Hubbry Logo
When Christmas Comes Around...When Christmas Comes Around...Main
Open search
When Christmas Comes Around...
Community hub
When Christmas Comes Around...
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
When Christmas Comes Around...
When Christmas Comes Around...
from Wikipedia

When Christmas Comes Around...
Studio album by
ReleasedOctober 15, 2021 (2021-10-15)
Recorded2021
Studio
  • Brooklyn Bridge Music
  • The Eastwood Stage at Warner Bros. Studio
  • Everland Studios
  • Glenwood Place Studios
  • The Listening Station
  • Manhattan Beach Recording
  • Ocean Way
  • The Ribcage
  • Southern Ground
  • The Vibe Room
GenrePop
Length47:51
LabelAtlantic
Producer
Kelly Clarkson chronology
Meaning of Life
(2017)
When Christmas Comes Around...
(2021)
Kellyoke
(2022)
Singles from When Christmas Comes Around...
  1. "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)"
    Released: September 23, 2021
  2. "Santa, Can't You Hear Me"
    Released: December 9, 2022

When Christmas Comes Around... is the second Christmas album and ninth studio album by American singer Kelly Clarkson, released through Atlantic Records on October 15, 2021, nearly four years after her eighth album Meaning of Life (2017). Produced by Jesse Shatkin, Jason Halbert, Joseph Trapanese and Aben Eubanks, it is her second Christmas album after Wrapped in Red (2013). Featuring cover versions of Christmas songs, as well as original co-penned tracks and duets with Chris Stapleton, Ariana Grande and Brett Eldredge, its release was preceded by the singles "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)" and "Santa, Can't You Hear Me". It also includes previously released singles "Christmas Eve", "All I Want for Christmas Is You", and "Under the Mistletoe" as bonus tracks. The album was nominated for Best Traditional Pop Vocal Album at the 65th Annual Grammy Awards.[1]

Promotion for the album included a Christmas special of the same title, which premiered on NBC on December 1, 2021. The Christmas special premiered with a 0.6 rating and 4.3 million total viewers.[2][3] A deluxe reissue of the album featuring two new tracks was released on November 1, 2024, including the single "You for Christmas".[4]

Background and recording

[edit]

"My purpose for choosing this lyric as the title of this project was to bring forth a sense of reality to the fact that we are probably in very different places emotionally When Christmas Comes Around... Some of us are consumed with a new love, some of us reminded of loss, some filled with optimism for the coming new year, others elated for some much deserved time away from the chaos our work lives can sometimes bring us. Wherever you are, and whatever you may be experiencing, I wanted everyone to be able to connect to a message on this album. Each year you may even have a new favorite depending on where you are in your life, but while change can be unpredictable there is no better time of year, in my opinion, to breathe hope into one’s life and let possibility wander."

—Clarkson on naming the album When Christmas Comes Around...[5]

Following the release of her first Christmas album Wrapped in Red in 2013 on RCA Records, Clarkson transferred to Atlantic Records and has issued the Christmas tracks "Christmas Eve" (2017), "Under the Mistletoe" (with Brett Eldredge), and a cover of Vince Vance & the Valiants' "All I Want for Christmas Is You" (2020).[6] In an interview on the television program Entertainment Tonight, she revealed that she was not originally intending to record another Christmas studio album due to her fondness for her first, but later decided to following the emotional stress induced by the highly publicized divorce the previous year.[7] In recording the album, Clarkson recorded cover versions of various Christmas classics and wrote new material featuring duets with American recording artists Chris Stapleton and Ariana Grande.[6]

Themes and inspirations

[edit]

Atlantic Records has promoted When Christmas Comes Around... as an exploration of "a wide range of holiday emotions and experiences anchored by Clarkson's incomparable vocal prowess".[6] Clarkson has elaborated that the album will explore various themes of love, loss, hope, and optimism — emotions that people tend to experience during the holiday season.[5][7]

Drawing inspiration from her experiences during the past two years, she remarked of the album's title, her first to not have a titular track since My December (2007), as "when Christmas comes around, we are all in different places." Further adding that its selection of tracks will both evoke a somber and posit a jolly atmosphere. Characterizing it as "a different Christmas album", she portrayed When Christmas Comes Around... as feeling more like a normal studio album, but "there's Christmas sprinkled on it."[7]

