Hubbry Logo
Charlie Falconer, Baron Falconer of ThorotonCharlie Falconer, Baron Falconer of ThorotonMain
Open search
Charlie Falconer, Baron Falconer of Thoroton
Community hub
Charlie Falconer, Baron Falconer of Thoroton
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Charlie Falconer, Baron Falconer of Thoroton
Charlie Falconer, Baron Falconer of Thoroton
from Wikipedia

Charles Leslie Falconer, Baron Falconer of Thoroton, PC, KC (born 19 November 1951) is a British Labour politician, peer and barrister who served as Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice[a] under Prime Minister Tony Blair from 2003 to 2007.

Key Information

Born in Edinburgh, Falconer read law at Queens' College, Cambridge and then worked as a barrister in London. During his time as a barrister, he was a flatmate of Tony Blair. Although Blair went into politics, Falconer focused on his legal career and became a Queen's Counsel. After Blair was elected as Prime Minister, Falconer was created a life peer and made Solicitor General for England and Wales. He is the only known person to have served as Solicitor General as a peer. Later, he served successively as Minister of State for the Cabinet Office, Minister of State for Housing, Planning and Regeneration and Minister of State for Criminal Justice, Sentencing and Law Reform.

In 2003, Falconer became the Lord Chancellor and the first Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs. He went on to become the first Secretary of State for Justice in a 2007 reorganisation and enlargement of the portfolio of the Department for Constitutional Affairs, and held this role for over a month until Gordon Brown became Prime Minister in June 2007. Falconer was named Shadow Justice Secretary under the acting leadership of Harriet Harman in 2015, and continued in this role after the election of Jeremy Corbyn as leader of the party, until he resigned on 26 June 2016. He was appointed as Shadow Attorney General in the Shadow Cabinet of Keir Starmer in April 2020, and stepped down from the role in November 2021.

Early life and career

[edit]

Charles Leslie Falconer was born in Edinburgh, Scotland, on 19 November 1951, the son of John Leslie Falconer, a solicitor, and his wife Anne Mansel.[1] His paternal grandfather was John Ireland Falconer, a former Lord Provost of Edinburgh.[2] Falconer was educated at the Edinburgh Academy and Trinity College, Glenalmond.[1] He read law at Queens' College, Cambridge.

Falconer became a flatmate of Tony Blair when they were both young barristers in London in the late 1970s in Wandsworth, having first met as pupils at rival Scottish schools in the 1960s. While Blair went into politics, Falconer concentrated on his legal career. He practised from Fountain Court Chambers in London, and became a Queen's Counsel in 1991.[3]

Falconer applied to be the Labour candidate for the safe seat of Dudley North ahead of the 1997 general election, but he "fluffed" his interview with the Labour constituency committee by refusing to take his four children out of public schools. Barrister Ross Cranston was selected instead and won the seat, holding it from 1997 to 2005. Cranston succeeded Falconer as Solicitor General for England and Wales, serving from 1998 to 2001.[4]

Ennoblement and junior ministerial career

[edit]

On 14 May 1997, just after Blair became Prime Minister, Falconer was created a life peer as Baron Falconer of Thoroton, of Thoroton in the County of Nottinghamshire.[5] He was the first peer created on the new Prime Minister's recommendation, and immediately joined the government as Solicitor General.

Falconer became Minister of State at the Cabinet Office in 1998, taking over responsibility for the Millennium Dome following the resignation of Peter Mandelson. He acquired the nickname of "Dome Secretary" (a play on the position of Home Secretary) over time. He was heavily criticised for the failure of the Dome to attract an audience, but resisted calls for his resignation. This was in contrast to the sacking of Dome chief executive Jennie Page just one month after the fiasco of the New Millennium eve opening night.

Following the 2001 election, Falconer joined the Department for Transport, Local Government and the Regions as Minister for Housing, Planning and Regeneration. He moved on to the Home Office in 2002, being given responsibility for criminal justice, sentencing and law reform. He reportedly annoyed some of his fellow lawyers by suggesting that their fees were too high.

Cabinet minister, 2003–2007

[edit]

In 2003 Falconer joined the Cabinet as the Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs, becoming also Lord Chancellor "for the interim period" before the office was planned to be abolished. The government argued that the position of a cabinet minister as a judge and head of the judiciary was no longer appropriate and would not be upheld by the European Convention on Human Rights.

The announcement was generally seen as a rushed "back-of-an-envelope" plan. There had been no Green paper discussions nor White paper proposals; and it became something of a shock to realise that the proposed abolition of the office of Lord Chancellor would require primary legislation. The policy of removing the Lord Chancellor's judicial role was said to be disliked by Lord Irvine of Lairg, the previous Lord Chancellor.

The post of Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs took over the remaining responsibilities of the Lord Chancellor, and also became the sponsoring department for the Secretary of State for Wales and the Secretary of State for Scotland. Falconer announced his intention not to use the Lord Chancellor's power to sit as a judge and stopped wearing the traditional robe and wig of office. Falconer hoped to be the last to hold the title, ending 1,400 years of tradition.

