Hubbry Logo
Death of Darwin DormitorioDeath of Darwin DormitorioMain
Open search
Death of Darwin Dormitorio
Community hub
Death of Darwin Dormitorio
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Death of Darwin Dormitorio
Death of Darwin Dormitorio
Death of Darwin Dormitorio
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Darwin Dioso Dormitorio (May 6, 1999 – September 18, 2019) died as the result of maltreatment at the Philippine Military Academy (PMA), Baguio, Benguet, Philippines. He was laid to rest on September 25, 2019, in his hometown of Cagayan de Oro and was given full military honors.[2] In 2019, the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP), along with the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI), announced plans to investigate his death,[3][4] and a House of Representatives resolution was filed seeking a congressional inquiry into the incident.[5] In 2020, two PMA cadets were indicted for murder and three PMA doctors were also charged with participation in the crime.[6]

Key Information

Cadet background

[edit]

Cadet 4th class Dormitorio, who would have been a member of PMA Madasigon Class of 2023,[7] was a 20-year old plebe of the Philippine Military Academy (PMA), the military school of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP). His father, retired Army Col. William Dormitorio, is a graduate of PMA Marangal Class of 1974.[8][9] Dormitorio was the youngest of the three children and his parents described him as "very kind" and "just quiet."[10]

Before admittance into the PMA, Dormitorio was a freshman Agricultural and Biosystems Engineering student at Xavier University – Ateneo de Cagayan.

Hazing incident

[edit]
Facade of the Philippine Military Academy

Initial reports indicated that Dormitorio died from continuous vomiting after complaining of stomach pain while in his barracks in Fort Del Pilar, Baguio.[11][12] However, subsequent reports revealed that he was found unconscious in Room 209 at the PMA's Mayo Hall Annex, at around 3:40 AM of September 17, 2019. He was still rushed to the Fort del Pilar Hospital in Baguio but was declared dead on arrival at around 5:15 AM. According to the PMA report, his cause of death was "blunt force trauma."[13][14]

Dormitorio reportedly wrote a letter in late August 2019 telling his parents that he was confined in the hospital but was doing fine as he was adjusting to life in the PMA. The letter later circulated on social media.[10] He told them that they can visit him but if they weren't available, a visit from his brother or sister would be fine. He asked his parents for extra money to purchase uniforms, and asked that his brother or sister bring him pizza and doughnuts should one of them visit him. He also told his family that he missed them and Brando, their pet Doberman. He gave the letter to another cadet's mother so that it could reach his parents.[8] The letter prompted Dormitorio's brother Dexter to visit him in the hospital on August 25, 2019.[10]

Dormitorio also wrote a report of the incident that happened on the night of August 21, 2019, detailing the punishment he got from PMA Cadets 3rd Class Shalimar Imperial and Felix Lumbag after spending half of his allowance. This was taken as an offense by the upperclassman cadets. Consequently, he was made to perform "pumping exercises" and "bridge under bunks." Dormitorio fell down several times during one of these punishments, which prompted Lumbag to punch him in the ribs.[15][16][17]

On September 17, 2019, he was sent back to the hospital, where he was diagnosed with urinary tract infection and was later discharged the same day. According to Col. Allen Rae Co, Chief of Baguio Police Provincial Office, the victim was beaten up by the three suspects for losing Cadet First Class Axl Rey Sanopao's boots. Sanopao then ordered Imperial and Lumbag to "punish" the victim for not being able to find his boots. He was allegedly maltreated in the evening of September 17, 2019, by the two new suspects, who electrocuted his genitals using a taser flashlight.[18][19]

Suspects

[edit]

On September 26, 2019, the police identified but refused to reveal the names of two more PMA upperclassmen as additional suspects in Dormitorio's death, along with Sanopao, Imperial, and Lumbag. The police are expected to file a case against the suspects for violating Republic Act 1105 or the Anti-Hazing Act of 2018 and murder, as it was established that the suspects had been planning to harm the victim since August 19, 2019.[20]

A 2nd Class cadet was also added to the list of suspects on September 27, 2019,[21] and another cadet was added on September 29, bringing the total to seven.[22] The said suspect, who was also not identified, was the one who kicked the victim prior to his hospital confinement on September 1, 2019. The cadets were Cadet Imperial, Cadet Lumbay and Cadet Manalo.[21]

Trial

[edit]

Baguio Municipal Trial Court for Cities Branch 1 convicted two PMA cadets Cadet 3rd Class Julius Carlo Tadena and Cadet 2nd Class Christian Zacarias of slight physical injuries, sentencing them to a month in prison.[23][24][25]

Meanwhile, the court acquitted three military doctors, former PMA Station Hospital chief Lt. Col. Ceasar Candelaria and medical officers Capt. Flor Apple Apostol and Maj. Maria Ofelia Beloy, of reckless imprudence resulting in homicide.[23][24][25] In November 2025, the Court of Appeals' 14th Division denied the petition of Dexter, his brother, seeking to hold the PMA and several medical officers administratively liable for allegedly failing to prevent the incident and properly treat his injuries. The court likewise upheld the Ombudsman's dismissal of administrative charges against four physicians—the three and Capt. Allain Saa; and two officers—Lt. Gen. Ronnie Evangelista, who has been retired since 2020, and Lt. Gen. Bartolome Vicente Bacarro; as there was no grave abuse of discretion. By late 2025, a separate administrative case for malpractice against the doctors remains pending before the Professional Regulation Commission.[26]

Other cases for violation of the Anti-Hazing Law, Anti-Torture Act, and murder were filed before the Baguio Regional Trial Court Branch 5.[25] On August 16, 2024, the court convicted Tadena, along with the principal suspects[7]—Shalimar Imperial Jr. and Felix Lumbag Jr.—for hazing; with the latter two also for murder; and sentenced them to life imprisonment.[27]

[edit]

This story was featured on the docudrama program Imbestigador in its 41st episode, "Dormitorio." Darwin Dormitorio was portrayed by Martin del Rosario, while his brother Dexter Dormitorio was portrayed by Biboy Ramirez.