Release

[edit]

When Christmas Comes Around... was released by Atlantic Records on October 15, 2021.[7] A special edition shipped exclusively to Target retail stores would also feature a Christmas card signed by Clarkson.[8] Its lead single "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)", was released on September 23, 2021.[9] "Glow" with Stapleton and "Santa, Can't You Hear Me" with Grande were released as promotional singles alongside the album's release.[10][11] The deluxe reissue of the album was released on November 1, 2024.[4]

Critical reception

[edit]
Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusicStarStarStar[12]
Slant MagazineStarStarStarHalf star[13]

In a roundup of new holiday albums, The New York Times music critic Jon Caramanica praised Clarkson's "nimble" vocals and wrote that the original tracks, some of them strikingly "uncelebratory," make the album stand out.[14] In the year-end episode of his Times podcast Popcast, Caramanica again praised the album, calling it "very, very good [...] solid [and] impressive," though "not quite Mariah-level."[15] Mike DeWald of Riff Magazine praised how Clarkson's original songs are "something fresh and listenable."[16] Sal Cinquemani of Slant Magazine, who gave the album three-and-a-half out of five stars, criticized some production choices but praised Clarkson's "impressive" vocals and "melodic variations" on the classics as the "chief selling point."[17]

Marcy Donelson of AllMusic gave the album three out of five stars, called it "a vibrant, fully orchestral, high-volume set on average", and singled out "Merry Christmas (To the One I Used to Know)" and "Santa, Can't You Hear Me" as highlights among the newest tracks."[12] Vulture's Justin Curto called Clarkson "the queen of the holidays", calling the album a gift for Christmas. Curto especially appreciated the collaboration with Ariana Grande, as it sounds "as majestic as you would expect from the two singers."[18] Sal Cinquemani from Slant Magazine found that while the original songs on When Christmas Comes Around... "don't quite live up to the lofty bar she previously set" on Wrapped in Red, the album "juxtaposes the yuletide blues with jubilant holiday standards," further noting that "Clarkson's vocals, then, are the album’s chief selling point."[17]

Track listing

[edit]
When Christmas Comes Around...[19][20]
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
1."Merry Christmas Baby"Jesse Shatkin3:45
2."It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas"Meredith WillsonShatkin1:54
3."Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)"
3:51
4."Merry Christmas (To the One I Used to Know)"
  • Clarkson
  • Eubanks
  • Halbert
  • Halbert
  • Trapanese
4:10
5."Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree"Johnny MarksShatkin1:52
6."Glow" (with Chris Stapleton)
Halbert3:18
7."Santa Baby"
Halbert2:50
8."Santa, Can't You Hear Me" (with Ariana Grande)
  • Clarkson
  • Eubanks
Halbert4:02
9."Last Christmas"George MichaelHalbert3:09
10."Jingle Bell Rock"
  • Joseph Beal
  • James Ross Boothe
Shatkin1:56
11."Blessed"Halbert3:34
12."Christmas Come Early"
Halbert2:59
13."Under the Mistletoe" (with Brett Eldredge; Bonus track)
  • Clarkson
  • Eubanks
  • Eubanks
  • Shatkin
3:45
14."All I Want for Christmas Is You" (Bonus track)Shatkin3:46
15."Christmas Eve" (Bonus track)
  • Clarkson
  • Halbert
Halbert3:00
Total length:47:51
When Christmas Comes Around...Again – Deluxe edition[4]
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
1."You for Christmas"Ronson2:54
2."Sleigh Ride"Ronson2:10
3."Merry Christmas Baby"
  • Clarkson
  • Eubanks
Shatkin3:45
4."It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas"WillsonShatkin1:54
5."Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)"
  • Clarkson
  • Halbert
  • Collins
  • HalbertTrapanese
3:51
6."Merry Christmas (To the One I Used to Know)"
  • Clarkson
  • Eubanks
  • Halbert
  • Halbert
  • Trapanese
4:10
7."Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree"MarksShatkin1:52
8."Glow" (with Chris Stapleton)
  • Clarkson
  • Halbert
  • Hills
  • Warner
  • Thomas
Halbert3:18
9."Santa Baby"
Halbert2:50
10."Santa, Can't You Hear Me" (with Ariana Grande)
  • Clarkson
  • Eubanks
Halbert4:02
11."Last Christmas"MichaelHalbert3:09
12."Jingle Bell Rock"
  • Beal
  • Boothe
Shatkin1:56
13."Blessed"
  • Robbins
  • Gad
  • Cohen
Halbert3:34
14."Christmas Come Early"
  • Strand
  • Baker
  • Kestner
  • Lubben
Halbert2:59
15."Under the Mistletoe" (with Brett Eldredge; Bonus track)
  • Clarkson
  • Eubanks
  • Eubanks
  • Shatkin
3:45
16."All I Want for Christmas Is You" (Bonus track)
  • Stone
  • Powers
Shatkin3:46
17."Christmas Eve" (Bonus track)
  • Clarkson
  • Halbert
Halbert3:00

