Hubbry Logo
Economy pickingEconomy pickingMain
Open search
Economy picking
Community hub
Economy picking
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Economy picking
Economy picking
Economy picking
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Economy picking is a guitar picking technique designed to maximize picking efficiency by combining alternate picking and sweep picking; it may also incorporate the use of legato in the middle of alternate picking passages as way to achieve higher speed with fewer pick strokes. Specifically:

  • When picking multiple notes on a string, alternate picking (alternating between down-strokes and upstrokes) is used.
  • When changing to a new string, sweep picking (picking in the direction of travel: down-stroke if moving down or upstroke when moving up) is used.
  • When playing a lick, scale or pattern that would require alternate strokes or sweeps, but a few notes are spared with the use of legato.

Rationale

[edit]

This minimizes movement in the picking hand, and avoids the motion of "jumping" over a string prior to picking it, as often occurs in alternate-picking when changing strings. Thus the picking pattern of an ascending three-note-per-string scale would be: D-U-D-D-U-D-D-U-D, and the descending pattern would start just like alternate picking (up stroke first): U-D-U-U-D-U-U-D-U.

Guitarists notable for their use of economy picking

[edit]

Gypsy picking

[edit]

The picking technique of gypsy jazz has been described[2] as similar to economy picking, but with the further requirement that when the pattern switches from string to string in either direction, a rest stroke is performed.

For example, on switching from the G to the B string, the plectrum moves in the same direction and comes to rest on the E string. However, on switching from the B to the G string, the plectrum moves upward and executes a down stroke on the G string, again coming to rest on the B string. This technique was employed by gypsy guitarist Django Reinhardt and has been preserved by his successors. However, he did not invent it. He may have learned it from other gypsy players, of whom two of his chief influences were banjoist Gusti Mahla and guitarist Jean "Poulette" Castro.[3] However, this technique was commonly taught in numerous guitar methods in the early twentieth century and was employed by American jazz banjo players.[2]

Legato

[edit]

Many players have found a way to incorporate legato in the middle of picked passages, either with strictly alternate strokes or with sweeps. There seems to be a predominant idea that economy picking is achieved strictly by the incorporation of sweeps, but economy can also be achieved by the use of legato. Notable players who have used legato together with picked notes to achieve higher speed and a more smooth sound are Eddie Van Halen, Paul Gilbert, Buckethead, among others. Author Chris Brooks refers to this as compound picking and used it as the basis for the 2017 book, "Neoclassical Speed Strategies".

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Economy picking

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Economy picking is a guitar technique that combines within a single string with sweep-like directional continuity when transitioning between adjacent strings, minimizing pick movement to enhance speed and efficiency. Developed as a hybrid approach, it allows players to maintain momentum by using consecutive strokes in the same direction across strings, such as a downstroke followed by another downstroke on the lower string, rather than strictly alternating up and down motions. The technique emerged in jazz contexts as early as the 1950s, where consecutive downstrokes or upstrokes were employed for fluid phrasing, but it gained widespread recognition in the through Australian guitarist , who systematized and popularized it via his instructional materials and debut album Brave New Guitar in 1986. Gambale's innovations built on earlier directional picking ideas, transforming it into a cornerstone for fusion and shred styles, influencing subsequent generations of guitarists. In practice, economy picking is most effective with scalar patterns using three notes per string, where ascending lines typically follow a down-up-down pattern per string, continuing downward across strings, while descending lines reverse to up-down-up with upward continuity. This method contrasts with pure alternate picking's rigid up-down alternation, which can introduce slight hesitations at string changes, and sweep picking's broader sweeps, by blending the two for versatile single-note lines. Prominent practitioners include fusion pioneer , rock virtuoso Eric Johnson, neoclassical shredder , jazz guitarist , and metal players like and , who leverage it for rapid, articulate passages in genres from to heavy metal. Its benefits include reduced physical strain on the picking hand, smoother integration, and enhanced fluidity for complex rhythms like semi-quavers and sextuplets, though some players, such as , favor for its sharper attack even at high speeds.

