Hubbry Logo
Inns of ChanceryInns of ChanceryMain
Open search
Inns of Chancery
Community hub
Inns of Chancery
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Inns of Chancery
Inns of Chancery
Inns of Chancery
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Staple Inn, the only Inn of Chancery building to survive largely intact

The Inns of Chancery or Hospida Cancellarie were a group of buildings and legal institutions in Holborn, London, initially attached to the Inns of Court and used as offices for the clerks of chancery, from which they drew their name. Existing from at least 1344, the Inns gradually changed their purpose, and became both the offices and accommodation for solicitors (as the Inns of Court were to barristers) and a place of initial training for barristers.

The practice of training barristers at the Inns of Chancery had died out by 1642, and the Inns instead became dedicated associations and offices for solicitors. With the founding of the Society of Gentleman Practisers in 1739 and the Law Society of England and Wales in 1825, a single unified professional association for solicitors, the purpose of the Inns died out, and after a long period of decline the last one (Clement's Inn) was sold in 1903 and demolished in 1934.

History

[edit]

The Inns of Chancery evolved in tandem with the Inns of Court. During the 12th and early 13th centuries the law was taught in the City of London, primarily by the clergy. But during the 13th century an event occurred which ended legal education by the Church. A papal bull in 1218 prohibited the clergy from practising in the secular, common law courts. As a result, law began to be practised and taught by laymen instead of by clerics. To protect their schools from competition, Henry II and Henry III issued proclamations prohibiting the teaching of the civil law within the City of London.[1] These schools were based in hostels or "inns", which later took their name from the landlord of the inn in question.[2]

Early-18th-century engraving of Furnival's Inn by Sutton Nicholls

The Inns of Chancery sprung up around the Inns of Court, and took their name and original purpose from the chancery clerks, who used the buildings as hostels and offices where they would draft their writs.[3] As with the Inns of Court the precise dates of founding of the Inns of Chancery are unknown, but the one commonly said to be the oldest is Clifford's Inn,[4] which existed from at least 1344.[5] Thavie's Inn, founded in 1349, is considered to be the next oldest, and several legal historians mistakenly considered it the oldest of them all.[6]

For several centuries, education at one of the Inns of Chancery was the first step towards becoming a barrister. A student would first join one of the Inns of Chancery, where he would be taught in the form of moots and rote learning.[7] He would also be taught by Readers sent from the Inn of Court that his Inn of Chancery was attached to, who would preside over the moots and discuss cases with the students.[8] At the end of each legal term, particularly promising students would be transferred to the parent Inn of Court and begin the next stage of their education.[8] By 1461 there were approximately 100 students studying at the Inns of Chancery at any one time.[9]

At the same time, the Inns of Chancery was used as accommodation and offices by solicitors, the other branch of the English legal profession.[5] During the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries the purpose of the Inns changed. After the outbreak of the First English Civil War in 1642, the practice of teaching barristers in the Inns ceased, and as a result the Inns of Chancery became a dedicated association for solicitors instead, offering offices and accommodation. The foundation of the Society of Gentlemen Practisers and Law Society of England and Wales in 1739 and 1825 respectively as professional bodies for the solicitors profession relegated the Inns of Chancery to little more than eccentric dining clubs, and they were gradually dissolved and sold. In 1897 a popular book reported that nobody could remember the purpose of the buildings and that an 1850 investigation had failed to uncover their origins.[10] The last Inn to be sold was Clement's Inn, which was sold in 1903,[5] and demolished in 1934.[9]

Inns

[edit]
Staple Inn in 1886
Garden House, Clements Inn, 1883 by Philip Norman

John Fortescue wrote of ten Inns of Chancery, each one attached to an Inn of Court "like Maids of Honour to a Princess".[7] Only nine are known of in detail;[11] the other was St George's Inn.[12]

The ten Inns were:

(An eleventh Inn of Chancery, the Outer Temple, was said to exist by the legal historian John Baker in 2008.[13] This is denied by other writers.[14])

Many Inns were originally independent of the Inns of Court, and fell in and out of allegiance with them, with some claiming independence right up to the nineteenth century. Most Inns became directly attached to Inns of Court during the sixteenth century, however, when the Inns of Court began charging higher acceptance fees to students trained in independent Inns of Chancery than they did to students trained in "their" Inns of Chancery.[15]

Inner Temple attachments

[edit]

Clement's Inn was the last to be dissolved, being shut down in 1903. Located near St Clement Danes, the Inn was also named after Saint Clement and took as its coat of arms his, with a large letter C in sable.[15] The buildings were completely rebuilt in the 19th century in the Queen Anne Style. Noted members included Sir Edmund Saunders, and William Shakespeare made Justice Shallow, a character in Henry IV, Part 2, a member of the Inn.[16] Members were noted as "a wild lot" known for their drinking and parties.[17] In its later years the Inn was a poor one, and had no library or chapel, with most of the funds being spent on repairs and maintenance for the building.[18]

