Hubbry Logo
Labour FirstLabour FirstMain
Open search
Labour First
Community hub
Labour First
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Labour First
Labour First
Labour First
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Labour First is a British political organisation associated with the Labour Party. It was originally founded in 1980 but refounded in 1988. Born out of the political right wing of the Labour Party's struggles with its left wing, it sees itself as protecting the tradition of the "old Labour right".[1][2] It has been described externally as "the voice of the party’s traditional right" and "a group on the right of the party".[3][4] It organises petitions, endorses likeminded candidates, and runs events.

Key Information

History

[edit]

The original Labour First formed in 1980 as a grouping of Members of Parliament (MPs) on the right of the Labour Party who, while politically aligned with fellow Labour right faction, The Manifesto Group, desired a more collegiate party and thought that the left-right factional battles of the 1970s and 1980s were damaging the party's electoral prospects. The group's chair was Brynmor John and its secretary was Edmund Marshall. By 1983, the grouping had effectively merged into the Labour Solidarity Campaign, the successor to The Manifesto Group.[5]

In late 1987, the Labour Solidarity Campaign was in the process of winding itself up, believing that it had won its fight against the Labour left. A core of Labour Solidarity activists centred around John Spellar argued that there was a need to continue to organise. With Brynmor John's permission, they continued under the Labour First name, founding the current incarnation of Labour First.[5][6]

Aims and views

[edit]

Labour First aims to counter the left wing of the Labour Party, ensuring that what they define as "moderate" voices are heard, which they believe will ensure Labour remains as electable as possible in the Westminster system.[6] It calls these aims "Clause One Socialism", after Clause One of the Labour Party constitution, which sets the Labour Party's aims as maintaining a Labour Party in the Parliament of the United Kingdom.[7]

Labour First represents pro-NATO, pro-United States, pro-nuclear weapon, and pro-European Union (EU) stances in the party.[8]

Structure and activities

[edit]

Labour First is a network of freely associating Labour Party members who share their personal contact details with the organisation. It maintains a network of volunteer local organisers. In 2016, the Birmingham Mail identified MPs John Spellar, Tom Watson, and Ian Austin as having links with Labour First, and reported it as describing itself as "a network of Labour moderates fighting against Momentum and other Hard Left groups to keep Labour as a broad-based and electable party". MP Khalid Mahmood has also attended Labour First events.[9]

Its secretary is Luke Akehurst, the Labour MP for North Durham, and its chair is Keith Dibble, a Labour councillor and cabinet member on Rushmoor Council in Hampshire. In 2017, Labour First employed its first full-time national organiser.[10] In 2019, a digital organiser was also employed. It organises petitions, endorses "moderate" candidates in Labour Party elections, and runs a series of meet-ups and events both at Labour Party conference and in the country at large.

Labour First Parliamentary Network

[edit]

The Labour First Parliamentary Network is a parliamentary caucus open to Labour MPs who share the politics of Labour First. It was founded after the 2024 general election by Luke Akehurst and its convener Gurinder Singh Josan as a competitor to the left-wing Socialist Campaign Group. In a joint statement, Akehurst, Josan, John Spellar and Ruth Smeeth invited Labour MPs to join the group, stating that it took several years of "hard graft" to win the party back from those on the left, who they warned were "still waiting in the wings to take advantage of any discord within the party".[11][12] The group has been described as "pro-Starmer" and is led by Josan, Akehurst, Smeeth and Spellar, with over 50 members as of February 2025.[12][13]

[edit]

Historically, Labour First had little connection with Progress (since 2021 Progressive Britain), a more recent Labour party factional organisation on the right of the Labour party, originally associated with New Labour.[14] The rise of Jeremy Corbyn and Momentum in the Labour Party saw Progress and Labour First, while remaining distinct organisations with different traditions, carry out more joint activities, including joint endorsement of candidates in internal party elections.[15][6] During the 2020 Labour Party leadership election, Labour First formed a joint venture with Progress called Reclaiming Labour, holding meetings around the country analysing why Labour lost heavily in the 2019 United Kingdom general election.[16]

In April 2020, immediately on the election of Keir Starmer as party leader, Labour First and Progress launched jointly a new umbrella organisation called Labour to Win, with goals including "to bring about fundamental change in the party's culture and organisation".[17] Labour to Win endorsed candidates in the 2020 Labour National Executive Committee (NEC) elections; owing to the newly adopted single transferable vote nature of the elections and in the spirit of electing a pluralistic NEC, the organisation chose only to endorse six of its own candidates and also to endorse three candidates politically more to the left than Labour to Win but who had a commitment to broad church Labour politics.[18]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Labour First

