Hubbry Logo
Question!Question!Main
Open search
Question!
Community hub
Question!
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Question!
Question!
Question!
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

"Question!"
Single by System of a Down
from the album Mezmerize
ReleasedJuly 12, 2005 (2005-07-12)
Length3:20
Label
Composers
LyricistSerj Tankian
Producers
System of a Down singles chronology
"B.Y.O.B."
(2005) 		"Question!"
(2005) 		"Hypnotize"
(2005)
Maxi single
Cover of the maxi single of "Question!"
DVD single
Cover of the DVD single of "Question!"
Music video
"Question!" on YouTube

"Question!" is a song by American heavy metal band System of a Down, released in July 2005 as the second single from their fourth studio album, Mezmerize (2005).

Release

[edit]

After the release of "B.Y.O.B.", the band were deciding what song to release as a single. They eventually chose "Question!" after finding out radio stations had already been playing the track.[1]

Music video

[edit]

Shavo Odadjian produced the video, and co-directed it alongside Howard Greenhalgh, after allegedly having an image of the video in a nightmare, which consisted of a boy offering a girl berries, unaware that they were poisonous.[2] It is claimed that before the dream he did not intend to produce the video and did not want any special treatment over other possible producers for being in the band, thus submitting the idea anonymously.[3]

Filmed mostly in the Los Angeles Theatre, which opened in 1931, the video opens with a gray-haired, gray-clothed, and gray-skinned boy shooting a red bird with a slingshot in an alleyway, after which the song starts. It then switches to the band members in dark suits in the theatre's forestage performing music for a play, similar to an orchestra. Based on a theme of life, death, and reincarnation, the play revolves around two lovers, a man in a dark suit and a woman in a red dress, who are shown both as children and as adults. As the music reaches its climax, the woman collapses after eating a red berry and the man screams in grief. The video closes with an intense scene of a woman giving birth in a hospital room, followed by a shot of a newborn baby wrapped in red cloth. The color red significantly links the bird, the girl, the woman, and the baby in a cycle of rebirth.

Tankian described the theatre, "It's an amazing old theater that is due for renovation. I'm glad they haven't renovated it yet, because it has the right character for what we were looking for. It has a fairy tale vibe."[3]

Track listing

[edit]
CD single
No.TitleLyricsMusicLength
1."Question!" (album version)TankianTankian, Malakian3:20
2."Sugar" (explicit live version)TankianMalakian, Odadjian3:54
Maxi CD single
No.TitleLyricsMusicLength
1."Question!" (album version)TankianTankian, Malakian3:20
2."Forest" (explicit live version)TankianMalakian5:11
3."Prison Song" (explicit live version)Tankian, MalakianMalakian3:27
4."Question!" (live video)TankianTankian, Malakian3:25
DVD single
No.TitleLyricsMusicLength
1."Question!" (concept video)TankianTankian, Malakian3:48
2."B.Y.O.B." (concept video)Tankian, MalakianMalakian4:17
3."Sugar" (explicit live version)TankianMalakian, Odadjian3:54
4."B.Y.O.B." (explicit live from Astoria)Malakian, TankianMalakian4:19

Personnel

[edit]

System of a Down

Additional personnel

Production

  • Rick Rubin – production
  • Andy Wallace – mixing
  • David Schiffman – engineering
  • Jason Lader – editing
  • Dana Neilsen – editing
  • Phillip Broussard – engineering assistance
  • John O'Mahony – Pro Tools engineering
  • Steve Sisco – mixing assistance
  • Joe Peluso – mixing assistance
  • Vartan Malakian – artwork
  • Brandy Flower – graphic design

Charts

[edit]
Chart (2005) Peak
position
Canada Rock Top 30 (Radio & Records)[4] 29
Hungary (Single Top 40)[5] 7
Ireland (IRMA)[6] 47
UK Singles (OCC)[7] 41
UK Rock & Metal (OCC)[8] 3
US Bubbling Under Hot 100 (Billboard)[9] 2
US Alternative Airplay (Billboard)[10] 9
US Mainstream Rock (Billboard)[11] 7

Certifications

[edit]
Region Certification Certified units/sales
United States (RIAA)[12] Gold 500,000‡

‡ Sales+streaming figures based on certification alone.

