Ah Girls Go Army
Ah Girls Go Army
Main page
A

Ah Girls Go Army

logo
Community Hub0 subscribers
Read side by side
Ah Girls Go Army
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Ah Girls Go Army
Directed byJack Neo
Written byLink Sng
Starring
  • Apple Chan
  • Glenn Yong
  • Samantha Tan
  • Shirli Ling
  • Farah Farook
  • Eswari Gunasagar
  • Kelly Kimberly Cheong
  • Belle Chua Bei Er
  • Karyn Wong Shimin
  • Charlene Huang Xiang Lin
  • Veracia Yong
  • Xixi Lim
  • Ke Le
  • Juliet Hor
  • Yong Yu
  • Chloe Goh
  • Vanessa Tiara Tay
  • Debra Loi
  • Jonathan Tee
  • Vince Chua
  • Chuang Li
  • Chan Li Li
Edited byYim Mun Chong
Production
companies
J Team Productions
mm2 Entertainment
Asia Momentum Media
Distributed byCathay Organisation
Release dates
  • 1 February 2022 (2022-02-01)
(Singapore, Malaysia, Brunei)
Running time
120 minutes
CountrySingapore
LanguagesEnglish
Mandarin
BudgetS$2 million
Box officeS$2.5 million (as of 17 Feb 2022)

Ah Girls Go Army (simplified Chinese: 女兵外传; traditional Chinese: 女兵外傳; pinyin: nǚ bīng wàizhuàn; lit. 'Female Soldiers' Biography') is a 2022 Singaporean military comedy film directed by Jack Neo. A spin-off of Neo's Ah Boys to Men films, the film follows the first batch of female recruits as they undergo and serve National Service in the fictional near future of Singapore.

The film stars Apple Chan, Xixi Lim, Samantha Tan, Shirli Ling, Farah Farook, Eswari Gunasagar, Kelly Kimberly Cheong, Belle Chua Bei Er, Karyn Wong Shimin, Charlene Huang Xiang Lin, Veracia Yong, Juliet Hor, Glenn Yong, Ke Le, Yong Yu, Chloe Goh, Vanessa Tiara Tay, Debra Loi and Summer Loh.[1]

It was one of the five 2022 Malaysian and Singaporean Chinese New Year films, including Reunion Dinner (Singapore), Nasi Lemak 1.0, Kongsi Raya and Small Town Heroes (Malaysia). On release, the film was panned by critics.

Synopsis

[edit]

The film is set in a theoretical future where, due to the declining birth rate in Singapore, there are not enough males to fulfil the National Service manpower requirements.[2] The film focuses on the first batch of female SAF recruits, who are 14 Gen-Z girls from different socio-economic backgrounds. They undergo Basic Military Training, which pushes them to their physical and emotional limits. As they undergo their training, they begin to appreciate National Service, and also learn to manage their personal issues.

Cast

[edit]
  • Apple Chan as 2nd Lieutenant Roxanne Tan
  • Glenn Yong as 2nd Sergeant C K Chow
  • Ke Le as Recruit Princess See[3]
  • Belle Chua as Recruit Joey Tay
  • Xixi Lim as Recruit Yuan Yuan Yuan
  • Samantha Tan as Recruit Goh Bee Bee
  • Eswari Gunasagar as Recruit Kamala
  • Charlene Huang as Recruit Lau Lan Lan
  • Shirli Ling as Recruit Chow Ai Lian
  • Veracia Yong as Recruit Peh Mani
  • Kelly Kimberly Cheong as Recruit Amanda Ong
  • Karyn Wong as Recruit Karen Seow
  • Farah Farook as Recruit Fatimah
  • Chloe Goh as Recruit Zhang Li
  • Vanessa Tiara Tay as Recruit Bobo Chia
  • YY Yong Yu as Recruit Soh Bi Qing
  • Juliet Hor as Recruit Monica Chng[4]
  • Jonathan Tee as Sergeant Mar Tee
  • Debra Loi
  • Jaze Phua as Sergeant Ho
  • Andruew Tang as Sergeant Hulk Tan

Production

[edit]

Development

[edit]

Plans for the film were announced in September 2021. Neo had wanted to shoot this film as he wanted to explore the scenario where conscription of women for National Service is required to support Singapore's defence. Neo said that Singaporeans are fortunate to live in a relatively safe and stable world, but wanted to know what happens should the population of young people drop to levels below what is required for defence given the falling birth rate each year. He added that the film wishes to explore if women can step up for defence much like men are expected, mirroring the first batch of male recruits called up in 1967.[1][5][6] The film is sponsored by companies like Holistic Way, Foodpanda, CARRO Group, Nippon Paint, Ogawa, Seng Choon, New York Skin Solutions, and Livingcare.

