Hubbry Logo
Stella ImmanuelStella ImmanuelMain
Open search
Stella Immanuel
Community hub
Stella Immanuel
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Stella Immanuel
Stella Immanuel
Stella Immanuel
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Stella Gwandiku-Ambe Immanuel (born 1965) is a Cameroonian-American physician and pastor. In mid-2020 amid the COVID-19 pandemic, a video went viral on social media platforms in which Immanuel said hydroxychloroquine can cure COVID-19, and that public health measures such as social distancing and the wearing of face masks were ineffective and unnecessary. The platforms removed Immanuel's videos and posts, which they said promoted misinformation related to the pandemic.[1]

Key Information

Immanuel is also the founder of a charismatic religious organization called Fire Power Ministries; in her role as its founder, she has made fringe claims about other medical conditions, especially in relation to human sexuality. She has said endometriosis, infertility, miscarriage, and sexually transmitted infections (STIs) are caused by spirit spouses, and has also endorsed a number of conspiracy theories that include the involvement of space aliens and the Illuminati in manipulating society and government.[2]

Immanuel emigrated to the United States after completing her medical education in Nigeria.[3][4] As of 2021, she practices at a private clinic in Houston, Texas.[1]

Early life and education

[edit]

Stella Gwandiku-Ambe Immanuel was born in 1965 in Cameroon.[3][5] She recalled an interest in becoming a doctor from the age of four.[6] Immanuel attended Cameroon Protestant College, a secondary school in Bali, Cameroon. In 1990, she graduated from medical school at the University of Calabar in Nigeria, and in 1992, she moved to the United States.[6][4] Immanuel completed a pediatric residency at the Bronx-Lebanon Hospital Center in New York City.[6]

Career

[edit]

Immanuel began her career at a pediatric clinic in Louisiana.[4] In December 1998, she began practicing at the Southern Pediatric Clinic in Alexandria, Louisiana. In February 1999, she joined the General Pediatric Care Clinic as a pediatrician.[6] In 2006, she owned the Rapha Medical and Therapeutic Clinic in Louisiana.[4] She is a licensed physician in Texas.[5][7] The Texas Medical Board licensed Immanuel in November 2019 with an address associated with Houston's Rehoboth Medical Center, which she also owns.[1]

Immanuel is a pastor, founder of Fire Power Ministries, and host of a radio-and-television show entitled Fire Power. She is a self-described "wealth transfer coach" and has written several books as part of her Occupying Force series. She has been an outspoken supporter of U.S. president Donald Trump and a long-time critic of what she views as sexual immorality, including "unmarried couples living together, homosexuality, bestiality, polygamy" and what she calls "homosexual terrorism".[4][8][9] According to Concordia University theological studies professor André Gagné, Immanuel's beliefs originate in African Pentecostalism and the charismatic movement.[10]

A January 2020 medical malpractice lawsuit filed against Immanuel alleged that a 37-year-old woman died after Immanuel failed to remove a needle fragment from her arm. According to the lawsuit, the woman told Immanuel that the broken needle had lodged in her arm while injecting methamphetamine. Immanuel prescribed medication but did not take X-rays or attempt to retrieve the needle. It was removed later, by a different physician, after a flesh-eating infection had developed.[11] In April 2020, local deputies were unable to serve notice of the Louisiana suit because Immanuel had moved to Houston, where she set up a new practice.[1]

Medical and other claims

[edit]

Immanuel's medical claims are sometimes combined with her spiritual beliefs: she believes many gynecological illnesses are the result of having sex dreams with succubi and incubi, and receiving demon sperm; and that endometriosis, infertility, miscarriage, and sexually transmitted infections are caused by spirit spouses.[5][2] In a 2015 sermon, Immanuel said space alien DNA is used in medical treatments and that "reptilian spirits" and other extraterrestrials run the U.S. government.[2][12] The same year, she also said Illuminati are using witches to destroy the world through abortion, gay marriage, children's toys, and media, including Harry Potter, Pokémon, Wizards of Waverly Place and Hannah Montana. In another 2015 sermon, she said scientists are developing vaccines to stop people from being religious.[5][2]

COVID-19 misinformation

[edit]
See also: Tea Party Patriots § America's Frontline Doctors event, America's Frontline Doctors, Misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic, and Hydroxychloroquine § COVID-19

On July 27, 2020, Immanuel appeared in a Tea Party Patriots-backed press event that was organized by the group "America's Frontline Doctors"[a] in front of the steps of the U.S. Supreme Court Building.[13] She said she had cured COVID-19 in 350 patients at her clinic using a combination of hydroxychloroquine, azithromycin, and zinc,[b] and that public health measures such as the wearing of facial coverings and social distancing are unnecessary.[14][15][16] Republican representative Ralph Norman from South Carolina attended the event.[14] The far-right website Breitbart News published the press event's video.[17]

On October 15, 2021, the Texas medical board took corrective action against Immanuel over her hydroxychloroquine prescription for COVID patient. In the decision, the board ordered Immanuel to submit proof of informed consent, or permission given by a patient who understands the possible health outcomes, for all of the off-label treatments she provides. She also was ordered to pay a $500 fine to the medical board.[18]

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) had earlier removed the emergency use authorization for the antimalarial medication hydroxychloroquine against COVID-19; the FDA said the drug had not been proven to be an effective treatment for the disease.[5][13][14][19][20]

