Hubbry Logo
Ask Me WhyAsk Me WhyMain
Open search
Ask Me Why
Community hub
Ask Me Why
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Ask Me Why
Ask Me Why
Ask Me Why
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

"Ask Me Why"
US promotional single sleeve
Single by the Beatles
from the album Please Please Me
A-side"Please Please Me"
Released
  • 11 January 1963 (1963-01-11) (UK)
  • 25 February 1963 (US)[1]
Recorded26 November 1962[1]
StudioEMI, London
GenrePop
Length2:24
Label
SongwriterLennon–McCartney
ProducerGeorge Martin
The Beatles UK singles chronology
"Love Me Do"
(1962) 		"Please Please Me" / "Ask Me Why"
(1963) 		"From Me to You"
(1963)
The Beatles US singles chronology
"Please Please Me" / "Ask Me Why"
(1963) 		"From Me to You"
(1963)
Alternative cover
B-side label of UK single
B-side label of UK single

"Ask Me Why" is a song by the English rock band the Beatles originally released in the United Kingdom as the B-side of their single "Please Please Me". It was also included on their 1963 debut album Please Please Me. It was written primarily by John Lennon and credited to the Lennon–McCartney partnership.

Composition

[edit]

Written in early 1962, "Ask Me Why" is principally a John Lennon composition,[2] but was credited to Lennon and Paul McCartney, as were all other Lennon–McCartney originals on the first pressings of Please Please Me album. McCartney said, "It was John's original idea and we both sat down and wrote it together, just did a job on it. It was mostly John's."[3][4] It was part of their live act prior to their recording contract, and was one of the songs performed at their first Parlophone recording session in EMI's Abbey Road studio two on 6 June 1962.[2][5][6] The song emulates the style of Smokey Robinson and the Miracles, by whom Lennon was influenced, and draws its opening guitar phrase from the Miracles' "What's So Good About Goodbye" (1961).[7]

Structure

[edit]

The song is in the key of E major, with some leaning to its relative minor of C♯ minor, and is in 4
4 time. Structurally, the song is complex and, as Alan Pollack states, contains three different variants of the verse.[8] The song also contains "jazzy parallel sevenths" in most of the chords, and has a live ending.[citation needed]

Recording

[edit]

"Ask Me Why" was originally recorded at Abbey Road studios on 6 June 1962 with drummer Pete Best. As the session was a 'commercial test', none of the performances recorded that day were deemed suitable for release, and the two quarter-inch tape reels from that session are presumed to have been destroyed by EMI. However, two songs survived; "Besame Mucho" and "Love Me Do" were later discovered on acetate discs.[9][10] The group also performed "Ask Me Why" for the BBC Light Programme's Teenager's Turn – Here We Go; the performance, recorded at the BBC Playhouse in Hulme, Manchester, was broadcast nine days after the EMI session.

The song was recorded again, along with "Please Please Me", on 26 November 1962 with Ringo Starr on drums. The Beatles also rehearsed "Tip of My Tongue", another Lennon and McCartney song which was also being considered for the B-side of the "Please Please Me" single.[7] However, producer George Martin felt that "Tip of My Tongue" still needed some work, and it was eventually given to Tommy Quickly to record.[11]

Other releases

[edit]

Cover versions

[edit]

The song was covered by the Smithereens on their 2008 album B-Sides The Beatles.[12][importance of example(s)?]

Personnel

[edit]

Engineered by Norman Smith

Personnel per Ian MacDonald[7][4]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Ask Me Why

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
"Ask Me Why" is a song by the English rock band , written primarily by with contributions from and credited to the Lennon-McCartney songwriting partnership. Released as the B-side to the band's second single, "," on January 11, , it marked an early milestone in their career as one of their first original compositions to gain public release. Composed in the spring of , the song draws stylistic influences from American , particularly the work of and , including their 1961 track "What's So Good About Goodbye." Its express themes of romantic devotion, with Lennon delivering the lead vocals in a distinctive, harmonized style that showcases the band's evolving vocal interplay. The track was first attempted in recording on June 6, 1962, at EMI's , but those tapes were later destroyed by the label. A remake was completed on November 26, 1962, in just six takes under the production of George Martin and engineering by Norman Smith, featuring John Lennon on lead vocals and rhythm guitar, Paul McCartney on backing vocals and bass guitar, George Harrison on lead guitar and backing vocals, and Ringo Starr on drums. Beyond its single release, "Ask Me Why" was included on the Beatles' debut album Please Please Me, issued in March 1963, helping to establish their sound during the British Invasion. In the United States, it appeared on the album Introducing... The Beatles, released on January 10, 1964. The song also received airplay on BBC radio, with the band performing live versions five times between 1962 and 1963, one of which was later released on the compilation album On Air – Live At The BBC Volume 2 in 2013. Despite its position as a B-side, "Ask Me Why" exemplifies the Beatles' early songwriting prowess and their fusion of pop, rock, and doo-wop elements, contributing to their rapid rise to fame.