Casting

[edit]

Casting began via online auditions in September 2021, the same time when plans were first announced. Those who participated were to send videos of themselves acting as a character they chose.[1][5] The auditions attracted thousands of audition videos submitted for the film, thus increasing the number of female recruit roles from an initial 10 to 14. The cast was unveiled in October that year, with some prominent faces including Apple Chan, ex-Night Owl Cinematics talent Samantha Tan, founder/content creator of Double Up 欢迎光玲 (known for their viral Chinese comedy skits) Charlene Huang Xiang Lin, voice actress and martial arts content creator Kelly Kimberly Cheong, Miss Vasantham finalist Eswari Gunasagar, Farah Farook, Xixi Lim, Mediacorp artistes Ke Le and Glenn Yong among others.[7][8]

Filming

[edit]

Filming is expected to last 25 days, with all scenes being completed by November 2021.[5] Shooting only began on 12 November 2021, when the lensing ceremony was held. The scenes were finished in December 2021.[9]

Controversy

[edit]

An uproar ensued over one of the characters named "Amanda Man" by netizens raising concerns over offence potentially caused to the transgender community and perpetuating misconceptions, coming after actress Kelly Kimberly Cheong posted a picture of herself during the film's lensing ceremony. The post has since been taken down, and Cheong clarified that the character she plays is a "cisgender, biological girl" who is known for her fighting ability. Cheong later raised the issue to Neo, adding that the character is a tomboy and did not mean for the backlash to happen. Nonetheless, Neo still pledged to change the character's name, apologising for any distress caused. The character was eventually changed to "Amanda Ong".[10][11][12][13][14]

Some criticism was also given to the naming of an obese character as 'Yuan Yuan Yuan' (meaning Round Round Round in Mandarin), played by Xixi Lim, which was slammed as fat-shaming and a lack of creativity. Neo refuted these criticisms, saying that people should watch the movie first before commenting and that the character did more things than they thought. Lim added that the character's name was "cute" as it sounded like her double name, and hopes those watching will get the message that people who are large can do many things just like those who are small.[15][16]

Release

[edit]

The film was released in Singapore cinemas on 1 February 2022, the first day of Chinese New Year.[1][5] Before the release, on 21 January, the producers of the film announced an exclusive giveaway of 8,888 non-fungible tokens via Cathay Cineplexes during advance ticket sales that began on 28 January.[17]

Reception

[edit]

The movie received widespread criticism and scorn prior and after its release. The Straits Times film correspondent John Lui gave the film 2/5 stars,[18] remarking that it was "as funny as a positive Covid test", that it "takes effort to be this terrible" - "where effort is made to make fun of women being women", that it was "making fun of people already made fun of in society".[19] Douglas Tseng from 8 Days gave it 1/5 stars, describing Jack Neo's directing and storytelling as "tone deaf", and full of pervasive product placements. Tseng also criticised the unflattering depiction of women in the movie, remaking "Seriously, do young women really behave like this? Jack, when was the last time you hung out with young women?".[20] Lim Yian Lu from Yahoo! Life similarly criticised the product placement and incoherent plot, giving it 1/5 stars.[21] Delfina Utomo from Time Out said the movie is mostly a "chaotic Facebook Live video of someone selling me products", a film with low-brow humour that is characteristic of Neo's previous films, and the plot revolving around "taking initiative". Utomo also pointed out that the scriptwriters writing the film had no idea of "what it's like being woman", saying that the dialogue and plot appeared condescending even as it avoided objectifying women. This is emphasised by the fact that the film's characters acted or spoke in a childish manner, further elaborated with a film's character whose suicide attempt was treated rather insensitively.[22]

Matthaeus Choo from Sinema.SG commented that though Jack Neo has previous movie successes by bringing to life emotions shared by Singaporeans, the film appeared to be disconnected from reality. Choo added that while Ah Boys to Men was able to scrape by as the characters are stand-ins for people being encountered in real life, the movie does not have that link, criticising the stereotypes that underpin the show.[23] Amanda Tan from Youthopia said that the movie was a "slipshod" rendition of the original Ah Boys to Men film series, referencing previous criticisms made by previous reviewers including a poorly written story and characters not being fully developed with the only saving point being good-looking actors. Tan pointed that as a Gen-Z woman, she only took the message that it was a "misogynistic portrayal of women", being unable to comprehend the unrealistic plot.[24]

The Ministry of Defence also chimed in, asking anyone that wishes to really know what girls undergo in Basic Military Training to watch their 2015 series instead.[25]

