Hubbry Logo
Generating set of a groupGenerating set of a groupMain
Open search
Generating set of a group
Community hub
Generating set of a group
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Generating set of a group
Generating set of a group
from Wikipedia

The 5th roots of unity in the complex plane form a group under multiplication. Each non-identity element generates the group.

In abstract algebra, a generating set of a group is a subset of the group set such that every element of the group can be expressed as a combination (under the group operation) of finitely many elements of the subset and their inverses.

In other words, if is a subset of a group , then , the subgroup generated by , is the smallest subgroup of containing every element of , which is equal to the intersection over all subgroups containing the elements of ; equivalently, is the subgroup of all elements of that can be expressed as the finite product of elements in and their inverses. (Note that inverses are only needed if the group is infinite; in a finite group, the inverse of an element can be expressed as a power of that element.)

If , then we say that generates , and the elements in are called generators or group generators. If is the empty set, then is the trivial group , since we consider the empty product to be the identity.

When there is only a single element in , is usually written as . In this case, is the cyclic subgroup of the powers of , a cyclic group, and we say this group is generated by . Equivalent to saying an element generates a group is saying that equals the entire group . For finite groups, it is also equivalent to saying that has order .

A group may need an infinite number of generators. For example the additive group of rational numbers is not finitely generated. It is generated by the inverses of all the integers, but any finite number of these generators can be removed from the generating set without it ceasing to be a generating set. In a case like this, all the elements in a generating set are nevertheless "non-generating elements", as are in fact all the elements of the whole group − see Frattini subgroup below.

If is a topological group then a subset of is called a set of topological generators if is dense in , i.e. the closure of is the whole group .

Finitely generated group

[edit]

If is finite, then a group is called finitely generated. The structure of finitely generated abelian groups in particular is easily described. Many theorems that are true for finitely generated groups fail for groups in general. It has been proven that if a finite group is generated by a subset , then each group element may be expressed as a word from the alphabet of length less than or equal to the order of the group.

Every finite group is finitely generated since . The integers under addition are an example of an infinite group which is finitely generated by both 1 and −1, but the group of rationals under addition cannot be finitely generated. No uncountable group can be finitely generated. For example, the group of real numbers under addition, .

Different subsets of the same group can be generating subsets. For example, if and are integers with gcd(pq) = 1, then also generates the group of integers under addition by Bézout's identity.

While it is true that every quotient of a finitely generated group is finitely generated (the images of the generators in the quotient give a finite generating set), a subgroup of a finitely generated group need not be finitely generated. For example, let be the free group in two generators, and (which is clearly finitely generated, since ), and let be the subset consisting of all elements of of the form for some natural number . is isomorphic to the free group in countably infinitely many generators, and so cannot be finitely generated. However, every subgroup of a finitely generated abelian group is in itself finitely generated. In fact, more can be said: the class of all finitely generated groups is closed under extensions. To see this, take a generating set for the (finitely generated) normal subgroup and quotient. Then the generators for the normal subgroup, together with preimages of the generators for the quotient, generate the group.

Examples

[edit]
  • The multiplicative group of integers modulo 9, U9 = {1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 8}, is the group of all integers relatively prime to 9 under multiplication mod 9. Note that 7 is not a generator of U9, since
     
    while 2 is, since
     
  • On the other hand, Sn, the symmetric group of degree n, is not generated by any one element (is not cyclic) when n > 2. However, in these cases Sn can always be generated by two permutations which are written in cycle notation as (1 2) and (1 2 3 ... n). For example, the 6 elements of S3 can be generated from the two generators, (1 2) and (1 2 3), as shown by the right hand side of the following equations (composition is left-to-right):
e = (1 2)(1 2)
(1 2) = (1 2)
(1 3) = (1 2)(1 2 3)
(2 3) = (1 2 3)(1 2)
(1 2 3) = (1 2 3)
(1 3 2) = (1 2)(1 2 3)(1 2)
  • Infinite groups can also have finite generating sets. The additive group of integers has 1 as a generating set. The element 2 is not a generating set, as the odd numbers will be missing. The two-element subset {3, 5} is a generating set, since (−5) + 3 + 3 = 1 (in fact, any pair of coprime numbers is, as a consequence of Bézout's identity).
  • The dihedral group of an n-gon (which has order 2n) is generated by the set {r, s}, where r represents rotation by 2π/n and s is any reflection across a line of symmetry.[1]
  • The cyclic group of order , , and the th roots of unity are all generated by a single element (in fact, these groups are isomorphic to one another).[2]
  • A presentation of a group is defined as a set of generators and a collection of relations between them, so any of the examples listed on that page contain examples of generating sets.[3]

Free group

[edit]

The most general group generated by a set is the group freely generated by . Every group generated by is isomorphic to a quotient of this group, a feature which is utilized in the expression of a group's presentation.