Reactions

[edit]

Government

[edit]

During a press briefing on September 23, 2019, Presidential Spokesperson Salvador Panelo said that President Rodrigo Duterte was "angry" about the hazing incident, which occurred just a year after he signed the Anti-Hazing Act of 2018 into law. The President then vowed to deliver justice for the victim.[28] However, a year after signing the law, Duterte stated in a press conference that removing hazing in educational institutions is impossible, describing such measure as "permanent insanity".[29]

In a statement, the Commission on Human Rights (CHR) called for the "total elimination" of hazing "in all schools and non-school-based organisations, including in military and army trainings" as it "curtails the right to life of individuals particularly the youth."[30] Its regional office in the Cordillera Administrative Region will conduct its own investigation into this incident.[31]

Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) Secretary Eduardo Año has also ordered the Philippine National Police (PNP) to be "transparent and not withhold information or whitewash" in investigating the hazing circumstances that led to the victim's death.[32]

Police and armed forces

[edit]

As a result of the incident, AFP Chief Lt. Gen. Noel Clement ordered the Inspector General of the Armed Forces to conduct a probe into the incident and to formulate changes in the PMA. Clement also asked all PMA cadets to undergo an orientation "to change their mindset, specifically in all their activities and dealings inside the academy."[33] PMA Superintendent Lt. Gen. Ronnie Evangelista and commandant of the Corps of Cadets Brig. Gen. Bartolome Vicente Bacarro have already tendered their resignation as a matter of "command responsibility." Evangelista was replaced by Rear Admiral Allan Cusi while Bacarro was replaced by Brig. Gen. Romeo Brawner, the former commander of the Marawi-based 103rd Brigade. Meanwhile, Lt. Col. Cesar Candelaria and Capt. Flor Apple Apostol, who were in charge of the PMA station hospital that initially treated the victim, were also replaced by Lt. Col. Nerio Zabala as officer-in-charge.[18][34]

On September 28, PNP chief Gen. Oscar Albayalde condemned the hazing incident, calling it an "'affront' to what the institution stands for."[35]

Social media and public

[edit]

In a tweet, Dormitorio's girlfriend Ashley Ravidas honored him by posing with his framed picture. "It's not easy loving a soldier, loving you has a high price to pay. I know my Cadet is watching over me, guiding me always. Continue serving up there, do what you love the most," she tweeted.[36] The hashtag #JusticeForDarwin was used by netizens to share their thoughts about the incident and about hazing as a "form of discipline." Some slammed Senator Ronald "Bato" dela Rosa for "ignoring" anti-hazing laws.[37]

The parents of Horacio Castillo III, the 22-year old freshman from University of Santo Tomas (UST) who died as a result of hazing on September 17, 2017, urged legislators in Congress to amend the Anti-Hazing Act of 2018. The Anti-Hazing Act was crafted in response to Castillo's death. The Castillos urged lawmakers to define hazing as a "heinous crime," hoping that it would "deter" those who plan to disregard and violate the said law.[38]

Politics

[edit]

Mayor Omaradji Pizarro of Kalilangan, Bukidnon, who is also Domitorio's uncle, called on legislators in Congress to review the implementation of the Anti-Hazing Act of 2018, which prohibits and penalizes hazing and regulates other forms of initiation rites in fraternities, sororities, and other organizations.[39][40] Similarly, Cagayan de Oro 2nd District Representative Rufus Rodriguez filed a resolution to investigate Dormitorio's death in the Congress.[41]

Several senators have also reacted to the incident. Panfilo Lacson, a member of PMA Class 1971, has dismissed calls for an inquiry into the incident, saying that the Anti-Hazing Act of 2018 was "very clear" and that the incident was "a clear violation of the Anti-Hazing Law as amended."[42] Ralph Recto called on the PMA to "relentlessly pursue" delivering justice to the victim while emphasizing that PMA cadets are "people's investments," since producing one PMA graduate costs PHP 2.982 million.[43] Ronald "Bato" dela Rosa lamented the resignation of Evangelista as head of PMA, calling him a "good officer whose career was wasted because of that very unfortunate incident."[44] Former Magdalo Representative Gary Alejano described Dormitorio's death an "isolated incident".[28]

Ako Bicol Representative Alfredo Garbin Jr. believed that the hazing can be only prevented if the suspects are arrested, charged, and convicted.[45]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Death of Darwin Dormitorio

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The death of Darwin Dioso Dormitorio (May 6, 1999 – September 18, 2019) resulted from severe physical trauma inflicted during rituals at the (PMA) in , , where he served as a 4th Class Cadet. Dormitorio, a 20-year-old recruit from City, endured repeated beatings and other forms of maltreatment by upperclassmen over several weeks, culminating in , , and organ failure despite medical intervention. The case exposed systemic tolerance of violent initiation practices within PMA's training regimen, drawing national scrutiny to hazing's lethal risks in Philippine military education. Legal proceedings against the involved cadets spanned nearly five years, reflecting delays in accountability amid institutional defenses and evidentiary challenges. In August 2024, a Regional Trial Court convicted three former PMA cadets of and , imposing sentences of up to 40 years imprisonment, while acquitting others due to insufficient evidence of direct participation. The convictions provided partial closure for Dormitorio's family, though his father, retired Lt. Col. William Dormitorio—a PMA alumnus—passed away days before the verdict without witnessing justice served. This tragedy underscored failures in oversight and reform efforts at PMA, despite prior anti-hazing laws, fueling calls for stricter enforcement and cultural overhaul in cadet training.