However, in 2006 Falconer told the House of Lords Constitution Committee that he regretted campaigning for the abolition of the role of Lord Chancellor and was glad the title had been reserved. In his opinion, the office "still had a role to play in defending the independence of the courts."[6]

Freedom of Information Act

[edit]

In his role as Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs, Falconer sought to make it easier for government bodies to refuse to release documents under the Freedom of Information Act (2000), on the grounds that they are too expensive and too time-consuming for civil servants to find. The legislation allowed requests for information to be refused if the cost they would incur exceeded £600 for Whitehall and £450 for other public bodies. Falconer proposed changes that would make no difference to this level, but would expand the number of activities whose cost would be included in the totals, thus making it easier for government parties to refuse requests for information. At the end of March 2007, Falconer's department announced that it would not introduce the proposals to parliament, but would instead have a second three-month consultation with the public (the previous consultation, also of three months, ended three weeks previous to this). Media elements reported this change as a 'backtracking', and Maurice Frankel, director of the Campaign for Freedom of Information, was quoted as saying "This raises the strong possibility that the government will decide to leave the current arrangements untouched".[7]

Later parliamentary career, 2007–

[edit]
Official Parliamentary Portrait in May 2018 by Chris McAndrew

Falconer was replaced in his ministerial posts by Jack Straw in Gordon Brown's inaugural cabinet reshuffle, with Straw becoming the first non-Member of the House of Lords to take up the office of Lord Chancellor.

In February 2008, Falconer told a BBC radio programme that the government should require certain news articles to be removed from online archives during sensitive trials.[8] This move was questioned as the articles were readily available in printed newspapers and other physical media, presenting a possible misunderstanding of the internet as a medium.[8]

On 7 June 2009, while being interviewed by the BBC Politics Show, Falconer called for an urgent debate on Gordon Brown's leadership, as Labour braced itself for "terrible" election results at the 2009 European Parliament Elections, following being "humiliated" at the 2009 County Council elections. He said he was "not sure" Labour could unite while Brown remained leader, arguing "can we get unity under the current leadership? I am not sure that we can and we need to debate it urgently and I think probably it will need a change in leader." He said he admired Gordon Brown "greatly" but said he had an "inability to hold the party together".[9]

In 2014, Falconer proposed the Assisted Dying Bill to the House of Lords, which seeks to legalise euthanasia in the UK for those who have less than six months to live, building on the experience of the Oregon Death with Dignity Act.[10]

Falconer was named Shadow Secretary of State for Justice under the acting leadership of Harriet Harman in 2015, and continued in this role after the election of Jeremy Corbyn as leader of the party, until—along with dozens of his colleagues—he resigned on 26 June 2016.[11][12] He was appointed Shadow Attorney General in the Starmer shadow cabinet on 6 April 2020, but stepped down following a shadow cabinet reshuffle in November 2021.[13]

In 2018, he apologised for his role as Lord Chancellor in the war on drugs, and now thought drug prohibition had been a "tragic disaster" for the poor worldwide. He thought governments should take control of drug supply, thus reducing the involvement of violent gangs, and proposed that the legal regulation of drug production and supply should be in the next Labour manifesto.[14]

Extraparliamentary activities

[edit]

Since leaving office, Falconer has gone on to hold various positions outside Parliament. On 22 May 2008, it was announced that he had been appointed as Chairman of the AmicusHorizon Group Limited, a Registered Social Landlord.[15]

On 8 July 2008, Falconer joined US law firm Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher as a senior counsel,[16] where he remained as late as April 2021.[17] At this time, the Greensill scandal caused controversy over his advice to extramural firms in relation to the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK, which he once called "the gift that keeps on giving" for lawyers; however, he regretted saying this.[17]

From 2022 to 2025, Falconer served as Chair of the London Drugs Commission, set up by Mayor of London Sadiq Khan to consider possible reforms to the UK's cannabis policy.[18]

Personal life

[edit]

He married Marianna Catherine Thoroton Hildyard,[19] a barrister, in 1985. She became a QC in 2002.[20] Hildyard is a Circuit Judge, known as Her Honour Judge Hildyard KC, and the Designated Family Judge for Luton.[21] Her father, Sir David Henry Thoroton Hildyard (grandson of Gen. Sir Henry John Thoroton Hildyard), was the British Ambassador to Chile and her brother, Sir Robert Henry Thoroton Hildyard, is a High Court Judge. They have four children: Hamish, William "Rocco", Rosie and Johnny. Falconer placed his three sons at independent Westminster School and St Paul's School, and his daughter at South Hampstead High School.[22] In the lead-up to the 1997 election, as he attempted to be selected for the seat of Dudley East, it proved to be an electoral problem for Falconer. He intended to keep his children at Westminster if selected, which caused the local selection panel to drop him from the selection procedure.[23]

He and his family own a house and a basement flat in Islington. They also own a country retreat in Thoroton, Nottinghamshire. Falconer's father used to live in the village, and they rent out his old home.

