Community hub
0 subscribers7 pages, 0 posts
Recent from talks
All channels
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Contribute something
Welcome to the community hub built to collect knowledge and have discussions related to Division of Ryan.
Nothing was collected or created yet.
Division of Ryan
View on Wikipediafrom Wikipedia
The Division of Ryan is an Australian electoral division in the state of Queensland. It is west of Brisbane, comprising parts of the City of Brisbane and City of Moreton Bay.
Key Information
Since 2022 its MP has been Elizabeth Watson-Brown of the Greens. Following the 2025 federal election, Watson-Brown remained as the sole Green MP in the Australian Parliament.
History
[edit]
The division was created in 1949 and is named after T. J. Ryan, Premier of Queensland from 1915 to 1919.
In the 2001 federal election, Liberal candidate Michael Johnson was elected.[1] He served as the member for Ryan until he was expelled from the Liberal Party. Johnson subsequently ran as an Independent in the 2010 federal election but lost.[2]
Since 2016 there has been a growing Greens vote, gaining 20% of the first-preference vote in the 2019 election. In 2022, Greens candidate Elizabeth Watson-Brown won the seat from LNP member Julian Simmonds.[3]
Location
[edit]Since 1984, federal electoral division boundaries in Australia have been determined at redistributions by a redistribution committee appointed by the Australian Electoral Commission. Redistributions occur for the boundaries of divisions in a particular state, and they occur every seven years, or sooner if a state's representation entitlement changes or when divisions of a state are malapportioned.[4]
Ryan is located in south-east Queensland, and is generally based on the western suburbs of the City of Brisbane.
The Division of Ryan encompasses a number of whole and part suburbs and localities:[5][6]
- Anstead
- Ashgrove (western and north-western part)
- Auchenflower
- Banks Creek (within the City of Brisbane)
- Bardon (southern part)
- Bellbowrie
- Brookfield
- Chapel Hill
- England Creek (within the City of Brisbane)
- Enoggera (western part)
- Enoggera Reservoir
- Ferny Grove
- Fig Tree Pocket
- Gaythorne
- Indooroopilly
- Kenmore
- Kenmore Hills
- Keperra
- Lake Manchester (within the City of Brisbane)
- Mitchelton
- Moggill
- Mount Coot-tha
- Paddington (southern part)
- Pinjarra Hills
- Pullenvale
- St Lucia
- Taringa
- The Gap
- Toowong
- Upper Brookfield
- Upper Kedron
Members
[edit]| Image | Member | Party | Term | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Nigel Drury (1911–1984) |
Liberal | 10 December 1949 – 11 November 1975 |
Retired | |
|
John Moore (1936–2025) |
13 December 1975 – 5 February 2001 |
Served as minister under Fraser and Howard. Resigned to retire from politics | ||
|
Leonie Short (1956–) |
Labor | 17 March 2001 – 10 November 2001 |
Lost seat | |
|
Michael Johnson (1970–) |
Liberal | 10 November 2001 – 20 May 2010 |
Lost preselection and then lost seat | |
| Independent | 20 May 2010 – 21 August 2010 | ||||
.jpg)
|
Jane Prentice (1953–) |
Liberal[a] | 21 August 2010 – 11 April 2019 |
Lost preselection and retired | |
|
Julian Simmonds (1985–) |
18 May 2019 – 21 May 2022 |
Lost seat | ||
|
Elizabeth Watson-Brown (1956–) |
Greens | 21 May 2022 – present |
Incumbent |
Election results
[edit]| Party | Candidate | Votes | % | ±% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Liberal National | Maggie Forrest | 35,806 | 34.61 | −3.89 | |
| Greens | Elizabeth Watson-Brown | 29,986 | 28.98 | −1.23 | |
| Labor | Rebecca Hack | 29,217 | 28.24 | +5.94 | |
| People First | Nicole de Lapp | 2,407 | 2.33 | +2.33 | |
| One Nation | Robbie Elsom | 2,327 | 2.25 | +0.00 | |
| Trumpet of Patriots | Ryan Hunt | 1,372 | 1.33 | +0.97 | |
| Family First | Donna Gallehawk | 1,340 | 1.30 | +1.30 | |
| Fusion | Gina Masterton | 1,007 | 0.97 | +0.97 | |
| Total formal votes | 103,462 | 97.06 | +0.12 | ||
| Informal votes | 3,136 | 2.94 | −0.12 | ||
| Turnout | 106,598 | 92.81 | +0.77 | ||
| Notional two-party-preferred count | |||||
| Labor | Rebecca Hack | 59,822 | 57.82 | +5.40 | |
| Liberal National | Maggie Forrest | 43,640 | 42.18 | −5.40 | |
| Two-candidate-preferred result | |||||
| Greens | Elizabeth Watson-Brown | 55,112 | 53.27 | +0.62 | |
| Liberal National | Maggie Forrest | 48,350 | 46.73 | −0.62 | |
| Greens hold | Swing | +0.62 | |||
Notes
[edit]- ^ Member of the Liberal National Party of Queensland sitting with the federal parliamentary Liberal Party.