Background

Cadet Profile


Darwin Dioso Dormitorio was a 20-year-old Filipino from Cagayan de Oro, Misamis Oriental, who enrolled as a fourth-class cadet at the Philippine Military Academy (PMA) in 2019.
The son of Colonel William Dormitorio, a PMA alumnus from the class of 1974, Dormitorio had pursued a lifelong ambition to join the academy and emulate his father's military career. His father took deliberate steps to prepare him for the demanding physical and disciplinary rigors of cadet training.
Dormitorio completed his secondary education at Xavier Ateneo de Cagayan, a Jesuit institution in his hometown, before gaining admission to PMA. He had an elder brother, Dexter Dormitorio.

Philippine Military Academy Context

The (PMA), situated in City, functions as the premier training institution for commissioning officers in the Armed Forces of the (AFP). Modeled after the at West Point, PMA was formally established in 1936, evolving from earlier colonial-era military schools dating back to 1898, with initial instruction provided by and U.S. Army officers. The academy admits approximately 200-300 cadets annually through a competitive national entrance examination, followed by a four-year integrating academic studies in , social sciences, and with intensive military and physical training to foster leadership and discipline. PMA's cadet structure emphasizes a strict class system, where fourth-class cadets—freshmen known as plebes—undergo rigorous under the direct oversight of upperclassmen, particularly third-class cadets. This , designed to build resilience, , and adherence to the , includes mandatory physical exercises, drills, and upperclassmen-led supervision during the "beast barracks" equivalent period known as Recognition Training. However, this system has repeatedly enabled unauthorized physical punishments and initiations, contravening formal regulations. Despite the enactment of Republic Act No. 11053, the Anti-Hazing Act of 2018, which imposes severe penalties for resulting in death, PMA has experienced recurrent incidents of maltreatment. Historical cases include a 1982 investigation revealing widespread brutality and following a cadet's death, and multiple fatalities documented between 1978 and 2019. Post-2018, the academy faced scrutiny over the 2019 of fourth-class cadets like Darwin Dormitorio, alongside a 2023 conviction for his death and a 2025 case resulting in a cadet's eight-month hospitalization from similar abuses. These events highlight persistent challenges in eradicating within PMA's traditions, despite administrative reforms and zero-tolerance policies enforced by AFP leadership.

Incident Details

Prelude to Abuse

Cadet 4th Class Darwin Dormitorio, a freshman at the (PMA), faced initial physical punishments from upperclassmen beginning on August 19, 2019, when 3rd Class Cadets Felix Lumbag Jr. and Shalimar Imperial accused him of misusing P2,000 of his P4,000 monthly stipend and subjected him to over 20 minutes of punches and kicks in Room 209, causing him to fall repeatedly. This incident, stemming from a financial dispute over allowance management, marked the onset of documented maltreatment, though PMA officials later classified such acts as unauthorized discipline rather than formal . Dormitorio was hospitalized from to 27 at the PMA station hospital for multiple soft tissue hematomas on his and back, as well as partial-thickness burns on his left , injuries directly linked to the August 19 . Upon discharge, persisted; on August 28, Imperial struck him again, resulting in a profuse . By September 6, Dormitorio required another hospitalization for a and chest contusion, which roommates downplayed as a "toothache" or "swollen " to avoid scrutiny. These recurrent episodes, totaling at least eight maltreatment instances since August, eroded his physical condition and set the stage for escalated punishments tied to accountability for academy property. The immediate prelude to the fatal sequence occurred on September 17, 2019, when 1st Class Sanopao ordered Dormitorio to locate missing combat boots that had been entrusted to him for safekeeping, a responsibility he failed to fulfill amid his weakening state. This infraction—common in military training for instilling responsibility but exploited here for punitive excess—prompted demands for retrieval under threat of disciplinary exercises, including squat thrusts, while Dormitorio was already in pain and fatigued from prior injuries. Police investigations later identified this boot-related accountability as the trigger for intensified physical by Lumbag, Imperial, and others, diverging from PMA's stated anti-hazing protocols that prohibited such unsupervised enforcement. The boots remained unrecovered, underscoring how minor lapses in plebe oversight escalated into severe reprisals within the academy's hierarchical structure.

Specific Acts of Maltreatment

Cadet Fourth Class Darwin Dormitorio endured multiple instances of physical abuse by upperclassmen at the in the days leading to his death on , 2019. On , Second Class Christian Zacarias kicked Dormitorio more than five times in the legs, hips, and ribs while he was performing exercises, causing him to fall and resulting in visible yellowish and purple bruises on his body. The following day, September 17, Cadets Third Class Felix Lumbag Jr. and Shalimar Imperial punched and kicked Dormitorio while he was hanging from a , as reported by First Class Benson Tasic, who observed the incident after Dormitorio sought help. Suspects Lumbag and Imperial later described these actions as "frolics," claiming they involved only attempts to hit without actual force or mere touching, despite the evident injuries. Videos of maltreatment involving Dormitorio and other cadets surfaced publicly on October 24, 2019, corroborating a of physical within the , though specific details from the footage were not detailed in initial reports. The cumulative blunt force trauma from these beatings caused severe internal injuries, including ruptures and tears in the , kidneys with massive contusions, and accumulation of 2 liters of blood in the , leading to acute . External signs included swollen testicles the size of two adult fists, burn marks on genitalia, head bruises, and a swollen, congested with engorged vessels, all consistent with repeated kicks and punches to the , , and head. Dormitorio had previously documented similar maltreatment in a letter to his parents approximately one month earlier, detailing abuses by upperclassmen.

