Hubbry Logo
The Magic ShowThe Magic ShowMain
Open search
The Magic Show
Community hub
The Magic Show
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
The Magic Show
The Magic Show
The Magic Show
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
The Magic Show
Original Production Art by David Edward Byrd
MusicStephen Schwartz
LyricsStephen Schwartz
BookBob Randall
Productions1974 Broadway

The Magic Show is a one-act musical with music and lyrics by Stephen Schwartz and a book by Bob Randall. It starred magician Doug Henning. Produced by Edgar Lansbury, Joseph Beruh, and Ivan Reitman, it opened on Broadway on May 28, 1974 at the Cort Theatre in Manhattan, and ran for 1,920 performances, closing on December 31, 1978. Henning was nominated for the Tony Award for Best Featured Actor in a Musical and director Grover Dale was nominated for the Tony Award for Best Direction of a Musical.

It originally began life as Spellbound, produced by Ivan Reitman with a book by David Cronenberg and music by Howard Shore. That version premiered at the Royal Alexandra Theatre in Toronto in 1973, starring Henning and Jennifer Dale. When Reitman took it to New York, the book and score were entirely replaced,[1] but Henning's illusions and magic tricks remained unchanged.

The Magic Show was a rare Broadway musical with a star who could neither sing nor dance. As composer-lyricist Stephen Schwartz told critic Peter Filichia, "This wasn't the case of writing for a star, but writing around a star."[2]

Synopsis

[edit]

The setting for the show is a seedy nightclub, the Top Hat, where an aging alcoholic magician, "Feldman the Magnificent," chews the scenery in his overly grand performance. Manny, the Top Hat owner, wants to replace him and brings in Doug. Doug is very unconventional and has an assistant named Cal. Cal is in love with Doug, but he does not notice her and is focused on advancing his career. Donna and Dina are the rock act in the club. One of them dates the nephew of a big agent named Goldfarb. Goldfarb is coming to the club to check out Donna and Dina's act, and everyone is excited.

Meanwhile, Doug pays little attention to Cal and decides that he needs a "beautiful assistant". Cal is hurt, as Doug conjures up the beautiful Charmin. Donna and Dina get jealous, and along with Feldman, plot to expose the secrets to Doug's tricks during the show. Doug finally realizes he loves Cal, and gets to her before she leaves. Charmin is sent back to wherever she came from, and all ends up well.

Musical numbers

[edit]
  • Up to His Old Tricks - Entire Company
  • Solid Silver Platform Shoes - Dina and Donna
  • Lion Tamer - Cal
  • Style - Feldman and Company
  • Charmin's Lament - Charmin
  • Two's Company - Dina and Donna
  • The Goldfarb Variations - Dina, Feldman, Donna, Manny and Charmin
  • Doug's Act - Doug
  • A Bit of Villainy - Feldman, Dina and Donna
  • West End Avenue - Cal
  • Sweet, Sweet, Sweet - Charmin, Manny, Mike and Steve
  • Before Your Very Eyes - Dina, Donna and Feldman

Cast and characters

[edit]
Character Broadway
1974
Dina Cheryl Barnes
Doug Doug Henning
Manny Robert LuPone
Donna Annie McGreevey
Charmin Anita Morris
Steve Lloyd Sannes
Goldfarb Sam Schacht
Cal Dale Soules
Mike Ronald Stafford
Feldman David Ogden Stiers

Notable cast replacements

[edit]

Broadway (1974–1978)

[edit]

Opening night band

[edit]
  • Stephen Reinhardt, keyboards, musical director
  • Paul Shaffer, keyboards
  • Steve Manes, bass
  • Brian McCormick, guitar
  • Gerry Weiner, guitar
  • Joey Saulter, drums
  • Charles Birch, percussion

Reception

[edit]

Reviews for the show were mixed. In the New York Times, Clive Barnes wrote what he called "an adulterated rave", because "Mr. Henning is terrific. He is the greatest illusionist I have ever seen … On the other hand, the show is awful. This is a 'Magic Show' where they should keep the magic and abandon the show."[3] The Times' Sunday critic Walter Kerr concurred that “If the star of the occasion, magician Doug Henning, were entirely serious about his business, he would promptly make the rest of the show disappear.” However, Kerr concluded that "the show is the kind that parents will take children to on the pretext that they are doing the children a favor. But they go for their own fun, really."[4]

