Hubbry Logo
ManthanManthanMain
Open search
Manthan
Community hub
Manthan
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Contribute something
Manthan
Manthan
Manthan
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Manthan
Directed byShyam Benegal
Written byKaifi Azmi (dialogue)
Screenplay byVijay Tendulkar
Story by
StarringGirish Karnad
Smita Patil
Naseeruddin Shah
CinematographyGovind Nihalani
Edited byBhanudas Divakar
Music byVanraj Bhatia
Production
company
Release date
Running time
134 minutes
CountryIndia
LanguageHindi

Manthan, also released under the translated title The Churning, is a 1976 Hindi film directed by Shyam Benegal, inspired by the pioneering milk cooperative movement of Verghese Kurien, and written jointly by him and Vijay Tendulkar.[1] It is set amidst the backdrop of the White Revolution of India. Aside from the great measurable success that this project was, it also demonstrated the power of "collective might" as it was entirely crowdfunded by 500,000 farmers who donated Rs. 2 each.[2][3][4] Manthan is the first crowdfunded Indian film.[5]

The film won the 1977 National Film Award for Best Feature Film in Hindi and National Film Award for Best Screenplay for Vijay Tendulkar, and was also India's submission for the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film in 1976.[6] A restored version was released in the Cannes Classics section of the 2024 Cannes Film Festival.[7]

The title song ("Mero Gaam Katha Parey") was sung by Preeti Sagar. She won the Filmfare Award for Best Female Playback Singer for that year.[8] The song was later used as the soundtrack for the television commercial for Amul.[9][10][11]

Plot

[edit]

Dr. Manohar Rao, a young veterinary doctor with his team of Deshmukh, Chandravarkar, and others comes to a village in Kheda district, Gujarat. The village is inhabited by poor people whose chief occupation seems to be cattle-rearing and producing milk, which they sell to a local dairy owner Mishra. Mishra pays them excessively low amounts for their milk. Dr. Rao and his team have arrived to set up a Cooperative society dairy which will be owned collectively and managed by the villagers themselves. As Dr. Rao and his team grapple with village politics, rigid casteism, and general distrust of the village folk, they face planned hostility from the local Dalit community's leader Bhola who harbours deep anger and resentment against the upper-caste Sarpanch (Panchayat Head). Local village women are led by a feisty young woman Bindu, mother of a young child whose husband has supposedly left her.

Dr. Rao wins the trust of Bindu and other villagers by testing their milk and paying them fair amounts for their high fat-content milk and this irks Mishra. Deshmukh is worried by the caste politics and divide between the upper-castes and Dalits in the village and repeatedly warns Rao against getting involved in it. Chandravarkar gets attracted to a local Dalit girl and has a rendezvous with her in secret. The Dalits don't want to join the cooperative as they feel that the upper-caste Sarpanch and his cronies will usurp the society as well. Rao and his associates talk sense into them and organise an election for the post of the head of the cooperative. Bhola begins to trust and believe in Rao's ideals when Rao fires Chandravarkar for cheating the Dalit girl on the pretext of marrying her and bails Bhola out of jail when Sarpanch gets him arrested for rowdy behaviour.

Meanwhile, a mutual admiration and liking develops between Rao and Bindu, which is cut short when Bindu's husband returns home suddenly, and Rao's wife comes to visit him in the village. In the election, the Dalit representative Moti (nominated by Bhola) defeats the Sarpanch in a tiebreaker and the Dalits erupt in joy. The Sarpanch takes the loss terribly on his ego and joins Mishra, also aided by Bindu's husband. Together, they manipulate Bindu into putting her thumb impression on legal papers that claim Dr. Rao has raped her. Dr. Rao is extremely agitated when the allegations are brought against him and starts to wonder if he has bitten off more than he can chew. His wife also falls sick with Typhoid. Dr. Rao finishes the setting up of the board and leaves with his wife, greatly troubling Bhola. Bhola, however, continues to carry on the work of the cooperative with support from a few villagers and notably, Bindu. Both of them have been inspired and churned as new, brave individuals by the work of Dr. Rao.

Cast

[edit]

Development and production

[edit]

The word manthan literally means "churning", and other meanings may be deep contemplation, the churning of facts, analysis aimed at a solution, or conclusion. The film traces a small set of poor farmers of Kheda district in Gujarat who had the vision and foresight to act in a way that was good for the society and not for the self alone. Under leaders like local social worker Tribhovandas Patel, who took up the cause of the farmers, lead to the formation of Kaira District Co-operative Milk Producers' Union. Soon the pattern was repeated in each district of Gujarat, which in turn led to the formation of Amul, a dairy cooperative in Anand, Gujarat in 1946, which is today, jointly owned by some 2.6 million milk producers in Gujarat, India.[12]

Eventually, this led to the initiation of White Revolution of India in 1970, by creating a "Nationwide Milk Grid", and the setting up of Gujarat Co-operative Milk Marketing Federation Ltd. (GCMMF) in 1973, whose 500,000 members jointly financed the film, by donating Rs. 2 each.[2][3] Upon its release, truckloads of farmers came to see "their" film, thus making it a box office success.[2][13]

Release

[edit]

The film was released on Blu-ray by the UK-based distributor Second Run on 27 October 2025, based on the 4K restoration by Film Heritage Foundation.[14][15]

Restoration

[edit]

The film was restored by Film Heritage Foundation at Prasad Studios, Chennai and L’Immagine Ritrovata Laboratory, in association with Gujarat Co-operative Milk Marketing Federation Ltd. (Amul), cinematographer Govind Nihalani, and director Shyam Benegal.[16] The film was shot on Gevacolor, Eastman, and Kodak in the 1970s. The original camera negative from the NFAI and a 35 mm print preserved at the Film Heritage Foundation archive were used for the restoration.[17]

The film was repaired by FHF conservators. Prasad Lab in Chennai performed scanning and digital clean-up under the supervision of the Bologna-based L'Immagine Ritrovata lab. The restored version was selected for a world premiere at the Cannes Film Festival 2024‘s Cannes Classics strand.[18] A special premiere of the restored film was held on World Milk Day - June 1, 2024 - at Eros Cinema in Mumbai that was attended by Shyam Benegal and the cast and crew of the film. The film was released in 51 cities and 101 cinemas across India on June 1 and 2, 2024.[19]

Soundtrack

[edit]

All music is composed by Vanraj Bhatia.

