Hubbry Logo
Scroll and KeyScroll and KeyMain
Open search
Scroll and Key
Community hub
Scroll and Key
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Scroll and Key
Scroll and Key
Scroll and Key
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Scroll and Key Society is a secret society, founded in 1842 at Yale University, in New Haven, Connecticut. It is one of the oldest Yale secret societies and reputedly the wealthiest.[1] The society is one of the reputed "Big Three" societies at Yale, along with Skull and Bones and Wolf's Head.[2] Each spring the society admits 15 rising seniors to participate in its activities and carry on its traditions.

Key Information

History

[edit]

Scroll and Key was established by John Addison Porter, with aid from several members of the Class of 1842 (including Leonard Case Jr. and Theodore Runyon) and a member of the Class of 1843 (William L. Kingsley), after disputes over elections to Skull and Bones Society. Kingsley is the namesake of the alumni organization, the Kingsley Trust Association (KTA), incorporated years after its founding.

Members of the 1866 delegation

Lyman Hotchkiss Bagg wrote that "up until as recent a date as 1860, Keys had great difficulty in making up its crowd, rarely being able to secure the full fifteen upon the night of giving out its elections." However, the society was on the upswing: "the old order of things, however, has recently come to an end, and Keys is now in possession of a hall far superior...not only to Bones hall but to any college-society hall in America."[3]

In addition to financing its activities, Scroll and Key has made significant donations to Yale over the years. The John Addison Porter Prize, awarded annually since 1872, and in 1917 the endowment for the founding of the Yale University Press, which has funded the publication of The Yale Shakespeare and sponsored the Yale Series of Younger Poets, are gifts from "Keys".

Traditions

[edit]
  • At the close of Thursday and Sunday sessions, members are known to sing the "Troubadour" song on the front steps of the Society's hall, a remnant of the tradition of public singing at Yale.[4][5] The song (written in the 1820s by Thomas Haynes Bayly) was recorded by Tennessee Ernie Ford on his 1956 album, This Lusty Land, as "Gaily the Troubador".
  • In keeping with the practice of adopting secret letters or symbols such as Skull and Bones' "322," Manuscript Society's "344," and The Pundits' "T.B.I.Y.T.B," Scroll and Key is known to use the letters "C.S.P. and C.C.J."[6]
  • Members of the society sign letters to each other "YiT", as opposed to Skull and Bones' "yours in 322".[6]
  • Outside of its tap-related activities, the society has been known to hold two major annual events called "Z Session".[6]

Tomb

[edit]
Scroll and Key's tomb
Tomb during its expansion, 1901

The society's building, called a "tomb", was designed in the Moorish Revival style by Richard Morris Hunt and constructed in 1870.[7] A later expansion was completed in 1901. Architectural historian Patrick Pinnell includes an in-depth discussion of Keys' building in his 1999 history of Yale's campus, relating the then-notable cost overruns associated with the Keys structure and its aesthetic significance within the campus landscape. Pinnell's history shares the fact that the land was purchased from another Yale secret society, Berzelius (at that time, a Sheffield Scientific School society).

Regarding the tomb's distinctive appearance, Pinnell noted that "19th-century artists' studios commonly had exotic orientalia lying about to suggest that the painter was sophisticated, well traveled, and in touch with mysterious powers; Hunt's Scroll and Key is one instance in which the trope got turned into a building."[8] Later, undergraduates described the building as a "striped zebra Billiard Hall" in a supplement to a Yale yearbook.[9] More recently, it has been described by an undergraduate publication as being "the nicest building in all of New Haven".[10]

Membership

[edit]

Scroll and Key taps annually a delegation of fifteen, composed of men and women of the junior class, to serve the following year. Membership is offered to a diverse group of highly accomplished juniors, specifically those who have "achieved in any field, academic, extra-curricular, or personal".[11] Delegations frequently include editors of the Yale Daily News and other publications, artists and musicians, social and political activists, athletes of distinction, entrepreneurs, and high-achieving scholars.[12][13]

Mark Twain was an honorary member, under the auspices of Joseph Twichell, Yale College Class of 1859.[14]

