Hubbry Logo
search
search button
Sign in
Historyarrow-down
starMorearrow-down
Hubbry Logo
search
search button
Sign in
I Said I Love You First
Community hub for the Wikipedia article
logoWikipedian hub
Welcome to the community hub built on top of the I Said I Love You First Wikipedia article. Here, you can discuss, collect, and organize anything related to I Said I Love You First. The purpose of the hub is to connect people, foster deeper knowledge, and help improve the root Wikipedia article.
Add your contribution
Inside this hub
I Said I Love You First

I Said I Love You First
Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco lying in bed viewed through a keyhole
Studio album by
ReleasedMarch 21, 2025 (2025-03-21)
Genre
Length34:38
Language
  • English
  • Spanish
Label
Producer
Selena Gomez chronology
Revelación
(2021)
I Said I Love You First
(2025)
Benny Blanco chronology
Friends Keep Secrets 2
(2021)
I Said I Love You First
(2025)
Singles from I Said I Love You First
  1. "Call Me When You Break Up"
    Released: February 20, 2025
  2. "Ojos Tristes"
    Released: April 28, 2025
  3. "Sunset Blvd"
    Released: July 31, 2025

I Said I Love You First is a collaborative studio album by American singer Selena Gomez and American record producer Benny Blanco. It is Gomez's fourth studio album and Blanco's second. Following their respective studio albums Rare (2020) and Friends Keep Secrets (2018), it was released on March 21, 2025, through SMG Music, Friends Keep Secrets, and Interscope Records.[1][2]

The album features guest appearances from Gracie Abrams, the Marías, Tainy, and J Balvin, with additional contributions from Charli XCX and Finneas. I Said I Love You First achieved the biggest first-week album sales for Gomez and Blanco's careers in the United States, debuting at number-two on the Billboard 200. It became the first album by a real-life couple to top the Vinyl Albums chart in history. Internationally, the album has charted within the top-10 in 15 counties. It received generally favorable reviews from critics. Rolling Stone named the album as one of the best albums of 2025 so far.[3]

I Said I Love You First was preceded by several singles and promotional singles: "Scared of Loving You" was surprise-released on February 14, 2025, followed by "Call Me When You Break Up" with Gracie Abrams on February 21, 2025. "Sunset Blvd", was released on March 14, 2025, whereas "Younger and Hotter Than Me" was released alongside the album on March 21, 2025.

Background

[edit]

The first time Gomez and Blanco collaborated in the studio was for the former's second solo studio album, Revival.[4] For the album, Blanco has production credits on the singles "Kill Em with Kindness" and "Same Old Love". The pair then returned to the studio to record the collaborative single "I Can't Get Enough" with Tainy and J Balvin, which was released in February 2019. Later, Blanco also participated in the creation of Gomez's standalone single "Single Soon", which was released in August 2023.[4]

In December 2023, Gomez officially confirmed her relationship with Blanco, and in December 2024, the couple officially announced their engagement.[4] In October 2024, Gomez stated that she had no date in mind for her next album's release, telling Variety "I currently don't have anything, but I will say music is going to always be a part of me," and, "I don't think any movements are happening right now, but it will always be in my life."[5] Gomez later affirmed "Music isn't going away," and "I just set it down for a second."[6]

On January 17, 2025, Blanco shared a short clip on TikTok responding to a fan who wrote him, "Benny please make some new songs for our queen." The clip showed Gomez recording music in her home studio.[7] Then on January 23, 2025, Gomez shared a video on her social media while working on new music in her home recording studio.[8] After a number of speculations, on February 13, Gomez announced the release of the album on March 21 and released a surprise promotional single "Scared of Loving You" for Valentine's Day. Many different signed, regular and limited CD, LP and 12-inch vinyls of the album were available for pre-order, along with pre-saving on streaming platforms.