In response to these criticisms, Ah Boys to Men actor Tosh Zhang slammed those hating the film on Facebook, alluding to the silent majority who watched the movie and defending the cast, congratulating them for their effort. Several main and supporting cast members thanked Zhang for his support. Zhang also put up a more forceful post on Instagram.[26][27] Neo justified product placements in the film by saying it is difficult to make money from movies. Quoting an example, Neo said that if a movie production cost $1 million, another $3 million is needed before it starts to earn profits.[28][29]

Box office

[edit]

Despite negative reviews, the movie raked in S$1.15 million as of 3 February 2022, with the S$1 million mark achieved over the first six days.[30] It reached the S$1.3 million mark a day later,[31] then S$1.67 million on 7 February[32] and eventually grossing over S$2 million as of 17 February 2022. In Malaysia and Brunei, the film had a grossing of RM1.5 million as of 17 February 2022.[33] Despite high profits at the box office, mm2 Entertainment admitted that reception to the movie was "mixed".

Sequel

[edit]

Plans for a sequel called Ah Girls Go Army Part 2 were announced on 7 February 2022,[32] with the release date tentatively set for June 2022. Some scenes have already been shot as part of the sequel, with additional scenes to be shot in March.[34] The film, now known as Ah Girls Go Army Again, was released on 16 June 2022.[35]

"The girls go through gruelling obstacles in their GBMT journey, which eventually lands them in a dangerous situation and their actions will shock the nation."[36][37]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Ah Girls Go Army

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Ah Girls Go Army is a 2022 Singaporean military comedy film written and directed by Jack Neo, centering on a cohort of young women compelled to enlist for National Service in an imagined near-future scenario where insufficient male recruits due to demographic trends mandate female conscription.[1][2] The film, a spinoff from Neo's Ah Boys to Men franchise, depicts the recruits' training rigors, interpersonal dynamics, and personal growth amid boot camp challenges, blending humor with themes of discipline, patriotism, and gender roles in national defense.[1][3] Despite widespread critical derision for its clichéd jokes, stereotypical portrayals of Gen Z youth, and perceived insensitivity—such as a character name evoking transgender tropes that drew pre-release accusations of transphobia, leading to director Neo's public apology—the movie resonated with audiences and grossed over S$2 million at the Singapore box office, marking it as the highest-earning local production amid pandemic restrictions and prompting a swift sequel, Ah Girls Go Army Again, released the same year.[4][5][3] Additional pre-release scrutiny targeted a plus-sized recruit's depiction as fat-shaming, which Neo defended as motivational rather than derogatory.[6]

Plot

Summary

Ah Girls Go Army is a 2022 Singaporean comedy film set in a fictional near-future where declining birth rates and insufficient male enlistments prompt the government to introduce mandatory National Service for females.[7][8] The narrative centers on the inaugural cohort of young women, primarily from Generation Z, who are conscripted into the Singapore Armed Forces to undergo Basic Military Training (BMT).[1] This policy shift addresses demographic pressures, including Singapore's fertility rate, which fell to 1.05 children per woman in 2023, exacerbating manpower shortages for defense.[9] The story follows these recruits as they navigate the rigors of military life, transitioning from civilian comforts to disciplined routines involving physical drills, obstacle courses, and team-building exercises. Diverse in backgrounds—from urban influencers to academically inclined peers—the protagonists confront initial resistance, physical limitations, and interpersonal dynamics within their platoon.[10] The film explores their adaptation process, highlighting struggles with authority, peer rivalries, and personal growth amid the structured environment of BMT.[11] Central conflicts revolve around overcoming individual weaknesses and fostering camaraderie to meet training demands, culminating in a scenario that tests their resolve during a broader national emergency.[12] Through these experiences, the recruits mature, transforming initial reluctance into a sense of duty and unity, underscoring themes of resilience and collective responsibility in service to the nation.[13]

Cast and Characters

Main Cast

Apple Chan stars as Second Lieutenant Roxanne Tan, the platoon commander guiding the new female enlistees through basic military training. Chan, previously known for her role as Lieutenant Zhang Xinyi in Ah Boys to Men 4 (2017), brings experience to the ensemble while the film marks a continuation of her military-themed portrayals.[14] The recruit ensemble predominantly consists of debut film performers, including Xixi Lim as the overweight and indolent Yuan Yuan Yuan, Samantha Tan as a fellow trainee, Shirli Ling, and Farah Farook, who collectively form the core group of young women adapting to conscript life.[15][14][16] These actresses were selected from thousands of audition submissions, highlighting the production's emphasis on fresh talent for the recruit roles.[17] Glenn Yong reprises his character as Second Sergeant C K Chow, a stern instructor originating from the Ah Boys to Men series, providing continuity with the franchise's established military figures. The cast incorporates diverse representation, notably with transgender actress Kelly Kimberly Cheong in a supporting role, selected through open auditions alongside other newcomers like Tan.[17]

