Hubbry Logo
Margaret GarnerMargaret GarnerMain
Open search
Margaret Garner
Community hub
Margaret Garner
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Margaret Garner
Margaret Garner
Margaret Garner
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Thomas Satterwhite Noble's 1867 painting The Modern Medea was based on Garner's story.

Margaret Garner (died 1858) was an enslaved African-American woman who killed her own daughter and intended to kill her other three children and herself rather than be forced back into slavery.[1] Garner and her family had escaped enslavement in January 1856 by traveling across the frozen Ohio River to Cincinnati. They at first found refuge but they were pursued and apprehended by U.S. Marshals and slave catchers acting under the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850. It was just before Margaret was taken that she enacted the killing. Garner's defense attorney, John Jolliffe, moved to have her tried for the homicide in Ohio, to keep her in a free state to challenge slavery and the fugitive-slave law in court in front of an Ohio jury but Margaret and her remaining family were taken back south into slavery. Garner's story was the inspiration for the novel Beloved (1987) by Nobel Prize–winning author Toni Morrison and its subsequent adaptation into a film of the same name starring Oprah Winfrey (1998).

Early life

[edit]

Garner, who was mixed-race and described at the time with the derogatory term 'mulatto', was born a house slave to the Gaines family of Maplewood plantation, Boone County, Kentucky. She may have been the daughter of the plantation owner John Pollard Gaines.[2] In 1849 she married Robert Garner, an enslaved man. That December, the plantation and all the people enslaved there were sold to John P. Gaines's younger brother, Archibald K. Gaines. The Garners' first child, Thomas, was born early in 1850.[2]

Three of Garner's younger children (Samuel, Mary, and Priscilla) were also mixed race; each was born five to seven months after a child born to Archibald Gaines and his wife. These light-skinned children were likely the children of Archibald Gaines, the only adult white male at Maplewood, who either forced Garner into a sexual relationship with him or repeatedly sexually assaulted her.[3] The timing of the pregnancies suggests that the children were each conceived after Gaines's wife had become pregnant and was sexually unavailable to him.[2]

In a contemporary account, abolitionist Levi Coffin described Margaret Garner at her arrest as "a mulatto, about five feet high ... she appeared to be about twenty-one or twenty-three years old." She also had an old scar on the left side of her forehead and cheek, which she said had been caused when a "White man struck me." Her two sons were about four and six years old, and her daughter Mary was two and a half, and baby girl Priscilla, an infant.

The escape

[edit]

On January 28, 1856, Robert and Margaret Garner, who was pregnant, together with family members, escaped and fled to Storrs Township, a rural area just west of Cincinnati, along with several other enslaved families. Robert Garner had stolen his enslaver's horses and sleigh along with his gun. Seventeen people were reported to have been in their party. In the coldest winter in 60 years, the Ohio River had frozen. At daybreak, the group crossed the ice in Boone County, Kentucky, just west of Covington, and escaped to Storrs Township before dividing to avoid detection.[4]

The Garners and their four children, with Robert's father Simon and his wife Mary, made their way to the home of Margaret's uncle Joe Kite,[2] who had himself been formerly enslaved, and who lived along Mill Creek below Cincinnati. The other nine people in their party reached safe houses in Cincinnati and eventually escaped via the Underground Railroad to Canada. Kite went to abolitionist Levi Coffin for advice on how to get the group to safety. Coffin agreed to help them escape the city, and told Kite to take the Garner group further west of the city, where many free Black people lived, and to wait until night.

Slave catchers and U.S. Marshals found the Garners barricaded inside Kite's house before he returned. They surrounded the property and then stormed the house. Robert Garner fired several shots and wounded at least one deputy marshal. Margaret killed her two-year-old daughter Mary with a butcher's knife rather than see the child returned to slavery. She had wounded her other children, preparing to kill them and herself, when she was subdued by the posse.

Trial

[edit]

The entire group was taken to jail. The subsequent trial lasted for two weeks, after which the judge deliberated another two weeks. It was "the longest and most complicated case of its kind."[2] A typical fugitive slave hearing would have lasted less than a day. The core issue was whether the Garners would be tried as persons, and charged with the murder of their daughter, or tried as property under the Fugitive Slave Law. The defense attorney argued that Ohio's right to protect its citizens should take precedence. The slave catchers and owner argued for the precedence of federal law over the state.

The defense attempted to prove that Margaret Garner had been liberated under a former law covering slaves taken into free states for other work. Her attorney proposed that she be charged with murder so that the case would be tried in a free state (understanding that the Governor would later pardon her). The prosecuting attorney argued that the federal Fugitive Slave Law took precedence over state murder charges. Over a thousand people turned out each day to watch the proceedings, lining the streets outside the courthouse. Five hundred men were deputized to maintain order in the town.

