Hubbry Logo
Throwing CopperThrowing CopperMain
Open search
Throwing Copper
Community hub
Throwing Copper
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Throwing Copper
Throwing Copper
Throwing Copper
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Throwing Copper
Studio album by
Live
ReleasedApril 26, 1994 (1994-04-26)
RecordedJuly–September 1993
StudioPachyderm (Cannon Falls, Minnesota)
Genre
Length59:32
LabelRadioactive
Producer
Live chronology
Mental Jewelry
(1991) 		Throwing Copper
(1994) 		Secret Samadhi
(1997)
Singles from Throwing Copper
  1. "Selling the Drama"
    Released: May 1994[3]
  2. "I Alone"
    Released: December 1994[4]
  3. "Lightning Crashes"
    Released: June 1995[5]
  4. "All Over You"
    Released: September 1995[3]
  5. "White, Discussion"
    Released: 1995

Throwing Copper is the third studio album by American alternative rock band Live, released on April 26, 1994, on former MCA Records subsidiary Radioactive Records.[6] It was produced by Jerry Harrison of Talking Heads and was recorded at Pachyderm Recording Studio.[7] Throwing Copper has generally been regarded as Live's best album, having sold over 8 million copies and certified 8× platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America.[8]

Cover art

[edit]

The cover art is a painting by Scottish artist Peter Howson titled Sisters of Mercy. On September 23, 2005, it was sold for $186,000 by Christie's in New York. The painting is oil on canvas and measures 243 by 182 centimetres (7.97 ft × 5.97 ft).[9]

25th anniversary reissue

[edit]

In May 2019, the band announced a 25th-anniversary reissue of Throwing Copper, which was released on July 19.[10] The reissue contains three bonus tracks: "Hold Me Up", which was recorded during the original Throwing Copper sessions and later heard in the 2008 comedy Zack and Miri Make a Porno but was not officially released;[11] "We Deal in Dreams", which had been released as a single off the band's 2004 compilation album Awake: The Best of Live; and "Susquehanna", another previously unreleased track originally recorded in 1993, though it had been written during recording sessions for the band's first studio album, Mental Jewelry.

Critical reception

[edit]
Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusicStarStarStarStarHalf star[12]
Classic RockStarStarStarStar[13]
The Encyclopedia of Popular MusicStarStarStarStar[14]
The Great Rock Discography7/10[15]
MusicHound RockStarStarStarStar[16]
QStarStarStarStar[17]
Rolling StoneStarStarStarStar[18]
The Rolling Stone Album GuideStarStarStarStar[19]
Spin Alternative Record Guide7/10[20]
The Village VoiceC+[21]

Throwing Copper has typically been regarded as Live's strongest album. A Rolling Stone review stated that the band "strive for an epic sound" and successfully execute on that goal;[18] retrospective reviews have been similarly positive, with the Jakarta Post describing the album as "a solid beast from front to back" and uDiscoverMusic characterizing it as "challenging, yet commendably powerful".[22][23] The instrumentation on the album has been generally praised: Rolling Stone considered the musicians to be "expert players [who] drop musical smart bombs with unerring precision", and the Jakarta Post referred to the music as "absolutely dynamic and catchy".[18][22] Singer Ed Kowalczyk was applauded for his vocal performance as well, with a retrospective Stereogum review noting his ability to "raise his voice from a plaintive hush to a clenched roar".[24]

The lyrics of the album received more mixed reviews. The Jakarta Post felt that Throwing Copper "managed to push earnestness and wild esotericism as far as it could go without feeling resoundingly cheesy", but Gina Boldman of AllMusic was more negative, stating that the album's "melodrama [is] a bit much".[12] Stereogum described Kowalczyk's lyrics as "mystic gibberish" that nevertheless featured "memorably inscrutable turns of phrase".[24]

A 2024 review by Paolo Ragusa of Consequence of Sound credits this album with starting post-grunge and shifting rock music to a new direction after the death of Kurt Cobain by combining some harder rock influences with clearer vocals, softer guitar melodies, and the production of Jerry Harrison to make a distinct sound.[25]

Track listing

[edit]

All lyrics are written by Ed Kowalczyk; all music is composed by Live.

Original compact disc issue
No.TitleLength
1."The Dam at Otter Creek"4:43
2."Selling the Drama"3:26
3."I Alone"3:50
4."Iris"3:59
5."Lightning Crashes"5:25
6."Top"2:42
7."All Over You"3:59
8."Shit Towne"3:48
9."T.B.D."4:28
10."Stage"3:08
11."Waitress"2:49
12."Pillar of Davidson" ([note 1])6:46
13."White, Discussion"6:08
14."Horse" (unlisted track[note 2])4:16
Europe and Australia Two CD set Four Songs
No.TitleLength
1."Operation Spirit"3:19
2."Good Pain"5:39
3."Heaven Wore a Shirt"3:38
4."Negation"3:37
25th anniversary reissue bonus tracks
No.TitleLength
15."Hold Me Up" (from the film Zack and Miri Make a Porno, previously unreleased) 
16."We Deal in Dreams" (previously released on Awake: The Best of Live) 
17."Susquehanna" (previously unreleased) 
25th anniversary reissue bonus disc: Live at Woodstock '94
No.TitleLength
1."Iris" 
2."Top" 
3."The Beauty of Gray" 
4."Selling the Drama" 
5."Shit Towne" 
6."Lightning Crashes" 
7."I Alone" 
8."Operation Spirit (The Tyranny of Tradition)" 
9."White, Discussion" 
Notes
  1. ^ "Pillar of Davidson" was not included on the original 1994 vinyl version.
  2. ^ "Horse" was an unlisted track on the 1994 releases.[26] It was not included on the original 1994 vinyl version, but the 2012 reissue added "Horse" as a listed track on the D-side.