Lyon's Inn was "a place of considerable antiquity", with records from 1413.[4] Originally a hostel, it was purchased by the inhabitants and turned into an Inn of Chancery. Initially a small but respected Inn that educated people as noted as Sir Edward Coke, Lyon's Inn became a disreputable institution that "perished of public contempt long before it came to the hammer and the pick".[19] By the time it was dissolved it was inhabited only by the lowest lawyers and those struck off the rolls, and when surveyed it was found that it was run by only two Ancients, neither of whom had any idea what their duties were, and the Inn had not dined for over a century.[19] The Inn was dissolved in 1863,[20] pulled down in 1868[21] and replaced with the third Globe Theatre.[20]

Clifford's Inn was the oldest of the Inns of Chancery, and was first mentioned in 1344.[5] Although generally considered a dependent of the Inner Temple, its members always maintained that they were independent.[22] As a note of that "independence" it became custom for the Inner Temple to send them a message once a year, which would be received but deliberately not replied to.[22] Their coat of arms was a modified form of the Clifford family arms, with "cheque or and azure, a fess gules, a bordure, bezantée, of the third."[22] Noted students include John Selden; Sir Edward Coke was also said to have studied there, but historical records find no evidence of this, and he was always associated with Lyon's Inn more than Clifford's.[23]

Middle Temple attachments

[edit]

The first lawyers to occupy the premises which later became the Middle Temple came from St George's Inn,[24] arriving by 1346.[25] The inn was later deserted in favour of New Inn.[26]

Strand Inn, also called Chester Inn,[21] was the shortest lived of the Inns of Chancery. Founded in the fifteenth century it was pulled down in the 1540s by Lord Somerset in his role as Lord Protector so that he could build Somerset House.[4] The students instead went to New Inn, and Strand Inn was absorbed into that Inn. Thomas Occleve was said to have studied at Strand Inn.[4]

New Inn was founded in the late 15th century on the premises of Our Lady Inn, a hostel.[4] Noted students included Sir Thomas More, who attended New Inn before going to Lincoln's Inn.[27] The buildings of New Inn were pulled down in 1902 to make way for a road between Holborn and the Strand.[4] After the destruction of Strand Inn, New Inn was the only Inn of Chancery left attached to the Middle Temple.[28]

Lincoln's Inn attachments

[edit]

Furnival's Inn was founded before or during the reign of Henry IV and named after the Lords Furnival.[29] During the 1820s the Inn was completely rebuilt. Noted tenants include Charles Dickens, who began to write The Pickwick Papers whilst living there.[30] The Inn was demolished in 1897.[31]

Thavie's Inn was the second oldest Inn of Chancery, and was founded around 1349. It was sold in 1769.[32] Lawyers from Thavie's Inn were the first to occupy the premises which became Inner Temple in the 1320s.[33]

Gray's Inn attachments

[edit]

Staple Inn dated from at least 1415,[34] and was originally an inn where wool merchants stayed and haggled. In reference to this, the Inn coat of arms contained a bale of wool.[35] During the reign of Elizabeth I it was the largest of the Inns of Chancery, with 145 students and 69 as permanent residents. The buildings survived the great fire of London and were rebuilt in the seventeenth century,[36] and again in the nineteenth.[34] The Inn was shut down and the building sold to the Prudential Assurance Company in 1884, and part of it is now used as the headquarters of the Institute of Actuaries.[37]

Barnard's Inn, originally known as Mackworth's Inn after its owner, John Mackworth, was established in 1454 as an Inn of Chancery.[38] A large Inn, Barnard's had 112 students a year during the reign of Elizabeth I with 24 in permanent residence.[38] When it was an institute of legal education, it enforced the odd practice of fining a student when he got something wrong: a halfpenny for a defective word, a farthing for a defective syllable and a penny for an improper word.[38] Barnard's was under the supervision of Gray's Inn, who traditionally sent a Reader to the Inn every year, who was treated with great respect.[38] Noted pupils included Sir John Holt, later a distinguished jurist.[38] The Inn was badly damaged in the Gordon Riots after a rioter set fire to the distillery next door. In 1880 it was bought by the Worshipful Company of Mercers and used to house the Mercers' School.[39]

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]

