savers-value-village-raises-2025-outlook-with-net-sales-target-of-169b-as-us-comps-climb-62/ar-AA1JJVHL
  81. https://www.tipranks.com/news/company-announcements/savers-value-village-reports-strong-growth-amid-challenges
  82. https://seekingalpha.com/article/4829656-savers-value-village-the-contrarian-case-for-passing-on-savers
  83. https://seekingalpha.com/article/4805227-savers-value-village-remains-on-sale
  84. https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/svv/revenue/
  85. https://assets.ctfassets.net/312853a4ptgv/6McNOdFm04UiNDH0zStakt/f7be0c2ddcdbc28a45be85bfd27b00c7/Savers_Thrift_Report_2024_NA_09182024_2.pdf
  86. https://s202.q4cdn.com/614174375/files/doc_governance/2025/10/SVV-Impact-Sustainability-Report-2025.pdf
  87. https://s202.q4cdn.com/614174375/files/doc_downloads/2024/03/21/Savers-ESG-Report_Final.pdf
  88. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0040162523006856
  89. https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/17/18/8397
  90. https://nonprofitquarterly.org/judge-finds-that-savers-misled-public-about-its-giving-delivers-mixed-ruling/
  91. https://www.investigatewest.org/charity-or-business-some-consumers-still-confused-by-value-village/
  92. https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=7372ea07-74a8-41d6-a8e3-c764fa243321
  93. https://www.investigatewest.org/value-village-rebuked-by-judge-for-deceiving-consumers/
  94. https://apnews.com/article/minnesota-state-government-washington-bob-ferguson-3c2d0cea42591a1fc303590052504054
  95. https://www.atg.wa.gov/news/news-releases/ag-ferguson-files-multi-million-dollar-lawsuit-against-profit-value-village
  96. https://law.justia.com/cases/washington/supreme-court/2023/100-493-1.html
  97. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/thrift-store-chain-case-no-213112531.html
  98. https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=e6e686db-a786-46b6-ba0f-8c0c6961bdd3
  99. https://truthinadvertising.org/blog/tina-org-joins-the-fight-against-value-village-in-wash-supreme-court/
  100. https://dockets.justia.com/docket/california/candce/5:2024cv01649/426594
  101. https://www.tvilawsuit.com/
  102. https://www.nlrb.gov/case/05-CA-118436
  103. https://www.osha.gov/ords/imis/establishment.violation_detail?id=316001387&citation_id=01001
  104. https://www.indeed.com/cmp/Savers__value-Village/reviews?fcountry=ALL&fjobtitle=Team%2BMember&ftopic=jobsecadv
  105. https://www.investigatewest.org/the-thrift-store-chain-that-dressed-up-like-a-charity-and-got-sued/
  106. https://nonprofitquarterly.org/is-value-village-savers-the-trump-foundation-of-second-hand-stores/
  107. https://whatcomwatch.org/index.php/article/has-value-village-fooled-us/
  108. https://www.cascadepbs.org/news/2023/05/charity-or-business-some-consumers-still-confused-value-village/
  109. https://blog.charitywatch.org/donors39-intentions-violated-at-for-profit-thrift-stores/
  110. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/consumers-look-to-value-village-for-a-bargain-many-are-finding-ridiculous-markups-1.7101270
  111. https://www.investigatewest.org/thrift-giant-resisted-oversight-of-its-charitable-work-in-washington/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.