The video was viewed millions of times, and was retweeted by President Trump and his son Donald Trump Jr., before it was removed from Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube because it broke their rules on misinformation.[21][22] At a press conference on July 28, President Trump was asked why he would trust Immanuel in the context of her claims about alien DNA and its supposed use in medicine; Trump defended Immanuel, saying, "I thought she was very impressive, in the sense that, from where she came—I don't know what country she comes from—but she said she's had tremendous success with hundreds of different patients. I thought her voice was an important voice, but I know nothing about her."[5]

After being pressed further, Trump abruptly ended the briefing.[23] After her content was removed from Facebook, Immanuel expressed her frustration on Twitter, saying, "Hello Facebook put back my profile page and videos up or your computers with [sic] start crashing till you do. You are not bigger that [sic] God. I promise you. If my page is not back up face book [sic] will be down in Jesus [sic] name."[24]

She later posted a tweet accusing technology companies of censorship; that content was also removed from the platform.[1]

In July 2021, she sued CNN and specifically Anderson Cooper, saying that their coverage of her in 2020 had defamed her.[25] She lost the case after failing to show the network made any false statements.[26]

In March 2023, MedPage Today reported that Immanuel was the single highest prescriber of ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine in the United States for the years 2021 and 2022. In 2021, Immanuel wrote just over 69,000 prescriptions for hydroxychloroquine—vastly above the average of 43 prescriptions in the database MedPage Today reviewed. Rheumatologists, who prescribe hydroxychloroquine for autoimmune diseases, wrote 561 hydroxychloroquine prescriptions, on average, that year. Immanuel also wrote almost 32,000 prescriptions for ivermectin in 2021, well above the average of 15.[27]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Stella Immanuel

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Stella Gwandiku Immanuel is a Cameroonian-born American physician and Pentecostal pastor based in the area, where she maintains a medical practice specializing in and while leading Fire Power Ministries, a deliverance-focused church emphasizing aggressive against demonic . Trained abroad and licensed in , Immanuel integrates her Christian faith with clinical work, attributing many issues to spiritual causes resolvable through faith, , and specific pharmaceuticals like combined with . She rose to prominence in 2020 by claiming to have treated over 350 patients with this regimen, reporting zero fatalities, and participating in a press event with to promote early outpatient use of such therapies amid debates. Data from prescription tracking shows her as the leading U.S. prescriber of and from 2020 to 2022, issuing thousands of scripts, though she faced Texas Medical Board corrective action in 2021 for one case lacking in-person evaluation. Her ministry, rooted in the Mountain of Fire and Miracles tradition, hosts revivals and radio programs teaching "violent prayers" for liberation from supernatural afflictions, including those she links to reproductive and gynecological disorders.

Early life and education

Upbringing in

Stella Gwandiku-Ambe Immanuel was born in 1965 in Bali Nyonga, a town in the Northwest Region of . She was raised in this region, where she completed her early education, including secondary schooling at the Cameroon Protestant College in Bali. During her upbringing in , Immanuel developed an interest in from a young age, which influenced her later pursuit of medical training abroad. Limited public details exist regarding her background or specific childhood experiences in , though she has identified strongly with her Cameroonian roots in professional profiles.

Medical training and early career in Nigeria

Immanuel, born in , pursued her medical studies in neighboring due to regional educational opportunities and completed her Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery (MBBS) at the in 1990. The , a federal institution founded in 1975 in , offered a aligned with the Medical and Dental Training Council of Nigeria's standards, emphasizing clinical rotations in , , , and obstetrics-gynecology during the six-year program. This training equipped her with foundational knowledge in tropical diseases common to , including management using antimalarials like . Following graduation, Nigerian medical protocol required a one-year provisional (house job) at an approved to qualify for full registration with the Medical and Dental Council of Nigeria. While specific locations for Immanuel's are not publicly detailed, this period constituted her initial hands-on clinical experience in 's sector, where physicians often rotated through departments handling high patient volumes amid resource constraints. Such early exposure likely involved treating infectious diseases and maternal-child health issues prevalent in the region. Immanuel's time in Nigeria ended with her in 1992, after approximately two years post-graduation, marking the transition from her foundational training and provisional practice to pursuing further credentials abroad. Public records provide scant details on exact postings or patient caseloads during this phase, consistent with the opaque documentation of early careers for many international medical graduates from that era.

Immigration and initial practice in the United States

Immanuel, born in and trained as a physician in , immigrated to the in the early . Upon arrival, she pursued validation of her foreign medical credentials to enable practice in the U.S. healthcare system, which requires international graduates to pass examinations such as the (USMLE) and complete any necessary residency training. She obtained a full, unrestricted from the Texas Medical Board, allowing her to practice independently. With over 30 years of experience by 2020, her U.S. career commenced in the mid-1990s, focusing initially on . Immanuel established her early practice in the metropolitan area, including , where she specialized in , , and emergency care. Her operations emphasized for families, integrating her medical background with a commitment to underserved communities in . No major disciplinary actions were recorded against her prior to 2020 related to her initial practice.