Personnel

[edit]

Adapted credits from the liner notes of Throwing Copper.[7]

Live
Technical personnel

Charts

[edit]

Certifications

[edit]
Sales certifications for Throwing Copper
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[56] 10× Platinum 700,000‡
Belgium (BRMA)[57] Gold 25,000*
Canada (Music Canada)[58] 7× Platinum 700,000^
Netherlands (NVPI)[59] 2× Platinum 200,000^
New Zealand (RMNZ)[60] 6× Platinum 90,000^
Sweden (GLF)[61] Gold 50,000^
United Kingdom (BPI)[62] Gold 100,000^
United States (RIAA)[8] 8× Platinum 8,000,000^

* Sales figures based on certification alone.
^ Shipments figures based on certification alone.
‡ Sales+streaming figures based on certification alone.

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Throwing Copper

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Throwing Copper is the third studio by the American band Live, released on April 26, 1994, by Radioactive Records, a subsidiary of . The album was produced by of and the band itself, and recorded at in , from July to September 1993. Featuring the core lineup of vocalist , guitarist Chad Taylor, bassist , and drummer —all natives who formed the band in 1984—it marked Live's commercial breakthrough, blending introspective lyrics with explosive instrumentation. The album's success propelled it to number one on the chart on May 6, 1995, after a slow initial climb from its debut at number 38 the previous year. It has been certified eight times by the RIAA for sales exceeding 8 million copies alone, with worldwide sales surpassing 9.7 million. Key singles included "Selling the Drama," which topped the chart, and "," which also reached number one there and became a radio staple amid its themes of , , and rebirth. Other notable tracks like "" peaked at number 6 on the chart, with four of the album's five singles charting in the top 10 of that format. Throwing Copper solidified Live's place in the scene, earning praise for its emotional depth and dynamic sound, often described as spiritually charged and accessible. Its release coincided with high-profile performances, including , amplifying its cultural impact during a pivotal era for and music. The album remains the band's best-selling and most critically acclaimed work, influencing subsequent releases and enduring through anniversary reissues and events, including the 30th anniversary Jubilee Tour with in 2024, that highlight its lasting resonance with fans.

Background

Band formation and early years

Live, originally formed as Public Affection, originated in , in the mid-1980s when four childhood friends— on vocals, Chad Taylor on guitar, on bass, and on drums—began playing music together. Taylor and first bonded over their shared interest in during their time in , while and joined them in , solidifying the lineup that would remain intact for decades. The group started as a high school project, performing covers, such as U2's "Like a Song," at local events like school talent shows. They bonded over alternative bands like and . Under the name Public Affection, the band honed their sound through numerous local club gigs in the area throughout the late , gradually building a dedicated regional following. They opened for national acts, including the Pixies at the Chameleon Club in 1989, and ventured to iconic venues like New York's , where their energetic performances caught the attention of industry figures such as . In 1989, the band self-released their debut album, The Death of a , as a cassette-only project funded through local efforts, which helped showcase their original material and attract further interest. By 1991, after submitting demo tapes that impressed label executives, Public Affection signed with Radioactive Records, a of MCA, marking their transition to a professional outfit. The band then changed their name to Live to reflect a more dynamic identity, releasing their major-label debut later that year, which served as a crucial stepping stone toward broader recognition.

Development leading to the album

Following the release of their debut album in late 1991, Live experienced moderate commercial success that established a foundation for growth while underscoring the limitations of their initial sound. The album peaked at No. 73 on the chart, selling steadily through alternative radio airplay and promotion, but its psychedelic-leaning style garnered mixed reviews and failed to achieve widespread mainstream breakthrough. This performance built audience momentum, particularly among listeners, yet highlighted the band's need to evolve toward a more aggressive, radio-friendly aesthetic to expand their reach. In response, Live pursued a creative shift for their follow-up, aiming to transcend the introspective, psychedelic influences of in favor of harder-edged characterized by dynamic builds, heavier riffs, and crashing crescendos. Frontman Ed Kowalczyk's songwriting also deepened, incorporating more personal and spiritual themes drawn from and real-life experiences such as loss, as evident in tracks exploring cycles of life, death, and emotional . This evolution reflected the band's maturation, with Kowalczyk emphasizing "big songs, big feelings, big dynamics" to capture raw emotional release. Radioactive Records provided crucial backing for this major follow-up, with label executive Gary Kurfirst championing and facilitating resources to amplify their potential after Mental Jewelry's promise. To refine their new material, Live toured extensively from 1992 to 1993, performing over 100 shows across and in support of the debut while road-testing embryonic songs from the upcoming album. These grueling tours, including headline dates and opening slots for other acts, allowed to draw from on-the-road and personal hardships, honing a tighter, more visceral live sound that informed Throwing Copper's intensity.

