Hubbry Logo
Earring Magic KenEarring Magic KenMain
Open search
Earring Magic Ken
Community hub
Earring Magic Ken
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Earring Magic Ken
Earring Magic Ken
Earring Magic Ken
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Earring Magic Ken
Earring Magic Ken inside the product box; front side displayed
TypeFashion doll
Invented byRuth Handler
CompanyMattel
CountryUnited States

Earring Magic Ken, also known as "Gay Ken" and "Fey Ken",[1] is a model of the Ken doll introduced by Mattel in 1993 as a companion to its Earring Magic Barbie figure, one of five dolls in the Earring Magic Barbie line.[2][3]

The doll is notable for inspiring a toy craze among gay men (including some claims that it was the highest selling Ken doll of all time) and for the controversy that ensued upon its debut.

The doll

[edit]

Mattel had conducted a survey of girls asking if Ken should be retained as Barbie's boyfriend or whether a new doll should be introduced in that role.[4] Survey results indicated that girls wanted Ken kept but wanted him to look "cooler".[4] USA Today noted after the American International Toy Fair that the doll Soul Train Jamal, from the Shani doll line, was also wearing an earring that year.[5] According to manager of marketing communications for Mattel, Lisa McKendall, "We tried to keep [Ken] as cool as possible."[5] This model of the Ken doll was dressed in a lavender mesh shirt, purple pleather vest, a necklace with a circular charm and, as the name indicates, an earring in his left ear.[6][7]

These clothing choices led to gay commentator Dan Savage joking that Mattel toy designers had "spent a weekend in LA or New York dashing from rave to rave, taking notes and Polaroids."[8] He also suggested that little girls' idea of coolness was shaped by homoerotic MTV music videos, Madonna's dancers, and what ACT UP/Queer Nation members were wearing to demonstrations and parties.[8] Donna Gibbs told the San Francisco Examiner in November 1993 that the team of women who made the doll were surprised that gay men wanted him.[2] Art historian Erica Rand and feminist writer Ann Ducille both cast doubt on this claim in 1995 and 1996 respectively.[3][9] In 2021, former designer Carol Spencer told Mel Magazine that discussion about Earring Magic Ken's gay aesthetic did occur at Mattel.[10] According to Spencer, "the male Mattel designer – who was married with several children and working on the project – sa[id] to me: 'They will turn Ken gay with this doll!'"[11]

Media reception

[edit]

On February 11, 1993, Carol Lawson at The New York Times responded to his unveiling at the American International Toy Fair with the claim that Mattel was attempting to "gender bend" Ken by making him appeal to both boys and girls.[6] She also suggested that selling Ken as gender non-conforming may have been a subtle apology for a Barbie with a voice box that said "Math class is tough!" in 1992.[6] 1993 saw Mattel and other toy companies experimenting with selling girl toys to boys, and vice versa as a larger sales trend.[6] Manager of marketing communications for Mattel, Lisa McKendall, told The New York Times "We never would have done this a few years ago. But now you see more earrings on men. They are more accepted in day-to-day life. We are trying to keep Ken updated."[6] The article discussing Ken's "gender-bending" went on to be syndicated throughout North America, including the Seattle Post-Intelligencer,[6] the Vancouver Sun,[6] and the Philadelphia Daily News.[12]

Several days later, Frank DeCaro responded to this article in Newsday, writing, "Ever since Mattel introduced Earring Magic Ken a few weeks ago, people have been wondering whether there's something more in the Dream House closet than a few Bob Mackie originals and some two-inch-wide [5 cm] hangers."[13] He pointed out that other Ken dolls released recently, such as Sun Sensation Ken and Western Stampin' Ken, seemed to be "pushing the envelope of macho wardrobe acceptability" by wearing a crop top and chaps, respectively.[13] Donna Gibbs, director of media relations at Mattel, emphasized that his look was not attempting to be controversial, saying, "Ken's still a clean-cut guy, but he's just a little more contemporary [. . .] Men are wearing earrings today, it's become a mainstream phenomenon. So Ken should have an earring, why not?"[13] As with the New York Times article, this syndicated widely across North America.