Overview

Definition

Economy picking is a hybrid guitar picking technique that integrates elements of , which involves a strict up-down motion on the same string, and , characterized by continuous directional strokes across multiple strings, to reduce superfluous pick movements and enhance efficiency. This method builds upon alternate picking by allowing the pick's direction to flow naturally between strings, prioritizing the shortest path for transitions rather than rigid alternation. The core characteristic of economy picking lies in its "economy of motion," where the pick continues in the same direction from the final note on one string to the initial note on the adjacent string, facilitating smoother and faster execution of scalar passages and arpeggios. It employs two primary pick orientations: inside picks, which occur when the pickstroke crosses between two adjacent strings (such as an upstroke on the A string followed by a downstroke on the D string), and outside picks, which involve the pickstroke arcing around the outer edge of the strings (such as a downstroke on the A string continuing to a downstroke on the D string). These orientations assume basic proficiency with a plectrum, enabling players to navigate string changes with minimal reversal of the pick's trajectory. For a simple textual illustration of the pick path in a three-notes-per-string ascending scale, consider starting on the low E string: execute a downstroke for the first note, an upstroke for the second, and a downstroke for the third; the pick then maintains the downward motion for the first note on the A string (an outside pick), followed by an upstroke and downstroke on the A string, before an upstroke transitions inside to the first note on the D string, and so on. This pattern repeats across strings, promoting continuous flow without unnecessary lifts or reversals.

Historical Development

While related sweep picking techniques have roots in efficient motions employed by early 20th-century guitarists in classical and traditions, where they facilitated fluid navigation on acoustic instruments, economy picking emerged in contexts as early as the . These foundational approaches were adapted by mid-20th-century and fusion players on electric guitars, emphasizing minimal pick travel for greater speed and expression, though not yet formalized under the modern term. Notable early adopters include and guitarist , who employed consecutive strokes for fluid phrasing on electric guitars. The technique gained prominence in the 1980s amid the rise of neoclassical shredding and fusion guitar, with Australian guitarist Frank Gambale credited for developing and systematizing it during his early career. Gambale's 1986 album Brave New Guitar showcased a comprehensive application of economy picking for scales and arpeggios, evolving from related "sweep picking" methods he refined in instructional videos and his 1994 book Speed Picking, the first dedicated publication on the subject. Concurrently, Yngwie Malmsteen, emerging in the neoclassical metal scene, popularized economy picking through his high-speed runs, integrating it seamlessly with alternate picking since his debut in the early 1980s. In the 2010s, Troy Grady's Pickslanting video series provided biomechanical breakdowns of economy picking in Malmsteen's style, examining rotational forearm motions and downward pickslanting for efficient string changes. By the 2020s, economy picking had evolved into a staple of cross-genre , featured in resources like Chris Brooks' 2021 Economy Picking Guitar Technique, which offers structured exercises for metal, , and rock applications.