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Question!

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The interrobang (‽) is a nonstandard punctuation mark that combines the question mark (?) and the exclamation mark (!) into a single glyph, designed to denote a sentence that functions as both an interrogative and an exclamatory statement, such as a rhetorical question infused with surprise, disbelief, or emphasis. Invented in 1962 by American advertising executive Martin K. Speckter, the interrobang was proposed as a way to make written communication more expressive, particularly in advertising and journalism where sentences often blend inquiry with strong emotion. Its name is a portmanteau of "interrogative" (referring to the question mark) and "bang," a printers' slang term for the exclamation mark dating back to early typesetting practices. Speckter introduced the mark in his article “Making a New Point, or, How About That?” published in Type Talks magazine, encouraging its adoption by overlaying the two symbols, and it briefly gained traction in the mid-1960s through typographical societies, typefaces like Americana, and even Remington typewriters that included it as a key. Despite initial enthusiasm, the interrobang saw limited mainstream adoption and largely fell out of use by the late 1970s, overshadowed by the simpler convention of juxtaposing "?" and "!" (as ?! or !?). Included in the Unicode standard since 2005 (U+203D), it remains a niche symbol primarily employed in informal writing, comics, or creative contexts to convey excited incredulity—such as "You're really going to eat that‽"—though it lacks a dedicated key on most standard keyboards and is not recommended in style guides like those from the Associated Press or Chicago Manual of Style, despite support in many modern fonts. In specialized applications, such as chess notation, it occasionally appears to indicate a move that is both questionable and brilliant.

Background and recording

Development

The song "Question!" emerged during System of a Down's intensive songwriting and recording sessions for their companion albums and Hypnotize in late 2004 and early 2005, part of a larger project that yielded over 30 tracks from which the band selected material for release. Lyrics for the track were written by frontman , while the was composed collaboratively by Tankian and guitarist , reflecting the band's evolving dynamic where Malakian took a more prominent role in vocal and lyrical contributions across the albums. The song's creation was shaped by Tankian's personal existential inquiries into life, death, and the afterlife—elements that echoed System of a Down's activist focus on war, imperialism, and societal disillusionment, amid the broader geopolitical climate of the era. Early demo iterations of "Question!" were refined in band rehearsals leading up to the albums' completion, featuring unusual time signature shifts between 5/4, 9/8, 6/8, and 4/4 that were recorded without a fixed structure, and its melodic, acoustic-driven structure—contrasting the heavier aggression of tracks like "B.Y.O.B."—positioned it as a strong candidate for wider accessibility, leading to its selection as the second single from Mezmerize after the lead track's release in March 2005.

Recording sessions

The recording sessions for "Question!" occurred at The Mansion in Laurel Canyon and Akademie Mathematique of Philosophical Sound Research Studios, both in Los Angeles, California, as part of the broader production for System of a Down's album Mezmerize from June to November 2004. The track was co-produced by Rick Rubin and Daron Malakian, with engineering by Andy Wallace. Central to the production were Serj Tankian's layered vocals, which incorporated highs reaching E5 to convey the song's haunting melody. Shavo Odadjian's bass lines underscored the groove, particularly in the jazzy beats of the verses, while John Dolmayan's dynamic drumming provided rhythmic drive, with his parts finalized by July 2004. Malakian's guitar work featured jangling acoustic elements in the chorus alongside aggressive nu-metal riffs in the verses, blending melodic and heavy dynamics. Sessions faced challenges in achieving balance between the track's accessible, melodic chorus and its intense verses, compounded by album-wide issues such as Tankian's need for multiple vocal re-takes due to late-night adjustments and Dolmayan's extended drum tracking, which took considerably longer than on prior efforts. Mixing, overseen by Wallace, emphasized clean production values to amplify the song's radio-friendly qualities, wrapping up in early 2005 ahead of the album's May release.

