Hubbry Logo
The Given DayThe Given DayMain
Open search
The Given Day
Community hub
The Given Day
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
The Given Day
The Given Day
The Given Day
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Given Day is a novel by American writer Dennis Lehane published in September 2008; it is about the early twentieth-century period and set in Boston, Massachusetts, where its actions include the 1919 police strike. It also features Tulsa, Oklahoma, where the thriving Greenwood District was known as the "Black Wall Street".

Key Information

List of Characters

[edit]

Luther Laurence — houseman, athlete
Lila Waters Laurence — Luther's wife

Aiden "Danny" Coughlin — Boston police officer
Captain Thomas Coughlin — Danny's father
Connor Coughlin — Danny's brother, assistant district attorney, Suffolk County
Joe Coughlin — Danny's youngest brother
Ellen Coughlin — Danny's mother
Lieutenant Eddie McKenna — Danny's godfather

Nora O'Shea — domestic help for the Coughlin household
Avery Wallace — domestic help for the Coughlin household

Babe Ruth — baseball player, Boston Red Sox
Stuffy McInnis — Ruth's teammate
Johnny Igoe — Ruth's agent
Harry Frazee — owner, Boston Red Sox

Steve Coyle — Danny Coughlin's patrol partner
Claude Mesplede — alderman of the Sixth Ward
Patrick Donnegan — boss of the Sixth Ward

Isaiah and Yvette Giddreaux — heads of Boston chapter of the NAACP
"Old" Byron Jackson — head of the bellmen's union, Hotel Tulsa
Deacon Skinner Broscious — gangster, Tulsa
Dandy and Smoke — enforcers for Deacon Broscious
Clarence Jessup "Jessie" Tell — numbers runner, Luther's friend, Tulsa
Clayton Tomes — houseman, friend of Luther’s, Boston

Mrs. DiMassi — Danny Coughlin's landlady
Frederico and Tessa Abruzzee — Danny's neighbors

Louis Fraina — head of the Lettish Workingman’s Society
Mark Denton — Boston Police Department patrolman, union organizer
Rayme Finch — agent, Bureau of Investigation
John Hoover — lawyer, Department of Justice
Samuel Gompers — president of the American Federation of Labor
Andrew J. Peters — mayor of Boston
Calvin Coolidge — governor of Massachusetts
Stephen O'Meara — Boston police commissioner until December 1918
Edwin Upton Curtis — O'Meara’s successor as Boston police commissioner
Mitchell Palmer — attorney general of the United States
James Jackson Storrow — Boston power broker, former president of General Motors

[2]

Plot summary

[edit]

The Given Day is a historical novel set in Boston, Massachusetts and Tulsa, Oklahoma. The story has two main characters: Aiden "Danny" Coughlin, an ethnic Irish Boston Police patrolman, whose father is a prominent detective and captain in the department; and Luther Laurence, a talented black amateur baseball player from Columbus, Ohio.

The novel starts at the end of the First World War, when union organizing activities are high across the country. The year is 1918 and the BPD patrolmen have not been given a raise since 1905; they are working for below-poverty level wages. The Boston Social Club (BSC) is the fraternal organization of the BPD patrolmen and its members begin to discuss their grievances and possible actions. Due to his family's high status and reputation in the police department, Danny is reluctant to attend BSC meetings. His partner, Steve Coyle, is able to get him to attend some meetings where the BSC hopes to join the American Federation of Labor, a national union. BPD Captain Thomas Coughlin (Danny's father), FBI agent Rayme Finch, and a Department of Justice lawyer, the young J. Edgar Hoover, assign Danny to infiltrate the Roxbury Lettish Workingman's Society in promise of his detective's stripes. Danny is told that they may be collaborating with other radical cells to plan a national revolt on May Day. As Danny is undercover attending meetings with the Letts, he begins to identify with some of the principles they preach. He soon is elected as the vice-president of the BSC.

Luther Laurence and his pregnant wife, Lila, move from Columbus to Tulsa, Oklahoma to start a new life closer to some of her relatives in the Greenwood District. Laurence and his friend Jessie earn some extra money running numbers for a local bookie and gangster, Deacon Skinner Brocious. When Jessie gets caught skimming from Deacon, a deadly confrontation ensues. Laurence has to leave his wife in Tulsa and flees to Boston, where his uncle sets him up with the Giddreauxs, a black couple who lead the Boston chapter of the recently formed National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP). In Boston Luther gets work as a handyman and servant in the home of police Captain Thomas Coughlin. While working for the Coughlins, Laurence becomes close friends with Nora O'Shea, an Irish immigrant and servant. She was taken in by the Coughlins five years earlier, when the captain found her shivering in the streets on Christmas Eve. Nora and Danny had a love affair, which ended when he discovered a dark secret from her past. She has become engaged to his younger brother, a rising attorney.

Luther is manipulated by Lieutenant Eddie McKenna, best friend to Captain Coughlin and godfather to Danny. Delving into Luther's past, McKenna has discovered that he is running from the deadly altercation in Tulsa. Laurence has been earning his board at the Giddreauxs' home by renovating an old building as the new NAACP headquarters in Boston. McKenna forces him to obtain NAACP membership information and to build a secret chamber in the new headquarters.