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Labour First is a network of moderate members within the United Kingdom's Labour Party, dedicated to amplifying centrist voices, promoting electorally viable policies, and shielding the party from dominance by organised hard-left factions. Founded to counter radical influences that it views as detrimental to Labour's governance prospects, the group organises annual conferences, regional meetups, and efforts—targeting £72,000 annually—to bolster moderate candidates and office-holders. Key objectives include maximising Labour's parliamentary and local representation, ensuring party leadership prioritises power retention over ideological purity, and advocating for pragmatic stances on issues like defence, migration, and economic realism to appeal beyond core activists. Prominent figures associated with Labour First include Luke Akehurst, its secretary and since 2024 the Labour MP for North Durham, who has long campaigned against Corbyn-era leftism through roles in Labour Students and the party's National Executive Committee. The organisation has influenced internal party dynamics by backing Keir Starmer's leadership shift towards moderation post-2020, contributing to the deselection of hard-left candidates and the normalisation of pro-NATO, fiscally cautious positions within Labour. In 2024, following Labour's general election victory, Akehurst and fellow MP Gurinder Singh Josan launched the Labour First Parliamentary Network as a moderate counterweight to left-wing groupings like the , aiming to shape legislative priorities. While praised by supporters for restoring Labour's electability after the defeat—attributed partly to hard-left overreach—Labour First has faced from party leftists for alleged authoritarian tactics in candidate selections and perceived alignment with interests, including strong advocacy for amid Gaza conflicts, which some label as overly interventionist. Akehurst's selection for a safe northern seat despite residing in drew accusations of parachutism, highlighting tensions over regional representation versus ideological reliability. These frictions underscore Labour First's defining role as a bulwark for in a party historically prone to factional strife, prioritising causal factors like voter appeal and institutional stability over purist demands.

History

Founding and Initial Objectives

Labour First originated as an informal grouping of Labour MPs in 1980, during a period of intense internal conflict within the Labour Party between its moderate and left-wing factions following electoral defeats and ideological battles in the late 1970s. The organization was formally refounded in 1988 by Labour MP John Spellar, who relaunched it to consolidate the party's traditional right-wing elements against the rising influence of the hard left, particularly amid challenges to party leadership and policy direction under Neil Kinnock. The initial objectives centered on promoting electoral viability and pragmatic governance as prerequisites for advancing Labour's goals, emphasizing the need to counter left-wing dominance that was perceived to alienate voters and hinder electability. Labour First positioned itself as a defender of the party's moderate wing, advocating for policies and candidate selections that prioritized winning power over ideological purity, with a focus on maintaining links while rejecting unilateral and other hard-left positions that had contributed to Labour's 1983 election rout. This refounding reflected broader efforts within Labour to modernize and shift away from the that had marginalized the party, aiming to restore among the electorate by fostering , realism in , and commitment to parliamentary .

Expansion During the Corbyn Era

During Jeremy Corbyn's leadership of the Labour Party from September 2015 to April 2020, Labour First markedly expanded its organizational reach and internal advocacy as a moderate counterweight to the ascendancy of hard-left groups like Momentum, which drew in over 300,000 new party members committed to Corbyn's platform of radical economic policies and foreign stances often at odds with mainstream electability. The influx of left-leaning recruits shifted power dynamics within constituency labour parties (CLPs) and the National Executive Committee (NEC), prompting Labour First to intensify recruitment drives, training sessions for activists, and slate-based candidacies to reclaim influence in these bodies. Led by secretary Luke Akehurst, the group emphasized defending Clause I of the party constitution—prioritizing working-class representation—against what it viewed as entryism by activists prioritizing ideological purity over electoral viability. Labour First's expansion manifested in heightened participation in internal elections, where it backed moderate candidates against Momentum-endorsed rivals, securing notable wins in CLP executive positions concurrent with Corbyn's 2015 victory and subsequent contests. In 2016, amid the parliamentary rebellion following the referendum and Corbyn's loss of the shadow cabinet's confidence, the organization mobilized supporters for the leadership challenge by and later , framing the effort as essential to restoring party unity and competence. This period saw Labour First forge tactical alliances with kindred groups like , amplifying their joint voice at party conferences and in media critiques of Corbyn's handling of allegations, which the later deemed unlawful in party governance. A pivotal campaign came at the 2017 Labour conference, where Labour First co-hosted a rally with to rally delegates against a Momentum-backed rule change lowering the MP nomination threshold for leadership bids from 15% to 10%, arguing the reform would entrench untested radicals and hinder opposition effectiveness. The proposal's defeat underscored Labour First's growing sway among wary MPs and veteran members, who joined or reactivated affiliations to preserve gatekeeping mechanisms against perceived . By 2018–2019, as Corbyn's approval waned amid electoral setbacks and internal divisions, Labour First's advocacy extended to elections, where moderates under its umbrella gained seats to scrutinize selections and block hard-left dominance, laying groundwork for post-Corbyn reforms. This era transformed Labour First from a niche network into a coordinated bulwark, prioritizing causal links between leadership stability and voting success over expansive ideological shifts.

Developments Under Starmer Leadership

Following Keir Starmer's election as Labour Party leader on April 4, 2020, Labour First partnered with the centrist group to form the 'Labour to Win' on , 2020, explicitly in response to Starmer's appeal for unity and renewal after the party's defeat. This alliance sought to consolidate moderate and right-leaning elements within the party, focusing on electing pragmatic candidates to key bodies like the National Executive Committee () and countering residual hard-left influence from the Corbyn years. Labour to Win quickly demonstrated influence by endorsing a slate of candidates in July 2020, including figures like Johanna Baxter and Gurinder Singh Josan, many of whom secured election, thereby bolstering Starmer's control over party governance and disciplinary processes. The group continued to back internal selections favoring electability over ideological purity, aligning with Starmer's policy pivots—such as abandoning pledges and emphasizing fiscal responsibility—which distanced Labour from 2019's . Labour First's parliamentary network, including chair Luke Akehurst, advocated for rule changes to prioritize working members in leadership elections and expedite handling of complaints, contributing to over 400 suspensions or expulsions of activists linked to by mid-2021. By 2024, Labour First's efforts through Labour to Win had helped entrench moderate dominance, aiding Starmer's campaign strategy that yielded 411 seats in the July 4 general election. However, post-election dynamics revealed strains, with reports in October 2025 highlighting fractures in the Labour right—exacerbated by policy disputes over issues like welfare cuts—as (Progress's rebranded successor) and Labour First diverged on Starmer's governance approach. Despite this, Labour First maintained its focus on safeguarding the party's pro-business, union-skeptical wing against left-wing resurgence, as evidenced by Akehurst's successful candidacy in North Durham.

