Hubbry Logo
search
logo
BBC HD avatar
BBC HD
BBC HD
current hub
B

BBC HD

logo
Community Hub0 Subscribers
Read side by side
BBC HD
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

BBC HD was a high-definition television channel owned by the BBC. The channel was initially run as a trial from 15 May 2006 until becoming a full service on 5 April 2008 before its discontinuation on 25 March 2013. It broadcast only during the afternoon and evening and only broadcast material shot in high definition, either in a simulcast with another channel or by inserting a repeat of an HD programme.

Key Information

The channel featured a mix of programmes from the channels BBC One, BBC Two, BBC Three, BBC Four, CBBC and CBeebies, although earlier and later in its existence programmes from BBC One and BBC Two were given priority. All programmes that aired on the UK version of the channel were produced in high definition. The channel also carried coverage of sport and music events, with some coverage being broadcast in experimental formats such as 3D television.

The channel closed for the final time at 01:20 am on the night of Monday 25 March 2013, and was replaced with BBC Two HD the following day on Tuesday 26 March, partly as a result of budget cuts affecting the entire corporation.[1]

History

[edit]

Trial

[edit]

BBC HD began broadcasting on 15 May 2006 as a trial station to test the possibility and technical practicality of broadcasting programmes in HD.[2][3] The first programme to be broadcast that was specifically made for HD was natural history programme Planet Earth, which was shown on 27 May 2006. The trial in 450 businesses and homes was set to last until June 2007; however, just before this deadline, the BBC Trust began a Public Value Test of the service to determine whether, as the BBC argued, the service was of worth to the general public. As a result, the HD service was extended throughout the testing period, which began on 21 May. The result of the test, announced on 19 November, was that they had approved the BBC Executive's high definition television proposals to allow the launch of UK's first free-to-air, mixed-genre public service HD channel.[4][5]

Official launch

[edit]

The channel officially launched on 1 December 2007, although much of the programme makeup and format of the broadcasts remained the same from the trial.[6] This new channel was nationwide and platform neutral, in that it was carried by all providers as a free to air channel. This channel, as recommended by the BBC Trust's Public Value Test, broadcast only for around nine hours a day during prime time and only showed programmes made specifically for HD. The channel would air programmes from across the BBC channels.

This arrangement continued until 2010, when the increase in HD content saw several changes. 2010 had been the BBC's internal deadline for the majority of new content to be produced in HD and as a result the broadcast space was fast running out.[7] As a result, on 3 November 2010, BBC One HD launched as a separate simulcast of the channel and at approximately the same time, BBC HD's broadcast hours were extended to twelve hours a day.[8][9][10] Due to BBC One HD's launch, BBC HD on Virgin Media moved from channel 108 to channel 187. The channel now catered for the programming of the BBC's channels other than BBC One.[9]

From 2011, the channel also began to experiment with showing select programmes in 3D. The first such broadcasts were the live men's and women's finals of the 2011 Wimbledon Championships[11] and continued with the broadcast of that year's Strictly Come Dancing final in December.[12] 2012 saw one of the most ambitious levels of 3D coverage with the BBC screening the opening and closing ceremonies and the men's 100m final of the 2012 Summer Olympics including a daily highlights programme in 3D.[13] In addition to this, the channel also broadcast in 3D the men's and women's finals of the 2012 Wimbledon Championships,[14] the natural history programme Planet Dinosaur Ultimate Killers in August,[15] the second half of the Last Night of the Proms on 8 September 2012,[16] the adaptation of Mr Stink on 23 December 2012 and Killer Dinosaurs and the Royal Christmas Message on 25 December.[17]

Closure

[edit]

Initial reports of the closure of the channel began to surface in July 2011 when Broadcast magazine claimed that the BBC HD would become more of a simulcast of BBC Two[18] when Danielle Nagler, head of HD and 3D at the BBC, left the corporation in September.[19] Although this was later disproved,[20] it caused speculation about the channel's future given that the new head of the channel was Janice Hadlow, controller of BBC Two.[19]

The channel's future was again called into question following the BBC's Delivering Quality First review of the corporation's spending. The review sought cost-cutting measures following the government settlement that froze the license fee, reducing the BBC's income, and saw the corporation take on additional responsibility for funding some services.[1] The review recommended that BBC HD should close and be replaced with a simulcast of BBC Two.[1][21] The proposals were approved by the BBC Trust in May 2012[22] and subsequently, BBC Two HD launched on 26 March 2013, replacing BBC HD; which was closed the night before.[2][23]

The "BBC HD" name remains in use for a channel available to the maritime industry, including on select cruise ships.

Broadcast

[edit]
A BBC High Definition Outside Broadcast van at the 2005 World Athletics Championships, Helsinki.

Availability

[edit]

At the time of the official launch, BBC HD was available universally on all HD broadcasters as a free-to-air station. Satellite viewers could watch the channel on Freesat or Sky, who received their signal from the Astra 1N satellite. The channel was also available to cable television customers through Virgin Media's basic package. The service was also carried on digital terrestrial television in London, from Crystal Palace, until May 2007 as part of the channel's trial and gradually made available nationwide on a region-by-region basis from 2 December 2009.[24]

The service expanded into the Republic of Ireland with the channel's carriage on UPC Ireland's Digital+ HD service from 5 August 2009[25] and on the Sky Ireland platform from 27 April 2010.[26]

Technical specifications

[edit]

The channel was broadcast at a display resolution of 1440 by 1080i, which despite being less than the usual 1920 by 1080 resolution used for HD broadcasts was still acceptable to the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) of which the BBC is a member.[27] But after years of pressure from bloggers and tech experts alike,[citation needed] the BBC finally relented and switched BBC HD to full 1920 resolution for all broadcasts, not just when 3D was being broadcast. The channel encoded in H.264/MPEG-4 AVC for satellite and terrestrial broadcasts and in MPEG-2 for cable transmissions.