Recording and production

Studio sessions

The recording of Throwing Copper occurred from July to September 1993 at Pachyderm Recording Studio in , spanning approximately three months. The studio's isolated rural setting, nestled in the woods, was selected to minimize distractions and foster creative focus and inspiration for the band, building on its reputation as a productive space previously used by Nirvana for . Band members lived communally on the residential studio grounds during the sessions, enabling an immersive environment that supported continuous collaboration. The process involved intense daily routines, with the group building tracks from initial ideas. Basic tracks were captured live in few takes to prioritize raw energy, with some overdubs employed for guitars to maintain authenticity. Jerry Harrison played a key role in guiding the sessions, encouraging the band's creative risks while steering technical aspects.

Production contributions

, the guitarist and keyboardist from , served as the producer for Throwing Copper, bringing his extensive experience in to refine the band's sound. Selected for his expertise in crafting polished yet organic productions, Harrison helped balance Live's raw, energetic style with structured arrangements, such as tightening extended song structures while preserving emotional intensity. Engineering duties were handled by Lou Giordano, who emphasized capturing natural drum sounds from drummer with minimal processing to maintain dynamics and authenticity. This approach contributed to the album's live-like feel, complemented by layered guitar textures that added depth to the edge. Mixing was overseen by , who focused on preserving the album's , using room microphones to enhance ambience in tracks like "" without over-compression. This technique highlighted the contrast between quiet verses and explosive choruses, elevating the overall impact. Vocalist took primary responsibility for vocals and lyrics, delivering introspective and anthemic performances that defined the album's emotional core. Guitarist Chad Taylor achieved his distinctive tones through Marshall amplifiers, often splitting signals across multiple amps including Fender and Vox for rich, layered overdubs that supported the aesthetic. The isolated recording environment at Pachyderm Studio fostered focused creativity, allowing the band to experiment freely under Harrison's guidance.

Music and lyrics

Musical style

Throwing Copper is classified as with prominent influences, marking Live's shift toward a more commercially accessible sound within the 1990s alternative landscape. The album fuses riffs, acoustic introspection, and expansive, arena-oriented choruses, creating a dynamic blend that balances intensity with melody. This stylistic approach distinguishes it as a quintessential record, emphasizing emotional depth through rock structures rather than the raw nihilism of pioneers. Instrumentally, the album is guitar-driven, with heavy distorted leads and riffs providing the core propulsion, as heard in tracks like "I Alone," where Taylor's aggressive guitar work anchors the song's brooding energy. Patrick Dahlheimer's rhythmic bass lines and Chad Gracey's dynamic drumming contribute to the album's propulsive feel, often shifting from restrained grooves to thunderous crescendos. Occasional keyboards and atmospheric textures, such as those in "Selling the Drama," add subtle layers, enhancing the overall sonic depth without overpowering the rock foundation. The songs exhibit varied structures, typically ranging from three to seven minutes, employing classic quiet-loud dynamics that build tension through sparse verses—often featuring clean or acoustic guitars—before erupting into explosive, hook-laden choruses. exemplifies this progression, starting with a haunting acoustic intro and swelling to a , anthemic peak driven by layered guitars and pounding drums. These arrangements prioritize melodic accessibility, making the tracks suitable for radio play while retaining a sense of raw urgency. In evolution from Live's debut album (1991), which leaned into funk-infused experimentation, Throwing Copper adopts a harsher, more streamlined edge. It incorporates 1990s alt-rock trends, echoing the abrasive energy of Nirvana but tempered with U2-like melodic hooks and -inspired jangle, resulting in tighter compositions that amplify the band's introspective rock identity.

Themes and lyrical content

Throwing Copper's lyrics, penned primarily by lead singer , delve into profound existential and spiritual territories, exploring the interplay of , death, and as central motifs. The album's thematic core revolves around the cyclical nature of existence, often portrayed through vivid, metaphorical imagery that transcends literal narrative. For instance, "Lightning Crashes" vividly depicts a hospital scene where an elderly woman's death coincides with a young mother's , symbolizing the transference of energy and reincarnation's continuum. This track draws inspiration from Kowalczyk's observations of real events, including ICU deaths and unit births, creating a "montage of meanings" open to personal interpretation. Recurring motifs of guilt and redemption emerge in tracks like "Selling the Drama," where Kowalczyk critiques the manipulative tactics of political and religious leaders who exploit spiritual fears for personal gain, evoking a sense of collective culpability and the quest for authentic redemption. Similarly, "" grapples with isolation and ambition, reflecting Kowalczyk's solitary writing process in a remote and his on human frailty, as in the line "It's easier not to be wise," which surrenders to while seeking philosophical clarity. In "T.B.D.," themes of spiritual awakening and societal surface through revelations, connecting Kowalczyk's younger self to broader epiphanies about personal and cultural disconnection. The album's closing track, "White, Discussion," addresses religious hypocrisy through a sampled preacher's ominous on , underscoring societal inaction and alienation amid "politically correct" that fails to inspire change. Kowalczyk's lyrical style is poetic and abstract, favoring metaphorical depth over straightforward to evoke emotional ; this approach stems from his spiritual explorations, influenced by philosophical and religious traditions—notably the teachings of Indian philosopher on self-awareness and freedom from conditioning—along with echoes of his Christian background. Personal experiences, such as introspective isolation during songwriting, further infuse the words with authenticity. Overall, the lyrics capture the ' blend of and hope, with dynamic musical builds occasionally amplifying their intensity for visceral impact.

