Hubbry Logo
Comrade Kim Goes FlyingComrade Kim Goes FlyingMain
Open search
Comrade Kim Goes Flying
Community hub
Comrade Kim Goes Flying
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Comrade Kim Goes Flying
Comrade Kim Goes Flying
Comrade Kim Goes Flying
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Comrade Kim Goes Flying
Film poster
Hangul
김동무는 하늘을 난다
RRGimdongmuneun haneureul nanda
MRKimdongmunŭn hanŭrŭl nanda
Directed byKim Gwang-Hun
Nicholas Bonner
Anja Daelemans
Written bySin Myong Sik
Kim Chol
Produced byAnja Daelemans
Nicholas Bonner
Ryom Mi Hwa
StarringHan Jong Sim
Pak Chung Guk
Edited byAlain Dessauvage
Release date
  • 9 September 2012 (2012-09-09) (Toronto Film Festival)
Running time
81 minutes
CountriesUnited Kingdom
Belgium
North Korea
LanguageKorean

Comrade Kim Goes Flying is a 2012 North Korean romantic comedy feature film,[1] set and filmed in Pyongyang, North Korea.[2]

Plot

[edit]

Comrade Kim Yong Mi is a North Korean coal miner. Her dream of becoming a trapeze artist is crushed by the arrogant trapeze star Pak Jang Phil, who believes that "miners belong underground and not in the air".[3] Co-director Nicholas Bonner described it as a "girl-power fairy tale about dreaming to fly", adding that his hope was "for Korean audiences to see the film on both sides of the border and be entertained".[1] The three producers reportedly "steered [the North Korean writers] toward comedy and away from the more predictable propaganda line of triumph through hard work".[1]

Cast

[edit]

The film is directed by Kim Gwang Hun, Nicholas Bonner and Anja Daelemans; produced by Anja Daelemans, Nicholas Bonner and Ryom Mi Hwa; and written by Sin Myong Sik and Kim Chol.[4][3]

The main cast is as follows:[4]

  • Han Jong Sim as Kim Yong Mi ("Comrade Kim")
  • Pak Chung Guk as Pak Jang Phil
  • Ri Yong Ho as Commander Sok Gun
  • Kim Son Nam as Yong Mi's father
  • Ri Ik Sung as the coal mine manager
  • Kim Un Yong as Ri Su Yon (trapeze artist)
  • Han Kil Myong as Yong Mi's Grandmother
  • An Chang Sun as Jang Phil's mother

Production

[edit]

It is a coproduction of Belgian production company Another Dimension of an Idea, the Korea Film Export & Import Corporation, and British travel company Koryo Group.[4][3] It is the fourth film produced by Koryo Group in collaboration with North Korea. The previous three films The Game of Their Lives (2002), A State of Mind (2004) and Crossing the Line (2006) were documentaries. Comrade Kim Goes Flying was shot in Pyongyang, with a North Korean cast and crew.[2]

Reception

[edit]

Comrade Kim Goes Flying premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival in September 2012.[4] The film also showed at the 2012 Pyongyang International Film Festival.[2][5] In October, it was shown at the Busan International Film Festival in South Korea.[6] In March 2013 it played in the United States, with the Wall Street Journal calling it a "feel-good style of a Doris Day–Rock Hudson picture".[7] The film was screened at the Bucheon International Fantastic Film Festival in July 2018.[8]

The programmer for Toronto described the film in these terms: "A winning, life-affirming fable about a young coal miner's pursuit of her dream to become an acrobat, Comrade Kim Goes Flying is the first Western-financed fiction feature made entirely in North Korea".[9]

Reviewing the film for Variety, Jay Weissberg wrote: "Comrade Kim Goes Flying proves that cooperation with the West really is possible, at least in cinema. A candy-hued throwback to a chirpy Technicolor time when pluck wins out and 'postmodern' wasn't yet invented, this 'let's put on a show!' tale of a young woman miner's dream of becoming an acrobat has been winning hearts since preeming at Toronto".[10]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Comrade Kim Goes Flying