Over time, changes were made to the way that the channel is broadcast or received. Following the launch of BBC One HD on 3 November 2010, both the new channel and BBC HD were statistically multiplexed on the satellite feeds.[28] Equally, on 6 June 2011, the satellite transponder carrying BBC One HD and BBC HD was upgraded to DVB-S2.[29] In addition to the satellite changes, alterations were made in March 2011 for the Freeview HD encoders to change automatically between 1080i at 50 fields per second to 1080p at 25 frames per second depending on the programme's GOP.[30] Unfortunately some receivers did not handle the transitions between these modes well, resulting in sound and picture disruption.[31]

2009-2010 bitrate drop

[edit]

On 5 August 2009, the channel's satellite encoders on the Astra 2D satellite were replaced by newer models. A side effect of this change was a drop in bitrate from 16 megabits per second (Mb/s) to 9.7 Mbit/s, leading to a large number of complaints to the BBC.[32][33][34][35][36][37] The problem only occurred on the satellite platforms as the cable versions were encoded by the provider themselves and so remained at 17 Mbit/s[38] while the later launched terrestrial version was statistically multiplexed between 3 Mbit/s and 17 Mbit/s.[39] Further anger ensued that the new satellite bitrate fell below the recommendations set out by the European Broadcasting Union (EBU), of which the BBC is a member. These recommend a minimum of 12 Mbit/s, but as Andy Quested, principal technologist at the BBC stated, the current technology gave a consistent reliable output of 8-10 Mbit/s which would soon become the requirements with improved technology.[27][40]

Within four months of the change, by mid December, the number of complaints on this issue to the BBC reached 130 of which one was passed straight to the BBC Trust.[41] At around the same time a petition was added to the official Number10 website in December 2009, petitioning then Prime Minister Gordon Brown to bring the BBC into line with the EBU standards.[42] The petition was sparked by the BBC's insistence that there was no problem with the bit rate. In addition, tests run by consumer publication Which?, published in December 2009, found no significant decline in picture quality on the BBC HD channel, labelling the difference in picture quality between the new and old BBC HD broadcasts as "insignificant".[43] Meanwhile, the international version of BBC HD continued to broadcast on satellite at the higher bitrate and screen resolution.[44] The following year, on 30 April 2010, a delegation of viewers who had complained met with Andy Quested and Danielle Nagler[45] to argue that BBC HD was failing to "deliver a very high quality technical service to viewers, by adhering to, or seeking to exceed, industry standards for picture resolution". The visitors took part in an evaluation of the new and old encoder's picture quality (by an ITU R500 test) and the results demonstrated that the new encoder, at much reduced bit rate, was not only "as good as" but actually much better than the old.

The issue was resolved when, on 3 June 2010, the BBC introduced variable bitrate encoding and fixed previous problems with mixing, fading and noise in pictures.[46] The variable bitrate encoding allowed the channel to maintain the same average bandwidth while allowing an increase in bitrate for more demanding programme scenes such as fast movement. Equally the fixes for mixing and fading treated specific problems with changing scenes, while a configuration change for 'noisy' video means the BBC no longer needed to use noise reduction techniques that often reduced the overall picture quality. The changes were welcomed by campaigners.[47]

3D broadcasts

[edit]

Whenever the BBC has broadcast programmes or events in 3D, there were other technical changes made to the channel that accompanied it. The BBC's first broadcast of the Wimbledon finals in 2011[11] saw the screen resolution increased from the usual 1440 by 1080 to 1920 by 1080 between 13 June and 6 July.[48] Equally, the same occurred for the 2011 Strictly Come Dancing final[12] when the resolution was changed between 8 December 2011 and 5 January 2012. An increase to 1920 horizontal resolution was again observed on 30 May 2012 as part of the preparations of 2012's 3D broadcasts.[13][49]

Presentation

[edit]

The BBC HD channel only ever ran at its peak for an average of twelve hours a day, usually from mid afternoon, and was only ever allowed to expand beyond these hours for coverage of significant sporting events. When off air, the channel would broadcast a looped series of clips identified as the BBC HD Preview. These were of extended trailers and extracts for upcoming programmes on the channel separated by the channel's idents. These segments were also notable in their hourly broadcasts of the HD testcard, nicknamed Test Card X, overlaid with a BLITS audio test signal which allowed users to test and adjust their picture quality and position and the quality of their surround sound respectively.[50] Equally, an audio visual synchronization animation was also broadcast hourly.[50]

The channel's presentation was unique from the other BBC channels and used its own style of programme idents and trailers. The channel originally used an ident that featured a diamond shape falling backwards down a stream before exploding to several more diamond shapes before taking its place back where it started to be back-lit over an announcement.[51] These were used until 2009 when the presentation changed to a style featuring an ordinary scene which would become extraordinary when viewed through a rotating diamond shape.[51] An example of this was a cat chasing pigeons that was seen as a lion when looked through the diamond shape.[51][52] Original programme trailers and slides used the back-lit diamond shape as a base, while the 2009 versions used bright colours and textures inspired from the idents, for example the picnic blanket from the cat ident.[51]

Programming

[edit]
See also: List of television programmes broadcast by the BBC

The channel's programmes were sourced from every BBC channel and were of mixed genres. The channel would only broadcast productions made in high definition and would not upscale any programmes from standard definition for use on the channel - in contrast to the BBC One HD and BBC Two HD simulcast services. Any individual programme could contain up to 25 per cent non-HD material converted from SD, for example archive shots in a documentary. Some high definition recording formats like HDV as well as some film formats like 16 mm are considered by BBC to be "non-HD". As many of the BBC's top productions were made in HD from soon after the channel launched, many of these productions were broadcast on the station at some point.

Live events

[edit]

The channel had broadcast several live and significant events in HD. Sporting events include the Wimbledon Tennis Championships, the Australian Open and French Open from 2009, the FIFA World Cup 2006 and 2010, the Euro 2008 Championships, the US Masters golf, Open Golf, England football internationals, action from the FA Cup and Six Nations rugby. The channel also broadcast the 2008 Summer Olympics and Paralympics, the 2010 Winter Olympics and the 2012 Summer Olympics. For the latter, the channel simulcast BBC Three's Olympic coverage and broadcast some of BBC Two's content in HD late at night, time permitting. In 2008, BBC Sport officials indicated that they hoped to offer all of their output in HD by 2012, based on the availability of global feeds and planned new studios or HD-friendly renovations in London and Manchester.[53]

Non sport broadcast include simulcasts of The Proms, the Eurovision Song Contest 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010 and 2011 and the 2009 United States presidential inauguration and coverage of the 2010 United Kingdom general election. It also regularly broadcast Test Card X which would last 90 seconds to 2 minutes.

Children

[edit]

The channel also aired select CBBC and CBeebies shows produced in the HD format.

