Hubbry Logo
search
logo
The Music Box avatar
The Music Box
The Music Box
current hub
T

The Music Box

logo
Community Hub0 Subscribers
Read side by side
The Music Box
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Music Box
Lobby card, 1932
Directed byJames Parrott
Written byH. M. Walker
Produced byHal Roach
StarringStan Laurel
Oliver Hardy
CinematographyLen Powers
Walter Lundin
Edited byRichard C. Currier
Music byHarry Graham
Marvin Hatley
Leroy Shield
Distributed byMetro-Goldwyn-Mayer
Release date
  • April 16, 1932 (1932-04-16) (US)
Running time
29:16
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish

The Music Box is a Laurel and Hardy short film comedy released in 1932. It was directed by James Parrott, produced by Hal Roach and distributed by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer. The film, which depicts the pair attempting to move a piano up a long flight of steps, won the first Academy Award for Best Live Action Short (Comedy) in 1932.[1][2] In 1997, it was selected for preservation in the National Film Registry by the Library of Congress as being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant".[3][4][5] The film is widely seen as the most iconic Laurel and Hardy short, with the featured stairs becoming a popular tourist attraction.

Plot

[edit]

In a music store, a woman arranges for the purchase and delivery of a player piano as a birthday surprise for her husband. Upon disclosing her address at 1127 Walnut Avenue to the store manager, the Laurel and Hardy Transfer Company is enlisted to transport the instrument using their horse-drawn freight wagon.

Encountering a formidable challenge in the form of a lengthy stairway leading to the residence, the duo attempts to navigate the piano up the steps. Amidst their arduous efforts, they inadvertently cause the instrument to descend the stairs multiple times, resulting in a series of mishaps and encounters with various individuals, including a nursemaid, a cop, and the imposing Professor Theodore von Schwartzenhoffen. Remaining persistent, Laurel and Hardy eventually succeed in reaching the top, only to face further misfortune as the piano rolls back down, dragging Ollie along. After carrying the piano to the top again, they are told a simpler route is available, so they carry the piano all the way back down in order to drive it up. Despite finding no one there, they get the instrument into the house, making a mess of the living room in the process.

Their struggles culminate in a confrontation with the irate Professor, who resides at the address. Infuriated by the mess and the piano, an instrument he detests, he destroys it with an axe just as his wife returns. Upon learning he was the piano's intended recipient, the professor regrets his actions and agrees to sign for the delivery. A final mishap involving an ink-spraying pen causes him to lose his temper once more, prompting Laurel and Hardy to hastily depart.

Cast

[edit]

Uncredited cast

Location

[edit]
The stairs in 2009
Downward view, 2010
Sign at top of hill, Descanso Drive

The steps, 133 with multiple landings,[7] which are the focal point of The Music Box, still exist in the Silver Lake district of Los Angeles, near the Laurel and Hardy Park. The steps are a public staircase that connects Vendome Street (at the base of the hill) with Descanso Drive (at the top of the hill),[8] and are located at 923-925 North Vendome Street near the intersection of Del Monte Drive. A plaque commemorating the film was set into one of the lower steps.[9]

The steps can also be seen in the Charley Chase silent comedy Isn't Life Terrible? (1925), during a scene in which Chase is trying to sell fountain pens to Fay Wray. The steps are also used, for a gag similar to Hats Off and The Music Box, in Ice Cold Cocos (1926), a Billy Bevan comedy short directed by Del Lord.[10] The steps are also referenced in The Laurel and Hardy Love Affair, a short story by Ray Bradbury, as the meeting place of the couple in the story, who call each other Ollie and Stan in homage to the comedic duo.