Technique

Execution Mechanics

Economy picking execution begins with alternate picking on a single string, employing a down-up-down pattern for three notes to establish even timing and control. To transition to the adjacent string, the pick maintains the momentum of the final stroke, such as continuing a downstroke directly onto the first note of the next string, thereby reducing extraneous motion compared to strict alternation. This hybrid approach integrates elements of alternate and sweep picking for fluid string changes. In ascending patterns, where pitch increases from lower to higher strings, the sequence per string uses a down-up-down motion, allowing the concluding downstroke to sweep seamlessly into a downstroke on the subsequent string for efficiency. Descending patterns reverse this, applying up-down-up per string to enable consecutive upstrokes across strings. Turnarounds at the scale's peak or trough reverse the pick direction only when essential, preventing "free strokes" where the pick moves without sounding a note, thus preserving rhythmic consistency. Practitioners start with exercises in three-notes-per-string configurations to build proficiency. For instance, the scale ascending from the low E string involves: on string 6 (frets 0-2-4, notes E-F#-G#), down-up-down; on string 5 (frets 2-4-5, B-C#-D), down-up-down; continuing similarly across strings to maintain directional flow. As skill develops, incorporate patterns like diminished 7th shapes, applying the same rules—e.g., down-up-down for ascending sweeps across the three-note groupings per string—to enhance precision in wider intervals. Common challenges include over-picking, where excess hand motion creates tension, and inconsistent pick angles that disrupt flow; counter these by adopting a relaxed, light grip on the , angled at about 45 degrees relative to the strings for optimal contact. Employ primarily wrist rotation for intra-string alternates, supplemented by subtle forearm involvement for broader sweeps during string changes, to promote relaxed execution. This technique performs best on electric guitars equipped with low string action, typically around 1.5-2mm at the 12th on the low E , to minimize resistance during rapid transitions. Thin to medium picks, gauged at 0.6-0.8mm, are recommended to facilitate speed and reduce in extended passages.

Benefits and Rationale

Economy picking is grounded in an efficiency principle that substantially reduces the pick's travel distance during string changes relative to strict , enabling guitarists to sustain higher tempos such as 16th notes at 200 BPM or beyond in demanding scalar and sequences. By maintaining directional continuity—such as consecutive upstrokes when descending across strings—this approach conserves motion and promotes smoother transitions. Musically, the technique excels in creating fluid scalar passages and sweeps that yield a more connected, -like , enhancing expressiveness in solos while simultaneously reducing physical over extended performances. This legato quality arises from the seamless string-to-string flow, which minimizes interruptions in phrasing and supports dynamic control. From a physiological standpoint, economy picking harmonizes with natural and by leveraging the of the preceding to propel the pick across strings, thereby minimizing tension and strain on the muscles. Troy Grady's high-speed motion analyses illustrate how this alignment—often involving upstroke escape (USX) and downward pickslanting—optimizes energy transfer and reduces the cognitive and muscular demands of rapid picking. In comparative evaluations, economy picking delivers superior articulation clarity at elevated speeds, where frequently introduces string noise and timing inconsistencies due to excessive pick reversal. For instance, exercises in Brooks' 2021 book Economy Picking Guitar Technique demonstrate these advantages through progressive etudes that highlight reduced errors in note separation and sustain. The technique's learning curve is notably accessible, as it extends existing alternate picking proficiency by incorporating directional efficiencies, allowing intermediate players to rapidly advance toward professional-level speed without requiring a complete technical rebuild.

Sweep Picking

Sweep picking represents a specialized application within economy picking, characterized by a continuous, unidirectional motion of the across adjacent strings to articulate arpeggiated figures, such as a downstroke from the high E string to the low E string. This technique emphasizes fluid directional picking to minimize motion changes, distinguishing it as a core subset that prioritizes sweeping for multi-string efficiency in scalar and passages. In execution, sweep picking relies on rest strokes, where the pick penetrates each string and briefly rests against the subsequent string before proceeding, ensuring note separation without reversing direction. This method is particularly suited to symmetrical arpeggios like diminished or augmented shapes, often employing Yngwie Malmsteen-inspired patterns such as a 1-5-1 note configuration per string (root-fifth-root) to facilitate rapid, cascading runs. For ascending sweeps, known as outside picking, the motion travels from lower to higher strings, while descending sweeps, or inside picking, reverse this path, creating contrasting directional flows that enhance phrase variety. Common practice patterns include three-string arpeggios in keys like , starting with the root on the high E string, the third on the B string, and the fifth on the , then rolling the hand to maintain shape across positions. These exercises build between hands, beginning at slow tempos to isolate the sweeping arc before accelerating, often using a to refine timing. Key challenges in sweep picking involve achieving consistent volume balance across strings, as thicker lower strings can overpower higher ones without precise pick angle adjustments and dynamic control. Additionally, preventing "hammer-on bleed"—unintended ringing from fretted notes—requires vigilant muting with the fretting hand's unused fingers to dampen adjacent strings during transitions. Historically, sweep picking evolved from violin bowing techniques adapted to the guitar, initially referred to broadly as "economy" picking in mid-20th-century contexts before being distinctly termed "sweep" by 1980s shred guitar innovators like Yngwie Malmsteen, who popularized its use in neoclassical metal arpeggios. This distinction arose amid the shred movement, separating pure sweeping from broader economy variants. Sweep picking integrates briefly into overall economy picking to enable hybrid efficiency, combining with alternate strokes for seamless scale navigation.

