Hubbry Logo
DesiertoDesiertoMain
Open search
Desierto
Community hub
Desierto
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Desierto
Desierto
Desierto
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Desierto
Theatrical release poster
Directed byJonás Cuarón
Written by
  • Jonás Cuarón
  • Mateo Garcia
Produced by
Starring
CinematographyDamian Garcia
Edited byJonás Cuarón
Music byWoodkid
Production
companies
Distributed byCinépolis Distribución (Colombia and Mexico)[1][2]
Version Originale/Condor
Orange Studio (France)[1]
Release dates
  • 13 September 2015 (2015-09-13) (TIFF)
  • 15 April 2016 (2016-04-15) (Mexico)
Running time
88 minutes[3]
Countries
  • Mexico
  • France
Languages
  • English
  • Spanish
Budget$3 million[4]
Box office$4.9 million[2][5]

Desierto is a 2015 thriller film co-written and directed by Jonás Cuarón.[6] It was produced by Cuarón together with his father Alfonso and his uncle Carlos, and distributed by STXfilms. The film stars Gael García Bernal (also executive producer) and Jeffrey Dean Morgan. It was shown in the Special Presentations section of the 2015 Toronto International Film Festival,[7] where it won the Prize of the International Federation of Film Critics (FIPRESCI) for Special Presentations,[8] and was selected as the Mexican entry for the Best Foreign Language Film at the 89th Academy Awards but it was not nominated.[9][10]

Plot

[edit]

A group of Mexican migrant workers seek a better life by crossing the US border illegally; when the truck carrying them breaks down in the middle of nowhere, the driver points the migrants and his partner Mechas in the direction of the United States and wishes them luck. Moises is also a member of the migrants and follows as the group splits in two while trying to pass the border.

Sam is a merciless, rifle-toting vigilante who, with his faithful but vicious Malinois dog, Tracker,[11] hunts for rabbits near the border and notices the group trespassing; with the help of Tracker and the use of his M1 Garand rifle, Sam kills most of the group, including Mechas and leaves Moises and Adela (Alondra Hidalgo) as the sole survivors after a long chase. Unable to follow the last two, Sam decides to continue his hunt the next day and leaves with Tracker.

Adela and Moises find a spot to rest, with Adela confessing to Moises that her companion, who was one Sam's victims, was sent by her parents to protect her and even though he molested her during their journey, he didn't deserve to die that way. Moises confesses to Adela that he had already been to the US and that he has a family waiting for him in Oakland, showing a talking teddy bear which his son gave to him before being deported, and that Moises promised him he would bring it back. Meanwhile, Sam rests by a campfire with Tracker, describing to his loyal dog how he used to love the desert but now the heat is playing with his mind and he wants to escape from it.

The next morning Adela and Moises steal Sam's truck, using the teddy bear to distract Sam and Tracker. The duo manage to start the truck and seem to have finally escaped when Sam shoots Adela in the arm, causing Moises to crash the truck which further injured Adela. They continue on foot, followed by Sam and Tracker. Moises stops to take care of Adela's wound, then tells her he has to leave her and takes Sam's jacket and flare gun with him. Moises has a change of heart and uses a round of the flare gun to distract Sam from Adela; Tracker closely pursues Moises in a cactus field where Moises is forced to use the flare gun on Tracker and shoot him in the mouth before escaping; Sam finds a mortally wounded Tracker and reluctantly shoots him to end his suffering before swearing vengeance on Moises.

After a long time chasing Moises as they are climbing on a rock structure, Sam is dehydrated and tired; Moises hides between the rocks and pushes Sam as he is standing on the edge, causing both of them to fall and breaking Sam's leg in the process. Both try to reach the rifle, but Moises takes it and menaces Sam with the rifle for murdering so many people and trying to kill Moises and Adela as Sam begs for his life, for forgiveness, and for water. Instead, Moises leaves with the rifle, telling Sam that the desert will kill him and leaves Sam to die despite his pleas for Moises to come back.

Moises returns for Adela; he finds her alive, but unconscious, and carries her until they cross a salt lake.