Although similar in appearance, the staircase is not the same one used by The Three Stooges in their 1941 film An Ache in Every Stake. Those stairs (147 steps in length) are approximately two miles northeast, located at 2212 Edendale Place in the Silver Lake district of Los Angeles.[11][12]

Reception

[edit]

The short was popular with audiences in 1932 and generally well received by critics. After previewing The Music Box in late February that year, the New York trade paper The Film Daily assured theater owners that the comedy "is up to the Laurel-Hardy standard, and should score easily."[13] Motion Picture Herald, after previewing the film in March, described it as "great fun" and noted, "Unusually long for a comedy [short], it is well worth the extra length."[14] The Chicago-based movie magazine Motion Picture is even more enthusiastic about the comedy in its June 1932 issue:

[Laurel and Hardy's] latest "short" lasts thirty minutes. And it is a fast and funny half-hour. Perhaps they got their idea from Charlie Chaplin, who once was screamingly funny as a piano-mover's helper—but don't hold that against them. They have improved on Chaplin, which is no easy task. Not with a pair as absurdly, ridiculously, and insanely awkward as these two. The gags are almost as side-splitting as they are.[15]

Not all contemporary reviews, however, were positive. Variety, the entertainment industry's leading paper in 1932, did not publish its review of The Music Box until November 22, over seven months after MGM officially released the short to theaters. The reviewer, Alfred Greason, wrote:

Less than average subject for this comedy pair, who depend on house wrecking for their laughs instead of upon the laughs within the situations themselves. Any pair of clowns can make haw-haws out of roughhouse; this pair have reached distinction by reason of a comic quality within themselves. Resort to house wrecking argues lack of resources in the 'script' department.[16]

Leslie Halliwell gave it four of four stars: "Quintessential Laurel and Hardy, involving almost all their aspects including a slight song and dance."[17]

Remakes

[edit]
A Still from the short Hats Off!.
  • The film is a partial remake of their lost silent short Hats Off! (1927), directed by Hal Yates, which utilized a washing machine instead of a piano, and was filmed at the same location and is today considered a lost film.[18] Hats Off was itself remade by Edgar Kennedy in 1945 as It's Your Move (again directed by Yates), but utilizing a different staircase although located in the same vicinity where the "Music Box Steps" are in Silver Lake (known as the Descanso Stairs, they are situated at the intersection of Descanso and Larissa drives, specifically between the residences of 3217 Descanso Drive and 3200-3206 Larissa Drive, and one block from Sunset Boulevard, which can be seen in the background in several long shots).
  • Hal Roach Studios colorized The Music Box in 1986 with a remastered stereo soundtrack featuring the Hal Roach Studios incidental stock music score conducted by Ronnie Hazelhurst. The film was later released on VHS along with a colorized version of Helpmates.
  • The Music Box was also dubbed in Spanish, with the lengthy title No cualquiera aguanta un piano, mucho menos una pianola (the English translation being "Not anyone can bear a piano, let alone a pianola").
  • With some aspects of the original script omitted, actor Jorge Arvizu and other actors have produced additional Spanish versions of The Music Box, as well as other remakes of Laurel and Hardy shorts and features.

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

The Music Box

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Music Box is a 1932 American pre-Code comedy short film starring the duo Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy as inept piano movers tasked with delivering a player piano up a steep flight of 133 steps to a residence at 1127 Walnut Avenue in the Silver Lake neighborhood of Los Angeles, leading to escalating slapstick chaos involving a pompous doctor and a nurse.[1][2] Directed by James Parrott and produced by Hal Roach at the Hal Roach Studios, the 29-minute film was released on April 16, 1932, and distributed by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer.[3] It won the Academy Award for Best Short Subject (Comedy) at the 5th Academy Awards in 1933, becoming the inaugural recipient of this category.[4] The film's premise originated from an earlier silent short, Hats Off (1927), also starring Laurel and Hardy and filmed at the same Silver Lake location, though that version is now considered lost except for a few stills.[5][2] Stan Laurel, uncredited in the role, served as the de facto creative force behind the script and direction for most of the duo's Roach-era productions, infusing The Music Box with his signature style of escalating absurdity and physical comedy centered on everyday frustrations.[6] The production emphasized practical effects and the duo's chemistry, with the iconic staircase serving as both a literal and metaphorical obstacle in their Sisyphean struggle.[5] Critically acclaimed for its tight pacing, visual gags, and enduring appeal, The Music Box holds a 7.9/10 rating on IMDb from over 8,000 user votes and a 91% approval on Rotten Tomatoes based on 115 reviews, often cited as one of Laurel and Hardy's best shorts.[3][1] Its legacy endures through restorations and public domain availability, influencing later comedy films with themes of futile labor.[6] In June 2024, the Los Angeles City Council designated the film's staircase location as a historic-cultural monument, honoring its cultural significance with plans for a commemorative sign at Vendome Street and Del Monte Drive.[7][8]