Background

Writing and Inspiration

"Ask Me Why" was primarily written by in the spring of 1962, during ' residency at the Star-Club in , , with contributing to the composition and receiving co-writing credit under the standard agreement. later recalled, "It was John’s original idea and we both sat down and wrote it together, just did a job on it. It was mostly John’s," highlighting Lennon's dominant role in its creation. The song emerged amid The Beatles' early songwriting phase, as the band expanded their repertoire of original material beyond covers during their intensive performances, which demanded long sets and encouraged creative development. This period marked a shift toward self-penned songs, with Lennon and McCartney honing their collaborative skills to build a distinctive sound. Lennon drew significant inspiration from and , incorporating their harmonic and rhythmic elements from and R&B into the track, particularly the introductory guitar motif derived from the Miracles' 1961 single "What's So Good About Goodbye." The song was conceived as a centered on themes of devotion and emotional reassurance, reflecting Lennon's aim to capture sincere romantic commitment.

Early Versions

"Ask Me Why" was first captured on tape during ' inaugural recording session at 's on June 6, 1962, as part of their audition for producer . This demo version, featuring drummer , was one of four tracks laid down that evening alongside "Love Me Do," "P.S. I Love You," and a cover of "Bésame Mucho," but it remained unreleased and the master tapes were reportedly destroyed or recorded over by . The session marked the band's initial foray into professional recording facilities, with the group performing the song in a raw, unpolished form that highlighted their evolving songwriting. Prior to this studio attempt, "Ask Me Why" saw its live debut through informal rehearsals and performances during ' Hamburg residency at the Star-Club starting in April 1962. These early shows, beginning shortly after the venue's opening on , incorporated the track into the band's setlist, blending it with covers and other nascent originals amid grueling nightly gigs that honed their stage presence. The song's inclusion in these performances represented a pivotal step in integrating self-penned material into their repertoire, moving beyond the predominantly cover-based sets of prior tours. Compared to the polished final version recorded in November 1962, the early iterations of "Ask Me Why" exhibited a simpler with fewer layered harmonies and a more straightforward rhythmic drive. As an early Lennon-McCartney original composed in spring 1962, "Ask Me Why" played a key role in ' shift from relying on cover songs to emphasizing their own compositions. This transition underscored the band's growing confidence in original material, helping to define their identity amid the competitive audition landscape.

Composition

Lyrics

"Ask Me Why" explores themes of romantic devotion, reassurance, and , portraying as a source of profound that dispels previous misery. The narrator expresses unwavering affection, emphasizing how the beloved's openness fosters a deep connection, culminating in the repeated declaration "I love you" to underscore commitment and constancy. This emotional vulnerability is evident in lines like "my happiness still makes me cry," which highlight the overwhelming joy of the relationship, transforming potential sorrow into tears of fulfillment. The song's lyrical structure consists of three distinct verse variants, a bridge, and a fade-out chorus that reinforces the central . The initial and repeated verses follow a similar pattern, beginning with "I love you 'cause you tell me things I want to know" and building to assurances of enduring , while the variant introduces subtle shifts for progression. The bridge provides contrast with "I can't believe it's happened to me / I can't conceive of any more misery," shifting to before returning to the chorus "Ask me why, I'll say I love you / And I'm always thinking of you," which fades out with multiple repetitions for emphasis. Poetic devices enhance the song's intimacy, including an rhyme scheme in the verses that creates a rhythmic flow, such as "know" rhyming with "show" and "blue" with "true." Imagery depicts love as a protective force against emotional turmoil, with phrases like "should never, never, never be blue" evoking a shield of reassurance. The wording draws brief influence from Smokey Robinson's style, evident in sophisticated phrasing like "conceive of any more misery." John Lennon's authorship infuses the lyrics with a personal touch, reflecting his early vocal style influences from soul through emotive, direct phrasing that conveys raw sincerity.