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Comrade Kim Goes Flying is a North Korean co-directed by British filmmaker Nicholas Bonner, Belgian director Anja Daelemans, and North Korean Kim Gwang-hun, depicting the story of a 28-year-old coal miner named Kim Yong-mi who dreams of becoming a trapeze artist in the state circus. The , set and entirely shot in , follows Kim's journey from the coal mines to auditioning for the circus, where she confronts vertigo and competes for a spot while developing a romance with a fellow performer. Produced as a rare international collaboration—a Belgium-UK-North Korea co-production with a budget of approximately $1.2 million, half funded privately and half by North Korean authorities—the movie was filmed over six years and marked the first fiction feature with an all-North Korean cast to be edited outside the country. It premiered in before being selected for the and screened at events like the , representing an unusual "" narrative in North Korean cinema that emphasizes individual ambition over typical state propaganda. Notably, it became the first North Korean screened in since 2003, highlighting its role in bridging cultural divides through lighthearted storytelling amid the regime's isolation.

Production

Development and Collaboration

The project originated in 2006 when British filmmaker and tour operator Nicholas Bonner and Belgian producer Anja Daelemans discussed the concept during a winter evening in , initially envisioning it as a to depict the everyday dreams and aspirations of ordinary North Koreans. This marked a departure from Bonner's prior work, which included documentaries such as State of Mind (2009) filmed in , leveraging his established contacts from organizing tours to the country since the . The directing team expanded to include North Korean filmmaker Kim Kwang-hun, forming an unprecedented Western-North Korean collaboration under the auspices of the Korean Feature Film Studio, the state's primary production entity. Negotiations for approval spanned several years, involving persistent outreach to North Korean authorities amid the regime's strict controls on foreign involvement, with the project requiring alignment with official ideological standards to proceed. Production commenced around 2010-2011 following clearance, highlighting logistical hurdles in a society with limited international access, such as restricted equipment imports and mandatory script reviews for compliance with state narratives. This joint effort represented North Korea's first feature-length co-production with Western partners, financed partly by European entities and edited abroad, though all occurred domestically under close oversight to maintain narrative conformity. The played a supervisory role in vetting foreign collaborations, ensuring the film adhered to principles without deviating into criticism of the regime.

Filming Process

The filming of Comrade Kim Goes Flying occurred entirely within , with principal photography spanning 45 days primarily in , including its boulevards and the state circus featuring the Pyongyang Trapeze Troupe, as well as rural sites for relevant scenes. The production, completed in 2012 ahead of its September premiere at the , relied on North Korean state crews and equipment, which lacked prior experience with synchronized sound recording or 35mm film processes, necessitating the introduction of digital technologies and AVID editing systems by Western collaborators. Regime-imposed constraints significantly shaped the execution, including mandatory adherence to pre-approved scripts that precluded depictions of , , or issues, ensuring all content aligned with state parameters without allowances for unscripted reshoots or deviations. Government censors and local oversight limited flexibility, while an industry reshuffle halted filming for approximately one year during , further compressing the schedule to achieve the film's 81-minute runtime through tightly controlled access to locations and performers. A rough edit was assembled in before final digital refinements in with North Korean participation and completion in , highlighting the logistical hurdles of integrating limited domestic technical capacity with external expertise.

Cast Selection and Roles

Han Jong-sim, a professional acrobat from the Circus with no prior acting experience, was cast as the lead character Kim Yong-mi, a coal miner pursuing a career as a circus performer. Directors selected her based on her physical skills to authentically depict the role's demanding aerial stunts, prioritizing acrobatic authenticity over dramatic training; she received intensive coaching from veteran actors on set. The role of Pak Jang-phil, Kim Yong-mi's love interest and circus colleague, went to Pak Chung-guk, another non-actor and real-life acrobat from the same troupe, chosen for his ability to perform the film's high-wire and trapeze sequences convincingly. This approach to principal favored state-employed performers embodying everyday labor and discipline, reflecting the regime's emphasis on worker archetypes capable of self-improvement through collective effort. Supporting characters included established professionals like Ri Yong-ho as the authoritative circus commander Sok Gun, whose experience helped mentor the leads. Other roles, such as the rival acrobat and family members, drew from a mix of amateurs and seasoned North Korean cinema figures to blend realism with narrative polish. The production eschewed foreign or celebrity talent entirely, adhering to state protocols for an all-domestic cast to uphold ideological purity and proletarian representation.

