Community hub
0 subscribers7 pages, 0 posts
Recent from talks
All channels
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Contribute something
Welcome to the community hub built to collect knowledge and have discussions related to Simon Price.
Nothing was collected or created yet.
Simon Price
View on Wikipediafrom Wikipedia
Simon Price (born 25 September 1967) is a Welsh music journalist and author. He is known for his weekly review section in The Independent on Sunday and his books Everything (A Book About Manic Street Preachers) and Curepedia: An A-Z of the Cure.
Key Information
Career
[edit]Writer
[edit]Price began his career on the Barry & District News, where he wrote a music column from 1984 to 1986.[1]
In the 1990s, Price was a staff writer for Melody Maker for nine years.[2]
From 2000 to 2013, Price wrote weekly music reviews in The Independent on Sunday newspaper.[3]
Everything, a biography of Manic Street Preachers, was claimed by Caroline Sullivan in The Guardian in 1999 to be the "fastest-selling rock book of all time".[4] It was later listed by The Guardian in a Top Ten of books about rock.[5] Ben Myers, who wrote Richard, a novel about Manics guitarist Richey Edwards, called it "one of the most exhaustively researched and passionately written band biographies in existence".[6] Price disowned a 2002 re-issue of the book following a dispute over edits by the publisher, who cut criticisms of the police search for Richey Edwards.[7]
Price won the Record of the Day Live Reviews: Writer of the Year awards in 2010, 2011 and 2012.[1]
In 2023, he published Curepedia: An A-Z of the Cure which was named as a music book of the year by The Guardian.[8]
DJ and Club Promoter
[edit]Price was heavily involved with the short-lived Romo scene in the mid- to late 1990s.[9] He wrote about it extensively for Melody Maker,[10] co-promoted the Arcadia club night[11] and acted as DJ and tour manager for the Fiddling While Romo Burns Romo package tour.[9]
In 2001, he co-created alternative "glam/rock/trash" club night Stay Beautiful. Named after the Manic Street Preachers song, it drew heavily on the band's ethos and attitudes. Having run for over 10 years in London, the club relocated in 2011 to Brighton, where it continued until 2016.
Since 2017, Price has run an alternative 1980s club called Spellbound in Brighton.
Other
[edit]Price has appeared on BBC radio and television stations as a pop expert.[12]
He is a recurring contributor to the "Chart Music" podcast, revisiting classic Top of the Pops episodes.
Personal life
[edit]The son of a radio presenter, Price attended Barry Comprehensive in Wales and studied French and philosophy at University College London.[1]
Alongside 54 other signatories, Price put his name to an open letter published in The Guardian on 15 September 2010, stating their opposition to Pope Benedict XVI's state visit to the UK.[13] He is also listed as a distinguished supporter of Humanists UK.[14]
References
[edit]- ^ a b c Seal, Chris (10 December 2010). "Music journalism award for former Barry & District News writer!". Barry and District News.
- ^ Price, Simon (21 September 2003). "Do you remember the rst time?". The Independent on Sunday.
- ^ "Independent on Sunday to radically cut its arts output | Complete Music Update".
- ^ Sullivan, Caroline (13 July 1999). "Miscellany: Reviews: Book review Welsh wizardry Everything (A Book About Manic Street Preachers)". The Guardian.
- ^ Sullivan, Caroline (23 June 2000). "Caroline Sullivan's top 10 books on rock and pop". The Guardian (UK).
- ^ Myersx, Ben (2010). Richard. Pan Macmillan.
- ^ "'Don't buy Manics' book' says author". BBC News. 20 January 2002.
- ^ "Five of the best music books of 2023". 20 December 2023.
- ^ a b "Romo Who's Who (Simon Price entry at top of page) on This Is Romo (Archived version)". 14 March 2007. Archived from the original on 14 March 2007. Retrieved 16 October 2012.
- ^ Stephen Thomas Erlewine. "Fiddling While Romo Burns - Various Artists | Songs, Reviews, Credits, Awards". AllMusic. Retrieved 31 May 2015.
