Hubbry Logo
Ship graveyardShip graveyardMain
Open search
Ship graveyard
Community hub
Ship graveyard
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Ship graveyard
Ship graveyard
Ship graveyard
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
Large ships are scrapped in Alang, India
Aerial view of Alang
Staten Island boat graveyard in 1973
Shipwrecks in Camaret-sur-Mer
French navy graveyard at Landévennec near Brest
Boat cemetery in Bénodet
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Ship graveyards.
Tangalooma Wrecks near Moreton Island, Queensland, Australia
Tangalooma Wrecks near Moreton Island, Queensland, Australia

A ship graveyard, ship cemetery or breaking yard is a location where the hulls of scrapped ships are left to decay and disintegrate, or left in reserve. Such a practice is now less common due to waste regulations and so some dry docks where ships are broken (to recycle their metal and remove dangerous materials like asbestos) are also known as ship graveyards.

By analogy, the phrase can also refer to an area with many shipwrecks which have not been removed by human agency, instead being left to disintegrate naturally. These can form in places where navigation is difficult or dangerous (such as the Seven Stones, off Cornwall, or Blackpool, on the Irish Sea); or where many ships have been deliberately scuttled together (as with the German High Seas Fleet at Scapa Flow); or where many ships have been sunk in battle (such as Ironbottom Sound, in the Pacific). Such regions are also likely to be described as shipwreck graveyards.[1]


The majority of the ships in the world are constructed in the developed countries. Ships last about 25–30 years, after which they become too expensive to maintain and are sold to be broken down. Most of them are directly sold to the ship recycling companies in India, Bangladesh, Pakistan and other developing countries, also known as the (semi-)periphery countries from Immanuel Wallerstein's World System Theory. In 2014, 54 percent of the ships went to the beaches of India and Bangladesh.[2] This is consistent with the period 2012–2018. From the total of 6,702 scrapped ships worldwide, 3,586 ships have been scrapped in India and Bangladesh, which comes down to 53.5 percent.[3]

As of January 2020, with 30% share India has the highest global revenue and highest share of global ship breaking (number and volume of ships broken).[4]

It is estimated that ship breaking yards provide more than 100,000 jobs to people worldwide and that they yield millions of tons of steel every year with a minimal consumption of electricity.[5] Besides steel, this industry also yields a huge amount of solid wastes in the form of scrapped wood, plastic, insulation material, glass wool, sponge, waste paper, oiled rope and cotton waste.[6]

List of ship graveyards

[edit]

Africa

[edit]
See also: List of shipwrecks of Africa

Asia

[edit]
See also: List of shipwrecks of Asia

Europe

[edit]

France

[edit]

Sweden

[edit]

United Kingdom

[edit]

North America

[edit]

Canada

[edit]


United States

[edit]
See also: List of shipwrecks of the United States

Oceania

[edit]

Australia

[edit]
See also: List of shipwrecks of Australia and Australasian Underwater Cultural Heritage Database

New South Wales:

Northern Territory:

Queensland:

South Australia: As of November 2020 there are 19 ships' graveyards in South Australia.[12]

Others

Tasmania:

  • Little Betsey Island Ships' Graveyard (Hobart)
  • East Risdon Ships' Graveyard (Hobart)
  • Strahan Ships' Graveyard (Strahan)
  • Tamar Island Ships' Graveyard (Launceston)

Victoria:

Western Australia:

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Ship graveyard

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

A ship graveyard, also known as a ship cemetery or breaking yard, is a coastal or marine location where decommissioned, wrecked, or obsolete ships are abandoned to disintegrate naturally or systematically dismantled for scrap metal, reusable components, and recycling.
These sites serve as endpoints for vessels reaching the end of their operational life, driven by economic factors such as high maintenance costs and regulatory retirements, with global shipbreaking activity recycling materials equivalent to a major steel industry contributor.
Notable ship graveyards include industrial breaking hubs in South Asia, such as Alang in Gujarat, India—established in 1983 and capable of handling up to 160 vessels at once—where approximately half of the world's large ships are beached and manually disassembled, generating employment for over 30,000 workers but frequently resulting in accidents due to rudimentary safety practices and exposure to toxins like asbestos, oil, and heavy metals.
Other examples encompass abandoned wreck clusters, such as the 300-plus derelict ships in Nouadhibou Bay, Mauritania, left by foreign fishing fleets amid 1980s fuel crises and lacking salvage due to economic disincentives, forming expansive rusting barriers that hinder local maritime access and ecology.
While ship graveyards facilitate resource recovery—reclaiming steel that avoids extensive new mining—they often evade stringent international waste regulations, leading to persistent controversies over pollution leaching into sediments and worker fatalities exceeding safer yard benchmarks elsewhere.

Definition and Classification

Core Definition


A ship graveyard, also termed a ship cemetery, refers to a site where decommissioned vessels are abandoned to naturally disintegrate or are stored prior to scrapping. These locations typically accumulate hulls of obsolete ships that have reached the end of their operational life, often due to age, economic unviability, or structural failure. Unlike active ship-breaking facilities, which systematically dismantle vessels for metal recovery, ship graveyards may feature ships left in situ to rust and decay without immediate recycling efforts, though the terms are sometimes used interchangeably for beaching sites where partial dismantling occurs. Such graveyards form through deliberate placement for cost-effective disposal or unintended accumulation from wrecks and abandonments. For instance, coastal beaches in regions like Gujarat, India, host thousands of ships annually beached for breaking, creating vast expanses of rusting hulls exposed to tidal actions and atmospheric corrosion. Environmentally, these sites pose risks from hazardous materials like asbestos and oil residues leaching into ecosystems, prompting international regulations such as the Basel Convention to govern ship disposal. Economically, they support recycling industries by supplying steel—accounting for up to 98% of a ship's recoverable material—but often under lax labor and safety standards in developing nations.

Types and Distinctions

![Shipwrecking in Alang, India, 2017]float-right Ship graveyards encompass locations where decommissioned or derelict vessels accumulate, distinguished primarily by operational intent and disposal method. Active shipbreaking yards focus on systematic dismantling for scrap metal extraction, processing an estimated 90% of global end-of-life ships annually, with hulls cut using thermal methods like oxy-fuel torches amid manual labor. These sites contrast with passive abandonment zones, where vessels are left to corrode naturally without structured recycling, often due to failed salvage attempts or economic abandonment, as seen in Mauritania's Bay of Nouadhibou hosting over 200 ships since the 1980s from illegal flagging practices. Key distinctions in active yards include beach-based breaking, dominant in developing regions like India's Alang, where tides facilitate grounding for cost-effective disassembly—handling up to 5 million tons yearly—but exposing workers to hazards like asbestos and heavy metals without consistent safety protocols. In contrast, dry-dock or quay-side facilities in regulated areas, such as Turkey's Aliaga, employ cranes and contained environments for safer, cleaner operations compliant with conventions like the Hong Kong International Convention for ship recycling, though comprising only about 5% of global capacity due to higher costs. Passive graveyards further divide into surface beaching or sites versus submerged wreck clusters; the former, like Pakistan's Gadani, blend abandonment with opportunistic scrapping, while underwater assemblages from wartime scuttling or storms form incidental marine habitats but evade surface "graveyard" designation by lacking visible hull decay. Intentional non-scrapping disposals, such as sinking for artificial reefs under programs like the U.S. Navy's excess ships initiative—deploying over 100 vessels since 1980—prioritize ecological or roles over recovery, distinguishing them from commercial graveyards by engineered submersion rather than terrestrial or intertidal decay. Reserve fleets, or "mothball" anchorages, represent temporary distinctions, storing operable vessels like the U.S. Maritime Administration's fleet of up to 100 ships for potential reactivation, differing from permanent graveyards by against deterioration.

Historical Development

Pre-Modern Examples

In pre-modern eras, ship disposal emphasized resource recovery over abandonment, with wooden vessels dismantled manually to salvage timber, sails, cordage, and metal fittings for reuse in construction, fuel, or new ships. Unlike modern steel-hulled graveyards featuring decaying hulks, pre-modern examples involved localized breaking on beaches, slipways, or harbors, often following wrecks or decommissioning, as large-scale concentrations of derelict ships were uncommon due to the high value of materials and limited fleet sizes. This process relied on axes, adzes, and labor-intensive methods, typically occurring soon after a vessel's obsolescence to prevent rot or theft of components. Early organized dismantling practices emerged in Europe during the late medieval and early modern periods. In Tudor England (1485–1603), naval and merchant ships, including warships, were routinely broken up on beaches or in rudimentary dry docks, with oak timber repurposed for building or barrel-making amid resource shortages from intensive shipbuilding under Henry VIII. Records indicate this shifted from ad hoc wreck salvage—where local salvors stripped beached vessels for legal claims—to more systematic state oversight for royal fleets, reflecting growing maritime economies. Similar methods prevailed in Mediterranean ports like Venice's Arsenale, where galleys were stripped for components post-campaign, though without dedicated graveyard sites. Ancient and medieval precedents focused on ritual or utilitarian disposal rather than commercial scrapping. Iron Age bog offerings, such as the Nydam boats in Denmark (circa 3rd–4th centuries AD), involved deliberate sinking or burial of vessels as votive sacrifices, preserving hulls for archaeological insight into construction but not routine scrapping. In Anglo-Saxon England, elite ship burials like Sutton Hoo (early 7th century) repurposed vessels as grave goods, with non-elite ships likely dismantled for timber in coastal settlements. These practices underscore causal drivers: wood's scarcity incentivized immediate reuse, precluding graveyard formations seen in eras of expendable metal hulls.

Industrial Era and 20th Century Expansion

The advent of iron-hulled ships in the early 19th century transformed shipbreaking from informal beach dismantling of wooden vessels to a structured industry, primarily in the United Kingdom, Netherlands, and United States. Operations relied on labor-intensive methods using chisels, sledgehammers, and later steam saws, with yards selected for tidal access and proximity to steel mills to facilitate material recycling. In Britain, commercial shipbreaking pioneered at sites like Henry Castle’s Baltic Wharf in 1838, initially focusing on wooden warships before adapting to iron structures. The 20th century saw significant technological and scale expansions, driven by steel demand and post-war surpluses. Around 1910, oxy-acetylene cutting torches enabled precise steel hull dissection, supplemented by mechanically-driven shears for processing panels into furnace-ready sizes. In the UK, firms such as Thomas W. Ward, established in 1878, grew to operate 13 yards by the 1920s, handling vast tonnages including 154 ships scrapped in 1905 and over 500,000 tons of dreadnought-era vessels. Methods involved top-down stripping of non-ferrous metals, followed by beaching ships on shelving shores for final breakdown using cranes, derricks, and drop weights, with a typical battleship requiring 60-70 workers over 16 months. In the United States, prompted the rapid of over 100 wooden steamships as part of the Emergency Fleet, many scuttled post-armistice at in the for scrapping. Dismantling occurred in phases from the to , involving firms like Western Marine and Salvage and , which extracted engines, boilers, and propellers amid economic pressures including the . amplified this trend, directing numerous vessels to Western scrapyards for recovery, sustaining industry growth until stricter regulations and labor costs began shifting operations abroad in the mid-century.

Post-2000 Globalization

![Huge ship at Alang ship graveyard][float-right] The expansion of ship graveyards in the post-2000 era has been driven by the globalization of maritime trade, which increased the global merchant fleet size and generated a surge in end-of-life vessels requiring scrapping. Between 2000 and 2010, the world merchant fleet grew by approximately 50%, from around 800 million deadweight tons (DWT) to over 1.2 billion DWT, fueled by rising international trade volumes, particularly in container shipping and bulk carriers supporting China's economic boom. This fleet expansion led to higher scrapping demands, with annual global ship recycling volumes peaking at over 1,000 vessels in years like 2013, when 1,119 ships were dismantled, predominantly in Asian yards handling 92% of the world's total of 29 million tonnes scrapped that year. The economic incentive for owners to scrap in low-cost locations outweighed stricter regulations in Europe and North America, where labor and environmental compliance costs were significantly higher. South Asia emerged as the epicenter, with India's Alang-Sosiya yard in transforming into the world's largest shipbreaking facility by the mid-2000s, more than one-third of global retirements. Established in but scaling dramatically post-2000, Alang's tidal beaches and cheap labor attracted vessels beached for manual dismantling, employing tens of thousands and quantities—up to 4-5 million tonnes annually at peak. Similarly, Bangladesh's Chittagong yard, which briefly held the top spot before Alang's dominance, expanded to employ over 200,000 workers by the 2010s, capitalizing on lax of international standards to handle hazardous materials like asbestos and residues. Pakistan's Gadani beach also grew, though smaller . These sites thrived on "beaching" methods, where ships are grounded at high tide and cut apart on-site, a practice enabled by flag-of-convenience registries allowing circumvention of origin-country rules. International efforts to regulate the industry intensified post-2000, with the Hong Kong International Convention for Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships adopted in 2009, aiming to curb toxic waste dumping, though ratification lagged until recent years. The European Union's Ship Recycling Regulation in 2013 banned EU-flagged vessels from non-compliant yards, listing approved "green" facilities, yet global scrapping largely persisted in South Asia due to non-EU flags on most traded ships. Reports from organizations like Human Rights Watch highlight persistent worker fatalities—hundreds annually from explosions, falls, and toxic exposure—and coastal pollution, including heavy metals contaminating fisheries, but industry analyses note economic contributions, such as Bangladesh's yard supplying 20-30% of national steel needs. Scrapping volumes fluctuated with freight rates; low activity in 2024 saw only 324 vessels recycled (4.6 million gross tonnes), the lowest since 2005, amid high ship values delaying retirements. Future projections anticipate a tripling of activity, with 16,000 ships (700 million DWT) expected by 2035, underscoring Asia's continued centrality despite regulatory pressures.