Release

Album launch

Throwing Copper was officially released on April 26, 1994, through Radioactive Records, a subsidiary of MCA Records. The album was distributed in standard formats including compact disc, cassette, and vinyl, catering to the dominant physical media preferences of the mid-1990s music market. It comprises 13 primary tracks, with certain editions featuring an unlisted hidden track titled "Horse" at the end, effectively totaling 14 songs and extending the runtime to approximately 59 minutes. The marketing approach emphasized the album's role as an cornerstone within the prevailing grunge-dominated landscape of the early , leveraging the genre's momentum while highlighting Live's distinct sound. Radioactive Records prioritized radio promotion, particularly targeting college and stations with the "Selling the Drama," which was serviced to airwaves in advance of the full release to generate early buzz. Building on the and modest commercial traction gained from the band's prior album , the label allocated enhanced budgetary resources for recording at Pachyderm Studio and subsequent promotional efforts, enabling a more robust rollout than their earlier work. Initial market reception was tempered, with Throwing Copper debuting at number 38 on the chart in its first full week of sales on May 14, 1994, reflecting a slow start amid competition from established acts. Sales momentum gradually accelerated through grassroots word-of-mouth among enthusiasts and the band's relentless touring schedule, which included opening slots for major acts and headline shows that helped solidify its grassroots appeal before the breakout success of later singles.

Cover artwork

The cover artwork for Throwing Copper features the 1989 oil-on-canvas painting by Scottish artist , measuring 72 by 96 inches. The piece, created during a period of personal turmoil for Howson, portrays a blind man desperately clutching a red while seeking refuge in a derelict cliff-edge church, only to be callously led toward his doom by a group of amused young women; Howson intended the work to evoke stark questions about human existence and lack of mercy. The artwork's intense, surreal depiction of vulnerability and betrayal aligned with the album's lyrical exploration of passion and inner conflict, with frontman stating that the guitar intro to the track "" drew direct inspiration from the painting's haunting atmosphere. The band selected —an existing work rather than a new commission—for its raw emotional energy, which they felt captured the album's thematic depth. Album art directors Tim Stedman and Todd Gallopo integrated the painting prominently on the cover, emphasizing its dramatic urban and figurative elements without additional band imagery to heighten a sense of enigma. In a notable cultural milestone, the original painting sold at auction in New York on September 23, 2005, for $186,000, establishing a then-world record price for Howson's work. This sale underscored the artwork's enduring impact beyond music, bridging and .

Promotion

Singles releases

The five main singles from Throwing Copper were released progressively from to 1995, capitalizing on radio airplay in the format to propel the album's success. These tracks, primarily promoted via CD singles, promotional copies with live B-sides, and music videos for rotation, helped establish Live as a major act in the mid-1990s rock scene.
SingleRelease DatePeak Chart PositionsNotes
"Selling the Drama"May 1994No. 1 US Alternative Airplay; No. 4 US Mainstream Rock; No. 43 US Hot 100First single from the album; introduced Live's sound to mainstream audiences through heavy radio rotation.
"I Alone"November 1994No. 6 US Alternative AirplaySecond single; emphasized the band's introspective lyrics and built momentum ahead of the album's chart climb. (Note: Direct link to chart history; positions verified via archived Billboard data)
"Lightning Crashes"January 1995No. 1 US Alternative Airplay (9 weeks); No. 1 US Mainstream Rock (10 weeks); No. 12 US Hot 100 AirplayThird single and biggest hit; its emotional narrative on life and death resonated widely, driving Throwing Copper to No. 1 on the Billboard 200 after 52 weeks.
"All Over You"July 1995No. 4 US Alternative Airplay; No. 2 US Mainstream Rock; No. 33 US Hot 100 AirplayFourth single; not commercially released in the US but gained traction via airplay, highlighting the album's raw energy.
"White, Discussion"October 1995No. 15 US Alternative Airplay; No. 12 US Mainstream Rock; No. 71 US Hot 100 AirplayFifth and final single; promotional release focused on radio, extending the album's alt-rock relevance with its apocalyptic themes.
Each single contributed to the album's radio dominance, with Throwing Copper ultimately selling over 9.7 million copies worldwide, certified 8× in the . "" in particular marked a turning point, its reign at No. 1 on radio cementing Live's breakthrough and sustaining airplay for subsequent tracks. The promotional strategy emphasized alternative formats, where the singles amassed significant spins, fostering organic growth without heavy reliance on physical sales in the pre-digital era.

Touring and live performances

Following the release of Throwing Copper, Live launched an extensive 1994–1995 world tour to promote the album, performing over 260 shows across , , and beyond. Early in the cycle, the band opened for established acts and joined multi-artist packages, including Peter Gabriel's WOMAD tour in summer 1994, where they played venues like Polaris Amphitheatre in , on July 14. They also gained exposure through appearances on MTV's , building momentum through club and theater dates that showcased their evolving sound. By late 1994, following the album's growing radio airplay, the itinerary expanded to include larger U.S. venues, setting the stage for arena-level performances. A milestone event came on August 12, 1994, when Live performed at in , debuting several Throwing Copper tracks to a crowd estimated at over 350,000 attendees across the three-day event. Their set, which included "Selling the Drama" and six other songs from the album alongside selections from prior releases, captured the band's raw energy amid the mud-soaked, nostalgic revival of the original 1969 . This appearance marked a pivotal exposure, airing on and helping propel Throwing Copper toward mainstream breakthrough. By 1995, Live had transitioned to headlining status, supporting the album's hit singles like "Lightning Crashes" with arena tours featuring openers such as and . Shows at venues like on July 30 and Molson Amphitheatre on September 12 drew thousands, solidifying their live reputation. Setlists evolved with the album's success, starting with heavy emphasis on nearly the full Throwing Copper tracklist in 1994—such as openers "The Dam at Otter Creek" and closers "Operation Spirit (The Tyranny of Tradition)"—to highlight unfamiliar material. As singles gained traction into 1995, performances shifted to prioritize hits like "" and "All Over You" while retaining core album staples, allowing for dynamic interaction and extended jams on fan favorites. This progression helped cement Live's status as a compelling live act, fostering a dedicated following through consistent touring intensity.

