Hubbry Logo
Charles Harding SmithCharles Harding SmithMain
Open search
Charles Harding Smith
Community hub
Charles Harding Smith
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Charles Harding Smith
Charles Harding Smith
Charles Harding Smith
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Charles Harding Smith (24 January 1931 – 1997) was a Northern Irish loyalist and the first effective leader of the Ulster Defence Association (UDA). An important figure in the Belfast-based "defence associations" that formed the basis of the UDA on its formation in 1971, Smith later became embroiled in feuds with other UDA leaders and was eventually driven out of Northern Ireland by his opponents.

Key Information

Development of the UDA

[edit]

A former soldier in the British Army Smith, at the time residing in Rosebank Street on the Shankill Road, called a meeting of other locals at the Leopold Street Pigeon Fanciers Club to develop a response to attacks by republicans from the neighboring Ardoyne area.[2] The location was chosen because Smith was himself a pigeon fancier and a member of the club.[3] At the meeting, it was agreed to establish a vigilante group, the Woodvale Defence Association (WDA), with Smith in command assisted by Davy Fogel, who organised military drilling for the forty or so recruits, and Ernie Elliott.[2]

The WDA gained widespread notoriety and was blamed for a series of bomb attacks and shootings, most of which had been carried out by the Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF).[4] Nevertheless, Smith's reputation as a hardline loyalist was boosted as a result and when his group merged with other similar vigilante movements to form the Ulster Defence Association (UDA) in late 1971 he was chosen as chairman of the new group's thirteen-member Security Council ahead of the other leading candidates Tommy Herron and Jim Anderson.[4] According to journalist Martin Dillon, Smith was heavily influenced by William Craig and William McGrath, both of whom saw a need for a group to replace the Ulster Special Constabulary and felt that they could easily influence Smith to their way of thinking.[5]

Smith soon took charge of procuring arms for the UDA. In early 1972, working in tandem with Belfast businessman John Campbell who agreed to bankroll the purchases, he was put in contact with a Scottish arms dealer from whom Smith was to purchase £50,000 worth of weapons. Smith sent three WDA associates, John White, Bobby Dalzell, and Robert Lusty (who was also a serving officer in the Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC)), to meet the arms dealer in a London hotel, following them without attending the actual meeting. The "arms dealer" was actually a Special Branch agent and, after recording the conversation with the WDA men, arrested all three. Smith went to Scotland Yard the same day to inquire about his friends only to be arrested himself.[6]

Smith remained in custody in England until December 1972 when his case came to trial. Campbell claimed that the deal had been organised for the RUC to entrap the arms dealer, whom they believed to be a Provisional IRA member and a series of mistakes by the prosecution helped to ensure that the case collapsed with Smith acquitted.[7][8] The trial was used as part of early arguments regarding collusion between the RUC and loyalists as a list of RUC Special Branch suspects was uncovered in Smith's house while he attempted to call Chief Constable Graham Shillington as a character witness.[9]

Return to Belfast

[edit]

By the time Smith returned to Belfast in December 1972 there had been changes in the UDA with Tommy Herron in effective control of the organisation and Davy Fogel the dominant figure amongst the WDA. Smith immediately took back control of his west Belfast stronghold, threatening Fogel with death if he didn't fall into line. Fogel, a close ally of Ernie Elliott, who was killed in circumstances that Smith had been rumoured to be involved in, although it was later determined that Elliott was shot dead after a drunken brawl on Sandy Row had descended into a gunfight, decided it was best not to go up against Smith and stood down.[10]

However, Smith was not satisfied and, after putting out intelligence that Fogel had been taking UDA funds for himself, arrested Fogel and held him captive for three hours in a Shankill social club where he was told to leave the area. Fogel briefly left for east Belfast but when the UDA there made it clear he wasn't welcome either he left to live in England, from where he controversially gave an interview about his time in the UDA to The Sunday Times.[11] Among claims made by Fogel in this interview was one that Smith was attempting to take control of the UDA with the help of the UVF.[12] Smith was a strong admirer of the UVF's military structure and hoped to replicate it in the UDA but he had a deep dislike of UVF leader Gusty Spence.[13] As part of his remit to instil military discipline, Smith moved against a culture of racketeering that had become endemic in the west Belfast UDA during his absence. It was this initiative that led to the rumours concerning Smith's involvement in the death of Elliott, who had been named by some of his rivals in the UDA as a gangster.[14]

Despite Smith's show of strength following his return to Belfast his public persona remained low-key, with Herron fast emerging as the public face of the UDA. Much of this was down to the fact that Smith was inarticulate and unable to project a good image, unlike Herron who was a good talker and fairly charismatic.[15] The emergence of these two leaders at the same time however was to bring the fledgling movement into near civil war.

