Hubbry Logo
Corporal CleggCorporal CleggMain
Open search
Corporal Clegg
Community hub
Corporal Clegg
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Corporal Clegg
Corporal Clegg
Corporal Clegg
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
"Corporal Clegg"
Song by Pink Floyd
from the album A Saucerful of Secrets
PublishedLupus Music Ltd
Released29 June 1968 (1968-06-29) (UK)
27 July 1968 (US)
Recorded12 February 1968
StudioAbbey Road, London, UK
Genre
Length4:12
LabelEMI Columbia (UK)
Tower (US)
SongwriterRoger Waters
ProducerNorman Smith

"Corporal Clegg" is a song by English rock band Pink Floyd and is featured on second album, A Saucerful of Secrets (1968).[1] It was written by Roger Waters[1] and features David Gilmour, Nick Mason and Richard Wright sharing the lead vocals, which is the only Floyd song to do so.[2] The song also features a kazoo. Producer Norman Smith was a genuine war hero, serving in WW2 as a glider pilot.

The Pink Floyd website credits the brass parts to "The Stanley Myers Orchestra".[3]

Lyrics

[edit]

The song is about a shell-shocked soldier who lost his leg in World War II. He is described as having a medal of "orange, red and blue", which may be a reference to the Burma Star. It is the first mention of war in a Pink Floyd song, something that would become a common theme in Roger Waters' lyrics, Roger having lost his father thus in 1944.[1] Waters told Mojo magazine[citation needed] that this song is autobiographical. He explained: "Corporal Clegg is about my father and his sacrifice in World War II. It's somewhat sarcastic—the idea of the wooden leg being something you won in the war, like a trophy."[4] This can be seen as rather lighter in tone than Pink Floyd's later tackling of the subject, though, despite the irony (Clegg "won" his wooden leg in the war) and darkness behind the lyrics; indeed, among the cacophony of voices towards the end we hear an officer telling his one-legged man: "Clegg! Been meaning to speak to you. About that leg of yours! You're excused parade from now on!" and members of the band actually corpsing in the chorus. It is possible that the main character got his name after Thaddeus von Clegg, a German clockmaker, who invented the kazoo in the 1840s.

Music videos

[edit]

Although the song was never performed live, two videos of the song exist. The first one was shot on 19 or 20 February 1968 for Belgian RTB TV's Tienerklanken show, and features the band miming to a work-in-progress version of the song with a different ending.[5] The second one was shot on 22 July 1969 for the West-German SDR TV and broadcast on 21 September that year.[6] The video takes place in a room with a dining table covered with exquisite food, and all four band members, wearing helmets, officer's caps, and Roger Waters wearing a trench coat, are there enjoying the food. An accidental spillage of wine triggers a full scale food fight, resulting in the room getting completely trashed and all four band members covered in food (even the cameraman gets dragged into it), whilst the Dove of Peace (an actual white dove) is caught in the "crossfire". Interspersed throughout the video is footage of war and the band performing the song.

Reception

[edit]

In a negative review for A Saucerful of Secrets, Jim Miller of Rolling Stone described "Corporal Clegg" as having "the virtue of brevity, as well as not sounding like it was written in a drugged stupor".[7] Continuing, Miller described the song's "unoriginal melody" as being "much too Beatley for these post-Sgt. Pepper days".[7]

Personnel

[edit]

with:

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Corporal Clegg

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
"" is a by the English rock band , written by bassist and released on their second studio album, , in 1968. The track narrates the story of a fictional veteran who lost a leg in in 1944, acquired a wooden prosthetic, and received a described in garish colors, later entertaining himself and others with performances that mortify his wife. Featuring lead vocals by drummer and prominent sections, the song draws its title from Thaddeus von Clegg, the 19th-century inventor of the , and reflects Waters' sarcastic commentary on wartime sacrifice. Waters has stated that the composition is autobiographical, alluding to his own father's during the , marking an early instance of his recurring preoccupation with military conflict's human toll. While not a commercial single, "Corporal Clegg" has been critiqued by some listeners and band associates as among 's less accomplished efforts, emblematic of the transitional phase following Syd Barrett's departure and preceding their more experimental psychedelic work.

