Hubbry Logo
Alice MitchellAlice MitchellMain
Open search
Alice Mitchell
Community hub
Alice Mitchell
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Alice Mitchell
Alice Mitchell
Alice Mitchell
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Alice Jessie Mitchell (November 26, 1872 – March 31, 1898) was an American woman who gained notoriety for the murder of her lover, Freda Ward. On January 23, 1892, the 19-year-old Mitchell cut the throat of Ward, then 17 years old.[1] Mitchell was subsequently found insane by means of a jury inquisition and placed in a psychiatric hospital until her death in 1898.[2]

Key Information

Early life

[edit]

Alice Mitchell was born in 1872 to George and Isabella Mitchell.[3] Alice was never interested in the toys that young girls were interested in. She was interested in playing on the swing in her yard, and playing both baseball and football. Alice had four siblings: her older brothers Robert and Frank, her eldest sister Mattie and her older sister Addie. She was closest with her brother Frank. Together, they played with marbles and practiced shooting with a rifle. Alice also liked horses and helped take care of her father's horse. Her mother tried to teach her sewing and needlework, but Alice never enjoyed doing this work nor was ever able to learn how. Alice was not interested in boys as a child as most girls her age were. In fact, as she grew older, she was sometimes rude to young men.[3]

Relationship with Freda Ward

[edit]
An earlier crayon portrait of Frederica Ward from the Appeal Avalanche

Alice and Freda met at the Higbee School for Young Ladies. They were very open about their relationship: they kissed, hugged, and held hands. This was not considered as homosexual behavior during this period and intimate female friendships were called "chumming" in Memphis. However, their relationship was more serious than "chumming", and Alice especially had an obsession with Freda. Freda's family left Memphis and moved upriver to Golddust, Tennessee. Because Alice and Freda did not live in the same city, they only saw each other occasionally. However, when one of them would make the trip to see the other, they would stay together for weeks at a time. When visiting, the two would share a bed at night. Freda was not as serious about the relationship as Alice was, and was interested in two men in addition to Alice. The two dated until Freda's eldest sister and surrogate mother Ada Volkmar forbade Freda to communicate with Alice.[3]

Depression

[edit]

Alice had devised a scheme in which she would begin dressing as a man, marry Freda, and both would go to live in St. Louis as husband and wife with Alice (as Alvin J. Ward) finding work to support Freda. Freda accepted this proposal. Ada Volkmar discovered their letters, including the proposal, and sent a letter to Alice and to Alice's mother Isabella, telling Alice to stay away from Freda. Because their relationship was exposed and they were not allowed to see each other, Alice fell into a deep depression. She was rarely with her family, would stay awake at night, and ate very little. Alice would spend her time remembering her relationship with Freda: she would observe her photograph of Freda and reread letters. Alice often signed receipts with the name "Freda Ward" and claimed that she did not realize what she was doing.[3]

Murder of Freda Ward

[edit]

Freda Ward was with her older sister Jo Ward and her friend Christina Purnell in Memphis when Alice slashed Freda with George Mitchell's razor. Freda, Jo, and Christina were heading towards the river to board the steamboat Ora Lee to head to Golddust. After following them in a wagon, driven by her friend Lillie Johnson, Alice saw Freda and walked over to her on thawing ice. Alice took the razor she had purchased to assist in her growing a mustache for her planned elopement with Freda[4] from her pocket and slashed Freda across her face. Jo tried to protect Freda by attacking Alice with an umbrella, but the attack was not successful. Angered by the umbrella, Alice sliced Jo's collarbone. Freda, bleeding and disoriented, was finally killed by Alice with a deep slice across her throat. After killing Freda, Alice went back to the wagon and told Lillie Johnson what she had done and expressed a desire to kill herself. Lillie said she should go home to her mother and confess instead, which they did.[5] Later, both she and Alice were arrested. Lillie was suspected of knowing Alice's plans ahead of time but did nothing to prevent it.[6] Lillie was released on bond but Alice had to remain in jail.