Narrative Content

Plot Summary

Kim Yong-mi, a 28-year-old coal miner in rural , dreams of becoming a circus acrobat on the , practicing secretly despite her father's disapproval and insistence that she prioritize mining work. Selected for a construction brigade in , she attends a performance at the state circus, where she meets her idol, the renowned trapeze artist Ri Su-yon, who inspires her to audition for the troupe. At the audition, Kim falters due to her fear of heights and is mocked by the troupe's arrogant star performer, Pak Jang-phil, who dismisses her background as incompatible with circus artistry. Joining the under the guidance of her supportive mining manager, Sok Gun, she undergoes rigorous to conquer her and refine her skills, eventually showcasing a performance at a workers' festival that catches Pak's attention and sparks his romantic interest. Pak travels to Kim's village to convince her father of her potential, securing permission for her to join the circus. Through dedicated practice and a decisive trial act, Kim overcomes initial rivalries within the troupe and debuts successfully in an aerial routine, achieving her aspiration via persistent effort and alignment with collective goals.

Key Themes and Symbolism

The film centers on the aspiration of its protagonist, Kim Yong-mi, a dedicated coal who harbors a dream of becoming a trapeze artist despite her fear of heights, portraying individual ambition as achievable through relentless personal effort and communal encouragement. This motif underscores perseverance as a driver, with Yong-mi's journey from underground labor to aerial performance symbolizing upward mobility facilitated by disciplined training and group solidarity, as seen in her audition successes and troupe integration. Circus feats serve as overt symbols of collective prowess, where synchronized acts like trapeze swings and high-wire walks represent the harmony of individual talents contributing to a greater ensemble display, mirroring the protagonist's transition from solitary mining quotas to team-oriented spectacles that exalt unified strength. Falls and near-misses in these sequences function as temporary setbacks, invariably resolved through mutual aid and renewed resolve, ensuring no depiction of irredeemable failure and reinforcing motifs of redemption via shared endeavor. Romantic elements infuse the with light-hearted optimism, framing a relationship between Yong-mi and fellow performer Pak Jang Pil as a harmonious byproduct of aligned ambitions, derived from situational humor in training mishaps and exaggerated enthusiasm rather than conflict. This posits as emergent from state-sanctioned pursuits, with restraint in physical expressions emphasizing selfless compatibility over personal indulgence.

Ideological Context

Alignment with Juche Ideology

The film's , Kim Yong-mi, a who aspires to become a trapeze , exemplifies 's core tenet of through industrious labor and mastery over one's destiny, as articulated in Kim Il-sung's human-centered revolutionary philosophy. Her progression from exceeding production quotas in the mines—embodying the Stakhanovite ideal of heroic labor—to succeeding in the elite Circus underscores the ideology's emphasis on individual achievement achieved via collective effort and personal determination, rather than external dependencies. This narrative structure aligns with , where the "positive hero" model promotes state-approved behaviors of perseverance and unity, subordinating personal ambition to societal . Pyongyang is depicted as a utopian hub of harmony and achievement, with the Circus serving as a for a cohesive society thriving under centralized leadership, reflecting Juche's vision of national self-sufficiency and "single-hearted unity." Conflicts among characters, such as class-based prejudices, are resolved through re-education and mutual support, reinforcing the ideology's resolution of contradictions via ideological guidance rather than division. The film's portrayal of the Circus's international acclaim further glorifies the state's cultural prowess, tying personal triumphs to collective national prestige. Mandatory ideological elements include subtle invocations of the eternal president Kim Il-sung's legacy through themes of guided , and anti-imperialist undertones in the rejection of individualistic "capitalist" pursuits in favor of communal endeavor. These features adhere to North Korean cinematic directives, where functions as a "weapon of ideological education," sugar-coating revolutionary messages to foster . The emphasis on comrades' support for Yong-mi's success explicitly counters Western , aligning with Juche's critique of external influences.