No.TitlePlaybackLength
1."Mero Gaam Katha Parey"Preeti Sagar 

Awards and nominations

[edit]
Year Award Category Nominee(s) Result
1976 National Film Awards Best Feature Film in Hindi Shyam Benegal Won
Best Screenplay Vijay Tendulkar Won
1978 Filmfare Awards Best Female Playback Singer Preeti Sagar (For Mero Gaam Katha Parey) Won

Further reading

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Manthan

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
(English: The Churning), released in 1976, is a Hindi-language film directed by that portrays the initiation of a cooperative in a village by an idealistic , highlighting rural economic empowerment and social tensions including and class divides. The narrative draws from the real-life , India's Operation Flood program led by , which transformed dairy farming through cooperatives like and elevated millions of rural producers. Produced with innovative from approximately 500,000 farmers via the , each contributing two rupees, Manthan marked the first such collective financing of an Indian feature film. Featuring realistic performances by as the Dr. Rao, as a village woman embodying resilience, and in a supporting role, the film blends documentary-style authenticity with dramatic exploration of patriarchal structures and community mobilization. Its 2024 4K restoration premiered in the Cannes Classics section, affirming its enduring relevance in depicting grassroots development and social reform without romanticization.

Historical and Inspirational Context

Origins in the White Revolution

The , officially designated as Operation Flood, was initiated on January 13, 1970, by India's (NDDB) under the leadership of , with the objective of achieving milk self-sufficiency through a nationwide network of farmer-owned cooperatives modeled on the successful Anand Milk Union Limited () in . This program addressed chronic milk shortages by emphasizing collective procurement, processing, and distribution, transforming from a net importer to the world's largest milk producer by the 1990s, with annual procurement rising from 190,000 tons in 1970 to millions of tons thereafter. The initiative's core principle—empowering small-scale dairy farmers via democratic cooperatives—directly informed the conceptual origins of Manthan, positioning the film as a narrative extension of these real-world efforts to foster rural economic autonomy. Manthan emerged specifically as an NDDB-commissioned project in 1976 to propagate the ethos underpinning Operation Flood, portraying the establishment of a village-level union amid resistance from traditional power structures. The film's script, drawing from the socio-economic dynamics observed in Gujarat's districts, fictionalized the arrival of a veterinary expert to organize farmers, mirroring Kurien's strategies in replicating Amul's framework across states. This origin reflected NDDB's strategic use of cinema for outreach, as the board sought to accelerate adoption of practices by illustrating their potential to alleviate and dependency on exploitative intermediaries, a challenge Operation Flood had empirically tackled since 1970. Funded innovatively through contributions of two rupees each from approximately 500,000 Gujarat dairy farmers—many affiliated with —the production exemplified the participatory model it aimed to promote, ensuring grassroots buy-in and alignment with goals. Post-release, Manthan was screened extensively in rural via portable projectors to educate producers on cooperative benefits, contributing to heightened enrollment in NDDB programs and underscoring the film's role as a deliberate artifact of the revolution's expansion phase.

Verghese Kurien and the NDDB's Involvement

, often called the "Milkman of " for leading Operation Flood—the program that transformed into the world's largest milk producer—served as chairman of the (NDDB) from its inception in 1965 and directly commissioned Manthan to illustrate the dairy cooperative model's triumphs and challenges. Established to replicate the cooperative's success in , the NDDB under Kurien viewed the film as a tool for ideological outreach, depicting how rural communities could achieve economic self-reliance through collective ownership of milk processing rather than dependence on exploitative middlemen. Kurien's vision drew from his hands-on role in founding the Kaira District Co-operative Milk Producers' Union () in 1946, which emphasized farmer control and technological upgrades like veterinary services and chilling plants, principles mirrored in the film's narrative of an idealistic veterinarian organizing villagers. To fund production, Kurien directed the NDDB to collect two rupees from each of approximately 500,000 dairy farmers via deductions at milk collection centers in 1975, amassing roughly one million rupees (equivalent to about $120,000 at the time) without relying on subsidies or private investors. This approach aligned with Kurien's philosophy of , ensuring the film resonated as a endeavor among the very producers it portrayed, and positioned Manthan as the first crowdfunded feature film globally. The NDDB retained production oversight, collaborating with director to maintain fidelity to real events, including caste-based social tensions and resistance from local elites that Kurien had navigated during Amul's expansion. Post-release in 1976, the NDDB deployed mobile projection teams to screen Manthan free of charge in over villages, using it to recruit new cooperatives and demonstrate tangible benefits like steady and community empowerment, which contributed to Operation Flood's scaling from three million tons of milk procurement in 1970 to over 20 million tons by 1990. Kurien personally endorsed the film, later urging Benegal to produce a exploring the movement's evolution, reflecting his belief in cinema's role in sustaining mobilization. This strategic involvement underscored Kurien's broader strategy of blending technical innovation with cultural narrative to counter skepticism toward cooperatives, prioritizing empirical outcomes like increased rural s over top-down directives.