Falconer was chairman of Cambridge University Amnesty International between 2006 and 2007, and is the director of Sudan Divestment.[24] He is chairman of the board for a social enterprise set up at Pentonville Prison, Liberty Kitchen.[25]

Falconer lost over five stone between 2012 and 2014, consuming only Diet Coke and apples apart from dinner, eschewing tea, coffee and alcohol, and jogging for 45 minutes a day.[26]

In the general election in July 2024, his son Hamish was elected as MP for Lincoln.[27]

Arms

[edit]
Coat of arms of Charlie Falconer, Baron Falconer of Thoroton
Notes
Displayed on a gilded ceiling panel in the House of Lords.[28]
Crest
A falcon Or supporting with the dexter claws a pilgrim's pikestaff connected by a chain Argent to a ring around the sinister leg also Argent.
Escutcheon
Per pale Or and Argent two barrulets per pale Ermine and Erminois over all a falcon's head erased Azure grasping in the beak pendent a Mediterranean sweet briar rose affronty Proper slipped Sable all between three mullets Azure.
Supporters
On either side a falcon Or murally gorged Argent masoned Sable the exterior leg of each falcon standing on a bugle horn Azure banded Argent the bell inwards that to the dexter with a round buckle Or attached to the collar by a line Azure and that to the sinister with a falcon's bell attached to the collar by a line Azure.[29]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
Charles Leslie Falconer, Baron Falconer of Thoroton PC KC (born 1951), is a British Labour Party politician, , and who served as the last of the from 2003 to 2007 and briefly as the inaugural in 2007. Born in , Falconer pursued a career as a commercial in , where he shared a flat with future in the 1970s, forging a close personal and political alliance that propelled his entry into government upon Labour's 1997 election victory. Ennobled as a in 1997, he held junior ministerial roles before his appointment to the Cabinet, overseeing significant constitutional reforms including the abolition of the traditional Lord Chancellor's office, the establishment of the UK Supreme Court, and the creation of the to modernize judicial selection. As Lord Chancellor, Falconer implemented the , which separated the roles of head of the judiciary and government minister, a change critics argued diminished the office's historical independence while proponents viewed it as essential for upholding judicial impartiality amid executive dominance. His tenure also advanced the unification of courts, prisons, and justice policy under one department, aiming to streamline administration but facing scrutiny over and . Post-government, Falconer has remained active in the , notably sponsoring private member's bills to legalize for terminally ill adults, efforts that highlight ongoing debates over , safeguards, and potential risks of in end-of-life choices. These initiatives, reintroduced periodically since 2014, reflect his commitment to reform, though they have drawn opposition from those emphasizing alternatives and ethical concerns about state-sanctioned death.

Early life and education

Family background and upbringing

Charles Leslie Falconer was born on 19 November 1951 in , , into a middle-class family with legal ties. His father, John Leslie Falconer, was a solicitor based in Edinburgh's Morningside district, reflecting a professional background in the legal field common to the city's establishment circles. His mother was Anne Falconer. Falconer grew up with one brother and one sister, though a second sister passed away after a prolonged illness around 1999. The family's circumstances provided a stable, professional environment in post-war , where parental emphasis on education steered Falconer toward independent schooling from an early age, indicative of aspirations aligned with Scotland's meritocratic legal and administrative traditions. This upbringing in a solicitor's household likely fostered an early familiarity with legal principles and , though Falconer himself pursued a distinct path in rather than the familial solicitor practice.

Academic and early professional influences

Falconer received his secondary education at Trinity College, Glenalmond, a boarding school in Scotland, before proceeding to Queens' College, Cambridge, where he read law and graduated in 1973. His Cambridge studies emphasized traditional legal doctrines and analytical reasoning, equipping him with the intellectual framework for a career at the Bar, though specific academic mentors or pivotal coursework influences remain undocumented in primary records. Upon graduation, Falconer was called to the Bar by the in 1974 and commenced practice as a commercial in , focusing on Chancery and commercial disputes. This early immersion in high-stakes litigation honed his advocacy skills, with contemporaries noting his rapid ascent due to a sharp, pragmatic approach to complex cases rather than reliance on academic prestige. By 1991, at age 39, he took silk as Queen's , an unusually early elevation reflecting professional recognition of his courtroom effectiveness and client earnings exceeding £500,000 annually. A key early professional connection was his friendship with , forged during school years in and sustained through shared lodgings in during their nascent barrister phases in the mid-1970s. This association exposed Falconer to Blair's political ambitions amid legal practice, subtly shifting his focus from pure advocacy toward broader constitutional and policy-oriented legal thinking, though Falconer maintained a commercially oriented caseload without notable litigation in these years.

Barrister practice and key cases

Falconer was called to the Bar by the in July 1974. Between 1974 and 1997, he practiced as a commercial , pupilling and working at Fountain Court Chambers in , a set renowned for its expertise in commercial disputes and . His work focused on complex commercial litigation, though specific cases from this period remain largely undocumented in public records due to the confidential nature of much commercial practice. Falconer was appointed Queen's Counsel in 1991, reflecting his standing in the field. Contemporaries noted his substantial earnings from this practice, which he relinquished upon entering in 1997, representing a significant financial sacrifice. No particularly high-profile or landmark cases are publicly associated with his pre-political career, consistent with the often private resolution of commercial matters at the commercial bar.