Portrayal of State Propaganda Elements

The film Comrade Kim Goes Flying integrates North Korean state propaganda through its depiction of an idealized socialist society, emphasizing collective harmony, worker diligence, and national in line with principles. Kim Yong-mi, a from a , exemplifies the model by exceeding production quotas and aspiring to trapeze artistry, portraying individual ambition as achievable only through state-supported communal effort. This narrative structure follows conventions, using a positive to promote ideological education and "single-hearted unity," where class tensions—such as urban performers mocking Yong-mi's rural background—are resolved via re-education and group solidarity rather than inherent conflict. Visual and thematic elements reinforce by showcasing 's landmarks, including signage, and omitting any depiction of material shortages or dissent, presenting a cheerful, optimistic nation countering external critiques. Yong-mi's success at the Pyongyang Circus symbolizes national prestige and revolutionary optimism, with colleagues rallying to aid her training, underscoring themes of mutual support under the state's guidance as per Kim Jong-il's directives on art as a tool for ideological reinforcement. The film's upbeat tone and focus on communal achievement over personal rivalry align with post-1990s North Korean cinema trends promoting positivity amid hardships, though critics note this sugarcoats socioeconomic realities, deflecting issues through . Nationalism is propagated via Yong-mi's journey from obscurity to international acclaim, framing personal triumphs as extensions of and state glory, without direct leader appearances but implicit endorsement through ideological motifs. This portrayal serves state goals by modeling patriotic behavior and unity, consistent with cinema's emphasis on self-mastery and anti-individualist ethics, where success derives from loyalty to the system rather than innate talent alone.

Release and Distribution

Premiere Events

The world premiere of Comrade Kim Goes Flying took place at the on September 8, 2012, marking the first international screening of the North Korean co-production. The event featured introductions by co-directors Nicholas Bonner and Anja Daelemans, highlighting the film's collaborative origins between North Korean state filmmakers and Western partners. Shortly thereafter, the film debuted in at the from September 20 to 27, 2012, under official state sponsorship, where it received the Best Direction Award. Screenings were attended by a controlled including North Korean officials, invited diplomats, and international filmmakers, reflecting the regime's oversight of cultural events and limited access for the general public. No widespread theatrical release occurred domestically beyond such state-authorized viewings. In 2013, the film had its European premiere at the Tromsø International Film Festival on January 15, followed by limited screenings across and select Asian venues, often requiring coordination with North Korean diplomatic channels for promotional materials and approvals. These events drew audiences of professionals, cultural attachés, and enthusiasts, but maintained restricted distribution aligned with the production's sensitive geopolitical context.

International Screenings and Availability

The international dissemination of Comrade Kim Goes Flying faced significant barriers stemming from North Korea's tight control over cultural exports and reluctance among Western distributors to promote state-affiliated propaganda, limiting it largely to niche festival circuits rather than commercial theatrical runs. Screenings occurred at the in October 2012, where the film was presented twice as a rare North Korean entry in . It also appeared at the , highlighting its appeal to audiences interested in unconventional Asian cinema. Other festival engagements included the Center for Asian American Media Festival (CAAMFest) in 2013, extending its visibility to select international audiences focused on Asian and independent films. Home media availability remained restricted, with DVD releases handled by independent distributors rather than major studios. A Region 2 DVD edition surfaced in around 2012, catering to European markets with multilingual subtitles. Broader digital access emerged via , where the full film became available for rent or download by 2016 through the production team's efforts. In , domestic DVDs were distributed following a state television broadcast on January 3, 2016, but the country lacks widespread infrastructure, precluding official streaming options there.

