Hubbry Logo
Boston Symphony OrchestraBoston Symphony OrchestraMain
Open search
Boston Symphony Orchestra
Community hub
Boston Symphony Orchestra
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Boston Symphony Orchestra
Boston Symphony Orchestra
Boston Symphony Orchestra
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Boston Symphony Orchestra (BSO) is an American symphony orchestra based in Boston. It is the second-oldest orchestra in the United States and one the five major American symphony orchestras commonly referred to as the "Big Five".[1][2][3][4] Founded by Henry Lee Higginson in 1881, the BSO performs most of its concerts at Boston's Symphony Hall and in the summer performs at Tanglewood.

Key Information

Since its founding, the orchestra has had 17 music directors, including George Henschel, Serge Koussevitzky, Henri Rabaud, Pierre Monteux, Charles Munch, Erich Leinsdorf, William Steinberg and James Levine. Andris Nelsons is the current music director of the BSO. Seiji Ozawa had held the title of BSO music director laureate. Bernard Haitink had held the title of principal guest conductor of the BSO from 1995 to 2004, then conductor emeritus until his death in 2021. The orchestra has made gramophone recordings since 1917 and has occasionally played on soundtrack recordings for films, including Schindler's List.

History

[edit]

Early years

[edit]
Henry Lee Higginson, founding father of the BSO.

The BSO was founded in 1881 by Henry Lee Higginson. Its first conductor was George Henschel, who was a noted baritone as well as conductor, and a close friend of Johannes Brahms. For the orchestra, Henschel devised innovative orchestral seating charts and sent them to Brahms, who replied approvingly and commented on the issues raised by horn and viola sections in a letter of mid-November 1881.[5] The BSO's first concert took place on October 22, 1881.[6] The program consisted of Beethoven's The Consecration of the House, as well as music by Joseph Haydn, Christoph Willibald Gluck, Franz Schubert and Carl Maria von Weber.

The BSO at Boston Music Hall in 1891.

The orchestra's four subsequent music directors were all trained in Austria, including the seminal and highly influential Hungarian-born conductor Arthur Nikisch, in accordance with the tastes of Higginson. Wilhelm Gericke served twice, from 1884 to 1889 and again from 1898 to 1906. According to Joseph Horowitz's review of correspondence, Higginson considered 25 candidates to replace Gericke after receiving notice in 1905. He decided not to offer the position to Gustav Mahler, Fritz Steinbach, and Willem Mengelberg but did not rule out the young Bruno Walter if nobody more senior were to accept. He offered the position to Hans Richter in February 1905, who declined, to Felix Mottl in November, who was previously engaged, and then to previous director Nikisch, who declined; the post was finally offered to Karl Muck, who accepted and began his duties in October 1906. He was conductor until 1908 and again from 1912 to 1918.[7]

The music director 1908–12 was Max Fiedler. He conducted the premiere of Ignacy Jan Paderewski's Symphony in B minor "Polonia" in 1909.

Following American entry into World War I, Muck (born in Germany but a Swiss citizen since childhood), was falsely accused by unscrupulous newspaper editor John R. Rathom of knowingly refusing a request to play The Star Spangled Banner. Although Higginson had not told Muck of the request and the BSO always ended future concerts with the American national anthem, Muck was subjected by Rathom to a trial by media anyway and was arrested by Federal agents shortly before a performance of Johann Sebastian Bach's St Matthew Passion in March 1918. Along with 29 of the BSO best musicians, Muck was imprisoned in Fort Oglethorpe, a German-American internment camp in the State of Georgia, without trial or appeal until the summer after the Armistice, when he and his wife agreed that be deported to neutral Denmark. Muck felt deeply insulted by the injustice of these events, vowed never to perform on American soil again, and conducted thereafter only in Europe.

The BSO's next two titled conductors were French: Henri Rabaud, who took over from Muck for a season, and then Pierre Monteux from 1919 to 1924. Monteux, because of a musician's strike, was able to replace 30 players, thus changing the orchestra's sound; the orchestra developed a reputation for a "French" sound which some claim persists to some degree to this day.[8]

Koussevitzky and Munch

[edit]
Symphony Hall, Boston, the main base of the orchestra since 1900

The orchestra's reputation increased during the 1924–1949 music directorship of Serge Koussevitzky. One million radio listeners tuned in when Koussevitzky and the orchestra were the first to perform a live concert for radio broadcast, which they did on NBC in 1926.[9]

In August 1942, the American Federation of Musicians kicked off the two-year long musician's strike, with the goal of musicians receiving more in royalty payments from record companies. Initially, the BSO were the only major performing group in the nation unaffected; the orchestra's musicians hadn't been unionized since the orchestra's founding. By the end of 1942, however, the orchestra joined the AFM, effectively joining the strike, and also kicking off a long series of live radio concerts on CBS with Koussevitzky conducting.[10]

Under Koussevitzky, the orchestra gave regular radio broadcasts and established its summer home at Tanglewood, where Koussevitzky founded the Berkshire Music Center, which is now the Tanglewood Music Center. Those network radio broadcasts ran from 1926 through 1951, and again from 1954 through 1956. The orchestra continues to make regular live radio broadcasts to the present day. The Boston Symphony has been closely involved with Boston's WGBH Radio as an outlet for its concerts.

Koussevitzky also commissioned many new pieces from prominent composers, including the Symphony No. 4 of Sergei Prokofiev, George Gershwin's Second Rhapsody and the Symphony of Psalms by Igor Stravinsky. They also gave the premiere of Béla Bartók's Concerto for Orchestra, which had been commissioned by the Koussevitzky Music Foundation at the instigation of Fritz Reiner and Joseph Szigeti.

Koussevitzky started a tradition of commissions that the orchestra continued, including new works by Heitor Villa-Lobos (Symphony No. 11) and Henri Dutilleux for its 75th anniversary, Roger Sessions, and Andrzej Panufnik, for the 100th, and lately for the 125th works by Leon Kirchner, Elliott Carter, and Peter Lieberson. Other BSO commissions have included John Corigliano's Symphony No. 2 for the 100th anniversary of Symphony Hall. Hans Werner Henze dedicated his Eighth Symphony to the orchestra.

Although Koussevitsky recommended his protégé Leonard Bernstein to be his successor after he retired in 1949,[11] the BSO awarded the position to the Alsatian maestro Charles Munch, who would lead until 1962. Munch had made his Boston conducting debut in 1946. He led orchestra on its first overseas tour, and also produced their first stereo recording in February 1954 for RCA Victor. In 1952, Munch appointed the first woman to hold a principal chair in a major U.S. orchestra, flutist Doriot Anthony Dwyer, who remained as BSO principal for 38 years.[12]

Leinsdorf, Steinberg, and Ozawa

[edit]

Erich Leinsdorf became music director in 1962 and held the post until 1969. William Steinberg was then music director from 1969 to 1972. Steinberg was "ill and ailing" according to composer/author Jan Swafford, and "for four years he was indisposed much of the time."[13] After Steinberg's retirement, according to BSO trustee John Thorndike (who was on the search committee) the symphony's board spoke to Colin Davis and "investigated very thoroughly" his appointment, but Davis's commitments to his young family did not allow his moving to Boston from England;[14] instead he accepted the post of BSO principal guest conductor, which he held from 1972 to 1984. As the search continued, Leonard Bernstein met with four board members and recommended Michael Tilson Thomas, who had been Assistant Conductor and Associate Conductor under Steinberg, for the directorship, but the young conductor "did not have sufficient support among the BSO players," according to journalist Jeremy Eichler.[14] The committee eventually chose Seiji Ozawa, who became Music Director in 1973 and held the post until 2002, the longest tenure of any Boston Symphony conductor. In 1979, he led the Boston Symphony Orchestra's visit to the People's Republic of China to celebrate the normalization of US-China diplomatic relations, making it the second American orchestra to ever visit the country.[15]

Ozawa's tenure involved significant dissension and controversy. One concern was his handling of the Tanglewood Music Center. Greg Sandow wrote in The Wall Street Journal in December 1998 that Ozawa "had taken control of the school with what many people thought was surprising and abrupt brutality. Members of the faculty, themselves world-famous, had angrily resigned."[16] The first departure was in the fall of 1996, when Ozawa fired Richard Ortner, the Festival's administrator.[17] After a tumultuous season, at the end of summer 1997, pianist Gilbert Kalish resigned from the faculty by sending Ozawa what the pianist/conductor Leon Fleisher later described as "a blistering letter of resignation, and he made it public"; Fleisher, who was also a long-term member of the Tanglewood faculty, wrote, "Most of the faculty felt he was speaking for them."[17] Ozawa reduced Fleisher's role at the Center, offering him instead a "ceremonial puppet role", and Fleisher resigned, writing to Ozawa that the proposed role was "somewhat akin to having my legs chopped off at the knees, you then gently taking me by the arm and inviting me for a stroll. I must decline the invitation."[17] By contrast, Boston Globe music critic Richard Dyer wrote that:

...not every change was for the better...But there can be no question that Tanglewood is a busier, more adventurous, and more exciting place than it was before Ozawa became music director.[18]