Alice was tried that summer and declared "presently insane," meaning that she was insane before the murder. According to her own testimony, Alice killed Freda because if they could not get married, then there was no reason for either of them to live and no one should marry Freda if she could not. All charges were dropped against Lillie Johnson and Alice was ordered to Western State Hospital for the Insane located at Bolivar, Tennessee. She died there in 1898.[3]

The case, which was exploited by sensationalist press, focused attention on the sexual attachments of women and drew out discussions of lesbianism into the public discourse.[7] The case was headlined as "A Very Unnatural Crime" across the country.[8] The case influenced the popular literature of the era which began to depict lesbians as "murderous" and "masculine".[9] One identity that came to be thought of lesbians was the "mannish lesbian" creating dialogue of gender expression.[8]

The case history produced by Mitchell's defense describes her as "a regular tomboy."[10] In the courtroom, Alice Mitchell was presented as "insane" by her attorneys and her trial was not tried in criminal court but for questioning of lunacy.[8]

This story was featured on Investigation Discovery's Deadly Women.

Mitchell's story is the subject of the book Alice + Freda Forever by Alexis Coe, which is being adapted into a film directed by Jennifer Kent.[11]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Alice Mitchell

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Alice Jessie Mitchell (1872–1898) was an American woman from , who murdered her seventeen-year-old female romantic partner, Frederica "Freda" Ward, by slitting her throat on a riverfront railroad track on January 25, 1892. The two young women, former schoolmates at the Higbee School for Girls, had developed an intense romantic attachment, with Mitchell cropping her hair, adopting male attire, and insisting on a marital union in which she would pose as Ward's husband. Mitchell's motive stemmed from Ward's rejection of their planned elopement and her decision to end the relationship, prompting Mitchell to declare, "I killed Freda because I loved her, and she refused to marry me." The crime and ensuing trial garnered national media scrutiny, sensationalizing the same-sex elements of their bond and raising questions about female romantic friendships in the late nineteenth century. Deemed insane by a following psychiatric testimony attributing the act to a "malady of the mind," Mitchell avoided execution and was committed to the Western State Hospital for the Insane in , where she died on March 31, 1898, at age twenty-five, reportedly from consumption or possibly .

Early Life and Family

Childhood and Education

Alice Mitchell was born on November 26, 1872, in to George Mitchell, then aged 45, and Isabella Vance Mitchell. The family relocated to , where Mitchell spent her early years in a indicative of middle-to-upper-class circumstances, as her father engaged in activities supporting the family's social standing in the community. Mitchell received her education at the Higbee School for Young Ladies, a private finishing institution in Memphis catering to daughters of affluent white families, emphasizing , domestic skills, and moral instruction to prepare students for and rather than professional pursuits. Enrollment in such schools was common for girls of her background during the late , reflecting societal expectations for roles in the post-Civil War South. She attended during her teenage years, likely in the late , prior to the events of 1892.

Familial Mental Health History

Alice Mitchell's mother, Isabella Mitchell, suffered from puerperal insanity—a severe form of —following the births of Alice in 1872 and her sister Sallie. These episodes manifested as acute mental disturbances shortly after , leading to Isabella's hospitalization on multiple occasions for treatment of manic or delusional symptoms. During Alice's 1892 insanity hearing, her father, George Mitchell, provided testimony detailing these familial incidents to establish a hereditary basis for mental vulnerability, emphasizing Isabella's condition after bearing seven children in total. The defense leveraged this history to argue that Alice's psychological deterioration, including erotomanic delusions, stemmed from inherited predisposition rather than mere moral failing, aligning with contemporaneous medical views on hereditary . No verified records indicate mental illness in Alice's father or siblings beyond the maternal line, though the puerperal episodes were framed as evidence of latent familial instability exacerbated by physiological stress. This testimony contributed to the court's declaration of Alice as "presently insane" prior to the murder, committing her to indefinite institutionalization rather than execution.

Relationship Dynamics with Freda Ward

Formation of Intense Attachment

Alice Mitchell and Frederica "Freda" Ward met as students at the Higbee School for Young Ladies, a private institution in Memphis, Tennessee, during the late 1880s. Their initial interaction occurred within a social circle that included Ward's sister Josephine and mutual friend Lillie Johnson, fostering a rapid development of companionship typical of schoolgirl bonds at the time, often termed "chumming," which involved close emotional ties and shared daily activities. This friendship soon evolved into an intense attachment for Mitchell, characterized by public displays of affection including kissing and hugging, which contemporaries noted as exceeding conventional female friendships of the era. While Ward reciprocated to some degree, Mitchell's fixation grew disproportionately stronger, influenced by their differing temperaments—Mitchell being more assertive and Ward more reserved—laying the groundwork for Mitchell's subsequent delusional convictions about their union. Historical accounts indicate this phase marked the onset of Mitchell's erotomanic tendencies, though contemporaneous observers initially viewed the pair's behavior as an extension of permissible intimate female associations prevalent in Victorian finishing schools.

