Hubbry Logo
Pass OverPass OverMain
Open search
Pass Over
Community hub
Pass Over
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Pass Over
Pass Over
Pass Over
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
Pass Over
Film poster
Directed bySpike Lee (directed by)
Danya Taymor (created in collaboration with and directed for the stage by)
Screenplay byAntoinette Nwandu
Produced bySpike Lee
StarringJon Michael Hill
Julian Parker
Ryan Hallahan
Blake DeLong
CinematographyChayse Irvin
Edited byHye Mee Na
Production
company
Distributed byAmazon Studios[2]
Release dates
  • January 2018 (2018-01) (Sundance)[1]
  • April 20, 2018 (2018-04-20)
Running time
75 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish

Pass Over is a 2018 American drama film directed by Spike Lee, and starring Jon Michael Hill, Julian Parker, Ryan Hallahan and Blake DeLong. It is a performance of the play of the same name by Antoinette Nwandu, directed for the stage by Danya Taymor, and filmed by Spike Lee.[3]

Premise

[edit]

Moses and Kitch, two young black men, chat their way through a long, aimless day on a Chicago street corner. Periodically ducking bullets and managing visits from a genial but ominous stranger and an overtly hostile police officer, Moses and Kitch rely on their poetic, funny, at times profane banter to get them through a day that is a hopeless retread of every other day, even as they continue to dream of their deliverance.

Cast

[edit]

Production

[edit]

The film was shot in 2017 at the Steppenwolf Theatre in Chicago.[4] The stage production was directed by Danya Taymor and the film recording of the performance was directed by Spike Lee.

Release

[edit]

The film premiered at the 2018 Sundance Film Festival.[5] It was then released via Amazon Prime on April 20, 2018.[6]

Reception

[edit]

The film has a 93% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.[7] Chuck Bowen of Slant Magazine awarded the film two stars out of four.[8] Chris Nashawaty of Entertainment Weekly graded the film a B.[9] Nick Allen of RogerEbert.com awarded the film three and a half stars.[10] Bradley Gibson of Film Threat gave the film a 8 out of 10.[11]

The Hollywood Reporter gave it a positive review, calling it "More powerful than its filmed-play format might suggest."[12]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Pass Over

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Pass Over is a play written by Antoinette Chinonye Nwandu, first premiered at Steppenwolf Theatre Company in Chicago during the summer of 2017. Drawing from the biblical Exodus story and Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot, it centers on two young Black men named Moses and Kitch who linger on an urban street corner, trapped in a cycle of idleness, banter, and peril from police encounters and street violence, while dreaming of escape to a "Promised Land."
The work addresses themes of systemic racism, existential stagnation, and the Black American experience through profane dialogue and surreal interruptions, including visits from a white passerby and a reverend figure. A filmed version directed by Spike Lee debuted at the 2018 Sundance Film Festival and streamed on Amazon Prime, expanding its reach beyond stage audiences. Its 2021 Broadway production at the August Wilson Theatre, directed by Danya Taymor with actors Jon Michael Hill, Namir Small and Ryan Donowho, was the first play to open there post-COVID theater shutdowns, running from August to October and earning acclaim for its visceral energy alongside critique for its uneven structure and relentless intensity.

Original Play

Development and Writing

Antoinette Nwandu began writing Pass Over in late 2013 to early 2014, while teaching public speaking and theater at . The play originated as a response to the 2012 and the subsequent acquittal of , through which Nwandu sought to channel collective grief and rage experienced by . Her students—young Black and Brown men from areas like East New York, , and —provided loose inspiration for the central characters, informing their dialogue and rhythmic speech patterns. Nwandu's writing process emphasized sound, rhythm, and , beginning with character voices captured in broken lines with minimal to mimic natural speech and allow for flexibility. Early drafts featured iterative "takes" akin to rehearsals, evolving through multiple versions with varying endings; one character was absent in initial iterations, and the tone was predominantly tragic, culminating in a attributed to systemic racism. The script underwent workshops, including a key session at in April 2016, which facilitated refinements ahead of its premiere later that year. Subsequent revisions occurred during rehearsals for Steppenwolf's production, incorporating three temporal layers—biblical, slavery-era, and contemporary—to deepen the narrative structure. For the 2021 Broadway transfer, Nwandu rewrote the ending to allow the protagonists to survive, shifting focus from tragedy to Black resilience and joy, influenced by the 2020 killing of , racial justice protests, and her personal experiences including a and marital dissolution. This evolution reflected Nwandu's intent to prioritize for Black audiences over mere depiction of brutality.