Cast

[edit]

Release

[edit]

The film was first released at the Toronto International Film Festival in September 2015. In December 2015, STX Entertainment announced that it would release the film in North American theaters the following March.[12] The film was released in France and Mexico in April 2016 and had grossed $2.8 million as of 15 May 2016.[13] The North American release was delayed until 14 October 2016.[14]

Reception

[edit]

Critical response

[edit]

The film holds a 63% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 93 reviews with an average rating of 5.7/10. The site's consensus reads "Desierto's thought-provoking themes and refreshing perspective are unfortunately offset by a predictable plot and thinly written characters."[15] On Metacritic, the film has a score of 51 out of 100, based on 24 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews".[16]

Dave Robinson of outlet Crash Landed reviewed the home entertainment release of Desierto awarding it 3 stars, taking note of its technical acumen in providing a thriller, but its "ill-defined script accomplishing nothing beyond passive entertainment" and of special note its complete lack of special features.[17]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Desierto

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
is a 2015 Mexican-French survival thriller co-written and directed by , son of filmmaker who served as producer alongside Jonás and . The film centers on a group of undocumented Mexican migrants whose truck breaks down in the remote while attempting an illegal crossing into the , leading to a deadly pursuit by a lone American vigilante armed with a high-powered and accompanied by his dog. Starring as migrant Moises, who leads survivors in evasion, and as the unnamed hunter driven by anti-immigrant rage, it portrays the harsh environmental and human threats inherent to unauthorized border traversal. Premiering at the in 2015 and selected as Mexico's entry for the Best Foreign Language Film at the though not nominated, Desierto received mixed critical reception for its tense action sequences and capturing the 's unforgiving expanse, but drew criticism for a simplistic, one-sided depiction of dynamics that emphasizes vigilante brutality while downplaying other empirical risks migrants face, such as , violence, and human smuggling operations. With a critic score of 64% based on aggregated reviews highlighting its primal survival elements akin to a " version" of , the film underscores causal perils of isolation and pursuit but has been faulted by some for reductive characterizations that align with institutional narratives favoring migrant victimhood over multifaceted enforcement realities. Developed over seven years by Cuarón to explore extremes through a thriller lens, Desierto grossed modestly upon limited release, reflecting its niche appeal amid polarized debates.

Production

Development and Writing

Jonás Cuarón conceived the idea for Desierto during a trip to approximately a decade before the film's premiere, motivated by encounters with anti-immigrant amid rising border tensions. His personal experience living between and the for over 20 years further shaped his interest in portraying the immigrant journey through a thriller lens, emphasizing visual storytelling over dialogue to humanize migrants as resilient protagonists. Cuarón drafted the initial around 2008, collaborating with co-writer Mateo García to develop a narrative of border-crossing peril and vigilante confrontation, drawing partial influence from documentaries such as Gael García Bernal's Who Is Dayani Cristal? for authentic elements of migrant tragedy. He shared early versions with his father, Alfonso Cuarón, whose feedback emphasized relentless action sequences and environmental metaphors, concepts that paralleled their later co-written (2013), with Desierto functioning as a terrestrial counterpart focused on human versus landscape survival. The writing process spanned roughly seven years, evolving from conceptual outlines into a genre-driven script that avoided overt by prioritizing primal horror and moral ambiguity in the setting, reflecting Cuarón's aim to engage audiences viscerally on themes of vulnerability and hatred.

Casting and Crew

The film was directed by , who co-wrote the screenplay with Mateo Garcia. Producers included , , himself, and Alex Garcia, with executive producers such as David Linde, , Nicolas Celis, and Santiago García Galván. was handled by Damián Brea, and the score was composed by Woodkid. Gael García Bernal starred as Moises, a migrant who leads a group attempting to cross the U.S.- border on foot after their transport fails. Jeffrey Dean Morgan portrayed Sam, a self-appointed vigilante who hunts the migrants with a high-powered from his . Supporting roles included Alondra Hidalgo as Adela, Diego Cataño as Mechas, Marco Pérez as Lobo, and Óscar Flores Guerrero as Ramiro.
ActorRole
Gael García BernalMoises
Jeffrey Dean MorganSam
Alondra HidalgoAdela
Diego CatañoMechas
Marco PérezLobo
Óscar Flores GuerreroRamiro

Filming Locations and Techniques

Principal photography for Desierto occurred over a 10-week period in the remote deserts of Baja California Sur, Mexico, selected to authentically represent the harsh U.S.-Mexico border terrain. Director Jonás Cuarón scouted potential sites for four years across the United States and Mexico before choosing this location for its isolation and natural desolation, including areas in the Sonoran Desert near Catavina and La Paz. The encountered substantial logistical hurdles, including hours-long drives between setups in regions lacking infrastructure, extreme daytime temperatures surpassing 100 degrees (38 degrees ), and hazards like venomous snakes, which restricted filming to brief morning and late afternoon windows. Damian García relied solely on natural lighting, harnessing available augmented by reflectors and bounce boards, eschewing artificial sources to underscore the environment's relentless hostility. Techniques emphasized visual through wide-angle lenses that captured expansive vistas to juxtapose the landscape's indifference against diminutive human figures, paired with intimate close-ups to convey character emotions in scenes of sparse . Action elements incorporated trained dogs for pursuit sequences under animal handler Javier Lecuna, while budget limitations led to the use of live snakes in a pivotal scene surrounding a character, heightening on-set tension without relying on .

