Hubbry Logo
Whatever WorksWhatever WorksMain
Open search
Whatever Works
Community hub
Whatever Works
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Whatever Works
Whatever Works
Whatever Works
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
Whatever Works
Theatrical release poster
Directed byWoody Allen
Written byWoody Allen
Produced by
Starring
CinematographyHarris Savides
Edited byAlisa Lepselter
Production
companies
Distributed bySony Pictures Classics
Release dates
  • April 22, 2009 (2009-04-22) (Tribeca)
  • June 19, 2009 (2009-06-19) (United States)
Running time
92 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Budget$15 million[1]
Box office$35 million[2]

Whatever Works is a 2009 American comedy film directed and written by Woody Allen and starring Larry David, Evan Rachel Wood, Patricia Clarkson, Ed Begley Jr., Michael McKean, and Henry Cavill. It was released on June 19, 2009, received mixed reviews and grossed $35 million.

Plot

[edit]

Boris Yelnikoff is a cynical, misanthropic chess teacher and former Columbia quantum mechanics professor. Divorced, he avoids most people, and except for three friends and his students, is patronizing to anyone he meets who does not match him intellectually.

Boris comes home one night to find Melody, a simpleminded 21-year-old, on his doorstep. He reluctantly helps her, and learns that she has run away from her fundamentalist parents in Mississippi. She asks if she can stay the night, which Boris eventually allows. While staying with Boris, Melody develops a crush on him, despite their age difference, varying cultures and intelligence. Boris later falls in love with her, and they marry.

A year later, Melody's mother, Marietta, finds Melody, explaining that she and her husband, John, thought Melody had been kidnapped. She goes on to tell her that John left her and sold their house after John lost money in the stock market. She meets Boris and is disappointed with him, so she tries to persuade Melody to end the marriage. The three go for lunch and meet Boris's friend, Leo. When Marietta goes to use the restroom, a young man, Randy Lee James, inquires about Melody and Marietta slyly decides to recruit Randy, who has fallen in love with Melody at first sight, to end her marriage. Later that evening, Leo, who had taken an interest in Marietta, asks her over for dinner. They spend the evening together, and discover that she is a talented photographer.

Boris explains to the audience that over the next few weeks Marietta has changed and started experimenting with artistic photography, exotic new habits, and starting an open relationship with Leo and his business partner, Morgenstern. Marietta still hates Boris and keeps trying to get Melody to marry Randy. She takes Melody to an outdoor market and "accidentally" runs into Randy, who questions her about her marriage. Melody sees past Marietta's attempt and tells him that her marriage is fine. She warns her mother to stop, but Marietta continues to try. Later, while shopping for clothes, Melody meets Randy in yet another planned encounter and he gets her to admit that her relationship with Boris is not entirely satisfying. He then invites her to the boat he lives on, and the two kiss and begin an affair.

John arrives at Boris and Melody's home remorseful and hopes to get the family back together. They all go to Marietta's photography exhibit opening together, and he sees how his ex-wife has changed since she moved to New York. Distraught, he retreats to a bar, drinking away his misery. While there, he meets a recently divorced gay man, Howard, and admits what he has known most of his adult life: that he is also gay.

Melody finally tells Boris she is in love with Randy. Boris is devastated, and jumps out the window. He lands on another woman, Helena, breaking her arm and leg. When he visits her in the hospital, Boris asks her if there is anything he can do to make it up to her, Helena says she would like to go to dinner with him.

Finally, Boris hosts a New Year's Eve party, where everyone is in their new relationships: Marietta with Leo and Morgenstern, John with Howard, Melody with Randy, and finally Boris with Helena. Melody and her parents have completely shed their former Southern conservative mindsets and wholeheartedly adopted the liberal New York City way of life and values. Everyone is now the best of friends, and at midnight they kiss their significant others.

Afterward, Boris breaks the fourth wall to tell the audience that one has to find all the enjoyment one can to find, "Whatever Works".

Cast

[edit]

In addition, Adam Brooks and Lyle Kanouse portray Boris' two other unnamed friends.

