Hubbry Logo
David AbramDavid AbramMain
Open search
David Abram
Community hub
David Abram
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
David Abram
David Abram
David Abram
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

David Abram is an American ecologist and philosopher best known for his work bridging the philosophical tradition of phenomenology with environmental and ecological issues.[1][2] He is the author of Becoming Animal: An Earthly Cosmology[3] (2010) and The Spell of the Sensuous: Perception and Language in a More-than-Human World (1996), for which he received the Lannan Literary Award for Nonfiction.[4] Abram is founder and creative director of the Alliance for Wild Ethics (AWE);[5] his essays on the cultural causes and consequences of ecological disarray have appeared often in such journals as the online magazine Emergence, Orion, Environmental Ethics, Parabola, Tikkun, and The Ecologist, as well as in numerous academic anthologies.[6]

Key Information

In 1996, Abram coined the phrase "the more-than-human world" as a way of referring to earthly nature (introducing it in the subtitle of The Spell of the Sensuous and throughout the text of that book); the term was gradually adopted by other scholars, theorists, and activists, and has become a key phrase within the lingua franca of the broad ecological movement.[7] In recent writings, Abram sometimes refers to the more-than-human world as "the commonwealth of breath."[8]

Abram was the first contemporary philosopher to advocate a reappraisal of "animism" as a complexly nuanced and uniquely viable worldview—one which roots human cognition in the sensitive and sentient human body, while affirming the ongoing entanglement of our bodily experience with the uncanny sentience of other animals (each of which encounters the same world that we perceive yet from an outrageously different angle and perspective).[9] A close student of the traditional ecological knowledge systems of diverse indigenous peoples, Abram articulates the entwinement of human subjectivity not only with other animals but with the varied sensitivities of the many plants upon which humans depend, as well as our cognitive entanglement with the collective sensitivity and sentience of the particular earthly places—the bioregions (or ecosystems)—that surround and sustain our communities. In recent years his work has come to be closely associated both with the "new animism," and with a broad movement loosely termed "New Materialism," due to Abram's espousal of a radically transformed sense of matter and materiality.[10]

Abram is currently a senior visiting scholar in ecology and natural philosophy at Harvard Divinity School.[11]

Life and early influences

[edit]

Born in the suburbs of New York City, Abram began practicing sleight-of-hand magic during his high school years in Baldwin, Long Island; it was this craft that sparked his ongoing fascination with perception. In 1976, he began working as "house magician" at Alice's Restaurant in the Berkshires of Massachusetts and soon was performing at clubs throughout New England[12] while studying at Wesleyan University. After his second year of college, Abram took a year off to travel as an itinerant street magician through Europe and the Middle East; toward the end of that journey, in London, he began exploring the application of sleight-of-hand magic to psychotherapy under the guidance of R. D. Laing. After graduating summa cum laude from Wesleyan in 1980, Abram traveled throughout Southeast Asia as an itinerant magician, living and studying with traditional, indigenous magic practitioners (or "medicine persons") in Sri Lanka, Indonesia, and Nepal. Upon returning to North America, he continued performing while devoting himself to the study of natural history and ethnoecology, visiting and learning from Native communities in the Southwest Desert and the Pacific Northwest. A much-reprinted essay written while studying ecology at the Yale School of Forestry in 1984, entitled "The Perceptual Implications of Gaia",[13] brought Abram into association with the scientists formulating the Gaia Hypothesis. He was soon lecturing in tandem with biologist Lynn Margulis and geochemist James Lovelock, both in Britain and the United States. In the late 1980s, Abram turned his attention to exploring the decisive influence of language upon the human senses and upon our sensory experience of the land around us. Abram received a doctorate for this work from Stony Brook University in 1993.[14]

Abram's writing is informed by his studies among indigenous peoples in Indonesia, Nepal, and the Americas, as well as by the American nature-writing tradition that stems from Henry David Thoreau, Walt Whitman, and Mary Austin. His philosophical work is informed by the European tradition of phenomenology—especially by the writings of the French phenomenologist, Maurice Merleau-Ponty. Abram's evolving work has also been influenced by his friendships with the archetypal psychologist James Hillman, the iconoclastic evolutionary biologist Lynn Margulis, and the social critic and radical historian Ivan Illich—as well as by his esteem for the American poet Gary Snyder and the agrarian novelist, poet, and essayist Wendell Berry.[5]

The more-than-human world

[edit]

Writing in the mid-1990s, and finding himself frustrated by the problematic terminology of environmentalism (dismayed by the longstanding conceptual gulf between humankind and the rest of nature tacitly implied by the use of conventional terms like "environment" and even by the word "nature" itself, which is so often contrasted with "culture" as though there were a neat divide between the two), Abram coined the phrase "the more-than-human world" in order to signify the broad commonwealth of earthly life, a realm that manifestly includes humankind and its culture, but which also necessarily exceeds human culture. The phrase was intended, first and foremost, to indicate that the space of human culture was a subset within a larger set — that the human world was necessarily sustained, surrounded, and permeated by the more-than-human world — yet by the phrase Abram also meant to encourage a new humility on the part of humankind (since the "more" could be taken not just in a quantitative but also in a qualitative sense). Upon introducing the phrase as the central term for "nature" in his 1996 book The Spell of the Sensuous (subtitled Perception and Language in a More-than-Human World), the phrase was gradually adopted by many other theorists and activists, soon becoming an inescapable term within the broad ecological movement.[7]