Backlash against Ken's gender non-conformity followed shortly after. In another widely syndicated article, opinion writer Tom Zucco expressed extreme distaste for Ken's recent outfits in the Saint Petersburg Times.[14] He referred to Ken's style transformation as "disturbing" and said that "Little girls of America need to know that most of us are not and never have been like Ken [. . .] In reality, most of us aren't very glamorous or flamboyant. We don't want to be glamorous or flamboyant. We can't even spell glamorous or flamboyant."[14] Zucco purchased Sun Sensation Ken for his daughter (because Earring Magic Ken was not yet on sale) and remarked that her enjoyment of the toy must be due to "a slick marketing campaign by Mattel, peer pressure, and the fact that The World Is Going To Hell In A Handbasket!"[14]

In the March 23, 1993 issue of gay magazine The Advocate, Denise Lessard suggested that gay men would soon be "paying more attention to [Barbie's] boyfriend Ken" due to his rebranding.[15] She described Earring Magic Ken's outfit as "sport[ing] streaked hair, a mesh (!) top, neck chains, a purple leathery vest, and an earring."[15] This March blurb in The Advocate (misidentified as a February blurb in several sources) would later be reported as the publication that suggested to gay men that they should buy the doll.[1][16] Gay publication Genre also discussed the doll during this time.[1]

In July 1993, Dan Savage wrote an article on Earring Magic Ken titled, "Ken Comes Out."[8] He noted in his article that, in addition to his outfit's perceived flamboyance, his necklace resembled a chrome cock ring that some gay men were wearing as charms at the time.[8] Amelia Jones considers the cock ring to have been the defining accessory of the doll that cast doubt on Mattel's insistence that it had no relation to gay fashion.[3] Savage expressed feelings of ambivalence about Ken's new style, writing, "Queer Ken is the high water mark of, depending on your point of view, either queer infiltration of popular culture or the thoughtless appropriation of queer culture by heterosexuals [. . .] Queer imagery has so permeated our culture that from rock stars (Axl Rose and his leather chaps) to toy designers, mainstream America isn't even aware when it's adopting queer fashions and mores."[8]

Despite the controversy, Donna Gibbs from Mattel told the Wall Street Journal in August 1993 that, "Everybody loves Barbie and we're pleased that [gay men] are finding something to enjoy in our products as well."[17] However, by October 1993, Lisa McKendall was phrasing this statement to the Bay Area Reporter as, "if there are 'other people' who enjoy our product, of course we're pleased" and emphasizing that Ken was "wholesome."[18] Donna Gibbs told the San Francisco Examiner in November 1993, "The Ken doll was not intentionally designed for any audience other than our primary one, girls ages 3 to 10."[2]

Earring Magic Ken was a fixture in popular culture throughout 1993. He was joked about on The Tonight Show with Jay Leno[4] and on the premiere of the short-lived Chevy Chase Show.[19] The doll was awarded "Dubious Achievements of 1993" by Esquire alongside gaffes by baseball player Darryl Strawberry and actor Richard Gere.[20]

Consumer reception

[edit]

Kitsch-minded gay men responded to this press by buying the doll in record numbers, making Earring Magic Ken the best-selling Ken model in Mattel's history.[10] The doll debuted in stores for around $11 (equivalent to $24 in 2024) and had completely sold out by the Christmas season, largely due to gay men buying the doll in droves.[21] Due to high demand, Chicago's FAO Schwarz created a wait list, and, allegedly, some shops in San Francisco began to sell Earring Magic Ken for prices ranging from $17 to $24 (equivalent to $37 to $52 in 2024).[1] (The latter claim was disputed in the Bay Area Reporter in October 1993 by the general manager of San Francisco FAO Schwarz.[16] According to him, only a few gay men were coming into his store, and Earring Magic Ken was selling better in New York and Chicago than San Francisco.)[16] Earring Magic Ken was also popular with gay men in the United Kingdom, and sold well at the toy shop Hamleys in 1993.[22] Toy scalper Mr. Barger told the Wall Street Journal in 1996 that Earring Magic Ken was so popular that he was able to re-sell him to specialty shops at premium prices.[23] Richard Roeper, writing for the Chicago Sun Times, referred to him as "The Cabbage Patch Doll of the summer of '93."[24]

A major appeal of the doll for many gay men was that Mattel did not market it to them on purpose.[25] Rick Garcia, director of Chicago's Catholic Advocates for Lesbian and Gay Rights, told People magazine in 1993 that the stereotypical dress was funny to him because he believed it was an accident, and that it would have offended him if it was purposeful.[25] In 1993, many newspapers interviewed individual gay men in California to understand the phenomenon. A San Francisco resident described Earring Magic Ken as, "a pariah setting foot in one of America's sanctuaries."[17] Another California resident, Bill Harley, described Earring Magic Ken as, "A campy, funny thing to have."[26] Laguna Beach resident Keith Clark-Epley had more reservations about the toy, saying that, "It's an uptight heterosexual male doll following gay fashion and who is still behind the times," and believed that calling the doll gay could potentially reinforce negative stereotypes about gay people.[27]