Production

Development Process

Shyam Benegal conceived the idea for Manthan after producing documentaries on Operation Flood, the dairy development program spearheaded by Verghese Kurien, aiming to create a narrative feature film that illustrated the cooperative movement's transformative effects on rural communities. Kurien, as chairman of the National Dairy Development Board (NDDB), supported the project, viewing it as a means to propagate the model's success and farmer empowerment against exploitative middlemen. Discussions between Benegal and Kurien focused on production costs, with Kurien committing NDDB resources and proposing the unprecedented funding mechanism of soliciting small contributions from participating farmers. The screenplay was developed collaboratively, with , a noted Marathi , tasked with writing the script; he produced multiple drafts depicting the social and economic churning in a village, and Benegal selected the version that best balanced realism and dramatic tension. This process emphasized authentic portrayal of dynamics, drawing from real events in where Amul's model originated under Kurien's guidance in the 1940s and expanded nationally via NDDB from 1970. The film's agenda-driven nature, as a tool for social mobilization rather than pure entertainment, influenced decisions on casting non-professional locals alongside established actors to enhance .

Innovative Funding Model

The production of Manthan pioneered a grassroots crowdfunding approach in Indian cinema, with funding sourced directly from the dairy farming community it depicted. In 1976, approximately 500,000 milk producers affiliated with Gujarat's cooperative societies contributed two rupees each, totaling around 10 lakh rupees to cover the film's budget. This mechanism was orchestrated by the (NDDB) under , who arranged for the deductions to be made at village-level milk collection centers, ensuring broad participation without individual financial strain. The model's innovation lay in its alignment with cooperative principles, transforming passive beneficiaries of the into active stakeholders and owners of the narrative medium. This financing deviated from conventional state or private sponsorship prevalent in of the era, emphasizing collective agency over top-down patronage. The explicitly acknowledged the contributors as producers, fostering a sense of shared authorship that mirrored the film's themes of rural . NDDB's involvement extended beyond to distribution, screening the film in over 4,000 villages to reinforce , though critics later noted its promotional undertones for the dairy movement. The approach demonstrated scalability of micro-contributions for cultural projects, predating modern platforms by decades, and underscored empirical viability of decentralized in resource-constrained contexts.

Filming and Technical Aspects

Manthan was primarily filmed on location in Sanganva, a rural village approximately 26 kilometers from in , , to capture the authentic environment of the dairy cooperative movement. spanned 45 days, during which the production team integrated local farmers and villagers as extras and supporting actors to enhance realism. Actors, including lead performers, wore the same clothing throughout the schedule to maintain visual continuity and immerse in the village's daily hardships. The shoot faced constraints from a limited budget of around ₹10 , necessitating efficient operations and reliance on non-professional locals, which contributed to the film's raw, documentary-style aesthetic. Cinematographer employed handheld and natural-light techniques to document rural life unvarnished, emphasizing stark landscapes and community interactions without stylized embellishments. Technically, the film was shot in on 35mm , yielding a runtime of 134 minutes. This format supported Nihalani's vivid color palette, which highlighted Gujarat's arid terrain and cooperative activities, later preserved through restorations using the original camera negative. The approach prioritized causal fidelity to real events over dramatic artifice, aligning with the film's advocacy for economic .

Narrative and Content

Plot Summary

Dr. Rao, a young veterinary surgeon portrayed by , arrives by train in a remote village in Gujarat's to spearhead the formation of a dairy cooperative aimed at liberating local farmers from exploitative middlemen. The villagers, primarily impoverished cattle rearers, have long been under the thumb of Mishraji, a domineering trader played by , who purchases their at undervalued prices, compounded by indebtedness to the village panchayat head. Dr. Rao's initiative seeks to enable direct sales to urban markets, rewarding milk quality and fostering economic self-sufficiency through . Initial efforts encounter staunch opposition fueled by entrenched caste hierarchies, skepticism toward urban interlopers, and vested interests of local elites. Key figures include Bindu, a strong-willed woman and single mother enacted by , who initially resists due to personal vulnerabilities, and Bhola, a defiant low-caste youth played by , embodying grassroots rebellion. Tensions escalate with incidents such as the poisoning of Bindu's cow by her returning husband, highlighting interpersonal and social fractures. Dr. Rao, assisted by a local social worker akin to , persists by providing veterinary aid, conducting awareness sessions on and breeding, and navigating village politics rife with false accusations. A subtle romantic tension emerges between Dr. Rao and Bindu, underscoring themes of cross-class affinity, yet remains unfulfilled amid societal constraints. As yields to participation, the solidifies, transforming erstwhile adversaries into stakeholders and culminating in the villagers' triumphant march symbolizing unity and autonomy. Dr. Rao's eventual quiet departure leaves behind a self-sustaining movement, reflective of the real-world ethos that propelled India's .

Cast and Performances

portrayed Dr. Manohar Rao, the idealistic veterinary surgeon who arrives in the village to establish a dairy . played Bindu, a resilient Harijan woman who emerges as a leader in the cooperative movement. enacted Bhola, a simple rural buffalo herder whose loyalty and evolving awareness drive key conflicts. Supporting roles included as the exploitative village moneylender Mishra, as Chandravarkar, in a antagonistic capacity, and as Rao's urban colleague. Performances emphasized naturalistic restraint and rural authenticity, with minimal dialogue amplifying subtle expressions and body language. Karnad's portrayal of Rao was restrained and adaptable to village dynamics, though often overshadowed by Shah's intensity. Shah delivered a standout as Bhola, modulating speech to convey , , and tentative through expressive gestures and physicality. Patil's Bindu conveyed a spectrum of emotions—from protective ferocity and verbal confrontations to understated sensuality and silent resolve—defying conventional cinematic tropes for rural women and infusing the role with raw and simmering defiance. Puri's moneylender exuded menace through piercing stares and deliberate drawls, establishing his screen presence as a calculating opportunist. Agashe's urban interloper was marked by awkward gestures and shrugs, highlighting cultural disconnects. Overall, the ensemble contributed to the film's documentary-like realism, praised for originality in character interpretation amid and economic tensions.

