Hubbry Logo
Sharon CarrSharon CarrMain
Open search
Sharon Carr
Community hub
Sharon Carr
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Sharon Carr
Sharon Carr
Sharon Carr
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Sharon Louise Carr (born 1979), also known as "The Devil's Daughter", is a Belizean woman who, in June 1992, aged 12, murdered 18-year-old Katie Rackliff at random as the latter walked home from a nightclub in Camberley, Surrey, England.

Key Information

The murder initially went unsolved until June 1994, when Carr attacked and stabbed another pupil at Collingwood College Comprehensive School for no apparent reason and then repeatedly boasted about the murder of Rackliff to friends and family and in her diary entries made in prison. She was convicted of the murder in 1997, attracting much media interest due to her young age and the brutality of the killing. She was ordered to serve at least 14 years’ imprisonment but has remained imprisoned long after this minimum tariff expired due to her disruptive behaviour in prison. A restricted Status prisoner, she has continued to regularly attack and attempt to kill staff members and fellow inmates and has regularly expressed her desire to kill others. In September 2022, it was reported that her case would again go before a parole board.

Background

[edit]

Carr was born in Belize on 21 December 1979 and was brought up by her mother and stepfather.[2] She was one of four children and grew up in great poverty.[3] She never knew her biological father.[3] After moving to England in 1986, the family settled in Camberley, Surrey.[2][3] Her parents' marriage soon ended following a serious domestic violence incident in which Sharon's mother poured boiling fat over Sharon's stepfather.[4] The incident caused the couple to be hospitalised with burns, and Sharon's mother was charged with assault.[3]

At school, Sharon was initially described as polite and helpful by teachers.[2] Friends said that she was a sociable girl who preferred the company of older boys and that she occasionally showed flashes of aggression.[3] Later, she became much more badly behaved, becoming disruptive and attention-seeking, and she had problems relating to authority.[2][3] In 1990, her headteacher at Cordwallis Junior School in Camberley contacted social services over her behaviour.[3] Sharon was briefly put into foster care, but she returned home after only one month away.[2] By the time she started secondary school, her mother had a new partner who already had two daughters.[3]

Murder of Katie Rackliff

[edit]

In the early hours of 7 June 1992, Carr randomly stabbed 18-year-old apprentice hairdresser Katie "Kate"[5] Rackliff to death as the latter walked home from Ragamuffins nightclub in Camberley.[3][6] Carr stabbed Rackliff—who was a stranger to her—32 times with a six-and-a-half-inch knife through her ribs, in her heart and in her vagina and anus.[3] Some of Rackliff's jewellery was then stolen.[7] Rackliff's body was taken by Carr and some accomplices and driven to Farnborough, where she was dragged along a road and then dumped by a cemetery wall.[3] A group of boys found the body later that morning.[3]

When police investigated the killing, they noted the brutality of the attack.[2] Some of the knife blows that Rackliff had suffered had gone straight through her body.[2] Her sexual organs had been mutilated, and officers found that her clothes had been pulled up, but there was no sign of sexual assault.[2] Due to the nature and severity of the injuries inflicted and the fact that the attack appeared to be sexually motivated, police believed the attacker to be an adult male.[4][8][9] In part because of this, the real killer went unidentified, and the case went initially unsolved.[8][10][9][7]

Stabbing of pupil

[edit]

With Carr not apprehended, she returned to school but was excluded twice in early 1994.[3] On 7 June 1994, the second anniversary of Rackliff's murder, Carr attacked a 13-year-old fellow pupil with a knife, for no apparent reason, in the toilets at Collingwood College Comprehensive School.[4][2][3][11] Carr stabbed the victim in the back, causing a lung puncture; the attack was stopped when five students entered the toilets and intervened.[4] The victim said that Carr was smiling and appeared happy during the attack.[4] Carr did not return home that day and was found on school grounds the next morning;[1] after being arrested, she told officers that she enjoyed stabbing cats and had beheaded a dog.[3]

Initial imprisonment and further attacks

[edit]

