.jpg/250px-G-HAAT_(35321548351).jpg){kind=small}
.jpg)
Community hub
0 subscribers8 pages, 0 posts
Recent from talks
All channels
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Contribute something
Welcome to the community hub built to collect knowledge and have discussions related to NOTAR.
Nothing was collected or created yet.
NOTAR
View on Wikipediafrom Wikipedia
.jpg)
NOTAR ("no tail rotor") is a helicopter system which avoids the use of a tail rotor. It was developed by McDonnell Douglas Helicopter Systems (through their acquisition of Hughes Helicopters). The system uses a fan inside the tail boom to build a high volume of low-pressure air, which exits through two slots and creates a boundary layer flow of air along the tailboom utilizing the Coandă effect. The boundary layer changes the direction of airflow around the tailboom, creating thrust opposite the motion imparted to the fuselage by the torque effect of the main rotor. Directional yaw control is gained through a vented, rotating drum at the end of the tailboom, called the direct jet thruster. Advocates of NOTAR assert that the system offers quieter and safer operation than a traditional tail rotor.[1]
Development
[edit]
The use of directed air to provide anti-torque control had been tested as early as 1945 in the British Cierva W.9. During 1957, a Spanish prototype designed and built by Aerotecnica flew using exhaust gases from the turbine instead of a tail rotor. This model was designated as Aerotecnica AC-14. The Fiat 7005 used a pusher propeller that blew against a cascade of tail vanes at the rear of its fuselage.
Development of the NOTAR system dates back to 1975, when engineers at Hughes Helicopters began concept development work.[2] On December 17, 1981, Hughes flew an OH-6A fitted with NOTAR for the first time. The OH-6A helicopter (serial number 65-12917) was supplied by the U.S. Army for Hughes to develop the NOTAR technology and was the second OH-6 built by Hughes for the U.S. Army. A more heavily modified version of the prototype demonstrator first flew in March 1986 (by which time McDonnell Douglas had acquired Hughes Helicopters). The original prototype last flew in June 1986 and is now at the U.S. Army Aviation Museum in Fort Novosel, Alabama.
A production model NOTAR 520N (N520NT) was later produced and first flew on May 1, 1990. It collided with an Apache AH-64D and crashed on September 27, 1994 while flying as a chase aircraft for the Apache.
Concept
[edit]Although the concept took over three years to refine, the NOTAR system is simple in theory and works to provide some directional control using the Coandă effect.[2][3] A variable pitch fan is enclosed in the aft fuselage section immediately forward of the tail boom and driven by the main rotor transmission. This fan forces low pressure air through two slots on the right side of the tailboom,[notes 1] causing the downwash from the main rotor to hug the tail boom, producing lift, and thus a measure of directional control. This is augmented by a direct jet thruster and vertical stabilisers.
Benefits of the NOTAR system include increased safety (the tail rotor being vulnerable), and greatly reduced external noise as tail rotors on helicopters produce much of the aircraft's sound. NOTAR-equipped helicopters are among the quietest helicopters certified by FAA.[4]
-
1 Air intake 2 Variable pitch fan 3 Tail boom with Coandă Slots 4 Vertical stabilizers 5 Direct jet thruster 6 Downwash 7 Circulation control tailboom cross-section 8 Anti-torque lift -
Diagram showing the movement of air through the NOTAR system -
Applications
[edit].jpg)
There are several production helicopters that utilize the NOTAR system, which are produced by MD Helicopters:
- MD 530N: a 2025 NOTAR variant of the Hughes/MD500 series helicopter powered by the Rolls-Royce C30 engine
- MD 520N: a NOTAR variant of the Hughes/MD500 series helicopter
- MD 600N: a larger version of the MD 520N
- MD Explorer: a twin-engine, eight-seat light helicopter
See also
[edit]Notes
[edit]- ^ NOTAR is an American-designed system and so this is true for American-made helicopters whose main rotors rotate counterclockwise (viewed from above). Many helicopters made elsewhere, such as France and Russia, have clockwise rotating main rotors and with the opposite resultant torque would require the slots to be on the left.
References
[edit]
Wikimedia Commons has media related to NOTAR.
- ^ "NOTAR Helicopter Design". Kulikov Aircraft Design. 7 January 2000. Archived from the original on 27 May 2000.
- ^ a b Frawley, Gerard: The International Directory of Civil Aircraft, 2003–2004, page 155. Aerospace Publications Pty Ltd, 2003. ISBN 1-875671-58-7
- ^ "NOTAR Technology". MD Helicopters. 2006. Archived from the original on 12 March 2007.
- ^ Federal Aviation Administration. "AC 36-1H - Noise Levels for U.S. Certificated and Foreign Aircraft". Retrieved 27 June 2022.