Notable members

[edit]
Dean Acheson
Fareed Zakaria
Sargent Shriver
Cole Porter
Calvin Trillin
Harvey Cushing
Garry Trudeau
Name Yale class Notability References
Leonard Case Jr. 1842 Founder of Case School of Applied Science, later Case Western Reserve University [15]
Theodore Runyon 1842 Envoy and ambassador to Germany; Battle of Bull Run [15]
Carter Harrison III 1845 Mayor of Chicago and U.S. representative [15]
Homer Sprague 1852 President of the University of North Dakota
Randall L. Gibson 1853 U.S. senator, Confederate brigadier-general, and president of Tulane University [15]
George Shiras Jr. 1853 U.S. Supreme Court Justice [15]
Brinley D. Sleight 1858 Newspaper editor, member of the New York State Assembly [16]
John Dalzell 1865 U.S. Congress [15]
George Bird Grinnell 1870 Anthropologist, historian, naturalist, and writer [17]
Edward Salisbury Dana 1870 American mineralogist [15]
Fred Dubois 1872 U.S. senator [15]
Henry deForest 1876 Southern Pacific Railroad [15]
Gilbert Colgate 1883 President and chairman of Colgate & Co. [15]
George Edgar Vincent 1885 President of the University of Minnesota; president of the Rockefeller Foundation [18]
James Gamble Rogers 1889 Architect, designed many of Yale's buildings [18]
Herbert Parsons 1890 U.S. Congress [15]
Harvey Cushing 1891 Neurosurgeon, considered father of brain surgery [18]
William Nelson Runyon 1892 Acting governor of New Jersey [15]
Frank Polk 1894 Secretary of State, Davis Polk & Wardwell, managed the conclusion of World War I [15]
Allen Wardwell 1895 Davis Polk & Wardwell; Bank of New York; vice-president of the American-Russian Chamber of Commerce [15]
Lewis Sheldon 1896 Paris Peace Conference, Olympic medalist [15]
Cornelius Vanderbilt III 1895 Brigadier general in the U.S. Army during the World War I [18]
William Adams Delano 1895 Architect; designed many of Yale's buildings [15]
Joseph Medill McCormick 1900 U.S. Senate and publisher of the Chicago Tribune [15]
Joseph M. Patterson 1901 Founder of the New York Daily News; manager of the Chicago Tribune [18]
Robert R. McCormick 1903 Chicago Tribune; Kirkland & Ellis[15] [15]
James C. Auchincloss 1908 U.S. Congress, governor of the NYSE, US military intelligence in World War I [15]
William C. Bullitt 1912 Ambassador to France, ambassador to the Soviet Russia [15]
Mortimer R. Proctor 1912 Governor of Vermont [15]
Cole Porter 1913 Entertainer, songwriter [19]
Dean Acheson 1915 51st Secretary of State [15]
Wayne Chatfield-Taylor 1916 President, Export-Import Bank; Undersecretary of Commerce; Assistant Secretary of the Treasury [20]
Dickinson W. Richards 1917 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine [15]
Ethan A. H. Shepley 1918 Chancellor of Washington University in St. Louis [15]
John Enders 1919 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine [15]
Brewster Jennings 1920 Founder and president of the Socony Mobil Oil Company Standard Oil of New York [15]
Seymour H. Knox 1920 American retailer, F. W. Woolworth Company [15]
Richardson Dilworth 1921 Mayor of Philadelphia [21]
William Hawks 1923 Film producer [22]
James Stillman Rockefeller 1924 President and chairman, First National City Bank of New York; Olympic gold medalist [15]
Huntington D. Sheldon 1925 Central Intelligence Agency; president of the Petroleum Corporation of America [15]
Newbold Morris 1925 New York lawyer and politician [15]
Benjamin Spock 1925 Pediatrician, author, and Olympic gold medalist [20]
John Hay Whitney 1926 U.S. ambassador to the United Kingdom, publisher of New York Herald Tribune [23]
Frederic A. Potts 1926 Chairman, Philadelphia National Bank; New Jersey Senate [15]
Paul Mellon 1929 Philanthropist [20]
Benjamin Brewster 1929 Director, Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey (later Exxon) [15]
Raymond R. Guest 1931 U.S. ambassador to Ireland; special assistant to Secretary of Defense [15]
Donald R. McLennan 1931 Founder and chairman, insurance brokerage firm Marsh McLennan [15]
Robert F. Wagner, Jr. 1933 Mayor of New York City [24]
J. Peter Grace 1936 W. R. Grace & Co.
Peter H. Dominick 1937 U.S. Senator, U.S. Congressman, U.S. Ambassador to Switzerland [25]
Sargent Shriver 1938 Peace Corps; vice-presidential candidate, Presidential Medal of Freedom [15]
Cyrus Vance 1939 Secretary of State; secretary of the Army; chairman, Federal Reserve Bank of New York [15]
Robert D. Orr 1940 Governor of Indiana; U.S. ambassador to Singapore [15]
Cord Meyer, Jr. 1943 Central Intelligence Agency; United World Federalists [15]
George Roy Hill 1943 Academy Award for Directing The Sting [15]
Frederick B. Dent 1944 U.S. Secretary of Commerce [15]
John Vliet Lindsay 1944 Mayor of New York City, congressman from New York City [24]
Thomas Enders 1953 Ambassador to Spain, ambassador to European Union, ambassador to Canada [15]
Philip B. Heymann 1954 Watergate special prosecutor, deputy U.S. attorney general; professor at Harvard Law School [15]
Warren Zimmermann 1956 U.S. ambassador to Yugoslavia, author [15]
Roscoe S. Suddarth 1956 President of the Middle East Institute; U.S. ambassador to Jordan [15]
Calvin Trillin 1957 Writer [26]
A. Bartlett Giamatti 1960 Yale University president; National League president, MLB commissioner [20]
Peter Beard 1961