Following a period of marginalisation Jim Anderson, who was serving as caretaker leader of the UDA, had resigned as chairman of the UDA and as a result a meeting was called of the group's leaders in March 1973 to determine who would succeed him. By this time Smith and Herron were recognised as the undisputed leaders of the Belfast UDA; there was a fear that whichever of the two was chosen as chairman the other one would automatically feel obliged to challenge his leadership.[16] As a result, it was determined that someone else should be appointed chairman as a compromise candidate and as Highfield-based activist Andy Tyrie, a man noted for his skill as an organiser, was chairing the conference it was decided that he would be acceptable to both men as chairman of the UDA.[16] Tyrie soon proved to be a powerful rival to the two leaders. In September 1973, Herron was kidnapped and shot dead. As of 2014, his murder remains unsolved.[17]

Feud

[edit]

Tyrie had not proven to be the puppet Smith had hoped and had consolidated his power through his close involvement with Glenn Barr and the Ulster Workers Council during the strike of May 1974, an event that had helped to give real credence to Tyrie's leadership abilities.[18] Fearing the growing power of Tyrie, Smith criticised the UDA leader for sending a delegation to Libya to meet Muammar al-Gaddafi, who was a hate figure for many loyalists due to his providing arms to the PIRA.[19] Smith, who had known about the trip in advance but had raised no objections, verbally attacked Tyrie over the Libya debacle in a meeting of the Inner Council in December 1974 before declaring the following January that he intended to split his West Belfast Brigade from the rest of the UDA.[20]

Two weeks after announcing the schism Smith was attending a meeting at the West Belfast UDA's headquarters with Tommy Lyttle when he noticed a sniper on a nearby roof. Smith, who was wearing a bullet-proof vest, opened his coat as if to challenge the sniper to fire but was seriously wounded when the sniper did shoot twice, hitting him both times with armour-piercing bullets.[20] With Smith in hospital Tyrie called a meeting of the leading figures in the Shankill UDA and managed to convince Lyttle and other leading figures that Smith was too divisive a figure to remain in charge.[20]

Smith was out of the hospital after only two weeks and declared himself back in charge but before long he had fallen foul of a number of important people. Two Shankill UDA members had been interned on the basis of evidence that rumours suggested had come from Smith whilst he had also clashed with the local UVF after suggesting that they merge but only on the basis that he would be in control. He began to make threats against Barr and Chicken, two popular members who were leading figures on the UDA's political side.[21] Smith called a meeting of his commanders, but, on 6 February 1975, in an attack arranged in advance by his opponents within the UDA,[citation needed] a gunman burst in and shot him twice in the chest.[22] The gunman walked up to the injured Smith and prepared to shoot him in the head but the gun jammed and he again survived an attempt on his life.[22]

Departure

[edit]

Smith spent another week in hospital after which he again returned to his Belfast home. Loyalist Davy Payne was sent to his house with another hitman and the two ordered Smith to leave Northern Ireland. He was taken to the airport the following day and left for England, leaving Tyrie as sole leader of the UDA.[22] Smith settled in Southowram, Halifax Yorkshire, where he worked as a lorry driver before his death in 1997.[23] During Dáil Éireann debates in 2005 he was named as a "self-confessed British intelligence agent".[24]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Charles Harding Smith

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Charles Harding Smith (24 January 1931 – 1997) was a Northern Irish loyalist and former British soldier who served as the first leader of the (UDA), the predominant loyalist paramilitary group during , commanding its West brigade from the organisation's formation in September 1971 until his ousting in 1973. Under Smith's direction, the UDA focused on defensive against republican paramilitaries while erecting barricades and expanding membership in Protestant working-class areas, though internal rivalries soon erupted into feuds that saw him targeted and wounded twice by snipers amid a power struggle with figures like . In April 1972, Smith was arrested alongside UDA associate John White in on charges of illegal arms procurement, reflecting early efforts to militarise the group beyond improvised weapons. Following his removal from leadership and the assassination attempts, he fled for , where he lived until dying of natural causes.