Frattini subgroup

[edit]

An interesting companion topic is that of non-generators. An element of the group is a non-generator if every set containing that generates , still generates when is removed from . In the integers with addition, the only non-generator is 0. The set of all non-generators forms a subgroup of , the Frattini subgroup.

Semigroups and monoids

[edit]

If is a semigroup or a monoid, one can still use the notion of a generating set of . is a semigroup/monoid generating set of if is the smallest semigroup/monoid containing .

The definitions of generating set of a group using finite sums, given above, must be slightly modified when one deals with semigroups or monoids. Indeed, this definition should not use the notion of inverse operation anymore. The set is said to be a semigroup generating set of if each element of is a finite sum of elements of . Similarly, a set is said to be a monoid generating set of if each non-zero element of is a finite sum of elements of .

For example, {1} is a monoid generator of the set of natural numbers . The set {1} is also a semigroup generator of the positive natural numbers . However, the integer 0 can not be expressed as a (non-empty) sum of 1s, thus {1} is not a semigroup generator of the natural numbers.

Similarly, while {1} is a group generator of the set of integers , {1} is not a monoid generator of the set of integers. Indeed, the integer −1 cannot be expressed as a finite sum of 1s.

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
In group theory, a generating set for a group GG is a subset SGS \subseteq G such that every element of GG can be expressed as a finite product of elements from SS and their inverses. This concept is analogous to a spanning set in linear algebra, where the elements of SS, known as generators, collectively produce the entire group through repeated application of the group operation. The subgroup generated by SS, denoted S\langle S \rangle, is the smallest subgroup of GG containing SS, and SS is a generating set precisely when S=G\langle S \rangle = G. Generating sets are fundamental to understanding group structure, as they provide a way to describe complex groups in terms of simpler building blocks. A group is called finitely generated if it admits a finite generating set, a property that holds for many important groups such as the integers under addition or the symmetric group on nn letters, but not for all groups, like the rational numbers under addition. Finitely generated groups form a central class in the study of group theory, enabling techniques like presentations, where a group is specified by a finite set of generators and relations among them. The minimal number of generators required for a group GG, denoted d(G)d(G) or the rank of GG, is a key invariant that measures the "complexity" of GG's structure. For free abelian groups, this rank coincides with the dimension of QZG\mathbb{Q} \otimes_{\mathbb{Z}} G over Q\mathbb{Q}. For general finitely generated abelian groups with non-trivial torsion, d(G)d(G) exceeds the free rank, with the precise value depending on the structure of the torsion subgroup (e.g., the number of invariant factors in its decomposition). For non-abelian groups, it relates to concepts like Frattini subgroups, which consist of non-generators. Generating sets also underpin computational group theory, where algorithms rely on them to solve problems like the word problem or isomorphism testing in finitely presented groups.

Definitions and Properties

Generating Set

In group theory, a subset SS of a group GG is called a generating set for GG if every element of GG can be expressed as a finite product of elements from SS and their inverses. This means that starting from the elements of SS, one can reach any group element through successive multiplication and inversion operations. The subgroup generated by SS, denoted S\langle S \rangle, is the smallest subgroup of GG containing SS, consisting precisely of all such finite products. If S=G\langle S \rangle = G, then SS generates GG. Unlike a basis in the context of free groups, where the generators satisfy no nontrivial relations, a general generating set may involve relations among its elements, allowing for redundancies or dependencies that do not occur in free bases. Every group GG has a generating set, such as GG itself, and the empty set generates the trivial group containing only the identity element. A group is finitely generated if it admits a finite generating set. The concept of generating sets was formalized by Walther von Dyck in 1882, particularly in his work on free groups and abstract presentations of groups via generators and relations.