Personnel

[edit]

Credits adapted from the album's liner notes

Recorded and engineered at

  • Brooklyn, New York (Brooklyn Bridge Music)
  • Burbank, California (The Eastwood Stage at Warner Bros. Studio, The Listening Station, Glenwood Place Studios)
  • Los Angeles, California (The Ribcage)
  • Nashville, Tennessee (Ocean Way, Southern Ground)
  • New York City (Manhattan Beach Recording)
  • Pasadena, California (The Vibe Room)
  • Studio City, California (Everland Studios)
  • Universal City, California

Performance credits

  • Kelly Clarkson – all vocals
  • Jessi Collins – background vocals
  • Luke Edgemon – background vocals
  • Brett Eldredge – featured vocals
  • Ariana Grande – featured vocals
  • Nayanna Holley – background vocals
  • Tiffany Palmer – background vocals
  • Bridget Sarai – background vocals
  • Chris Stapleton – featured vocals
  • Brandon Winbush – background vocals

Musicians

Production

Charts

[edit]
Chart performance for When Christmas Comes Around...
Chart (2021–2025) Peak
position
Australian Albums (ARIA)[21] 61
Belgian Albums (Ultratop Flanders)[22] 147
Canadian Albums (Billboard)[23] 31
Dutch Albums (Album Top 100)[24] 26
German Albums (Offizielle Top 100)[25] 42
Hungarian Albums (MAHASZ)[26] 23
Lithuanian Albums (AGATA)[27] 58
New Zealand Albums (RMNZ)[28] 19
Scottish Albums (OCC)[29] 80
Swiss Albums (Schweizer Hitparade)[30] 41
UK Albums (OCC)[31] 94
US Billboard 200[32] 22
US Top Holiday Albums (Billboard)[33] 1

Release history

[edit]
When Christmas Comes Around... release history
Region Date Format Label Catalog number Ref.
Various October 15, 2021 Atlantic 864083-4 [19][34]
Christmas card CD 864006-3 [8]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
When Christmas Comes Around... is the ninth studio album and second Christmas album by American singer , released on October 15, 2021, through . The 15-track project blends traditional holiday standards with original songs, highlighting Clarkson's versatile vocals across upbeat anthems and melancholic ballads, and includes collaborations with on "," on "Glow," and on "Mr. Christmas." Produced primarily by , the album was recorded during the and reflects a range of , from joy to heartbreak, inspired by Clarkson's personal experiences. The lead single, "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)," a sassy pop track about post-breakup resilience, was released on September 23, 2021, and set the tone for the album's modern twist on festive themes. Other originals like "Merry Christmas (To the One I Used to Know)" and covers such as "It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas" and "" showcase Clarkson's interpretive range, earning praise for her powerful delivery. Upon release, When Christmas Comes Around... debuted at number one on the Billboard Top Holiday Albums chart and reached number 22 on the , selling over 43,000 units in its first week. It has since accumulated 47 weeks on the Top Holiday Albums chart as of November 2025, maintaining a strong seasonal presence. Critics lauded Clarkson's vocal prowess and the album's emotional depth, with awarding it 3.5 out of 5 stars for juxtaposing yuletide blues with jubilant standards. The project received a Grammy nomination for Best Vocal Album in 2023. In 2024, a deluxe edition titled When Christmas Comes Around... Again added two new tracks, further extending its holiday appeal.