Delusional Plans and Escalation

In late 1891, Alice Mitchell formulated an elaborate scheme to elope with Freda Ward to , , where Mitchell intended to assume a male identity as "Alvin J. Ward," Freda's supposed brother, while living with her as husband and wife. To execute this, Mitchell planned to cut her hair short, don male attire, secure employment as a to financially support Ward, and even conduct a mock . These delusions stemmed from Mitchell's fixation on possessing Ward exclusively, viewing their bond as an indissoluble marital union despite Ward's growing reservations. The plans unraveled in August 1891 when Ward's older sister, Hortense Volkmar, intercepted compromising letters and confronted Ward, halting the intended . Ward subsequently terminated the relationship, warning Mitchell in correspondence to cease contact, as their scheme risked social ruin and familial intervention. Undeterred, Mitchell escalated her obsession by cropping her own hair, practicing a masculine and mannerisms, and persisting in unwanted communications, interpreting Ward's rejection as temporary or illusory. By early 1892, Ward's announcement of an to a male suitor intensified Mitchell's , fueling beliefs that Ward's family and conspired to separate them permanently. Mitchell confided in acquaintances about contemplating violence to "rescue" Ward from this fate, acquiring her father's and shadowing Ward's movements in Memphis. This progression from romantic fantasy to premeditated lethal reflected Mitchell's deepening erotomanic detachment from reality, where Ward's was reframed as warranting death over loss. On January 25, 1892, this culminated in Mitchell ambushing Ward near the , slashing her throat in a swift attack witnessed by passersby.

Psychological Deterioration

Symptoms of Erotomania and Paranoia

Alice Mitchell exhibited core symptoms of erotomania, characterized by a fixed delusional belief that Freda Ward harbored secret, reciprocal romantic affection toward her, despite Ward's explicit rejections and attempts to distance herself. This delusion manifested in elaborate, unrealistic plans for their union, including Mitchell's intention to disguise herself as a man named "Fred" using a false mustache, elope with Ward, and enter into a mock marriage where Mitchell would support Ward financially while Ward performed domestic roles. Physicians testifying for the defense described this as a hallmark of erotomania, an irrational and morbidly intense erotic obsession untethered from reality, often involving the erotomanic's conviction of the beloved's hidden devotion. Compounding the were symptoms of , including possessive jealousy and fears that external influences—such as Ward's family or societal pressures—were conspiring to their relationship. Mitchell's behaviors escalated to acts of , such as secretly cutting Ward's in December 1891 to "possess" a part of her, and persistent correspondence insisting on their destined union even after Ward burned Mitchell's letters and declared the attachment over. experts linked these to paranoid ideation, where rejection fueled suspicions of interference, culminating in Mitchell's homicidal rationale: she murdered Ward on January 23, 1892, stating, "I knew I couldn’t have her and I did not want anybody else to have her," reflecting a delusional imperative to eliminate rivals or prevent loss. Post-murder indicators further evidenced the disorders' severity: Mitchell displayed no , laughing as she recounted, "Well, she bled mightily," and preserved a bloodied thumb-stall from the act as a memento, behaviors interpreted by contemporaries as erotomanic fixation persisting amid paranoid detachment from moral or social norms. Additional symptoms included chronic headaches, emotional volatility, and a developmental lag estimated at five years behind her chronological age of 19, which defense physicians attributed to hereditary factors exacerbating the framework. While these diagnoses were advanced by five expert witnesses emphasizing over moral culpability, the court's acceptance of rested on observable behaviors rather than modern diagnostic criteria, highlighting era-specific interpretations of as impulsive rather than volitional.