The presiding judge, Pendery, ruled that Federal fugitive warrants had supervening authority. Defense attorney John Jolliffe then tried a strategy of arguing that the Fugitive Slave Act violated the guarantee of religious freedom, by compelling citizens to participate in evil by returning slaves. Pendery rejected this argument.

On the closing day of the trial, the antislavery activist Lucy Stone took the stand to defend her earlier conversations with Margaret (the prosecution had complained). She spoke about the interracial sexual relationship that underlay part of the case:

Recalling to everyone's memory the faces of Margaret's children, and of A. K. Gaines, Stone told the packed courtroom: "The faded faces of the Negro children tell too plainly to what degradation the female slaves submit. Rather than give her daughter to that life, she killed it. If in her deep maternal love she felt the impulse to send her child back to God, to save it from coming woe, who shall say she had no right not to do so?"[2]

Margaret Garner's actions were driven by her enslaver's abuse and the well known abuse slaves faced nationwide. Women were known to commit infanticide to alleviate the burden of slavery from their children; however, in Garner's case her children faced even more oppression due to their being mulattos. Mulattos were seen as a threat as well as a disgrace among the plantation and white families because the birth of mulatto children highlighted infidelity within the slave-owning families. They reminded the family of a perceived sin, and were often beaten or sold. Garner underwent drastic measures to protect her child not only from the cruelty of the institution of slavery but from the double threat, due to the child's mulatto status.[5]

Margaret Garner was not immediately tried for murder but was forced to return to a slave state along with Robert and their youngest child, a daughter of about nine months old. When Ohio authorities got an extradition warrant for Garner to try her for murder, they were unable to find her for the arrest. Archibald K. Gaines, her enslaver, kept moving her between cities in Kentucky.

Sent south and death

[edit]

Ohio officials missed finding Margaret in Covington by a few hours, missed apprehending her again in Frankfort, and finally caught up with her enslaver in Louisville, only to discover that he had put the enslaved people on a boat headed for his brother's plantation in Arkansas. The Liberator reported that, on March 6, 1856, the steamboat Henry Lewis, on which the Garners were being transported, began to sink after colliding with another boat. Margaret Garner and her baby daughter were either thrown overboard during the collision or, according to an alternate account, Garner deliberately jumped overboard after tossing her baby into the river. The baby drowned. It was reported that Margaret expressed "frantic joy" that her baby had died, and that she had tried to drown herself.[6] She and Robert were kept in Arkansas only a short time before being sent to Gaines' family friends in New Orleans as a household servant. The Garners then disappeared from sight.

In 1870, a reporter from The Cincinnati Chronicle found Robert Garner and gathered more about his life.[7] Robert and Margaret Garner had worked in New Orleans, and in 1857 were sold to Judge Dewitt Clinton Bonham for plantation labor at Tennessee Landing, Mississippi. Robert said 24 year old Margaret had died in 1858 of typhoid fever, in an epidemic in the valley. He said that before she died, Margaret urged him to "never marry again in slavery, but to live in hope of freedom."[2]

Memorialization

[edit]

Most prominently, in 2016, Nikki M. Taylor captured Garner's circumstances in "Driven Toward Madness: The Fugitive Slave Margaret Garner and Tragedy on the Ohio." Taylor, the first African American woman to write a history of Garner, grounds her approach in black feminist theory. She melds history with trauma studies to account for shortcomings in the written record. In so doing, she rejects distortions and fictionalized images, probes slavery's legacies of sexual and physical violence and psychic trauma in new ways, and fleshes out a figure who had been rendered an apparition by the archives.[8]

Garner's life story was also the basis of Frances Harper's 1859 poem "Slave Mother: A Tale of Ohio". She also inspired Kentucky painter Thomas Satterwhite Noble's 1867 painting, The Modern Medea; Medea was a woman in Greek mythology who killed her own children. The painting, owned by Cincinnati manufacturer Procter and Gamble Corporation, was presented as a gift to the National Underground Railroad Freedom Center, where it remains on permanent display.

Garner's life also inspired Toni Morrison to write her Pulitzer Prize-winning novel Beloved (1987). Morrison also wrote the libretto for the opera Margaret Garner (2005), composed by Richard Danielpour. Folk musician Jake Speed's "Maggie Don't You Weep" (2003) is similarly inspired by Garner's life.

Other fiction writing inspired by Garner's story includes John Jolliffe's Belle Scott[9] (1856), N. K. Jemisin's The Fifth Season[10] (2015), and K. A. Simpson's A Coven's Lament (2017).