Composition and release

[edit]

Gomez announced her engagement to Blanco on December 11, 2024.[9] Two months later, she revealed they worked on a collaborative studio album, writing in an Instagram post: "my NEW album I Said I Love You First with my best friend @itsbennyblanco, is out on 3/21". According to a press release, the album will celebrate "the pair's love story" and "chronicles their entire story—before they met, falling in love and looking to what the future holds".[1]

I Said I Love You First is a pop[10][11] alt-pop,[12] and bedroom pop[12] album that also includes elements of synth-pop,[13] pop rock,[13] folk-pop,[13] Latin pop[14] and hyperpop.[10] It follows a narrative starting with the end of a failed relationship to the meeting between Gomez and Blanco to "the couple's present-day happiness".[14][15] Its first track is a voice recording of a speech given by Gomez to the cast and crew of Wizards of Waverly Place.[10]

As part of the album's extended rollout, Gomez made the previously unreleased 2016 track "Stained", available for digital download via her official website on March 22, 2025.[16] Two days later, on March 24, a new special track titled "Talk" was released as a digital exclusive;[17] the song had previously been featured in an Apple commercial to promote the iPhone 16e and interpolates Cake's "Never There".[18] Gomez released the Seven Heavens Version of the album for digital download on March 25, featuring the song "That's When I'll Care".[19] The following day, she released the Call Me When You Break Up Special Edition, which included the acoustic and extended versions of "Call Me When You Break Up".[20] She further released two digital limited editions, with live from Vevo recordings of "Scared of Loving You" and "How Does It Feel to Be Forgotten" included respectively. On April 30, she announced the deluxe version of the album, titled I Said I Love You First... and You Said It Back, to be released on May 2.[21][22]

Promotion

[edit]

Gomez and Blanco revealed the track list of their upcoming album, I Said I Love You First on March 4.[23] On March 19, Gomez and Blanco appeared on Spotify's Countdown To series to talk about the creation of the album.[24] Hot Ones, a YouTube series, released an episode featuring an interview with Blanco and Gomez on March 20.[25] An interview on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon was released on March 21 to promote the album.[26]

Singles

[edit]

On February 13, 2025, "Scared of Loving You" was surprised released for Valentine's Day and was released as the album's first promotional single, alongside an official lyric video. It is a ballad written with Finneas O'Connell.[27][2] The lead single, "Call Me When You Break Up", was released the following week on February 20, 2025. The song is a collaboration with American singer-songwriter Gracie Abrams. "Younger and Hotter Than Me" was released as a promotional single, along with the album's release.[28] "Ojos Tristes" was released as the album's second single.[29][30] "Sunset Blvd" was initially released as a promotional single on March 14, 2025, alongside a music video, and was later released to Italian radio on July 31, 2025, as the album's third single.[31][32][33]

Critical reception

[edit]
Professional ratings
Aggregate scores
SourceRating
AnyDecentMusic?6.0/10[34]
Metacritic66/100[35]
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusic[36]
Clash8/10[15]
The Guardian[14]
NME[37]
Pitchfork5.9/10[38]
Rolling Stone[39]
Sputnikmusic3/5[11]

According to the review aggregator Metacritic, I Said I Love You First received "generally favorable reviews" based on a weighted average score of 66 out of 100 from ten critic scores.[35] Martina Rebecca Inchingolo of the Associated Press complimented I Said I Love You First for its inclusion of guest artists and its experimentation with different genres.[10] Jason Lipshutz of Billboard said that Gomez "at long last adds a compelling new entry to her catalog",[40] while Dakota West Foss of Sputnikmusic called it her "strongest collection of songs to date".[11] Robin Murray of Clash said the album surpassed expectations, calling it "a genuine thrill" and praising Blanco's "world-building capabilities".[15] Both Alexis Petridis of The Guardian and Georgia Evans of NME criticized the album's lack of a clear identity, with the former finding the nature of its songs unmemorable.[14][37]

Rob Sheffieldd of Rolling Stone praised the album for its diversity and versatility in genres and styles, describing the album as: "a valentine that delivers exactly what it promises—a pop icon and a superstar producer celebrating a real-life romance that we all can root for."[39] Rolling Stone and Complex named the album as one of the best album of 2025 so far.[3][41] Billboard named the song "Ojos Tristes" from the album as the tenth best Latin song of 2025 so far, writing: "This stunning reimagining of Jeanette's iconic 1981 hit, "Ojos Tristes" intertwines modern, nostalgic melodies with the enchanting vocals of Selena Gomez. This bilingual collaboration with Benny Blanco and The Marías — with frontwoman María Zardoya's distinctive, warm vocals providing harmonies — yields a lovely track that breathes new life into the original. Gomez's ethereal vocals soar throughout the song, beautifully complementing The Marías' signature sound".[42]