Thematic Analysis

Promotion of Cooperative Economics

The film Manthan portrays as a mechanism for rural , depicting the establishment of a village-level that enables small-scale farmers to bypass exploitative middlemen and secure fair prices through and management. In the narrative, the , Dr. Rao—a veterinary surgeon inspired by —arrives in a village to organize farmers into a society, emphasizing democratic and profit-sharing among members rather than reliance on urban capitalists or local traders who previously dictated terms and retained most earnings. This model is shown to foster economic , with villagers pooling resources to build a collection center and processing unit, leading to increased incomes and reinvestment in community infrastructure. Central to the film's is the cooperative's in addressing power imbalances in the dairy , where individual farmers previously sold at low, fluctuating rates to dominant traders, resulting in chronic and indebtedness. By contrast, the cooperative introduces standardized , veterinary support, and marketing linkages, transforming from a subsistence product into a viable that generates surplus for reinvestment. The story illustrates causal links between and outcomes: initial resistance from caste-based hierarchies and vested interests gives way to broad participation, including from marginalized groups, as tangible benefits like timely payments and improvements materialize, underscoring cooperatives' potential to disrupt feudal economic structures without external dependency. Manthan's production reinforced its promotional message, as it was crowdfunded by approximately 500,000 members of Gujarat's dairy cooperatives, each contributing ₹2 (about US$0.25 at the time), marking it as the world's first financed through grassroots investment. This real-world application of the not only minimized financial risk for the (NDDB) but also embedded authenticity, with proceeds intended to support further cooperative expansion. The film's release in rural areas, often paired with educational screenings by NDDB teams, amplified its impact, inspiring an estimated millions of farmers nationwide to replicate the model, contributing to India's output rising from 21 million tonnes in 1970 to over 100 million tonnes by the 2000s through federated cooperatives like . Critically, while Manthan idealizes the as a for rural underdevelopment, it acknowledges challenges such as internal conflicts over leadership and , reflecting real tensions in early NDDB initiatives where risked undermining democratic ideals. Nonetheless, empirical evidence from the validates the film's core thesis: cooperatives achieved scale efficiencies, with Gujarat's federation processing over 25 million liters of daily by 2020, empowering 3.6 million farmers through equitable distribution and technical upgrades, in contrast to state-led or private models that often favored large producers. This promotion of producer-owned enterprises over hierarchical alternatives aligns with observed successes in reducing rural migration and enhancing nutritional security in participating regions.

Depiction of Social Dynamics

Manthan portrays rural Indian society as stratified by rigid , class, and hierarchies, where dominant upper castes and economic elites maintain control over resources and , often exploiting lower castes and the poor through traditional trading systems. The arrival of veterinary doctor Rao disrupts these dynamics by advocating for a model that insists on egalitarian participation, forcing villagers to confront entrenched power structures such as the sarpanch's authority and separate milking lines for Dalits enforced by upper-caste leaders. Caste dynamics are central, with Dalit characters initially skeptical of the cooperative due to fears of continued exploitation by higher castes like the Thakurs, who hold political and economic sway in the village. Bhola, a Dalit youth played by Naseeruddin Shah, embodies this tension, doubting Rao's outsider intentions but eventually emerging as a leader by contesting elections and championing collective ownership, thus depicting Dalits not as passive victims but as active agents in social transformation. Class conflicts arise from the exploitative practices of milk traders like , who profit from unequal pricing and indebtedness of small farmers, a system the counters by eliminating middlemen and promoting fair among producers. This economic shift threatens the rural elite's dominance, illustrating how fosters class mobility for impoverished herders while exposing the fragility of feudal-like dependencies. Gender hierarchies are depicted through characters like Bindu, a woman who asserts agency by restarting the after setbacks and resisting patriarchal manipulations, challenging stereotypes of female passivity in rural settings. In contrast, Rao's urban wife exhibits casteist attitudes and detachment from village life, underscoring intersecting oppressions that the 's inclusive ethos begins to erode, though not without resistance from traditional norms. Overall, the film illustrates social churning as a contentious process, where the dairy cooperative serves as a catalyst for , enabling lower castes, the economically disadvantaged, and women to negotiate power against dominant groups, though it highlights the persistence of dialectics between progress and backlash in rural .

Critiques and Limitations

Despite its artistic merits, Manthan has been critiqued for its propagandistic undertones, largely due to its funding by the (NDDB), which solicited Rs. 2 contributions from 500,000 milk producers to finance the Rs. 10 lakh production, explicitly aiming to promote the cooperative dairy model of Operation Flood. Journalist John Dayal, in a contemporary , labeled it a "propaganda movie for Gujarat's milk cooperative federation," contending that director remained "very soft in his critique of the system" amid rural exploitation and struggles, especially given the film's release during the 1975–1977 period. Benegal himself later confirmed the NDDB's deployment of the film as a tool for propagating its developmental agenda. Analyses framing Manthan as a postcolonial realist work highlight narrative limitations in depicting developmental interventions, noting an overreliance on the Dr. Manohar Rao's external , which can infantilize rural subjects by portraying them as requiring elite guidance to overcome feudal resistance. The film's optimistic cooperative triumph, while grounded in real events, is seen to romanticize policy outcomes, underemphasizing how statist initiatives like Operation Flood often failed to penetrate deep-seated hierarchies and local power structures, as evidenced by persistent villager skepticism toward bureaucratic outsiders. In terms of , the film's handling of and dynamics—such as Dalit characters' confrontations with upper-caste elites and women's roles in —has drawn mixed scholarly assessment, with some arguing it prioritizes economic mobilization over dissecting entrenched patriarchal or -based oppressions, potentially simplifying subaltern agency into reformist narratives rather than radical critique. This approach, while innovative for 1976 , limits deeper causal exploration of how cooperatives might replicate existing inequalities without broader structural reforms.