References
[edit]- ^ corporateName=Australian Electoral Commission; address=10 Mort Street, Canberra ACT 2600; contact=13 23 26. "2001 Profile of the division of Ryan". Australian Electoral Commission. Retrieved 25 January 2023.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link) - ^ "Ryan - 2010 Federal Election - ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)". www.abc.net.au. Retrieved 25 January 2023.
- ^ "Ryan (Key Seat) - Federal Electorate, Candidates, Results". abc.net.au. Retrieved 25 January 2023.
- ^ Muller, Damon (14 November 2017). "The process of federal redistributions: a quick guide". Parliament of Australia. Archived from the original on 23 May 2022. Retrieved 19 April 2022.
- ^ "Map of the Federal Electoral Division of Ryan" (PDF). Australian Electoral Commission. March 2018. Archived (PDF) from the original on 11 March 2019. Retrieved 18 April 2019.
- ^ "Queensland Globe". State of Queensland. Retrieved 8 April 2019.
- ^ Ryan, Qld, 2025 Tally Room, Australian Electoral Commission.
External links
[edit]Division of Ryan
View on Grokipediafrom Grokipedia
Geography and Demographics
Boundaries and Location
The Division of Ryan is an outer metropolitan electorate located in Queensland, Australia, encompassing an area of 370 square kilometres on the north-western fringe of Brisbane.[2] It covers portions of the Brisbane City Council local government area and the Moreton Bay Regional Council.[3] The electorate lies primarily north of the Brisbane River, extending from inner-city suburbs adjacent to the central business district westward to semi-rural localities.[6] Its boundaries incorporate established residential suburbs such as Bardon, Indooroopilly, Kenmore, St Lucia, and The Gap, along with areas like Chapel Hill, Enoggera, Ferny Grove, and Pullenvale.[7] The current configuration was determined during the 2017 Queensland redistribution, gazetted on 27 March 2018, and first applied at the 2019 federal election.[2] This adjustment aimed to balance enrolment numbers while preserving community interests in the region's growing suburban zones.[3]Population Profile and Socio-Economic Indicators
As of the 2021 Australian Census, the Division of Ryan recorded a population of 163,797 people.[8] The electorate's demographic profile reflects a relatively young and urban population, with a median age of 36 years, 18.5% aged under 15, and 10.7% aged 65 and over.[8] Females comprised 50.9% of residents, slightly outnumbering males at 49.1%.[8] Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people accounted for 1.2% of the population.[8] Country of birth data indicates 67.7% were born in Australia, with notable overseas-born groups including 4.8% from England and smaller proportions from India, New Zealand, and China.[8] English was spoken at home by 79.4% of residents, followed by Mandarin (3.7%) and other languages reflecting diverse migrant communities.[8] Religious affiliation showed 45.0% reporting no religion or secular beliefs, the largest group, with 19.9% identifying as Catholic and 15.1% as Anglican.[8] Marital status among those aged 15 and over indicated 48.0% married and 39.3% never married.[8] Socio-economic indicators point to a relatively advantaged electorate, characterized by high educational attainment and professional employment. Among people aged 15 and over, 46.5% held a bachelor degree or higher qualification, exceeding national averages.[8] The largest occupational group was professionals at 38.3%, with significant representation in health care and social assistance (11.5% of employed persons) and education and training (8.9%).[8] Median weekly personal income stood at $983, while median household income reached $2,301, reflecting substantial earning capacity.[8] Housing tenure data underscores home ownership prevalence, with 30.5% of dwellings owned outright, 35.8% owned with a mortgage (median weekly repayment $500), and 31.4% rented (median weekly rent $420).[8] These metrics, derived from Census variables on income, education, and occupation, align with patterns of relative socio-economic advantage, though pockets of student populations near the University of Queensland introduce variability in lower-income brackets.[8]| Indicator | Value (2021 Census) |
|---|---|
| Median Age | 36 years[8] |
| % with Bachelor Degree or Higher | 46.5%[8] |
| % Professionals (Employed) | 38.3%[8] |