In the ensuing decades, it has become common for news articles[28][29][30] and trivia books[4] to claim that Dan Savage's article is what led Mattel to discontinue Earring Magic Ken. This rumor first appeared in a 1994 review of Dan Savage's new radio show, "Strange and Stranger," in which the reviewer says that Savage scared Mattel into shelving the toy[31] and was repeated in the 2005 book Brand Failures: The Truth About the Biggest Branding Mistakes of All Time.[4] However, upon questioning by Ann Ducille in 1996 for her essay, "Toy Theory: Black Barbie and The Deep Play of Difference," Mattel denied that Earring Magic Ken was pulled from the market for reasons other than standard discontinuation practices.[32] In the '90s, Mattel changed 98% of their Barbie line each year,[33] and was distributing coupons for Christmas shopping to encourage sales of their toys as early as August 1993.[34] No Earring Magic Barbie products (including the Barbie dolls that made up the majority of the collection) were sold after 1993.[35] In 2021, the toy collector Cammy told Mel Magazine that the six-month window Earring Magic Ken was on the shelves was very normal for a seasonal fashion doll.[11]

Legacy

[edit]

Earring Magic Ken has been displayed at several museums as an example of both gay pride and brand failures, including the Missouri History Museum,[36] the National Museum of Play,[37] the Fleming Museum,[38] and the New York Historical Society.[39] Earring Magic Ken appeared — with a changed necklace — as a character in the 2023 film Barbie, played by Tom Stourton, alongside Sugar Daddy Ken as a pair of discontinued Ken dolls.

See also

[edit]
Listen to this article (2 minutes)
Spoken Wikipedia icon
This audio file was created from a revision of this article dated 9 October 2014 (2014-10-09), and does not reflect subsequent edits.
(Audio help · More spoken articles)

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Earring Magic Ken

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

is a model of the Ken doll manufactured by in 1993 as a companion to the Earring Magic line, featuring two-tone blonde hair, a silver hoop in the left ear, lilac net shirt, lilac vinyl vest, black pants with pink stitching, silver , and black oxfords. The doll's design stemmed from input by young girls desiring a "cooler," MTV-inspired update to the traditional Ken figure. Despite targeting children, its styling—including a resembling a chrome ring associated with adult accessories in gay club culture—sparked perceptions of homosexual coding, driving cult demand among and positioning it as one of the top-selling Ken variants of its era. responded to parental and media backlash by swiftly discontinuing the doll, apologizing for unintended associations, and pulling it from shelves, which only amplified collector interest.

Origins and Development

Focus Group Research

Mattel conducted sessions with approximately five-year-old girls in the early to address declining sales of Ken dolls and refresh the character's image, which participants viewed as outdated. The young respondents indicated a preference for a "cooler" Ken, emphasizing updates that would align with perceived trendy or edgy . A prominent recommendation from these groups was adding a single to Ken's design, with girls citing influences like rock stars as a means to boost his appeal and make him more relatable to contemporary . This input shaped the core feature of the Earring Magic Ken variant, intended as a companion to the Earring Magic line. Company representatives later attributed the doll's stylistic overhaul—marking Ken's first major redesign since his 1961 debut—to findings from these consumer research efforts, underscoring the role of child feedback in product iteration. The process highlighted how direct input from the target demographic could lead to unintended cultural interpretations post-launch, though framed it as a straightforward response to demands for modernization.

Design and Production Choices


Mattel designed Earring Magic Ken in 1993 as a companion doll to the Earring Magic Barbie line, aiming to modernize Ken's appearance to better appeal to contemporary children. The company conducted focus groups with five- to six-year-old girls to identify elements perceived as "cool" for a male doll, leading to key stylistic choices including a ponytail hairstyle, blonde highlights, and an earring in the left ear. These features were selected based on the girls' preferences for edgier, fashion-forward looks inspired by early 1990s trends, rather than adult cultural interpretations. The production incorporated thematic accessories tied to the Earring Magic concept, such as changeable earrings and a silver with a clear loop intended as a trendy, masculine jewelry piece to enhance the doll's modern vibe. choices featured a , a vinyl vest with stitching, and pants with matching details, all crafted from typical doll materials like vinyl and fabric to align with the line's emphasis on customizable play. Mattel's team prioritized vibrant colors and unconventional textures to differentiate Ken from prior iterations, reflecting the feedback without explicit intent to evoke specific subcultural aesthetics. As a limited-edition release within the broader ecosystem, production was scaled for seasonal distribution, utilizing Mattel's standard injection-molded vinyl manufacturing processes but with specialized painting for the two-tone hair and metallic accents. The 's mold, including articulated joints for posing, followed established Ken prototypes, but the unique ensemble marked a departure from conservative styling, driven by empirical input from child consumers over traditional market assumptions. This approach underscored Mattel's reliance on direct youth validation for product iteration, though it overlooked potential adult perceptions of the resulting flamboyant silhouette.

