Miss Wisconsin
Miss Wisconsin
Main page
1762307

Miss Wisconsin

logo
Community Hub0 subscribers
Read side by side
from Wikipedia
Laura Kaeppeler, Miss Wisconsin 2011 & Miss America 2012

Key Information

Christina Anna Thompson, Miss Wisconsin 2007
Tracy Ann Gest, Miss Wisconsin 2005

The Miss Wisconsin competition is the pageant, held annually in New Berlin, that selects the representative for the U.S. state of Wisconsin in the annual Miss America pageant.

Wisconsin has won the Miss America title three times: 1973, 2012, and 2023.


On September 17, 2024, the state pageant announced that the Miss Wisconsin pageant (as well as the Miss Wisconsin's Teen pageant) will be held in New Berlin, Wisconsin. This will mark the first time that Waukesha County will host the annual state pageants. Miss Wisconsin moved to Oshkosh in 1963 after four years being held in Kenosha.

Jordenne Demiree Butler of Onalaska was crowned Miss Wisconsin on June 20, 2026, at the West Performing Arts Center in New Berlin. She will compete for the title of Miss America 2027 on September 6, 2026 in West Palm Beach, Florida.

On Saturday, June 20, 2026, outgoing Miss Wisconsin 2025, Willow Ybre Newell crowned Jordenne Demiree Butler in New Berlin, who competed with the appointed title of Miss River City. She was Miss Wisconsin's Teen 2015 making her the fourth state teen titleholder to advance to the Miss Wisconsin title. The dancer also has the distinction of being the oldest woman, at age 27, to be crowned Miss Wisconsin, and the first to win the state crown with an appointed local title since Jeanne "Jeannie" Eleanor Huston was appointed Miss La Crosse when she was also appointed Miss Wisconsin in 1952, the year when the Wisconsin Junior Chamber of Commerce did not sponsor and organize a Miss Wisconsin contest.

Butler, who likely is the very last woman born in the twentieth century to be named Miss Wisconsin, will now advance to the 2026 Miss America competition this September in West Palm Beach, Florida where Miss America 2027 is chosen.

Meghan Marie Coffey DeMore (Miss Wisconsin 2006), who became state pageant executive director earlier in 2026, made history as the first former Miss Wisconsin to become state executive director, after several years as co-executive director and operations manager.

Results summary

[edit]

The following is a visual summary of the past results of Miss Wisconsin titleholders at the national Miss America pageants/competitions. The year in parentheses indicates the year of the national competition during which a placement and/or award was garnered, not the year attached to the contestant's state title.

Placements

[edit]
  • Miss Americas: Terry Meeuwsen (1973), Laura Kaeppeler (2012), Grace Stanke (2023)
  • 1st runners-up: Mary Alice Fox (1960), Joan Mary Engh (1963), Judith Hieke (1974)
  • 2nd runners-up: Barbara Burk Baugh (1968), Tina Marie Sauerhammer (2004)
  • 3rd runners-up: N/A
  • 4th runners-up: Sharon Mae Singstock (1966)
  • Top 8: Christina Anna Thompson (2008)
  • Top 10: Keungsuk Kim (1982), Tania Ziegler (1994), Mary-Louise Kurey (2000)
  • Top 11: Mandi Jo Genord (2025)
  • Top 12: Paula Mae Kuiper (2014)
  • Top 15: Clara Ethel Koehler (1924), Bette Annne Miller (1941), Phyllis Ann Kessler (1949), Tianna Marie Vanderhei (2019)
  • Top 16: Antoine (Toni) Lunde (1946)
  • Top 18: Marie Marguerite Huebner (1933)

Awards

[edit]

Preliminary awards

[edit]

Non-finalist awards

[edit]
  • Non-finalist Interview: Nicole Jean Locy (1998)
  • Non-finalist Talent: Lynn Byron Holden (1957), Marilyn Jean Sembell (1976), Gail Marie Soller (1983), Maria Kim (1988), Tricia Ann Luedtke (1991), Stephanie Klett (1993), Joya Josephine Zamora (2001)

Other awards

[edit]
  • Miss Congeniality: N/A
  • Bernie Wayne Performing Arts Award: Mary-Louise Kurey (2000)
  • Dr. David B. Allman Medical Scholarship: Carol Ann Schmitt (1975)
  • Quality of Life Award Finalists: Laura Herriot (2002), Molly McGrath (2005)
  • Special Education Award: Carol Ann Schmitt (1975)
  • Special Scholarship Award: Barbara Jean Bonville (1964)
  • STEM Scholarship 2nd runner-up: Jennifer Marie Schmidt (2022)
  • AHA Go Red for Women Leadership Award Regional Winner: Mandi Jo Genord (2025)

Winners

[edit]
  •   Declared as winner
  •   Ended as a runner-up
  •   Ended as a finalist or semi-finalist
Year Name Hometown Age Local title Miss America talent Placement at Miss America Special scholarships at Miss America Notes
2026 Jordenne Demiree Butler Onalaska 27 Miss River City (appointed title) Jazz Dance, "Thats Life" by Frank Sinatra TBD TBD Competed for Miss Wisconsin six times, tied a state pageant record with Tianna Marie Vanderhei (2018)

Previously Miss Wisconsin's Outstanding Teen 2015
2025 Willow Ybre Newell Racine 22 Miss Racine Vocal "I am Telling You" from the musical "Dreamgirls" First black woman to be named Miss Wisconsin
2024 Mandi Jo Genord Beaver Dam 22 Miss Northern Lights Lyrical jazz dance "You Don't Own Me" by Lesley Gore Top 11 Preliminary Fitness Award