Formation and Operational Processes

Causes of Ship Abandonment

Ships reach of their operational life and are decommissioned for scrapping primarily due to structural deterioration from prolonged exposure to corrosive marine environments, metal , and , which escalate repair and maintenance expenses beyond feasible levels after approximately 25 to 30 years of service for most commercial vessels. Owners compare ongoing operational costs—such as , wages, and dry-docking—against the vessel's residual scrap value, which fluctuates with global market prices; high steel , as seen in 2021 when prices surged over 50% year-on-year, incentivizes accelerated scrapping to recover light displacement tonnage (LDT) at rates up to $600 per ton. Fuel inefficiency further compounds economic unviability, as older ships, often designed with slower speeds and higher consumption rates, fail to compete with modern fleets optimized under frameworks like the IMO's Energy Efficiency Design Index (EEDI), which mandates reduced emissions and fuel use for newbuilds; for instance, a 1980s-built bulk carrier might consume 20-30% more bunker fuel per ton-mile than a post-2010 equivalent, rendering it unprofitable during freight rate downturns like the 2015-2016 slump when Baltic Dry Index fell below 300 points. Regulatory non-compliance accelerates abandonment, exemplified by the phase-out of single-hull tankers under MARPOL Annex I, which required decommissioning by 2010-2015 for vessels over 5,000 DWT unable to meet double-hull standards, resulting in over 1,000 such ships scrapped globally in that period to avoid operational bans and insurance denials. Accidental causes, including collisions, groundings, or severe weather events, lead to abandonment when damage renders salvage impractical or crew safety demands evacuation, as in the case of vessels declared constructive total losses by insurers; NOAA data indicates that such derelict vessels often accumulate in high-risk coastal zones due to navigational errors or storms, with over abandoned or derelict vessels reported in U.S. waters alone as of 2023, many stemming from unmaintained recreational or small commercial craft but scaling to larger wrecks in hurricane-prone areas like the Gulf of Mexico. Owner financial distress, including bankruptcy or wage arrears, prompts outright abandonment without decommissioning plans, stranding ships in ports; the IMO recorded 174 seafarer abandonment cases in 2023, often tied to owner insolvency, leaving vessels seized by port states for eventual scrapping or disposal.

Scrapping and Dismantling Techniques

Ship scrapping, or shipbreaking, entails the controlled disassembly of decommissioned vessels to extract recyclable materials, with steel accounting for 90-95% of recoverable mass by weight. Primary techniques include beaching and dry-docking, differentiated by site preparation and environmental containment. Beaching, dominant in South Asian yards such as Alang, India, involves maneuvering the vessel onto intertidal mudflats at high tide, securing it with chains and cables, and exploiting tidal cycles for access during low tide. Dry-docking, by contrast, positions the ship within an enclosed facility where water is pumped out, enabling disassembly on stable, drained ground with integrated pollution controls. Prior to cutting, preparation mitigates hazards: fuel tanks are drained to avert explosions, oils and lubricants removed, and an inventory of hazardous materials compiled per the Hong Kong International Convention for the Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships, which entered into force on June 26, 2025. Reusable components like engines, fittings, and non-structural items are salvaged first, followed by stripping of insulation and coatings. Dismantling follows a top-down , commencing with the and progressing to main decks, lower holds, and hull to maintain . sections are severed using oxygen-fuel torches equipped with regulators and flashback arrestors, producing manageable plates lifted by cranes for shoreside sorting and shredding. Non-ferrous metals may employ mechanical shears or reciprocating saws to avoid . In beaching operations, manual labor predominates, with workers ascending scaffolds or the hull itself to apply torches, whereas dry-dock settings incorporate heavier machinery for precision cuts. Land-based variants extend dry-docking by transferring pre-cut sections inland for final , minimizing tidal dependencies but requiring substantial . Duration varies from weeks for smaller vessels to over a year for large tankers, contingent on and method. guidelines, such as Resolution A.962(23), emphasize sequenced removal to prevent collapses, with cutting directed from ends toward .

Prominent Locations

Asia

Asia dominates global ship breaking, with South Asian beaches accounting for over 85 percent of worldwide vessel dismantling in 2023. This concentration stems from low labor costs, abundant manual workforce, and permissive environmental oversight, enabling the beaching method where ships are grounded at high tide and cut apart on-site. In 2024, 255 of 409 dismantled ships globally ended up in South Asian yards, underscoring the region's pivotal role despite documented risks to workers and ecosystems from hazardous materials like asbestos and oil residues.

South Asia (India, Bangladesh, Pakistan)

's Alang-Sosiya yard in operates across a 12-kilometer beachfront with 153 plots, making it the world's largest shipbreaking facility. It employs approximately 15,000 workers who manually dismantle vessels using oxy-acetylene torches and hammers, recovering and other metals for resale. Activity has declined sharply, with only 25-30 plots active as of due to international pressure for safer practices and competition from , reducing 's share from historical highs. Bangladesh's Chittagong yard, stretching 18 kilometers north of Chattogram port, handled over 45 percent of global ship recycling in 2023. The site processes end-of-life bulk carriers and tankers via beaching, with workers exposed to toxic substances; records show at least 10 fatalities and 33 injuries in 2022 alone, often from falls or explosions. Despite upgrades in some yards, non-compliance with international standards persists, contributing to groundwater contamination and health issues among laborers. Pakistan's Gadani yard near spans 10 kilometers with 132 plots, third globally in capacity and employing 5,000 to workers seasonally. Operations mirror regional practices, involving and piecemeal cutting, but frequent accidents, including a 2024 incident killing two workers under a falling iron plate, highlight inadequate measures. The yard's output has fluctuated, dropping to seven active sites by 2023 amid regulatory and economic shifts.

Other Asian Sites

Turkey's Aliaga yard near , situated in western , serves as a key facility for European-flagged vessels, dismantling dozens annually through dry-docking and cutting methods that partially mitigate beach-based hazards. China's operations, concentrated in areas like , handle smaller volumes under stricter national regulations, focusing on state-owned ships with mechanical dismantling to reduce manual risks. Vietnam's sites, such as those near Vung Tau, process regional traffic but remain minor contributors globally, often facing typhoon-related disruptions. These locations collectively represent under 10 percent of Asian activity, overshadowed by South Asian dominance.

South Asia (India, Bangladesh, Pakistan)

, particularly , , and , accounts for the majority of global shipbreaking activity, with these countries dismantling over 90% of the world's end-of-life vessels due to favorable economics including cheap labor and lax regulations compared to Western standards. In 2024, 255 of 409 dismantled ships worldwide ended up in n yards, underscoring the region's dominance despite international efforts to enforce safer practices under the Hong Kong Convention. India's Alang-Sosiya yard in Gujarat operates 131 active plots out of 153, employing approximately workers directly and supporting indirectly through ancillary activities like steel re-rolling. The yard handled 101 ships in 2024, down from 137 in 2023, but saw a 13% increase in arrivals from April to August 2025 amid recovering global shipping trends and government incentives for compliance. Over 115 yards there meet Hong Kong Convention standards for safer recycling, though enforcement varies and worker exposure to and heavy metals persists without universal PPE. Bangladesh's Chattogram (Chittagong) yards, concentrated in and Bhatiary, feature nearly 150 plots with 30-40 operational, breaking 60-70% of global obsolete bulk carriers, tankers, and containers. The industry peaked at 280 ships in 2021 but declined sharply thereafter due to regulatory pressures and competition, employing 40,000 directly and 200,000 indirectly while generating Tk1,200-1,400 crore annually in duties and taxes. records show hundreds of worker deaths over the past decade from explosions, falls, and toxic exposures, with at least 6 fatalities in 2023 alone, often linked to beaching methods on intertidal zones lacking containment for oil spills and hazardous waste. Pakistan's Gadani yard, 40 km northwest of , spans 132 plots and was once the third-largest globally but has seen drastic , with only 7 vessels beached in 2023 versus 75 in , attributed to safety incidents and imports of cheaper . A 2016 explosion there killed 26 workers and left over 100 missing, highlighting chronic issues like absent safety gear and open burning of wastes that release PAHs and PCBs into coastal sediments. Across these sites, beaching techniques dominate, enabling manual dismantling but causing persistent ecological harm through untreated effluents and worker health risks, though proponents note the yards supply vital "green steel" for infrastructure while NGOs like the Shipbreaking Platform document underreported incidents to push for reforms.

Other Asian Sites

China maintains numerous ship recycling facilities, with an estimated 80 to 90 yards operational as of recent industry assessments, primarily concentrated in coastal provinces such as Jiangsu and Guangdong. These yards emphasize compliance with environmental standards, utilizing structured dismantling processes rather than beach-based beaching common in South Asia. The sector's capacity remains elastic, allowing adaptation to fluctuating global demand for vessel scrapping. A prominent example is the Changjiang Ship-breaking Yard in , , situated in the New Port Area for optimal access to shipping routes. Established as one of China's largest operations, it prioritizes measures during disassembly, handling a range of vessel types through mechanized cutting and recovery. Similarly, Jiangmen Zhongxin Shipbreaking & Steel Co., Ltd., in Guangdong Province, contributes to the region's output, focusing on steel reclamation from decommissioned ships. While China's shipbreaking volume trails that of South Asian hubs—accounting for a smaller share of the global total due to higher operational costs and regulatory hurdles—these facilities serve as viable options for owners seeking cleaner recycling practices amid international scrutiny of hazardous waste handling. Operations here typically involve dry-docking or pier-based breaking, reducing risks of pollutant leaching compared to tidal beaching methods elsewhere. No major ship graveyards have been documented in Southeast Asian nations like Vietnam, Malaysia, Thailand, or Indonesia for modern commercial scrapping, where activities center more on waste imports or repair rather than large-scale vessel dismantling.

Europe

Europe features fewer large-scale ship graveyards compared to Asia due to rigorous environmental regulations, including the European Union's Ship Recycling Regulation (SRR) adopted in 2013, which requires EU-flagged commercial vessels over 500 gross tons to be recycled exclusively at facilities on the European List, emphasizing safe and environmentally sound practices over unregulated beaching. As of July 2023, this list includes 48 approved yards, with 38 located in Europe (covering EU countries, Norway, and the United Kingdom), focusing on controlled dismantling in dry docks or slipways to minimize pollution and worker hazards. These regulations have shifted much European shipbreaking away from hazardous informal methods, though challenges persist in enforcement and capacity to handle the aging fleet. Prominent European ship graveyards often involve historical or abandonments rather than commercial scrapping. The Landévennec site in , , serves as a naval cemetery where the moors decommissioned warships, such as frigates and destroyers from the , in a sheltered bend of the Aulne near Brest, awaiting eventual dismantling; vessels here have included the frigate La Motte-Picquet and others left to rust since the 1990s, creating a ghostly tableau visible from the shore. Similarly, Scapa Flow in Scotland's Orkney Islands holds the remnants of 74 German warships scuttled by their crews on June 21, 1919, following World War I; while some were raised and scrapped in the interwar period, seven major wrecks, including battleships like SMS König and SMS Kronprinz, remain submerged, forming Europe's largest known concentration of intact large-ship wrecks, with ongoing concerns over oil leakage from deteriorating hulls. Other notable sites include the Purton Hulks along the River Severn in Gloucestershire, England, where over 80 vessels—primarily barges and schooners—were deliberately grounded between 1909 and the 1970s to reinforce eroding riverbanks; these wooden and steel hulks, many dating to the early 20th century, now decay in the mudflats, preserved by the low-oxygen environment and accessible via a public footpath. In regulated commercial contexts, yards like those in Ghent, Belgium, and Aliaga, Turkey (included on the EU list despite its Asian location), handle dismantling of end-of-life vessels under strict oversight, processing hundreds of ships annually while complying with hazardous material inventories required since 2020. These locations underscore Europe's prioritization of ecological safeguards, contrasting with global hotspots, though historical graveyards continue to pose long-term contamination risks from untreated wrecks.