Music and Artistic Elements

Soundtrack Composition

The soundtrack for Manthan was composed by , a Mumbai-born musician trained in Western at institutions including the Royal Academy of Music in , who collaborated extensively with director following their work on Ankur (1974). Bhatia's score emphasized and regional folk elements to align with the film's depiction of rural and the cooperative dairy movement, blending traditional melodies with subtle contemporary orchestration to evoke authenticity without overpowering the narrative. The composition features sparse songs integrated into the storyline, with the standout track "Mero Gaam Katha Parey" (also rendered as "Mero Gaam Kaatha Paarey"), a folk-style sung by (sometimes credited as Priti Sagar), whose voice Bhatia selected for its suitability to the theme. Lyrics for the song were penned by Neeti Sagar (or Niti Sagar), drawing on Gujarati rural idioms to underscore themes of community and longing for progress. This track recurs thematically throughout the film, serving both as a diegetic element sung by villagers and a that reinforces the ethos, with Bhatia layering it over scenes of and social mobilization. Bhatia's approach prioritized instrumental restraint, using acoustic elements like folk percussion and strings to mirror the film's realist aesthetic, avoiding the orchestral excess common in commercial of the era. The overall score, clocking under 30 minutes including vocals, was recorded in 1976 prior to the film's release on of that year, and has been noted for its enduring simplicity, with "Mero Gaam Katha Parey" nominated for a Award in the folk song category. No additional playback singers or major songs beyond this core piece are documented in primary credits, reflecting Benegal's preference for integrated, non-intrusive music that prioritized documentary-like over musical .

Cinematography and Style

Govind Nihalani served as the cinematographer for Manthan, employing a neorealist approach that emphasized authenticity in portraying rural Gujarat's landscapes and . His work featured dynamic camera movements, transitioning from expansive panoramic shots of village cooperatives and operations to intimate close-ups that captured the nuances of farmers' expressions and interactions, fostering a documentary-like immersion in the narrative. This technique of varied shot types and strategic framing highlighted spatial relationships and communal activities, underscoring the film's themes of grassroots empowerment without ornate visual flourishes. Budget limitations during the 45-day location shoot necessitated the use of a of different stocks, which Nihalani adapted to maintain visual consistency amid resource scarcity, contributing to the raw, unpolished aesthetic that mirrored the economic struggles depicted. Strategic was deployed to set tonal atmospheres, with natural daylight dominating exteriors to evoke the harsh yet resilient rural environment, while selective interior illumination amplified emotional tensions in scenes of conflict and cooperation. The overall style aligned with Shyam Benegal's ethos, prioritizing functional simplicity over spectacle to serve the story's socio-political content, as evidenced by visual symbolism—such as motifs of churning representing struggle—that conveyed deeper causal links between individual actions and transformation without overt . Nihalani's contributions thus reinforced the film's realism, blending artistry with empirical depiction of cooperative processes to avoid stylized exaggeration.

Release, Reception, and Awards

Initial Release and Distribution

Manthan premiered theatrically in on September 28, 1976. The film was produced by the Co-operative Milk Marketing Federation Ltd. (GCMMF), with funding raised through small contributions of ₹2 each from roughly 500,000 dairy farmers across , marking it as India's first crowdfunded . This grassroots financing model aligned with the film's narrative on , enabling production without reliance on conventional commercial backers. Distribution emphasized outreach to rural audiences to advance the dairy cooperative agenda. Post-theatrical release, , architect of India's , arranged for 16mm prints to be circulated nationwide to villages, facilitating screenings that doubled as educational tools for the milk producers' movement. This strategy leveraged the film's propagandistic intent, prioritizing ideological dissemination over broad commercial exhibition, though specific theatrical distributors beyond GCMMF's involvement remain undocumented in primary records. International release followed later, with a U.S. debut in October 1980.

Contemporary Reviews and Box Office

Upon its 1976 release, Manthan garnered praise from Indian critics for its authentic portrayal of rural socio-economic dynamics and the cooperative dairy movement, with reviewers highlighting Shyam Benegal's direction, Vijay Tendulkar's , and strong ensemble performances led by and . The film's critical standing was affirmed by its wins at the 24th National Film Awards in 1977, including Best Feature Film in and Best , awards recognizing artistic merit based on contemporary evaluations by a government jury. However, not all reception was unanimous; some 1970s press commentary, such as in outlets like Patriot or Link, critiqued it as overt endorsing the National Dairy Development Board's agenda, reflecting skepticism toward its institutional backing and didactic elements. Financially, Manthan eschewed traditional box office metrics typical of mainstream Hindi cinema, as its ₹10 lakh budget was crowdfunded uniquely by 500,000 Gujarat dairy farmers donating ₹2 each to promote the "White Revolution" model. It recouped costs and achieved success via non-theatrical rural distribution, with mobile Super 8 projectors facilitating screenings in thousands of Gujarat villages, drawing large crowds of investors who traveled by bullock cart. This grassroots approach yielded a "rousing reception" in its primary market, prioritizing outreach over urban earnings, though precise gross figures remain undocumented in available records.