Narrative Structure

Plot Summary

Desierto depicts a group of approximately fourteen migrants, including (), who seek to enter the illegally by traversing the desolate desert border region. is driven by the goal of reuniting with his young son living in . The migrants' truck malfunctions shortly after departure, stranding them without water or shelter in the scorching expanse, forcing them to proceed on foot under the guidance of their coyote smuggler. As the group advances, they attract the attention of Sam (Jeffrey Dean Morgan), a lone American equipped with a , dogs, and a long-range , who perceives himself as a defender against crossings. Sam initiates a methodical , using his elevated vantage and weaponry to pick off multiple migrants from afar, scattering the survivors amid chaos and terror. The remaining individuals, grappling with injuries, thirst, heatstroke, and disorientation, fragment further while fleeing; assumes a protective role toward a vulnerable among them, employing ingenuity and the terrain's features to prolong their evasion. The pursuit escalates into direct peril from Sam's dogs and marksmanship, culminating in desperate measures for survival against both human and environmental threats.

Character Portrayals

Moises, portrayed by , serves as the film's central , depicted as a resilient and altruistic migrant deported from the following a routine for a broken taillight that escalated into detention. Having previously lived in Oakland with his family, including his son, Moises joins a group of undocumented immigrants attempting an illegal border crossing to reunite with loved ones, showcasing mechanical skills and survival instincts honed from prior experiences. His character arc emphasizes and moral fortitude, as he prioritizes aiding vulnerable companions—particularly Adela (Alondra Hidalgo), a young woman he shields during attacks—over personal escape, positioning him as a leader who navigates the desert's harsh terrain using knowledge of its features like canyons for evasion. This portrayal draws implicit biblical symbolism from his name, evoking leading exiles through wilderness, though the film prioritizes visceral action over explicit . In contrast, Sam, played by , represents the antagonistic , characterized as a solitary, ideologically motivated American who patrols the U.S.-Mexico borderlands in a pickup truck equipped with a , tracking dog, and apparent disdain for official border enforcement. His depiction is deliberately sparse, with substantial elements—potentially humanizing his motivations—removed during to amplify his role as an archetypal predator, listening to amid visual markers of rural Americana that underscore cultural alienation from the migrants. Sam's actions methodically decimate the group, firing from elevated positions and pursuing survivors, which critics interpret as embodying unchecked and racial hostility rather than nuanced psychology, rendering him a symbolic "monster" devoid of redemption or dialogue that might contextualize his rage. This minimalist approach, while critiqued for oversimplification, heightens thriller tension by focusing on his inexorable pursuit. Supporting characters within the migrant caravan, including Mechas (Diego Cataño), Lobo (Marco Pérez), and Ramiro (Oscar Flores), are portrayed as ordinary individuals driven by economic desperation or family ties, but their roles emphasize collective vulnerability over deep individuation. Adela emerges as a key secondary figure under Moises's protection, symbolizing innocence amid brutality, while the group's rapid attrition through dehydration, exposure, and Sam's attacks illustrates the dehumanizing perils of the journey without delving into backstories that might dilute the film's survival-horror pace. Overall, these portrayals prioritize archetypal contrasts—heroic endurance versus predatory zeal—over psychological realism, aligning with the film's thriller genre conventions to critique border dynamics through action rather than exposition.