Early Life and Background

Birth and Family

Charles Harding Smith was born on 24 January 1931 in , . He came from a Protestant family in a city divided along sectarian lines, with Belfast's Protestant communities centered in areas like the , where unionist identity was deeply entrenched amid industrial employment in shipyards and factories. Verifiable details about his members, such as parents or siblings, remain limited in historical records. Smith's early life unfolded in working-class Protestant neighborhoods facing economic pressures from the interwar depression and periodic communal tensions, including riots in 1935 that highlighted pre-Troubles divisions between unionists and nationalists. These environments fostered exposure to loyalist sentiments, though specific personal influences prior to adulthood are not well-documented.

Military Service in the British Army

Charles Harding Smith had no verified military service in the , contrary to some uncredited claims in secondary accounts. Prior to his emergence in loyalist activities, he worked as a shipyard laborer in 's Harland and Wolff yards before transitioning to a civilian role as a tyre salesman in the late 1960s. This background in and fostered practical organizational abilities and familiarity with working-class Protestant networks in West , which later informed his leadership in informal defense committees amid rising sectarian tensions. By the time civil unrest intensified following the riots, Smith resided in the Rosebank Street area and leveraged these community ties rather than formal experience.

Rise in Loyalist Vigilantism

Context of the Troubles and Republican Violence

The in commenced with widespread riots in August 1969, sparked by clashes between civil rights marchers, loyalist counter-demonstrators, and security forces, escalating into arson attacks that destroyed over 300 homes and displaced approximately 1,800 families, mostly Catholic residents fleeing Protestant neighborhoods in . The formation of the (PIRA) in December 1969 marked a shift toward organized republican violence, with the group initiating bombings and shootings against British troops and Protestant targets to advance its goal of a . By 1970, PIRA attacks had contributed to 25 total deaths in the conflict, including targeted killings of Protestant civilians, fostering sectarian no-go areas where republican gunmen imposed control and state forces faced ambushes. The July 1970 Falls Curfew exemplified the growing IRA entrenchment and state policing limitations: British Army searches for arms in Belfast's Lower Falls uncovered Official IRA weapons, prompting sustained gunfire from republicans, a four-day curfew, and clashes that resulted in four civilian deaths, over 300 arrests, and the seizure of 86 firearms and 12,000 rounds of ammunition. Unionist communities perceived this as evidence of unchecked republican militarization in adjacent Catholic enclaves, where IRA units operated with impunity, conducting cross-community shootings and bombings that killed at least a dozen Protestants that year. Such incidents, coupled with IRA assertions of defending nationalist areas, reinforced loyalist views of an asymmetric threat, as Protestant districts lacked equivalent paramilitary fortifications yet endured retaliatory violence. Internment without trial, enacted on August 9, 1971, via , saw 342 individuals—predominantly Catholic and suspected IRA affiliates—detained in raids across , aiming to dismantle republican networks amid surging attacks. However, the policy correlated with intensified PIRA activity, contributing to 173 total deaths that year, including over 100 attributed to republican paramilitaries, many targeting and civilians in Protestant areas. Loyalists interpreted these developments, including IRA sniping of soldiers and sectarian murders, as an existential peril to 's constitutional status and Protestant-majority demographics, exposing perceived failures in state protection that incentivized informal for community defense. By early 1971, the cumulative toll—dozens of IRA-orchestrated killings—had solidified as a primary driver of , independent of prior grievances.

Formation of Pre-UDA Groups in West Belfast

In early 1971, escalating IRA bombings and shootings in West Belfast, coupled with riots that displaced Protestant families from mixed areas, prompted residents in the vicinity to establish informal vigilante patrols for . These ad-hoc groups arose from community frustration over the perceived inadequacy of protection and the 1970 disbandment of the , filling a security vacuum amid over 150 bombings recorded that year alone. Charles Harding Smith, utilizing his prior service in the , positioned himself as a organizer in these efforts, leading the formation of the Woodvale Defence Association—one of the most substantial local entities—which convened initially among pigeon breeders and emphasized tangible barriers and watches against incursions rather than ideological agendas. His , described as direct yet non-doctrinaire, prioritized operational , discouraging extraneous political debate to maintain focus on immediate threats like republican gunfire into Protestant districts. By mid-1971, the Woodvale group coordinated with the longstanding Shankill Defence Association—originally set up in for similar protective roles—to pool resources for patrols and intelligence sharing, creating proto-structures that addressed overlapping territories without full amalgamation. This collaboration, numbering hundreds in the Shankill alone, deterred several attempted republican advances but remained decentralized, reflecting localized responses to violence that had already claimed dozens of civilian lives in the area since .