Some critics were fonder of the show. In One More Kiss, his book surveying Broadway musicals of the 1970s, Ethan Mordden wrote that the show's success was "first, because Henning really did have a wonderful act, and, second, because the frame was amusing enough. Director-choreographer Grover Dale gave it atmosphere, David Ogden Stiers as the cast-off magician was a wily piece of camp, and Schwartz's score is capable and surprising." At least one of the songs, "West End Avenue", became a standard; Peter Filichia wrote that it was "one of the most popular cabaret songs of the late '70s".[5]

DVD version

[edit]

In 2001, a filmed performance staged especially for the cameras in 1980, directed by Norman Campbell at the Queen Elizabeth Theatre in Toronto, was issued on DVD by Image Entertainment. This production, originally intended for cinema release, differed notably from the original Broadway production, with several of the most memorable songs, such as "West End Avenue" and "Solid Silver Platform Shoes", removed. Doug Henning reprised his original starring role, while Didi Conn co-starred as Cal.

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

The Magic Show

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Magic Show is a one-act musical that integrates live magic illusions into its storytelling, featuring music and lyrics by and a book by Bob Randall. It premiered on Broadway at the Cort Theatre on May 28, 1974, starring Canadian magician in the lead role of a young performer named Doug, and ran for 1,920 performances until its closure on December 31, 1978, making it one of the longest-running Broadway shows of its era. Set in the fictional Top Hat nightclub in , the plot revolves around the ambitious young magician Doug, who headlines alongside his assistant Cal (played by Dale Soules) and faces sabotage from the jealous, scheming veteran performer Feldman. Doug remains committed to using magic for wonder and entertainment rather than deceit, ultimately triumphing over his rival through illusions and romance, while wooing Cal in the process. The show blends Schwartz's witty, upbeat songs—such as "Up to His Old Tricks", "Solid Silver Platform Shoes", "Style", and "Lion Tamer"—with Henning's elaborate stage magic, including disappearing acts and levitations that were seamlessly incorporated into the narrative. Directed and choreographed by with musical direction by , the production was produced by Edgar Lansbury, Joseph Beruh, and , and earned Tony Award nominations in 1975 for Best Featured Actor in a Musical (Henning) and Best Direction of a Musical. Henning's charismatic performance revitalized interest in on stage, influencing subsequent illusion-based theater, and the show was later adapted into a 1981 Canadian television special directed by Norman Campbell, which was released on DVD in 2001.

Background

Development

In 1973, producers Edgar Lansbury, Joseph Beruh, and conceived The Magic Show as a Broadway vehicle to showcase the talents of Canadian magician Doug , whom they discovered in his production Spellbound, which had produced earlier that year. The project aimed to elevate Henning's act from a simple magic to a structured musical, capitalizing on his innovative illusions while addressing the challenges of theatrical integration. Bob Randall was commissioned to write the book, crafting a loose, minimal set in a seedy nightclub called the Passaic Top Hat, where Henning's character navigates rivalries and romance to frame a series of magic performances. composed the music and lyrics in a contemporary pop-rock style, designing songs that supported rather than overshadowed the illusions, with the structure adapted to accommodate Henning's limited singing skills by emphasizing ensemble numbers and spoken interludes. Development involved workshops and rehearsals to synchronize tricks—such as levitations and escapes—with the musical sequences, presenting technical hurdles in timing cues and stage mechanics to ensure seamless transitions between illusions and performer movements. These efforts culminated in New York previews beginning May 16, 1974, at the Cort Theatre, just weeks before the official opening. Financed through traditional Broadway investors, the production carried significant risks typical of the era, with musicals often requiring $300,000 to $700,000 in amid high failure rates for experimental formats. Blending revue-style with a musical was particularly precarious, as it deviated from proven narrative-driven successes, potentially alienating audiences expecting either pure spectacle or cohesive . Despite these uncertainties, the producers proceeded, betting on Henning's to drive commercial viability.