Musical Structure

"Ask Me Why" is composed in the key of , employing a 4/4 , with a of approximately 134 beats per minute, and has a total duration of 2:24. The song follows a complex verse-bridge form without a distinct chorus, structured as an intro followed by an initial verse, a variant verse (serving a refrain-like function), a bridge, another variant verse, a return to the initial verse, a second variant verse, a second bridge, and an outro that concludes with a variant verse and a complete ending. This arrangement, atypical for tracks, creates a dynamic flow through subtle variations in each section. Harmonically, the song relies on a progression centered around I-IV-V chords in , enriched with added sevenths for added complexity, such as the opening E7 chord and parallel sevenths evoking a jazzy feel. The initial verse progresses as E7 - F♯7 - G♯7 - F♯7 - B7 - E (I - ii - iii - ii - V - I), while the bridge shifts to A - B - E - E augmented (IV - V - I - V♯5 of IV), introducing momentary leans toward the relative minor of C♯. Rhythmically, the track features a syncopated pseudo-Latin beat, with phrases often starting mid-measure and incorporating in the bridge for emphasis. Guitar strums are syncopated, contributing to the driving momentum, while the chorus-like sections include harmonic vocal layering through close harmonies on sustained "woah" notes sung in slow by backing vocalists and . Stylistically, "Ask Me Why" blends elements of pop and doo-wop through its nostalgic arrangement and signature close vocal harmonies, infused with early rock 'n' roll via a corny backbeat and energetic rhythmic drive. This combination results in a sophisticated yet accessible sound typical of the band's early Merseybeat phase.

Recording and Production

Studio Sessions

The principal recording of "Ask Me Why" occurred on November 26, 1962, at EMI Studios (later renamed Abbey Road Studios) in Studio Two, London, as part of the sessions for the Beatles' second single, the A-side of which was "Please Please Me." This marked one of the band's early professional recordings with drummer Ringo Starr, who had joined permanently in August 1962, amid a compressed timeline to capitalize on the success of their debut single "Love Me Do." The group taped the song in six takes, following the completion of 18 takes for ""; the sixth take was deemed the best and used as the master without further or splicing. Recorded live onto a two-track in a single three-hour evening session starting at 7:00 p.m., the track featured no overdubs, double-tracking of vocals, or additional production layers, reflecting the rudimentary techniques of the era and the urgency to prepare material for an imminent release. A straightforward mono mix was created on November 30, , during a brief session dedicated to finalizing the single. The expedited process underscored the Beatles' demanding schedule in late 1962, including ongoing live tours and the push to deliver a pre-Christmas hit after "Love Me Do" had reached number 17 on the charts, heightening expectations for rapid output from their new contract. An earlier, rougher demo of the song had been attempted on June 6, 1962, during the band's debut EMI audition, but those tapes were destroyed.

Personnel

The recording of "Ask Me Why" featured the core lineup of , with no additional session musicians involved. provided lead vocals and played rhythm guitar, handled bass guitar and backing vocals, contributed lead guitar and backing vocals, and played drums. The production team consisted of as producer and Norman Smith as recording engineer, overseeing the sessions at Studios on 26 November 1962. Specific instrumentation included McCartney's 1961 , Harrison's 1957 Gretsch 6128 Duo Jet , and amplifiers for the guitars, contributing to the song's characteristic sound.

Release and Reception

Commercial Releases

"Ask Me Why" was first released as the B-side to the Beatles' single "" in the on January 11, 1963, by Records under catalogue number 45-R 4983. The single peaked at number 2 on the UK Singles Chart. The song appeared on the Beatles' debut album, , which released in the UK on March 22, 1963. In the United States, issued "Please Please Me" / "Ask Me Why" as a single on January 3, 1964, under catalogue number VJ 498. In the United States, the single peaked at number 3 on the in March 1964. It was included on later pressings of the album , with the version featuring the song released around February 10, 1964, by . Subsequent reissues featured the track on the 1987 compact disc edition of . The song was part of the mono remasters in box set, originally issued on in 2009 and on vinyl in 2014. Digital versions of "Ask Me Why" became available on major streaming platforms starting in 2015.