Logos

[edit]
  • Logo used from 2006 to 2008.
    Logo used from 2006 to 2008.

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

BBC HD

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
BBC HD was a high-definition television channel operated by the British Broadcasting Corporation, broadcasting from its launch in 2006 until its closure in 2013.[1][2] The service initially operated as a trial before becoming the UK's first free-to-air HD channel in December 2007, available on satellite and cable platforms.[3] It showcased upgraded versions of existing BBC programmes alongside content natively produced in high definition, emphasizing the enhanced visual fidelity of formats like natural history documentaries and dramas.[1] The channel played a key role in promoting HD adoption among British viewers by demonstrating superior picture quality in a range of genres, from factual series to entertainment, funded through the BBC's licence fee model.[4] Notable for its technical innovation, BBC HD contributed to the transition from standard to high-definition broadcasting, though its content reflected the broader editorial output of the BBC, which has faced persistent criticism for left-leaning bias in reporting and cultural programming, as documented in analyses of institutional influences within public media. Despite such debates, the service achieved high production standards in visual presentation, aiding public familiarity with HD technology prior to widespread platform integration. BBC HD ceased operations on 26 March 2013, replaced by a BBC Two HD simulcast, primarily due to budget constraints and the strategic shift toward embedding HD across the BBC's primary channels rather than maintaining a standalone service.[2] This closure aligned with fiscal efficiencies sought amid licence fee pressures and the normalization of HD production, marking the end of a dedicated showcase but facilitating broader access to high-definition content.[5] The channel's legacy endures in the BBC's ongoing HD offerings, underscoring early efforts to leverage public funding for technological advancement in television.

History

Trial Phase (2006–2007)

The BBC initiated its high-definition television trial in mid-2006 to evaluate the technical feasibility of HD production, distribution, and reception across multiple platforms, as well as to gauge audience interest in the format.[6] Announced on 8 November 2005, the trial involved simulcasting select peak-time highlights from BBC One in HD, with broadcasts commencing on 15 May 2006 via satellite on Sky Digital and cable through ntl:telewest (later Virgin Media) for subscribers equipped with compatible HD receivers.[6][7] The service operated as the United Kingdom's first free-to-air HD channel, initially featuring test streams previewing upcoming content before transitioning to live programming, such as scenes from the natural history series Planet Earth.[4][7] Programming during the trial emphasized a limited selection of high-impact content to test end-to-end workflows, including capture, post-production, coding, playout, and transmission, with broadcasts confined primarily to afternoons and evenings to manage resource constraints.[8] Simulcasts drew from existing BBC output, prioritizing visually demanding material like sports and drama to demonstrate HD benefits, though native HD production remained nascent.[6] For the satellite and cable streams, the focus was on BBC One highlights, while technical parameters included MPEG-2 encoding for video and both stereo and Dolby Digital 5.1 audio options during early tests.[9] A complementary digital terrestrial trial launched in June 2006, involving collaboration with ITV, Channel 4, and Five, under a one-year Ofcom licence utilizing an unused frequency in the London area without disrupting existing Freeview services.[10] This closed audience test distributed set-top boxes to 450 households and businesses starting 5 June 2006, featuring a broader programme mix including Planet Earth, Bleak House, Poirot, 2006 FIFA World Cup coverage, and Desperate Housewives to assess multiplex capacity and viewer preferences.[10][11] Initial findings indicated strong public enthusiasm, with 86% of aware participants expecting BBC content in HD and high satisfaction with picture quality, informing subsequent evaluations.[8] The trial extended into 2007 amid ongoing assessments, with the satellite and cable service continuing operations beyond the initial 12-month period to support further data collection on viewer uptake and infrastructure readiness.[4] By mid-2007, positive technical results and audience feedback prompted the BBC Trust to initiate a Public Value Test, evaluating the service's spectrum efficiency and public service value against costs, culminating in provisional approval for expansion in September 2007.[12] This phase underscored HD's viability for public service broadcasting while highlighting challenges like limited native content and platform-specific bitrate limitations.[8]

Launch and Operational Growth (2008–2012)

BBC HD transitioned from its trial phase to full operational status, building on its initial free-to-air launch on satellite and cable platforms on 1 December 2007.[13] In 2008, the channel expanded internationally, initiating broadcasts to Scandinavian countries through localized feeds managed by BBC Worldwide. Domestically, programming output grew with increased resilience in scheduling, allowing for more consistent HD-native content such as episodes of Top Gear, Doctor Who, and nature documentaries like Planet Earth, alongside live events.[14] By March 2009, daily broadcast hours extended to nine, up from previous limited afternoon and evening slots, enhancing viewer access and content volume.[15] This period saw further platform integration, with BBC HD becoming available on Freeview HD in December 2009, coinciding with the rollout of terrestrial HD services and reaching households without subscription satellite or cable.[16] International availability continued to develop, including a dedicated Australian feed launched in 2008 on Foxtel HD+ for subscribers.[17] The launch of BBC One HD on 3 November 2010 prompted operational adjustments, including statistical multiplexing on satellite feeds to accommodate both channels and a channel number shift for BBC HD on Virgin Media to 187.[18] BBC Sport targeted full HD coverage of its output by 2012, leveraging global feeds and new production capabilities to broadcast events like major tournaments in enhanced format. Internationally, a Latin American feed debuted in 2011, followed by a Brazilian version in 2012, reflecting BBC Worldwide's strategy to capitalize on growing global HD demand. These expansions supported steady domestic adoption amid rising HD set penetration in the UK.