Bibliography

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Inns of Chancery

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Inns of Chancery were a group of ten lesser inns in London, established primarily in the 14th and 15th centuries, that functioned as preparatory institutions for aspiring barristers by providing foundational legal education before students advanced to the more prestigious Inns of Court. Originating from buildings initially occupied by clerks of the royal Court of Chancery, these inns focused on practical instruction in areas such as the preparation of writs, conveyancing, and basic pleading, serving as an essential first step in the medieval and early modern English legal training system. Each Inn of Chancery was formally attached to one of the four principal Inns of Court—Inner Temple, Middle Temple, Lincoln's Inn, or Gray's Inn—by at least the 16th century, with students typically spending one to two years there under the oversight of their affiliated "greater" inn. The nine Inns of Chancery that survived into the 16th century were Barnard's Inn and Staple Inn (attached to Gray's Inn), Clifford's Inn, Clement's Inn, and Lyon's Inn (attached to Inner Temple), Furnival's Inn and Thavie's Inn (attached to Lincoln's Inn), New Inn (attached to Middle Temple), and Strand Inn (initially attached to Inner Temple but demolished in 1549 to make way for Somerset House). These institutions, often housed in timber-framed buildings clustered around Holborn and the Strand, not only offered lodging and moots (mock legal debates) but also fostered a collegiate environment that emphasized discipline and ethical conduct among young lawyers. By the early 17th century, however, their educational role began to shift toward training attorneys and solicitors rather than barristers, reflecting broader changes in the legal profession. The decline of the Inns of Chancery accelerated during the English Civil War, when formal teaching ceased around 1642 amid societal upheaval, leaving them to operate mainly as private dining clubs for legal practitioners. The formation of the Society of Gentlemen Practisers in 1739, which evolved into the Law Society of England and Wales in 1825, further diminished their influence by establishing centralized training for solicitors. Consequently, the inns were gradually sold off for urban development between 1769 (Thavie's Inn) and 1903 (Clifford's Inn), with their sites repurposed into offices, housing, or modern buildings, though some structures like those at Staple Inn survive as historic landmarks. Today, the Inns of Chancery represent a vanished layer of England's legal heritage, underscoring the evolution from informal medieval apprenticeships to the formalized bar training that persists through the surviving Inns of Court.

Origins and Historical Development

Early Origins

The emergence of the Inns of Chancery in medieval England was closely tied to the evolving landscape of legal education during the 12th and 13th centuries. Prior to this period, legal training had been largely dominated by the clergy, who held a monopoly on learning and often handled writs and court procedures in ecclesiastical and secular contexts. However, as the English common law developed as a distinct lay system, canon law prohibitions on clerics engaging in secular business prompted a transition to professional lay practitioners. This shift necessitated alternative venues for training outside the clerical universities like Oxford and Cambridge, where canon law prevailed over common law practice. In response, the Inns of Chancery initially served as lodging houses and preliminary training grounds for young clerks associated with the royal Court of Chancery and aspiring lawyers in the late 12th and 13th centuries. These establishments, located primarily between the City of London and Westminster, provided accommodations for students who observed court proceedings at Westminster Hall and practiced basic skills such as drafting writs—essential documents for initiating common law actions. By clustering near the royal courts, these inns facilitated informal education through apprenticeships and discussions, filling the gap left by the closure of early London law schools around 1235 under Henry III, possibly due to economic pressures like famine. This practical, guild-like approach contrasted with the theoretical focus of universities, making the inns vital for hands-on preparation in a burgeoning legal profession. The earliest documented Inn of Chancery, Clifford's Inn, was established around 1344 when Isabel, widow of Robert de Clifford, leased the property to a group of law students for £10 annually, marking the formalization of these societies in the mid-14th century. While possible precursors existed earlier in the century, such as informal hostels for Chancery clerks, Clifford's Inn exemplifies the transition from ad hoc arrangements to organized institutions. These inns were intrinsically linked to the Court of Chancery, the royal secretariat responsible for issuing writs and overseeing equitable remedies, as many residents were clerks learning administrative and procedural aspects of law that complemented the more advanced Inns of Court. This connection underscored the need for structured, non-university-based education to meet the demands of an expanding common law system, where writ knowledge was foundational for legal practice.