Creative Team

The creative team behind The Magic Show was instrumental in blending musical theater with live illusions, creating a that revolutionized Broadway's approach to magic as entertainment. Producers Edgar Lansbury, Joseph Beruh, and led the effort, securing funding and the Cort Theatre venue for its premiere, while associate producer Nan Pearlman handled logistical support to ensure the production's innovative format could thrive. Their vision transformed a Canadian workshop production into a long-running hit, emphasizing Doug Henning's magic as the central draw. Director and choreographer shaped the show's dynamic staging, integrating Henning's illusions with musical numbers to maintain a seamless flow in the setting. His emphasized fluid transitions between songs and tricks, allowing the magic to feel organic to the 1970s rock-infused style. Dale's dual role ensured that physical movement enhanced the illusions' impact, contributing to the production's energetic, audience-engaging hybrid form. Music director Stephen Reinhardt oversaw the orchestration and live band, synchronizing musical cues precisely with Henning's illusions to heighten dramatic reveals, such as timed swells during vanishments. His arrangements supported Stephen Schwartz's score, fostering the show's signature blend of pop-rock and theatrical magic without overpowering the visual spectacle. Scenic designer David Chapman's sets evoked a gritty nightclub, using modular platforms and hidden compartments that facilitated illusion mechanics while immersing audiences in a seedy, intimate atmosphere. Costume designer Randy Barcelo's outfits captured 1970s flair with practical elements, like flowing fabrics for Henning's acts and ensemble wear that incorporated prop concealment for tricks. Lighting designer Richard Nelson's work was pivotal in accentuating illusion moments, employing spotlights and color washes to guide audience focus and amplify the wonder of effects like levitations and transformations. His design enhanced the show's theatrical magic by creating shadows and highlights that made the illusions appear more miraculous on the stage. Star magician served as the primary illusion consultant, adapting and performing classic tricks like and floating effects for the theatrical format, with additional designs by Glen Haring and construction by John Gaughan to ensure reliability during the show's 1,920 performances. Henning's input, alongside contributions from illusion builders, tailored the magic to integrate seamlessly with the musical elements, defining the production's enduring legacy.

Productions

Original Broadway Production

The original Broadway production of The Magic Show opened on May 28, 1974, at the Cort Theatre in , following previews that began on May 16. Starring Canadian magician Doug in the lead role, with supporting performances by as the embittered magician Feldman and others including Robert Cruikshank and Louisa Flaningam, the show quickly established itself as a unique blend of musical theater and live illusion. Presented as a one-act musical without intermission, the production was built around Henning's magic sequences. The stage at the Cort Theatre was equipped with custom mechanics to support the illusions, including scenic designs by David Chapman that incorporated elements like trapdoors and specialized lighting rigs tailored to Henning's acts, with additional magic assistance from Brian Lumley and Glen Priest. These technical features allowed for seamless integration of tricks such as levitations and transformations, central to the show's appeal as a showcase for Henning's innovative style. The engagement proved remarkably durable, accumulating 1,920 performances over nearly four and a half years before closing on December 31, 1978. Henning departed the cast in 1976 for other projects, but the production continued with replacements until its conclusion, marking it as one of the longer-running Broadway musicals of the 1970s.

National Tours

The first national tour of The Magic Show launched on December 17, 1974, and concluded on July 27, 1975, bringing the production to major U.S. cities including , , and with adaptations that scaled down some illusions to accommodate varying theater sizes and regional venues. The tour, produced by Joseph Beruh, Edgar Lansbury, and , was directed and staged by with magic created by , though Henning himself remained committed to the Broadway run and did not participate in the road performances, with Peter DePaula taking the lead role as the magician. Notable stops included a run at 's starting December 17, 1974; 's Forrest Theatre from February 4 to 16, 1975; and from June 7 to July 20, 1975, at ' Shubert Theatre in . Touring the show presented logistical challenges, particularly in transporting the elaborate magic props across cities and training local crews to execute the illusions reliably without Henning's direct oversight. Adjustments were necessary for acoustics and stage configurations in non-Broadway houses, ensuring the musical numbers and tricks maintained their impact despite the mobility demands. Cast rotations were employed to keep performances fresh, drawing from replacement actors familiar with the roles to sustain energy over the seven-month itinerary. A second national tour served as a farewell extension from June 26 to September 3, 1978, emphasizing performances that appealed to audiences, including stops in key North American cities. Produced by Robert S. Fishko, Irving Siders, Edgar Lansbury, Joseph Beruh, and , this shorter run reproduced the original direction by under Herb Vogler, with choreography by Jay Fox and illusions supervised by technician . The tour highlighted the show's enduring popularity, allowing audiences outside New York to experience the magic in a live setting before the production concluded.