The publication of The Spell of the Sensuous[4] proved to be catalytic for the formation and consolidation of several new disciplines, especially the burgeoning field of ecopsychology (both as a theoretical discipline and as therapeutic practice), as well as ecophenomenology and ecolinguistics. Already translated into numerous languages, the first French translation of the text was completed by the eminent Belgian philosopher-of-science, Isabelle Stengers, in 2013.[15]

Further work

[edit]

Since 1996, Abram has lectured and taught at universities throughout the world, while nonetheless maintaining his independence from the institutional world of academe. He was named by the Utne Reader as one of a hundred visionaries currently transforming the world,[16][17] and profiled in the 2007 book, Visionaries: The 20th Century's 100 Most Inspirational Leaders.[18] His ideas have often been debated (sometimes heatedly) within the pages of various peer-reviewed academic journals, including Environmental Ethics, Environmental Values and the Journal of Environmental Philosophy[19] In 2001, the New England Aquarium and the Orion Society sponsored a public debate between Abram and distinguished biologist E. O. Wilson, at the old Town Hall in Boston, on science and ethics. (An essay by Abram that grew out of that debate, entitled "Earth in Eclipse," has been published in several versions.[20]) In the summer of 2005, Abram delivered a keynote address for the United Nations "World Environment Week" in San Francisco, to 70 mayors from the largest cities around the world.[21]

In 2006, Abram—together with biologist Stephan Harding, ecopsychologist Per Espen Stoknes, and environmental educator Per Ingvar Haukeland—founded the non-profit Alliance for Wild Ethics (AWE), for which he serves as Creative Director.[5] According to their website, the Alliance is "a consortium of individuals and organizations working to ease the spreading devastation of the animate earth through a rapid transformation of culture. We employ the arts, often in tandem with the natural sciences, to provoke deeply felt shifts in the human experience of nature. Motivated by a love for the more-than-human collective of life, and for human life as an integral part of that wider collective, we work to revitalize local, face-to-face community – and to integrate our communities perceptually, practically, and imaginatively into the earthly bioregions that surround and support them."[22]

In 2010 Abram published Becoming Animal: An Earthly Cosmology,[3] which was the sole runner-up for the inaugural PEN Edward O. Wilson Award for Literary Science Writing,[23] and a finalist for the 2011 Orion Book Award.[24] A review in Orion by Potowatami elder Robin Wall Kimmerer described the book thus: "Prose as lush as a moss-draped rain forest and as luminous as a high desert night ... Deeply resonant with Indigenous ways of knowing, Becoming Animal lets us listen in on wordless conversations with ancient boulders, walruses, birds, and roof beams. His profound recognition of intelligences other than our own enables us to enter into reciprocal symbioses that can in turn, sustain the world. Becoming Animal illuminates a way forward in restoring relationship with the earth, led by our vibrant animal beings to re-inhabit the glittering world,"[25] while in the UK, a review in the journal Resurgence said: "David Abram is a true magician, superbly skilled in both sleight-of-hand magic and the literary art of awakening us to the superabundant wonders of the natural world. He is one of America's greatest Nature writers... The language is luminous, the style hypnotic. Abram weaves a spell that brings the world alive before your very eyes."[26]

In 2014 Abram held the international Arne Næss Chair of Global Justice and Ecology at the University of Oslo, in Norway.[27] In that same year he became a distinguished fellow of Schumacher College, where he teaches regularly.[28] For 2022–2023, Abram is senior visiting scholar in ecology and natural philosophy at the Center for the Study of World Religions at Harvard University.[29] He also teaches a weeklong intensive each summer on Cortes Island, in British Columbia.[30] Abram lives with his family in the foothills of the southern Rockies.[5]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

David Abram

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
David Abram (born 1957) is an American cultural ecologist, geophilosopher, and author whose work examines the interplay between human sensory perception, language, and the more-than-human environment. Drawing on the phenomenology of alongside fieldwork with indigenous shamans in the 1980s, Abram argues that alphabetic literacy has historically obscured the participatory reciprocity between humans and the animate earth. Abram's seminal book, The Spell of the Sensuous: Perception and Language in a More-Than-Human World (1996), posits that recovering oral, indigenous modes of sense-making could foster ecological reciprocity by reanimating the perceived agency of entities. This text, informed by his experiences in Balinese and Nepali healing traditions, critiques the abstracting effects of on embodied awareness. In Becoming Animal: An Earthly Cosmology (2010), he extends these themes to explore human embodiment as continuous with atmospheric and terrestrial processes, advocating for an ethical attunement to planetary rhythms. As founder of the Alliance for Wild Ethics, Abram promotes experiential practices to cultivate participatory sensing amid environmental crises, influencing and perceptual philosophy while challenging anthropocentric assumptions in Western thought. His contributions emphasize the causal primacy of sensory participation in shaping cultural ontologies, urging a return to the earth's inherent expressiveness over detached abstraction.

Early Life and Education

Childhood and Formative Experiences

David Abram was born on June 24, 1957, on , New York. He spent his childhood in the coastal suburbs of Baldwin, , amid marshes and creeks that offered direct immersion in local ecosystems. His mother worked as a performing concert pianist, potentially influencing his early appreciation for expressive arts. A pivotal formative experience occurred during high school, when Abram took up sleight-of-hand , fostering a profound interest in perceptual processes and the phenomenology of illusion. This pursuit of as a teenager laid groundwork for his later explorations of sensory awareness and human-nature reciprocity.