Growth and Peak Period

The Inns of Chancery experienced significant expansion during the 15th century, evolving from informal hostels for Chancery clerks into structured preparatory institutions for legal training. By around 1470, Sir John Fortescue described ten such inns, each accommodating at least 100 students focused on initial legal studies, indicating a total enrollment of at least 1,000 young men across the network. This growth reflected the increasing demand for legal education amid England's expanding administrative and judicial systems, with the inns providing essential entry points for aspiring lawyers before progression to the Inns of Court. Key establishments during this period included Lyon's Inn, founded in the early 15th century and attached to the Inner Temple, and Staple Inn, which became an Inn of Chancery around 1415 and was linked to Gray's Inn. Barnard's Inn followed in 1454, also affiliated with Gray's Inn, while New Inn emerged in the late 15th century under Middle Temple oversight. By 1500, nine inns had solidified their presence in London's legal quarter, fostering a vibrant ecosystem of preliminary instruction. These institutions profoundly influenced the legal profession by serving as gateways for aspiring barristers, where students engaged in basic studies of writs, pleadings, and court procedures, building foundational knowledge and professional networks. Under oversight from affiliated Inns of Court, they emphasized communal living and mentorship, preparing entrants for advanced training while integrating into the broader legal community. During the Elizabethan era, the inns reached their peak societal role, hosting moots, readings, and social functions that reinforced legal discourse and camaraderie within London's expanding legal landscape. For instance, Staple Inn, one of the largest, supported around 145 students during Elizabeth I's reign, underscoring its prominence in nurturing future practitioners. This period marked the inns' zenith as hubs of intellectual and social activity, contributing to the profession's prestige before shifts in legal practice began to alter their trajectory.

Functions and Organization

The Inns of Chancery provided preliminary legal training for aspiring barristers, emphasizing rote memorization of foundational legal texts such as original and judicial writs, alongside practical exercises like moots—mock trials where students debated simpler cases under the supervision of utter-barristers. This initial education also introduced basic principles of equity law derived from the Court of Chancery, preparing students for the procedural and discretionary aspects of legal practice that complemented common law. Unlike the more advanced, disputatious seminars in the Inns of Court, the Chancery Inns focused on building elementary skills through structured repetition and observation. Daily routines in the Inns of Chancery revolved around mandatory attendance at readings—formal expositions of statutes delivered by readers dispatched from the Inns of Court—and disputations, where students engaged in supervised discussions to refine arguments following these lectures. These sessions occurred on designated days during term time, such as Tuesdays and Thursdays for readings and Wednesdays and Fridays for moots, with additional grand moots held during vacations to simulate courtroom proceedings. Supervised studies under benchers ensured disciplined progress, distinguishing the preparatory, residential environment of the Chancery Inns from the independent advocacy training in the major Inns. Functioning as "nurseries" for legal students, the Inns of Chancery served a transitional role, grooming promising individuals for advancement to the Inns of Court after demonstrating proficiency in basics like writ drafting and equity procedures. However, this barrister-oriented training effectively ceased by 1642 amid the disruptions of the English Civil War, which suspended readings and moots across the legal inns. In the post-17th century period, the Inns of Chancery evolved to emphasize training for solicitors, shifting from advocacy preparation to administrative legal work, including client pleading and procedural management in courts like King's Bench and Common Pleas. This change reflected the Inns' declining prestige and the rise of printed legal literature, which supplanted traditional moots and readings with more practical apprenticeship models for the emerging solicitor profession.

Attachment System to Inns of Court

The Inns of Chancery established voluntary affiliations with one of the four principal Inns of Court—Inner Temple, Middle Temple, Lincoln's Inn, or Gray's Inn—beginning in the sixteenth century, forming dependent satellite relationships that provided governance, oversight, and pathways to full legal practice. These attachments were rooted in historical ties and mutual recognition rather than formal charters, allowing Chancery inns to operate as preparatory institutions under the supervisory authority of their affiliated Inn of Court. For instance, the Inner Temple oversaw Clifford's, Clement's, and Lyon's Inns, while Gray's Inn was linked to Staple and Barnard's Inns, with such associations solidified by at least the reign of Elizabeth I. Ultimate authority for calling members to the bar resided exclusively with the Inns of Court, ensuring that Chancery students progressed to their parent inn for admission as barristers after meeting preparatory requirements. These attachments offered significant benefits, including shared educational resources such as the appointment of readers by the Inns of Court to deliver lectures in the Chancery inns, fostering structured progression from basic legal training to advanced common law practice. Students benefited from mutual support in the form of recommendations for principals and access to the prestige and networks of the parent inn, which enhanced professional opportunities and housed attorneys, solicitors, and junior barristers. For example, Gray's Inn recommended individuals like Thomas Cary as principals for Staple Inn in 1584, illustrating collaborative oversight that strengthened the overall legal ecosystem. This system created clear pathways for career advancement, with Chancery inns serving as entry points that funneled talent into the Inns of Court, while the attachments ensured alignment with professional standards without fully subsuming the smaller inns' identities. Despite these ties, each Inn of Chancery retained operational independence through its own internal structures, including principals, halls, treasurers, and governing bodies like the twelve ancients or rulers, which managed daily affairs, commons, and fees. However, ultimate authority rested with the parent Inn of Court, which could intervene in elections, finances, and educational compliance, as seen in the Inner Temple's monitoring of Clifford's Inn through bench table orders. This hierarchical balance allowed Chancery inns to preserve unique customs, such as specific festive days or ceremonial rituals, while benefiting from the oversight that maintained educational quality. Historical disputes occasionally arose over the degree of independence, with some Chancery inns asserting greater autonomy from their parent institutions. For example, Clifford's Inn, attached to the Inner Temple, maintained claims of separation through its self-governing rules and rejected the Inner Temple's late assertion of rights to sale proceeds in 1900, as ruled in Smith v. Kerr, affirming its charitable status independent of direct control. Earlier tensions included a 1560s conflict between the Inner and Middle Temples over control of Lyon's Inn, resolved in favor of the Inner Temple by figures like Sir Nicholas Bacon of Gray's Inn, highlighting the voluntary yet contested nature of these affiliations. Internal complaints, such as the 1615 petition by Clifford's Inn members against their principal's financial practices, further underscore the oversight dynamics that sometimes strained relations.