Medical Decline and Death

Following repeated episodes of physical trauma in early September 2019, Cadet Fourth Class Darwin Dormitorio exhibited escalating symptoms of distress, including vomiting, severe abdominal pain, weakness, and paleness. On September 6, he was hospitalized at the (PMA) Station Hospital for a and contusion to the chest, alongside complaints of a swollen and . On September 17, Dormitorio was admitted to the PMA hospital at approximately 9:15 a.m., where personnel diagnosed him solely with a urinary tract infection (UTI), noting old bruises but no acute abdominal symptoms such as rigidity or vomiting at the time of examination; he received treatment, ate, bathed, and was discharged by 5:00 p.m., though observers noted his weakened and pale condition. That evening, he vomited around 7:40 p.m. and later reported intense stomach pain, with further episodes of vomiting occurring at 12:30 a.m. and 1:05 a.m. on September 18. At 3:40 a.m. on September 18, Dormitorio was found unresponsive in his room, without a or respiration; he was rushed to the PMA hospital by 3:50 a.m. but was pronounced dead at 5:15 a.m. from complicated by . An autopsy by the Baguio City medico-legal office revealed acute peritonitis secondary to blunt force trauma to the abdomen as the cause of death, with the stomach containing approximately 2 liters of blood indicative of severe internal hemorrhage, alongside ruptures and tears in the large intestine, bruised and swollen kidneys with massive contusions, testicles enlarged to the size of two adult fists with adjacent burn marks, head bruises, and a swollen, congested brain with engorged vessels. These findings, attributed to cumulative blunt trauma, contradicted the PMA hospital's UTI diagnosis and absence of detected abdominal injury, prompting negligence charges against involved medical personnel.

Investigation

Initial Response and Evidence Collection

The (PMA) responded to Cadet 4th Class Darwin Dormitorio's death on September 18, 2019, by cooperating with the (PNP) and pledging support for an external probe into potential maltreatment. On September 20, 2019, the PNP directed a "deep probe" amid initial suspicions of , with authorities identifying three persons of interest by September 21. PMA leadership took swift internal actions, sacking all officials directly responsible for oversight of the incident on September 23, 2019, while Superintendent Lt. Gen. Ronnie Evangelista resigned the following day, citing accountability for the lapse. Concurrently, Justice Secretary issued Department Order No. 503, tasking the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) with building a case for possible charges based on emerging evidence. Initial evidence collection centered on witness testimonies from Dormitorio's fellow cadets, who described repeated physical abuses framed by upperclassmen as mere "frolics," alongside medical records from his hospitalization showing symptoms of internal distress prior to . An , performed shortly after death, documented extensive —including a massively swollen , ruptured , lacerated filled with two liters of , and acute —contradicting early attributions to natural causes and bolstering maltreatment claims. By late September, the Baguio City Police Office had gathered timelines from these sources, advancing toward filing anti-hazing and murder complaints against identified suspects.

Autopsy Findings

The of Fourth Class Darwin Dormitorio, conducted following his on September 18, 2019, determined the primary cause to be acute secondary to blunt traumatic injury to the . This condition arose from perforations and internal hemorrhaging that led to severe infection and systemic failure, consistent with reports of complicated by internal bleeding from physical trauma. Key findings included extensive abdominal and thoracic trauma, with the containing approximately 2 liters of and exhibiting signs of serious . The showed multiple ruptures and tears, while the kidneys were bruised, swollen, and marked by massive contusions at the poles. Cranial examination revealed bruises on the head, along with a swollen and congested featuring engorged vessels. Genital injuries were particularly severe, with the testicles swollen to the size of two adult fists and exhibiting a reddish discoloration, accompanied by marks in the vicinity. External injuries to the genitalia and abdomen further corroborated the pattern of blunt force and possible thermal trauma inflicted during the preceding incidents. These medico-legal observations directly linked the fatal injuries to repeated , as evidenced in subsequent legal proceedings.

Charges and Suspects

On October 8, 2019, the family of Darwin Dormitorio filed criminal complaints against seven upperclassmen cadets at the for violations of Republic Act No. 11053, the Expanded Anti-Hazing Law of 2018, in connection with the activities that led to his death. These cadets, identified through witness testimonies and evidence of including beatings and tasering, also faced general proceedings under the for of an officer. In June 2020, the Department of Justice found to file murder charges against two of the seven cadets, citing aggravating circumstances under the such as evident premeditation and abuse of superior strength in the hazing rituals. Additionally, three PMA physicians were charged as accessories for alleged in failing to report Dormitorio's injuries and for issuing a falsified attributing his death to natural causes rather than trauma. Warrants of arrest were issued by the City Regional Trial Court on July 7, 2020, for these civilian charges, separate from the ongoing military proceedings. The principal suspects in the civilian murder and hazing case that proceeded to trial were former third-class cadets Shalimar Imperial Jr., Felix Lumbag Jr., and Julius Tadena, accused of directly participating in the fatal beatings over multiple days in September 2019. Dormitorio's family expressed dissatisfaction with the prosecutorial resolution, arguing it insufficiently implicated additional upperclassmen and officials who enabled the culture.

Trial Process

The trial of the principal suspects in the death of Darwin Dormitorio was conducted at the Regional Trial Court (RTC) Branch 5 in City, under Presiding Judge Maria Ligaya Itliong Rivera. Following the 2019 incident, charges of and violation of Republic Act No. 11053, the Anti-Hazing Act of 2018, were filed against former PMA cadets Jomari Shalimar Imperial Jr., Felix Lumbag Jr., and Julius Carlo Tadena, among others. Proceedings spanned approximately five years, marked by delays partly attributable to the , which disrupted hearings and evidence gathering. The prosecution presented evidence including witness testimonies from fellow PMA cadets who detailed the physical punishments inflicted on Dormitorio, such as repeated kicks, punches, and possible use of a , triggered initially by his loss of a during drills. Police investigation reports from the Baguio City Police Office and medical records corroborated these accounts, documenting blunt force trauma, soft tissue hematomas, and injuries indicative of prolonged maltreatment over several days. Earlier related proceedings at the Baguio Municipal in Cities Branch 1 resulted in convictions for slight physical injuries against Tadena and another on August 4, 2023, providing foundational findings on direct causation of harm. Defense arguments centered on contesting the degree of intent and direct involvement in the fatal injuries, with lawyers indicating plans to appeal the RTC's determinations. The trial underscored challenges in prosecuting within military institutions, including issues that led to resignations of PMA officials like Superintendent Lt. Gen. Ronnie Evangelista and Brig. Gen. Bartolome Bacarro, though these were addressed in separate administrative probes rather than the criminal proceedings. Emotional testimonies and family presence in court highlighted the human toll, yet the process emphasized forensic and testimonial proof to establish guilt beyond under Philippine law.