| Median Weekly Household Income | $2,301[8] |
| % Home Ownership (Outright or Mortgage) | 66.3%[8] |
Historical and Electoral Context
Establishment and Early Elections (1949–1980s)
The Division of Ryan was established in the 1948 federal electoral redistribution to account for population growth in Queensland, particularly in Brisbane's western suburbs including Indooroopilly, St Lucia, and surrounding areas. Named after Thomas Joseph Ryan (1876–1921), who served as Queensland Premier from 1915 to 1919 and as the federal Member for West Sydney until his death, the electorate reflected the region's ties to early 20th-century Labor figures despite its subsequent conservative leanings.[3][9] The division was first contested at the 10 December 1949 federal election, aligning with the Liberal-Country Party coalition's defeat of the Chifley Labor government. Liberal candidate Edward Nigel Drury won decisively with 60.26% of the primary vote to Labor's 39.74%, securing a margin consistent with the national swing toward Robert Menzies' opposition. Drury, a businessman and pastoralist, held the seat continuously through re-elections in 1951, 1954, 1955, 1958, 1961, 1963, 1966, 1969, 1972, and 1974, often polling over 50% primary support.[10][11] This period marked Ryan as a reliable Liberal bastion, buoyed by the electorate's growing middle-class suburbs and low industrial base, which favored conservative policies on economic stability and anti-communism. Labor's strongest challenge came in 1969, achieving 42.37% primary amid national volatility, yet Drury retained the seat with Liberal primaries at 49.32%. No significant boundary changes disrupted this dominance until later decades.[11] Upon Drury's retirement, John Moore succeeded him at the 13 December 1975 election, capturing 43.24% primary in a multi-candidate field but winning comfortably on preferences following the dismissal of the Whitlam government. Moore maintained the Liberal hold through the 1980s, weathering the 1983 Hawke landslide with 53.09% primary and 57.6% two-party preferred. Subsequent 1984 and 1987 contests yielded Liberal two-party margins of 60.4% and 58.87%, respectively, affirming Ryan's entrenched conservative character.[11]Shifts in the 1990s and 2000s
During the 1990s, the Division of Ryan saw a strengthening of Liberal Party support under incumbent John Moore, who had held the seat since 1975. In the 1990 federal election, Liberals secured 57.2% of the two-party-preferred (2PP) vote, increasing to 60.6% in 1993 and reaching a decade-high of 66.9% in 1996 amid a national swing to the Howard-led Coalition.[11] By the 1998 election, the margin dipped to 59.5% 2PP, reflecting a modest 3.6% swing to Labor consistent with Queensland trends but still maintaining a comfortable Liberal hold.[11] Moore resigned on 5 February 2001, triggering a by-election on 17 March. Labor candidate Leonie Short won with 50.2% of the 2PP vote against Liberal Bob Tucker, marking a 9.7% swing to Labor and ending 26 years of continuous Liberal representation in the seat.[12][13] The result, with turnout at 88.7% of 87,634 enrolled voters, highlighted government fatigue following the introduction of the goods and services tax, though Labor's hold proved short-lived.[14] At the October 2004 federal election, Liberal Michael Johnson reclaimed Ryan for the Coalition, defeating Short and restoring the pre-by-election alignment.[15] Johnson retained the seat in 2007 with a reduced but secure margin, as Liberal primary support held amid national trends favoring the opposition.[16] These events underscored Ryan's status as a Liberal-leaning electorate prone to volatility in by-elections but resilient in general contests.Recent Volatility (2010s–Present)
The Division of Ryan saw initial volatility in 2010 when incumbent Liberal National Party (LNP) MP Michael Johnson was deselected following allegations of irregularities in travel expense claims, leading to a preselection win by Jane Prentice, who retained the seat with a two-party-preferred (TPP) margin of 12.7% against Labor. Prentice maintained strong holds in subsequent elections, achieving TPP margins of 10.3% in 2013, 9.6% in 2016, and 8.5% in 2019, reflecting the electorate's status as a safe LNP seat amid consistent primary vote shares around 50-55% for the LNP.