Hubbry Logo
search
logo
The Man Who Cried avatar
The Man Who Cried
The Man Who Cried
current hub
T

The Man Who Cried

logo
Community Hub0 Subscribers
Read side by side
The Man Who Cried
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Man Who Cried
Theatrical release poster
Directed bySally Potter
Written bySally Potter
Produced byChristopher Sheppard
StarringChristina Ricci
Cate Blanchett
John Turturro
Johnny Depp
Harry Dean Stanton
CinematographySacha Vierny
Edited byHervé Schneid
Music byOsvaldo Golijov
Production
companies
Distributed byUniversal Pictures (United Kingdom, Ireland, South Africa, Australia, New Zealand and Benelux; through United International Pictures)[1]
Mars Distribution (France)[2]
Release date
  • 2 September 2000 (2000-09-02) (Venice)
Running time
100 minutes
CountriesUnited Kingdom
France
LanguagesEnglish
Yiddish
Russian
French
Italian
Romani
Romanian
Budget$20 million[3]
Box office$1.8 million[4]

The Man Who Cried is a 2000 historical musical drama film written and directed by Sally Potter, and starring Christina Ricci, Cate Blanchett, Johnny Depp, Harry Dean Stanton and John Turturro. The film tells the story of a young Jewish girl who, after being separated from her father in Soviet Russia, grows up in England and moves to Paris as a young adult, shortly before the beginning of World War II. It is the last film worked on by the French cinematographer Sacha Vierny.

Plot

[edit]

Fegele Abramovich, a Russian Jew is separated from her father as a child in 1927. Her father has travelled to America to seek his fortune and plans to send for Fegele and her grandmother. Before leaving, he sings "Je Crois Entendre Encore" from the Bizet opera Les pêcheurs de perles to her. After her father leaves, the village is attacked and burned in a pogrom. Fegele escapes with the help of neighbours; after overcoming many obstacles, she is crowded onto a boat headed for Britain, with only a photo of her father and a coin given by her grandmother.

A British official renames her "Susan" and places her with foster parents. Schoolmates taunt her by calling her a "gypsy", but she does not yet understand English. A teacher at the school overhears her singing "Je Crois Entendre Encore" in Yiddish, and teaches her to sing and speak in English.

An older Suzie joins a singing dance troupe. In Paris she shares an apartment with an older Russian dancer named Lola. They perform at a formal party alongside a mysterious performing horseman, Cesar, a Romani to whom Suzie becomes attracted. They overhear a tenor singing "Je Crois Entendre Encore"; the voice belongs to Dante, an Italian opera singer who immediately catches Lola's eye. Lola falls for his charms, enticed by his wealth and success. Dante, Lola, Suzie, and Cesar all work for an opera company directed by Felix Perlman. Dante is an imperious follower of Mussolini; this alienates him from Suzie even as he becomes Lola's lover. Meanwhile, Cesar introduces Suzie to his "family" (essentially his entire tribe), and they fall in love.

Dante rifles through Suzie's things after a dalliance with Lola in the apartment, and deduces her Jewish heritage from her father's photo. An elderly Jewish neighbour downstairs, Madame Goldstein, also knows that Suzie is Jewish and has warned her of the dangers foretold by the German invasion of Poland. A year later, as the Germans approach Paris, an exodus begins of Jews fleeing from the Nazis. Crowds for the opera dwindle, leaving only Dante and Suzie as cast members. Dante attempts to seduce Suzie, who rebuffs him. He lashes out, insulting her heritage and that of Cesar. Perlman reminds Dante that if Mussolini aligns with the Nazis, Dante's own position in Paris would be precarious. Perlman closes down the show and the Nazis enter Paris the following morning.

Dante reluctantly returns to his earlier role as minstrel. After another rebuff from Suzie, Dante betrays her to a German officer as a Jew. Lola warns Suzie and urges her to leave Paris, and purchases tickets for them both on an ocean liner headed for America. The night of the party, the Nazis attack the Romani village and kill a child. When Cesar comes to her apartment to say goodbye, Suzie expresses her desire to stay and help Cesar fight the Nazis for his family, but he tells her she must flee and find her father. They share a tender last evening together.

Lola is killed when the ocean liner is torpedoed and sunk. Suzie is rescued and brought to New York.

Suzie searches for her father and discovers that he changed his name, gave up singing, and moved west after hearing about the attack on his home village, which he assumed killed all the members of his family. Suzie finds him in Hollywood where he has established himself as a studio head with a new family. Suzie learns also that he's dying. She goes to the hospital, walks past his new wife and children who are waiting outside the door to his room, and is reunited with her father. Overjoyed, he cries as she sits at his side singing "Je Crois Entendre Encore" in Yiddish.

Cast

[edit]

The singing voices for the characters of Dante and Suzie were provided by Salvatore Licitra and Iva Bittova, respectively.[5]

Release

[edit]

The film was first presented at the Venice Film Festival on 2 September 2000. The film screened at the London Film Festival; the Mar del Plata Film Festival, Argentina; the Tokyo International Film Festival & the Reykjavik Film Festival, Iceland among others.