A more basic concern involved perceived shortcomings in Ozawa's musical leadership; as Sandow wrote in the 1998 article, "what mattered far more was how badly the BSO plays."[16] He noted that a group of Boston Symphony musicians had privately published a newsletter, Counterpoint, expressing their concerns; in the summer of 1995[19] concertmaster Malcolm Lowe and principal cellist Jules Eskin wrote that in rehearsal Ozawa gave no "specific leadership in matters of tempo and rhythm," no "expression of care about sound quality", and no "distinctly-conveyed conception of the character of each piece the BSO plays."[16]

The BSO's managing director, Mark Volpe, responded that some board members considered Sandow's article a "hatchet job", and some unnamed BSO "observers" were said in The Boston Globe to believe that Sandow "might be sharpening blades for BSO members with axes to grind".[19] Sandow called the suggestion "nonsense", saying, "I found them [players criticizing Ozawa in his article], they didn't find me".[19] André Previn wrote to The Wall Street Journal defending Ozawa,[20] and Lowe wrote to the Journal that he was "frustrated and upset to see my name attached to the article since your reporter did not contact me and chose to quote a letter published nearly four years ago in an internal orchestra publication."[20] Boston Symphony Board of Trustees president Nicholas T. Zervas described Sandow as expressing an "`insulting, reductive, and racist view of [Ozawa] as a samurai kept in place in order to raise Japanese money"[20] – a point Sandow rebutted in a letter to the Journal, saying "These are things I didn't say. I'd heard the charge about Japanese money while I was writing my piece, so I asked Mark Volpe, the BSO's General Manager, what he thought of it. Mark refuted it, and I quoted him approvingly."[20] Critic Lloyd Schwarz defended Sandow in the Boston alternative paper, The Boston Phoenix[21]

Various current music critics described a decline in the orchestra's playing during Ozawa's tenure. Jan Swafford wrote:

Now and then he gave a standout performance, usually in the full-throated late-Romantic and 20th-century literature, but most of the time what came out was glittering surfaces with nothing substantial beneath: no discernable concept, no vision.[13]

In a 2013 survey of recordings of The Rite of Spring by Igor Stravinsky, the composer Russell Platt wrote in The New Yorker:

Seiji Ozawa's downright depressing account, recorded in 1979: the Boston Symphony Orchestra's sonic shine, developed by Ozawa's predecessors Monteux and Charles Munch, is audibly dripping away, its dispirited musicians losing their sense of individual responsibility to the score. It is a record of a professional relationship that went on far too long.[22]

On June 22, 1999, the symphony announced Ozawa's departure as music director, as of 2002, following the sudden announcement of Ozawa's appointment as music director of the Vienna State Opera – a decision the board had heard about only a day earlier, where Volpe said he was "a little surprised at the timing".[23] He gave his last concert with the orchestra in July 2002.[18]

During Ozawa's tenure, Bernard Haitink served as principal guest conductor from 1995 to 2004. Haitink was named conductor emeritus in 2004, and actively served in the post as a returning guest conductor through his retirement in 2019.

Levine and Nelsons

[edit]

In 2004, James Levine became the first American-born music director of the BSO. Levine received critical praise for revitalizing the quality and repertoire since the beginning of his tenure, including championing contemporary composers.[24] During Levine's tenure, by February 2009 the BSO had performed 18 world premieres, 12 of them conducted by Levine.[25] To fund the more challenging and expensive of Levine's musical projects with the orchestra, the orchestra established an "Artistic Initiative Fund" of about $40 million. (As of March 2013, the Boston Symphony also claimed an endowment of $413 million, the largest of any orchestra in the world.)[26] Levine suffered from recurring injuries and health problems during his BSO tenure,[27] which led to his resignation as BSO music director as of September 1, 2011.[28]

In the wake of Levine's resignation, Andris Nelsons made his first guest-conducting appearance with the BSO in March 2011, as an emergency substitute for Levine at Carnegie Hall in Mahler's Symphony No. 9.[29] He subsequently guest-conducted the BSO at Tanglewood in July 2012,[30] and made his first appearance with the BSO at Symphony Hall in January 2013. In May 2013, the BSO named Nelsons as its 15th music director, effective with the 2014–2015 season. His initial contract was for 5 years, with 8–10 weeks of scheduled appearances in the first year of the contract, and 12 weeks in subsequent years. Nelsons held the title of Music Director Designate for the 2013–2014 season.[31] In August 2015, the BSO announced the extension of Nelsons' contract as music director through the 2021–2022 season, with a new contract of 8 years to replace the initial 5-year contract, and which also contains an evergreen clause for automatic renewal.[32] In October 2020, the BSO announced a further extension of Nelsons' contract as music director through August 2025, with an evergreen clause for automatic renewal.[33] In January 2024, the BSO announced the conversion of Nelsons' contract as its music director to a rolling evergreen contract.[34]

In September 2015, the orchestra announced a new artistic collaboration with the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra, of which Nelsons was appointed as its next Gewandhauskapellmeister, effective with the 2017–2018 season.[35][36]

Unequal-pay lawsuit

[edit]

On July 2, 2018, BSO principal flautist Elizabeth Rowe filed a lawsuit in the Superior Court of Suffolk County, Massachusetts, claiming pay discrimination on the basis of gender. Rowe said she was paid much less than principal oboist John Ferrillo since 2004 and was seeking more than $200,000 in unpaid compensation from the orchestra.[37] The BSO tried to discredit Rowe's claim that she was being discriminated against because of the unequal pay compared to Ferrillo by saying in a court filing that the two wind instruments were not comparable.[38] After mediation,[39] the case was settled out of court in February 2019 for an undisclosed amount.[40][41]

Recent history

[edit]

In January 2020, the BSO cancelled its planned tour of Asia, the first American orchestra to cancel overseas travel in the wake of the COVID-19 outbreak.[42] Subsequent events related to the COVID-19 pandemic included the following:

  • Cancellation of the 2020 Tanglewood summer festival season[43]
  • Cancellation of its scheduled subscription concerts through November 2020, the first-ever full cancellation of the orchestra's autumn subscription concerts in its history[44]
  • Staff redundancies effective September 1, 2020[45]
  • Reduction in orchestra musician compensation in its latest labour agreement, from August 24, 2020, through August 27, 2023[46]

In succession to Mark Volpe, Gail Samuel became the BSO's president and chief executive officer in June 2021, the first woman to be named to the posts in the history of the orchestra.[47] In December 2022, the BSO announced simultaneously the resignation of Samuel as its president and CEO, effective January 3, 2023,[48] and the appointment of Jeffrey D. Dunn as its interim president and CEO, effective January 4, 2023.[49] In May 2023, the BSO announced the appointment of Chad Smith as its next president and chief executive officer, effective in the autumn of 2023.[50][51]

[edit]

The Boston Pops, the Boston Symphony Orchestra minus its principal players, was founded in 1885, and plays lighter, more popular classics, and show tunes. Arthur Fiedler was the conductor who did the most to increase the fame of the Boston Pops over his tenure from 1930 to 1979. Film composer John Williams succeeded Fiedler as the conductor of the Pops from 1980 to 1993. Since 1995, conductor Keith Lockhart has led the Boston Pops.

The Boston Symphony Chamber Players were launched in 1964. Today they are the only chamber ensemble composed of principal players from an American symphony orchestra. In addition to regular performances in Boston and Tanglewood, they have performed throughout the United States and Europe. They have also recorded for RCA Victor, Deutsche Grammophon, Philips, and Nonesuch.

Performing with the BSO and Boston Pops for major choral works is the Tanglewood Festival Chorus. Organized in 1970 by its founding director, John Oliver, the Chorus comprises over 300 volunteer singers. Before the creation of the Tanglewood Festival Chorus, and for some time after, the BSO frequently employed the New England Conservatory Chorus conducted by Lorna Cooke DeVaron, Chorus pro Musica, Harvard Glee Club and Radcliffe Choral Society. In February 2017, the BSO announced the appointment of James Burton as the new conductor of the Tanglewood Festival Chorus and as the newly created BSO Choral Director, both with immediate effect.[52] Burton founded the Boston Symphony Children's Choir in 2018.[53]

Recordings

[edit]

The Boston Symphony made its first acoustical recordings in 1917 in Camden, New Jersey, for the Victor Talking Machine Company conducted by Karl Muck. Among the first discs recorded was the finale to Tchaikovsky's fourth symphony. Under Serge Koussevitzky, the orchestra made its first electrical recordings, also for Victor, in the late 1920s. These electrical recordings included Ravel's Boléro. Recording sessions took place in Symphony Hall. Koussevitzky's final recording with the Boston Symphony was a high fidelity version of Sibelius' Symphony No. 2, recorded in 1950 and released on LP.

In February 1954, RCA Victor began recording the orchestra in stereo, under the direction of Charles Munch. RCA Victor continued to record Munch and the orchestra through 1962, his final year as music director in Boston (see the Charles Munch discography for a complete list of commercial recordings with the BSO under Charles Munch). During Munch's tenure, Pierre Monteux made a series of records with the BSO for RCA Victor (see Pierre Monteux for a complete list of commercial recordings with the BSO).

Erich Leinsdorf, who had already made numerous recordings for RCA Victor, continued his association with the company during his seven years in Boston. These included a critically acclaimed performance of Brahms' German Requiem (see Erich Leinsdorf for a complete list).