Reception

Critical Evaluations

Critics praised Comrade Kim Goes Flying for its novelty as a rare North Korean , offering glimpses into the country's filmmaking style and optimistic worldview. Variety described it as a "candy-hued throwback to a chirpier era of ," appreciating its kitschy fun, strong ensemble spirit, and technical competence in circus sequences despite limited resources. The highlighted its light, refreshing tone and "" elements, positioning it as an unprecedented rom-com from that provides unique cultural insights otherwise unavailable. However, reviews critiqued the film's artistic limitations, citing a shallow plot and predictable character arcs that prioritize ideological uplift over depth or subtlety. The characterized it as a simplistic tale of upward mobility through determination, emblematic of state-sanctioned narratives that constrain creative nuance. Such constraints result in formulaic storytelling, with romantic and comedic elements feeling contrived rather than organically developed, limiting broader appeal beyond its curiosity value. Aggregate critic scores reflect this mixed assessment, with reporting a 62% approval rating based on limited professional reviews, equivalent to roughly 5-6 out of 10. While entertaining for its breezy pace and visual vibrancy, the film is generally seen as hampered by North Korean production norms, yielding competent but unremarkable cinema rather than innovative artistry.

Public and Audience Responses

members frequently praised Comrade Kim Goes Flying for its rarity as a North Korean accessible outside the country, appreciating the humorous elements and colorful depictions of everyday aspirations in a coal-mining and circus setting. On , the film garnered an average user rating of 6.2 out of 10 from 354 ratings, reflecting moderate enthusiasm driven by its novelty and lighthearted rom-com structure. In online discussions, particularly on , viewers highlighted its cultural intrigue, with one user calling it "incredible" for evoking "candy-coated technicolour golden age Hollywood" aesthetics, while others noted the vibrant as a standout despite perceived acting limitations. Reaction videos on , such as those describing the film as "hilariously weird," underscored its appeal as a quirky window into North Korean normalcy, emphasizing post-2012 glimpses of amid state-sanctioned narratives. Skepticism emerged among viewers aware of North Korean media constraints, who dismissed the film's unrelenting positivity as inauthentic , with forum comments labeling it a "not especially good / film" that prioritizes ideological messaging over realism. ' perspectives remain sparse in public discourse, though broader critiques of regime films often question their portrayal of universal joy as disconnected from lived hardships. The film's niche draw centered on film festivals, where it garnered attention for its exoticism—screenings at events like in 2012 and in 2018 attracted curiosity seekers—but it saw limited mainstream uptake beyond circuits and online availability.

Controversies and Criticisms

Propaganda Accusations

Critics have accused Comrade Kim Goes Flying of functioning as soft due to its uncritical depiction of North Korean society and state institutions, portraying everyday life in as vibrant and harmonious without addressing underlying hardships or political controls. The 's production under the oversight of the April 25 Film Studio, North Korea's primary state-run entity responsible for ideological content, ensured alignment with regime narratives, as co-productions required approval to exclude any negative portrayals of the country. This mirrors the Democratic of Korea's longstanding use of cinema for indoctrination, dating to Kim Il-sung's era when films served as tools for mass education in ideology and loyalty to the leadership. A 2013 Variety review highlighted the film's overt propagandistic elements, such as its uplifting girl-power message that boosts regime appeal among domestic audiences, while questioning whether such transparency undermines its persuasive impact internationally. Academic analysis in a 2016 journal article frames the film as part of North Korea's to export cinema globally, refiguring its from isolated to culturally engaging nation, thereby softening perceptions without challenging core authoritarian structures. These elements, including subtle endorsements of collective labor and national pride, position the movie as an extension of state messaging rather than neutral entertainment, despite its rom-com format.

