Hubbry Logo
HonestReportingHonestReportingMain
Open search
HonestReporting
Community hub
HonestReporting
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Contribute something
HonestReporting
HonestReporting
HonestReporting
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Key Information

HonestReporting or Honest Reporting is an Israeli media advocacy group.[1] A pro-Israel media watchdog,[2][3] it describes its mission as "combat[ting] ideological prejudice in journalism and the media, as it impacts Israel".[1]

History

[edit]

HonestReporting describes itself as "a charitable organisation" with a mission "to combat ideological prejudice in journalism and the media, as it impacts Israel".[1] It was founded in October 2000 by Shaul Rosenblatt, founder and head of Aish Hatorah-United Kingdom in response to controversy over the Tuvia Grossman photograph at the outbreak of the Second Intifada. The episode is often cited by those who accuse the media of having an anti-Israel bias, and was the impetus for the founding of HonestReporting.[4][5][6]

Within six weeks, HonestReporting had an email list of 10,000 volunteers to monitor the media and respond accordingly. Irwin Katsof offered to lead fundraising efforts to hire professional staff.[6] By 2003 the list had 150,000 subscribers and began raising funds for it to become an independent organization.[citation needed]

As of 2022, the Chief Executive Officer of HonestReporting was Jacki Alexander.[7] She previously worked at the American Israel Public Affairs Committee in Florida and has a master's degree in the History of International Relations from the London School of Economics and BA in History and Religious Studies.[citation needed] Gil Hoffman was appointed as the Executive Director of HonestReporting in 2022. He previously served as the chief political correspondent and analyst for the Jerusalem Post.[8]

In March 2006, a dedicated website by HonestReporting for covering the Media in the UK was launched by two expatriate Britons, CEO Joe Hyams, and Managing Editor Simon Plosker;[9] in 2011, the HR UK website was merged into the main site.[10]

HonestReporting Canada

[edit]

HonestReporting Canada (HRC) was founded as an independent group in 2003 to monitor Middle East news coverage in Canada. Journalist Jonathan Kay credited HRC with reducing perceived anti-Israel bias in the English-language media in Canada by 2011.[11][12] In 2012, a campaign by HRC led to a Canadian Broadcast Standards Council investigation after local politician Stéphane Gendron made controversial comments on the French-language V Television Network.[13]

In November 2024, Honest Reporting Canada's assistant director, Robert Walker, was criminally charged with 17 counts of mischief for allegedly vandalizing several properties in a Toronto neighborhood by spraypainting anti-Palestinian graffiti.[14] Walker had previously warned of the dangers of antisemitic graffiti, saying that "[a] small, only minimally irritating act of vandalism, if tolerated or overlooked, can quickly become a stepping stone to more antisemitic acts, and more dangerous ones, too".[15] According to the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Honest Reporting Canada has not commented on the arrest and continues to employ Walker.[15] The charges were withdrawn on March 5, 2025, in recognition of a $1000 charitable donation by Walker to the Sick Kids Foundation that "meets the ends of justice in all the factors that the Crown is required to consider" according to the prosecution.[16]

Activities

[edit]

HonestReporting reviews news articles and op-eds regarding Israel to check for and respond to any bias or fake news.[17][18] HonestReporting is not a news organization, and therefore does not seek to follow journalistic ethics and standards.[19]

HonestReporting's actions have resulted in a number of corrections in the media including:

  • Idris Muktar Ibrahim, a producer at CNN, was found to have written on Twitter praise for Hamas and in a separate tweet posted "#TeamHitler."[20] After HonestReporting contacted CNN about the producer's ability to report impartially, CNN ended their working relationship with him.[21] He later apologized.[22]
  • In 2012, HonestReporting filed a complaint with the Press Complaints Commission (PCC) in the UK after The Guardian ran a correction apologizing for having called Jerusalem Israel's capital, contrary to the paper's style guide. HonestReporting acted to initiate a judicial review after the PCC initially ruled that The Guardian had not breached the PCC code, saying that the ruling had "potential to further delegitimize Jerusalem's status as Israel's capital." The PCC retracted its original ruling and asked the paper to defend its position. The Guardian, then modified its style guide so that it no longer categorically states that Tel Aviv is the capital of Israel rather than Jerusalem.[23]
  • Award-winning journalist Shatha Hammad was discovered to have posted on Facebook that she referred to Adolf Hitler as her "friend"[24] and that they "share the same ideology, such as the extermination of the Jews"[25] Hammad made other posts using the nickname "Hitler" and denying Israel's right to exist.[26] She also termed terrorists who murdered Israeli worshippers in the 2014 Jerusalem synagogue attack as "martyrs." After HonestReporting's exposure of her posts, the Thomson Reuters Foundation and the Kurt Schork Memorial Fund withdrew the awards they had granted her.[27]
  • News producer Fady Hanona was discovered to have posted Anti-semitic social media posts by HonestReporting,[28][29] leading news outlets he previously worked for such as The New York Times, The Guardian, and others to cut ties with him.[30]

Reception

[edit]

The American Journalism Review described the organisation as a "pro-Israeli pressure group".[31]

After being criticized by HonestReporting for articles published by The Independent, author Robert Fisk wrote in the Independent that some of their readers sent him hate-mail.[32]

Following a 2004 article published in the British Medical Journal which criticised Israel for a high level of Palestinian civilian casualties and claimed that the pattern of injuries suggested routine targeting of children in situations of minimal or no threat, the journal received over 500 responses to its website and nearly 1,000 sent directly to its editor. In an analysis of the responses published in the journal, Karl Sabbagh concluded that the correspondence was orchestrated by Honest Reporting and aimed at silencing legitimate criticism of Israel. In his analysis, Sabbagh pointed to evidence that the correspondents had not read the article. Sabbagh also documented a significant proportion of offensive, abusive and racist insults among the correspondence. An editorial by the BMJ referred to the campaign as bullying and said that the best way to counter such behaviour was to expose it to public scrutiny.[33][34] Daniel Finkelstein, associate editor of The Times, responded that Sabbagh's piece was "anti-Israel propaganda" that did not meet even "basic academic standards" of scientific analysis.[35]