Composition and lyrics

Musical style

"Question!" is classified as , incorporating elements of and through its dynamic shifts and unconventional rhythms. The track features a tempo of 181 beats per minute in the key of , creating a mid-tempo groove that alternates between intense and atmospheric passages. The song follows a verse-chorus structure, beginning with an eerie acoustic intro riff that builds tension before exploding into palm-muted riffs in drop C tuning, emphasizing heaviness and aggression. This leads to an anthemic chorus with clean melodic breaks, where layered harmonies and soaring leads provide contrast to the verse's rhythmic drive. Daron Malakian's guitar work stands out with tight, riff-based sections and harmonic solos that add progressive flair, bridging the song's heavy and melodic components. Serj Tankian's vocals showcase a wide range, transitioning from low growls and spoken-word delivery in the verses to high-pitched, melodic choruses that enhance the track's emotional intensity. Shavo Odadjian's bass lines incorporate slap techniques and accents that lock in with the groove, providing rhythmic foundation and occasional melodic fills that complement the guitars. ’s drumming maintains a propulsive beat, with fills that underscore the song's structural shifts. Compared to the band's earlier album (2001), "Question!" reflects a more polished production on (2005), courtesy of , which allows greater space for instrumental interplay while retaining System of a Down's signature blend of aggression and accessibility for broader radio appeal. This evolution bridges their raw, experimental edge with refined, anthemic songwriting.

Themes and interpretation

The lyrics of "Question!" delve into existential doubt through introspective queries about life, death, and the , exemplified by lines such as "Do we, do we know / When we fly? / When we, when we go / Do we die?" which challenge perceptions of mortality and spiritual transition. These elements critique societal by questioning blind adherence to religious or cultural narratives that evade real-world issues, including the use of as an escape from earthly conflicts. The song's themes also evoke ideas of and cyclical existence, with references to "ghosts" and "sweet berries ready for two"—interpreted as allusions to souls and biblical temptation akin to —suggesting continuity beyond physical death. Amid the 2005 release of the album , "Question!" reflects broader anti-war sentiment, aligning with System of a Down's vocal and that perpetuates conflict. The band's Armenian heritage and ongoing to raise awareness of the further inform these themes, framing personal agency as a resistance against historical cycles of violence and denial. Frontman has articulated this perspective by stating, "Death is life, and life is death, depending on how you live it," emphasizing how individual choices intersect with larger geopolitical chaos. Critics and fans interpret the track as a urgent call for in times of turmoil, probing the illusions fostered by and to encourage and one's role in societal disorder. The repetitive structure of the chorus reinforces symbolism of life's inescapable cycles—birth, death, and rebirth—mirroring the band's political against repetitive patterns of and conflict. This layered approach underscores personal agency as a counter to existential and collective despair.

Release and promotion

Release history

"Question!" was released on July 12, 2005, by American Recordings and as the second single from System of a Down's fourth studio album, . The single was initially available in the United States through digital download and promotional CD formats, targeting alternative and rock radio stations to build on the momentum of the album's May 17 release, which debuted at number one on the chart with 453,000 copies sold in its first week. The international rollout began with promotional singles distributed to European markets in mid-2005, ahead of physical releases. In the , the single was issued on August 22, 2005, as a standard featuring the album version of "Question!" backed by a live recording of "" from the festival. A maxi-single followed on August 29, 2005, including additional live tracks such as "Highway to Die" from the in and enhanced content like music videos. Limited-edition formats, including a numbered box set bundling the , maxi-single, and a DVD single with alternate videos and live audio, were also produced for collectors. Label executives prioritized summer radio for "Question!" to sustain Mezmerize's commercial success during the peak touring season, aligning the single's promotion with the band's live performances across and . Digital bundles incorporating select album tracks became available later in , expanding accessibility amid the growing popularity of online music distribution. While no official 7-inch vinyl single was produced, promotional efforts emphasized the track's energetic style to engage rock audiences.