Western Involvement Debates

The collaboration between British tour operator and filmmaker Nicholas Bonner, Belgian director Anja Daelemans, and North Korean co-director Kim Gwang-hun on Comrade Kim Goes Flying (2012) ignited ethical debates over Western participation in North Korean media projects. Proponents of the involvement, including the directors themselves, argued that the film served to humanize North Korean individuals by focusing on universal themes like personal ambition and romance, portraying coal miner Kim Yong-mi as an aspiring trapeze artist pursuing her dreams through collective effort and state-supported opportunities. In a , Bonner emphasized the intent to create "North Korea's first rom-com" that resonated with local audiences by depicting relatable human elements absent from typical regime , potentially fostering subtle cultural exchange without overt political messaging. Critics countered that such participation reflected naivety or unwitting complicity, effectively legitimizing the by adhering to Pyongyang's production constraints and guidelines, which precluded any of systemic issues like repression or economic hardship. A 2013 review (republished in 2020 contexts) described the film as "as clear a piece of cinematic as I have ever seen," questioning how Western directors could overlook its reinforcement of state ideology under the guise of lighthearted , especially given Bonner's prior documentaries that had already granted the regime controlled access to foreign filmmakers. Similarly, analyses highlighted the risk of for an oppressive system, as the project played by Pyongyang's rules—requiring approval from state bodies like the Korea Film Studios—without mechanisms to ensure independent content. The outcomes underscored asymmetrical benefits, with the film enhancing North Korea's through its domestic box-office success—drawing record crowds in cinemas—and international screenings that presented a sanitized view of the country, yet yielding no reciprocity for critical Western-led projects. As the first fully Western-financed feature shot entirely in , it demonstrated rare access but also regime leverage, as subsequent attempts at dissenting or investigative films have faced denial or , perpetuating one-sided engagement.

Omissions of North Korean Realities

The film Comrade Kim Goes Flying portrays North Korean coal miners and workers as enthusiastic and self-motivated in pursuing personal ambitions, such as training, without depicting the severe systemic hardships that define daily life for many citizens. This idealized narrative omits the Arduous March of 1994–1998, during which food shortages and led to an estimated 600,000 to 1 million deaths from starvation and related causes, as documented in analyses of demographic data and defector reports. Such events, exacerbated by state policies prioritizing military spending over agriculture, highlight a pattern of resource mismanagement absent from the film's depiction of abundant communal support. Political prison camps, known as , receive no acknowledgment in the production, despite and witness accounts confirming their operation as sites of , forced labor, and executions for perceived disloyalty, with estimates of 80,000 to 120,000 inmates across facilities like Camp 15 at Yodok. The Commission of Inquiry on in the DPRK has detailed these camps' role in systematic , including and , based on defector testimonies corroborated by geospatial evidence. In contrast, the film's workers exhibit unbridled optimism untethered from such coercive institutions. The pervasive surveillance apparatus, exemplified by the inminban system—where groups of 20–40 households monitor and report on each other's political reliability under threat of —is entirely absent, allowing the narrative to present social interactions as harmonious rather than enforced. Defector testimonies consistently describe this as fostering an atmosphere of mutual distrust and compelled conformity, where public displays of enthusiasm mask underlying fear of repercussions for . The smiling, aspirational workers in the film contradict empirical indicators of chronic , such as a 19% stunting rate among children under five reported by surveys in 2017, reflecting intergenerational effects of food insecurity persisting beyond the 1990s . Refugee health assessments upon arrival in show North Korean youth exhibiting significantly higher rates of growth stunting compared to peers, attributable to caloric deficits and limited protein access under state . These conditions, verified through biometric data rather than self-reported optimism, underscore that the film's portrayal of voluntary zeal likely stems from scripted regime incentives, including punishment for suboptimal performance, rather than genuine, uncoerced individual drive.