When the Coughlins discover Nora's secret, she is banned from their household. Luther is banned after being caught spending time with her and giving her food. Danny's involvement in the BSC takes him away from his family as well; his father is particularly opposed to Danny's new "radical and Bolshevik-like" views. Nora, Danny and Luther form a close friendship. Nora is on her own just as she was five years ago, the men of the BPD are counting on Danny to lead them to a fair wage and working conditions, and Laurence is trying to escape McKenna's clutches and make it back to his wife and child.

The story culminates in the historical Boston Police Strike, which is precipitated by the police commissioner's refusal to allow the nascent police union's right to affiliate with national labor organizations, or to exist. In the chaos of the strike, Luther saves Danny's life. By this time Danny had reunited with and married Nora. Luther reconciles the difficult situation he had run from in Tulsa, and succeeds in returning there to join his wife and recently born child in the Greenwood District. (This is before the area was destroyed in the 1921 Tulsa Race Riot.)

Babe Ruth storyline

[edit]

The notable historic ball player Babe Ruth is featured as a recurring character in The Given Day, along with other historic figures. He appears in the prologue and various transitions within the novel. In the prologue, the Boston Red Sox and Chicago Cubs are traveling by train from Chicago to Boston during the 1918 World Series. The train breaks down in Ohio. Ruth happens upon a pick-up game among some African-American players, one of whom happens to be Luther Laurence. Ruth admires his skills, then is joined by other of the Cubs and Red Sox players, who want to take on the African Americans. Ruth's team ends up cheating and although he knows it is wrong, he sides with his teammates. He is ashamed of his action and reflects on it at different points when he re-appears in the book.

Reception

[edit]

Critics were generally favorable, commenting that Lehane had written a big American novel. Janet Maslin wrote in The New York Times, "He has written a majestic, fiery epic that moves him far beyond the confines of the crime genre."[3] She concludes by writing:

The Given Day is a huge, impassioned, intensively researched book that brings history alive by grounding the present in the lessons of the past. When Mr. Lehane writes of “a man who wore his power like a white suit on a coal black night,” he could be writing about a distant time — or writing about his own.[3]

Colette Bancroft of the St. Petersburg Times wrote "That time and place give Lehane scope to tell a uniquely American story, one grounded in our history yet ringing with issues that concern us still, almost a century later: race, immigration, terrorism, economic instability, political corruption and the corrosive gap between the haves and have-nots."[4]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

The Given Day

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Given Day is a by American author , published in , that chronicles intersecting lives in during the turbulent year of 1919 amid labor unrest, the pandemic, and post-World War I social upheaval. The narrative centers on two fictional families—one Irish-American police family and one African-American household—entangled with historical events like the , featuring real figures such as and , while exploring themes of class struggle, immigration, and the . Lehane's expansive work, the first in his Coughlin series, spans multiple perspectives and subplots, including anarchists, revolutionaries, and domestic tensions, culminating in the violent clashes of the police strike that reshaped labor relations in the United States. Critics praised its ambitious scope and vivid portrayal of early 20th-century America, with reviewers highlighting Lehane's shift from to a "big American novel" that captures the era's chaos without romanticizing its hardships. No major awards were conferred upon the book, though it received strong commercial and critical acclaim for its character depth and historical fidelity.

Publication and Development

Writing Process and Research

Dennis Lehane began researching The Given Day with a dedicated year of extensive reading focused on the 1919 , immersing himself in historical materials to establish the novel's factual foundation before drafting. This preparatory phase emphasized the social and labor tensions of post-World War I America, including the era's Bolshevik influences and urban unrest, which Lehane identified as central to the narrative's causal dynamics rather than idealized depictions. The writing process unfolded spontaneously, with Lehane allowing character arcs and plot elements to develop organically while anchoring them to the strike's known endpoint, avoiding rigid outlines in favor of iterative refinement over approximately five years from the early until publication in 2008. He integrated verifiable historical details, such as the 1918-1919 pandemic's devastation in —which killed over 4,500 residents and exacerbated social strains—drawing from period records to portray its epidemiological and societal impacts without exaggeration. Lehane's first-generation Irish-American background, rooted in his parents' immigration from and familial storytelling traditions, informed the novel's exploration of immigrant experiences and class conflicts, approached through unromanticized realism rather than ethnic nostalgia. This personal lens complemented his research-driven method, prioritizing causal links between economic pressures, ethnic divisions, and labor organizing over narrative conveniences.

Publication History

was released on September 23, 2008, by William Morrow, an imprint of Publishers, in a edition. The , Lehane's eighth work of , represented a departure from his established contemporary toward a expansive historical epic rooted in early 20th-century . This shift was highlighted in promotional materials that emphasized the book's deep ties to 's cultural and historical identity, leveraging Lehane's reputation for evoking the city's gritty essence as seen in prior bestsellers such as . Publishers anticipated strong interest from readers familiar with Lehane's earlier successes, positioning the 704-page volume as a ambitious canvas for exploring themes of labor unrest, race, and family amid post-World War I turmoil.