Western Europe

Western Europe's ship graveyards primarily feature deliberately grounded vessels for coastal protection or decommissioned naval hulls held pending dismantlement, contrasting with Asia's large-scale industrial scrapping. Strict environmental regulations and high labor costs limit extensive beaching operations, resulting in fewer but historically significant sites concentrated in the UK and France. These locations preserve remnants of commercial and military maritime history, often visible along riverbanks or estuaries. The Purton Hulks in , , constitute mainland Britain's largest ship graveyard, comprising around 86 abandoned vessels beached along a two-mile stretch of the River Severn's . Following a riverbank that threatened the adjacent , authorities began run-aground in , positioning obsolete barges, trows, and warships to reinforce the eroding mudflats against tidal scour. The fleet includes wooden Severn trows from the early 20th century, steel barges, and concrete vessels constructed during World Wars I and II for wartime shortages; many now partially buried and decaying, they continue to stabilize the shoreline despite natural deterioration. In Brittany, France, the Landévennec naval ship cemetery lies in a sheltered meander of the Aulne River near Brest, housing decommissioned French Navy vessels withdrawn from service and awaiting scrapping or disposal. Established as a low-cost storage site for disarmed ships, it contains hulls from World War II through the Cold War, including frigates like the Commandant l'Hermite (scrapped in 2016) and destroyers, often shrouded in fog for a spectral appearance. The site reflects France's naval decommissioning practices, with vessels towed here post-2000 to avoid active harbor maintenance costs, though gradual removal occurs under EU environmental standards. Smaller collections exist elsewhere, such as the boat cemetery at Camaret-sur-Mer in , , where decaying fishing vessels line the harbor, and the two sunken barges at Hamburg-Blankenese in , remnants of post-war inland navigation abandoned in the shallows. These sites underscore Western Europe's emphasis on regulated abandonment over unregulated breaking, prioritizing habitat integration and historical preservation amid rising levels.

Northern Europe

Northern European ship scrapping operations, concentrated in , and , prioritize environmental compliance, worker , and material recovery under regulations and the Hong Kong International Convention for the and Environmentally of Ships, which entered into in 2013. These facilities handle a fraction of global tonnage compared to Asian yards—Europe's total approved capacity is around 1.4 million light displacement tons (LDT) across 23 yards as of 2018—due to higher labor costs and stringent standards that mandate hazardous waste removal before dismantling. Denmark hosts several prominent sites, including Fornaes Ship Recycling at the Port of on Jutland's eastern , which focuses on scrapping vessels through controlled cutting and processes, emphasizing recovery for . Fayard A/S and facilities in Frederikshavn, such as those operated by Smedegaarden A/S and Modern American Services, also conduct dismantling, achieving near-total recycling while adhering to EU pre-approval for ship imports. These operations recycle up to 98% of a vessel's components, with hazardous materials like asbestos and oils disposed of via certified handlers, contrasting with less regulated global practices. In Norway, scrapping occurs at specialized yards like in and sites in , including Vats, where the largest (FPSO) vessel to date began in 2022—a 235-meter-long unit loaded for dismantling, marking a in handling complex offshore structures. Hanøytangen has processed vessels such as the Hordafor IV in 2025, with processes involving full decommissioning, component salvage, and compliance with Norwegian Pollution Control Act requirements for zero-discharge operations. Recent initiatives, including partnerships by Höegh Autoliners with Nordic Circles in 2025, aim to upcycle decommissioned ships into certified construction materials, supported by seven EU-approved Norwegian yards. Finland's Repair Yard Ltd. contributes to regional capacity, performing repairs and scrapping under environmental protocols that minimize heavy metal leaching into waterways. Overall, Northern Europe's model reflects a shift toward sustainable practices, driven by rather than , with lists updated in 2023 to include 38 European facilities, though economic pressures often lead flagged ships to be exported for breaking elsewhere.

North America

North America's ship graveyards primarily consist of regulated scrapping and recycling facilities rather than the vast beaching operations common in South Asia, driven by strict environmental laws under frameworks like the U.S. Resource Conservation and Recovery Act and Canada's Basel Convention implementation. These sites handle decommissioned vessels, including military surplus and commercial ships, with operations emphasizing hazardous material containment to mitigate pollution risks. Unlike unregulated global hotspots, North American yards recycle up to 98% of a ship's steel while complying with international standards, such as EU approvals for select U.S. facilities. Activity remains limited in scale, processing fewer than 100 large vessels annually across the continent, compared to thousands in Asia.

United States

The hosts the continent's most prominent shipbreaking hub at the of Brownsville, , operational since the early and now home to three major facilities: Metals, International Shipbreaking Ltd. (ISL)/EMR, and SteelCoast. ISL, for instance, became the only U.S. site EU-approved for in , dismantling vessels like the USS Bonhomme Richard in after a rendered it unsalvageable. These yards process supertankers, aircraft carriers, and offshore structures, yielding millions of tons of scrap steel annually; Brownsville alone handled over 20 large ships in 2022. Methods involve dry-docking or floating sheerlegs for cutting, with asbestos and oil removed under EPA oversight to prevent releases. In the Northeast, Staten Island, New York, serves as a graveyard for smaller vessels like tugs and barges, with clusters of hulks moored along the waterway since the mid-20th century. This site, visible from shores, stores derelict craft awaiting piecemeal dismantling amid urban industrial decay, though federal regulations have curtailed expansion due to waterway navigation hazards. Historical precedents include San Francisco's late-1800s yard, where Gold Rush-era sailing ships were broken for timber and iron, but modern operations prioritize for its deep-water access and lower costs. Other areas, like Mallows Bay, Maryland, feature preserved WWI wooden "Ghost Fleet" wrecks scuttled in the 1920s, now a national park rather than active scrapping ground.

Canada

Canada's ship recycling capacity is nascent and regionally concentrated, with only two operational sites on the East Coast as of 2025, handling mostly domestic derelict vessels under Transport Canada's guidelines. Marine Recycling Corporation in Port Colborne, Ontario, focuses on smaller craft, dismantling hulls for scrap while managing pollutants like PCBs, though output remains under 10 vessels yearly. On the West Coast, Union Bay, British Columbia, hosted Deep Water Recovery's operations from 2020, targeting abandoned fishing boats and barges, but faced revocation of water access in July 2025 over unpermitted hazardous waste handling and community pollution complaints from the K'ómoks First Nation. Emerging proposals include for expanded West Coast facilities, leveraging dry docks for , and Bull , Newfoundland, eyed for attracting international . These efforts address thousands of in Canadian waters—estimated at over 25,000—but prioritize removal over large-scale breaking due to bans on exporting hazardous ships. Historical sites like Royston, , preserve 14 sunk as breakwaters in the early , serving ecological rather than industrial roles today. Regulatory gaps have sparked NGO , emphasizing to avoid Asia-style environmental shortcuts.

United States

The Port of Brownsville in Texas serves as the primary hub for commercial ship recycling in the United States, handling the dismantling of decommissioned naval vessels, merchant ships, and offshore structures. Located along the Brownsville Ship Channel approximately 15 miles inland from the Gulf of Mexico, the port features multiple facilities operated by companies including ESCO Marine, International Shipbreaking Limited, Marine Metals, and All-Star Metals. These yards have collectively dismantled over 500 ships, with capabilities to process vessels up to 1,000 feet in length, and the port secures over 85% of U.S. Navy and Maritime Administration (MARAD) ship recycling contracts as of 2022. In the mid-Atlantic region, ship breaking activities have historically centered on the James River Reserve Fleet near Fort Eustis, Virginia, known as the "Ghost Fleet." This reserve once comprised over 800 World War II-era vessels, including cargo ships, cruisers, destroyers, and aircraft carriers, but by 2010, fewer than 25 remained, with most towed to nearby yards like Bay Bridge Enterprises in Chesapeake, Virginia, for scrapping. Bay Bridge, acquired by the Adani Group in 2005, specialized in federal reserve ships and contributed significantly to reducing the fleet from 107 ships in 2001 through environmentally regulated dismantling processes. Mallows Bay on the Potomac River in Maryland hosts the largest concentration of wooden shipwrecks in the , with remnants of over 100 World War I-era steamships and schooners scuttled after the war due to obsolescence. Constructed hastily for wartime needs but rendered surplus by 1919, these vessels were burned en masse on November 7, 1925—the largest single-time destruction of ships in U.S. history—and their hulks left in shallow waters, forming an artificial reef ecosystem. Designated a National Marine Sanctuary in 2019, the site preserves these skeletal remains without active scrapping, emphasizing ecological and historical value over salvage. The in the , Rossville, New York, functions as a marine scrapyard specializing in tugs, barges, ferries, and wooden vessels, established in the 1930s by John J. Witte and still operational under . Featuring dozens of rusting hulls from to paddlewheelers, the private facility processes smaller through beaching and disassembly, visible from adjacent shores or by but restricted on . Unlike larger ocean-going scrapping sites, it focuses on regional inland and harbor vessels, contributing to metal recovery without the scale of Brownsville operations.

Canada

Canada's shipbreaking industry is compared to global hubs in , with operations emphasizing environmental compliance and worker under stringent federal and provincial regulations. The primary facility is Marine (MRC) in Port Colborne, , on the , which operational since and holds the distinction of being the world's oldest continuously active shipbreaking yard. MRC specializes in dismantling lakers and other vessels, having recycled over 100 ships for recovery, including recent projects like the bulk carriers St. Clair and Manistee in 2022, and the Algoma Transport in 2024. The yard adheres to ISO 14001 environmental standards, employing methods such as cold cutting with plasma torches and oxy-acetylene to minimize pollution, contrasting with beaching techniques prevalent elsewhere. A secondary site operated in Union Bay, , by Deep Water Recovery Ltd. from 2020, focused on dismantling derelict barges and smaller vessels at a former log-sort yard but drew international scrutiny for inadequate hazardous material handling and potential releases. The operation processed several vessels, including fishing boats and tugs, but lacked full regulatory oversight for large-scale shipbreaking, leading to protests from NGOs like the Shipbreaking Platform over risks to marine ecosystems and worker safety. In August 2025, authorities canceled the Crown land lease, halting activities due to environmental violations and non-compliance with waste management laws. Military vessel disposal has occurred at sites like Sydney, Nova Scotia, where Irving Shipbuilding dismantled the destroyer HMCS Athabaskan starting in 2017, following federal procurement guidelines for secure scrapping. As of 2025, Canada has only two active east-coast recycling operations, prompting initiatives to develop west-coast capacity in Port Alberni, Vancouver Island, to handle growing demand from Pacific fleets amid Basel Convention restrictions on exporting hazardous ships. These efforts aim to localize dismantling, reducing reliance on foreign yards while meeting EU-like standards for toxic substance removal prior to export.

Other Regions

In Africa, the of in contains one of the world's largest assemblages of abandoned ships, with estimates exceeding vessels—predominantly European and n fishing trawlers—left to rust and decay since the late 1980s. These accumulations resulted from overexploited fisheries, high operational costs, and lax enforcement against illegal vessel disposal, transforming the coastal bay into a de facto graveyard spanning several kilometers. Unlike active shipbreaking sites in , features no systematic dismantling; ships remain intact hulls exposed to tides and corrosion, posing navigational hazards and contributing to marine debris. Ghana hosts informal shipbreaking operations along its Atlantic shores, particularly near and Prampram, where end-of-life vessels are beached and manually scrapped without consistent regulatory oversight. These activities, involving cutting torches and rudimentary labor, hazardous materials like asbestos, oils, and into coastal ecosystems, as documented in environmental assessments from 2022. Licensing occurs through the Maritime , but gaps allow from untreated , affecting fisheries and in adjacent communities. South Africa is developing Africa's first certified green ship recycling facility at 34South on its west coast, announced in 2021, designed to comply with standards for safe dismantling and . This initiative aims to process larger vessels using dry-dock methods rather than beaching, reducing environmental risks associated with tidal operations; construction targets operational status by the mid-2020s, positioning it as a compliant alternative amid global scrutiny of substandard yards. In Oceania, commercial shipbreaking remains minimal due to stringent environmental regulations and high labor costs, with most regional vessels exported to Asian yards for scrapping; , for instance, dismantled fewer than 10 large ships domestically in 2023. Historical graveyards persist, such as in 's , where obsolete vessels from the early were broken up on mudflats, leaving remnants visible as of 2024. Similarly, the Victorian Ships Graveyard off features scuttled hulls from the 1920s–1940s, now artificial reefs rather than active scrap sites, supporting marine biodiversity but not industrial recycling. Pacific islands like in harbor extensive World War II-era wrecks—over 60 Japanese vessels sunk in 1944—functioning as submerged graveyards preserved for diving and historical study, without ongoing scrapping.