After arrest, Carr was sent to a medical assessment centre, where she tried to strangle two members of staff.[2] She was charged with two counts of actual bodily harm for this in addition to the charges for the attack at Collingwood College.[2] She was convicted in December 1994 and sentenced to be detained "at Her Majesty's pleasure".[2][3] She was initially held in various psychiatric units but continued to regularly seriously assault other females, and so was transferred to an all-boys unit at Aycliffe Secure Centre.[7] In September 1995, she was transferred to Bullwood Hall young offenders' institution in Essex, where it was thought her aggressive and sexualised behaviour could be better managed.[7]

Confessions to Rackliff murder

[edit]

Soon after her transfer to Bullwood Hall, staff discovered that Carr was talking about the killing of Katie Rackliff to friends and family on the telephone and in her diary.[2] She also admitted to attacking a prison officer who she said she had a 'crush' on and talked about it to a probation officer.[2] Staff alerted police, who seized Carr's writings and drawings.[2][11] Her diaries were found to contain details of her sexual excitement at the thought of Rackliff's death, and Carr also commented that she felt "jealous" of her victim and remarked about the devil and the forces which motivated her.[3] One passage read "If only I could kill you again [...] I promise I would make you suffer more this time, you fucking slag. Your terrified screams turned me on."[3] The sexual element of the killing had previously been indicated by the mutilation of Rackliff's body.[7] Carr had also written "I swear I was born to be a murderer", and in a letter to a friend, wrote "I'm a killer. Killing is my business. And business is good."[3][10] She had also drawn pictures of the knife involved.[2] Detectives questioned Carr on the murder, and she confessed to the killing, admitting that she had repeatedly stabbed Rackliff.[2] She graphically described one particular injury and provided details that the police had deliberately withheld, meaning that she had knowledge that only the killer would have.[2] Carr also knew that a bracelet had been stolen from Rackliff, which police had not revealed.[2] Carr helped police film a reconstruction of the murder in which she acted out the murder and, when questioned about the attack, repeatedly laughed about the details.[3]

Police found that Carr had a long history of cruelty to animals, having once decapitated a dog with a spade, and concluded that she probably had a form of psychopathic disorder.[10][6] Carr continued to write her boasts about the murder even after being questioned by the police, and in January 1996 gave a further series of confessions to prison officers that she had a 'crush' on.[2][3] On the fourth anniversary of the murder on 7 June 1996, she wrote in her diary: "Respect to Katie Rackliff. Four years ago today."[2]

Murder trial

[edit]

Carr was charged with the murder of Rackliff in May 1996.[2] Her accomplices did not stand trial. On 25 March 1997, after a month-long trial at Winchester Crown Court, Carr was convicted of murder.[2][3] The jury had deliberated for five hours before reaching a unanimous guilty verdict, choosing to convict her for murder and not manslaughter.[3] The conviction meant that Carr was officially Britain's youngest ever female murderer, having been only 12 at the time of the killing (Mary Bell, who was convicted at age 11 in connection with the killings of two boys in 1968, was convicted of manslaughter instead of murder).[2][11] When sentencing Carr, Mr Justice Baker remarked: "What is clear is that you had a sexual motive for this killing and it is apparent both from the brutal manner in which you mutilated her body and chilling entries in your diary, that killing, as you put it, turns you on. You are in my view an extremely dangerous young woman."[3] Carr was smiling as she left the dock after the conviction.[4] She received a minimum tariff of 14 years imprisonment after her trial.[6]

Criminal psychologist Gordon Tressler noted the extremely unusual nature of the case, saying: "This is a difficult case to understand. One can find precedents of young children killing other young children, but in this case it was a child killing someone who was almost an adult."[2]

Carr was branded "The Devil's Daughter" in the press.[10][12][13][14] The media reported extensively on the historical conviction of such a young murderer, highlighting her obsession with death and violence.[2][3][11]

Subsequent imprisonment and continued attacks

[edit]

Following her murder conviction, Carr was held in HM Prison Holloway.[7] She was later transferred to Broadmoor Hospital in 1998.[7] While in Broadmoor, she continued to assault staff and other residents and admitted wanting to kill a fellow inmate by slitting her throat.[6] On occasions, she also claimed to believe that she was a lizard and tried to cut herself to attempt to find out whether she was still human.[6]

In 2004, it was reported that Carr's defence team were challenging her 14-year minimum tariff as well as her conviction, with Carr wanting her murder conviction to be replaced with one of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.[6] However, the appeals were dismissed.[6][7]