Marketing

The marketing campaign for "Question!" emphasized targeted outreach to build anticipation and fan engagement following the May 2005 release of the parent album Mezmerize. Radio promotion focused on alternative rock stations, with advance plays beginning shortly after the album's launch, fostering organic airplay that propelled the track to No. 9 on the Alternative Airplay chart and No. 7 on the Mainstream Rock chart. To amplify visibility, the band integrated live performances of "Question!" into their Mezmerize/Hypnotize world tour from 2005 to 2006, where it was played 66 times across shows, including high-profile appearances at Ozzfest 2005. These concerts highlighted the song's energetic delivery and connected with audiences amid the tour's promotion of the double-album concept. Media appearances played a key role in discussing the track's introspective themes of existential questioning and loss. Band members, including and , gave interviews to in 2005, elaborating on the song's lyrical depth within the album's broader . Similar discussions occurred in Kerrang! features around the Mezmerize era, linking the music to the band's . Complementing this, leveraged their foundation to tie the song's motifs to anti-war initiatives, encouraging fan involvement in petitions during the 2005 promotional period. A digital strategy targeted younger demographics through early online platforms. "Question!" was offered as a digital download exclusive on starting May 17, , alongside the album, facilitating immediate access for fans. Additionally, streaming previews were promoted on , the band's active profile in , to drive viral sharing and community interaction.

Music video

Concept and production

The "Question!" music video was co-directed by bassist and director . The creative vision centered on a for the cycle of life, beginning with death and concluding with birth, inspired by a dream Odadjian experienced involving a boy unknowingly offering poisonous berries to a girl. Filming occurred at the historic , a 1931 venue then closed to the public, in early July 2005. Production emphasized practical effects to realize the surreal visuals, including the progressive decay of the theater sets around the performers. The band members performed in stylized, monochromatic attire—grays and blacks—to complement the video's dreamlike, desaturated aesthetic. Odadjian played a hands-on role in storyboarding, drawing from the band's broader philosophical explorations of , , and renewal, which echo Eastern concepts of seen in their lyrical themes. In , the footage was meticulously edited to align with the song's shifting rhythms and time signatures, incorporating slow-motion techniques to heighten the emotional and thematic resonance of the life's cycles motif. The completed video premiered on in August 2005.

Plot summary

The music video for "Question!" opens with a gray-haired boy shooting down a red bird with a slingshot as the song begins. The scene swiftly transitions to the band performing energetically in a grand, opulent theater, intercut throughout the video to provide a rhythmic anchor to the unfolding narrative. Key scenes depict two lovers, shown first as children playing together and later as adults in a relationship. The , dressed in a dress, eats a red berry and collapses, dying, as the man grieves beside her. This culminates in a scene of a giving birth to a newborn baby swaddled in red cloth, signifying the persistent cycle of life, death, and rebirth despite loss. Visually, the video utilizes a predominantly black-and-white palette accented by vivid red elements—the bird, berry, dress, and blanket—to highlight motifs of mortality and hope, aligning with the song's introspective questioning of existence and the . The 4:30 runtime extends beyond the track's 3:20 length through additional symbolic footage, emphasizing the thematic depth of and continuity.

Critical reception

Initial reviews

Upon its release in July 2005 as the second single from System of a Down's album , "Question!" received generally positive initial reviews from music critics, who appreciated its blend of the band's signature intensity with more radio-friendly elements. awarded 3.5 out of 5 stars, praising the album's chaotic energy and broad appeal. Mixed feedback emerged from other outlets, with the single's punchy production and relatable existential queries making it a strong follow-up to the album's "B.Y.O.B." These reviews often contextualized "Question!" within 's broader reception, underscoring how the single balanced System of a Down's political edge—evident in probing and —with pop sensibilities that propelled the album to commercial success.

Retrospective assessments

In the , retrospective analyses of System of a Down's (2005), which includes "Question!", praised the album for capturing the era's anti-war sentiment while evolving the band's sound toward greater melodic accessibility and punk influences, marking a pivotal shift that solidified their mainstream breakthrough. This reappraisal positioned "Question!" as emblematic of the band's ability to blend introspective balladry with urgent social critique, influencing later nu-metal and revivals by demonstrating how heavy music could incorporate pop-like hooks without diluting its edge. The song's legacy endures in curated lists of 2000s and metal highlights, where it is frequently ranked among System of a Down's top tracks for its haunting intro and existential questioning of societal priorities. , in 2020 interviews amid the , reflected on the band's protest-oriented discography as an ongoing call to address global injustices, linking its themes of human cost and deception to contemporary geopolitical crises. Academic examinations in have dissected System of a Down's broader oeuvre for masterfully fusing melodic with aggressive , using dynamic shifts from soft verses to explosive choruses to amplify critiques of war and inequality. Studies on identity in cite the band's lyrical probing of personal and collective turmoil as a key example of how , as Armenian-American artists, negotiates and through hybrid heavy metal forms. This scholarly focus highlights its role in broader discussions of how popular music sustains political discourse beyond initial release. Among fans, "Question!" maintains cult status, evidenced by its accumulation of over 163 million streams on Spotify as of November 2025, reflecting sustained engagement with its themes in streaming-era playlists and live setlists.