Pre-Murder Behavioral Indicators

Prior to the , Alice Mitchell exhibited marked changes in demeanor and habits consistent with deepening obsession and delusional ideation. In preparation for her scheme with Freda Ward, Mitchell cropped her short, adopted a masculine and posture, and acquired men's , intending to pass as "Alvin J. Ward," a male provider who would support Ward in while Ward posed as his sister. These alterations, observed by and acquaintances, deviated sharply from her prior feminine presentation and reflected a persistent fantasy of marital union despite Ward's rejection following the discovery of their correspondence in late 1891. Mitchell's correspondence and verbal disclosures revealed an unyielding fixation, with letters to Ward containing fervent declarations of love and insistence on their union, even after parental intervention and Ward's explicit refusal to proceed. She confided elaborate escape plans to third parties, including a friend named Lillie Johnson, detailing her disguise and relocation, while dismissing arguments and ridicule from others as futile. members noted her growing isolation and emotional volatility, linking it to a pattern of aversion to conventional female roles and prior infatuations with other women, such as Clara Bailey in 1889, which they interpreted as signs of emerging sexual perversion and instability. These behaviors escalated in the weeks before January 23, 1892, as Mitchell procured a straight razor—ostensibly for shaving in her male persona but later used in the killing—and made repeated, surreptitious attempts to contact or observe Ward, undeterred by prohibitions. Physicians later testified that such premeditated delusions and refusal to accept reality indicated pre-existing insanity, including erotomanic tendencies, rather than mere romantic fervor. No documented suicide attempts occurred, but her possessive rhetoric, echoed in trial accounts as "if I can't have her, no one will," underscored a lethal possessiveness that family had failed to mitigate despite awareness of her hereditary mental vulnerabilities.

The Murder Incident

Confrontation and Killing on January 23, 1892

On the afternoon of January 25, 1892, in Memphis, Tennessee, 19-year-old Alice Mitchell confronted 17-year-old Frederica "Freda" Ward near the riverfront on Front Street, as Ward prepared to board a ferry with her sister Josephine "Jo" Ward to return to Gold Dust, Arkansas. Mitchell, who had been driven to the area in a buggy by her friend Lizzie Johnson, spotted Ward and her sister exiting a nearby house and immediately leaped from the vehicle to intercept them. Armed with a straight razor she had taken from her father's shaving kit, Mitchell seized Ward and slashed her face twice before slitting her throat in a rapid attack witnessed by Jo Ward and Johnson. As Ward collapsed from the severe arterial bleeding, Jo Ward struck Mitchell with an umbrella, knocking her to the ground and briefly interrupting the assault; Mitchell quickly recovered, pursued the fleeing Ward, and inflicted the fatal wound. Contemporary accounts reported Mitchell exclaiming "I'll fix her!" during the initial approach, reflecting her intent amid the rejection of her prior romantic overtures toward Ward. Ward died within minutes from the throat laceration, her body left on the sidewalk near the levee as bystanders and authorities responded to the public scene. Mitchell, subdued but initially unresisting, was arrested on the spot; she later stated her aim had been to kill Ward and then herself, thwarted by Jo Ward's intervention, which prompted additional cuts to ensure Ward's death. The incident, occurring around 3:00 to 4:00 p.m., drew immediate crowds and marked a shocking escalation from Mitchell's earlier delusional plans for a same-sex union with Ward, whom she had viewed as her "husband" in informal vows.

Motive as Stated by Mitchell

Alice Mitchell confessed to the murder shortly after the incident on January 25, 1892, claiming that her actions stemmed from an obsessive love for Freda Ward. She stated that if she could not marry Ward and live with her as husband and wife—with Mitchell assuming a male role—no one else should possess her. This possessive rationale framed the killing as a means to prevent Ward from pursuing relationships with others, particularly men, amid Ward's family's rejection of their plans to relocate to St. Louis under the guise of a heterosexual marriage. In her statements, Mitchell emphasized that the was an act of profound affection, reportedly saying, "I killed her because I loved her," underscoring a delusional belief that death would unite them eternally or spare Ward from a life without Mitchell. She had premeditated the act, intending to slit Ward's throat with a and then her own, but failed in the suicide attempt, later expressing no remorse and viewing the outcome as inevitable given Ward's perceived shift in affections toward suitors like Harry Bilger. During the legal proceedings, Mitchell reiterated these sentiments, attributing the violence to jealousy over Ward's independence and refusal to elope, rather than denying intent.