Plot and Content

Synopsis

The Magic Show is set in the Top Hat Club, a rundown in , where the aging and alcoholic magician Feldman the Magnificent performs his outdated routines to a sparse audience. The story centers on , a naive and unconventional young magician who arrives with his assistant Cal to audition for the club's owner, Manny, after Feldman is fired for his unreliability. quickly secures the headline spot, impressing Manny with his fresh style, but his arrival disrupts the club's dynamics, particularly as a , Goldfarb, is scheduled to visit to scout the resident rock duo, Donna and , who along with Feldman scheme to 's act and expose his illusions as mere tricks. As Doug's performances unfold, interweaving magic routines with the club's daily chaos, romantic tensions emerge between him and Cal, who harbors unrequited feelings for her employer while feeling overshadowed by his focus on creating the perfect glamorous assistant. To elevate his show, Doug conjures the beautiful and enchanting as his onstage partner, which delights the audience but devastates Cal, prompting her to consider leaving the club and pursuing her own dreams elsewhere. Meanwhile, Feldman, Donna, and Dina's repeated attempts to undermine Doug—through pranks and interference during his tricks—backfire spectacularly, highlighting the genuine wonder of Doug's and exposing their jealousy-driven motives. The narrative builds to a climax when Goldfarb witnesses Doug's grand , a transformative spectacle that not only captivates the agent but also revitalizes the Top Hat Club, saving it from closure. In a moment of realization, Doug recognizes Cal's true value and his love for her, banishing Charmin in a final act of and embracing a that blends with . The story concludes triumphantly, underscoring themes of perseverance in , the blurred line between and authenticity, and the redemptive power of belief and creativity.

Musical Numbers

The Magic Show features eleven musical numbers composed by , presented in a compact one-act format that runs approximately 90 minutes and blends pop-rock energy with flair to drive the narrative forward. These songs not only advance character development and plot progression but also synchronize with Doug Henning's illusions, using musical builds and pauses to accentuate trick reveals, such as sudden appearances or transformations during key sequences. The score's structure emphasizes pieces for spectacle alongside intimate solos that reveal personal motivations, creating a dynamic interplay between , , and magic. The show opens with the ensemble number Up to His Old Tricks, an upbeat vaudeville-style opener performed by the full company, which introduces the rundown nightclub and the bombastic routines of the veteran magician Feldman, while incorporating Henning's initial illusions like a tear-and-restore to hook the audience on the show's hybrid format. This is followed by Solid Silver Platform Shoes, a lively pop-rock for the nightclub's aspiring singers Dina and Donna ( and Annie McGreevey), functioning as a comic showcase of their glamorous fantasies and highlighting the venue's eclectic entertainment lineup without direct magic ties. Next, Lion Tamer, a solo for Cal (Dale Soules), adopts a theatrical ballad style with whimsical lyrics expressing her daydreams of adventure and her infatuation with the young magician , advancing the romantic subplot while timed to coincide with a lion-related in Doug's act for added dramatic flair. The patter song Style, performed by Feldman () with ensemble support, contrasts the old-school pomp of traditional magic against Doug's fresh approach in a fast-paced, dance-infused rock number that underscores generational tensions and sets up the central conflict. Two's Company, a duet for Donna and Dina, explores their dysfunctional partnership through witty, syncopated lyrics in a light , reinforcing the comedic undercurrents without magic elements. Charmin's Lament, a humorous delivered by the conjured assistant (Jill ), laments her illusory existence and fleeting affections, propelling the subplot of romantic entanglements in a style blending and , with no overt magic integration but echoing the prior trick. The Goldfarb Variations, performed by Cal with company involvement, serves as a quirky ensemble interlude commenting on human (and animal) instincts in a playful, vaudeville-inspired tune that transitions into the agent's visit and heightens the stakes for Doug's performance. West End Avenue, sung by Cal in a poignant, New York-inflected ballad style, conveys her frustration and longing for a stable life beyond the nightclub, deepening her character arc and providing emotional respite amid the show's energetic pace. A Bit of Villainy, a comic for Feldman, Donna, and , satirizes scheming in a vaudeville-tinged rock vein, functioning to reveal the antagonists' plot to sabotage Doug's debut while building suspense toward illusion-based confrontations. The tender ballad Sweet, Sweet, Sweet, sung by supporting characters including , Manny (Loyd Sannes), and others, captures a moment of vulnerability and budding romance, providing plot momentum toward resolution in a arrangement. The production culminates in the finale Before Your Very Eyes, an exuberant company number in pop-rock style that celebrates belief in magic and love, integrating Henning's signature illusions like a levitation or metamorphosis to deliver a climactic reveal and thematic closure. During the original Broadway run from 1974 to 1978, no major song cuts occurred, though the 1980 Canadian filmed adaptation substituted numbers such as West End Avenue with Where Did the Magic Go? and Solid Silver Platform Shoes with It's Gonna Take a Magician to fit the medium, alongside minor lyric tweaks to Charmin's Lament.