Then, the orchestra switched to Deutsche Grammophon (DG) under William Steinberg. RCA Victor recorded several LPs with Steinberg and Berlioz's Symphonie Fantastique with Georges Prêtre during the transition to DG (see William Steinberg for a complete list of commercial recordings). Michael Tilson Thomas, who was the assistant conductor and associate conductor under Steinberg, also made several recordings for DG; some of these have been reissued on CD.

Due to Steinberg's illness, DG recorded the BSO with Rafael Kubelík in Beethoven's Symphony No. 5 (part of his cycle of Beethoven symphonies with nine different orchestras), Ma Vlast by Bedřich Smetana and in Béla Bartók's Concerto for Orchestra as well as with Eugen Jochum conducting Symphony No. 41 by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart and Franz Schubert's Symphony No. 8.

As a guest conductor in the 1960s, Ozawa made several recordings with the BSO for RCA Victor. He continued the BSO relationship with DG while making several other releases for New World Records.[54] Over the course of Ozawa's tenure, the BSO diversified its relationships, making recordings under Ozawa with CBS, EMI, Philips Records, RCA, and TELARC.

The BSO also recorded for Philips under Colin Davis. Leonard Bernstein made records for both Columbia and DG with the BSO, including selections from his last concert ever as a conductor on August 19, 1990, at Tanglewood. The BSO has also appeared on Decca with Vladimir Ashkenazy, with Charles Dutoit and André Previn for DG, and on Phillips and Sony Classical with Bernard Haitink.

The BSO has also done recordings for film scores on occasion. Films such as Schindler's List and Saving Private Ryan (both composed and conducted by John Williams) were recorded by the orchestra at Symphony Hall.

In the James Levine era, the BSO had no standing recording contract with a major label;[55] the Grammy Award-winning recording of Levine conducting the BSO with Lorraine Hunt Lieberson in Peter Lieberson's Neruda Songs, released on Nonesuch Records, was the only major label recording during Levine's tenure. On February 19, 2009, the BSO announced the launch of a new series of recordings on their own label, BSO Classics. Some of the recordings are available only as digital downloads. The initial recordings included live concert performances of William Bolcom's 8th Symphony and Lyric Concerto, the latter with flutist James Galway, Mahler's Sixth Symphony, the Brahms Ein deutsches Requiem, and Ravel's complete Daphnis et Chloé,[56] which won the 2010 Grammy Award for Best Orchestral Performance.[57]

In April 2015, the BSO announced a new recording partnership with Deutsche Grammophon that focuses on the music of Dmitri Shostakovich, with Nelsons as conductor.[58] The first recording in the series, of the Tenth Symphony recorded in concert in April 2015, was released on CD in August 2015, and subsequently won the year's Grammy award for Best Orchestral Performance. The most recent recording in the series, released in October 2023, concluded the cycle of Shostakovich symphonies, featuring performances of the 2nd, 3rd, 12th, and 13th symphonies.

Music directors

[edit]

Composer Chair

[edit]
[edit]

In the 1974–1975 American television situation comedy Paul Sand in Friends and Lovers, several cast members played fictional personnel of the Boston Symphony Orchestra. The show's star, Paul Sand, portrayed Robert Dreyfuss, who played double bass, while Steve Landesberg played violinist Fred Meyerbach. Craig Richard Nelson was the orchestra's conductor, Mason Woodruff, and Dick Wesson was its manager, Jack Riordan. In one episode, Robert's father Ben, played by Jack Gilford, had a job in the orchestra's ticket office. Guest stars who appeared as musicians playing in or with the orchestra during the show's 15-episode run included Henry Winkler as a cellist, Leon Askin as a violinist, and Susan Neher as a flutist.[59][60][61][62][63]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Boston Symphony Orchestra

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Boston Symphony Orchestra (BSO) is an American symphony orchestra founded in 1881 by philanthropist Henry Lee Higginson, who envisioned a permanent ensemble to elevate musical standards in the United States following European models he encountered during his studies in Vienna. The orchestra's inaugural concert took place on October 22, 1881, at the Boston Music Hall under conductor Georg Henschel, marking the beginning of its tradition of high-caliber performances. Since establishing Symphony Hall as its permanent Boston home in 1900—designed with acoustic principles informed by scientific measurements to optimize sound quality—the BSO has maintained a regular season there, complemented by summer residencies at Tanglewood in the Berkshires since 1937, where it performs outdoors and hosts the Tanglewood Music Center for young musicians. Under its current music director, Andris Nelsons, who assumed the role in 2014, the BSO continues to commission new works, produce acclaimed recordings, and foster educational initiatives, building on legacies from conductors like Serge Koussevitzky, who expanded its American music advocacy and founded the Tanglewood program. The orchestra's defining characteristics include its commitment to artistic excellence, evidenced by a roster of internationally renowned musicians and a history of premiering significant compositions, though it has navigated challenges such as financial dependencies on private patronage and occasional labor disputes inherent to large ensembles.

History

Founding and Early Years

The Boston Symphony Orchestra was established in 1881 by Henry Lee Higginson, a Boston financier, Civil War veteran, and philanthropist who aimed to create a permanent professional ensemble delivering symphonic music of the highest standard to elevate public appreciation, drawing from European models he encountered during studies in Vienna. Higginson announced his intention on March 30, 1881, via newspaper publications, committing personal funds to sustain the orchestra without reliance on ticket profits or deficits, ensuring artistic independence. The inaugural concert occurred on October 22, 1881, at Boston's Music Hall, under the baton of Georg Henschel, a German-born composer and baritone chosen by Higginson as the first conductor for his ties to Brahms and broad musicianship. The program comprised overtures by Gluck and Haydn, Beethoven's Symphony No. 2, and Schubert's Symphony No. 5, marking the BSO's debut commitment to core classical works. Henschel led through 1884, followed by Wilhelm Gericke (1884–1889), Arthur Nikisch (1889–1893), and Emil Paur (1893–1898), whose tenures refined ensemble precision and interpretive depth amid expanding subscription series. Persistent acoustic limitations at Music Hall prompted Higginson to oversee construction of a dedicated venue, resulting in Symphony Hall's opening on October 15, 1900, designed by McKim, Mead & White with input from acoustician Wallace Clement Sabine for scientifically optimized sound reflection and clarity. Gericke conducted the hall's inaugural event, solidifying the orchestra's infrastructure for sustained growth. Higginson's direct oversight maintained operational stability, with the BSO performing weekly concerts that built its national stature by the early 20th century through rigorous rehearsals and importation of European talent.

Koussevitzky and Munch Eras

Serge Koussevitzky, a Russian-born conductor, assumed leadership of the Boston Symphony Orchestra in 1924 and served until 1949, during which he elevated the ensemble's international stature through advocacy for contemporary music. Under his direction, the orchestra premiered 146 new works worldwide and performed extensively by American composers, including 123 pieces by 46 such artists by 1939 alone. Koussevitzky established a commissioning program that supported living composers and founded the Berkshire Music Center (now Tanglewood Music Center) in 1940 to nurture young talent, fostering an environment for orchestral training and innovation. His recordings with the BSO, particularly of Russian symphonic works like those of Tchaikovsky, set benchmarks for interpretive depth and technical execution during the era's acoustic and early electrical recording technologies. Koussevitzky also expanded the orchestra's reach through tours, including performances in Australia, and emphasized programming that balanced core repertoire with premieres, conducting 308 concerts across the United States and abroad. Charles Munch succeeded Koussevitzky as music director in 1949, holding the position until 1962 and infusing the BSO with his expertise in French orchestral literature. Munch directed recordings for RCA Victor from 1949 onward, capturing mono sessions until 1953 and stereo thereafter, which preserved performances of works by composers like Debussy and Ravel noted for their spontaneity and tonal vitality. He advanced the orchestra's globalization with international tours, including the BSO's first visit to Japan in 1960, and continued support for new music while appointing the ensemble's first female member in 1952, marking progress in personnel diversity. Munch's approachable style and emphasis on ensemble warmth sustained audience engagement amid postwar economic adjustments.

Leinsdorf, Steinberg, and Ozawa Tenures

Erich Leinsdorf served as music director of the Boston Symphony Orchestra from 1962 to 1969, succeeding Charles Munch and emphasizing technical precision and discipline in performances. He founded the Boston Symphony Chamber Players in 1964 to promote chamber music drawn from the orchestra's repertoire, focusing on works by the great masters such as Bach, Mozart, and Beethoven. Under Leinsdorf, the orchestra produced numerous recordings for RCA Victor, including acclaimed interpretations of symphonies by Brahms and Beethoven, which enhanced its reputation for taut ensemble playing. However, his rigorous approach and heavy workload led to tensions with musicians, management, and trustees, contributing to a perception among some players of an overly demanding leadership style. William Steinberg succeeded Leinsdorf as music director from 1969 to 1972, maintaining a straightforward commitment to the classical repertoire without sensationalism. Influenced by conductors like Otto Klemperer and Arturo Toscanini, Steinberg delivered solid performances, including a notable European tour in 1971 that received acclaim for its interpretive depth. His tenure, however, was curtailed by failing health and competing commitments, such as his ongoing role with the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra, limiting his impact despite the orchestra's continued high standards. Seiji Ozawa held the position from 1973 to 2002, marking the longest tenure of any BSO music director at 29 years and surpassing Serge Koussevitzky's record. He globalized the orchestra through innovative programming, extensive recordings, and international tours, including the BSO's first visit to mainland China in 1979 following U.S.-China diplomatic normalization. Ozawa's universal style, drawing from influences like Munch and Leonard Bernstein, earned two Emmy Awards for television productions with the BSO, such as the 1976 PBS series Evening at Symphony. Yet, his leadership faced criticism from some musicians and reviewers for producing coarse, imprecise ensemble sound and vague interpretations, with reports of internal dissatisfaction contributing to perceptions of declining technical rigor by the late 1990s. Despite these challenges, Ozawa's era expanded the BSO's global profile and artistic reach.