NOTAR
View on Grokipediafrom Grokipedia
NOTAR, an acronym for "No Tail Rotor," is a patented anti-torque system for helicopters that replaces the conventional tail rotor with a combination of pressurized airflow and aerodynamic effects to counteract the main rotor's torque, thereby providing yaw control without exposed rotating blades. Developed by Hughes Helicopters (later McDonnell Douglas Helicopter Systems, now MD Helicopters) starting in 1975, the technology—exclusively used by MD Helicopters—draws low-pressure air through an intake behind the main rotor mast, where a variable-pitch fan pressurizes the tail boom and directs the airflow through longitudinal slots on the boom's right side, leveraging the Coandă effect to generate a lateral force that adheres to the boom's surface and creates up to 60% of the required anti-torque in hover.[1][2] The remaining directional control is achieved via a rotating direct jet thruster at the tail boom's end, which expels air for precise yaw adjustments, while fixed vertical stabilizers contribute to stability during forward flight.[1]
The system was first flight-tested on a modified OH-6 helicopter in 1975, with initial full-scale demonstration in 1981, leading to the certification of the first production model, the MD 520N, in September 1991.[3][1] NOTAR-equipped helicopters, such as the MD 520N, MD 600N, and MD Explorer series, provide benefits including reduced noise, improved safety, and simplified maintenance, though challenges like higher costs and specialized training have constrained broader adoption.[4][1][5][2]
History and Development
Origins and Invention
Helicopters generate significant torque from their main rotors, necessitating an anti-torque mechanism to maintain directional control and prevent uncontrolled yaw. Conventional tail rotors, while effective, introduce mechanical complexity through additional drive systems, gearboxes, and maintenance requirements, increasing overall aircraft weight and operational costs.[6] Furthermore, tail rotors are vulnerable to damage from foreign object debris, ground strikes, or collisions in confined spaces, contributing to a notable portion of non-combat helicopter accidents due to phenomena like loss of tail rotor effectiveness (LTE).[7] Tail rotors also produce high noise levels, particularly in urban environments, where their impulsive blade-vortex interactions amplify community disturbance and limit operational acceptability for civil and law enforcement applications. The NOTAR (No Tail Rotor) system originated as an innovative solution to these challenges, conceived by engineers at McDonnell Douglas Helicopter Company (MDHC, formerly Hughes Helicopters) in the mid-1970s. Development began in 1975 as a company-funded Independent Research and Development (IRAD) program aimed at evaluating circulation control rotor (CCR) principles for anti-torque generation, leveraging blowing along the tail boom to manipulate airflow without mechanical rotors.[6] This approach built on foundational CCR concepts, where a high-velocity jet adheres to a curved surface via the Coanda effect to enhance circulation and control forces. The system's invention was formalized with the issuance of a key U.S. patent in April 1980, crediting MDHC for the integrated design combining internal circulation control with direct jet thrust.[6] Early theoretical work for NOTAR drew heavily from NASA's rotor research in the 1960s, particularly studies at the Ames Research Center exploring circulation control for advanced rotorcraft configurations. Researchers at Ames conducted wind tunnel tests on Coanda jet applications to airfoils and rotors, demonstrating potential for improved lift and control through boundary layer manipulation, as detailed in seminal investigations from the era.[8] These efforts, including analyses of turbulent Coanda jets for rotor augmentation, provided the aerodynamic groundwork that MDHC adapted for tail boom anti-torque, shifting focus from traditional mechanical solutions to fluidic control.[9] Between 1975 and 1980, MDHC conducted initial conceptual sketches, analytical modeling, and feasibility studies to validate NOTAR's viability, with bench testing at the Culver City whirl tower commencing in August 1976 to gather baseline aerodynamic data.[6] A primary motivation was reducing urban noise pollution from tail rotors, aligning with growing regulatory pressures for quieter helicopters in civilian airspace; early simulations projected significant decibel reductions through elimination of tail rotor blade passage noise.[6] By December 1977, conceptual flight evaluations confirmed the approach's promise, paving the way for subsequent government-contracted validation while addressing safety concerns in noise-sensitive operations.[6]Key Milestones and Prototypes
The development of the NOTAR system advanced through a series of prototypes and testing phases in the 1980s and early 1990s, beginning with integration onto the MD 500 series helicopter. In 1981, McDonnell Douglas Helicopter Systems (MDHS) modified an MD 500 (derived from the Hughes OH-6) as the first full-scale prototype, incorporating the NOTAR anti-torque mechanism in place of a conventional tail rotor. Ground tests on this prototype successfully demonstrated yaw control capabilities, utilizing circulation control airflow along the tail boom to counteract main rotor torque without mechanical components, marking a critical validation of the system's feasibility for directional stability.[10] Subsequent testing expanded to aerodynamic validations and flight trials. Throughout the 1980s, MDHS conducted wind tunnel tests at its facilities to refine the NOTAR design, confirming the effectiveness of the Coanda effect in generating sufficient anti-torque thrust via slotted tail boom airflow, which addressed challenges like downwash separation and supported overall system efficiency. These empirical evaluations built on the basic anti-torque requirements of single-rotor helicopters by proving NOTAR's practical implementation. Flight testing milestones followed, with the maiden flight of the MD 520N prototype—a production-oriented NOTAR-equipped model—occurring on May 1, 1990, followed by extensive evaluations that demonstrated reliable handling and reduced noise compared to tail-rotor designs.[11] Certification efforts culminated in 1991, when the MD 520N achieved FAA type certification on September 13, becoming the first single-main-rotor helicopter to operate without a tail rotor under full regulatory approval. This milestone validated NOTAR for commercial use, with initial deliveries commencing later that year to operators including police departments. Following the 1997 merger of McDonnell Douglas with Boeing, collaborative efforts under the new Boeing MD Helicopters entity led to the certification of the MD 600N on May 15, 1997, an enlarged NOTAR variant offering enhanced performance and capacity while retaining the core anti-torque principles tested in prior prototypes.[12][13][10][14]Evolution Post-Merger