Academic Training and Initial Influences

Abram completed his undergraduate studies at , graduating summa cum laude following a year-long interruption during which he traveled through performing sleight-of-hand . He subsequently pursued doctoral research in philosophy, earning a Ph.D. from the at Stony Brook in 1993 for a dissertation examining , , and the of sensory . During his graduate work from 1987 to 1993, Abram focused on the of , integrating phenomenological methods with ecological inquiry. His dissertation emphasized the perceptual foundations of human experience and indigenous animistic worldviews, drawing on fieldwork among traditional communities in and the to challenge Western assumptions about subjectivity and the nonhuman environment. Key intellectual influences during this period included the phenomenological philosophy of , whose emphasis on embodied perception and the primacy of sensory engagement informed Abram's critique of abstract rationalism and his advocacy for a reciprocal human-nature . This framework, rooted in direct experiential analysis rather than detached theorizing, underpinned Abram's early arguments for reinterpreting as a sophisticated perceptual reciprocity rather than primitive superstition.

Core Philosophical Framework

Phenomenological Foundations

David Abram's phenomenological framework draws primarily from Maurice Merleau-Ponty's emphasis on the primacy of perceptual experience as the foundational mode of human engagement with the world, rejecting reductions of reality to abstract mental representations. In Merleau-Ponty's Phenomenology of Perception (1945), perception is portrayed as an embodied, pre-reflective interplay between the sensing body and its surroundings, which Abram extends to underscore the participatory nature of sensing itself. Abram contends that genuine phenomenology, by attending to the "things themselves" as lived through the senses, reveals perception not as a passive reception of stimuli but as a dynamic, reciprocal exchange wherein the perceiver is shaped by—and shapes—the perceptual field. Central to Abram's adaptation is the concept of the body as the "flesh" of the world, echoing Merleau-Ponty's late where the human body is not separate from but continuous with the elemental medium of , such as air, light, and earth. This chiasmic relation—Merleau-Ponty's term for the reversible intertwining of self and other—posits that sensory experience emerges from an intimate reciprocity, where the world's expressivity (e.g., the rustle of leaves or the texture of stone) elicits and informs human awareness without requiring linguistic mediation. Abram argues this embodied reciprocity counters the objectifying gaze of modern science and , restoring as the origin of meaning, which arises "in the heat of meeting, encounter, participation" rather than from detached cognition. By radicalizing Husserlian phenomenology through Merleau-Ponty, Abram critiques inconsistencies in earlier traditions, such as the tendency to bracket the body's sensory immersion, and insists on a "more eloquent" disclosure of 's ecological depth. This foundation yields an ethical dimension: attentive cultivates responsibility toward the animate , as ignoring the sensuous world's agency fosters alienation and environmental disregard. Empirical support for this view draws from of indigenous perceptual practices, where heightened sensory attunement reveals the landscape as responsive and expressive, aligning with phenomenological descriptions of the world as a "collective field of experience lived through from many different angles." Abram's approach thus grounds abstract ecological concerns in the concrete primacy of the senses, prioritizing direct, verifiable experiential evidence over theoretical constructs.

Critique of Literacy and Language

Abram's critique posits that the advent of alphabetic in marked a profound shift in human perception, detaching from its embodied, oral roots and fostering a abstracted, dualistic that alienates humans from the more-than-human environment. In oral traditions, emerges as a participatory medium intertwined with , breath, and sensory reciprocity with the , where words are not fixed symbols but dynamic expressions mirroring the rhythms of , animal calls, and natural phenomena. This contrasts with phonetic alphabets, which prioritize visual abstraction over auditory and tactile dimensions, enabling and interior but severing 's direct ties to the speaking body and surrounding . Drawing on Maurice Merleau-Ponty's phenomenology, Abram argues that pre-literate languages sustain an animistic reciprocity, where perception and expression blend human and nonhuman agencies into a coherent, sensuous field, as evidenced in indigenous practices where stories serve as mnemonic anchors to specific places and beings. Alphabetic writing, however, internalizes reflection, transforming thought into a self-referential loop that objectifies the external world, facilitating scientific but contributing to the ecological dissociation underlying modern environmental crises. He emphasizes that this estrangement is not solely caused by —oral cultures also engage —but amplified by the alphabet's visual dominance, which narrows sensory engagement to the eye, diminishing participatory awareness of air, earth, and other species. Abram illustrates this through historical transitions, such as the Greek adoption of the around the 8th century BCE, which decoupled script from pictorial representation and vocal intonation, paving the way for philosophy's emphasis on abstract reason over embodied . In contemporary terms, he warns that digital text further entrenches this visual bias, yet holds potential for recovery if paired with renewed oral and gestural practices to restore 's ecological embeddedness. This framework underscores his broader call for a return to perceptual participation, where again becomes a bridge rather than a barrier to the living world.

Major Works and Ideas

The Spell of the Sensuous (1996)

The Spell of the Sensuous: Perception and Language in a More-Than-Human World was first published in 1996 by , a division of . In the book, Abram develops a phenomenological critique of modern perceptual habits, positing that the ongoing ecological unraveling stems from Western culture's progressive abstraction of human experience from its sensuous, participatory roots in the natural world. He draws primarily on Maurice Merleau-Ponty's phenomenology to argue that perception is not a passive representation but an active, reciprocal engagement where the sensing body and the sensed environment mutually shape one another, countering dualistic views that treat nature as mere objective resource. This framework, Abram maintains, reveals the more-than-human world as inherently expressive and alive, with humans evolving as co-participants rather than detached observers. Central to Abram's analysis is the transformative role of language in perceptual estrangement. He contends that pre-alphabetic, oral languages—evident in many indigenous traditions—remain tethered to the gestures, sounds, and rhythms of specific landscapes, fostering a direct reciprocity between speakers and their surroundings, as seen in storytelling or Balinese healing practices. Alphabetic writing, however, internalizes the voice as silent, visual symbols, enabling abstract thought but severing linguistic vitality from sensory immediacy and contributing to a view of the earth as inert matter manipulable by human will. Abram supports this with observations from his fieldwork in and , where shamans engage the sensuous agency of nonhuman entities through perceptual attunement rather than supernatural intervention, challenging ethnocentric dismissals of such practices as mere superstition. He further invokes Edmund Husserl's phenomenological reduction to highlight how indigenous worldviews sustain a primal intimacy with phenomena, unmediated by Cartesian subject-object splits. Abram concludes that restoring ecological reciprocity demands a deliberate re-sensitization: cultivating attentiveness to the textures, airs, and calls of the surrounding world to counteract literacy-induced forgetting. This "simple premise," as he terms it, holds that human identity emerges only through convivial exchange with nonhuman others, urging a shift from abstract representation to embodied participation. The earned the International Lannan Literary Award for Nonfiction and has shaped discussions in ecological philosophy by integrating , , and firsthand ethnographic insights.