Africa and Oceania

In Mauritania, the Bay of Nouadhibou serves as a major repository for abandoned vessels, accumulating over 300 ships since the 1980s, primarily European and Asian fishing trawlers illegally dumped due to high decommissioning costs and lax enforcement. These rusting hulks, often exceeding 50 meters in length, litter the coastal waters and shoreline, posing navigational hazards and releasing contaminants like heavy metals and oils into the marine environment. Efforts to clear the site have been limited; by 2021, only partial removals occurred under international pressure, leaving the majority intact as a de facto graveyard. Shipbreaking activities in Africa remain limited compared to South Asia, with sites in Ghana's Kpone area involving beaching methods that release pollutants such as marine oils, depleting local fish stocks and contaminating sediments. In Angola, the Ship's Cemetery near Luanda features rusting wrecks along remote beaches, remnants of wartime abandonments and post-colonial scrapping, though not a primary industrial site. South Africa hosts historical wrecks at , Africa's southernmost point, where over a dozen 19th- and 20th-century vessels lie scattered due to treacherous currents, alongside emerging regulated facilities like the proposed 34South yard aiming for EU-compliant green recycling. Namibia's Skeleton Coast also preserves natural wreck sites from fog-induced strandings, with notable 20th-century losses like the Dunlop in 1943, but lacks organized breaking operations. In , ship graveyards primarily consist of intentionally scuttled hulks repurposed as breakwaters or artificial reefs, rather than scrapping hubs. Australia's region encompasses multiple sites, including Island Ships' Graveyard with over vessels sunk between the and to stabilize channels, such as the Ferdinand () and Ina (). The graveyard off holds 47 documented from the 19th and 20th centuries, scuttled for or disposal, including the McClary (). 's Tangalooma Wrecks, formed by 15 deliberately sunk vessels in the to create a tourist reef near , now support diverse marine life while preserving hulls like the collier Walrus. New Zealand features several historical abandonment sites, notably Rangitoto Island's Wreck Bay with 13 ships dumped from 1887 to 1947, including the steamer Waihora (1882 wreck) and barges used as quarantine hulks, now colonized by intertidal ecosystems. Ōtamahua (Quail Island) in Lyttelton Harbour contains remnants of more than a dozen vessels from the early 20th century, scuttled for harbor works or after service in Antarctic expeditions. These sites reflect colonial-era practices of economical disposal amid limited industrial scrapping infrastructure, with modern regulations prohibiting unregulated dumping in favor of controlled artificial reefs.

Environmental and Ecological Effects

Pollutant Release and Long-Term Contamination

Ship breaking operations release a variety of hazardous pollutants into air, soil, sediment, and water, primarily through mechanical cutting, burning, and dismantling processes that expose and mobilize toxic materials embedded in ship structures. These include polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) from insulation, paints, and cables; asbestos from insulation and fireproofing; heavy metals such as lead, mercury, cadmium, and chromium from paints, batteries, and alloys; persistent hydrocarbons like polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and total petroleum hydrocarbons (PHCs); and residual oils, fuels, and toxic compounds from ballasts and coatings. A single large vessel can contain hundreds of tonnes of PCB-contaminated materials and up to 7.5 tonnes of asbestos, with thousands of liters of oils released during scrapping. In beach-based ship graveyards, such as Alang in India, the grounding and tidal exposure of hulls facilitate direct leaching and runoff of these contaminants into coastal waters and sediments, amplified by oxyacetylene cutting that generates airborne particulates and slag. Studies at Alang have documented elevated heavy metal concentrations in suspended particulate matter, with seasonal peaks in PHCs and PAHs in seawater attributable to monsoon-driven dispersion and deposition. Similarly, at Gadani in Pakistan, systematic sampling reveals significantly higher heavy metal levels in yard soils and nearby waters compared to reference sites, indicating localized hotspots from incomplete material recovery. Long-term contamination persists due to the bioaccumulative and persistent nature of many pollutants, particularly PCBs and , which bind to sediments and enter marine food webs, leading to trophic magnification in and . Soil analyses near mega-scale yards show metal/loid enrichment affecting crop quality and posing ingestion risks to local populations via contaminated and produce. Sediments in these areas exhibit chronic toxicity, with POPs causing delayed ecological effects like reproductive impairment in benthic organisms and biomagnification in predators, as evidenced by multi-year monitoring linking shipbreaking inputs to elevated tissue burdens in coastal biota. Regulatory gaps in developing-nation sites exacerbate persistence, as incomplete hazardous waste segregation allows diffuse releases that resist natural attenuation over decades. ![Shipwrecking in Alang, India, 2017][float-right]