Ideology and Policy Positions

Core Principles and Electoral Focus

Labour First identifies as a network of moderate Labour Party members committed to safeguarding the party from the influence of the organised hard left while amplifying the perspectives of social democrats and democratic socialists. Its foundational emphasis lies in advancing policies that improve conditions for ordinary working people and their families, viewing the Labour Party as inherently tied to Clause One of its , which prioritises and democratic control of key industries and services. The group upholds the link as an essential component of the party's structure, advocating for unions' role in representing workers without subordinating electoral viability to ideological purity. Central to its ideology is a commitment to strong local government, where elected councillors exercise greater authority over communities rather than deferring to unaccountable quangos or community groups. On national security, Labour First supports Britain's active participation in , opposition to unilateral , and maintenance of the transatlantic alliance with the , framing these stances as integral to a robust defence posture. While not prescribing detailed economic policies, the organisation prioritises "mainstream and election-winning policies" that position Labour as a credible of capable of delivering tangible benefits to voters. Electorally, Labour First's overriding focus is on maximising Labour's chances of retaining power and securing the largest possible number of parliamentary seats and council positions, subordinating internal factionalism to the imperative of victory. Members are required to be active campaigners, with the group's name reflecting a that places success above narrower ideological currents. This manifests in efforts to influence candidate selections, favouring nominees deemed electable in target seats—particularly those appealing to traditional working-class voters—over hard-left candidates perceived as divisive or unelectable, as evidenced by its campaign urging members to oppose Jeremy Corbyn's bid on grounds that it would undermine Labour's broader appeal. Post-2019 election losses, the group intensified advocacy for selections prioritising winnability in Red Wall constituencies, contributing to moderate successes in reselections amid factional contests.

Stances on Internal Party Reform

Labour First opposes mandatory reselection of sitting MPs, contending that it prioritizes factional challenges over stable representation and electability. The group has actively campaigned to maintain higher thresholds in the trigger ballot system, under which a (CLP) branch or affiliate must secure support from at least 50% of branches and unions to initiate a full candidate selection contest, thereby protecting incumbents from routine deselection attempts by activist minorities. This position gained prominence during the 2018-2019 debates, where Labour First mobilized against proposed rule changes that would have lowered the trigger threshold to one-third, a reform advocated by left-wing groups like to facilitate challenges against centrist MPs. The organization advocates for candidate selection processes that emphasize electability, loyalty to the party leadership, and adherence to mainstream values, often supporting National Executive Committee (NEC) oversight to veto extreme or non-compliant candidates. Labour First secretary Luke Akehurst, an NEC member since 2018, has defended these mechanisms, arguing they prevent local CLPs—potentially dominated by unrepresentative activists—from imposing unelectable nominees. During the Corbyn leadership (2015-2020), the group coordinated with allies like Progress to secure NEC seats via coordinated slates, blocking reforms that would expand membership-elected positions and dilute trade union or parliamentary influence. Under Keir Starmer's leadership post-2020, Labour First has endorsed centralized reforms to membership rules and complaints procedures, including enhanced powers for the and party general secretary to suspend or expel members involved in or factional disruption, as implemented in the 2021 rule changes. These stances reflect a broader commitment to structures that prioritize party unity and leadership authority over expansive internal democracy, which the group views as vulnerable to capture by ideological minorities.

Positions on Key Policy Issues

Labour First advocates for mainstream economic policies aimed at improving conditions for working families through electability and pragmatic governance, emphasizing fiscal responsibility and growth-oriented measures over radical redistribution. The organization supports maintaining the Labour Party's links while prioritizing policies that appeal to a broad electorate, including business-friendly reforms to foster job creation and stability. On , Labour First has criticized past Labour approaches for failing to address voter concerns adequately, calling for stronger controls and reduced reliance on overseas labor to restore public confidence in border management. As part of the party's "old right" tradition, it endorses hawkish positions that align with reducing net migration and tackling smuggling networks, viewing unchecked inflows as a drag on wages and public services. In defence and security, Labour First opposes unilateral and champions robust military capabilities, including commitment to obligations and the UK-US . Its leadership has advocated for enhanced defence spending and strategic reviews to counter global threats, with figures like secretary Luke Akehurst contributing to parliamentary debates on fiscal allocations for military readiness. Foreign policy stances emphasize active international engagement, including a full role in European affairs despite realities, and strong bilateral ties such as military cooperation with . Labour First representatives have pushed for resetting and deepening -Israel relations post-conflict, prioritizing shared security interests over domestic partisan pressures. Regarding welfare and public services, the group favors empowering local authorities to tailor policies without central interference, promoting efficient delivery through elected councillors rather than unelected bodies, to enhance accountability and responsiveness. This approach extends to supporting increased NHS funding within balanced budgets, as reflected in broader moderate Labour priorities.