Medical career

Licensing and practice in pediatrics and emergency medicine

Stella Immanuel holds a medical license in Texas authorizing practice in pediatrics and emergency medicine, issued by the Texas Medical Board in November 2019. She is also licensed to practice medicine in Arkansas and Arizona. Her Texas license remains active as of 2023, with no record of revocation or suspension. Immanuel practices primarily as a pediatrician at a in , where she has over 30 years of experience in the field following her medical degree from the University of Calabar Faculty of Medicine in . listed as providing services in and , though specific details on formal residency training in are not publicly documented in state licensing records. There is no evidence of by the American Board of Pediatrics or the American Board of Emergency Medicine, which is typically required for specialists in these areas but not mandatory for state licensure. In October 2021, the Medical Board addressed complaints regarding Immanuel's remote prescription of for treatment without an in-person examination, resulting in a non-disciplinary remedial plan requiring completion of ethics and telemedicine education courses. This action did not restrict her ability to practice or . Earlier, in August 2020, the board issued a general warning to physicians against unsubstantiated treatment claims, citing potential violations of standards of care, though no formal sanction followed at that time.

Clinic operations and patient treatment approaches

Stella Immanuel owns and operates Rehoboth Medical Center, a brick-and-mortar clinic located in the area of , where she provides services including . The clinic, associated with her medical license granted in November 2019, functions as a facility but expanded during the to include telemedicine consultations through her platform DrStellaMD.com, staffed by licensed physicians and nurse practitioners. This hybrid model enabled high-volume patient interactions, with prescription data indicating tens of thousands of fills annually, primarily remotely. Immanuel's patient treatment approaches emphasize early outpatient intervention for infectious diseases, particularly , using off-label prescriptions of (HCQ) and combined with adjuncts like and . By July 2020, she reported treating 350 patients with this regimen, claiming zero hospitalizations or deaths among them. Prescription records from Symphony Health show she issued approximately 69,000 HCQ and 32,000 prescriptions in 2021, and 30,996 HCQ and 16,085 prescriptions in 2022, making her the highest U.S. prescriber of these drugs during that period. These approaches prioritize repurposed and antimalarial agents over standard supportive care, with Immanuel advocating for their use in high-risk patients to prevent progression. In response to concerns over for off-label COVID-19 treatments, the Texas Medical Board imposed a remedial plan on Immanuel in October 2021 requiring enhanced on risks, which was terminated in January 2022 after compliance. Her protocols align with broader early-treatment strategies outlined in peer-reviewed proposals for multidrug regimens in settings, though mainstream guidelines from bodies like the FDA and CDC do not endorse HCQ or for outside trials due to insufficient efficacy evidence from large randomized studies.

Prescription patterns for off-label medications

Stella Immanuel's prescription patterns for off-label medications are marked by unusually high volumes of (HCQ) and , primarily directed toward treatment and prevention—uses lacking FDA authorization. According to Symphony Health prescription claims data covering 2020 through 2022, Immanuel ranked as the top U.S. prescriber of both drugs. In 2021, she issued approximately 69,000 HCQ prescriptions and 32,000 prescriptions, compared to national averages of 43 HCQ and 15 prescriptions per prescriber that year. Her 2022 figures remained elevated at 30,996 HCQ and 16,085 prescriptions, while second-half 2020 data showed around 10,000 HCQ and 1,500 prescriptions amid rising pandemic interest in these agents. For perspective, rheumatologists prescribing HCQ for approved indications like averaged just 561 prescriptions annually. These patterns relied heavily on mechanisms, with prescriptions originating from online consultations via Immanuel's platform DrStellaMD.com and networks like . This approach allowed for rapid patient access, direct pharmacy shipping of medications, and treatment of thousands seeking alternatives to standard protocols, though data lacks explicit indication confirmation and assumes off-label intent based on contemporaneous advocacy. A specific instance underscored procedural aspects of her off-label prescribing. In October 2021, the Medical Board determined that Immanuel prescribed HCQ to a patient without establishing an adequate physician-patient relationship, documenting , or fully disclosing risks such as cardiac effects, prompting corrective action including a $500 fine and mandated ethics training. No comparable volume data exists for other off-label drugs in her practice.

Religious ministry

Founding and leadership of Fire Power Ministries

Stella Immanuel established Fire Power Ministries in 2002 as a charismatic deliverance-focused emphasizing , prayer, and to combat demonic influences. The ministry draws inspiration from the teachings of Dr. D.K. Olukoya, founder of Mountain of Fire and Miracles Ministries, whom Immanuel describes as her spiritual father, and she has served as branch for that larger network in . Initially registered as a faith-based entity in May 2006 at a residential address in , the ministry expanded its operations, including hosting radio and television programs titled Fire Power. As founder and senior leader, Immanuel positions herself as a "prophet of to the nations" and "God's Warrior Princess," directing services that promote aggressive, "violent" tactics—drawing from biblical references like Matthew 11:12—to confront and expel evil spirits, with the motto "the violent taketh it by force." Under her leadership, the ministry conducts weekly studies, monthly revival conferences, and events such as baptisms of the Holy Ghost at facilities like Bethel Revival Ranch in Pattison, , while encouraging extended fasting and nightly prayers for breakthroughs. Programs also include , health fairs, and outreach like orphanage scholarships and microeconomic support in , , alongside a Christian resource center distributing books, videos, and CDs on spiritual topics. The ministry relocated or expanded to , operating churches in areas like Katy and , where Immanuel leads sessions aimed at cleansing participants of curses, , and generational demonic bonds through rituals and . 's approach integrates her self-described expertise in identifying spiritual sources of personal defeat, deception, and weakness, urging believers to maintain vigilance against satanic forces via structured points and warfare strategies.