Background

Context in Pink Floyd's Evolution

joined as a and co-vocalist in January 1968 amid Syd Barrett's deteriorating mental health and onstage unreliability, initially to augment performances while Barrett remained nominally in the band. Barrett's formal departure was agreed upon in March 1968, with the split announced publicly on April 6, allowing the remaining members—, Richard Wright, and —to stabilize the lineup with Gilmour's fuller integration. This transition occurred during sessions for the band's second album, , recorded intermittently from August 1967 to May 1968 at EMI's , marking the first release where Barrett contributed minimally and no longer dominated songwriting. The album reflected Pink Floyd's pivot away from Barrett's free-form, whimsical toward a more disciplined experimentalism, incorporating structured compositions and studio innovations that foreshadowed rock developments of their later career. With Barrett's influence waning, Waters began asserting greater creative control, particularly in lyrical contributions, as evidenced by tracks like "Corporal Clegg," which credited Waters alongside , Mason, and Gilmour for its development. This song exemplified the band's adaptation to lineup , blending input with Waters' emerging thematic focus on societal , distinct from Barrett-era . The period encapsulated Pink Floyd's survival amid crisis, as the group retained core personnel while jettisoning Barrett's lead role to pursue viability in a competitive scene; A Saucerful of Secrets, released on June 29, 1968, in the UK, thus served as a bridge album, encapsulating residual psychedelia with nascent structural rigor that Waters and Gilmour would refine in subsequent works.

Songwriting Contributions

"Corporal Clegg" is credited to Roger Waters, Richard Wright, David Gilmour, and Nick Mason, marking the first Pink Floyd song to receive collective authorship attribution to all four active members following Syd Barrett's departure. This shared credit reflects contributions beyond Waters' primary lyrical and compositional foundation, including arrangements shaped by group input during a transitional period. The song's whimsical, satirical tone draws from Barrett-era , with melodic elements echoing unreleased Barrett tracks like "Scream Thy Last Scream," suggesting an effort to preserve the band's original stylistic identity amid the post-Barrett uncertainty. This emulation occurred as the group navigated creative voids left by Barrett's exit in early , prioritizing continuity in their evolving sound. Waters has claimed the track as autobiographical, stating in a 2009 Mojo interview that it concerns his father's sacrifice. However, this assertion conflicts with verifiable timeline details: Eric Fletcher Waters died on February 11, 1944, during the campaign, predeceasing any postwar return depicted in the ' reference to a wooden leg "won" that year. Born in September 1943, Waters lacked direct experiential basis for such narrative elements, underscoring a prioritization of thematic symbolism over literal personal history in his composition.

Composition and Recording

Musical Elements

"Corporal Clegg" is characterized by an upbeat, marching rhythm driven by bass, , and patterns that evoke military cadences. The song spans 4 minutes and 13 seconds, featuring a prominent solo that mimics fanfares in place of a conventional guitar lead. Instrumentation blends rhythm guitar strums, , and organ accents with layered group vocals in the choruses, producing a jaunty, satirical tone akin to novelty numbers rather than straightforward rock. Structurally, it shifts abruptly from cheerful verses to chaotic, dissonant interludes with distorted guitar and percussion overlays, yielding a jagged quality that some analyses describe as disjointed and less cohesive than peers' experimental compositions. These elements highlight the track's role in Pink Floyd's shift toward fragmented , prioritizing quirky disruption over seamless progression.