Organizational Structure

Membership and Governance

Labour First operates as an informal network of Labour Party members who voluntarily associate by sharing their contact details to facilitate coordination on moderate priorities, rather than as a formal affiliate with mandatory dues or structured enrollment. Participation is restricted to verified Labour Party members supportive of its aims, including safeguarding the party from hard-left dominance and promoting electable mainstream policies, with no public disclosure of exact membership figures. Voluntary donations, starting from small amounts such as £3, fund activities like events and communications, but are not required for involvement. Governance remains lightweight and non-hierarchical, centered on a small core team without a publicized executive committee or board. Luke Akehurst has served as secretary since 2006, managing day-to-day operations, advocacy, and alliances with groups like for influencing Labour's National Executive Committee elections. This structure prioritizes flexibility for rapid response to internal party challenges, such as candidate selections, over bureaucratic processes, enabling focus on mobilizing moderates at conferences and local levels.

Parliamentary Network

The Labour First Parliamentary Network serves as a caucus for moderate Labour MPs and peers, established to foster unity and discipline within the following the 2024 general election. Launched in October 2024, it aims to provide a dedicated space for parliamentarians aligned with Labour First's centrist principles, emphasizing delivery, electoral success, and safeguards against hard-left resurgence. The network counters influences like the by promoting coordinated efforts to maintain party cohesion under Keir Starmer's leadership, drawing on the organization's historical role in resisting Corbyn-era dominance. Convened by Gurinder Singh Josan, the Labour MP for and a director of Labour First Ltd, the network builds on years of campaigning to reclaim the party from internal divisions. Key figures associated include former MP John Spellar (now a peer), Labour peer Baroness Anderson, and activist Luke Akehurst, who serves as Labour First's director. Its priorities, as articulated at launch, include enforcing parliamentary discipline, prioritizing government delivery on commitments, and strategizing for future elections to maximize Labour seats. The initiative reflects a return to Labour First's origins in the as an MP-focused grouping, adapting to the post-2024 landscape where Labour holds a majority but faces risks from factional discord. Activities center on regular meetings to discuss legislative strategy, leadership support, and responses to policy challenges, with an eye toward influencing beyond Starmer. Open to MPs endorsing pro-EU, pro-NATO stances and pragmatic governance, the network positions itself as a bulwark for electoral over ideological purity. By October 2025, it had facilitated discussions warning of opportunistic left-wing maneuvers amid early controversies, underscoring its role in sustaining moderate influence.

Activities and Campaigns

Advocacy Efforts Against Hard-Left Influence

Labour First has positioned itself as a bulwark against the influence of organized hard-left groups within the Labour Party, emphasizing the need to maintain moderate policies capable of winning elections. The organization explicitly states its goal of protecting the party from such elements to ensure it remains focused on electable, mainstream positions rather than ideological . A primary avenue of advocacy has involved contesting elections to the Labour () to secure moderate representation and block hard-left dominance, particularly during the Corbyn era when groups like sought to entrench their power. In , Labour First secretary Luke Akehurst ran for an seat, pledging to prioritize the party's interests over Momentum's agenda and criticizing the hard-left's control of () sections on the NEC. Akehurst's successful candidacies, including in subsequent years, contributed to efforts that helped shift NEC composition toward moderation, limiting the hard-left's ability to dictate internal rules. The group has also campaigned against rule changes that would amplify hard-left leverage, such as proposals to lower the threshold for leadership nominations from 15% to 10% of MPs, which moderates argued would facilitate repeated challenges by fringe candidates. In September 2017, at Labour Conference, Akehurst urged members to oppose this amendment, warning that a left-leaning would likely approve it, thereby entrenching instability and ideological purity tests over electoral viability. Labour First similarly opposed pushes for mandatory reselection of MPs, viewing them as tools for hard-left activists to moderates through local party ballots, and supported instead the existing trigger ballot system that requires demonstrated dissatisfaction before full selections. These efforts align with broader moderate resistance to reforms that could revive the internal strife of the , prioritizing party unity and electability.

Support for Moderate Candidates

Labour First intervenes in Labour Party candidate selection processes at both parliamentary and local levels to promote moderates over hard-left contenders, mobilizing members through endorsements, , and organizing to prioritize electability and realism. This approach stems from the group's foundational goal, established in 1988, of countering infiltration by entryist left-wing factions that could undermine the party's broad appeal. In parliamentary selections, Labour First has backed specific moderate figures, such as Luke Murphy, a group organizer, who was selected as the Labour candidate for in February 2024 after a contested process emphasizing competence in policy areas like . The organization also collaborates with allied networks like Labour to Win to slate candidates for National Executive Committee () elections, including endorsements for figures like Luke Akehurst, Labour First's secretary, in 2020, focusing on those committed to and electoral viability over ideological purity. For sub-national contests, Labour First-endorsed candidates achieved successes in the 2020 London Assembly selections, where Corbynsceptic moderates, including those supported by the group, prevailed against left-wing rivals in key races, such as the selection of in a competitive . This pattern extended to internal races; in the 2025 Labour deputy election, Labour First advocated for centrist-oriented candidates to reinforce Starmer's governance-focused agenda, underscoring their preference for figures who prioritize pragmatic policymaking. These efforts often involve coordinated slates and member outreach, as seen in Labour to Win's 2021 internal election recommendations, where Labour First contributed to backing a of 27 and other committee candidates vetted for alignment with mainstream Labour values. By focusing on verifiable track records—such as prior electoral wins or union ties—Labour First aims to insulate selections from activist-driven disruptions, though critics from the party left argue this tilts processes toward establishment figures.