Minimal Generating Sets

A generating set SS of a group GG is minimal if it generates GG and no proper subset of SS generates GG. Equivalently, SS is called irredundant, meaning that omitting any single element from SS results in a subset that fails to generate the entire group GG. This irredundancy provides a characterization: for each sSs \in S, the element ss does not belong to the subgroup generated by S{s}S \setminus \{ s \}. Minimal generating sets exhibit a form of independence, where no element in the set can be expressed as a product of elements from the remaining set and their inverses. However, such sets are independent in the strong sense only in free groups; in general groups, minimality does not imply freeness, as relations among generators may exist. Every generating set of a group contains a minimal generating set. To see this, consider the collection of all subsets of a given generating set that still generate GG, partially ordered by reverse inclusion; any chain in this poset has a lower bound given by the intersection, and Zorn's lemma yields a minimal element under inclusion, which is a minimal generating set. For finite groups, this follows by iteratively removing redundant elements. Minimal generating sets are generally not unique, even up to cardinality, except in special cases like free groups where the rank equals the cardinality of any minimal generating set. For instance, the cyclic group Z/6Z\mathbb{Z}/6\mathbb{Z} has minimal generating sets of different sizes, such as the singleton {1}\{1\} and the set {2,3}\{2, 3\}. The quaternion group Q8Q_8 also admits multiple minimal generating sets, all of size 2, reflecting its non-abelian structure.

Finite Generation

Finitely Generated Groups

A group GG is finitely generated if there exists a finite subset SGS \subseteq G such that the subgroup generated by SS equals GG, denoted S=G\langle S \rangle = G with S<|S| < \infty. This property captures groups that can be constructed from a finite number of elements via the group operation, encompassing all finite groups and many infinite ones central to group theory. A fundamental structural result for this class is that every finitely generated abelian group decomposes as a direct sum of cyclic groups, either finite or infinite, according to the fundamental theorem of finitely generated abelian groups. In the non-abelian setting, finitely generated subgroups of free groups are free, a consequence of the Nielsen-Schreier theorem stating that every subgroup of a free group is free. However, not every subgroup of a finitely generated free group is finitely generated, as some have infinite rank. Free groups of finite rank illustrate infinite yet finitely generated groups, where the rank determines the minimal size of a generating set. The concept of finite generation in groups parallels Hilbert's basis theorem in ring theory, where polynomial rings over Noetherian rings inherit Noetherian properties (every ideal finitely generated); analogously, a Noetherian group is one where every subgroup is finitely generated.

Rank of a Finitely Generated Group

In group theory, the rank of a finitely generated group GG, denoted d(G)d(G), is defined as the smallest cardinality of a generating set for GG. This minimal number captures the "dimension-like" aspect of the group's generation, analogous to the dimension of a vector space. The rank d(G)=0d(G) = 0 if and only if GG is the trivial group, as the empty set generates the identity element alone. Several key properties of the rank follow from this definition. If HH is a homomorphic image of GG, then d(H)d(G)d(H) \leq d(G), since the image of any generating set of GG generates HH. For direct products of finitely generated groups with finite rank, d(G×H)d(G)+d(H)d(G \times H) \leq d(G) + d(H), reflecting the generation by combining generating sets from each factor. The rank is also invariant under group automorphisms, as an automorphism maps a minimal generating set to another generating set of the same cardinality. These properties highlight the rank's role in preserving structural information under basic group operations. For non-abelian free groups, the rank coincides with the number of elements in a basis, which forms a minimal generating set; any generating set with fewer elements fails to span the free structure. In the context of free products, the rank of the free product FmFnF_m * F_n of two free groups of ranks mm and nn is m+nm + n, as the bases freely combine without relations, though related considerations arise in the Burnside problem regarding finite presentations of such products. This underscores the rank's utility in classifying generation within free and product constructions.