Individual Inns by Affiliation

Inner Temple Attachments

The Inns of Chancery attached to the Inner Temple consisted of three institutions—Clifford's Inn, Clement's Inn, and Lyon's Inn—located in the vicinity of Fleet Street and focused on providing preliminary training in equity law for aspiring barristers before progression to the parent Inn. These attachments formed part of the broader system where the Inns of Court oversaw legal education at the Chancery inns, with the Inner Temple formally linking to Clifford's, Clement's, and Lyon's by the 16th century. Clifford's Inn, the oldest of the Inner Temple attachments, traces its origins to 1344, when Isabel de Clifford leased the property to a group of law students for an annual rent of £10, marking the earliest surviving reference to such an arrangement. The Inn operated semi-independently, retaining its own rules and customs despite formal affiliation with the Inner Temple in the 16th century, and served as initial lodging and instruction for young lawyers. Notable among its residents was the jurist and scholar John Selden, admitted in 1603 before transferring to the Inner Temple. Sir Edward Coke was also a notable member, recognized as one of the foremost legal minds during the reign of Queen Elizabeth I and the author of the famous statement “A man’s home is his castle – for where shall he be safe if it not be in his house?” It was just outside the area destroyed by the Great Fire of 1666 and escaped unscathed. Subsequent to the Great Fire, it served as the location of the court settling the hundreds of post-fire City land disputes. In the 19th century, Clifford's Inn appeared in several novels by Charles Dickens, providing glimpses of its daily life and atmosphere. In The Pickwick Papers (1836–1837), a body is found by a new tenant concealed in a locked cupboard in a flat at the Inn. In Bleak House (1852–1853), the character Melchisedec has chambers there. In Little Dorrit (1855–1857), Edward "Tip" Dorrit works as a clerk at Clifford's Inn for six months. In Our Mutual Friend (1864–1865), it is described as a "quiet place" where John Rokesmith speaks with Noddy Boffin. Dickens often depicted real London scenes without naming them explicitly, and Clifford's Inn likely inspired unnamed locations in other works. There is also unproven speculation that Dickens envisaged Ebenezer Scrooge's residence in A Christmas Carol (1843) at Clifford's Inn, based on a reference in the story to St Dunstan, suggesting the church of St Dunstan in the West, located nearby. Among other notable 19th-century residents of Clifford's Inn was the author Samuel Butler, who lived there from 1871 to 1886 and wrote significant works including Erewhon and The Way of All Flesh. The Inn also housed the eccentric bibliophile George Dyer (1755–1841), who resided there for nearly 50 years from 1792 until his death and was featured in Charles Lamb's essay "Amicus Redivivus." By the late 19th century, declining membership led to its dissolution. As the last surviving Inn of Chancery linked to the Inner Temple, the property was sold in 1903 following a Chancery suit, with most buildings demolished in 1934, leaving only the gatehouse intact today. The name Clifford’s Inn is retained by a 1930s building on the site comprising both offices and apartments. A blue plaque on the building remembers Virginia and Leonard Woolf, resident immediately after their wedding. Among twentieth century residents were Lord Denning, Master of the Rolls. Clement's Inn, whose exact founding date remains unknown but likely dates to the mid-14th century, functioned as a preparatory venue for Chancery clerks and Inner Temple students, situated near the Strand and St. Clement Danes church. Its buildings were comprehensively rebuilt in the 19th century in the Queen Anne style, reflecting a period of modernization amid shifting legal practices. The Inn gained a reputation for its lively membership, described as a "wild lot" prone to drinking and revelry, though regulations limited wine consumption to a half-pint per member on grand days by the mid-19th century. Clement's Inn declined in the late 19th century, with its buildings sold and demolished starting around 1891 to make way for new developments. Lyon's Inn emerged around 1413, with early records indicating its establishment as a hostel that evolved into an educational institution for law students attached to the Inner Temple, whose freehold the parent Inn purchased in 1583. Located off the former Wych Street in what is now the Aldwych area, it provided foundational training in legal procedures, including readings delivered by Inner Temple members as early as the 1560s. The Inn's fortunes waned in the 19th century due to reduced enrollment, leading to its dissolution and sale by members in 1863, after which the site was demolished as part of urban redevelopment.