Inspirations and Biblical Parallels

Antoinette Nwandu cited Samuel Beckett's (1953) as a primary structural influence, adapting its depiction of two figures trapped in repetitive, existential limbo—marked by banter, games, and futile anticipation—to portray the protagonists' entrapment on an urban street corner. She described Beckett's work as instrumental in drawing her to theater, enabling her to infuse Pass Over with absurd, cyclical dialogue that underscores themes of stagnation and unfulfilled longing. The play originated in 2012 as Nwandu's response to the killing of on February 26 of that year, transforming personal and communal grief into a meditation on Black aspirations amid systemic violence. The biblical provides the core mythic framework, with Nwandu explicitly framing Pass Over as a reflection on its liberation narrative, contrasting its hopeful trajectory against Godot's despair. The protagonist embodies the biblical figure who confronts and leads the enslaved from , here reimagined as a street-wise leader yearning to escape modern oppression toward a "promised land" of abundance, evoked through repeated invocations of milk and honey from Exodus 3:8 and 3:17. His companion Kitch serves as a foil, akin to the doubting masses in , bound by habit yet complicit in their shared stasis. Nwandu structures the drama across three temporal layers rooted in Exodus motifs: ancient Egyptian bondage, antebellum plantation slavery (where the men could represent fugitives seeking passage north), and contemporary urban poverty, each illustrating cycles of subjugation and failed exodus. The title Pass Over directly references the Passover ritual in Exodus 12, commemorating the tenth plague where the angel of death spared Hebrew homes marked with lamb's blood, precipitating Pharaoh's release of the slaves—an event symbolizing divine protection and transition from peril. The character , a white interloper offering deceptive hospitality, parallels Pharaoh's false accommodations or the biblical tempter, culminating in a betrayal that echoes the plagues' judgment on oppressors. This biblical integration draws from African American traditions, including that recast Exodus as allegory for —such as ""—and Martin Luther King Jr.'s sermons invoking Pharaoh's downfall to critique segregation, which Nwandu credits for embedding hope within communal resilience. Unlike Godot's absent savior, Pass Over's arc resolves with redemptive possibility, aligning with 's covenantal promise and Nwandu's aim to affirm healing over nihilism.

Early Productions and Broadway Run

Pass Over received its world premiere at in , with previews beginning on June 1, 2017, and performances running through July 9, 2017, in the Upstairs Theatre. Directed by Danya Taymor, who replaced in the role, the production featured a cast including . A filmed version of this Steppenwolf staging, directed by , premiered at the and was released on on April 20, 2018. The play made its New York debut as part of Lincoln Center Theater's LCT3 program at the Claire Tow Theater, opening on June 18, 2018, following previews, and extended its limited run through July 22, 2018. Retaining Taymor's direction, the production starred as Kitch, Namir Smallwood as , and Ryan Hallahan in the roles of and the Police Officer. This staging marked an evolution from the original, with adjustments to the script reflecting ongoing refinements by playwright Antoinette Nwandu. Pass Over transferred to Broadway at the August Wilson Theatre under Lincoln Center Theater's production banner, beginning previews on August 4, 2021, and officially opening on August 22, 2021, as the first straight play to return to Broadway following the COVID-19 theater shutdown in March 2020. The limited engagement concluded on October 10, 2021, after 49 performances. Directed again by Taymor, the cast included returning performers Hill as Kitch and Smallwood as Moses, with Gabriel Ebert replacing Hallahan in the supporting roles of Mister and Police Officer. Nwandu substantially revised the play for this mounting, extending its length, broadening its tonal range, and altering the ending to emphasize themes of healing and hope amid its critique of systemic violence.

Film Adaptation

Development and Pre-Production

The filmed version of Pass Over originated from the play's successful world premiere at Chicago's , which ran from June 8 to July 30, 2017, under the stage direction of Danya Taymor. , drawn to the production's fusion of biblical motifs, , and contemporary urban violence, initiated the project to capture it cinematically without altering the live performance dynamic. The collaboration between Lee and the Steppenwolf team emphasized preserving the play's raw theatrical energy, with Lee serving as in tandem with Taymor's stage oversight. Pre-production was expedited and discreet to maintain performance authenticity, with filming arranged over a single weekend in late November 2017 at the Steppenwolf Theatre. coordinated an invitation-only audience comprising community groups and students, facilitated in part by Chicago activist , to replicate a genuine live atmosphere while avoiding external pressures that could influence the actors. The secrecy surrounding the shoot—kept from the cast and broader public until after completion—aimed to prevent self-conscious adjustments, ensuring the capture reflected the production's organic rhythm as experienced during its Chicago run. Technical preparations focused on multi-camera setups for intimate angles, diverging from standard filming by incorporating Lee's signature mobility, such as dolly shots, to enhance emotional proximity without disrupting the stage action. Antoinette Nwandu, the , described the filming as a serendipitous extension of the play's mission to reach wider audiences beyond theater walls, aligning with Lee's history of adapting stage works like . No script revisions occurred; the film retained the 90-minute runtime and dialogue intact from the Steppenwolf staging, starring as and Ryan Hallahan alternating as Kitch and Mister. Post-capture editing by Lee refined the footage for cinematic flow, premiering at the before Amazon Studios' release. This approach prioritized fidelity to the live event over narrative reconfiguration, distinguishing it from conventional screen adaptations.