### Marine Ecosystem Interactions ![Shipwrecks in Camaret-sur-Mer][float-right] Shipwrecks in marine environments, including those forming graveyards, serve as artificial substrates that facilitate colonization by epibenthic organisms such as [algae](/page/Algae), [barnacles](/page/Barnacle), and corals, thereby creating complex habitats that enhance [local](/page/.local) [biodiversity](/page/Biodiversity).[](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10831220/) Studies indicate that these structures support higher abundances and biomasses of reef-associated [fish](/page/Fish) compared to adjacent soft-bottom habitats, functioning similarly to natural reefs by providing [shelter](/page/Shelter) and foraging sites.[](https://coastalscience.noaa.gov/project/assessing-the-ecological-function-of-shipwrecks-artificial-reefs-and-rocky-reefs-on-the-southeastern-us-continental-shelf/) For instance, research on southeastern U.S. [continental shelf](/page/Continental_shelf) wrecks demonstrates elevated densities of [predatory fish](/page/Predatory_fish) [species](/page/Species), contributing to trophic [complexity](/page/Complexity) within the [ecosystem](/page/Ecosystem).[](https://nicholas.duke.edu/news/artificial-reefs-take-towering-presence-havens-marine-predators) In contrast, active shipbreaking yards, such as [Alang](/page/Alang) in [India](/page/India), introduce persistent contaminants including [heavy metals](/page/Heavy_metals), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) that leach into coastal waters, adversely affecting marine biota.[](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0025326X25005740) Empirical data from [Alang](/page/Alang) reveal elevated levels of these pollutants in sediments and [seawater](/page/Seawater), correlating with reduced [phytoplankton](/page/Phytoplankton) and [zooplankton](/page/Zooplankton) populations essential to the [food web](/page/Food_web).[](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/373660356_Emerging_Pollutants_in_the_Marine_Coastal_Environment_of_the_World%27s_Largest_Ship_Breaking_Yard-Alang_India) These toxins bioaccumulate in benthic organisms and [fish](/page/Fish), disrupting reproductive cycles and inducing physiological stress, with long-term alterations to coastal [habitat](/page/Habitat) physiochemistry documented in multiple assessments.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/our-work/the-problem/environmental-costs/) While decommissioned wrecks can mitigate habitat loss in degraded areas by acting as de facto artificial reefs—evidenced by increased megafauna presence like sharks and mackerels—their ecological value diminishes if initial pollution from sinking events smothers underlying seagrass or coral.[](https://ocean.si.edu/ecosystems/coral-reefs/when-wrecks-become-reefs) In shipbreaking contexts, the beaching method exacerbates sediment contamination, leading to biodiversity declines in adjacent fisheries, as observed in Gujarat where dozens of aquatic species exhibit impaired growth and survival.[](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0025326X86908362) Overall, interactions hinge on wreck age, material integrity, and site management, with peer-reviewed surveys underscoring the need for containment to prevent net negative impacts.[](https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/74/1/12/7479881) ## Socioeconomic Dimensions ### Economic Contributions and Employment The shipbreaking industry, primarily operating in large-scale graveyards in [South Asia](/page/South_Asia), generates substantial economic value through the [recycling](/page/Recycling) of [steel](/page/Steel) and other metals, supplying raw materials to domestic industries and reducing import dependencies. Globally, the market was valued at USD 3.98 billion in 2023, with projections for growth to USD 7.64 billion by 2032, driven by [demand](/page/Demand) for scrap [steel](/page/Steel) in [construction](/page/Construction) and [manufacturing](/page/Manufacturing) sectors.[](https://www.fortunebusinessinsights.com/ship-breaking-market-108231) In [Bangladesh](/page/Bangladesh), a key hub, the sector contributes Tk 1,200 to 1,400 crore annually in government revenue via import duties, VAT, taxes, and supplementary duties on scrapped materials.[](https://www.tbsnews.net/supplement/how-shipbreaking-contributing-bangladeshs-economy-978836) Employment in these graveyards predominantly involves manual labor for dismantling, cutting, and [material](/page/Material) sorting, attracting migrant workers from rural areas due to the availability of entry-level jobs requiring minimal skills. In Bangladesh's Chittagong yards, estimates from NGO and World Bank studies indicate direct [employment](/page/Employment) of 22,000 to 50,000 workers, alongside indirect jobs in transportation, [steel](/page/Steel) re-rolling mills, and ancillary services like [welding](/page/Welding) and fabrication.[](https://cbe.miis.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1110&context=joce) These operations support local economies by providing livelihoods in regions with [limited](/page/The_Limited) industrial alternatives, though wages remain low and tied to piece-rate systems based on [tonnage](/page/Tonnage) processed.[](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S294973612300057X) In India's Alang yard, the largest globally, economic activity has shown recovery, with a 13% increase in end-of-life ship arrivals reported in early 2025, boosting local scrap supply chains and associated revenues from material sales.[](https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/logistics/alang-ship-breaking-yard-in-gujarat-sniffs-recovery-records-13-rise-in-ship-arrivals/article70079283.ece) The industry's output feeds re-rolling mills, which produce reinforcement bars and other steel products, contributing to infrastructure development and foreign exchange savings by substituting imported steel.[](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1462901116300569) Overall, ship graveyards in developing economies sustain a recycling ecosystem that enhances material circularity, though benefits accrue unevenly, with primary value captured by yard owners and downstream processors.[](https://www.idpublications.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/Full-Paper-IMPACTS-OF-SHIPBREAKING-INDUSTRY-IN-BANGLADESH-SEARCH-FOR-A-SUSTAINABLE-SOLUTION.pdf) ### Global Supply Chain Dynamics The global [supply chain](/page/Supply_chain) for ship scrapping involves the transnational movement of end-of-life vessels from ship-owning nations—predominantly in [Europe](/page/Europe), [East Asia](/page/East_Asia), and [North America](/page/North_America)—to dismantling yards concentrated in [South Asia](/page/South_Asia) and parts of the [Middle East](/page/Middle_East), driven by differentials in labor costs, regulatory stringency, and [scrap](/page/Scrap) [material](/page/Material) [demand](/page/Demand).[](https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2019/04/ship-recycling_a64c6a7b/397de00c-en.pdf) Ship owners, facing high decommissioning expenses in [home](/page/Home) ports [due](/page/A_due) to stringent environmental and [safety](/page/Safety) standards, [export](/page/Export) vessels to facilities in [Bangladesh](/page/Bangladesh), [India](/page/India), and [Pakistan](/page/Pakistan), where beaching methods enable low-cost breaking amid weaker [enforcement](/page/Enforcement) of international norms.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/platform-publishes-list-2024/) This flow peaked in [efficiency](/page/Efficiency) during periods of [steel](/page/Steel) market booms, as recycled ship [steel](/page/Steel)—constituting [up to](/page/Up_to) 90-95% of a vessel's mass—feeds global mills, reducing reliance on virgin ore amid rising circular economy pressures.[](https://blog.bccresearch.com/global-ship-recycling-market-turning-end-of-life-vessels-into-a-circular-opportunity) In 2024, 409 ships were dismantled worldwide, with 255 (over 62%) processed in South Asian yards, [accounting](/page/Accounting) for approximately 80% of global scrapped [tonnage](/page/Tonnage) under substandard conditions characterized by tidal beaching and minimal waste containment.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/platform-publishes-list-2024/) [Bangladesh](/page/Bangladesh) emerged as the preferred destination, handling the largest volume despite periodic bans on imports, followed by [India](/page/India) and [Pakistan](/page/Pakistan); [China](/page/China) and [Turkey](/page/Turkey) captured the [remainder](/page/Remainder), often for smaller or state-owned vessels.[](https://safety4sea.com/80-of-global-tonnage-is-scrapped-under-substandard-conditions/) Leading exporters included [China](/page/China), which sent over 50 vessels to South Asian breakers, reflecting state-owned fleet renewals, alongside [Greece](/page/Greece) and Panama-flagged ships from European owners seeking to offload aging bulk carriers and tankers.[](https://www.brookesbell.com/news-and-knowledge/article/data-reveals-majority-of-global-tonnage-scrapped-under-substandard-conditions-159353/) These dynamics illustrate regulatory [arbitrage](/page/Arbitrage), where OECD-country bans on domestic scrapping since the 1980s shifted 70-80% of the market to non-OECD sites, sustaining a $9.1 billion industry in 2025 projected to reach $13 billion by 2030 through scrap demand in construction and automotive sectors.[](https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/ship-recycling-market-report-2025-081200920.html)[](https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/15/7/5919) Material recovery integrates scrapping into broader supply chains, yielding ferrous scrap (70-80% of vessel weight), non-ferrous metals, and reusable components that circumvent tariffs on primary metals via secondary markets.[](https://www.transparencymarketresearch.com/ship-breaking-market.html) However, supply volatility arises from freight rate cycles—e.g., high rates in 2021-2022 delayed scrapping, creating backlogs—and geopolitical factors, such as EU carbon regulations pushing cleaner but costlier dry-dock methods in Turkey over Asian beaches.[](https://www.ics-shipping.org/news-item/ics-leadership-insights-live-ship-recycling-round-up/) Empirical data from UNCTAD indicates Asia dominates both vessel supply (over 50% of global tonnage origins) and recycling capacity, perpetuating a north-south trade imbalance where developed economies externalize end-of-life management costs estimated at $200-500 per light displacement ton in Asia versus $1,000+ in Europe.[](https://unctadstat.unctad.org/datacentre/dataviewer/US.ShipScrapping) This structure, while economically rational for owners under first-principles cost minimization, underscores causal tensions between short-term recycling efficiencies and long-term externalities in pollution and labor risks borne by importing regions.[](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0308597X24002203) ## Controversies and Regulatory Frameworks ### Labor Conditions and Safety Records ![Shipwrecking in Alang, India, 2017](./_assets_/Shipwrecking_in_Alang%252C_India%252C_2017-03-17_by_Planet_Labs.jpg) Shipbreaking operations in major yards such as [Alang](/page/Alang), [India](/page/India), and Chattogram, Bangladesh, predominantly rely on manual labor under hazardous conditions, with workers dismantling vessels using rudimentary tools like torches and hammers without consistent provision of [personal protective equipment](/page/Personal_protective_equipment) (PPE).[](https://www.ilo.org/resource/other/ship-breaking-hazardous-work) Exposure to toxic substances including [asbestos](/page/Asbestos), [heavy metals](/page/Heavy_metals), and oil residues occurs routinely, contributing to acute injuries and chronic health issues such as respiratory diseases and cancer among workers.[](https://annalsofglobalhealth.org/en/articles/10.5334/aogh.4735) Migrant laborers, often from rural areas, endure long hours—typically 12 or more per day—low wages averaging $2-5 daily, and inadequate [housing](/page/Housing) in makeshift camps lacking [sanitation](/page/Sanitation).[](https://www.shipbreakingplatform.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Policy-Brief-TISS-Working-Conditions-ASSBY-2019.pdf) Safety records reflect elevated risks, particularly in beaching yards where ships are grounded on intertidal zones and cut apart piecemeal, leading to frequent falls, crush injuries from collapsing [steel](/page/Steel) plates, and explosions from residual fuels.[](https://www.industriall-union.org/cleaning-up-ship-breaking-the-worlds-most-dangerous-job) In Alang, at least 14 workers died in 2018 from such accidents, marking one of the yard's deadliest years on record, while 10 fatalities occurred in 2014 alone, primarily from falling debris.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/platform-publishes-list-2018/)[](https://ejatlas.org/conflict/dirty-and-dangerous-shipbreaking-in-alang) Chattogram yards reported 257 [deaths](/page/2022_in_anime) and numerous injuries from 2005 to 2024, with an annual average exceeding 13 fatalities in recent years, often due to absent safety harnesses and [fire suppression systems](/page/Fire_suppression_system).[](https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/news/257-lives-lost-accidents-over-last-2-decades-3696906)[](https://www.tbsnews.net/economy/industry/over-13-workers-die-year-bangladeshs-shipbreaking-industry-760538) Across South Asian yards including Pakistan's Gadani, at least 470 workers have died and 512 suffered severe injuries since 2009, underscoring the industry's status as one of the world's most perilous occupations per International Labour Organization assessments.[](https://courthousenews.com/new-rules-may-not-change-dirty-and-deadly-ship-recycling-business/)[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/our-work/the-problem/human-costs/) Efforts to mitigate risks, such as India's adoption of [Hong Kong](/page/Hong_Kong) Convention-aligned standards in over 115 [Alang](/page/Alang) yards by 2025, have yielded partial compliance but minimal gains in on-site conditions, as evidenced by persistent reports of bypassed [safety](/page/Safety) protocols and underreporting of incidents.[](https://www.industriall-union.org/lives-saved-ships-broken-the-human-cost-and-promise-of-ship-recycling) In contrast, regulated yards in developed nations like the [United States](/page/United_States) exhibit fatality rates orders of magnitude lower, attributable to enforced [mechanization](/page/Mechanization), PPE mandates, and environmental controls, though they process far less tonnage [due](/page/A_due) to higher costs.[](https://www.maritimeinjuryguide.org/blog/maritime-accidents-injuries-ship-breakers/) NGO monitoring, while valuable for aggregating local [data](/page/Data), draws from activist coalitions whose emphasis on worst-case examples may amplify [visibility](/page/Visibility) of non-compliance without fully [accounting](/page/Accounting) for incremental regulatory [enforcement](/page/Enforcement).[](https://www.equaltimes.org/death-injury-and-disease-the) ### International Conventions and Enforcement Challenges The primary international framework governing ship recycling is the Hong Kong International Convention for the [Safe](/page/Safe) and Environmentally [Sound](/page/Sound) Recycling of Ships, adopted by the [International Maritime Organization](/page/International_Maritime_Organization) (IMO) in 2009 and entering into force on June 26, 2025, after ratification by 15 countries representing more than 40% of global merchant shipping tonnage by gross tonnage.[](https://www.imo.org/en/mediacentre/pressbriefings/pages/hong-kong-convention-entry-into-force.aspx) The convention mandates requirements such as an [Inventory](/page/Inventory) of Hazardous Materials (IHM) for ships over 500 gross tons, Ship Recycling Facility Plans, and authorization of recycling yards to minimize risks from hazardous substances like [asbestos](/page/Asbestos), PCBs, and [heavy metals](/page/Heavy_metals) during dismantling.[](https://www.dnv.com/news/2025/hong-kong-convention-and-how-to-obtain-ihm-certification-for-ship-recycling/) It builds on earlier IMO Guidelines for Ship Recycling adopted in 2003, which emphasized safe practices but lacked binding force.[](https://www.imo.org/en/mediacentre/hottopics/pages/recycling-of-ships-and-hong-kong-convention.aspx) Complementing the HKC is the Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal, effective since [1992](/page/1992), which classifies end-of-life ships containing hazardous materials as "wastes" subject to prior [informed consent](/page/Informed_consent) and [export](/page/Export) bans to non-consenting parties, particularly developing nations.[](https://www.basel.int/Implementation/ShipDismantling/Overview/tabid/2762/Default.aspx) This application creates jurisdictional overlaps, as ships flagged in HKC parties may still require Basel notifications if destined for non-party yards, complicating exports from regions like the [European Union](/page/European_Union) where stricter interpretations prevail.[](https://www.bimco.org/regulatory-affairs/our-regulatory-work/insights/current-status-on-ship-recycling/) Enforcement faces systemic hurdles, including incomplete [ratification](/page/Ratification)—major scrapping hubs like [India](/page/India) and [Pakistan](/page/Pakistan) have delayed full [implementation](/page/Implementation) despite economic reliance on the industry—and a [shortage](/page/Shortage) of compliant facilities, with only around 30 yards globally meeting HKC standards as of mid-2025, potentially causing recycling backlogs and higher costs estimated at up to 20-30% per vessel for IHM certification and surveys.[](https://www.hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2025/09/the-impact-of-the-hong-kong-convention-on-ship-recycling-3-months-in) [Flag](/page/Flag) states, often those of convenience with limited oversight, bear primary responsibility for compliance, yet port state controls and on-site audits remain inconsistent, exacerbated by beaching methods in [South Asia](/page/South_Asia) that evade dry-dock requirements and enable unreported hazardous releases.[](https://www.qrsclass.org/hong-kong-convention-ship-recycling-regulatory-challenges-facing-the-industry/) Conflicts between HKC's ship-focused approach and Basel's [waste](/page/Waste) regime have led to legal deadlocks, such as EU prohibitions on exporting to non-HKC beaches, while weak local governance, corruption, and industry lobbying in host countries undermine yard authorizations and worker protections.[](https://www.rivieramm.com/news-content-hub/news-content-hub/deadlock-after-hong-kong-convention-threatens-global-ship-recycling-85710) Non-governmental organizations argue the HKC's thresholds for hazardous materials are insufficiently stringent, permitting practices that perpetuate environmental contamination despite its entry into force.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/hkc-fails-to-ensure-sustainable-ship-recycling/) Overall, while the conventions establish global baselines, their efficacy hinges on enhanced monitoring, capacity-building in developing states, and harmonization efforts, with initial post-2025 data indicating persistent non-compliance in over 90% of global tonnage recycled outside approved facilities.[](https://www.bimco.org/regulatory-affairs/our-regulatory-work/insights/current-status-on-ship-recycling/) ### Debates on Outsourcing to Developing Nations ![Shipwrecking in Alang, India, 2017](./_assets_/Shipwrecking_in_Alang%252C_India%252C_2017-03-17_by_Planet_Labs.jpg) Outsourcing of shipbreaking to developing nations, primarily in [South Asia](/page/South_Asia) such as [India](/page/India), [Bangladesh](/page/Bangladesh), and [Pakistan](/page/Pakistan), arises from stringent environmental and labor regulations in developed countries that render domestic scrapping economically unviable. Facilities like [Alang](/page/Alang) in [India](/page/India) handle approximately 30% of the global ship [recycling](/page/Recycling) market as of 2020, processing thousands of vessels annually and generating foreign exchange through [steel](/page/Steel) recovery and [scrap](/page/Scrap) exports.[](https://www.macrothink.org/journal/index.php/ijssr/article/download/22624/17408) This practice allows shipowners from [Europe](/page/Europe) and [North America](/page/North_America) to offload end-of-life vessels to yards offering lower labor costs—often $1-2 per day—and minimal regulatory oversight, thereby reducing disposal expenses that can exceed millions in compliant facilities.[](https://cpr.usm.my/images/Working%2520Paper%25202009/Working%2520Paper%25202010/CenPRIS%2520Working%2520Paper%2520No.%2520132%252010.pdf) Proponents argue that outsourcing sustains vital economic activity in impoverished regions, where shipbreaking yards employ tens of thousands of workers and supply recycled steel critical for local construction and manufacturing. In Alang, the industry has dismantled over 8,000 ships since 1982, supporting migrant labor from across India and contributing to regional GDP through direct jobs, ancillary services, and material reuse that offsets virgin steel imports.[](https://annalsofglobalhealth.org/en/articles/10.5334/aogh.4735) Similarly, yards in Bangladesh and Pakistan drive employment in coastal economies, with the sector positioned as a comparative advantage for nations lacking advanced industries but possessing abundant low-skilled labor.[](https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/shipbreaking-salvage-industry-driving-jobs-foreign-growth-simmonds-bgfce) Advocates, including industry groups and some developing country governments, contend that prohibiting such trade would exacerbate poverty without viable alternatives, emphasizing that revenues fund infrastructure and that recent upgrades in Alang—such as improved beaching techniques and waste containment—demonstrate progress toward sustainability.[](https://maritimeindia.org/sustainable-ship-recycling-in-india-social-technological-and-environmental-analysis/) Critics, often from environmental NGOs and human rights organizations, highlight the outsourcing of pollution and hazards, framing it as "toxic colonialism" where developed nations evade responsibility by exporting vessels laden with asbestos, PCBs, and heavy metals to sites with inadequate safeguards. Reports document frequent accidents, including at least 10 worker deaths in Alang in 2014 from falls, crushing, and toxic exposures, alongside chronic health issues like respiratory diseases among unprotected laborers.[](https://ejatlas.org/conflict/dirty-and-dangerous-shipbreaking-in-alang)[](https://www.shipbreakingplatform.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Policy-Brief-TISS-Working-Conditions-ASSBY-2019.pdf) These groups argue that lax enforcement perpetuates a cycle of exploitation, with studies estimating disproportionate environmental contamination in coastal ecosystems near yards.[](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27424206/) Central to the [debate](/page/Debate) is the tension between international frameworks like the [Basel Convention](/page/Basel_Convention), which classifies end-of-life ships as [hazardous waste](/page/Hazardous_waste) requiring prior [informed consent](/page/Informed_consent) for transboundary movement, and industry preferences for the Hong Kong Convention's focus on safe [recycling](/page/Recycling) practices without export bans. Enforcement challenges persist, as shipowners circumvent Basel controls via flags of convenience or misdeclarations of trading status, leading to [630](/page/630) commercial vessels dismantled in substandard yards in [2020](/page/2020) alone.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/issues-of-interest/the-law/basel-convention/)[](https://www.politico.eu/article/clash-of-conventions-why-new-regulation-scrapping-ships-worrying-industry/)[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/platform-publishes-list-2020/) While some analyses question the convention's [efficacy](/page/Efficacy) in protecting developing nations—citing unintended barriers to legitimate [trade](/page/Trade)—others assert that stronger adherence could compel [cleaner](/page/Cleaner) practices without halting economic flows.[](https://earth.org/how-the-basel-convention-has-harmed-developing-countries/)[](https://maritime-executive.com/editorials/breaking-ships-building-consensus-how-the-basel-ban-and-hkc-can-coexist) Empirical assessments [underscore](/page/Underscore) that, absent comprehensive global standards, [outsourcing](/page/Outsourcing) debates [hinge](/page/Hinge) on balancing immediate livelihood gains against long-term human and ecological costs, with source credibility varying between NGO-driven alarmism and industry-optimistic reports.[](https://insight.dickinsonlaw.psu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1542&context=psilr&httpsredir=1&referer=)