Commercial performance

Chart achievements

Throwing Copper achieved significant commercial success on music charts worldwide, particularly in , where it became a cornerstone of 1990s radio airplay. The album debuted at number 38 on the US on the chart dated May 14, 1994. It climbed steadily over the following year, reaching the top spot on , 1995, after 52 weeks on the chart, marking a rare slow-burn ascent in the SoundScan era. The album remained on the for a total of 121 weeks, reflecting its enduring popularity driven by radio hits and touring. Internationally, Throwing Copper topped the Australian Albums Chart for a cumulative 10 weeks across two separate runs in 1995 and 1996, underscoring its appeal in the region. In , it also reached number 1 on the RPM Top 100 Albums chart during May 1995. The album performed solidly in , peaking at number 37 on the with 11 weeks in the top 100 and number 28 on Germany's Offizielle Top 100. On the 1995 year-end chart, it ranked number 8 in the United States, highlighting its dominance that year. The singles from Throwing Copper were instrumental in propelling the album's chart performance, particularly on rock-oriented formats. Two tracks—"Selling the Drama" and ""—reached number 1 on Billboard's Modern Rock Tracks (now ) chart. "," released in January 1995, held the top spot for nine weeks on Modern Rock Tracks and 10 weeks on Mainstream Rock Tracks, while peaking at number 12 on the Hot 100 Airplay chart due to strong radio play despite no commercial single release in the . "Selling the Drama" led Modern Rock Tracks for 3 weeks starting May 21, 1994. "" peaked at number 6 on Modern Rock Tracks in August 1995. These radio successes helped sustain the album's chart longevity.
Chart (1994–1996)Peak Position
US 1
Australian Albums1
Canadian RPM Top 100 Albums1
Albums (OCC)37
German Albums (Offizielle Top 100)28
Throwing Copper is widely regarded as one of the defining albums of the , contributing to its placement among the decade's top-selling and most influential releases in the genre.

Sales certifications

Throwing Copper has sold over 8 million copies in the United States, earning an 8× certification from the (RIAA) on January 4, 2000. Worldwide, the album has sold over 9.7 million units, solidifying its status as a commercial powerhouse in the genre. The 's sales trajectory began modestly upon its 1994 release but gained momentum in 1995, reaching the top of the chart and achieving status that year, largely propelled by the success of the single "." Later reissues, including the 25th anniversary edition in 2019, further boosted its enduring commercial appeal. Amid the explosion, Throwing Copper outperformed numerous peers, capitalizing on the era's demand for introspective, radio-friendly rock.

Certifications

The following table summarizes key international certifications for Throwing Copper:
CountryUnits SoldDate
Australia10× Platinum700,0002019
7× Platinum700,0001997
Platinum100,0001996
6× Platinum90,000—
Gold50,000December 3, 1997
Gold100,000July 22, 2013
8× Platinum8,000,000January 4, 2000

Reception

Critical response

Upon its release in , Throwing Copper garnered positive attention from critics for its raw energy and anthemic qualities. gave the album four out of five stars, praising how it "captures the anger and ache of the moment in riveting songs driven home by expert players." Subsequent reviews solidified its reputation as a cornerstone of . editor rated it 4 out of five stars, describing it as Live's breakthrough that established a muscular, anthemic rock sound and marked a milestone in the genre. However, opinions were divided on the album's spiritual and esoteric themes, with some reviewers viewing them as pretentious or overly sentimental; observed that the lyrics pushed "earnestness and wild esotericism as far as it could go without becoming pretentious," though elements like abstract metaphors occasionally risked feeling cheesy. Critics widely agreed that frontman Ed Kowalczyk's searing vocals and producer Jerry Harrison's polished yet dynamic production were the album's standout features, elevating its emotional intensity and sonic punch. Many considered Throwing Copper the pinnacle of Live's career, with Classic Rock Magazine later noting it as a "consistently solid" effort that bordered on brilliant, though the band never quite recaptured its heights. In retrospectives from the 2020s, the album's enduring emotional resonance amid the era has been emphasized. uDiscover described it as a "challenging, powerful work" that tapped into the period's pain, faith, and fury, launching Live into the spotlight despite occasional oversight in alt-rock histories.

Awards and recognition

The album's lead single garnered critical industry recognition, with its music video earning a nomination for Viewer's Choice at the . The success of Throwing Copper propelled the band Live to broader honors, including the Rock Artist of the Year award at the 1995 .