Commercial performance

Chart positions

"Question!" achieved moderate commercial success on rock-oriented charts, reflecting its appeal within the alternative metal genre but limited mainstream crossover. In the United States, the single peaked at number 9 on the Billboard Alternative Songs chart, where it spent 13 weeks, and reached number 3 on the Mainstream Rock chart with a 15-week run. It peaked at number 2 on the Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles chart in 2005, marking a near-entry driven by album buzz from Mezmerize but falling short of the Hot 100. Internationally, the track entered the UK Singles Chart at number 41 and charted for 2 weeks overall. The song demonstrated longevity on rock formats, remaining in rotation on alternative radio stations into amid sustained interest in System of a Down's dual-album release strategy with Mezmerize and Hypnotize. Its digital footprint remains robust, with approximately 163 million streams on as of November 2025, reflecting sustained listener engagement two decades after release. The song's resurgence in the streaming era, particularly through algorithmic playlists in the , has bolstered the long-term sales of its parent album Mezmerize, which exceeded 7 million copies worldwide. In comparisons among Mezmerize singles, "Question!" has surpassed tracks like "Revenga" and "Cigaro" in cumulative digital metrics, underscoring its enduring appeal over initial physical sales performance.
Chart (2005)Peak PositionWeeks on Chart
US Billboard Alternative Songs913
US Billboard Mainstream Rock315
US Bubbling Under Hot 1002-
UK Singles (OCC)412

Sales and certifications

In the United States, "Question!" was awarded a Gold certification by the (RIAA) in 2022 for 500,000 units sold, including streaming equivalents. Globally, the track has not received major international certifications from bodies such as the or .

Track listing and personnel

Track listings

The "Question!" single was released primarily in the UK in 2005 by and American Recordings, featuring the album version alongside live recordings from the band's tour performances at the festival in on January 26, 2005. No official remixes were issued, though various fan-made edits appear in unofficial discographies.

UK CD Single (Columbia 676056 1)

No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Question!" (album version)Tankian, Malakian3:20
2."" (live)Tankian, Odadjian, Malakian, Dolmayan4:00

UK Enhanced Maxi CD Single (Columbia 676056 2)

No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Question!" (album version)Tankian, Malakian3:23
2."Forest" (explicit live version)Tankian, Odadjian, Malakian, Dolmayan5:11
3."Prison Song" (explicit live version)Tankian, Odadjian, Malakian, Dolmayan3:30
Video 1"Question!" (live video from , June 11, 2005)—3:27

UK DVD Single (Columbia 676056 9, PAL)

No.TitleWriter(s)Length
DVD-Video 1"Question!" ()—3:48
DVD-Video 2"B.Y.O.B." (, explicit edit)Tankian, Malakian4:24
DVD-Audio 1"Sugar" (, January 26, 2005)Tankian, Odadjian, Malakian, Dolmayan4:03
DVD-Audio 2"B.Y.O.B." (live from Astoria Theatre, , April 4, 2005)Tankian, Malakian4:21

Promotional CD Singles

European promo CD (American Recordings SAMPCS15006, 2005) and promo CDr (, 2005) both feature a of the title track.
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Question!" ()Tankian, Malakian3:21
The album version appears on (American Recordings/Columbia CK 90592, 2005) at 3:20; a clean edition of the album omits no lyrics for this track, as it contains no explicit content. Digital downloads of the single tracks, including live versions, were made available via and other platforms in 2005, but no dedicated extended play with 2005 recordings was officially released.