Development and Leadership of the UDA

Unification and Initial Organization

In September 1971, Charles Harding Smith, having founded the Woodvale Defence Association as a vigilante response to republican attacks in West , spearheaded the merger of this and other similar groups—such as those in North and East —into the (UDA), an umbrella body aimed at coordinating loyalist defenses. This unification occurred amid intensifying IRA bombings and shootings, which had prompted the spontaneous formation of localized defence associations earlier that year to protect Protestant neighborhoods from encroachment. Smith assumed the role of West Belfast commander within the nascent UDA, which prioritized operational readiness over political posturing; he emphasized military-style training and direct intervention, drawing on his British Army experience to instill discipline. The group's structure included a fifteen-member inner council chaired by Smith to oversee strategic decisions across regions. By early 1972, UDA membership had surged to between 25,000 and 40,000, fueled by recruitment from Protestant working-class communities seeking protection amid perceived failures of state security forces. Initial activities centered on uniformed street patrols equipped with batons, vehicle checkpoints to monitor movement, and visible deterrence against republican advances into loyalist territories, often conducted alongside British Army units to maintain order in volatile areas.

Consolidation as Overall Leader (1971-1972)

In September 1971, Charles Harding Smith, as a founder and leader of the Woodvale Defence Association, orchestrated the unification of disparate loyalist vigilante groups across into the (UDA), establishing a central coordinating to streamline command structures. This move addressed the fragmented nature of earlier defence associations, drawing on Smith's prior experience in organising West loyalist patrols to impose a hierarchical framework amid rising republican attacks. By late 1971, Smith had solidified his position as the UDA's overall leader, operating without a formal title but exercising authority through a security council, with Davy Fogel serving as his key deputy responsible for training members in . Leveraging his service, Smith enforced discipline across the organisation's emerging brigades in areas like West and North , coordinating patrols and resource allocation to counter IRA incursions while quelling localised power bids that threatened unity. Internal challenges, including rivalries with figures like East Belfast's , were managed through council directives rather than outright feuds during this period, prioritising operational cohesion over factionalism. Throughout 1972, Smith maintained focus on defensive imperatives, discouraging political discourse within UDA meetings to avoid diluting efforts against escalating threats, such as the Provisional IRA's Bloody Friday bombings on 21 July, which killed nine and injured over 130 in city centre. This approach, attributed to Smith's limited interest in ideology, kept the group oriented toward security patrols and deterrence, with the UDA's membership swelling to an estimated 25,000 by mid-1972 under his oversight. Coordination extended to joint actions with other loyalist elements, ensuring brigade-level compliance amid the British Army's temporary withdrawal from some areas during in July 1972.

Defensive Operations Against IRA Threats

Under Smith's leadership following the UDA's unification in September 1971, the organization prioritized defensive patrols in Protestant enclaves such as the and Woodvale areas of West Belfast, where local vigilante groups had already formed to counter IRA incursions amid escalating republican violence. These patrols, often involving uniformed members, aimed to secure boundaries against IRA gunmen and bombers who had targeted loyalist neighborhoods, establishing buffer zones that limited republican access and mirrored the IRA's own no-go areas in Catholic districts. By late 1971, such operations had grown to involve thousands of UDA personnel on the streets, presenting the group as a protector under the "law before violence." In response to specific IRA threats, including shootings and bombings that killed Protestant civilians—such as the IRA's sectarian attacks in throughout 1971—the UDA manned barricades and conducted visible deterrence patrols, claiming these measures prevented deeper penetrations into loyalist territories. For instance, at the end of May 1972, UDA units under Smith's command erected the first major roadblocks in West , coordinating with local defense associations to block potential IRA entry points and respond to heightened republican activity following events like Bloody Friday. On May 14, 1972, UDA spokesmen publicly warned of expanding Protestant no-go zones across if failed to address IRA aggression, a threat tied to ongoing loyalist displacements and attacks. UDA records and contemporary assessments indicate these actions contributed to a perceived reduction in successful IRA raids on Protestant areas during 1971-1972, as armed presence deterred opportunistic strikes amid the broader collapse of policing in divided neighborhoods. While these operations provided tangible community protection—evidenced by fewer reported IRA successes in loyalist enclaves compared to prior unrest—critics noted risks of escalation, including instances of UDA overreach such as intimidating residents suspected of republican leanings within Protestant zones. Such tactics, however, arose in direct causal response to IRA strategies like indiscriminate bar bombings and civilian targeting, which had already sectarianized the conflict and eroded trust in state security, prompting loyalists to adopt as a necessary bulwark. Smith's emphasis on defense aligned with the UDA's initial charter to safeguard Unionist areas without proactive offense, though the inherent volatility of armed patrols invited retaliatory cycles from the IRA.