Association with Tony Blair

Falconer first met during their school years in , establishing a personal friendship that persisted into their professional lives. By 1976, both had qualified as barristers and worked in the same chambers, with Blair temporarily residing in Falconer's flat during the late in . This period marked the early stages of their legal careers, where Falconer focused on practice while Blair began transitioning toward political involvement. As pursued a parliamentary seat, winning election as MP for in 1983, Falconer remained at the Bar, building a successful practice that culminated in his appointment as Queen's Counsel in 1991, at which point he earned approximately £500,000 annually. Their association during this era was primarily social and rooted in shared living arrangements rather than joint professional endeavors, though it laid the foundation for Falconer's later political roles under Blair's premiership. No records indicate collaborative legal cases between them, with Falconer's career emphasizing independent commercial litigation.

Entry into politics

Ennoblement and initial Labour roles

Following the Labour Party's in the 1997 on 1 May, which elevated to , Falconer—a longtime personal friend and former flatmate of from their barrister days—was granted a life peerage. He was created Baron Falconer of Thoroton, of Thoroton in the County of , enabling his introduction to the and eligibility for ministerial office without prior parliamentary experience. This rapid ennoblement, one of several for 's close associates, underscored the new government's reliance on trusted non-politicians for legal and administrative roles, bypassing traditional routes through elected positions. Falconer's initial Labour role was as , appointed in May 1997 alongside the Attorney General, , to provide legal advice to the government and represent it in court proceedings. In this junior law officer position, which lasted until 1998, he focused on supporting the administration's early legislative agenda, including constitutional reforms, while leveraging his commercial background as Queen's Counsel since 1991. The appointment highlighted Blair's strategy of placing legal experts in advisory roles to navigate the complexities of and incorporation under the European Convention.

Junior ministerial positions (1997–2003)

Following the Labour Party's victory in the 1997 general election, Falconer was appointed on 6 May 1997, serving until 28 July 1998. In this role within the Law Officers' Department, he provided legal advice to the government and handled prosecutions in high-profile cases, including contributing to the Law Officers Act 1997, which adjusted the salaries and appointments of law officers. On 28 July 1998, Falconer transitioned to at the , a position he held until 11 June 2001. There, he oversaw aspects of modernization and the "Better Government" initiative aimed at improving policy coordination across departments. Notably, he assumed responsibility for the project after the resignation of in 1998, managing its development and operations amid escalating costs that reached £789 million by completion, drawing criticism for financial mismanagement despite its role as a flagship millennium celebration. After the 2001 general election, Falconer was appointed Minister of State for Housing, Planning and Regeneration at the , Local Government and the Regions on 8 June 2001, serving until 28 May 2002. His duties included advancing urban regeneration policies and sustainable housing initiatives, such as supporting the Urban 's emphasis on mixed-tenure developments to address in deprived areas. Falconer then moved to the as for the System on 29 May 2002, remaining until 12 June 2003. In this capacity, he focused on sentencing reforms and proposals, contributing to early development of the government's criminal justice agenda, including consultations on reducing reoffending rates through community penalties and preparatory work for the 2003 .

Cabinet roles under Tony Blair (2003–2007)

Appointment as Lord Chancellor

On 12 June 2003, Prime Minister appointed Charlie Falconer as and the first Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs, following the abrupt resignation of Lord Irvine of Lairg from the . This appointment occurred amid Blair's broader constitutional reform agenda, which sought to separate the judiciary from the executive by abolishing the traditional role as head of the judiciary and creating a new , while transferring judicial administration to a dedicated Department for Constitutional Affairs headed by Falconer. Falconer's selection drew criticism for perceived , as he had been Blair's flatmate in the 1970s and lacked the conventional judicial experience typically expected of Lord Chancellors, who historically were senior judges rather than political appointees or without bench time. Critics, including opposition figures and constitutional experts, argued that elevating a close personal ally to oversee sweeping changes to Britain's unwritten constitution undermined institutional independence and resembled executive overreach akin to presidential appointments. Despite this, Falconer's legal background as a and prior ministerial roles in housing (2001) and (2002–2003) positioned him to implement the government's timetable, which included consultations on the Lord Chancellor's future and legislative proposals for judicial restructuring. The appointment effectively made Falconer the custodian of the Lord Chancellor's office during its transitional phase, with his dual role emphasizing the new department's focus on constitutional matters over traditional judicial oversight, a shift that required parliamentary approval through subsequent bills like the Constitutional Reform Act 2005. While mainstream media outlets reported the move as part of Blair's modernization drive, conservative commentators highlighted risks to judicial impartiality from politicizing the post, though empirical outcomes of the reforms—such as the 2009 establishment—later demonstrated functional continuity without immediate erosion of independence.