Historical Basis

Key Events of 1918-1919 Boston

The Spanish influenza pandemic reached in August 1918, with the first serious cases reported among military personnel at camps near the city, rapidly spreading to civilians by early September. The outbreak overwhelmed local hospitals and resources, with over 11,700 influenza cases reported in from mid-September to the end of 1918, contributing to more than 4,000 deaths in the city by year's end—compared to just 51 flu-related deaths the previous year. This surge strained municipal services, including , as police officers were reassigned to enforce quarantines and manage public gatherings amid widespread closures of schools, theaters, and churches. In September 1919, the strike erupted when 1,113 of the city's 1,375 officers walked off the job on September 9, demanding recognition of their union, higher wages to offset rising living costs, and improved working conditions after years of grievances including long shifts and inadequate pay. The action, affiliated with the , led to immediate disorder as looters exploited the absence of uniformed patrols, resulting in riots, vandalism, and at least nine civilian deaths over several days of unrest. Governor responded by supporting Edwin Upton Curtis's refusal to negotiate with the union, deploying state militia and volunteer forces to restore order while declaring that "there is no right to strike against the public safety by anybody, anywhere, anytime." Coolidge's firm stance, which prioritized maintaining law and order over strikers' demands, ultimately led to the dismissal of all striking officers and their replacement, catapulting him to national prominence as a defender of public authority. These events unfolded against the backdrop of the First , a period of heightened national anxiety in over Bolshevik-inspired radicalism, exacerbated by labor strikes, immigrant agitation, and anarchist violence following and the . In , rallies that year devolved into riots amid broader fears of communist infiltration in unions and among the city's large immigrant , fueling suspicions that police unionization efforts masked subversive intents. This context intensified scrutiny of the police strike, with critics linking it to wider patterns of unrest, including a wave of anarchist bombings across U.S. cities earlier in 1919, though no direct evidence tied Boston's police action to such plots. The federal government's subsequent , beginning in November 1919, targeted suspected radicals nationwide, reflecting the era's causal linkage between economic grievances, foreign ideologies, and perceived threats to domestic stability.

Accuracy of Portrayal

The novel faithfully depicts the core grievances precipitating the of September 9, 1919, where officers endured 83- to 98-hour workweeks for annual wages of $1,200 to $1,400, equivalent to $0.21 to $0.25 per hour, amid broader postwar labor unrest. Lehane's portrayal underscores the strike's ultimate failure not through heroic worker but via causal sequences of disorder—looting and riots that alienated , framing strikers as threats akin to and necessitating state intervention by Governor , who deployed the to restore order by September 13. Ethnic dynamics in the Irish-dominated police force, comprising nearly three-fourths of Irish descent amid Protestant oversight, align with historical records of internal frictions exacerbated by radical agitators, though the narrative avoids romanticizing labor radicals as unalloyed protagonists. Tensions between rank-and-file Irish officers and external influences, including suspected socialist infiltration, reflect documented suspicions that contributed to Commissioner Edwin Upton Curtis's refusal of union recognition, prioritizing departmental discipline over concessions. Fictional elements, such as invented character involvements in events, introduce minor liberties but remain anchored to verifiable data: the 1918-1919 claimed over 4,000 lives in by late 1918 alone, compounding social strain, while strike-related violence included riots with nine total deaths, including five from fire into crowds, emphasizing reactive chaos rather than premeditated . Depictions of Mayor critique his conciliatory hesitancy—such as appointing a citizens' committee that failed to avert the walkout and his absence from the city during peak rioting on —yet balance this against the pragmatic imperative of quelling disorder, as unchecked substantiated calls for firmer to prevent broader . Lehane's integrates these elements without undue exaggeration, drawing from period accounts to illustrate how initial sympathy for police demands eroded amid tangible threats to public safety.

Plot Structure

Primary Storylines

The novel centers on the parallel trajectories of two protagonists whose lives intersect amid Boston's turbulent social landscape in 1919. Aiden "Danny" Coughlin, a patrolman in the and son of the department's powerful deputy superintendent Thomas Coughlin, grapples with professional frustrations over low wages, long hours, and inadequate equipment, leading him to advocate for union representation within a force dominated by his family's . In a concurrent arc, Luther Laurence, an African American factory worker fleeing a violent incident in , relocates to with his wife, securing employment as a houseman in an Irish American household while confronting pervasive and economic exclusion in the city's labor market. These individual narratives converge during the 1918-1919 outbreak, the , and schemes by radical anarchists, underscoring how personal decisions and loyalties play out against the pressures of epidemic disease, labor unrest, and threats to public order.