Background and development

Conception and inspirations

Kelly Clarkson's second Christmas album, When Christmas Comes Around..., emerged as a natural extension of her 2013 holiday project , aiming to create a more intimate and emotionally varied collection that reflected contemporary life experiences. Announced on September 23, 2021, via , the album was positioned as a follow-up that delved deeper into personal storytelling, with Clarkson expressing a desire to craft music that resonated amid shifting personal circumstances. Central to the album's conception were Clarkson's reflections on her family life and evolving role as a mother to her two children, then aged 5 and 7, whom she described as "magical beings" that brought unexpected joy and a profound sense of responsibility. She noted that motherhood, which she initially never envisioned for herself, profoundly shaped the album's joyful and nostalgic tone, infusing it with themes of , snuggling, and simple traditions like cookies for Santa to evoke and hope. This familial influence contributed to the project's therapeutic quality, particularly in the wake of the previous two years marked by pandemic-related cancellations and disruptions, which Clarkson cited as prompting a need for " cheer" to counter emotional hardships. The title track's lyric choice underscored Clarkson's intent to capture "holiday magic" in a post-pandemic context, acknowledging how individuals might be in "very different places emotionally" during the season, blending optimism with realism to "breathe hope into one’s life." Inspirations also drew from classic holiday songs, such as reworking elements into originals like "Glow" featuring Chris Stapleton, which adopted a soulful, vintage vibe reminiscent of traditional carols, and her ongoing experiences performing Christmas music on The Kelly Clarkson Show, where the festive energy of live segments reinforced her passion for the genre's emotional range.

Song selection process

The standard edition of When Christmas Comes Around... consists of 15 tracks, strategically blending covers of holiday standards with original songs to create a festive yet personal collection. Notable covers include the soulful rendition of "Merry Christmas Baby," originally by Charles Brown, while originals such as "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)" inject a sassy, contemporary edge reflective of Clarkson's evolving artistry. This mix was curated to balance nostalgia with innovation, ensuring the album appeals to both traditional listeners and those seeking fresh holiday fare. Kelly Clarkson, as , played a pivotal role in emphasizing soulful and upbeat selections to differentiate the project from her 2013 album Wrapped in Red, which leaned more heavily on orchestral big-band arrangements. She aimed for a vibrant, emotionally resonant sound that captured joy amid personal challenges, drawing from influences like and holiday music. Producer Jason Halbert noted the intentional focus on uplifting production, such as playful horns and girl-group-style vocals on tracks like "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)," to lighten potentially heavy themes without veering into melancholy. Collaboration with key producers, including Halbert and Jesse Shatkin, facilitated the curation of traditional carols like "It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas" alongside modern interpretations, such as the duet "Santa, Can't You Hear Me" with Ariana Grande. Live elements, including a 40-piece orchestra for strings, added a timeless soulfulness to the selections. Certain songs were excluded to maintain thematic cohesion, particularly avoiding overly somber pieces that might undermine the album's celebratory tone; Halbert explained this choice as a way to transform personal introspection into relatable, lighthearted holiday spirit.

Recording and production

Studio sessions

The recording of When Christmas Comes Around... took place primarily in 2021 at studios in Los Angeles and Nashville, including The Eastwood Stage at Warner Bros. in Burbank, California, and Brooklyn Bridge Music in Nashville, Tennessee. These locations facilitated a collaborative environment that blended Clarkson's pop sensibilities with country influences, reflecting her Texas roots and current residence in the region. Sessions extended from summer through fall 2021, with Clarkson juggling the demanding schedule of her daytime talk show, , which taped in during this period. This timeline enabled her to record vocals and oversee production during off-days and breaks, ensuring the project aligned with an release. The process emphasized live , including brass sections and orchestral elements, to achieve a warm, organic holiday atmosphere that prioritized emotional depth over polished digital production. COVID-19 protocols presented notable challenges, leading to some remote contributions from collaborators and musicians to minimize on-site gatherings while maintaining safety. Despite these constraints, the sessions captured the album's intimate, festive spirit through in-person band performances where possible, with engineers like Robert Venable and handling key tracking duties. This approach contributed to the album's cohesive sound, blending classic covers with original tracks in a live-feel setting.