### Marine Ecosystem Interactions ![Shipwrecks in Camaret-sur-Mer][float-right] Shipwrecks in marine environments, including those forming graveyards, serve as artificial substrates that facilitate colonization by epibenthic organisms such as [algae](/page/Algae), [barnacles](/page/Barnacle), and corals, thereby creating complex habitats that enhance [local](/page/.local) [biodiversity](/page/Biodiversity).[](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10831220/) Studies indicate that these structures support higher abundances and biomasses of reef-associated [fish](/page/Fish) compared to adjacent soft-bottom habitats, functioning similarly to natural reefs by providing [shelter](/page/Shelter) and foraging sites.[](https://coastalscience.noaa.gov/project/assessing-the-ecological-function-of-shipwrecks-artificial-reefs-and-rocky-reefs-on-the-southeastern-us-continental-shelf/) For instance, research on southeastern U.S. [continental shelf](/page/Continental_shelf) wrecks demonstrates elevated densities of [predatory fish](/page/Predatory_fish) [species](/page/Species), contributing to trophic [complexity](/page/Complexity) within the [ecosystem](/page/Ecosystem).[](https://nicholas.duke.edu/news/artificial-reefs-take-towering-presence-havens-marine-predators) In contrast, active shipbreaking yards, such as [Alang](/page/Alang) in [India](/page/India), introduce persistent contaminants including [heavy metals](/page/Heavy_metals), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) that leach into coastal waters, adversely affecting marine biota.[](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0025326X25005740) Empirical data from [Alang](/page/Alang) reveal elevated levels of these pollutants in sediments and [seawater](/page/Seawater), correlating with reduced [phytoplankton](/page/Phytoplankton) and [zooplankton](/page/Zooplankton) populations essential to the [food web](/page/Food_web).[](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/373660356_Emerging_Pollutants_in_the_Marine_Coastal_Environment_of_the_World%27s_Largest_Ship_Breaking_Yard-Alang_India) These toxins bioaccumulate in benthic organisms and [fish](/page/Fish), disrupting reproductive cycles and inducing physiological stress, with long-term alterations to coastal [habitat](/page/Habitat) physiochemistry documented in multiple assessments.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/our-work/the-problem/environmental-costs/) While decommissioned wrecks can mitigate habitat loss in degraded areas by acting as de facto artificial reefs—evidenced by increased megafauna presence like sharks and mackerels—their ecological value diminishes if initial pollution from sinking events smothers underlying seagrass or coral.[](https://ocean.si.edu/ecosystems/coral-reefs/when-wrecks-become-reefs) In shipbreaking contexts, the beaching method exacerbates sediment contamination, leading to biodiversity declines in adjacent fisheries, as observed in Gujarat where dozens of aquatic species exhibit impaired growth and survival.[](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0025326X86908362) Overall, interactions hinge on wreck age, material integrity, and site management, with peer-reviewed surveys underscoring the need for containment to prevent net negative impacts.[](https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/74/1/12/7479881) ## Socioeconomic Dimensions ### Economic Contributions and Employment The shipbreaking industry, primarily operating in large-scale graveyards in [South Asia](/page/South_Asia), generates substantial economic value through the [recycling](/page/Recycling) of [steel](/page/Steel) and other metals, supplying raw materials to domestic industries and reducing import dependencies. Globally, the market was valued at USD 3.98 billion in 2023, with projections for growth to USD 7.64 billion by 2032, driven by [demand](/page/Demand) for scrap [steel](/page/Steel) in [construction](/page/Construction) and [manufacturing](/page/Manufacturing) sectors.[](https://www.fortunebusinessinsights.com/ship-breaking-market-108231) In [Bangladesh](/page/Bangladesh), a key hub, the sector contributes Tk 1,200 to 1,400 crore annually in government revenue via import duties, VAT, taxes, and supplementary duties on scrapped materials.[](https://www.tbsnews.net/supplement/how-shipbreaking-contributing-bangladeshs-economy-978836) Employment in these graveyards predominantly involves manual labor for dismantling, cutting, and [material](/page/Material) sorting, attracting migrant workers from rural areas due to the availability of entry-level jobs requiring minimal skills. In Bangladesh's Chittagong yards, estimates from NGO and World Bank studies indicate direct [employment](/page/Employment) of 22,000 to 50,000 workers, alongside indirect jobs in transportation, [steel](/page/Steel) re-rolling mills, and ancillary services like [welding](/page/Welding) and fabrication.[](https://cbe.miis.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1110&context=joce) These operations support local economies by providing livelihoods in regions with [limited](/page/The_Limited) industrial alternatives, though wages remain low and tied to piece-rate systems based on [tonnage](/page/Tonnage) processed.[](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S294973612300057X) In India's Alang yard, the largest globally, economic activity has shown recovery, with a 13% increase in end-of-life ship arrivals reported in early 2025, boosting local scrap supply chains and associated revenues from material sales.[](https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/logistics/alang-ship-breaking-yard-in-gujarat-sniffs-recovery-records-13-rise-in-ship-arrivals/article70079283.ece) The industry's output feeds re-rolling mills, which produce reinforcement bars and other steel products, contributing to infrastructure development and foreign exchange savings by substituting imported steel.[](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1462901116300569) Overall, ship graveyards in developing economies sustain a recycling ecosystem that enhances material circularity, though benefits accrue unevenly, with primary value captured by yard owners and downstream processors.[](https://www.idpublications.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/Full-Paper-IMPACTS-OF-SHIPBREAKING-INDUSTRY-IN-BANGLADESH-SEARCH-FOR-A-SUSTAINABLE-SOLUTION.pdf) ### Global Supply Chain Dynamics The global [supply chain](/page/Supply_chain) for ship scrapping involves the transnational movement of end-of-life vessels from ship-owning nations—predominantly in [Europe](/page/Europe), [East Asia](/page/East_Asia), and [North America](/page/North_America)—to dismantling yards concentrated in [South Asia](/page/South_Asia) and parts of the [Middle East](/page/Middle_East), driven by differentials in labor costs, regulatory stringency, and [scrap](/page/Scrap) [material](/page/Material) [demand](/page/Demand).[](https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2019/04/ship-recycling_a64c6a7b/397de00c-en.pdf) Ship owners, facing high decommissioning expenses in [home](/page/Home) ports [due](/page/A_due) to stringent environmental and [safety](/page/Safety) standards, [export](/page/Export) vessels to facilities in [Bangladesh](/page/Bangladesh), [India](/page/India), and [Pakistan](/page/Pakistan), where beaching methods enable low-cost breaking amid weaker [enforcement](/page/Enforcement) of international norms.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/platform-publishes-list-2024/) This flow peaked in [efficiency](/page/Efficiency) during periods of [steel](/page/Steel) market booms, as recycled ship [steel](/page/Steel)—constituting [up to](/page/Up_to) 90-95% of a vessel's mass—feeds global mills, reducing reliance on virgin ore amid rising circular economy pressures.[](https://blog.bccresearch.com/global-ship-recycling-market-turning-end-of-life-vessels-into-a-circular-opportunity) In 2024, 409 ships were dismantled worldwide, with 255 (over 62%) processed in South Asian yards, [accounting](/page/Accounting) for approximately 80% of global scrapped [tonnage](/page/Tonnage) under substandard conditions characterized by tidal beaching and minimal waste containment.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/platform-publishes-list-2024/) [Bangladesh](/page/Bangladesh) emerged as the preferred destination, handling the largest volume despite periodic bans on imports, followed by [India](/page/India) and [Pakistan](/page/Pakistan); [China](/page/China) and [Turkey](/page/Turkey) captured the [remainder](/page/Remainder), often for smaller or state-owned vessels.[](https://safety4sea.com/80-of-global-tonnage-is-scrapped-under-substandard-conditions/) Leading exporters included [China](/page/China), which sent over 50 vessels to South Asian breakers, reflecting state-owned fleet renewals, alongside [Greece](/page/Greece) and Panama-flagged ships from European owners seeking to offload aging bulk carriers and tankers.[](https://www.brookesbell.com/news-and-knowledge/article/data-reveals-majority-of-global-tonnage-scrapped-under-substandard-conditions-159353/) These dynamics illustrate regulatory [arbitrage](/page/Arbitrage), where OECD-country bans on domestic scrapping since the 1980s shifted 70-80% of the market to non-OECD sites, sustaining a $9.1 billion industry in 2025 projected to reach $13 billion by 2030 through scrap demand in construction and automotive sectors.[](https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/ship-recycling-market-report-2025-081200920.html)[](https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/15/7/5919) Material recovery integrates scrapping into broader supply chains, yielding ferrous scrap (70-80% of vessel weight), non-ferrous metals, and reusable components that circumvent tariffs on primary metals via secondary markets.[](https://www.transparencymarketresearch.com/ship-breaking-market.html) However, supply volatility arises from freight rate cycles—e.g., high rates in 2021-2022 delayed scrapping, creating backlogs—and geopolitical factors, such as EU carbon regulations pushing cleaner but costlier dry-dock methods in Turkey over Asian beaches.[](https://www.ics-shipping.org/news-item/ics-leadership-insights-live-ship-recycling-round-up/) Empirical data from UNCTAD indicates Asia dominates both vessel supply (over 50% of global tonnage origins) and recycling capacity, perpetuating a north-south trade imbalance where developed economies externalize end-of-life management costs estimated at $200-500 per light displacement ton in Asia versus $1,000+ in Europe.[](https://unctadstat.unctad.org/datacentre/dataviewer/US.ShipScrapping) This structure, while economically rational for owners under first-principles cost minimization, underscores causal tensions between short-term recycling efficiencies and long-term externalities in pollution and labor risks borne by importing regions.[](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0308597X24002203) ## Controversies and Regulatory Frameworks ### Labor Conditions and Safety Records ![Shipwrecking in Alang, India, 2017](./_assets_/Shipwrecking_in_Alang%252C_India%252C_2017-03-17_by_Planet_Labs.jpg) Shipbreaking operations in major yards such as [Alang](/page/Alang), [India](/page/India), and Chattogram, Bangladesh, predominantly rely on manual labor under hazardous conditions, with workers dismantling vessels using rudimentary tools like torches and hammers without consistent provision of [personal protective equipment](/page/Personal_protective_equipment) (PPE).[](https://www.ilo.org/resource/other/ship-breaking-hazardous-work) Exposure to toxic substances including [asbestos](/page/Asbestos), [heavy metals](/page/Heavy_metals), and oil residues occurs routinely, contributing to acute injuries and chronic health issues such as respiratory diseases and cancer among workers.[](https://annalsofglobalhealth.org/en/articles/10.5334/aogh.4735) Migrant laborers, often from rural areas, endure long hours—typically 12 or more per day—low wages averaging $2-5 daily, and inadequate [housing](/page/Housing) in makeshift camps lacking [sanitation](/page/Sanitation).[](https://www.shipbreakingplatform.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Policy-Brief-TISS-Working-Conditions-ASSBY-2019.pdf) Safety records reflect elevated risks, particularly in beaching yards where ships are grounded on intertidal zones and cut apart piecemeal, leading to frequent falls, crush injuries from collapsing [steel](/page/Steel) plates, and explosions from residual fuels.