Casting and Principal Crew

The film adaptation of Pass Over retained the principal cast from the Steppenwolf Theatre Company's 2017 Chicago production, preserving the intimacy of the stage performance in its cinematic translation. portrays Moses, the more aspirational and biblically named character trapped in a cycle of street life; Julian Parker plays Kitch (short for "Kitchen"), his more fatalistic companion; Ryan Hallahan embodies the dual roles of Mister and Master, representing white liberal condescension and historical ; and Blake DeLong appears as Ossifer, officer embodying institutional violence.
ActorRole(s)
Julian ParkerKitch
Ryan HallahanMister / Master
Blake DeLongOssifer
Spike Lee directed the film alongside Danya Taymor, who had helmed the original stage version, with Lee also credited as producer through his 40 Acres and a Mule Filmworks. Antoinette Nwandu wrote the screenplay, adapting her own 2017 play without significant alterations to accommodate the medium. Key technical crew included Chayse Irvin, who captured the single-set production with a focus on close-ups to emphasize actor performances; costume designer Marci Rodgers; and editor Hye Mee Na. The production was backed by Amazon Studios, which acquired rights post-Sundance premiere.

Filming and Technical Aspects

The film adaptation of Pass Over was captured live on the stage of Chicago's Steppenwolf Theatre during a 2017 performance of the company's world-premiere production, directed onstage by Danya Taymor. oversaw the filming in close collaboration with Taymor, employing a multi-camera setup to record the action from multiple angles, which enabled editing to create dynamic cuts and a sense of cinematic immediacy rather than a static recording. This technique transformed the theatrical presentation into a more fluid, film-like experience, with sequences featuring rapid angle changes that mimicked shooting on a confined set. The filming incorporated the original stage technical elements, including Wilson Chin's minimalist set design depicting an urban corner with a single lamppost and bench to symbolize and stasis. Marcus Doshi's utilized stark, shadowy contrasts and selective spotlights to heighten the production's ominous mood, evoking perpetual night and impending threat through dim, flickering illumination that played against the actors' movements. Justin Ellington's integrated ambient noises, echoes, and abrupt effects to amplify tension and realism, with microphones capturing both performers' dialogue and audience reactions for immersive audio layering. The shoot took place before an invited of local community groups, preserving the live performance's raw energy and spontaneous interplay while maintaining theatrical intimacy; this was not the general public, contributing to an unpolished authenticity in the captured responses. No extensive reshoots or location changes were involved, as the relied on the confined space to mirror the play's themes of cyclical , with Lee's direction focusing on preserving the performers' improvisational vigor—particularly the rhythmic, profane banter between leads and Ryan Hallahan—through precise camera framing and timing.

Premiere and Distribution

The filmed adaptation of Pass Over, directed by and Danya Taymor, received its world premiere at the on January 26, 2018, where it screened as part of the NEXT section showcasing innovative independent works. The production, capturing a staging from , featured original cast members as Moses and Ryan Hallahan as Kitch, with the festival presentation emphasizing its blend of theatrical intimacy and cinematic techniques like close-ups and dynamic camera movements to heighten tension. Following Sundance, the film had additional festival screenings, including at (SXSW) on March 10, 2018, broadening exposure to audiences interested in socially provocative narratives. Amazon Studios handled distribution, releasing Pass Over exclusively as a streaming original on Prime Video worldwide on , 2018, bypassing traditional theatrical rollout in favor of direct-to-digital . This approach aligned with the film's origins as a recorded stage performance, prioritizing home viewing to reach broader demographics amid discussions of urban violence and racial dynamics in the U.S. The release garnered attention for its timely resonance, particularly post-Ferguson, though viewership metrics remained modest compared to larger Amazon originals, reflecting the niche appeal of its 75-minute runtime and experimental format. As of 2025, the film remains available on Prime Video, with no reported or international theatrical variants beyond festival circuits.