Middle Temple Attachments

The Inns of Chancery attached to the Middle Temple were notably fewer in number and shorter-lived compared to those affiliated with other Inns of Court, primarily consisting of St. George's Inn, Strand Inn, and New Inn. These attachments reflected the Middle Temple's historical development in the vicinity of the Strand, where proximity to royal and urban expansions often led to their transience and eventual displacement. St. George's Inn served as an early precursor to the Middle Temple itself, with its legal occupants relocating to the Temple site by 1346, marking one of the earliest documented migrations of chancery students to an Inn of Court. Situated in Seacole Lane near St. Sepulchre's Church without Newgate, the inn's exact foundation date remains unknown, and records are sparse, indicating minimal documentation of its operations. It was eventually deserted due to its poor condition and remote location, with surviving students transferring to the emerging New Inn in the late medieval period. Strand Inn, established in the 15th century, functioned briefly as a satellite to the Middle Temple, providing preliminary legal training before its abrupt end. Located along the Strand, it was demolished in the 1540s—specifically by 1549—when the site was requisitioned by Edward Seymour, Duke of Somerset, to construct Somerset House as his royal residence. This royal intervention exemplified how the inn's proximity to Westminster and the Thames influenced its short existence, leaving the Middle Temple with reduced chancery attachments thereafter. New Inn, founded around 1485 in the parish of St. Clement Danes, endured longer as a key preparatory institution for Middle Temple students, though its active role waned over time. It notably hosted Sir Thomas More as a student in his youth, serving as an initial training ground in legal pleading and moots before he progressed to Lincoln's Inn. By the 17th century, its educational functions diminished, with the last moot held in 1831 and no further Readers sent to the Middle Temple after 1846; surviving records begin in 1601 but suffered losses from wars, plagues, and fires. The inn was compulsorily purchased and demolished in 1902 by the London County Council to widen roads for the Kingsway development, with proceeds allocated to legal education (£55,000), Middle Temple Benchers (£45,500), life tenants (£26,000), and members (£31,000); it fully faded by 1937 with the death of its last member. Collectively, these inns highlight the Middle Temple's attachments as more transient than those of other societies, shaped by the area's royal developments and urban pressures that prioritized palatial and infrastructural projects over legal hostels.

Lincoln's Inn Attachments

Lincoln's Inn, one of the four Inns of Court, had two Inns of Chancery attached to it: Furnival's Inn and Thavie's Inn, both situated in the Holborn area of London and primarily serving administrative legal functions such as training in the preparation of writs and documents for attorneys and solicitors. These attachments operated under the governance of Lincoln's Inn, providing preliminary legal education before students advanced to the parent Inn. Furnival's Inn was established around 1388 during the reign of Richard II, when it was demised to law students by the Lords Furnival, and it became formally attached to Lincoln's Inn through a purchase in 1547 for £120 from the Earl of Shrewsbury. The inn's original buildings were largely destroyed around 1640 and rebuilt, but in 1817, Lincoln's Inn declined to renew the lease, leading to a major reconstruction between 1818 and 1820 by architect Henry Peto into chambers and a hotel. Notably, Charles Dickens resided at Furnival's Inn from 1834 to 1837 while writing The Pickwick Papers, and the location later inspired fictional settings in his Martin Chuzzlewit. The inn was demolished in 1897 to make way for the Prudential Assurance Company's Gothic Revival headquarters, designed by Alfred and Paul Waterhouse. Thavie's Inn, the second oldest Inn of Chancery after Clifford's Inn, originated before 1348 from property owned by the armourer John Tavy, whose will bequeathed it for the upkeep of St. Andrew Holborn church. It was acquired by Lincoln's Inn in 1551 via a quitclaim from Gregory Nicholas for £75, solidifying its role as an attached institution for legal training. Records of the inn are sparse, but it was sold by Lincoln's Inn in 1772 to Thomas Middleton for £4,100 to fund improvements to the parent inn's estate; the site subsequently burned down before 1804, was rebuilt as private housing by 1818, and later served as a workhouse and infirmary before destruction during World War II. Thavie's Inn also gained literary notability, appearing as the residence of the character Mrs. Jellyby in Dickens's Bleak House. These two inns shared a focus on preparatory legal work in equity and common law administration, fostering an environment that influenced early 19th-century novelists like Dickens, whose works often depicted the legal world's intricacies through their Holborn locales.