1972 Arms Trafficking Arrest

In April 1972, Charles Harding Smith, then chairman of the (UDA), was arrested in along with UDA member John White and three associates—Bobby Dalzell, Robert Lusty, and an RUC officer—for attempting to illegally procure firearms from criminal contacts. The group had traveled to at Smith's direction to acquire handguns and ammunition, intending to ship them to to bolster UDA defenses amid escalating IRA attacks on Protestant communities during the early . White and the others were apprehended in the foyer of the London Hilton Hotel after a meeting with purported arms suppliers, while Smith was detained shortly afterward. The charges centered on to contravene firearms laws by negotiating the purchase of approximately 20 revolvers and from underworld figures, with no actual weapons exchanged but evidence of intent gathered through . Smith's detention in for much of 1972 created a temporary leadership vacuum within the UDA, as he was unable to direct operations from amid the ongoing republican violence. Released on pending , the case highlighted the UDA's urgent push to arm its vigilante units legally, though the organization itself retained its defensive association status at the time. At the trial in December 1972, the defendants argued the procurement efforts were a necessary response to IRA threats targeting loyalist areas, framing the actions as rather than criminal enterprise. The jury accepted this defense, acquitting Smith, White, and the co-defendants, allowing Smith's return to later that month. The outcome underscored the challenges of prosecuting arms acquisitions in the context of Northern Ireland's security crisis but did not resolve the UDA's broader armament needs.

Expansion of UDA Activities and Intimidation Tactics

Under Charles Harding Smith's leadership from 1971 to early 1973, the (UDA) transitioned from loosely coordinated vigilante groups into a more structured entity with quasi-military capabilities, including uniformed patrols, checkpoints, and barricades in Protestant enclaves to deter incursions by the (IRA). By mid-1972, these measures had expanded significantly, with Smith's deputy Davy Fogel overseeing the erection of the first UDA roadblocks and street barricades in West Belfast at the end of May, enhancing territorial control amid escalating republican violence in adjacent areas. The organization's membership swelled to an estimated 25,000 by late 1972, organized under a 15-member inner council chaired by Smith, enabling systematic defensive operations. This expansion incorporated dedicated intelligence-gathering units focused on identifying IRA suspects and potential infiltrators within loyalist communities, often leading to preemptive actions such as threats, expulsions, or targeted violence against perceived threats. UDA internal security committees, formalized under Smith's oversight, vetted residents and monitored for republican sympathies, reflecting a proactive stance against infiltration in areas where IRA no-go zones had previously isolated Protestant neighborhoods. Such efforts were rationalized by UDA as essential for community cohesion and survival, given the IRA's documented assassinations and bombings in loyalist districts during 1971-1972, though they frequently blurred into broader sectarian enforcement. Parallel to these defensive functions, the UDA developed punishment squads that administered beatings and intimidation against "anti-social elements"—including joyriders, thieves, and drug dealers—within loyalist areas, with practices emerging as early as 1972 to enforce discipline and prevent behaviors that could invite IRA exploitation or weaken morale. These tactics, conducted in so-called "romper rooms," were internally justified as restorative justice in the absence of effective policing amid the Troubles' chaos, where British Army and RUC presence was stretched thin in contested zones. However, civilian complaints mounted, with reports of excessive force against non-combatants, including Protestants, highlighting abuses that alienated segments of the community despite the stated protective rationale. While UDA patrols demonstrably restricted open IRA operations in fortified loyalist territories—contributing to fewer successful republican penetrations compared to pre-1971 disorganized defenses—these intimidation methods also fostered resentment and occasional internal backlash.