During the Gaza war, HonestReporting said that the journalists who had photographed the October 7 attacks were "part of the plan" and involved in "coordination with the terrorists"; later, the group's executive director said he had no evidence for the allegation. The report led two Israeli politicians to threaten that these journalists be killed,[36] while the Israeli Prime Minister's office said the journalists were "accomplices in crimes against humanity".[37] The Associated Press, Reuters, The New York Times and CNN strongly refuted allegations that they had prior knowledge of the Hamas attack. Yousef Masoud, whose photos were published in the NYT and AP, started photographing 90 minutes after the attack started. Reuters said that its pictures, taken by two freelance photojournalists, were taken two hours after the attack began. Additional criticism also came from the Committee to Protect Journalists. The AP and CNN announced that they would stop working with one of the freelance photographers, after HonestReporting showed a picture of him being kissed by Hamas leader Yehia Sinwar.[38][39][37] Reuters described the allegations from HonestReporting as "irresponsible" and "baseless speculation" that resulted in threats towards journalists. HonestReporting stated that they "stated nothing firmly" and are not responsible for the consequences of "asking questions."[19] In a February 2024 letter to the Office of the Consulate General of Israel in New York, The New York Times demanded that Israel cease circulating the allegations, stating that "Honest Reporting has once again been trafficking in falsehoods about Mr. Masoud".[40]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

HonestReporting

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
HonestReporting is a non-profit media watchdog organization founded in 2000 in response to biased coverage of the Second , dedicated to monitoring and challenging anti- distortions, inaccuracies, and ideological prejudices in international journalism. Operating as a 501(c)(3) entity with headquarters in New York, it scrutinizes news articles, opinion pieces, images, and broadcasts concerning , the , and Jewish communities, disseminating daily alerts through its IsraBite newsletter and platforms to subscribers worldwide. The group's core activities include documenting media lapses, naming accountable journalists and outlets, and coordinating campaigns that have secured retractions, apologies, and policy changes, such as prompting anchor to retract an offensive remark and leading to parliamentary inquiries into potential Hamas-linked financial dealings. A landmark achievement came in late 2023, when investigations revealed Gaza-based freelance photojournalists employed by Western agencies who glorified or anticipated the attacks, resulting in AP, , and suspending their work with implicated individuals. HonestReporting also conducts educational initiatives, including virtual webinars, resources, and missions to since 2004, aiming to foster public understanding and journalistic accountability amid declining global trust in media. Critics, primarily from outlets and advocates aligned with Palestinian narratives, have accused it of partisanship and endangering reporters by highlighting their alleged affiliations, though these objections have not deterred its exposés of systematically skewed sourcing in conflict reporting.

History

Founding and Early Years

HonestReporting was founded in October 2000 by Rabbi Shaul Rosenblatt, the CEO of UK, amid the escalation of violence during the Second Intifada, which began on September 28, 2000. The initiative emerged from frustration with international media portrayals that Rosenblatt viewed as systematically biased against , particularly in the context of ideological prejudice influencing journalistic reporting on the conflict. A pivotal incident was the Associated Press photograph published on September 30, 2000, by The New York Times and other outlets, depicting Tuvia Grossman—a Jewish American student savagely beaten by a Palestinian mob in Jerusalem—misidentified in captions as a Palestinian victim of Israeli police brutality. This error, corrected only after intervention by Grossman's father, highlighted for Rosenblatt the need for organized scrutiny of media accuracy and fairness in Israel-related coverage. The organization launched as a modest alert service, distributing bulletins to subscribers identifying instances of anti-Israel distortion, omission, or factual inaccuracy in global press reports, and urging recipients to contact news organizations directly for accountability. Early efforts focused on high-profile cases, such as challenging over the Grossman image, which demonstrated the potential of collective to elicit retractions and editorial responses. Within months, subscriber numbers surged to tens of thousands, enabling campaigns that influenced outlets like to engage in high-level discussions on coverage standards. By early 2001, HonestReporting had formalized as a U.S. nonprofit under the name Middle East Media Watch, Inc., later rebranding to its current form, while maintaining its core model of rapid-response monitoring without reliance on emerging social media platforms. This period marked the establishment of its grassroots methodology, prioritizing empirical verification of claims over narrative alignment, and setting the stage for broader advocacy against perceived institutional biases in journalism.

Expansion and Key Milestones

Following its establishment as an email alert service in 2000, HonestReporting rapidly expanded its subscriber base to tens of thousands within months, evolving from a initiative into a structured with dedicated teams in the United States and to enable round-the-clock operations. The reached a peak of nearly 50,000 subscribers and began providing media briefings to U.S. newsrooms, including during Ariel Sharon's 2001 election victory, positioning itself as a resource for journalists covering Israel-related events. By 2003, HonestReporting established an affiliate in , HonestReporting Canada, building on origins tied to U.K.-based efforts from 2000 to monitor and respond to regional media coverage. In 2004, it launched educational missions to , which continued annually and expanded to include virtual formats during the period, hosting participants from multiple countries. Further international growth occurred in 2017 with the initiation of dedicated operations in and , enhancing its capacity to address in those regions. On August 26, 2018, HonestReporting opened its international headquarters in downtown , equipped with video production facilities and increased internship capacity, attended by staff, donors, and local officials including Jerusalem Deputy Mayor . In 2022, the organization underwent significant leadership restructuring to support broader impact, appointing Jacki Alexander as Global CEO in September, Gil Hoffman as Executive Director and Executive Editor in July, and Simon Plosker as Editorial Director; this coincided with a 534% increase in social media reach, including 78 viral posts garnering hundreds of thousands of views. By 2025, marking its 25th anniversary, HonestReporting had solidified as a global media watchdog with nonprofit status in the United States (incorporated 2001), Israel, and Canada, emphasizing expanded digital advocacy and education.