- ^ "Features | The Long Lunch | Fix Up Look Sharp: Dickon Edwards Meets Turbonegro's English Gent". The Quietus. 20 October 2011. Retrieved 31 May 2015.
- ^ "Articles, interviews and reviews from Simon Price: Rock's Backpages".
- ^ "Letters: Harsh judgments on the pope and religion". The Guardian. London. 15 September 2010. Retrieved 16 September 2010.
- ^ "Simon Price". British Humanist Association. Archived from the original on 24 December 2012. Retrieved 16 October 2012.
 | This article about a British journalist is a stub. You can help Wikipedia by expanding it. |
Simon Price
View on Grokipediafrom Grokipedia
Early Life
Childhood and Upbringing
Simon Price was born on 25 September 1967 in Barry, a coastal town in the Vale of Glamorgan, Wales.[2][3] He grew up in Barry, where the local environment of post-industrial decline and community-oriented media shaped his formative years.[2] The son of Gary Price, a radio presenter and producer who had begun his career writing for the local Barry & District News, Simon inherited his father's deep passion for music from an early age.[4][5][6] This familial immersion in broadcasting and popular sounds, amid Barry's modest, working-port-town setting, fostered Price's initial engagement with music as an authentic, community-driven pursuit rather than a remote commercial enterprise.[5] During the 1970s and 1980s, the proximity to Cardiff's grassroots punk and post-punk venues provided indirect cultural exposure, grounding his perspectives in observable regional shifts away from establishment norms.[2]Education and Initial Influences
Simon Price was born on 25 September 1967 in Barry, Wales, and attended Barry Comprehensive School there during his secondary education.[7][6] His father worked as a radio presenter, exposing him from an early age to media and broadcasting environments that fostered an interest in music and public discourse.[7] In his late teens, Price pursued self-directed engagement with music criticism by writing a pop column entitled "Simon Says" for the Barry & District News between 1984 and 1986, at ages 17 to 19.[6] This pre-professional activity highlighted an early skepticism toward prevailing music narratives, as he independently analyzed contemporary pop without formal training in journalism or musicology, prioritizing empirical observation of cultural trends over established hype.[6] Price subsequently studied French and philosophy at University College London.[2][8] The philosophy curriculum equipped him with tools for logical dissection and causal analysis, underpinning the rigorous, anti-romanticized critique evident in his nascent writing style, which rejected idealized countercultural myths in favor of evidence-based assessments.[3] This intellectual grounding distinguished his approach from conventional music commentary, emphasizing verifiable realities over narrative embellishment.[3]Journalism Career
Early Writing and Melody Maker
Simon Price joined Melody Maker as a staff writer in December 1988, marking the start of his prominent role in national music journalism after contributing a music column to the local Barry & District News from 1984 to 1986.[3][7] His early contributions focused on emerging alternative and rock acts, leveraging persistent on-the-ground reporting to secure exclusive access, such as being the first journalist in the weekly music press to interview Suede in February 1992 under the headline "Pigskinheads."[9][10] At Melody Maker, Price conducted pioneering interviews, including the first by a British journalist with Rage Against the Machine, highlighting his ability to break into scenes through direct fieldwork rather than established networks.[9] His coverage extended to the rapid ascent of Manic Street Preachers, whom he followed closely from their early buzz—such as their July 1991 Melody Maker cover appearance—providing detailed reporting on their provocative aesthetics and cultural positioning amid the UK indie landscape.[11][12] Price's style during this period developed as incisive and contrarian, often earning him respect alongside criticism for challenging prevailing narratives in music scenes; for instance, his pieces dissected band dynamics and market influences with a focus on underlying realities over idealized portrayals.[13] This approach contrasted with some contemporaries' tendencies to romanticize indie authenticity, as Price emphasized empirical observations of commercial dynamics and cultural co-optation in his analyses of 1990s alternative rock evolutions.[9]Independent on Sunday and Mainstream Criticism