Examples

Cyclic Groups

A cyclic group is a group that can be generated by a single element. Formally, if GG is a group and there exists gGg \in G such that G=g={gkkZ}G = \langle g \rangle = \{ g^k \mid k \in \mathbb{Z} \}, then GG is cyclic, with gg serving as a generator. The infinite cyclic group is isomorphic to the additive group of integers Z\mathbb{Z}, generated by $1,whileafinitecyclicgroupoforder, while a finite cyclic group of order nisisomorphictois isomorphic to\mathbb{Z}/n\mathbb{Z}, generated by &#36;1 modulo nn. In a cyclic group G=gG = \langle g \rangle, the singleton set {g}\{g\} forms a generating set provided the order of gg equals the order of GG; for finite cyclic groups of order nn, any element whose order is nn—specifically, those coprime to nn—can serve as a generator. Larger generating sets are possible, such as {gkgcd(k,n)=1}\{g^k \mid \gcd(k, n) = 1\} for finite cases, but the minimal generating set consists of a single element. Non-trivial cyclic groups have rank $1, meaning the smallest generating set has cardinality &#36;1, and the rank of Z\mathbb{Z} is $1$. Cyclic groups admit straightforward presentations in terms of generators and relations: the infinite cyclic group is presented as x\langle x \mid \rangle, while the finite cyclic group of order nn is presented as xxn=e\langle x \mid x^n = e \rangle, where ee is the identity. Every subgroup of a cyclic group is itself cyclic, generated by a power of the original generator. For instance, every subgroup of Z\mathbb{Z} is cyclic, taking the form nZn\mathbb{Z} generated by the integer n0n \geq 0.

Symmetric Groups

The symmetric group SnS_n on nn letters is the group of all permutations of a set with nn elements, and it is generated by the set of all transpositions (ij)(i\, j) for 1i<jn1 \leq i < j \leq n, which has cardinality n(n1)2\frac{n(n-1)}{2}. This generating set consists entirely of elements of order 2, and any permutation in SnS_n can be expressed as a product of these transpositions, though not uniquely. Minimal generating sets for SnS_n are of particular interest. While the full set of transpositions has size n(n1)2\frac{n(n-1)}{2}, smaller generating sets exist; for instance, SnS_n is generated by the n1n-1 adjacent transpositions (12),(23),,(n1n)(1\, 2), (2\, 3), \dots, (n-1\, n). For n3n \geq 3, the minimal number of generators, known as the rank of SnS_n, is 2; a concrete example is the set {(12),(12n)}\{(1\, 2), (1\, 2\, \dots\, n)\}, where the first element is a transposition and the second is an nn-cycle. A key result characterizes generating sets consisting solely of transpositions: SnS_n is generated by a set of transpositions if and only if the underlying graph—whose vertices are the nn letters and edges correspond to the transposed pairs—is connected. This implies that at least n1n-1 transpositions are needed for such a generating set, as a connected graph on nn vertices requires at least n1n-1 edges. The adjacent transpositions also admit a presentation as a Coxeter group, known as the Coxeter presentation of SnS_n: s1,s2,,sn1si2=1,(sisj)2=1 for ij2,(sisi+1)3=1 for 1in2,\langle s_1, s_2, \dots, s_{n-1} \mid s_i^2 = 1, \, (s_i s_j)^2 = 1 \text{ for } |i-j| \geq 2, \, (s_i s_{i+1})^3 = 1 \text{ for } 1 \leq i \leq n-2 \rangle, where si=(ii+1)s_i = (i\, i+1). This presentation highlights the reflection group structure of SnS_n, with the relations encoding the geometry of the associated Coxeter diagram of type An1A_{n-1}. For the infinite symmetric group Sym(Ω)\mathrm{Sym}(\Omega) on a countably infinite set Ω\Omega, no finite generating set exists, as the group is uncountable while any finitely generated group must be countable. In particular, it cannot be generated by finitely many transpositions. The subgroup of finitary permutations (those moving only finitely many elements) is countable and generated by the infinite set of all transpositions.