Production

[edit]

The film was shot in New York City, marking Allen's return to his native city after shooting four films in Europe. David was hesitant to take the role, pointing out to Allen that his work on Curb Your Enthusiasm was improvisation, but Allen encouraged him to take the role anyway.[3]

Partly to counter assertions that the film is autobiographical,[4] Allen has pointed out that the script was written in the early 1970s, with Zero Mostel in mind for Boris; it was shelved after the actor's death in 1977. Thirty years later, Allen revisited the script in an attempt to create a film before a potential threat of a Screen Actors Guild strike.[3] According to Allen, the only significant changes to the script involved updating the topical references.[4][5]

Soundtrack

[edit]

Release

[edit]

On February 2, 2009, Variety reported that Sony Pictures Classics had purchased U.S. distribution rights to Whatever Works. It premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival in New York City,[3] on April 22, 2009. Sony gave the film a limited US release, beginning June 19, 2009. Maple Pictures released the film in Canada theatrically, and on DVD in October 2009. The film had its UK release on June 25, 2010.[4]

Reception

[edit]

On Rotten Tomatoes the film holds an approval rating of 50% based on 165 reviews, with an average rating of 5.4/10. The website's critical consensus reads, "Based upon a script written in the 1970s, Woody Allen's Whatever Works suffers from a lack of fresh ideas."[6] According to another review aggregator, Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 top reviews from mainstream critics, the film has an average score of 45 out of 100, based on 30 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews".[7]

Reflecting the evenly split approval of the critics, Matthew Oshinsky of The Star-Ledger wrote that the film was a good example of Allen's "ability to write great roles for women" and the film is nowhere near his best work, but it has some funny lines and that "it's at least pleasant".[8]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Whatever Works

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Whatever Works is a 2009 American romantic comedy film written and directed by , starring as Boris Yellnikoff, a middle-aged, divorced, and misanthropic former child-prodigy turned chess tutor in . The story centers on Boris's reluctant involvement with Melody Celestine, a naive and homeless young woman from portrayed by , whose arrival disrupts his pessimistic worldview and leads to a series of unconventional relationships involving her family members, including her mother played by . Filmed entirely on location in New York, the movie represents Allen's return to his native setting following a series of European-based productions, incorporating his signature direct-address narrative technique where David frequently breaks the to comment on events. Premiering at the before a limited U.S. release on June 19, 2009, it explores themes of , moral relativism, and human incompatibility through Boris's cynical lens, emphasizing pragmatic acceptance over idealistic pursuits. Critically, the film garnered mixed reception, with a 50% approval rating from critics on who noted its familiar Allen tropes alongside commendations for David's acerbic portrayal, while audience scores were higher at around 64%. Financially, it underperformed domestically with $5.3 million in U.S. grosses but achieved greater success internationally, totaling $35.1 million worldwide against a modest budget. No major awards were won, though it highlighted David's transition from television to film lead roles.

Synopsis

Plot Overview

Boris Yellnikoff, a divorced and highly intelligent former physics professor once nominated for the , resides in and harbors a profound disdain for humanity. After a failed by stepping in front of an oncoming subway train, Boris frequently breaks the to address the audience directly, recounting events as they unfold. He supplements his income by teaching chess to children in while living in a modest walk-up apartment. One evening, Boris encounters St. John, a 19-year-old runaway from who begs for food and after fleeing her sheltered upbringing in the . Initially dismissive and viewing her as a burden due to her naivety and lack of sophistication, Boris reluctantly allows her to stay. Over time, Melody develops strong affections for Boris, leading to an improbable romantic and marital relationship; she abandons her fundamentalist Christian beliefs, embraces , and adopts Boris's cynical and intellectual interests. Melody's mother, Marian, arrives in New York searching for her daughter and reacts with horror to the marriage upon discovering Boris's atheism and age disparity. However, Marian soon embarks on an affair with a neighboring , undergoes a personal liberation, and relocates permanently to the city to pursue painting. Melody's father, John, follows and experiences his own transformation, revealing homosexual inclinations and forming a relationship with a local bookseller. The members establish mismatched partnerships within New York's social circles. The narrative concludes with Boris reflecting on the unforeseen compatibilities and contentment arising from these developments, reiterating his philosophy through continued direct addresses to the audience, as the characters settle into their altered lives.

Development and Pre-production

Script Conception

The screenplay for Whatever Works originated in the as a vehicle tailored for actor , whom had befriended during preparations for an unproduced stage project. Following Mostel's sudden death from a heart attack on September 8, 1977, at age 62, Allen shelved the script, which featured a misanthropic New York intellectual railing against life's absurdities. The project remained dormant for over three decades until the 2007–2008 Writers Guild of America strike, which halted new screenplay development from November 2007 to February 2008, prompted Allen to revisit archived material. Allen selected Whatever Works for its comedic potential and structural completeness, adapting it minimally to align with contemporary sensibilities while preserving the original framework of direct audience address, philosophical monologues, and interpersonal dynamics. This revival marked Allen's return to directing in after a series of European-set films, including Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008), allowing him to reengage with familiar urban backdrops and thematic concerns like urban alienation and . The script's evolution thus reflected Allen's pragmatic approach to production constraints, prioritizing an existing blueprint over ideation from scratch amid external disruptions.