Content and Themes

Plot Summary

Pass Over follows Moses and Kitch, two young Black men trapped in a repetitive cycle on an urban corner, where they engage in crude banter, rap freestyles, and shared dreams of escaping to free from hardship. Their conversations reveal frustrations with daily , including and the constant threat of violence, as they yearn for a to "pass over" into and , drawing direct parallels to the biblical Exodus narrative. The duo's routine is disrupted by the arrival of a white stranger dubbed "Mister," who approaches carrying a picnic basket filled with food, offering sustenance and paternalistic advice on achieving the through opportunity and moral uprightness. This encounter exposes tensions around race, privilege, and false promises of equality, as Mister's well-intentioned but oblivious demeanor clashes with the men's lived realities. Subsequently, a enters the scene, wielding authority and a , which heightens the stakes and forces and Kitch to confront immediate peril rooted in systemic policing and . The , running approximately 90 minutes without intermission, unfolds in real time on this confined setting, blending absurdist waiting akin to Samuel Beckett's with raw depictions of entrapment and fleeting hope.

Core Themes and Symbolism

Pass Over examines the entrapment of Black men within cycles of systemic racial oppression and violence, portraying their daily existence as a limbo marked by existential dread and the constant threat of police brutality. Drawing from Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot, the protagonists Moses and Kitch engage in repetitive banter on a street corner, awaiting an elusive escape to a "promised land" of safety and opportunity, which symbolizes unattainable freedom amid urban decay. This setup critiques the futility of hope in environments shaped by institutional barriers, where aspirations for upward mobility are thwarted by prejudice and danger. Biblical allusions to the form a central layer, equating the street corner to —a site of bondage—and the characters' dreams to the ' quest for . Playwright Antoinette Nwandu layers this with historical echoes of , positioning the corner as a metaphorical from which escape seems perpetually deferred. The title Pass Over evokes the narrative of divine protection and liberation, underscoring a yearning for transcendence over oppression, reinforced by the character's name , who embodies prophetic leadership burdened by failure. Symbolism permeates the work, with the street corner functioning as a liminal void of entrapment, mirroring both Godot's barren road and Exodus's wilderness of waiting. Provisions like the offered by the white character "" parody biblical , representing illusory sustenance tainted by and racial rather than genuine deliverance. Encounters with white figures—Mister as a false benefactor and the Cop as an enforcer of lethal authority—highlight power imbalances, where apparent aid devolves into violence, symbolizing failed interracial alliances and the inescapability of predatory policing. These elements collectively interrogate whether liberation requires internal healing or external upheaval, a tension Nwandu revised in later versions to emphasize communal recovery over despair.

Critical Analysis of Social Commentary

Pass Over presents a stark indictment of American society as an oppressive "Egypt," where Black men like Moses and Kitch are perpetually ensnared in cycles of violence, poverty, and fatal encounters with police, drawing parallels to the biblical Exodus to underscore themes of subjugation and unfulfilled liberation. The arrival of the white character Mister symbolizes insidious white privilege and liberal paternalism, culminating in betrayal and death, which playwright Antoinette Nwandu frames as emblematic of broader systemic failures in addressing Black suffering. This commentary, penned in response to Trayvon Martin's 2012 killing, channels collective grief into a surreal critique of racial inequities, positioning police and white benevolence as existential threats rather than isolated actors. Yet, the play's portrayal risks oversimplifying causal dynamics by foregrounding external while sidelining intra-community factors empirically linked to urban hardship. data from the Uniform Crime Reporting program indicate that in 2019, individuals represented 51.3% of arrests for and nonnegligent —a disproportionate figure given their 13.2% share of the U.S. population—with over 90% of victims killed by offenders. Such patterns persist in recent years, underscoring that the primary vector of lethal violence in depicted settings stems from within affected communities, not predominantly from interracial policing, which accounts for a small fraction of overall mortality. Compounding this, structural elements like family dissolution play a verifiable role in perpetuating the stagnation Pass Over evokes, yet receive no dramatic scrutiny. In 2023, 47% of Black mothers headed single-parent households, compared to 21% overall, with consistently associating —prevalent at rates exceeding 70% for Black children—with elevated risks of , educational underachievement, and criminality. These correlations, evident since the 1965 Moynihan Report and reinforced by longitudinal studies, point to behavioral and cultural shifts post-1960s as key drivers, rather than immutable , given Black socioeconomic gains in that era amid declining overt . By emulating Waiting for Godot's existential stasis, the narrative implicitly endorses passivity, awaiting a "Promised Land" beyond personal or communal agency, which may inadvertently cultivate the victimhood orientation scholars like John McWhorter decry as counterproductive to empowerment. Nwandu's revisions for hopefulness notwithstanding, the core dramaturgy prioritizes rage over realism, potentially mirroring biases in academia and media that amplify grievance narratives while downplaying self-determination, as evidenced by backlash against reviewers questioning its universality—responses branding critique as racism rather than engaging evidence. This selective lens, while artistically potent, limits the play's capacity to illuminate actionable paths out of the corner it so vividly traps its protagonists upon.