Photographer

Timothy Mellon 1964 American businessman and grandson of Andrew Mellon [27]
Garry Trudeau 1970 Doonesbury cartoonist [20]
Stone Phillips 1977 Dateline NBC [15]
Rick E. Lawrence 1977 Associate justice of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court [15]
Gideon Rose 1985 Editor of Foreign Affairs [15]
Fareed Zakaria 1986 Editor of Newsweek and host of a CNN show
Dave Baseggio 1989 Director of professional scouting for the Seattle Kraken
Dahlia Lithwick 1990 Editor at Newsweek and Slate [28]
Jeannie Rhee 1994 Special council member for the obstruction of justice investigation [29]
Jacob W. Dell 1995 Pastor, spiritual advisor, and faith-based influencer, First Congregational Church, Woodbury, Connecticut
Tom Perriello 1996 U.S. congressman and executive director, Open Society Foundation [30]
Alexandra Robbins 1998 Journalist [31]
Ari Shapiro 2000 Co-host of All Things Considered for National Public Radio [28]
Elizabeth Wilkins 2005 CEO of the Roosevelt Institute
Maggie Goodlander 2009 U.S. Representative from New Hampshire's 2nd District [32]
John-Michael Parker 2010 Connecticut state representative [33]
Cory Finley 2011 Film director [34]
Abraar Karan 2011 Infectious disease doctor [34]
Johan Lenox 2011 Composer and songwriter [34]
Willa Fitzgerald 2013 Actress [35]
Tyler Varga 2015 Former NFL fullback [36]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Scroll and Key

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Scroll and Key, incorporated as the Kingsley Trust Association, is a secret senior society at founded in 1841 as the second such organization after . It annually taps fifteen juniors for membership, initiating them into rituals and deliberations held within a distinctive windowless building on College Street known as the Tomb. The society originated from dissatisfaction among Yale students, including William Kingsley (class of 1843), William Huntington (class of 1843), and John Porter (class of 1842), who were overlooked for selection into and sought to establish an alternative fraternity emphasizing different ideals of camaraderie and distinction. Membership has historically conferred prestige and networking opportunities, yielding alumni who achieved prominence in diplomacy, arts, medicine, and public service, such as , the 51st U.S. Secretary of State, and , the renowned composer. While maintaining strict secrecy regarding internal proceedings, Scroll and Key's enduring influence stems from the empirical success of its members in elite domains rather than unsubstantiated narratives of undue power.

History

Founding and Early Years

The Scroll and Key Society, incorporated as the Kingsley Trust Association, was established in 1841 at , becoming the second secret senior society after , which had been founded in 1832. It emerged from disputes over exclusivity in Yale's existing literary and debating societies, with founders including John Addison Porter of the Class of 1842, William Kingsley of the Class of 1843, and William Huntington. The society's creation reflected broader tensions among student groups seeking alternative paths to prestige and camaraderie outside the dominant structure. In its early years, Scroll and Key selected approximately 15 senior members annually through a secretive process, initially involving society members assembling at to visit and recruit chosen juniors en masse. Meetings occurred in rented spaces or members' rooms, later shifting to a custom-designed penthouse suite in a New Haven office building before the construction of a dedicated hall. The society was formally incorporated in 1860, with early member William Kingsley playing a key role in that process, solidifying its institutional presence amid Yale's evolving student culture.

Growth and Institutionalization

Following its founding in 1842 as the Kingsley Trust Association by members of Yale's Class of 1843, including William T. Kingsley and John Addison Porter, rapidly established itself as a principal rival to among Yale's senior societies. The society's early operations involved renting quarters, such as rooms on the fourth floor of the Leffingwell Building at Church and Court Streets starting in 1847, which facilitated regular meetings and initiation rituals among its initial cohorts of approximately 15 seniors annually. This structure mirrored ' model but emphasized themes of intellectual pursuit and trusteeship, drawing from the liberal arts ethos prevalent in mid-19th-century Yale. A pivotal step in institutionalization occurred with the construction of its dedicated headquarters, known as the , at 484 College Street. Commissioned in 1869 and completed in 1870, the building was designed by architect in a Moorish Revival style, featuring a compact, windowless facade that underscored the society's secretive operations while providing a permanent venue for assemblies. Funded through alumni contributions, the Tomb represented a shift from transient rentals to owned infrastructure, enabling expanded internal practices and symbolizing the society's growing prestige and financial self-sufficiency among Yale's elite networks. By the 1870s, Scroll and Key further entrenched its institutional role through formal endowments and academic initiatives, such as establishing the John Addison in 1872 to honor scholarly achievement in the arts and sciences, administered via the Kingsley Trust. The society's alignment with Yale's evolving social hierarchy was reinforced by the standardization of Tap Day in 1879, a campus-wide for senior society selections that integrated Scroll and Key into the university's formalized extracurricular framework. These developments, coupled with sustained membership of 15 per class, positioned it as one of Yale's "Big Three" societies by the late , alongside and the later Wolf's Head.