Levine and Nelsons Eras

James Levine served as music director of the Boston Symphony Orchestra from the 2004–05 season until his resignation in March 2011. Levine, who had first guest-conducted the BSO in April 1972, was appointed to the post in October 2001 with the role effective for the 2004–05 season, succeeding Seiji Ozawa after a 29-year tenure. His leadership emphasized re-energizing the ensemble through intensified rehearsal schedules and programming that included new works by contemporary composers, building on the orchestra's established strengths in the Romantic repertoire. Levine's era saw the BSO maintain its commitment to high-fidelity performances, though his tenure was curtailed by escalating health challenges, including sciatica, tremors, and multiple surgeries following a 2006 fall that tore his rotator cuff. Levine announced his resignation on March 2, 2011, citing the need to prioritize recovery amid frequent absences that disrupted programming and leadership continuity. The BSO board accepted the decision, praising his artistic contributions while noting the practical limitations imposed by his condition, which had already led to canceled appearances, including at Tanglewood. Following his departure, the orchestra operated under interim leadership, including guest conductors, as it searched for a successor; Levine's exit marked an unfinished legacy, with some critics observing that while he elevated technical precision, chronic health issues prevented deeper institutional reforms. Andris Nelsons succeeded Levine as the BSO's fifteenth music director, beginning his tenure in the 2014–15 season after an announcement on May 16, 2013. At age 34 upon appointment, Nelsons became the youngest BSO music director in over a century, following a debut with the orchestra at Carnegie Hall in March 2011. His leadership has focused on expansive programming, including cycles of symphonies by composers like Shostakovich, alongside opera excerpts and American works, while fostering collaborations such as his concurrent role as Gewandhauskapellmeister with the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra starting in 2018. Nelsons has overseen acclaimed recordings, including the complete Shostakovich symphonies and concertos, as well as the opera Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District, released under Deutsche Grammophon, which have garnered critical praise for their intensity and orchestral transparency. Under Nelsons, the BSO has emphasized innovative seasons, such as the 2025–26 program announced on April 10, 2025, which explores American music in honor of the United States' 250th anniversary, featuring premieres and thematic concerts on faith, environment, and national evolution. His tenure, extending into 2025, includes refreshed venue experiences at Symphony Hall, with updates like enhanced lighting and photography displays, alongside performances of works by Mahler, Debussy, and Strauss that highlight the orchestra's precision and dynamic range. Nelsons' approach integrates rigorous preparation with artistic risk-taking, sustaining the BSO's reputation for interpretive depth amid dual international commitments.

Recent Developments

In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Boston Symphony Orchestra canceled 316 concerts and events by August 2020, resulting in $35 million in lost revenue. The orchestra laid off 50 full-time staff members and negotiated a new three-year labor agreement with musicians, who accepted an average 37% salary reduction in the first year to preserve operations. Labor relations saw further developments in August 2023, when the BSO reached a three-year agreement with its musicians without public disclosure of terms, following expiration of the prior contract. By June 2025, bargaining began for the first musicians' contract since a 2019 lockout, amid concerns over the orchestra's financial health post-pandemic. Under Music Director Andris Nelsons, the BSO completed its "Decoding Shostakovich" cycle in May 2025 with performances of the Violin Concerto No. 1 and Symphony No. 15 at Symphony Hall. The orchestra initiated a Beethoven symphony cycle in January 2025, dividing the nine works across programs for focused exploration. The 2024-25 season featured the debut of Composer Chair Carlos Simon on opening night September 19, 2024, alongside world-class performers and boundary-pushing works. In April 2025, the BSO announced its 2025-26 season, marking the orchestra's 145th year with five world or American premieres, including two by Simon, and Boston premieres of BSO-commissioned pieces. Personnel changes included the appointment of a new concertmaster in May 2024 and an associate concertmaster in June 2025. Five veteran string players performed their final concert in July 2025. Nelsons led semi-staged performances of Puccini's Tosca at Tanglewood in July 2025, highlighting the orchestra's summer programming ambitions.

Musical Leadership

Music Directors

The music directors of the Boston Symphony Orchestra, responsible for artistic leadership, repertoire selection, and ensemble development, have included fifteen principal figures since the orchestra's founding in 1881. These conductors, often serving multiple nonconsecutive terms in the early years, elevated the BSO from a regional ensemble to a globally acclaimed institution through innovations in programming, touring, and recording.
Music DirectorTenureKey Contributions
Sir George Henschel1881–1884Selected by founder Henry Lee Higginson after a guest appearance; established professional standards as the inaugural conductor, while also composing and educating.
Wilhelm Gericke1884–1889, 1898–1906Longest pre-Koussevitzky tenure; initiated regular New York performances, Promenade Concerts in 1885, and relocation to Symphony Hall in 1900.
Arthur Nikisch1889–1893Emphasized Wagnerian influences; noted for charismatic style praised by Tchaikovsky for its enchantment.
Emil Paur1893–1898Prioritized Brahms's contemporary works, which proved demanding for audiences.
Karl Muck1906–1908, 1912–1918Conducted the orchestra's first transcontinental U.S. tour in 1915 and early recordings in 1917; commended by Higginson for rigorous preparation.
Max Fiedler1908–1912Served as interim between Muck terms; focused on transitional stability.
Henri Rabaud1918–1919Appointed urgently post-Muck; brief tenure amid wartime disruptions.
Pierre Monteux1919–1924Navigated a 1920 musicians' strike to sustain operations; emphasized precision.
Serge Koussevitzky1924–1949Unionized the orchestra; transformed it into a world-class entity and established the Tanglewood Music Center.
Charles Munch1949–1962Directed inaugural European tours (1952, 1956) and an Australia/Far East tour (1960); valued for improvisational energy.
Erich Leinsdorf1962–1969Heightened technical discipline; founded the Boston Symphony Chamber Players.
William Steinberg1969–1972Health-limited term; upheld fidelity to core classical works.
Seiji Ozawa1973–2002Longest tenure; broadened international profile via tours and contemporary integrations; designated Music Director Laureate in 2002.
James Levine2004–2011First American-born appointee; earned a Grammy for Ravel's Daphnis et Chloé (2010) and led a 2007 European tour.
Andris Nelsons2014–presentDebuted with BSO in 2011; initiated recording series in 2014 as Ray and Maria Stata Music Director.
Interim periods, such as between Ozawa's departure and Levine's arrival (2002–2004, with Bernard Haitink as principal guest conductor), highlight the orchestra's continuity amid transitions. The role demands balancing tradition with innovation, as evidenced by Koussevitzky's foundational expansions and Ozawa's global outreach, which collectively amassed over a century of documented performances and recordings.

Principal Conductors and Composer Chairs

The Boston Symphony Orchestra has appointed principal guest conductors to assist the music director with programming and performances. Michael Tilson Thomas served in this role from 1972 to 1974, following his earlier positions as assistant and associate conductor under William Steinberg. Sir Colin Davis held the principal guest conductor title concurrently from 1972 to 1984, conducting numerous subscription series and recordings with the ensemble. Bernard Haitink was appointed principal guest conductor in 1995, a position he maintained until 2004, during which he led over 100 performances and earned acclaim for his interpretations of Mahler and Bruckner. No principal guest conductor has been named since Haitink's tenure, though the orchestra frequently engages distinguished guest conductors such as Karina Canellakis and David Afkham for regular appearances. Assistant conductors, including Anna Handler (appointed 2024) and Samy Rachid (appointed 2023), support operations and youth initiatives but do not hold principal titles. In January 2024, the BSO established the Deborah and Philip Edmundson Composer Chair, an endowed three-season position to foster new works and collaboration. Carlos Simon was named the inaugural holder for 2024–2027, with responsibilities including composing commissioned pieces, advising on programming, and leading educational outreach. This role builds on prior composer-in-residence efforts, such as the 2018–2020 project featuring Julius P. Williams, but represents a permanent endowed commitment to contemporary composition.