Casting Decisions

The role of Boris Yellnikoff, the film's central misanthropic physicist, was cast with , whose established persona as a curmudgeonly from the HBO series (1999–2024) suited the character's acerbic worldview without requiring emulation of Woody Allen's signature neuroticism. David's selection emphasized his innate ability to deliver improvised-seeming rants and social discomfort, aligning with the script's demands for unpolished authenticity over rehearsed intensity. Evan Rachel Wood was chosen for Melody Celestine, the impressionable young runaway from whose arc involves shifting from Southern naivety to broader self-awareness amid her improbable romance with Boris. Wood's prior roles in films like Thirteen (2003) demonstrated her range in depicting youthful vulnerability evolving into maturity, making her a fit for Melody's transition from pageant-queen simplicity to pragmatic adaptation in New York. Supporting roles included as Marietta Celestine, Melody's initially rigid mother, whose character's ideological pivot from evangelical to libertine openness benefited from Clarkson's experience in portraying multifaceted parental figures, as seen in prior Allen collaborations like Another Woman (1988). Clarkson noted the role's appeal in its layered contradictions, requiring minimal preparation to capture the figure's transformative zeal. Other key parts, such as as Melody's father John and as her suitor Randy, rounded out the ensemble with actors capable of contrasting Boris's cynicism through earnest or idealized traits. Woody Allen's casting approach for Whatever Works, filmed in 2008, prioritized actors who could deliver lines with spontaneous naturalism rather than method immersion or extensive blocking, reflecting his long-standing production of capturing unforced dialogue through quick takes and limited rehearsals to preserve comedic timing. This method extended to , who relied on his improvisational background for Boris's direct-address monologues, minimizing scripted rigidity in favor of lived-in delivery.

Production

Filming Process

for Whatever Works began in April 2008 and concluded in May 2008, spanning approximately six weeks in . The shoot marked Woody Allen's return to filming exclusively in after several European productions, leveraging the city's dynamic street life to ground the story's neurotic, urban milieu. Filming occurred on location throughout , with key sites in and the East Village providing the authentic, bustling backdrop essential to the film's New York-centric narrative. Specific spots included streets near East Houston and Forsyth for exterior scenes, capturing pedestrians and architecture without extensive to preserve spontaneity and realism. This approach aligned with Allen's preference for on-location shooting to integrate the environment organically into performances. The production incorporated fourth-wall breaks, with lead actor addressing the audience directly in multiple scenes, necessitating coordinated blocking to align actor movements with static camera setups for seamless integration. Allen's directing emphasized efficiency, with cast reports indicating limited rehearsals to foster improvisational energy in dialogue-heavy sequences. Scenes were often captured in a single take or with minimal coverage, prioritizing verbal rhythm over technical polish.

Post-production and Technical Elements

Alisa Lepselter edited Whatever Works, continuing her long-standing partnership with that began in 1999 and emphasizing the director's preference for efficient workflows to retain the spontaneity of on-set improvisations. Her approach involved streamlined cuts that preserved the film's rapid-fire dialogue and comedic timing, avoiding extensive restructuring to align with Allen's minimalist revision process, which typically limits reshoots and relies on capturing authentic performances during . This resulted in a runtime of 92 minutes, with focused on tightening scenes to heighten the chaotic interpersonal dynamics without diluting the script's philosophical asides. Harris Savides provided cinematography, shooting on 35mm film to achieve a textured, documentary-like quality that highlighted New York's less glamorous neighborhoods through available lighting and handheld techniques, diverging from the more contrived elegance of Allen's contemporaneous European productions like (2005) and (2008). Savides' visual strategy prioritized naturalistic grit over romanticization, employing shallow in interior shots to isolate characters amid cluttered urban backdrops, which reinforced the film's themes of existential disconnection while adhering to practical, low-overhead methods suited to the production's scale. color grading maintained a desaturated palette to evoke the protagonist's cynical worldview, with minimal digital intervention to uphold the organic feel of the location footage. Technical elements incorporated straightforward practical effects for key sequences, such as the opening , executed through on-location staging and minimal prosthetics rather than CGI, reflecting Allen's aversion to heavy and the film's efficient resource allocation. in integrated diegetic New York ambient noise to ground the narrative, with foley work enhancing everyday mishaps for comedic punctuation, all processed to support the film's intimate, stage-like direct-address style without elaborate mixing.