Affiliates and International Reach

HonestReporting established its international headquarters in on August 26, 2018, marking a significant expansion from its initial U.S.-based operations to enhance global monitoring and advocacy efforts. This move centralized international activities in downtown , facilitating closer coordination with on-the-ground developments in while supporting outreach to worldwide media outlets. The organization maintains primary offices in New York, New York, for U.S. operations and inquiries, and , Israel, for its core international functions, as indicated by dedicated phone lines: (888) 748-7425 for the U.S. and +972 (2) 652-9558 for . These locations enable HonestReporting to address media coverage across multiple languages and regions, with staff, contributors, and supporters distributed internationally to amplify its influence. While primarily focused on English-language media in the United States and other English-speaking , HonestReporting extends its reach through monitoring of global outlets and limited affiliates specialized in foreign-language media. It engages with news organizations in numerous , leveraging online platforms and —where its reach has grown exponentially since 2022—to challenge biases beyond and . Organizations bearing similar names, such as HonestReporting (founded independently in 2003), operate separately without formal affiliation.

Mission and Organizational Structure

Core Objectives and Principles

HonestReporting's primary mission is to ensure truth, integrity, and fairness in while combating ideological in media coverage, particularly as it pertains to and its impacts on public discourse. This objective stems from the organization's view that biased reporting undermines democratic processes by distorting facts and fostering misinformation about the and Jewish communities. Core objectives include systematically monitoring global media outlets for inaccuracies, omissions, or skewed narratives in stories involving , the broader , and related topics; analyzing such coverage to identify patterns of ; and exposing these issues through detailed reports and alerts to prompt . The group also educates the public on evaluating news reliability via resources like webinars, news literacy materials, and guided missions to , aiming to empower individuals to discern fair reporting from prejudiced content. Additionally, HonestReporting facilitates advocacy by providing subscribers with tools to contact journalists and editors directly, seeking or retractions where standards are breached. Guiding principles emphasize a commitment to , defined by the organization as adherence to verifiable facts over ideological narratives, while holding individual reporters and outlets accountable rather than broadly condemning "." HonestReporting promotes balanced context in coverage, countering what it describes as , human errors, and underlying biases that lead to incomplete or misleading stories. These principles are operationalized through daily updates, such as the IsraBite News digest, and an active strategy to highlight discrepancies between reported events and on-the-ground realities. The organization maintains that fostering media integrity ultimately supports a well-informed citizenry essential for healthy democracies.

Governance, Funding, and Operations

HonestReporting functions as a 501(c)(3) registered in the United States with EIN 06-1611859, enabling it to receive tax-deductible contributions. Its governance comprises separate structures for its U.S. and Israeli entities: the U.S. board, led by President , Secretary Max Blankfeld, and Treasurer David Barish, includes additional members Salo Aizenberg, Martha Barvin, Sarah Biser, Morris Mintz, and Aaron Spool. In , the Amuta (registered nonprofit association) is chaired by , with board members including Jacki Alexander and Ilene Nechamkin, alongside associates such as Bentzi Binder, , Sheara Einhorn, former Ambassador Yoram Ettinger, Jerry Glazer, Reuven Harow, Gil Hoffman, Gershon Lewis, and Simon Plosker. Executive leadership includes Jacki Alexander, appointed in September 2022 after serving in operations roles at ; Executive Director Gil Hoffman, appointed in May 2022 with prior experience as a political correspondent for ; and Editorial Director Simon Plosker. These roles oversee strategic direction, with an executive committee handling key decisions as indicated in IRS filings. Funding relies predominantly on private donations from individuals and supporters, without disclosed reliance on government grants or corporate sponsorships. The organization solicits contributions via its website, phone, and mail, directing U.S. checks to a New York post office box and U.K. checks to a separate address, emphasizing donor support for media accountability efforts. Operations center on a global network with primary hubs in New York City (corporate office at 165 East 56th Street) and Jerusalem (international headquarters opened August 2018), supplemented by support in Canada and the U.K.. A staff of approximately 20, including directors for operations (Maya Levy-David), finance (Jerry Glazer), and special funding campaigns (Lewis Gershon), handles daily functions such as content production and donor relations; recent expansions added senior editors, social media strategists, and development directors in 2023 to enhance monitoring and outreach capabilities. Activities emphasize rapid response to media coverage, with 2023 operations yielding 122.8 million social media impressions and over 100 corrections secured.

Methods and Activities

Media Monitoring Processes

HonestReporting maintains a continuous monitoring operation focused on international media coverage of and related conflicts, scrutinizing print, broadcast, and digital outlets for instances of , factual inaccuracies, and deviations from journalistic standards such as fairness and contextual accuracy. Staff analysts review articles, pieces, images, and broadcasts daily, producing summaries like the "IsraBite News" roundup to highlight key developments and potential distortions. This process incorporates input from subscribers who patrol local and global media, submitting alerts on suspected , which staff then verify through against primary sources, including official statements and on-the-ground reporting. Central to their methodology is the Falsehood Identification & Breakdown (FIB) framework, introduced in 2025, which categorizes five primary narrative distortions: delegitimizing 's sovereignty (e.g., denying Jewish historical ties to the land), justifying or legitimizing violence against (e.g., framing as "resistance"), denying or minimizing such violence (e.g., underreporting the scale of attacks like those on , 2023), deflecting blame onto for adversaries' actions, and fabricating or distorting facts (e.g., uncritically adopting unverified casualty figures from groups like ). FIB is paired with mechanisms analyzing how manifests, such as through selective omission or loaded , and integrates tools like the BiasBreaker AI for pattern detection and efficiency in tracking across platforms. This system builds on an earlier model of eight categories of , encompassing misleading , imbalanced reporting, opinions disguised as news, distortion of facts, true facts leading to false conclusions, lack of transparency, and related violations, as outlined in their 2016 . For in-depth research, HonestReporting employs professional media intelligence tracking software to quantify coverage patterns, such as comparative analyses of hate crime reporting, cross-referencing with databases like FBI statistics to identify disparities in emphasis or sourcing. Monitoring prioritizes high-impact outlets, including major Western broadcasters and newspapers, with a focus on real-time response to breaking events to counter narratives that could influence or . The organization's Jerusalem-based , supplemented by global affiliates, ensures coverage spans English-language and select international media, emphasizing empirical verification over ideological alignment in assessments.