Production Details

"Corporal Clegg" was recorded during the spring 1968 sessions for Pink Floyd's second album, , at Studios in , under the production of Norman Smith. These sessions marked a transitional phase for the band, following Syd Barrett's departure, with contributing fully to the track's guitar parts and the absence of Barrett's involvement evidencing the group's raw adjustment to a new lineup dynamic. Smith, an staff producer, guided the recording toward a more disciplined structure, utilizing basic tracks laid down earlier and adding overdubs to elements like percussion, brass, and kazoos to build the song's quirky, satirical texture. The production incorporated panning for humorous effects, notably in the solos that shift rapidly between channels, enhancing the comedic portrayal of the character's medal-clinking and leg-thumping . Sound effects mimicking the wooden leg's "thump"—achieved through percussive overdubs and bass elements—were integrated to underscore the ' absurdity, though constrained by the era's analog , including limited multitrack capabilities at EMI's facilities, which relied on tape bouncing for layering. Band decisions prioritized capturing the ensemble's live interplay, with minimal polish on Gilmour's and Nick Mason's lead vocals, resulting in a direct, unrefined energy that reflected the post-Barrett reconfiguration rather than experimental overdub excess. Engineer Peter Bown oversaw the technical aspects, contributing to the track's crisp yet rudimentary typical of late-1960s rock recordings.

Personnel

The personnel for "Corporal Clegg" comprised Pink Floyd's core quartet, reflecting their self-contained production approach without external session musicians. provided bass guitar and backing vocals, while serving as the primary songwriter. contributed electric guitar, , and vocals, including lead elements. handled keyboards such as organ and , along with vocals. performed on drums and percussion, and delivered vocals, marking one of his rare lead vocal contributions to the band's catalog.

Lyrics and Themes

Lyrical Content

The lyrics of "Corporal Clegg", written primarily by Roger Waters, center on a fictional World War II veteran named Corporal Clegg who sustains a leg injury in 1944, resulting in amputation and replacement with a wooden prosthetic. The narrative opens with the chorus: "Corporal Clegg had a wooden leg / He won it in the war, in 1944 / Corporal Clegg had a medal too / In orange, red and blue / He found it in the zoo", introducing absurd elements such as the medal's vibrant colors and its origin in a zoo, which underscore a satirical tone toward military honors. Subsequent verses shift to Clegg's domestic life, portraying and decline: "Dear, dear, were they really sad for me? / Dear, dear, will they really laugh at me?", followed by interactions with his wife, "Mrs. Clegg, you must be proud of him / Mrs. Clegg, another drop of ". This evokes themes of and spousal amid , culminating in "Corporal Clegg, umbrella in the rain / He's never been the same / No one is to blame / Corporal Clegg received his in a dream", suggesting the veteran's altered state and illusory recognition. The song marks Pink Floyd's first direct reference to in their recorded output, employing a caricatured figure to highlight personal aftermath without broader historical context. Repetition in the chorus reinforces the and as motifs of ironic "achievement", with the zoo-found medal implying fabrication or triviality of accolades.

Interpretations and Symbolism

The primary interpretation of "Corporal Clegg," as articulated by co-writer in a 2009 Mojo magazine interview, frames the song as an autobiographical reflection on his father's death in combat, employing to depict the wooden leg acquired in 1944 as a hollow "prize" emblematic of futile sacrifice. This aligns with Waters' emerging thematic interest in war's personal toll, marking the track as a precursor to later explorations of paternal loss and in Pink Floyd's catalog. Symbolically, the medal "in orange, red, and blue" purportedly found "in the zoo" satirizes the artificial pomp of military decoration, reducing heroic commemoration to absurdity and critiquing societal glorification of valor amid veterans' post-war struggles, including implied spousal alcoholism and domestic discord. The kazoo's mimicry of a bugle further underscores whimsy, evoking music-hall irreverence that some analysts link to Syd Barrett's stylistic legacy, positioning the song as a transitional coping artifact for the band navigating Barrett's departure rather than a rigorously anti-establishment polemic. From an anti-war perspective, the narrative lampoons institutional and its dehumanizing aftermath, portraying the titular corporal as a pitiable figure whose "medals and his leg" yield no meaningful redemption, a view echoed in characterizations of the track as darkly humorous commentary on wartime injury's enduring stigma. Counterinterpretations, however, contend this reduces complex causality to caricature, neglecting empirical data on veterans' adjustment; longitudinal studies indicate that high-combat survivors often demonstrated resilience, with moderating exposure toward enhanced later-life rather than universal disillusionment. Such portrayals risk undervaluing soldiers' instrumental role in Allied triumph, a causal chain rooted in collective sacrifice that forestalled Axis hegemony, thereby prioritizing individual over strategic necessity in assessing martial symbolism.