In 2007, Carr was moved again to the medium-secure Orchard Unit but was sent to HM Prison Bronzefield in Surrey in 2015 as a Restricted Status prisoner as she was presenting a risk to patients and staff.[7] Her warrant stated that she no longer required treatment or that no effective treatment could be given.[7] In December 2018, she was moved to HM Prison Low Newton in County Durham but was quickly moved back to Bronzefield after a violent incident with another inmate in August 2019.[7] In the same year, her application for her Restricted Status to be downgraded was denied.[7] She appealed against this decision in 2020, but this was also denied on the grounds that she had yet to provide any significant evidence of a reduction in risk.[7][9] Category A prison supervisors at Bronzefield reported that Carr was still evidencing incidents of volatile relationships and was continuing to have paranoid thoughts.[7] She had also disclosed the desire to murder another prisoner.[7]

As of September 2022, Carr continues to be imprisoned despite the expiration of her minimum tariff.[12][7][4] It was also reported in September 2022 that Carr was to have another parole hearing to determine whether she would be released.[12]

In August 2023, Carr was denied parole after still being considered a danger to the public.[15]

Lasting notoriety

[edit]

Carr's case has been noted for being particularly unusual. While female murderers are themselves uncommon, females who kill strangers are even more unusual, and the case of a 12-year-old girl killing an adult stranger has been described as unique.[4][2]

In 2005, there was another stabbing incident at Collingwood College, in which a 14-year-old stabbed a fellow pupil.[16] This led to renewed media interest in the school and the Carr case, with allegations being made that there was a culture of problems at Collingwood.[16] However, local MP Michael Gove defended the school.[16] In 2010, Carr's case was again discussed in the press when another British child, 15-year-old Lorraine Thorpe, became Britain's youngest convicted female double murderer.[17][18][19] Carr's case also returned to the news in 2016 when two female children were convicted of the murder of a vulnerable woman named Angela Wrightson, which led to comparisons with Carr's case.[20]

Another known case of a child killing an adult stranger was the 2023 murder of 19-year-old Shawn Seesahai by two 12-year-old boys.[21]

[edit]

Carr's case has featured in a number of documentaries:

  • In 2014, Carr was the subject of a season 8 episode of Deadly Women, titled "Never too Young".[22] The show incorrectly states her sentence as life without parole.
  • In 2017, Carr was the subject of an episode of Teens Who Kill, a series shown on Channel 5.[23]
  • In 2017, a documentary on Carr, made by television personality Jo Frost, aired on Crime+ Investigation, as part of the series Jo Frost on Britain's Killer Kids.[24]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Sharon Carr

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Sharon Louise Carr (born 1981) is a Belizean-British woman convicted of murdering 18-year-old Katie Rackliff by stabbing her more than 30 times in Camberley, Surrey, on 7 June 1992, when Carr was 12 years old, making her the youngest girl ever convicted of murder in the United Kingdom. Her conviction in 1997 at Winchester Crown Court relied on Carr's detailed confessions and writings revealing intimate knowledge of the crime scene, such as the theft of a bracelet, absent forensic evidence linking her directly. She received a life sentence with a minimum tariff of 14 years, detained at Her Majesty's pleasure. Carr's case highlighted her early obsession with violence, evidenced by school notebooks filled with declarations like "I am a killer. Killing is my business - and business is good" alongside drawings of knives and fantasies. Prior to her conviction, she had engaged in other violent acts, including stabbing a classmate in the in 1994 and attempting to strangle staff at a youth assessment center. In custody, Carr has displayed persistent instability, including fantasies of ing fellow inmates, leading to the denial of applications, such as one in 2022 when she was incarcerated at HMP Bronzefield. Her background includes being born in before moving to the , with family instability following her parents' separation contributing to behavioral deterioration at school.

Early Life

Family Background and Upbringing

Sharon Carr was born in Belize in 1981 and raised by her mother and stepfather, the latter being a soldier in the British Army. The family relocated to England, eventually settling in Camberley, Surrey, where Carr spent her early childhood. Carr's home life was marked by instability, as her parents later separated. In response, she was briefly placed in for approximately one month before returning to reside with her mother. Limited detail further aspects of her family dynamics or sibling relationships, with contemporary reporting emphasizing the post-relocation family dissolution as a key element of her upbringing.