Reception

[edit]

The film received mixed to negative reviews, currently holding a 35% 'rotten' rating on review aggregate Rotten Tomatoes. The consensus, based on 69 reviews, says 'The storyline is overwrought and awkward, and the audience is distanced from the flatly drawn characters.'[6] Metacritic calculated an average score of 40 out of 100 based on 22 reviews, indicating "mixed or average reviews".[7]

Awards

[edit]
Wins
Nominations

Soundtrack

[edit]
The Man Who Cried OST
Soundtrack album by
Osvaldo Golijov
Released22 May 2001
GenreSoundtrack
Length53:49
LabelSony Classical
ProducerSally Potter
Soundtrack
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusicStarStarStar link
SoundtrackNetStarStarStarHalf star link

The Man Who Cried: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack was released 22 May 2001. It features new music composed by Osvaldo Golijov, and was produced by Sally Potter and performed by the Royal Opera House Orchestra Covent Garden, Salvatore Licitra, and Taraf de Haïdouks.[8]

No.TitleWriter(s)Performer(s)Length
1."Je crois entendre encore" (Voice)Georges BizetSalvatore Licitra & The Orchestra of the Royal Opera House3:42
2."Jalousie" (Instrumental)Jacob Gade, Winifred MayVasko Vassilev; Pamela Nicholson3:00
3."Di quella pira" (Voice)Giuseppe VerdiLicitra2:15
4."Close Your Eyes" (Instrumental)Osvaldo GolijovKronos Quartet3:45
5."Tiganeasca" (Instrumental)Sapo PerapaskeroTaraf de Haïdouks2:27
6."E Lucevan le stelle" (Voice)Giacomo PucciniLicitra3:24
7."Cesar's Song" (Instrumental)GolijovKronos Quartet3:45
8."Baladele Revolutiei" (Instrumental)PerapaskeroTaraf de Haïdouks3:17
9."Dido's Lament" (Voice)Henry PurcellIva Bittová, Taraf de Haïdouks1:47
10."Je crois entendre encore" (Voice)BizetKatia And Marielle Labèque, Salvatore Licitra3:52
11."Ducho Balvaio" (Instrumental)PerapaskeroTaraf de Haïdouks3:29
12."Torna a surriento" (Voice)Ernesto de Curtis, Giambattista de Curtis, Alfredo MazzucchiKatia Labèque, Salvatore Licitra3:12
13."Without a Word" (Instrumental)GolijovKronos Quartet, Fred Frith, Christopher Laurence3:34
14."Bangi Khelimos" (Instrumental)PerapaskeroTaraf de Haïdouks2:15
15."Gloomy Sunday" (Voice)Rezsö Seress, László Jávor, Desmond CarterIva Bittova, Brian Dee, Andrew Cleyndert, Clarke Tracey, Steven Prutsman3:27
16."Close Your Eyes (Yiddish)" (Voice)Golijov, Sally PotterSalvatore Licitra, Kronos Quartet2:13
17."Je crois entendre encore (Yiddish)" (Voice)BizetLicitra4:16

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

The Man Who Cried

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Man Who Cried is a 2000 drama film written and directed by Sally Potter, centering on a young Jewish girl separated from her father amid pogroms in Russia and her subsequent odyssey through England and Paris.[1] The story spans from 1927 to the eve of World War II, depicting protagonist Fegele—renamed Susie upon arrival in England—as she works as a chorus dancer in Paris, forms bonds with fellow performer Lola (Cate Blanchett) and Romani horseman Cesar (Johnny Depp), and confronts antisemitism and personal displacement.[2] Featuring a multinational cast including Christina Ricci in the lead, John Turturro as a lecherous opera impresario, and Harry Dean Stanton, the film employs operatic elements and multilingual dialogue to underscore themes of exile and identity.[3] Produced with a modest budget by Christopher Sheppard, it premiered at the Venice Film Festival and received mixed critical response, with commendations for atmospheric visuals and performances outweighed by critiques of underdeveloped plotting and emotional restraint.[4] Despite limited commercial success, earning under $1 million at the box office, the picture highlights Potter's stylistic evolution from her earlier work Orlando.[3]

Production

Development and Pre-Production

Sally Potter conceived The Man Who Cried in the late 1990s, extending the exploratory style of her 1992 film Orlando by shifting from grand historical spectacle to a more intimate narrative of personal exile and cultural displacement.[5] The screenplay, written by Potter herself, emphasized a young protagonist's odyssey amid rising antisemitism in Europe, incorporating multilingual dialogue in Yiddish, Russian, French, and English to evoke authentic intercultural tensions and isolation.[6] Potter's vision integrated operatic elements, leveraging the protagonist's involvement in a Paris opera troupe to fuse musical performance with dramatic storytelling, aiming for a stylized blend of historical realism and emotional questing that prioritized visual minimalism and performative artifice over conventional naturalism.[5] This approach built on her experimental roots while accommodating a larger-scale production, reflecting her intent to examine human resilience through layered, non-literal aesthetics. Financing was secured via UK-French co-productions led by Working Title Films, with backing from Universal Pictures, enabling a $20 million budget—substantially higher than Potter's prior low-budget features like The Tango Lesson (1997)—which supported pre-production completion by late 1999.[7] [8] Unlike her typical deferral of director's fees until post-release, Potter received payment during the working process for this project, underscoring its relatively robust commercial framework despite creative challenges from studio involvement.[9]