Integration of faith healing with medical practice

Immanuel maintains that numerous physical ailments, including gynecological conditions like and , stem from spiritual causes such as sexual encounters with demonic entities during dreams or . In her sermons and writings, she describes these interactions as leading to infertility, cysts, and other reproductive disorders, advocating prayers to expel the spirits responsible before or alongside interventions. This perspective frames illness not merely as biological but as a manifestation of spiritual oppression, requiring confrontation through "violent " and to achieve breakthroughs in health. Through Fire Power Ministries, Immanuel promotes biblical healing scriptures as a foundational tool for addressing diseases, citing passages such as Deuteronomy 7:15—which promises removal of "all sickness" and "evil diseases"—and :5, emphasizing by Christ's stripes. Her ministry distributes resources like downloadable healing scripture compilations and hosts and fairs that blend scriptural declarations with practical support, encouraging believers to invoke divine against ailments ranging from chronic infections to unspecified "evil diseases." As a licensed pediatrician operating a in , she integrates these elements by viewing demonic influences as underlying factors in persistent medical issues, reportedly incorporating and exorcism-like rituals into patient care to target what she identifies as roots of symptoms. This approach reflects Immanuel's self-described training under influences like Dr. D.K. Olukoya, emphasizing aggressive spiritual tactics—"the violent taketh it by force"—to dismantle demonic strongholds believed to perpetuate illness. While she prescribes conventional medications for conditions like , her framework prioritizes faith-based expulsion of entities over exclusive reliance on pharmaceuticals, asserting that true healing demands addressing the spiritual dimension ignored by mainstream . Critics from medical regulatory bodies have scrutinized this fusion, citing it as unorthodox and potentially delaying evidence-based treatments, though Immanuel defends it as biblically mandated wholeness encompassing body and spirit.

Specific doctrinal teachings on spiritual warfare

Immanuel's doctrinal teachings on center on the imperative for believers to engage in aggressive, biblically grounded confrontation with demonic entities that hinder personal destiny and spiritual progress. She posits that spiritual battles are not metaphorical but literal engagements against principalities, powers, and rulers of darkness, requiring "violent" faith as per Matthew 11:12—"the violent taketh it by force"—to seize victories from satanic control. This involves identifying sources of defeat, such as evil covenants, familiar spirits, and "destiny killers," which she describes as supernatural agents dispatched to thwart God's ordained paths for individuals. Central to her framework are "judgmental prayers," where believers pronounce divine verdicts on , invoking scriptural authority to bind, loose, and dismantle strongholds. In sermons, she instructs on using as a to " the ," reclaim stolen territories, and operate as "God's ," emphasizing persistence until adversaries are fully consumed. Effective warfare, per her teachings, demands submission to the , invocation of ' blood for protection, and daily fervent to demolish altars of affliction, break ancestral yokes, and neutralize monitoring spirits. Immanuel outlines practical "keys" in her writings and ministrations, including sustained fire prayers against the strongman—the chief overseeing —and targeted assaults on satanic arrests that block callings or . She warns that passivity invites casualties, urging believers to maintain vigilance through of scriptures, of ties, and corporate warfare sessions to enforce . These elements form a deliverance-oriented , where spiritual victories manifest in physical healing and breakthroughs, aligning with her integrated ministry approach.

Public statements and advocacy

Participation in America's Frontline Doctors

Stella Immanuel emerged as a prominent figure in America's Frontline Doctors (AFLD), a physician-led group advocating for alternative approaches to COVID-19 management, through her participation in a July 27, 2020, press conference held outside the Supreme Court in Washington, D.C. During the event, which featured about a dozen doctors in white coats, Immanuel delivered opening remarks asserting that she had treated over 350 COVID-19 patients using a regimen of hydroxychloroquine, zinc, and Zithromax (azithromycin), reporting no fatalities among them. She claimed the combination served as both a cure and prophylactic, referencing a 2005 National Institutes of Health study on chloroquine's antiviral properties against SARS-like viruses, and criticized regulatory restrictions on the drug as driven by "fake science." The press conference aimed to counter prevailing public health narratives by promoting hydroxychloroquine's use, opposing mask mandates and lockdowns, and calling for school reopenings, with speakers including Immanuel emphasizing frontline treatment efficacy over experimental vaccines or ventilators. A video of the event, particularly Immanuel's segment, amassed millions of views after being shared by Donald Trump Jr. and President Trump on social media, before platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube removed it for violating policies against unsubstantiated COVID-19 treatment claims. Immanuel's involvement aligned with AFLD's broader mission to facilitate access to off-label medications like via telemedicine consultations and legal challenges against restrictions, though she was not listed among the group's initial organizers tied to conservative networks. Her statements during the event drew subsequent scrutiny from medical regulators and fact-checkers, who highlighted the lack of evidence supporting her anecdotal outcomes at the time.