Recent Initiatives Post-2024 Election

In October 2024, Labour First established the Labour First Parliamentary Network, a for Labour MPs and peers aligned with its moderate, "old right" orientation. Convened by Josan, MP for , the network includes key figures such as Luke Akehurst, secretary of Labour First and MP for North Durham, former MP John (now a peer), and Baroness Anderson. Its stated purpose is to foster , support the delivery of government priorities under , and safeguard electoral success by providing a counterweight to the left-wing , without endorsing specific policy positions. The initiative reflects Labour First's post-election emphasis on consolidating moderate influence amid the parliamentary arithmetic of Labour's , which included a larger cohort of MPs potentially susceptible to left-wing pressures. By creating a dedicated forum distinct from broader centrist alliances, prioritizes internal cohesion over public , aiming to prevent rebellions and maintain alignment with Starmer's leadership. In early 2025, Labour First hosted a fringe event at the on February 26, titled "Upholding : The fight for Labour's future," to reinforce moderate principles and discuss strategies for resisting hard-left resurgence within the party. This gathering underscored the group's ongoing commitment to amplifying pragmatic voices in governance, focusing on empirical delivery rather than ideological shifts. Through its participation in the pre-existing Labour to Win umbrella grouping with , Labour First continued post-election efforts to enforce loyalty to the , including coordination on National Executive Committee matters and motions to block left-wing challenges. This has been credited with sustaining factional unity during early government controversies, though tensions over issues like have tested its cohesion.

Relationships with Allied Groups

Ties to Progress and Other Centrist Networks

Labour First forged a significant with , a prominent New Labour-oriented group, through the joint establishment of the 'Labour to Win' umbrella organization on April 5, 2020. This partnership emerged immediately following Keir Starmer's election as Labour leader, explicitly responding to his emphasis on party renewal and unity by consolidating moderate voices to counter residual hard-left influence from the Corbyn era. 'Labour to Win' functions as a coordinated platform for endorsing candidates in internal elections, such as those for the National Executive Committee and Conference Arrangements Committee, and mobilizing support for policy positions aligned with electoral viability over ideological purity. The collaboration bridges Labour First's roots in traditional social democratic unionism with 's advocacy for market-oriented reforms and pro-business policies, enabling resource-sharing for advocacy against and procedural takeovers by Momentum-affiliated activists. By spring 2020, the groups pooled membership networks—Labour First drawing from moderates and Progress from urban professionals—to amplify influence in rule changes and leadership contests, contributing to the dilution of hard-left dominance in party structures by 2021. Following 's 2021 rebranding as amid merger with the , the 'Labour to Win' framework persisted, evidenced by joint endorsements in 2023 National Constitutional Committee elections and ongoing conference fringe activities. Beyond Progress, Labour First maintains looser affiliations within centrist ecosystems, including endorsements overlapping with Labour Together's candidate slates, though without formal merger. These ties emphasize pragmatic coalition-building for electability, as demonstrated in coordinated opposition to pushes by left-leaning factions during the 2021 party conference. Such networks prioritize of voter preferences—favoring centrist platforms that secured Labour's 1997-2010 governments—over purist demands, fostering a bulwark against radical shifts that empirical data links to electoral defeats in 2010, 2015, and 2019.

Distinctions from Broader Moderate Coalitions

Labour First differentiates itself from broader moderate coalitions within the Labour Party, such as (formerly ) and Labour Together, by maintaining a narrower focus on internal party governance and resistance to hard-left influence rather than expansive policy development or electoral strategy. While groups like emphasize think-tank-style policy research and debates to shape the party's ideological direction, Labour First prioritizes campaigning within constituency Labour parties (CLPs) to defend moderate candidates against deselection attempts and promote democratic structures that prevent dominance by activist minorities. This internal orientation stems from Labour First's roots as a pre-Blairite organization founded in 1988, representing the "old Labour right" committed to traditional social democratic principles, in contrast to the more market-oriented or New Labour elements in broader coalitions. Unlike Progressive Britain, which has incorporated elements outside strict social democracy and engages in wider ideological advocacy, Labour First adheres closely to established party traditions without formally endorsing specific policy positions, avoiding the think-tank role adopted by allies. In comparison to Labour Together, described as a donor-influenced "super PAC" focused on long-term electoral planning and support, Labour First operates more as a pressure group, emphasizing member-driven efforts to safeguard party rules on selections and elections against radical reforms. This distinction highlights Labour First's commitment to preserving the party's broad-church nature through procedural defenses, rather than the strategic, resource-heavy coalitions that integrate policy innovation with external funding networks.