Following the 1997 merger between Boeing and McDonnell Douglas, the civilian helicopter division—including production of NOTAR-equipped models such as the MD 520N, MD 600N, and MD Explorer—was transferred to RDM Holdings, a Dutch firm, in 1999 as Boeing divested non-core assets to streamline operations.[15] This shift positioned the new entity, later rebranded as MD Helicopters under various ownership changes, to prioritize commercialization in civilian sectors like law enforcement and utility missions, where NOTAR's reduced noise and enhanced safety offered competitive edges over traditional tail rotor designs.[15] Boeing retained intellectual property rights to the NOTAR system but licensed its use, enabling continued integration into MD's light helicopter lineup for broader market accessibility.[16] In the 2000s, MD Helicopters encountered significant economic hurdles, including ownership instability after RDM's bankruptcy in 2003 and subsequent acquisition by Patriarch Partners in 2005, which exacerbated parts shortages and led to production slowdowns.[15] These factors contributed to operational challenges, such as idle aircraft among operators due to support issues, limiting overall output; by 2010, NOTAR-equipped helicopters totaled around 250 units across models, with the MD 520N alone reaching approximately 102 airframes by mid-2006 and few additional deliveries in the ensuing years amid market contraction.[17][18] Further challenges arose in 2022 when MD Helicopters filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection before emerging later that year under new ownership by an investment consortium led by MBIA Insurance Corp., Bardin Hill Investment Partners LP, and MB Global Partners.[19] Revival efforts intensified in the mid-2020s under this ownership, focusing on upgrades to extend the viability of existing NOTAR fleets for niche roles in police and training operations. In 2020, MD introduced glass cockpit solutions for the MD 520N, integrating digital avionics to mitigate obsolescence in legacy systems and improve pilot situational awareness.[20] Subsequent enhancements included a 2023 engine retrofit program upgrading the MD 520N's Rolls-Royce 250-C20 to the more powerful C30, boosting hot-and-high performance by up to 50% while reducing operating costs.[21] By 2025, these initiatives culminated in the MD 530N variant, a direct evolution of the MD 520N with enhanced power and efficiency, supporting ongoing low-volume production of roughly 20 units annually tailored to specialized civilian demands.[22]Technical Principles
Anti-Torque Fundamentals
In single-rotor helicopters, the main rotor generates lift by rotating and imparting momentum to the air downward, which, per Newton's third law of motion, produces an equal and opposite torque on the helicopter fuselage. This torque reaction causes the body to yaw uncontrollably in the direction opposite to the main rotor's rotation unless counteracted.[23][24] Traditional anti-torque systems address this by using a tail rotor mounted at the end of the tail boom to produce a lateral thrust force, creating a counter-torque moment about the helicopter's center of gravity. The magnitude of this thrust required to balance the main rotor torque is determined by the equation , where is the moment arm—the perpendicular distance from the main rotor's axis of rotation to the line of action of the tail rotor thrust.[25][26] The NOTAR (No Tail Rotor) system fundamentally replaces this mechanical tail rotor with an internal aerodynamic mechanism that achieves equivalent directional stability and yaw control through pressurized airflow directed within the tail boom structure. Instead of relying on exposed blades to generate thrust via angular momentum, NOTAR employs engine-driven fans to supply low-pressure air that is selectively exhausted to produce counteracting forces, eliminating the vulnerabilities associated with rotating components while maintaining full anti-torque capability.[27][6] At its core, NOTAR's yaw control operates by creating differential pressure across the opposing sides of the tail boom, where modulated airflow generates an asymmetric side force sufficient to oppose the main rotor torque entirely. This approach leverages the tail boom's geometry to direct air jets that induce pressure imbalances, providing precise directional control without mechanical linkages to external rotors.[6][27]Circulation Control and Coanda Effect
The Coandă effect describes the tendency of a fluid jet to attach to and follow a nearby curved surface, resulting from the entrainment of surrounding fluid that creates a pressure gradient and accelerates the flow along the surface. This attachment energizes the boundary layer, delaying separation and thereby increasing lift or side force on the surface.[5] In the NOTAR system, the Coandă effect enables yaw control by directing high-velocity air through narrow slots positioned along the length of the tail boom. The ejected air adheres to the boom's curved surface, generating asymmetric circulation that produces a lateral force to counteract main rotor torque. This circulation is amplified by the main rotor's downwash, which helps maintain flow attachment and enhances the overall anti-torque effectiveness without relying on rotating components.[28] The aerodynamic performance of this circulation control mechanism is quantified by the blowing coefficient , which measures the jet momentum relative to the dynamic pressure over the reference area: Here, represents the mass flow rate of the blown air, the jet velocity, the ambient air density, the freestream velocity (often the rotor downwash speed), and the tail boom's effective surface area. Higher values of (typically around 0.4 for optimal operation) correlate with greater side force coefficients, though efficiency peaks when balancing jet momentum against power input.[28] This approach offers higher efficiency in low-speed flight regimes compared to conventional mechanical tail rotors, as the Coandă-based circulation generates required lateral forces with reduced energy expenditure by leveraging surface-attached flow rather than direct propulsion.[5]Jet Thrust Augmentation