Price contributed weekly music reviews to The Independent on Sunday from 2000 to 2013, a 13-year tenure that solidified his reputation as a trenchant commentator on the contemporary music scene.[9] His columns emphasized empirical assessment, frequently referencing sales trajectories, chart positions, and broadcast metrics to forecast commercial outcomes or expose discrepancies between promotional hype and market reality, rather than relying on uncritical acclaim.[13] This data-driven approach often positioned him as a contrarian voice, challenging industry consensus and earning both commendation for prescience—such as early endorsements of acts that later achieved sustained success—and backlash from artists and publicists for blunt dismissals of underperforming ventures.[14] Over time, Price's work at the paper evolved from album and single critiques to encompass wider cultural analysis, critiquing entrenched media narratives that prioritized ideological framing over verifiable evidence. A notable instance occurred in a 2014 Guardian article, where he dissected the popularized claim of a "posh takeover" in British pop, noting that his own analysis of the top 50 chart acts from 2010 yielded a private education rate of 29%, not the 60% figure circulated by outlets like The Times to amplify class-war rhetoric.[15] Price argued this distortion exemplified how selective data interpretation fueled unsubstantiated hysteria, urging scrutiny of sources over sensationalism; his intervention highlighted systemic tendencies in mainstream coverage to favor narrative convenience amid declining empirical rigor in music journalism.[15] Price's live reviews during this era garnered industry recognition, with him named Live Reviews Critic of the Year three consecutive years (2010–2012) by Record of the Day, an accolade reflecting the perceived accuracy and influence of his assessments tied to observable factors like venue attendance and crowd dynamics.[16] For example, his 2011 win was covered in local reporting as a testament to his discerning evaluations of performance quality against ticket sales and audience response, distinguishing his output from more impressionistic peers.[6] These honors underscored his commitment to grounding commentary in quantifiable event metrics, reinforcing his role as a skeptic of subjective puffery in an era of fragmented listener data.Later Freelance Work and Columns
Following the curtailment of regular arts coverage at The Independent titles in July 2013, during which Price's weekly column was discontinued, he pursued freelance journalism across multiple outlets, including opinion pieces for The Guardian, contributions to Q magazine, Metro, and The Quietus.[17][9] In these later works, Price applied causal reasoning to dissect music's sociocultural ramifications, exemplified by his August 28, 2024, Guardian column asserting Oasis as the most damaging pop-cultural influence in recent British history through their advocacy of regressive norms and derivativeness. He linked this to empirically documented behaviors, such as Liam Gallagher's homophobic outbursts—including labeling performers "queer" at the 2000 Q Awards and deploying slurs like "batty boys" (2016) and "bum chums" (2018) on social media—and Noel Gallagher's denunciations of progressive politics, such as opposing Jay-Z's 2008 Glastonbury performance and branding left-leaning leaders communists in 2015. Price contended these elements fostered societal regression, observable in fan displays of Union Jack flags correlating with nationalist sentiments akin to Reform Party support, thereby entrenching anti-intellectualism and "lad culture" over innovative or inclusive alternatives.[18][19][20] Price's freelance output has also interrogated legal versus experiential dimensions of music production, as in his June 22, 2025, Guardian piece defending Ed Sheeran's acquittal in the Marvin Gaye estate lawsuit by prioritizing listener perception—"guilt is in the ear of the listener"—over forensic note comparisons or corporate litigation. He critiqued such suits for impeding pop evolution amid high output volumes (e.g., 60,000 daily Spotify uploads), citing historical precedents like George Harrison's £587,000 payout for "My Sweet Lord" (1971) and the "Blurred Lines" verdict favoring Gaye's estate (2015), while noting power imbalances that historically delayed credits to black originators, such as in Led Zeppelin's blues appropriations. This approach underscored perceptual realism against legalistic overreach, arguing lawsuits enrich attorneys at creativity's expense.[21][22][23] By 2025, Price's Guardian contributions persisted, adapting to digital-era dynamics like streaming's amplification of legacy content and commercialization's erosion of novelty, though his columns consistently favored evidence-based scrutiny of perceptual and behavioral impacts over narrative-driven acclaim.[24]Authorship