Key collaborators

The album's primary production was handled by Jesse Shatkin and Jason Halbert, longtime collaborators of Clarkson who shaped its blend of festive covers and original compositions. Shatkin, known for his work on Clarkson's earlier albums like Piece by Piece, produced several classic covers, including "Merry Christmas Baby," "It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas," "Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree," "Santa Baby," and "Under the Mistletoe," infusing them with lush, orchestral arrangements that emphasize Clarkson's vocal range. Halbert, Clarkson's musical director and frequent co-producer, led the production on the original tracks, such as "Glow" (co-produced with Danja), bringing a contemporary pop-soul edge to the holiday themes. Songwriting for the originals highlighted Clarkson's hands-on involvement, as she co-wrote multiple tracks to personalize the album's emotional core. For "Glow," a duet with Chris Stapleton, Clarkson collaborated with songwriters Jason Halbert, Hayley Warner, Jesse Thomas, and Danja (Floyd Nathaniel Hills), crafting lyrics about enduring love amid holiday glow. She also co-penned "Santa, Can't You Hear Me" with Aben Eubanks, addressing themes of longing and festive frustration, while "Merry Christmas (To the One I Used to Know)" was co-written with Halbert and Eubanks, reflecting on post-breakup holidays. Additionally, "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)" featured Clarkson alongside Halbert and Jessi Collins, turning personal heartbreak into an upbeat anthem. Throughout, Clarkson contributed to arrangements, ensuring the tracks aligned with her vision of joyful yet introspective Christmas music. Guest vocalists added star power and vocal chemistry to key duets. joined Clarkson on "," delivering harmonious pleas in a track that became a standout single for its playful yet poignant delivery. provided soulful country-inflected vocals on "Glow," complementing Clarkson's performance with his gravelly to evoke warmth and nostalgia.

Music and lyrics

Musical style and genre

When Christmas Comes Around... is characterized by a predominant pop-soul and R&B style, infused with and elements that give it a warm, nostalgic feel. The album's sound draws on traditional while incorporating contemporary production, creating a dynamic blend that feels both festive and personal. Clarkson's vocal delivery remains versatile and powerful, echoing the emotive range seen in her non-holiday albums like Meaning of Life, where she similarly explores soulful pop terrains. Instrumentation plays a key role in evoking classic Christmas atmospheres, with prominent use of sections for lively energy, pianos for melodic warmth, and strings for orchestral depth. These elements contribute to the album's big-band influences, adding a layer of sophistication to the holiday arrangements without overwhelming the intimacy of the performances. The production, handled by collaborators like , ensures a polished yet organic that highlights Clarkson's voice as the central force. The tracks exhibit notable variations in tempo and mood, ranging from upbeat swing numbers to more subdued . For instance, "" features a swinging, brass-driven that captures joyful exuberance, while "" opts for an intimate approach with gentle piano and strings for emotional resonance. Similarly, "It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas" delivers an energetic, pop-infused swing vibe, contrasting with quieter gospel-tinged moments in tracks like "Blessed." These shifts keep the album engaging, balancing high-energy holiday cheer with reflective introspection.

Thematic elements

The lyrical content of When Christmas Comes Around... emphasizes themes of joy, family, love, and resilience, portraying the holiday season as a time for emotional recovery and connection amid life's challenges. Clarkson has described the album as reflecting the "varying stages of our lives," where holidays can evoke both celebration and , particularly in the context of post-pandemic recovery when many were emerging from isolation and . This sense of reality grounds the songs in authentic experiences, highlighting love's enduring role in fostering hope and togetherness during difficult periods, such as personal upheavals or global hardships. Original tracks like "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)" explore and resilience, with that depict a moving forward from heartbreak to reclaim holiday joy, refusing to let past relationships dim the season's spirit. The song serves as an of self-empowerment, blending festive imagery with messages of independence and emotional strength, allowing listeners to find liberation in the holidays. Clarkson co-wrote the track, infusing it with personal conviction drawn from her own life transitions, which adds layers of relatability to its themes of love's evolution and personal growth. Nostalgia permeates the album's cover versions of holiday standards, such as "It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas" and "," which evoke fond memories of traditional celebrations through vivid depictions of family gatherings, twinkling lights, and shared warmth. These selections tie into broader by prioritizing secular elements like communal cheer and seasonal magic, creating a comforting bridge to collective cultural experiences without overt religious focus. Clarkson's interpretations personalize these classics, with references to loved ones underscoring the album's emphasis on relational bonds and enduring affection.

