Allmusic editor Michael Gallucci wrote that on Still in the Game, "Sweat goes one-on-one with his audience, playing into their hearts and souls with his typically smooth-croon grandeur. It all sounds a bit familiar (as well as a bit programmed) – and the Jermaine Dupri, Erick Sermon and Too Short cameos add absolutely nothing to Sweat's sweet mix – but there's a cool sexuality in his grooves and moves."[1] Matt Diehl from Entertainment Weekly found that "despite his new album’s defensive title, Still in the Game, Keith Sweat shouldn't worry — his long-running career proves he's an R&B lover-man for the ages. Cameos from Snoop Dogg, Too Short, and Erick Sermon feel superfluous: Sweat’s seductive burr of a voice is all he needs — when he lolls around the line "come into my bedroom" like molasses on the tongue, it's pure Spanish fly soul. Keep a copy of this in the boudoir."[2] Paul Verna from Billboard felt that Still in the Game "makes it clear that he hasn't deviated from the singing style that made him a household name. However, this sets [...] should expose the vocalst to a younger and more streetwise audience and enhance his sales prospects."[3]
Still in the Game debuted and peaked at number six on the US Billboard 200 and number two on the Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums chart in the week of October 10, 1998,[4] with first week sales of 96,000 copies.[5] On October 14, 1998, it was certified Gold and Platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) for shipments figure in excess of 1 million copies.[6]