Critical and Commercial Response

The single "" backed with "Ask Me Why" marked a breakthrough for the Beatles, reaching number 2 on the UK Singles Chart and earning a silver disc for sales exceeding 250,000 copies by April 1963. While "Ask Me Why" did not chart independently, its inclusion as the B-side contributed to the overall commercial momentum of the release, with the single ultimately selling over 1 million copies in the UK during 1963. Early reviews of the single in publications like New Musical Express highlighted ' vocal harmonies as a standout feature, though the track was generally viewed as secondary to the A-side's more immediate appeal. The accompanying album , which featured "Ask Me Why" as the second track, propelled further by topping the for 30 weeks starting in May 1963. In retrospective analyses, "Ask Me Why" has been praised as an underrated gem from ' early catalog, often cited for its sophisticated structure and demonstration of influences, particularly and ' style in the vocals and call-and-response elements. Modern reviews of , such as AllMusic's 4-out-of-5-star assessment, commend the album's raw energy and the song's role in showcasing the band's emerging harmonic prowess.

Legacy

Cover Versions

Due to the relative obscurity of "Ask Me Why" among ' more prominent hits, the has inspired only a limited number of mainstream cover versions, with most reinterpretations appearing in niche or contexts. One of the earliest adaptations came from the French beat group Les Lionceaux, who recorded "Je Suis Fou" in 1964 for their self-titled album, translating the lyrics into French while embracing the energetic ye-ye pop style that dominated European youth culture during the mid-1960s. In 1966, The Big Ben Banjo Band featured an instrumental medley rendition—including "Ask Me Why" alongside "Do You Want to Know a Secret" and "Bad to Me"—on their album Banjos Go Beatles, reimagining the song through a lively banjo-led arrangement that accentuated its rhythmic bounce. The Armenian Philharmonic Orchestra, under conductor George Pehlivanian, provided a symphonic orchestral interpretation in 1993 on Beatles Symphonic Volume 4, transforming the original's pop harmonies into a sweeping classical arrangement that highlighted the melody's lyrical flow. American rock band delivered a guitar-driven rock cover in 2008 for their tribute album B-Sides the Beatles, infusing the track with raw energy and intensity while preserving its roots.

Live Performances and Cultural Significance

"Ask Me Why" was a staple in ' early live , particularly during their 1962–1963 performances, where it showcased the band's raw energy and developing stage presence. The song was first recorded for radio on June 11, 1962, during a BBC session for Teenager's Turn – Here We Go at the in , featuring drummer ; the group performed it alongside "" and "A Picture of You" before a studio audience. It was broadcast on June 15, 1962. Later that year, on December 31, 1962, included "Ask Me Why" in their explosive New Year's Eve set at the Star-Club in , , captured on amateur audience tapes that were later commercially released in 1977 as Live! at the Star-Club in Hamburg, ; 1962. By 1963, with on drums, the band recorded a polished live version on September 3 for the 's Pop Go The Beatles, broadcast on September 24, highlighting their tightened harmonies and crowd-pleasing delivery. Regularly featured in setlists throughout 1962 and 1963—appearing at venues like and various UK tours—"Ask Me Why" embodied the youthful vigor of ' pre-fame grind, often positioned mid-set to engage audiences with its upbeat rhythm and call-and-response elements. As their repertoire expanded with hits like "" and "I Want to Hold Your Hand," the song was gradually phased out after 1963, reflecting the band's evolution toward more sophisticated material and global stardom. These early renditions, marked by loose arrangements and enthusiastic vocals, captured the unpolished excitement that propelled from club circuits to international arenas. Culturally, "Ask Me Why" exemplifies The Beatles' early incorporation of influences, particularly the smooth harmonies reminiscent of & the Miracles, symbolizing the British Invasion's selective borrowings from to craft a hybrid pop sound. Its status as a lesser-known B-side and album track underscores the devotion of hardcore fans who cherished deep cuts, fostering a legacy of communal listening and bootleg trading that sustained the band's mystique beyond chart-toppers. The song's intricate vocal layering contributed to The Beatles' reputation for harmonic innovation in early pop songwriting, paving the way for more experimental arrangements in tracks like and influencing contemporaries in blending with rock. Today, it enjoys occasional revivals by acts, such as HELP! A Beatles Tribute and The Meetles, who perform it to evoke the era's raw authenticity.