Robert Dafford's mural "The Flight of the Garner Family" depicts the group crossing the frozen Ohio River. Painted on a floodwall beneath the John A Roebling Suspension Bridge in Covington, Kentucky, the mural is part of an 18-image series depicting events from Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky history.

See also

[edit]

Citations

[edit]
  1. ^ Carroll, Rebecca (January 31, 2019). "Margaret Garner, a Runaway Slave Who Killed Her Own Daughter". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved June 19, 2024.
  2. ^ a b c d e f g Weisenburger, Steven. "A Historical Margaret Garner". Michigan Opera Theatre. Archived from the original on May 20, 2011. Retrieved April 20, 2009. Bertram Wyatt-Brown reminds us, Southern men commonly referred to their pregnant wives' last trimester or so when they were sexually unavailable as 'the gander months' because it was supposedly natural, and to some extent informally countenanced, for them to seek intimate 'comfort' with unmarried women or with enslaved women, if they owned any.
  3. ^ "Margaret Garner - Kentucky Commission on Human Rights". kchr.ky.gov. Retrieved November 2, 2024.
  4. ^ Schuckers, Jacob William (1874). The Life and Public Services of Salmon Portland Chase: United States Senator and Governor of Ohio; Secretary of the Treasury and Chief-justice of the United States. D. Appleton & Company. pp. 171–172. ISBN 9780608402611 – via Google Books. {{cite book}}: ISBN / Date incompatibility (help)
  5. ^ McKissack, Patricia C.; Fredrick McKissack (1995). Sojourner Truth ain't I a woman?. Littleton, MA: Sundance Publishers & Distributors. ISBN 0590446916.
  6. ^ "The Cincinnati slave - another thrilling scene in the tragedy" (PDF). The Liberator. 26 (12): 3. March 21, 1856.
  7. ^ "Margaret Garner". Kentucky Commission on Human Rights.
  8. ^ https://www.ohioswallow.com/9780821421604/driven-toward-madness/
  9. ^ Jolliffe, John (February 23, 2012). Belle Scott, or, Liberty overthrown: a tale for the crisis. ISBN 978-1275837690.
  10. ^ Kene, Jason (June 17, 2016). "Fantasy Writer N.K. Jemisin on the Weird Dreams That Fuel Her Stories". Wired.

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Margaret Garner

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Margaret Garner (June 4, 1834 – 1858) was an enslaved African American woman in antebellum Kentucky who, in January 1856, fled with her husband Robert, their four children, and other relatives across the frozen Ohio River to Cincinnati, Ohio, seeking freedom. Upon discovery and capture by U.S. marshals and her owner Archibald K. Gaines, Garner used a butcher knife to fatally slit the throat of her two-year-old daughter Mary and attempted to kill her other children and herself, stating that death was preferable to re-enslavement. The Garner case precipitated one of the most protracted fugitive slave trials in U.S. history, lasting two weeks in federal court, where Commissioner John L. Pendery ultimately ruled under the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 that the family must be returned to Gaines despite arguments from abolitionist counsel that prior exposure to free soil had emancipated them. The incident, involving seventeen escapees in total, intensified national debates over slavery's inhumanity and the enforcement of in free states, with Garner portrayed in contemporary accounts as both a tragic figure and a symbol of resistance against bondage's atrocities. After the ruling, Gaines transported the Garners southward to evade murder charges, where Margaret Garner died in 1858 during a typhoid outbreak.

Early Life and Enslavement

Birth and Family Background

Margaret Garner was born into circa 1834 in , on the Maplewood plantation owned by the Gaines family. Historical records indicate she was a , reflecting mixed racial ancestry typical of many enslaved individuals fathered by white enslavers through coerced relations. She performed duties as a house slave, which involved domestic labor within the Gaines household, distinguishing her role from field work on the plantation. Details on Garner's parents and siblings remain scarce due to the limited documentation of enslaved families under antebellum laws that treated them as rather than individuals with ties. No verified names for her mother or father appear in primary historical accounts, though her light complexion suggested paternal white ancestry, possibly linked to the Gaines family or another enslaver. The Gaines plantation records, focused on economic assets, rarely preserved personal family histories of the enslaved, contributing to gaps in her early background.