Commercial performance

[edit]

In the United States, I Said I Love You First debuted at number two on the Billboard 200, with first-week sales of 120,000 album-equivalent units, consisting of 71,000 pure album sales and 64.04 million on-demand streams, making both Blanco and Gomez's highest first-week sales by units overall, as well as Gomez's seventh top-ten effort on the chart and Blanco's first.[43] The album became top-selling pure sales album of the week, topping both the Top Album Sales and Top Vinyl Albums charts, it become the first album by a real-life couple to top the Vinyl Albums chart in history, as well as making Gomez's fourth consecutive number-one album on the charts and Blanco's first.[43][44] In the same week, four songs from the album entered the Billboard Hot 100: "Call Me When You Break Up" (46), "Ojos Tristes" (56), "How Does It Feel to Be Forgotten" (71) and "Sunset Blvd" (97).[45]

Internationally, the album debuted in the top ten in 15 countries, including Australia, Canada, and several European countries. In the United Kingdom, the album debuted at number four, earning Gomez her second top-five album in the country and the first for Blanco.[46] 11 songs from the album make appearances on various official charts including Canada (8 songs), United Kingdom (4 songs), Ireland (3 songs), and 5 songs in the Billboard Global 200.[47]

Track listing

[edit]
I Said I Love You First track listing
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
1."I Said I Love You First"0:44
2."Younger and Hotter Than Me"
  • Gomez
  • Levin
  • O'Connell
3:09
3."Call Me When You Break Up" (with Gracie Abrams)
2:06
4."Ojos Tristes" (with the Marías)
3:21
5."Don't Wanna Cry"
3:27
6."Sunset Blvd"
  • Blanco[p]
  • Chrome Sparks
  • Schoudel[v]
2:47
7."Cowboy"
  • Gomez
  • Levin
  • Høiberg
  • Ibanez
  • Jake Torrey
  • Blanco[p]
  • Cashmere Cat
  • Schoudel[v]
3:04
8."Bluest Flame"
  • Blanco[p]
  • Cashmere Cat
  • Brady
  • Schoudel[v]
2:42
9."How Does It Feel to Be Forgotten"
  • Gomez
  • Levin
  • Sudduth
  • Tranter
  • William Fly
2:41
10."Do You Wanna Be Perfect"
  • Gomez
  • Levin
  • Høiberg
  • Malvin
  • Blanco[p]
  • Cashmere Cat
  • Chrome Sparks
  • Schoudel[v]
0:37
11."You Said You Were Sorry"
  • Gomez
  • Levin
  • Høiberg
  • Ibanez
  • Tranter
  • John Byron
  • Blanco[p]
  • Cashmere Cat
  • Schoudel[v]
2:59
12."I Can't Get Enough" (with Tainy and J Balvin)
  • Blanco
  • Tainy
2:37
13."Don't Take It Personally"
  • Gomez
  • Levin
  • Slatkin
  • Sudduth
  • Tranter
2:34
14."Scared of Loving You"
  • Gomez
  • Levin
  • O'Connell
1:50
Total length:34:38
I Said I Love You First... And You Said It Back digital deluxe edition track listing
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
15."That's When I'll Care"
  • Blanco[p]
  • Kirkpatrick
  • Schoudel[v]
3:04
16."Talk"
  • Blanco[p]
  • Kirkpatrick
  • Schoudel[v]
2:12
17."Stained" (performed by Selena Gomez)
  • Gomez
  • Michaels
  • Høiberg
  • Omelio
  • Cashmere Cat
  • Robopop
3:29
18."Bluest Flame" (DJ Sliink remix)
  • Gomez
  • Levin
  • Aitchison
  • Høiberg
  • Brady
  • Blanco[p]
  • Cashmere Cat
  • Brady
  • Schoudel[v]
2:44
19."How Does It Feel to Be Forgotten" (live from Vevo)
  • Gomez
  • Levin
  • Sudduth
  • Tranter
  • Fly
2:27
20."Call Me When You Break Up" (with Gracie Abrams; acoustic version)
  • Gomez
  • Levin
  • Abrams
  • Tranter
  • Michaels
  • Høiberg
  • Brady
  • Larsson
  • Fredriksson
  • Blanco
  • Casey Kalmenson
2:50
21."Cowboy" (GloRilla remix)
  • Blanco[p]
  • Cashmere Cat
  • Schoudel[v]
2:43
22."Guess You Could Say I'm in Love"
  • Blanco[p]
  • Gonzalez
  • Cashmere Cat
  • Schoudel[v]
3:13