Response and Advocacy Tactics

HonestReporting's response tactics center on rapid identification and public dissection of media inaccuracies or biases related to . The organization conducts daily monitoring of international news outlets, scanning articles, broadcasts, and for distortions, omissions, or falsehoods. Upon verification, staff apply analytical frameworks like the Falsehood Identification & Breakdown (FIB), which categorizes errors into types such as fabrication, inversion, or contextual omission, supported by evidence from primary sources including , official records, or eyewitness accounts. These analyses form the basis of published exposés on HonestReporting's , where detailed critiques name specific journalists, editors, or outlets and demand through , retractions, or personnel reviews. For instance, in response to coverage perceived as whitewashing terrorist activities, the group has highlighted journalists' prior social media posts or affiliations, urging media employers to investigate potential conflicts of interest. Such outputs aim to counter narratives by presenting verifiable counter-evidence, often drawn from Israeli Defense Forces statements or independent verifications, rather than unsubstantiated assertions. Advocacy extends through action alerts distributed to subscribers, typically numbering two to eight daily, which outline the issue and provide scripted messages or contact details for media personnel. Supporters are mobilized to engage outlets via emails, phone calls, or campaigns, applying pressure to enforce journalistic standards. This tactic has been employed in high-profile cases, such as post-October 7, 2023, efforts targeting reports on Gaza operations, where alerts encouraged demands for balanced sourcing and rejection of unverified claims from Hamas-linked entities. Beyond reactive measures, HonestReporting promotes proactive advocacy via media literacy resources and training, including webinars on recognizing categories like misleading terminology or selective framing. These initiatives equip journalists and the public with tools to challenge ideological , emphasizing empirical over narrative conformity, though critics from pro-Palestinian outlets have characterized such efforts as attempts to influence .

Research and Reporting Outputs

HonestReporting generates research outputs primarily in the form of analytical articles, frameworks, and periodic reports that dissect media coverage for inaccuracies, omissions, and biases related to . These publications emphasize empirical patterns in reporting, such as disproportionate sourcing from adversarial entities like or selective framing of casualties, drawing on of major outlets including , , , and . A central tool in their reporting is the Falsehood Identification & Breakdown (FIB) framework, launched on July 20, 2025, which classifies distortions into five categories: delegitimizing 's sovereignty, justifying or legitimizing violence against or , denying such violence, deflecting blame onto , and fabricating or distorting facts including atrocity propaganda. HonestReporting applies FIB to specific stories, such as debunking claims of Israeli "colonialism" or denialism around , 2023, events, often integrating AI-assisted detection via their BiasBreaker tool to highlight narrative mechanisms in real-time. Data-centric outputs include reviews of external and internal analyses, as in the July 23, 2025, article "Behind the Headlines," which cited a February-May 2024 Fifty Global Research Group study of 170+ articles finding 85% failed to note casualty figures from the Gaza Ministry of Health likely include terrorists, with only 3% estimating terrorist deaths and near-total reliance on unverified data across outlets like and AP. Another referenced study by Gilboa and Sigan, covering October 2023-April 2024 New York Times articles, revealed 46% expressed empathy for versus 10% for , with opinion pieces criticizing outnumbering those on by over 3:1. HonestReporting also disseminates categorical guides, such as the December 10, 2023, outline of eight types—misleading terminology, imbalanced reporting, opinions as news, lack of , selective omission, true facts out of , visual , and distortion of reality—to equip readers and journalists in spotting prejudice. Quarterly and annual activity reports quantify outputs, with the 2023 End-of-Year Report (January 16, 2024) detailing critiques issued, corrections obtained, and exposure of journalist affiliations with groups like , while the 2024 End-of-Year Report (June 26, 2025) tracked post-October 7, 2023, monitoring spikes. These reports serve as accountability records, often including metrics on advocacy reach and media responses.

Notable Campaigns and Exposés

Pre-2023 Initiatives

HonestReporting originated from a 2000 incident involving a widely circulated photograph depicting an injured individual, later identified as Jewish American student Tuvia Grossman, being assaulted by a Palestinian mob in during the early stages of the Second Intifada; the image was initially captioned by as showing a Palestinian victim, prompting the nascent group's first organized subscriber campaign to demand corrections from media outlets. This effort, launched as a small alert list in October 2000 by co-founders including Shraga Simmons, mobilized public complaints that pressured to issue a correction on October 5, 2000, acknowledging the misidentification and clarifying Grossman's identity as an i. The campaign highlighted perceived systemic errors in visual journalism during conflict reporting, establishing HonestReporting's model of grassroots advocacy through subscriber alerts to flag inaccuracies and bias in coverage of . By 2003, formalized as a nonprofit, HonestReporting expanded its operations to include systematic media monitoring, focusing on distortions in reporting from major outlets during the ongoing and subsequent events; this included critiques of outlets like the for unbalanced portrayals of Israeli security operations. A pivotal pre-2023 exposé occurred in August 2006 amid the Second Lebanon War, when HonestReporting identified digital manipulations in photographs submitted by Reuters freelancer Adnan Hajj, including a image where smoke plumes were cloned and intensified to exaggerate damage from Israeli airstrikes. subsequently withdrew the altered photo, retracted 920 images by Hajj, terminated his contract, and implemented stricter photo-editing protocols, admitting the manipulations violated its standards; the incident, amplified by bloggers and HonestReporting alerts, underscored vulnerabilities in wire service verification processes during wartime. Throughout the 2000s and 2010s, HonestReporting's initiatives emphasized rapid-response campaigns against perceived anti-Israel narratives, such as challenging the BBC's 2009 documentary Gaza: What Really Happened? for selective editing that minimized Hamas rocket fire while amplifying civilian hardship claims, leading to viewer complaints and internal BBC reviews. These efforts also extended to educational missions to Israel starting in 2004, where participants received briefings from officials and journalists to contextualize media narratives on the ground, aiming to counter remote reporting biases. By aggregating subscriber actions, the organization claimed responsibility for prompting over 5,000 media corrections globally by the early 2010s, though independent verification of each instance varies; such pre-2023 activities laid the groundwork for data-driven bias analyses, prioritizing factual rebuttals over opinion.