Organizational Structure

Venues and Facilities

The Boston Symphony Orchestra's principal concert venue is Symphony Hall, located at 301 Massachusetts Avenue in Boston, Massachusetts. Completed in September 1900 at a cost of $771,000, the hall was designed by the architectural firm McKim, Mead & White as a permanent home for the orchestra following the demolition threat to its prior venue, the Old Boston Music Hall. The structure accommodates 2,625 seats and is celebrated for its superior acoustics, achieved through empirical design principles including wall curvature and ceiling coffers tested via scale models and organ simulations. Designated a U.S. National Historic Landmark in 1999, Symphony Hall hosts BSO performances from September through May, typically on Tuesday and Thursday evenings, Saturday evenings, and Friday afternoons. The orchestra's summer venue is Tanglewood, a 210-acre estate in Lenox and Stockbridge, Massachusetts, acquired in 1937 after donation by Mrs. Gorham Brooks and Mary Aspinwall Tappan in 1936. Primary facilities include the open-air Koussevitzky Music Shed for large-scale BSO concerts, the 1,200-seat Seiji Ozawa Hall inaugurated in 1994 for chamber and Tanglewood Music Center performances, and the Linde Center for Music and Learning, opened in 2019 as the first year-round facility with rehearsal spaces, a performance hall, and educational amenities. Tanglewood also encompasses the Tanglewood Music Center, founded in 1940 by music director Serge Koussevitzky, providing training facilities for advanced musicians including dormitories, practice rooms, and studios. The site's outdoor grounds support picnics and informal events, with concerts emphasizing a blend of formal programming and accessible public engagement during the July-to-August season. Additional facilities support operations and rentals, including Symphony Hall's adjacent spaces for events and Tanglewood's grounds for private functions amid manicured lawns and views of Stockbridge Bowl. Renovations have addressed wear, such as Symphony Hall's stage replacement in 2006 to preserve structural integrity without altering acoustics. These venues enable the BSO's dual-city model, balancing urban precision with rural immersion. The Boston Pops Orchestra, founded in 1885 as a subsidiary ensemble of the Boston Symphony Orchestra, draws primarily from BSO musicians to perform lighter classical, popular, and American songbook repertoire, with annual seasons at Symphony Hall including the Holiday Pops and Spring Pops series. Under conductor Keith Lockhart since 1995, it has maintained traditions like the Fourth of July Pops concert with fireworks, emphasizing accessible programming distinct from the BSO's core symphonic focus. The Tanglewood Festival Chorus, established in 1970, functions as the BSO's resident volunteer choral ensemble, consisting of approximately 200 auditioned singers who perform with the orchestra in Symphony Hall, at Tanglewood, and on recordings, specializing in large-scale works like Mahler's symphonies and Verdi's requiems. At the Tanglewood Music Center, the BSO's summer academy founded in 1940, advanced fellows participate in intensive programs including the Tanglewood Music Center Orchestra, which performs under BSO Music Director Andris Nelsons and guest conductors, alongside chamber music and mentorship by BSO members to foster professional development. This initiative, held annually at the BSO's Tanglewood campus in Lenox and Stockbridge, Massachusetts, admits around 150-170 fellows selected via competitive auditions, emphasizing orchestral training, conducting studies, and composition. Educational outreach includes Days in the Arts (DARTS), launched in 1968 as a two-week summer immersion at Tanglewood for about 200 high school students from diverse backgrounds, integrating music, dance, theater, and visual arts with BSO faculty involvement to promote artistic exposure. Additionally, BSO Youth Concerts, offered during the regular season at Symphony Hall, target school groups with tailored programs featuring BSO musicians to introduce live orchestral performance and build audience appreciation among youth. Community efforts extend to free or low-cost chamber concerts in neighborhood venues, drawing from BSO repertoire to engage local audiences.

Artistic Profile

Repertoire and Programming

The Boston Symphony Orchestra's core repertoire centers on the symphonic canon of the Classical, Romantic, and early 20th-century periods, encompassing symphonies, concertos, and orchestral works by composers such as Joseph Haydn, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Ludwig van Beethoven, Johannes Brahms, Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky, Gustav Mahler, Jean Sibelius, and Richard Strauss. This foundation reflects the orchestra's establishment in 1881 with programs drawn from established European masters, as performed in its inaugural concert under Georg Henschel. Programming has evolved to incorporate national emphases tied to music directors' backgrounds; for example, during Serge Koussevitzky's tenure from 1924 to 1949, the BSO delivered over 830 performances of French repertoire, including pieces by César Franck, Hector Berlioz, Claude Debussy, and Maurice Ravel. Koussevitzky also championed Soviet-era composers, conducting 96 performances of Dmitri Shostakovich's works with the BSO and Tanglewood Music Center Orchestra. Subsequent directors further diversified emphases while preserving the standard repertoire. Charles Munch (1949–1962) sustained French influences through interpretations of Debussy and Ravel, alongside international tours that showcased the orchestra's versatility in core symphonic literature. Under Seiji Ozawa (1973–2002), programming expanded to include broader modern works, with tours such as the 1979 visit to China highlighting cross-cultural exchanges in established orchestral scores. The BSO has consistently balanced masterworks with contemporary commissions, premiering new pieces at Symphony Hall and Tanglewood since the festival's inception in 1937 under Koussevitzky. In recent seasons under Music Director Andris Nelsons (since 2014), programming adopts thematic structures to connect historical and modern works, such as explorations of faith, environment, and American music evolution in the 2025–26 season. This includes Nelsons leading 14 subscription programs, featuring five world or American premieres, two commissioned from Composer Chair Carlos Simon. The orchestra's dedication to new music aligns with its founding principle of broadening access to orchestral art, evidenced by ongoing commissions and Tanglewood premieres that integrate emerging composers into the symphonic tradition. Tanglewood programming extends this with festival-style events, blending classics like Mozart's symphonies with contemporary debuts.

Recordings and Discography

The Boston Symphony Orchestra initiated commercial recordings in 1917, initially focusing on shorter works and later expanding to full symphonies under music directors like Pierre Monteux and Serge Koussevitzky. Koussevitzky's tenure from 1924 to 1949 marked a prolific period with RCA Victor, yielding over 200 sessions that captured the orchestra's evolving sound in repertoire such as Beethoven's symphonies, Sibelius's complete cycle, and premieres of contemporary American works by composers like Walter Piston. These efforts, often recorded acoustically then electrically, solidified the BSO's international profile through vivid interpretations praised for technical precision and interpretive depth. Postwar directors Charles Munch (1949–1962) and Erich Leinsdorf (1962–1969) continued the tradition on RCA, emphasizing French repertoire under Munch—such as Ravel and Debussy suites—and Germanic standards under Leinsdorf, including Brahms and Bruckner cycles, with the orchestra's string section noted for its luminous tone. Seiji Ozawa's 29-year directorship (1973–2002) produced an extensive catalog primarily for Philips and Deutsche Grammophon, encompassing Mahler's symphonies, Stravinsky ballets, and a Grammy-winning recording of Ravel's Daphnis et Chloé (2010, originally taped in 1970), which earned the award for Best Orchestral Performance in 2010 for its atmospheric chorus-orchestra blend. James Levine's briefer era (2004–2011) yielded fewer releases, mainly on DG, featuring operatic excerpts and Beethoven concertos with soloists like Anne-Sophie Mutter. Under Andris Nelsons (since 2014), the BSO revived its recording profile via an exclusive Deutsche Grammophon partnership, launching with Wagner's Tannhäuser Overture and Sibelius's Symphony No. 2 in 2015. The centerpiece is the decade-long Shostakovich project (2015–2025), documenting all 15 symphonies, violin and cello concertos, piano concertos, and Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District across 19 CDs, with live Symphony Hall tapings featuring soloists including Yo-Yo Ma and Yuja Wang. Symphonies Nos. 4 and 11 (2018) secured two Grammys in 2019 for Best Orchestral Performance and Best Engineered Album, Classical, while other installments earned nominations, highlighting Nelsons' emphasis on raw intensity and archival completeness. Additional releases include Messiaen's Turangalîla-Symphonie (2023) and Ravel piano concertos, underscoring a shift toward multifaceted programming.

Financial and Operational Realities

Endowment and Revenue Sources

The Boston Symphony Orchestra, as a nonprofit institution, relies on a robust endowment to underwrite a portion of its operating budget and ensure long-term financial stability. Established through the personal philanthropy of founder Henry Lee Higginson, who covered annual deficits exceeding $1 million from 1881 to 1918, the endowment has grown substantially over time via targeted campaigns, donor gifts, and investment performance. By 2020, it reached $456 million, the largest among U.S. orchestras at that point, and expanded to over $540 million by 2021 under former CEO Mark Volpe's leadership, which tripled its value through strategic fundraising. As of the fiscal year ending August 2024, the orchestra's net assets—predominantly comprising the endowment—totaled $618 million, supporting annual distributions for artistic programming, facilities maintenance, and educational initiatives. Revenue generation diversifies across earned income, philanthropic support, and endowment yields, reflecting the structural economics of major symphony orchestras where ticket sales alone cannot cover full costs. In fiscal year 2024, total revenue amounted to $117 million, with program service revenue—primarily from subscription series, single-ticket sales at Symphony Hall, and summer performances at Tanglewood—contributing $47 million, or approximately 40%. Contributions and grants from individuals, corporations, and foundations provided $37 million, or 32%, underscoring the critical role of donor campaigns like the Tanglewood Forever initiative, which targeted endowment augmentation. Investment income from endowment assets added $5.4 million, or 5%, while ancillary sources such as recordings, licensing, and occasional tours supplemented the remainder. This funding model aligns with industry norms for elite ensembles, where contributed revenue and endowment spending bridge the gap between box office earnings (typically 30-40% of budget) and expenses exceeding $120 million annually, as evidenced by the BSO's $124 million in fiscal 2024 outlays. Government grants, including from the National Endowment for the Arts, remain marginal, comprising under 1% in recent years. Sustained growth in the endowment has buffered against economic volatility, such as post-2008 market losses, enabling resilience amid fluctuating attendance and inflation pressures.