National and International Recognition

Manthan received significant national acclaim through the 24th National Film Awards, presented in 1977 for outstanding films of 1976. The film was awarded the National Film Award for Best Feature Film in Hindi, recognizing director Shyam Benegal's direction and the film's overall contribution to . Additionally, it won the National Film Award for Best for Vijay Tendulkar's original script, which effectively captured the socio-economic themes of rural cooperative movements. These honors underscored the film's artistic merit and its alignment with government-supported initiatives promoting narratives. On the international stage, Manthan was selected as India's official entry for the Best Foreign Language Film category at the in 1977, highlighting its global relevance in depicting grassroots economic reforms, though it did not secure a . The film was screened at the , where it was praised for illustrating cooperative principles applicable to developing economies worldwide. These recognitions affirmed Manthan's role in elevating Indian beyond domestic boundaries, emphasizing authentic portrayals over commercial entertainment.

Restoration and Recent Developments

4K Restoration Process

The 4K restoration of Manthan was undertaken by the Film Heritage Foundation in collaboration with the Gujarat Co-operative Milk Marketing Federation Ltd. (), utilizing the original 35mm camera negative preserved at the National Film Development Corporation-National Film Archive of and a 35mm release print held by the Foundation. The process addressed significant degradation in the source materials, including color fading, green mould growth, flicker, and scratches on the negative, as well as vertical green lines and sync discrepancies from the film's original . Initial physical repair of the damaged negative was performed by Film Heritage Foundation conservators, followed by scanning of the repaired elements using wetgate technology suitable for aged negatives at Prasad Corporation Pvt. Ltd.'s facilities in , under the supervision of specialists from L'Immagine Ritrovata laboratory in . Digital frame-by-frame clean-up to remove dirt, stabilize flicker, and correct defects was conducted at the Chennai lab, while audio elements—lacking a usable sound negative—were digitized from the release print and restored to synchronize with the visuals, accounting for dubbing-era misalignments. Subsequent color grading, final sound restoration, and digital mastering occurred at L'Immagine Ritrovata in , ensuring fidelity to the 's original aesthetic as guided by director and , who participated extensively in approvals. The entire effort spanned approximately 1.5 years, reconstructing the edit by cross-referencing multiple prints to match the director's intended version. Benegal endorsed the result, noting its meticulous recovery of the 's visual and auditory integrity as originally envisioned.

2024 Cannes Premiere and Aftermath

The 4K restored version of Manthan, undertaken by the Film Heritage Foundation, received its world premiere in the Cannes Classics section at the 77th on May 17, 2024. The screening highlighted the film's original crowd-funded origins, with 500,000 dairy farmers contributing ₹2 each in 1976 to finance its production under the auspices of the . Lead actor attended the event, joined by restoration director and managing director , while director was absent due to health concerns. The premiere concluded with a five-minute for Shah and the restoration team, underscoring appreciation for the film's technical revival and thematic resonance. The Cannes screening generated widespread acclaim, with international outlets praising the restored print's clarity—which addressed issues like faded colors and emulsion scratches—and its portrayal of rural empowerment through dairy farming. This positive reception prompted an immediate theatrical re-release in , announced shortly after the festival and executed on June 1 and 2, 2024, coinciding with . Distributed by and across approximately 50 cities and 100 screens, the limited run drew new audiences, including younger viewers unfamiliar with the 1976 original, and reinforced the film's ties to Amul's ongoing model as the brand marked its 50th anniversary. Post-re-release commentary from participants, such as , emphasized the version's enhanced visual and auditory fidelity, which preserved the authenticity of non-professional rural actors while amplifying the narrative's critique of and economic hierarchies.

Legacy and Broader Impact

Influence on Indian Cinema

Manthan (1976), directed by , exemplified the parallel cinema movement's emphasis on by depicting rural India's cooperative dairy revolution through a documentary-like lens, influencing filmmakers to prioritize authentic portrayals of , class, and economic struggles over commercial formulas. Benegal's approach in the film, which integrated non-professional rural actors and regional dialects, set a for grounded narratives that critiqued power dynamics and promoted collective agency, shaping the stylistic and thematic foundations of India's new wave cinema in the and . The film's innovative funding—crowdfunded by approximately 500,000 dairy farmers who each contributed ₹2 (equivalent to about ₹200 in 2024 terms)—pioneered community-based financing in Indian cinema, reducing dependence on urban commercial backers and enabling independent projects aligned with causes. This model not only mirrored the on-screen theme of cooperative self-reliance but also demonstrated the feasibility of collective investment for socially oriented films, inspiring alternative production strategies in that bypassed mainstream studio constraints. Manthan's commercial viability, despite its art-house roots, bridged parallel and mainstream sensibilities, encouraging 'middle cinema' hybrids that blended realism with broader appeal and influencing directors to tackle and themes in subsequent works. Benegal's legacy through the film extended to fostering a cinema of humanistic inquiry, as evidenced by its role in elevating documentaries' narrative techniques into feature films, which persisted in shaping politically engaged Indian .

Real-World Policy and Economic Outcomes

The dairy cooperative model portrayed in Manthan, exemplified by the Anand Milk Union Limited () in , formed the basis for India's Operation Flood program, launched in 1970 under the (NDDB) to replicate the "Anand Pattern" nationwide. This three-tier structure—village-level societies collecting milk, district unions processing it, and state federations marketing—eliminated exploitative middlemen, ensured fair pricing for producers, and integrated smallholder farmers into a market-oriented system. Operation Flood catalyzed a surge in milk production, transforming from a net importer with stagnant output of approximately 21 million tonnes annually in the early —yielding just 110 grams daily—to the world's largest producer. By 1989, domestic milk powder production had risen from 22,000 tonnes pre-project to 140,000 tonnes, with subsequent growth accelerating to 239.3 million tonnes in 2023–24, a 63.6% increase from 146.3 million tonnes in 2014–15. Economically, the model boosted rural incomes and , particularly for women who comprised a significant portion of milk producers, contributing to alleviation in dairy-dependent regions like where Amul's network now procures from over 3.6 million farmers daily. Nationally, generates substantial farm revenue, supporting 80 million smallholders and accounting for India's 24% share of global output at over 230 million tonnes annually, though challenges persist in productivity per animal and . Policy-wise, the success influenced sustained government investment in cooperatives over private or state monopolies, embedding the Anand Pattern in NDDB's expansion to 96,000 village societies by the 1990s, though critics note uneven replication outside due to issues in some federations.