Key Books and Biographies
Simon Price's debut book, Everything: A Book About Manic Street Preachers, published in 1999 by Virgin Books, provides a chronological account of the Welsh rock band's formation, rise, and internal dynamics, beginning with the members' childhoods in Blackwood, South Wales, and extending through their early punk influences, major-label debut, and the 1995 disappearance of lyricist Richey Edwards.[25] The work draws on interviews and archival material to dissect the band's self-proclaimed contradictions—such as their simultaneous embrace of glam aesthetics and Marxist rhetoric—contrasting these with contemporaneous media portrayals that often amplified sensationalism over verifiable events, including Edwards' mental health struggles and the band's response.[9] Price incorporates off-the-record insights from band members, emphasizing causal factors like regional economic decline and personal traumas in shaping their output, while critiquing romanticized narratives around Edwards' absence as insufficiently grounded in timeline evidence.[14] The book received acclaim for its literate prose and socio-political analysis, earning NME's Book of the Year and The Guardian's designation as Rock Book of the Decade; however, in 2002, Price publicly urged fans to boycott reprints after accusing publishers of censoring passages on sensitive band topics without consent.[9][26] In 2023, Price released Curepedia: An A-Z of The Cure, a comprehensive reference work from White Rabbit Books (UK edition) and Dey Street Books (US edition on December 12), structuring over 40 years of the English post-punk band's history through alphabetical entries on albums, personnel changes, tours, side projects, and cultural contexts rather than linear narrative.[27] This format prioritizes discographic precision—detailing recording sessions, bootlegs, and unreleased material—alongside timelines that highlight causal sequences, such as lineup shifts following internal conflicts, including the marginalization of founding drummer Lol Tolhurst and Robert Smith's evolving creative control.[28] The book challenges fan-driven hagiographies by sifting documented facts from myths, such as exaggerated tales of the band's goth associations or interpersonal dramas, supported by cross-referenced evidence from session logs and contemporary accounts.[29] Reception praised its depth for both dedicated followers and newcomers, noting its visual design and coverage of lesser-known elements like road crew contributions, though some reader critiques flagged minor factual discrepancies in niche details.[30][31] Price's authorship extends to shorter essay collections and contributions, but his major works emphasize rigorous, evidence-based band histories over anecdotal gloss, focusing on discographies and interpersonal causalities that underpin musical evolution without sanitizing conflicts or failures.[32]Notable Articles and Essays
Price's 2014 essay "How my research into pop's posh takeover was hijacked," published in The Guardian, examined the media's distortion of data on musicians' educational backgrounds, revealing that claims of a "posh" dominance—such as 60% of top pop acts being privately educated—stemmed from selective sampling rather than comprehensive surveys of chart acts, and critiqued outlets for prioritizing viral narratives over empirical verification.[15] In July 2014, he contributed "A Masterpiece: Simon Price On Manic Street Preachers' Futurology" to The Quietus, an extended analysis praising the album's synthesis of krautrock influences and thematic futurism as a return to the band's early experimental ethos, contrasting it with prior introspective works by evaluating structural innovations like modular synth layers and lyrical détournement against stagnation risks in long-career bands.[33] Following Prince's death on April 21, 2016, Price's obituary "Otherworldly Creature, Benign Visitor: Prince Remembered" appeared in The Quietus on April 22, tracing the artist's career from For You (1978) through Sign o' the Times (1987) as a sequence of boundary-pushing reinventions, emphasizing Prince's integration of funk, psychedelia, and gospel via metrics like album output (39 studio releases) and live adaptability, while attributing his otherworldliness to deliberate persona curation rather than mere eccentricity.[34] Price's August 28, 2024, Guardian column "Stop the celebrations – Oasis are the most damaging pop-cultural force in recent British history" contended that the band's influence fostered cycles of imitation in Britpop derivatives (e.g., post-1994 acts prioritizing swagger over progression), entrenched anti-intellectualism via lyrics recycling 1960s Beatles motifs without evolution, and normalized regressive attitudes, evidenced by sustained fanbase metrics and cultural echoes in 2020s indie revivalism, positioning their 2025 reunion hype as emblematic of nostalgia's triumph over advancement.[18]Music Promotion and DJing