Product Description

Physical Appearance

Earring Magic Ken is a 12-inch articulated manufactured by in 1993 as part of the Earring Magic line. The doll depicts a male figure with blonde hair featuring chunky highlights styled in a . It has a muscular, buff physique akin to action figures, with jointed elbows, wrists, and knees for posing. The doll's outfit consists of a sheer long-sleeve layered under a faux or pleather vest. It wears dark faux pants and black lace-up oxford shoes or loafers. Distinctive accessories include a silver hoop clipped to the left ear and a prominent silver circle worn around the neck, which some observers noted resembled a due to its design and placement. The doll also comes with a matching clip-on sized for human wear, intended for children playing with the .

Accessories and Packaging

The Earring Magic Ken doll, model number 2290, was packaged in a standard rectangular cardboard box measuring approximately 13 inches tall, featuring a clear window on the front to display the doll. The box artwork highlighted the doll in its full outfit against a vibrant background, with the product name "Earring Magic Ken" prominently printed above and branding elements emphasizing the "Earring Magic" line's theme of customizable earrings. Accessories included with the doll consisted primarily of its dressed ensemble: black pants accented with pink stitching, a lilac mesh sleeveless shirt, a lilac vinyl vest featuring pink stitching and a attached silver ring detail, and a necklace formed by a silver chain threaded through a large silver ring pendant. The doll also came with a single removable silver hoop earring, aligning with the line's focus on earring play, though Ken variants lacked the interchangeable earring options available for Barbie counterparts. No additional standalone items, such as extra outfits, stands, or grooming tools, were included in the standard packaging.

Launch and Initial Marketing

1993 Release Details

Earring Magic Ken was released by in 1993 as a companion to the Earring Magic line, aimed at updating Ken's image to appeal to contemporary trends. The doll was first unveiled at the American International Toy Fair in in February 1993, where it drew early attention for its redesigned appearance. priced the at $11 upon market launch, positioning it as an affordable accessory to the ecosystem. Initial distribution focused on major toy retailers, with availability expanding through the spring and summer of 1993. By May 1993, media coverage had begun highlighting the doll's distinctive features, contributing to buzz ahead of peak holiday sales. Stock depleted rapidly, with most stores reporting complete sell-outs by Christmas 1993, indicating strong consumer demand despite emerging criticisms. Various accounts describe it as the best-selling Ken variant in Mattel's history, though official sales figures from the company remain undisclosed.

Target Audience and Promotion

Earring Magic Ken was designed for , particularly those aged around five years, who formed the core demographic for doll play. Mattel derived this targeting from workshops with children in this age range, who indicated waning interest in traditional Ken figures and requested a more contemporary, "cool" version to enhance scenarios with . The research emphasized elements like removable earrings and stylish attire to align with children's exposure to , such as on , without intending appeal to adult collectors or specific subcultures. The doll's promotion centered on its role within the Earring Magic Barbie product line, marketed as an accessory-focused extension to foster creative customization among child users. Mattel positioned Earring Magic Ken as a trendy boyfriend figure, with advertising and packaging showcasing clip-on earrings and fashion-forward clothing like a mesh shirt and vest to evoke playful modernity suitable for girls' imaginative games. Released in as one of six dolls in the series, the strategy aimed to reverse sluggish Ken sales by refreshing the character's image through standard retail channels and seasonal campaigns, though specific advertisement details emphasized the line's overall interactive features rather than Ken individually.

Consumer Reception

Mainstream Sales and Popularity

Despite Mattel's intent to revitalize Ken's appeal among young girls through focus group research indicating a desire for more fashionable accessories like earrings, Earring Magic Ken failed to achieve significant traction with its primary target audience of children and families. The doll's mature styling, including a mesh shirt, ponytail, and silver necklace, was perceived as too adult-oriented for five-year-old girls, leading to lackluster initial sales in mainstream retail channels. This misalignment with child preferences contributed to the doll not fulfilling its commercial goal of boosting Ken doll purchases among the core demographic, as evidenced by ongoing concerns over Ken's declining popularity post-release. While the doll retailed for approximately $11 upon its February 1993 debut and reportedly sold out in many stores by the season, this depletion of stock did not reflect broad mainstream popularity driven by family buyers. Instead, available points to limited uptake from parents and children, with the overall attributed more to unintended collector than sustained from the intended market. Claims of Earring Magic Ken as the highest-selling Ken variant ever remain unverified by official data and are not supported as stemming from mainstream child-oriented sales.