Babe Ruth Segments

In The Given Day, the intercalary chapters devoted to Babe Ruth serve as periodic counterpoints to the primary Boston-based narratives, shifting focus to the baseball star's exploits during the 1919 season with the Boston Red Sox. These segments depict Ruth's evolving role on the team, where he appeared in 130 games, primarily as an rather than his prior position as a , compiling a 9–5 record on the mound while transitioning to everyday play that allowed him to set a major league record with 29 home runs. This portrayal underscores Ruth's on-field dominance, including leading the in home runs, runs batted in (113), and (.456), amid growing tensions with Red Sox owner over salary demands and positional preferences. Ruth's personal excesses feature prominently in these chapters, illustrating his off-field indulgences such as prodigious alcohol consumption and disruptive behavior, which contrasted sharply with the disciplined collective efforts depicted in the storylines. For instance, the segments capture Ruth's participation in post-season tours, including a fall 1919 West Coast exhibition series alongside players from the , where he drew massive crowds for informal games against local teams to supplement his income amid contract disputes. Such depictions align with historical accounts of Ruth's holdouts and threats to prioritize over regular-season duties, reflecting his prioritization of individual gain in an era when owners sought to curb player autonomy through bans on off-season exhibitions. Thematically, these Ruth-focused interludes function as respites from the novel's examination of labor unrest and social upheaval, positioning —and Ruth's —as a symbol of escapist morale restoration in the immediate , when the sport's popularity surged as a national unifier. By weaving in factual elements like trade rumors—Frazee actively shopped Ruth during the season due to his salary demands exceeding $10,000 annually, foreshadowing his eventual sale to the New York Yankees on December 26, 1919, for $100,000—the chapters emblemize unchecked American individualism against the backdrop of institutional constraints and communal strife elsewhere in the text. Specific vignettes, such as imagined exhibition games evoking real disruptions, parallel broader motifs of ambition clashing with order, though critics have noted these insertions occasionally disrupt narrative cohesion by diverting from the core historical tensions.

Characters and Characterization

Fictional Protagonists

Aiden "Danny" Coughlin serves as one of the novel's central fictional protagonists, depicted as a young Irish-American patrolman in the and the son of a influential . His character embodies the of an ambitious officer grappling with familial duty and emerging sympathies for labor reforms, particularly after witnessing poor working conditions and post-World War I disillusionment. Coughlin's involvement in agitating for the —a nascent police association—stems from firsthand exposure to officers' grievances over low pay and long hours, leading to professional repercussions as he prioritizes reform over blind allegiance to authority. Luther Laurence represents the other primary invented protagonist, portrayed as a Black migrant from who flees Tulsa following a fatal altercation with a white during the 1919 race riots' prelude. Employed as a houseman in the Coughlin household, Laurence navigates Boston's ethnic enclaves while concealing his past and attempting to secure passage for his pregnant wife Ida to join him. His decisions reflect survival imperatives amid entrenched racial hostility, such as evading threats and exploiting temporary alliances, rather than ideological commitments, underscoring the precarious existence of in Northern cities post-Great Migration. Nora O'Shea, the Coughlin family's Irish immigrant housemaid, illustrates the burdens on working-class women within extended immigrant households strained by the 1918 influenza epidemic and political tensions. Her arc highlights pragmatic choices driven by economic necessity and personal attachments, including romantic entanglements that expose vulnerabilities in patriarchal family structures, without romanticizing her resilience as heroic defiance. The broader Coughlin siblings and relatives further depict familial fractures, where loyalty to kin competes with individual aspirations amid disease outbreaks and economic hardship, grounding their portrayals in the era's documented immigrant assimilation challenges.

Supporting and Historical Figures

Thomas Coughlin, the veteran and patriarch of the Coughlin family, serves as a key supporting figure whose rigid adherence to hierarchical order and anti-union sentiments heighten familial and departmental tensions during the lead-up to the strike. His character draws from the era's documented police leadership, which often prioritized loyalty to city authorities over rank-and-file grievances, as evidenced by historical accounts of internal police factionalism in 1919 . Coughlin's prejudices against labor radicals and ethnic minorities underscore the novel's exploration of class and ethnic divides within . Nora O'Shea, a progressive entangled romantically with Danny Coughlin, functions narratively to bridge personal relationships with broader social reform efforts, providing ideological contrast to the Coughlin household's conservatism. Her involvement in and labor circles reflects the real participation of women in early 20th-century , though fictionalized for dramatic effect. Similarly, Esther Coughlin, Danny's , embodies the constraints on women's roles amid ethnic Irish family dynamics, her illustrating personal loyalties strained by societal expectations in flu-impacted households segregated by class and origin. Fictional antagonists like Adam Figgis, a corrupt , amplify conflicts by embodying opportunistic exploitation during the unrest, mirroring documented instances of in strike-era records where personal vendettas exacerbated factional splits. Anarchist plotters, including unnamed radicals scheming against , are composites inspired by the era's real subversive activities, such as bomb plots attributed to groups like the Galleanists, which fueled public fears and justified crackdowns; their portrayal highlights causal links between and perceived threats to order, without overstating their influence on the strike itself. Historical figures anchor the narrative to verifiable events. , as governor, is depicted intervening decisively against the strikers, consistent with his October 1919 telegram asserting "no right to strike against the public safety," a stance that aligned with his anti-labor and propelled his vice-presidential candidacy. Woodrow Wilson's portrayal reflects his administration's policies, including A. Mitchell Palmer's raids targeting anarchists and from 1919 onward, which the novel ties to Boston's anti-radical hysteria. , then a young Justice Department official, appears in a minor capacity overseeing anti-subversive efforts, accurately evoking his early career focus on immigrant radicals as documented in Bureau records. John Reed, the journalist and revolutionary sympathizer, interacts with fictional characters to illustrate leftist intellectual circles, true to his real advocacy for labor causes before his 1920 death. These integrations emphasize causal realism in linking national policies to local upheavals.