Initial Signs of Behavioral Disturbance

Sharon Carr displayed early indicators of behavioral disturbance during her pre-teen years, including escalating disruptiveness at school and reported instances of animal cruelty. Born in and relocated to , , with her family, Carr attended Collingwood College Comprehensive, where she was initially viewed by teachers as polite and helpful. However, her conduct soon shifted to attention-seeking and disruptive actions in the lead-up to the June 1992 murder, reflecting a pattern of instability amid family upheaval, including her parents' separation and a brief period in before returning to her mother's home. Further signs emerged through sadistic acts toward animals, such as decapitating a neighbor's dog with a spade, and possibly frying hamsters alive on a suggestion from a friend, behaviors suggestive of emerging cruelty and lack of empathy. These incidents, recounted in trial-related accounts, preceded her violent escalation and aligned with her self-described preoccupation with death and killing. Carr's personal writings expressed this fixation explicitly, including statements like "I was born to be a murderer" and descriptions of killing as a "mass turn-on," indicating an internalized fantasy of violence that psychologists later linked to her dangerous profile, though no formal diagnosis preceded the crime.

Juvenile Crimes

Murder of Katie Rackliff

On 7 June 1992, 18-year-old apprentice hairdresser Katie Rackliff was stabbed to death while walking home alone from the Ragamuffins nightclub in Camberley, Surrey. Her body was found in an alleyway off King Street, having sustained 29 stab wounds inflicted with a knife, including some that penetrated through her body and mutilations to her sexual organs; her clothes had been pulled up, though no evidence of sexual assault existed. The attack appeared random, with no known prior connection between Rackliff and her assailant. Sharon Carr, aged 12 at the time, perpetrated the murder, approaching Rackliff from behind and stabbing her repeatedly. Carr later detailed the act in diary entries and verbal confessions, expressing exhilaration and stating phrases such as "I was born to be a murderer" and "I am a killer," alongside drawings of knives; she demonstrated knowledge of non-public details, including a specific injury and a stolen bracelet from the victim. Although Carr provided inconsistent accounts implicating two unnamed boys as accomplices in some versions, these individuals were eliminated via alibis, and no forensic evidence linked anyone else to the scene; Carr was determined to be the sole perpetrator based on her admissions and writings. The case initially went unsolved, with investigators suspecting a male due to the savagery of the wounds.

Assault on a Schoolmate

In June 1994, Sharon Carr, aged 13, carried out an unprovoked assault on a 13-year-old female classmate at in , . The attack occurred in a school bathroom, where Carr stabbed the victim in the back with a knife, inflicting a wound that punctured her . Eyewitness accounts noted that Carr displayed no during the incident, instead smiling and appearing happy as she inflicted the injury. Fellow students intervened to halt the assault, prompting Carr to flee the immediate scene. She was subsequently located and apprehended the following day while hiding on the school grounds. The assault highlighted Carr's escalating violent tendencies, which had previously included unreported animal cruelty, and it directly precipitated her entry into the criminal justice system. Police investigations following the stabbing uncovered Carr's personal writings, including diary entries boasting of deriving pleasure from violence, which later linked her to prior crimes.

Arrest and Initial Conviction for Assault

On 7 June 1994, Sharon Carr, aged 14, stabbed her 13-year-old classmate Ann-Marie Clifford in the back with a knife during an unprovoked attack at Collingwood College in Camberley, Surrey, puncturing the victim's lung. Witnesses observed Carr smiling with apparent glee immediately after the assault, which occurred exactly two years after her unsolved murder of Katie Rackliff. Carr was arrested at the scene by police, who took her into custody for the violent attack on a fellow pupil. The incident prompted an investigation into her behavior, revealing prior concerns about her aggression at school, though no prior formal charges had been filed. In juvenile proceedings, Carr was convicted of wounding with intent to cause . She received a and was detained at Bullwood Hall Young Offenders Institution in , marking her initial entry into the secure youth justice system. While incarcerated for this offense, Carr later boasted about the Rackliff murder during a phone call, leading to further investigation.