AHA Go Red for Women Leadership Award Regional Winner
Previously Miss Wisconsin's Outstanding Teen 2018
2023 Lila Hui Szyryj Madison 22 Miss South Central Classical piano, "Revolutionary Etude" by Frederic Chopin She is the fifth Asian-American, first Chinese-American, and first Madison native to win Miss Wisconsin.
2022 Kylene Elizabeth Spanbauer Fond du Lac 23 Miss Harbor Cities Baton, "Holding Out for a Hero" Did not compete; originally 1st runner-up, later assumed the title after Stanke won Miss America 2023[1]
Previously Miss Wisconsin's Outstanding Teen 2016
Grace Stanke Wausau 20 Miss Badgerland Classical Violin, "The Storm" by Antonio Vivaldi Winner Preliminary Talent Award Winner Previously Miss Wisconsin's Outstanding Teen 2017;[2] first woman to hold both state titles[citation needed]
2021 Jennifer Marie Schmidt[3] Racine 25 Miss Rock River Valley Jazz Dance STEM Scholarship 2nd runner-up
2019–20[a] Alyssa Marie Bohm[6] Mount Pleasant 24 Tap Dance, "Feeling Good"
2018 Tianna Marie Vanderhei[7] Wisconsin Rapids 25 Miss Wood Violet Contemporary Dance, "Lean on Me" by Bill Withers Top 15[8] Preliminary On Stage Interview Award[9] Competed for Miss Wisconsin six times, a state pageant record[citation needed]
2017 McKenna Holly Collins[10] Waunakee 20 Miss Madison Ballet en Pointe, “Habanera” from Carmen Previously a company member at the Madison Ballet[11]

Daughter of Wisconsin's Alice in Dairyland 1992, Kristan Ann Conrad[12]
2016 Courtney Jean Pelot[13] Manitowoc 22 Miss Green Bay Area Dance, "Burnin' Up" by Jessie J
2015 Rosalie Elizabeth Smith[14] Waukesha 19 Miss New Berlin Lyrical Dance, "Heaven" by Beyoncé
2014 Raeanna Mary Johnson Holmen 24 Miss Madison Lyrical Dance, "Hallelujah" 3rd runner-up at National Sweetheart 2011 pageant[15]

First woman to hold the Miss Wisconsin title twice

4th runner-up at Miss Wisconsin USA 2017 pageant[citation needed]
2013 Paula Mae Kuiper[16] Mount Pleasant 19 Miss Madison Piano, "Hungarian Rhapsody" Top 12
2012 Kathryn (Kate) Bess Gorman[citation needed] Onalaska 23 Miss La Crosse/Oktoberfest Vocal, "20th Century Fox Mambo" from Smash
2011 Raeanna Mary Johnson[17] Holmen 21 Miss Seven Rivers Lyrical Dance, "Hallelujah" by Alexandra Burke Did not compete; originally 1st runner-up, later assumed the title after Kaeppeler won Miss America 2012
Laura Kaeppeler Kenosha 23 Miss Southern Wisconsin Operatic Vocal, "Il Bacio" by Luigi Arditi Winner[18] Preliminary Talent Award Contestant at National Sweetheart 2010 pageant[citation needed]

Married TV producer, Mike Fleiss in 2014[19]
2010 Kimberly Brooke Sawyer Egg Harbor 22 Miss Green Bay Area Classical Vocal, "Donde lieta uscì" from La bohème
2009 Kristina Kelly Smaby Holmen 22 Miss Madison Ballet en Pointe, "River Deep – Mountain High"
2008 Briana Rose Lipor Racine 21 Miss South Central Classical Vocal, "Chi Il Bel Sogno di Doretta" from La rondine
2007 Christina Anna Thompson[20] Pleasant Prairie 23 Miss Madison Classical Violin, "Praeludium & Allegro" by Fritz Kreisler Top 8
2006 Meghan Marie Coffey New Berlin 22 Miss New Berlin Baton Twirling, "Stuff Like That There" Previously Wisconsin's National Teenager 2003
2005 Tracy Ann Gest Menomonee Falls 20 Miss New Berlin Classical Piano, "Morceaux de fantaisie" Previously Beauties of America Teen 2003[citation needed]
2004 Molly Jean McGrath Wisconsin Rapids 22 Miss Madison Theatrical Ballet en Pointe, "All That Jazz" Quality of Life Award Finalist
2003 Tina Marie Sauerhammer Green Bay 22 Miss Madison Classical Cello, "Le cygne" 2nd runner-up Preliminary Talent Award
2002 Jayme Michel Dawicki New Berlin 22 Miss Southern Wisconsin Classical Piano, "Wedding Day at Troldhaugen"
2001 Laura Margaret Herriot Princeton 23 Miss Berlin Vocal, "Oh, Lady Be Good!" Quality of Life Award Finalist
2000 Joya Josephine Zamora Kenosha 23 Miss Eastern Shore Vocal, "Life Is Just a Bowl of Cherries" Non-finalist Talent Award
1999 Mary-Louise Kurey Brookfield 24 Miss West Allis Classical Vocal, "Il Bacio" Top 10 Bernie Wayne Performing Arts Award