[17] This stability disrupted dramatically in the 2022 federal election, where the Greens' Elizabeth Watson-Brown capitalized on a 9.9% swing in primary votes to 30.2%, securing a TPP victory over LNP candidate Julian Simmonds with 52.6% to 47.4%—a 5.2% swing away from the LNP and marking the first non-LNP hold since 1949.[18] The result stemmed from preferences flowing strongly from Labor (22.3% primary), highlighting rising Green appeal among affluent, university-educated voters prioritizing climate and progressive policies in Brisbane's western suburbs.[18] In the 2025 election, Watson-Brown retained the seat amid further primary vote flux, with Greens dropping 1.23% to 28.98%, LNP falling 3.89% to 34.61%, and Labor surging 5.94% to 28.24%, yet securing a TPP of 53.27% against LNP's 46.73% for a margin of approximately 3.3%.[19] This outcome, despite national Greens setbacks, underscored ongoing volatility driven by redistributing voter bases, with Labor's gains pressuring Green primaries but preferences preserving the hold.[20][19]Members and Representation
Chronological List of Members
The Division of Ryan has been represented by six members in the Australian House of Representatives since its establishment for the 1949 federal election.| Member | Party | Term |
|---|---|---|
| Edward Nigel Drury | Liberal Party of Australia | 10 December 1949 – 11 November 1975[10] |
| John Moore | Liberal Party of Australia | 13 December 1975 – 8 October 2001 |
| Michael Andrew Johnson | Liberal Party of Australia | 10 November 2001 – 21 August 2010[21] |
| Jane Prentice | Liberal Party of Australia | 21 August 2010 – 2 July 2019 |
| Julian Graham John Simmonds | Liberal Party of Australia | 2 July 2019 – 21 May 2022[22] |
| Elizabeth Watson-Brown | Australian Greens | 21 May 2022 – present (re-elected 3 May 2025)[23][24] |
Profiles of Prominent MPs: Achievements and Critiques
John Moore, a Liberal Party member, represented Ryan from 4 November 1975 until 8 October 2001, accumulating over 25 years in the House of Representatives. His parliamentary service included roles on various committees, such as the Joint Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade, contributing to policy scrutiny in those areas. Moore served as Minister for Industry, Science and Technology in 1996, later as Minister for Business and Consumer Affairs from 1997 to 1998, and briefly as Minister for Defence Industry, Science and Personnel in 1998, where he oversaw initiatives to bolster Australia's defence capabilities and industry partnerships. Critiques of Moore's tenure are limited in public record, though his defeat of Labor candidate Peter Beattie in the 1980 election highlighted competitive dynamics in the seat, with Beattie later becoming Queensland Premier. No major scandals or policy failures are prominently documented in contemporaneous reports. Jane Prentice, representing the Liberal National Party, held Ryan from 21 August 2010 to 2 July 2019. As Assistant Minister for Social Services and Disability Services from 2017 to 2018, she advanced welfare reforms, including enhancements to the National Disability Insurance Scheme implementation and support for carer payments, drawing on her prior experience as a Brisbane City Councillor focused on community services. Her advocacy extended to women's economic security and disability employment programs. However, Prentice faced criticism for claiming approximately $14,039 in taxpayer-funded flights for her husband between Canberra and Brisbane from 2010 to 2013, amid reports of his prior $1 million tax debt, raising questions about entitlement usage despite no formal breach finding. Her 2018 preselection loss to Julian Simmonds by 256 votes to 103 was decried by some Coalition figures as a setback for female representation, with internal party tensions cited as exacerbating gender imbalances in promotions.[27][28][29] Elizabeth Watson-Brown, the Australian Greens member, has represented Ryan since 21 May 2022, securing re-election on 3 May 2025. A former architect and Life Fellow of the Royal Australian Institute of Architects since 2011, she holds portfolios in infrastructure, transport, and sustainable cities, advocating for public transport expansions and climate-resilient urban planning in Queensland's western Brisbane suburbs. Her 2022 victory, overturning an LNP margin of 6%, marked a rare Greens breakthrough in a traditionally conservative seat, attributed to voter shifts on environmental and housing issues. Critiques include perceptions of Greens policies under her influence prioritizing ideological environmental goals over fiscal practicality, as voiced in broader analyses of party platforms, though specific to Ryan, opponents have highlighted potential disruptions to local development from stringent sustainability mandates.[5][24][18]Key Elections and Results