Conditions of Enslavement on Maplewood Plantation

Margaret Garner was born into enslavement on June 4, 1834, at Maplewood Plantation in , initially under the ownership of John Pollard Gaines, a U.S. military officer and who held multiple enslaved people on the property. By the , the plantation had passed to Archibald K. Gaines, John's relative, who continued to enforce the institution through labor demands and control over family units. Maplewood operated as a mixed farm producing crops such as and , typical of Kentucky's plantations, where enslaved individuals performed both field labor—planting, harvesting, and processing fibers under seasonal pressures—and domestic tasks in the owner's household. As a house slave, Garner was assigned indoor duties including cooking, cleaning, laundry, and childcare for the Gaines family, roles that offered marginally less exposure to outdoor elements than field work but provided no protection from exploitation or . Enslaved women like Garner and her mother, Elizabeth (known as Lizzie), faced routine from owners, with historical accounts indicating repeated by Archibald Gaines, resulting in Garner bearing at least one child, Mary, fathered by him. Such assaults were systemic in , legally unpunishable, and contributed to the status of Garner and her children, heightening their vulnerability to sale or harsher treatment due to perceived racial ambiguity. Living conditions at Maplewood reflected standard antebellum enslavement: enslaved people resided in rudimentary quarters, often log structures with dirt floors, inadequate clothing, and limited rations of cornmeal, pork fat, and , supplemented by garden plots if permitted. bonds were routinely disrupted, as evidenced by Garner's husband, , being held on a neighboring owned by the Haines , forcing irregular contact and complicating efforts to maintain unity. Discipline involved , including whippings for perceived infractions like "unruliness," which records note among Maplewood's enslaved population, fostering an environment of fear and desperation that culminated in escape attempts. The plantation's scale supported around a dozen to twenty enslaved individuals during Garner's tenure, though exact numbers vary; by 1860, post-escape, only five remained in two designated slave houses. Owners like the Gaines brothers profited from this coerced labor without granting rights, medical care, or , perpetuating cycles of trauma across generations, as Garner's light complexion—likely from her own mixed parentage under John Gaines—mirrored inherited abuses. These conditions underscored the coercive essence of , often portrayed as milder than Deep South cotton regimes but equally dehumanizing through intimate violence and economic extraction.

The Escape and Infanticide

Planning the Flight from

In late 1856, Margaret Garner, an enslaved woman on Archibald K. Gaines's Maplewood Plantation in , joined a coordinated escape effort involving seventeen enslaved individuals from Gaines's property and neighboring farms, including the Marshall plantation. The group, which included Margaret's husband Robert Garner, their four young children, and Robert's parents Simon and Mary Garner, planned the flight to exploit the Ohio River's frozen surface, which provided a rare crossing opportunity during a severe winter with snow covering the ground. This natural condition minimized reliance on boats or guides, though the escape still demanded secrecy amid heightened risks from slave patrols and the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850. Preparations centered on acquiring means of to evade detection, with the fugitives securing a large and two horses from one of their owners' stables without permission, enabling a swift nighttime departure. The plan specified a night start—late Saturday evening into Sunday morning—to leverage reduced activity on plantations and potential delays in pursuit due to the religious observance, though slaveholders often ignored such customs. Route details targeted a point below , opposite Cincinnati's Wester Row, for the river crossing, followed by dispersal into smaller groups to reach safe houses, such as that of sympathizer Kite Runyan. Coordination among the seventeen required trusted communication networks among the enslaved, honed from shared experiences of labor on nearby and farms, but specifics of meetings or signals remain undocumented beyond the collective resolve to prioritize death over recapture.

Crossing the Ohio River and Immediate Aftermath

On the night of , 1856, Margaret Garner, who was pregnant, her husband Robert Garner, their four young children, Robert's parents Simon and Mary, and approximately eleven other enslaved individuals from nearby plantations in Boone and Kenton counties, , fled northward toward the . The group utilized a pulled by two to travel several miles at full speed through snowy conditions to a point below , opposite Cincinnati's Wester Row area. The was frozen solid due to an unusually cold winter, enabling the fugitives to cross on foot rather than by boat, a rare opportunity that multiple enslaved groups exploited that month. They reached the Ohio side at dawn, dispersing to evade detection before regrouping. , , their children, and Simon and Mary sought shelter at the home of Joseph Kite, a relative of the Garners, located below Mill Creek in . Archibald K. Gaines, the enslaver of Margaret and her children, quickly mobilized a posse of slave catchers upon discovering the escape and crossed into Ohio in pursuit. The fugitives' location was betrayed, possibly by a neighbor or informant, leading Gaines's group to surround Kite's house within hours of their arrival. Cincinnati's black community, alerted by Kite's son Elijah who sought aid from abolitionist Levi Coffin, mobilized to assist but arrived too late to relocate the group undetected. The Garners barricaded themselves inside, resisting capture with available weapons as federal authorities, enforcing the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850, prepared to intervene.