Post-October 7, 2023 Efforts

Following the Hamas-led attack on on October 7, 2023, which killed approximately 1,200 people and saw over 250 taken hostage, HonestReporting intensified its media monitoring, publishing over 400 critiques in 2023 alone focused on coverage of the ensuing war. The organization prioritized exposés on journalists' ethical breaches and ties to militants, alongside data-driven reports quantifying imbalances in reporting. A key early campaign, launched in November 2023 under the banner "Broken Borders" or "Photographers Without Borders," scrutinized how Gaza-based photojournalists affiliated with Western agencies gained unprecedented access to the attack sites hours after the incursion began. This investigation highlighted individuals like Hassan Eslaiah, whose images of gunmen were distributed by the (AP) and , leading both outlets to cut ties with him amid questions over prior coordination. Similar scrutiny targeted contributor Mohammed Fayq Abu Mostafa, exposed for publicly urging Gazans to breach the border on via , and AP freelancer Issam Adwan, identified as a operative; these revelations prompted reassignments and terminations. HonestReporting's submissions influenced ' Pulitzer Prize entry review process and inspired legal actions, including a against AP alleging material support for through such affiliations. The group extended its efforts to CNN's Abdel Qader Sabbah, revealing his praise for a terrorist who killed 37 and other sympathetic actions, resulting in his reassignment from frontline duties. In August 2025, further reporting identified a Gaza journalist who won a Pulitzer as a confirmed terrorist, critiquing ' dismissal of the evidence despite Sinwar's involvement in the planning. These exposés extended to agencies like (AFP), whose staff crossed into with , yet later sought protections for freelancers amid ongoing risks. Complementing investigative work, HonestReporting commissioned quantitative analyses of war coverage. A July 2025 report by Fifty Global Research Group examined 2024 articles on Gazan casualties from eight outlets (, , New York Times, Washington Post, , AP, Guardian, ABC Australia), finding 100% reliance on Ministry of Health figures without balancing Israeli data, 85% omission that these included terrorists, and 50% skepticism toward Israel's estimates versus under 2% for '. A parallel review of 1,398 New York Times articles showed 46% expressing empathy for versus 10% for , with 72 op-eds critical of compared to 23 of . HonestReporting also campaigned against media's unverified use of casualty data, arguing in May 2025 that it perpetuates inflated civilian tolls ignoring militant embeddings in civilian sites, as evidenced by IDF footage and a report on systematic distortions. The organization urged disclaimers in reporting and contacted outlets like and , while linking skewed coverage to post-October 7 spikes through correlative studies of media negativity and incident surges. These efforts amplified via , boosting impressions from 3.5 million pre-attack to 56 million in October 2023 alone. Annual "Dishonest Reporter" awards continued, spotlighting patterns in outlets like for imbalanced war narratives.

Impact and Achievements

Corrections and Retractions Secured

HonestReporting has secured hundreds of corrections, retractions, and apologies from international media outlets for inaccuracies in coverage of and related conflicts. The organization's efforts have targeted factual errors, such as misattributing events, omitting key context, or relying on unverified sources, often prompting outlets to amend articles, issue on-air clarifications, or reassign personnel. In its 2023 annual report, HonestReporting documented over 100 significant corrections achieved that year amid heightened scrutiny following the attacks. A prominent example occurred on , 2023, when anchor publicly apologized on air for characterizing the stabbing deaths of Lucy Dee and her two daughters by Palestinian terrorists as a "shootout" between the victims and attackers, a framing exposed by HonestReporting as minimizing the terrorist nature of the incident. The apology followed a campaign that garnered over 1.5 million views on . Similarly, removed a from its website falsely depicting Israeli women as unable to without guardians, after HonestReporting highlighted the claim's lack of basis in . In August 2023, HonestReporting prompted ABC News Australia to issue a formal acknowledgment of error in a headline about a Tel Aviv terror attack, where the piece failed to identify the Palestinian perpetrator or Israeli victims, violating basic journalistic standards on attribution. That same month, IOL corrected a report misstating Tel Aviv as Israel's capital, while other outlets including BBC News, CBS News, UPI, SABC News, and The New York Times issued amendments for comparable lapses in accuracy. Earlier successes include 20 major corrections in November 2017 from entities such as , the , , and the , addressing distortions in terminology and event descriptions related to . HonestReporting Canada, an affiliated entity, secured an on-air correction from CTV on October 18, 2022, after the network erroneously reported killed 49 Palestinian civilians in an incident later clarified as targeting militants. In 2016, the group obtained retractions from newspapers and the Daily Mail's online edition for unsubstantiated claims.
OutletDateCorrection Details
CNN (Christiane Amanpour)April 20, 2023On-air apology for framing terrorist stabbing of Dee family as "shootout"
ABC News AustraliaAugust 2023Acknowledgment of error in terror attack headline omitting perpetrator/victim identities
The Guardian2023Removal of misleading map on women's rights in Israel
IOLAugust 2023Correction identifying Tel Aviv, not Jerusalem, as Israel's capital in report
CTV (via HonestReporting Canada)October 18, 2022On-air clarification that incident involved militants, not 49 civilians
These interventions have extended to retractions of contributor credibility, such as the reassigning Gaza correspondent Issam Adwan and both AP and severing ties with photojournalist Hassan Eslaiah after exposures of their problematic social media activity glorifying violence or . similarly discontinued use of freelancer Soliman Hijjy following revelations of his pro-Hitler posts. Such outcomes underscore HonestReporting's role in enforcing , though critics argue the pressure can influence .