Summary of Election Outcomes
The Division of Ryan, established ahead of the 1949 Australian federal election, has historically favored non-Labor parties, with Liberal or Liberal National Party (LNP) candidates securing victory in every contest from inception through 2019.[18] This pattern reflected the electorate's affluent, suburban character in Brisbane's west, yielding LNP two-candidate preferred (TCP) margins often above 10%, including 14.6% in 2004 under John Moore and 6% in 2019 under Julian Simmonds.[18] The 2022 election marked a departure, as Australian Greens candidate Elizabeth Watson-Brown defeated Simmonds with 52.7% of the TCP vote to the LNP's 47.3%, on an 8.7% swing that ended decades of conservative control.[4] Voter turnout stood at 92%, with first preferences showing Greens at 32.6%, LNP at 34.9%, and Labor at 19.2%.[4] Watson-Brown retained the seat in the 2025 federal election, achieving 53.3% TCP against the LNP amid a 0.6% swing to the Greens, solidifying the division's recent volatility amid broader Queensland trends toward minor parties in urban seats.[30][5] The result followed a competitive primary vote, underscoring sustained progressive gains in the electorate despite national Labor advances elsewhere.[30]Analysis of 2022 Green Victory
The 2022 Australian federal election, conducted on 21 May 2022, saw the Australian Greens secure the Division of Ryan for the first time, with Elizabeth Watson-Brown defeating the incumbent Liberal National Party (LNP) MP Julian Simmonds by a two-candidate-preferred (TCP) margin of 53.3% to 46.7%.[18] This outcome reversed the LNP's previous TCP margin against Labor of 10.3% from 2019, reflecting a swing of over 14% away from the LNP in the TCP contest against the Greens.[4] Primary vote shares underscored the fragmentation: Greens 34.9%, LNP 30.7%, Labor 17.0%, and other parties/independents 17.4%, enabling the Greens to lead on first preferences before preferences from Labor (over 80% to Greens) and minors consolidated their win.[18][4] Contributing factors included a national anti-Coalition swing of around 4% amid dissatisfaction with the Morrison government's record on climate policy, bushfire response, and perceived lack of integrity, which disproportionately impacted inner-urban seats like Ryan with high concentrations of tertiary-educated professionals.[31] Locally, Ryan's demographics—encompassing affluent western Brisbane suburbs with growing enrollment at the University of Queensland and a median age under 40—aligned with rising Green support among younger voters prioritizing environmental issues, evidenced by the party's primary vote increase from 17.8% in 2019.[18] Watson-Brown's campaign focused on community consultations, opposition to overdevelopment, and advocacy for public transport improvements, resonating in areas like Indooroopilly and Taringa where urban density concerns amplified.[24] The result highlighted preferential voting dynamics in three-cornered contests: Labor's subdued primary, partly due to strategic voter shifts to Greens as the primary anti-LNP option, funneled critical preferences, a pattern observed in other Queensland inner-city seats like Brisbane and Griffith.[31] While some analyses attribute the win to broader "progressive" realignment, empirical data points to tactical desertion by former LNP voters in response to federal scandals and local incumbency fatigue, rather than uniform ideological migration.[32] The LNP's vote collapse from 51.0% primary in 2019 stemmed from candidate vulnerabilities, including Simmonds' narrow 2019 win and limited local profile compared to Watson-Brown's grassroots organizing.[18] This victory marked one of only four lower house gains for the Greens nationally, bucking Labor's overall majority formation, and signaled volatility in traditionally conservative urban fringes where socioeconomic affluence correlates with openness to minor party disruption of major-party dominance.[31] Post-election scrutiny of AEC data confirmed no irregularities, with turnout at 88.5% and formal votes aligning with historical norms.[4]2025 Election Developments