Themes and Interpretations

Labor Conflicts and Public Order

In The Given Day, Dennis Lehane portrays the Boston police officers' grievances—such as stagnant wages averaging $1,200 annually amid rising post-World War I living costs, 12-hour shifts without overtime, and disciplinary abuses—as valid catalysts for unionization efforts through the Boston Social Club's affiliation with the American Federation of Labor (AFL). These demands reflect documented hardships, including the department's refusal to recognize collective bargaining, which prompted 1,117 of 1,544 officers to strike on September 9, 1919. However, the novel illustrates how these legitimate claims escalated into widespread disorder, with fictional accounts mirroring historical riots that involved looting, assaults, and property destruction estimated at $350,000, underscoring the causal link between work stoppage and civic breakdown rather than triumphant solidarity. Lehane critiques the union leadership's strategic errors, particularly through protagonist Danny Coughlin's arc, where overreliance on AFL solidarity proves illusory as national labor leaders, wary of associations, withhold support; this miscalculation aligns with the historical outcome of all strikers being permanently dismissed without reinstatement, enabling the hiring of a new force and elevating Calvin Coolidge's profile via his insistence on public safety over accommodation. The depicts the strike's immediate consequences—nine civilian deaths, mostly from State Guard interventions amid unchecked mobs—as evidence that police abstention from duty inherently invites , with violence spiraling into a self-perpetuating cycle independent of initial intentions. Ultimately, the balances acknowledgment of officers' economic against the non-negotiable priority of civil order, rejecting the normalization of disruption as a pathway to reform; Coolidge's famous declaration—"There is no right to strike against the public safety by anybody, anywhere, anytime"—resonates as a pragmatic response, as the unrest validated replacing the force to avert prolonged vulnerability, prioritizing societal stability over individual concessions. This portrayal avoids romanticizing labor action, emphasizing instead how unchecked strikes erode and invite opportunistic chaos, a theme reinforced by the failure to secure lasting gains despite initial grievances.

Radicalism and Social Upheaval

In The Given Day, anarchist cells are portrayed as active conspirators plotting bombings against symbols of authority, mirroring the real Galleanist anarchists' campaign of terror in 1919, when followers of dispatched package bombs to 36 prominent officials, including judges and businessmen, resulting in multiple explosions. These fictional plots, investigated by protagonist Danny Coughlin, emphasize the anarchists' role as immigrant-driven networks seeking societal disruption through targeted violence, such as assaults on police stations, rather than abstract . The narrative underscores their destabilizing impact, depicting preparations for attacks that exploit post-World War I chaos to advance anti-government agendas. Bolshevist influences appear through radical agitators promoting revolutionary upheaval, framed as extensions of the same that fueled the era's bombings, including the June 2, 1919, attempt on A. Mitchell Palmer's home by anarchist Carlo Valdinoci, which killed the bomber and damaged the residence. Lehane integrates these elements to illustrate causal links between imported ideologies and domestic threats, with characters encountering and cells that blend with Bolshevik tactics to incite disorder. The novel contextualizes the First Red Scare and as pragmatic responses to verifiable dangers, not unfounded panic; Palmer's intelligence efforts, led by a young , targeted radicals amid a wave of over 30 bombings in 1919 alone, leading to arrests of suspected plotters. This portrayal counters retrospective dismissals of the raids as hysteria by highlighting empirical precedents—like the anarchists' use of and shrapnel devices—that justified heightened vigilance against groups openly advocating violent overthrow. Lehane's depiction ultimately cautions against underestimating ideological zeal's potential for bloodshed, presenting radicalism as a tangible catalyst for anarchy in early 20th-century America.

Ethnic and Racial Dynamics

In The Given Day, the novel portrays Irish dominance within the as a key vector for anti-Black , with the force comprising predominantly Irish-American officers who enforced informal segregation and viewed Black residents as threats to . This dynamic manifests in the experiences of Luther Laurence, an African American migrant from Georgia, who endures violent mistreatment at the hands of Detective Eddie McKenna, an Irish cop embodying the era's raw ethnic animosities and casual brutality toward non-whites. Such depictions align with historical realities of Northern , where Irish police often channeled their own marginalization into aggression against Black communities amid post-World War I job scarcities. Ethnic enclaves in functioned as insular strongholds for survival, with Irish neighborhoods in and Charlestown prioritizing kin networks for and , while concentrated in the North End's factories and tenements. These groups' clannishness intensified conflicts over scarce manual labor post-armistice, as returning soldiers and demobilized industries fueled competition that pitted immigrants against each other and against the , which hovered around 13,000 in 1920 and clustered in the South End. Lehane renders this not as abstract ideology but as pragmatic group , where resource rivalry—exacerbated by an overheated —breeds interracial friction without romanticizing victimhood. De facto segregation permeated Boston's housing and public spaces, confining Black families to overcrowded districts vulnerable to the 1918 influenza outbreak, which killed over 7,500 in the city and struck urban poor hardest due to poor sanitation and delayed medical access in minority areas. Laurence's narrative arc echoes the Red Summer of 1919's nationwide race riots, including expulsive violence akin to events in other cities, underscoring how flu-ravaged conditions amplified prejudices during labor unrest like the police strike. The novel's treatment avoids anachronistic framing, instead attributing tensions to empirical pressures of density, disease, and demographic shifts in a city where whites outnumbered Blacks by over 40 to 1.