Themes and Philosophical Elements

Pragmatism Over Ideology

In Whatever Works (2009), the Boris Yellnikoff, a disillusioned former professor and avowed , directly espouses a prioritizing empirical functionality over dogma, repeatedly asserting to the that individuals should adopt "whatever works" to navigate life's chaos, irrespective of rational consistency or doctrinal purity. This stance manifests in Boris's dismissal of both militant and religious as secondary to outcomes that sustain psychological equilibrium, evidenced by his tolerance of contradictory beliefs among associates if they correlate with reported contentment. Boris's personal evolution underscores this pragmatism: following a botched suicide attempt in the late 1990s, precipitated by his view of humanity's inherent irrationality and cosmic indifference, he shifts from unyielding nihilistic pessimism—characterized by contempt for moral absolutes and predictions of societal collapse—to a provisional endorsement of adaptive behaviors yielding tangible stability, grounded in direct observation of behavioral changes rather than abstract principles. His narrative breaks the fourth wall to emphasize that human flourishing emerges not from ideological adherence but from mechanisms that empirically mitigate despair, such as improvised social arrangements that persist despite logical flaws. The film illustrates critique of inflexible ideologies through characters' transitions, exemplified by the family of Boris's young companion Celestine, whose initial Southern Baptist —marked by strict moral codes and literal —dissolves into eclectic pursuits after exposure to New York City's diversity, resulting in measurable improvements in self-reported : 's mother embraces secular artistry, her father pursues same-sex relationships, and these shifts, though inconsistent with their prior worldview, are validated by Boris as "working" based on their sustained functionality and absence of relapse into prior discontent. This pattern rejects purity tests, favoring causal evidence of fulfillment over coherence, as when family members' conversions align with enhanced interpersonal dynamics and creative output, detached from evaluative judgments on belief validity.

Happiness and Human Relationships

In Whatever Works, the central relationship between Boris Kopeikin, a cynical, intellectually in his sixties, and St. John, a young, uneducated woman from , exemplifies serendipitous bonds that transcend conventional mismatches in age, class, and worldview. After becomes homeless in following a fallout with her conservative family, she seeks shelter with Boris, leading to an improbable that stabilizes through mutual adaptation rather than shared ideals. Boris's initial condescension gives way to companionship, while Melody gains independence and self-assurance, illustrating how trial-and-error accommodations foster enduring satisfaction absent from prescriptive romantic models. The film extends this dynamic to secondary pairings, such as Melody's mother Marietta, whose arrival exposes familial tensions but prompts her own relational . Initially horrified by her daughter's union, Marietta rejects her rigid Southern upbringing, engaging in affairs that defy her prior heteronormative commitments, including a liaison with a younger artist and eventual openness to same-sex relationships. These developments underscore resilience as the causal mechanism for relational viability, where initial improbabilities—spanning generational, socioeconomic, and experiential divides—are navigated via pragmatic adjustments rather than idealized compatibility. Such portrayals challenge societal norms emphasizing uniform partner selection criteria, positing as an emergent outcome of functional disequilibria rather than harmonious . Boris's direct addresses to the audience reinforce this by framing relationships as contingent experiments, where "whatever works" supplants dogmatic expectations of or equitable exchange. Empirical realism prevails, with couplings persisting not through emotional transcendence but through iterative compromises that yield practical fulfillment, as evidenced by the characters' sustained despite external .

Soundtrack and Music

Composition and Usage

The soundtrack for Whatever Works consists primarily of licensed pre-existing recordings rather than an original score, featuring a eclectic mix of standards, light orchestral pieces, and classical excerpts selected to punctuate the film's comedic rhythm and urban milieu. Key tracks include "Hello I Must Be Going" performed by from the 1930 film Animal Crackers, "Salty Bubble" by Tom Sharpsteen and His Orlandos, "Butterfly By" by , and "Honeymoon Swoon" by Werner Tautz, alongside classical selections such as Symphony No. 9 in D Minor. These pieces, drawn from Woody Allen's longstanding preference for archival music over composition, total approximately 60 minutes across 13 tracks on the official . In the film, the music functions sparingly to heighten ironic or transitional moments without overshadowing , such as the deployment of Beethoven's Symphony No. 5 during a scene symbolizing fateful encounters, which amplifies the comedic timing of character interactions. Other cues, like novelty tunes during relational shifts, provide brief underscoring for chaotic family dynamics, maintaining a light, non-intrusive presence that evokes New York's eclectic energy through jazz-inflected selections. The compilation album was released commercially on June 30, 2009, by , following the film's U.S. theatrical debut on June 19.