Evolution in the 20th and 21st Centuries

In the early , Scroll and Key maintained its status as one of Yale's most selective senior societies, drawing members from prominent families and future leaders in government, business, and medicine. Notable alumni included , who served as U.S. from 1949 to 1953 and shaped post-World War II foreign policy, including the and formation. Other influential figures encompassed , founder of the in 1961, and Harvey Cushing, a pioneering neurosurgeon who advanced brain surgery techniques in the 1910s and 1920s. The society's alumni network facilitated access to elite positions, with members like A. Bartlett Giamatti later becoming Yale's president from 1978 to 1986, underscoring its enduring role in institutional leadership. Mid-century adaptations reflected broader societal shifts, yet Scroll and Key preserved its secretive traditions amid Yale's transition to coeducation in 1969, initially remaining all-male like most senior societies. By the late 1980s, facing debates and pressures for inclusivity, the society voted to admit women, marking a pivotal from its exclusively male origins. This change preceded similar moves by peers like , which resisted until 1992, and aligned Scroll and Key with Yale's diversifying student body without diluting its tap-based selection of high-achieving juniors. Into the , Scroll and Key has continued tapping 15 seniors annually, emphasizing intellectual and leadership potential over rigid demographics, resulting in ideologically varied membership. For instance, in 2023, the society selected a leader from Yale's chapter, illustrating openness to progressive voices amid critiques of elite exclusivity. Contemporary alumni such as , a host and foreign affairs analyst tapped in the 1980s, and , creator of the comic strip since 1970, highlight its sustained cultural and media influence. Despite external scrutiny over secrecy and networking advantages, the society has endured without major scandals, adapting rituals to coed dynamics while prioritizing verifiable merit in selections.

Traditions and Operations

Selection and Initiation Rituals

The selection for Scroll and Key begins in mid-February each year, when current senior members initiate contact with prospective juniors during designated periods set by a coordinating . Each active member nominates up to four candidates, drawing from personal networks and aiming for a mix of known individuals and those who complement the group's dynamics, such as athletes, performers, or leaders in specific extracurriculars. An initial pool of 40 to 80 candidates is compiled and deliberated upon internally, with the list halved through discussion; Scroll and Key notably forgoes interviews, relying instead on member consensus. Pre-tap offers may be extended approximately one week before Tap Night, typically in mid-April, allowing to commit or explore multiple invitations during a "scramble week." On Tap Night itself, formal inductions occur, with Scroll and Key historically escorting selectees in black limousines for a dramatic public reveal, evolving from 19th-century courtyard tappings where seniors physically struck ' backs to signal selection. The taps 15 new members annually, maintaining a consistent amid Yale's broader landscape. Initiation follows tapping with cryptic public rituals featuring eccentric displays, such as blindfolded processions or theatrical antics, though Yale regulations prohibit restraint or hazing. These outward spectacles culminate a week of pre-induction activities, after which new members enter regular Thursday and Sunday meetings involving 5- to 6-hour personal biography sessions to build loyalty and cohesion. Details of any private ceremonies remain closely held, consistent with the society's emphasis on internal traditions over public disclosure.

Meetings, Symbols, and Internal Practices

Members of Scroll and Key convene for meetings twice weekly, typically on Thursdays and , within the confines of their windowless at 490 College Street in New Haven. These gatherings, attended by the society's approximately 15 senior members, emphasize and occur under conditions of strict , with no of discussions or proceedings. The society's iconography centers on the scroll and key, emblematic motifs reflected in its name and crest, which likely symbolize preservation of and selective access, respectively, though precise esoteric meanings are withheld from non-members. Internal practices include the ritualistic sharing of "bios"—detailed autobiographical confessions—that promote vulnerability and lifelong camaraderie among initiates, a common to Yale's landed senior societies but adapted uniquely within Scroll and Key's operations. Annual initiation on Tap Night features public elements, such as processions from the to select , but subsequent internal rituals and deliberations remain opaque, shielded by oaths of enforced since the society's founding in 1842. This veil of privacy extends to symbolic artifacts like membership pins, which bear the scroll and key but disclose no further operational details.

Physical Infrastructure

The Tomb: Design and Location

The Scroll and Key Society's building, referred to as the Tomb, stands at 490 College Street in , situated at the corner of College and Wall streets. This location places it within Yale University's campus vicinity, proximate to other senior society structures. Architect designed the building in the Moorish Revival style, with construction completed in 1870. Key design features include light-colored stone accented by dark-striped bands, golden Moorish screens, and an emphasis on symmetrical facades, evoking Middle Eastern architectural influences. The structure's opaque and fortress-like appearance aligns with the society's secretive operations, though it functions primarily as a meeting hall rather than an actual . Prior to acquiring this dedicated edifice, Scroll and Key members convened in a custom penthouse suite within a New Haven office building, reflecting the society's evolution toward institutional permanence following ' precedent of a purpose-built hall in 1856. The Tomb remains in use today, underscoring its enduring role in the society's activities.