Becoming Animal (2010)

Becoming Animal: An Earthly Cosmology was published on August 24, 2010, by , a division of Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, spanning 336 pages with 978-0375421716. In this work, Abram extends the phenomenological and ecological themes from his earlier book The Spell of the Sensuous, arguing that contemporary humans have become alienated from their sensuous, participatory relation to the natural world due to alphabetic and digital , which prioritize visual, objective distance over embodied reciprocity. He posits that reclaiming our "animal" senses—particularly through heightened attention to breath, touch, and the elemental forces like air and shadow—enables a deeper with the more-than-human environment, fostering ethical responsiveness amid ecological crises. Abram structures his arguments around experiential phenomenology, drawing on Maurice Merleau-Ponty's emphasis on the body as the primary site of to critique modern philosophy's dualism between mind and matter. Key chapters explore phenomena such as the reciprocity of encounters with nonhuman entities, the overlooked agency of air as a medium of , and the perceptual lessons from shadows and mirrors, which reveal the world's inherent ambiguity and our embeddedness within it. He advocates practices like attentive wandering and sensory immersion to counteract cultural dissociation, suggesting these restore a participatory cosmology where humans actively co-constitute the earth's vitality rather than dominating it from an illusory exterior vantage. This framework positions ecological renewal not as abstract policy but as a transformation in perceptual habits, attuned to the pulse of the animate landscape. The book received attention in environmental philosophy circles, with reviews praising its evocative, synesthetic prose for inspiring renewed sensorial engagement with nature, though some noted its reliance on poetic intuition over empirical methodologies. In Environmental Ethics, Gregory Caicco highlighted its contribution to rethinking human-nature relations through embodied perception. Critics in journals like The Trumpeter appreciated the inspirational quality of Abram's accounts of perceptual shifts but questioned the universality of his proposed ecological practices, such as unstructured wandering, in diverse cultural contexts. Overall, Becoming Animal has been regarded as a call to sensorial rejuvenation, influencing discussions in eco-phenomenology by challenging anthropocentric abstractions with calls for reciprocal, fleshly participation in the biosphere.

Key Concepts in Human-Nature Reciprocity

Abram's conception of human-nature reciprocity centers on the participatory of perception, wherein the engages in a mutual exchange with the sensuous environment, as influenced by phenomenologist . , in this view, constitutes a "reciprocal encounter" between the perceiver and the perceived, where the surrounding world actively shapes and responds to human senses, rather than serving as passive objects of observation. This reciprocity manifests through bodily immersion, as human forms evolve in "delicate reciprocity with the manifold textures, sounds, and shapes of an animate earth," fostering a dynamic interplay that animates both participant and . A core element is animistic perception, which Abram describes as an experiential mode recognizing the agency and inherent in nonhuman entities, such as forests or stones, creating a "world that watches" through reciprocal sensory solicitation. In oral cultures, this reciprocity is sustained via mimetic language and gestures tied to environmental rhythms, enabling ongoing dialogue with the more-than-human world, where entities like leaves or winds elicit human attention and response. Alphabetic literacy, however, disrupts this balance by internalizing language toward abstract human constructs, muting the land's expressiveness and denying nature's , thus eroding participatory bonds. Extending these ideas, Abram emphasizes sensory re-engagement to restore reciprocity, urging attunement to the ecosystem's "multiple intelligences" through practices that affirm human animality within a field of . This involves recognizing as inherently synaesthetic and animistic, where direct encounters reveal the world's expressive subjectivity, countering modern detachment and enabling ethical interdependence with nonhuman kin. Such concepts underscore Abram's broader ecological phenomenology, prioritizing empirical sensory evidence over abstracted dualisms to reveal causal interdependencies in human-nature relations.

Activism, Performance, and Practical Engagements

Performance Art and Magic Background

David Abram developed an early interest in sleight-of-hand magic during his teenage years in the suburbs of , where he was raised on [Long Island](/page/Long Island). By the mid-1970s, he had honed these skills into professional performances, beginning with a position as house magician at in the , , in 1976. From there, he entertained audiences at clubs and restaurants across and throughout the , accumulating seven years of steady stage work by the early . His acts focused on perceptual manipulation, using manual dexterity to create illusions that heightened sensory awareness and challenged audience expectations of reality. This foundation in Western stage magic extended into performance art practices that emphasized embodied interaction and environmental engagement. Abram's routines often incorporated elements of improvisation and direct bodily presence, blurring the lines between entertainer and participant to evoke a sense of wonder and reciprocity with the surrounding world. Unlike conventional magic, his approach drew on the magician's craft to explore themes of and , prefiguring his later philosophical inquiries into how human senses mediate encounters with nonhuman entities. Seeking deeper insights, Abram traveled to and in the late , apprenticing with traditional shamans and healers to study indigenous magical traditions. These experiences revealed magic not as solitary sleight-of-hand but as a relational practice embedded in ecological and cultural contexts, involving dialogue with spirits, animals, and landscapes. Upon returning, he began integrating these cross-cultural elements into his performances, applying sleight-of-hand techniques experimentally in therapeutic settings under psychological guidance, which further shaped his view of magic as a tool for sensory reawakening amid modern dissociation from .