Cast and Characters

Original Cast

The original Broadway production of The Magic Show opened on May 28, 1974, at the Cort Theatre, with starring as the lead magician, a wide-eyed young performer named Doug who uses illusions to navigate the seedy world of a . , a Canadian illusionist making his Broadway debut, embodied the role through his genuine enthusiasm and technical prowess in grand tricks, setting the tone for the show's blend of magic and musical theater. The supporting cast featured as Charmin, the seductive lounge singer whose vocals and charisma added a layer of glamour to the ensemble; as Feldman, the scheming and washed-up rival magician who served as the primary antagonist; and as Cal, Doug's assistant and love interest providing and grounding the fantastical elements. Additional key roles included as Manny, the club owner and bartender facilitating the club's chaotic atmosphere; as Dina, one half of the rock duo Dina and Donna; and Annie McGreevey as Donna, her counterpart in the musical numbers. The ensemble rounded out the production with performers like Loyd Sannes and Ronald Stafford portraying goons and other bit characters, alongside chorus members such as Joseph Abaldo, Jeff Mylett, Loni Ackerman, Louisa Flaningam, Timothy Jerome, , Natalie Mosco, and Dara Norman, who handled backup vocals, dance routines, and onstage assistance for Henning's illusions. These actors brought a vaudeville-inspired energy to their multifaceted duties, enhancing the show's improvisational feel and seamless integration of magic effects.
ActorRole
Doug (The Magician)
Charmin
Feldman
Cal
Manny
Dina
Annie McGreeveyDonna
Loyd SannesGoon/Ensemble
Ronald StaffordGoon/Ensemble

Notable Replacements

During its four-year Broadway run, The Magic Show saw several notable cast replacements in principal roles, often due to actors pursuing other opportunities or the demands of the production's demanding schedule. , the original star in the lead role of the young magician, performed through the majority of the 1,920 performances, taking only occasional breaks for television commitments such as his specials in 1975 and 1976; these absences were covered by standbys including , who briefly assumed the role (with the character's name changed from "Doug" to "Jeff") starting in March 1975. Later, Abaldo succeeded Mylett in the role (renamed "Joe") beginning March 30, 1977, ensuring continuity in the illusion-heavy production until the show's closing on December 31, 1978. In the role of Charmin, the seductive club singer, was replaced by Loni Ackerman from August 1975 to May 1976, a period during which Ackerman brought her experience from earlier Broadway shows like the 1971 revival of to the musical's ensemble dynamics. Morris, who had originated the part with her distinctive dance and vocal style, returned periodically but stepped away for projects including the 1975 musical Doctor Jazz. David Ogden Stiers, who originated the role of the pompous rival magician Feldman, departed early in the run around 1975 to pursue television work, including a guest spot on Kojak in December 1975; he was succeeded by Nicholas Wyman (credited as Nick Wyman), who took over the part. Wyman's tenure helped maintain the show's satirical edge on the nightclub's quirky ensemble, with replacements in supporting roles like Cal and occurring more frequently to accommodate the production's longevity, though specific dates for those shifts remain less documented.