Verdict and Sentencing

On August 16, 2024, the Regional Trial Court Branch 5 in City, presided over by Judge Maria Ligaya Itliong Rivera, convicted three former (PMA) cadets in connection with the 2019 hazing death of fourth-class cadet Darwin Dormitorio. Shalimar Imperial Jr. and Felix Lumbag Jr. were found guilty of under Article 248 of the , as well as violation of Republic Act No. 11053, the Anti-Hazing Act of 2018, for their direct participation in the physical assaults that contributed to Dormitorio's injuries and subsequent death. Julius Carlo Tadena was convicted of violating the same anti-hazing law for his role in facilitating or participating in the maltreatment, though not charged with . The court's 42-page decision emphasized the brutality of the rituals, including repeated beatings with a wooden bat and other objects over several days, which caused internal injuries leading to Dormitorio's death on September 18, 2019. All three convicts were sentenced to reclusion perpetua, a penalty equivalent to with a maximum service of 40 years under Philippine law. Imperial and Lumbag were each ordered to pay PHP 3 million in civil indemnity to Dormitorio's family, while Tadena was fined PHP 2 million; the two murder convicts were also held jointly and severally liable for additional damages, including PHP 175,000 in and temperate damages, PHP 75,000 in expenses, and PHP 100,000 in attorney's fees. Following the promulgation, the cadets were remanded to a civilian jail in , marking a departure from military custody. The defense indicated plans to appeal the verdict to the Court of Appeals, arguing insufficient evidence of intent for and challenging the causation between the acts and Dormitorio's death. This conviction represents one of the rare successful prosecutions under the enhanced anti-hazing law, which imposes reclusion perpetua when hazing results in death, amid historical leniency in similar military institution cases.

Hazing Culture in Philippine Military Institutions

Historical Prevalence

Hazing practices at the (PMA) trace their origins to the institution's founding in 1936, when upperclassmen from the preceding Academy imposed traumatic initiation rituals on the inaugural class of 120 cadets arriving on June 15. These rituals, intended to foster discipline and loyalty, persisted as an entrenched tradition, with alumni recalling their severity even decades later. By the late 1970s, had escalated to lethal levels, as evidenced by the death of Manuel Salas on February 13, 1978, from internal injuries sustained when upperclassmen dropped shot puts onto his stomach during a ; a fellow , , nearly died in the same incident. This was followed by the death of Andres Ramos Jr. on November 9, 1981, from traumatic shock due to repeated beatings by upperclassmen, prompting a investigation that exposed institutionalized brutality and beyond mere disciplinary measures, leading to the sentencing of one to five years' hard labor and the suspension of another for failing to report the abuse. The pattern continued into the early 2000s despite the enactment of Republic Act 8049, the Anti-Hazing Law, in 1995. Ace Bernabe Ekid collapsed during exercises in June 2000, with his family alleging involvement, though PMA officially attributed it to heatstroke without confirmation of abuse. In March 2001, Edward Domingo died of a cardio-respiratory attack after being beaten with a pipe and punched during initiation, resulting in two cadets receiving 12-year sentences; shortly after, on April 7, 2001, Monico de Guzman succumbed to injuries from a severe beating treated at General Hospital.
Cadet NameDate of DeathIncident Details
Manuel SalasFebruary 13, 1978Internal injuries from shot puts dropped on stomach during ritual.
Andres Ramos Jr.November 9, 1981Traumatic shock from upperclassmen beatings; led to investigation of systemic .
Edward DomingoMarch 10, 2001Cardio-respiratory failure after pipe beating and punches in .
Monico de GuzmanApril 7, 2001Death from severe beating injuries.
These incidents illustrate a historical recurrence of fatal hazing at PMA, spanning over four decades, rooted in upperclassmen-led traditions that prioritized tests of endurance and loyalty, often evading official sanction despite periodic reforms and legal prohibitions.

Causal Factors and Debates

Hazing at the (PMA) stems from traditions established in 1936, when upperclassmen initiated freshmen in rituals inherited from the earlier Constabulary Academy, intended to instill discipline and camaraderie but often escalating into . These practices reinforce a rigid hierarchy, with senior cadets wielding unchecked authority over plebes to enforce obedience, a dynamic exacerbated by the academy's isolation in and limited external oversight. Broader cultural factors, including a societal tolerance for physical initiation rites in fraternities and organizations, contribute to normalization, where is viewed as a test of endurance despite Republic Act 8049's prohibitions since 1995. Empirical patterns show persistence linked to power imbalances and a code of silence, where victims fear reprisal or expulsion for reporting, allowing abuses to recur across decades, as evidenced by at least five documented deaths at PMA since 1972. Institutional incentives, such as promoting group loyalty over individual accountability, further entrench the practice, with upperclassmen rationalizing violence as preparation for combat stress, though data indicates it fosters trauma rather than resilience. Hypermasculine norms within the all-male environment amplify this, equating submission to pain with manhood, a factor rooted in military traditions but distorted in the Philippine context by impunity and weak enforcement. Debates center on hazing's purported benefits versus its harms, with defenders arguing it builds unbreakable bonds and toughness essential for , citing historical precedents from U.S. academies like West Point that PMA emulates. Critics, including lawmakers, counter that it constitutes gratuitous brutality unrelated to professional training, rejecting it as any legitimate "" and pointing to repeated fatalities as proof of systemic failure. Reform advocates emphasize mindset shifts and stricter monitoring, as pledged by PMA leadership post-2019, yet skeptics highlight ongoing incidents, such as a 2024 barracks assault, questioning the efficacy of internal sanctions over independent probes. Underlying contention involves the honor code's erosion, where loyalty to peers overrides ethical reporting, perpetuating a cycle that laws alone have failed to break.