Confession and Investigation into the Murder

In 1996, while serving a sentence at Bulwood Hall young offenders' institution for the 1994 assault on her schoolmate, Sharon Carr produced writings and made statements alluding to her involvement in the unsolved 1992 murder of Katie Rackliff. These included a diary entry vividly describing the stabbing: "I bring the knife into her chest... I am joyful." Prison staff reported her boasting about the killing, prompting authorities to alert police and reopen the cold case investigation. Detectives questioned Carr for 27 hours over multiple sessions, during which she provided three accounts of approaching Rackliff randomly as she walked home from a nightclub in Camberley, Surrey, on June 6, 1992, and stabbing her repeatedly without provocation. In these admissions, Carr detailed inflicting 29 stab wounds, including mutilation to the victim's sexual organs, and pulling up her clothing—facts consistent with the autopsy but not publicly disclosed. She also referenced stealing a bracelet from Rackliff, another withheld detail known only to investigators. The investigation yielded no direct forensic tying Carr to the , as the case had gone cold with initial suspicions pointing to a male perpetrator due to the attack's ferocity. However, her precise recollection of non-public elements, combined with seized drawings and writings depicting , established her as the perpetrator and led to charges later that year. These admissions were pivotal, as Carr had no prior connection to Rackliff and selected her at random.

Murder Trial and Sentencing

Carr's trial for the of Katie Rackliff commenced at in early 1997. The prosecution presented no direct forensic evidence linking her to the crime scene, relying instead on her multiple confessions to prison staff and police, as well as entries recovered from her possessions that detailed the attack and included specifics withheld from public reports, such as the precise nature of certain injuries and the theft of a from the victim. In her statements, Carr described stabbing Rackliff approximately 29 or 30 times but alternated between claiming sole responsibility and alleging involvement of two unnamed boys, both of whom were later eliminated as suspects due to alibis. During the proceedings, Carr denied committing the , despite her prior admissions. Her writings, including boasts such as "I am a killer. Killing is my business - and business is good," were entered as evidence, illustrating her preoccupation with . On March 25, 1997, the jury returned a unanimous guilty verdict, convicting the then-17-year-old Carr of and establishing her as the youngest girl ever convicted of in British legal history. At sentencing, Carr received a mandatory term, with the court ordering her detention at Her Majesty's pleasure, the standard disposition for juvenile murderers under at the time. The initial tariff—the minimum period before eligibility—was set at 14 years, later reduced to 12 years by the Court of Appeal on December 10, 2003.

Adult Imprisonment

Transfer to Adult Facilities

Following her 1997 conviction for murder, Sharon Carr, then aged approximately 17, began serving her life sentence in young offenders' institutions, including HMP Bullwood Hall in . As she reached adulthood and exhibited ongoing violent conduct toward inmates and staff—resulting in assaults and threats—she was transferred to the adult prison estate, with placements in facilities such as in . One documented transfer occurred in 2019, when Carr was moved to Bronzefield after attacking another prisoner. She has also been held at in , among other adult sites, reflecting the prison service's response to her unmanageability in youth settings.

Repeated Violent Incidents in Custody

Following her transfer to adult correctional facilities after turning 18 in 1997, Sharon Carr exhibited a pattern of repeated violent assaults on staff and fellow inmates, contributing to multiple internal transfers and eventual placement in high-security institutions. These incidents included unprovoked attacks using improvised weapons, often resulting in serious injuries, and demonstrated a persistent lack of impulse control despite psychological interventions. Her behavior was cited by prison authorities as a ongoing risk factor, leading to restricted status and segregation measures. Prior to full adult incarceration, while at Bullwood Hall young offenders' institution in around 1995, Carr stabbed inmate Rachel Clifford in the back with a makeshift shank crafted from a melted plastic spoon, puncturing Clifford's and nearly causing her death; the attack was described as unprovoked. This incident followed prior assaults at other youth facilities that had prompted her transfer to Bullwood, where staff noted her boasting about prior , including the Rackliff murder. Such events underscored Carr's escalation from to targeted aggression in custodial settings. In adult prisons and later at , to which she was moved due to unmanageability, Carr continued assaulting personnel and inmates, including at least one documented case of slitting a fellow inmate's throat and multiple attempts to seriously harm staff. By August 2019, authorities recorded injuries to at least four individuals from her attacks or attempted murders in custody, reinforcing judicial assessments of her as an "extremely dangerous individual" unfit for release. These repeated violations, spanning over two decades, have been central to denials, with tribunals emphasizing her unchanged propensity for violence.