Internal Conflicts and Power Struggles

Rivalry with Emerging Figures like

As the (UDA) expanded rapidly following its formal unification in 1971, internal power dynamics began to strain under Charles Harding Smith's leadership, particularly with the ascent of figures like within West Belfast structures. Smith's authority, rooted in the area, emphasized decentralized, street-level defensive operations against republican threats, reflecting his background in pre-UDA vigilante groups. Tyrie, commanding A of the West Belfast Brigade, represented a more organizational approach, gaining influence through efficient coordination of local units and emerging as a capable administrator amid the group's growth to an estimated 30,000-50,000 members by late 1972. Tensions escalated after Smith's acquittal on arms charges in December 1972, triggering a fierce contest where Tyrie's rising profile challenged Smith's West-centric dominance. Smith viewed Tyrie's growing sway with suspicion, attempting to curb his independent initiatives, such as early diplomatic outreach efforts that diverged from Smith's preference for immediate, reactive action over formalized structures. This friction highlighted factional divides based on control rather than policy, as Smith's informal command style clashed with Tyrie's methodical buildup of support among brigade officers, foreshadowing broader fragmentation in early 1973 when the UDA's inner council sought compromises to avert open conflict. By March 1973, these rivalries manifested in Smith's reluctance to yield to Tyrie's momentum, contributing to the selection of Tyrie as a neutral chairman to bridge West Belfast factions, though Smith initially perceived him as manipulable. The disputes underscored personal ambitions over ideological rifts, with Smith's direct confrontation style yielding to Tyrie's consolidation of alliances, marking the onset of leadership erosion at the UDA's zenith of recruitment and visibility.

The 1973 Feud and Assassination Attempts

In 1973, internal power struggles within the (UDA) escalated following the unsolved killing of East Belfast commander on 8 September, creating a leadership vacuum that intensified rivalries among key figures including Charles Harding Smith. Smith's position as West Belfast brigadier came under direct threat as consolidated influence, particularly after Tyrie sanctioned a controversial UDA delegation to for arms procurement, which Smith publicly criticized in an Inner Council meeting. This dispute marked a shift from earlier joint leadership arrangements—where Smith had shared chairmanship with Jim Anderson—toward open factional hostility, with reports of sniping exchanges between Smith's supporters and rivals like Anderson. The feud manifested in targeted violence, including two murder attempts on Smith around the time of Herron's death, amid broader UDA infighting that claimed lives on both sides and underscored organizational fragmentation. Smith survived these bids, one involving a gunman firing shots at him inside UDA headquarters, but the attacks eroded his authority and highlighted the risks of intra-loyalist competition for control. Allegations surfaced of involvement by Tyrie-aligned elements, though Tyrie was installed as supreme commander as a compromise to avert full-scale civil war within the group, sidelining Smith's faction. These events contributed to Smith's resignation from UDA leadership later in 1973, driven by the feuds and resulting instability, which prioritized personal and brigade rivalries over unified operations against republican threats. The violence reflected deeper causal fractures in the UDA's command structure, including disputes over strategy and resources, ultimately weakening Smith's hold and paving the way for Tyrie's dominance.

Departure and Later Years

Exile from Belfast

Following the 1973 internal feuds within the (UDA), particularly the power struggle with , Charles Harding Smith's support base eroded amid betrayals by former allies, forcing his departure from . On January 14, 1973, he was shot by a gunman inside UDA headquarters on the , an attack linked to the escalating rivalries. He survived two separate assassination attempts, the second wounding him severely enough to underscore the lethal threats from within his own ranks, including one reportedly carried out by a subordinate. These events severed Harding Smith's direct operational ties to the UDA, as he lost control of key Shankill figures and the organization's broader leadership shifted under Tyrie. With his authority undermined and personal safety compromised, he relocated initially to in 1973, marking his effective exile from and withdrawal from frontline loyalist activities. This move prioritized survival over any immediate regrouping efforts, amid the collapse of his faction's influence in West Belfast.