Promotion of early COVID-19 treatments

In July 2020, Stella Immanuel prominently advocated for the use of as an early treatment for during a press conference organized by outside the U.S. Supreme Court on July 27. She claimed that , combined with and (a Z-Pak ), served as a cure when administered promptly after symptom onset, asserting she had treated over 350 patients with this regimen without any deaths or hospitalizations. Immanuel emphasized that early outpatient intervention prevented progression to severe illness, criticizing hospitals for withholding the treatment and attributing higher mortality rates to delayed care rather than the virus itself. Her statements drew from in her clinic, where she reported observing rapid recoveries among patients treated within the first few days of symptoms, contrasting this with what she described as suppressed data from her experience and select international reports. Immanuel argued that the regimen's efficacy stemmed from 's role in facilitating entry into cells to inhibit , a mechanism supported by studies but contested in clinical trials for COVID-19. She dismissed larger randomized controlled trials, such as the RECOVERY study published in June 2020, which found no mortality benefit from , insisting her real-world outcomes in high-risk patients provided superior . Following the video's viral spread—viewed millions of times before removal by platforms like , , and for violating policies on unverified medical claims—Immanuel continued promoting early treatments, including and later , through and public appearances. By 2021–2022, prescription data analysis identified her as the top U.S. prescriber of both and , with thousands of outpatient scripts issued, often for prophylactic or early-stage use based on her protocol. She maintained that bureaucratic restrictions, including the FDA's revocation of 's for in June 2020, hindered access and contributed to unnecessary deaths, positioning her advocacy as resistance to institutional overreach.

Broader critiques of mainstream medical institutions

Immanuel maintains that the exerts undue influence over mainstream medical institutions, prioritizing profit through chronic disease management rather than pursuing cures that could eliminate revenue streams from lifelong medications. She asserts that this model fosters dependency by promoting symptom-alleviating drugs while marginalizing cheaper alternatives, including off-label uses and natural remedies, thereby shaping clinical guidelines, funding, and physician training to align with corporate interests. In her view, regulatory agencies such as the FDA and CDC exemplify this corruption by suppressing evidence-based early treatments during the to facilitate the emergency authorization and widespread adoption of vaccines and other high-margin interventions. Immanuel has described these bodies as complicit in a broader agenda of control, including of physicians advocating repurposed drugs like and , which she claims were demonized despite clinical successes in her practice to protect pharmaceutical monopolies. She further contends that academic institutions and media outlets, often funded or aligned with industry stakeholders, amplify this suppression by discrediting alternative protocols and framing dissent as , thereby eroding in independent medical judgment. Immanuel's critiques extend to a perceived ideological in these entities, which she links to political influences that favor centralized authority over patient-centered care.

Regulatory scrutiny from medical boards

In October 2021, the Medical Board imposed corrective action on Stella Immanuel following an investigation into her July 2020 prescription of to a patient via telemedicine. The board determined that Immanuel failed to conduct an in-person evaluation, did not adequately document discussions of the drug's risks and benefits, and prescribed it without sufficient of its for the condition at the time, in violation of standards for and . The remedial agreement required Immanuel to pay a $500 administrative penalty and complete a education program, but did not restrict or suspend her . This action stemmed from a formal complaint process, including an Informal Settlement , where Immanuel agreed to the terms without admitting fault. No further disciplinary measures from the Medical Board have been reported as of 2025, despite Immanuel's continued high-volume prescribing of and for —ranking her among the top U.S. prescribers in 2020–2021 with over 2,000 such prescriptions. Broader scrutiny from medical boards has focused less on prescribing practices and more on public statements promoting unproven treatments, though Texas regulators issued a general warning to all physicians in August 2020 against advertising COVID-19 "cures" without evidence, which implicitly applied to figures like Immanuel. State medical boards nationwide have investigated hundreds of misinformation-related complaints during the , but disciplinary actions for speech alone remain rare, comprising under 1% of sanctions, often requiring ties to patient harm or substandard care as in Immanuel's case. Her remains active, enabling ongoing practice in .

Media and public backlash to fringe claims

In July 2020, following the viral dissemination of a video featuring Immanuel advocating as a treatment, journalists and users unearthed and publicized excerpts from her earlier sermons, where she asserted that supernatural entities engage in with humans during sleep, resulting in conditions such as , cysts, and due to "demon sperm" impregnating women spiritually. These claims, rooted in her teachings on "spiritual spouses" or marine s, drew immediate condemnation from outlets, which described them as pseudoscientific and emblematic of fringe religious extremism. Public reaction amplified the scrutiny, with late-night hosts like satirizing her assertions on , highlighting the incongruity between her medical credentials and demonological explanations for disease. Singer labeled Immanuel a "moron" on for promoting unverified COVID-19 remedies alongside such views, contributing to widespread online memes and derision that portrayed her as unqualified or delusional. Social media platforms, including , , and , removed or restricted content featuring her sermons and related discussions, citing violations of policies against , which further fueled perceptions of her marginalization by tech gatekeepers. Critics in outlets like The Washington Post and Vanity Fair framed these revelations as evidence of Immanuel's broader unreliability, arguing that her integration of Pentecostal spiritual warfare doctrines into medical advice undermined public health efforts during the pandemic, though such coverage often conflated her esoteric beliefs with her empirical challenges to pharmaceutical consensus. Additional assertions, such as vaccines containing "alien DNA" or masturbation summoning demons, intensified the backlash, leading to nicknames like "Dr. Demon Sperm" in public discourse and prompting calls for professional sanctions from medical regulators. Despite defenses from supporters who viewed the ridicule as elitist dismissal of non-Western spiritual traditions, the episode solidified Immanuel's image in secular media as a proponent of unverifiable supernatural etiologies for illness.