Psychological Assessment and Ongoing Risk

Diagnosed Traits and Personal Writings

Sharon Carr was diagnosed with following her sectioning under the and transfer to on June 16, 1998. In a 2003 court assessment, she was described as "very dangerous" and exhibiting traits consistent with a probable psychopathic disorder, though the specifics of any underlying mental illness remained unclear. Additional evaluations have attributed to her and , characterized by persistent violent behavior, lack of remorse, and manipulative tendencies observed in prison incidents and psychological reports. Carr's personal writings, primarily diary entries seized during investigations, reveal a preoccupation with violence and killing. These included graphic confessions to the 1992 murder of Katie Rackliff, such as: "I wish I could kill you again. I promise I would make you suffer more. Your terrified screams turn me on." Other entries boasted of her actions, stating: "I swear I was born to be a murderer. Killing for me is a mass turn-on and it just makes me so high I never want to come down" and "Killing is my business and business is good." These writings, which detailed the stabbing and the victim's final moments, were presented as evidence in her 1997 murder trial and underscored her absence of regret, with phrases like "I'm a killer. Killing is my business, and business is good" reflecting a thrill-seeking orientation toward homicide. The diaries also expressed escalating desires to commit further killings, aligning with patterns in her assessed disorders.

Parole Reviews and Denials

Sharon Carr became eligible for parole consideration after serving the minimum term of her life sentence for the 1992 murder of Katie Rackliff, though specific earlier reviews prior to 2022 are not publicly detailed in available reports. Her initial high-profile bid for release was reported in September 2022, amid assessments of her behavior in custody. A subsequent parole hearing in 2023 evaluated Carr's suitability for release or transfer to an , focusing on her risk profile. The denied her application, determining that the risk she posed remained too high to manage in the community, citing persistent violent tendencies and inadequate mitigation of underlying factors such as difficulties with rejection and relational instability. This decision was formalized in November 2023, with the board emphasizing public safety and her lack of sufficient progress despite participation in education, mentoring, and therapy programs. Rackliff's mother, Sandra, welcomed the November 2023 denial, stating that Carr "is where she belongs – behind bars," reflecting ongoing family opposition to any potential release. decisions in Carr's case have consistently prioritized empirical assessments of risk over chronological time served, underscoring evaluations of her unchanged propensity for violence observed in custodial incidents. Further reviews are anticipated at intervals determined by the board, but no subsequent approvals have been granted as of late 2023.

Public Perception and Legacy

Media Coverage and Nicknames

Sharon Carr's conviction on March 25, 1997, for the 1992 murder of Katie Rackliff drew extensive coverage in British newspapers, emphasizing the unprecedented youth of the perpetrator and the savagery of the crime, which involved 29 stab wounds inflicted on an 18-year-old stranger. Outlets highlighted the five-year delay in solving the case, initially attributed to an adult male assailant due to the victim's mutilation and the force required to drag her body, before Carr's 1994 assault on a schoolmate prompted her . Reports detailed her graphic school notebooks and diary entries boasting of the killing, such as "I am a killer. Killing is my business - and business is good," underscoring her lack of during the . The press sensationalized Carr's self-professed affinity for violence, quoting entries like "Every night I see the in my dreams" and "I was born to be a . Killing for me is a mass turn-on," which prosecutors described as evidence of an "evil and precocious" nature. This led to her being branded "the 's Daughter" in media accounts, a reflecting the demonic imagery in her writings and the horror of a deriving pleasure from . Subsequent reporting has revisited the case during parole hearings, with tabloids like The Sun republishing diary excerpts in 2023 amid bids for release, and broader outlets such as Metro noting denials based on her ongoing risk, including attacks on prison staff as recently as 2019. Coverage often contrasts her initial "polite" facade with the revealed , fueling debates on juvenile sentencing without endorsing leniency.