Release and Commercial Performance

Premiere and Distribution

Whatever Works had its world premiere as the opening night film at the 2009 Film Festival on April 22, 2009, in . This event highlighted Woody Allen's return to directing a story set in after several European productions. The film received a in the United States on , 2009, distributed by . In , releases commenced that same month, including in on June 19, capitalizing on Allen's heightened international profile following the Academy Award win for Vicky Cristina Barcelona earlier in 2009. Marketing efforts centered on Larry David's casting as the Boris Yellnikoff, leveraging his recognition from the television series to draw audiences. Promotional materials, including posters, prominently featured David alongside the tagline "Whatever Works," underscoring the film's comedic exploration of life's improvisations in a New York context.

Box Office Results

Whatever Works was released in the United States on June 19, 2009, in a limited engagement across nine theaters, earning $266,162 in its opening weekend. The film's domestic total reached $5,306,706, reflecting its niche appeal as an during a period of economic contraction amid the 2009 recession, which constrained on non-blockbuster films. Internationally, performance was substantially stronger, generating $30,713,828—accounting for 85.3% of the global gross of $36,020,534—driven particularly by markets in where Woody Allen's reputation retained significant draw. Against an estimated of $15 million, the worldwide earnings indicate modest profitability at the theatrical level, though ancillary revenues such as and distribution deals were not factored into these figures.
Market RegionGross EarningsPercentage of Worldwide Total
Domestic (US & Canada)$5,306,70614.7%
International$30,713,82885.3%
Worldwide Total$36,020,534100%
The disparity between domestic and international results underscores the film's limited mainstream accessibility in the , compounded by its cerebral, dialogue-driven style and timing during broader industry challenges like reduced theater attendance in 2009.

Reception

Critical Analysis

Whatever Works received mixed reviews from critics, with aggregate scores reflecting divided opinions on its execution and relevance. On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds a 50% approval rating based on 167 reviews, indicating a Rotten consensus that highlights its reliance on an outdated script lacking innovation. Similarly, Metacritic assigns a score of 45 out of 100 from 31 critics, categorizing it as mixed or average. Critics praised elements such as the film's humor, strong performances—particularly Larry David's portrayal of the misanthropic Boris Yellnikoff—and its philosophical exploration of life's contingencies. awarded it three out of four stars, commending the narrative arc as a progression from cynical wit akin to toward deeper reflections on human connection, reminiscent of Blaise Pascal's insights on the heart's reasons. Some reviewers appreciated the ensemble dynamics and the light-hearted dissection of ideological rigidity, viewing the story's embrace of as a refreshing counter to dogmatic worldviews. Conversely, detractors criticized the film for recycling Woody familiar tropes, including neurotic protagonists and misanthropic diatribes, which contributed to perceptions of staleness and uneven pacing. The script, originally written in the 1970s for , was faulted for feeling dated and out of step with contemporary sensibilities, exacerbating issues like contrived character transformations and overly theatrical dialogue. Additional complaints targeted the protagonist's overt cynicism as bordering on smugness, with some arguing it undermined the comedic intent. Reviewers from conservative-leaning outlets often highlighted the film's anti-dogmatic message—favoring personal happiness over rigid ideologies—as a strength, interpreting Boris's as a valid rebuke to overly prescriptive social norms. In contrast, critics from mainstream liberal publications took issue with the portrayal of Southern characters, decrying of religious and sudden ideological shifts as reductive and mocking, potentially reinforcing coastal amid broader institutional biases in media toward progressive sensitivities. These divergences underscore how source perspectives influence interpretations, with empirical aggregates revealing no consensus on whether the film's pragmatic redeems its structural shortcomings.

Audience Perspectives

Audience members have rated Whatever Works favorably on aggregate platforms, with an user score of 7.1 out of 10 based on 78,628 votes as of 2025, underscoring the appeal of David's performance as the curmudgeonly Boris, whose pragmatic worldview and fourth-wall-breaking asides resonate with viewers valuing unfiltered realism over sentimental tropes. This score, sustained over years of post-release voting, contrasts with more divided professional evaluations and highlights empirical viewer endorsement of the film's dismissal of ideological purity in favor of "whatever works" in human connections. Rotten Tomatoes audience approval stands at 61%, drawn from thousands of verified user ratings, where positive feedback frequently emphasizes the humor in David's delivery and the narrative's critique of , though detractors note discomfort with the improbable shifts in supporting characters like . Online discourse in forums such as reveals polarization: enthusiasts appreciate the anti-dogmatic thrust, with one thread lauding its interest over mainstream comedies despite limited likability, while others decry the film's cynicism and age-gap dynamics as "horrible and creepy," reflecting unease with its unapologetic character evolutions. Post-2010 engagement persists through streaming and home viewings, evidenced by steady IMDb review accumulation and forum revivals, fostering appreciation among audiences skeptical of cultural mandates on relationships and happiness, though without achieving overt status in broader lists. This enduring draw stems from the film's empirical focus on contingency over , prompting repeat discussions on platforms where users value its resistance to .