Music

Score Overview

The score for The Magic Show was composed by Stephen Schwartz between 1973 and 1974, following the success of his breakthrough musical Godspell (1971), which established his reputation for crafting accessible, upbeat tunes that infused theatrical storytelling with contemporary energy. Schwartz developed the music and lyrics iteratively at the piano, allowing natural rhythms from the words to drive the melodies, as seen in songs like "West End Avenue," which emerged with unexpected time signatures such as 7/4 and 9/4 during the process. This approach drew from his Godspell experience, where high school performances highlighted the power of energetic, eclectic styles to engage audiences, leading to a score that prioritized lively, character-driven numbers over complex operatic structures. Stylistically, the score blends pop and rock influences with folk elements and theatrical balladry, creating an intimate vibe that eschews the bombastic orchestration of traditional Broadway shows in favor of a -infused sound suited to the production's magical, setting. Schwartz's compositions feature conversational meters and inventive rhythms that mirror the illusions on stage, with upbeat ensemble pieces evoking wonder and solo ballads delivering emotional depth through irony and vulnerability. For instance, the music shifts fluidly between pop genres, maintaining a genial, youthful tone that enhances the show's themes without overpowering the live magic acts. The supports this intimate scale with a small rhythm-based of seven musicians, including keyboards, guitars, bass, , and percussion, allowing precise with the timing of the illusions through dynamic percussion cues and layered rock textures. This setup, arranged by Schwartz in collaboration with , emphasizes propulsion and surprise, aligning the score's pulse with the deceptive sleight-of-hand central to the narrative. Musically, the score explores themes of , , and wonder, paralleling the plot's motif of as both trickery and transformative force; songs delve into trust in illusions (as in the protagonist's in his craft), the pitfalls of and , and the awe of genuine enchantment. These elements are woven through character arcs, such as the young magician's confrontation with a scheming rival, using melodic motifs to underscore emotional revelations amid the spectacle. The original cast album, capturing the Broadway premiere's energy, was released in 1974 by Bell Records, featuring the principal performers and the live band's raw rock edge; it was later reissued by Arista and in CD format by January Records in 1998.

Opening Night Band

The opening night band for the Broadway production of The Magic Show was conducted by Stephen Reinhardt, who served as musical director and performed on keyboards. Reinhardt was joined by on keyboards, marking Shaffer's Broadway debut as a musician in the production. The ensemble included guitarists Brian McCormick and Jerry Wiener, bassist Steve Manes, drummer Richard Cook, and percussionist Charles Birch, forming a 7-piece group that supported the show's pop-rock score. This compact band delivered the musical accompaniment integral to the production's blend of illusion and song, with Shaffer's contributions later highlighted in his career trajectory from Broadway to television leadership.

Reception

Critical Response

Upon its premiere on May 28, 1974, at the Cort Theatre, The Magic Show received mixed reviews from critics, who were divided on its blend of spectacle and musical theater elements. Clive Barnes of praised magician Doug Henning's performance as "terrific," highlighting his "brilliant" illusions and charismatic stage presence that brought fresh energy to Broadway, but he criticized the book by Bob Randall as thin and the songs as feeble, deeming the overall show "not clever enough to be camp" or "smart enough to be silly." Similarly, in the New York Times commended Henning as a "splendid illusionist" and noted the innovative format that integrated seamlessly into the , describing it as the kind of entertainment that delighted audiences on a rainy afternoon, though he implied the structure prioritized spectacle over deeper substance. Common praises centered on Henning's dynamic illusions—such as making a 7,000-pound vanish—and his infectious energy, which critics agreed elevated the production's visual appeal and made it a standout for its theatrical magic. Schwartz's score also drew acclaim for its catchy, rock-infused numbers like "Lion Tamer," which were seen as lively and well-suited to the ensemble's tight performances, providing an engaging musical backdrop despite the show's modest plotting. Criticisms frequently targeted the weak plotting by Bob Randall, with reviewers pointing to an over-reliance on Henning's spectacle at the expense of narrative depth or character development, resulting in a book that felt underdeveloped and secondary to the tricks. This led to an initial chilly , often described as mixed or lukewarm. As the run progressed, reception evolved positively through audience word-of-mouth, which built enthusiasm and sustained packed houses, even as the show faced Tony Award snubs for its leads, book, and score—receiving only nominations for featured actor (Henning) and direction—despite its artistic innovations in visuals that made it a critics' favorite for . No aggregate score like exists for the era, but contemporary accounts highlight its enduring appeal as a visual darling amid the critiques.