Role in Society Functions

The Scroll and Key tomb, located at 444 College Street in , primarily functions as the exclusive venue for the society's internal gatherings, enabling privacy and seclusion essential to its operations. Constructed in 1866 in the Moorish Revival style, the windowless interior spaces facilitate confidential meetings without external observation, a design choice that underscores the society's emphasis on discretion since its early years when members met in rented rooms before acquiring dedicated facilities. Central to these functions are bi-weekly dinners and debates held on Thursday and Sunday evenings, where the fifteen senior members convene to dine, discuss , , and other topics, and deliberate on matters. These sessions, provided at no cost to participants, promote intellectual engagement and lifelong bonds among members, mirroring broader Yale senior practices that have persisted since at least the late . Historical accounts indicate that such gatherings evolved from assemblies in the to structured rituals in the , reinforcing the society's role in cultivating skills through peer interaction rather than formal instruction. Beyond routine meetings, the hosts initiation ceremonies for newly tapped members during the annual Tap Day process, typically in early , where rituals symbolize commitment to the society's values of truth and beauty. occasionally return for commemorative events, though specifics remain guarded; for instance, the 1978 centennial publication by former Yale President A. Bartlett Giamatti highlighted the building's enduring utility in sustaining these traditions amid Yale's evolving campus culture. The facility's opulent interiors, including stained flags and a central reported from rare infiltrations, support symbolic elements that enhance the deliberative atmosphere without public disclosure of proceedings. In the broader Yale context, the tomb's functions contribute to the society's niche as a selective forum for high-achieving undergraduates, historically influencing university governance—over two-thirds of members from 1872 to 1936 were from Scroll and Key or —by nurturing networks that extend into professional spheres post-graduation. Empirical evidence from membership outcomes, such as disproportionate representation in national leadership roles, suggests these gatherings foster causal pathways to influence through personal connections rather than overt coordination, countering unsubstantiated claims of undue .

Membership and Selection

Criteria and Process

Membership selection for Scroll and Key occurs annually among Yale's junior class, with current senior members choosing 15 individuals to join the society for their senior year. The process begins in late winter or early spring, typically around February, and culminates in Tap Week and Tap Night in April, where formal offers are extended and accepted publicly on Yale's . Unlike some other Yale senior societies, Scroll and Key does not conduct interviews with prospective members, relying instead on internal deliberations and evaluations by existing members. Each senior member initially nominates four juniors for consideration, generating a preliminary pool that is then narrowed through successive rounds of discussion, often starting with 40 to 80 candidates and reducing to the final 15 via rankings and consensus. Offers may be extended informally starting about a week before Tap Night, allowing candidates time to decide before the public ceremony. Specific criteria for selection remain undisclosed, as the society's operations are intentionally opaque, but reports indicate a focus on individuals who demonstrate achievement across varied domains, including academics, extracurricular activities, , or personal endeavors, while prioritizing diversity in backgrounds, perspectives, and interests to balance the group's dynamics. Members target specific niches, such as student leaders in groups or sports teams, alongside broader influencers, to assemble a class that complements the society's composition. This approach has evolved over time but maintains an emphasis on merit-based distinction without formal applications or public qualifications.

Demographic Composition and Changes

Upon its founding in 1842, Scroll and Key's membership comprised exclusively white male undergraduates from , selected for demonstrated excellence in scholarship, leadership, or extracurricular pursuits, with early members typically hailing from established families of Protestant background. This composition aligned with Yale's overall student body, which until the early enrolled few if any non-Protestants, Catholics, , or racial minorities, maintaining a student population over 95% white and male through selective admissions favoring legacy and elite preparatory school attendees. Yale's transition to coeducation in 1969 introduced women to the undergraduate population, comprising initially about 10% of the class of 1973 and rising to parity by the 1980s, prompting senior societies to adapt amid campus debates on inclusivity. Scroll and Key resisted coeducation longer than some peers but voted to admit women on , 1988, becoming the fifth of Yale's seven landed societies to do so and tapping its inaugural female members the following fall for the class of 1989. Racial and ethnic diversification followed broader shifts in Yale's admissions, which increased non-white enrollment from under 5% in the to over 50% by the through and recruitment efforts. While Scroll and Key discloses no membership statistics, its taps have included prominent non-white alumni such as journalist (class of 1986), reflecting gradual inclusion of minorities predating full coeducation. Recent selections demonstrate ideological breadth, including a leader from Yale's chapter in 2023, indicating reduced homogeneity in socioeconomic and political origins compared to the society's WASP-dominated origins.