Adoption in Gay Communities

Following the release of Earring Magic Ken in early 1993, the doll gained significant traction within gay male subcultures, primarily due to its resemblance to contemporaneous queer fashion trends, including a lavender mesh shirt, purple faux-leather vest, single earring, and a chrome-ring necklace widely interpreted as evoking a cock ring—a accessory associated with gay nightlife and BDSM aesthetics. This perception was amplified by sex advice columnist Dan Savage's July 1993 article "Ken Comes Out," published in The Stranger, where he described the doll as embodying a "queer Ken" inadvertently produced by Mattel's focus group research on hipper styles, stating, "The little girls of our great nation wanted a hipper Ken, and Mattel gave them a queer Ken. He may not have a bulge, but he's got a cock ring." Savage's piece, which highlighted the doll's "fruity" appearance and accessories mirroring MTV-influenced iconography (such as elements seen in performers like Prince or Madonna's dancers), prompted to purchase the doll ironically as a collectible and symbol of inadvertent corporate gay-coding. The resulting demand created a collector's frenzy, with reports of rapidly depleting stock from retailers, contributing to claims that it became the best-selling Ken variant in history despite availability limited to approximately six weeks before Mattel's discontinuation and partial recall in mid-1993. prices for mint-in-box examples subsequently rose from the original $11 retail to around $47 by the late , reflecting sustained interest among LGBTQ+ collectors. The doll's adoption extended its cultural footprint, positioning it as an accidental gay icon and touchstone for discussions of queer visibility in mainstream consumer products, with enduring references in media and even a cameo in the 2023 Barbie film underscoring its legacy within gay communities. Despite Mattel's intent to appeal to young girls via trendy updates, the unintended resonance with adult gay aesthetics led to its embrace as a subversive artifact, though exact sales figures attributable to gay buyers remain unverified by the company.

Media Coverage

Early Reports and Buzz

Earring Magic Ken was unveiled by at the American International Toy Fair in New York in February 1993, as a companion to the Earring Magic Barbie doll line designed to incorporate interchangeable earrings as a play feature. Initial media coverage portrayed the doll as an innovative update to Ken's traditional image, reflecting feedback from young girls who requested that Ken adopt an earring to coordinate with 's accessories. marketing manager Lisa McKendall described the addition of the earring, purple mesh vest, and as a "big breakthrough" in modernizing the doll for contemporary play patterns. Early reports in outlets like emphasized the toy's role in challenging gender stereotypes in playthings, positioning it alongside other industry efforts to diversify doll aesthetics amid shifting cultural norms in the early 1990s. By March 1993, some coverage began questioning the doll's masculine appeal, with critiquing its "faddish" styling in contrast to more explicit European toy lines, signaling emerging among mainstream observers. This initial buzz centered on retail previews and toy industry trade discussions, generating moderate interest in Ken's revamped look before broader cultural interpretations emerged later in the year.

Dan Savage's Influence

Dan Savage, a sex advice columnist for the Seattle alternative weekly The Stranger, published a 1993 column that drew widespread attention to Earring Magic Ken's design elements, framing them as inadvertently queer-coded. Savage highlighted the doll's purple mesh tank top, high-heeled black boots, and ponytail as echoing early 1990s gay rave attire, while specifically identifying the silver loop necklace as resembling a —a common accessory in gay club scenes at the time. In the article, Savage dubbed the doll "Queer Ken," positing that Mattel's focus groups—aimed at creating a "hipper" companion for Earring Magic Barbie—had unwittingly produced a version appealing to aesthetics rather than heterosexual teen trends. He wrote: "The little girls of our great nation wanted a hipper Ken, and gave them a hip Ken. A Ken." This interpretation, rooted in Savage's firsthand observations of Seattle's subculture, resonated amid the era's rising visibility of rave and club fashion influenced by scenes. Savage's column spurred demand among , who began purchasing the en masse as a kitschy , leading retailers to report stock shortages by mid-1993. This adoption transformed Earring Magic Ken from a limited-edition seasonal release into the fastest-selling and highest-volume Ken variant in 's history up to that point, with estimates of over 350,000 units sold in under six months—far exceeding typical Ken sales. While attributed initial success to broad appeal, Savage's piece is credited by observers with catalyzing the surge in communities, prompting the company to halt production amid the unintended buzz.

Controversy and Criticisms

Perceptions of Gay Coding

Upon its 1993 release, Earring Magic Ken's design elements—such as a single silver hoop earring in the left ear, a purple mesh T-shirt under a shiny vest, tight pants, and a necklace with a prominent clear plastic loop—prompted perceptions among observers that the doll evoked stereotypes of early 1990s gay male rave and club attire. The left-ear earring, in particular, aligned with a cultural shorthand from the 1980s and 1990s where such placement signaled homosexuality among men. The necklace drew specific scrutiny, with gay community members and commentators interpreting its looped design as resembling a cock ring, an accessory linked to queer nightlife, BDSM, and fetish elements prevalent in urban gay subcultures during the AIDS era. Columnist Dan Savage amplified this view in a 1993 Chicago Reader piece, describing the doll's overall aesthetic as unintentionally capturing "the gayest doll ever created" through its campy, metrosexual styling that mirrored perceptions of flamboyant gay fashion. These interpretations relied on contemporaneous stereotypes of gay men as fashion-forward, kinky, and tied to nightlife scenes, though Mattel maintained the features stemmed from focus group feedback aiming for an "edgy" MTV-inspired look without queer intent. Such perceptions contributed to the doll's embrace as an accidental icon within gay circles, where it symbolized rare, unintended visibility amid broader cultural homophobia, despite lacking explicit endorsement from . Critics noted that the coding was subjective, hinging on visual cues like the mesh top and highlighted blond hair that aligned with tropes later normalized but then associated primarily with gay aesthetics.