[](https://www.industriall-union.org/cleaning-up-ship-breaking-the-worlds-most-dangerous-job) In Alang, at least 14 workers died in 2018 from such accidents, marking one of the yard's deadliest years on record, while 10 fatalities occurred in 2014 alone, primarily from falling debris.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/platform-publishes-list-2018/)[](https://ejatlas.org/conflict/dirty-and-dangerous-shipbreaking-in-alang) Chattogram yards reported 257 [deaths](/page/2022_in_anime) and numerous injuries from 2005 to 2024, with an annual average exceeding 13 fatalities in recent years, often due to absent safety harnesses and [fire suppression systems](/page/Fire_suppression_system).[](https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/news/257-lives-lost-accidents-over-last-2-decades-3696906)[](https://www.tbsnews.net/economy/industry/over-13-workers-die-year-bangladeshs-shipbreaking-industry-760538) Across South Asian yards including Pakistan's Gadani, at least 470 workers have died and 512 suffered severe injuries since 2009, underscoring the industry's status as one of the world's most perilous occupations per International Labour Organization assessments.[](https://courthousenews.com/new-rules-may-not-change-dirty-and-deadly-ship-recycling-business/)[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/our-work/the-problem/human-costs/) Efforts to mitigate risks, such as India's adoption of [Hong Kong](/page/Hong_Kong) Convention-aligned standards in over 115 [Alang](/page/Alang) yards by 2025, have yielded partial compliance but minimal gains in on-site conditions, as evidenced by persistent reports of bypassed [safety](/page/Safety) protocols and underreporting of incidents.[](https://www.industriall-union.org/lives-saved-ships-broken-the-human-cost-and-promise-of-ship-recycling) In contrast, regulated yards in developed nations like the [United States](/page/United_States) exhibit fatality rates orders of magnitude lower, attributable to enforced [mechanization](/page/Mechanization), PPE mandates, and environmental controls, though they process far less tonnage [due](/page/A_due) to higher costs.[](https://www.maritimeinjuryguide.org/blog/maritime-accidents-injuries-ship-breakers/) NGO monitoring, while valuable for aggregating local [data](/page/Data), draws from activist coalitions whose emphasis on worst-case examples may amplify [visibility](/page/Visibility) of non-compliance without fully [accounting](/page/Accounting) for incremental regulatory [enforcement](/page/Enforcement).[](https://www.equaltimes.org/death-injury-and-disease-the) ### International Conventions and Enforcement Challenges The primary international framework governing ship recycling is the Hong Kong International Convention for the [Safe](/page/Safe) and Environmentally [Sound](/page/Sound) Recycling of Ships, adopted by the [International Maritime Organization](/page/International_Maritime_Organization) (IMO) in 2009 and entering into force on June 26, 2025, after ratification by 15 countries representing more than 40% of global merchant shipping tonnage by gross tonnage.[](https://www.imo.org/en/mediacentre/pressbriefings/pages/hong-kong-convention-entry-into-force.aspx) The convention mandates requirements such as an [Inventory](/page/Inventory) of Hazardous Materials (IHM) for ships over 500 gross tons, Ship Recycling Facility Plans, and authorization of recycling yards to minimize risks from hazardous substances like [asbestos](/page/Asbestos), PCBs, and [heavy metals](/page/Heavy_metals) during dismantling.[](https://www.dnv.com/news/2025/hong-kong-convention-and-how-to-obtain-ihm-certification-for-ship-recycling/) It builds on earlier IMO Guidelines for Ship Recycling adopted in 2003, which emphasized safe practices but lacked binding force.[](https://www.imo.org/en/mediacentre/hottopics/pages/recycling-of-ships-and-hong-kong-convention.aspx) Complementing the HKC is the Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal, effective since [1992](/page/1992), which classifies end-of-life ships containing hazardous materials as "wastes" subject to prior [informed consent](/page/Informed_consent) and [export](/page/Export) bans to non-consenting parties, particularly developing nations.[](https://www.basel.int/Implementation/ShipDismantling/Overview/tabid/2762/Default.aspx) This application creates jurisdictional overlaps, as ships flagged in HKC parties may still require Basel notifications if destined for non-party yards, complicating exports from regions like the [European Union](/page/European_Union) where stricter interpretations prevail.[](https://www.bimco.org/regulatory-affairs/our-regulatory-work/insights/current-status-on-ship-recycling/) Enforcement faces systemic hurdles, including incomplete [ratification](/page/Ratification)—major scrapping hubs like [India](/page/India) and [Pakistan](/page/Pakistan) have delayed full [implementation](/page/Implementation) despite economic reliance on the industry—and a [shortage](/page/Shortage) of compliant facilities, with only around 30 yards globally meeting HKC standards as of mid-2025, potentially causing recycling backlogs and higher costs estimated at up to 20-30% per vessel for IHM certification and surveys.[](https://www.hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2025/09/the-impact-of-the-hong-kong-convention-on-ship-recycling-3-months-in) [Flag](/page/Flag) states, often those of convenience with limited oversight, bear primary responsibility for compliance, yet port state controls and on-site audits remain inconsistent, exacerbated by beaching methods in [South Asia](/page/South_Asia) that evade dry-dock requirements and enable unreported hazardous releases.[](https://www.qrsclass.org/hong-kong-convention-ship-recycling-regulatory-challenges-facing-the-industry/) Conflicts between HKC's ship-focused approach and Basel's [waste](/page/Waste) regime have led to legal deadlocks, such as EU prohibitions on exporting to non-HKC beaches, while weak local governance, corruption, and industry lobbying in host countries undermine yard authorizations and worker protections.[](https://www.rivieramm.com/news-content-hub/news-content-hub/deadlock-after-hong-kong-convention-threatens-global-ship-recycling-85710) Non-governmental organizations argue the HKC's thresholds for hazardous materials are insufficiently stringent, permitting practices that perpetuate environmental contamination despite its entry into force.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/hkc-fails-to-ensure-sustainable-ship-recycling/) Overall, while the conventions establish global baselines, their efficacy hinges on enhanced monitoring, capacity-building in developing states, and harmonization efforts, with initial post-2025 data indicating persistent non-compliance in over 90% of global tonnage recycled outside approved facilities.[](https://www.bimco.org/regulatory-affairs/our-regulatory-work/insights/current-status-on-ship-recycling/) ### Debates on Outsourcing to Developing Nations ![Shipwrecking in Alang, India, 2017](./_assets_/Shipwrecking_in_Alang%252C_India%252C_2017-03-17_by_Planet_Labs.jpg) Outsourcing of shipbreaking to developing nations, primarily in [South Asia](/page/South_Asia) such as [India](/page/India), [Bangladesh](/page/Bangladesh), and [Pakistan](/page/Pakistan), arises from stringent environmental and labor regulations in developed countries that render domestic scrapping economically unviable. Facilities like [Alang](/page/Alang) in [India](/page/India) handle approximately 30% of the global ship [recycling](/page/Recycling) market as of 2020, processing thousands of vessels annually and generating foreign exchange through [steel](/page/Steel) recovery and [scrap](/page/Scrap) exports.[](https://www.macrothink.org/journal/index.php/ijssr/article/download/22624/17408) This practice allows shipowners from [Europe](/page/Europe) and [North America](/page/North_America) to offload end-of-life vessels to yards offering lower labor costs—often $1-2 per day—and minimal regulatory oversight, thereby reducing disposal expenses that can exceed millions in compliant facilities.[](https://cpr.usm.my/images/Working%2520Paper%25202009/Working%2520Paper%25202010/CenPRIS%2520Working%2520Paper%2520No.%2520132%252010.pdf) Proponents argue that outsourcing sustains vital economic activity in impoverished regions, where shipbreaking yards employ tens of thousands of workers and supply recycled steel critical for local construction and manufacturing. In Alang, the industry has dismantled over 8,000 ships since 1982, supporting migrant labor from across India and contributing to regional GDP through direct jobs, ancillary services, and material reuse that offsets virgin steel imports.[](https://annalsofglobalhealth.org/en/articles/10.5334/aogh.4735) Similarly, yards in Bangladesh and Pakistan drive employment in coastal economies, with the sector positioned as a comparative advantage for nations lacking advanced industries but possessing abundant low-skilled labor.[](https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/shipbreaking-salvage-industry-driving-jobs-foreign-growth-simmonds-bgfce) Advocates, including industry groups and some developing country governments, contend that prohibiting such trade would exacerbate poverty without viable alternatives, emphasizing that revenues fund infrastructure and that recent upgrades in Alang—such as improved beaching techniques and waste containment—demonstrate progress toward sustainability.[](https://maritimeindia.org/sustainable-ship-recycling-in-india-social-technological-and-environmental-analysis/) Critics, often from environmental NGOs and human rights organizations, highlight the outsourcing of pollution and hazards, framing it as "toxic colonialism" where developed nations evade responsibility by exporting vessels laden with asbestos, PCBs, and heavy metals to sites with inadequate safeguards. Reports document frequent accidents, including at least 10 worker deaths in Alang in 2014 from falls, crushing, and toxic exposures, alongside chronic health issues like respiratory diseases among unprotected laborers.[](https://ejatlas.org/conflict/dirty-and-dangerous-shipbreaking-in-alang)[](https://www.shipbreakingplatform.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Policy-Brief-TISS-Working-Conditions-ASSBY-2019.pdf) These groups argue that lax enforcement perpetuates a cycle of exploitation, with studies estimating disproportionate environmental contamination in coastal ecosystems near yards.[](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27424206/) Central to the [debate](/page/Debate) is the tension between international frameworks like the [Basel Convention](/page/Basel_Convention), which classifies end-of-life ships as [hazardous waste](/page/Hazardous_waste) requiring prior [informed consent](/page/Informed_consent) for transboundary movement, and industry preferences for the Hong Kong Convention's focus on safe [recycling](/page/Recycling) practices without export bans. Enforcement challenges persist, as shipowners circumvent Basel controls via flags of convenience or misdeclarations of trading status, leading to [630](/page/630) commercial vessels dismantled in substandard yards in [2020](/page/2020) alone.[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/issues-of-interest/the-law/basel-convention/)[](https://www.politico.eu/article/clash-of-conventions-why-new-regulation-scrapping-ships-worrying-industry/)[](https://shipbreakingplatform.org/platform-publishes-list-2020/) While some analyses question the convention's [efficacy](/page/Efficacy) in protecting developing nations—citing unintended barriers to legitimate [trade](/page/Trade)—others assert that stronger adherence could compel [cleaner](/page/Cleaner) practices without halting economic flows.[](https://earth.org/how-the-basel-convention-has-harmed-developing-countries/)[](https://maritime-executive.com/editorials/breaking-ships-building-consensus-how-the-basel-ban-and-hkc-can-coexist) Empirical assessments [underscore](/page/Underscore) that, absent comprehensive global standards, [outsourcing](/page/Outsourcing) debates [hinge](/page/Hinge) on balancing immediate livelihood gains against long-term human and ecological costs, with source credibility varying between NGO-driven alarmism and industry-optimistic reports.[](https://insight.dickinsonlaw.psu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1542&context=psilr&httpsredir=1&referer=)