Influence and Legacy

Notable Members

Scroll and Key has produced alumni who have achieved prominence in government, medicine, arts, and journalism. , class of 1915, served as U.S. from 1949 to 1953, shaping post-World War II foreign policy including the and formation. Acheson's tenure emphasized of Soviet influence, as detailed in his Present at the Creation. In medicine, Harvey Cushing, class of 1891, pioneered techniques and identified , earning recognition as the father of modern . He performed over 2,000 operations and authored foundational texts like The Pituitary Body and Its Disorders. The society's influence extends to the arts, with composer , class of 1913, creating enduring musicals such as (1948) and (1934), contributing over 500 songs to American theater. Porter's Yale involvement included writing more than 300 songs during his studies. Cartoonist , class of 1970, developed the comic strip, syndicated since 1970 and awarded the for Editorial Cartooning in 1975 for its satirical commentary on politics and society. Trudeau's work has appeared in over 1,000 newspapers worldwide. Journalist , class of 1986, hosts CNN's and authored bestsellers like (2008), analyzing global power shifts with data on economic indicators and geopolitical trends. Zakaria's editorial roles include managing editor at from 1992 to 2000. Writer Calvin Trillin, class of 1957, has published over 20 books, including About Alice (2006), and contributed to The New Yorker since 1963, focusing on food, politics, and personal essays grounded in firsthand observation. Other notable figures include A. Bartlett Giamatti, class of 1960, who served as Yale's 19th president from 1978 to 1986 and Major League Baseball commissioner from 1989 until his death, implementing drug testing policies. Cyrus Vance, class of 1939, acted as U.S. Secretary of State from 1977 to 1980, resigning over the Iran hostage crisis due to opposition to military intervention. These alumni demonstrate the society's historical ties to leadership roles, though individual success stems from personal merit rather than affiliation alone.

Contributions to Leadership and Society

Members of Scroll and Key have occupied prominent roles in American diplomacy and government, shaping key initiatives. , tapped into the society in the class of 1915, served as U.S. from January 21, 1949, to January 20, 1953, exerting significant influence on postwar U.S. , including the design of the in 1947, the in 1948, and the North Atlantic Treaty Organization in 1949. Similarly, , a 1939 member, held positions as from 1977 to 1980, Secretary of the Army from 1962 to 1964, and Deputy Secretary of Defense from 1964 to 1967, contributing to and frameworks. In public service and social programs, , admitted in the class of 1938, founded the in 1961 as its first director, launching initiatives that deployed over 15,000 volunteers to 55 countries by 1963 for development and cultural exchange efforts. Shriver also established programs like , Head Start, and under the Office of Economic Opportunity, addressing poverty and education gaps in the U.S. during the 1960s. Contributions extend to medical advancements, with Harvey Cushing, a society member from the class of 1891, pioneering as the first exclusive practitioner of the field. Cushing developed techniques for controlling surgical bleeding using silver clips, advanced electro-surgery, and described in 1912, a pituitary disorder affecting hormone regulation, which laid foundational work for modern and brain surgery. His innovations reduced operative mortality rates in neurosurgical procedures from over 50% to under 10% by the 1920s.

Controversies and Critiques

Allegations of Elitism and Exclusion

Critics of Yale's senior societies, including Scroll and Key, have long alleged that their highly selective membership processes foster by concentrating influence among a narrow subset of students, typically those from privileged socioeconomic backgrounds. Each year, Scroll and Key selects only 15 new members from approximately 1,400 seniors during Tap Day, a public that publicly honors the chosen while implicitly excluding the vast majority, thereby perpetuating perceptions of social hierarchy and networking exclusivity. Historically, Scroll and Key's membership was restricted to white Protestant males, mirroring Yale's broader admissions biases until the mid-20th century, which excluded women, racial minorities, and those from non-elite families; this composition reinforced allegations of exclusionary practices designed to consolidate power among establishment figures. The society's tomb-based meetings and lifelong bonds have been characterized as "bastions of ," enabling alumni networks that advantage members in elite professions like , , and , while sidelining others regardless of merit. Such critiques intensified during Tap Day ceremonies, described as epitomes of elitism for their theatrical public tapping, which some view as humiliating to non-selectees and emblematic of arbitrary gatekeeping rather than pure . Although Scroll and Key began admitting women in the late and has since tapped more diverse members—including, in recent years, individuals from leftist political groups—the underlying structure of limited slots continues to invite charges of systemic exclusion, with student publications decrying the societies as anachronistic relics that prioritize legacy and connections over broader representation. These allegations, often voiced in campus media with progressive leanings, argue that even diversified delegations fail to mitigate the inherent advantages conferred to a tiny cohort, though of causation between membership and later success remains correlative rather than definitively causal.