Production

Development

The Music Box originated as a partial remake of the Laurel and Hardy silent short Hats Off (1927), in which the duo futilely attempts to haul a washing machine up a long flight of stairs; the 1932 version updated the premise by replacing the appliance with a player piano, allowing for integrated sound effects, dialogue, and musical elements to amplify the comedic tension of futile labor.[9] This adaptation retained the core theme of escalating frustration against an insurmountable obstacle, tailored to the duo's evolving style under the transition to sound films.[9] The screenplay was crafted by H.M. Walker, the Hal Roach Studios' principal dialogue writer, who focused on building the narrative around physical comedy sequences that highlighted Laurel's bumbling ingenuity and Hardy's mounting irritation, culminating in chaotic escalations like the piano's repeated descents. Walker's script incorporated minimal but pointed verbal exchanges to complement the visual gags, ensuring the humor remained rooted in the duo's nonverbal rapport while leveraging the talkie medium.[10] Pre-production emphasized the piano delivery as the central premise to maximize slapstick opportunities, with the bulky instrument selected for its fragility and acoustic potential—such as interior "music" triggered during mishaps—to underscore the theme of absurd perseverance.[9] Principal photography planning in late 1931 prioritized location scouting for steep staircases that could visually convey the Herculean task, setting the stage for on-set improvisation.[9] Hal Roach greenlit The Music Box as part of his studio's 1931–1932 short film series featuring Laurel and Hardy, viewing it as an ideal vehicle to sustain their popularity by merging proven silent comedy tropes with synchronized sound innovation.[9] Roach's oversight ensured efficient production within the era's constraints, contributing to the film's tight 29-minute runtime and its status as a pinnacle of their Roach-era output.[9]

Filming and Locations

Principal photography for The Music Box commenced in December 1931 at Hal Roach Studios in Culver City, California, where interior scenes and backlot exteriors were captured.[9] The production wrapped within less than two weeks, with the extended staircase sequence requiring four days of location shooting to accommodate multiple takes under varying weather conditions.[5] Exterior scenes utilized a real neighborhood street in the Silver Lake district of Los Angeles, specifically the 133-step concrete staircase between 923 and 935 North Vendome Street, near the intersection with Del Monte Drive.[9] This location was selected for its steep incline, which amplified the comedic physicality of the delivery attempts, though the film's fictional address of 1127 Walnut Avenue bore no relation to the actual site.[9] House interiors, including the professor's residence, were constructed and filmed on the Hal Roach Studios backlot at 8822 Washington Boulevard, Culver City, to simulate the top of the stairs.[11] The central prop, a crated player piano, was custom-built to specifications by prop master Thomas Benton Roberts, encasing a real upright piano for authenticity and substantial weight during key sequences.[12] Multiple versions of the crate were constructed, some fitted with hidden rollers for controlled downhill slides, while others contained dummy pianos that were repeatedly wrecked across takes to depict the escalating chaos.[12][5] Filming the staircase stunts presented logistical hurdles, including inconsistent sunlight from cloudy days that necessitated non-sequential shooting to maintain visual continuity.[9] A special police detail was required to manage crowds of over 3,500 spectators, who disrupted takes and prompted Laurel and Hardy to sign approximately 2,000 autographs during brief lunch breaks.[5] Safety measures involved stunt doubles for hazardous falls, such as one standing in for Oliver Hardy during a face-down tumble, alongside careful coordination of the piano's repeated ascents and descents to prevent injuries amid the physical demands.[12] The rushed post-shoot editing, handled by Stan Laurel and sound editor Bert Jordan late into the night, further strained the tight schedule ahead of the film's April 1932 release.[9]