Family and Personal Loyalty

Thomas Coughlin, the patriarch of the Coughlin and a high-ranking , navigates the era's machine politics through calculated alliances that secure familial power and influence, viewing such pragmatism as essential for preserving the hierarchical against encroaching reforms. His approach prioritizes collective to established authorities, often at the expense of individual aspirations, as seen in his opposition to labor organizing that threatens police discipline. This stance clashes with the ideals of his son , a patrolman drawn to union , forcing a reckoning between paternal expectations and personal moral imperatives in a society where ambition risks familial rupture. The 1918 influenza pandemic amplifies the costs of such loyalties, exposing the inherent fragility of ties amid uncontrollable crises; sudden deaths sever bonds without regard for social standing, compelling survivors to confront isolation even within ostensibly supportive structures. In the Coughlin household, the flu's toll underscores how reliance on hierarchies offers illusory security, as illness erodes the pragmatic power bases that patriarchs like Thomas cultivate, revealing trade-offs where loyalty demands conformity yet fails to shield against existential vulnerabilities. By contrast, Luther Laurence, an African American uprooted from his Tulsa following a self-defensive killing, embodies forged in the absence of robust networks, migrating northward without the buffer of entrenched ethnic systems available to Irish-American clans like the Coughlins. His transient employment with the Coughlin household highlights the perils of individual agency in racially stratified societies, where severed necessitate autonomous strategies over dependence on , often leading to precarious improvisations amid urban upheaval. This divergence illustrates broader tensions between inherited obligations and solitary ambition, where marginalized figures must prioritize personal endurance devoid of the Coughlins' institutional safeguards.

Literary Analysis

Narrative Style

Lehane structures The Given Day with a multi-perspective that shifts primarily between protagonists Aiden Coughlin and Luther Laurence, supplemented by viewpoints from ancillary figures, to forge an expansive portrayal of early 20th-century Boston's social fabric. This technique amplifies the novel's epic scale, intertwining personal arcs with broader historical currents while maintaining narrative cohesion through dated chapter markers and thematic echoes. The prose prioritizes lucid immersion in the period's harsh realities, deploying expansive sentences laden with sensory particulars—such as the acrid tang of or the visceral toll of —to evoke 1919's unvarnished grit without ornate flourishes. Dialogue incorporates dialect-infused speech patterns, replicating Irish brogues and ethnic inflections to ground interactions in authentic regional cadences and heighten character distinction. Pacing modulates between surges of kinetic intensity in strike and riot sequences and contemplative respites focused on individual reckonings, fostering sustained propulsion over the 700-page span while eschewing hyperbolic excess. Vivid renderings of era-specific afflictions, including the hemorrhagic fevers and cyanotic suffocations of the 1918 outbreak, draw on documented epidemiological patterns to underscore the pandemic's pervasive dread.

Use of Historical Fiction

Lehane integrates documented historical events of 1919 into The Given Day, such as the that began on September 9, 1919, triggered by officers' demands for union recognition amid stagnant wages and post-war inflation exceeding 15 percent annually. Fictional protagonists like Irish-American patrolman Danny Coughlin and African-American laborer Luther Laurence navigate these upheavals, their invented arcs intersecting with real occurrences—including Babe Ruth's Red Sox games, which serve as chronological markers—to depict causal shifts from wartime optimism to paranoia and racial strife. This method prioritizes historical causality over dramatic invention, with Ruth's portrayals adhering to his verified persona as a boisterous, apolitical athlete rather than imposing modern interpretations. Character drives reflect 1919's economic and ideological pressures, including policemen's real grievances over $1,200 annual salaries insufficient against rising living costs and pervasive fears of Bolshevik infiltration following the 1917 , without retrofitting anachronistic progressive ideals onto period actors. Lehane's fidelity to these chains—evident in depictions of anarchist bombings and flu logistics drawn from contemporary records—avoids ahistorical moralizing, grounding ethnic loyalties and labor militancy in era-specific survival imperatives rather than abstracted equity narratives. Real figures like Mayor appear with documented traits, such as administrative indecision during the strike, ensuring inventions do not falsify established timelines or motivations. The narrative unfolds as a multi-threaded akin to 19th-century historical epics, encompassing over 700 pages to trace familial and societal ramifications across Boston's wards, though some analyses note the expanse occasionally strains pacing amid subplots. This structure amplifies thematic depth on American reinvention but invites critique for prolixity, with secondary threads risking dilution of core historical tensions despite bolstering immersive realism.