Preliminary Talent Award
1998 Jill Marie Patzner Arcadia 22 Miss Western Wisconsin Semi-classical Vocal, "Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again" from The Phantom of the Opera
1997 Nicole Jean Locy Glendale 22 Miss Western Wisconsin Vocal, "Someone Else's Story" from Chess Non-finalist Interview Award
1996 Jennifer Marie Streblow Oshkosh 18 Miss Oshkosh Vocal, "Someone Like You" from Jekyll & Hyde
1995 Pamela Lynn Polk Berlin 22 Miss Southeastern Wisconsin Vocal, "Operator"
1994 Laura Jean Voss Green Bay 22 Miss Green Bay Semi-classical Vocal, West Side Story Medley
1993 Tania Elizabeth Ziegler Fond du Lac 18 Miss Fond du Lac Classical Violin, "Bruch's Concerto No. 1 in G Minor" Top 10
1992 Stephanie Klett Beloit 25 Miss Wisconsin Central Coronet Medley, "Basin Street Blues" & "Ciribiribin" Non-finalist Talent Award[21] Later Secretary of the Wisconsin Department of Tourism[21] (2011-2019)
1991 Brenda Jo Haines Arcadia 19 Miss Arcadia Jazz Clarinet
1990 Tricia Ann Luedtke Oostburg 19 Miss Oshkosh Classical Piano, "Polichinelle in F Sharp Minor" Non-finalist Talent Award
1989 Kimberly Jean Totdahl Racine 23 Miss Kenosha Vocal & Dance, "Being Alive" Previously Miss Wisconsin T.E.E.N. 1982

Later Miss Wisconsin USA 1991
1988 Jeanie Marie Pfeiffer Franksville 25 Miss Milwaukee Vocal, "Rock-a-Bye Your Baby with a Dixie Melody"
1987 Maria Kim Shorewood 20 Miss Madison Classical Piano, "Fantaisie-Impromptu" Non-finalist Talent Award

Preliminary Talent Award
Previously Miss Wisconsin National Teenager 1983

Previously Miss Wisconsin Teen USA 1985. She is the younger sister of Keungsuk Kim (Miss Wisconsin 1981)
1986 Mara Ann Nesemann Brookfield 20 Miss Waukesha County Gymnastics Dance Routine, "1980"
1985 Mary Kay Anderson St. Francis 20 Miss St. Francis Piano, "Frederik Chopin's Etude, Winter Wind, Op 25, No 11" Later Miss Wisconsin USA 1988
1984 Barbara Marie Mullally Onalaska 22 Miss La Crosse/Oktoberfest Vocal, "Here I Am" Toured with Miss America USO Troupe, 1985
1983 Wendy Lynn Wagner Menomonie / Des Plaines, Illinois 22 Miss Menomonie Vocal, "Mira" from Carnival!
1982 Gail Marie Soller La Crosse 24 Miss La Crosse/Oktoberfest Classical Vocal, "Mon cœur s'ouvre à ta voix" Non-finalist Talent Award
1981 Keungsuk Kim Shorewood 19 Miss Milwaukee Classical Piano, "Kabalevsky's Prelude" Top 10 She is the older sister of Maria Kim (Miss Wisconsin 1987)
1980 Dana Lorraine Spychalla Appleton 19 Miss Fond du Lac Vocal, "The Music and the Mirror" from A Chorus Line
1979 Kristine Kay Konrad Oshkosh 19 Miss Oshkosh Vocal, "Starting Here, Starting Now"
1978 Carin Ann Kizewic Racine 24 Miss Milwaukee Ballet en Pointe, "The Overture" from Die Fledermaus
1977 Jennifer Mae Woychik Arcadia 19 Miss Arcadia Vocal Comedy, "I Love Trash"
1976 Julie Ann Nowak Greendale 19 Miss West Allis Popular Vocal, "Do You Know Where You're Going To?"
1975 Marilyn Jean Sembell Beloit / St. Louis, Missouri 25 Miss Lake Geneva Classical Piano, "Prelude in G minor" Non-finalist Talent Award
1974 Carol Ann Schmitt Green Bay 22 Miss Milwaukee Vocal, "Speak Softly Love" Dr. David B. Allman Medical Scholarship

Special Education Award
1973 Judith Hieke Menomonee Falls 19 Miss Milwaukee Flute Medley including "Cuanto le Gusta" 1st runner-up Preliminary Swimsuit Award
1972 Linda Marie Henderson Elm Grove 20 Miss Milwaukee-Summerfest Ballet[citation needed] Did not compete; originally 1st runner-up, later assumed the title after Meeuwsen won Miss America 1973
Terry Meeuwsen De Pere 23 Miss Appleton Vocal, "He Touched Me" from Drat! The Cat! Winner Preliminary Swimsuit Award