Challenges and Reforms

The Boston Symphony Orchestra has encountered persistent financial challenges, including multi-year operating deficits exacerbated by rising costs and fluctuating earned income. For instance, prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, the orchestra reported deficits over several seasons, with orchestra-performance revenues covering only a portion of expenses in fiscal year 2012-13. The pandemic intensified these pressures, resulting in a 50% revenue loss and necessitating federal aid, including a $10 million Shuttered Venues Operators Grant to support recovery. Labor relations presented additional hurdles, particularly amid economic uncertainty. In September 2020, musicians ratified a contract with a 37% first-year compensation reduction to preserve jobs during shutdowns, effective through August 2023. Gender pay disparities also surfaced, as evidenced by a 2018 lawsuit from principal flutist Elizabeth Rowe alleging unequal compensation, which settled in 2019 for an undisclosed amount after she sought over $200,000 in back wages. Post-pandemic recovery involved tense negotiations without strikes, unlike peer ensembles, but highlighted structural tensions over work rules and scheduling flexibility. Reforms have focused on stabilizing operations and adapting to contemporary demands. The August 2023 three-year labor agreement, ratified by musicians, restored annual wage growth, provided a retroactive "catch-up" increase following pandemic-era cuts, and introduced greater management flexibility in concert scheduling across Boston and Tanglewood venues. Leadership transitions aimed at innovation included the December 2022 resignation of President and CEO Gail Samuel, succeeded interim by Jeffrey Dunn and then permanently by Chad Smith in May 2023, who has prioritized technological integration and educational outreach to broaden appeal. Artistic adjustments, such as extending Music Director Andris Nelsons to an evergreen contract with expanded Tanglewood responsibilities and appointing Carlos Simon to a new composer chair in January 2024, signal efforts to refresh programming and institutional resilience. A 2024 rebranding initiative further sought to enhance audience accessibility and engagement amid declining traditional attendance trends.

Controversies and Criticisms

Artistic Decline and Performance Quality

During Seiji Ozawa's tenure as music director from 1973 to 2002, several critics observed a decline in the Boston Symphony Orchestra's performance standards, characterized by coarse and unmotivated playing. Music critic Greg Sandow described a Carnegie Hall performance under Ozawa as featuring "coarse, unmotivated playing from such a celebrated group," with the ensemble lacking polish, producing ugly sounds, and exhibiting shapeless phrasing in works like Dvořák's Symphony No. 7. BSO concertmaster Malcolm Lowe and cellist Jules Eskin echoed this in a 1998 Counterpoint article, noting Ozawa's failure to provide "specific leadership in matters of tempo and rhythm," insufficient "expression of care about sound quality," and absence of a "distinctly-conveyed conception of the character of each piece." This period's stagnation was attributed to Ozawa's prolonged leadership, which a prominent conductor anonymously described as weakening the orchestra's ability to achieve "crack unanimity," leading to its reputation as "perhaps the worst" among major American orchestras by the late 1990s. A New York Magazine review of Ozawa's final seasons highlighted the "bland" and "faceless" character of his music-making, contrasting it sharply with the vibrant legacies of predecessors like Serge Koussevitzky and Charles Munch, and deeming a leadership change "long overdue." The orchestra's limbo during Ozawa's health-related decline in the late 1990s exacerbated these issues, with performances of Mahler and Bach lacking depth and conviction. These critiques were not universal, as Ozawa's era included acclaimed recordings and international tours, but empirical observations from live concerts underscored a erosion in ensemble precision and interpretive vigor. Under current music director Andris Nelsons, who assumed the role in 2014, concerns about performance quality have resurfaced, with reports of inconsistency and disengagement in certain concerts. A February 2024 Carnegie Hall performance of Shostakovich's Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District drew sharp criticism for the violin section's "eclectic" and "disengaged" demeanor, with players appearing to chat and move bows minimally, resulting in sluggish responses and a lack of passion despite Nelsons' cues. Observer Joseph Horowitz noted the orchestra projected "just enough sound to avoid being called out," evincing "contempt for the audience" through joyless execution, unfavorably compared to more vibrant interpretations by regional ensembles like the South Dakota Symphony. The New York Times characterized Nelsons as a "fitful, inconsistent" director in a July 2025 review, praising isolated strengths like his handling of Puccini's Tosca but implying broader variability in orchestral cohesion. A 2019 analysis described the BSO under Nelsons as "content simply to abide," supporting new music without championing it and performing the canon without fresh advocacy, suggesting a lack of distinctive identity. These observations align with earlier guest-conductor comparisons, where the orchestra exhibited higher quality under substitutes than its primary leadership, pointing to potential rehearsal or motivational deficits rather than inherent technical limitations. While Nelsons has earned acclaim for recordings and select live interpretations, such as Shostakovich cycles, persistent critiques of slack energy and uneven commitment indicate ongoing challenges in sustaining peak artistic standards.

Labor Disputes and Pay Inequities

In March 1920, approximately 30 to 35 members of the Boston Symphony Orchestra, including concertmaster Frederick Fradkin, went on strike for two weeks, protesting Fradkin's dismissal by the board of trustees and broader issues of pay and working conditions. The trustees had fired Fradkin after he joined the Boston Musicians Protective Association, a local union affiliate, amid tensions over unionization; management withheld pay from strikers pending disciplinary action and ultimately replaced the holdouts, resulting in the loss of over 30 players. This episode marked a significant early labor conflict for the orchestra, which had operated as a non-union ensemble since its founding, reflecting management's resistance to collective bargaining in an era when musician salaries were competitive but union demands for formal protections were rising. The BSO maintained its non-union status for over two decades following the 1920 strike, enduring what was described as one of the longest labor struggles in U.S. orchestral history until an agreement with the American Federation of Musicians was reached in November 1942 under music director Serge Koussevitzky. This pact ended a deadlock over union recognition and working terms, allowing the orchestra—then the last major U.S. ensemble without union affiliation—to formalize relations amid wartime labor pressures and federal regulations. Subsequent decades saw relatively stable negotiations, with musicians ratifying multi-year contracts periodically, though specifics on salary increases have often remained undisclosed, as in the three-year agreement approved in August 2023 covering 92 full-time players. Prior to this, the 2020 base salary stood at $120,000, with the 2023 deal implying adjustments but providing no public figures on raises or benefits. Pay inequities gained prominence in July 2018 when principal flutist Elizabeth Rowe filed a lawsuit against the BSO under Massachusetts' equal pay act, alleging she earned approximately $70,000 less annually—around $185,000 compared to $255,000 for principal oboist William Hudgins—despite comparable tenure, qualifications, and responsibilities since joining in 2004. Rowe's complaint highlighted broader disparities, claiming female principals received systematically lower compensation than male counterparts in similar woodwind roles, potentially violating state law prohibiting pay differences based on gender for comparable work. The suit sought over $200,000 in back pay plus damages but settled confidentially in February 2019 without the orchestra admitting liability; principal salaries in major orchestras are often individually negotiated, which can lead to variances attributable to market factors like recruitment costs rather than discrimination, though Rowe attributed the gap to gender bias. No subsequent public lawsuits or strikes have emerged, but the case underscored ongoing scrutiny of compensation transparency in the industry, where blind auditions have increased female representation yet principal pay gaps persist.

Administrative and Ethical Issues

In December 2022, Gail Samuel resigned as president and CEO of the Boston Symphony Orchestra after serving 18 months in the role, which she assumed in June 2021 as the institution's first female leader. Her departure occurred amid ongoing post-pandemic financial recovery efforts, though no specific cause was publicly detailed beyond transitional assistance until January 3, 2023. This followed a period of administrative restructuring, including the appointment of an interim leader, highlighting turnover in executive governance during economic pressures. Administratively, the orchestra faced significant workforce reductions in August 2020, laying off 50 full-time staff members—approximately 28% of its 180 administrative employees—due to projected $35 million in lost revenue from canceled performances amid the COVID-19 pandemic. These measures were part of broader cost-cutting strategies, including furloughs and hiring freezes, to preserve operations without drawing further from endowment reserves strained by venue closures. On ethical fronts, a 2018 lawsuit by principal flutist Elizabeth Rowe alleged gender-based pay discrimination, claiming her annual compensation was about $70,000 less than that of principal oboist John Ferrillo, despite comparable responsibilities and tenure since 2004. The suit, seeking over $200,000 in back wages, spotlighted broader disparities, with data indicating female principals earned roughly 75% of male counterparts in similar roles, prompting scrutiny of opaque salary negotiations in orchestral contracts. The matter settled in February 2019 without admission of liability, amid Massachusetts' equal pay law requiring audits, though terms remained confidential. The orchestra also addressed allegations of sexual misconduct involving guest conductor Charles Dutoit, a frequent collaborator at Symphony Hall and Tanglewood. In December 2017, following public accusations by four women of assaults spanning 1985–2010, the BSO terminated its decades-long relationship with him. An independent investigation in early 2018 deemed claims by two former Tanglewood interns credible and uncovered additional reports from four other women associated with the BSO, leading to the revocation of an honorary title previously bestowed on Dutoit. This response aligned with heightened institutional accountability post-#MeToo, though critics noted the incidents predated modern protocols and involved non-musician staff.