Supporting Roles

Glenn Yong portrays Second Sergeant C.K. Chow, a platoon sergeant who serves as an instructor and disciplinarian, offering guidance to the recruits and embodying the military's emphasis on resilience and order.[1] His role provides a foil to the recruits' civilian backgrounds, highlighting the shift to structured service life.[4] Cameo appearances by actors from the Ah Boys to Men series, such as those playing advisory military figures, maintain continuity with the franchise and underscore intergenerational themes of national duty, portraying senior personnel who reinforce the value of conscription across demographics.[2][18] Family and civilian characters, enacted by emerging talents including Eswari Gunasagar and Farah Farook, depict relatives and peers who contrast the rigors of enlistment with pre-service comforts, often motivating recruits through familial expectations of contribution to society.[19][20] These portrayals emphasize causal links between personal growth and collective responsibility, drawing from Neo's recurring motifs in prior works.[21]

Production

Development and Concept

Ah Girls Go Army was conceived by director Jack Neo as a spinoff from his successful Ah Boys to Men military comedy franchise, which chronicles male conscripts' experiences in Singapore's National Service (NS).[2] Neo announced the project on September 29, 2021, with principal photography slated to begin soon after for a Chinese New Year 2022 release on February 1.[22] The concept shifts the focus to female protagonists, depicting a cohort of young women undergoing mandatory NS training in a hypothetical near-future Singapore where demographic pressures necessitate their enlistment.[2] The film's premise draws from Singapore's persistent low fertility rates, which fell to 0.97 children per woman in 2023, amplifying discussions on sustaining defense capabilities amid a shrinking population base, though NS remains exclusively male-mandated in reality.[23] Neo framed the narrative around recruits initially resisting enlistment but ultimately embracing discipline through communal challenges, without endorsing actual policy shifts toward female conscription.[21] This approach extends the franchise's comedic exploration of NS rigors—such as physical training and hierarchical dynamics—to gender-specific adaptations, highlighting resilience and adaptation in a defense context.[19] Produced on a budget of S$2 million, the film aligned with Neo's broader aim to instill patriotic values like perseverance and national duty, consistent with his prior works that celebrate military service as a rite of passage.[24]

Casting Process

Director Jack Neo conducted an open online audition for Ah Girls Go Army, which attracted thousands of applicants seeking roles as female recruits.[14][16] This process enabled the selection of 14 fresh faces, primarily young actresses aged 18 to 30, to embody the Gen Z recruits from diverse socioeconomic and educational backgrounds central to the film's narrative.[25][13] The emphasis on newcomers aimed to inject authenticity and relatability, mirroring the target audience's demographic while portraying contemporary Singaporean youth navigating basic military training in a fictional future scenario.[25] Neo announced the cast via a Facebook Live stream on October 23, 2021, highlighting the blend of these debutants with established collaborators from his prior military-themed films, such as Apple Chan reprising her officer role from Ah Boys to Men 4.[14][16] This strategic mix balanced novelty with proven familiarity, incorporating influencers and former models like Samantha Tan and Shirli Ling to enhance appeal without prior acting pedigrees dominating the ensemble.[14] The selection prioritized performers capable of conveying the physical and emotional demands of recruit life, though specific preparatory consultations with military personnel were not publicly detailed.[25]

Filming and Technical Aspects

Filming for Ah Girls Go Army occurred primarily at alternative sites simulating military environments, as the Ministry of Defence (MINDEF) was not involved in the production, unlike prior entries in director Jack Neo's military-themed series. Locations included an unused school in Bedok to replicate basic military training facilities, avoiding official Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) camps such as Pulau Tekong.[26][27] The production emphasized practical approaches for action and training sequences, with actors performing physical drills and obstacle courses on set to convey the rigors of enlistment, though without direct SAF consultation, leading to noted inaccuracies in depictions of military protocols. Neo directed with his established style, blending slapstick humor derived from cultural stereotypes, sentimental family melodrama, and heavy use of Singlish vernacular to ground the narrative in local Singaporean contexts.[28][19] Principal photography commenced in late 2021 and spanned approximately 25 days, wrapping by November to allow for post-production completion in January 2022, aligning with the film's targeted release on February 1, 2022, coinciding with Chinese New Year. Challenges during shoots included variable weather conditions and pandemic-related disruptions, which influenced on-location scheduling.[21][29]