Notes

  • ^[p] signifies a primary and vocal producer
  • ^[v] signifies a vocal producer
  • "Stained", "Talk", "That's When I'll Care", and the Vevo live versions of "Scared of Loving You" and "How Does It Feel to Be Forgotten" were available on separate exclusive digital store editions with their namesake during the original release week, excluding "That's When I'll Care" appearing on the Seven Heavens Version. A slowed and reverted edition was also available, an instrumental edition, and a narrated voice memo edition, that included voice memos that are placed prior to each standard edition track and detailed their creation.
  • A digital store exclusive "Call Me When You Break Up Special Edition" of the album was released and included the acoustic and extended versions of "Call Me When You Break Up", both versions include Gracie Abrams.
  • The acoustic version of "Call Me When You Break Up" and "Stained" were released on a worldwide digital bonus edition entitled "I Said I Love You First..." on the following week after release. The music videos for "Call Me When You Break Up", "Sunset Blvd", and "Younger and Hotter Than Me" appear on the Apple Music edition; the And You Said It Back edition additionally includes the "Talk" music video.
  • "Call Me When You Break Up" does not include Gracie Abrams on physical editions.[48]
  • "Ojos Tristes" contains an interpolation of "El Muchacho de los Ojos Tristes", written by Ana Magdalena and Manuel Alejandro, and performed by Jeanette.
  • "Ojos Tristes" does not credit them on physical editions.
  • "Cowboy" includes an uncredited spoken outro by GloRilla.
  • "Guess You Could Say I'm in Love" includes uncredited vocals by Greg Gonzalez.

Personnel

[edit]

Credits adapted from album liner notes.[49]

Musicians

[edit]
  • Selena Gomez – vocals
  • Benny Blanco – keyboards, programming (all tracks); bass, guitar (3); vocals (10), background vocals (11)
  • Finneas – background vocals, keyboards, piano, programming (tracks 1, 2, 14); glockenspiel, guitar, synthesizer (2, 14); bass (2)
  • Dylan Day – guitar (tracks 2, 4, 7, 9, 11, 13, 14), keyboards (6)
  • Lucy Healy – background vocals (tracks 2, 14)
  • Justin Tranter – background vocals (tracks 3, 5, 6, 9, 11, 13)
  • Cashmere Cat – keyboards, programming (tracks 3, 7, 8, 10); bass, guitar (3)
  • Dylan Brady – keyboards, programming (tracks 3, 8)
  • Julia Michaels – background vocals (track 3)
  • Gracie Abrams – vocals (track 3)
  • Pino Palladino – bass (tracks 4, 9, 11, 13)
  • Henry Kwapis – drums (tracks 4, 9, 11, 13)
  • Josh Conway – bass, guitar, programming (track 4)
  • María Zardoya – vocals, programming (track 4)
  • Jesse Perlman – guitar (track 4)
  • Mikky Ekko – background vocals (tracks 5, 9, 13); keyboards, programming (5)
  • Blake Slatkin – guitar, keyboards, programming (tracks 5, 13); background vocals (5)
  • Sebastian – guitar, keyboards, programming (track 5)
  • Jackson Shanks – guitar keyboards, programming (track 5)
  • Kiddo – background vocals (tracks 6, 7, 11)
  • Chrome Sparks – guitar, keyboards, programming (tracks 6, 10)
  • Michael Pollack – background vocals, keyboards (track 6)
  • GloRilla – background vocals (track 7)
  • Jake Torrey – guitar (track 7)
  • Charli XCX – background vocals (track 8)
  • Phillip A. Peterson – cello, violin (tracks 9, 11, 13, 14); string arrangement (9, 11, 13, 14)
  • William Fly – guitar (track 9)
  • John Byron – guitar (track 11)
  • Tainy – keyboards, programming (track 12)
  • J Balvin – vocals (track 12)
  • Chet Peterson – string arrangement (track 14)