Influence on Media Standards

HonestReporting's systematic exposures of journalistic lapses have compelled major wire services and news outlets to tighten vetting protocols for freelancers and stringers in high-conflict areas. In November 2023, following revelations that Gaza-based photojournalists employed by the (AP), , , and others appeared to have advance access or sympathies aligned with during the —including posting celebratory content or images with terrorist leaders—AP and severed ties with freelancer Hassan Eslaiah, while also discontinued use of Abdel Qader Sabbah due to documented affiliations. and AFP responded by reassigning or releasing at least six implicated personnel after HonestReporting highlighted antisemitic posts or terror connections, demonstrating a direct causal link between advocacy and operational adjustments to mitigate perceived impartiality risks. These interventions have elevated industry-wide awareness of the need for proactive scrutiny of contributors' digital footprints and affiliations, influencing even award processes; reportedly shared HonestReporting's findings during its Pulitzer review deliberations. Additionally, targeted critiques prompted terminological refinements, such as AP's shift from labeling operatives as "activists" to "fighters" in reporting, addressing distortions that conflate militants with civilians. Such changes reflect a broader recalibration in standards, where outlets now anticipate and respond to evidence-based challenges to sourcing integrity, reducing reliance on unverified inputs from adversarial entities like -controlled Gaza media. While mainstream critiques from left-leaning outlets often frame these outcomes as coercive, the verifiable patterns of bias—such as freelancers' pre-attack positioning and sharing—underscore the empirical basis for heightened standards, fostering causal accountability in coverage of asymmetric conflicts where one side systematically manipulates narratives. This has arguably diminished unchecked propagation of inflated casualty figures or uncontextualized accusations against , as media entities incorporate more rigorous cross-verification to align with factual realism over ideological priors.

Data-Driven Findings on Bias

HonestReporting has referenced and analyzed quantitative studies revealing patterns in media sourcing and framing that favor Palestinian narratives over Israeli ones in coverage of the -Hamas conflict. A 2024 study by the Fifty Global Research Group, examined by HonestReporting, reviewed articles mentioning Gazan casualties in eight major English-language outlets—including , , , , , , , and ABC Australia—from February to May 2024. It found that 100% of such articles incorporated casualty figures from the Hamas-run Gaza Ministry of Health, while only 4% included estimates provided by ; moreover, 85% failed to disclose that these figures encompass terrorists, with just 15% clarifying this point and only 3% offering terrorist casualty approximations. Outlets like and noted the lack of separation between civilians and combatants in 40% of cases, but , , and did so in fewer than 5%; conversely, 50% of articles treated Israeli casualty figures as "unverifiable," compared to under 2% questioning Hamas data. Another analysis cited by HonestReporting, conducted by researchers Gilboa and Sigan, focused on 1,398 articles from published in daily subscriber newsletters during the first seven months of the war (October 2023 to April 2024), out of 3,848 total Israel-Hamas-related pieces. This revealed that 46% of articles expressed empathy exclusively for , versus 10% for , resulting in coverage that was 4.4 times more sympathetic overall to ; in October 2023 alone, Palestinian sympathy was double that for . Among 50 articles on hostages, 56% blamed while 22% criticized , yet of 647 empathetic Palestinian-focused pieces, only 2 attributed responsibility to ; opinion pieces showed 72 critiquing compared to 23 on , a threefold disparity. Earlier, in a quantitative , HonestReporting compared Israel-related coverage in and media for June-July, amid unrest. outlets demonstrated higher negativity: The Guardian's articles were 68% negative, while saw negative pieces rise from 22 to 37; media, including (which quadrupled positive headlines) and (with a plurality neutral), exhibited fewer negative headlines in both raw numbers and percentages, indicating comparatively more balanced tones. These data points, drawn from content audits and sentiment scoring, illustrate HonestReporting's emphasis on empirical disparities in verification standards, source reliance, and emotional framing, which they contend distort public understanding by under-scrutinizing adversarial data from while amplifying unverified Palestinian casualty claims. A supplementary of New York Times post-October 7 reporting, also referenced, noted sparse detail on Israeli suffering alongside frequent personal Palestinian accounts and minimal references to violence by , , or . Such findings align with HonestReporting's broader monitoring, which tracks reliance on potentially manipulated statistics amid incentives for inflation by authorities.

Criticisms and Controversies

Accusations of Bias and Pressure

Critics, including media groups and journalists, have accused HonestReporting of exhibiting a pro-Israel in its monitoring and efforts, characterizing it as a partisan organization that selectively targets coverage critical of while overlooking alleged Israeli misconduct. For instance, outlets aligned with Palestinian perspectives, such as the Journal of Palestine Studies, have claimed that HonestReporting's campaigns against individual reporters—often based on their activity or past reporting—amount to efforts to Palestinian or pro-Palestinian voices, citing cases where freelancers were accused of anti-Israel for documenting conditions in Gaza or expressing empathy for civilians. Accusations of undue pressure tactics have centered on HonestReporting's campaigns urging media outlets to issue , retractions, or personnel changes, which detractors argue cross into or . In , multiple journalists interviewed by La Converse reported experiencing targeted complaints from HonestReporting Canada (HRC) to their editors, leading to internal investigations, content removals, or professional repercussions; one such case involved pressure to excise op-eds or guest segments deemed overly critical of Israeli policies. Similarly, , a site focused on Palestinian issues, has described HRC's activities since 2003 as a "silent war" on newsrooms, alleging coordinated efforts to enforce pro-Israel narratives through repeated submissions that escalate to public shaming on social media. Further criticisms highlight risks to journalists' safety, particularly in conflict zones. The Media Sustainability Support group contended in November 2023 that HonestReporting's unsubstantiated claims of affiliations between Palestinian reporters and —such as allegations against Al Jazeera staff—have been amplified by Israeli officials, effectively placing a "price on Palestinian journalists' heads" by justifying military actions against media workers. An Al Jazeera opinion piece echoed this, labeling a specific HonestReporting exposé as "irresponsible" for potentially endangering all media personnel in and the Palestinian territories by portraying routine reporting as complicity with terrorism. Canadian student media critics have also described these tactics as "coordinated " aimed at young or freelance journalists, urging resistance through reporting protocols.