Accusations Against Mattel

Critics accused of cultural insensitivity for designing Earring Magic Ken with features—such as a silver loop necklace resembling a used in , a purple mesh shirt, and a left-ear —that inadvertently signaled homoerotic appeal, despite the doll's intended role as a companion to the tween-targeted Earring Magic line released in early 1993. Columnist , in a May 1993 Chicago Reader article, lambasted for apparent cluelessness about these connotations, writing that the design team seemed to have "spent a weekend in [L.A.](/page/L(a) or New York dashing from to ," and he encouraged to buy the en masse, which propelled it to become the best-selling Ken variant in history. Mattel faced further accusations of denial and potential homophobia when the company publicly rejected any queer intent behind the doll's aesthetics, with spokesperson Lisa McKendall stating, "Absolutely not. It’s a necklace… We’re not in the business of putting cock rings into the hands of little girls!" Internal discussions at Mattel reportedly acknowledged the risk, as former designer Carol Spencer later recounted a male colleague warning during development, "They will turn Ken gay with this doll!" yet the company proceeded without adjustments. Additional criticisms targeted 's decision to discontinue the doll after approximately six months, interpreting the move as a panicked retreat from its unexpected popularity among gay consumers rather than a standard end, especially given the surge in sales driven by Savage's column and word-of-mouth in LGBTQ+ circles. issued an apology for the "unintended association with an adult sexual accessory" but maintained the design stemmed from requests for a more "urban" look to appeal to girls aged 9-12, without addressing the broader cultural fallout. These accusations highlighted perceived failures in and a reluctance to embrace or even recognize the doll's appeal beyond its target demographic.

Mattel's Response and Discontinuation

Corporate Decisions

Mattel developed Earring Magic Ken as a companion doll to the Earring Magic Barbie line, launched in early 1993, following internal market research conducted via focus groups with teenage girls. These groups expressed a desire for a more contemporary Ken doll, specifically requesting an earring to align with 1990s fashion trends influenced by pop culture icons like Madonna, prompting designers to incorporate elements such as a single earring, a mesh shirt, lavender mesh vest and pants, a ponytail, and a silver neck chain. The necklace design, which later drew scrutiny for resembling a cock ring, stemmed from efforts to modernize Ken's accessories, with artists drawing inspiration from nightlife venues like Studio 54 to appeal to a youthful, edgy aesthetic targeted at girls aged 9-12. Upon the doll's release, initially monitored its performance, which exceeded expectations by becoming the best-selling Ken variant in company history during its brief run, driven partly by unanticipated demand from adult male collectors. However, as media coverage and consumer buzz—particularly Dan Savage's column highlighting the doll's "gay coding"—amplified perceptions of the design as overtly homosexual, internal discussions at acknowledged the aesthetic's unintended queer connotations, leading to executive discomfort. In response, opted for abrupt discontinuation approximately six months after launch, withdrawing remaining stock from retail shelves despite ongoing sales momentum, a move former designer Carol Spencer later confirmed involved explicit deliberations over the doll's gay associations. The company publicly maintained that the pull aligned with routine product lifecycle practices rather than external pressure, though contemporaneous reports and the speed of the decision suggest aversion to as a key factor. No formal apology was issued, but the action effectively suppressed further production and distribution to mitigate reputational risks associated with the doll's niche popularity.

Reasons and Timeline

Mattel released Earring Magic Ken in early 1993 as part of the Earring Magic Barbie line, with the doll first showcased at the American International Toy Fair in in February 1993. By May 1993, it reached retail shelves, coinciding with initial media reports on its unconventional design features, including a silver hoop earring, mesh shirt, and a necklace with a ring pendant that some likened to a . The doll's rapid adoption in gay communities and coverage in outlets like The Stranger amplified buzz through the summer, positioning it as an inadvertent cultural phenomenon among adult collectors rather than its intended young female audience. Discontinuation occurred abruptly approximately six months after release, around , with halting production and recalling remaining stock from stores without issuing a formal recall notice or public explanation at the time. This timeline aligned with escalating media scrutiny and internal concerns at over the doll's perceived "gay coding," including stereotypes like the earring and jewelry that clashed with the company's family-oriented branding. Former employees later recounted internal "murmurs" about the doll's homosexual undertones, suggesting executives viewed it as an unintended marketing misfire that risked alienating conservative consumers and complicating sales to children. The core reasons for discontinuation centered on damage control amid the controversy, as the doll's popularity stemmed largely from ironic purchases by rather than organic demand from girls aged 6-12, per 's research that had initially inspired the "cooler" redesign. Despite record sales—reportedly the highest for any Ken variant— prioritized avoiding prolonged association with LGBTQ+ icon status, which conflicted with its conservative corporate stance in the early and potential backlash from parents perceiving the doll as promoting non-traditional . No evidence supports claims of widespread parental complaints driving the decision; instead, the pull reflected strategic retreat from a product that deviated from core market expectations, even as it boosted short-term revenue.