The Act of Killing Her Daughter

On January 28, 1856, shortly after reaching a in , , following their escape across the , Margaret Garner and her family were discovered by a posse led by U.S. Deputy Marshal John Simms. Realizing recapture was imminent, Garner seized a from the kitchen and slit the throat of her two-year-old daughter, Mary, nearly decapitating her in an act intended to spare the child from re-enslavement. Garner then attempted to kill her other three children—a nine-year-old daughter, a four-year-old son, and a three-month-old —first striking two of them on the head with a before attempting to cut their throats, but she was interrupted by alarmed neighbors and posse members who seized the weapons. She also tried to stab herself but was restrained. In a subsequent interview reported in the American Baptist on February 12, 1856, Garner explained her resolve, stating she acted "as cool[ly] as I now am; and would much rather kill them at once, and thus end their sufferings, than have them taken back to slavery." Quaker abolitionist Levi Coffin, who later documented the event, described Garner targeting the daughter she "probably loved the best" with one stroke of the knife, underscoring the deliberate nature of the infanticide amid the chaos of pursuit. Mary's body was the only fatality, with the surviving children suffering wounds that required medical attention but did not prove lethal.

Capture and Initial Custody in

On January 28, 1856, Archibald K. Gaines, the enslaver of Margaret Garner and her family, crossed the into and assembled a posse, including federal marshals, to track the fugitives after their escape the previous night across the frozen river. The group located the Garners hiding in the home of Margaret's cousin, Elijah Kite (), in rural Storrs Township just west of , where Kite had provided temporary shelter. Upon discovery, the family mounted a brief resistance, with Robert Garner wounding a pursuer, but they were subdued without further fatalities beyond the infant Margaret had already killed. The captured group—Margaret (pregnant at the time), her husband Robert, their three surviving children, and Robert's parents—was immediately transported to the Hamilton County jail in for detention. There, they were placed under the physical housing of the county facility but in the legal custody of U.S. Marshal Hiram G. Hurt, as required under federal fugitive slave protocols. Initial reports noted the surviving children bore visible wounds from Margaret's attempts to end their lives to spare them re-enslavement, while Margaret herself displayed composure amid the chaos. Public reaction in Cincinnati manifested rapidly, with crowds assembling outside the jail to protest the impending return of the Garners to , fueled by abolitionist sentiment in the free-state city bordering . Local newspapers, such as , published sensational accounts of the capture, amplifying national attention to the case and highlighting tensions over the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850. During this period of initial custody, before jurisdictional disputes escalated, authorities provided basic medical attention to the injured family members, though conditions in the overcrowded jail exacerbated their physical distress.

Federal vs. State Jurisdiction Conflict

Following her capture on , 1856, in , state authorities, led by Hamilton County Prosecutor John K. Rush, promptly indicted Margaret Garner for under Ohio law, seeking custody to conduct a state trial. Abolitionist sympathizers, including defense attorney John Jolliffe, supported this strategy, anticipating that a might confine her to an , where personal liberty laws could prevent re-enslavement or allow for . Federal officials countered by asserting the primacy of the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850, which mandated swift return of fugitives without state interruption, placing the Garners under U.S. Marshal Hiram G. Robinson's custody. On January 29, 1856, Common Pleas Judge issued a writ of to transfer Garner for prosecution, prompting federal resistance and a standoff at the county jail, where Deputy Sheriff Jefferson Buckingham briefly held the prisoners before yielding to marshals. The conflict proceeded to examination before U.S. Commissioner John L. Pendery, with arguments spanning February 4 to 7, 1856; the state emphasized charges as superseding federal claims, while pro-slavery advocates, including William Y. Gholson, insisted on uninterrupted enforcement of national slave recovery laws. On February 26, 1856, Pendery ruled against discharging Garner and three surviving children from federal custody, remanding them as fugitives; U.S. District Judge Humphrey H. Leavitt upheld this the next day, nullifying state jurisdiction and directing return to owners, though noting potential future for trial. This resolution prioritized federal authority over state criminal proceedings, fueling abolitionist outrage in —where Governor decried the outcome as tyranny—and exemplifying pre-Civil War frictions over slavery's interstate enforcement, as Northern courts increasingly clashed with federal mandates.