Track listing and credits

Track listing

The standard edition of Throwing Copper, released in 1994, consists of 14 tracks with a total runtime of 59:27. All lyrics on the were written by , with music composed by the band Live. The track "Horse" appears as an unlisted at the end of the original pressing.
No.TitleDuration
1."The Dam at Otter Creek"4:43
2."Selling the Drama"3:26
3."I Alone"3:51
4."Iris"3:59
5."Lightning Crashes"5:25
6."Top"2:42
7."All Over You"3:59
8."Shit Towne"3:48
9."T.B.D."4:28
10."Stage"3:08
11."Waitress"2:48
12."Pillar of Davidson"6:46
13."White, Discussion"6:08
14."Horse" (hidden track)4:14
International editions of the album generally follow the same track listing and sequencing as the original U.S. release, with no major alterations prior to later reissues.

Personnel

Throwing Copper was performed by the American rock band Live, consisting of on lead vocals and rhythm guitar, Chad Taylor on and backing vocals, on bass, and on drums and backing vocals. The album's production was led by of fame, who also contributed keyboards, alongside the band members themselves as co-producers. Gary Kurfirst served as . Engineering duties were handled by Lou Giordano, with mixing by at Music Head Studios in . mastered the album at Sterling Sound in New York. Additional credits include A&R and production coordination by Phil Schuster, art direction and design by Tim Stedman, and design assistance by Todd Gallopo. The recording took place at Pachyderm Recording Studio in . No significant guest musicians appear on the , with backing vocals provided by band members Taylor and Gracey.

Reissues and anniversaries

25th anniversary edition

To commemorate the 25th anniversary of Throwing Copper, the band Live issued a deluxe reissue on July 19, 2019, via Radioactive/MCA/UMe, featuring remastered audio across , vinyl, and digital formats. This edition incorporates three previously unreleased bonus tracks—"," "We Deal in Dreams," and "Susquehanna"—recorded as outtakes during the album's original 1993 sessions. "," in particular, had been informally known to fans through a 2008 film appearance but received its official release here, while the other two tracks offered fresh insights into the band's creative process during that era. The reissue's packaging enhances its collectible appeal with a 12-page booklet containing rare photographs from the recording period and an in-depth interview with the band members reflecting on the album's creation and impact. The 2-LP vinyl pressing is a limited-edition featuring opaque red and olive green colored discs, pressed at 180 grams for improved sound quality. Critics and fans celebrated the as an emotional revisit to Live's era, praising the remastering for revitalizing the album's raw energy and the bonus tracks for adding contextual depth without overshadowing the core material. The release garnered positive reviews for its sonic clarity and archival value, with outlets noting how it reignited appreciation for the album's blend of intensity and lyrical introspection.

30th anniversary celebrations

To mark the 30th anniversary of Throwing Copper's release on April 26, 1994, the band Live participated in promotional activities centered around live performances and media retrospectives, building on the precedent set by their 25th anniversary reissue in 2019. The primary celebration was the , a co-headlining U.S. run with —commemorating the simultaneous 30th anniversary of their album —and special guests for the first two dates and for the rest, which ran from August 16 to September 15, 2024, across 19 dates in amphitheaters and arenas. Live's sets heavily featured tracks from Throwing Copper, including staples like "Lightning Crashes," "I Alone," "Selling the Drama," "Top," "All Over You," "Shit Towne," "Pillar of Davidson," and "White, Discussion," delivering high-energy renditions that evoked the album's original intensity. Frontman described the tour as a "" opportunity to reconnect with fans through the album's enduring themes of and raw emotion. In media appearances tied to the anniversary, Kowalczyk joined Stone Temple Pilots' Robert DeLeo for an August 2024 podcast interview on Appetite for Distortion, where they discussed the albums' cultural resonance in the 1990s alt-rock scene and the tour's nostalgic appeal. Additional coverage included a retrospective feature in Louder magazine, which highlighted how Throwing Copper's blend of introspective lyrics and arena-ready hooks propelled Live to multi-platinum success upon its 1994 debut. A May 2024 review in Consequence positioned the album as a pivotal post-grunge milestone, crediting its release shortly after Kurt Cobain's death with shifting rock toward more accessible, anthemic sounds. These efforts revived fan engagement without a new physical reissue, focusing instead on live experiences and digital availability to introduce the to younger audiences via streaming platforms.

31st anniversary edition

On April 26, 2025, to celebrate the 31st anniversary of Throwing Copper, released a mix of the , providing an immersive audio experience available on compatible streaming platforms.

Legacy

Cultural impact

Throwing Copper epitomized the shift in the , blending the raw angst of Nirvana with more melodic and accessible structures that appealed to a broader audience. Released in the wake of Kurt Cobain's death, the album helped pioneer the movement by softening grunge's edges while retaining its emotional intensity, becoming one of the most-played albums of the decade. The album's spiritual and introspective lyrics fostered a dedicated , with fans drawn to themes of , , and existential reflection that resonated deeply in personal and communal contexts. The track "," in particular, became a staple for memorials, notably featured in tributes following the 1995 , where a remixed version incorporated news clips to evoke collective grief and renewal. Its poignant exploration of birth and also led to its inclusion in television soundtracks, such as the 2023 episode of the series Yellowjackets, amplifying its emotional reach across generations. In media, songs from Throwing Copper have appeared in film soundtracks, including the unreleased track "" in the 2008 comedy Zack and Miri Make a Porno, underscoring the album's versatility beyond radio and rotations. The album's enduring popularity is evident in its streaming metrics, with Live's catalog surpassing 980 million plays on by late 2025, largely driven by Throwing Copper's hits, and it continues to feature on radio playlists as a nostalgic yet timeless fixture.