Legacy and Cultural Impact

Achievements and Innovations

The Boston Symphony Orchestra advanced concert hall acoustics through the design of Symphony Hall, which opened on October 15, 1900, as the first venue scientifically engineered for optimal sound quality. Physicist Wallace Clement Sabine calculated absorption coefficients and targeted a reverberation time of 2.0 seconds when occupied, establishing principles that influenced global architectural practices for orchestral spaces. In recording technology, the BSO produced its initial acoustic recordings in 1917 with the Victor Talking Machine Company, contributing to the early documentation of symphonic performances. Under conductor Charles Munch, the orchestra pioneered stereo recordings starting in February 1954 with RCA Victor, enhancing fidelity for listeners. The BSO achieved a diplomatic milestone as the first American orchestra to tour the Soviet Union in 1956, fostering cultural exchange during the Cold War era. Under Georg Henschel and subsequent leaders like Wilhelm Gericke, innovations included initiating regular performances in New York and other cities, expanding the orchestra's national reach. Educationally, the Tanglewood Music Center, founded in 1940 by music director Serge Koussevitzky, introduced a pioneering fellowship program offering intensive training to emerging musicians through masterclasses, chamber music, and orchestral rehearsals with BSO members. This model has trained generations of performers, emphasizing practical immersion over traditional conservatory methods. Recent accolades include multiple Grammy Awards for orchestral performances under Andris Nelsons, such as Best Orchestral Performance in 2017 for Shostakovich Symphonies Nos. 5, 8, and 9, and in 2019 for Symphonies Nos. 4 and 11, which also won Best Engineered Album, Classical. The orchestra's decade-long Shostakovich symphony cycle concluded in 2025 with a 19-CD box set, earning further recognition for interpretive depth and recording excellence.

Influence on American Orchestral Tradition

The founding of the Boston Symphony Orchestra in 1881 by Henry Lee Higginson established a model for permanent, professionally staffed orchestras in the United States, relying on private philanthropy rather than ad hoc assemblies, which influenced the development of similar institutions in cities like New York and Chicago. Higginson's emphasis on European-trained conductors and a core repertoire of Germanic symphonic works from the outset elevated performance expectations, demonstrating that sustained high-quality orchestral music could attract large audiences and sustain cultural prestige without public subsidy. This approach, combined with the opening of Symphony Hall in 1900—renowned for its acoustics designed by Wallace Clement Sabine—provided a benchmark for venue quality and ensemble precision that other American orchestras emulated in their facilities and playing standards. Under Serge Koussevitzky's directorship from 1924 to 1949, the BSO significantly shaped American orchestral repertoire by premiering over 60 works by U.S. composers, including Aaron Copland's Symphony No. 3 in 1946 and commissions from Walter Piston and others, thereby integrating contemporary American music into the symphonic canon and encouraging its adoption elsewhere. Koussevitzky's mentorship of emerging talents like Leonard Bernstein, who assisted him at the BSO and later directed major U.S. ensembles, extended the orchestra's influence to the training of American conductors, fostering a generation that prioritized interpretive depth and innovation over rote tradition. His advocacy, described as unsurpassed among prominent conductors of the era, helped normalize the inclusion of living composers' works in orchestral programs, countering the dominance of 19th-century European staples. The establishment of the Tanglewood Music Center in 1940 under Koussevitzky's leadership further entrenched the BSO's role in American orchestral tradition by serving as a premier training ground for instrumentalists, with alumni comprising approximately 20% of members in U.S. symphony orchestras and 30% of principal players. This intensive program emphasized ensemble discipline, contemporary techniques, and exposure to professional rehearsals, directly populating peer ensembles with musicians versed in the BSO's rigorous standards and broadening the talent pool for American symphonic music. Through these mechanisms, the BSO not only disseminated elevated technical and artistic norms but also cultivated a self-sustaining ecosystem for orchestral excellence across the country.