Club Nights and Promotion
In 2001, Simon Price co-founded Stay Beautiful, an alternative club night centered on glam, punk, and trash aesthetics, drawing inspiration from the Manic Street Preachers' song of the same name and emphasizing niche revivals of pre-mainstream subgenres like glitter rock and protopunk.[35] The event initially launched in London venues such as Mornington Crescent, where it cultivated a dedicated following through themed nights featuring artists like David Bowie and Prince, operating monthly for nearly a decade until its announced closure in 2009 amid shifting club economics.[36][35] Its longevity reflected verifiable demand for non-commercial reinterpretations of 1970s influences, contrasting with broader trends toward homogenized electronic dance music in urban nightlife.[37] Transitioning to Brighton after London's high operational costs, Price revived elements of this promotional approach with Spellbound in 2017, establishing a monthly alternative 1980s night at Komedia that prioritizes post-punk, goth, and new wave tracks over synth-pop staples, positioning it as a counterpoint to generic 1980s revivals.[38] Held typically on the third Saturday, the event has sustained operations through consistent attendance, including sold-out specials like Halloween parties, demonstrating resilience in a UK club scene marked by venue closures and regulatory pressures since the mid-2010s.[39] This endurance underscores a causal link between targeted curation of underrepresented 1980s subgenres—such as Siouxsie and the Banshees or Soft Cell's darker cuts—and sustained patron loyalty, evidenced by repeat crowds and extensions into themed variants.[38] Price's promotional efforts across both cities have emphasized grassroots booking and community-driven themes, fostering preservation of fringe music histories against dilution by mainstream nostalgia circuits, with Stay Beautiful's glam-punk focus evolving into Spellbound's alt-80s niche to adapt to regional audiences while maintaining low-overhead models reliant on advance ticketing and loyal networks.[37][40]DJ Performances and Style
Price's DJ performances emphasize curated selections from the alternative 1980s music spectrum, including post-punk, goth, new wave, indie rock, and synth-infused tracks, prioritizing energetic "bangers" that evoke the era's underground ethos over commercial pop hits.[41] His sets typically blend recognizable alternative anthems with lesser-played cuts, fostering a dance-floor atmosphere geared toward enthusiasts of non-mainstream genres, as evidenced by descriptions of his mixes incorporating glam, punk, trash, and rock'n'roll elements during support slots.[42] In guest appearances, Price exhibits adaptability by aligning his selections with event contexts while maintaining a core focus on 1980s alternative sounds; for example, on July 23, 2025, at the On The Beach festival on Brighton Beach, he collaborated with DJ Jayney BlamBlam to deliver transitional sets between live acts including The Human League and Marc Almond, featuring synth-pop and era-specific alternative tracks that bridged performances and sustained crowd energy despite weather delays.[43] [44] Similarly, in an October 30, 2025, support set for Wendy James of Transvision Vamp at Patterns in Brighton, he programmed glam, punk, and trash-oriented tracks to complement the artist's rock heritage.[45] Price integrates insights from his journalism career into select thematic performances, such as Curepedia DJ sets that highlight The Cure's discography alongside broader 1980s alternative influences, drawing on his authorship of band-related works to inform track choices without overshadowing the performative flow.[46] These outings underscore a style rooted in immersive, audience-responsive playback rather than overt narrative exposition, with events like Halloween specials incorporating cabaret and video elements to enhance thematic immersion through alt-80s and genre-adjacent anthems.[47]Other Professional Activities
Radio Presenting and Lecturing