Themes and Symbolism

Immigration and Border Crossing

The film Desierto portrays across the US-Mexico border as a grueling test of endurance, with the serving as a primary symbol of natural and existential barriers that amplify human vulnerability. A group of migrants, including protagonist (played by ), attempts the crossing in a smuggler's truck that malfunctions deep in the arid expanse, compelling them to proceed on foot amid scorching heat, scarce water, and disorienting terrain. This setup underscores the physical toll of unauthorized entry routes, where , exhaustion, and exposure claim lives routinely; U.S. Border Patrol data indicate over 8,000 migrant deaths since 1998, predominantly from environmental causes in desert sectors like Arizona's. The desert's vast emptiness symbolizes not only geographical isolation but also the policy-driven funneling of crossings into lethal zones, as enforcement concentrates urban apprehensions while remote areas remain deadly funnels. Motivations for the migrants' journey reflect causal drivers of northward migration, including economic desperation and familial obligations—Moises seeks work to support his son left in —portrayed without romanticization amid the group's internal fractures, such as language barriers and opportunistic betrayals. Director drew from encounters with anti-immigrant sentiment in to frame the border as a contested , where the migrants' pursuit of opportunity collides with territorial assertions of . The narrative avoids idealizing the crossers, instead highlighting survival pragmatism, as characters ration meager supplies and navigate mirages, evoking first-principles realities of resource scarcity in unassisted treks that mirror documented cases of groups perishing en masse. The vigilante Sam (Jeffrey Dean Morgan), patrolling independently with a high-powered and tracking , introduces human predation as a thematic , symbolizing privatized defense amid perceived institutional failures in controlling illegal flows. His methodical hunts evoke moral tensions in enforcement extremes, though the film critiques this through his isolation and implied , contrasting the migrants' collective desperation. This dynamic allegorizes broader debates, where unchecked entries provoke vigilant responses, yet Cuarón's thriller format simplifies causal complexities—such as root economic disparities or influences—for suspense, drawing for reductive immigrant portrayals. Empirically, the desert's role grounds the symbolism in verifiable perils, with annual averages of over deaths underscoring how unauthorized crossings prioritize evasion over safety, often yielding high fatality rates in inhospitable terrains.

Vigilantism and Moral Ambiguity

In Desierto, vigilantism is centralized in the antagonist Sam (Jeffrey Dean Morgan), a solitary American who intercepts and slaughters Mexican migrants traversing the Sonora Desert toward the United States border on April 2015, as depicted in the film's timeline. Equipped with a scoped rifle affixed to his off-road vehicle, incendiary ammunition, and aggressive dogs, Sam executes a calculated extermination, picking off individuals from afar and pursuing survivors across unforgiving terrain. This portrayal amplifies real border patrol vigilantism—such as that by groups like the Minutemen in the 2000s—into a hyper-individualized, predatory hunt, devoid of coordination with authorities. The film's treatment eschews moral ambiguity in Sam's characterization, rendering him a for unadulterated : silent, methodical, and adorned with symbolic markers like a emblazoned with "No More Illegals" stickers, eliciting no redemptive traits or contextual rationale beyond prejudice. Director has described Sam as an embodiment of rhetoric-fueled hatred, where societal vulnerabilities manifest in lethal autonomy, intended as a visceral caution against escalating anti-immigrant sentiment observed in U.S. circa 2015. This binary framing—migrants as desperate innocents, vigilante as irredeemable predator—mirrors thriller conventions akin to (1932), prioritizing emotional indictment over ethical nuance. Critiques highlight this lack of ambiguity as a structural limitation, forgoing inquiry into migrants' illegal entry motivations or the vacuums in federal enforcement that vigilantes claim to fill, thus simplifying causal dynamics of incursions driven by economic disparities and violence in origin countries. Cuarón's binational lens, informed by two decades oscillating between and the U.S., underscores condemnation of extralegal violence while humanizing crossers' peril, yet interviews reveal no intent to equivocate Sam's actions as defensible . Mainstream analyses, often from outlets sympathetic to pro-immigration views, reinforce this as allegorical horror against nativism, though such interpretations may overlook empirical on unauthorized crossings exceeding 400,000 annually in the early .

Environmental and Survival Elements

The film portrays the Sonora Desert as a formidable adversary, with its extreme aridity and temperature fluctuations—daytime highs often surpassing 40°C (104°F)—intensifying the migrants' physical ordeal after their truck breaks down, compelling them to proceed on foot across unforgiving terrain lacking reliable water sources. emerges as a pervasive hazard, as the group rations scant supplies while navigating sun-exposed expanses that drain stamina and induce exhaustion, mirroring real border-crossing risks where heatstroke claims numerous lives annually. Survival tactics in the narrative emphasize primal resourcefulness amid environmental hostility: protagonist (Gael García Bernal) scavenges for shade under sparse rock outcrops and cacti, conserves motion to minimize perspiration, and prioritizes protecting vulnerable companions like children from direct , though these measures prove inadequate against the desert's relentless drain on bodily fluids and morale. The barren landscape's vastness fosters disorientation, with mirages and endless horizons underscoring isolation, while nocturnal drops in temperature add risks for the fatigued, compounding the migrants' dwindling numbers from both natural attrition and external violence. Ecologically, the desert's depiction draws on its authentic biodiversity threats—scorpions, rattlesnakes, and thorny vegetation that snag clothing and skin—but subordinates them to and hydric stressors, portraying as indifferently lethal rather than symbolically punitive, a realism grounded in the region's documented fatality rates for unauthorized crossings, estimated at over 400 deaths yearly in the mid-2010s due to exposure. This environmental gauntlet amplifies the thriller's tension, rendering every evasion from the vigilante a caloric and hydrative gamble, where failure to locate even trace moisture equates to capitulation.