Controversies and Critiques

Depictions of Age-Disparate Relationships

In Whatever Works, the central romantic pairing involves Boris Kaczarowski, a 62-year-old divorced played by , and St. Ann Celestine, a 21-year-old runaway from portrayed by , creating an age disparity of 41 years. The film presents their relationship as emerging from circumstance—Boris reluctantly shelters the homeless , who repays with domestic companionship and affection—evolving into based on mutual utility rather than conventional romance. This depiction challenges societal norms by emphasizing compatibility in intellect and temperament, with gaining sophistication and Boris finding temporary emotional relief, without explicit endorsement of the arrangement as a universal ideal. The narrative counters assumptions of inherent exploitation by highlighting Melody's agency as an adult capable of choice; she initiates intimacy, defends the union to her disapproving , and later exercises in its dissolution. Empirical realism is conveyed through the relationship's limited sustainability: after roughly one year of marriage on June 19, 2009 (the film's release aligning with its timeline), Melody leaves Boris for a younger peer-matched , reflecting causal outcomes where initial benefits yield to diverging life stages, yet ending amicably under the film's pragmatic . Criticisms, often from feminist perspectives, contend that such portrayals normalize power imbalances, where the older man's resources and experience inherently disadvantage the younger , potentially masking despite surface . These views align with broader concerns in analyses of Woody Allen's oeuvre, attributing recurring age-gap tropes to unchecked male privilege. Defenses invoke adult consent and character-driven realism, arguing the film's outcomes—Melody's growth and voluntary exit—demonstrate no predation, with causal from her proactive decisions underscoring viability when mutual benefits align. Real-world data supports mixed longevity in age-disparate unions: a Danish of over 2 million individuals found that women with younger husbands (reversed gap) face elevated mortality risks, while men benefit from younger spouses, though larger gaps overall predict higher dissolution rates, with couples differing by 3% more likely to separate than same-age pairs, implying greater challenges for 40-year disparities yet not precluding success via compatibility. This empirical pattern mirrors the film's non-idealized arc, prioritizing observable relational dynamics over normative prohibitions.

Ideological and Cultural Commentary

The film satirizes Southern through the character of , a naive runaway from whose family embodies rigid religious dogma, superstition, and provincialism, including beliefs in divine intervention and that constrain personal fulfillment. This portrayal has drawn for reinforcing elitist stereotypes of rural conservatives as backward and easily swayed, with conservative reviewers interpreting it as Woody Allen's urbane dismissing heartland values in favor of cosmopolitan . Such critiques argue the narrative arc—Melody's rapid "enlightenment" to and upon encountering New York life—exposes an ideological bias privileging secular fluidity over entrenched , though empirical observation in the plot reveals characters achieving greater agency and happiness by discarding unexamined creeds for pragmatic adaptations. Allen's script rejects both conservative religious and the pieties of progressive self-congratulation, as Melody's parents undergo their own conversions—her mother to bohemian artistry and her father to —only for these shifts to yield superficial pretensions that Boris, the cynical , debunks as equally dogmatic illusions. This dual critique underscores a causal realism: ideological commitments persist until contradicted by , with thriving ensuing from empirical functionality rather than ideological purity, evidenced by the characters' improved relationships and post-transformation. Defenders of the film's approach contend it debunks sensitivities around belief change by prioritizing observable outcomes over sentimental attachments to or novelty. Post-release, religious audiences and commentators pushed back against the film's endorsement of relativism, encapsulated in its title and Boris's mantra that "whatever works" supplants moral absolutes, viewing it as eroding foundational virtues in favor of hedonistic expediency. These objections, often from faith-based outlets, highlight a perceived promotion of ethical pragmatism that subordinates eternal truths to temporal satisfaction, potentially fostering societal cynicism. Counterarguments rooted in the film's internal logic emphasize its empirical lens: rigid dogmas—whether fundamentalist or otherwise—correlate with stagnation, while adaptive beliefs align with measurable well-being, as tracked through the characters' evolving domestic stability and personal autonomy from June 2009 onward in the narrative timeline. Sources amplifying this backlash, such as Christian media, reflect a doctrinal commitment that may amplify perceived threats to absolutism, yet the film's causal depiction of belief evolution holds against first-principles scrutiny of human adaptability.