Impact and Legacy

Influence on North Korean Cinema

Comrade Kim Goes Flying (2012) stands out as the first North Korean-Western co-production in fiction features, involving filmmakers from the , , and North Korea's state studios, with filming conducted entirely within the country. This collaboration facilitated the incorporation of stylistic elements atypical for domestic North Korean cinema, including vibrant , accelerated editing rhythms, and a tone of comedic optimism focused on an individual's aspirational journey from coal miner to trapeze artist. Such innovations arose from foreign input during in and , offering North Korean crews exposure to techniques that subtly challenged the rigid conventions of , which typically emphasizes heroism over personal dreams. The film's impact on North Korea's tightly controlled , dominated by state entities like the April 15 Film Studio, proved minimal and confined. Primarily conceived as an export-oriented project to humanize the regime internationally, it adhered to core tenets—promoting , unity, and positive heroes—without prompting reforms in internal output, which prioritizes ideological through sentimental, predetermined narratives. Scholarly appraisals underscore its role in reinforcing state-approved domestically while serving foreign audiences, rather than catalyzing broader stylistic or thematic shifts amid the regime's subordination of to politics. Post-release, the project generated sporadic interest in global engagements, such as festivals, but yielded no sequels or replicated co-productions, underscoring its status as an anomaly in an industry producing roughly 10 features annually, mostly adapted for television. State monopolies ensured continuity in propaganda-focused content, limiting any spillover from the film's hybrid approach to aspirational , which echoed longstanding motifs of self-improvement under guidance without introducing verifiable innovations in subsequent works.

Broader Geopolitical Implications

The film exemplifies North Korea's deployment of cinema as a component of , seeking to cultivate a facade of societal normalcy and individual agency to international viewers, thereby mitigating perceptions of total isolation under sanctions. Released in 2012 amid Kim Jong-un's early consolidation of power, it featured rare foreign co-production elements that facilitated screenings in and later in during the 2018 diplomatic thaw following , positioning it as a tool to humanize the regime during fleeting outreach efforts. This approach aligns with Pyongyang's broader tactics, which prioritize curated cultural artifacts over substantive reforms to counterbalance military posturing and economic in regional dynamics. Critically, the narrative of resilient aspiration it promotes—echoing tropes of collective triumph—diverges from verifiable realities, as evidenced by defector testimonies describing pervasive disillusionment and infrastructural decay unrecognizable from the regime's foundational era, alongside economic metrics indicating a GDP of approximately $1,300 and recurrent famines displacing claims. Such depictions risk normalizing distorted views in select leftist-leaning international circles, where academic and media sources prone to ideological may underemphasize causal links between ideology and stagnation, despite empirical refutations from of labor camps and harvest failures. Over the longer term, the film's geopolitical footprint remains negligible in prompting policy concessions or alliances, as North Korea's cultural overtures have failed to erode entrenched sanctions or shift alliances like those fortifying U.S.-South Korea-Japan coordination. Instead, it underscores the regime's instrumentalization of media to obscure entrenched violations, including via political prisons holding up to 120,000 people, as systematically documented without rebuttal in the UN Commission of Inquiry's 2014 findings—evasion tactics that prioritize regime survival over addressing causal drivers of isolation.