Criticisms and Debates

Accusations from the Labour Left

Members of the Labour Left, including supporters of and groups like , have accused Labour First of functioning as an undemocratic Blairite faction intent on preserving centrist dominance within the party, prioritizing electoral viability over socialist policies. Critics contend that Labour First's grassroots organizing mirrors the entryism they attribute to the left, but aimed at blocking progressive reforms, such as opposition to rule changes at the 2017 Labour conference that sought to reduce the MP nomination threshold for leadership contests from 15% to 10%, a move left-wing voices described as entrenching elite control by a minority of MPs. Such groups have further alleged that Labour First engaged in covert efforts to undermine Corbyn's , including recruiting organizers to compete for delegate positions at party conferences and local branch influence, framing these as "Militant-style" tactics repurposed by moderates to sideline socialist voices. For example, in responses to Labour First's calls for party unity, left-leaning publications portrayed the organization as viewing constituency units strategically to outmaneuver Momentum-backed members rather than foster genuine reconciliation. Additional accusations center on Labour First's role in leveraging internal complaints mechanisms, particularly investigations, to or marginalize left-wing activists, often those critical of , with detractors claiming this "weaponized" legitimate concerns to advance factional goals amid Corbyn's tenure. These claims, echoed in outlets aligned with pro-Palestinian perspectives, link Labour First figures like member Luke Akehurst to broader moderate strategies that allegedly diverted resources and amplified media narratives against the leadership, though empirical inquiries such as the Equality and Human Rights Commission's report substantiated institutional failings in handling rather than endorsing conspiracy narratives.

Responses to Claims of Elitism or Conservatism

Labour First advocates and supporters have rebutted accusations of by contending that such charges more aptly describe the hard left's detachment from the priorities of ordinary working people, whom they portray as alienated by radical policies favoring ideological purity over electoral success and practical governance. The group's mission explicitly emphasizes protecting the Labour Party from influences that divert it from "improving lives for ordinary working people and their families," framing moderates as the true representatives of mainstream members against a purportedly insular activist cadre. This perspective aligns with broader moderate critiques, such as those in Labour Uncut, which urge the party to reject "metropolitan " in favor of policies resonating with traditional voters outside urban centers. In response to specific claims of imposing top-down preferences, such as opposition to lowering leadership eligibility thresholds for underrepresented groups, Labour First figures like Luke Akehurst have argued that such measures undermine democratic member choice in favor of arbitrary quotas, which they deem "ridiculous" and antithetical to open, processes that empower voices rather than engineering outcomes. Akehurst and allies maintain that their advocacy for rigorous candidate vetting and rule adherence ensures accountability and electability, countering narratives of exclusion by citing the need to prioritize competence over identity-based mandates to deliver tangible benefits for working-class constituencies. Regarding labels of conservatism, Labour First responds by distinguishing prudent adherence to proven, electable platforms—such as maintaining affiliations, bolstering autonomy, and upholding commitments—from ideological intransigence, asserting that these stances preserve Labour's historic strengths against the hard left's "diversion" toward unelectable . Supporters point to empirical outcomes, including Labour's 2024 victory under a moderate that echoed their emphases on fiscal responsibility and , as validation that caution rooted in voter realities outperforms radical experimentation, which contributed to prior defeats like 2019. Akehurst has further defended social democratic principles against both populist right and far-left fragmentation, arguing that moderation fosters broad coalitions capable of governing effectively rather than conceding ground to extremes.

Empirical Assessments of Influence

Labour First's influence is discernible through its sustained representation on the Labour Party's , where affiliates like secretary Luke Akehurst have shaped disciplinary processes and candidate vetting since regaining moderate control post-2019. Akehurst, elected to the in multiple cycles including 2018 and subsequent terms, advocated for criteria emphasizing electability and alignment with mainstream policies, contributing to the suspension or exclusion of over 20 hard-left figures on grounds including during Keir Starmer's leadership transition. In candidate selections for the 2024 general election, oversight—facilitated by Labour First's networked presence alongside groups like Labour To Win—prioritized moderates, as evidenced by the nomination of Akehurst for North Durham despite local branch opposition, securing his election as MP with Labour retaining the seat's traditional majority profile. Similarly, allied members such as Gurinder Singh Josan were selected for winnable constituencies, reflecting a pattern where at least three pro-Starmer executives from moderate factions gained safe or notionally safe nominations, streamlining the slate toward centrist profiles over ideological purists. The faction's broader impact manifests in Labour's July 4, , landslide, capturing 412 seats (63% of ) and a 174-seat majority on 33.7% vote share, reclaiming 40+ Red Wall seats lost under Corbyn's harder-left platform in 2019. This reversal correlates with Labour First-backed shifts, including rule reforms tightening contests (requiring 20% MP nominations) and moderation on issues like and , which expanded voter appeal beyond 2019's 32.1% share. Quantitative isolation remains limited absent faction-specific endorsement tallies, but NEC voting records show moderate blocs, incorporating Labour First input, passing measures like centralized shortlisting in 10+ target seats, reducing internal dissent risks that plagued 2017-2019 selections. Left-leaning critiques in outlets like frame this as authoritarian purging, yet the empirical metric of electoral dominance—contrasting Corbyn-era losses—validates the causal efficacy of their anti-extremist interventions in restoring party competitiveness.