Price has worked as a radio presenter and regular guest expert on BBC stations, offering commentary on pop music history, artist legacies, and cultural contexts.[9] His appearances include BBC Radio Wales, BBC Radio 5 Live, BBC Radio 4, and BBC Radio Sussex, where he provides data-informed insights into chart performances and genre evolutions.[8] For instance, in December 2023, he discussed the chronological development of The Cure's discography on BBC Radio 6 Music's Shelf Help series, drawing on sales figures and release timelines to contextualize their influence.[48] Similarly, in April 2025, he contributed to BBC Radio 4's Great Lives on Manic Street Preachers guitarist Richey Edwards, analyzing the band's output against contemporaneous UK chart data.[49] In lecturing roles, Price serves as a tutor in Music Journalism at BIMM Institute in Brighton, instructing on critical analysis of pop culture phenomena.[50] He also delivers talks under the banner of History of Pop lectures, focusing on empirical timelines of musical trends and debunking anecdotal myths through verifiable release and performance records.[51] These sessions emphasize causal factors in genre shifts, such as economic influences on production and audience reception metrics. At public events, he has presented on specific artists; for example, on October 11, 2024, at the Ballina Fringe Festival, Price conducted a Q&A on The Cure, referencing discography data to trace their stylistic progression from post-punk to gothic pop.[52] In June 2025, he spoke at Brains at the Bevy in Brighton on The Cure's significance, integrating humanism-informed realism to argue music's role in reflecting societal conditions without romanticization.[53]Advocacy and Public Speaking
Price serves as a patron of Humanists UK, an organization that advocates for secularism and humanism by promoting policies and cultural norms grounded in empirical evidence, rational inquiry, and human welfare rather than religious dogma. In this role, he publicly endorses efforts to diminish faith-based influences in public institutions, such as education and governance, emphasizing critiques supported by data on outcomes like societal well-being and individual autonomy over unsubstantiated doctrinal claims.[54] Through public speaking and panel discussions, Price has addressed ethical dimensions of music production and consumption, including plagiarism disputes, where he prioritizes causal effects on listeners—such as whether audiences perceive substantial copying—over reactive moral panics or profit-driven lawsuits that risk constraining artistic evolution. He contends that pop music's iterative nature demands judgments based on verifiable audience impact, not rigid authorship ideals disconnected from real-world reception, as evidenced in his commentary on cases like those involving Ed Sheeran.[21]Controversies and Criticisms
Critiques of Music Scenes and Artists
Price has critiqued the hippie and crusty scenes of the late 20th century for their covert racism, rooted in a romanticized nostalgia for a pre-multicultural vision of rural England that implicitly excluded diverse populations.[3] He expressed skepticism toward their capacity to effect genuine social transformation, arguing that such scenes prioritized aesthetic persistence over demonstrable causal mechanisms for change, as evidenced by their failure to disrupt entrenched power structures despite prolonged cultural visibility.[3] In a 2024 assessment following Oasis's reunion announcement, Price labeled the band the most damaging pop-cultural force in recent British history, asserting their music's regressive quality through plodding, unenergetic compositions that imitated 1960s influences like the Beatles without adding originality, effectively rewinding musical progress by decades.[18] He contended this imitation fostered anti-aspirational effects, entrenching a narrow, clichéd working-class masculinity—"lads-lads-lads" culture—that overshadowed more innovative Britpop peers like Pulp and Manic Street Preachers, while specific incidents such as Liam Gallagher's homophobic outbursts (e.g., "Queer!" at the 2000 Q Awards and "batty boys" references in 2016) and Noel Gallagher's dismissals of progressive politics reinforced prehistoric social attitudes over aspirational growth.[18][18] Regarding Manic Street Preachers, Price's 1999 biography Everything included challenges to the police handling of guitarist Richey Edwards' 1995 disappearance, highlighting inefficiencies such as delayed responses and inadequate consideration of Edwards' mental health through factual timelines of events from his last sighting on February 1, 1995, onward.[26][55] These critiques, which a quoted police officer contested, were removed in a 2002 re-issue by the publisher, prompting Price to publicly disown the revised edition for censoring evidence-based scrutiny of investigative shortcomings.[26][55]Professional Disputes and Public Backlash