Responses to Criticisms

HonestReporting maintains that accusations of inherent pro-Israel bias overlook its evidence-based methodology for identifying media distortions, emphasizing that its critiques rely on verifiable facts such as timestamped photographs, contradicted eyewitness accounts, and deviations from journalistic standards rather than ideological predisposition. In response to claims that it pressures outlets through campaigns, the organization asserts that public exposure of inaccuracies prompts necessary accountability, citing over 1,000 corrections secured since its founding in 2003 as proof of efficacy without fabricating evidence. Regarding specific controversies, such as the November 2023 exposé on Gaza-based photojournalists who published images from attack sites on before Israeli authorities confirmed access, HonestReporting defends its reporting by highlighting geotagged metadata showing freelancers from , AP, , and others at breach points hours ahead of public knowledge, arguing this raises legitimate ethical questions about prior coordination rather than mere insinuation. Critics from outlets like AP characterized the analysis as unsubstantiated, yet HonestReporting counters that subsequent actions—such as AP and severing ties with implicated stringers—validate the concerns, while media failures to investigate complicity undermine press integrity. The group addresses allegations of endangering Palestinian journalists by framing its work as defensive against that fuels anti- narratives, noting that systemic media reluctance to scrutinize sources embedded in Hamas-controlled areas perpetuates imbalance; for instance, its stated in 2024 that watchdog efforts have compelled outlets like and AFP to enhance professionalism amid cooperation with adversarial entities. HonestReporting further promotes tools like its Falsehood Identification & Breakdown (FIB) framework to empower readers in dissecting objectively, positioning itself as an educational counterweight to what it describes as prevalent ideological in coverage of . HonestReporting's advocacy methods have sparked ethical debates over the balance between media accountability and potential intimidation of journalists. Critics, particularly from Canadian media outlets and associations, argue that the organization's "Action Alerts"—which publicly name journalists, share their photos and affiliations, and mobilize subscribers to contact media employers—constitute organized harassment rather than constructive criticism. For instance, journalists interviewed by La Converse reported receiving dozens or even hourly denigrating emails following such alerts, with messages like "Shame on you" and demands for their dismissal, leading to claims of self-censorship and a chilling effect on coverage of Israel-Palestine issues. Similarly, student journalists at the University of Alberta's Gateway newspaper faced petitions accusing their outlet of "fawning coverage" of anti-Israel demonstrations without context, resulting in inbox flooding and reputational attacks described by critics as "coordinated defamation" and "bullying." Organizations like the Canadian Association of Journalists (CAJ) and Fédération professionnelle des journalistes du Québec (FPJQ) have condemned these tactics as unethical intimidation, with CAJ vice-president Brent Jolly stating, "It’s not democracy, it’s dictatorship." Proponents of HonestReporting counter that such campaigns are ethical exercises in public advocacy, aimed at enforcing journalistic standards against factual inaccuracies and in reporting on , rather than suppressing . The organization maintains that highlighting specific errors—such as unverified claims or lack of transparency—through subscriber engagement promotes accountability, akin to reader feedback mechanisms used by media outlets. Ethical concerns are amplified in cases targeting junior or freelance reporters, where critics claim disproportionate pressure exploits power imbalances, yet HonestReporting frames its work as defending truth against what it identifies as systemic anti- distortions, without endorsing threats or . A 2021 Ipsos survey cited in critiques noted 31% of Canadian journalists reducing -related coverage due to online hate, though this encompasses broader harassment beyond HonestReporting's alerts. Legally, HonestReporting has faced no successful defamation lawsuits, reflecting the high bar for such claims under free speech protections in jurisdictions like the , , and , where advocacy groups enjoy broad latitude to criticize media. The organization itself has explained that suing s for bias is impractical due to requirements for proving , strong First Amendment (or equivalent) safeguards, and courts' reluctance to penalize opinion or fair comment on public matters. In , where much criticism centers on its affiliate HonestReporting , groups filed a complaint with the on October 11, 2024, questioning the affiliate's charitable status for allegedly engaging in political advocacy, but this administrative challenge has not resulted in legal penalties or revocation as of October 2025. Debates persist over whether mass mobilization crosses into or creates liability for subscriber actions, though no precedents exist against HonestReporting, underscoring tensions between protected expression and reputational harm in digital-age advocacy.