Casting Decisions

Christina Ricci portrayed the protagonist Suzie (later renamed Dolly by her adoptive family), a role spanning from childhood innocence to adult displacement, selected amid the film's need for an actress capable of embodying quiet resilience amid persecution.[10] Johnny Depp was cast as Cesar, the Romani horseman and love interest, leveraging his frequent depiction of marginalized, introspective figures to evoke the character's nomadic outsider status.[11] Cate Blanchett played Lola, Suzie's flamboyant roommate and rival, while John Turturro assumed the antagonistic role of Dante, the exploitative opera impresario, forming a notable pairing of contrasting theatrical energies with Blanchett's character.[12] The ensemble incorporated international talent to mirror the narrative's themes of migration and cultural intersection, including Russian actor Oleg Yankovskiy as Suzie's cantor father and Harry Dean Stanton in a supporting capacity as an American figure aiding her early journey.[13] Depp's portrayal of a Romani character, despite lacking Romani heritage, aligned with period practices in cinema where non-ethnic actors filled such roles without contemporaneous backlash, though later academic analyses highlight reliance on romanticized stereotypes rather than strict authenticity.[14] [15] Production under Universal Pictures reportedly introduced challenges, with director Sally Potter later describing the studio-backed process as difficult, potentially influencing the emphasis on bankable stars like Depp and Blanchett over purer artistic alignments.[16]

Filming Locations and Techniques

Principal photography for The Man Who Cried took place primarily in Paris, France, and various locations across England (United Kingdom) during 1999.[17][18] These sites were selected to evoke the film's 1920s–1930s setting, leveraging Parisian streets and English period architecture for scenes depicting European migration, circus life, and urban exile, thereby blending authentic historical environments with constructed sets to maintain narrative immersion. Cinematographer Sacha Vierny, whose collaboration with director Sally Potter marked his final project before his death in 2001, employed a tableau-style framing approach characterized by sumptuous, static compositions that emphasized emotional isolation and visual poetry over dynamic action.[19][20] This technique, combined with sparse dialogue and the rhythmic integration of operatic musical elements, created a stylized, nostalgic aesthetic suited to the film's themes of displacement, drawing on Vierny's expertise in luminous, painterly imagery honed from prior works with directors like Alain Resnais.[21] Production faced logistical hurdles in achieving period authenticity for costumes, props, and sets within the constraints of an independent film's modest resources, resulting in a mix of on-location shooting and evident constructed elements that occasionally underscored the artifice.[22] Despite these challenges, the approach prioritized evocative visuals over hyper-realism, aligning with Potter's experimental style while relying on Vierny's lighting to unify disparate scenes.[5]

Narrative Structure

Plot Summary

In 1927 Soviet Russia, a young Jewish girl named Fegele is separated from her father, a cantor who emigrates to America in search of opportunity, amid anti-Semitic violence that disrupts their family.[2] Shipped to England on a boat, she is renamed Susie by authorities and placed with a Christian foster family, where she grows up mute in English but discovers a gift for singing opera.[23] As an adult in the 1930s, Susie relocates to Paris to work as a chorus girl in an opera production, intending to save money for passage to America to reunite with her father.[4] There, she befriends the outgoing Russian performer Lola and develops a romance with Cesar, a Romani horseman employed by the theater's stables.[24] The narrative traces Susie's experiences amid escalating European fascism, including Nazi sympathies among some in her circle and the impending German invasion of France, as she confronts threats to her heritage and pursues clues about her father's whereabouts.[2] The story resolves in the 1940s through wartime upheavals and personal discoveries.[23]

Character Arcs

Suzie, originally named Fegele Abramovitch, begins as a young Jewish girl in Soviet Russia in 1927, separated from her cantor father during an escape from persecution, which instills a profound sense of loss and displacement.[3] Adopted in England and renamed Suzie by a Christian family, she undergoes a forced assimilation that suppresses her ethnic and linguistic identity, rendering her largely silent and introspective as she matures into adulthood.[3] Her trajectory shifts upon relocating to Paris as a chorus dancer, where interactions with the nomadic circus troupe—particularly her romantic entanglement with Cesar—reawaken her suppressed heritage through shared music and outsider solidarity, propelling her from passive endurance to active pursuit of her father in America amid escalating wartime threats.[2] [20] Cesar, portrayed as a Romani horseman working as an extra in operatic productions, embodies marginalization through his itinerant lifestyle and cultural detachment from settled society.[2] His arc intersects with Suzie's via mutual recognition of exclusion, evolving from a solitary, smoldering figure into a supportive partner who introduces her to Gypsy communal rhythms and equestrian freedom, fostering a bond tested by Nazi incursions that force their flight.[3] [2] This relationship highlights Cesar's progression toward vulnerability, contrasting his initial reticence with moments of profound connection that underscore shared resilience against prejudice. Lola, an ambitious Russian chorus girl rooming with Suzie, drives conflict through her opportunistic pursuit of social ascent, initially leveraging her allure to court Dante for financial security.[3] Her development reveals a shift from unbridled materialism to dawning disillusionment as Dante's fascist leanings emerge, straining her alliance with Suzie and exposing the fragility of her calculated interactions within the troupe.[2] Dante, the bombastic opera tenor and circus financier, arcs from self-aggrandizing performer—hiring the women as extras and reveling in adulation—to a revealed antagonist whose anti-Romani and antisemitic prejudices culminate in betrayal, alienating allies and amplifying the troupe's fractures during the Nazi advance.[2] [3]