References

  1. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2013/jun/26/comrade-kim-goes-flying-north-korea
  2. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2379424/
  3. https://asiasociety.org/hong-kong/events/comrade-kim-goes-flying
  4. https://comradekimgoesflying.com/
  5. https://comradekimgoesflying.com/statement_dir.php
  6. https://www.koreanfilm.org/koreanconnection.html
  7. https://gulfnews.com/general/stretching-horizons-of-film-in-north-korea-1.1172139
  8. https://variety.com/2013/film/reviews/film-review-comrade-kim-goes-flying-1200006015/
  9. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/la-xpm-2012-oct-06-la-ca-north-korea-20121007-story.html
  10. https://www.piie.com/blogs/north-korea-witness-transformation/two-films
  11. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/19/movies/north-korea-film-festival-pyongyang.html
  12. https://www.fastcompany.com/1681676/pyongyang-style-comrade-kim-goes-flying-straight-out-of-north-korea/
  13. https://www.dazeddigital.com/film-tv/article/39874/1/north-korea-western-film-production-comrade-kim-goes-flying
  14. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-19697323
  15. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/north-korean-directors-romantic-comedy-has-acrobatic-twist/
  16. https://www.eyeforfilm.co.uk/review/comrade-kim-goes-flying-2012-film-review-by-amber-wilkinson
  17. http://caamfest.com/2013/films/comrade-kim-goes-flying/
  18. https://vtncankor.wordpress.com/2012/10/29/movie-comrade-kim-goes-flying/
  19. https://comradekimgoesflying.com/synopsis.php
  20. https://www.ciffcalgary.ca/films/2013/comrade-kim-goes-flying
  21. https://www.flixist.com/nyaff-review-comrade-kim-goes-flying/
  22. https://papers.iafor.org/wp-content/uploads/papers/mediasia2018/MediAsia2018_42990.pdf
  23. https://www.bangkokpost.com/life/arts-and-entertainment/1459326/n-korean-underdogs-win-on-screen
  24. http://situations.yonsei.ac.kr/product/data/item/1601379784/detail/1dba398119.pdf
  25. https://comradekimgoesflying.com/festivals.php
  26. https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/studio/segments/240055-inside-north-korean-cinema-comrade-kim-goes-flying
  27. https://variety.com/2013/film/reviews/comrade-kim-goes-flying-1200506795/
  28. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Brhn-hbn3_E
  29. https://www.blu-ray.com/dvd/Comrade-Kim-Goes-Flying-DVD/243351/
  30. https://www.facebook.com/ComradeKimGoesFlying/posts/comrade-kim-goes-flying-is-now-available-to-rent-or-buy-you-can-stream-or-downlo/961422190637361/
  31. https://www.facebook.com/ComradeKimGoesFlying/
  32. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/comrade_kim_goes_flying
  33. https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueFilm/comments/uo88my/is_there_any_good_north_korean_cinema/
  34. https://www.reddit.com/r/northkorea/comments/29qm6l/is_there_anywhere_i_can_watch_comrade_kim_goes/
  35. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-9UrhAltWtc
  36. https://www.reddit.com/r/MovieSuggestions/comments/1i0i38e/north_korea_documentary_suggestionshopefully_a/
  37. https://filmint.nu/koreas-international-productions/
  38. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/bucheon-a-glimpse-north-korea-cinema-1129191/
  39. https://www.koreanquarterly.org/tag/comrade-kim-goes-flying-film/
  40. https://www.theawl.com/2016/05/playing-by-pyongyangs-rules/
  41. https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2018/08/north-koreas-search-for-totality/
  42. https://asiasociety.org/video/filmmaker-q-comrade-kim-goes-flying-complete
  43. https://www.38north.org/2023/01/food-insecurity-in-north-korea-is-at-its-worst-since-the-1990s-famine/
  44. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2013/12/new-satellite-images-show-scale-north-korea-s-repressive-prison-camps/
  45. https://www.ohchr.org/en/hr-bodies/hrc/co-idprk/commission-inquiryon-h-rin-dprk
  46. https://www.hrnk.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/HRNK_Ken-Gause_Translation_5_29_13.pdf
  47. https://libertyinnorthkorea.org/blog/north-korean-refugee-stories-meet-joo-ri
  48. https://apnews.com/article/d9d824f29b3b4128977e60117c2a11e0
  49. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8566798/
  50. https://www.nypost.com/2018/07/07/defector-says-north-korean-regime-turned-its-people-into-cannibals/
  51. https://www.france24.com/en/20180710-korea-approves-rare-screening-n-korea-films
  52. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14649373.2022.2108226
  53. https://yalebooks.yale.edu/2016/12/08/debunking-myths-about-north-korea/
  54. https://www.aei.org/articles/what-is-wrong-with-the-north-korean-economy/
  55. https://www.38north.org/2016/07/aabrahamian072216/
  56. https://www.csis.org/analysis/tenth-anniversary-un-commission-inquiry-report-human-rights-abuses-north-korea
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.