Litigation involving defamation and professional conduct

In July 2021, Stella Immanuel filed a $100 million lawsuit against and anchor in the U.S. District for the Eastern District of (Case No. 4:21-cv-00587), alleging that a July 2020 broadcast segment falsely portrayed her advocacy for as a COVID-19 treatment as fringe or dangerous, thereby damaging her reputation as a physician. The suit claimed the statements implied she was untrustworthy and seeking attention, without evidence of or falsity being sufficiently pled by Immanuel. In May 2022, the court dismissed the case with prejudice, ruling that Immanuel failed to demonstrate the statements were defamatory per se or that acted with , as her public prominence as a proponent invited scrutiny. Immanuel's subsequent appeal was dismissed in October 2022 for being filed one day late, with the Fifth Circuit upholding the lower court's procedural bar. In November 2022, Immanuel initiated another defamation action against Tegna Inc., parent company of local television stations, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, contesting coverage of her COVID-19 views and related medical practices as misleading and harmful to her professional standing. The complaint argued that Tegna's reporting falsely linked her to unsubstantiated claims, constituting libel under Virginia law, though the case's outcome remains unresolved in public records as of late 2022. Regarding professional conduct, the Medical Board investigated Immanuel in 2021 following a complaint about her off-label prescription of to a without adequate medical records or documentation, violating standards under Texas Occupations Code §164.052. In October 2021, after an Informal Settlement , the Board issued a remedial plan requiring her to complete training and submit practice records for review, but imposed no license suspension or fine, framing the action as corrective rather than punitive. Separately, in 2019, Immanuel faced a medical lawsuit in state court from the family of a deceased , alleging negligent treatment contributing to the death, though the suit predated her prominence and centered on standard clinical errors rather than public advocacy. The Louisiana case highlighted ongoing scrutiny of her clinical decision-making but did not result in publicly detailed disciplinary outcomes beyond the filing.

Reception

Support from alternative health and conservative circles

Stella Immanuel received prominent endorsement from conservative political leaders following her July 27, 2020, appearance in a viral video produced by America's Frontline Doctors, where she claimed hydroxychloroquine effectively treated COVID-19 without significant side effects. President Donald Trump retweeted the video multiple times, describing it as providing "great common sense" and defending the doctor during a July 28, 2020, White House briefing by calling her statements "very impressive" and "spectacular" amid questions about her other unconventional beliefs. Donald Trump Jr. also shared the video on Twitter, contributing to its accumulation of millions of views before platform removals for violating misinformation policies. Her affiliation with , a group linked to Tea Party Patriots co-founder Jenny Beth Martin and characterized as a right-wing organization opposing mainstream measures like lockdowns and mask mandates, further embedded her within conservative networks skeptical of federal health agencies. This alignment amplified her visibility among audiences distrustful of perceived overreach by institutions such as the FDA and CDC, with the group's events and statements framing early treatments as suppressed alternatives to vaccines. Conservative media personalities provided platforms for Immanuel's views, including an November 15, 2020, interview on The Candace Owens Show, where Owens highlighted her resistance to social media censorship over critiques and portrayed her as a victim of establishment suppression. Such appearances reinforced her status among audiences favoring individual and religious perspectives on health, including her emphasis on against illness. In alternative health circles, Immanuel's promotion of off-label uses for and as frontline therapies found resonance with advocates of repurposed drugs and outpatient protocols outside conventional pharmaceutical pipelines. Prescription data from 2020 to 2022 ranked her as the leading U.S. prescriber of both medications, with over 10,000 and thousands of orders, suggesting sustained patient demand and alignment with communities prioritizing accessible, low-cost interventions over experimental . This niche support often intersected with holistic and anti-big-pharma sentiments, viewing her persistence against regulatory scrutiny as evidence of challenging corrupt medical gatekeeping.

Empirical evaluations of her treatment claims

Immanuel promoted (HCQ), often in combination with and , as an effective early outpatient treatment for , claiming it could prevent hospitalization and death based on her clinical observations. Large randomized controlled trials (RCTs), however, have consistently failed to replicate these outcomes. The RECOVERY trial, involving over 4,700 hospitalized patients, found that HCQ did not reduce 28-day mortality compared to standard care (27.0% vs. 25.0%; rate ratio 1.09, 95% CI 1.00-1.19) and was associated with a higher incidence of prolonged . Similarly, a of 13 RCTs encompassing hospitalized patients reported no mortality benefit from HCQ (risk ratio 1.10, 95% CI 0.99-1.23) and potential increases in adverse events such as . For early outpatient use, which aligns more closely with Immanuel's advocacy, meta-analyses of non-hospitalized patients have shown no reduction in disease progression or hospitalization. A of seven RCTs concluded that HCQ did not interrupt progression to severe disease in mild cases. Another analysis of outpatient trials, including the COPE study, confirmed no decrease in hospitalization risk ( not significantly reduced). While some observational studies suggested benefits, such as reduced hospitalization odds (38%) with early HCQ, these were confounded by factors like healthier patient selection and lacked randomization, rendering them less reliable than RCTs. Regulatory bodies, including the FDA, revoked for HCQ in treatment by June 2020, citing insufficient evidence and safety risks from emerging trial data. Combinations involving and , which Immanuel endorsed to enhance HCQ's antiviral effects, have similarly lacked robust support in controlled settings. Early outpatient protocols using low-dose HCQ with and reported lower hospitalization rates in retrospective cohorts (e.g., 1.9% vs. higher in untreated), but prospective scoping reviews found no reliable evidence that alone or with prevents severe progression or . A randomized of HCQ plus with or in outpatients showed no significant differences in viral clearance or symptom resolution compared to . Immanuel later associated with ivermectin promotion, becoming a top U.S. prescriber, but RCTs evaluating it for have demonstrated no clinical benefit. The TOGETHER trial, a large adaptive RCT in non-hospitalized patients, found early did not reduce hospitalization or prolonged symptoms ( 0.97 for emergency visits). A of 12 RCTs in outpatients confirmed no effects on mortality, , or safety outcomes versus controls. Higher-dose regimens tested in subsequent trials also failed to show , aligning with Cochrane reviews that deemed evidence low-quality due to bias in positive smaller studies. Overall, high-quality empirical data from RCTs and meta-analyses do not substantiate 's claims, highlighting a disconnect between anecdotal and causal evidence from controlled evaluations.