Release and promotion

Marketing strategies

The marketing strategies for Kelly Clarkson's ninth studio album, When Christmas Comes Around..., emphasized early holiday excitement through digital and television platforms to build anticipation ahead of its October 15, 2021, release. Teaser campaigns commenced in September 2021, with Clarkson posting on Instagram about her personal obsession with Christmas and previewing lyrical content from the lead single "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)" on September 15. The full album announcement followed on September 23, 2021, shared across social media, where she revealed the tracklist featuring collaborations with artists like Ariana Grande and Chris Stapleton, alongside covers of holiday classics. As host of The Kelly Clarkson Show, Clarkson integrated promotions into episodes, announcing the single on September 15 and using the platform to share her enthusiasm for the project, leveraging her daytime TV audience for broad reach. To extend commercial reach, the campaign included partnerships with brands for merchandise directly tied to the . Official exclusive collections were launched in early October 2021 through channels, offering themed items such as apparel, ornaments, and bundled packages designed to complement celebrations. These collaborations aimed to create immersive fan experiences beyond music consumption. Engagement efforts featured virtual listening parties and behind-the-scenes content shared online to foster community interaction. Clarkson hosted a Holiday Kickoff Celebration livestream on December 3, 2021, performing tracks from the album and interacting with fans in real-time, serving as a post-release extension of pre-launch buzz. Additional behind-the-scenes videos, including recording sessions and personal holiday anecdotes, were posted on and throughout and , providing glimpses into the album's production. The strategies specifically targeted families and holiday enthusiasts, capitalizing on Clarkson's relatable persona as a and aficionado to promote wholesome, festive content suitable for multi-generational audiences. This focus aligned with broader promotional ties, such as the holiday special sponsored by , emphasizing home and .

Singles and media

The from When Christmas Comes Around..., "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)", was released on September 23, 2021, ahead of the album's launch, and received a lyric video highlighting its sassy, post-breakup holiday theme. A video of the track aired during Clarkson's holiday special, emphasizing its upbeat, empowering vibe. The duet "" with appeared on the album upon its October 15, 2021, release and was later issued as a live single on December 2, 2022, capturing their collaborative vocal chemistry in a big-band pop style. The track gained notable chart traction during the holiday season, boosted by a live featuring both artists on the special Kelly Clarkson Presents: When Christmas Comes Around, which premiered on December 13, 2021, and showcased festive staging with holiday lights and ensemble backing. Promotional efforts included performance videos for other tracks, such as "Glow" (a with ), which aired in TV specials like Christmas in Rockefeller Center on November 29, 2023, presenting the song's soulful, harmonious glow amid twinkling decorations. These visuals tied directly into the album's overarching holiday narrative, with the NBC special serving as a central media hub that integrated multiple songs from the project through celebrity cameos and themed segments.

Deluxe edition promotion

A deluxe edition of the album, titled When Christmas Comes Around... Again, was released on November 1, 2024, adding two new original tracks: "You for Christmas" and a cover of "O Holy Night." Clarkson promoted the reissue through social media announcements in late October 2024, including Instagram posts teasing the new content and encouraging pre-saves. The release was tied to her ongoing holiday specials and performances, further boosting the album's seasonal chart performance.

Critical reception

Contemporary reviews

Upon its release in October 2021, Kelly Clarkson's When Christmas Comes Around... received generally positive reviews from critics, who praised her and joyful delivery across the album's blend of original songs and holiday standards. Sal Cinquemani of awarded it 3.5 out of 5 stars, highlighting how Clarkson "juxtaposes the yuletide blues with jubilant holiday standards," noting her emotive performance on tracks like the duet with as a standout that captures heartfelt longing. Critics frequently commended Clarkson's versatile vocals, describing them as "compelling" and capable of infusing both upbeat and melancholic tunes with warmth and power. In Riff Magazine, the reviewer emphasized her "shine" on soulful opener "Merry Christmas Baby," praising the expansive arrangement that showcases her range without overpowering the holiday spirit. AllMusic's Marcy Donelson gave the album 3 out of 5 stars, calling it "a vibrant, fully orchestral, high-volume set on average" with soulful production that elevates covers like "It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas." Some reviews pointed to weaknesses in the album's reliance on over-familiar covers that occasionally lacked fresh innovation. Cinquemani noted the "faithful" rendition of "Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree," which felt off-theme amid the more personal originals. Similarly, a review in The Harvard Crimson praised the sentimental appeal and Clarkson's compelling vocals across the album's mix of originals and holiday standards. Aggregate scores reflected this mixed but favorable consensus, with Album of the Year compiling a 65/100 based on early critic input.