Release and Commercial Performance

Premiere and Distribution

Desierto had its world premiere at the on September 13, 2015, where it received the Prize of the for the Discovery program. The film subsequently screened at the in on October 25, 2015, marking its Mexican debut. STX Entertainment acquired North American distribution rights following the Toronto premiere, with the deal announced on October 6, 2015. In the United States, it received a on October 14, 2016. Distribución handled distribution in , positioning Desierto as the company's first major national tentpole release, with plans for four to five significant Mexican films annually thereafter. Internationally, the film saw releases in on April 13, 2016, the via Altitude Film Entertainment in 2016, through Alfa Pictures in 2017, and by Asmik Ace Entertainment in 2017. Production companies involved in financing and initial sales included , which managed international distribution prior to regional deals.

Box Office Results

Desierto was released on October 14, 2016, in a limited theatrical run, opening in 152 theaters and earning $514,282 in its first weekend, which accounted for approximately 25.7% of its total domestic gross. The film ultimately grossed $2,002,036 domestically, reflecting modest performance for an independent thriller amid competition from major releases. Internationally, Desierto performed better relative to its scale, accumulating $2,938,383 across various markets, including stronger showings in and parts of where its themes resonated with local audiences. This brought the worldwide total to $4,940,419, exceeding the film's estimated $3 million and indicating a profitable return for distributor after accounting for marketing and distribution costs.
TerritoryOpening WeekendTotal Gross
Domestic (US/)$514,282$2,002,036
InternationalNot specified$2,938,383
Worldwide-$4,940,419
The film's commercial viability was bolstered by its low and festival buzz from premieres at and San Sebastian, though limited and a niche subject matter constrained broader appeal.

Reception and Analysis

Critical Reviews

Desierto garnered mixed , with reviewers praising its visceral thriller elements and desert while frequently critiquing its one-dimensional characters and overt moral framing of and . The film earned a 60% approval rating on from 66 reviews, averaging 5.7/10, with the consensus highlighting thought-provoking themes undermined by predictability and shallow writing. compiled a 51/100 score from 24 reviews, signifying mixed assessments. Several critics lauded the film's technical prowess and suspenseful pacing. Justin Chang of Variety called it a "brutal and relentless chase thriller" executed with "swift, primal and unrelenting" intensity, crediting director Jonás Cuarón's lean direction, the harsh landscape visuals, and deep-focus shots that amplify tension as a potent allegory siding firmly with undocumented migrants against "murderous xenophobia run amok." Peter Sobczynski of RogerEbert.com awarded 2/4 stars but commended well-staged action sequences, Gael García Bernal's sympathetic lead performance, Jeffrey Dean Morgan's menacing antagonist, and Damian Garcia's cinematography evoking the desert's eerie isolation. The Critical Movie Critics site praised the "genius" timeliness of its premise, likening it to a high-stakes survival tale amid perilous border crossing. Detractors often highlighted thematic shallowness and dramatic inconsistencies. Sobczynski deemed it "ugly and ham-fisted," faulting the lack of character motivations, unconvincing villain arc, and obvious symbolism that rendered it as "arid and desolate" as its setting. The Guardian review described it as an immigration parable "limited by its monochrome morality," offering thrills via physical tension akin to Cuarón's influences but lacking novelty or specificity, ultimately "a little dry" in exploring xenophobia. Chang acknowledged manipulative backstories and absence of nuance in good-versus-evil dynamics, positioning it more as arthouse exploitation than profound commentary. The New York Times labeled it an "unpleasant" exercise in graphic violence featuring a "nut with a rifle" preying on border-crossers, offering little edifying insight despite its setup. The Hollywood Reporter critiqued its "sharply made but simplistic" approach to border issues, sharing a reductive perspective on migrants and enforcers. Mainstream outlets, often aligned with progressive viewpoints on , tended to emphasize the film's failure to inject ambiguity into its condemnation of , potentially overlooking its explicit portrayal of the hunter as a monstrous figure devoid of redemption. Despite these reservations, the film's raw depiction resonated in some quarters as a stark, unapologetic of border perils.