Reception and Impact

Critical Reviews

The 2018 film adaptation of Pass Over, directed by Danya Taymor and produced by , received widespread critical acclaim, earning a 93% approval rating on based on 14 reviews. Critics praised its innovative blend of theatrical staging and , with Ebert's Allen awarding it 3.5 out of 4 stars for vividly capturing the play's existential tension and social critique without diluting its raw intensity. The Hollywood Reporter's Sheri Linden highlighted the film's unflinching portrayal of despair amid racial injustice, noting its fidelity to the source material's tragic essence while commending the performances of leads John Michael Hill and Julian Parker. Reviews from major outlets emphasized the film's thematic depth, drawing parallels to Samuel Beckett's and the biblical Exodus narrative to explore cycles of violence and entrapment faced by young Black men. The New York Times commended Spike Lee's production oversight for exploding conventional "filmed play" boundaries, integrating audience reactions to heighten immersion and underscore communal witnessing of the characters' plight. However, the limited number of professional reviews reflects its niche release on , and some critiques noted its unrelenting bleakness, with no resolution offering uplift beyond symbolic hope. Mainstream acclaim aligned with the film's explicit engagement with police brutality and systemic racism—issues resonant in 2018 amid heightened national discourse—but audience scores were more divided, averaging 6.1/10 on , where viewers often described it as feeling like an unaltered stage recording lacking cinematic dynamism. While progressive-leaning publications lauded its provocative commentary on American racial dynamics, the film's reception echoed broader patterns in coverage of works addressing victimhood, where empirical scrutiny of causal factors like individual agency receives less emphasis than institutional indictments. Independent outlets like The Candler Blog appreciated its concert-like energy but acknowledged its stage-bound limitations, suggesting the adaptation prioritizes fidelity over broader accessibility. Overall, Pass Over solidified Nwandu's reputation for bold, language-driven drama, though its polarizing style underscores divides between critical establishments and general viewers on artistic versus propagandistic interpretations of social ills.

Audience and Commercial Performance

The Broadway production of Pass Over at the August Wilson Theatre opened on August 22, 2021, and closed on October 10, 2021, after a limited run of approximately seven weeks following previews that began earlier in August. The show generated a total gross of $1,829,202, with a highest weekly gross of $242,988 in its final week, an average ticket price of $42.20, and an average capacity of 47.59% across performances. These figures reflected commercial underperformance, as the production relied heavily on discounted $30 rush tickets available daily at the and distributed numerous complimentary tickets, filling about two-thirds of seats but often through non-revenue means rather than paid sales. As the first Broadway play to open following the COVID-19 shutdowns of March 2020, Pass Over benefited from initial curiosity about the industry's return but struggled to sustain broad commercial appeal amid a challenging post-pandemic market. Producers noted early sales momentum, yet reports indicated persistent half-empty houses for some performances, contributing to the decision for a short engagement despite critical acclaim for its Off-Broadway iterations. Prior regional productions, such as the 2017 Steppenwolf Theatre premiere in Chicago and the 2018 Lincoln Center Theater/LCT3 mounting, had achieved stronger relative success through awards like the 2019 Obie for Best New American Play and extended runs, but the Broadway transfer did not replicate that trajectory. Audience reception emphasized the play's intense emotional impact, with viewers reporting feelings of discomfort, urgency for , and unexpected optimism amid its raw depictions of racial peril and existential dread. For the Broadway debut, theatergoers exhibited an ebullient energy reflective of pent-up demand for live performance, blending the production's profane humor and rhythmic dialogue with the novelty of returning to full houses. Earlier stagings drew observations of predominantly white audiences, including mid-life attendees and interracial pairs, which some critiques suggested influenced interpretations of the work's racial themes, though such demographics were not systematically tracked for Broadway. Overall, while the play resonated with those seeking provocative , its niche focus on Black male vulnerability limited crossover appeal, aligning with its modest outcomes.

Awards and Nominations

Pass Over received the 2019 Lucille Lortel Award for Outstanding Play for its production at Theater/LCT3. The world premiere production in 2017 won Joseph Jefferson (Jeff) Awards. Antoinette Nwandu was awarded the Playwriting Award in 2017 for the script. The play was a finalist for the 2018 Susan Smith Blackburn Prize. Nwandu received the 2017 Sky Cooper New Play Prize from Marin Theatre Company, including a $10,000 award and developmental workshop. For the 2021 Broadway production, scenic designer Wilson Chin earned a 2022 Drama Desk Award nomination for Outstanding Scenic Design of a Play. The Off-Broadway production also received a Lucille Lortel nomination for Outstanding Scenic Design and a Henry Hewes Design Award nomination for Scenic Design. Earlier, the script was a 2015 finalist for the Ruby Prize and appeared on the 2016 Kilroys List.