In the NOTAR system, the direct jet thrust serves as a supplemental yaw control mechanism, directing vectored exhaust from nozzles at the tail boom tip to generate sideways force opposing main rotor torque. This thruster is particularly engaged during high-power operations like takeoff and sustained hover, where increased anti-torque demands exceed what circulation control alone can provide.[27] Air for the jet thruster is supplied by a shaft-driven variable-pitch fan within the tail boom, which draws ambient air and routes a portion through the rotating drum-like nozzles for precise directional control. In hover, this direct jet contributes approximately 40% of the total anti-torque force, complementing the circulation control to achieve full authority without mechanical tail rotor components.[27][2] The thrust generated by the jet follows the fundamental momentum equation: where is the thrust force, is the mass flow rate of the exiting air, and is the exhaust velocity relative to the ambient air. This direct momentum transfer integrates with the Coanda-effect circulation along the boom for balanced performance across flight regimes.[5] A key benefit of the jet thrust augmentation is its ability to mitigate torque saturation in hot/high altitude conditions, where traditional tail rotor systems often reach drive shaft and gearbox power limits, potentially compromising control. By relying on aerodynamic thrust without extended mechanical linkages, NOTAR maintains yaw authority even under elevated torque loads from dense air or high engine output.[2][6]System Design and Components
Tail Boom Structure
The NOTAR tail boom is a non-rotating, monocoque structure that functions as an internal plenum to distribute pressurized air for anti-torque control, eliminating the need for traditional rotating tail rotor components.[1] This slotted design features two narrow slots running along the right side—typically positioned at the upper and lower surfaces—for expelling low-pressure, high-volume airflow, which adheres to the boom's curved exterior via the Coanda effect to generate directional thrust.[1] The aerodynamic shaping, often cylindrical or elliptical in profile, optimizes boundary-layer control and minimizes drag, achieving coefficients as low as 1.2 in wind tunnel tests under optimal slot positioning and blowing ratios.[29] Constructed primarily from lightweight composites such as carbon-fiber, graphite, and Kevlar for the main structure, with aluminum alloy elements in some assemblies, the tail boom provides enhanced durability while providing a weight reduction of approximately 7% compared to a tail rotor system.[12][29] In the MD 520N configuration, the tail boom integrates seamlessly with the fuselage, contributing to a nominal empty weight of 1,585 lb (719 kg) and supporting the empennage, including horizontal and vertical stabilizers.[1] These material choices not only lower the structural mass but also improve resistance to fatigue in high-vibration environments typical of helicopter operations, with ongoing enhancements in composites for improved durability as of recent designs.[29][4] The absence of rotating parts in the tail boom design significantly reduces mechanical complexity, resulting in lower vibration transmission to the airframe and simplified maintenance requirements, with no need for periodic inspections of gearboxes, drive shafts, or rotor blades.[1] This contributes to higher reliability, as evidenced by over 1,000,000 flight hours accumulated across the NOTAR fleet as of 2010 without tail rotor-related failures.[1][16] By briefly leveraging circulation control principles, the boom's internal plenum ensures efficient air management without external protrusions that could increase drag or vulnerability.[29]Airflow Management Systems
The airflow management systems in NOTAR helicopters are responsible for generating, pressurizing, and directing air to provide anti-torque and yaw control without a traditional tail rotor. These systems primarily consist of a variable-pitch fan located at the base of the tailboom, driven by the main engine via a power takeoff shaft, which draws in and circulates high-volume, low-pressure ambient air throughout the structure.[2] Complementing the fan, engine bleed air—hot, compressed air extracted from the engine's compressor stages—is utilized for the direct jet thruster to augment thrust and enable precise directional control.[31] This dual-airflow approach ensures efficient torque counteraction, with the fan handling the bulk of circulation control while bleed air provides targeted high-velocity augmentation. Modulating valves serve as critical components for regulating airflow pressure and direction within the NOTAR system. These pilot-controlled valves adjust the flow of bleed air to the direct jet thruster, maintaining optimal pressure levels to respond to varying flight conditions and pilot demands.[31] In typical operations, the valves modulate to balance the system's output, preventing over-pressurization and ensuring smooth yaw authority; for instance, they proportionally increase or decrease bleed air delivery based on anti-torque requirements during hover or maneuvers.[2] The fan's variable pitch further aids in fine-tuning airflow volume, allowing the system to adapt dynamically without mechanical complexity. Ducting in NOTAR airflow management forms an integrated network that routes air from the fan and bleed air sources along the composite tailboom. These insulated ducts, often embedded within the boom's structure, direct pressurized air to longitudinal slots on the boom's right side and to the rear-mounted direct jet thruster.