References

  1. https://www.bso.org/about/history
  2. https://www.bso.org/about/history/bso-music-directors
  3. https://www.bso.org/symphony-hall/about/history
  4. https://www.bso.org/tanglewood/about/history
  5. https://www.bso.org/profiles/andris-nelsons
  6. https://www.bso.org/exhibits/serge-koussevitzky-champion-of-american-music
  7. https://www.bso.org/about
  8. https://www.bso.org/about/musicians/bso-musicians
  9. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1920/03/a-great-private-citizen-henry-lee-higginson/646213/
  10. https://www.bostonmagazine.com/news/2013/10/24/throwback-thursday-boston-symphony-orchestras-first-concert/
  11. https://www.wbur.org/news/2013/05/17/bso-music-directors-timeline
  12. https://symphony.org/exploring-conductor-serge-koussevitzkys-impact-at-the-boston-symphony-and-elsewhere/
  13. https://www.bso.org/exhibits/koussevitzky-as-champion-of-american-composers
  14. https://blogs.loc.gov/music/2024/08/a-maestro-for-the-ages-serge-koussevitzky-at-150/
  15. https://www.bso.org/tanglewood/about/history/tanglewood-online-exhibits/koussevitzky150/koussevitzky-150-recordings
  16. https://www.facebook.com/groups/1418016324890470/posts/2789588594399896/
  17. https://www.facebook.com/groups/7719320188080233/posts/25022143230704660/
  18. https://www.bso.org/exhibits/a-timeline-of-seiji-ozawa-and-the-bso
  19. https://www.mmone.org/the-boston-symphony-orchestra/
  20. https://academic.oup.com/book/25636/chapter/193047426
  21. https://www.bach-cantatas.com/Bio/Leinsdorf-Erich.htm
  22. https://www.nytimes.com/1969/03/24/archives/leinsdorf-plays-last-concert-as-boston-leader.html
  23. https://www.stage-plus.com/search/conductors/artist_85P78QBJEHFJ8C9M68
  24. https://www.britannica.com/biography/William-Steinberg
  25. https://www.bso.org/press/in-memoriam-seiji-ozawa
  26. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/arts/japanese-conductor-seiji-ozawa-who-amazed-audiences-at-boston-symphony-orchestra-dies-at-age-88
  27. https://www.gregsandow.com/old/ozawa.htm
  28. https://www.classicalwcrb.org/2024-02-09/seiji-ozawa-longtime-conductor-of-the-boston-symphony-orchestra-has-died-at-88
  29. https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2021/03/17/834194609/james-levine-former-met-opera-music-director-is-dead-at-age-77
  30. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/04/arts/music/04levine.html
  31. https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2011/03/04/134236139/james-levine-leaves-the-boston-symphony-orchestra
  32. https://artsbeat.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/02/james-levine-to-resign-as-music-director-of-boston-symphony-orchestra/
  33. https://www.wsj.com/articles/BL-METROB-12758?gaa_at=eafs&gaa_n=AWEtsqe1zBcRxe_saQ1x6LxBXUHbiFA3iE170bi7u4Yh7he4iDM709p0iHgF&gaa_ts=68fe6e8d&gaa_sig=1GyHhECEKG5lVQrRu4MJlDocQPagWPJlqKvLQ9b_KmiV17C6TaNIosPuFn4O9amF_Q29563_1_bqDce4h2JxMw%253D%253D
  34. https://www.cbc.ca/news/entertainment/poor-health-forces-levine-from-boston-symphony-post-1.1017508
  35. https://www.wgbh.org/2013-05-16/boston-symphony-orchestra-names-andris-nelsons-director
  36. https://andrisnelsons.com/bio/
  37. https://www.bso.org/press/boston-symphony-orchestra-and-music-director-andris-nelsons-announce-2025-26-season
  38. https://bostonclassicalreview.com/2025/09/nelsons-bso-open-season-in-a-freshened-symphony-hall-with-lively-mozart-swaggering-strauss/
  39. https://www.deutschegrammophon.com/en/artists/andris-nelsons/news/biography-242895
  40. https://symphony.org/boston-symphony-to-lay-off-50-staff-members-due-to-financial-impact-of-pandemic/
  41. https://www.wbur.org/news/2020/09/11/bso-labor-agreement-musicans-salary-cuts
  42. https://bostonclassicalreview.com/2020/04/facing-10-million-in-lost-revenue-bso-musicians-staff-take-pay-cuts/
  43. https://slippedisc.com/2023/08/boston-secretively-settles-its-musicians/
  44. https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/1l402yg/bso_begins_bargaining_first_musicians_contract/
  45. https://seenandheard-international.com/2025/05/boston-symphonys-decoding-shostakovich-cycle-concludes/
  46. https://bostonclassicalreview.com/2025/01/nelsons-boston-symphony-open-beethoven-cycle-in-top-form/
  47. https://www.bso.org/press/2024-2025-bso-season
  48. https://bostonclassicalreview.com/category/news/
  49. https://www.thestrad.com/boston-symphony-orchestra/5528.tag
  50. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/07/21/arts/music/andris-nelsons-boston-symphony-tanglewood.html
  51. https://www.bso.org/profiles/michael-tilson-thomas
  52. https://www.npr.org/sections/deceptivecadence/2013/04/14/177257680/remembering-colin-davis-a-conductor-beloved-late-in-life
  53. https://www.bso.org/profiles/bernard-haitink
  54. https://www.bso.org/profiles/karina-canellakis
  55. https://www.bso.org/profiles/david-afkham-2
  56. https://www.bso.org/press/bso-appoints-anna-handler-as-new-assistant-conductor-to-start-in-2024-25-season
  57. https://www.bso.org/press/bso-announces-andris-nelsons-contract-extension-carlos-simon-as-composer-chair-and-establishment-of-humanities-institute
  58. https://www.bso.org/profiles/carlos-simon
  59. https://www.bso.org/exhibits/the-building-of-symphony-hall
  60. https://www.annumarchitects.com/projects/boston-symphony-orchestra-symphony-hall/
  61. https://npgallery.nps.gov/NRHP/GetAsset/NHLS/99000633_text
  62. https://www.meetboston.com/listing/boston-symphony-orchestra-boston-pops-symphony-hall/11639/
  63. https://lenoxhistory.org/the-modern-era/tanglewood-music-center-history/
  64. https://www.bso.org/venues/tanglewood-venues
  65. https://btwberkshires.com/venue/tanglewood/
  66. https://www.bso.org/tmc/about
  67. https://www.bso.org/tanglewood/visit
  68. https://www.bso.org/symphony-hall/venue-rentals
  69. https://www.bso.org/tanglewood/book-an-event
  70. https://www.npr.org/2006/09/28/6161878/replacing-a-symphony-stage-carefully
  71. https://www.bso.org/pops
  72. https://www.bso.org/tfc
  73. https://www.bso.org/tmc
  74. https://www.bso.org/tmc/instrumental
  75. https://www.bso.org/tanglewood/days-in-the-arts
  76. https://www.bso.org/learn/students-educators/youth-concerts
  77. https://www.bso.org/press/boston-symphony-orchestra-announces-2025-26-community-chamber-concerts
  78. https://www.bso.org/stories/koussevitzky-and-french-composers
  79. https://www.bso.org/stories/koussevitzky-and-soviet-era-composers
  80. https://www.bso.org/bso-2025-2026-season
  81. https://www.bso.org/tli/about
  82. https://www.bso.org/seasons/2023-24-bso-season-performances
  83. https://classical.music.apple.com/us/artist/3513503
  84. https://www.naxos.com/Bio/Person/Boston_Symphony_Orchestra/46461
  85. https://www.amazon.com/Ravel-Daphnis-Chlo%25C3%25A9-Maurice/dp/B001VPJZP4
  86. https://newyorkarts.net/2015/01/wagner-tannhauser-overture-sibelius-symphony-no-2-bsos-first-recording-andris-nelsons/
  87. https://www.bso.org/press/andris-nelsons-and-the-bso-conclude-their-award-winning-decade-long-shostakovich-project-with-release-of-19-cd-box-set
  88. https://www.wbur.org/news/2019/02/10/boston-symphony-orchestra-grammy-shostakovich-recordings
  89. https://www.bso.org/cds-and-digital-media
  90. https://www.bso.org/2022-2023-annual-report/donors-2023
  91. https://www.bostonmagazine.com/news/2020/02/05/bso-mark-volpe-retirement/
  92. https://www.wbur.org/news/2021/06/17/outgoing-bso-ceo-mark-volpe-retires
  93. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/42103550
  94. https://tanglewoodforever.org/bso-announces-public-phase-of-64-million-tanglewood-forever-campaign/
  95. https://americanorchestras.org/fy24-nea-grants-to-orchestras/
  96. https://artsfuse.org/64169/fuse-commentary-just-how-perilous-is-the-life-of-the-boston-symphony-orchestra/
  97. https://therestisnoise.com/boston_not_so_r/
  98. https://classicalmusicguide.com/viewtopic.php?t=44711
  99. https://blog.workday.com/en-us/how-nonprofits-build-sustainable-financial-future-propel-missions.html
  100. https://www.bso.org/2020-2021-annual-report/bso-receives-10-million-covid-relief-grant
  101. https://www.facebook.com/hkaaa/posts/international-arts-news-boston-symphony-orchestra-musicians-agree-pay-cut-intern/3642787785765907/
  102. https://www.fisherphillips.com/en/news-insights/pay-equity-matters-mind-the-gap/boston-symphony-orchestra-flutist-settles-equal-pay-lawsuit.html
  103. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/21/arts/music/orchestra-labor-coronavirus.html
  104. https://www.bso.org/press/boston-symphony-orchestra-approves-new-three-year-labor-agreement
  105. https://www.berkshireeagle.com/arts_and_culture/berkshirelandscapes/boston-symphony-management-and-players-reach-three-year-labor-accord/article_260f5b0c-323c-11ee-bd12-43717bf66bf8.html
  106. https://theberkshireedge.com/sudden-change-in-leadership-at-the-boston-symphony-orchestra/
  107. https://www.classicalwcrb.org/blog/2023-05-15/new-leadership-for-the-boston-symphony-orchestra
  108. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/21/arts/music/mark-volpe-boston-symphony.html
  109. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/25/arts/music/boston-symphony-andris-nelsons-carlos-simon.html
  110. https://www.printmag.com/branding-identity-design/colossal-refresh-for-the-boston-symphony-orchestra/
  111. https://slate.com/culture/2011/04/the-elusive-maestro-why-the-process-of-finding-a-new-conductor-makes-music-lovers-weep.html
  112. https://nymag.com/nymetro/arts/music/classical/reviews/n_9445/
  113. https://www.artsjournal.com/uq/2024/02/the-boston-symphony-in-trouble.html
  114. https://classicalmusicguide.com/viewtopic.php?t=50523
  115. https://gregsandow.com/old/ozlet.htm
  116. https://whenandwhereinboston.org/entry/boston-symphony-orchestra-musicians-go-on-strike
  117. https://www.nytimes.com/1920/03/06/archives/dismiss-concert-master-boston-symphony-trustees-drop-fradkin-for.html
  118. https://www.nytimes.com/1920/03/12/archives/boston-orchestra-to-replace-strikers-symphony-management-gives-men.html
  119. https://www.classical-scene.com/2020/04/24/earlier-strokes/
  120. https://time.com/archive/6771597/music-boston-joins-the-union/
  121. http://www.nytimes.com/1942/11/29/archives/orchestra-in-union-effects-of-agreement-between-boston-symphony-and.html
  122. https://internationalmusician.org/boston-symphony-orchestra-ratifies-new-labor-agreement/
  123. https://theviolinchannel.com/boston-symphony-orchestra-approves-new-labor-agreement/
  124. https://www.npr.org/2018/07/05/626125374/seeking-pay-equity-female-flutist-sues-boston-symphony-orchestra
  125. https://www.npr.org/2018/12/11/675505122/lawsuit-against-boston-symphony-orchestra-exposes-extensive-gender-pay-gap
  126. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/21/arts/music/boston-symphony-elizabeth-rowe-settlement.html
  127. https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2018/12/boston-symphony-orchestra-gender-discrimination-lawsuit.html
  128. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/16/arts/music/gail-samuel-boston-symphony-orchestra.html
  129. https://www.bso.org/press/gail-samuel-resigns-as-bso-president-and-ceo
  130. https://www.classical-scene.com/2022/12/16/changing-of-a-guardian-at-the-bso/
  131. https://theviolinchannel.com/boston-symphony-orchestra-lays-off-50-administrative-staff-members-covid-19/
  132. https://www.boston.com/culture/music/2020/08/24/boston-symphony-orchestra-lays-off-50-full-time-administrative-staffers/
  133. https://www.npr.org/2019/02/21/696574690/top-flutist-settles-gender-pay-gap-suit-with-boston-symphony-orchestra
  134. https://www.wbur.org/news/2017/12/21/bso-cuts-ties-charles-dutoit
  135. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/02/arts/music/boston-symphony-finds-accusations-against-charles-dutoit-credible.html
  136. https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/03/02/590496543/sexual-assault-claim-against-conductor-dutoit-is-credible-boston-symphony-says
  137. https://www.bostonglobe.com/arts/music/2018/03/02/bso-report-finds-new-claims-sexual-misconduct-conductor/0xJU2Rx1tB9rLqApdxIIPP/story.html
  138. https://www.audimute.com/blog/symphony-hall/
  139. https://www.wired.com/2010/10/1015boston-symphony-hall-opens/
  140. https://www.wgbh.org/news/local/2017-02-13/boston-symphony-orchestra-wins-second-consecutive-grammy-for-best-orchestral-performance
  141. https://www.nbcboston.com/news/local/boston-symphony-orchestra-wins-grammy-award/4474/
  142. https://www.encyclopedia.com/media/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/boston-symphony-orchestra
  143. https://www.bostonmagazine.com/sponsor-content/tanglewood-music-center-stomping-ground-aspiring-musicians/
  144. https://www.cbsnews.com/boston/news/boston-pops-tanglewood-massachusetts/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.