Pre-Release Controversies

Character Naming Disputes

Prior to the film's release, the character portrayed by transgender actress Kelly Kimberly Cheong, a mixed martial arts practitioner, drew criticism for being named "Amanda Man," with detractors arguing the moniker mocked transgender identity by implying trans women remain men.[30][5] This backlash emerged in November 2021 after promotional materials surfaced online, prompting netizens to label the choice as transphobic and insensitive, particularly given Cheong's real-life transgender status.[31] Director Jack Neo responded with a public apology on November 18, 2021, stating he had no intention of offending anyone and that the name was not meant to reference gender identity, while expressing willingness to consider altering it if necessary.[30][31] Cheong herself clarified that the role depicts a cisgender, biological female tomboy rather than a transgender individual, emphasizing the character's traits as tough and androgynous without tying to her personal identity.[5] Defenders countered that the name was coincidental and unrelated to gender, pointing to the film's broader theme of promoting inclusivity for women of diverse backgrounds in national service, including those with non-traditional appearances.[31] Online discussions, amplified on platforms like Reddit's r/singapore subreddit, debated whether the naming reflected deliberate insensitivity or an oversight in a lighthearted comedy, with some users dismissing the uproar as overreaction to a phonetic similarity in English.[32] Ultimately, the character retained the name "Amanda Man" in the final film, released in 2022, without further reported alterations.[33]

Depiction of Physical Attributes

The portrayal of recruit physiques in Ah Girls Go Army, particularly the plus-sized character Yuan Yuan Yuan played by Xixi Lim, drew pre-release accusations of insensitivity and fat-shaming in January 2022. Critics, including netizens on platforms like Instagram and commentary from pages such as Wake Up Singapore, argued that the character's name—repeating "Yuan" (meaning "round" in Chinese)—mocked her body type and reinforced stereotypes of overweight individuals as comedic or inferior, especially in a military context demanding physical fitness.[34][6] Director Jack Neo defended the depiction, stating that audiences should view the full film before judging, as the character arc demonstrates Yuan Yuan Yuan's competence and transformation through training, subverting expectations of her physical limitations rather than deriding them.[6][34] Lim echoed this, describing the name as a playful, memorable double moniker akin to her own stage name "Xixi," and emphasized that her role highlights how plus-sized individuals can excel in demanding activities, outperforming slimmer peers in stamina and endurance during filming—mirroring real Basic Military Training (BMT) requirements where recruits, regardless of starting physique, must achieve standardized fitness benchmarks like the Individual Physical Proficiency Test (IPPT).[35][6] Supporters praised the realism of depicting diverse body types among recruits, arguing it reflects Singapore Armed Forces BMT realities where initial overweight enlistees undergo rigorous conditioning to meet combat readiness standards, fostering growth without endorsing mockery.[34] Opponents, including some media reviews like in The Straits Times, maintained the emphasis on physical traits perpetuated harmful tropes, though no alterations were made to the film's content amid the online discourse.[35] Lim later clarified post-release that while personal netizen comments were hurtful, the character's narrative empowered rather than shamed plus-sized viewers.[35]

Release

Theatrical Premiere

Ah Girls Go Army premiered theatrically in Singapore on February 1, 2022, aligning with the first day of Chinese New Year to leverage peak cinema attendance during the holiday period.[3][22] The release strategy targeted family-oriented audiences, positioning the film as a comedic exploration of female national service in a near-future Singapore scenario.[21] Promotional efforts included trailers distributed on YouTube and social media platforms, emphasizing the humor derived from Gen Z recruits adapting to military rigors and narratives of personal growth and resilience.[36][37] These materials highlighted ensemble dynamics and lighthearted challenges, aiming to appeal to younger demographics while building anticipation through viral sharing.[38] The rollout extended to regional markets in Southeast Asia, with screenings in countries such as Malaysia shortly following the Singapore debut, facilitating broader audience reach in the Mandarin-speaking film circuit.[8][39]

Distribution and Availability

Ah Girls Go Army became available for streaming on Netflix in regions including Singapore on September 19, 2023, providing post-theatrical digital access to audiences beyond its initial cinema run.[40][41] This global platform expanded reach to international viewers where licensed, though availability varies by territory.[42] The film was exported to markets like Malaysia and Brunei for theatrical distribution, leveraging director Jack Neo's regional appeal among Mandarin-speaking audiences, with synchronized releases on February 1, 2022.[24] Post-theatrical digital options in these areas align with Netflix's regional rollout, facilitating continued access without confirmed widespread physical home media releases such as DVD or Blu-ray editions.