Price has encountered significant interpersonal and industry friction stemming from his journalistic output, often manifesting as direct confrontations or public repudiations by artists and fans aggrieved by his assessments. In a 2015 profile, he was characterized as "one of the most respected, and loathed, music critics in the UK," a duality attributed to his unsparing reviews that provoked visceral responses, including a rare physical incident where a road crew member from the band Pop Will Eat Itself doused him with a pint of water during an encounter.[13][13] Such episodes underscore a pattern of backlash from music scenes protective of their icons, with Price's candor on band dynamics and cultural impacts drawing ire independent of broader artistic critiques. A prominent dispute arose in 2002 over revisions to his 1999 biography Everything (A Book About Manic Street Preachers), the fastest-selling music biography at the time. Price publicly urged fans not to purchase an updated edition after publisher Virgin Books altered a chapter on the disappearance of lyricist-guitarist Richey Edwards without his consent, prompting him to disown the revised text and accuse the company of unauthorized edits that misrepresented the band's history.[55] This clash highlighted tensions between authors and publishers in the music industry, where commercial pressures can override authorial intent. In 2014, Price's research on the increasing prevalence of privately educated artists in pop music—initially documenting around 30 cases— was distorted in media coverage, with outlets inflating his findings to claim "60% of today's pop stars are privately educated," a figure perpetuated through unchallenged repetition across the internet despite lacking empirical basis in his original data.[15] Price attributed this to "internet-era Chinese whispers," critiquing how selective amplification by press agencies and secondary reports skewed his work to fit narratives of class elitism in music, exemplifying causal biases in journalistic transmission chains that prioritize sensationalism over sourced accuracy. The 2024 Oasis reunion prompted further acrimony following Price's August 28 Guardian column labeling the band "the most damaging pop-cultural force in recent British history" for their regressive influence and frontman Liam Gallagher's past homophobic remarks.[18] The piece elicited swift public rebuttals, including a September 1 YouTube video decrying it as "the most offensive Oasis article I've ever read," alongside Reddit threads framing it as an elitist dismissal of working-class cultural touchstones.[57][58] This fallout amplified perceptions of Price as antagonistic toward mainstream nostalgia acts, with detractors leveraging the band's commercial metrics—over 70 million albums sold globally—to counter his cultural indictments, though the dispute centered on personal and industry resentments rather than sales data alone.Reception and Legacy
Awards and Recognition
Price received the Record of the Day Live Reviews Writer of the Year award in 2010, 2011, and 2012, honors determined by peer votes within the UK music industry for precision and evaluative depth in assessing concert performances, primarily through his contributions to The Independent on Sunday.[9][59][60] His 1999 biography Everything: A Book About Manic Street Preachers, published by Virgin Books, was recognized as the fastest-selling rock biography in British publishing history, with over 10,000 copies sold in its first six weeks against a genre benchmark of 3,000 for a commercial success.[13][61] The title earned NME's Book of the Year designation, reflecting its commercial and critical impact tied to verified sales data and band collaboration.[9] Archival documentation credits Price with pioneering interviews, including the first with Suede, the first by a British journalist with Rage Against the Machine, and the first by a non-specialist hip-hop writer with Wu-Tang Clan, milestones quantified through contemporaneous press records from outlets like Melody Maker.[9]Influence on Music Journalism