Conspiracy Claims and Empirical Rebuttals

Conspiracy theories surrounding Scroll and Key often portray it as part of a clandestine network, alongside societies like , that secretly orchestrates influence over U.S. government, , and agencies, selecting members to advance hidden agendas such as or elite preservation. These claims, popularized in fringe literature and online forums, allege rituals and oaths bind members to lifelong loyalty, enabling coordinated control, with the society's Moorish Revival "" building symbolizing esoteric power derived from ancient or occult origins. Proponents cite the society's alumni in high positions—such as (class of 1915) or founder (class of 1938)—as evidence of engineered dominance, extending theories from to imply a broader Yale-based cabal influencing events like decisions or corporate mergers. Empirical scrutiny reveals no verifiable evidence of such coordination; archival records and member accounts describe activities as social dinners, debates, and networking events within a clubhouse setting, lacking documentation of policy directives or illicit pacts. Selection occurs via peer nominations from Yale's senior class, prioritizing academic and extracurricular excellence, which naturally yields high-achieving whose successes—predating or independent of membership—stem from individual merit and Yale's rigorous admissions, not post-induction manipulation. For instance, composer (class of 1913) and journalist (class of 1957) leveraged personal talents and pre-society networks, with no causal link to society-driven plots; correlation of elite roles among the roughly 15 annual taps reflects in a talent pool, not causation. Investigations, including alumni publications, dismiss exaggerated influence as cultural myth, noting the society's operations mirror exclusive fraternities elsewhere, with transparency increasing since co-ed admission in 1988 and public member lists undermining secrecy claims. While networking benefits exist—facilitating post-graduation connections akin to associations—these are overt and legal, with no empirical supporting systemic control; quantitative analyses of Yale graduates show leadership distribution aligns with broader patterns, attributable to socioeconomic factors rather than society-specific machinations. Claims of occult ties falter against architectural records confirming the 1902 design as stylistic homage to 19th-century revivalism by architect , devoid of ritualistic function beyond meetings. Overall, narratives, often amplified by non-academic sources with ideological axes, overstate a defunct exclusivity model, as membership demographics have diversified and societal relevance waned amid Yale's evolving culture.

Achievements Countering Criticisms

, a Scroll and Key member from the class of 1915, served as U.S. from 1949 to 1953 and was instrumental in crafting post-World War II policies, including the , which delivered $13.3 billion in economic aid to 16 Western European nations between 1948 and 1952 to prevent communist expansion and facilitate recovery, and the formation of in 1949 as a collective defense alliance. These initiatives stabilized , fostering economic growth averaging 5-6% annually in recipient countries during the plan's implementation and laying groundwork for transatlantic security that endured through the . Sargent , class of 1938, directed the from its inception in 1961 until 1966, enlisting 15,000 volunteers by 1966 to undertake , , and projects in 50 countries, which evolved into a program serving over 240,000 Americans across 140 nations by promoting grassroots development and intercultural understanding. As head of the Office of Economic Opportunity from 1964 to 1966, he oversaw antipoverty initiatives like Head Start, which enrolled 500,000 preschool children by 1966 to address educational disparities, demonstrating measurable impacts on through expanded access to and job training. Shriver's efforts, including co-founding the in 1968, extended public service into disability advocacy, influencing global models for inclusive athletics. In scientific advancement, Harvey Cushing, elected to Scroll and Key during his Yale years circa 1891, established as a distinct specialty, achieving the first complete removal of a pituitary tumor in 1909 and refining operative techniques that lowered intracranial surgery mortality from approximately 50% pre-1900 to 5-10% by the 1920s through innovations like precise and tumor classification. His descriptions of conditions like in 1912 advanced and , while training programs at produced generations of surgeons, contributing to over 2,000 documented brain operations by 1930 with sustained improvements in patient outcomes. The society's direct philanthropy further underscores constructive influence, including a 1917 endowment establishing , which has published over 10,000 titles in humanities and social sciences since inception, and ongoing support for scholarships and prizes like the John Addison Porter Prize awarded annually since 1872 for original research. Such contributions, totaling over $1 million in reported donations by 2014, have bolstered academic accessibility at Yale, evidencing a commitment to intellectual advancement beyond membership exclusivity. These documented legacies in , service, , and education empirically refute claims of insular detriment by highlighting causal chains from individual excellence to broader societal gains.