Accolades and recognition

The album When Christmas Comes Around... received a for Best Traditional Pop Vocal Album at the , held in 2023 for releases from the previous year. The 2024 deluxe edition, retitled When Christmas Comes Around… Again and released on November 1, added the original track "You for Christmas" and a cover of "," which were promoted through official visualizers, live performances including at the Lighting, and streaming campaigns to extend the album's holiday appeal.

Commercial performance

Chart achievements

The album When Christmas Comes Around... debuted at number one on the Top Holiday Albums chart on October 30, 2021, marking Kelly Clarkson's second chart-topper on the ranking following her 2013 release . It held the summit position for three consecutive weeks during the 2021 holiday season and has re-entered the chart each year thereafter, accumulating a total of 47 weeks as of November 2025. On the all-genre , the album entered at number 22 in its debut week, becoming Clarkson's ninth top-40 entry on the tally. Internationally, the album achieved modest success on holiday-oriented lists. It peaked at number 31 on the Billboard Canadian Albums chart in January 2022. In the overall , it later re-entered at number 94 in January 2023 and number 79 in January 2024. The album's singles also made notable impacts on U.S. charts. The "Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)" debuted at number 79 on the dated December 25, 2021, marking Clarkson's 21st entry on the ranking. The collaboration "" peaked at number 76 on the Hot 100 in January 2023, while reaching number 50 on the Holiday 100. Both tracks benefited from seasonal airplay and streaming, contributing to the album's enduring chart presence. The 2024 deluxe edition, retitled When Christmas Comes Around... Again and featuring two new original songs ("You for Christmas" and "Sleigh Ride"), contributed to the album's ongoing presence on the Top Holiday Albums chart during the holiday period.

Sales figures

In the United States, When Christmas Comes Around... sold over 43,000 units in its first week, encompassing a combination of physical sales, digital downloads, and streaming-equivalent albums. The 2024 deluxe edition, titled When Christmas Comes Around... Again, provided a boost through renewed interest in holiday streaming and physical reissues during the season, supporting the album's sustained commercial performance.

Track listings and formats

Standard edition

The standard edition of When Christmas Comes Around..., released on October 15, 2021, by , comprises 15 tracks that mix original holiday songs co-written by with renditions of standards, totaling approximately 48 minutes in length. Produced primarily by , Jason Halbert, Aben Eubanks, and (arrangements), the album emphasizes Clarkson's versatile vocals over lush orchestral backings and contemporary pop elements. Several tracks feature guest artists, including on the duet "," on "Glow," and on "Christmas Come Early." The track listing, including durations and songwriters, is presented below:
No.TitleDurationSongwriter(s)
1""3:45, Aben Eubanks
2"It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas"1:54
3"Christmas Isn't Canceled (Just You)"3:51, Aben Eubanks, Mark Nilan Jr.,
4"Merry Christmas (To the One I Used to Know)"4:10, Jason Halbert, Mark Nilan Jr.,
5""1:53
6"Glow" (featuring )3:18, Jason Halbert, Jesse Shatkin, Hayley Warner, Danja
7""2:51Joan Javits, , Tony Springer
8"Santa, Can't You Hear Me" (featuring )4:03, Aben Eubanks
9""3:10
10""1:57Joe Beal, Jim Boothe
11"Blessed"3:35Lindy Robbins, Tobias Gad, KOLE
12"Christmas Come Early" (featuring )3:00Dave Lubben, Molly Kate Kestner, Brock Monroe, Bobby Strand
13""3:46, Usher Raymond IV
14"All I Want for Christmas Is You"3:47,
15"Christmas Eve"3:01, Jason Halbert, Mark Nilan Jr.,
Key arrangements highlight Clarkson's improvisational style, with prominent vocal ad-libs in originals like "" and covers such as "," where she incorporates soulful runs and scat elements to infuse personal energy into the festive material. The orchestral swells, arranged by , underscore these vocal flourishes, particularly in duets that blend harmonies seamlessly.