Constitutional and judicial reforms

As Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs from 12 June 2003 to 28 May 2007, Falconer spearheaded the , which received royal assent on 24 March 2005 and fundamentally restructured the UK's judicial and constitutional framework to enhance . The Act retained the ancient office of but stripped it of its previous roles as head of the judiciary and Speaker of the , transferring judicial leadership to the Lord Chief Justice—effective from 3 April 2006, when Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers succeeded Falconer in that capacity—and establishing a separate elected for the . A core provision Falconer championed was the creation of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, which replaced the Appellate Committee of the as the final court of appeal, opening on 1 October 2009 to provide institutional separation between the judiciary and legislature, thereby addressing long-standing concerns over perceived . The legislation also established the (JAC), operational from 3 April 2006, to oversee merit-based judicial selections independent of direct ministerial control, with Falconer emphasizing its role in balancing executive influence against professional judicial input. These reforms stemmed from a consultation paper, which Falconer advanced amid criticism that the traditional 's multifaceted role risked undermining ; he defended the changes as preserving the office's guardianship of the while modernizing it for contemporary governance. Implementation included statutory duties for the to protect , though subsequent evaluations noted ongoing tensions between political oversight and judicial autonomy. Falconer's tenure also saw preparatory work for broader court modernization, though major judicial efficiency drives, such as unified , built on prior initiatives rather than originating under him.

Implementation of the Freedom of Information Act

The (FOIA) was brought into full effect on 1 January 2005, providing a statutory right for individuals to request information from public authorities, subject to exemptions for sensitive matters such as and . As for Constitutional Affairs and from June 2003, Charlie Falconer, Baron Falconer of Thoroton, oversaw the Department for Constitutional Affairs (DCA)'s role in the final implementation phase, including coordination with the on guidance, training for public bodies, and secondary legislation. The commencement followed a delay from the originally intended 2002 rollout, attributed to the need for adequate preparation among over 100,000 public authorities to handle an estimated 24,000 initial requests annually. In October 2004, Falconer announced regulations capping fees for FOIA requests, establishing a "disproportionate cost" threshold of £600 (or £3,600 in staff time) for central government departments, beyond which requests could be refused if deemed excessive. These measures aimed to balance accessibility with administrative feasibility, though critics from organizations like the Campaign for Freedom of Information argued they risked discouraging legitimate inquiries by prioritizing cost control over transparency. Falconer defended the regime in a speech to the Society of Editors that month, emphasizing preparation efforts including a £7 million grant to local authorities for compliance systems. By mid-2005, early implementation data showed around 7,000 requests processed in the first six months, with compliance rates varying by authority. A notable early application of FOIA occurred in July 2005, when Falconer was compelled to disclose excerpts from his ministerial diary following a request by The Guardian, marking one of the Act's first high-profile enforcements against a senior cabinet member and testing exemptions for policy formulation. Falconer later articulated in a December 2005 Guardian article that FOIA's purpose was to empower citizens through access to decision-making data, rather than merely fueling media scrutiny, while acknowledging administrative burdens like requests for trivial details such as toilet paper stocks. Under his oversight, the DCA also supported the appointment of the first Information Commissioner, Richard Thomas, in 2002 (with expanded powers post-2005), to adjudicate disputes independently. Implementation proceeded amid debates over exemptions, with Falconer maintaining in parliamentary statements that the regime struck a pragmatic balance against risks of overwhelming public resources.

Transition to Gordon Brown era and opposition (2007–2010)

Demotion and ministerial shifts

Following the resignation of Tony Blair as Prime Minister on 27 June 2007, Gordon Brown assumed office and conducted a Cabinet reshuffle the following day, 28 June 2007, in which Falconer was dismissed from his dual role as Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice. Jack Straw, a more senior Labour figure aligned with Brown's faction, succeeded him in the position. This removal marked the end of Falconer's ministerial career under the Labour government, transitioning him to the backbenches; as a close personal and political associate of Blair, his ousting reflected Brown's efforts to consolidate power by sidelining perceived Blair loyalists and implementing a generational shift in the Cabinet. The preceding ministerial shift occurred on 9 May 2007, when reorganized the Department for Constitutional Affairs into the expanded , appointing Falconer as its inaugural while retaining his title. This restructuring, enacted via the Order 2007, merged prisons, probation, and criminal justice policy under Falconer's portfolio, ostensibly enlarging its scope beyond constitutional affairs. However, critics within legal circles viewed the change as diminishing the traditional independence of the —already curtailed by the —by subordinating it to a departmental secretary of state role more susceptible to executive influence, though Falconer publicly defended it as strengthening coordination on justice matters. Falconer's demotion to non-ministerial status under ended his four-year tenure in senior government roles, during which he had overseen significant reforms including the creation of the . With no further executive appointments until the 2010 general election loss, he focused on parliamentary scrutiny from the , occasionally critiquing Brown's leadership, such as calling for a debate on it in June 2009 amid Labour's declining poll ratings.