Themes and Interpretations

Identity, Exile, and Cultural Displacement

The protagonist's repeated name changes—from Fegele, her original Yiddish name in Soviet Russia, to Suzie upon adoption in England—illustrate the pressures of assimilation into alien cultures, where personal history is erased to facilitate survival and acceptance.[2] [4] These shifts underscore a core motif of rootlessness, as the character navigates identities imposed by adoptive families and new environments, detached from her Jewish paternal lineage and linguistic heritage.[3] Exile drives the narrative as a causal sequence beginning with separation from her cantor father amid 1927 Soviet pogroms and emigration waves, propelling her through England to 1930s Paris, where rising European fascism further erodes cultural anchors.[2] This displacement manifests not as mere relocation but as profound heritage loss, evident in her retention of fragmented Yiddish lullabies amid otherwise anglicized or francophone milieus, symbolizing an internalized void without sentimental restoration.[1] The film's portrayal avoids idealizing such rootlessness, instead depicting it as a persistent disorientation exacerbated by wartime alliances and betrayals under Nazi advances.[6] Interactions with marginal groups—Russian émigrés like Lola, Romani horseman Cesar, and opportunistic figures like Dante—expose hybrid identities forged in shared precarity, yet without romantic gloss, as cultural frictions arise from differing survival strategies amid antisemitic threats.[2] [1] Suzie's bonds, such as with Cesar's nomadic Romani troupe, highlight tentative cross-cultural affinities rooted in outsider status, but these are strained by external persecutions that prioritize ethnic purity over hybridity, reinforcing the protagonist's isolated Jewish core amid fluid, unstable affiliations.[3] This dynamic critiques assimilation's limits, portraying identity as a contested terrain shaped by historical forces rather than voluntary reinvention.[6]

Antisemitism and Historical Persecution

The film's pogrom sequence depicts Cossack horsemen torching a Jewish shtetl in Russia circa 1927, killing the protagonist's mother and prompting her orphaning and emigration, serving as the inciting incident for her displacement.[3] This portrayal evokes empirical patterns of interwar Eastern European antisemitism, where mob violence targeted Jewish communities through arson, murder, and expulsion, as documented in over 1,000 pogroms during the 1917–1921 Russian Civil War alone, claiming 35,000 to 250,000 Jewish lives primarily at the hands of White forces and irregular armies. Although the Soviet regime post-1921 officially criminalized antisemitism via decrees like the 1918 law equating pogroms with counter-revolution, latent prejudices endured, manifesting in unofficial harassment and sporadic incidents rather than state-sanctioned mass violence, challenging narratives of total suppression.[25] In Paris during the late 1930s, the narrative intensifies antisemitic depictions through the character Dante, a wealthy fascist who endorses Mussolini and Nazism, verbally assaults the Jewish protagonist Suzie, and rallies associates against Jews and Romani people amid rising swastika displays and policy echoes of Aryan supremacy.[2] This escalation causally links individual prejudice to broader ideological currents, reflecting documented surges in French antisemitism from 1933 onward, fueled by Nazi propaganda infiltration, economic scapegoating during the Depression, and groups like the Croix-de-Feu, which blended nationalism with anti-Jewish rhetoric, culminating in events such as the 1934 Clichy riots.[26] Dante's mob-like incitement parallels historical patterns where elite sympathizers mobilized street-level actions, as seen in Germany's Kristallnacht (November 9–10, 1938), where coordinated attacks destroyed 7,500 Jewish businesses and killed at least 91 Jews, setting precedents for European emulation.[27] Critiques of the film's approach highlight its selective emphasis on Jewish victims as noble archetypes amid multifaceted ethnic strife, potentially underrepresenting concurrent persecutions of Romani communities—also targeted by Dante—or Soviet-era tensions involving Ukrainians and others under nationalities policies that, while promoting autonomy, exacerbated resource-based conflicts.[28] Empirical records indicate that interwar pogroms and prejudices extended beyond Jews, with Romani facing expulsions and forced assimilation in Eastern Europe, yet the film's Jewish-centric lens aligns with protagonist focus but risks causal oversimplification by prioritizing one group's trauma over intersecting dynamics, as noted in analyses of Holocaust-era representations balancing Jewish and Romani narratives.[14] This selectivity mirrors broader historiographic debates where Soviet suppression claims obscured multi-ethnic violence patterns, privileging state ideology over ground-level data.[26]

Romance, Sexuality, and Intercultural Dynamics

In the film, the central romantic relationship develops between Suzie, a young woman of concealed Jewish heritage, and Cesar, a Romani horse trainer employed by the opera company, forming a poignant cross-cultural alliance between two marginalized figures navigating prejudice in pre-World War II Paris.[2][23] Their bond, marked by mutual understanding of outsider status, culminates in intimate scenes depicting physical and emotional closeness, including a bedroom encounter where Cesar's back is shown during intercourse, emphasizing vulnerability rather than explicitness.[29] This portrayal underscores sexuality as a means of asserting identity and connection amid encroaching threats, with Cesar's Romani background and Suzie's hidden Jewish roots intersecting in a relationship strained by societal taboos against such unions.[6] Contrasting this genuine affection, Lola, the ambitious Russian chorus girl and Suzie's roommate, engages in exploitative liaisons driven by opportunism, notably her affair with the fascist-leaning opera singer Dante Dominio, whom she pursues for financial security and social ascent.[20][3] These dynamics highlight power imbalances, as Lola's seductive dances and dalliances—featuring lewd choreography and suggestive performances—serve pragmatic ends, differing sharply from Suzie and Cesar's more egalitarian intimacy.[30] Such contrasts reveal intercultural frictions, including Russian émigré pragmatism clashing with the perils faced by Jewish and Romani characters, exacerbated by Dante's antisemitic rhetoric that indirectly endangers Suzie after he discovers her heritage during a post-coital search of her belongings.[31] The film's depiction of sexuality extends to communal settings like the opera's burlesque-infused rehearsals, where dance sequences blend eroticism with cultural expression, causally linking personal desires to broader identity struggles under persecution.[2] This intercultural lens portrays romance not as escapist but as fraught with real-world consequences, as the Nazi invasion severs Suzie and Cesar's union, forcing Cesar's flight and underscoring how ethnic prejudices dismantle even resilient bonds between Jewish and Romani individuals.[32]