Trial Evidence and Insanity Plea

The trial of Alice Mitchell began with a preliminary competency hearing in February 1892, rather than a full prosecution, as her defense attorneys, General and George Gantt, entered a of "present ." This asserted that Mitchell was mentally incompetent both prior to the on January 25, 1892, and at the time of the hearing, rendering her unfit to stand trial. Judge John A. DuBose presided over the proceedings in the Shelby County Criminal Court in , where the focus shifted from the act of to Mitchell's psychological capacity. Evidence supporting the insanity plea included intimate correspondence between Mitchell and Ward, with love letters exchanged as early as January 18, 1892, being read aloud in court; these documents detailed Mitchell's obsessive attachment and plans for Ward to disguise herself as a for a supposed . Mitchell herself testified, stating that she killed Ward "because I loved her, and she refused to marry me," which defense experts framed as indicative of delusional rather than rational intent. Physicians summoned by the defense, including medical authorities cited in contemporary reports, argued that Mitchell exhibited an "abnormal erotic " and morbid delusions, symptoms they linked to a broader mental predating the crime. This testimony emphasized her post-arrest behavior, such as apparent disorientation and inability to comprehend proceedings, as evidence of ongoing incapacity. The prosecution, representing the Ward family, countered that Mitchell was legally sane and capable of malice, portraying her actions as deliberate and vicious rather than the product of ; they dismissed the defense's psychological claims as exaggerated, insisting she understood the nature of her deed. Despite this opposition, the jury accepted the after reviewing the combined evidence of letters, witness accounts of Mitchell's prior erratic conduct, and expert medical opinions, adjudging her "presently insane" on or around March 18, 1892. As a result, no murder trial occurred; Mitchell was committed to an insane asylum without a on guilt, a outcome driven in part by her father's insistence on the insanity strategy over potential on lesser grounds. This ruling hinged on law allowing indefinite institutionalization for those deemed dangerously insane, bypassing or .

Expert Testimony on Hereditary Insanity

In the July 1892 lunacy for Alice Mitchell, defense experts emphasized hereditary as a predisposing factor to her , drawing on family to argue she was unfit for trial. Dr. Comstock, who had examined Mitchell, testified that her condition stemmed from hereditary , classifying it as an inherited diathesis manifesting in abnormal erotic instincts and imperative delusions. This view aligned with contemporaneous psychiatric understandings of , where inherited neural vulnerabilities could produce fixed delusional states without broader cognitive impairment. Supporting evidence included testimony from Mitchell's father, who detailed her mother's recurrent puerperal insanity—severe occurring after multiple births, including Alice's—which was presented as transmitting a to mental instability. Additional depositions highlighted insanity among female relatives, such as eccentric behaviors and institutionalizations, reinforcing the hereditary taint narrative over voluntary criminality. Experts contended this familial pattern explained Mitchell's erotomanic fixation and the impulsive murder, framing her actions as products of an unavoidable inherited defect rather than rational choice. Prosecution witnesses challenged the extent of heredity's role, noting Mitchell's apparent lucidity in planning and executing the crime, but the defense's hereditary arguments prevailed, leading the to declare her insane after brief deliberation on July 20, 1892. This testimony reflected late-19th-century forensic psychiatry's reliance on lineage-based , though modern critiques question its empirical basis given the era's limited diagnostic tools and potential conflation of social nonconformity with .

Institutionalization and Death

Commitment to Western State Hospital

Following a inquisition on July 30, 1892, Alice Mitchell was declared "presently insane and dangerous," resulting in her commitment to Western State Hospital for the Insane in , rather than facing a full conviction. The decision stemmed from expert testimony during proceedings that emphasized hereditary and erotomanic delusions as causal factors in the killing of Freda Ward, overriding arguments for her capacity to stand trial. This outcome reflected late-19th-century legal practices in , where insanity verdicts often led to indefinite institutionalization in state asylums for those deemed threats to public safety. Mitchell was formally transferred to the hospital on August 1, 1892, where the facility functioned primarily as a secure custodial environment for the criminally insane, emphasizing restraint over curative treatment amid limited psychiatric advancements of the . Western State Hospital, established as Tennessee's primary institution for such cases, housed patients under conditions typical of asylums, including isolation and minimal therapeutic intervention, with oversight by state-appointed physicians focused on . Her commitment was indefinite, contingent on periodic evaluations of sanity, though contemporary accounts indicate no successful petitions for release were pursued by her family or granted by authorities.