Gypsy Picking

Gypsy picking emerged in the 1930s as a specialized form of economy picking pioneered by , the Belgian-born Romani guitarist who adapted his playing after a 1928 fire severely injured his left hand, limiting him to using primarily his index and middle fingers for fretting. This technique builds on economy picking's directional efficiency by incorporating rest-stroke motions to achieve greater volume and speed in scalar passages, particularly within the syncopated phrasing of jazz manouche. The core mechanics involve alternating efficient sweeps with emphatic downstrokes for rhythmic accentuation, using a rest-stroke approach where the pick rests briefly on the adjacent after each downstroke to produce a louder, more controlled tone. Practitioners hold the pick firmly between the thumb and , employing an elbow-driven downstroke that sweeps across strings while maintaining stability for upstrokes, ensuring every string change begins with a downstroke to preserve momentum and phrasing continuity. This hybrid emphasizes three-notes-per-string patterns, blending directional continuity from economy picking with the swinging, off-beat accents characteristic of improvisation. In ascending minor scales, such as , the pattern typically follows a down-up-down sequence per string, with the pick sweeping fluidly to the next higher string on the final downstroke to facilitate seamless transitions and incorporate gypsy swing phrasing. This creates a propulsive feel, where the thumb-index grip enhances volume through the rest-stroke's percussive contact, allowing for dynamic expression without excessive pick angle adjustments. Gypsy picking is particularly suited to fast, improvised scalar lines in gypsy jazz, where it enables intricate runs over chord progressions like those in "Minor Swing," distinguishing itself from smoother metal sweeps through its integration of valve-like percussive accents on downstrokes for rhythmic punch. In modern adaptations from the 1990s onward, guitarists like Bireli Lagrene and Stochelo Rosenberg have refined gypsy picking for contemporary gypsy jazz ensembles, applying it to expanded harmonic contexts while retaining Reinhardt's foundational rest-stroke principles for high-speed solos.

Applications

Integration with Legato

Economy picking integrates with techniques by employing the pick primarily for efficient string crossings while relying on hammer-ons and pull-offs for subsequent notes within the same string, thereby minimizing the number of pick attacks and enhancing overall fluidity. For instance, in a three-note triplet, the guitarist might pick the initial note to establish attack and direction, then execute a hammer-on or pull-off for the second and third notes, creating a seamless transition that combines the precision of picking with the smoothness of left-hand articulation. This approach is particularly effective in arpeggio-based licks where economy picking handles the sweep across strings, followed by legato to connect notes without additional strokes. The primary benefits of this integration lie in its ability to produce smoother, more connected phrasing while reducing physical strain on the picking hand, allowing for higher speeds and greater endurance during extended solos. By limiting pick strokes, it fosters a more legato-like sound that blends the articulate attack of economy picking with the fluid expressiveness of slurs, resulting in lines that feel organic and less mechanical. This combination is especially valued in fusion music, where it enables complex semi-quaver and sextuplet patterns with enhanced dynamic control and reduced fatigue. Practical exercises for developing this integration often focus on scale runs that alternate between economy-picked transitions and segments, such as applying a 50% ratio in three-note-per-string patterns—picking the first two notes with down-up economy motion, then using a for the third. exercises can begin with across strings using economy directionality, concluding each shape with hammer-ons to link into the next , practiced slowly with a starting at 60 BPM and gradually increasing to build coordination. These routines emphasize chunking patterns into smaller segments, like octaves or mode fragments, to ingrain the hybrid flow. This technique gained prominence in 1980s for minimizing pick noise and achieving rapid, clean execution in high-speed solos, as seen in the intricate phrasing of players blending picked arpeggios with slurs. In modern progressive rock, it supports expressive dynamics and complex odd-meter passages, contributing to the genre's signature layered, fluid soundscapes. Technical proficiency requires the hand to synchronize precisely with the picking hand's speed, ensuring even timing and volume between picked and slurred notes to prevent uneven phrasing. Over-reliance on should be avoided to prevent muddiness, particularly at faster tempos; instead, maintain a balanced and use a 45-degree pick angle for clean string crosses.