Trial Outcome and Enforcement of Fugitive Slave Law

The fugitive slave hearing before U.S. Commissioner John L. Pendery, which began shortly after the Garners' capture on January 28, 1856, extended over several weeks amid intense legal maneuvering by abolitionists seeking to invoke Ohio state law for a trial. On February 26, 1856, Pendery issued his decision, ruling that Margaret Garner, her husband Robert, and their surviving children qualified as fugitives under the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 and must be remanded to the custody of their owner, Archibald K. Gaines, for return to . Pendery explicitly rejected arguments for discharging Garner from federal custody, holding that the Act's provisions barred any state-level prosecution of the charge, as it would interfere with the federal mandate to deliver fugitives without delay or substantive inquiry into their status. This ruling affirmed the supremacy of federal authority over conflicting state interests, effectively nullifying Ohio's attempt to assert jurisdiction via the murder indictment obtained on February 12, 1856, by prosecutor John Jolliffe. Pendery's decision aligned with precedents interpreting the 1850 Act as prohibiting personal liberty laws or criminal proceedings that could delay or prevent rendition, thereby enforcing the law's intent to expedite the recovery of escaped slaves across state lines. The ordered the immediate transfer of the Garner party—now reduced by the death of one child and including related fugitives claimed by Gaines and James P. Gaines—into U.S. Marshal custody for conveyance southward, underscoring the Act's role in overriding local humanitarian or legal objections. The outcome highlighted the 1850 Act's rigorous enforcement mechanisms, which empowered commissioners like Pendery to act as de facto judges in fugitive cases, often without juries or appeals, and imposed penalties on obstructors while compensating claimants for expenses. Despite public outcry and petitions from Cincinnati residents urging a murder trial, the federal process prevailed, resulting in the Garners' departure from Ohio under guard on March 1, 1856, bound for Louisville, Kentucky, before rejoining Gaines' plantation. This case, one of the most protracted fugitive hearings of the era, exemplified how the law compelled compliance even in instances of extreme violence, prioritizing property rights in human beings over state criminal justice claims.

Return to Slavery and Death

Separation and Journey South

Following the federal court's decision in early 1856, Margaret Garner, her husband Simon, and their newborn daughter—born during her custody in Cincinnati—were remanded into the custody of enslaver Archibald K. Gaines and transported back to his plantation in Boone County, Kentucky. Gaines, seeking to evade an outstanding Ohio state warrant for Garner's arrest on murder charges and to minimize risks of further flight, sold Garner, Simon, and the infant to his brother Legrand Gaines for relocation to a plantation in Chicot County, Arkansas. During the steamboat voyage southward from , the vessel collided with another boat, hurling Garner overboard; she survived the incident, but the infant daughter drowned. Garner's two older surviving children, who had also been part of the original escape party, did not accompany the group south and remained in under separate ownership arrangements, resulting in the family's permanent division. After a brief period in Arkansas, Garner and Simon were resold and transferred via New Orleans to a cotton plantation in Mississippi in 1857, where conditions involved intensified field labor.

Circumstances of Margaret Garner's Death

After her return to slavery following the legal proceedings in 1856, Garner was sold to a plantation owner in the American South, where she endured continued enslavement separate from her surviving children. She contracted typhoid fever, a bacterial infection often spread through contaminated water, amid harsh living conditions typical of Southern plantations. Garner succumbed to the disease in 1858, approximately two years after her capture, having survived initial hardships of the journey southward but ultimately perishing from the fever's complications. Her death occurred during what some accounts describe as a regional epidemic, highlighting the vulnerability of enslaved individuals to infectious diseases exacerbated by overcrowding, poor sanitation, and inadequate medical care. The exact location of her death varies in reports, with references to Mississippi plantations such as those in Issaquena County, though her burial site remains unknown.

Fate of Surviving Family Members

Following the judicial proceedings in , the Garner family experienced permanent separation, with Robert Garner's parents, Simon and Mary, retained in , rather than transported south with the younger members. Simon Garner was sold to a local planter named George, while Mary Garner remained enslaved on the James Marshall farm into the 1860s. Robert Garner, Margaret's husband, accompanied her and the surviving children southward via steamboat along the and Rivers, where a vessel accident resulted in the drowning of their daughter Priscilla (also called Cilia), leaving two children alive upon arrival in . The family was placed into on a there, where Robert continued in bondage until emancipation following the Civil War in 1865. In post-war interviews, Robert recounted details of the 1856 events and his wife's death, indicating he achieved freedom and resided in thereafter; his death was recorded in 1871, attributed to a . The two surviving children, whose names and individual fates remain undocumented in historical records, endured enslavement alongside their parents in until the conclusion of the Civil War granted them freedom, after which no further verifiable details emerge regarding their lives or descendants.