Long-term impact on public health discourse

Immanuel's high-profile advocacy for and as early treatments, beginning with the July 2020 America's Frontline Doctors video, contributed to a prolonged fragmentation in discussions, particularly among skeptics of centralized health authority. By challenging the dismissal of these repurposed drugs without widespread early-use trials, her positions amplified calls for decentralized medical decision-making and scrutiny of regulatory bodies like the FDA and CDC, which had revoked emergency authorizations for by June 2020 based on large-scale trials showing limited efficacy in hospitalized patients. This discourse persisted into subsequent pandemic phases, influencing conservative critiques of mandates and boosters as overreach, with her claims cited in debates over treatment access versus population-level interventions. Data on prescription patterns underscore her sustained role: from March 2021 to February 2023, Immanuel issued more and prescriptions than any other U.S. physician, totaling thousands of orders amid official warnings of inefficacy and risks. This practice fueled alternative health networks, where anecdotal success stories competed against meta-analyses, such as those from the Cochrane Collaboration in 2021 concluding insufficient evidence for in preventing or treating COVID-19. Her emphasis on physician autonomy resonated in legal challenges to medical boards, contributing to broader erosion of trust in expert consensus, as evidenced by polling data showing partisan divides in treatment beliefs widening post-2020. Longer-term, Immanuel's integration of rhetoric with medical claims—such as linking diseases to demonic influences—has embedded metaphysical elements into segments of alternative health discourse, complicating empirical debates with non-falsifiable assertions. While mainstream outlets, often aligned with institutional views, framed her as a vector leading to avoidable harms, her persistence through podcasts and clinics highlights a resilient counter-narrative prioritizing individual agency over collective guidelines. This duality has entrenched polarization, where messaging faces ongoing contestation from voices demanding transparency on suppressed data, such as early outpatient studies suggesting potential HCQ benefits in low-risk populations before definitive refutation. Empirical outcomes, including correlations debated in retrospective analyses, remain contested, but her influence exemplifies how viral dissent can sustain alternative paradigms amid evolving .