Preliminary Talent Award
1971 Patricia Ann Jacobs Wauwatosa 19 Miss Stevens Point Vocal & Dance, "On a Clear Day You Can See Forever" Toured with Miss America USO Troupe
1970 Linda Jane Johnson Milwaukee 19 Miss Madison Piano, "Polonaise"
1969 Cynthia Ann Morgan Janesville 18 Miss Janesville Vocal, "Old Devil Moon"
1968 Marilyn Kay Brahmsteadt Wisconsin Rapids 21 Miss La Crosse Vocal, "What a Diff'rence a Day Made"
1967 Barbara Burk Baugh Brookfield 20 Miss Milwaukee Vocal, "Mira" from Carnival! 2nd runner-up Barbara Burk Baugh Waters died at age 55 on October 26, 2002, at home in Brookfield, Wis. after a long battle with cancer.
1966 Candace Gail Hinz Milwaukee 19 Miss West Allis Piano & Watercolor Painting, "Tara's Theme" from Gone with the Wind
1965 Sharon Mae Singstock Oshkosh 20 Miss Oshkosh Vocal, "Rock-a-Bye Your Baby With a Dixie Melody" 4th runner-up
1964 Angela Gina Baldi Glendale 18 Miss North Shore Piano, "On Wisconsin in Three Variations"
1963 Barbara Jean Bonville Whitefish Bay 19 Miss North Shore Cello, "Pièce en forme de Habanera" by Maurice Ravel Special Scholarship Award
1962 Joan Mary Engh La Crosse 21 Miss La Crosse Vocal Comedy, "I'll Be Anything You Want Me to Be" 1st runner-up Preliminary Swimsuit Award Served as Wisconsin's Alice in Dairyland in 1960.
1961 Diane Margaret Anderson Eau Claire 19 Miss Eau Claire Violin & Ballet en Pointe, "The Swan"
1960 Karen Marie Fahrenbach Racine 21 Miss Racine Classical Ballet en Pointe, "The Sleeping Beauty" Karen Marie Fahrenbach Thompson died of cancer at age 68 on November 6, 2007, in Racine, Wisconsin.
1959 Mary Alice Fox Sheboygan 20 Miss Sheboygan Soft Shoe Comedy Dance 1st runner-up Preliminary Swimsuit Award
1958 Kay Joan Ross West Allis 24 Miss West Allis Art Presentation with Vocal & Dance
1957 Joan Carol Hentschel Wauwatosa 18 Miss Wauwatosa Interpretive Ballet, "3:00 in the Morning"
1956 Lynn Byron Holden Milwaukee 19 Miss Ripon Piano Non-finalist Talent Award Lynn Holden Noakes died at age 79 on April 8, 2016 in Florida
1955 Margaret Carolynne Walls Milwaukee 18 Miss Milwaukee Ballet, "Dying Swan" Margaret Walls Carseth died at age 88 on November 8, 2025 in San Antonio, Texas.
1954 Dixie Ann Sarchet Stevens Point 19 Miss Wisconsin Rapids Modern Dance, "Slaughter on Tenth Avenue" Dixie Ann Sarchet Kuenn married Detroit Tigers baseball player and future Milwaukee Brewers coach and manager Harvey Edward Kuenn on October 29, 1955, in Stevens Point, Wisconsin. She died at 69 on March 12, 2004, in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
1953 Judith Lee Jacobsen Wauwatosa 19 Miss Milwaukee Vocal & Dance, "Make Believe" & "Come Back to Sorrento"
1952 Jeanne "Jeannie" Eleanor Huston La Crosse 19 Miss La Crosse Cello
1951 Sheila Marie Murphy Marshfield 18 Miss Marshfield Monologue
1950 Gloria Betty Lange Milwaukee 20 Miss Milwaukee Operatic Vocal, "The Donkey Serenade" from The Firefly
1949 Phyllis Ann Kessler Green Bay 18 Miss Green Bay Baton Twirling Top 15 Phyllis Ann Kessler Lynn Sacho died at age 90 on March 7, 2022, in De Pere, Wisconsin. At the time of her death, she was the oldest and earliest living Miss Wisconsin titleholder.
1948 Marvene Margaret Fischer Milwaukee 19 Miss Milwaukee
1947 Gladys Elaine Berkley Baraboo 19 Miss Baraboo Monologue Gladys Elaine Berkley Stracy died of a brief illness in Madison, Wisconsin at age 38 on September 10, 1965. She remains as the only Miss Wisconsin from Sauk County.
1946 Antoine (Toni) Bernice Lunde Milwaukee / Westby 20 Miss Milwaukee Top 16 Antonie Lunde Early died at age 78 on March 9, 2006, at home in Greenwood, South Carolina.
1945 Eileen Christianson (Christy) Menomonie 20 Miss Menomonie
1944 Elsie (Elyse) Sutter Milwaukee 20 Miss Milwaukee N/A Did not compete in the Miss America 1944 pageant. She died at age 95 on September 16, 2019 in Florida.
1943 No Wisconsin representative at Miss America pageant
1942 Charlotte Ruth Lemmer Milwaukee 18 Miss Milwaukee
1941 Bette Anne Miller[22] Milwaukee 18 Miss Milwaukee Mid-Summer Festival Artistic Caricature of President Franklin D. Roosevelt Top 15 Bette Anne Miller Schapekahm died at age 87 on June 2, 2009 in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin.
1940 No Wisconsin representative at Miss America pageant
1939
1938
1937
1936 Aline Fern Schwartz Milwaukee 18 Miss Milwaukee
1935 No Wisconsin representative at Miss America pageant
1934 No pageant was held
1933 Marie Marguerite Huebner Portage[23] 20 Miss Portage Top 18 Marie Huebner Raimer died at age 93 on February 15, 2007 after a brief illness in Puyallup, Washington.
1932 No pageants were held
1931
1930
1929
1928
1927 Marjorie Mae Leffingwell Madison / Rio, Wisconsin Miss Madison Marjorie Mae Leffingwell Grate died at age 83 on December 23, 1992 in Madison, Wisconsin. Multiple Wisconsin representatives

Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant.
   Virginia June Hillyer competed as Miss Wisconsin
Virginia June Hillyer Fort Atkinson 17 Miss Fort Atkinson Virginia June Hillyer Kincaid was the first-ever crowned Miss Wisconsin and later died at age 77 of heart complications on November 25, 1986 in Panama City, Florida.
1926 Dorothy Bernadine Seiler Madison Miss Madison Dorothy Bernadine Seiler Bowley died at age 90 on April 3, 1996, in Augusta, Wisconsin. Multiple Wisconsin representatives

Contestants competed under local title at Miss America pageant
Florence Andrees Milwaukee Miss Milwaukee
Name not known Miss Racine
1925 Virginia Sara Armstrong Milwaukee Miss Milwaukee Was later named Miss South Bend (Indiana) 1927. Virginia "Ginny" Sara Armstrong Mahn died in Mount Dora, Florida, on July 16, 2009, at age 99. No Miss Wisconsin

Competed under local title at Miss America pageant
1924 Clara Ethel Koehler Milwaukee 26 Miss Milwaukee Top 15 Clara Ethel Koehler Lord died in Milwaukee at age 86 on June 30, 1984. She was the only contestant from Wisconsin to compete at Miss America who was born in the 19th century (June 1898). No Miss Wisconsin

Competed under local title at Miss America pageant
1923 No Wisconsin representative at Miss America pageant
1922
1921