Legacy and Influence

Cultural Impact

The film's central tenet of pragmatic —"whatever works" as a response to life's —has informed post-release philosophical critiques, particularly those examining relativism's risks in personal and decision-making. In analyses, this is portrayed as endorsing situational over absolute principles, with characters adapting beliefs fluidly to achieve fleeting amid cosmic indifference. Such discussions appear in outlets critiquing pragmatism's application beyond , including its parallels to broader cultural shifts toward outcome-based rationales in and political spheres. "Whatever Works" marked Woody Allen's return to settings after a European filmmaking phase, solidifying the as a backdrop for portrayals of intellectual urban eccentrics navigating relational chaos. This reinforced Allen's archetype of the city as a pressure cooker for misanthropic protagonists, influencing subsequent indie narratives centered on alienated cosmopolitans in dense, neurotic environments. While not a direct template, the film's blend of direct-address monologues and ensemble transformations echoed in lighter urban comedies exploring personal reinvention amid cultural clashes. Despite garnering no major Academy Award nominations and modest returns of approximately $35 million worldwide, the film has sustained niche appeal among Allen enthusiasts, with retrospective viewings highlighting its rejection of dogmatic ideologies as prescient amid escalating cultural polarization. Recent commentaries, including 2024 explorations of its predictive elements on flexible worldviews, position it as a to rigid partisanship, valuing adaptive over ideological purity. This endurance manifests in ongoing fan analyses and philosophical dissections, underscoring its role in debates on existential resilience rather than mainstream canonization.

Relation to Woody Allen's Oeuvre

"Whatever Works" represents Woody Allen's return to the autobiographical misanthropy characterizing his early career, particularly evident in films like "Annie Hall" (1977), as the screenplay was originally written in the 1970s for actor Zero Mostel, who died shortly before "Annie Hall"'s release. The protagonist Boris Yellnikoff, portrayed by Larry David, mirrors Allen's recurrent depiction of neurotic, atheistic New York intellectuals railing against human folly and cosmic indifference, a persona Allen frequently embodied onscreen in his initial phase. This revival of a decades-old script after Allen's European period underscores a causal continuity in his artistic evolution, prioritizing personal disillusionment over the stylistic experimentation of later works. The film's themes update this foundational with a post-9/11 inflection of deepened , portraying individual resilience amid societal and existential chaos rather than the lighter of mid-career efforts. Boris's and pragmatic philosophy—"whatever works"—echo Allen's persistent exploration of mortality, relationships, and , empirically sustained across four decades despite critiques tied to his 1992 personal scandals, which investigations cleared of legal wrongdoing with no charges filed. This focus on causal individual agency, unburdened by collective ideological impositions, subtly diverges from Hollywood's post-2017 cultural shift toward conformity, allowing Allen to maintain output in while U.S. institutions amplified unsubstantiated narratives. In oeuvre, "Whatever Works" thus exemplifies a deviation toward unadorned realism in character-driven , privileging empirical personal over narrative collectivism, as seen in Boris's rejection of ideological conversions for self-determined . This approach, rooted in first-hand observation of , contrasts with academia and media's toward framing work through politicized lenses, yet affirms his thematic consistency: success in dissecting and age-disparate bonds derives from unaltered scrutiny, not external validation.