Alliance for Wild Ethics and Organizational Efforts

The Alliance for Wild Ethics () is a nonprofit co-founded by David Abram, Stephan Harding, Per Espen Stoknes, and Per Ingvar Haukeland, with Abram serving as its director and creative director. The organization comprises individuals and groups dedicated to alleviating ecological damage to the living earth by catalyzing cultural shifts toward participatory, place-based modes of perception and sense-making. Drawing from indigenous traditions and ecocultural practices, AWE emphasizes bioregional reciprocity, sensory engagement with life, and the integration of human communities into their surrounding ecosystems. AWE's core efforts involve consultations and training programs for sustainable communities, organizations, and enterprises, aimed at rooting literate and digital cultures in oral, earth-centered storytelling. These initiatives promote "wild ethics" by leveraging arts and sciences to awaken wonder and ethical responsiveness to the animate world, countering the dissociation fostered by modern technological abstraction. The alliance collaborates with global partners to advance these goals, focusing on transformative practices that restore convivial relations between humans and the more-than-human environment. Under Abram's guidance, AWE supports projects dedicated to cultural metamorphosis, including efforts to rejuvenate oral traditions as a foundation for ecological awareness and decision-making. This work aligns with Abram's broader advocacy for perceiving the as a dynamic, reciprocal participant in human experience, rather than a mere resource.

Lectures, Workshops, and Field Experiences

Abram delivers lectures on topics such as the of perception, , and human reciprocity with the more-than-human world at academic and environmental institutions. For instance, he presented the Walter Orr Roberts Memorial Lecture titled "Science and the Sensory Experience of " at the Aspen Institute on June 19, 2018, exploring the boundaries between scientific inquiry and direct sensory engagement with the environment. He has also spoken at events like the Garrison Institute's conversation on "The More than Human World" on June 17, 2021, emphasizing perceptual participation in ecological crises. Through the Alliance for Wild Ethics, which he co-founded, Abram offers training and consultations that incorporate workshops to foster place-based ethical awareness and traditions drawn from indigenous and ecological perspectives. These programs aim to integrate human communities with local bioregions via practical engagements in natural settings, though specific event details are often tailored to organizational needs rather than publicly listed. Abram's workshops typically involve multi-day immersions emphasizing sensory awakening, storytelling, and reciprocal encounters with landscapes and nonhuman entities. Examples include "Falling Awake: The Ecology of Wonder," a six-day workshop at Hollyhock Retreat Center on Cortes Island, British Columbia, held July 28 to August 5, 2023, where participants deepened perceptual skills and explored dependence on the animate earth. Similarly, "Between the Human Animal and the Animate Earth," a five-day program at the same venue from July 25 to 30, 2025, focuses on animistic solidarity amid climate challenges through collective exploration and narrative practices. Field experiences led by Abram often combine philosophical inquiry with physical immersion in wild terrains, such as river journeys or ethnobotanical retreats. The "Into the Depths of a Planet" retreat on September 10–17, 2023, involved an eight-day, 45-mile paddle on Utah's Green River, facilitating improvisational exchanges with elemental forces and other species. Internationally, he co-led the two-week "Sentient in a More-than-Human " seminar from October 3–16 in a coastal ethnobotanical in southern , incorporating lectures on sensory and alongside interdisciplinary fieldwork. Earlier efforts, like the 2012 workshop "Between the Body & The Earth," utilized elemental encounters, magic, and shape-shifting exercises in natural locales to evoke participatory perception.

Criticisms and Intellectual Debates

Accusations of Cultural Appropriation

Lorraine F. Brundige, a scholar, and J. Douglas Rabb leveled accusations of cultural appropriation against David Abram in their 1997 article "Phonicating Mother Earth: A Critique of David Abram's The Spell of the Sensuous," published in Ayaangwaamizin: The International Journal of Indigenous Philosophy. They argued that Abram's phenomenological interpretation of Indigenous oral traditions and animistic perceptions imposes undue universals on diverse Indigenous philosophies, thereby appropriating and homogenizing voices shaped by specific cultural and historical contexts. This approach, they contended, echoes colonial patterns of extracting and generalizing Indigenous knowledge without regard for its heterogeneity or the imposition of external frameworks during settler histories. Brundige and Rabb specifically critiqued Abram's reliance on second-hand ethnographic accounts and his synthesis of practices from Aboriginal Australian, Native American, and other traditions to support claims about a pre-literate, sensuous reciprocity with the more-than-human world, asserting that such amalgamation overlooks intra-Indigenous differences and risks commodifying sacred elements for Western ecological philosophy. While Abram's fieldwork included apprenticeships with traditional healers in and during the 1980s, the critics maintained that non-Indigenous authors interpreting these experiences through alphabetic lenses perpetuate a form of intellectual extraction, prioritizing phenomenological universals over authentic, place-based Indigenous epistemologies. These accusations have been echoed in broader discussions of , where some reviewers highlight Abram's tendency to romanticize Indigenous relationality with nature as potentially extractive, though such claims remain limited primarily to academic Indigenous circles rather than widespread public discourse. No formal responses from Indigenous communities or legal challenges have been documented, and Abram's defenders argue his work fosters rather than ownership of traditions.