Controversies and Alternative Perspectives

Portrayals of Race and Policing

In Pass Over, Antoinette Nwandu portrays Black men in an urban American setting as ensnared by systemic barriers, poverty, and routine violence, with policing depicted as a capricious and lethal force symbolizing broader racial oppression. The protagonists, Moses and Kitch, inhabit a street corner marked by repetitive cycles of fear, slang-laden banter, and small-scale criminality, while aspiring to escape to a vague "Promised Land." Police presence looms as an omnipresent danger, indifferent to context; in the play's climax, Moses is fatally shot by an officer after displaying a shank, framing law enforcement as the ultimate arbiter of Black fate without exploring officer discretion or preceding threats. This representation has drawn criticism for oversimplifying and policing dynamics, prioritizing a of unrelenting victimhood over empirical complexities. Reviewers have faulted the play's "pungent poetic personifications of power and victimhood," arguing it reduces characters—including a well-meaning but oblivious passerby and a stereotypical cop—to caricatures that indict systemic whiteness without nuance or reciprocity. The cop's generic portrayal as inherently racist, meant to evoke universal culpability, has been deemed "wrong-headed and self-defeating," sidelining variations in police conduct and community factors. Empirical data underscores disparities in these depictions: while Black Americans face elevated homicide victimization rates (26.6 per 100,000 versus 7.1 overall), the overwhelming majority—88.7% in 2019—of known offenders against Black victims are , not police or perpetrators (8.6%). Police-involved killings of individuals, though tragic and numbering around 250 annually, constitute a fraction of total homicides (over 7,000 yearly), with justifiable homicides by law enforcement at 81 in 2022 per Supplementary Homicide Reports. Critics contend the play's emphasis on police as the primary threat distorts causal priorities, neglecting how elevated rates in certain communities—disproportionately involving offenders—generate more frequent and higher-risk police encounters. Alternative analyses challenge bias claims in lethal force: a 2017 study by economist Roland Fryer found no racial differences in police shootings after controlling for encounter , though non-lethal showed disparities attributable to situational variables rather than animus. Such perspectives argue that works like Pass Over, lauded in mainstream outlets for confronting "systemic racism," often amplify selective anecdotes amid institutional preferences for narratives aligning with prevailing academic and media framings, potentially eroding trust without addressing root contributors like family structure dissolution or cultural norms disincentivizing agency.

Debates on Victimhood Narratives

Critics have debated whether Pass Over perpetuates a victimhood narrative by depicting its Black protagonists, and Kitch, as existentially trapped on an urban street corner, endlessly cycling through hope, banter, violence, and death without achieving escape to a "promised land." The play's structure, blending Samuel Beckett's with the biblical Exodus, symbolizes systemic barriers—personified by white characters like the obsequious "Mister" (a white liberal offering false salvation) and "Police" (a trigger-happy officer)—as insurmountable forces preventing Black self-liberation. This framing, inspired by real events like the 2016 police shooting of Philando Castile, has been praised by some for capturing the despair of racialized trauma but faulted by others for reducing complex social dynamics to racial determinism, sidelining individual agency and intra-community factors. Theater critic Hedy Weiss's review of the 2017 Steppenwolf Theatre premiere exemplified these tensions, commending the actors' visceral commitment while critiquing the script's "heavy-handed symbolism" and reliance on "predictable" tragic outcomes driven by caricatured white oppressors, which she argued bordered on rather than nuanced . This assessment prompted backlash, including a signed by over 200 theater professionals demanding Weiss be barred from productions for alleged , reflecting broader institutional pressures to uncritically affirm victimhood depictions in race-themed works—a dynamic often linked to left-leaning biases in arts criticism that prioritize narrative affirmation over empirical scrutiny of causal factors like family structure or cultural norms. A Journal review of the 2021 Broadway transfer similarly described the play as a "moralizing story about ," implying its emphasis on overlooks evidence of socioeconomic gains since the , such as rising median household incomes (from $24,700 in 1967 to $48,300 in 2022, adjusted for ) and declining rates, which challenge portrayals of perpetual entrapment. Empirical data further underscores the debate: while police encounters contribute to fatalities, FBI indicate that from 1980 to 2022, over 90% of victims were killed by offenders, suggesting that narratives fixating on external (white) perpetrators may distort priorities away from addressing predominant intra-racial driven by factors like single-parent households (correlating with higher rates in peer-reviewed studies). Such critiques argue the play, despite its poetic intent, risks fostering resignation over resilience, though defenders counter that ignoring systemic ignores verifiable disparities in policing and opportunity.