Brief Return and Final Relocation to

Following the 1973 internal feuds and multiple assassination attempts on his life, including two shootings that left him wounded, Charles Harding Smith permanently departed amid escalating threats from rival UDA factions and former associates. These dangers, stemming from power struggles and accusations of overreach during his leadership, made sustained presence in untenable, prompting his relocation to by the mid-1970s. In , Harding Smith adopted a low-profile existence, severing ties with loyalist paramilitary networks and avoiding any revival of his earlier role in the UDA. He resided there until his death from natural causes in 1997, with no verified records of subsequent returns to for personal or organizational purposes despite occasional UDA leadership changes in the ensuing decades. This final settlement underscored the lasting impact of the violence and betrayals he encountered, prioritizing personal security over continued involvement in Northern Ireland's conflicts.

Controversies and Assessments

Accusations of Sectarian Violence and Criminality

The (UDA), under Charles Harding Smith's leadership from 1971 to 1973, was accused by republican sources and security reports of orchestrating sectarian intimidation campaigns in , particularly targeting Catholic residents in mixed or Protestant-majority areas during 1972 and early 1973. These efforts allegedly involved threats, vandalism, and sporadic shootings to expel families, contributing to the displacement of approximately 500 Catholic households from districts like the Shankill and Woodvale, exacerbating urban segregation amid the escalating . Such actions were framed by critics as proactive , though loyalist accounts contextualized them as defensive measures to prevent infiltration and reprisals following IRA attacks on Protestant civilians, including the 1971 that killed 15 and subsequent sniper fire in loyalist enclaves. Accusations of direct involvement in killings intensified with claims that UDA units under Smith conducted or enabled Protestant-on-Catholic murders, such as drive-by shootings and beatings in retaliation for republican violence; however, verifiable convictions tying Smith personally to specific homicides remain absent, with many allegations relying on unattributed rather than . The UDA's establishment of the covert Ulster Freedom Fighters (UFF) in September 1973—coinciding with Smith's declining influence—formalized targeted assassinations, with retrospective attributions to his era based on unproven preparatory logistics rather than documented orders. Loyalist perspectives rebut these as smears equating defensive patrols—initially baton-wielding and uniformed to deter IRA incursions—with the Provisional IRA's prior offensive campaign, which by mid-1972 had claimed over 150 Protestant lives through bombings and ambushes, including non-combatants, without equivalent provocation from unionist civilians. On criminality, the UDA faced charges of embedding protection rackets and extortion in controlled territories like West Belfast's Shankill, where businesses were reportedly compelled to pay for "security" amid 1972-1973 unrest, yielding funds critics labeled as detached from paramilitary defense. While such practices deviated from the UDA's origins, proponents within loyalist circles defended them as pragmatic revenue streams to procure arms and sustain patrols, absent British government funding for Protestant self-protection—contrasting with state policies disproportionately applied to nationalists. Smith reportedly advocated purging criminal factions, as evidenced by his clashes with figures like over profit motives, prioritizing operational discipline over racketeering. and academic sources, often influenced by left-leaning institutional biases, amplify these criminal narratives while underemphasizing IRA-linked through bank robberies and squads, fostering a false between loyalist responses and republican .

Evaluations of Role in Loyalist Self-Defense

Charles Harding Smith's leadership of the (UDA) from its formation in September 1971 until internal challenges in 1973 is evaluated by some historians as pivotal in establishing an effective deterrent against (IRA) incursions into Protestant enclaves. Under his chairmanship, the UDA coalesced disparate vigilante groups, such as the Woodvale Defence Association he headed, into a structured entity that rapidly expanded to approximately 30,000 members by mid-1972, facilitating organized patrols, barricades, and checkpoints in loyalist districts like the . This mobilization correlated with a shift in IRA operational patterns, as deep penetrations and bombings in core Protestant areas—such as the December 1971 Shankill furniture shop attack that killed four civilians—became less frequent following the UDA's proactive presence, which filled perceived gaps in and protection amid the 1971 policy's fallout. Smith's approach emphasized pragmatic over ideological posturing, discouraging political debates in UDA security councils to prioritize military training and arms acquisition, including his role in a 1972 gun-trafficking operation aimed at bolstering defensive capabilities. This non-doctrinaire style, as noted in assessments of early UDA dynamics, enabled broad recruitment from Protestant working-class communities wary of state inadequacies, fostering resilience that arguably prevented the kind of territorial losses seen in 1969 pogroms or isolated 1970 IRA raids. Empirical indicators include the UDA's erection of defensive infrastructure in West Belfast, which local accounts credit with stabilizing neighborhoods against retaliatory republican violence spikes post-Bloody Sunday in January 1972. Critiques of Smith's authoritarian internal control—evident in power struggles and his survival of assassination attempts by rivals—highlight risks of factionalism, yet these are weighed against counterfactuals where disorganized might have yielded to IRA momentum, as occurred in mixed areas without paramilitary backstops. Loyalist sources and retrospective analyses commend his tenure for unifying disparate groups under a defensive mandate, contrasting with later UDA fragmentation, and attribute to it a foundational role in maintaining unionist during the conflict's bloodiest early phase, when republican attacks peaked at over 1,800 incidents in alone but saw limited sustained gains in solidly Protestant zones. Such evaluations underscore causal links between UDA deterrence under Smith and reduced vulnerability in loyalist communities, prioritizing outcomes over methods amid state security strains.