Methodological and Empirical Critiques

Critics of Abram's phenomenological approach contend that it emphasizes subjective, first-person sensory immersion at the expense of intersubjective verification and empirical , akin to broader critiques of phenomenology as potentially solipsistic by confining analysis to individual experience without external validation. This method, drawing heavily from , privileges qualitative descriptions of perceptual reciprocity with nonhuman entities but offers no standardized protocols for replication or measurement, limiting its integration with scientific or cognitive studies. Abram's assertions regarding the historical shift from oral, participatory languages to alphabetic writing as a causal factor in human disconnection from have been challenged for insufficient empirical support; for instance, he acknowledges that in non-alphabetic societies, such as ancient , undermines the universality of this . Reviews in scientific outlets have noted that specific hypotheses, like the perceptual origins of abstract thought, "may well be mistaken at certain points" due to reliance on interpretive rather than controlled . Empirical gaps persist in validating claims of animistic enhancing ecological attunement, as these rest on anecdotal fieldwork among indigenous groups without quantitative metrics or longitudinal studies to correlate sensory practices with behavioral outcomes. Furthermore, the poetic and metaphorical style in works like The Spell of the Sensuous (1996) has drawn methodological reproach for prioritizing evocative narrative over precise argumentation, rendering key propositions—such as language's role in "reciprocal participation" with the sensuous world—hard to dissect logically or test against counterevidence. Abram's interpretations of indigenous cosmologies, including Australian Aboriginal Dreamtime concepts, depend on secondary accounts like Bruce Chatwin's The Songlines (1987) without independent corroboration, introducing risks of ethnographic distortion. While philosophically innovative, this approach sidesteps causal realism by conflating phenomenological description with explanatory mechanism, absent from peer-reviewed ecological modeling or neuroscientific inquiry into perception.

Abram's Responses and Defenses

Abram addressed methodological critiques of his eco-phenomenological framework, particularly those advanced by philosopher Ted Toadvine in the 2003 article "Limits of the Flesh: The Role of Reflection in David Abram's Ecophenomenology," through a detailed published in in 2005. Toadvine argued that Abram's emphasis on perceptual reciprocity and the "flesh of the world"—drawing from Maurice Merleau-Ponty's phenomenology—undermines human , reflection, and resistance by subsuming the self into an undifferentiated relational field, potentially excluding symbolic mediation and ethical contrariety. In his reply, "Between the Body and the Breathing Earth," Abram countered that his approach does not disparage reflection but situates it as inherently embodied and sensory, rooted in Merleau-Ponty's notion of as a chiasmic intertwining of body and world that preserves reciprocity without fusion. He maintained that true reflection emerges from perceptual engagement rather than detached abstraction, critiquing overly intellectualized for severing itself from corporeal experience. Abram rejected Toadvine's portrayal of his as denying separateness, asserting that the more-than-human world inherently involves otherness and incompossibility—evident in encounters with animals like whales or wolves, which resist human assimilation—and that entails mutual challenge, as in indigenous hunting practices where predator and prey engage in reciprocal antagonism rather than harmonious unity. Regarding symbolic mediation, Abram clarified that The Spell of the Sensuous foregrounds a , earthly symbolism—such as , , and —tied to the body's participation in the sensuous world, rather than excluding the symbolic in favor of raw perception; he argued that all corporeality is inherently expressive and symbolic, per Merleau-Ponty, challenging Toadvine's . On resistance and ethical agency, Abram defended as enabling critique and opposition, not erasing them, and dismissed Toadvine's moral qualms about as a projection of anthropocentric harmony onto ecosystems marked by predation and decay. Abram has not issued a formal published response to specific accusations of cultural appropriation leveled by scholars Lorraine F. Brundige and J. Douglas Rabb in their 1997 critique "Phonicating Mother Earth," which faulted his interpretations of indigenous oral traditions and perceptual practices as filtered through Western phenomenology, potentially misrepresenting Native epistemologies. However, in addressing related charges of and exoticization in his 2005 reply to Toadvine, Abram pointed to the uptake of his ideas by indigenous groups, such as the Peruvian PRATEC network's and of The Spell of the Sensuous for Andean Quechua communities, as evidence of dialogic resonance rather than imposition. He emphasized his methodological commitment to participatory apprenticeship with traditional healers in , , and the , framing these engagements as reciprocal exchanges that inform but do not colonize indigenous knowledge.