Reactions and Societal Impact

Official and Institutional Responses

Following the death of Cadet Fourth Class Darwin Dormitorio on September 18, 2019, the (PMA) relieved all officials directly responsible for the incident to enable an impartial investigation into the alleged . On September 24, 2019, PMA Superintendent Lieutenant General Ronnie Evangelista tendered his , citing the tradition of ; () Chief of Staff General Benjamin Madrigal accepted it. Evangelista stated that "maltreatment is wrong in PMA" and emphasized the academy's commitment to ascertaining that Dormitorio "did not die in vain" through completed investigations and prosecution proceedings. PMA Commandant of Cadets also resigned the same day, clarifying that the action was not an admission of but a measure to uphold command and preserve the institution's integrity. The Department of National Defense commended the resignations as an appropriate response to the maltreatment that caused Dormitorio's death and hospitalized two other cadets. Presidential spokesman , speaking for Malacañang, described the resignations as a "right step" and assured the public of a thorough probe without whitewash. In tandem, PMA initiated reviews of its protocols, practices, and culture to eradicate maltreatment, while providing logistical support to Dormitorio's family, including transport of his remains to City.

Public and Media Outrage

The death of Cadet Fourth Class Darwin Dormitorio on September 18, 2019, from injuries sustained during unauthorized physical training at the (PMA) elicited widespread public condemnation across platforms and traditional outlets in the . Netizens and activists decried the brutality revealed in reports, which documented over 30 lacerations, , and organ failure from repeated blows, fueling demands for and an end to entrenched practices in military institutions. On October 28, 2019, marking the 40th day since Dormitorio's death, students from Baguio City universities gathered at the PMA gates to light candles, offer prayers, and voice outrage against , highlighting perceived institutional tolerance for such rituals despite legal prohibitions. This symbolized broader civilian frustration with the military's internal handling of the case, as participants criticized the delay in identifying suspects and the initial classification of the incident as mere "horseplay." Media coverage amplified the public's anger, with outlets like Inquirer and publishing leaked videos of Dormitorio's maltreatment, which depicted upperclassmen forcing plebes into grueling exercises, thereby exposing systemic lapses in oversight at PMA. Reports emphasized the failure of the 2018 Anti-Hazing Law amendments, which mandated bystander reporting but appeared unenforced, prompting editorials questioning the academy's culture of impunity. This scrutiny led to calls for congressional probes, as lawmakers cited Dormitorio's case as emblematic of recurring cadet fatalities, with at least six similar deaths noted in recent years prior to 2019. The outrage extended to debates over hazing's role in "building character," with public commentators rejecting defenses from some PMA alumni who downplayed the incident as non-hazing due to its official ban, arguing instead that of physical trauma underscored causal links to ritualistic abuse rather than sanctioned training. backlash trended under hashtags decrying military , pressuring authorities for swift arrests and contributing to the eventual tagging of three upperclassmen as principal suspects by , 2019.

Political Discourse

President expressed outrage over Dormitorio's death on September 23, 2019, describing it as a tragic outcome of alleged at the PMA, while simultaneously defending moderated as a means to instill discipline and character in military trainees, stating that excessive violence crossed an unacceptable line. This stance drew criticism for potentially undermining anti- enforcement, as it highlighted a perceived tolerance for ritualistic violence within state institutions despite the existence of Republic Act No. 8049, the Anti-Hazing Law of 1995, amended in 2018 to impose stricter penalties including life imprisonment for deaths resulting from . Legislators across Senate committees swiftly condemned the incident, with multiple senators on September 22, 2019, demanding the full invocation of the Anti-Hazing Act against PMA suspects and decrying the "senseless killing" as a failure of institutional oversight in a premier military training body. Senator Aquilino "Koko" Pimentel III, on September 20, 2019, voiced personal sorrow as a fellow native, urging thorough investigation and accountability to prevent recurrence, emphasizing that PMA cadets should embody discipline rather than brutality. Similarly, Senator Juan Miguel Zubiri, on the same day, lamented the betrayal of public trust in PMA's rigorous standards, calling for justice to uphold the academy's role in producing ethical officers. Local political figures, including Cagayan de Oro Mayor Oscar Moreno, on September 21, 2019, pressed national authorities for a comprehensive probe, framing the death as emblematic of deeper cultural issues in military education that demanded systemic scrutiny beyond individual culpability. The discourse extended to broader debates on military impunity, with critics attributing persistent hazing to weak enforcement of laws post-high-profile cases like the 1990s deaths that prompted initial legislation, arguing that elite institutions like PMA evaded rigorous compliance due to internal solidarity and hierarchical deference. Proponents of reform highlighted the need for cultural overhaul, while defenders invoked traditions of "toughening" recruits, revealing partisan tensions between executive tolerance for disciplinary excesses and legislative pushes for zero-tolerance accountability.