Responses from Conservative Critics

Hedy Weiss, theater critic for the , reviewed the Steppenwolf Theatre Company's 2017 production of Pass Over positively for its acting and staging but critiqued the playwright's worldview as steeped in grievance culture, stating that Nwandu had "swallowed the of the grievance culture, whole," portraying Black men's escape from Chicago's South Side as an unattainable without agency beyond victimhood. Weiss argued the play's bleak fusion of narrative and reinforced a deterministic cycle of oppression, with characters trapped by systemic forces rather than personal responsibility. The review prompted backlash, including announcements from at least five theaters—such as Steep Theatre, the Hypocrites, and Others to Be Announced—that they would withhold complimentary tickets from Weiss, citing her commentary as racially insensitive. The defended Weiss, emphasizing the importance of diverse critical voices in sustaining a vibrant theater scene and rejecting efforts to silence dissent. Critics aligned with conservative principles, such as those prioritizing free speech over ideological conformity, viewed the blacklisting attempts as emblematic of intolerance toward reviews challenging narratives of perpetual victimhood, arguing that such responses undermine artistic discourse rather than engage with substantive critique. In broader commentary, the controversy highlighted conservative skepticism toward Pass Over's thematic emphasis on inescapable racial , with reviewers noting its "pungent poetic personifications of white power and black victimhood" as risking reinforcement of cycles without resolution through individual action. This perspective contrasts with acclaim from progressive outlets, which often praised the play's unflinching depiction of police brutality and structural inequality, but underscores a recurring conservative concern that such works prioritize over .