Influence and Legacy

Impact on Ecopsychology and Environmental Philosophy

David Abram's The Spell of the Sensuous: Perception and Language in a More-Than-Human World (1996) introduced a phenomenological approach to ecology, positing that human language and cognition emerge from participatory exchanges with the animate environment, thereby laying foundational groundwork for ecopsychology's emphasis on reciprocal human-nature bonds as essential for psychological well-being. This perspective reframes environmental disconnection not merely as behavioral but as a perceptual rift, where modern alphabetic literacy abstracts humans from sensory immersion in the "more-than-human world," contributing to widespread ecological alienation addressed in ecopsychological practices like nature-based therapy. Abram's integration of Maurice Merleau-Ponty's embodied perception with indigenous animistic traditions has influenced ecopsychologists to prioritize direct sensory engagement—such as tracking animal movements or attuning to wind patterns—as methods to restore participatory consciousness and mitigate anthropocentric dissociation. In environmental philosophy, Abram's work extends beyond descriptive phenomenology to critique Cartesian dualism's role in fostering exploitative attitudes toward nature, advocating instead for an ethical reciprocity rooted in the body's inherent reciprocity with ecological processes. By drawing on sources like Apache storytelling and Balinese shamanism alongside Western philosophy, he challenges abstract environmental ethics, urging philosophers to ground moral considerations in the vivacity of perceptual experience, as seen in his arguments that the earth's "breathing" rhythms inform human reciprocity rather than vice versa. This has resonated in debates over deep ecology, where Abram's animistic phenomenology—evident in essays linking linguistic evolution to oral traditions' earth-bound metaphors—provides a causal mechanism for how cultural shifts toward textuality diminished recognition of nonhuman agency, influencing thinkers to explore perceptual reorientation as a pathway to sustainable ethics. His later Becoming Animal: An Earthly Cosmology (2010) further amplifies this impact by applying these ideas to atmospheric interdependencies, reinforcing environmental philosophy's shift toward embodied cosmologies that prioritize empirical sensory data over idealized constructs. Abram's contributions have catalyzed interdisciplinary dialogues, with adopting his perceptual diagnostics to explain phenomena like "" through first-hand ecological immersion, while environmental philosophers cite his framework to counter reductionist with a realism of lived reciprocity. Despite critiques of romanticizing pre-modern perceptions, his insistence on verifiable sensory participation—drawn from fieldwork in and —lends empirical weight, evidenced by its integration into curricula and practices that empirically correlate heightened nature attunement with reduced ecological despair. Overall, Abram's oeuvre underscores a causal link between perceptual habits and , positioning restored sensorial reciprocity as both diagnostic and remedial for contemporary crises.

Broader Cultural and Scientific Reception

Abram's ideas have resonated in environmental and literary communities, where The Spell of the Sensuous (1996) is frequently cited for restoring sensory reciprocity with the natural world. Poet praised it for illuminating "the landscape of language, flesh, mind, history, mapping us back into the world." The book has influenced and , serving as an introductory text that links to ecological , as noted in analyses of its role in fostering participatory environmental awareness. Endorsements from figures in phenomenology and ecology underscore its appeal in humanities-oriented discussions of and embodiment, though direct penetration into mainstream popular media remains limited, with exposure primarily through podcasts, interviews, and niche publications. In scientific reception, Abram's emphasis on perceptual phenomenology has found niche integration in interdisciplinary and cognitive studies, informing explorations of and environmental interaction without relying on quantitative models. His framework, drawing from Merleau-Ponty, has prompted reflections on how sensory experience underpins ecological theory, yet it encounters skepticism in empirical disciplines for prioritizing qualitative encounter over testable hypotheses. Academic engagements, such as in and ecocultural studies, value its critique of alphabetic abstraction's alienating effects, but broader scientific communities often view it as philosophical speculation rather than falsifiable science. Overall, reception highlights a divide: enthusiastic adoption in for its poetic advocacy of earthly reciprocity, contrasted with cautious scientific appraisal that demands empirical grounding for claims about perceptual reciprocity with nonhuman entities. This pattern reflects Abram's positioning at phenomenology's edge, influencing applied fields like while eluding mainstream validation metrics.

Recent Activities and Ongoing Contributions (Post-2010)

Following the publication of Becoming Animal: An Earthly Cosmology in 2010, Abram held the international Chair in Global Justice and Ecology at the in 2014, where he advanced discussions on ecological phenomenology and . During the 2022–2023 academic year, he served as Senior Visiting Scholar in Ecology and at Harvard Divinity School's Center for the Study of , contributing to interdisciplinary explorations of human-nature reciprocity amid climate challenges. As co-founder and director of the Alliance for Wild Ethics, Abram has directed post-2010 efforts to integrate human cultures with bioregional ecosystems, promoting the revival of and perceptual practices to counter ecological disconnection. The alliance collaborates with scholars like Per Espen Stoknes, whose 2015 work on climate psychology aligns with its goals, and supports training in sustainable community practices drawing from indigenous and holistic traditions. Abram maintains active engagement through lectures and immersive workshops, including "Between the Human Animal and the Animate ," a five-day program at Hollyhock exploring animistic with , and "Sentient in a More-than-Human ," a two-week ethnobotanical retreat in emphasizing sensorial and anthropological perspectives on earthly intelligence. These field-based experiences, often held in natural settings, foster direct perceptual encounters to deepen ecological awareness. In parallel, Abram has produced essays and public addresses addressing contemporary crises, such as a 2020 reflection on the pandemic's perceptual implications and a 2021 lecture on " and in a More-than-Human World." More recently, in February 2024, he discussed earthly perspectives in an interview, and in December 2024, published "Coming To Our (Animal) Senses," critiquing anthropocentric in environmental discourse. These contributions underscore his ongoing emphasis on embodied perception as a corrective to cultural and ecological imbalances.