Backbench and early opposition activities

Following his replacement as on 28 June 2007, Falconer reverted to the backbenches in the , where he had no formal government or shadow roles during the remainder of the premiership. In October 2007, a public dispute emerged over Falconer's entitlement to a higher ministerial following his departure from office, with Brown personally intervening to block approval of the increased amount, reportedly due to Falconer's prior service as a special adviser without corresponding accrual. Falconer pursued legal action to claim what he argued was a double adjustment, highlighting tensions between the former colleagues. By June 2009, amid Labour's declining poll ratings and internal unrest, Falconer publicly urged the party to contemplate a change, stating that Brown's position had become untenable and that a new leader was necessary to salvage electoral prospects before the anticipated 2010 . This intervention, as a prominent Blair-era figure, intensified calls for Brown's but did not lead to an immediate shift, with Falconer citing the need for fresh direction to address voter disillusionment.

Shadow cabinet and later parliamentary career (2010–present)

Justice and constitutional spokesman roles

Following the 2010 general election, Falconer was appointed Shadow Spokesperson for Justice from 8 October 2010 to 6 September 2012, critiquing the coalition government's legal aid reforms and prison policies as undermining access to justice. He simultaneously served as Shadow Spokesperson for Constitutional and Deputy Prime Ministerial Issues from 17 October 2011 to 11 May 2015, opposing aspects of the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011 and advocating for stronger safeguards on devolution arrangements. In these capacities, he emphasized the need for judicial independence amid proposed changes to court fees and sentencing guidelines, arguing that such measures risked eroding public confidence in the legal system without empirical evidence of cost savings. In May 2015, under interim Labour leader , Falconer became Shadow and Shadow , a role he retained after Jeremy Corbyn's election as leader until resigning on 26 June 2016. He led opposition to Michael Gove's proposals to replace the with a British , warning in May 2015 that the would reject any such bill lacking cross-party consensus and broad judicial support. Falconer also criticized prison overcrowding and rehabilitation failures under the Conservatives, citing data from the showing recidivism rates exceeding 45% for short-sentence offenders as evidence of systemic underfunding. Falconer returned to the frontbench in April 2020 as Shadow Spokesperson for until November 2021, under Keir Starmer's leadership, focusing on pandemic-related court backlogs that had delayed over 500,000 cases by mid-2020 according to official statistics. He called for increased investment in digital infrastructure and restoration, contending that delays violated fair trial principles under Article 6 of the . Throughout these roles, Falconer's interventions drew on his prior experience as , prioritizing evidence-based critiques over partisan rhetoric, though some observers noted his alignment with Labour's broader resistance to constitutional tweaks without proposing wholesale alternatives.

Recent interventions in House of Lords debates

In September 2025, Lord Falconer sponsored and led the second reading debate on the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill in the , arguing that the legislation represented a historic opportunity to permit terminally ill adults in , with less than six months to live and mental capacity, to request assistance in ending their lives under strict safeguards. He emphasized the bill's evolution from prior private members' bills, including his own 2014 effort, and urged peers to prioritize scrutiny over obstruction, declaring his interests including funding from Dignity in Dying. On 19 September 2025, during further debate on the same bill, he supported an amendment establishing a special select committee for additional evidence gathering, collaborating with opponents like to address concerns over safeguards and potential coercion, while maintaining that the current legal framework under the Suicide Act 1961 inadequately served suffering patients. This intervention facilitated the bill's progression beyond second reading by a vote of 165 to 150, marking a step toward potential enactment following the ' prior approval. Earlier in May 2025, Falconer intervened in a debate on the (CCRC), criticizing its systemic failures over decades, exemplified by the wrongful conviction and 45-year imprisonment of Andrew Malkinson before in 2023, and calling for structural reforms to enhance and in reviews. In April 2025, he spoke on the steel industry crisis, pressing the government to intervene against Jingye Group's delays in supplying raw materials to British Steel's plant, warning of plant closures and job losses affecting 3,500 workers unless subsidies and procurement policies were enforced. On 11 December 2024, during the House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill debate, Falconer commended the measured tone of proceedings on removing 92 hereditary peers, positioning it as a preliminary step toward broader Lords reform without endorsing rushed abolition. In November 2024, he addressed pressures in social welfare and , highlighting increased demand amid economic strains, and welcomed maiden speeches in the Great British Energy Bill debate.

Extraparliamentary activities and advocacy

Campaigns on assisted dying

Lord Falconer of Thoroton has been a leading advocate for legalizing in the , focusing on providing terminally ill, mentally competent adults with the option to end their lives under strict safeguards. His campaigns emphasize empirical evidence from jurisdictions like and , where assisted dying laws have been implemented without widespread abuse, arguing that current prohibitions force unnecessary suffering on patients with less than six months to live. In June 2013, Falconer introduced the Assisted Dying Bill in the , proposing that terminally ill patients could request assistance to die after approval by two independent doctors and a judge, with provisions to prevent . The bill progressed to a second reading on 18 July 2014, lasting nearly 10 hours, but was halted by parliamentary time constraints before further stages. He reintroduced similar legislation in subsequent sessions, including 2014–2015, 2015–2016, and 2019–2021, each time aiming to establish a framework modeled on safeguards in existing foreign systems to ensure voluntary requests. Falconer's advocacy gained renewed momentum in 2024 following Labour's victory and Keir Starmer's commitment not to block a free vote on the issue. On 26 July 2024, he sponsored the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill in the Lords, which mirrors his earlier proposals by limiting eligibility to adults aged 18 or over with a expected to result in death within six months, requiring mental capacity and ' confirmations. The bill advanced through second reading on 19 September 2025, despite Falconer issuing an apology for initially failing to disclose his role as a vice-president of Dignity in Dying, the primary group supporting the measure. Throughout his campaigns, Falconer has cited data from Dignity in Dying and international reports showing low uptake rates—such as 0.4% of deaths in —and argued that safeguards mitigate risks of expansion, though critics including organizations contend these overlook potential coercion vulnerabilities among vulnerable groups. He has consistently positioned the legislation as a limited reform for end-of-life choice, rejecting broader expansions.