Audience and Commercial Feedback

The film received mixed reception, with aggregate scores indicating general dissatisfaction compared to critical evaluations. On , Desierto earned a 46% approval rating, or "Rotten" designation, based on over 2,500 user ratings. On , it holds a 6.1 out of 10 rating from 11,240 users, reflecting moderate appeal but frequent critiques of execution. Metacritic's user score stands at 5.1 out of 10, derived from 21 ratings, underscoring similar ambivalence. Common audience feedback highlighted the film's predictability and perceived narrative heavy-handedness, particularly in its depiction of border dynamics and moral framing. Users on IMDb described it as "poorly directed, predictable and shallow," with the premise of a lone targeting migrants viewed as implausible and overly simplistic. Others criticized the story for ignoring legal aspects of while prioritizing emotional manipulation, leading to complaints of the film "beating the audience over the head with its narrative." Positive responses, though less prevalent, praised its tension as a survival thriller and empathy-building elements for migrants' perils, but these were outnumbered by reservations about character depth and allegorical overreach. Commercial feedback from audiences manifested in limited word-of-mouth momentum, contributing to subdued home entertainment uptake beyond initial theatrical runs. The divergence between audience scores (mid-40s to low-60s percentiles) and critics' 64% approval suggests varied reception along ideological lines, with general viewers less receptive to the film's unambiguous portrayal of as villainy. This gap aligns with patterns where audiences prioritize coherence over thematic , potentially impacting broader market resonance for politically charged content.

Awards and Nominations

Desierto won the FIPRESCI Prize for its entry in the Special Presentations section at the , recognizing its use of "pure cinema to create a strong emotional impact." The film also secured the top prize at the 2016 in . The picture was chosen as Mexico's official submission for the Best Foreign Language Film category at the but did not receive a nomination. At the 59th Ariel Awards in 2017, Desierto garnered nominations for Best Picture, Best Director (Jonás Cuarón), Best Original Screenplay (Jonás Cuarón and Mateo García), Best Cinematography, Best Editing, Best Sound, Best Production Design, Best Special Effects, and Best Male Co-Acting (Diego Cataño). It was similarly nominated for Best Film at the 4th Platino Awards for Ibero-American Cinema. Additional recognition included a win for Best First Feature Film at the Diosa de Plata Awards and nominations at the Phoenix Film Critics Society Awards for Gael García Bernal in a supporting role, among 22 total nominations across various festivals and awards bodies.

Controversies and Political Context

Depiction of Immigration Debates

The film Desierto portrays undocumented Mexican migrants as desperate individuals risking death in the Sonoran Desert to reach the United States for economic opportunity, emphasizing their vulnerability to natural hazards like dehydration and exposure rather than detailing specific push or pull factors such as wage disparities or violence in origin countries. A group led by mechanic Moisés (Gael García Bernal) travels in a truck that breaks down, stranding them amid scarce resources, which underscores the perilous reality of unauthorized border crossings documented in U.S. Customs and Border Protection data showing over 400 migrant deaths in the Tucson sector alone from 1998 to 2015 due to environmental causes. The narrative frames immigration as a humanitarian crisis exacerbated by individual actors, with the migrants depicted as faceless everymen lacking detailed backstories to highlight the dehumanizing effects of the journey, as intended by director Jonás Cuarón. Opposing the migrants is Sam (), a lone American vigilante who systematically hunts them with a high-powered from his , symbolizing unchecked nativism fueled by inflammatory . Cuarón drew inspiration from overhearing anti-immigrant sentiments during a 2009 trip to , conceiving the film to critique how political discourse scapegoats migrants and incites violence, a view he linked to figures like in 2015 interviews. Sam's actions, including killing migrants one by one without dialogue explaining his motives beyond implied resentment, position him as a monstrous embodiment of , echoing real incidents like those reported by the involving armed civilian patrols in the 2000s and 2010s, though the film omits any exploration of rates or gaps that restrictionists cite as justifications for heightened . This binary depiction—sympathetic migrants versus a psychopathic enforcer—has been analyzed as a thriller allegory for U.S.- border tensions, with Cuarón stating in that it distills into "charged emotions" to provoke discussion on rhetoric's consequences rather than policy solutions. Bernal echoed this in interviews, asserting migration itself "is not a problem" but is politicized to breed hostility, aligning the film with pro-openness perspectives prevalent in Hollywood productions. Critics in outlets like The Atlantic interpreted it as a timely horror narrative amid election debates, portraying vigilante killings as akin to rising , yet some analyses noted its lack of depth in or migrant agency, potentially reinforcing simplistic victim-perpetrator dynamics over causal factors like unauthorized entry's scale—over 11 million encounters from 2010 to per records—without addressing deterrence or legal pathways. The film's release coincided with heightened public discourse, including Trump's border wall proposals, but it prioritizes visceral survival over empirical debate on net migration impacts, such as labor market effects or fiscal costs estimated by the at $116 billion annually in .