Aftermath and Reforms

Institutional Changes at PMA

In response to the death of Cadet 4th Class Darwin Dormitorio on September 18, 2019, from injuries sustained during hazing, the Philippine Military Academy (PMA) introduced multiple policy and structural adjustments to address maltreatment. These reforms, announced in late 2019, included a revamp of supervision and monitoring mechanisms, with the number of tactical officers per company increased from one or two to four to improve oversight of cadet interactions. Rooming assignments were altered to integrate cadets from all class levels into shared barracks, replacing prior same-year-level groupings, as part of efforts to disrupt patterns of isolated abuse by upperclassmen. Surveillance enhancements involved installing additional CCTV cameras in critical campus areas to deter and document potential incidents. Psycho-social interventions were formalized, providing stress and trauma management for first-year (fourth-class) and programs for upperclassmen, aimed at fostering emotional resilience and reducing aggressive behaviors. The PMA's station hospital received upgrades, including the addition of psychiatrists to the medical staff, to better handle physical and issues arising from cadet . Longer-term initiatives focused on cultural shifts, such as strengthening the cadet honor system to promote self-reporting of violations, empowering fourth-class cadets through expanded leadership roles, and instituting a comprehensive cadet leadership development framework. PMA leadership, under the newly appointed Commandant of Cadets Brigadier General Romeo Brawner Jr. in September 2019, explicitly declared a "war against hazing," emphasizing zero tolerance and integrating strict enforcement of Republic Act No. 11053, the Anti-Hazing Act of 2018. Segregation of first-year cadets from upperclassmen in certain activities was later cited as a preventive measure to limit opportunities for abuse. The Armed Forces of the Philippines considered involving third-party experts, such as academics or PMA alumni, to review institutional policies on cadet training and officer responsibilities, though specific outcomes of this process remain undocumented in . Despite these measures, subsequent incidents of cadet assaults in and 2025 suggest ongoing challenges in fully eradicating practices.

Broader Anti-Hazing Efforts

The Anti-Hazing Act of 2018 (Republic Act No. 11053), enacted on June 29, 2018, expanded prohibitions on to encompass all forms of rites in fraternities, sororities, organizations, and citizens' training, imposing penalties ranging from prision correccional to reclusion perpetua for deaths or serious injuries, alongside liability for cover-ups and failure to report. This legislation amended the earlier Anti-Hazing Law of 1995 (RA 8049), which had required prior notice for rites but permitted physical forms deemed non-abusive, a provision criticized for enabling persistent violence. The Dormitorio case, occurring just over a year after RA 11053's passage, underscored enforcement gaps, as upperclassmen cadets inflicted fatal beatings despite the ban, resulting in 2024 murder convictions under the act that carried sentences and PHP 3 million indemnities per perpetrator. Subsequent national responses emphasized stricter implementation across educational and military sectors. In October 2024, Senate President Juan Miguel Zubiri called on the Commission on Higher Education (CHED), Department of Education (DepEd), and Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) to initiate comprehensive anti-hazing campaigns, highlighting academic reluctance to fully dismantle traditions despite legal mandates. By February 2025, the Department of Justice endorsed Senate Bill 2271 to further amend RA 11053, aiming to address ongoing incidents through enhanced penalties and oversight mechanisms, as hazing deaths persisted in universities and fraternities post-2018. CHED, tasked with higher education compliance, advocated for segregated training in institutions like PMA while pushing broader regulatory reviews to curb fraternity violence, though critics noted uneven application amid cultural entrenchment. In May 2025, the government established an Anti-Hazing Inter-Agency Task Force to coordinate enforcement, involving , , and interior agencies in monitoring, investigations, and public awareness drives, reflecting a shift toward proactive beyond reactive prosecutions. These initiatives built on prior convictions, such as those in the Dormitorio case, to deter , yet from 2019–2024 indicated over 20 reported hazing-related fatalities nationwide, primarily in groups, signaling persistent challenges in cultural and . Organizations like publicly recommitted to non-violent recruitment in 2024, warning against rogue chapters, though such self-policing has yielded mixed results amid legal scrutiny. Overall, while RA 11053 facilitated landmark accountability, broader efforts hinge on inter-agency vigilance and legislative tightening to override entrenched norms.