References

  1. https://archives.yale.edu/repositories/12/resources/2385
  2. http://archives.yalealumnimagazine.com/issues/2004_09/old_yale.html
  3. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2002/06/30/secret-societies-tombs-and-tradition/
  4. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2008/12/05/yales-secret-social-fabric/
  5. https://ydnhistorical.library.yale.edu/?a=d&d=YDN20090527-01.2.77.31
  6. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2702903
  7. https://softschools.com/facts/cold_war/dean_acheson_facts/3714/
  8. https://walkoffame.com/cole-porter/
  9. https://yalealumnimagazine.org/articles/4072-the-origins-of-the-tomb
  10. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3012287/
  11. https://elischolar.library.yale.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1006&context=yale_history_pubs
  12. https://thenewjournalatyale.com/2002/04/the-hidden-curriculum/
  13. https://sah-archipedia.org/buildings/CT-01-009-0040
  14. https://archive.curbed.com/2018/6/21/17484316/yale-secret-society-tomb-history-skull-bones
  15. https://namcologne.wordpress.com/the-secret-societies-of-yale/
  16. https://secretary.yale.edu/services-resources/lectureships-fellowships-prizes/porter-and-field
  17. http://archives.yalealumnimagazine.com/issues/01_03/groups.html
  18. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/01/yale-skull-and-bones-secret-societies-diversity/677030/
  19. https://247wallst.com/special-report/2023/08/06/worlds-most-powerful-secret-societies/
  20. https://celebratewomen.yale.edu/history/timeline-women-yale
  21. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1991/06/11/secret-society-moves-to-admit-women/71c20a3a-0227-406c-8431-eea6365533b0/
  22. https://yalealumnimagazine.org/articles/3909-open-secrets
  23. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2024/02/28/behind-tomb-doors-yales-society-tap-process/
  24. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2009/04/17/the-evolution-of-tap-night/
  25. https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1999/3/18/yales-finest-hours-pyales-secret-societies/
  26. https://features.yaledailynews.com/blog/2017/02/24/the-choice-is-yours/
  27. https://www.uwire.com/2012/03/30/tapping-in-to-yales-secret-societies/
  28. https://ydnhistorical.library.yale.edu/?a=d&d=YDN20081205-01.2.76.3
  29. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Secret_Society_Buildings_New_Haven.jpg
  30. https://www.facebook.com/groups/439504127191333/posts/758489531959456/
  31. https://ninth-house.fandom.com/wiki/Scroll_%2526_Key
  32. https://www.nytimes.com/1982/04/16/nyregion/tap-day-fading-bit-of-old-yale.html
  33. https://www.journeysthrumylens.com/secret-societies-of-yale-university/
  34. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2002/04/12/tap-secrets-of-yale-societies/
  35. https://hiseye.org/12107/opticmagazine/the-comprehensive-college-guide-to-secret-societies/
  36. https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1988/3/19/yale-secret-society-to-admit-women/
  37. https://onlineexhibits.library.yale.edu/s/harvey-cushing/page/education
  38. https://academic.oup.com/neurosurgery/article/45/5/1002/2859110
  39. https://masterworksbroadway.com/artist/cole-porter/
  40. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2008/04/11/for-trudeau-road-to-comic-fame-began-on-york-street/
  41. https://www.lambiek.net/artists/t/trudeau.htm
  42. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2006/02/14/trustee-zakaria-86-found-his-niche-at-yale/
  43. https://www.thekeyexecutives.com/2021/11/01/universally-experienced-yales-fareed-zakarias-amazing-journey-in-journalism/
  44. https://lithub.com/calvin-trillin-on-the-importance-of-parenting-with-humor/
  45. https://history.state.gov/departmenthistory/people/acheson-dean-gooderham
  46. https://time.com/archive/6602177/the-cabinet-the-man-from-middletown/
  47. https://archives.yale.edu/repositories/12/resources/4513
  48. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2011/01/19/shriver-dies-at-95/
  49. https://prologue.blogs.archives.gov/2011/01/19/mr-shriver-and-his-peace-corps-guerrillas/
  50. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2384244/
  51. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5606407/
  52. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2018/04/20/didnt-get-tapped-for-a-society-here-are-six-other-exclusive-terrible-organizations-to-rush-next-year/
  53. https://harvardvoicemag.wordpress.com/2012/01/02/inside-yales-secret-societies/
  54. https://www.delanceyplace.com/view-archives.php?p=4491
  55. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2024/02/09/bayulgen-daniel-for-the-ancient-eight-and-beyond-diversity-means-survival/
  56. https://spyscape.com/article/9-exclusive-mysterious-university-secret-societies
  57. https://www.ranker.com/list/famous-scroll-and-key-members/user-x
  58. https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/a-look-inside-yales-secret-societies--and-why-they-may-no-longer-matter/2017/09/28/118c7eb2-8cca-11e7-84c0-02cc069f2c37_story.html
  59. https://yalealumnimagazine.com/articles/4501-the-evolution-of-secret-societies
  60. https://www.quora.com/How-do-secret-societies-like-Skull-Bones-impact-networking-and-opportunities-at-schools-like-Yale
  61. https://www.npr.org/2011/01/19/133049407/sargent-shriver-a-man-of-public-service
  62. https://www.sargentshriver.org/about-sspi/sargent-shriver
  63. https://hekint.org/2020/08/17/harvey-cushing-surgeon-author-soldier-historian-1869-1939/
  64. https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2016/01/29/secret-societies-tombs-or-vaults/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.