References

  1. https://www.concordtheatricals.com/p/63294/pass-over
  2. https://www.nolaproject.com/passover
  3. https://www.amazon.com/Pass-Over-Antoinette-Nwandu/dp/0802147429
  4. https://kilntheatre.com/the-deep-roots-and-radical-joy-of-antoinette-nwandus-pass-over/
  5. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/41752754-pass-over
  6. https://newyorktheater.me/2021/08/27/pass-over-on-broadway-review-fiery-foul-funny-flawed-and-first/
  7. https://variety.com/2021/legit/reviews/pass-over-antoinette-nwandu-broadway-1235046615/
  8. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7768846/
  9. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-production/pass-over-531737
  10. https://playbill.com/article/antoinette-chinonye-nwandus-pass-over-opens-on-broadway-august-22
  11. https://www.theintervalny.com/interviews/2018/06/antoinette-nwandu-on-pass-over/
  12. https://andscape.com/features/playwright-antoinette-nwandu-is-healing-her-audience-and-herself/
  13. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/23/theater/pass-over-broadway.html
  14. https://www.studiotheatre.org/plays/play-detail/2019-2020-pass-over/pass-over-exodus-godot
  15. https://www.npr.org/2021/08/04/1024833930/pass-over-covers-modern-issues-in-a-blend-of-the-bible-and-waiting-for-godot
  16. https://www.theatermania.com/news/casting-announced-for-world-premiere-of-pass-over-at-steppenwolf-theatre_80746/
  17. https://www.theatermania.com/news/first-look-at-steppenwolf-theatres-world-premiere-production-of-pass-over_81375/
  18. https://perform.ink/steppenwolf-announces-cast-director-update-pass/
  19. https://playbill.com/article/antoinette-nwandus-pass-over-opens-at-lct3
  20. https://www.theatermania.com/news/antoinette-nwandus-pass-over-opens-at-lct3-lincoln-center-theater_85617/
  21. https://www.broadwayworld.com/shows/Pass-Over-332681.html
  22. https://www.lct.org/shows/pass-over/
  23. https://playbill.com/article/antoinette-chinonye-nwandus-pass-over-closes-october-10-at-august-wilson-theatre
  24. https://www.lct.org/shows/pass-over-broadway/
  25. https://thefilmstage.com/sundance-review-spike-lee-captures-pass-over-with-blistering-cinematic-life/
  26. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7768846/fullcredits
  27. https://chicago.suntimes.com/2017/12/5/18330437/steppenwolf-s-pass-over-secretly-filmed-by-spike-lee
  28. https://www.chicagotribune.com/2017/12/05/spike-lee-secretly-filmed-pass-over-at-steppenwolf/
  29. https://playbill.com/article/10-moments-that-made-pass-over-possible
  30. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/11/movies/spike-lees-pass-over-melds-cinema-and-theater.html
  31. https://www.amazon.com/Pass-Over-Jon-Michael-Hill/dp/B08CS5TYX5
  32. https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/pass-over-2018
  33. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7768846/fullcredits/
  34. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/pass_over/cast-and-crew
  35. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-reviews/pass-1080086/
  36. https://www.tvguide.com/movies/pass-over/cast/2030059252/
  37. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/pass_over
  38. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/general-news/pass-theater-review-1120843/
  39. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/movies/la-et-mn-pass-over-review-20180419-story.html
  40. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7768846/releaseinfo/
  41. https://www.pastemagazine.com/movies/spike-lee/spike-lees-pass-over-to-stream-on-amazon-prime
  42. https://deadline.com/2018/01/spike-lee-hollywood-white-culture-shes-gotta-have-it-netflix-sundance-1202265758/
  43. https://www.studiotheatre.org/plays/play-detail/2019-2020-pass-over
  44. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/22/theater/pass-over-review.html
  45. https://nystagereview.com/2018/06/18/pass-over-a-tragic-quest-in-black-and-white/
  46. https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2020/feb/20/pass-over-review-kiln-london
  47. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/09/20/shades-of-beckett-in-pass-over
  48. https://thirdcoastreview.com/stages/2017/06/17/pass-over-reworks-waiting-for-godot
  49. https://www.inlander.com/archive/in-antoinette-nwandus-pass-over-two-black-men-wonder-if-its-ever-possible-to-reach/article_38e93fad-1922-5903-bed9-c8a093283458.html
  50. https://udreview.com/a-look-into-pass-over/
  51. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/04/theater/pass-over-antoinette-chinonye-nwandu-broadway.html
  52. https://www.americantheatre.org/2017/06/27/when-critics-dont-like-their-reflection/
  53. https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2019/crime-in-the-u.s.-2019/topic-pages/tables/table-43
  54. https://www.fbi.gov/news/press-releases/fbi-releases-2022-crime-in-the-nation-statistics
  55. https://www.americanprogress.org/article/the-economic-status-of-single-mothers/
  56. https://datacenter.aecf.org/data/tables/107-children-in-single-parent-families-by-race-and-ethnicity
  57. https://www.theatrecriticism.com/pass-over-an-expletive-riddled-dialog-of-exasperation-hopelessness/
  58. https://johnmcwhorter.substack.com/p/do-black-people-enjoy-being-told
  59. https://ndigo.com/2017/07/12/pass-overs-controversial-review/
  60. https://www.candlerblog.com/2018/03/11/review-pass-over/
  61. https://playbill.com/production/pass-overaugust-wilson-theatre-2021-2022
  62. https://www.broadwayworld.com/article/PASS-OVER-Announces-Rush-Ticket-Policy-20210814
  63. https://www.forbes.com/sites/marchershberg/2021/08/19/pass-over-might-need-a-miracle-to-survive/
  64. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/05/theater/pass-over-broadway-reopens.html
  65. https://udreview.com/theater-review-pass-over-at-the-rep/
  66. https://www.newyorktheatreguide.com/reviews/pass-over-broadway-review-no-one-is-off-the-hook-in-this-challenging-yet-optimistic-play
  67. https://www.vulture.com/2021/08/theater-review-pass-over-broadway-antoinette-nwandu.html
  68. https://lortelaward.com/outstanding-play/
  69. https://www.concordtheatricals.com/a/118269/antoinette-chinonye-nwandu
  70. https://www.americantheatre.org/2017/09/29/antoinette-nwandu-receives-2017-18-paula-vogel-playwriting-award/
  71. https://www.blackburnprize.org/year/2018_/
  72. https://www.marintheatre.org/news-details/41
  73. https://wilsonchin.com/pass-over
  74. https://perform.ink/what-the-hell-is-happening-with-pass-over/
  75. https://vpc.org/black-homicide-victimization-in-the-united-states-national/
  76. https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2019/crime-in-the-u.s.-2019/tables/expanded-homicide-data-table-6.xls
  77. https://vpc.org/studies/blackhomicide24.pdf
  78. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/rethinking-the-role-of-race-in-crime-and-police-violence/
  79. https://www.nacdl.org/Content/Race-and-Policing
  80. https://www.americantheatre.org/2017/06/27/the-review-that-shook-chicago/
  81. https://news.wttw.com/2017/06/22/sun-times-critic-hedy-weiss-under-fire-steppenwolf-review
  82. https://www.wsj.com/articles/pass-over-antoinette-chinonya-nwandu-boca-jessica-provenz-11630014381
  83. https://www.broadwayworld.com/article/Where-Are-All-of-the-Female-Theatre-Critics-20221111
  84. https://chicago.suntimes.com/2017/6/13/18440050/pass-over-envisions-a-godot-like-endgame-for-young-black-men
  85. https://www.chicagotribune.com/2017/06/23/some-theaters-say-they-will-no-longer-invite-sun-times-critic-hedy-weiss-to-openings/
  86. https://chicago.suntimes.com/2017/6/23/18320145/we-stand-by-our-critic-and-a-vital-chicago-theater-scene
  87. https://stageandcinema.com/2017/06/11/pass-over/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.