Cause of Death in 1898

Alice Mitchell died on March 31, 1898, at the age of 25 while confined at Western State Hospital in . The official cause of death, as recorded on her death certificate and reported in contemporary press accounts, was consumption, the common term at the time for pulmonary , a disease prevalent in institutional settings due to and poor sanitation. A conflicting account emerged later, with one of Mitchell's attorneys claiming in an that she had committed by jumping into the asylum's rooftop , though this was not documented in official records or contemporaneous newspapers and appears unsubstantiated by primary . Tuberculosis remained the attributed cause in historical summaries drawing from institutional and media reports of the .

Interpretations and Controversies

Historical Sensationalism vs. Modern Narratives

The murder of Freda Ward by Alice Mitchell in 1892 generated widespread coverage in American newspapers, with reports emphasizing the pair's intense "romantic friendship" and Mitchell's delusional plan to disguise herself as a man named "Fred" to marry Ward and live as husband and wife. Outlets like the Memphis Commercial Appeal and national papers detailed love letters exchanged between the women, Mitchell's act of cutting Ward's throat with a during a confrontation, and the subsequent courtroom reading of correspondence that portrayed the relationship as obsessive and transgressive of norms. This framing amplified public fascination with themes of forbidden passion and female deviance, often likening the case to fictional scandals and speculating on "unnatural" attachments without substantive evidence of sexual conduct beyond affectionate common in 19th-century women's correspondences. In contrast, 20th- and 21st-century narratives, particularly in popular histories and scholarship, reinterpret the incident as a proto-lesbian driven by societal repression of same-sex desire. Works such as Alexis Coe's Alice + Freda Forever: A Murder in Memphis (2014) and Lisa Duggan's analysis in Sapphic Slashers (2000) emphasize Mitchell's "mannish" traits and the romance's intensity, attributing the killing to Ward's rejection amid family interference and cultural taboos, while downplaying contemporaneous medical assessments of Mitchell's . These accounts often project modern identity categories onto the events, framing Mitchell as an early butch figure whose violence stemmed from possessive love rather than , and citing the case as emblematic of emerging sexological discourse on lesbianism. Such modern retellings, however, underemphasize trial evidence substantiating the successful insanity plea, including expert testimony on hereditary insanity linked to Mitchell's family history—such as her mother's documented mental instability and relatives' institutionalizations—which indicated erotomanic delusions predating and motivating the act. Contemporary observers, including defense psychiatrists, argued that Mitchell's fixation represented rather than rational romantic grievance, evidenced by her premeditated purchase of the , post-murder composure suggesting detachment from reality, and prior threats of or homicide if denied Ward. While historical press exploited the story for titillation, privileging empirical indicators of over speculative eros provides a more causally grounded explanation for the violence, avoiding anachronistic overlays that risk conflating delusion with consensual identity.

Critiques of Romanticization and Causal Factors

Some historical analyses and popular accounts have portrayed the Mitchell-Ward relationship as a poignant example of repressed same-sex affection in the late , emphasizing societal intolerance as the primary driver of the tragedy and framing the as an inevitable outcome of forbidden . This romanticization, evident in works like Alexis Coe's Alice + Freda Forever (), highlights letters and plans while minimizing the premeditated brutality of the throat-slashing on , , and Mitchell's subsequent unrepentant demeanor during . Critics contend that such narratives, often produced in contexts with ideological incentives to elevate historical figures, overlook primary from the proceedings, where the successful rested not on external pressures but on intrinsic mental defects. Trial testimony from multiple psychologists established Mitchell's condition as a form of or hereditary , predating and independent of her fixation on Ward. Family history included her mother's puerperal following , a sibling's by poison, and other relatives' documented instability, supporting a rather than situational romance as the causal root. Behaviors cited as insane—such as , aversion to feminine tasks, and delusional marriage schemes—were interpreted contemporaneously as symptoms of sexual inversion linked to degeneration, not normative variation; modern reinterpretations equating these with alone risk conflating with causation, ignoring how Mitchell's prior obsessive acts and failed prior attempts on Ward indicate pathological compulsion over rational passion. This emphasis on mental pathology aligns with causal realism, prioritizing verifiable familial and behavioral antecedents over speculative sociocultural blame. Sources advancing romanticized views, frequently from advocacy-oriented outlets, exhibit selective emphasis that aligns with contemporary , potentially understating the empirical weight of insanity verdicts rendered by disinterested medical experts in 1892. The jury's finding of "present insanity" on July 18, 1892, leading to commitment rather than punishment, underscores that contemporaries discerned as the operative factor, not mere spurned affection.