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
Miss Wisconsin is the title held by an unmarried woman selected through an annual scholarship competition to represent the U.S. state of Wisconsin as a delegate to the Miss America pageant.[1] Founded in 1936 as a preliminary to the Miss America Organization, the program emphasizes educational opportunities and community service initiatives for participants.[1] The competition is open to women aged 18 to 28 who are U.S. citizens and residents of Wisconsin, focusing on their talents, achievements, and personal platforms rather than solely physical appearance.[1] The Miss Wisconsin Scholarship Organization, which administers the event, awards scholarships to contestants at various levels, contributing to the Miss America system's annual awards of more than $5 million in tuition assistance nationwide.[1][2] Held each June in New Berlin following a 2024 relocation from Oshkosh, the pageant includes preliminary events in talent, interview, evening wear, and on-stage questions.[3] Notable achievements include three Miss Wisconsin titleholders who have won the national Miss America crown: Terry Anne Meeuwsen in 1973, Laura Kaeppeler in 2012, and Grace Stanke in 2023.[1] In June 2025, Willow Newell of Racine became the first Black woman to be crowned Miss Wisconsin, earning $13,000 in scholarships plus additional awards for her performance.[4]

History

Establishment and early years

The Miss Wisconsin program was established in 1927 as part of the broader expansion of state-level preliminary competitions to select representatives for the national Miss America pageant, which had begun in 1921 to promote tourism and local beauty contests across the United States.[5] The Miss Wisconsin Scholarship Organization was formally founded in 1936 as a preliminary to the Miss America Organization.[1] This development aligned with the growing popularity of such events in the Midwest, where local civic groups and chambers of commerce organized pageants to foster regional pride and attract visitors.[6] Initial competitions were small-scale affairs held in various Wisconsin communities during the late 1920s, often tied to summer festivals, theater events, or local promotions rather than a centralized state structure. For instance, early events took place in Milwaukee, where the pageant drew from city-based contests, and in smaller towns like Fort Atkinson and Green Bay, emphasizing local talent and participation over large-scale production.[5] These gatherings typically involved a handful of contestants judged on poise, appearance, and basic performance elements, reflecting the era's focus on wholesome entertainment.[7] The first official Miss Wisconsin titleholder was Virginia June Hillyer of Fort Atkinson, crowned in 1927 and selected to represent the state at the Miss America pageant later that year in Atlantic City, New Jersey.[8] Hillyer, a 17-year-old contestant, competed among dozens of regional delegates, highlighting the nascent role of state preliminaries in feeding into the national event.[9] In the pre-World War II era, the program emphasized community involvement through volunteer-led events that encouraged civic engagement, such as parades and talent showcases.[10] These early years laid the groundwork for the pageant's evolution, prioritizing personal development and regional representation amid the economic challenges of the Great Depression.[6]

Key milestones and organizational changes

The Miss Wisconsin program experienced significant disruptions during World War II, with competitions scaled back or paused in certain years due to wartime constraints affecting the broader Miss America organization, resulting in no state representative sent to the national pageant in 1940 and 1943.[11] In 1963, the pageant relocated its headquarters and primary venue from Kenosha, where it had been based since 1959, to Oshkosh, marking a shift that solidified the event's presence in the Fox Valley region for over six decades.[12][13] This move was followed by another organizational relocation in 2024, when the program announced its departure from Oshkosh to New Berlin, effective for the 2025 competition at the West Performing Arts Center, driven by needs for updated facilities and expanded community engagement.[3][14] The COVID-19 pandemic prompted further adaptations in 2020, as the Miss Wisconsin competition was postponed indefinitely for health and safety reasons, extending the reigning titleholder's term through the year and aligning with national delays in the Miss America event until 2021.[15][16] This period also introduced virtual components to preliminary events and programming to maintain contestant preparation and public involvement amid restrictions.[15] A notable diversity milestone occurred in June 2025, when Willow Ybre Newell of Racine, competing as Miss Racine, was crowned Miss Wisconsin, becoming the first Black woman to hold the title in the program's history.[4][17][18]

Organization and competition format

Affiliation and eligibility

The Miss Wisconsin Scholarship Organization serves as the official state preliminary to the Miss America Organization, selecting Wisconsin's representative for the national competition, with the state's participation in Miss America dating back to 1927.[19] Eligibility for the Miss Wisconsin competition aligns with Miss America standards and requires contestants to be unmarried women who are U.S. citizens, residents of Wisconsin, between the ages of 18 and 28 as of specified dates in the competition year, with no children or prior pregnancies, and committed to community service and personal achievement.[20][21] Contestants, known as delegates, qualify by winning one of the official local preliminary pageants across Wisconsin, such as Miss Madison, Miss Racine, or Miss La Crosse/Oktoberfest, which collectively select up to approximately 30 delegates for the state competition each year.[20][22][23] The Miss Wisconsin Scholarship Program awards financial support to promote education and leadership, providing the titleholder with a $13,000 scholarship while offering cash awards to non-finalists, including $1,000 for outstanding talent performances and $500 for interview scores.[24][25]