Positions on drug policy and other reforms

Charles Falconer has advocated for a shift away from prohibitionist drug policies toward legalization and regulation, citing the failure of the "war on drugs" to reduce harm and its exacerbation of social inequalities. In September 2018, he publicly apologized for his role in supporting stringent anti-drug measures during Tony Blair's government, describing the approach as a "tragic disaster" that disproportionately damaged impoverished communities by fueling black markets and organized crime. He endorsed an open letter from cross-party politicians urging the legalization of drug production and sale under state control to disrupt criminal enterprises, arguing that empirical evidence from prohibition's persistence showed it ineffective at curbing supply or demand. Falconer's views evolved into active leadership on policy reform through his chairmanship of the London Drugs Commission, established in May 2022 by Mayor to examine drug-related harms in the capital. The commission, after four years of deliberation involving experts and data analysis, released a May 2025 report with 42 recommendations, including the of possessing small quantities of natural for personal use and its removal from the to enable regulated access and . Falconer framed these proposals as evidence-based responses to 's widespread prevalence—used by an estimated 10-15% of adults annually—prioritizing interventions over , while cautioning against broader without safeguards. The report also addressed and opioids, recommending enhanced treatment access and police diversion schemes rather than punitive measures, drawing on data showing over 1,000 drug-related deaths in in 2023 alone. Falconer has maintained that such reforms are not "soft on drugs" but pragmatic, supported by international examples like Portugal's model, which correlated with reduced overdose rates and transmission post-2001, though he acknowledges debates over increased youth experimentation in legalized markets elsewhere. Beyond drugs, Falconer has supported broader reforms emphasizing rehabilitation over incarceration, consistent with his post-governmental advocacy, though specific positions remain tied to empirical critiques of over-reliance on punishment without addressing root causes like and .

Controversies and criticisms

Efforts to curtail Freedom of Information access

As Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs from 2003 to 2007, Lord Falconer oversaw the implementation of the , which came into full effect on 1 January 2005, but soon advocated for measures to limit its scope amid concerns over administrative burdens. In a December 2005 article, he argued that the Act was intended to empower citizens rather than enable "irresponsible" or requests driven by "the wilder fevers of and ," signaling government intent to introduce curbs on excessive inquiries. In late , Falconer's department proposed amendments to the Act's enforcement code, including provisions to charge fees for requests exceeding a low cost threshold (initially £600 for central government), aggregate multiple requests from the same applicant within a 60-day period to deny expensive ones, and factor in ministers' and advisors' time when assessing the test for disclosure. These changes, outlined in a consultation released on 27 2006, were criticized by campaigners and media outlets as an attempt to "neuter" the legislation by deterring journalists and requesters, potentially reducing transparency on government operations. The proposals followed internal government estimates of £35 million in annual compliance costs, though opponents, including the Campaign for , contended that such figures were inflated to justify evasion of accountability. Falconer defended the reforms as necessary to prevent abuse, stating in 2006 that the Act should not facilitate "fishing expeditions" by journalists seeking unsubstantiated stories. By May 2007, further plans were unveiled to prioritize "serious" requests over "mischievous" ones, with Falconer emphasizing deterrence of vexatious inquiries that strained public resources. Although some proposals, like mandatory fees, were ultimately withdrawn amid parliamentary and public opposition, the Information Commissioner's Office approved modified aggregation rules in 2008, which critics attributed to Falconer's influence in weakening the Act's original intent. These efforts reflected broader New Labour tensions between promised openness and practical governance challenges, with Falconer later reflecting in 2017 that the Act had made government "less careless" despite the pushback. Lord Falconer has been a prominent advocate for legalizing in the since at least 2013, when he chaired the Commission on Assisted Dying, which recommended reforms to permit physician-assisted for terminally ill patients under strict conditions.) In 2014, he introduced the Assisted Dying Bill [HL] in the , proposing that mentally competent adults with a expected to result in death within six months could request assistance to end their life, with safeguards including judicial approval and confirmation of voluntariness by two doctors. The bill passed its second reading by 125 votes to 109 but stalled in committee and did not become law.) Falconer's advocacy persisted through subsequent parliamentary sessions, marking his seventh attempt by 2024 to introduce similar legislation. He has argued that the current law, under which assisting suicide is punishable by up to 14 years in prison, has effectively broken down, as evidenced by cases like that of Tony Nicklinson, where courts refused to clarify legality, leading some Britons to travel abroad for assisted deaths. In debates, Falconer has emphasized empirical evidence from jurisdictions like Oregon and the Netherlands, where assisted dying laws have not led to significant expansions beyond terminal cases, claiming rates remain low at around 0.4-4% of deaths. Opponents, including disability rights groups, counter that such data understates coercion risks for vulnerable individuals, citing studies showing familial pressure in some cases, though Falconer maintains safeguards like mandatory reporting and mental capacity assessments mitigate this. In 2024, Falconer supported the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, originally introduced in the Commons by , which advanced to the Lords where he serves as sponsor. The bill permits terminally ill adults in , with less than six months to live and mental capacity, to self-administer approved substances for an assisted after approvals by two doctors and a judge. It passed its second reading in the Lords on 19 September 2025 by 187 to 136 votes, following a compromise amendment establishing a select to scrutinize safeguards, amid debates highlighting fiscal estimates of low uptake (fewer than 1,000 cases annually) and concerns over inadequacies driving requests.Bill) Falconer has framed the as addressing a "once-in-a-generation" opportunity post-Labour's , rejecting slippery slope fears by pointing to stable eligibility in comparator countries over two decades. Critics, including medical bodies like the , argue the bill's criteria could evolve, potentially encompassing non-terminal suffering, as seen in Belgium's expansions.01323-6/fulltext)