References

  1. http://www.murderbygaslight.com/2010/01/freda-ward-girl-slays-girl.html
  2. https://www.elmwoodcemetery.org/default.aspx?p=204937&beid=204484
  3. http://outhistory.org/exhibits/show/mitchell/duggan-trials
  4. http://outhistory.org/exhibits/show/mitchell/emmawilliams
  5. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26433097
  6. https://www.memphisflyer.com/on-alice-and-freda
  7. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-tennessean-alice-mitchell-dead-1898/14226503/?locale=en-US
  8. https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/LB7G-DC7/alice-jessie-mitchell-1872-1898
  9. https://oxfordamerican.org/item/398-alice-and-freda-forever
  10. https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=7806&context=etd
  11. https://murderpedia.org/female.M/m/mitchell-alice.htm
  12. https://lernerbooks.com/shop/show/19740
  13. https://medium.com/the-awl/erotomania-and-murder-in-memphis-be9c3133efe6
  14. https://www.bookbrowse.com/mag/btb/index.cfm/book_number/4034/in-the-dream-house
  15. https://focuslgbt.com/blog/alice-freda-1892-memphis-girls-young-love-ends-tragically-creates-national-headlines/
  16. https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/fatal-attraction-love-murder-tennessee
  17. https://wlwofthepast.wordpress.com/2021/04/27/alice-mitchell-freda-ward/
  18. http://wordbasket.blogspot.com/2014/10/the-great-lesbian-murder-circus-of.html
  19. https://www.coloradohistoricnewspapers.org/?a=d&d=RMW18920721-01.2.135
  20. https://www.storiesofthesupernatural.info/strangerthanfiction/the-memphis-murderess
  21. https://www.theawl.com/2014/10/erotomania-and-murder-in-memphis/
  22. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6a/Erotopathia_-_morbid_erotism_%28IA_101745215.nlm.nih.gov%29.pdf
  23. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/social-sciences-and-humanities/alice-mitchell-found-guilty-murdering-her-lover
  24. https://www.encyclopedia.com/social-sciences/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/mitchell-alice
  25. https://cdnc.ucr.edu/?a=d&d=MB18920210.2.15
  26. https://www.nytimes.com/1892/01/26/archives/a-most-shocking-crime-a-memphis-society-girl-cuts-a-former-friends.html
  27. https://oulurepo.oulu.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/51570/nbnfioulu-202408215540.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
  28. https://www.jstor.org/stable/3174907
  29. https://storage.lib.uchicago.edu/pres/2007/pres2007-0190.pdf
  30. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-memphis-appeal-avalanche-homosexuali/84408523/
  31. https://gahistoricnewspapers.galileo.usg.edu/lccn/sn88054137/1892-07-28/ed-1/seq-7/ocr/
  32. http://outhistory.org/exhibits/show/amct/1892-
  33. https://abandonedsoutheast.com/2016/11/01/mental-asylum/
  34. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/15533150/alice_jessie-mitchell
  35. https://theywillkillyou.com/profile/alice-jessie-mitchell
  36. https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-st-joseph-herald-ward-murdered-by-l/14225966/
  37. https://www.amazon.com/Alice-Freda-Forever-Murder-Memphis/dp/1936976609
  38. https://read.dukeupress.edu/books/book/528/Sapphic-SlashersSex-Violence-and-American
  39. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/The-Trials-of-Alice-Mitchell%253A-Sensationalism%252C-and-Duggan/b05cae9178205689b74fcaa98c8df46fbf99af10
  40. https://lambdaliterary.org/2014/10/alice-freda-forever-a-murder-in-memphis-by-alexis-coe/
  41. https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/fatal-attraction-love-and-murder-tennessee
  42. https://www.autostraddle.com/21-indications-that-this-1892-teenage-murderess-was-insane-and-by-insane-i-mean-gay-277747/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.