Release and Media Appearances

Album Integration

"Corporal Clegg" serves as the fourth track on side one of , positioned after the hypnotic repetition of "Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun" and before the extended improvisational title track. This sequencing integrates the song as a concise, vocally driven interlude with satirical and a distinctive solo, providing rhythmic structure and thematic contrast within the album's eclectic blend of psychedelic experimentation and songcraft. Released on June 29, 1968, by Columbia in the , reflects Pink Floyd's transitional phase following Syd Barrett's departure, where "Corporal Clegg" exemplifies ' emerging songwriting amid collective instrumental explorations. The track contributes to the album's fragmented psychedelic aesthetic, bridging more conventional rock elements with abstract soundscapes, yet its self-contained narrative form distinguishes it from the band's subsequent shift toward unified concept albums like The Dark Side of the Moon. peaked at number nine on the , marking modest commercial success without standout singles or targeted promotion for individual tracks such as "Corporal Clegg."

Television Performances

Pink Floyd's television appearances for "Corporal Clegg" consisted of two mimed performances recorded in 1968, serving as early promotional clips akin to proto-music videos, with the band performing in a studio setting against a plain backdrop. The first occurred on the Belgian program Tienerklanken, taped in on February 18 or 19, 1968, and broadcast on BRT television on March 31, 1968; notably played the solo live during the miming. A second mimed rendition aired on the German show P wie Petersilie (also known as P1), broadcast on Südwestdeutscher Rundfunk (SDR) in on July 22, 1968, featuring similar studio visuals and instrumentation. These clips, preserved in archival footage, capture the band's transitional lineup post-Syd Barrett, with on lead vocals and the group emphasizing the song's novelty elements like the and toy . No official was produced for "Corporal Clegg," distinguishing it from contemporaries like "," and the television versions remain the primary visual records of its era-specific presentation. The track was never performed live by Pink Floyd in concert tours, restricting documented performances to these studio-mimed television segments and the original album recording. This absence from live sets aligns with the band's evolving repertoire amid lineup changes and a shift away from Barrett-era material by mid-1968.

Reception and Legacy

Initial Critical Response

Jim Miller's 1968 review in Rolling Stone singled out "Corporal Clegg" amid the album's broader inconsistencies, crediting it with "the virtue of brevity" while critiquing its lugubrious tempo and placement as a jarring interlude in an otherwise experimental set. The track received scant independent attention, typically subsumed into assessments of A Saucerful of Secrets as a whole, which drew mixed verdicts reflecting fatigue with psychedelic excess and the band's post-Barrett transition; instrumental elements, including unconventional additions like kazoos, were often deemed routine or mismatched. Critics positioned it as filler disrupting the album's sonic cohesion, with production described as less polished than prior efforts, underscoring perceptions of uneven execution.