References

  1. https://www.beatlesbible.com/songs/ask-me-why/
  2. http://www.beatlesebooks.com/introducing-the-beatles
  3. https://www.discogs.com/master/618247-The-Beatles-On-Air-Live-At-The-BBC-Volume-2
  4. https://www.the-paulmccartney-project.com/song/ask-me-why/
  5. https://somethingelsereviews.com/2014/05/23/deep-beatles-ask-me-why-star-club-1962/
  6. https://www.beatlesbible.com/1962/06/06/the-beatles-first-abbey-road-recording-session/
  7. http://www.beatlesebooks.com/ask-me-why
  8. https://www.beatlesbible.com/albums/live-at-the-star-club-hamburg-germany-1962/
  9. https://www.thebeatles.com/ask-me-why
  10. https://www.icce.rug.nl/~soundscapes/DATABASES/AWP/amw.shtml
  11. https://www.hooktheory.com/theorytab/view/the-beatles/ask-me-why
  12. https://songbpm.com/%40the-beatles/ask-me-why---remastered-2009
  13. http://www.beatleswiki.com/wiki/index.php/Ask_Me_Why
  14. https://www.beatlesbible.com/1962/11/26/recording-please-please-me-single/
  15. https://www.beatle.net/50-years-ago-the-beatles-record-their-second-single/
  16. https://www.fabfourmixnotes.com/26-november-1962-the-beatles-record-please-please-me-ask-me-why-tip-of-my-tongue-session-notes/
  17. https://www.beatlesbible.com/1962/11/30/mixing-please-please-me-ask-me-why/
  18. https://www.guitarworld.com/news/musicians-guide-songs-and-instruments-featured-beatles-please-please-me-album
  19. https://www.beatlesbible.com/1963/01/11/single-release-please-please-me-ask-me-why/
  20. https://www.officialcharts.com/songs/the-beatles-please-please-me/
  21. https://www.thebeatles.com/please-please-me
  22. https://www.beatlesbible.com/1964/01/03/us-single-please-please-me/
  23. https://www.beatlesbible.com/albums/introducing-the-beatles/
  24. https://www.discogs.com/release/7184020-The-Beatles-Please-Please-Me
  25. https://www.beatlesbible.com/1963/04/05/the-beatles-receive-their-first-silver-disc/
  26. https://chartmasters.org/the-best-selling-singles-by-the-beatles/
  27. https://www.songfacts.com/facts/the-beatles/please-please-me
  28. https://www.beatlesbible.com/1963/03/22/lp-release-please-please-me/
  29. https://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/psup/amp/article/4/1-2/42/402771/The-Beatles-New-Record-s-a-Gas-The-Beatles-and
  30. https://www.allmusic.com/album/please-please-me-mw0000649873
  31. https://secondhandsongs.com/performance/38670/all
  32. https://www.discogs.com/release/14247982-Les-Lionceaux-Les-Lionceaux
  33. https://www.radiofrance.fr/francebleu/podcasts/les-tresors-de-champagne-ardenne/les-lionceaux-des-remois-au-sommet-des-annees-ye-ye-2294994
  34. https://www.discogs.com/release/3843856-The-Big-Ben-Banjo-Band-Banjos-Go-Beatles
  35. https://www.discogs.com/release/22476794-George-Pehlivanian-Armenian-Philharmonic-Beatles-Symphonic
  36. https://www.discogs.com/master/853759-The-Smithereens-B-Sides-The-Beatles
  37. https://www.beatlesbible.com/1962/06/11/radio-teenagers-turn-here-we-go/
  38. https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/the-beatles/1962/cavern-club-liverpool-england-23cbac5f.html
  39. https://www.setlist.fm/stats/average-setlist/the-beatles-23d6a88b.html?year=1963
  40. https://symposium.music.org/19/item/1860-the-ballad-style-in-the-early-music-of-the-beatles.html
  41. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WdoAroOhL5A
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.