References

  1. https://www.davidabram.org/david-abram-bio
  2. https://gettherapybirmingham.com/the-ecology-of-enchantment-david-abrams-earth-centered-philosophy/
  3. https://www.davidabram.org/books
  4. https://www.amazon.com/Spell-Sensuous-Perception-Language-More-Than-Human/dp/0679776397
  5. https://emergencemagazine.org/essay/creaturely-migrations-breathing-planet/
  6. https://humansandnature.org/david-abram/
  7. https://www.agci.org/people/0034x000013tCEXAA2/david-abram
  8. http://environment-ecology.com/biographies/499-david-abram.html
  9. https://encyclopedia.pub/entry/38408
  10. http://dialogic.blogspot.com/2005/04/david-abram-spell-of-sensuous.html
  11. https://philpapers.org/rec/ABRIEA-2
  12. https://www.linkedin.com/in/david-abram-0ab94a8
  13. https://adrianharris.org/blog/2020/04/08/david-abram/
  14. https://philpapers.org/rec/ABRMAT
  15. https://www.davidabram.org/essays/magic-and-machine-65hd4-fj357-c3fbd
  16. https://emergencemagazine.org/interview/the-ecology-of-perception/
  17. https://bluelabyrinths.com/2016/06/15/the-phenomenology-of-language-in-david-abrams-the-spell-of-the-sensuous/
  18. https://readingandwalking.ca/2021/07/12/david-abram-the-spell-of-the-sensuous-perception-and-language-in-a-more-than-human-world/
  19. https://childrenofthecode.org/interviews/abram.htm
  20. https://lacuna.org.uk/environment/david-abram-language-and-stories-shape-the-world/
  21. https://www.samwoolfe.com/2016/06/book-review-spell-of-the-sensuous-by-david-abram.html
  22. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/10862969909548053
  23. https://projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/retreat/files/abram_the_spell_of_the_sensuous_perception.pdf
  24. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1996-03-01-ls-41670-story.html
  25. https://www.supersummary.com/the-spell-of-the-sensuous/summary/
  26. https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/david-abram/the-spell-of-the-sensuous/
  27. https://mayasheth.github.io/2021/05/23/the-spell-of-the-sensuous
  28. https://cdn.bookey.app/files/pdf/book/en/the-spell-of-the-sensuous.pdf
  29. https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/319/the-spell-of-the-sensuous-by-david-abram/
  30. https://books.google.com/books/about/Becoming_Animal.html?id=YKLOfABpUs4C
  31. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/314402256_David_Abram_Becoming_Animal_An_Earthly_Cosmology_New_York_Pantheon_Books_2010_336_pages_US2695_ISBN_978-0375421716
  32. http://boughtbooks.blogspot.com/2012/11/david-abram-becoming-animal.html
  33. https://absa.upce.cz/index.php/absa/article/view/2574
  34. https://www.spiritualityandpractice.com/book-reviews/view/20252/becoming-animal
  35. https://trumpeter.athabascau.ca/index.php/trumpet/article/view/1256
  36. https://www.bookrags.com/studyguide-becoming-animal/chapanal001.html
  37. https://earthzine.org/the-beauty-of-a-difficult-read-a-review-of-becoming-animal/
  38. https://www.greenspirit.org.uk/bookreviews2/2012/02/09/becoming-animal-an-earthy-cosmology-by-david-abram/
  39. https://philpapers.org/rec/CAIDAB
  40. https://brill.com/abstract/journals/wo/16/1/article-p99_5.xml
  41. https://www.davidabram.org/essays/animism-perception-magic
  42. https://www.themarginalian.org/2019/07/07/the-spell-of-the-sensuous-david-abram/
  43. https://www.davidabram.org/essays/making-magic-53gma
  44. https://scott.london/interviews/abram.html
  45. https://www.ttbook.org/people/david-abram
  46. https://dark-mountain.net/sensing-knowing-a-conversation-with-david-abram/
  47. https://environment-ecology.com/biographies/499-david-abram.pdf
  48. https://www.davidabram.org/awe
  49. https://macaulay.cuny.edu/calendar-of-events/a-talk-by-philosopher-david-abram/
  50. https://orionmagazine.org/contributor/david-abram/
  51. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hos9KCwi5zI
  52. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t_2B5lyNt_o
  53. https://wildethics.org/
  54. https://www.davidabram.org/events/falling-awake-the-ecology-of-wonder
  55. https://hollyhock.ca/programs/7411/between-the-human-animal-the-animate-earth/
  56. https://www.theriverspath.org/utah-river-retreats/into-the-depths-of-a-breathing-planet-with-david-abram/
  57. https://www.wasiwaska.org/seminar/sentient-nature-in-a-more-than-human-world/
  58. https://iseethics.wordpress.com/2012/02/20/workshop-david-abram-between-the-body-the-breathing-earth/
  59. https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.apaonline.org/resource/collection/13B1F8E6-0142-45FD-A626-9C4271DC6F62/v07n2AmericanIndians.pdf
  60. https://www.academia.edu/95692647/An_Ecological_Conception_of_Personhood_Forthcoming_Environmental_Ethics
  61. https://scholarsbank.uoregon.edu/bitstreams/32373e2f-9432-44fa-a879-d57aae74ebcd/download
  62. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26167967
  63. https://www.davidabram.org/essays/magic-and-machine-65hd4-fj357-5886a
  64. https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=F1sVZMwAAAAJ&hl=en
  65. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/08873260701415538
  66. https://orionmagazine.org/article/ecopsycology-in-ten-easy-lessons/
  67. https://thecouch.hethem.nl/under-the-spell-of-the-sensuous/
  68. https://sonicacts.com/archive/under-the-spell-of-the-sensuous
  69. https://www.purposeguides.org/david-abram
  70. https://www.ecopsychology.org/journal/ezine/archive4/waking.htm
  71. https://footnotes2plato.com/2022/12/05/in-dialogue-with-david-abram-on-the-more-than-human-world/
  72. https://jungpage.org/learn/articles/book-reviews/876-no-going-back-coming-full-circle-qthe-spell-of-the-sensuousq-by-david-abram
  73. https://www.reddit.com/r/askphilosophy/comments/1exb3rj/what_are_peoples_thoughts_on_david_abrams_the/
  74. https://www.davidabram.org/events
  75. https://www.davidabram.org/dynamic-media
  76. https://emergencemagazine.org/interview/honoring-the-wild-proliferation-of-earthly-perspectives/
  77. https://www.davidabram.org/essays/coming-to-our-animial-senses
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.