Fan and Retrospective Assessments

"Corporal Clegg" has elicited divided responses among fans, frequently appearing in low rankings within 's catalog. In Ultimate Classic Rock's 2018 ranking of all 167 songs, it placed 111th from the bottom, faulted for hollow, cliché-laden lyrics and an unforgivable pun in its closer. Similarly, Vulture's ranking of 165 songs positioned it at 104th, critiquing its absence of melody or purpose amid superficial stylings. Society of Rock identified it as the weakest track on , attributing its shortcomings to the era's turmoil following Syd Barrett's exit. Defenses against such dismissals highlight its chorus catchiness and understated on disabled veterans. Reddit discussions from 2023 praise its quirky, bizarre sound and early manifestation of ' anti- motifs, with some users appreciating how it captures the band's eccentric side pre-The Dark Side of the Moon. ProgArchives forum threads similarly debate its merits, with contributors viewing it as Waters' emulation of Barrett's whimsical style—a of British oddity—rather than a precursor to heavier critiques, though consensus eludes elevation to status. Retrospective assessments underscore the track's role in the band's post-Barrett transition, marked by experimental awkwardness rather than lasting . Analyses note its jagged structure and elements as relics of 1968's psychedelic flux, emblematic of a group grappling with lineup changes and stylistic shifts without yet achieving cohesive breakthroughs. Fan forums like Pink Floyd echo this, with members questioning its appeal outright amid broader critiques. No unified reevaluation has propelled it higher, reflecting its position as a curio in the Floyd evolutionary arc from Barrett-era whimsy to Waters-dominated conceptuality.

Cultural Influence

The song "Corporal Clegg" has seen limited engagement in beyond Floyd's original recording, with covers primarily confined to amateur performances and acts rather than mainstream artists. Notable instances include a guitar cover by independent musician MusiKmaury uploaded to in September 2022 and occasional live renditions by the band The Machine, performed in approximately 3% of their shows as of documented setlists. A cover by the obscure group Samarin, Morgan & Hull LLP is listed in music databases, but no samples or remixes by prominent producers have gained traction. This scarcity indicates no significant revival or adaptation in contemporary genres, underscoring its niche status within fandoms. While the track's satirical depiction of a war veteran's plight prefigures ' more developed critiques of in later works such as (1979), evidence of direct causal influence on broader anti-war discourse remains absent. Prog rock analyses note it as Waters' inaugural foray into war themes, yet its simplistic narrative and vaudeville-style arrangement lack the conceptual depth to propagate tropes beyond the band's internal evolution. Fan interpretations occasionally link it to personal loss, as Waters confirmed in a 2009 Mojo interview that the character draws from his father's sacrifice, but this has not translated to verifiable shifts in public attitudes toward veterans or . The song's cultural footprint persists mainly in specialized circles, with sporadic mentions in enthusiast forums and archival reviews rather than or societal commentary. Interpretations framing the protagonist's as a PTSD appear in psychiatric , but these are retrospective and do not demonstrate widespread adoption or normalization of anti-war veteran narratives in 1960s-1970s culture. Absent documentation of endorsements, adaptations, or references in , , or debates, claims of outsized legacy in challenging militaristic views overstate its impact, which empirical coverage patterns confirm as marginal.