Plot

A woman purchases a player piano from a music store as a surprise birthday present for her husband, Professor von Schwarzenhoffen, and arranges for delivery to their home at 1127 Walnut Avenue. Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy, operating as the Laurel & Hardy Transfer Company with a horse-drawn dolly, load the crated piano onto their cart and set off. Upon arriving, they discover the address is accessible only via a long flight of 131 steep steps.[13] The duo begins pushing the piano up the stairs, but it repeatedly rolls back down, causing chaos. They encounter a nursemaid pushing a baby carriage, who scolds them; in the ensuing tussle, the piano tumbles down again, nearly hitting a passing policeman who then pursues them. The professor himself appears, pompously demanding they cease the noise, but ends up with his silk top hat crushed under the piano.[14] After multiple failed attempts, including using a hand truck and ropes that fail spectacularly, they finally hoist the piano to the top using a block and tackle from a nearby porch. A postman informs them of an easier route via a side street driveway, prompting them to lower the piano back down and attempt to wheel it around—only for it to roll away again, dragging Hardy downhill. Exhausted, they manage to get the piano into the empty house through an upstairs window, but it falls into a decorative fountain in the living room, flooding the space. When the professor returns with his wife and learns the piano was her gift to him, he flies into a rage and destroys it with an axe. Upon realizing his mistake, he apologizes profusely and signs for the delivery. However, as Laurel hands over the receipt pen, it squirts ink in the professor's face, leading to one final chase as the duo flees.[14][13]

Cast and Characters

The Music Box stars the comedy duo Laurel and Hardy in the lead roles, with supporting characters played by uncredited actors in bit parts. The principal cast is as follows:
  • Stan Laurel as Stan Laurel
  • Oliver Hardy as Ollie Hardy
  • Billy Gilbert as Professor Theodore von Schwartzenhoffen, M.D., A.D., D.D.S., F.L.D., F.F.F.und F.
  • Dinah as Susie (the dog)[3]
  • Eleanor Fredericks as Nursemaid[3]
  • Gladys Gale as Mrs. von Schwartzenhoffen[15]
  • William Gillespie as Piano Salesman[16]
  • Charlie Hall as Postman
  • Hazel Howell as Woman with Dog[16]
  • Lilyan Irene as Neighbor Woman
  • Sam Lufkin as Police Officer
Additional uncredited bit players include May Wallace as a neighbor with a baby carriage and other passersby.

Release and Reception

Premiere and Distribution

The Music Box premiered in the United States on April 16, 1932, as a short subject comedy produced by Hal Roach Studios and released through Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer's distribution network.[3] This initial theatrical rollout positioned the film within MGM's program of two-reel shorts, designed to complement feature films in double bills and provide affordable entertainment amid the economic hardships of the Great Depression.[17] Distributed domestically via MGM's extensive theater chain and internationally to markets including the United Kingdom (August 5, 1932), Australia (September 16, 1932), and several European countries throughout 1932 and 1933, the 29-minute film adhered to the standard short-subject format, enabling broad accessibility in cinemas worldwide.[18] Its rollout capitalized on Laurel and Hardy's rising stardom, with MGM leveraging the duo's established appeal from prior shorts to secure playdates alongside major features.[19] The film contributed to the duo's profitability for Roach and MGM through its critical acclaim and Oscar win, though exact rental figures remain undocumented in primary records. Initial marketing emphasized its slapstick ingenuity and the stars' chemistry, promoting it as an essential Laurel and Hardy entry often paired in theater programs with major features of the era.[20]

Critical Response

Upon its release, The Music Box received strong praise from contemporary critics for its comedic ingenuity. Variety described it as "one of [Laurel and Hardy's] best" two-reelers, highlighting the "interminable flight of steps" as a premise ripe for laughs, with top-notch direction and gags that fully exploited the duo's physical comedy.[21] The short's critical acclaim culminated in its winning the Academy Award for Best Short Subject (Comedy) at the 5th Academy Awards in 1933, marking the only Oscar ever awarded to a Laurel and Hardy production. Retrospective reviews have continued to celebrate the film as a comedy classic. In 1997, it was selected for preservation in the National Film Registry by the Library of Congress as being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant."[22] On Rotten Tomatoes, it holds a 100% approval rating from four critic reviews.[23] Critics consistently acclaim The Music Box for its masterful visual gags—such as the escalating disasters in the piano delivery sequence—and the duo's impeccable timing, which builds tension through protracted, Sisyphean struggles.[24][25] However, some observers note that the sound effects, particularly intrusive music tracks added in later re-releases, can feel dated compared to the film's pristine visual humor.[26]