Closure and Transition (2013)

On 26 March 2013, BBC HD ceased broadcasting at 6:00 a.m., marking the end of its operations as a dedicated high-definition showcase channel after nearly seven years.[5][19] The closure was part of the BBC's strategic shift toward providing high-definition simulcasts of its primary terrestrial channels, prioritizing broader accessibility over specialized HD programming.[2] In the final hours before shutdown, the channel aired a retrospective sequence featuring vintage test cards—such as Test Card X, Television Eye from 1934, and others—alongside clean idents, serving as a nod to broadcasting history without interrupting regular content.[20] Immediately following the closure, the channel slot transitioned to BBC Two HD, a full-time simulcast of the standard-definition BBC Two England service, available subscription-free across major platforms including Sky HD (channel 169), Freeview HD/YouView (channel 102), Freesat HD (channel 107), and Virgin Media HD (channel 118).[5][2] This replacement ensured that viewers retained HD access to core BBC content, with BBC Two HD inheriting the same channel numbers previously occupied by BBC HD, minimizing disruption for audiences.[21] The move aligned with the BBC's broader HD expansion, as evidenced by subsequent launches of additional HD simulcasts like BBC Three HD and BBC Four HD later in 2013, reflecting a resource allocation toward mainstream channels amid license fee constraints.[1] The transition did not involve significant technical overhauls but rather a reallocation of bandwidth and programming feeds, with BBC HD's curated mix of HD-native and upscaled content giving way to consistent simulcasting.[22] BBC executives framed the change as enhancing value for license fee payers by embedding HD into flagship services, though it reduced the availability of exclusive HD experiments previously featured on BBC HD.[2] Post-closure, select BBC HD programming migrated to other outlets, but the dedicated window for high-end HD production trials effectively ended, signaling a maturation of the BBC's overall HD infrastructure.[19]

Technical Specifications

Core Standards and Formats

BBC HD adhered to 1080-line high-definition standards, broadcasting at a resolution of 1920×1080 pixels in a 16:9 aspect ratio.[23] The primary scanning format was 1080i50, delivering 50 interlaced fields per second for video-originated content such as live events and studio productions, which provided effective motion resolution suited to European PAL-derived broadcast norms.[24] Select programming, particularly film-originated or progressively captured material, utilized 1080p50 or 1080p25 to preserve spatial detail and reduce interlacing artifacts, with dynamic GOP (group of pictures) switching between interlaced and progressive modes implemented from 2011 to accommodate mixed-source feeds without visible disruptions on compatible receivers.[25] Video compression employed H.264/MPEG-4 AVC codec for digital terrestrial (Freeview HD) and satellite (Freesat, Sky) transmissions, enabling efficient bandwidth use at variable bitrates typically ranging from 8 to 12 Mbps for video, though peaks reached 16–18 Mbps during high-motion sequences before multiplex constraints reduced averages to around 9.7 Mbps in later years.[26] Cable platforms like Virgin Media used MPEG-2 encoding, which required higher bitrates (up to 15–20 Mbps) for comparable quality due to less efficient compression.[27] Chroma subsampling followed 4:2:0 standards, with colorimetry in ITU-R BT.709 gamut to ensure compatibility with HD displays. Audio transmission supported Dolby Digital (AC-3) encoding, defaulting to 2.0 stereo channels at 192 kbps for most content, while 5.1 surround mixes at 384–448 kbps were applied to qualifying programmes like dramas and concerts when production masters included multichannel stems.[28] Dual audio tracks were occasionally multiplexed, including MPEG-1 Layer II stereo as a fallback for legacy receivers, though primary playout prioritized Dolby for enhanced immersion on HD sets.[29] Loudness normalization targeted -23 LUFS per EBU R128 guidelines in later operations, minimizing dynamic range compression to preserve artistic intent.[30]

Bitrate Fluctuations and Quality Adjustments

The BBC HD channel initially transmitted using constant bitrate (CBR) encoding at approximately 16 Mbps during its early years, providing a stable data rate for high-definition content across platforms like satellite and cable.[31] In late 2009, the broadcaster deployed new encoders that reduced the bitrate by about 40% to 9.7 Mbps, with the BBC asserting that advancements in compression maintained or improved picture quality despite the lower average rate.[31][32] This adjustment positioned BBC HD among the lower-bitrate HD services globally, prompting viewer complaints about visible artifacts such as blurring and noise, particularly in complex scenes.[32] To address these issues, on 3 June 2010, BBC HD transitioned to variable bitrate (VBR) encoding, which dynamically adjusted the data rate based on content complexity—allocating more bits to intricate visuals like fast motion or detailed textures while conserving during simpler segments.[31] This shift resolved prior encoding flaws, including improper handling of fades, mixing, and low-level noise, while keeping the average bitrate near 9-10 Mbps to fit transmission constraints.[31] VBR enabled bitrate fluctuations ranging from lower thresholds during static shots to peaks exceeding 10 Mbps for demanding material, enhancing overall perceptual quality without increasing bandwidth demands.[31] These changes reflected broader efforts to balance high-definition fidelity with efficient spectrum use, especially on multiplexed platforms like Freesat and Sky, where fixed capacity limited options.[33] Unlike the UK feed, the international BBC HD service retained higher bitrates closer to the original 16 Mbps levels, avoiding some domestic quality trade-offs until its later phase-out.[34] Viewer feedback and technical petitions influenced these adjustments, underscoring tensions between compression efficiency and uncompressed-like visuals in early HD broadcasting.[35]

Advanced Features and Experiments

BBC HD implemented advanced encoding techniques to optimize picture quality, including the use of H.264 (AVC) compression standards capable of supporting both interlaced and progressive formats.[24] In March 2011, a software upgrade to the Freeview HD encoder enabled automatic detection of progressive scan material via the "pic_struct" flag in the bitstream, allowing seamless switching to 1080p25 encoding for such content while defaulting to 1080i50 for interlaced segments like credits or cross-fades.[24] This adaptation occurred at group of pictures (GOP) boundaries to minimize artifacts, enhancing fidelity for natively progressive footage such as location shoots.[24] Experiments with 1080p broadcasting commenced alongside this upgrade on 22–23 March 2011, testing auto-switching between 1080i and 1080p25 on Freeview HD to improve overall quality without requiring a dedicated channel.[36] However, the changes triggered audio dropouts and picture glitches on certain devices, including 2010–2011 Sony Bravia models (e.g., KDL-40EX403) and Samsung TVs, though Panasonic sets were unaffected.[36] Manufacturers responded with firmware updates by late June 2011, such as over-the-air patches for Toshiba and USB/internet fixes for Sony and Samsung, resolving most compatibility issues after BBC collaboration.[36] A prominent experimental initiative involved frame-compatible 3D broadcasting, where stereoscopic content was compressed into side-by-side or top-and-bottom formats within the standard 1080i HD signal for compatibility with existing 2D infrastructure.[37] Trials began in earnest around 2010–2011, transmitting 3D programmes on the BBC HD channel across platforms like Freeview, Freesat, Sky, and Virgin Media, including sports events such as Wimbledon where progressive encoding was temporarily suspended to prioritize 3D stability.[37] These broadcasts required viewer-side processing to unpack the frames for 3D displays, aiming to assess public viability without disrupting 2D viewing.[38] By July 2013, the BBC halted 3D programming indefinitely, citing insufficient viewer adoption and lack of sustained appetite for the technology despite initial trials.[39]