[32] The layout minimizes turbulence and heat loss, with the ducts branching to distribute airflow evenly for the Coandă effect along the slots while channeling higher-pressure bleed air to the thruster's rotating nozzle. Servo-actuated mechanisms control the thruster's orientation, vectoring the exhaust jet left or right for yaw response.[2] Control logic for NOTAR airflow systems translates pilot inputs into precise adjustments for proportional yaw control. Anti-torque pedals link directly to the modulating valves and fan pitch controls, as well as the servo actuators on the direct jet thruster, ensuring immediate and balanced response to torque variations from the main rotor.[31] In the MD 600N, for example, this logic integrates with the yaw stability augmentation system, where pedal deflection modulates valve positions to vary slot pressure and thruster deflection, providing up to 60% of hover anti-torque via circulation control while the remainder comes from the jet.[32] The system's design emphasizes redundancy through dual-path airflow—fan for primary circulation and bleed air for augmentation—reducing vulnerability to single failures and enhancing overall reliability.[2]Integration with Main Rotor
The NOTAR system integrates seamlessly with the helicopter's main rotor and powerplant by mechanically coupling its variable-pitch fan to the main rotor transmission via a dedicated drive shaft, ensuring that anti-torque generation is directly linked to main rotor operation without the need for a separate tail rotor driveshaft. This configuration draws power from the engine for the fan while avoiding the mechanical losses inherent in long driveshafts used for conventional tail rotors.[11][33] Synchronization between the NOTAR and main rotor is achieved through real-time monitoring via sensors on the main rotor gearbox, which detect torque and RPM variations to dynamically adjust fan pitch and airflow output, maintaining balanced anti-torque across flight regimes including hover and forward flight. In autorotation, a one-way clutch in the transmission allows the main rotor to freewheel independently while preserving limited NOTAR functionality for directional control. This integration leverages the main rotor's downwash to enhance circulation control along the tailboom, augmenting the jet thrust from the rear nozzle for precise yaw authority.[34][1] In MD Helicopters models such as the 520N, the NOTAR design reduces loading on the main rotor by eliminating the weight and power demands of a traditional tail rotor system, permitting an increased useful load of approximately 250 pounds (113 kg) compared to the predecessor MD 500E, despite an empty weight increase of about 100 pounds (45 kg) from the NOTAR components. This adaptation stems from the lighter composite tailboom and more efficient power utilization, allowing higher gross weights without compromising main rotor performance.[3] The elimination of a mechanical tail rotor also simplifies flight controls, as anti-torque pedals now modulate only the NOTAR's internal vanes and external thruster with reduced authority requirements—typically providing 60% of anti-torque via Coanda-effect circulation and the remainder via directed jet thrust—thereby lowering pilot workload and enhancing responsiveness in yaw maneuvers.[1]Operational Applications
Civilian and Commercial Models
The MD 520N, introduced in 1991, represents the first production helicopter equipped with the NOTAR system for civilian applications, primarily serving law enforcement agencies.[35] This five-seat light utility model, powered by a single Allison 250-C20R turboshaft engine, debuted with deliveries to the Phoenix Police Department, which received its initial seven units that year.[35] By mid-2002, approximately 99 MD 520N helicopters had been registered worldwide, with a significant portion—estimated at around 50 units—dedicated to police operations due to the system's low noise profile and enhanced safety features.[36] The MD 600N, a stretched derivative of the MD 500 series, entered service in 1997 following its first flight in 1994, expanding NOTAR's commercial footprint with capacity for up to eight passengers including the pilot. Certified for single-pilot operations, this model features a six-blade main rotor and the same NOTAR anti-torque mechanism, making it suitable for utility missions such as geophysical and aerial surveying where precise low-altitude hovering is required.[32] Its design supports diverse non-military roles, including transport of survey crews and equipment to remote sites, leveraging the system's stability in confined areas.[32] In urban police patrols, NOTAR-equipped helicopters like the MD 520N provide key benefits, including reduced noise levels of approximately 2-7 EPNdB compared to conventional tail-rotor designs in various flight conditions, enabling discreet operations over populated areas.[37] The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department adopted a fleet of MD 520N models in the 1990s, integrating forward-looking infrared (FLIR) systems for enhanced surveillance, and noted the NOTAR's resistance to foreign object damage (FOD) in dusty environments due to the absence of exposed tail rotor blades. This FOD resilience minimizes ingestion of debris during ground operations, improving reliability in arid or urban settings. For news gathering, the MD 600N's NOTAR system offers a quieter acoustic signature, facilitating extended low-hover operations over sensitive sites like state parks or cities without excessive disturbance.[38] The inherent aerodynamic stability of NOTAR enhances low-altitude control in crosswinds, supporting safer positioning for aerial footage.[4] Overall, the NOTAR fleet has accumulated over 1 million flight hours as of 2010, with reduced mechanical failures attributed to fewer moving parts compared to tail rotors, contributing to high operational uptime in commercial service; continued operations suggest substantially higher totals today.[16] In 2023, MD Helicopters introduced an engine upgrade for the MD 520N, featuring a more powerful Rolls-Royce M250-C40B turbine, which improves hot-and-high performance and payload capacity for ongoing law enforcement and utility missions.[21]Military and Specialized Uses