Enduring Relevance and Debates

The themes of rural empowerment and depicted in Manthan continue to resonate in contemporary , where dairy cooperatives modeled on the system sustain livelihoods for millions of small farmers amid persistent economic disparities and agricultural volatility. The film's portrayal of resistance against feudal exploitation mirrors ongoing challenges in rural and resource distribution, as evidenced by the enduring success of Operation Flood, which expanded milk production from 21 million tonnes in 1970 to over 200 million tonnes by 2023 through networks. Its emphasis on technological intervention combined with social mobilization highlights causal mechanisms for alleviation, such as veterinary training and fair pricing, that have influenced policy in developing economies beyond . Debates surrounding Manthan often center on its dual role as artistic realism and promotional tool, given its funding by the (NDDB) and 500,000 dairy farmers contributing two rupees each. Critics from alternative viewpoints have labeled it a piece that idealized state-backed cooperatives while downplaying internal conflicts, such as within societies or over-reliance on bureaucratic oversight, potentially masking exploitative dynamics in the NDDB's expansion. In contrast, scholarly analyses commend its postcolonial realist approach, arguing it authentically captures hierarchies and patriarchal barriers without statist glorification, portraying protagonists as active reformers rather than passive victims. These discussions underscore source biases in film criticism: mainstream outlets like BBC emphasize inspirational narratives tied to verifiable economic outcomes, while outlets skeptical of government interventions, such as independent blogs, highlight unexamined power structures in the cooperative model. The 2024 4K restoration and Cannes screening revived scrutiny of its narrative balance, prompting reflections on whether its optimism holds against modern critiques of cooperative scalability in the face of globalization and climate impacts on dairy farming. Ultimately, empirical data on Amul's growth—handling 26% of India's milk supply via 3.6 million members as of 2023—lends credence to the film's causal depiction of collective efficacy over individualist alternatives.