Distribution and Availability

Domestic Platforms and Access

BBC HD was primarily accessible in the United Kingdom through free-to-air digital terrestrial television (DTT), satellite, and cable platforms, requiring viewers to possess HD-compatible equipment such as set-top boxes or televisions. The channel's distribution expanded progressively from its trial phase, achieving broad domestic coverage by 2010 across major providers.[4][40] On Freeview, the dominant DTT service, BBC HD debuted on 2 December 2009 coinciding with the Freeview HD launch, initially serving regions like those covered by the Winter Hill transmitter before a phased nationwide rollout completed in 2010. It was positioned at channel 54 on the electronic programme guide (EPG).[40][41] Satellite distribution included Sky Digital, where BBC HD was available from the trial broadcasts commencing 11 May 2006 on EPG slot 169, and Freesat, a free-to-air satellite service launched in May 2008, which carried the channel on position 109 from early operations.[4][42] Cable provider Virgin Media (formerly NTL:Telewest) offered BBC HD from the May 2006 trial onward, assigned to channel 187, maintaining this slot through the channel's operational period until 2013.[4][42]
PlatformLaunch Date on PlatformEPG Position
Freeview (DTT)2 December 200954
Sky Digital11 May 2006 (trial)169
FreesatMay 2008109
Virgin Media11 May 2006 (trial)187

International Distribution

BBC HD maintained limited international distribution through targeted partnerships with pay-TV operators, focusing on regions with established BBC content deals rather than broad global availability. In Australia, the channel launched on Foxtel's HD+ service in June 2008, providing subscribers access to a mix of BBC's high-definition factual, entertainment, and arts programming tailored for the market.[43] [44] This feed operated as part of Foxtel's premium HD tier, emphasizing content not widely available in standard definition elsewhere in the region.[45] In the Nordic countries, BBC HD made its European debut in early December 2008 via Canal Digital, a pay-TV provider serving Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and Finland.[46] The launch accompanied other BBC channels like BBC Knowledge and BBC Entertainment, targeting households with HD-capable setups and highlighting the channel's role in expanding BBC's premium content footprint beyond the UK.[47] These regional versions mirrored the UK service's multi-genre focus but adjusted for local broadcasting rights and advertising opportunities.[48] Satellite transmissions of BBC HD extended reception potential to parts of Europe, the Middle East, and Asia via beams from Astra 4A (covering Europe) and NSS 12 (reaching into Asia), allowing free-to-air access in fringe areas with suitable dishes, though official carriage required subscription services.[49] International distribution ceased following the UK channel's closure on 25 March 2013, with feeds in Australia and the Nordics discontinued and supplanted by specialized BBC Studios channels such as BBC Earth HD, reflecting a shift toward genre-specific international offerings.[46] Residual maritime and cruise ship feeds persisted in limited form post-2013, but mainstream availability ended.[50]

Programming and Content

Strategic Focus and Genres

The BBC HD channel functioned primarily as a showcase service for high-definition programming, aiming to highlight content that derived the greatest visual and auditory benefits from the HD format to drive viewer adoption and future-proof public service broadcasting.[51] This strategy aligned with the BBC's broader goals of enhancing audience immersion in public service genres and supporting the UK's digital infrastructure transition, including the evolution of digital terrestrial television (DTT).[51] Unlike standard-definition channels, BBC HD prioritized selective simulcasts and repeats of peak-time content from BBC One and BBC Two, comprising approximately 50% and 33% of its schedule respectively, with limited acquisitions under 5% to minimize costs while maximizing HD-native productions.[51] Programming emphasized genres where enhanced resolution and widescreen aspect ratios amplified impact, such as natural history documentaries (e.g., Planet Earth series repeats), high-production dramas, and arts performances, which showcased intricate details like wildlife textures or theatrical lighting unattainable in SD.[52] Factual content, including science and history programs, formed a core pillar, alongside selective sports coverage of major events like the Olympics to exploit dynamic motion clarity.[51] Comedy, children's programming, and lifestyle segments rounded out the mixed-genre approach, but everyday formats like news bulletins or soap operas were largely excluded, as they offered marginal HD advantages and risked diluting the channel's premium positioning.[52] By 2012, this curation targeted over 60% reach in HD-enabled households, focusing on original UK content to bolster creative industries without competing directly with subscription HD rivals.[51]

Notable Broadcasts and Live Events

BBC HD's trial launch on 15 May 2006 featured the premiere of select episodes from the natural history series Planet Earth, marking the UK's first free-to-air high-definition broadcasts. Produced by the BBC Natural History Unit and narrated by David Attenborough, the series utilized advanced filming techniques to capture detailed footage of diverse ecosystems, such as polar ice caps and deep-sea environments, demonstrating the visual potential of HD resolution. Five episodes from the first part aired sequentially from 7:00 pm on 27 May 2006, establishing Planet Earth as a flagship for the channel's early programming.[4] The channel transmitted live high-definition coverage of the 2008 Beijing Summer Olympics, including the Opening Ceremony on 8 August 2008 and select competitions across athletics, swimming, and gymnastics. This formed part of the BBC's multi-channel strategy, which encompassed BBC One, BBC Two, and BBC HD, alongside up to six interactive streams for additional events, totaling extensive hours of Olympic content. The Games represented a milestone as the first Olympics produced entirely in HD, with BBC HD providing enhanced clarity for viewers on compatible platforms like Freeview and cable.[53] BBC HD also carried significant portions of the 2012 London Summer Olympics, hosted in the UK, featuring live streams of marquee events such as the Opening Ceremony on 27 July 2012, track and field competitions at the Olympic Stadium, and cycling races. Integrated with BBC One HD and Red Button services, the coverage offered viewers options for up to 24 additional HD streams via interactive features, emphasizing national achievements like Mo Farah's gold medals in the 10,000m and 5,000m events. This domestic hosting amplified the channel's role in delivering immersive HD experiences before its closure in March 2013.[54][55] Other live events included annual broadcasts of the Wimbledon Tennis Championships, where HD feeds highlighted matches from Centre Court, such as the 2012 men's final between Roger Federer and Andy Murray on 8 July 2012, capturing the grass-court action with superior detail on player movements and crowd reactions. Similarly, FA Cup finals, like the 2012 match between Chelsea and Liverpool on 5 May 2012, were aired in HD, showcasing penalty shootouts and tactical play in enhanced format. These transmissions underscored BBC HD's emphasis on sports as a core genre for demonstrating technical advantages over standard definition.