Commercial Success and Awards

The Magic Show proved to be a major commercial success on Broadway, running for 1,920 performances over four and a half years from its opening on May 28, 1974, to its closure on December 31, 1978, at the Cort Theatre, making it one of the longest-running musicals of the decade. Following a mixed critical reception, the production quickly drew sold-out houses and sustained high grosses, establishing it as a reliable hit amid a season of financial uncertainty. The show's appeal to audiences under 35 helped fuel Broadway's broader resurgence during the mid-1970s economic , when overall gross receipts for the 1974-75 season rose 24 percent to $57.4 million despite economic headwinds. This success, driven by its blend of , , and accessible , attracted families and magic enthusiasts, contributing to increased attendance and providing a financial foundation for producers Edgar Lansbury, Joseph Beruh, and to pursue subsequent projects. The release of the original cast album on in 1974 further bolstered profitability through ancillary sales. In recognition of its achievements, the production earned two Tony Award nominations in 1975: Doug Henning for Best Featured Actor in a Musical and Grover Dale for Best Direction of a Musical, underscoring its impact on the theatrical landscape.

Legacy

Cultural Impact

The Magic Show significantly boosted the career of its star, Canadian magician , marking his American debut and transforming him into a household name. Opening on Broadway in 1974, the production ran for 1,920 performances over four years, allowing Henning to showcase grand illusions within a rock musical framework that captivated audiences. This exposure directly launched his subsequent ventures, including a series of seven annual television specials titled Doug Henning's World of Magic beginning in 1975, which earned several Emmy nominations and one win, along with additional specials—such as his recreation of Houdini's Water Torture Cell escape—and headline residencies in casinos, where he performed innovative large-scale magic shows. In the mid-1980s, Henning retired from performing magic to pursue interests in and ran unsuccessfully for political office in . The musical played a pivotal role in reviving interest in stage magic during the post-Houdini era, a period when the art form had waned since the decline of vaudeville in the 1930s. By presenting magic as accessible and entertaining rather than sideshow spectacle, The Magic Show administered a "shot in the arm" to the profession, sparking a nationwide boom that expanded magic clubs, shops, and the number of amateur and professional magicians in the United States. Henning's casual style—featuring jeans, tie-dye, and long hair—influenced modern illusionists by shifting away from traditional tuxedo-clad presentations toward a more youthful, countercultural vibe. On Broadway, The Magic Show advanced the integration of illusions into musical theater, blending narrative songs with live magic to create a hybrid format that emphasized spectacle and audience wonder. This approach helped normalize magic as a structural element in productions, influencing the evolution toward visually immersive shows that prioritize innovative staging and effects alongside storytelling. For composer-lyricist , the musical reinforced his status as a Broadway powerhouse in the 1970s, coming on the heels of (1971) and Pippin (1972) and achieving comparable commercial success with hits like "Lion Tamer." Its extended run and enduring songbook entries solidified Schwartz's versatility, paving the way for his later landmark works, including Wicked (2003), by demonstrating his ability to craft scores that support unconventional theatrical elements. Beyond individual careers, The Magic Show left a broader legacy by inspiring subsequent magic-infused theatrical works and fostering educational initiatives in that explore techniques. The production's success highlighted the artistic potential of magic in mainstream , encouraging programs at institutions like theater conservatories to incorporate illusions into curricula. In , marking the show's 50th anniversary since its May 28 premiere, theater enthusiasts and magic historians reflected on its niche yet persistent influence, crediting it with sustaining magic's vitality in live performance.

Filmed Version

The filmed version of The Magic Show was produced in 1981 at Toronto's for Canadian television, utilizing a multi-camera setup to capture the performance under the direction of Norman Campbell. reprised his starring role as the young magician Doug, joined by as Cal and as Charmin, along with additional performers such as Jon Finlayson and . Adapted specifically for the screen, the production shortened the runtime to about , incorporated close-up shots on key illusions to enhance visual intimacy, and modified elements like song lyrics and routines—such as replacing "West End Avenue" with "Where Did the Magic Go?"—while preserving Henning's signature tricks. These changes allowed for tighter editing and cinematic flair but diminished the spontaneous energy of a live interaction present in the stage version. Image Entertainment released the filmed version on DVD in July 2001, providing a key archival medium that introduced the show to new audiences beyond its original broadcast. Critics offered mixed responses to the adaptation, noting its uneven musical elements, but it was widely praised for preserving Henning's innovative magic and charismatic performance, ensuring lasting access to this pivotal work in his career despite its limited initial theatrical reach.