References

  1. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-69014789
  2. https://frontline.thehindu.com/arts-and-culture/cinema/50-years-of-manthan-caste-class-dialect-revisited-shyam-benegal-dalit-characters-white-revolution-verghese-kurien/article68340034.ece
  3. https://www.lifestyleasia.com/ind/entertainment/movies/manthan-movie-true-story-shyam-benegal/
  4. https://homegrown.co.in/homegrown-voices/manthan-how-a-landmark-1976-indian-film-was-crowdfunded-by-500000-indian-farmers
  5. https://www.festival-cannes.com/en/2024/manthan-the-power-of-the-collective/
  6. https://asianmoviepulse.com/2024/05/film-review-manthan-shyam-benegal/
  7. https://www.thehindu.com/entertainment/movies/how-manthans-depiction-of-class-caste-and-gender-hierarchies-remain-relevant/article68224709.ece
  8. https://www.festival-cannes.com/en/f/manthan/
  9. https://ibef.org/research/case-study/india-s-white-revolution
  10. https://www.worldfoodprize.org/en/laureates/19871999_laureates/1989_kurien/
  11. https://www.outlookindia.com/culture-society/manthan-and-the-art-of-the-propaganda-film
  12. https://ica.coop/en/newsroom/news/cannes-cooperatives-and-story-indias-white-revolution
  13. https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/mumbai-news/manthan-in-cannes-stirs-joy-in-anand-101716665274462.html
  14. https://scroll.in/reel/1040/did-you-know-that-the-first-crowd-sourced-film-came-from-india-in-1976
  15. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/hindi/bollywood/news/shyam-benegal-verghese-kurien-was-fond-of-manthan-and-wanted-me-to-make-a-sequel/articleshow/110825661.cms
  16. https://www.telegraphindia.com/culture/land-of-milk-and-money-manthan-director-shyam-benegal-on-amuls-success-in-gujarat/cid/2029029
  17. https://thebetterindia.com/282666/manthan-movie-making-of-gujarat-amul-dairy-farmers-white-revolution/
  18. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/how-kuriens-idea-led-to-the-making-of-manthan-cammes-film-festival-9352080/
  19. https://www.moneycontrol.com/entertainment/movies/cannes-classics-why-shyam-benegal-manthan-india-first-crowdfunded-film-produced-by-5-lakh-farmers-was-also-an-emergency-movie-article-12721570.html
  20. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/hindi/bollywood/news/manthan-made-on-rs-2-donations/articleshow/16348081.cms
  21. https://poemsindia.substack.com/p/the-benegal-blueprint
  22. https://thebetterindia.com/171583/amul-shyam-benegal-farmers-produced-film/
  23. https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/features/manthan-remaking-a-classic-627020/
  24. https://indianexpress.com/article/long-reads/shyam-benegal-manthan-gujarat-village-9748293/
  25. https://indiancine.ma/RPY/info
  26. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0074858/technical/
  27. https://filmheritagefoundation.co.in/film-heritage-foundation-restores-shyam-benegals-acclaimed-hindi-film-manthan-1976/
  28. https://itpworld.online/2024/11/05/manthan-the-churning-india-hindi-1976/
  29. https://www.thecitizen.in/life/shyam-benegals-classic-manthan-is-born-again-1046908
  30. https://perpendicularcinema.com/2018/11/25/manthan-1976/
  31. https://www.ashokkarania.com/bollywood/manthan-the-amul-story-of-influencing-change-indias-first-crowd-funded-movie/
  32. https://www.moneycontrol.com/entertainment/movies/cannes-2024-manthan-offers-cutting-edge-commentary-on-caste-class-and-cooperative-ownership-article-12728187.html
  33. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0074858/
  34. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0074858/fullcredits/
  35. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/manthan
  36. https://www.thehindu.com/features/cinema/manthan-1976/article3892670.ece
  37. https://www.thehindu.com/entertainment/movies/how-smita-patil-moved-movie-goers-with-her-performance-in-manthan/article68303688.ece
  38. https://indiafellow.org/blog/all-posts/learning-from-manthan-and-co-operative-model/
  39. https://www.thehindu.com/entertainment/movies/shyam-benegals-manthan-based-on-pioneering-milk-cooperative-movement-to-be-showcased-at-cannes-today/article68185824.ece
  40. https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/ahmedabad/manthan-at-cannes-film-festival-amul-model-is-indias-gift-to-the-world-gcmmf-md-jayen-mehta-9337707/
  41. https://www.sociologygroup.com/manthan/
  42. https://www.counterview.net/2025/01/shyam-benegals-manthan-propaganda-film_5.html
  43. https://www.rediff.com/movies/report/shyam-benegal-manthan-is-my-most-influential-film/20240518.htm
  44. https://www.iosrjournals.org/iosr-jhss/papers/Vol.28-Issue3/Ser-8/C2803080913.pdf
  45. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/339442585_Portrayal_of_Dalits_in_Shyam_Benegal_Films_A_Critical_Analysis_of_Ankur_and_Manthan
  46. https://serenademagazine.com/vanraj-bhatia/
  47. https://www.thehindu.com/entertainment/music/vanraj-bhatias-multi-faceted-oeuvre/article34551344.ece
  48. https://cinemawithoutborders.com/the-restored-version-of-manthan-received-a-standing-ovation-at-the-cannes-film-festival/
  49. https://myswar.co/album/manthan-1976
  50. https://ashokdaranade.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/1991-04-06-SNA-Interview-Vanraj-Bhatia.pdf
  51. https://gaana.com/album/manthan
  52. https://atulsongaday.me/2019/01/05/mero-gaam-kaathha-paarey/
  53. https://www.hindilyrics4u.com/music_director/vanraj_bhatia.php
  54. https://www.academymuseum.org/en/programs/detail/manthan-019475cd-1806-1a03-8813-ec1d21a0c294
  55. https://zenodo.org/records/10589120/files/Cinematic%20Techniques.pdf
  56. https://www.newsclick.in/shyam-benegal-pioneer-politically-engaged-cinema
  57. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0074858/releaseinfo/
  58. https://www.hindustantimes.com/entertainment/bollywood/when-shyam-benegal-shared-how-farmers-helped-in-making-manthan-a-success-they-all-would-come-on-bullock-carts-101734966912625.html
  59. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0074858/awards/
  60. https://www.hindustantimes.com/entertainment/bollywood/shyam-benegal-s-manthan-restored-version-of-farmers-funded-classic-shines-at-cannes-101716006920904.html
  61. https://variety.com/2024/film/asia/cannes-classics-the-churning-manthan-restoration-1236006256/
  62. https://www.thehindu.com/entertainment/movies/shyam-benegals-manthan-restored-version-of-farmers-funded-classic-shines-at-cannes/article68189449.ece
  63. https://www.thehindu.com/entertainment/movies/cannes-2024-amul-md-on-restored-manthan-indias-first-crowdfunded-film/article68199081.ece
  64. https://indianexpress.com/article/entertainment/shyam-benegals-restored-version-of-manthan-to-re-release-on-june-1-bookings-open-9354827/
  65. https://www.hindustantimes.com/entertainment/bollywood/after-cannes-2024-premiere-shyam-benegal-s-manthan-set-for-theatrical-re-release-in-india-101716533807417.html
  66. https://morungexpress.com/restored-version-of-manthan-to-be-screened-across-50-indian-cities-on-world-milk-day
  67. https://www.bfi.org.uk/lists/indian-parallel-cinema-essential-directors
  68. https://www.newindianexpress.com/cities/bengaluru/2024/Dec/25/shyam-benegals-lasting-legacy-in-indian-parallel-cinema
  69. https://www.afaqs.com/news/mktg/manthan-returns-in-time-for-amuls-global-launch-to-retell-its-story-to-new-gen-indian-consumers
  70. https://www.ndtv.com/people/shyam-benegal-the-legacy-of-a-visionary-who-shaped-indian-parallel-cinema-7341221
  71. https://countercurrents.org/2024/12/shyam-benegal-the-pioneer-of-parallel-cinema-movement-end-of-an-era/
  72. https://amul.com/m/about-us
  73. https://ijsi.in/articles/milk-revolutionin-gujarat/
  74. https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2172546
  75. https://www.niti.gov.in/sites/default/files/2023-04/Working-Paper-Indias-White-Revolution.pdf
  76. https://www.thebullvine.com/dairy-industry/from-extinction-to-empire-can-u-s-dairy-learn-from-indias-white-revolution/
  77. https://agriculture.institute/cooperative-and-farmers-organizations/amul-cooperative-success-dairy-industry/
  78. https://www.impriindia.com/insights/indian-dairy-sector/
  79. https://ieg.worldbankgroup.org/sites/default/files/Data/reports/India_Dairy.pdf
  80. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1871141309003254
  81. https://www.thehansindia.com/cinema/why-shyam-benegals-manthan-is-more-than-just-a-film-932934
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
Contribute something
User Avatar
No comments yet.