Event structure and judging

The Miss Wisconsin Scholarship Competition is an annual event held each June, typically spanning one week that includes two preliminary competition evenings, one final night, and additional activities such as visits to local organizations and a Night to Ignite Gala.[1] The competition evaluates contestants across five core phases, each emphasizing different aspects of scholarship, leadership, and personal development. The private interview phase, lasting 10 minutes (including a 30-second opening, 9 minutes of questions, and a 30-second closing), assesses communication skills, intelligence, and goals, and carries a 30% weight in scoring.[20] Talent performance, limited to a maximum of 90 seconds, highlights artistic abilities like vocal music, dance, or instrumental work and accounts for 20% of the score.[20] The evening gown phase, also weighted at 20%, focuses on poise, personal style, and stage presence as contestants model formal attire.[20] Health and fitness, presented in athletic attire with a fitness routine, evaluates physical conditioning, discipline, and self-assuredness, comprising another 20%.[20][26] Finally, the on-stage conversation phase, weighted at 10%, requires a response to a question tied to the contestant's community service initiative, testing articulation and passion.[20] A panel of 5 to 7 judges, drawn from diverse professional backgrounds to ensure balanced evaluation, scores each phase using standardized criteria aligned with Miss America guidelines.[27] Judges are instructed to consider factors such as time limits strictly, with deductions possible for overruns, and their scores determine overall rankings without ties in final placements.[20] The highest-scoring contestant is crowned Miss Wisconsin and advances to represent the state at the Miss America competition, while up to four runners-up are selected based on cumulative scores, often receiving scholarships and serving in supporting roles.[28]

National results

Placements at Miss America

Miss Wisconsin titleholders have competed at the national Miss America pageant since 1924, achieving three wins, three first runner-up placements, two second runner-up finishes, and numerous other semifinalist and top 10 honors over nearly a century of participation.[29] The state's first notable success came in the late 1950s and 1960s, with Mary Alice Fox earning first runner-up at Miss America 1960, followed by Joan Mary Engh as first runner-up in 1963, Sharon Singstock as fourth runner-up in 1966, and Barbara Baugh as second runner-up in 1968.[29] This period established Wisconsin as a competitive presence, with consistent top-five contention. The 1970s represented a peak, highlighted by Terry Anne Meeuwsen's victory as Miss America 1973—her first Miss America win from the Badger State—and Judy Hieke's first runner-up finish the following year at Miss America 1974.[29][30] Success waned in the 1980s and 1990s, yielding only occasional top 10 finishes, such as Keungsuk Kim in 1981 and Tania Ziegler in 1993.[29] The 2000s and 2010s brought resurgence, including Tina Sauerhammer's second runner-up at Miss America 2004, Mary-Louise Kurey's top 10 in 1999, Christina Thompson's top 8 in 2007, Laura Kaeppeler's Miss America 2012 win, Paula Mae Kuiper's top 12 in 2013, and Tianna Vanderhei's top 15 in 2018.[29] These decades featured 5 total top 10 or equivalent semifinalist placements, underscoring Wisconsin's strong performance relative to many states.[29][31] In recent years, Grace Stanke, Miss Wisconsin 2022, won Miss America 2023, marking the state's third national title and continuing the momentum from the 2010s.[32] At Miss America 2025, Mandi Genord, Miss Wisconsin 2024, advanced to the top 11 as a semifinalist.[33]
Year (Miss America)Titleholder (Miss Wisconsin Year)Placement
1960Mary Alice Fox (1959)1st Runner-Up
1963Joan Mary Engh (1962)1st Runner-Up
1966Sharon Singstock (1965)4th Runner-Up
1968Barbara Baugh (1967)2nd Runner-Up
1973Terry Anne Meeuwsen (1972)Winner
1974Judy Hieke (1973)1st Runner-Up
1981Keungsuk Kim (1980)Top 10
1993Tania Ziegler (1992)Top 10
1999Mary-Louise Kurey (1998)Top 10
2004Tina Sauerhammer (2003)2nd Runner-Up
2007Christina Thompson (2006)Top 8
2012Laura Kaeppeler (2011)Winner
2013Paula Mae Kuiper (2012)Top 12
2018Tianna Vanderhei (2017)Top 15
2023Grace Stanke (2022)Winner
2025Mandi Genord (2024)Top 11

Awards and scholarships received

Miss Wisconsin contestants have secured several preliminary awards at the national Miss America competition, including nine wins across the talent and swimsuit categories. For instance, in 2023, Grace Stanke earned the preliminary talent award for her classical violin performance of "Czardas," which contributed to her overall victory as Miss America 2023.[29] Similarly, Mandi Genord received the preliminary fitness award and the AHA Leadership Award in 2025 during the competition's health and fitness phase.[31] Contestants from Wisconsin have also garnered seven non-finalist awards, primarily in talent and interview categories. A notable early example is Lynn Byron Holden, who won the non-finalist talent award in 1957 for her vocal presentation.[29] Other recipients include Stephanie Ann Klett in 1992 for non-finalist talent.[29] In addition to preliminary and non-finalist honors, Miss Wisconsin delegates have received various special national recognitions. Mary-Louise Kurey was awarded the Bernie Wayne Performing Arts Award in 2000 for her exceptional stage performance.[29] For social impact initiatives, Molly McGrath placed as a Quality of Life Award finalist in 2004, highlighting her community service efforts.[29] STEM-focused scholarships have further supported delegates pursuing science, technology, engineering, and mathematics fields, aligning with platforms like that of Grace Stanke, who advocated for clean energy through nuclear engineering.[34] Wisconsin delegates have earned scholarships through these national awards and placements, with distributions including approximately $3,000 for preliminary winners, $1,000 for non-finalist talents, and varying amounts for special categories such as the $5,000 Quality of Life finalist scholarships.