Gray's Inn Attachments

The Inns of Chancery attached to Gray's Inn were Staple Inn and Barnard's Inn, both located in Holborn in northern London and reflecting elements of commercial law training due to their historical ties to mercantile activities. Staple Inn, founded around 1415, originated as a hall for wool staple merchants involved in the taxation and trade of wool, a key medieval English export, before evolving into an Inn of Chancery affiliated with Gray's Inn. It was the largest such inn, accommodating up to 140 resident students in 1577 during the Elizabethan era, when overall enrollment in the Inns of Chancery peaked amid expanding legal education demands. The inn was sold in 1884 to the Prudential Assurance Company, with part of the site acquired by the Patent Office; its iconic timber-framed frontage from 1586 survives as a Grade I listed historic building, one of the few remnants of the Inns of Chancery. Barnard's Inn, established in 1454 and originally known as Mackworth's Inn after its early owner, John Mackworth, served as the other key attachment to Gray's Inn, providing preliminary legal training with a focus on practical skills suited to commercial disputes. It hosted around 112 students annually during the Elizabethan period, contributing to the era's high demand for legal practitioners. The inn sustained significant damage during the 1780 Gordon Riots, when anti-Catholic mobs targeted nearby properties, but received compensation for repairs. Sold in 1888, its 15th-century hall endures as a preserved structure, now serving as the primary venue for Gresham College since 1991. These two inns shared a location in northern London, emphasizing commercial law aspects through their mercantile roots, and stand out for the partial preservation of their buildings compared to most other Inns of Chancery, which were largely demolished.

Decline and Modern Legacy

Factors Leading to Decline

The outbreak of the English Civil War in 1642 led to the immediate cessation of barrister training at the Inns of Chancery, as the conflict disrupted legal education across all inns, emptying halls and suspending traditional exercises like readings and moots. This interruption, coupled with evolving educational needs that favored more formal university study over the inns' apprenticeship model, marked the beginning of their institutional decline. Following the Restoration in 1660, the Inns of Chancery were repurposed primarily as offices and associations for solicitors, who had been increasingly excluded from the Inns of Court since the mid-16th century, reflecting a sharpening divide between the barrister and solicitor branches of the profession. However, this role was undermined by the professionalization of solicitors through organizations like the Society of Gentleman Practisers in 1739 and, more decisively, the Law Society of England and Wales in 1825, which centralized training, regulation, and social functions, rendering the inns obsolete as professional hubs. Economic pressures further accelerated the decline, as declining memberships and maintenance costs prompted the sale of inn properties for urban development in 19th- and early 20th-century London; for instance, New Inn was compulsorily purchased in 1902 by the London County Council for the Kingsway improvement scheme, while Clifford's Inn, the last surviving inn, was sold in 1903 and later demolished. The status of the Outer Temple as a potential tenth Inn of Chancery remains disputed among historians, with evidence from 15th-century records suggesting its brief existence as a preparatory society, though lacking comprehensive documentation to confirm its full integration with the other inns.

Current Status and Remnants

Today, only fragments of the Inns of Chancery remain in London, with two sites preserving notable structures from their original layouts. Staple Inn, attached to Gray's Inn, stands as the sole largely intact example, its timber-framed frontage on High Holborn dating to the late 16th century and having miraculously survived both the Great Fire of 1666 and World War II bombing. Designated a Grade I listed building by Historic England, it serves as a protected historic site, though its hall was destroyed by a V-1 flying bomb in 1944 and subsequently rebuilt. Barnard's Inn, also linked to Gray's Inn, retains its medieval hall—one of the few City structures to endure both the Great Fire and the Blitz—and is now the headquarters of Gresham College, which uses the space for lectures and events since 1991. Most other Inns of Chancery have been entirely erased from the landscape, leaving only traces in street names and modern developments. Clifford's Inn, affiliated with the Inner Temple, was dissolved in 1903, with its buildings demolished in 1934 to make way for a contemporary mansion block containing grade A offices and luxury residential apartments; only the original gatehouse in Clifford's Inn Passage survives as a listed remnant. Clement's Inn, connected to the Inner Temple, met a similar fate, sold in 1884 and its buildings demolished by 1891, its site now occupied by modern office and residential buildings. The legacy of the Inns of Chancery endures in the foundational structure of English legal education, where their role in preliminary training for what became the solicitors' profession influenced the division between barristers (trained at the Inns of Court) and solicitors, a distinction that persists today despite reforms like the Legal Practice Course. Archives from sites like Staple and Barnard's Inns, held by Gray's Inn and the Law Society, provide key resources for understanding this evolution. In the 21st century, heritage efforts have highlighted these remnants through commemorative plaques, such as the black plaque at Staple Inn marking the 1944 destruction of its hall, and occasional scholarly discussions on early inns like St. George's Inn, an early precursor to the Middle Temple absorbed by 1346, where records continue to fuel debates about their exact operations and affiliations. No significant physical changes to the surviving remnants have occurred since the mid-20th century, underscoring their status as static echoes of medieval legal institutions.