Historical Depictions and Accuracy

Factual Basis for Events

The film's portrayal of Jewish emigration from Russia following the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution aligns with historical records of widespread displacement. The Russian Civil War (1917–1922) and accompanying pogroms, which killed between 50,000 and 200,000 Jews, prompted significant outflows, with over 2 million Jews leaving the former Russian Empire by the mid-1920s, many seeking refuge in Western Europe including France and Britain.[33] This wave included families fleeing violence and economic collapse, mirroring the protagonist's early journey.[34] Antisemitism persisted in the Soviet Union despite the state's official policy of atheism and suppression of religion, providing a realistic backdrop for familial persecution depicted in the narrative. Under Bolshevik rule, anti-Jewish violence continued through state-sanctioned discrimination and cultural stereotypes, evolving into Stalin-era campaigns like the 1930s purges that disproportionately targeted Jewish intellectuals and officials.[35] Popular antisemitism endured grassroots forms, contradicting the regime's ideological rejection of religious prejudice.[25] Paris's interwar refugee communities, particularly Russian and Eastern European Jewish enclaves, are accurately reflected in the film's setting of émigré networks and cultural adaptation. By the 1930s, Paris hosted around 43,000 Russian exiles and tens of thousands of Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe, forming vibrant but precarious communities in districts like Belleville and the Marais, often reliant on informal economies.[36] These groups included performers and laborers escaping Soviet consolidation and earlier pogroms.[37] The depicted cabaret culture in 1930s Paris draws from the era's flourishing nightlife, sustained through the Années folles into the Depression years. Venues like the Moulin Rouge and Folies Bergère employed diverse expatriates in song, dance, and revue shows, blending artistic innovation with commercial spectacle amid economic flux.[38] Refugee artists, including Russians, integrated into this scene, performing Yiddish-inflected or multicultural acts.[39] The rising Nazi influence in 1930s France, shown through growing antisemitic tensions, corresponds to the era's political shifts. French fascist leagues, such as the Croix-de-Feu, gained traction with over 500,000 members by 1936, echoing pro-German sentiments and anti-immigrant rhetoric that paralleled Nazi ideology without direct German control.[40] This domestic extremism foreshadowed collaborationist attitudes.[41] The 1940 German invasion, a pivotal event in the film, matches documented military history. On May 10, 1940, Wehrmacht forces launched Fall Gelb, bypassing the Maginot Line through the Ardennes, overwhelming Allied defenses and leading to France's armistice on June 22 after six weeks of combat, resulting in over 1.8 million French prisoners.[42] This rapid conquest enabled immediate occupation policies affecting refugees and Jews.[43]

Artistic Liberties and Criticisms

The film's depiction of a large-scale antisemitic pogrom in a Russian Jewish village in 1927 serves as a pivotal inciting event, portraying Cossack-led mob violence that destroys the community and separates the young protagonist from her father. However, following the Bolshevik consolidation of power after the Russian Civil War (1917–1922), Soviet authorities implemented explicit policies condemning antisemitism and actively suppressing pogroms to maintain order and legitimize the regime, with major outbreaks of such violence having largely ceased by the mid-1920s in favor of subtler, state-orchestrated discriminatory measures like cultural assimilation pressures and professional quotas. This sequence likely amplifies overt, pre-revolutionary-style persecution for visceral dramatic effect, potentially distorting the historical shift toward institutionalized rather than chaotic antisemitism under Soviet rule, though isolated incidents persisted amid broader anti-religious campaigns. To streamline the narrative across decades, the film compresses timelines and adjusts character nationalities and trajectories, such as the protagonist's rapid transition from a 1927 refugee child in England to an adult performer in 1930s Paris amid rising Nazism. These alterations prioritize thematic exploration of displacement and identity over precise chronology, which can oversimplify the protracted, multifaceted causes of interwar Jewish and Romani migrations, including bureaucratic emigration barriers from the USSR and varying national responses to fascism, thereby risking a causal narrative that emphasizes personal fate over systemic geopolitical factors. Criticisms of Romani representation center on stereotypical elements, including the casting of non-Roma actor Johnny Depp as Cesar, a charismatic Romani horseman whose romance with the Jewish protagonist dominates much of the film's latter acts. Scholar Yosefa Loshitzky notes that such portrayals draw on entrenched romantic tropes of the "hot Gypsy lovers," projecting seductive, adventurous ideals onto Romani figures that align with historical exoticization rather than authentic cultural dynamics, particularly in a story intersecting Jewish and Romani persecutions under Nazism. This choice, while enhancing intercultural drama, has been seen as perpetuating reductive projections amid the film's focus on outsider solidarity, without deeper engagement with Romani historical agency or diversity.

Release and Commercial Performance

Premiere and Distribution

The film premiered at the 57th Venice International Film Festival on September 2, 2000, competing for the Golden Lion.[44] Following its festival debut, it screened at the BFI London Film Festival on November 5, 2000, before a general release in the United Kingdom on December 8, 2000.[44][45] In the United States, the film opened on May 25, 2001, with a limited theatrical rollout targeted at art-house audiences, aligning with its independent production and stylistic approach under director Sally Potter.[46] Distribution emphasized select urban markets and festival circuits to reach niche viewers interested in dramatic period pieces, rather than wide commercial release.[3] Promotional materials, including trailers, focused on the ensemble cast featuring Johnny Depp as the Romani horseman Cesar, Cate Blanchett as cabaret performer Lola, and Christina Ricci in the lead role of Suzie, leveraging their established profiles to draw attention to the film's intercultural romance and historical themes.[47] Home video distribution followed, with DVD editions becoming available by early 2002 to extend accessibility beyond initial screenings.[48]