Interpretations and Legacy

Role in Abolitionist Rhetoric and Public Reaction

Abolitionists leveraged Margaret Garner's act of as a poignant indictment of slavery's psychological toll, portraying it as a rational response to the Fugitive Slave Law's enforcement rather than mere criminality. In publications such as The Fugitive Slave Law, and Its Victims (1856), compiled by the , her case was detailed alongside others to demonstrate how the law compelled enslaved to extreme measures, with Garner's reported statement—"I would rather kill them than have them taken back"—cited to underscore maternal desperation under bondage. Advocates like attorney John Jolliffe, who represented her, argued in court and public appeals that her actions stemmed from slavery's degradation, framing the incident as evidence that the institution destroyed human bonds and justified resistance. This rhetoric aligned with broader abolitionist narratives emphasizing slavery's incompatibility with natural rights, using Garner's story in speeches and tracts to rally Northern support against compromise measures. Public reaction to the January 1856 events was intensely divided along sectional lines, with Northern abolitionist organs like the Anti-Slavery Bugle depicting Garner as a whose "heroic" choice highlighted 's barbarism, prompting petitions and fundraisers to secure her freedom in . newspapers, including the Commercial and Gazette, covered the trial extensively, fueling debates that exposed jurisdictional tensions under the Fugitive Slave Law and amplifying anti-slavery sentiment amid rising tensions prefiguring the Civil War. In contrast, Southern outlets condemned her as a savage perpetrator, reinforcing pro-slavery defenses of and order, while even some Northern moderates decried the violence without endorsing repatriation. The case's , covered in over 100 periodicals nationwide, intensified polarization, with abolitionists like invoking it in lectures to critique gender-specific oppressions under , though her was often reshaped to fit sentimental ideals of motherhood. Garner's episode contributed to abolitionist momentum by humanizing fugitive experiences, influencing works like sentimental and that recast her as a sacred defiance against of . However, this usage sometimes ventriloquized her voice, prioritizing anti-slavery advocacy over her agency, as critiqued in later analyses of how activists constructed narratives from limited . Overall, the reaction underscored slavery's role in eroding moral consensus, galvanizing calls for its immediate end without resolution in Garner's favor.

Ethical and Moral Controversies Surrounding the Infanticide

Garner's act of killing her two-year-old daughter with a on , , to prevent the child's return to provoked intense moral scrutiny over whether such could constitute a justifiable response to institutionalized . Abolitionists framed it as an ultimate expression of maternal love, arguing that the perpetual threat of familial separation, , and under rendered death a merciful alternative to a lifetime of suffering. , a prominent Quaker abolitionist who aided the Garner family, described the as a deliberate choice born of desperation, with Garner declaring she would rather see her children dead than enslaved, highlighting the ethical calculus of sparing them anticipated horrors like those she endured, including by her owner. Contemporary sentimental literature amplified this justification, portraying Garner-inspired figures as heroic mothers fulfilling a sacred duty to protect innocence from moral corruption induced by bondage. In Harriet Beecher Stowe's Dred () and Hattia M. Keith's Liberty or Death (), enslaved protagonists commit as an honorable act aligned with republican ideals of , evoking classical precedents like the Roman Virginius slaying his to preserve her . These narratives contended that slavery's causal degradation—severing maternal and commodifying offspring—nullified conventional prohibitions against , positioning the act as resistance rather than depravity. Opposing perspectives, particularly from pro-slavery apologists, rejected any extenuation, viewing the as evidence of innate savagery or ethical inferiority among enslaved Africans, decoupled from 's role. Southern racialized such incidents to affirm women's supposed propensity for unnatural crimes, countering abolitionist attributions of blame to the "peculiar institution" by insisting on inherent traits over environmental causation. This stance preserved the moral legitimacy of , portraying Garner's violence as a barbaric outlier that underscored the need for white oversight rather than . The core ethical controversy centered on the tension between the absolute value of human life and the relativizing force of systemic brutality, with Garner's case exemplifying how inverted maternal instincts into lethal agency. While abolitionists invoked it to indict 's causal role in eroding natural bonds—evidenced by parallel cases of enslaved women aborting or killing offspring to evade reproduction's burdens—critics maintained that no circumstance could legitimize premeditated child-killing, regardless of context. Historical legal leniency in similar Southern trials, often acquitting accused mothers to uphold plantation stability, further muddied , prioritizing institutional preservation over punitive .

Cultural Representations and Modern Assessments

Margaret Garner's story has been depicted in modern literature, most notably inspiring Toni Morrison's 1987 Pulitzer Prize-winning novel Beloved, in which the protagonist Sethe commits to spare her children from re-enslavement, mirroring Garner's desperate act amid the Fugitive Slave Law's enforcement. Morrison drew directly from newspaper accounts of Garner's trial, using the historical event to explore slavery's psychological devastation on maternal bonds and individual agency. The narrative also informed the 2005 opera Margaret Garner, composed by Richard Danielpour with libretto by , which premiered elements in 2005 and fully staged in 2006; it portrays Garner's escape, recapture, and as a tragic confrontation between freedom and bondage, emphasizing her internal conflict as a under slavery's constraints. The opera, performed by companies like Opera Carolina, frames her choices within the era's legal and moral tensions, advancing abolitionist themes while humanizing the enslaved family's plight. Nineteenth-century sentimental fiction, such as antislavery novels and stories from the , fictionalized Garner's to evoke and indict slavery's dehumanizing effects, often portraying it as a perverse inversion of maternal driven by the institution's causal brutality. Modern scholarly assessments interpret Garner's act as an extreme manifestation of gendered resistance, where enslaved women resorted to as a final assertion of against slavery's systematic violation of units and . Historians argue that such choices stemmed from the peculiar institution's incentives—perpetual bondage, familial separation, and sexual exploitation—rendering a perceived liberation preferable to subjugation, as evidenced by Garner's stated intent to kill her children and herself rather than allow their return to plantations. This view positions her not as a mere tragic figure but as emblematic of enslaved mothers' coerced agency, challenging narratives that pathologize without accounting for slavery's coercive . Analyses caution against decontextualizing the event, noting how contemporary racial biases linked to supposed enslaved depravity, while empirical records of slavery's documented abuses—whippings, rapes, and sales—substantiate the desperation underlying her decision.