Titleholders

List of Miss Wisconsin winners

The Miss Wisconsin Scholarship Program, affiliated with the Miss America Organization, has crowned titleholders annually since 1927, though competitions were not held every year in the early decades due to economic challenges during the Great Depression and interruptions during World War II (notably no pageant in 1943). Later disruptions included the cancellation of the 2020 event amid the COVID-19 pandemic, leading to an extension of the 2019 winner's reign into 2020; in such cases, runners-up or adjusted selections filled roles to ensure continuity. When a titleholder advances to win Miss America, a successor is often crowned mid-reign to represent the state, as seen in 1972, 2011, and 2022. The following table provides a chronological list of all titleholders, with hometowns derived from local affiliations or reported residences, ages at time of crowning where documented, community service platforms where specified, and notes on immediate post-title activities such as national competition results or special circumstances. Data is compiled from official program records and contemporaneous news reports.[29]
YearNameHometownNotes
1924Clara KoehlerMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee; semi-finalist at Miss America 1924.
1927June HillyerMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee.
1933Marie HuebnerPortageMiss Portage; semi-finalist at Miss America 1933.
1936Aline Fern SchwartzMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee.
1941Betty Ann MillerMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee; top 15 finalist at Miss America 1941.
1942Charlotte LemmerMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee.
1944Elyse Sutter(Not specified)Limited details available; wartime competition.
1945Eileen ChristyMenomonieMiss Menomonie.
1946Antoine Bernice LundeMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee; top 16 finalist at Miss America 1946.
1947Gladys BerkleyBarabooMiss Baraboo.
1948Marvene FischerMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee.
1949Phyllis Ann KesslerGreen BayMiss Green Bay; top 15 finalist at Miss America 1949.
1950Gloria Betty LangeMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee.
1951Sheila Marie MurphyMarshfieldMiss Marshfield.
1952Jeannie HustonLa CrosseMiss La Crosse.
1953Judith Lee JacobsenMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee.
1954Dixie Ann SarchetWisconsin RapidsMiss Wisconsin Rapids.
1955Margaret WellsMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee.
1956Lynn HoldenRiponMiss Ripon; non-finalist talent award at Miss America 1956.
1957Joan HentschelWauwatosaMiss Wauwatosa.
1958Kay Joan RossWest AllisMiss West Allis.
1959Mary Alice FoxSheboyganMiss Sheboygan; 1st runner-up at Miss America 1959, preliminary swimsuit award.
1960Karen FahrenbachRacineMiss Racine.
1961Diane AndersonEau ClaireMiss Eau Claire.
1962Joan Mary EnghLa CrosseMiss La Crosse; 1st runner-up at Miss America 1962, preliminary swimsuit award.
1963Barbara BonvilleNorth Shore (Milwaukee area)Miss North Shore; special scholarship award at Miss America 1963.
1964Angela Gina BaldiNorth Shore (Milwaukee area)Miss North Shore.
1965Sharon SingstockOshkoshMiss Oshkosh; 4th runner-up at Miss America 1965; participated in U.S.O. Troupe.
1966Candace Gail HinzWest AllisMiss West Allis.
1967Barbara BaughMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee; 2nd runner-up at Miss America 1967.
1968Marilyn BrahmsteadtLa CrosseMiss La Crosse/Oktoberfest.
1969Cindy MorganJanesvilleMiss Janesville.
1970Linda JohnsonMadisonMiss Madison.
1971Patti JacobsStevens PointMiss Stevens Point; participated in U.S.O. Troupe.
1972Terry Anne MeeuwsenAppletonMiss Appleton; Miss America 1973 winner, preliminary talent and swimsuit awards (initial 1972 titleholder; succeeded upon national win).
1972Linda HendersonMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee; successor to Meeuwsen after her Miss America victory.
1973Judy HiekeMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee; 1st runner-up at Miss America 1973, preliminary swimsuit award.
1974Carol Ann SchmittMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee; special education award at Miss America 1974.
1975Marilyn SembellLake GenevaMiss Lake Geneva; non-finalist talent award at Miss America 1975.
1976Julie Ann NowakWest AllisMiss West Allis.
1977Jennifer WoychikArcadiaMiss Arcadia.
1978Carin KizewicMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee.
1979Kristine KonradOshkoshMiss Oshkosh.
1980Dana SpychallaFond du LacMiss Fond du Lac.
1981Keungsuk KimMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee; top 10 finalist at Miss America 1981.
1982Gail Marie SollerLa CrosseMiss La Crosse/Oktoberfest; non-finalist talent award at Miss America 1982.
1983Wendy Lynn WagnerMenomonieMiss Menomonie.
1984Barbara MullallyLa CrosseMiss La Crosse/Oktoberfest; Department of Defense Tour participant.
1985Mary Kay AndersonSt. FrancisMiss St. Francis.
1986Mara NesemannWaukesha CountyMiss Waukesha County; Department of Defense Tour participant.
1987Maria KimMadisonMiss Madison; preliminary talent award and non-finalist talent award at Miss America 1987.
1988Jeanie Marie PfeifferMilwaukeeMiss Milwaukee; Department of Defense Tour participant.
1989Kimberly TotdahlKenoshaMiss Kenosha.
1990Tricia Ann LuedtkeOshkoshMiss Oshkosh; non-finalist talent award at Miss America 1990.
1991Brenda HainesArcadiaMiss Arcadia.
1992Stephanie Ann KlettWisconsin Central (Wausau area)Miss Wisconsin Central; non-finalist talent award at Miss America 1992.
1993Tania ZieglerFond du LacMiss Fond du Lac; top 10 finalist at Miss America 1993.
1994Laura VossGreen BayMiss Green Bay.
1995Pamela PolkSoutheastern Wisconsin (Kenosha area)Miss Southeastern Wisconsin.
1996Jennifer StreblowOshkoshMiss Oshkosh.
1997Nicole LocyWestern Wisconsin (Eau Claire area)Miss Western Wisconsin; non-finalist interview award at Miss America 1997.
1998Jill PatznerWestern Wisconsin (Eau Claire area)Miss Western Wisconsin; Miss America Scholar.
1999Mary-Louise KureyWest AllisMiss West Allis; top 10 finalist at Miss America 1999, preliminary talent winner, Bernie Wayne Performing Arts Award.
2000Joya ZamoraEastern Shore (Door County area)Miss Eastern Shore; Bert Parks non-finalist talent award at Miss America 2000.
2001Laura HerriotBerlinMiss Berlin; Quality of Life Award finalist at Miss America 2001.
2002Jayme DawickiSouthern Wisconsin (Janesville area)Miss Southern Wisconsin.
2003Tina SauerhammerMadisonMiss Madison Area; 2nd runner-up at Miss America 2003, preliminary talent winner (later earned M.D.).
2004Molly McGrathMadisonMiss Madison Area; Quality of Life Award finalist at Miss America 2004.
2005Tracy GestNew BerlinMiss New Berlin.
2006Meghan CoffeyNew BerlinMiss New Berlin.
2007Christina ThompsonMadisonMiss Madison – Capital City; top 8 finalist at Miss America 2007.
2008Briana LiporSouth Central (Janesville area)Miss South Central.
2009Kristina SmabyMadisonMiss Madison – Capital City.
2010Kimberly SawyerGreen BayMiss Green Bay Area.
2011Laura KaeppelerSouthern Wisconsin (Kenosha area)Miss Southern Wisconsin; Miss America 2012 winner, preliminary talent winner (initial 2011 titleholder; succeeded upon national win).
2011Raeanna JohnsonSeven Rivers (La Crosse area)Miss Seven Rivers; successor to Kaeppeler after her Miss America victory.
2012Kate GormanLa CrosseMiss La Crosse / Oktoberfest.
2013Paula Mae KuiperMadisonMiss Madison – Capital City; top 12 at Miss America 2013.
2014Raeanna JohnsonMadisonMiss Madison – Capital City.
2015Rosalie SmithNew BerlinMiss New Berlin.
2016Courtney PelotGreen BayMiss Green Bay Area.
2017McKenna CollinsMadisonMiss Madison – Capital City.
2018Tianna VanderheiWood Violet (Wisconsin Rapids area)Miss Wood Violet; top 15 at Miss America 2018, preliminary interview award winner.
2019/2020Alyssa BohmMount PleasantMiss Rock River Valley; title extended into 2020 due to COVID-19 pandemic cancellation of competition; platform focused on Special Olympics involvement; competed at Miss America 2020 (pageant postponed).[35]
2021Jennifer SchmidtRock River Valley (Janesville area)Miss Rock River Valley; competed at Miss America 2022.
2022Grace StankeWausauMiss Badgerland, age 20; platform: nuclear energy promotion for clean environment; Miss America 2023 winner, preliminary talent winner (initial 2022 titleholder; succeeded upon national win).[36]
2022Kylene SpanbauerFond du LacMiss Harbor Cities, age 23; successor to Stanke after her Miss America victory; competed at Miss America 2024.[37]
2023Lila SzyryjMadisonMiss South Central, age 21; platform: "Journalism 101" promoting media literacy and journalistic accountability; first Madison native and Chinese American titleholder; competed at Miss America 2024.[38][39]
2024Mandi GenordBeaver DamMiss Northern Lights, age 22; platform: "Connecting Lives: Adoption Resources" advocating for adoption awareness; top 11 semi-finalist at Miss America 2025, preliminary health & fitness winner, AHA Leadership Award recipient.[40][41][33]
2025Willow Ybre NewellRacineMiss Racine, age 22; platform: "The Art of Belonging," focusing on inclusion and sense of belonging through the arts; first Black titleholder; competed at Miss America 2026.[18][42][43]