Commercial Success

Box Office Earnings

Ah Girls Go Army, released on 1 February 2022, earned S$1.15 million at the Singapore box office within its first three days, coinciding with the Chinese New Year holiday period.[43] By 7 February, the film had grossed S$1.67 million, surpassing initial projections amid cinema capacity restrictions imposed by pandemic measures.[24] The film's momentum continued, crossing S$2 million by 18 February and establishing it as the highest-grossing Singapore-made production since the COVID-19 outbreak began, outperforming other local releases under similar operational constraints such as reduced seating and heightened health protocols.[3] This performance was bolstered by positive word-of-mouth among audiences, particularly families and national service enthusiasts, despite limited marketing budgets typical of independent Singaporean productions.[43] By December 2022, cumulative earnings reached S$2.26 million in Singapore, securing its position as the top-grossing Asian film of the year domestically and highlighting director Jack Neo's track record with patriotic-themed comedies that resonate during festive seasons.[44] In comparison to Neo's prior franchises like Ah Boys to Men, which amassed over S$10 million per installment in pre-pandemic years, Ah Girls Go Army demonstrated resilience in a constrained market, though on a smaller scale reflective of evolving audience behaviors and venue limitations.[44]

Reception

Critical Assessments

Professional critics largely panned Ah Girls Go Army (2022), directed by Jack Neo, for its formulaic scripting, reliance on outdated stereotypes, and tone-deaf portrayal of female recruits in a military setting.[45] [9] Aggregate review scores reflected this negativity, with IMDb users rating the film 4.1 out of 10 based on 195 votes as of early 2023, citing issues like poor writing and overt product placement.[1] Similarly, Letterboxd's average user score stood at 2.4 out of 5 from 316 ratings, underscoring critiques of its simplistic humor and lack of depth in character development.[46] The Straits Times review described the film as "as funny as a positive Covid test," faulting it for getting core elements wrong despite a premise exploring gender dynamics in national service, and labeled its execution as firing "blanks" in comedic and narrative impact.[9] 8 Days magazine called it a "tone-deaf military comedy," questioning Neo's understanding of contemporary young women through depictions that leaned on exaggerated physical attributes and insensitive gags, such as body-shaming tropes around a character's weight.[45] Sinema.SG critiqued its departure from Neo's typical semi-autobiographical style into "complete fiction," arguing it exposed weaknesses in handling military pride and recruit experiences without authentic grounding.[7] Some reviews acknowledged the film's intent to address demographic pressures via a timely all-female conscription scenario amid Singapore's low birth rates, but dismissed the execution as formulaic and unoriginal, recycling Neo's prior army comedies without fresh insight.[28] Time Out Singapore's assessment implied the film's English-heavy dialogue and cultural in-jokes failed to land broadly, reinforcing perceptions of insensitivity in humor targeting gender roles and physical fitness standards.[11] Overall, critics viewed it as entertaining for undemanding audiences but flawed in scripting nuance and avoidance of stereotypes that clashed with modern sensitivities.[45] [9]

Audience and Cultural Responses

The film elicited strong grassroots support among audiences appreciative of its pro-National Service (NS) messaging, contrasting with pre-release controversies and contributing to widespread social media discussions on familial and patriotic duties. Public endorsements highlighted the movie's appeal to everyday viewers who valued its emphasis on resilience and collective responsibility, with online chatter spiking amid its rapid box office trajectory.[47][48] Actor Tosh Zhang, known from the related Ah Boys to Men series, publicly rebuked detractors as "the truly low class ones" in a February 4, 2022, social media post, attributing the film's early S$1 million earnings to the dedication of its cast and crew while dismissing critics as disconnected from popular sentiment. This defense underscored the populist resonance of the production, positioning it as a counter to perceived elitist dismissals and amplifying supporter voices online.[49][50] The narrative's depiction of female conscription amid a fictional demographic crisis prompted societal debates on gender equity in defense obligations, linking to Singapore's real-world resident total fertility rate of 1.04 in 2022—the lowest on record—and associated concerns over population sustainability and youth engagement with NS. These discussions reflected broader cultural tensions around eroding traditional values of military service, with the film serving as a populist vehicle to reaffirm duty amid declining birth rates and shifting generational priorities.[51][52]