Personnel

"Question!" was performed by the four members of : provided lead vocals and keyboards, handled guitars and backing vocals while also contributing music composition, played bass, and performed on drums. The track's production was led by as producer, with serving as co-producer; no guest musicians appear on the studio recording. The single was released by American Recordings and . Certain editions of the single include live B-sides, such as performances of "" recorded during the band's 2005 tour, with audio captured by on-site sound engineers including Cameron McCauley for the January 26 show at Showground.

References

  1. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/interrobang
  2. https://www.grammarly.com/blog/punctuation-capitalization/say-what-meet-the-interrobang/
  3. https://www.masterclass.com/articles/interrobang-punctuation-mark-explained
  4. https://www.revolvermag.com/music/inside-system-downs-epic-outraged-double-album-mezmerizehypnotize/
  5. https://www.discogs.com/release/2127577-System-Of-A-Down-Mezmerize
  6. https://www.revolvermag.com/music/6-things-you-didnt-know-about-system-downs-mezmerize-and-hypnotize/
  7. https://www.billboard.com/music/music-news/new-soad-album-to-begin-with-a-bomb-63822/
  8. https://www.songfacts.com/facts/system-of-a-down/question
  9. https://www.discogs.com/master/35665-System-Of-A-Down-Mezmerize
  10. https://therangeplanet.proboards.com/thread/3807/serj-tankian
  11. https://tunebat.com/Info/Question-System-Of-A-Down/6y2DHyCYf6azhUfXmnuH6w
  12. https://www.scribd.com/document/385639722/System-of-a-Down-Question-pdf
  13. https://www.kerrang.com/the-20-greatest-system-of-a-down-songs-ranked
  14. https://www.allmusic.com/album/mezmerize-mw0000209577
  15. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yKKww6hDLCg
  16. https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/11839-mezmerize-hypnotize/
  17. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/style/2005/05/22/mezmerize-casts-a-familiar-spell/3dbc6045-b398-40d0-916e-2136cd6786b3/
  18. https://www.grammy.com/news/serj-tankian-interview-system-of-a-down-memoir-politics-new-music
  19. https://www.theguardian.com/music/2021/mar/24/serj-tankian-system-of-a-down-armenia
  20. https://wrvu.org/nine-years-later-system-of-a-down-still-mezmerizes-me/
  21. https://www.billboard.com/music/music-news/system-of-a-down-mezmerizes-album-chart-62790/
  22. https://www.discogs.com/master/149868-System-Of-A-Down-Question
  23. https://www.discogs.com/release/2559196-System-Of-A-Down-Question
  24. https://loudwire.com/rock-radio-hit-songs-2005/
  25. https://www.setlist.fm/stats/system-of-a-down-23d69cd7.html?tour=43d623c3
  26. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2n1mgsXxDXw
  27. https://www.ultimate-guitar.com/news/interviews/soad_guitarist_sometimes_i_feel_alienated_from_my_band.html
  28. https://www.salon.com/2003/02/06/axis_justice/
  29. https://myspace.com/soad/music/songs
  30. https://imvdb.com/video/system-of-a-down/question
  31. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6349382/
  32. https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/system-of-a-down-pose-question-100462/
  33. https://www.shazam.com/song/187472735/question/music-video
  34. https://www.discogs.com/release/742936-System-Of-A-Down-Question
  35. https://soad.fandom.com/wiki/Question!
  36. https://soad.fandom.com/wiki/Mezmerize
  37. https://www.theprp.com/2024/11/21/news/system-of-a-downs-shavo-odadjian-argues-nu-metal-was-more-of-a-era-than-a-style/
  38. https://knotfest.com/blogs/culture/the-20-greatest-system-of-a-down-tracks-ranked
  39. https://uproxx.com/indie/system-of-a-down-reunion-interview/
  40. https://journals.lib.unb.ca/index.php/MC/article/download/20202/23304/28558
  41. https://www.academia.edu/38774757/Free_Thinkers_Are_Dangerous_Millennial_Counterculture_and_the_Music_of_System_of_a_Down
  42. https://kworb.net/spotify/artist/5eAWCfyUhZtHHtBdNk56l1_songs.html
  43. https://chartmasters.org/system-of-a-down-albums-and-songs-sales/
  44. https://genius.com/System-of-a-down-question-lyrics
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.