Specialized Programming

BBC HD emphasized programming that leveraged high-definition visuals for intricate details, particularly in arts and cultural content such as operas, ballets, and classical music performances. These broadcasts often included live or recorded events from prestigious venues like the Royal Opera House, where the enhanced resolution captured nuances in staging, costumes, and performer movements that standard definition could not convey.[56][57] For example, the channel aired Puccini's Tosca from the Royal Opera House on Christmas Eve 2011, presented in HD alongside BBC Two.[56] Similarly, it featured world premieres by the Royal Ballet, including choreographer Wayne McGregor's Infra at Covent Garden, highlighting dynamic choreography and set designs optimized for HD scrutiny.[57] Classical music and choral events also formed a key part of this specialized slate, with broadcasts like The Nutcracker ballet and Lessons and Carols from King's College, Cambridge, which benefited from HD's clarity in capturing orchestral precision and architectural backdrops.[58] These selections aligned with BBC HD's role as a showcase for high-profile original productions, prioritizing content where visual fidelity enhanced artistic appreciation over mainstream entertainment.[15] Such programming filled schedule gaps beyond simulcasts, demonstrating HD's potential for cultural depth rather than broad appeal.[59] Nature and wildlife documentaries, produced natively in HD, further exemplified specialized content, with repeats of series like Planet Earth emphasizing expansive landscapes and animal behaviors in unprecedented detail—though mainstream dramas like Doctor Who occasionally interspersed, the channel's curatorial focus remained on visually demanding genres.[59] This approach underscored BBC HD's experimental mandate to test and promote HD technology through content inherently suited to its advantages, rather than routine repeats.[15]

Reception and Impact

Viewership Data and Audience Engagement

BBC HD's viewership grew steadily from its 2006 launch amid rising high-definition equipment adoption, though it remained niche due to limited household penetration. By December 2009, the channel reached over 3 million viewers, a tripling from January of that year.[60] In the Christmas period spanning late December 2009 to early January 2010, BBC HD's reach expanded to 2.5 million viewers, with an audience share of 2.4% among homes equipped for HD viewing.[60] Standout programming boosted engagement, including the Christmas Day Doctor Who special, which drew 470,000 viewers and a 13.9% share in HD homes, and a pre-Christmas Top Gear episode with 550,000 viewers and 14.9% share.[60] Approaching its March 2013 closure, BBC HD sustained an average weekly reach of 5.1%—or 3.0 million individuals aged 4 and over—for at least 15 consecutive minutes of viewing.[61] Among those viewers, average weekly time spent totaled 1 hour and 46 minutes.[61] Audience appreciation remained robust, with an Appreciation Index of 85.4 out of 100 based on surveys of UK adults aged 16 and over.[61] Additionally, 76.7% of respondents viewed the channel's programming as distinct and innovative, underscoring strong engagement from its core HD-capable demographic despite modest overall scale.[61]

Critical Assessments of Quality

Viewer complaints about the picture quality on BBC HD intensified in late 2009, with many describing broadcasts as fuzzy, grainy, and less crisp than initial transmissions from the channel's 2006 launch.[62] These issues prompted a surge in formal submissions to Ofcom, the UK broadcasting regulator, highlighting perceived degradation in high-definition standards.[62] The BBC responded by asserting that technical specifications remained consistent, with any visible grain stemming from source material—such as film-originated programs retaining natural texture—and inevitable compression artifacts in HD delivery.[63] Nonetheless, external observers and viewers attributed the changes to the adoption of new, more efficient encoders that lowered average bitrates to around 14-16 Mbps, enabling a denser schedule but at the cost of detail preservation compared to higher-bitrate alternatives used by rivals.[64] In June 2010, the BBC convened a viewer panel for blind comparative tests, incorporating their recommendations—such as refined noise reduction and dynamic range adjustments—into future workflows to address subjective quality perceptions.[65] Despite these efforts, ongoing forum discussions among enthusiasts noted BBC HD's relative lack of "sparkle" and sharpness versus ITV HD or Channel 4 HD, often linking it to conservative bitrate allocations amid license fee constraints.[66] Critiques of programming quality were less formalized but centered on the channel's reliance on HD versions of existing BBC output rather than pioneering more original, HD-exclusive content, which some argued diluted its showcase potential despite strong reception for nature documentaries and live events.[67] Overall, while technical delivery drew the sharpest scrutiny, these assessments reflected tensions between public funding imperatives and viewer expectations for premium HD fidelity.

Broader Influence on HD Adoption

The launch of BBC HD positioned the British Broadcasting Corporation as a pioneer in high-definition television broadcasting within the United Kingdom, with the service explicitly designed to accelerate consumer adoption of HDTV technologies. In its public value test application to the BBC Trust, the corporation outlined plans for a free-to-view HD channel to serve as a "trusted guide" to emerging technologies, educating audiences on HD benefits and addressing prevalent confusion about required equipment, such as the need for compatible set-top boxes noted by 49% of surveyed consumers unaware of this prerequisite.[51] By committing to a 2007/2008 rollout across platforms, including digital terrestrial television, the BBC aimed to future-proof free-to-view services and stimulate manufacturer investment in HD receivers, with internal research indicating that 90% of HD-aware consumers anticipated BBC content in the format.[51] Industry stakeholders endorsed this approach, recognizing the BBC's unique public service mandate as enabling it to "drive uptake of receiving equipment" and foster market stability for competitors, thereby increasing overall consumption through heightened consumer awareness and enthusiasm generated by exposure to HD programming.[68] The channel's emphasis on showcase content—such as enhanced nature documentaries and live events—demonstrated tangible quality improvements over standard definition, potentially expediting the development and affordability of MPEG-4 compatible decoders essential for broader penetration.[68] This leadership role aligned with public policy objectives for a "digital Britain," where early HD availability on universal platforms could preempt a digital divide by encouraging upgrades among license fee payers who, per stakeholder views, expected such innovation from the BBC.[51] Although quantitative data directly attributing HD set sales surges to BBC HD remains limited, the service's operational trial from May 2006 and full launch in December 2007 coincided with nascent HD ecosystem growth, including incentives for pay-TV providers to expand offerings and the eventual integration of HD into core BBC channels by 2013, reflecting a maturation where initial demonstration effects had normalized the format.[51] Allocated promotional budgets in the millions for launch-year marketing further underscored efforts to clarify the HD value proposition, positioning BBC HD as a catalyst for market entry by other broadcasters once critical mass was achieved.[51] This strategic focus contributed to the UK's transition from analog to digital HD standards, though adoption was also influenced by concurrent commercial satellite advancements and regulatory spectrum allocations.[68]