Free Groups

Free Groups on a Set

The free group on a set SS, denoted FSF_S, is defined as the group generated by the elements of SS subject only to the relations that each generator has an inverse and the group axioms hold, with no additional relations imposed among the generators. This makes FSF_S the "freest" possible group with SS as a generating set, where the elements of SS act independently except for the necessary inverse pairings. Formally, SS serves as a free basis for FSF_S, ensuring that the only way to obtain the identity is through the trivial combinations dictated by the group operation. A key characterizing feature of the free group FSF_S is its universal property. For any group HH and any function f:SHf: S \to H, there exists a unique group homomorphism ϕ:FSH\phi: F_S \to H such that the diagram commutes, meaning ϕ\phi extends ff on SS. This property underscores the role of FSF_S as the initial object in the category of groups generated by a set isomorphic to SS, allowing any assignment of images to the generators in SS to lift uniquely to a homomorphism from FSF_S. Consequently, free groups provide a universal construction for studying groups via their generating sets, as any group generated by a set mapping to SS arises as a quotient of FSF_S by some normal subgroup. Elements of FSF_S are represented as finite reduced words over the alphabet SS1S \cup S^{-1}, where S1={s1sS}S^{-1} = \{s^{-1} \mid s \in S\} and a word is reduced if it contains no subword of the form ss1ss^{-1} or s1ss^{-1}s for any sSs \in S. The group operation is concatenation of words followed by free reduction to eliminate adjacent inverse pairs, ensuring each non-empty reduced word corresponds to a unique non-identity element. The empty word represents the identity element. This word model highlights the absence of relations, as distinct reduced words yield distinct group elements, and the generating set SS freely combines without cancellation beyond inverses. If SS is finite and non-empty, then FSF_S is an infinite group, as the set of reduced words of arbitrary length grows without bound. The rank of FSF_S, defined as the cardinality of a minimal generating set, equals S|S|, making SS a basis of that size. The concept of free groups was introduced by Jakob Nielsen in his 1921 paper in Mathematisk Tidsskrift, where he established foundational properties for finitely generated free groups and proved that finitely generated subgroups of free groups are free. Otto Schreier extended this work in 1926, proving the full Nielsen-Schreier theorem that every subgroup of a free group is free, regardless of generation, and providing an index formula relating ranks. These developments solidified free groups as a cornerstone of combinatorial group theory.

Basis for Free Groups

In a free group FF, a basis is a generating set XX such that FF is freely generated by XX, meaning every element of FF can be uniquely represented as a reduced word in the elements of XX1X \cup X^{-1}, where reduced words have no cancellations like xx1xx^{-1} or x1xx^{-1}x for xXx \in X. This ensures no nontrivial relations hold among the generators beyond the group operation, distinguishing bases from mere generating sets. The free group on XX is the universal object mapping XX injectively into any group while preserving the group structure. The cardinality of any basis for a free group FF, known as the rank of FF, is unique; that is, any two bases of FF have the same number of elements. This invariance follows from the Nielsen-Schreier theorem, which states that every subgroup of a free group is free and provides a formula for the rank of such subgroups: if FF has rank nn and HH is a subgroup of finite index mm, then the rank of HH is 1+m(n1)1 + m(n-1). For FF itself, this implies basis equivalence in cardinality, with the theorem originally proved by Nielsen for finitely generated cases and extended by Schreier. Nielsen transformations provide a method to convert one basis of a free group into another through elementary operations on generating sets. These include: (1) replacing a generator xix_i with its inverse xi1x_i^{-1}; (2) interchanging two generators xix_i and xjx_j; and (3) replacing a generator xix_i with a product xixjx_i x_j or xjxix_j x_i, followed by possible reindexing. Any finite generating set can be transformed into a basis via a finite sequence of these transformations, and two bases are equivalent if one can be obtained from the other by such operations. This process, introduced by Nielsen, generates the automorphism group of the free group and is fundamental for simplifying presentations. The Schreier transversal method constructs an explicit basis for a subgroup HH of a free group FF with basis XX. Given a transversal {uuF/H}\{u \mid u \in F/H\} consisting of coset representatives (chosen as shortest reduced words, for example), the Schreier generators are defined as su,x=uxv1s_{u,x} = u \cdot x \cdot v^{-1}, where uu ranges over the transversal, xXX1x \in X \cup X^{-1}, and vv is the representative of the coset uxHu x H. The set of nontrivial such su,xs_{u,x} (after reduction) forms a basis for HH, with redundancy removable via Nielsen transformations. This combinatorial construction proves the freeness of HH and enables explicit computation. Finding a basis for a finitely generated subgroup of a free group is algorithmically decidable, relying on the solvability of the word problem in free groups. The word problem is resolved by the free reduction algorithm: given a word in the generators, repeatedly cancel adjacent inverse pairs until no further reductions are possible; the word represents the identity if and only if it reduces to the empty word. Using this, one can enumerate cosets via breadth-first search to build a Schreier transversal, compute the generators, and apply Nielsen transformations to obtain a basis, all in finite time for finite rank cases.