Official Military Perspectives

The Ministry of Defence (MINDEF) explicitly stated it had no involvement in the production of Ah Girls Go Army, distinguishing the film from earlier entries in Jack Neo's military series that received Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) support.[27] [53] In the wake of the film's February 1, 2022, release, MINDEF on February 4 shared clips from its own 2015 seven-episode web series documenting real female volunteers' Basic Military Training (BMT), emphasizing unportrayed hardships like nighttime route marches, blisters, and abrasions to inform public curiosity about women in military service.[54] [55] This response underscored differences between the film's comedic dramatizations and documented SAF training realities for female personnel.[56] Former female SAF soldiers, who serve as volunteers rather than conscripts, have highlighted inaccuracies in the film's depiction of physical and social aspects of service, including oversimplified portrayals of endurance training, unit cohesion, and gender-specific challenges that deviate from their experiences.[28] While acknowledging the film's intent to evoke national service ethos amid recruitment needs, MINDEF has shown no official endorsement and maintains a policy against female conscription, with Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen stating on May 9, 2022, that enlisting women—even in non-combat roles—would impose societal costs exceeding benefits, such as delayed workforce participation.[57] [58] This stance tolerates the movie's fictional premise of mandatory service for women due to birth rate declines but reflects unchanged policy, prioritizing male conscription for operational readiness without extending it to females.[59]

Sequel

Ah Girls Go Army Again Overview

Ah Girls Go Army Again is a 2022 Singaporean military comedy film directed by Jack Neo, functioning as a direct sequel to the 2022 original Ah Girls Go Army. Released theatrically on 16 June 2022, it extends the narrative by depicting the same group of female recruits advancing to Guard Basic Military Training (GBMT), where they encounter intensified physical and situational demands.[60][61] The plot centers on the recruits navigating grueling obstacles during training, which culminate in a dangerous scenario requiring them to solidify their camaraderie and personal growth. Core elements include misunderstandings surrounding Sergeant Chow's directives, prompting the characters—portrayed by returning leads such as Apple Chan as the protagonist, Xixi Lim, Glenn Yong, and Belle Chua—to confront escalated trials that build on their foundational experiences from basic training in the first film. This continuation emphasizes themes of resilience and unity under pressure, without recapping prior events.[60][62] The sequel's development followed the original film's strong box office performance, which exceeded S$2 million in Singapore earnings, prompting an announcement for a follow-up to capitalize on audience interest in the premise of female National Service enlistment. Jack Neo retained his directorial oversight, preserving the comedic lens on military life while amplifying stakes for narrative progression.[24]

Sequel Production and Reception

The sequel, Ah Girls Go Army Again, entered production shortly after the original film's release on February 1, 2022, with principal photography wrapping by April 20, 2022, enabling a swift theatrical debut on June 16, 2022.[63][64] Director Jack Neo, responding to critiques of the first film's excessive product placement and stereotypical portrayals, incorporated adjustments such as minimizing commercial intrusions after initial scenes and enhancing plot coherence to better align with audience feedback on pacing and character development.[65][66] Neo emphasized that such input drives refinement, stating criticism aids improvement rather than deterring the team.[66] The narrative amplifies themes of personal maturity and interpersonal bonds forged through perilous training exercises, depicting the recruits' progression from novice "Ah Girls" to resilient "Ah Women" via rigorous Guard Basic Military Training (GBMT) obstacles that test endurance and unit cohesion.[65] Production maintained high technical standards, with polished action sequences and reduced reliance on formulaic humor, though some training depictions remained plot-driven rather than deeply exploratory of platoon dynamics.[65] Reception proved mixed, earning an IMDb user rating of 5/10 from 119 reviews, reflecting divided sentiments on its execution.[60] Reviewers noted partial success in mitigating prior flaws, with one assessment praising the sequel's surprise elevation over low expectations through tighter storytelling and authentic character arcs, yet critiquing underdeveloped ensemble interactions.[65] Cast members, including Xixi Lim, framed ongoing backlash as indicative of the film's cultural relevance, prioritizing empowerment motifs over detractors' focus on stereotypes.[66] Debates persist on efficacy: while adjustments curbed some insensitivities like overt commercialism, persistent elements of contrived peril and selective diversity representation suggest incomplete resolution of foundational critiques from the original.[65][66]