Commercial Outcomes

Sales Data and Records

Despite initial controversy, Earring Magic Ken achieved unusually strong sales for a Ken doll variant, with reports indicating sell-outs in many stores by Christmas 1993, driven largely by purchases from gay consumers responding to media buzz. The doll, released in early 1993 as part of Mattel's Earring Magic line, remained on shelves for approximately six months before discontinuation, yet it outperformed typical Ken models during that period. Multiple accounts describe it as the best-selling Ken doll in Mattel's history, attributing this to ironic demand sparked by perceptions of its "gay-coded" design rather than broad mainstream appeal. Exact sales figures, however, have never been publicly released by Mattel, leaving assessments reliant on anecdotal reports and secondary analyses of market response. Post-discontinuation scarcity further amplified its commercial legacy, as remaining stock was rapidly depleted amid collector interest.

Post-Discontinuation Availability

Following its discontinuation in late 1993, Earring Magic Ken dolls entered secondary markets, where they have remained available through online auctions, collector forums, and specialty retailers without any official reissues from . The doll's production run, estimated at around 350,000 units prior to , ensured a supply sufficient to meet ongoing demand from enthusiasts, though pristine or boxed examples command premiums due to the item's cult status stemming from its brief commercial run and ensuing publicity. Platforms like and host regular listings, with loose or played-with dolls typically reselling for $40 to $100, while near-mint or original-packaged variants fetch $200 to $400 or more, reflecting variability in condition and . Collector interest surged post-2023 with renewed attention from the Barbie film, which referenced discontinued variants including Earring Magic Ken, boosting secondary market visibility but not scarcity, as the doll's status as Mattel's top-selling Ken edition sustains broader circulation among hobbyists. No verified reports indicate Mattel recalls or redistributions, leaving availability confined to private sales and estate clearings, where values have stabilized around historical highs without evidence of artificial scarcity.

Cultural Legacy

Collector's Market

Earring Magic Ken dolls command premium prices in collector markets due to their limited production run following the discontinuation prompted by public backlash. Mint-in-box examples, preserving original packaging and accessories like the controversial , routinely sell for $100 or more on platforms such as , with some listings reaching up to $500 based on seller claims of rarity and condition. Loose or played-with dolls fetch lower values, typically $40 to $80, reflecting wear but retaining appeal for enthusiasts of 1990s oddities. Demand stems partly from the doll's status as an accidental , attracting buyers beyond traditional collectors, including those interested in LGBTQ+ history and memorabilia. Auction records and resale data indicate steady appreciation since the early 2000s, though not to the extremes of ultra-rare variants; for instance, estate sales occasionally yield bargains at $10–25 per unit, underscoring variability in secondary markets. Specialty retailers price verified examples at fixed rates around $80, emphasizing authenticity and completeness of features like the snap-on earring. While not officially recalled, the rapid pull from shelves created perceived , fueling a collector niche where condition—particularly retention of the purple mesh vest and ponytail—directly correlates with value. Recent 2023–2025 transactions confirm prices stabilizing in the mid-range, with eBay averages hovering near $50 for standard listings amid fluctuating supply from private hoards.

References in Media and Pop Culture

Earring Magic Ken gained early notoriety in 1993 through media commentary on its unconventional design. Columnist Dan Savage, writing in The Stranger (syndicated in outlets like the Chicago Reader), published "Ken Comes Out" on July 22, 1993, describing the doll's purple mesh vest, ponytail, and necklace—likened by Savage to a cock ring—as evoking 1990s gay rave attire, which propelled discussions of its unintended gay coding. The doll also featured in late-night television humor, with host Jay Leno joking about it on The Tonight Show, contributing to widespread coverage in outlets including CNN, The New York Times, and People magazine that framed it as a marketing misstep. The doll's cultural footprint reemerged in the 2023 film , directed by , where it inspired a character among Weird Barbie's assortment of discontinued Kens. Portrayed by actor , Earring Magic Ken appears alongside Sugar Daddy Ken in a scene referencing Mattel's past discontinuations, with dialogue from Gloria () explicitly naming him and noting his fate. This cameo nods to the doll's 1993 history as an accidental , integrating it into broader celebrating Mattel's quirky variants.