References

  1. https://www.innertemple.org.uk/who-we-are/history/historical-articles/the-inns-of-court-and-inns-of-chancery-and-their-records/
  2. https://www.graysinn.org.uk/the-inn/history/the-historic-estate/inns-of-chancery/
  3. https://www.papalencyclicals.net/councils/ecum12-2.htm
  4. https://scholarship.law.vanderbilt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4201&context=vlr
  5. https://cliffordsinn.uk/history-of-cliffords-inn/
  6. https://www.gresham.ac.uk/hire-barnards-inn-hall
  7. https://scholarship.law.nd.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3938&context=ndlr
  8. https://digitalcommons.law.uw.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1060&context=wlr
  9. http://www.minnesotalegalhistoryproject.org/assets/Antiquities%2520of%2520Inns%2520of%2520Court%2520and%2520Chancery%25201804.pdf
  10. https://www.innertemple.org.uk/who-we-are/history/historical-articles/lost-in-the-past-the-rediscovered-archives-of-cliffords-inn/
  11. https://cbr.cba.org/index.php/cbr/article/download/1225/1225
  12. https://www.innertemplelibrary.org.uk/inner-temple/history/inns-of-chancery/
  13. http://cliffordsinn.info/history.html
  14. https://www.charlesdickenspage.com/dickens-london/cliffords-inn
  15. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/1906/1906-h/1906-h.htm
  16. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Dictionary_of_National_Biography,_1885-1900/Dyer,_George
  17. https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/lsehistory/2022/08/09/devoid-of-famous-tradition-the-history-of-clements-inn/
  18. https://regrom.com/2020/04/10/regency-hot-spots-clements-inn/
  19. https://www.grubstreetproject.net/places/5872/
  20. https://www.middletemple.org.uk/archive-history/archive-month/january-2020-new-inn-middle-temple%E2%80%99s-lost-inn-chancery
  21. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Inns-of-Court
  22. https://www.lincolnsinn.org.uk/library-archives/tales-from-the-archive/september-2017-furnivals-inn/
  23. https://www.lincolnsinn.org.uk/library-archives/tales-from-the-archive/november-2016-tavy-thavy-or-davy-the-mystery-of-thavies-inn/
  24. https://medievallondon.ace.fordham.edu/exhibits/show/medieval-london-sites/stapleinn
  25. https://www.familysearch.org/en/wiki/Staple_Inn%2C_Middlesex%2C_England_Genealogy
  26. https://historiclondontours.com/tales-of-london/f/maids-of-honour-to-a-princess
  27. https://exploring-london.com/tag/staple-inn/
  28. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/english-law-under-two-elizabeths/english-legal-system-under-elizabeth-i/EBD7B26D74D5867806E082BFF2DDF70F
  29. https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/assets/Services-Environment/chancery-lane-conservation-area-character-summary-management-strategy.pdf
  30. https://programme.openhouse.org.uk/listings/4838
  31. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1103274
  32. https://www.grubstreetproject.net/places/277/
  33. https://www.ianvisits.co.uk/articles/londons-alleys-barnards-inn-ec1-35314/
  34. https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/1888-05-17/debates/41e31b84-8f6b-4319-afda-fa85a89ddad9/BarnardSInn%25E2%2580%2594SaleOfTheInn
  35. https://www.gresham.ac.uk/about-us/venues/barnards-inn-hall
  36. https://www.middletemple.org.uk/archive-history/archive-month/january-2020-new-inn-middle-temple%25E2%2580%2599s-lost-inn-chancery
  37. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/collected-papers-on-english-legal-history/inn-of-the-outer-temple/ACB6D3795EC34624C8B610EB95A07645
  38. https://www.innertemple.org.uk/who-we-are/history/cliffords-inn/
  39. https://www.gibberd.com/projects/cliffords-inn
  40. https://www.londonmuseum.org.uk/collections/v/object-439081/clements-inn-garden-house/
  41. https://www.graysinn.org.uk/the-inn/archives/barnards-inn-and-staple-inn-archives/
  42. https://www.londonremembers.com/memorials/staple-inn-hall
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.