Accusations of Ideological Bias

Critics have accused Desierto of exhibiting left-leaning ideological bias through its portrayal of border vigilantes as one-dimensional villains driven solely by , while presenting undocumented migrants as uniformly sympathetic victims devoid of agency or contextual complexities in immigration policy. The film's narrative frames the American character, played by , as a monstrous hunter whose actions symbolize broader , without exploring potential motivations rooted in concerns over illegal crossings, , or national . This reductive depiction, according to some reviewers, serves as thinly veiled for laxer enforcement, aligning with progressive critiques of restrictionist policies. The Hollywood Reporter's review highlighted the film's "reductive view of immigrant and border issues," arguing that its simplistic moral binaries undermine any deeper engagement with the subject matter, prioritizing ideological messaging over balanced storytelling. Similarly, the noted that the movie's "clean demarcations between " could alienate audiences by ignoring nuances in the real-world debate, such as economic strains or security risks associated with mass unauthorized migration. These critiques suggest the film functions more as political allegory than neutral thriller, especially given director Jonás Cuarón's public statements decrying anti-immigrant "" as , which echo left-liberal framings of border enforcement as inherently hateful. Further commentary in media analyses has positioned Desierto within a pattern of Hollywood productions advancing liberal ideologies on immigration, where films like this amplify narratives of migrant victimhood while sidelining counterarguments, potentially contributing to polarized public discourse. Producer and star Gael García Bernal's promotional remarks, describing the story as a "nightmare" born from divisive rhetoric, reinforced perceptions of the film as partisan, with little acknowledgment of empirical data on immigration's fiscal or cultural impacts. Although mainstream outlets largely commended its timeliness amid 2016 U.S. election debates, dissenting voices argued this reflected institutional biases favoring emotive, one-sided portrayals over causal analysis of policy trade-offs.

Real-World Border Policy Implications

The film Desierto portrays a solitary American conducting lethal enforcement against undocumented migrants in the absence of depicted official intervention, reflecting broader debates on the adequacy of U.S. border security measures during a period of fluctuating illegal crossings. In fiscal year 2015, U.S. Border Patrol agents apprehended 337,117 individuals attempting unauthorized entry along the southwest border, a decline from prior years but indicative of sustained pressure on enforcement resources. This volume contributed to operational strains, prompting discussions on supplementary measures like physical barriers and increased patrols, which some analysts argue deter high-risk desert traversals responsible for migrant fatalities. Real-world vigilante activities, unlike the film's isolated killer archetype, have historically involved citizen groups such as the , which from 2005 onward conducted non-lethal observations and reports to authorities to highlight enforcement gaps amid apprehensions exceeding 1 million annually in peak years prior to 2015. These efforts influenced policy by publicizing vulnerabilities, leading to expansions in Border Patrol staffing under the , though federal officials have consistently rejected armed civilian involvement to avoid legal and safety risks. The film's director, , drew inspiration from encounters with anti-immigrant rhetoric in , framing vigilantes as symptoms of rather than responses to systemic overload, a perspective echoed in promotional interviews emphasizing migrant humanity over enforcement necessities. Empirical data underscores causal links between porous borders and humanitarian costs: at least 330 migrant deaths were recorded along the U.S.-Mexico border in 2015, primarily from and exposure in remote areas migrants select to evade detection, with undercounts suggested by local examiners reporting over twice the federal figures in key sectors. responses, including targeted , have correlated with reduced overall crossings and apprehensions in subsequent low-migration periods, implying that amplified could mitigate such tragedies by discouraging attempts rather than relying on ad hoc civilian actions critiqued in the film. Cuarón has advocated for dialogue to counter "hateful" narratives, positioning Desierto as a call for reformed pathways over fortified borders, though this overlooks documented associations between unchecked entries and downstream fiscal burdens estimated at billions annually in public services.