The adoption of NOTAR systems in military applications has been limited primarily to prototype evaluations for special operations, where the technology's reduced acoustic signature supports stealthy insertions. In the late 1990s and early 2000s, the U.S. Army's 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment (SOAR), known as the Night Stalkers, tested modified MH-6 "Little Bird" helicopters equipped with NOTAR, including one armed AH-6 variant (serial #25356) and one for personnel transport (serial #23650). These prototypes aimed to leverage the quieter operation for covert missions but were ultimately not adopted due to challenges with power margins, control authority, and transportability, leading to their reversion to standard configurations without operational deployment.[39] In specialized roles, NOTAR helicopters excel in high-risk scenarios such as search-and-rescue (SAR) operations and offshore oil rig support, where the absence of a tail rotor enhances survivability by minimizing vulnerability to wire strikes and other obstacles. The system's design eliminates the risk of tail rotor contact with wires, vegetation, or structures common in confined or cluttered environments, providing greater operational resilience during low-level missions. For instance, MD 902 Explorer models with NOTAR have been utilized in SAR due to their agility and stability in urban or rugged terrains, while their safety profile suits the wire-prone settings of offshore platforms.[4][1] Performance evaluations highlight NOTAR's advantages in maneuverability and signature management for these uses. The system's reliance on airflow control rather than mechanical blades reduces inertia and enhances precision during hovers and tight turns. Additionally, assessments have confirmed a 30% reduction in noise compared to conventional tail rotors, contributing to lower detectability in sensitive operations, though infrared signature benefits remain secondary to noise suppression.[15][11] As of 2023, over 80 MD 520N units remain in active service with private security firms and law enforcement agencies, particularly for urban threat environments where low noise and personnel safety are critical. Examples include deployments by agencies like the Burbank Police Department, operating MD 520N models for patrol and response in densely populated areas.[40][41]Training and Certification
The MD 520N, the first production helicopter equipped with the NOTAR system, received Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) type certification on September 17, 1991, marking the initial regulatory approval for commercial operations. This certification process included flight tests demonstrating sufficient yaw authority, such as in sideward flight up to 17 knots, to ensure safe control across various flight regimes, including transitions to autorotation.[13][42] The European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) also type certified the MD 520N, enabling its use in European airspace and facilitating broader international deployment.[1] Pilot training for NOTAR-equipped helicopters emphasizes familiarization with the system's airflow-based yaw control, which differs from traditional tail rotor mechanisms by relying on variable air pressure and Coandă effect rather than mechanical blade pitch changes. For experienced rotorcraft pilots transitioning from tail rotor models like the MD 500 series to the MD 520N, MD Helicopters offers a dedicated three-day program consisting of one day of ground school on NOTAR operations and 2-3 hours of flight time to highlight these differences, including pedal inputs for valve modulation and response characteristics.[43] General transition training for new NOTAR pilots includes up to 4-5 hours of flight time alongside ground instruction, significantly less than the extended familiarization often required for complex tail rotor systems, allowing quicker proficiency in anti-torque management.[12][43] Autorotation training is a key component, with demonstrations confirming adequate yaw control during power-off descents, as verified in factory programs.[44] Specific training requirements incorporate NOTAR-unique hazards, such as potential airflow disruptions from environmental factors, though dedicated simulator programs are not universally mandated beyond standard FAA rotorcraft curricula. Compliance with FAA standards ensures pilots demonstrate competence in NOTAR handling during practical tests, without requiring additional ratings beyond the existing rotorcraft category and class. Recurrent training, typically every 12 months, reinforces these skills with 2-3 hours of flight time focused on system nuances.[45][43] Global adoption of NOTAR systems benefits from harmonized international standards, with FAA and EASA certifications recognized under bilateral agreements, streamlining operations in over 20 countries by the early 2000s. This regulatory framework, aligned with International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Annex 8 airworthiness principles, supports civilian applications in models like the MD 520N without necessitating unique ICAO-specific amendments.[36]Advantages and Limitations
Performance Benefits
The NOTAR (No Tail Rotor) system enhances helicopter safety by eliminating the tail rotor, which is involved in a significant portion of helicopter accidents, such as strikes affecting ground personnel; for example, in U.S. civil turbine helicopter accidents from 1988–1993, tail rotor issues contributed to about 16% of incidents.[46] This design removes a major hazard for ground personnel and reduces the risk of in-flight malfunctions associated with tail rotor strikes. Furthermore, the system's simpler construction results in a significantly lower parts count—reduced from 33 components in conventional tail rotor assemblies to 13—representing about a 60 percent decrease that contributes to overall reliability and ease of maintenance.[6] In terms of operational efficiency, NOTAR-equipped helicopters demonstrate potential fuel efficiency improvements due to optimized airflow management and reduced mechanical drag. Additionally, the system enables quieter performance, with reductions of up to 6.5 EPNdB on flyover compared to equivalent tail rotor helicopters, making it suitable for noise-sensitive environments such as urban operations.[37] Reliability is bolstered by the airflow-based components and fewer wear-prone moving parts. NOTAR also improves hover stability, particularly in challenging wind conditions, approved for hovering in crosswinds up to 30 knots.[12] This enhanced stability stems from the Coanda effect's consistent directional thrust, providing better resistance to gusts without the vulnerabilities of exposed rotor blades.Engineering Challenges and Drawbacks