Influence on the band and genre

Throwing Copper propelled Live to international stardom, selling over 8 million copies in the United States and topping the chart in 1995, a year after its release. The album's success, driven by hits like "" and "I Alone," marked a significant escalation from the band's earlier releases, leading to arena tours, performances, and a cover feature. This breakthrough established Live as a cornerstone of the era, but it also intensified pressures on the group. Their follow-up album, (1997), debuted at No. 1 and built on Throwing Copper's sound with deeper mystical elements, yet it faced criticism for struggling to match the prior record's immediacy and commercial peak, often cited as an example of challenges. Over time, escalating internal tensions—particularly over songwriting credits and publishing revenue, where frontman claimed a larger share—strained relationships, culminating in the band's 2009 hiatus amid declining sales and personal conflicts. In the broader landscape, Throwing Copper played a pivotal role in defining by infusing the genre with raw emotional depth and spiritual introspection, distinguishing it from the angst-driven sounds of pioneers like Nirvana. Released shortly after Cobain's in April 1994, the album's blend of anthemic riffs and introspective lyrics helped birth a movement that emphasized melodic accessibility, influencing subsequent acts in the post-grunge wave. Bands such as drew from its model of emotive, radio-friendly , extending Throwing Copper's impact into the late pop-rock scene. For , Throwing Copper solidified his reputation as a commanding spiritual rock voice, with lyrics exploring and self-examination that echoed influences from and . This vocal and thematic style carried into his solo career after departing Live in 2009, where albums like No Comprendo () revisited similar introspective motifs of personal and existential growth. In retrospect, as Kowalczyk reflected in 2019, the album's themes remain timeless, with his matured vocal approach enhancing live performances during anniversary tours that reaffirm its enduring resonance. By 2024, marking 30 years since its release, Throwing Copper is widely regarded as Live's definitive statement, encapsulating the band's peak creative and commercial synergy amid the explosion.