Reception and Legacy

Initial Critical Response

Upon its publication in September 2008, The Given Day received acclaim for its ambitious historical scope and vivid recreation of post-World War I Boston's social turbulence, including the 1919 police strike and . Janet of lauded the novel's "fierce-terrible" intensity, describing it as a "huge, impassioned, intensively researched book that brings alive by grounding the present in the lessons of the past." Similarly, commended Lehane's integration of real events and figures, such as and the era's labor unrest, portraying it as an exploration of the amid human frailties, with protagonists Danny Coughlin and Luther Laurence providing compelling depth. Critics offered mixed assessments of the novel's structure, praising its readability despite its 704-page length but faulting excessive subplots and sprawl that diluted focus. John Freeman, also in , called it "massive [and] enormously readable" for tracing Coughlin family dynamics and interracial alliances, yet critiqued it as "too long" with "too many cartoonish villains" and underdeveloped secondary characters, such as the domestic servant Nora. Bookreporter echoed this, characterizing the work as a "sprawling tale" that captured the era's chaos but risked overwhelming readers with its breadth. The novel's handling of ideological tensions, particularly in labor conflicts and radicalism, drew attention for its sympathetic lens on union organizers like Danny Coughlin, who evolves from police to advocate amid portrayals of socialists as principled against "terrorist" labels. While Kirkus highlighted achievements in evoking the strike's bloody riots without overt bias critique, some ers implied predictability in resolutions tied to historical outcomes, maintaining narrative momentum but limiting surprise. Freeman noted the foreknown strike's end but credited Lehane's pacing for engagement, balancing unrest's authenticity against soap-opera elements in dialogue and plot.

Commercial Success and Sales

The Given Day, published in September 2008 by William Morrow, entered the New York Times bestseller list shortly after release, reflecting initial commercial momentum driven by author Dennis Lehane's prior successes with novels like (2001) and (2003), both of which achieved bestseller status and film adaptations. Exact sales figures remain undisclosed by publishers, but the ranked fourth among Lehane's top-selling works, indicating respectable performance without reaching the scale of his earlier . editions followed in 2009, sustaining domestic availability through retailers like Amazon and , while international versions expanded reach via specialized distributions. The book's Boston-centric narrative likely bolstered regional sales in markets, though it garnered no major literary prizes such as the or Pulitzer, limiting broader award-driven boosts. Overall, commercial outcomes aligned with expectations for a historical epic diverging from Lehane's typical crime genre, prioritizing established fan interest over breakout phenomenon status.

Long-Term Influence and Critiques

The Given Day has influenced subsequent by integrating gritty realism with labor unrest narratives, portraying the 1919 not as a heroic triumph but as a cautionary episode of societal disruption that ultimately reinforced public order through decisive intervention. Analyses highlight how Lehane's depiction underscores the strike's causal chain—union militancy leading to widespread riots, , and loss of life, followed by the mobilization of non-striking officers and state militia under Governor , culminating in the union's dissolution despite eventual wage concessions without rights. This framing counters romanticized labor histories by emphasizing empirical outcomes: the strike's failure eroded public sympathy for police unionism and propelled Coolidge's national political ascent via his stance that "there is no right to strike against the public safety by anybody, anywhere, anytime." Critiques of the often commend its avoidance of ideological in labor depictions, instead favoring a causal realism that traces upheaval to its disruptive endpoints, including overlooked long-term consequences like heightened anti-union sentiment and the prioritization of institutional stability over worker . Literary observers note Lehane's nuanced —acknowledging union grievances while questioning the propriety of public safety employees striking, as reflected in the author's own assessment of the event's irresolvable tensions. This approach has drawn for privileging verifiable historical sequences over , though some left-leaning reviewers argue it underplays systemic exploitation in favor of order's restoration, potentially aligning with establishment perspectives on . Within Lehane's oeuvre, The Given Day serves as a foundational bridge to his later Coughlin , introducing protagonists like and Joe Coughlin whose arcs extend into Prohibition-era tales of and ambition in Live by Night (2012) and World Gone By (2015), blending historical sweep with noir elements to explore enduring themes of loyalty and moral compromise. Recent reread discussions, such as urban scholar Carlo Rotella's 2017 reflection tying the novel's motifs of inequality and upheaval to contemporary , reaffirm the strike's legacy as a emblem of unresolved tensions between individual agency and collective disorder. In 2023 analyses of Lehane's Small Mercies, commentators invoke The Given Day to underscore its persistent influence in rendering Boston's ethnic frictions and institutional breakdowns with unflinching precision, sustaining its relevance amid modern reckonings with the city's social fault lines.