References

  1. https://blackpast.org/african-american-history/margaret-garner-incident-1856/
  2. https://omekas.bcplhistory.org/s/borderlands/page/GarnerStory
  3. https://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook.cfm?smtID=3&psid=510
  4. https://kentucky-museum.org/margaret-garner/
  5. https://omekas.bcplhistory.org/s/cbc/item/3707
  6. https://boonecountykyhistory.org/pages/margaret-garner---boone-county-slave.php
  7. https://kchr.ky.gov/Hall-of-Fame/Pages/Margaret-Garner.aspx
  8. https://omekas.bcplhistory.org/s/borderlands/item/13314
  9. https://explorekyhistory.ky.gov/items/show/179
  10. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/42534414/archibald_kincaid-gaines
  11. https://scholarship.law.uc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1012&context=fcj
  12. https://blackartstory.org/2022/09/08/margaret-garner-incident-1856/
  13. https://laurajeffries.substack.com/p/signs-of-margaret-garner-history
  14. https://www.kentuckyarchaeologicalsurvey.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/In-Search-of-Margaret-Garner-Archaeological-Investigations-Maplewood_compressed.pdf
  15. https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/df0149fc544145a393bac195ed42b192
  16. https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/142/article/964916
  17. https://scholarworks.lib.csusb.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1164&context=history-in-the-making
  18. https://scalar.lehigh.edu/toni-morrison/the-story-of-margaret-garner-inspiration-for-beloved
  19. https://oberlinheritagecenter.org/lucy-stone-and-the-margaret-garner-tragedy/
  20. https://coloredconventions.org/ohio-organizing/biographies/margaret-garner/
  21. https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/2020/07/29/margaret-garners-story-has-resonated-decades-its-one-she-never-got-tell/5478537002/
  22. https://omekas.bcplhistory.org/s/borderlands/item-set/3706
  23. https://www.aaihs.org/the-fugitive-slave-margaret-garner-and-tragedy-on-the-ohio/
  24. https://accessgenealogy.com/black/margaret-garner-and-seven-others-fugitive-slave-law.htm
  25. http://www.jstor.org/stable/1897542
  26. https://ohiomemory.ohiohistory.org/archives/876
  27. https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/the-bill-of-rights-and-the-fugitive-slave-laws.htm
  28. https://encyclopediaofarkansas.net/entries/margaret-garner-18344/
  29. https://freedomcenter.org/heroes/margaret-garner/
  30. https://www.npr.org/transcripts/4633538
  31. https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv224tv5r
  32. https://archive.org/download/fugitiveslavelaw1856mays/fugitiveslavelaw1856mays.pdf
  33. https://www.aaihs.org/margaret-garner-and-the-complexities-of-slavery-and-gender/
  34. https://digitalcollections.wesleyan.edu/_flysystem/fedora/2023-03/22185-Original%2520File.pdf
  35. https://dacemirror.sci-hub.se/journal-article/629ac4bb812317016f1be4e8f6dfb0d0/reinhardt2002.pdf
  36. https://originalpeople.org/margaret-garner/
  37. https://cdr.lib.unc.edu/downloads/fx719r11s?locale=en
  38. https://www.aaihs.org/black-women-and-the-racialization-of-infanticide/
  39. https://ageofrevolutions.com/2022/07/25/she-had-smothered-her-baby-on-purpose-enslaved-women-and-maternal-resistance/
  40. https://www.upress.virginia.edu/title/5000/
  41. https://www.arts.gov/initiatives/nea-big-read/beloved
  42. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/margaret-garner
  43. https://www.wunc.org/2007-06-22/margaret-garner-from-opera-carolina
  44. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14664650701387896
  45. https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5406/j.ctt3fh57q
  46. https://www.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.5406/illinois/9780252037900.001.0001/upso-9780252037900-chapter-001
  47. https://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1093&context=mcnair
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.