References

  1. Ah Girls Go Army (2022) - IMDb
  2. Singapore's 'Ah Boys to Men' Franchise Getting Female-Driven Spinoff
  3. 'Ah Girls Go Army' breaks pandemic box office record in Singapore
  4. Ah Girls Go Army Review: Jack Neo's Tone-Deaf Military Comedy ...
  5. Jack Neo apologises over Ah Girls Go Army character played by ...
  6. Jack Neo says Ah Girls Go Army character 'Yuan Yuan' isn't fat ...
  7. Film Review: 'Ah Girls Go Army' - Sinema.SG
  8. Ah Girls Go Army (Film) - TV Tropes
  9. At The Movies: Courting greatness in King Richard; Ah Girls Go ...
  10. I got to watch 'Ah Girls Go Army' on official work ... - Mothership.SG
  11. I Watched Ah Girls Go Army So Nobody Has To - Time Out
  12. Ah Girls Go Army Again - InCinemas
  13. Ah Girls Go Army: Jack Neo loses the plot (again) with 5th military ...
  14. Director Jack Neo unveils Ah Girls Go Army cast | The Straits Times
  15. Director Jack Neo unveils Ah Girls Go Army cast | The New Paper
  16. Director Jack Neo Unveils The Cast Of The New Ah Girls Go Army ...
  17. NOC talent Samantha Tan & TikToker Kelly Kimberly join 'Ah Girls ...
  18. Singapore's military movie franchise 'Ah Boys To Men' to get female ...
  19. Ah Girls Go Army puts gender twist on Jack Neo's military series
  20. Samantha Tan, Eswari Gunasagar to join cast of Jack Neo's Ah Girls ...
  21. Jack Neo to release Ah Girls Go Army for Chinese New Year 2022
  22. Jack Neo's Ah Girls Go Army coming for Chinese New Year 2022
  23. Ah Girls Go Army puts gender twist on Jack Neo's military series
  24. Ah Girls Go Army Part 2 slated for June 2022 release
  25. 11 Facts About The Ah Girls Go Army Movies, Like Wild Boar Sightings
  26. r/singapore on Reddit: Ah Girls Go Army Review: Jack Neo's Tone ...
  27. 10 things to know about Jack Neo's Ah Girls Go Army
  28. Former Women Soldiers of SAF on What Jack Neo Got Wrong
  29. Uncle Brownie and Ah Girls Go Army - mrbrown's photo stories
  30. Ah Girls Go Army director Jack Neo apologises for character named ...
  31. Jack Neo apologises for transgender actress being named 'Amanda ...
  32. r/singapore on Reddit: Jack Neo apologises for naming trans actress ...
  33. Not limited to playing laughing stocks: Ah Girls Go Army transgender ...
  34. Jack Neo & Actress Respond to Criticisms That They Fat-Shame a ...
  35. Xixi Lim Doesn't Think She Was Fat-Shamed In Ah Girls Go Army
  36. Official Trailer - Ah Girls Go Army《女兵外传》- Opening 1 Feb 2022
  37. Ah Girls Go Army | Trailer 1 - video Dailymotion
  38. 'Ah Girls Go Army' Movie Premieres On 1 Feb 2022, Now ... - MS News
  39. Ah Girls Go Army - Callout For Beloved Malaysians - YouTube
  40. Where to watch 'Ah Girls Go Army (2022)' on Netflix | Flixboss
  41. Watch Ah Girls Go Army | Netflix
  42. Ah Girls Go Army streaming: where to watch online? - JustWatch
  43. 'Ah Girls Go Army' makes S$1.15 million within 3 days of movie's ...
  44. 'Ah Girls Go Army' makes S$2.26 million, was S ... - Mothership.SG
  45. Ah Girls Go Army Review: Jack Neo's Tone-Deaf Military Comedy ...
  46. Ah Girls Go Army - Reviews, film + cast - Letterboxd
  47. Despite the negative chatter, Ah Girls Go Army brand sponsors aren ...
  48. Original 'Ah Boys to Men' actor Tosh Zhang slams haters of 'Ah Girls ...
  49. Tosh Zhang Calls Haters Of Ah Girls Go Army “The Truly Low Class ...
  50. Tosh Zhang Calls Haters Of Ah Girls Go Army “The Truly Low Class ...
  51. Record number of marriages, drop in Singaporean births in 2022
  52. A new film depicts a future where women are conscripted in Singapore
  53. 6 Facts About Ah Girls Go Army Before You Watch It During CNY
  54. MINDEF urges S'poreans curious about women soldiers in BMT to ...
  55. MINDEF 'Roasts' Ah Girls Go Army by Resharing Its Female BMT ...
  56. MINDEF Reminds S'poreans What 'Real' Women's BMT Is Like By ...
  57. Oral Reply by Minister for Defence Mr Ng Eng Hen to Parliamentary ...
  58. Cost of enlisting women into NS, even in non-military roles, far ...
  59. A Gender-Comedy Prediction for Singapore's Military - Bloomberg.com
  60. Ah Girls Go Army Again (2022) - IMDb
  61. Ah Girls Go Army Again (2022) - Popcorn Singapore
  62. Jack Neo - Ah Girls Go Army Again (2022) - Letterboxd
  63. Jack Neo PreparesTo Make More Money With Ah Girls Go Army Again
  64. 'Ah Girls Go Army Again' to be released on June 16, 2022
  65. I had low expectations for 'Ah Girls Go Army Again', but the movie ...
  66. 'It's not criticism we're afraid of': Jack Neo and Ah Girls Go Army cast ...
User Avatar
No comments yet.