Implications for Juvenile Justice

Sharon Carr's trajectory through the UK's youth justice system exemplifies the challenges of addressing premeditated violence committed by pre-adolescents exhibiting severe antisocial traits. Convicted initially for in 1994 and later for in 1997 after confessing while in custody, she was detained at Her Majesty's pleasure with a 14-year , reflecting the system's capacity to impose indeterminate sentences on juveniles as young as 12 for . Her placement in young offenders' institutions, such as Bullwood Hall in starting in 1995, was intended to facilitate rehabilitation, yet her aggressive and sexualized conduct there—including boasting about the killing—prompted police involvement and highlighted the limitations of standard juvenile custodial measures for high-risk cases. Persistent violent incidents in youth facilities, including assaults on staff and , necessitated Carr's segregation and transfer to adult prisons like HMP Send and HMP Bronzefield by age 18, underscoring that juvenile environments may inadequately contain or reform individuals with early-manifested sadistic tendencies. This progression aligns with policy allowing transfers when youth institutions cannot ensure safety, as per provisions under the Act 1991, but it raises questions about early identification and specialized intervention for exceptional offenders who do not respond to rehabilitative programming. Empirical patterns in such rare cases suggest that factors like diagnosed personality disorders can override age-related assumptions, prioritizing incapacitation over optimistic reform. Ongoing parole denials, including a 2022 bid rejected due to assessed high risk of reoffending, demonstrate the system's emphasis on evidence-based risk evaluation over chronological age or time served, even after over 30 years in custody. These decisions, informed by psychiatric reports citing unchanged dangerousness, reinforce the retention of life-equivalent tariffs for juvenile murderers under English law, countering pressures for blanket reductions in minimum terms. Carr's case thus informs arguments for robust, individualized assessments in youth justice, ensuring public protection trumps uniform leniency in instances of irredeemable early violence, without altering the foundational age of criminal responsibility at 10.

References

  1. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/i-was-born-to-be-a-killer-every-night-i-see-the-devil-in-my-dreams-1275032.html
  2. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/britain-youngest-female-murderer-parole-release-b2176083.html
  3. https://www.the-independent.com/news/uk/crime/i-was-born-to-be-a-killer-every-night-i-see-the-devil-in-my-dreams-1275032.html
  4. https://ico.org.uk/media2/migrated/decision-notices/4024151/ic-194913-c6x3.pdf
  5. https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/uk-news/girls-horrific-injuries-made-cops-32480030
  6. https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/world-news/teen-stabbed-death-12-year-35905892
  7. https://pod.wave.co/podcast/our-true-crime-podcast/bf00e7a1-2905-4713-a389-2611179fe02d
  8. https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueCrimeDiscussion/comments/176e5vg/in_june_1992_12yearold_sharon_carr_murdered/
  9. https://metro.co.uk/2023/11/06/uks-youngest-female-murderer-the-devils-daughter-to-stay-in-prison-19782288/
  10. https://medium.com/%40chelsealynnqueen94/the-murder-of-katie-rackliff-sharon-louise-carrs-brutal-crime-and-lasting-infamy-17a387b8e244
  11. https://www.harwichandmanningtreestandard.co.uk/news/22643378.britains-youngest-female-killer-sharon-carr-bid-release/
  12. https://murderpedia.org/female.C/c/carr-sharon.htm
  13. https://metro.co.uk/2023/08/03/uks-youngest-female-murderer-could-be-released-from-prison-in-days-19248839/
  14. https://www.turnedupdead.com/katie-rackliff/
  15. https://www.metro.co.uk/2023/11/06/uks-youngest-female-murderer-the-devils-daughter-to-stay-in-prison-19782288/
  16. https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/teenager-found-stabbed-death-genital-35903863
  17. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-4996588/Sharon-Carr-murdered-Katie-Rackliff-just-12.html
  18. https://www.the-independent.com/news/uk/crime/britain-youngest-female-murderer-parole-release-b2176083.html
  19. https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/devils-daughter-who-killed-woman-30664584
  20. https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1831831/sharon-carr-Britain-s-youngest-female-murderer-denied-parole
  21. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/381680764_Juvenile_Justice_in_the_United_Kingdom_and_Hong_Kong_Historical_and_Modern_Perspectives
  22. https://www.the-independent.com/news/the-girl-who-killed-aged-12-1275008.html
  23. https://www.cps.gov.uk/crime-info/youth-crime
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.