References

  1. http://www.manbehindthedoll.com/mbtd_earring.htm
  2. https://money.howstuffworks.com/barbie-earring-magic-ken-gay-icon-1993.htm
  3. https://www.fastcompany.com/90922067/ken-mattel-barbie-influence-fashion/
  4. https://www.them.us/story/barbie-movie-queer-history-magic-earring-ken-allan-love-wins
  5. https://www.dazeddigital.com/life-culture/article/56336/1/ken-has-always-been-gay-barbie-earring-magic-ryan-gosling
  6. https://melmagazine.com/en-us/story/earring-magic-ken
  7. https://www.vulture.com/article/barbie-earring-magic-ken-story.html
  8. https://www.nyhistory.org/blogs/earring-ken-proud-billy-new-york-historical-celebrates-pride-two-new-acquisitions
  9. https://www.prismfl.org/post/earring-magic-ken
  10. https://www.facebook.com/groups/281238235383286/posts/2785798134927271/
  11. https://en.barbiepedia.com/barbie/earring-magic-barbie-ken-doll-2290.html
  12. https://dollect.net/database/barbie-1993-earring-magic-ken/
  13. https://www.manbehindthedoll.com/mbtd_earring.htm
  14. https://gurinskas.home.blog/2019/06/05/introducing-earring-magic-ken-hes-wearing-a-what-as-a-necklace/
  15. https://www.ebay.com/itm/335864348639
  16. https://www.ebay.com/itm/326602445193
  17. https://www.greenwichtime.com/business/article/How-a-Ken-doll-became-an-epic-fail-for-Mattel-16712922.php
  18. https://medium.com/counterarts/c-ck-ring-ken-the-history-and-controversy-mattel-wanted-you-to-forget-4fbc33b7b8ae
  19. https://www.reddit.com/r/HobbyDrama/comments/12i6ttf/dolls_barbie_the_short_yet_fabulous_life_of/
  20. https://gcn.ie/earring-magic-ken-gay-legacy/
  21. https://chicagoreader.com/news/ken-comes-out/
  22. https://www.nytimes.com/1993/02/11/garden/toys-will-be-toys-the-stereotypes-unravel.html
  23. https://www.tampabay.com/archive/1993/03/17/get-real-ken/
  24. https://www.polygon.com/23802276/cock-ring-ken-earring-magic-barbie-movie
  25. https://time.com/6296386/barbie-ken-history/
  26. https://selinker.livejournal.com/18194.html
  27. http://brandfailures.blogspot.com/2006/11/brand-idea-failures-earring-magic-ken.html
  28. https://xtramagazine.com/culture/gay-of-the-day-earring-magic-ken-59413
  29. https://chicagoreader.com/news-politics/ken-comes-out/
  30. https://www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/ken-comes-out/Content?oid=882402
  31. https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/true-story-mattel-accidentally-releasing-181817544.html
  32. https://www.etonline.com/all-the-discontinued-dolls-featured-in-barbie-allan-midge-earring-magic-ken-and-more-208575
  33. https://mashable.com/article/barbie-movie-all-the-discontinued-barbies-explained
  34. https://english.elpais.com/culture/2023-07-29/from-a-doll-wanted-by-the-fbi-to-a-sugar-daddy-ken-these-are-the-discontinued-mattel-toys-that-appear-in-barbie.html
  35. https://www.ctpost.com/business/article/How-a-Ken-doll-became-an-epic-fail-for-Mattel-16712922.php
  36. https://www.queerty.com/time-mattel-gay-ken-doll-freaked-everyone-else-freaked-20180408/
  37. https://www.workandmoney.com/s/most-valuable-ken-doll-accessories-c5e467574f704db3
  38. https://www.ebay.com/p/25034754970
  39. https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2023/07/barbie-weird-discontinued-dolls
  40. https://www.thehour.com/business/article/How-a-Ken-doll-became-an-epic-fail-for-Mattel-16712922.php
  41. https://www.facebook.com/groups/296747439486941/posts/770884555406558/
  42. https://www.reddit.com/r/Barbie/comments/12wzn4k/cant_believe_my_luck_scored_5_new_in_box_earring/
  43. https://www.reddit.com/r/Barbie/comments/1aliu9e/how_much_would_an_earring_magic_ken_cost/
  44. https://mrjoe.com/products/earring-magic-ken-mattel
  45. https://www.ebay.com/itm/335450482011
  46. https://www.elle.com/culture/movies-tv/a44613357/barbie-movie-easter-eggs-explained/
  47. https://screenrant.com/barbie-movie-easter-eggs-toy-references/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.