Notable titleholders and alumni

Among the most prominent Miss Wisconsin titleholders are those who have achieved the national Miss America crown, marking significant milestones for the program. Terry Meeuwsen, crowned Miss Wisconsin in 1972, became the first woman from the state to win Miss America 1973.[44] Following her reign, Meeuwsen pursued a career in broadcasting, co-hosting the daily talk show A New Day at WTMJ-TV in Milwaukee before joining the Christian Broadcasting Network (CBN) as co-host of The 700 Club, a role she has held since 1986, where she also serves as an author and advocate for orphan care through her nonprofit, Orphan's Promise.[45] Laura Kaeppeler, Miss Wisconsin 2011, succeeded as Miss America 2012, the second from Wisconsin to claim the title.[46] Post-pageant, Kaeppeler has focused on advocacy for at-risk youth, particularly children of incarcerated parents, while working as an inspirational speaker, performer, and co-host of the Health Interrupted podcast, emphasizing wellness and resilience.[47] She holds a bachelor's degree in music and vocal performance from Carthage College and established the Laura M. Kaeppeler '10 Scholarship Fund to support future students.[48] Grace Stanke, who won Miss Wisconsin in 2022, was crowned Miss America 2023, becoming the third from the state and the first nuclear engineer to hold the title.[49] A University of Wisconsin-Madison graduate with a bachelor's in nuclear engineering, Stanke has advocated for clean energy and women in STEM during her reign, and now works as a nuclear engineer at Constellation Energy, promoting sustainable power solutions.[50] Other standout titleholders include Willow Newell, the 2025 Miss Wisconsin and the first Black woman to win the state crown, a milestone that highlights growing diversity in the program.[4] A Carthage College alumna with a degree in musical theater, Newell is a vocalist and diversity advocate, using her platform to promote inclusivity and storytelling through performance; she competed at Miss America 2026.[51][43] Tina Sauerhammer, Miss Wisconsin 2003 and second runner-up at Miss America, exemplifies achievement in medicine and business. A double board-certified plastic surgeon, she founded Wisconsin Plastic Surgery, where she specializes in reconstructive procedures for breast cancer survivors and children with disabilities, while advocating for organ and tissue donation.[52] Former Miss Wisconsin titleholders have pursued diverse careers, contributing to fields like media, science, and public service; for instance, alumni networks support community volunteering and scholarship initiatives across the state.[1]

References

User Avatar
No comments yet.