References

  1. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-production/the-magic-show-3468
  2. http://www.musicalschwartz.com/magicshow.htm
  3. https://broadwaymusicalhome.com/shows/magic-show.htm
  4. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0718645/
  5. https://stephenschwartz.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/MagicShow.pdf
  6. https://www.thecut.com/2018/05/i-think-about-this-a-lot-a-song-from-the-magic-show-musical.html
  7. https://www.nytimes.com/1974/06/25/archives/profits-more-elusive-on-broadway-surprise-member-money-to-be-made.html
  8. https://playbill.com/production/the-magic-show-cort-theatre-vault-0000003503
  9. https://forums.geniimagazine.com/viewtopic.php?t=55331
  10. https://doughenningproject.com/category/illusions/
  11. https://playbill.com/article/how-to-watch-the-magic-show-stephen-schwartzs-other-huge-70s-hit
  12. https://doughenningproject.com/category/magic-show/
  13. https://www.ibdb.com/tour-production/the-magic-show-522778
  14. https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/436023804/
  15. https://ar.pinterest.com/pin/musical-theatre-broadway--59743132551416243/
  16. https://www.ebay.com/itm/154142668136
  17. https://www.freightwaves.com/news/freight-all-kinds-getting-the-show-on-the-road
  18. https://www.ibdb.com/tour-production/the-magic-show-531994
  19. https://musicalcyberspace.com/musicals-l-o/magic-show-the/
  20. https://stephenschwartz.com/works/the-magic-show/
  21. https://castalbums.org/recordings/Magic-Show-The-1974-Original-Broadway-Cast/1907/
  22. https://www.discogs.com/release/4456832-Original-Broadway-Cast-The-Magic-Show
  23. https://castalbums.org/shows/The-Magic-Show/210
  24. https://genius.com/albums/Stephen-schwartz/The-magic-show
  25. https://ovrtur.com/production/2881108
  26. https://www.discogs.com/master/565210-Original-Broadway-Cast-The-Magic-Show
  27. https://www.nytimes.com/1974/06/13/archives/star-of-the-magic-show-transforms-act-into-art-avoids-stereotypes.html
  28. https://doughenningproject.com/2022/12/03/the-co-stars-of-the-magic-show/
  29. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-cast-staff/jeff-mylett-96069
  30. https://playbill.com/person/jeff-mylett-vault-0000087460
  31. https://ovrtur.com/biography/10169937
  32. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-cast-staff/loni-ackerman-29295
  33. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-cast-staff/anita-morris-53750
  34. https://playbill.com/person/nick-wyman-vault-0000050026
  35. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-cast-staff/nicholas-wyman-75079
  36. https://www.broadwayworld.com/shows/The-Magic-Show-5819/replacement-cast
  37. https://castalbumreviews.com/the-magic-show/
  38. https://stephenschwartz.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/Schwartz-On-Orchestrations.pdf
  39. https://playbill.com/article/vintage-playbill-stephen-schwartzs-the-magic-show-1974-com-205858
  40. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-cast-staff/paul-shaffer-8065
  41. https://www.nytimes.com/1974/11/10/archives/arts-and-leisure-guide-opening-this-week-broadway-theater-off.html
  42. https://playbill.com/article/long-runs-on-broadway-com-109864
  43. https://www.nytimes.com/1975/06/15/archives/broadway-enjoying-a-profitable-period-despite-recession-broadway-as.html
  44. https://doughenningproject.com/2020/03/24/original-magic-show-vinyl-cast-album/
  45. https://www.nytimes.com/2000/02/09/arts/doug-henning-a-superstar-of-illusion-is-dead-at-52.html
  46. https://www.nytimes.com/1977/02/06/archives/where-how-to-put-a-little-magic-in-your-trip.html
  47. https://doughenningproject.com/2024/05/28/50-years-of-the-magic-show/
  48. https://magictimes.com/mt-july-9-15-2001/
  49. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0130103/
  50. https://www.amazon.com/Magic-Show-Doug-Henning/dp/B00005KH3G
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.