Associations with Blair-era policies and scandals

Falconer served as a key figure in Tony Blair's government, having been a flatmate of Blair during their time as barristers in in the mid-1970s, a relationship that facilitated his rapid elevation to in May 1997 despite limited prior public office experience. He was ennobled as Baron Falconer of Thoroton shortly thereafter, enabling his appointment to the , and subsequently held roles including Minister of State for Housing and Planning from 1998 to 2001 and from 2001 to 2002, where he oversaw the troubled project, which incurred losses exceeding £800 million by its closure in December 2000 amid criticisms of poor planning and value for public money. In June 2003, Blair appointed Falconer as and for Constitutional Affairs, a dual role embodying Blair's push for modernizing Britain's unwritten constitution, including the separation of judicial and legislative functions through the , which established the UK Supreme Court effective October 2009. This reform aimed to enhance but drew accusations from critics of undermining the historic office of without sufficient safeguards against executive overreach. Falconer's tenure also aligned with Blair's broader agenda of and human rights incorporation via the , though he later reflected in 2015 that the legal basis for the 2003 —supported by government intelligence dossiers—was flawed, contributing to perceptions of policy misjudgments within Blair's inner circle. Falconer's involvement in the , established on 13 August 2003 following the death of weapons expert Dr. David Kelly, drew significant scrutiny; as , he selected Lord Hutton to chair the probe into Kelly's suicide amid controversy over the government's naming of Kelly as the source of reports questioning WMD claims, and he indefinitely adjourned the statutory coroner's , a decision critics argued limited independent forensic examination and favored a government-friendly remit focused on process rather than broader intelligence failures. The inquiry's January 2004 report cleared Blair's administration and targeted the , prompting resignations including that of Chairman and Director-General , while Hutton's narrow scope was later decried by figures like former UN weapons inspector as inadequate for addressing systemic issues in the rush to war. Regarding the 2006-2007 , Falconer faced parliamentary questioning in April 2006 over the vetting of peerage nominations amid allegations that Labour Party loans totaling £3.6 million from four individuals were linked to Blair's recommendations for life peerages, some blocked by the ; while not personally implicated in wrongdoing, his role as placed him at the intersection of honours processes and Blair's advisory circle, leading him to caution ministers against public commentary on investigation to avoid perceptions of interference. No charges resulted against Falconer, but the affair highlighted tensions in Blair-era reliance on private funding, with Falconer later advocating retrospective disclosure rules for party loans in response.

Personal life and honours

Family and relationships

Falconer is the son of John Falconer, a solicitor, and his wife Anne. In 1985, he married Marianna Catherine Thoroton Hildyard, a fellow and daughter of Sir David Hildyard, whose final posting was as to . The couple's surname derives in part from Thoroton, a village associated with his wife's . Falconer and his wife have four children: Hamish (born 20 December 1985), William, Rosie, and Johnnie. Their eldest son, Hamish Falconer, was elected Labour MP for Lincoln in the 2024 general election.

Coat of arms and distinctions

The heraldic achievement of Charles Leslie Falconer, Baron Falconer of Thoroton, was granted by Garter King of Arms on 6 April 2010, including arms, crest, and supporters. The escutcheon is blazoned as Azure, two arrows barbs upwards Or between three falcons rising Argent beaked and legged Or. The crest features a Or supporting with the dexter claws a pilgrim's pikestaff connected by a chain Argent to a ring around the sinister leg also Argent. As a in the , Falconer employs the standard coronet of a British : a of velvet lined with ermine, turned up ermine, ensigned by six silver balls (pearls) on points rising from a of gold. His post-nominal distinctions include PC, denoting membership in the since 2003, and KC, as , originally appointed QC in 1991 and updated following the accession of King Charles III.

References

  1. https://wiki.openrightsgroup.org/wiki/Lord_Falconer_of_Thoroton
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.