References

  1. https://firepowerministry.org/about-dr-stella-immanuel/
  2. https://health.usnews.com/doctors/stella-immanuel-2566879
  3. https://firepowerministry.org/
  4. https://www.click2houston.com/news/local/2020/07/31/full-interview-houston-doctor-in-viral-video-touting-hydroxychloroquine-as-virus-cure-doubles-down-on-claims/
  5. https://www.medpagetoday.com/special-reports/exclusives/103353
  6. https://kffhealthnews.org/morning-breakout/medical-board-corrects-texas-doctor-in-hydroxychloroquine-case/
  7. https://firepowerministry.org/ministry-programs/
  8. https://www.thecityceleb.com/biography/public-figure/doctor/stella-immanuel-biography-nationality-books-net-worth-husband-daughter-age-instagram-controversy/
  9. https://www.thefamousnaija.com/2020/07/dr-stella-immanuel-biography-age.html
  10. https://www.thefamouspeople.com/profiles/stella-immanuel-103223.php
  11. https://therealarah.medium.com/9-things-you-need-to-know-about-dr-stella-g-immanuel-3113e1cbf6e4
  12. https://drstellamd.com/dr-stellas-bio/
  13. https://www.carlumegboro.com/2020/07/29/what-you-must-know-about-the-us-based-dr-stella-immanuel/
  14. https://www.bbc.com/pidgin/tori-53574144
  15. https://www.quora.com/Can-foreign-medical-graduates-practice-in-the-USA
  16. https://www.healthgrades.com/physician/dr-stella-immanuel-28rnt
  17. https://www.medifind.com/doctors/stella-g-immanuel/9399973
  18. https://katychristianmagazine.com/2020/09/25/stella-immanuel-the-doctor-and-evangelist-you-do-not-know/
  19. https://www.tmb.state.tx.us/
  20. https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/houston/article/Texas-Medical-Board-takes-corrective-action-16583413.php
  21. https://www.doximity.com/pub/stella-immanuel-md
  22. https://texasscorecard.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/remedial-plan-immanuel-md.pdf
  23. https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/health/article/Medical-board-warns-Dr-Immanuel-others-touting-15455333.php
  24. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33387997/
  25. https://africans-in-america.com/2020/08/04/mima-fondong-meet-the-daughter-of-trending-dr-stella-immanuel/
  26. https://www.facebook.com/FirePowerMinistriesWithDrStellaImmanuel/
  27. https://www.facebook.com/houstonchronicle/posts/dr-stella-immanuel-leads-a-church-in-katy-called-fire-power-ministries-and-she-f/1709158325910772/
  28. https://firepowerministry.org/home/
  29. https://theconversation.com/stella-immanuels-theories-about-the-relationship-between-demons-illness-and-sex-have-a-long-history-143587
  30. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-53579773
  31. https://www.france24.com/en/20200728-aliens-and-reptilians-us-viral-video-doctor-s-odd-beliefs
  32. https://firepowerministry.org/healing-scriptures/
  33. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/health-truth-spirituality-w-dr-stella-immanuel-ep-46/id1668607581?i=1000660231420
  34. https://www.unmc.edu/healthsecurity/transmission/2023/03/14/stella-immanuel-highest-u-s-prescriber-of-ivermectin-and-hcq/
  35. https://assets-global.website-files.com/672372641a56ed99d9221164/67fee3ce4853e57a5be0998c_88950250380.pdf
  36. https://religiondispatches.org/the-spiritual-warfare-worldview-of-trumps-conspiracy-doctor-is-part-of-a-transnational-movement/
  37. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tRmxjGJ3kOU
  38. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DL1Z8mRNCYo
  39. https://firepowerministry.org/power-against-familiar-spirits/
  40. https://firepowerministry.org/dealing-with-the-strongman/
  41. https://firepowerministry.org/attacking-the-enemy-of-your-calling/
  42. https://www.rev.com/transcripts/americas-frontline-doctors-scotus-press-conference-transcript
  43. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/28/technology/virus-video-trump.html
  44. https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/28/tech/facebook-youtube-coronavirus
  45. https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/houston/article/houston-doctor-drug-viral-video-sued-louisiana-15443105.php
  46. https://www.bmj.com/content/370/bmj.m3046
  47. https://www.newsweek.com/what-scientific-tests-reveal-about-dr-immanuels-hydroxychloroquine-claims-1521147
  48. https://www.click2houston.com/news/investigates/2020/07/31/houston-doctor-in-viral-video-claiming-theres-a-cure-for-covid-19-tells-her-side-of-the-story/
  49. https://ceflix.org/videos/watch/1882426/big-pharma-and-its-profits:-a-conversation-with-dr.-stella-immanuel-on-world-markets-with-tatenda-belle
  50. https://bigleaguepolitics.com/dr-stella-immanuel-launches-100-million-dollar-lawsuit-against-cnn-after-being-vindicated-on-hydroxychloroquine/
  51. https://yournews.com/2025/10/08/4127663/silencing-the-truth-dr-stella-immanuel-on-charlie-kirk-big/
  52. https://www.facebook.com/12NewsNow/posts/houstons-dr-stella-immanuel-has-made-national-news-after-president-trump-retweet/10157258421421604/
  53. https://www.khou.com/article/news/health/hydroxychloroquine-doctor-stella-immanuel-texas-medical-board/285-aa37adb5-2573-4d35-9106-851f6731fdcf
  54. https://www.governing.com/now/states-try-to-protect-doctors-who-spread-covid-misinformation
  55. https://texasscorecard.com/state/texas-senators-consider-covid-19-vaccine-freedom-measures/
  56. https://www.fox13news.com/news/texas-medical-board-warns-physicians-who-claim-covid-19-cure
  57. https://www.medpagetoday.com/special-reports/features/112871
  58. https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/media/this-was-the-week-america-lost-the-war-on-misinformation/2020/07/30/d8359e2e-d257-11ea-9038-af089b63ac21_story.html
  59. https://www.vanityfair.com/style/2020/07/demon-sex-donald-trump
  60. https://www.bbc.com/pidgin/tori-53585781
  61. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/07/29/madonna-instagram-covid-coronavirus-stella-immanuel-bathtub/
  62. https://www.facebook.com/ktla5/posts/dr-stella-immanuel-one-of-the-doctors-featured-in-a-video-removed-from-social-me/10159032143284614/
  63. https://www.businessinsider.com/stella-immanuel-member-tea-party-pro-trump-group-2020-7
  64. https://www.democracynow.org/2020/7/29/headlines/trump_retweets_doctor_who_warned_of_sex_with_demons_and_alien_dna
  65. https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/doctordefamation.pdf
  66. https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/texas/txedce/4:2021cv00587/207941/39/
  67. https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/cnn-sheds-defamation-suit-by-hydroxychloroquine-touting-doctor
  68. https://reason.com/volokh/2022/10/21/immanuel-v-cnn-no-revival-for-appeal-filed-a-day-late/
  69. https://www.law.com/2022/11/07/texas-doctor-retains-steven-biss-to-sue-network-over-coverage-of-her-views-on-covid-19/
  70. https://www.businessinsider.com/trump-coronavirus-video-stella-immanuel-sued-2019-patient-death-report-2020-7
  71. https://www.beaumontenterprise.com/news/article/houston-doctor-drug-viral-video-sued-louisiana-15443243.php
  72. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/jul/28/trump-covid-19-briefing-hydroxychloroquine-video
  73. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5g7EWA9GFkQ
  74. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2022926
  75. https://www.amjmed.com/article/S0002-9343%2821%2900523-4/fulltext
  76. https://ascpt.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/cts.13468
  77. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2667193X22000606
  78. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1567576921002721
  79. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-22446-z
  80. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0924857920304258
  81. https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.12.29.20248975v1.full
  82. https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT04370782
  83. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2115869
  84. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38908535/
  85. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2801828
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.