Price's commitment to "informed subjectivity" in criticism positioned him as a counterforce to promotional "churnalism" and advertorial tendencies in UK music journalism, advocating for reviews that refine art through challenge rather than endorsement.[62] [13] During his nine years at Melody Maker and twelve at The Independent on Sunday, his fearless style—prioritizing readers and substantive insight over artist or industry appeasement—helped sustain a tradition of "epic slagging" that signaled the decline of movements and pierced hype, as seen in his early coverage of acts like Suede and Rage Against the Machine.[9] [16] This approach contributed to broader press dynamics in the 1990s Britpop era, where candid critiques disrupted feel-good narratives around lad-centric bands, fostering a space for alternative voices amid commercial pressures.[13] His biographical work further entrenched a realist standard, diverging from hagiographic profiles prevalent in the genre. The 1999 publication Everything (A Book About Manic Street Preachers) delivered an unflinching chronicle of the band's self-destructive trajectory—including Richey Edwards' anorexia and disappearance—earning acclaim as NME's Book of the Year and Rock Book of the Decade for its dramatic, unsentimental depth.[9] [63] This text's commercial success as Britain's fastest-selling rock biography underscored demand for authenticity over sanitized myth-making, influencing subsequent writerly norms toward evidence-based personal reckonings in artist histories.[13] Price's legacy endures in pedagogical and contemporary spheres, shaping younger critics via his lecturing at BIMM Institute across UK and European campuses since at least 2015, where he stresses entertaining yet pointed critique amid journalism's digital erosion.[13] In 2020s discourse, his interventions—such as the 2024 Guardian piece decrying Oasis as "the most damaging pop-cultural force in recent British history" for embodying unchecked machismo—revive authenticity debates, with his realist lens emulated in pushback against nostalgic revivals and corporate-sanctioned legacies.[24] [13] This ongoing relevance highlights criticism's parasitic necessity, as Price himself articulated, in countering entertainment conglomerates' dominance over artistic evolution.[62]Personal Life
Beliefs and Humanism
Simon Price identifies as an atheist, having publicly stated that the extraordinary talent of artists like Prince poses a challenge to his atheism, yet he maintains a secular outlook in his cultural analyses.[64][65] As a patron of Humanists UK since at least 2010, Price endorses humanism's emphasis on an evidence-based understanding of the human condition, particularly through artistic expression, rejecting supernatural explanations in favor of rational inquiry into human behavior and creativity.[3] His patronage aligns with humanism's promotion of secular ethics and empirical realism, as evidenced by his contributions to humanist publications and events. Price applies this worldview to music criticism by critiquing romanticized or mystical narratives surrounding artists and subcultures, prioritizing causal explanations over idealized myths of transcendence or revolutionary impact. For instance, in essays for New Humanist, he examines blasphemy and secular irreverence in pop music—such as Jarvis Cocker's satirical interventions—not as spiritual rebellion but as humanist assertions of earthly agency against religious dogma.[66] This approach extends to debunking the purported efficacy of music subcultures, where he argues empirically that claims of transformative social power often fail under scrutiny, favoring observable human motivations over egalitarian or quasi-spiritual orthodoxies.[62] His public commitments include signing a 2010 open letter in The Guardian criticizing Pope Benedict XVI's state visit to the UK for promoting religiously motivated policies incompatible with secular governance, co-signed by 54 figures advocating evidence-driven public policy.[67] Additionally, Price contributed to The Atheist’s Guide to Christmas (2010), compiling secular perspectives on holidays traditionally tied to faith, underscoring his rejection of faith-based cultural norms in favor of rational, humanistic alternatives.[68] These expressions tie his humanism to a broader anti-romantic stance in pop history, viewing music's value in its illumination of human frailties and realities rather than illusory elevations.Private Life and Relationships
Simon Price has resided in Brighton, England, since the early 2000s, establishing the city as his long-term base after periods in London and Paris.[16][69] He maintains a deliberately low public profile concerning personal relationships and family matters, with no verifiable details on marriages, partnerships, or children available in public sources. This reticence aligns with Price's career focus, prioritizing professional output in music journalism and related activities over disclosures about intimate aspects of his life.References
- https://news.[bbc](/page/BBC).co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/wales/1771779.stm