Box Office Results

The Man Who Cried opened in limited release in the United States and Canada on May 25, 2001, across 11 theaters, generating $93,455 in its debut weekend.[49] The film's total domestic gross reached $747,092 over its theatrical run.[50] Internationally, earnings were similarly modest, contributing to a worldwide box office total of $1,322,763.[18] This performance reflected the challenges faced by independent dramas with specialized themes, which typically achieve limited mainstream penetration despite name recognition from cast members including Johnny Depp and Cate Blanchett.[51]
TerritoryGross
United States & Canada$747,092
International$575,671
Worldwide$1,322,763

Reception

Critical Responses

Critical reception to The Man Who Cried was mixed, with reviewers praising its visual style and performances while frequently criticizing the narrative execution, sentimentality, and pacing.[4] The film holds a 35% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 69 reviews, reflecting a consensus that the "storyline is overwrought and awkward, and the audience is distanced from the flatly drawn characters."[4] On Metacritic, it scores 40 out of 100 from 22 critics, indicating generally unfavorable response.[52] Roger Ebert awarded the film three out of four stars, commending its ambition in spanning time and space while trusting viewers to track the protagonist's emotional journey without heavy exposition.[2] He highlighted the director's restraint in building quiet intensity amid historical upheaval. In contrast, Peter Bradshaw of The Guardian described it as an "engaging drama" with stylish performances from Cate Blanchett and John Turturro, but noted its improbability and occasional absurdity.[53] However, another Guardian review labeled it "disappointing" and "deeply sentimental," faulting the destiny-driven plot set in 1930s France.[54] Variety critiqued it as a "beaucoup-vu" (overly familiar) drama of displacement and survival, suggesting the themes of Jewish exile and pre-war Paris felt clichéd despite the ensemble.[3] Common praises centered on the lush cinematography, haunting score, and strong acting—particularly Christina Ricci's restrained portrayal of the mute protagonist and supporting turns by Blanchett and Johnny Depp—but detractors pointed to melodramatic plotting, bizarre tone shifts from operatic excess to understated tragedy, and a slow pace that alienated viewers.[20] [55] The BBC noted "bizarre casting" and stylistic fusions that yielded "moments" but lacked cohesion.[56] Overall, while aesthetically admired, the film's execution drew dominant complaints for failing to emotionally engage despite its historical scope.[57]

Audience and Commercial Feedback

Audience reception to The Man Who Cried has been mixed, with aggregate user ratings indicating moderate appeal. On IMDb, the film averages 6.1 out of 10 from 17,002 ratings, reflecting divides among viewers on its artistic merits versus accessibility.[18] Rotten Tomatoes audience score stands at 59% based on over 25,000 ratings, where positive responses emphasize visual beauty and thematic resonance, while detractors cite emotional overreach.[4] Common viewer feedback highlights tensions between the film's pacing—often described as deliberate and poetic—and its capacity to engage broadly. Supporters value Sally Potter's stylistic approach, including evocative cinematography and musical elements, for evoking historical and emotional depth.[4] [58] In contrast, frequent complaints focus on perceived emotional manipulation, where dramatic elements feel contrived rather than earned, and underdeveloped characters that provide limited dimensionality for the cast.[4] The film's commercial resonance with audiences remains niche, evidenced by steady but unremarkable user engagement without spikes from revivals or viral interest. Retrospective discussions in film blogs note occasional appreciation for its introspective tone, yet it lacks a dedicated cult following or widespread reevaluation driving renewed viewership.[18]

Awards and Nominations

The Man Who Cried competed for the Golden Lion at the 57th Venice International Film Festival in 2000 but did not win.[59] Cate Blanchett received acclaim for her portrayal of Lola, earning the National Board of Review Award for Best Supporting Actress in 2001.[60] She also won the Florida Film Critics Circle Award for Best Supporting Actress in 2002.[60] Additionally, Blanchett secured the Chlotrudis Society for Independent Film's Audience Award for Best Supporting Actress in 2002.[61] The film's score by Osvaldo Golijov was nominated for Discovery of the Year at the 2001 World Soundtrack Awards.[62] The film garnered no nominations from the Academy Awards or Golden Globe Awards.[63]

Music and Soundtrack

Composition and Contributions

The original score for The Man Who Cried was composed by Osvaldo Golijov, marking his debut in film scoring.[64][65] Golijov, an Argentine composer known for syncretic works drawing on Jewish and Latin American traditions, crafted music that fused Yiddish folk elements—such as lullabies and doinas—with operatic motifs and Eastern European gypsy influences, creating a tapestry reflective of the film's multicultural immigrant narrative set in 1920s-1930s Europe.[66][67] Key stylistic choices included adaptations of classical opera arias into diegetic cabaret performances, notably a Yiddish rendition of Georges Bizet's "Je crois entendre encore" from Les pêcheurs de perles, which Golijov arranged to evoke emotional intimacy through altered language and instrumentation.[68] Original cues like "Close Your Eyes" and "Cesar's Song" employed string quartets for melancholic introspection, blending modal scales from klezmer music with contemporary minimalism to underscore themes of displacement without overt sentimentalism.[69][70] Collaborators extended beyond Golijov to include the Kronos Quartet, who performed his string-based pieces with a raw, folk-inflected timbre; tenor Salvatore Licitra, delivering powerhouse operatic vocals for arias like "Di quella pira" from Verdi's Il trovatore; and the Romanian gypsy ensemble Taraf de Haïdouks, contributing energetic tracks such as "Tiganesca" that incorporated violin and cimbalom for authentic Balkan flair.[71][72] These multilingual elements—spanning Yiddish, French, Italian, and Romani influences—were selected to mirror the characters' linguistic fragmentation and cultural hybridity, with Golijov prioritizing acoustic authenticity over synthesized effects.[73][74]