Death

Circumstances of 1997 Death

Charles Harding Smith died of natural causes in in 1997 at the age of 66. Following his departure from in the mid-1970s, Smith had resettled in , , where he lived quietly and worked as a lorry driver. His passing received no notable public recognition, such as funerals attended by former associates or media obituaries, consistent with his obscurity after internal UDA conflicts diminished his role. The lack of detailed records on the precise date or any preceding illness underscores the private nature of his final years, distant from the of .

References

  1. https://academic.oup.com/book/38620/chapter/335183807
  2. https://www.dib.ie/biography/lyttle-thomas-tucker-a4982
  3. https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9780748626878-003/html
  4. https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/sunday-life/news/terrorists-in-turmoil/28403583.html
  5. https://dbpedia.org/page/Charles_Harding_Smith
  6. https://historica.fandom.com/wiki/Charles_Harding_Smith
  7. https://dokumen.pub/crimes-of-loyalty-a-history-of-the-uda-9780748626878.html
  8. https://cain.ulster.ac.uk/issues/violence/bodbol.htm
  9. https://thehistorypress.co.uk/article/the-falls-curfew-reassessing-the-past/
  10. https://cain.ulster.ac.uk/othelem/chron/ch71.htm
  11. https://www.nam.ac.uk/explore/troubles-1969-2007
  12. https://cain.ulster.ac.uk/issues/violence/majinc.htm
  13. https://cain.ulster.ac.uk/othelem/organ/uorgan.htm
  14. https://alphahistory.com/northernireland/loyalist-paramilitaries/
  15. https://aliciapatterson.org/j-scott-keech/northern-ireland-divided-against-itself/
  16. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2025/may/18/andy-tyrie-obituarry
  17. https://cain.ulster.ac.uk/islandpublications/Hall_1988_Chronology-1968-1988.pdf
  18. https://repository.londonmet.ac.uk/7357/1/603302.pdf
  19. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/uncivil-war/most-deadly-year/A5C26CC28CB6B3BE846AF8E2597EBEB4
  20. https://www.persee.fr/doc/irlan_0183-973x_1996_num_21_1_1298
  21. https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/ADA323626.pdf
  22. https://military-history.fandom.com/wiki/Loyalist_feud
  23. https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/ADA365345.pdf
  24. https://www.nbuprg.co.uk/uda---a-short-history.php
  25. https://balaclavastreet.wordpress.com/2014/12/16/terminal-effects-the-guns-of-the-loyalist-paramilitaries/
  26. https://republicanarchive.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/brian-nelson.pdf
  27. https://military-history.fandom.com/wiki/Davy_Fogel
  28. https://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/articles/z9mqnk7
  29. https://pureportal.coventry.ac.uk/files/28490893/Binder1.pdf
  30. https://pureportal.coventry.ac.uk/files/28441825/The_Return_of_Captain_Moonlight_.pdf
  31. https://www.thetimes.com/uk/obituaries/article/andy-tyrie-obituary-uda-leader-at-height-of-the-troubles-03pn2lzsg
  32. https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/struggle-for-power-within-uda/28130828.html
  33. https://www.jstor.org/stable/25545373
  34. https://www.jstor.org/stable/25545332
  35. https://thenorthernirelandtroubles.wordpress.com/2015/09/15/16th-september-deaths-events-in-northern-ireland-troubles/
  36. https://www.patfinucanecentre.org/relationships-between-british-authorities-and-loyalist-paramilitary-organisations
  37. https://military-history.fandom.com/wiki/UDA_West_Belfast_Brigade
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.