References

  1. https://www.songfacts.com/facts/pink-floyd/corporal-clegg
  2. https://music.apple.com/us/song/corporal-clegg/1065974583
  3. https://www.songfacts.com/lyrics/pink-floyd/corporal-clegg
  4. https://genius.com/Pink-floyd-corporal-clegg-lyrics
  5. https://www.antiwarsongs.org/canzone.php?id=2364&lang=en
  6. https://www.quora.com/What-does-the-song-Corporal-Clegg-by-Pink-Floyd-mean
  7. https://dangerousminds.net/comments/corporal_clegg_worst_pink_floyd_song_ever/
  8. http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=17905
  9. https://ultimateclassicrock.com/david-gilmour-joins-pink-floyd/
  10. https://rock95.com/pink-floyd-saucerful-of-secrets/
  11. https://eyesoremerch.com/blog/pink-floyd-visionaries-of-progressive-rock-and-psychedelia/
  12. https://www.discogs.com/master/10352-Pink-Floyd-A-Saucerful-Of-Secrets
  13. https://www.psychedelicbabymag.com/2018/07/pink-floyds-best-kept-secret-saucerfu.html
  14. https://forums.stevehoffman.tv/threads/were-pink-floyd-inspired-by-unreleased-barrett-songs.370844/
  15. https://www.reddit.com/r/pinkfloyd/comments/2f49ol/album_analyzation_2_a_saucerful_of_secrets/
  16. https://songbpm.com/%40pink-floyd/corporal-clegg
  17. https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/how-the-kazoo-became-major-part-of-pink-floyd/
  18. https://www.songsterr.com/a/wsa/pink-floyd-corporal-clegg-tab-s16098t4
  19. https://forums.stevehoffman.tv/posts/12179500/
  20. https://theeliteextremophile.com/2021/03/01/deep-dive-pink-floyd/
  21. https://www.progarchives.com/album-reviews.asp?id=1434
  22. https://forums.stevehoffman.tv/threads/a-saucerful-of-secrets-recording-sessions.1219335/
  23. https://tropedia.fandom.com/wiki/Gratuitous_Panning
  24. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQAN5SMYWho
  25. https://music.fandom.com/wiki/A_Saucerful_Of_Secrets:Pink_Floyd
  26. https://musicbrainz.org/release/05c5e2bc-3daf-344e-bf9a-d0e16cad13ca
  27. https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/four-pink-floyd-songs-featuring-nick-masons-vocals/
  28. https://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/pinkfloyd/corporalclegg.html
  29. https://www.musixmatch.com/lyrics/Pink-Floyd/corporal-clegg-1
  30. https://www.neptunepinkfloyd.co.uk/corporal-clegg-lyrics-pink-floyd-saucerful-of-secrets
  31. https://songmeanings.com/songs/view/2805/
  32. https://www.songmeaningsandfacts.com/corporal-clegg-a-surreal-satire-on-war-and-valor/
  33. https://www.tailem.com/corporal-clegg-song-a-saucerful-of-secrets/reviews/pink-floyd-artist
  34. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/232992176_The_Long-Term_Effects_of_World_War_II_Combat_Exposure_on_Later_Life_Well-Being_Moderated_by_Generativity
  35. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10563452/
  36. https://www.pinkfloyd.com/albums/a-saucerful-of-secrets/
  37. https://www.floydianslip.com/pink-floyd/albums/a-saucerful-of-secrets
  38. https://www.officialcharts.com/albums/pink-floyd-a-saucerful-of-secrets/
  39. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9MPDzhdVEmo
  40. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gebcv74mAU8
  41. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XnwcHXUuokw
  42. https://x.com/pinkfloyd/status/1947614412568965120
  43. https://bravewords.com/news/pink-floyd-rare-1968-tienerklanken-tv-performance-of-corporal-clegg-streaming-video/
  44. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ws3CZcJrHGg
  45. https://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=17905
  46. https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-album-reviews/a-saucerful-of-secrets-184964/
  47. https://ultimateclassicrock.com/pink-floyd-songs-ranked/
  48. https://www.vulture.com/article/best-pink-floyd-songs.html
  49. https://societyofrock.com/worst-pink-floyd-songs/
  50. https://www.reddit.com/r/pinkfloyd/comments/1387762/whats_this_subreddits_thought_on_corporal_clegg/
  51. https://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=1434
  52. https://www.neptunepinkfloyd.co.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?t=177
  53. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vf7pn_yQdUg
  54. https://guestpectacular.com/artists/the-machine/events/12186/song/corporal-clegg
  55. https://www.whosampled.com/Samarin%2C-Morgan-%2526-Hull-LLP/Corporal-Clegg/
  56. https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/pink-floyd-song-about-roger-waters-father/
  57. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/the-british-journal-of-psychiatry/article/corporal-clegg/4F188A956E5E69304E421EEA66E4A4B6
  58. https://www.whosampled.com/Pink-Floyd/Corporal-Clegg/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.