Role in the Film

The Yiddish lullaby composed by Osvaldo Golijov serves as a recurring motif that anchors the protagonist Fegele's (later Suzie) sense of identity and familial continuity amid displacement. Sung by her father in the opening sequence as pogroms erupt in their Russian shtetl in 1927, the lullaby symbolizes her severed Jewish heritage and the quest to reunite with him, reappearing in variations to evoke memory and longing during her silent wanderings through England and Paris.[75][6] Opera selections, including arias from Bizet's Carmen such as "Je crois entendre encore," function to amplify the film's emotional intensity, mirroring the characters' passions and underscoring a sense of fatalism tied to impending European catastrophe. These pieces integrate with gypsy violin accompaniments during Suzie's cabaret performances, heightening her isolation through musical interludes that compensate for sparse dialogue and highlight cultural clashes between her heritage and adopted environments.[2][76][6] While the soundtrack's eclectic blend—merging Golijov's score with full opera renditions—effectively counters the protagonist's emotional restraint and drives narrative exposition, some reviewers noted its potential to veer toward melodrama, inflating quieter dramatic moments with operatic grandeur that risks sentimentality in the service of thematic emphasis.[3][11]

Legacy and Retrospective Analysis

Cultural and Artistic Impact

The Man Who Cried has exerted a limited influence on subsequent independent cinema, primarily reinforcing director Sally Potter's established style of stylized, introspective narratives rather than catalyzing shifts in genre conventions or thematic explorations of displacement. While the film's portrayal of a Jewish émigré's journey amid rising antisemitism draws on historical motifs of exile, it has not been widely cited as a direct progenitor for later indie works on similar themes, such as identity loss in migratory contexts.[6] Instead, it contributes to Potter's oeuvre by extending her interest in artifice and emotional restraint, evident in prior films like Orlando (1992), without introducing paradigm-altering techniques.[5] The film's archival significance lies in its representation of early 2000s art-house cinema grappling with personal and cultural identity, particularly through its blend of operatic elements and restrained performances. It provided an early platform for Cate Blanchett to demonstrate versatility in evoking classical Hollywood glamour within a modern indie framework, influencing perceptions of her dramatic capabilities before mainstream breakthroughs.[77] Availability on select streaming services has enabled sporadic niche rediscovery, appealing to audiences interested in period dramas with musical undercurrents, though it remains outside broader cultural revivals.[18] Academic engagement with the film is sparse, with discussions centering on its visual aesthetics—such as close-ups and silhouette compositions—over substantive innovations in content or narrative structure. Critics like J. Hoberman have noted its resourceful employment of stylistic elements to elevate otherwise conventional storytelling, underscoring its value as a technical exercise rather than a transformative cultural artifact.[5] This focus highlights the film's endurance as a case study in visual physicality within Potter's body of work, rather than a catalyst for wider discourse on displacement or identity politics.[5]

Enduring Criticisms and Reassessments

Critics have persistently highlighted the film's uneven pacing and contrived narrative structure, which undermine its dramatic tension despite the gravity of historical persecution depicted. Rose Capp described the protagonist Susie as a "frustratingly blank canvas, shaped by but rarely shaping other characters or events," arguing that this passivity, combined with deserted, theatrical settings in Paris, fosters detachment rather than immersion.[6] Similarly, J. Hoberman noted the loss of "driving drama" amid "casting silliness," where mismatched portrayals erode realism in scenes of exile and identity crisis.[78] These flaws causally stem from Sally Potter's stylized direction, prioritizing visual and musical eclecticism over coherent progression, resulting in a muddled journey from Russia to America and France that feels forced rather than organic.[79] Casting choices have drawn ongoing scrutiny for compromising authenticity, particularly Christina Ricci's portrayal of the resilient Jewish refugee Suzie and Johnny Depp's role as a Romani horseman. Reviewers contended that Ricci's performance lacks the depth to convey agency amid victimhood, rendering the character's silence—extending through the film's first third—as emotionally vacant rather than poignant.[58] Depp's accent and demeanor were seen as unconvincing, further distancing audiences from the ethnic and cultural stakes of Romani persecution under Nazism.[80] While the film factually nods to pogroms and deportations as causal drivers of displacement—events verifiable in historical records—the emphasis on passive suffering without robust character-driven responses has been faulted for sidelining personal agency, prioritizing sentimental destiny over nuanced resilience.[54] Later reassessments in the 2010s and 2020s, often in film blogs and retrospectives, reinforce critiques of emotional shallowness beneath heavy themes of loss and prejudice. A 2022 analysis lamented the "wasted time" on a story with strong performers like Cate Blanchett yet undermined by pretentious execution, echoing earlier views of schmaltzy melodrama clashing with minimalism.[81] Capp's "crocodile tears" metaphor persists as a causal lens: contrived theatricality and incidental use of Jewish heritage as "dramatic pretext" fail to elicit authentic empathy, despite acknowledgments of the soundtrack's strengths in evoking era-specific multicultural tensions.[6] These views balance recognition of factual historical victimization—such as the 1930s rise of antisemitism—with unexcused narrative weaknesses, maintaining that Potter's feminist inversions, like objectifying male characters, flatten relational dynamics without deepening thematic impact.[82]