The 2025 Australian federal election for the Division of Ryan, held on 3 May 2025, featured a contest between incumbent Greens MP Elizabeth Watson-Brown and Liberal National Party (LNP) candidate Maggie Forrest, with Labor's Rebecca Hack polling strongly in primaries but directing preferences to the Greens as in the previous election.[19][30] Pre-election analysis identified Ryan as a key marginal seat for the LNP to reclaim from the Greens' 2022 upset victory, amid national focus on economic pressures and housing affordability in Brisbane's western suburbs.[30] Local campaigning emphasized infrastructure upgrades and environmental policies, with the Greens highlighting climate action and the LNP targeting cost-of-living relief.[30] Primary vote results showed the LNP leading with 35,806 votes (34.61%, a 3.89% swing against them), followed closely by the Greens at 29,986 votes (28.98%, down 1.23%) and Labor at 29,217 votes (28.24%, up 5.94%).[19] Minor parties and independents, including One Nation (2.25%), Gerard Rennick's People First (2.33%), and Family First (1.30%), fragmented the vote but did not alter the two-candidate-preferred (TCP) dynamic between the Greens and LNP.[19] Turnout reached 92.8% of the 114,891 enrolled voters.[30] In the TCP count, Watson-Brown secured victory with 53.27% (55,112 votes) against Forrest's 46.73% (48,350 votes), expanding the Greens' margin to 6.54% from 2.6% in 2022—a 0.62% swing to the Greens reliant on Labor preferences.[19][30] This retention marked a rare Greens hold outside inner-city electorates, underscoring persistent progressive preference flows in the affluent, university-influenced division despite a national LNP surge in Queensland seats.[30] No major controversies disrupted the campaign, though post-election scrutiny focused on preference deals' role in outcomes.[30]Political Dynamics and Issues
Voter Demographics and Influences
The Division of Ryan encompasses a population of 163,797 as recorded in the 2021 Australian Census, with a median age of 36 years, reflecting a relatively youthful demographic compared to the national median of 38.[8] Approximately 71% of residents are of working age (15–64 years), while 18.5% are children under 15 and 10.5% are aged 65 and over; the sex distribution shows 49.1% males and 50.9% females.[8] Indigenous Australians comprise 1.2% of the population, below national averages, with top countries of birth including Australia (67.7%), England (4.8%), and China (2.7%); Mandarin is the most common non-English language spoken at home (3.7%).[8] Religiously, 45% report no religion, higher than state and national figures, followed by Catholicism at 19.9%.[8] Socioeconomically, Ryan stands out as affluent and highly educated, with median weekly personal income at $983, family income at $2,867, and household income at $2,301—all surpassing Queensland ($1,675 household) and Australian ($1,746 household) medians.[8] Over 46.5% of those aged 15 and over hold a bachelor's degree or higher, far exceeding Queensland's 21.9% and Australia's 26.3%; professionals dominate occupations at 38.3%, with health care and social assistance as the leading industry (including hospitals at 5.1%).[8] Housing reflects stability, with 30.5% owning outright, 35.8% owning with a mortgage (median $2,200 monthly), and 31.4% renting (median $420 weekly).[8]| Key Socioeconomic Indicators (2021 Census, aged 15+) | Ryan (%) | Queensland (%) | Australia (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bachelor's degree or higher | 46.5 | 21.9 | 26.3 |
| Professionals (occupation) | 38.3 | N/A | N/A |
| Median weekly household income | $2,301 | $1,675 | $1,746 |
The electorate's diverse sub-areas—affluent conservative suburbs versus student-heavy precincts—exacerbate swings, with preferences often flowing from Greens to Labor or independents on integrity and anti-corruption platforms, while economic downturns bolster Liberal National appeals to property owners.[33] Local data indicates mental health and homelessness as rising community priorities, intersecting with demographics of renters and younger families.[35] Overall, causal factors like educational attainment drive cultural progressivism, yet high asset ownership enforces fiscal restraint, yielding hybrid influences resistant to uniform partisan loyalty.[33]