Controversies and Criticisms

Funding Efficiency and License Fee Justification

The funding of BBC HD, launched on 15 May 2006, derived from the compulsory television licence fee, which totalled £3.5 billion in revenue for the BBC in the 2005/06 financial year, representing the corporation's primary income source. Allocations to HD services were not itemized separately in annual reports but formed part of broader technology and transmission expenditures, estimated at around 10-15% of the BBC's total budget during the channel's early years, with HD production upgrades adding incremental costs for native content creation amid predominantly simulcast programming.[69] Critics, including licence fee payers during pre-launch consultations, raised efficiency concerns, noting that 68% of respondents were satisfied with standard-definition picture quality and only 44% supported funding an HD channel via the universal licence fee, preferring subscription models for optional enhancements.[69] This reflected perceptions of inequity, as households without HD-capable equipment—comprising over 90% of UK homes at launch—subsidized benefits for a minority, with much early content consisting of upscaled repeats rather than exclusive native HD material, potentially duplicating standard-channel outputs without proportional value addition.[69] Proponents, including BBC executives, justified the expenditure as fulfilling the corporation's charter remit to innovate and lead technological standards, arguing that early HD investment accelerated national adoption—from under 10% HD penetration in 2006 to over 90% by 2013—and delivered public benefits like enhanced clarity for genres such as sports and drama, outweighing initial costs through long-term efficiencies in broadcasting infrastructure.[70] The BBC Trust approved the service following a Public Value Test, which assessed benefits like improved viewer experience against minimal market distortion, though empirical cost-benefit data remained internal and contested by skeptics questioning returns given BBC HD's peak audience share of under 1% in its final years.[70] By the channel's closure on 16 March 2013, integration of HD into core services like BBC One HD was cited as evidence of strategic success, obviating a standalone multiplex and yielding spectrum efficiencies, yet retrospective analyses highlighted ongoing debates over whether licence fee hypothecation incentivized over-investment in niche formats absent direct consumer choice mechanisms.

Content Bias Allegations

Allegations of content bias in BBC HD stemmed from its role as a high-definition simulcast of BBC One, BBC Two, and BBC News programming, which inherited the same editorial decisions as the standard-definition feeds during its run from June 2006 to March 2013. Critics, particularly from Eurosceptic and conservative perspectives, argued that the channel's news and current affairs segments exhibited a systemic pro-European Union (EU) tilt through underrepresentation of withdrawalist viewpoints. For instance, analysis of BBC Radio 4's Today programme from 2004 to 2015—overlapping with BBC HD's lifespan—revealed that only 3.2% of 4,275 EU-themed speakers advocated for exit, despite polls showing 33-50% public support for such positions, with most skeptic voices limited to UKIP representatives like Nigel Farage.[71] A January 2013 Newsnight episode, broadcast in HD on BBC HD, featured one withdrawal advocate against 18 pro-EU speakers, exemplifying claims of imbalance in prime-time analysis.[71] [72] Immigration coverage on BBC HD drew similar scrutiny for alleged omission of public concerns. Reports highlighted instances where anti-immigration sentiments were sidelined, such as vox pops deemed "rabidly racist" being excluded despite reflecting broader unease, contributing to perceptions of a metropolitan, liberal filter on policy debates.[71] This pattern aligned with earlier findings, including two 2005 independent reviews that criticized the BBC's EU reporting as inadequate and unintentionally biased toward integration, prompting the appointment of a Brussels-based Europe editor to address deficits in skeptic perspectives—changes that carried into HD-era broadcasts.[73] A 2013 Cardiff University study further quantified left-of-centre tendencies in BBC output, noting disproportionate airtime for opposition parties and topics like immigration where pro-establishment views dominated source appearances (54.8% from elite institutions in 2012).[74] Insider admissions reinforced these claims; former BBC political editor Andrew Marr acknowledged in 2007 a "massive bias to the left" among staff, while ex-presenter Peter Sissons described a pro-EU cultural orthodoxy stifling dissent.[71] Such critiques contrasted with BBC defenses of impartiality, including responses to 2006 coverage of the Israeli-Hezbollah conflict, where governors upheld adherence to standards despite isolated lapses in framing.[75] Overall, while accusations arose from both political flanks, empirical monitoring by groups like News-Watch emphasized structural omissions favoring progressive consensus on EU and immigration—issues prominent in BBC HD's news relays—over contrarian empirical realities like rising public skepticism.[72][76]

Technical and Policy Disputes

In 2009, BBC HD faced viewer complaints regarding perceived degradation in picture quality following changes to transmission parameters. Viewers, particularly in London, accused the BBC of intentionally reducing bitrates to cut costs after implementing new MPEG-4 encoders on August 5, which were selected to better handle diverse HD content such as progressive and interlaced mixes in programs like the BBC Proms.[64] [63] The BBC confirmed a bitrate reduction from 16 Mbps to 9 Mbps to optimize bandwidth usage across Freeview HD services, emphasizing that bitrate alone does not determine quality and that the adjustments aimed to improve encoding efficiency without compromising overall standards.[63] Initial issues with scene transitions, such as mixes and fades, were acknowledged and addressed through interim fixes and collaboration with the encoder supplier, though the broadcaster maintained that subjective and objective testing had preceded the rollout.[64] [63] A significant policy dispute arose in 2011 over the BBC's proposal to impose digital rights management (DRM) on Freeview HD broadcasts, including BBC HD, to protect content from unauthorized recording by complying with rules from the Digital Transmission Licensing Administrator (DTLA), led by Intel.[77] The scheme involved scrambling video decoding information, but submissions to Ofcom were redacted for "commercial sensitivity" to avoid aiding circumvention or harming negotiations with rights holders, limiting public scrutiny during consultation.[77] Critics identified technical flaws, including ease of defeat, disruption to closed captions and assistive audio for disabled viewers, and exclusion of UK manufacturers and open-source devices due to proprietary DTLA rules.[77] Public response was overwhelmingly negative, with 426 of 432 individual license fee payers opposing it in 459 total responses, alongside objections from academics, the Royal National Institute of Blind People, and the Linux Foundation; institutional support came primarily from broadcasters and rights holders.[77] Despite this, Ofcom approved the proposal, citing commercial imperatives over broader public feedback, effectively enabling a framework that prioritized content protection.[77] BBC HD primarily transmitted in 1080i50 format for live content to match PAL-derived frame rates, with some progressive 1080p25 for film-originated material, a decision defended for compatibility with European standards but occasionally critiqued by viewers favoring full progressive scan for reduced motion artifacts on larger screens.[25] In May 2011, the channel shifted select transmissions to 1080p to align production formats more closely with display, aiming to enhance quality without re-encoding.[25] The channel's policy of broadcasting only native HD productions, avoiding upscaling from standard definition, was upheld to maintain authenticity, though isolated viewer perceptions of softness in certain outputs fueled ongoing debates about encoding efficiency.[63]