References

  1. https://www.marineinsight.com/environment/what-is-a-ship-graveyard/
  2. https://www.maritimeinjurycenter.com/accidents-and-injuries/ship-breaking/
  3. https://shipbreakingbd.info/ship-breaking-around-the-world/
  4. https://www.marineinsight.com/environment/10-largest-ship-graveyards-in-the-world/
  5. https://www.chemistryworld.com/features/the-toxic-tide-of-ship-breaking/4015158.article
  6. https://www.thrillist.com/travel/nation/the-world-s-biggest-ship-graveyard
  7. https://www.splashtravels.com/world-history/9-enormous-ship-graveyards-carved-time
  8. https://safety4sea.com/watch-the-dark-side-of-shipbreaking-practices-in-bangladesh/
  9. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/our-work/the-problem/human-costs/
  10. https://sanctuaries.noaa.gov/mallows-potomac/shipwrecks/
  11. https://porteconomicsmanagement.org/pemp/contents/part3/ports-circular-economy/ship-recycling-scrapping-demolition/
  12. https://www.marineinsight.com/guidelines/10-types-of-ship-disposal-techniques/
  13. https://maritimeducation.com/10-largest-ship-graveyards-in-the-world-where-vessels-go-to-die/
  14. https://www.naval-history.net/WW1NavyBritish-Shipbreak.htm
  15. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-7342-8_1
  16. https://d3pcsg2wjq9izr.cloudfront.net/files/6496/articles/6415/Shipbreaking.pdf
  17. https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/1922/december/shipbreaking-great-britain
  18. https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/1979/february/pictorial-scrapping-our-world-war-ii-navy
  19. https://www.industriall-union.org/lives-saved-ships-broken-the-human-cost-and-promise-of-ship-recycling
  20. https://ejatlas.org/print/dirty-and-dangerous-shipbreaking-in-chittagong
  21. https://www.hrw.org/report/2023/09/28/trading-lives-profit/how-shipping-industry-circumvents-regulations-scrap-toxic
  22. https://www.lloydslist.com/LL1152167/Ship-recycling-volumes-in-2024-drop-to-lowest-levels-since-2005
  23. https://www.marineinsight.com/shipping-news/ship-recycling-to-double-with-16000-vessels-expected-to-be-scrapped-in-next-decade/
  24. https://www.worldfinance.com/markets/the-nature-of-shipbreaking-is-casting-a-shadow-over-the-shipping-industry
  25. https://www.martide.com/en/blog/why-are-vessels-scrapped-what-happens
  26. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0921344915301531
  27. https://nextship.net/news/4
  28. https://ersj.eu/journal/2364/download/Ecological%2BAspect%2Bof%2BVessel%2BDecommissioning%2BMarket.pdf
  29. https://marinedebris.noaa.gov/what-marine-debris/abandoned-and-derelict-vessels
  30. https://www.imo.org/en/ourwork/legal/pages/seafarer-abandonment.aspx
  31. https://www.imarest.org/resource/mp-the-growing-number-of-abandoned-vessels.html
  32. https://www.marineinsight.com/guidelines/how-ship-dismantling-is-done/
  33. https://www.imo.org/en/mediacentre/pressbriefings/pages/hong-kong-convention-entry-into-force.aspx
  34. https://www.osha.gov/sites/default/files/publications/3375shipbreaking.pdf
  35. https://www.imorules.com/GUID-0326AE95-5BF0-4C0F-A2BB-96C8211DB168.html
  36. https://circulareconomy.earth/publications/towards-a-just-and-circular-shipbreaking-industry-in-south-asia
  37. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/platform-publishes-list-2024/
  38. https://maritimeindia.org/sustainable-ship-recycling-in-india-legal-economic-and-political-analysis/
  39. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/our-work/the-problem/india/
  40. https://www.seaisi.org/details/26630?type=news-rooms
  41. https://www.dw.com/en/scrapping-ships-in-bangladesh/video-68163450
  42. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/our-work/the-problem/pakistan/
  43. https://www.industriall-union.org/pakistans-unsafe-shipbreaking-yard-claims-lives-of-two-workers
  44. https://www.arabnews.com/node/2377836/pakistan
  45. https://www.meremblasting.com/top-10-biggest-ship-breaking-yards-in-the-world-merem-blasting
  46. https://www.the-sun.com/news/8994249/ship-graveyards-asia/
  47. https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/southeast-asia-links-vietnam-s-ship-graveyard-typhoon-ruby-myanmar-jade-curse-more
  48. https://maritimefairtrade.org/majority-of-global-ship-breaking-takes-place-at-bangladesh-india-pakistan/
  49. https://www.gmsinc.net/article/alang-ship-recycling-insights-into-operations-challenges-and-opportunities
  50. https://www.marineinsight.com/shipping-news/indias-alang-ship-breaking-yard-sees-13-jump-in-ship-arrivals-after-years-of-decline/
  51. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0025326X24014280
  52. https://www.facebook.com/groups/shipbreaking/posts/10165621891368943/
  53. https://maritime-executive.com/article/bangladesh-could-lose-top-position-in-the-global-shipbreaking-market
  54. https://dredgewire.com/bangladesh-shipbreaking-industry-faces-historic-decline-amid-global-disruptions/
  55. https://www.tbsnews.net/supplement/how-shipbreaking-contributing-bangladeshs-economy-978836
  56. https://shippinginbox.com/bangladeshs-shipbreaking-industry-struggles-with-safety-despite-global-convention/
  57. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/platform-publishes-list-2023/
  58. http://www.humanrights.asia/news/ahrc-news/AHRC-ART-066-2016/
  59. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S016041202400117X
  60. https://www.theclimategroup.org/sites/default/files/2024-12/Turning%2520the%2520Tide%2520-%2520Ship%2520Recycling%2520as%2520a%2520Source%2520of%2520Green%2520Steel%2520in%2520India.pdf
  61. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/our-work/the-problem/environmental-costs/
  62. https://www.wirana.com/market-china.php
  63. https://www.trusteddocks.com/shipyards/5126-xiagang-changjiang-ship-breaking-factory
  64. https://isranetwork.com/profile/Changjiang
  65. https://www.trusteddocks.com/catalog/country/47-china
  66. https://datamarnews.com/noticias/illegal-vessel-dismantling-market-takes-heavy-toll-in-south-asia/
  67. https://environment.ec.europa.eu/news/eu-ship-recycling-regulation-evaluation-and-list-update-2025-02-19_en
  68. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/issues-of-interest/the-law/eu-srr/
  69. https://environment.ec.europa.eu/news/ship-recycling-updated-list-european-facilities-includes-three-new-yards-2023-07-27_en
  70. https://www.industriall-union.org/stronger-enforcement-of-eu-ship-recycling-regulation-is-needed
  71. https://www.outono.net/elentir/2022/08/23/the-adventure-of-two-spanish-explorers-inside-an-abandoned-french-frigate/
  72. https://www.yahoo.com/news/warship-cemetery-slideshow-wp-022248595.html
  73. https://www.ww2wrecks.com/portfolio/scapa-flow-the-largest-shipwreck-graveyard-of-europe/
  74. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/article-12496015/Incredible-hulks-Fascinating-pictures-one-Britains-biggest-ship-graveyards-containing-wrecks-vessels-deliberately-beached-save-river-bank-collapsing.html
  75. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/our-work/the-problem/eu-row/
  76. https://www.maritimeships.com/global-list-of-notable-shipbreaking-yards/
  77. https://severnestuarypartnership.org.uk/explore-the-estuary/exploring-guide/purton-hulks/
  78. https://uk.style.yahoo.com/bizarre-ship-graveyard-hamburg-blankenese-085400401.html
  79. https://www.fornaes.com/contact/
  80. https://www.trusteddocks.com/catalog/region/northern-europe
  81. https://www.smedegaarden.net/
  82. https://en.greenyard.no/recycling
  83. https://www.afgruppen.com/news/2022/11/significant-floating-production-vessel-a-recycling-first-for-norway/
  84. https://maritime-executive.com/index.php/article/norway-and-hoeegh-autoliners-launch-plan-to-upcycle-end-of-life-ships
  85. https://clui.org/newsletter/spring-2010/american-ship-breaking
  86. https://www.portofbrownsville.com/americas-premier-ship-recycling-port/
  87. https://www.facebook.com/InternationalShipbreaking/
  88. https://us.emrgroup.com/what-we-do/our-specialist-areas/marine-structures-and-vessels
  89. https://buriedhistory.exploratorium.edu/tour/ship-breaking-yard
  90. https://savingplaces.org/places/ghost-fleet
  91. https://www.facebook.com/cheknews/posts/there-are-only-two-ship-recycling-operations-in-canada-and-both-are-on-the-east-/1214444540727921/
  92. https://www.facebook.com/groups/407597160668310/posts/1369017551192928/
  93. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/vancouver-island-ship-dismantling-company-has-water-access-revoked-1.7580133
  94. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/shipbreaking-british-columbia/
  95. https://maritime-executive.com/article/canada-to-boost-ship-recycling-capacity-on-the-west-coast
  96. https://www.saltwire.com/newfoundland-labrador/bull-arm-site-recycling-old-ships
  97. https://www.canada.ca/en/public-services-procurement/corporate/stories/cleaning-water.html
  98. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gh8Tmp4BR7w
  99. https://thediscourse.ca/deep-dive/ship-breaking
  100. https://www.npr.org/2012/07/25/156732936/when-the-ship-comes-in-to-brownsville-rip-it-up
  101. https://www.pilotonline.com/2012/03/02/shipyard-that-handled-ghost-fleet-moves-on/
  102. https://alexandracharitan.com/blog/2018/6/4/staten-island-boat-graveyard
  103. https://seawayreview.com/great-lakes-shipbreaking-canadas-mrc-provides-clean-end-of-life-ship-recycling/
  104. https://www.thescubanews.com/2024/03/13/where-ships-go-to-die/
  105. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXH9dZ513a0
  106. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/press-release-province-shuts-down-hazardous-shipbreaking-at-union-bay/
  107. https://tc.canada.ca/en/binder/18-ship-recycling-canada
  108. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U6DRmmPbkDM
  109. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/advocates-want-ship-recycling-facility-vancouver-island-bc-9.6936710
  110. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c36wJ2wxdiA
  111. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/shipbreaking-practices-threaten-ghanian-shores/
  112. https://www.rivieramm.com/news-content-hub/news-content-hub/the-first-certified-lsquoeu-equivalentrsquo-shipbreaking-facility-in-africa-63315
  113. https://34south.africa/about/
  114. https://maritimereview.co.za/Articles/ArtMID/397/ArticleID/234/Africa%25E2%2580%2599s-role-in-ship-scrapping
  115. https://www.scubadoctor.com.au/victorian-ships-graveyard.htm
  116. https://www.marineinsight.com/maritime-history/nouadhibou-is-this-the-largest-ship-graveyard-in-the-world/
  117. https://www.cbsnews.com/baltimore/news/the-worlds-biggest-ship-graveyard/
  118. https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/bay-of-nouadhibou-ship-graveyard
  119. https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g293763-d7269538-Reviews-Ship_s_Cemetery_Graveyard-Luanda_Luanda_Province.html
  120. https://globerovers.com/africa-southernmost-lighthouse/
  121. https://www.oldsaltblog.com/2011/10/western-africas-graveyards-of-ships/
  122. https://www.environment.sa.gov.au/topics/heritage/maritime-heritage/visiting-maritime-heritage-places/ships-graveyards/port-adelaide
  123. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/shipwreck-found-drone-ship-graveyard-australia/
  124. https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/traveller/inspiration/you-don-t-need-to-be-a-diver-to-explore-australia-s-incredible-ship-graveyard-20240117-p5exx0.html
  125. https://new.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/en/arts-culture-heritage/heritage-walks-places/rangitoto-ships-graveyard.html
  126. https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/otamahua-ships-graveyard
  127. https://shipbreakingplatform.org/issues-of-interest/why-ships-are-toxic/
  128. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanplh/article/PIIS2542-5196%2825%2900211-6/fulltext
  129. https://shipbreakingbd.info/environmental-pollution/
  130. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11270-006-9205-z
  131. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0045653505006703
  132. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352485525004980
  133. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/environmental-impact-of-ships/environmental-impacts-of-shipbreaking/57722F93CF7F93F8F6E539F9FD5D91C3
  134. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030438942302215X
  135. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0308597X21001536
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.