References

  1. https://philippinediaryproject.com/about-the-philippine-diary-project/about-darwin-dormitorio/
  2. https://www.hazinginfo.org/hazing-death-details?recordId=rec7SfMcBHxQ05Hq
  3. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1207155
  4. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1973553/darwin-dormitorio-slay-3-ex-pma-cadets-guilty-of-murder-hazing
  5. https://web.senate.gov.ph/press_release/2019/0920_pimentel1.asp
  6. https://www.abs-cbn.com/regions/2024/8/16/court-convicts-3-pma-cadets-over-hazing-death-of-darwin-dormitorio-1243
  7. https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/regions/917380/family-of-pma-cadet-finds-justice-after-5-year-battle/story/
  8. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1231403
  9. https://www.rappler.com/philippines/luzon/pma-hazing-victim-darwin-dormitorio-father-died-before-verdict-august-16-2024/
  10. https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2019/10/10/1959046/highest-ranking-pma-cadet-quits-post-over-dormitorios-death
  11. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1167731/cagayan-de-oro-mourns-for-pma-cadet-killed-in-hazing
  12. https://www.rappler.com/philippines/240858-darwin-dormitorio-lifelong-dream-join-pma/
  13. https://www.facebook.com/XavierAteneoOfficial/posts/the-xavier-ateneo-community-mourns-the-death-of-darwin-dormitorio-a-young-cadet-/2381872765237694/
  14. https://www.facebook.com/PIABaguioCity/posts/here-dexter-dormitorio-the-elder-brother-of-the-late-cadet-4cl-darwin-dormitorio/2423196231271978/
  15. https://www.pma.edu.ph/about.php
  16. https://kahimyang.com/articles/3155/the-history-of-the-philippine-military-academy
  17. https://www.educatly.com/university/61827/philippine-military-academy
  18. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/2079923/another-hazing-case-rocks-pma
  19. https://www.nytimes.com/1982/08/15/world/philippine-military-academy-is-under-attack.html
  20. https://www.hanknuwer.com/plebes-dying-to-belong/
  21. https://www.rappler.com/philippines/luzon/military-academy-hazing-cadet-hospital-2025/
  22. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1973705/3-ex-cadets-in-deadly-pma-hazing-found-guilty
  23. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1171990/updated-timeline-more-details-of-dormitorios-hell-days-at-pma
  24. https://www.sunstar.com.ph/baguio/local-news/timeline-the-slow-death-of-cadet-darwin-dormitorio
  25. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1169473/pma-cadet-beaten-up-over-missing-boots-police
  26. https://cebudailynews.inquirer.net/260388/pma-cadet-beaten-up-over-missing-boots-police
  27. https://coconuts.co/manila/news/freshman-cadet-darwin-dormitorio-allegedly-killed-over-missing-boots/
  28. https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/710249/witness-abuse-of-dormitorio-just-frolics-suspects-claimed/story/
  29. https://www.facebook.com/ONENewsPH/videos/pma-hazing-videos/548090189274696/
  30. https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/711293/autopsy-reveals-serious-injuries-suffered-by-dormitorio/story/
  31. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=49SqwWFfcrs
  32. https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/711125/relieved-pma-hospital-chief-maintains-dormitorio-only-had-uti/story/
  33. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1081050
  34. https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/09/23/19/pma-sacks-officials-linked-to-hazing-death-of-cadet
  35. https://www.rappler.com/philippines/240885-pma-superintendent-resigns-death-darwin-dormitorio/
  36. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1168220/nbi-ordered-to-probe-death-of-pma-cadet-dormitorio
  37. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1170909/timeline-the-hell-cadet-dormitorio-endured-at-pma
  38. https://www.hazinginfo.org/hazing-death-details?recordId=rec7SfMcBHZxQ05Hq
  39. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1167479/pma-cadets-death-traced-to-hazing-corps-indignant
  40. https://www.philstar.com/nation/2024/08/16/2378371/3-pma-cadets-found-guilty-murder-hazing-dormitorio-case
  41. https://www.manilatimes.net/2019/10/15/latest-stories/breakingnews/7-cadets-in-dormitorio-hazing-death-face-general-court-martial/640976
  42. https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/709780/7th-suspect-in-dormitorio-death-identified-police/story/
  43. https://www.rappler.com/philippines/240901-pma-identifies-suspects-darwin-dormitorio-death/
  44. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1170159/pma-hazing-probe-tags-2-more-suspects-they-tasered-victim
  45. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1297586/murder-raps-vs-2-cadets-3-doctors-in-pma-hazing
  46. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1107008
  47. https://www.pna.gov.ph/index.php/articles/1108335
  48. https://www.rappler.com/philippines/264850-pma-cadet-dormitorio-family-dissatisfied-prosecutor-resolution/
  49. https://www.rappler.com/philippines/luzon/ex-pma-cadets-convicted-darwin-dormitorio-death/
  50. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-asian-studies/article/same-banana-hazing-and-honor-at-the-philippine-military-academy/72BD566ACD00B7299A324D2EDC2D357A
  51. https://www.rappler.com/newsbreak/iq/241722-pma-record-hazing-deaths/
  52. https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=81140
  53. https://utppublishing.com/doi/full/10.3138/jmvfh-2023-0016
  54. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1060826518815147
  55. https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/09/27/19/hazing-not-a-rite-of-passage-for-pma-cadets-says-lawmaker
  56. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SroERT2ltEU
  57. https://news.abs-cbn.com/news/09/23/19/pma-sacks-officials-linked-to-hazing-death-of-cadet
  58. https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2019/09/25/1954845/pma-head-steps-down-over-death-cadet
  59. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1081297
  60. https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2019/09/23/1954155/3-tagged-pma-cadets-death
  61. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1182746/baguio-students-light-candles-on-40th-day-of-dormitorio-death
  62. https://www.facebook.com/ONENewsPH/posts/thebigstory-videos-showing-maltreatment-of-slain-cadet-darwin-dormitorio-inside-/697175784021644/
  63. https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/10/11/19/ex-pma-head-suggests-separating-plebes-from-cadets-to-end-hazing-cycle
  64. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1081184
  65. https://www.rappler.com/features/voices/newsletters/241500-hazing-what-hazing/index.html
  66. https://www.facebook.com/NewsWithSense/posts/updated-noting-at-least-6-cadet-deaths-in-recent-years-suspending-pma-recruitmen/1321453841369398/
  67. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1081225
  68. https://www.bworldonline.com/editors-picks/2019/10/10/258317/hazing-and-impunity/
  69. https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/708916/senators-condemn-hazing-in-pma-invoke-implementation-of-anti-hazing-act-vs-suspects/story/
  70. https://web.senate.gov.ph/press_release/2019/0922_zubiri1.asp
  71. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1081081
  72. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1083595
  73. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1179235/psychiatrists-hospital-upgrade-among-changes-after-pma-hazing-death
  74. https://www.sunstar.com.ph/baguio/local-news/pma-adopts-anti-hazing-measures
  75. https://mb.com.ph/18/2/2025/ched-s-task-to-prevent-hazing
  76. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1082420
  77. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1174251/third-party-eyed-to-review-pma-policies
  78. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/2079574/pma-says-another-cadet-assaulted-in-2024
  79. https://elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocs/2/85055
  80. https://lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1995/ra_8049_1995.html
  81. https://web.senate.gov.ph/press_release/2024/1004_zubiri1.asp
  82. https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/nation/2025/2/3/doj-supports-amendment-to-anti-hazing-act-1548
  83. https://doj.gov.ph/news_article.html?newsid=_dwU03yrTJn1q2KRKvNUYCaSCWmm-UjQ3UPB0FGa9Ow
  84. https://currentph.com/2024/11/01/tau-gamma-phi-reaffirms-anti-hazing-stance-amid-recent-tragedies-warns-of-renegade-chapters/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.