Impact and Legacy

Role in Party Electoral Success

Labour First contributed to the Labour Party's restoration of electability following the defeat, where the party secured only 202 seats with 32.1% of the vote amid perceptions of unelectability under Jeremy Corbyn's left-wing . The organization actively supported Keir Starmer's successful bid for party , announced on April 4, 2020, viewing it as a "turning point after five dismal years" of internal divisions and policy extremism that alienated moderate voters and key demographics. By aligning with Starmer's emphasis on competence, economic realism, and —contrasting Corbyn-era positions—Labour First helped foster a platform that prioritized broad electoral appeal over ideological purity. In parallel, Labour First influenced candidate selection processes by backing moderate figures through interventions in National Executive Committee (NEC) elections and local party mechanisms. Following victories in the April 2023 NEC elections, where endorsed candidates like Johanna Baxter and Gurinder Singh Josan prevailed, the group strengthened moderate control over party governance, enabling stricter oversight of selections to favor winnable, centrist-oriented aspirants rather than hard-left activists. This approach facilitated the deselection or marginalization of candidates tied to Corbynism, whose associations with scandals and radical policies had contributed to the 2019 loss of Jewish voter support and broader . Labour First's director, Luke Akehurst, exemplified this strategy by securing the North Durham nomination in 2023 and winning the seat in the July 4, 2024, , where Labour gained 174 seats to reach 411 amid a fragmented opposition. The faction's collaboration with allies like , via the 2020 "Labour to Win" initiative, reinforced party unity under Starmer, countering residual left-wing challenges and enabling policy resets—such as abandoning Corbyn's pledges for pragmatic fiscal rules—that resonated with swing voters in Red Wall and southern marginals. Empirical outcomes underscore this impact: Labour's 2024 vote share rose modestly to 33.7%, but tactical voting against Conservatives and amplified seat gains under first-past-the-post, yielding a 174-seat majority without the internal fractures that plagued prior campaigns. Labour First's organizational focus on "election-winning policies" and active campaigning thus supported the structural reforms that positioned Labour for after 14 years in opposition.

Long-Term Effects on Labour Moderation

Labour First's persistent organizational efforts, including targeted interventions in elections, have contributed to a structural tilt toward moderation within the Labour Party since the mid-2010s. By securing seats on the —such as Luke Akehurst's election in 2020—the group influenced candidate selection processes and party governance, enabling the sidelining of hard-left figures and the prioritization of electable moderates. This shift was pivotal in the 2020 leadership contest, where , backed by moderate networks including Labour First affiliates, defeated left-wing challengers and initiated a purge of Corbyn-era influences, including rule changes to bar figures like from standing as candidates. Policy-wise, these internal dynamics fostered a departure from the radicalism of the 2019 manifesto, with Labour under Starmer adopting , such as adhering to spending rules and implementing welfare adjustments like the 2024 cuts to winter fuel payments for pensioners, moves critiqued by the left but defended as necessary for economic credibility. Labour First's emphasis on "mainstream and election-winning policies" aligned with this pivot, promoting pro-business stances and union pragmatism over ideological purity, which helped normalize centrist positions like robust support and restrained plans in the 2024 platform. The resulting 2024 general election landslide, securing 412 seats, validated this moderation by demonstrating voter preference for competence over transformative , as evidenced by the party's gains in and among working-class voters alienated by prior left-wing dominance. Long-term, Labour First's model of grassroots mobilization and alliance-building—distinct from broader coalitions—has embedded safeguards against left-wing resurgence, such as enhanced member vetting and oversight, potentially insulating the party from future factional takeovers. However, this has exacerbated tensions, contributing to the 2025 emergence of breakaway left-wing initiatives led by ex-Corbynites, signaling that moderation's success in attaining power came at the expense of ideological cohesion on the party's left flank. Empirical assessments, including factional polling, indicate declining tolerance between Labour's wings since 2022, with moderates' ascendance correlating to improved metrics under Starmer, though risks of internal sabotage persist if left disaffection grows.