References

  1. The Man Who Cried | Films - Sally Potter
  2. The Man Who Cried movie review (2001) - Roger Ebert
  3. The Man Who Cried - Variety
  4. The Man Who Cried - Rotten Tomatoes
  5. Potter, Sally - Senses of Cinema
  6. Crocodile Tears: Sally Potter's The Man Who Cried
  7. Pushing limits? Yes - Los Angeles Times
  8. Ovitz joins foreign legion - Variety
  9. Money? - Sally Potter
  10. Christina Ricci for "The Man who Cried" - Dark Horizons
  11. THE MAN WHO CRIED (Sally Potter, 2000) - Dennis Grunes
  12. Sally Potter: 'There's nothing like hearing a whole place vibrate with ...
  13. Oleg Yankovskiy filmography - FamousFix.com list
  14. [PDF] The Representation of Romanies and Jews in Some Holocaust Films
  15. (PDF) The Imagined Gypsy: the Palindrome of the 'Human Being'
  16. Interview : Sally Potter -
  17. The Man who Cried, Feature Film, 1999-2000 | Crew United
  18. The Man Who Cried (2000) - IMDb
  19. Sacha Vierny | | The Guardian
  20. FILM REVIEW; Big Moments, Beautiful but Mysterious
  21. The Representation of Romanies and Jews in Some Holocaust Films
  22. The Man Who Cried - Chlotrudis Society for Independent Film
  23. The Man Who Cried (2000) - Turner Classic Movies - TCM
  24. The Man Who Cried (2000) - Plot - IMDb
  25. Jews in Russia and the Soviet Union: Chronology of Events - Refworld
  26. Elissa Bemporad. Legacy of Blood: Jews, Pogroms, and Ritual ...
  27. Pogroms | Holocaust Encyclopedia
  28. 'Man Who Cried' a stoic slice of Holocaust era - Seattle PI
  29. The Man Who Cried (2000) - Parents guide - IMDb
  30. Film review: Man Who Cried, The - Deseret News
  31. Not Much More Than Tears in 'The Man Who Cried'
  32. The Man Who Cried | Films - Adventure Pictures
  33. Jews In and After the 1917 Russian Revolution
  34. Soviet Jewish immigrants | Research Starters - EBSCO
  35. A Note on Anti-Semitism in Soviet Russia (Post-Stalin Period) - jstor
  36. After the Romanovs: Russian Exiles in Paris - Tocqueville 21
  37. Interwar Paris: Capitale de Refuge - We Refugees Archive
  38. The Spectacular History of Paris' Cabarets
  39. Cheap Thrills: The Highs and Lows of Paris's Cabaret Culture
  40. Nationalism, Collaboration, and Resistance: France under Nazi ...
  41. How France's Vichy Regime Became Hitler's Willing Collaborators
  42. Battle of France | History, Summary, Maps, & Combatants - Britannica
  43. German Invasion of Western Europe, May 1940
  44. Release info - The Man Who Cried (2000) - IMDb
  45. The Man Who Cried (2000) UK, US and World Release Dates
  46. The Man Who Cried Tickets & Showtimes | Fandango
  47. The Man Who Cried (2000) Theatrical Trailer - YouTube
  48. https://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/3191/man-who-cried-the/
  49. The Man Who Cried - Box Office Mojo
  50. The Man Who Cried - Box Office Mojo
  51. The Man Who Cried (2001) - Box Office and Financial Information
  52. The Man Who Cried Reviews - Metacritic
  53. The Man Who Cried | Movies | The Guardian
  54. The Man Who Cried | Reviews | guardian.co.uk Film
  55. The Man Who Cried - Rolling Stone
  56. Films - review - The Man Who Cried - BBC
  57. Review: The Man Who Cried - Blogcritics
  58. The Man Who Cried (2000) - User reviews - IMDb
  59. All the awards and nominations of The Man Who Cried - Filmaffinity
  60. The Man Who Cried - Where to Watch and Stream - TV Guide
  61. 2002, 8th Annual Awards - Chlotrudis Society for Independent Film
  62. The Man Who Cried (2000) - Awards - IMDb
  63. The 72nd Academy Awards | 2000 - Oscars.org
  64. The Man Who Cried - Osvaldo Golijov
  65. The Man Who Cried, film score | Details - AllMusic
  66. Golijov: Last Round; Lullaby and Doina, etc | Music - The Guardian
  67. Yiddishkayt as Listening Key in the Music of Osvaldo Golijov | In geveb
  68. The Man Who Cried (2000) - Soundtracks - IMDb
  69. https://www.discogs.com/release/5584618-Various-The-Man-Who-Cried-Original-Motion-Picture-Soundtrack
  70. The Man Who Cried: CDs & Vinyl - Amazon.com
  71. ‎The Man Who Cried (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) - Album by ...
  72. The Man Who Cried - Original Motion Picture Soundtrack - Spotify
  73. The Man Who Cried Soundtrack (2000) - MovieMusic.com
  74. The Man Who Cried Soundtrack - SoundtrackINFO
  75. Lullaby & Doina — Osvaldo Golijov
  76. Sunday March 8 2020 Program notes - Ensemble Q
  77. Where We Are Is Here: On the Influence of Female Filmmakers
  78. The Man Who Cried | Telescope Film
  79. Gender Trouble - Artforum
  80. 'The Man Who Cried' Saw Johnny Depp Adrift in a Career Low
  81. Movie Review: The Man Who Cried – Made Me Cry That I Wasted ...
  82. The Man Who Cried | Reviews - Screen Daily
User Avatar
No comments yet.