Technical

[edit]
  • Benny Blanco – mixing (tracks 1–8, 10, 11, 13, 14); engineering, recording (all tracks)
  • Chris Gehringermastering
  • Cashmere Cat – mixing (track 5); engineering, recording (3, 7, 8, 10)
  • Serban Ghenea – mixing (tracks 9, 12)
  • Finneas – engineering (tracks 1, 2, 14), recording (2, 14)
  • Dylan Brady – engineering (tracks 3, 8), recording (3)
  • Josh Conway – engineering, recording (track 4)
  • María Zardoya – engineering (track 4)
  • Blake Slatkin – engineering (tracks 5, 13), recording (13)
  • Jackson Shanks – engineering (track 5)
  • Justin Tranter – engineering (track 5)
  • Mikky Ekko – engineering (track 5)
  • Sebastian – engineering (track 5)
  • Chrome Sparks – engineering (tracks 6, 10), recording (10)
  • Aron Forbes – recording (tracks 2, 14)
  • Chris Sclafani – recording (track 3)
  • Michael Harris – recording (tracks 4, 9, 11, 13)
  • Bart Schoudel – recording (track 6)
  • Phillip A. Peterson – recording (tracks 9, 11, 13, 14)
  • Chet Peterson – recording (track 14)
  • Will Quinnell – mastering assistance
  • Bryce Bordone – mixing assistance (tracks 4, 9, 12)
  • Andy Petr – recording assistance (tracks 4, 9, 11, 13)
  • Ryan Tharayil – recording assistance (tracks 9, 11, 13)
  • Ashlyn Banner – production coordination

Charts

[edit]
Chart performance for I Said I Love You First
Chart (2025) Peak
position
Australian Albums (ARIA)[50] 5
Austrian Albums (Ö3 Austria)[51] 5
Belgian Albums (Ultratop Flanders)[52] 6
Belgian Albums (Ultratop Wallonia)[53] 5
Canadian Albums (Billboard)[54] 6
Czech Albums (ČNS IFPI)[55] 30
Danish Albums (Hitlisten)[56] 15
Dutch Albums (Album Top 100)[57] 12
Finnish Albums (Suomen virallinen lista)[58] 40
French Albums (SNEP)[59] 12
German Albums (Offizielle Top 100)[60] 2
Greek Albums (IFPI)[61] 96
Hungarian Albums (MAHASZ)[62] 12
Icelandic Albums (Tónlistinn)[63] 32
Irish Albums (OCC)[64] 4
Italian Albums (FIMI)[65] 48
Lithuanian Albums (AGATA)[66] 22
New Zealand Albums (RMNZ)[67] 6
Norwegian Albums (VG-lista)[68] 10
Polish Albums (ZPAV)[69] 5
Portuguese Albums (AFP)[70] 3
Scottish Albums (OCC)[71] 3
Slovak Albums (ČNS IFPI)[72] 21
Spanish Albums (PROMUSICAE)[73] 5
Swedish Albums (Sverigetopplistan)[74] 45
Swiss Albums (Schweizer Hitparade)[75] 6
UK Albums (OCC)[76] 4
US Billboard 200[77] 2

Release history

[edit]
I Said I Love You First release history
Initial release date Region Edition Format(s) Label Ref.
March 21, 2025 Various Standard
[78]
March 28, 2025 I Said I Love You First...
  • Digital download
  • streaming
[79]
May 2, 2025 I Said I Love You First... And You Said It Back [80]
June 27, 2025 Japan CD [81]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
Add your contribution
Related Hubs