References

  1. BBC launches five new HD channels - BBC News
  2. BBC Blogs - About the BBC - Hello BBC Two HD; Goodbye BBC HD
  3. Press Office - BBC One HD to launch Autumn 2010
  4. BBC launches UK's first free high definition broadcasts
  5. BBC Two HD Channel to launch 26 March - Media Centre
  6. Press Office - BBC to trial High Definition broadcasts in 2006
  7. BBC launch free-to-air HD trial - DVB
  8. [PDF] A HIGHER DEFINITION: - BBC
  9. BBC HD Test Transmition | AVForums
  10. Press Office - Broadcasters join forces in DTT high definition trial - BBC
  11. Press Office - HD Ready viewers expect HD TV on Freeview - BBC
  12. https://uk.practicallaw.thomsonreuters.com/1-376-3905?transitionType=Default&contextType=data
  13. Press Office - BBC HD to launch on 1 December
  14. BBC Internet Blog: BBC HD TV Update
  15. BBC HD Channel Up To Nine Hours Per Day
  16. Freeview HD launch: BBC HD and ITV1 HD now available -- sort of
  17. BBC HD (Australia and New Zealand) | Logopedia - Fandom
  18. Press Office - BBC One HD Channel to launch 3 November
  19. BBC Two HD replaces BBC HD channel on March 26th - Engadget
  20. BBC HD Shutdown - Test Card Wiki - Fandom
  21. BBC TWO HD launch causes some channel number shifts
  22. BBC2 HD Simulcast Channel To Replace BBC HD On 26 March
  23. [PDF] TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION FOR THE DELIVERY OF ... - BBC
  24. Software Upgrade for BBC HD on Freeview HD
  25. BBC shifts some HD transmissions to 1080p... - The Register
  26. BBC HD - Hollywood source video specifications - Digital Spy Forum
  27. [PDF] TECHNICAL STANDARDS FOR DELIVERY OF TELEVISION ...
  28. BBC Internet Blog: Questions around surround sound on Freeview HD
  29. BBC One HD DOES sometimes do 5.1 Surround Sound Broadcasting
  30. [PDF] Audio Quality Information & Standards for - BBC
  31. BBC confirms use of variable bit-rate encoding on HD channel
  32. Head of BBC HD says 'reducing bit rate has no impact on picture ...
  33. BBC HD quality better than ever - Broadband TV News
  34. Bitrates of BBC HD channels - Digital Spy Forum
  35. BBC agrees to improve its HD bandwidth and quality??
  36. UPDATE: BBC experiments with 1080p broadcasts on Freeview HD
  37. Research and Development: iPlayer3D update - BBC
  38. Research and Development: 2D compatible 3D broadcasts - BBC
  39. BBC 3D programming 'on hold' indefinitely - BBC News
  40. The development of TV in the UK | free and easy for 22 years
  41. BBC HD on Freeview: Rolling out across UK in 2010 - CNET
  42. The BBC One HD channel is ready for launch
  43. BBC Worldwide announces UK.TV acquisition and new channels in ...
  44. BBC Worldwide takes control of Australian channel UKTV | BBC ...
  45. Foxtel Signs Key Content Deal With BBC - Via Satellite
  46. BBC HD makes its European debut as BBC Worldwide launches ...
  47. BBC HD goes Nordic | News | C21Media
  48. WorldScreen.com - BBC Launches Channels Portfolio in Scandinavia
  49. BBC HD - LyngSat
  50. About: BBC HD (international)
  51. [PDF] BBC Management's PVT application for a High Definition Television ...
  52. [PDF] BBC high definition television channel Public Value Test Joint BBC ...
  53. 2008 Olympics press pack - BBC
  54. The London Games on the BBC - Media Centre
  55. Different ways to listen and watch the BBC's Olympics 2012 coverage
  56. BBC Two - Tosca from the Royal Opera House
  57. BBC Two - The Royal Ballet World Premiere
  58. Europe: Free BBC HD Channel is Up | TV Tech
  59. BBC Internet Blog: BBC HD: What Works Best?
  60. Press Office - 2009 a breakthrough year for the BBC's TV channels
  61. [PDF] BBC Audience Information Data Tables (document 1) January
  62. BBC High Definition service draws complaints
  63. BBC Internet Blog: Picture Quality on BBC HD: a response
  64. U.K.: BBC Responds to Complaints of HD Degradation | TV Tech
  65. BBC HD: Beeb publishes critics' advice for improving picture quality
  66. The HD channels - why does BBC look "fuzzy" - Digital Spy Forum
  67. Who on earth makes the BBC HD programming choices? - AVForums
  68. [PDF] BBC Trust – HDTV Public Value Assessment Summary of Industry ...
  69. [PDF] A BMRB Report for: - BBC
  70. Public Value Tests - BBC Trust
  71. None
  72. [PDF] News-watch's Research into the BBC's Coverage of the EU 1999
  73. BBC acts on accusations of Europe bias - The Guardian
  74. Hard Evidence: how biased is the BBC? - The Conversation
  75. Is the BBC biased?The Corporation and the coverage of the 2006 ...
  76. [PDF] The Brussels Broadcasting Corporation? | Civitas
  77. How the BBC's HD DRM plot was kept secret … and why
User Avatar
No comments yet.