Legacy

Remakes and Adaptations

In the 1950s, television shows produced parodies of the film. There have been no major feature film remakes of The Music Box, though the film's premise influenced similar comedy shorts and contributed to the urban legend surrounding the "Music Box Steps" in Los Angeles, a real set of 133 steps in the Silver Lake neighborhood that became a tourist attraction due to the movie's enduring popularity.[2][8] Home video releases of the short have kept it accessible to new generations, with inclusions in 1990s VHS compilations of Laurel and Hardy works and restored versions issued on DVD and Blu-ray during the 2010s, such as the 2011 Hallmark DVD set and the 2020 ClassicFlix Blu-ray restoration.[27][28]

Cultural Impact

The Music Box has achieved iconic status in film history, particularly through the 133-step staircase in Silver Lake, Los Angeles, known as the Music Box Steps, which served as a central location in the short and was designated a Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument in June 2024 in recognition of its role in the production.[7] This site draws tourists and film enthusiasts annually, with events like Music Box Steps Day hosted by the Silver Lake Improvement Association since 1995, including its 30th annual celebration in October 2024.[29][30] The short is widely regarded as a pinnacle of slapstick comedy, exemplifying Laurel and Hardy's mastery of physical humor through escalating mishaps and precise timing, which has influenced generations of filmmakers in the genre.[31] Its style of choreographed chaos and character-driven gags has inspired action-comedy performers drawing from classic physical comedy traditions, as well as elements in modern animations that emphasize exaggerated, consequence-free falls and props.[32] Preservation efforts have ensured the film's accessibility, with the UCLA Film & Television Archive restoring The Music Box from original 35mm nitrate negatives as part of a broader Laurel and Hardy initiative launched in 2013, supported by donors including the Winklevoss Foundation.[33] Additionally, the short's public domain status, resulting from lapsed copyright renewals, has allowed free public access and distribution since the early 2000s, facilitating its use in educational screenings and online archives.[34] The film's enduring legacy has solidified Laurel and Hardy's status as comedy legends, with The Music Box frequently referenced in later works. This broader cultural footprint underscores the short's role in defining timeless comedic tropes that transcend its era.

References

  1. The Music Box (1932) - Rotten Tomatoes
  2. Classic Movie Travels: The Music Box Steps
  3. The Music Box (Short 1932) - IMDb
  4. The Music Box (Short 1932) - Awards - IMDb
  5. The Music Box (1932) | Hometowns to Hollywood
  6. Short – “The Music Box” (1932) Review, with Laurel and Hardy
  7. Laurel And Hardy's 'The Music Box' To Get Sign At Silver Lake Steps ...
  8. Los Angeles honors Silver Lake staircase, site of Laurel and Hardy's ...
  9. [PDF] film essay for The Music Box - Library of Congress
  10. H. M. Walker - The Lucky Corner
  11. The Music Box (Short 1932) - Filming & production - IMDb
  12. The Music Box - Production Sidelights - Talkies
  13. AFI|Catalog - American Film Institute
  14. The Music Box (Short 1932) - Release info - IMDb
  15. Laurel and Hardy Timeline - Way Out West Tent
  16. Films at the Baker – 1930s - Lockhart - Gaslight-Baker Theatre
  17. Variety (November 1932)
  18. Complete National Film Registry Listing - Library of Congress
  19. The Music Box | Reviews - Rotten Tomatoes
  20. Block-Heads; The Music Box review – five-star absurdity from Laurel ...
  21. Review: Laurel & Hardy: The Definitive Restorations on Kit Parker ...
  22. Laurel & Hardy's Genius of Everyday Chaos - PopMatters
  23. Lux Radio Theater 1944 : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming
  24. Laurel and Hardy - The Definitive Restorations Volume One Blu-ray
  25. Collections Etc Laurel and Hardy 6-DVD Set - Amazon.com
  26. Music Box Steps Day - Silver Lake Improvement Association
  27. Graphic Stunt Comedy and the Emergence of Crisis Slapstick - jstor
  28. The Actors Who Inspired Jackie Chan's Comedy Style - Screen Rant
  29. Laurel and Hardy Film Preservation Fund
  30. Laurel & Hardy : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming
  31. "I was born a poor black child." The iconic opening line and scene ...
User Avatar
No comments yet.