The NOTAR system's reliance on a pressurized fan, circulation control slots along the tail boom, and direct jet thrusters introduces engineering complexity compared to conventional tail rotors, as it incorporates multiple interdependent components such as servo actuators, nozzles, and modulators that require precise calibration for effective anti-torque generation.[1] This design, while eliminating drive shafts and gearboxes, results in higher initial acquisition costs due to the specialized materials and assembly processes involved in the composite tail boom and enclosed fan assembly.[4] Early development efforts highlighted challenges like low-speed flow separation over the tail boom, necessitating additional features such as boundary layer fences and exhaust deflectors to maintain airflow integrity.[47] Performance limitations become evident in demanding environmental conditions, particularly hot and high altitudes, where the system's power draw—stemming from the fan's efficiency, which was around 50% in early NOTAR development and later improved to approximately 73%—imposes an engine power penalty that reduces hover capabilities.[47][3] For instance, the MD 520N's hover out-of-ground effect altitude drops from 9,400 ft on a standard day to 5,600 ft at ISA +20°C, limiting its suitability primarily to light helicopters under 4,000 lb gross weight and restricting broader adoption in heavier or high-altitude operations.[1] Additionally, circulation control via boom slots loses effectiveness above 30 knots forward speed as the main rotor wake shifts away, requiring supplemental jet thrust and potentially complicating yaw control in transitional flight regimes.[47] Ongoing research as of 2025 aims to improve fan efficiency and reduce power penalties for broader applications.[37] Maintenance demands are elevated due to the NOTAR's unique components, with 100-hour inspections mandated for the fan assembly, hub, blades, nozzle actuators, and counter-rotating vanes to check for damage, play, or foreign object ingestion, alongside life limits such as 7,500 hours for fan blades and 2,400 hours for support bearings.[1] These procedures necessitate specialized technician training focused on airflow systems and servo operations, contributing to higher upfront operational overheads, including direct operating costs estimated at $452 per hour for the MD 520N (2014 figures, encompassing maintenance labor and spares).[1] Although the enclosed fan design offers resistance to foreign object damage, any debris accumulation or erosion in slots or nozzles can degrade anti-torque authority, underscoring the need for rigorous cleanliness checks during routine servicing.[32]Comparisons to Traditional Tail Rotors
The NOTAR (No Tail Rotor) system offers several advantages over traditional tail rotor configurations in terms of weight and mechanical complexity. By eliminating the tail rotor, driveshaft, and associated gearbox, NOTAR reduces the propulsion group weight by approximately 7%, enhancing overall efficiency without the added mass of external rotor components.[37] This design simplification also minimizes potential failure modes, as there are no rotating blades or long driveshafts susceptible to wear, vibration-induced fatigue, or damage from foreign objects, thereby improving system reliability compared to conventional setups that require periodic maintenance on these elements.[12] In noise and safety metrics, NOTAR provides notable improvements. The system generates lower external noise levels, with flyover measurements showing about 6.5 EPNdB less than equivalent tail rotor helicopters, primarily due to the absence of the tail rotor's high-frequency blade slap and the enclosure of the internal fan.[37] Safety benefits stem from zero exposed blades, eliminating risks of strikes to personnel, obstacles, or structures; in contrast, traditional tail rotors contribute to approximately 16% of U.S. civil turbine helicopter accidents, often involving contact with ground crew, wires, or terrain during low-altitude operations.[46] Cost-effectiveness comparisons reveal a mixed profile for NOTAR. Acquisition costs for NOTAR-equipped models like the MD 520N tend to be comparable to conventional designs, with pre-owned examples averaging around $900,000 as of 2025, similar to MD 500E variants. However, lifecycle costs benefit from reduced maintenance needs, as the elimination of tail rotor components lowers inspection and overhaul expenses over time, potentially yielding savings through fewer moving parts and enhanced durability in demanding environments. A specific side-by-side analysis in MD 500 variants highlights performance trade-offs. The MD 520N with NOTAR achieves a maximum range of 204 nautical miles at sea level, compared to the MD 500E's 235 nautical miles, attributable to differences in fuel capacity and drag. Conversely, maximum gross weight remains comparable at 3,000 pounds for normal operations in both, though the NOTAR's internal fan adds minor complexity that can limit external load capabilities relative to the MD 500E's 3,550-pound external rating; the MD 520N supports up to 3,850 pounds external.[1][48]| Metric | NOTAR (e.g., MD 520N) | Traditional Tail Rotor (e.g., MD 500E) |
|---|---|---|
| Weight (Empty) | 1,481–1,585 lb (system ~7% lighter propulsion) | 1,657 lb |
| Noise (Flyover) | ~6.5 EPNdB quieter | Baseline tail rotor noise |
| Safety (Accident Attribution) | Zero blade strikes; enhanced ground safety | ~16% of accidents involve tail rotor |
| Acquisition Cost (Pre-owned Avg., as of 2025) | ~$900,000 | ~$900,000–$1,500,000 |
| Range | 204 NM | 235 NM |
| Max Gross Weight | 3,000 lb (normal); 3,850 lb (external) | 3,000 lb (normal); 3,550 lb (external) |