Deluxe edition (2024)

On November 1, 2024, released the deluxe reissue of her 2021 holiday , titled When Christmas Comes Around... Again, through . This expanded version comprises 17 tracks in total, incorporating the original 15 songs alongside two new recordings. The additions include the original composition "You for Christmas," a festive track written by Clarkson, and a newly arranged cover of the classic "." These tracks were produced to enhance the album's holiday offerings, providing fresh material for listeners during the season. The responds to ongoing fan interest in Clarkson's , extending the album's availability with updated content to celebrate the holidays anew. It features refreshed packaging, including new artwork that distinguishes it from the standard edition.

Credits

Personnel

Kelly Clarkson provides lead vocals on all tracks of When Christmas Comes Around.... Featured vocalists include on "," on "Glow," and on "." Background vocals are contributed by Jessi Collins, Nayanna Holley, Brandon Winbush, and Bridget Sarai across various festive tracks. The album's musicians encompass a range of instrumentalists supporting the holiday arrangements. Key contributors include:
RolePersonnelNotes
Drums, PercussionAaron RedfieldTracks 1, 2, 5, 7, 10, 13
DrumsLester EstelleTracks 3, 4, 6, 8, 9, 11, 12, 15
GuitarAben EubanksTracks 13, 15
GuitarErick SernaTracks 2, 5, 7, 10, 13, 14
GuitarLuke SullivantTrack 9
Bass, Upright BassKyle WhalumTracks 3, 4, 6, 8, 9, 11, 13
Piano, Keyboards, Hammond B-3, ProgrammingJason HalbertTracks 3, 4, 6, 8, 9, 11, 12, 15
Synthesizer, Drum Programming, PercussionTracks 1, 2, 5, 7, 10, 13, 14
KeyboardsAben EubanksTrack 8
Piano, OrganTommy KingTracks 1, 2, 5, 7, 10
Trumpet, Brass ArrangementTracks 1, 2, 5, 7, 10, 13, 14
Technical staff for the standard edition includes producers Jesse Shatkin (tracks 1, 2, 5, 7, 10, 14), Jason Halbert (tracks 6, 8, 9, 11, 12, 15; co-producer Danja on track 6), along with engineers Robert Venable (tracks 3, 4, 6, 8, 9, 11, 12, 15), Drew Atz (brass recording on tracks 1, 2, 5, 7, 10), and Spencer Dennis (assistant brass recording on tracks 1, 2, 5, 7, 10). The 2024 deluxe edition (When Christmas Comes Around... Again) retains the original personnel for its standard tracks while adding contributions for the two new songs, "You for Christmas" and "Sleigh Ride." Musicians include Greg Kurstin on piano and keyboards for multiple tracks, Leroy Clampitt on bass, and Mark Ronson as producer for both new tracks. Background vocals continue with Jessi Collins and Bridget Sarai. Featured vocalists remain Ariana Grande, Chris Stapleton, and Brett Eldredge on their respective tracks.

Production details

The production of When Christmas Comes Around... involved a collaborative effort to blend contemporary pop arrangements with holiday instrumentation, emphasizing post-recording refinement for sonic clarity and warmth. Mixing was primarily handled by Grammy-winning engineer Șerban Ghenea at MixStar Studios in , where he applied his signature approach to balance vocals, orchestral elements, and rhythmic layers across the tracks. Engineered by John Hanes, the mixing process focused on enhancing the album's festive dynamics while maintaining Clarkson's vocal prominence. Mastering was completed by at Sterling Sound in , with assistance from Will Quinnell, ensuring consistent loudness and tonal balance suitable for streaming and physical formats. Gehringer's work contributed to the album's polished, radio-ready sound, particularly in integrating live-recorded brass and strings for a rich holiday texture. Some tracks also received additional engineering from Jason Halbert, who oversaw arrangements and production to refine the overall cohesion. For the 2024 deluxe edition, titled When Christmas Comes Around... Again, the two new tracks—"You for Christmas" (original) and "" (cover)—underwent fresh production, including new recordings and overdubs to expand the album's emotional range. These additions were mixed by both Șerban Ghenea and , with mastering handled by , , and Will Quinnell at Sterling Sound, providing updated sonic enhancements for the reissue. This process allowed for subtle refinements, such as layered harmonies and instrumental accents, distinct from the original 2021 sessions.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.