References

  1. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1178663/
  2. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/whatever_works
  3. https://www.the-numbers.com/movie/Whatever-Works-%282009%29
  4. https://www.npr.org/2009/06/15/105400872/woody-allen-on-life-films-and-whatever-works
  5. https://nymag.com/movies/features/56930/
  6. https://www.sonyclassics.com/whateverworks/_pdf/whateverworks_presskit.pdf
  7. https://www.woodyallenpages.com/films/whatever-works/
  8. https://www.bamboo-nation.com/2009/06/whatever-works-works.html
  9. https://www.australianjewishnews.com/best-films-of-2009/
  10. https://www.cnn.com/2009/SHOWBIZ/Movies/06/18/whatever.works.cast/index.html
  11. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SaAg-0Kb1eE
  12. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1178663/fullcredits/
  13. https://www.villagevoice.com/interview-woody-allen-on-whatever-works-the-meaning-of-life-or-lack-thereof-and-the-allure-of-younger-women/
  14. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1178663/locations/
  15. https://www.woodyallenpages.com/2017/09/whatever-works-filming-locations-new-york-city/
  16. https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/NoFourthWall
  17. http://nycmovieguru.com/whateverworks.html
  18. https://www.cinemablend.com/new/Interview-Woody-Allen-Cast-Whatever-Works-13604.html
  19. https://www.sonyclassics.com/bluejasmine/bios/alisa.html
  20. https://variety.com/2009/film/markets-festivals/whatever-works-1200474445/
  21. https://shotonwhat.com/whatever-works-2009
  22. https://www.woodyallenpages.com/2020/01/every-cinematographer-from-woody-allens-films-gordon-willis-carlos-di-palma-darius-khondji-vittorio-storaro-and-more/
  23. https://www.deepfocusreview.com/reviews/whatever-works/
  24. https://openjournals.uwaterloo.ca/index.php/kinema/article/download/1235/1560?inline=1
  25. https://www.summit.org/resources/articles/why-whatever-works-really-doesnt-work-at-all-woody-allen-and-the-dangers-of-pragmatism/
  26. https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/whatever-works-2009
  27. https://theschleicherspin.com/2009/06/29/a-review-of-woody-allens-whatever-works/
  28. https://cinematicpassions.wordpress.com/2009/06/30/whatever-works/
  29. https://middleofrow.com/2009/06/29/review-whatever-works/
  30. https://www.chrisknipp.com/writing/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=1296
  31. https://www.npr.org/transcripts/105400872
  32. https://blog.cinemaautopsy.com/2009/10/17/film-review-whatever-works-2009/
  33. https://www.indiewire.com/features/general/the-9-women-you-meet-in-woody-allen-movies-186057/
  34. https://cdn.bookey.app/files/pdf/book/en/woody-allen-by-tom-shone.pdf
  35. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1178663/soundtrack/
  36. https://music.apple.com/ca/album/whatever-works-original-motion-picture-soundtrack/1469574243
  37. https://www.allmusic.com/album/whatever-works-original-motion-picture-soundtrack--mw0000821914
  38. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FVojudn2Qek
  39. https://www.discogs.com/release/11538700-Various-Whatever-Works-Original-Motion-Picture-Soundtrack
  40. https://www.theguardian.com/film/gallery/2009/apr/23/woody-allen-larry-david-whatever-works
  41. https://filmmakermagazine.com/4133-tribeca-allen-returns-to-nyc-with-whatever-works/
  42. https://www.sonyclassics.com/whateverworks/article.html
  43. https://www.screendaily.com/whatever-works/5000396.article
  44. https://www.orlandosentinel.com/2009/07/01/larry-david-talks-about-whatever-works/
  45. https://www.ebay.com/itm/333781209086
  46. https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt1178663/
  47. https://woodyallenmoblynching.com/whatever-works/
  48. https://www.slantmagazine.com/film/dixie-twist-in-praise-of-whatever-works/
  49. https://www.metacritic.com/movie/whatever-works/critic-reviews/
  50. https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2009/07/what-j15.html
  51. https://www.theepochtimes.com/article/movie-whatever-works-woody-allen-1511779
  52. https://christiananswers.net/spotlight/movies/2009/whateverworks2009.html
  53. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1178663/ratings/
  54. https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/4is4ou/serious_whatever_works_staring_larry_david_why_do/
  55. https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/79damm/whatever_works_2009_with_larry_david_is_horrible/
  56. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1178663/reviews/
  57. https://www.reelviews.net/reelviews/whatever-works
  58. https://www.salon.com/2015/07/15/the_12_most_age_inappropriate_romantic_pairings_in_woody_allens_career/
  59. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1178663/plotsummary/
  60. https://www.theguardian.com/film/filmblog/2010/jun/28/whatever-works-age-gap-woody
  61. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3000022/
  62. https://english.elpais.com/society/2023-08-03/from-socioeconomic-status-to-the-number-of-ex-partners-what-makes-a-lasting-romance.html
  63. https://www.movieguide.org/reviews/movies/whatever-works.html
  64. https://www.lacan.com/symptom12/
  65. https://www.commonwealmagazine.org/woody-allen-nihilist
  66. https://www.vvdailypress.com/story/news/local/desert-dispatch/2010/05/10/the-dangerous-allure-pragmatism/37121009007/
  67. https://www.ocregister.com/2010/05/07/tibor-machan-the-fatal-allure-of-political-pragmatism/
  68. https://citiesincinema.wordpress.com/2019/11/04/woody-allens-manhattan-new-york/
  69. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SfW1kru9l0
  70. https://edwardfeser.blogspot.com/2021/08/adventures-in-old-atheism-part-v-woody.html
  71. https://www.npr.org/transcripts/105400872?storyId=105400872
  72. https://www.jetir.org/papers/JETIR1905I42.pdf
  73. https://people.bu.edu/rcarney/carncult/woody.htm
  74. https://theartsdesk.com/film/whatever-works
  75. https://www.breitbart.com/entertainment/2009/07/16/whatever-works-doesnt/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.