Current Status and Future Prospects
Production and Adoption Trends
The NOTAR system, introduced in production helicopters starting with the MD 520N in 1991, has seen limited manufacturing output primarily through MD Helicopters' models, including the MD 520N, MD 600N, and MD 900 Explorer variants. Approximately 380 units have been produced across these models since 1991, with the MD 520N accounting for around 102 aircraft built by mid-2006, the MD 600N reaching about 79 units by 2011, and the MD 900 Explorer approximately 200 units by the mid-2010s.[17][18] Production peaked in the late 1990s at roughly 20 units per year, driven by initial demand from law enforcement and utility sectors, before declining sharply to an average of 5 units annually after 2010 due to market saturation and shifting priorities toward conventional tail rotor designs.[17][18] NOTAR-equipped helicopters hold less than 1% market share within the global light helicopter fleet, which exceeds 40,000 units overall, reflecting their niche application in urban operations where noise reduction is prioritized. Adoption is heavily concentrated in the United States, comprising about 80% of the active fleet, with the remainder primarily in Europe for police and training roles; examples include the Phoenix Police Department's long-term use of seven MD 520N units since 1991. As of 2023, approximately 85 MD 520N helicopters remain in service. This limited penetration stems from the technology's specialized appeal, contrasting with the broader dominance of models like the Bell 206 and Robinson R44 in light utility segments.[49][50][21] Production trends have shown stagnation over the past decade, attributed to high certification and maintenance costs that deter widespread scaling beyond initial adopters, with no new NOTAR models entering full production since the early 2000s. However, interest has seen a modest uptick from 2023 to 2025, fueled by upgrades to existing fleets such as the MD 520N engine enhancements, which aim to revitalize the system's performance for modern missions. MD Helicopters' 2022 Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing disrupted parts availability for NOTAR operators, leading to temporary support challenges, though the company's emergence in 2022 under new ownership by an investment consortium including MBIA Insurance Corp., Bardin Hill Investment Partners LP, and MB Global Partners has enabled a revival, including resumed order fulfillment and fleet modernization efforts.[51][21][52][53]Recent Innovations and Research
Recent innovations in NOTAR technology have focused on enhancements to improve system performance and efficiency. In 2023, MD Helicopters introduced an engine upgrade for the MD 520N, replacing the original Allison 250-C20 with a more powerful Rolls-Royce 250-C30 turboshaft engine, boosting horsepower and addressing previous power limitations in hot-and-high conditions while maintaining NOTAR compatibility. This upgrade enhances yaw authority and overall mission capabilities for existing operators.[21] Research efforts have explored NOTAR integration with emerging electric and hybrid propulsion systems for urban air mobility. Hybrid concepts combining NOTAR's tail boom thrust vectoring with distributed electric propulsion have been proposed in conceptual designs by 2024, enabling quieter and more maneuverable aircraft for short-range passenger transport. These designs mitigate the noise and safety issues of conventional tail rotors while incorporating regenerative braking from electric motors to recharge batteries during descent, supporting extended operational envelopes in noise-sensitive environments. NASA's conceptual Quiet Single Main Rotor eVTOL incorporates NOTAR principles to minimize acoustic footprints.[54][55]Potential for Broader Implementation
The potential for broader implementation of NOTAR systems lies in their compatibility with emerging trends in sustainable and autonomous aviation. NOTAR's inherent noise reduction—up to 8-10 dB lower than traditional tail rotors—positions it well for integration into urban air mobility (UAM) operations, where quieter propulsion is essential for community acceptance and regulatory compliance.[4] Recent conceptual designs, such as NASA's Quiet Single Main Rotor eVTOL, incorporate NOTAR to minimize acoustic footprints while leveraging electric propulsion, suggesting opportunities for hybridization with sustainable aviation fuels (SAF) that could reduce lifecycle emissions without altering the system's core mechanics.[55] This synergy could enable NOTAR-equipped platforms to meet decarbonization goals, as SAF compatibility is inherent to turbine-based helicopters, potentially expanding applications in eco-conscious fleets by 2035 amid projected UAM market growth to $41.5 billion.[56] However, significant barriers hinder widespread adoption, primarily high research and development (R&D) costs exceeding $100 million for major upgrades, as seen in MD Helicopters' investments, alongside scaling challenges for larger airframes.[51] The system's complexity demands specialized pilot training and maintenance, increasing operational overhead compared to conventional tail rotors, while competition from simpler ducted fan alternatives in eVTOL designs limits market penetration.[4] Performance limitations, such as reduced efficiency in high-altitude or hot conditions due to airflow dependencies, further restrict viability beyond light helicopters.[4] Projections indicate niche growth in urban operations, where NOTAR's safety advantages—eliminating exposed tail rotor hazards—align with rising demand for low-risk aerial logistics. The FAA's 2025 Advisory Circular AC 21.17-4 on powered-lift certification provides pathways for innovative anti-torque systems like NOTAR in eVTOL hybrids, facilitating testing and integration into national airspace by late 2020s.[57] Industry analyses forecast limited broader adoption, with NOTAR potentially capturing under 5% of the helicopter anti-torque market unless manufacturing costs decline through advanced materials, maintaining its role as a specialized solution rather than mainstream.[4]References
- https://ntrs.[nasa](/page/NASA).gov/api/citations/20200000509/downloads/20200000509.pdf