Advanced Topics

Frattini Subgroup

The Frattini subgroup of a group GG, denoted Φ(G)\Phi(G), is defined as the intersection of all maximal subgroups of GG; if GG has no maximal subgroups, then Φ(G)=G\Phi(G) = G. Equivalently, Φ(G)\Phi(G) consists of all non-generators of GG, meaning the elements gGg \in G such that, for any generating set SGS \subseteq G containing gg, the set S{g}S \setminus \{g\} still generates GG. This equivalence, known as Frattini's theorem, highlights the role of Φ(G)\Phi(G) in identifying superfluous elements within generating sets. Φ(G)\Phi(G) is a characteristic subgroup of GG, invariant under all automorphisms, and fully invariant under endomorphisms. It is also verbal, belonging to every variety of groups containing GG. For a finite pp-group PP, Φ(P)=PPp\Phi(P) = P' P^p, where PP' is the derived subgroup and PpP^p is the subgroup generated by all pp-th powers of elements in PP; consequently, P/Φ(P)P / \Phi(P) is an elementary abelian pp-group. A key theorem states that a subset SGS \subseteq G generates GG if and only if the image of SS in the quotient G/Φ(G)G / \Phi(G) generates G/Φ(G)G / \Phi(G). This implies that the minimal number of generators d(G)d(G) of GG equals d(G/Φ(G))d(G / \Phi(G)), providing a way to determine the rank by examining the simpler quotient structure. For the free group FnF_n of rank n2n \geq 2, the Frattini subgroup is trivial, Φ(Fn)={e}\Phi(F_n) = \{e\}, and thus Fn/Φ(Fn)FnF_n / \Phi(F_n) \cong F_n. This reflects that free groups are Frattini-free, meaning they have no non-trivial non-generators.

Generating Sets in Extensions and Quotients

In group quotients, if SS is a generating set for a group GG, then the image π(S)\pi(S) under the natural projection π:GG/N\pi: G \to G/N (for normal subgroup NGN \trianglelefteq G) generates the quotient G/NG/N. Consequently, the minimal number of generators satisfies d(G/N)d(G)d(G/N) \leq d(G), though this number may decrease; for instance, the symmetric group S3S_3 has d(S3)=2d(S_3) = 2, but the quotient S3/A3C2S_3 / A_3 \cong C_2 has d(C2)=1d(C_2) = 1. The minimal number cannot increase, as the image of any generating set for GG generates G/NG/N. In group extensions given by a short exact sequence 1NGQ11 \to N \to G \to Q \to 1, the minimal number of generators satisfies d(G)d(N)+d(Q)d(G) \leq d(N) + d(Q). To see this, let SS generate NN and TT generate QQ; choose lifts T~\tilde{T} of elements of TT to GG. The set ST~S \cup \tilde{T} generates GG, since T~N=G\langle \tilde{T} \rangle N = G (as π(T~)=Q\pi(\langle \tilde{T} \rangle) = Q) and NN is normal, so conjugates of elements of S=N\langle S \rangle = N by elements of T~\langle \tilde{T} \rangle lie in NN and generate NN, ensuring NST~N \subseteq \langle S \cup \tilde{T} \rangle. Equality holds in split extensions under suitable conditions, such as when the complement isomorphic to QQ requires no additional relations with NN to achieve minimality, as in the semidirect product C3C4C_3 \rtimes C_4 where d(G)=2=d(N)+d(Q)=1+1d(G) = 2 = d(N) + d(Q) = 1 + 1. Generators of the quotient QQ lift to a generating set for GG precisely when the extension splits, in which case a section s:QGs: Q \to G provides lifts s(T)s(T) generating a complement to NN; combined with generators of NN, this yields a generating set for GG. In non-split extensions, such as central extensions like the quaternion group Q8Q_8 with N=1C2N = \langle -1 \rangle \cong C_2 and QC2×C2Q \cong C_2 \times C_2, lifts alone do not suffice to generate GG without including elements from NN, though the overall inequality still holds with d(Q8)=2<d(N)+d(Q)=3d(Q_8) = 2 < d(N) + d(Q) = 3. A key result due to Gaschütz provides conditions under which equality d(G)=max(d(N),d(Q))d(G) = \max(d(N), d(Q)) holds for finite groups. Specifically, Gaschütz's lemma states that if NN is an elementary abelian pp-group for prime pp, then there exists a generating set XX for GG such that the images of XX generate QQ and the pp-th powers of XX generate NN; this implies d(G)=d(Q)d(G) = d(Q) when pp does not divide Q|Q|, or more generally d(G)=max(d(N),d(Q))d(G) = \max(d(N), d(Q)) if the extension allows minimal overlap in generation. For example, in finite soluble groups, this lemma ensures the rank is controlled by the larger of the two when the kernel's structure aligns with the action. In applications to finite pp-groups, generating sets in the chief factors determine the overall rank d(G)d(G), which equals the dimension of G/Φ(G)G / \Phi(G) as an Fp\mathbb{F}_p-vector space; since chief factors are elementary abelian and the Frattini quotient G/Φ(G)G / \Phi(G) is the bottom chief factor in the chief series, the ranks of these factors (particularly the maximal one) bound and often equal d(G)d(G), as seen in extraspecial pp-groups where d(G)d(G) matches the rank of the largest chief factor. This structure aids in computing ranks via chief series decompositions.