References

  1. https://variety.com/2016/artisans/production/jonas-cuaron-desierto-1201900512/
  2. https://www.motionpictures.org/2016/09/jonas-cuaron-talks-about-his-savagely-intense-film-desierto/
  3. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3147312/plotsummary/
  4. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/desierto_2016
  5. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3147312/
  6. https://kinotuskanac.hr/en/movie/ostavljeni
  7. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3147312/awards/
  8. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-reviews/desierto-review-822868/
  9. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2015/sep/16/desierto-review-immigration-parable-toronto-film-festival-gael-garcia-bernal
  10. https://www.screendaily.com/features/jonas-cuaron-talks-the-highs-and-lows-of-making-desierto/5095614.article
  11. https://www.kpbs.org/news/midday-edition/2016/10/14/playing-cat-and-mouse-desierto
  12. https://holacultura.com/interview-with-desierto-director-jonas-cuaron/
  13. https://www.elpasotimes.com/story/entertainment/movies/2016/10/11/desierto-thrilling-immigration-horror-story/91924890/
  14. https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt3147312/credits/
  15. https://www.movieinsider.com/m12009/desierto
  16. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3147312/fullcredits/
  17. https://www.themoviedb.org/movie/258363-desierto/cast?language=en-US
  18. https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/desierto-2016
  19. https://theactionelite.com/desierto-2015-review/
  20. https://deadline.com/2016/10/desierto-review-gael-garcia-bernal-jeffrey-dean-morgan-jonas-cuaron-1201834307/
  21. https://www.horrorhomeroom.com/cuarons-desierto-rise-white-man-monster/
  22. https://www.thewrap.com/desierto-review/
  23. https://www.indiewire.com/features/general/desierto-review-gael-garcia-bernal-jonas-cuaron-trump-immigration-1201736496/
  24. https://collider.com/desierto-review-tiff-2015/
  25. https://www.creativescreenwriting.com/desierto/
  26. https://www.cinemablend.com/news/1566889/why-jeffrey-dean-morgans-desierto-backstory-was-completely-cut-from-the-film
  27. https://www.cbr.com/jeffrey-dean-morgan-on-playing-desiertos-complex-villain/
  28. https://www.screendaily.com/reviews/desierto-review/5093071.article
  29. https://borderlandshistory.org/2016/09/02/film-notes-dread-and-despair-in-desierto/
  30. https://usafacts.org/articles/how-many-people-die-crossing-the-us-mexico-border/
  31. https://newsroom.ucla.edu/releases/how-dehydration-leads-to-migrant-deaths-in-desert
  32. https://time.com/4527000/desierto-immigration-donald-trump-gael-garcia-bernal/
  33. https://www.iom.int/news/us-mexico-border-worlds-deadliest-migration-land-route
  34. https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2016/10/desierto-movie-review/503993/
  35. https://forumtogether.org/article/explainer-migrant-deaths-at-the-border/
  36. https://www.moriareviews.com/horror/desierto-2015.htm
  37. https://remezcla.com/features/film/desierto-interview-gael-garcia-bernal-jonas-cuaron/
  38. https://thecriticalcritics.com/reviews/movie-review-desierto/
  39. https://variety.com/2015/film/markets-festivals/stx-entertainment-acquires-thriller-desierto-after-toronto-debut-exclusive-1201604193/
  40. https://variety.com/2015/film/festivals/morelia-desierto-cinepolis-distribucion-1201627415/
  41. https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt3147312/
  42. https://www.the-numbers.com/movie/Desierto
  43. https://www.metacritic.com/movie/desierto/
  44. https://variety.com/2015/film/festivals/toronto-film-review-desierto-1201595641/
  45. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/14/movies/desierto-review-jonas-cuaron-gael-garcia-bernal.html
  46. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3147312/reviews/
  47. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3147312/ratings/
  48. https://fipresci.org/awards/desierto/
  49. https://www.latimes.com/espanol/entretenimiento/articulo/2016-09-14/hoyla-ent-mexico-apuesta-por-desierto-de-jonas-cuaron-para-el-oscar-20160914
  50. https://www.pimientafilms.com/en/desierto-en/
  51. https://www.reuters.com/article/lifestyle/migration-not-a-problem-desierto-film-star-garca-bernal-says-idUSKCN0RF1RA/
  52. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/general-news/desierto-director-jonas-cuaron-says-848316/
  53. https://laist.com/shows/take-two/desierto-explores-the-charged-emotions-of-immigration
  54. https://www.chicagotribune.com/2016/03/03/desierto-review-jeffrey-dean-morgan-gael-garcia-bernal-star-in-immigrant-cat-and-mouse-tale/
  55. https://lrmonline.com/news/politics-and-the-movies-why-do-democrats-go-to-the-movies-more-opinion/
  56. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/movies/la-et-mn-desierto-gael-garcia-bernal-feature-20161006-snap-story.html
  57. https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/blog/understanding-dhs-2015-deportation-numbers/
  58. https://www.aclu.org/border-humanity-project-aclus-fight-for-humanity-at-the-border
  59. https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/RL33353.html
  60. https://www.iom.int/news/iom-counts-3771-migrant-fatalities-mediterranean-2015
  61. https://www.migrationpolicy.org/news/crisis-border-not-numbers
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.