References

  1. https://www.labourfirst.org/
  2. https://labourlist.org/2025/09/we-need-street-fighting-social-democracy-to-beat-reform/
  3. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/article/2024/may/31/luke-akehurst-labour-activist-turned-controversial-election-candidate
  4. https://www.thejc.com/news/politics/meet-luke-akehurst-part-of-britains-pro-israel-furniture-and-now-labour-mp-ckwg3h7s
  5. https://www.politicshome.com/news/article/who-are-the-labour-tribes
  6. https://labourlist.org/2020/04/progress-and-labour-first-launch-labour-to-win-umbrella-organisation/
  7. https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2015/10/labour-s-warring-factions-who-do-they-include-and-what-are-they-fighting
  8. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1369148118815408
  9. https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/newspape/isj2/2016/isj2-149/thomas.html
  10. https://socialismtoday.org/archive/193/corbyn.html
  11. https://www.counterfire.org/article/the-end-of-blairism-jeremy-corbyn-the-labour-party-and-the-left/
  12. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/sep/11/labour-groups-urge-moderates-to-block-move-to-lower-leadership-threshold
  13. https://labourlist.org/2023/03/luke-akehurst-why-i-voted-for-the-nec-motion-to-block-corbyns-candidacy/
  14. https://newlaborforum.cuny.edu/2018/08/28/the-remarkable-rise-of-jeremy-corbyn/
  15. https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk-politics/2025/10/the-labour-right-is-fracturing
  16. https://labourlist.org/2020/07/labour-to-win-unveils-pluralistic-set-of-nec-candidate-recommendations/
  17. https://jacobin.com/2021/06/labour-party-centrism-blairism-progressive-britain-keir-starmer
  18. https://unherd.com/2020/04/can-keir-starmer-rescue-labour/
  19. https://www.labourfirst.org/about
  20. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-33490959
  21. https://www.the-independent.com/news/uk/politics/labour-pressure-group-claims-jeremy-corbyn-would-destroy-chances-of-electability-as-leader-10382371.html
  22. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/oct/28/leftwingers-ahead-in-labour-candidate-selection-battles
  23. https://labourlist.org/2019/08/how-labours-trigger-ballot-system-works/
  24. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/oct/17/labour-trigger-ballot-deselection-campaign
  25. https://labourlist.org/2018/06/why-labour-members-are-talking-about-mandatory-reselection-again/
  26. https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/labour-selection-process-keir-starmer-maurice-mcleod-lauren-townsend/
  27. https://labour.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/Democracy-Review_.pdf
  28. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/jan/16/eddie-izzard-says-labour-infighting-must-end-after-nec-defeat
  29. https://labourlist.org/2018/02/luke-akehurst-is-social-democracy-in-crisis/
  30. https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/labour/2025/02/labours-old-right-has-been-reborn
  31. https://parallelparliament.co.uk/mp/luke-akehurst/debate/2025-06-02/commons/commons-chamber/strategic-defence-review
  32. https://parallelparliament.co.uk/mp/luke-akehurst/debate/2025-01-27/commons/commons-chamber/fiscal-policy-defence-spending
  33. https://www.lfi.org.uk/luke-akehurst-champions-uk-israel-military-cooperation/
  34. https://www.lfi.org.uk/luke-akehurst-mp-with-a-ceasefire-in-place-its-time-for-a-reset-of-uk-israeli-relations/
  35. https://www.labourfirst.org/labour_group_policy
  36. https://www.labourfirst.org/donate
  37. https://labourlist.org/2022/07/luke-akehurst-why-im-standing-to-represent-local-parties-on-labours-nec-2/
  38. https://labourlist.org/2018/03/progress-and-labour-first-reveal-nec-slate/
  39. https://www.politicshome.com/news/article/old-right-group-labour-first-launches-parliamentary-network
  40. https://members.parliament.uk/member/5059/registeredinterests
  41. https://www.politico.eu/newsletter/london-playbook/gruel-britannia/
  42. https://quizlet.com/gb/1022911340/evaluate-the-view-that-the-major-political-parties-are-more-internally-divided-than-between-them-flash-cards
  43. https://labourlist.org/2018/06/luke-akehurst-why-im-standing-for-labours-nec/
  44. https://d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/labourfirst/pages/1037/attachments/original/1507126128/Local_Groups_Guidance_Note.pdf?1507126128
  45. https://labourlist.org/2020/06/labour-to-win-launches-as-new-coalition-of-mainstream-labour-activists/
  46. https://labourlist.org/2024/06/our-rolling-list-of-labour-parliamentary-candidate-selections/
  47. https://labourlist.org/2021/03/labour-to-win-unveils-slates-of-candidates-for-internal-labour-elections/
  48. https://labourlist.org/2020/02/corbynsceptics-score-victories-in-london-assembly-candidate-selections/
  49. https://labourlist.org/2025/09/labour-first-deputy-leadership-election-2025/
  50. https://labourlist.org/2025/09/bridget-phillipson-vs-lucy-powell-for-deputy-leader/
  51. https://www.labourfirst.org/social_democracy_event_2025
  52. https://www.progressivebritain.org/making-progress/
  53. https://www.labourtowin.org/labour-party-conference/
  54. https://archive.progressivebritain.org/2011/11/09/the-story-of-the-labour-right/
  55. https://weeklyworker.co.uk/worker/1447/putting-capital-and-careers-first/
  56. https://www.labourfirst.org/labourtowinqa
  57. https://www.progressivebritain.org/a-century-which-proves-labour-only-wins-on-the-centre-ground/
  58. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/aug/03/labours-factions-keir-starmer-left-party-right
  59. https://unherd.com/newsroom/labour-together-is-far-more-dangerous-than-momentum/
  60. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/mar/20/momentum-no-secret-plot-want-fair-say-labour-party
  61. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/labour/12145352/Jeremy-Corbyn-Momentums-militant-style-blueprint-for-gaining-influence-over-Labour.html
  62. https://workersliberty.org/story/2017-07-26/reply-labour-first-party-unity
  63. https://mondoweiss.net/2020/02/even-with-corbyn-gone-antisemitism-threats-will-keep-destroying-the-uk-labour-party/
  64. https://www.the-independent.com/news/uk/politics/forde-report-labour-jeremy-corbyn-2017-election-b2126500.html
  65. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-39113671
  66. https://labour-uncut.co.uk/2016/09/
  67. https://skwawkbox.org/2019/07/17/right-wing-labour-first-group-calls-push-for-bame-young-and-working-class-leaders-ridiculous/
  68. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c800g7qlrjzo
  69. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/ng-interactive/2024/jul/04/uk-general-election-results-2024-live-in-full
  70. https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-10009/
  71. https://www.labourfirst.org/leadershipelectionresult
  72. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-51049756
  73. https://www.labourfirst.org/labournecreport
  74. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-54939145
  75. https://uknewspulse.co.uk/luke-akehurst
  76. https://jacobin.com/2025/10/labour-corbyn-starmer-leadership-scandal
  77. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c7220exjzvno
  78. https://www.thenation.com/article/world/britain-labour-austerity-starmer/
  79. https://ukandeu.ac.uk/labours-factions-more-toxic-than-brexit/
  80. https://yougov.co.uk/politics/articles/51943-five-years-after-being-elected-labour-leader-the-majority-of-britons-are-unclear-what-keir-starmer-stands-for
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.