References

  1. https://www.udiscovermusic.com/news/live-throwing-copper-deluxe-reissue/
  2. https://www.loudersound.com/features/live-throwing-copper
  3. https://number1albums.com/throwing-copper-live-may-6-1995/
  4. https://bestsellingalbums.org/album/27173
  5. https://www.musicvf.com/album.php?artist=Live&album=Throwing%2BCopper
  6. https://www.classicrockreview.com/2014/05/1994-live-throwing-copper/
  7. https://stereogum.com/2256032/stone-temple-pilots-live-announce-purple-throwing-copper-joint-30th-anniversary-tour/news
  8. https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/live-alt-rock-band-crime-lawsuits-1234677011/
  9. https://outandaboutnow.com/through-the-fire/
  10. https://mediafiveent.com/archive/viewprofile.php?id=174
  11. https://musicianguide.com/biographies/1608000961/Live.html
  12. https://www.liveabout.com/live-biography-and-profile-2898029
  13. https://www.classicrockhistory.com/top-10-live-songs-the-band-live/
  14. https://www.udiscovermusic.com/stories/live-throwing-copper-album/
  15. https://genius.com/albums/Live/Throwing-copper
  16. https://www.songfacts.com/facts/live/all-over-you
  17. https://www.concertarchives.org/bands/live--6?year=1992
  18. https://www.concertarchives.org/bands/live--6?year=1993
  19. https://tapeop.com/interviews/153/jerry-harrison
  20. https://gearspace.com/board/so-much-gear-so-little-time/202365-lives-throwing-copper-anything-amp-everything-about.html
  21. https://www.lpm.org/music/2019-08-06/lives-ed-kowalczyk-we-were-a-big-band-in-our-own-minds-right-away
  22. https://consequence.net/2024/05/live-throwing-copper-review-post-grunge/
  23. https://www.discogs.com/master/65591-Live-Throwing-Copper
  24. https://mikeladano.com/2014/10/07/review-live-throwing-copper-1994/
  25. https://www.waves.com/inside-the-mix-tom-lord-alge
  26. https://www.thegearpage.net/board/index.php?threads/chad-taylors-sounds-on-lives-throwing-copper.2075719/
  27. https://www.allmusic.com/album/throwing-copper-mw0000113266
  28. https://www.allmusic.com/style/post-grunge-ma0000005020
  29. https://www.loudersound.com/reviews/live-throwing-copper-album-of-the-week-club-review
  30. https://rockandrollglobe.com/rock/this-is-not-a-black-and-white-world-lives-mental-jewelry-turns-30/
  31. https://theyeargrungebroke.com/2024/04/live-throwing-copper-1994-2/
  32. https://www.lansingstatejournal.com/story/entertainment/music/2015/02/20/live-ed-kowalczyk-interview/23774561/
  33. https://loudwire.com/live-ed-kowalczyk-25-years-throwing-copper-future-recording-plans/
  34. https://www.allmusic.com/blog/post/ed-kowalczyk-on-revisiting-throwing-copper
  35. https://www.songfacts.com/facts/live/selling-the-drama
  36. https://www.songwritingmagazine.co.uk/interviews/i-alone-live-ed-kowalczyk
  37. https://www.songfacts.com/facts/live/white-discussion
  38. https://musicbrainz.org/release-group/9f31404b-49d0-365e-935d-cb040b762abf
  39. https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-lists/1994-the-40-best-records-from-mainstream-alternatives-greatest-year-29203/
  40. https://www.udiscovermusic.com/stories/live-lightning-crashes-story-behind-song/
  41. https://www.udiscovermusic.com/news/lives-mental-jewelry-25th-anniversary/
  42. https://www.therockpit.net/2019/live-celebrates-25-years-of-throwing-copper-album-with-electrifying-reissue/
  43. https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-4560961
  44. https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/12477041.The_artist_himself_explains_Sisters_of_Mercy/
  45. https://www.sfexaminer.com/culture/live-s-throwing-copper-more-than-an-album/article_ca02d027-8533-5c21-aba7-2b66471581b4.html
  46. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/art/3647144/Market-news-the-Royal-House-of-Hanover.html
  47. https://www.pinterest.com/pin/throwing-copper-by-live-the-album-cover-artwork-designed-and-directed-by-tim-stedman-and-todd-gallopo-features-the-o-in-2025--799529740138048187/
  48. https://www.flickr.com/photos/freaks4live/9904774494
  49. https://www.glasgowtimes.co.uk/news/12827521.its-hammer-time-for-howsons-paintings/
  50. https://livetheband.com/
  51. https://www.billboard.com/music/rock/live-ed-kowalczyk-tour-interview-7767911/
  52. https://www.concertarchives.org/bands/live--6?year=1994
  53. https://www.setlist.fm/stats/live-13d6b90d.html?tour=6bd69696
  54. https://www.grammy.com/news/on-this-day-in-music-revisiting-woodstock-1994-30th-anniversary-videos
  55. https://dolbydisaster.com/?p=24772
  56. https://www.tampabay.com/archive/1995/05/14/live-s-tour-lineup-is-hot/
  57. https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/live/1995/miami-arena-miami-fl-5bd46b98.html
  58. https://www.setlist.fm/stats/average-setlist/live-13d6b90d.html?tour=6bd69696
  59. https://www.concertarchives.org/bands/live--6?year=1995
  60. https://www.billboard.com/charts/billboard-200/1994-05-14/
  61. https://www.billboard.com/charts/billboard-200/1995-05-06/
  62. https://tsort.info/music/ay1995.htm
  63. https://www.aria.com.au/charts/news/all-the-aria-albums-chart-1s
  64. https://www.officialcharts.com/albums/live-throwing-copper-0/
  65. https://bestsellingalbums.org/year-end/Billboard_Top_Albums_1995
  66. https://www.musicvf.com/song.php?id=26153
  67. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/live-today-release-the-super-deluxe-25th-anniversary-edition-of-their-landmark-8x-multi-platinum-sophomore-album-throwing-copper-300887872.html
  68. https://www.udiscovermusic.com/news/live-throwing-copper-vinyl/
  69. https://www.thejakartapost.com/life/2019/08/01/after-25-years-lives-throwing-copper-remains-alternative-rock-gem.html
  70. http://www.rockonthenet.com/mtvvma/viewers.htm
  71. https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/live-artist-of-the-year-51696/
  72. https://heavymetal.fandom.com/wiki/Throwing_Copper
  73. https://www.loudersound.com/reviews/lives-throwing-copper-25-years-on-suddenly-contemporary
  74. https://www.discogs.com/release/937552-Live-Throwing-Copper
  75. https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/live/throwing-copper/
  76. https://www.discogs.com/release/2932169-Live-Throwing-Copper
  77. https://sterling-sound.com/discography/throwing-copper-bonus-disc/
  78. https://www.universalmusic.ca/press-releases/live-celebrates-25-years-of-throwing-copper-with-electrifying-super-deluxe-reissue/
  79. https://bigtakeover.com/recordings/LiveThrowingCopper25thAnniversaryEditionRadioactiveMCAUMe
  80. https://jocorecords.com/products/live-throwing-copper-25th-anniversary-limited-edition-opaque-red-olive-green-colored-vinyl-2-lps
  81. https://www.seattlepi.com/lifestyle/blogcritics/article/Music-Review-Live-Throwing-Copper-25th-14396675.php
  82. https://getreadytorock.me.uk/blog/2019/07/album-review-live-throwing-copper-25th-anniversary-edition/
  83. https://stonetemplepilots.com/
  84. https://www.stereogum.com/2256032/stone-temple-pilots-live-announce-purple-throwing-copper-joint-30th-anniversary-tour/news/
  85. https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/lve/2024/dailys-place-amphitheater-jacksonville-fl-4355af4b.html
  86. https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/lve/2024/the-pavilion-at-montage-mountain-scranton-pa-13558d75.html
  87. https://www.iheart.com/podcast/966-appetite-for-distortion-27615384/episode/robert-deleo-stp-and-ed-kowalczyk-204055575/
  88. https://ultimateclassicrock.com/stone-temple-pilots-live-2024-set-lists/
  89. https://www.facebook.com/livetheband/videos/31-years-ago-today-we-released-throwing-copper-and-to-celebrate-we-are-thrilled-/9437555273022542/
  90. https://www.35000watts.com/throwing-copper-thirty-years-later/
  91. https://kfor.com/news/these-emotional-musical-tributes-are-still-powerful-20-years-after-oklahoma-city-bombing/
  92. https://www.udiscovermusic.com/news/live-lightning-crashes-yellowjackets-soundtrack/
  93. https://www.musicmetricsvault.com/artists/live/6eoJpTIlcuxJNjV5fDzDJH
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.