References

  1. https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/dennis-lehane/the-given-day/
  2. https://www.bookbrowse.com/reviews/index.cfm/book_number/2193/the-given-day
  3. https://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/19/books/review/freeman.html
  4. https://www.amazon.com/Given-Day-Coughlin-Book/dp/0380731878
  5. https://www.goodreads.com/interviews/show/19.Dennis_Lehane
  6. https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2009/jan/24/dennis-lehane
  7. https://historicalnovelsociety.org/reviews/the-given-day/
  8. https://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/18/books/18masl.html
  9. https://www.amazon.com/Given-Day-Novel-Dennis-Lehane/dp/B002SB8P56
  10. https://www.seattletimes.com/entertainment/books/lehanes-the-given-day-busting-heads-in-boston/
  11. https://www.neh.gov/humanities/2014/marchapril/feature/the-devastation-1918
  12. https://www.boston.gov/news/notes-archives-onthisday-1918-spanish-flu-arrived-boston
  13. https://www.westfield.ma.edu/historical-journal/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/FLU-PANDEMIC-FINAL-COMPRESSED.pdf
  14. https://www.bpstrike1919.org/about-the-1919-boston-police-strike/
  15. https://www.americanheritage.com/strike-made-president
  16. https://coolidgefoundation.org/resources/statement-on-the-police-strike/
  17. http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/saccov/redscare.html
  18. https://www.newyorkalmanack.com/2020/07/the-first-red-scare-socialist-suppression-and-explosive-anarchism/
  19. https://libcom.org/article/short-history-boston-police-strike-1919
  20. https://revolutionarycorridor.org/the-1919-boston-police-strike/
  21. https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/september-9/the-boston-police-department-goes-on-strike
  22. https://www.iwp.edu/articles/2020/10/01/the-boston-police-strike-a-harbinger-for-today/
  23. https://www.bostonirish.com/history/2021/picket-line-boston-police-strike-1919
  24. https://www.iboston.org/mcp.php?pid=policeStrike&laf=hpe
  25. https://www.jstor.org/stable/361175
  26. https://sabr.org/journal/article/showdown-babe-ruths-rebellious-1921-barnstorming-tour/
  27. https://baseballhall.org/discover-more/history/barnstorming-tours
  28. https://sabr.org/gamesproj/game/may-15-1919-bostons-babe-ruth-pitches-11-innings-of-rocky-relief-for-a-win-over-white-sox/
  29. https://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2009/jan/29/dennis-lehane-given-day-babe-ruth
  30. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2008/10/06/briefly-noted-the-given-day
  31. https://sobrief.com/books/the-given-day
  32. https://libcom.org/article/given-day-dennis-lehane
  33. https://bookbrief.io/books/the-given-day-dennis-lehane/character-analysis
  34. https://www.csmonitor.com/Books/Book-Reviews/2008/0929/the-given-day
  35. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2009/jan/31/given-day-dennis-lehane-chris-petit
  36. https://nvdatabase.swarthmore.edu/content/boston-police-strike-better-working-conditions-1919
  37. https://www.encyclopedia.com/history/united-states-and-canada/us-history/boston-police-strike-1919
  38. http://americanstudier.blogspot.com/2015/09/september-16-2015-given-days-boston.html
  39. https://shec.ashp.cuny.edu/items/show/1903
  40. https://aidanjmcquade.com/2014/07/
  41. https://www.fbi.gov/history/famous-cases/palmer-raids
  42. https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2013/04/luigi-galleani-palmer-raids-the-bomb-throwing-anarchists-who-terrorized-boston-100-years-before-the-tsarnaevs.html
  43. https://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/2007/december/palmer_122807
  44. https://reason.com/2020/01/29/the-long-shadow-of-the-palmer-raids/
  45. https://digitalcommons.bucknell.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1005&context=honors_theses
  46. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/entertainment/2008/09/21/when-bostons-police-went-on-strike-in-1919-the-city-collapsed-into-anarchy/ee0adbd7-3116-4d01-9eb3-83b4fd7ee491/
  47. https://www.paulreverehouse.org/italian-immigration-to-america-and-bostons-north-end/
  48. https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/jfk-and-the-history-of-irish-immigration-in-boston.htm
  49. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9714293/
  50. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/d235/9b3c69f09b3313fc74cc8e892ed7b098eb93.pdf
  51. https://www.amazon.com/Given-Day-Coughlin-Book/dp/0688163181
  52. https://medium.com/@frat1309/the-given-day-by-dennis-lehane-fd9190332d72
  53. https://www.readinggroupguides.com/printpdf/reviews/the-given-day
  54. https://www.thesomervilletimes.com/archives/132359
  55. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7528412/
  56. https://www.writersdigest.com/oct-15/straight-talk-with-dennis-lehane
  57. https://www.bookbrowse.com/mag/reviews/index.cfm/book_number/2193/the-given-day
  58. https://www.bookreporter.com/reviews/the-given-day
  59. https://mhl.org/borrow/recommendations/new-york-times-best-seller-lists?date=2008-10-30
  60. https://www.accio.com/business/dennis_lehane_best_selling_books
  61. https://www.abebooks.com/9780061804304/Given-Day-Lehane-Dennis-0061804304/plp
  62. https://www.the-independent.com/news/people/profiles/dennis-lehane-the-writer-who-makes-crime-pay-2335400.html
  63. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/la-xpm-2012-oct-14-la-ca-dennis-lehane-20121014-story.html
  64. https://www.boston.gov/news/imagine-boston-2030-book-review-carlo-rotella-given-day
  65. https://chireviewofbooks.com/2023/05/11/the-other-south-coming-to-terms-with-bostons-racist-legacy-in-small-mercies/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.