Notable Practitioners

Django Reinhardt laid foundational groundwork for economy picking through his gypsy jazz style in the 1930s and 1940s, incorporating sweep-like motions and directional efficiency in pieces like "Minor Swing," influencing subsequent players with his two-fingered approach that emphasized fluid string transitions. In the fusion and shred genres of the 1980s, Frank Gambale popularized economy picking as a core technique during his tenure with Chick Corea's Elektric Band starting in 1987, showcasing it in tracks like "Time Track" and through instructional videos that detailed his "Gambale Sweep Picking" method, which integrates sweep and alternate motions for high-speed improvisation. Yngwie Malmsteen advanced neoclassical shred with economy picking on his 1984 debut album Rising Force, particularly in "Black Star," where ascending arpeggios employ continuous downstrokes across strings for relentless speed and precision. Eric Johnson exemplified precise hybrid economy picking in his 1986 album Tones, using it to blend pentatonic runs with sweep motions in songs like "Cliffs of Dover," achieving a clean, articulate tone through angled pick attacks. Jimmy Bruno elevated economy picking in jazz during the 1990s, applying it to standards on albums like 1990 and The Power of the Tongue, where his right-hand technique enabled smooth, rapid lines over chord changes without sacrificing swing feel. Steve Morse integrated fluid economy picking into progressive fusion with the Dixie Dregs from the 1970s onward, as heard in tracks like "Take It Off the Top" from What If (1978), combining it with hybrid elements for versatile, genre-blending solos. In recent years, Chris Brooks has influenced modern practitioners through his 2021 book Economy Picking Guitar Technique, which provides exercises and etudes demonstrating its application in shred contexts, alongside tutorials emphasizing transitions from . Martin Miller has advanced technical demonstrations of economy picking in the 2010s via his JTC Guitar masterclasses, such as Guide to Picking, Part 3: Workouts and Economy Picking, focusing on workouts that build speed through string-skipping and directional efficiency. These artists have collectively propelled economy picking forward by embedding it in landmark recordings and educational resources, expanding its role from and fusion to broader rock and instructional applications.