Generalizations

Generating Sets in Semigroups

In a semigroup TT, a nonempty subset STS \subseteq T is a generating set for TT if every element of TT can be expressed as a finite product of elements from SS. Unlike in groups, where inverses allow for more flexible combinations, generation in semigroups relies solely on the associative operation to form products without cancellation or reversal. The subsemigroup generated by SS, denoted S\langle S \rangle, is the smallest subsemigroup of TT containing SS and consists of all finite nonempty products of elements from SS. Properties of generating sets in semigroups differ markedly from those in groups due to the potential lack of cancellativity. In noncancellative semigroups, distinct products from SS may represent the same element, leading to relations that collapse the free structure, but S\langle S \rangle still equals TT by definition if SS generates TT. For instance, if cancellativity fails, multiple words over SS might yield the same product, complicating uniqueness but not the generation itself. Groups serve as a special case where the presence of inverses expands the generated structure beyond positive products alone. Finitely generated semigroups, those with a finite generating set, encompass important examples like free semigroups, where the free semigroup on a finite set XX is generated precisely by XX and consists of all nonempty finite words over XX under concatenation, with no relations imposed. Rees's theorem provides insight into ideal structures, stating that every completely 0-simple semigroup is isomorphic to a Rees matrix semigroup over a group with zero adjoined. In cancellative semigroups, generating sets connect to broader structures via the group of fractions. A relative generating set for a semigroup TT modulo a subsemigroup GG is a set AA such that AG=T\langle A \cup G \rangle = T; for cancellative TT embeddable in its group of fractions FF (under Ore conditions), a generating set SS of TT is relative to FF if SS generates FF as a group, meaning elements of SS and their formal inverses span FF. For example, the semigroup (N,+)(\mathbb{N}, +) of natural numbers under addition is generated by {1}\{1\}, and its group of fractions is (Z,+)(\mathbb{Z}, +), where {1}\{1\} relatively generates Z\mathbb{Z} via positives and negatives.

Generating Sets in Monoids

In a monoid MM with identity element ee, a subset SMS \subseteq M is said to generate MM if every element of MM can be expressed as a finite (possibly empty) product of elements from SS, with the empty product defined as ee. The submonoid generated by SS, denoted S\langle S \rangle, is the smallest submonoid of MM containing SS; it consists of ee together with all finite non-empty products of elements from SS. A key property of the submonoid generated by SS is that it always includes the identity ee, distinguishing monoids from semigroups, which lack a required identity. Finitely generated monoids admit presentations via a finite set of generators and a set of relations, where the monoid is the quotient of the free monoid on those generators by the congruence generated by the relations. In commutative monoids, the minimal cardinality of a generating set is termed the rank of the monoid. For numerical semigroups—cofinite additive submonoids of the non-negative integers—this minimal cardinality is known as the embedding dimension; for instance, the numerical semigroup generated by {2, 3} has embedding dimension 2, as no proper subset generates it. A fundamental result is that every monoid is a homomorphic image of a free monoid, obtained by quotienting the free monoid on the underlying set of the monoid by the appropriate kernel congruence. As an example, consider the monoid (N0,+)(\mathbb{N}_0, +) of non-negative integers under addition, with identity 0; it is generated by the singleton set {1}, since every nN0n \in \mathbb{N}_0 is the sum of nn copies of 1 (or 0 as the empty sum), and unlike the group Z\mathbb{Z}, elements lack additive inverses.

References

  1. https://groupprops.subwiki.org/wiki/Finitely_generated_group
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.