References

  1. https://honestreporting.com/
  2. https://honestreporting.com/what-is-honestreporting/
  3. https://honestreporting.com/about/
  4. https://honestreporting.com/honestreporting-recap-our-top-10-most-popular-content-of-2022/
  5. https://honestreporting.com/landing_pages/2022-first-quarter-activities-report/
  6. https://honestreporting.com/gaza-photojournalists-media-fail-to-address-their-own-ethics-and-morals/
  7. https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/israeli-advocacy-group-accepts-news-outlets-had-no-prior-warning-hamas-attack-2023-11-10/
  8. https://www.mediasupport.org/blogpost/how-an-israeli-media-watchdogs-unsubstantiated-allegations-has-put-a-price-on-palestinian-journalists-heads/
  9. https://about.aish.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/Aish_AR2024-v15-EDITED-DIGITAL-PAGES-FINAL.pdf
  10. https://techinquiry.org/?entity=honestreporting%252Ecom%252C%2520inc%252E&guard=
  11. https://honestreporting.com/the-photo-that-started-it-all/
  12. https://honestreporting.com/honestreporting-25-years-on-from-a-spark-to-a-flame/
  13. https://www.readthemaple.com/meet-the-billionaire-funded-pro-israel-group-influencing-media/
  14. https://honestreporting.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/2017-Q1-Report.pdf
  15. https://honestreporting.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/2018-Q4-Report-Web-NB.pdf
  16. https://honestreporting.com/landing_pages/2022-end-of-year-annual-report/
  17. https://honestreporting.com/honestreportings-new-jerusalem-international-hq-opens-for-business/
  18. https://honestreporting.com/coffee-bean-roasted-over-jerusalem-west-bank/
  19. https://honestreporting.com/contact-us/
  20. https://www.highperformr.ai/company/honestreporting
  21. https://jcpa.org/article/watching-the-pro-israeli-media-watchers/
  22. https://honestreporting.com/impact-report-honestreporting-social-media-reach-going-through-the-roof/
  23. https://honestreporting.com/the-journalism-org-thats-out-to-wreck-honestreporting/
  24. https://honestreporting.com/governance-and-finance/
  25. https://honestreporting.com/honestreporting-announces-appointment-of-jacki-alexander-as-new-global-ceo/
  26. https://honestreporting.com/honestreporting-announces-appointment-of-gil-hoffman-as-new-executive-director/
  27. https://honestreporting.com/landing_pages/2023-end-of-year-annual-report/
  28. https://honestreporting.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Form-990-Public-1.pdf
  29. https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/honest-reporting/
  30. https://honestreporting.com/other-ways/
  31. https://www.zoominfo.com/pic/honestreporting/76220162
  32. https://www.zoominfo.com/c/honestreporting/76220162
  33. https://honestreporting.com/reader-alerts/
  34. https://honestreporting.com/fib-falsehood-identification-breakdown-framework/
  35. https://honestreporting.com/red-lines/
  36. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLLuF-lEHTGTwQ_sLoa-NBS9sF_--Q4U8U
  37. https://honestreporting.com/honestreporting-research-study-comparing-us-media-coverage-of-hate-crimes-against-minorities-including-jews/
  38. https://quillette.com/2025/10/12/the-media-war-on-israel-gil-hoffman/
  39. https://honestreporting.com/take_action_center/call-out-complicity/
  40. https://honestreporting.com/how-hamas-manipulates-the-media-and-controls-the-narrative-about-its-war-with-israel/
  41. https://www.njspj.org/how-to-avoid-bias-in-your-middle-east-reporting-honestreporting-com-webinar-3-p-m-edt-september-22/
  42. https://mondoweiss.net/2025/08/how-honestreporting-canada-wages-a-silent-war-on-canadian-newsrooms/
  43. https://honestreporting.com/behind-the-headlines-the-data-that-exposes-medias-anti-israel-media-bias/
  44. https://honestreporting.com/media-critiques/
  45. https://honestreporting.com/the-eight-categories-of-media-bias/
  46. https://honestreporting.com/activity-reports/
  47. https://honestreporting.com/25-years-planting-the-seeds-of-honestreporting/
  48. https://honestreporting.com/bold-distortions-and-outright-lies-2/
  49. https://www.reuters.com/article/economy/reuters-toughens-rules-after-altered-photo-affair-idUSL18678707/
  50. https://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/5254838.stm
  51. https://honestreporting.com/honestreporting-recap-our-top-10-most-popular-content-of-2023/
  52. https://honestreporting.com/making-an-impact-a-year-on-from-october-7/
  53. https://honestreporting.com/photographers-without-borders-ap-reuters-pictures-of-hamas-atrocities-raise-ethical-questions/
  54. https://honestreporting.com/gaza-journalist-identified-as-hamas-terrorist-won-a-pulitzer-reuters-cant-see-the-problem/
  55. https://honestreporting.com/afp-whose-staff-crossed-into-israel-with-hamas-now-begs-israel-to-protect-its-freelancers/
  56. https://honestreporting.com/media-must-stop-relying-on-hamas-provided-casualty-figures/
  57. https://honestreporting.com/did-media-coverage-of-the-israel-hamas-war-influence-the-rise-in-post-october-7-antisemitism/
  58. https://honestreporting.com/2024-dishonest-reporter-of-the-year-awards/
  59. https://honestreporting.com/honestreporting-in-the-media-cnns-amanpour-apologizes/
  60. https://honestreporting.com/honestreportings-top-media-corrections-august-2023/
  61. https://honestreporting.com/abc-news-australia-issues-mea-culpa-over-appalling-tel-aviv-terror-attack-piece/
  62. https://honestreporting.com/tag/corrections/
  63. https://honestreporting.com/hr-corrections-november-2017/
  64. https://honestreporting.ca/hrc-prompts-ctv-on-air-correction-after-network-falsely-claimed-israel-killed-49-palestinian-civilians-2/
  65. https://honestreporting.com/more-corrections-secured-by-honestreporting/
  66. https://honestreporting.com/the-antisemitic-social-media-history-of-aps-correspondent-in-gaza/
  67. https://honestreporting.com/broken-borders-media-showcase-oct-7-pictures-by-gaza-photojournalists-as-images-of-the-year/
  68. https://www.washingtonpost.com/style/media/2023/11/09/cnn-ap-photographer-hamas/
  69. https://www.jpost.com/opinion/article-824076
  70. https://honestreporting.com/journalists-with-hamas-ties-a-running-list-of-honestreportings-top-exposures-since-oct-7/
  71. https://honestreporting.com/impact-honestreportings-work-garnering-global-media-attention-translating-into-political-action/
  72. https://honestreporting.com/wire-services-face-fallout-over-exposure-of-gaza-photojournalists-oct-7-actions/
  73. https://fifty.global/
  74. https://www.jpost.com/israel-hamas-war/article-801593
  75. https://honestreporting.com/bias-by-the-numbers-june-july-2017/
  76. https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1653985
  77. https://www.laconverse.com/en/articles/enquete---des-journalistes-denoncent-les-pressions-du-groupe-pro-israelien-honest-reporting-canada
  78. https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2023/11/22/watching-the-watchdogs-americas-reckoning-with-israeli-media-manipulation
  79. https://thegatewayonline.ca/2025/10/how-honestreporting-targets-young-journalists/
  80. https://www.ap.org/media-center/ap-in-the-news/2023/media-watchdog-says-it-was-just-raising-questions-with-insinuations-about-photographers-and-hamas/
  81. https://honestreporting.com/why-not-sue-the-media-2/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
Contribute something
User Avatar
No comments yet.