References

  1. https://www.guitarworld.com/lessons/economy-picking
  2. https://fretello.com/news/skill/economy-picking/
  3. https://hubguitar.com/technique/economy-picking-overview
  4. https://www.guitarworld.com/lessons/how-to-use-economy-picking
  5. https://www.ultimate-guitar.com/en/wiki/Economy_picking
  6. https://tomhess.net/The-Best-Guitar-Picking-Technique
  7. https://karlgolden.org/insidepicking
  8. https://stringjoy.com/sweep-picking-tasteful/
  9. https://groups.google.com/g/rec.music.makers.guitar.jazz/c/Z-ZANsvnuqc
  10. https://www.amazon.com/Speed-Picking-Frank-Gambale/dp/0793527511
  11. https://www.guitarworld.com/lessons/cracking-code-troy-grady-yngwie-malmsteens-rotational-picking-mechanic
  12. https://www.fundamental-changes.com/book/economy-picking-guitar-technique/
  13. https://www.guitar9.com/column/economy-picking-demystified
  14. https://guitarpickreviews.com/economy-picking-basics-play-fast-faster/
  15. https://troygrady.com/primer/reference/picking-style/dwps-economy/
  16. https://forum.troygrady.com/t/economy-picking/70826
  17. https://www.stringsandbeyond.com/blog/choosing-the-right-pick-for-your-electric-guitar/
  18. https://www.guitarworld.com/lessons/controlled-burn-basics-economy-picking
  19. https://guitarlessonsmyrtlebeach.com/2025/06/21/economy-picking/
  20. https://www.lvlupgtr.com/2024/08/28/mastering-economy-picking-on-guitar/
  21. https://acousticguitar.com/how-to-strengthen-your-picking-skills-through-efficient-patterns/
  22. https://www.riffhard.com/how-to-improve-picking-accuracy-on-the-guitar/
  23. https://troygrady.com/primer/reference/escape-motion-reference/usx-motion/
  24. https://troygrady.com/primer/reference/pickslanting-reference/pickslanting-and-sweeping/
  25. https://chrisbrooks.com/economy-picking-guitar-technique-book/
  26. https://www.theamericanguitaracademy.com/post/alternate-vs-economy-picking-mastering-your-guitar-picking-technique
  27. https://ugtra.com/alternate-picking-vs-economy-picking-which-guitar-picking-technique-suits-your-playing-style-best/
  28. https://www.academia.edu/29161980/Sweep_Picking
  29. https://www.fundamental-changes.com/sweep-picking-guitar-technique-part-1/
  30. https://www.guitarworld.com/lessons/master-sweeping-learning-rest-stroke
  31. https://openlab.citytech.cuny.edu/english-comp-2-deron/files/2024/05/Evolution-of-Guitar-Technique_-From-a-Historical-Perspective-2.pdf
  32. https://www.jazzguitar.be/blog/django-reinhardt/
  33. https://www.djangobooks.com/Item/gypsypicking
  34. https://www.jazzguitar.be/blog/gypsy-jazz-arpeggios-and-picking/
  35. https://www.jazzguitar.be/forum/guitar-technique/69708-rest-stroke-technique-aka-gypsy-picking.html
  36. https://www.guitarworld.com/lessons/learn-a-killer-chris-poland-lick
  37. https://www.thewizardofshred.com/index/integrating-major-diminshed-arpeggios
  38. https://karlgolden.org/howtoeconomypick
  39. https://www.guitarworld.com/gw-archive/prog-gnosis-making-effective-use-economy-picking
  40. https://reverb.com/news/django-reinhardts-lasting-impact-on-guitarists
  41. https://www.flatpick.com/category_s/2218.htm
  42. https://www.frankgambaleguitarschool.com/course/gambale-sweep-picking
  43. https://www.guitarmasterclass.net/ls/Pick-Like-Yngwie/
  44. https://www.guitarworld.com/lessons/clean-sweep-mastering-sweep-picked-arpeggios-yngwie-malmsteen
  45. https://www.guitarworld.com/lessons/eric-johnson-tasty-solos
  46. http://fromthewoodshed.com/2007/11/18/jimmy-bruno-no-nonsense-jazz-guitar-picking/
  47. https://www.allaboutjazz.com/musicians/jimmy-bruno
  48. https://www.facebook.com/stevemorseguitar/posts/steve-is-known-for-his-alternate-picking-virtuosity-creativity-and-ability-to-ad/1253837776104001/
  49. https://jasobrecht.substack.com/p/steve-morse-the-complete-1978-dixie
  50. https://www.amazon.com/Economy-Picking-Guitar-Technique-Economical/dp/1789333717
  51. https://jtcguitar.com/store/package/guide-to-picking-part-3-workouts-and-economy-picking
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.